GERMANY PROPERTY REPORT 2019 - RESEARCH - BNP Paribas Real Estate

Page created by Dana Contreras
 
CONTINUE READING
GERMANY PROPERTY REPORT 2019 - RESEARCH - BNP Paribas Real Estate
RETAIL MARKET
GERMANY
PROPERTY REPORT 2019

                                  RESEARCH

                                 Real Estate
                       for a changing world
GERMANY PROPERTY REPORT 2019 - RESEARCH - BNP Paribas Real Estate
CONTENTS
OVERVIEW                                                            24     Bremen                                                       52      Mannheim

                                                                    26                                                                  54
3
                                                                           Cologne                                                              Munich

                                                                    28                                                                  56
       Executive Summary

4
                                                                           Dortmund                                                             Münster

                                                                    30                                                                  58
       Macroeconomic
       overview                                                            Dresden                                                              Nuremberg

7      Retail Investment                                            32     Düsseldorf                                                   60      Osnabrück

10     The German                                                   34     Erfurt                                                       62      Stuttgart

                                                                    36                                                                  64
       retail markets

14
                                                                           Essen                                                                Trier

                                                                    38                                                                  66
       Most active
       retailers 2018                                                      Frankfurt                                                            Wiesbaden

                                                                    40     Hamburg                                                      68      Würzburg

                                                                    42
AT A GLANCE
                                                                           Hannover

16                                                                  44
                                                                                                                                        REFERENCES
       Aachen                                                              Heidelberg

18     Berlin                                                       46     Karlsruhe                                                    70      Letting

20     Bonn                                                         48     Leipzig                                                      71      Investment

22     Braunschweig                                                 50     Mainz

IMPRINT
Publisher and copyright: BNP Paribas                        Realisation: KD1 Designagentur, Cologne                                                            carbon neutral
Real Estate GmbH                                            Title picture: B. Balsereit, Cologne                                                                natureOffice.com | DE-140-234158
                                                                                                                                                                print production
Prepared by: BNP Paribas Real Estate                        Status: January 2019
Consult GmbH                                                Circulation: 450

All rights reserved. This Property Report is protected in its entirety by copyright. No part of this publication may be reproduced, translated, transmitted, or stored in a retrieval
system in any form or by any means, without the prior permission in writing of BNP Paribas Real Estate GmbH.

The statements, notifications and forecasts provided here correspond to our estimations at the time when this report was prepared and can change without notice. The data come
from various sources which we consider reliable but whose validity, correctness or exactness we cannot guarantee. Explicitly, this report does not represent a recommendation of
any kind, nor should it be regarded as forming a basis for making any decisions regarding investment or letting or renting property or premises. BNP Paribas Real Estate can accept
no liability whatsoever for any information contained or statements made herein.
GERMANY PROPERTY REPORT 2019 - RESEARCH - BNP Paribas Real Estate
RETAIL MARKET GERMANY 2019 OVERVIEW

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
   RETAIL IN THE MIDST OF CHANGE

   In no other market segment of the German real estate market are structures changing as
   quickly as in the retail sector. The main driver for many developments and discussions
   is e-commerce, which is continuing to expand its share of total retail turnover and at the
   same time recording above-average growth rates. The online business scores not only
   with a comfortable order and fast delivery times, but in many cases also with very fair
   exchange or return conditions. What it does not offer, however, is the emotional shopping
   experience of shopping, combined with upstream or downstream activities, which as an
   overall package result in a pleasant and interesting leisure time organisation.

   TOP RENTS STABLE TO FALLING

   ▸▸ In 38 of 64 cities regularly analysed by BNP Paribas Real Estate, the top rent has not
       changed. However, 24 cities showed decreases.

   ▸▸ T
       he majority of the retail markets were also able to maintain the rent level, as the
      pressure on demand that had been built up for a long time has remained unchanged
      due to the very limited supply in the top locations and retailers being absolutely keen
      to occupy these specific locations.

   ▸▸ S
       horter lease durations that involve a risk sharing between tenant and landlord
      (e. g. turnover-based rent components), play an important role, especially in the case
      of larger space units.

   OVERALL DEMAND REMAINS GOOD

   ▸▸ T
       he top 10 German locations outperformed their previous year’s results with an
      inner-city take-up of almost 193,000 m² (almost 430 contracts recorded), whereas the
      nationwide result shows declines.

   ▸▸ In a more ambitious competitive environment, larger shopping metropolises with a
       wide range of complementary catering and leisure facilities seem to be better off at the
       moment than many B- and C-cities.

   IN TERMS OF EXPANSION, GERMANY REMAINS A SAFE HAVEN

   ▸▸ A
       large number of renowned retailers such as Uniqlo, Topshop, Arket, Zalando and
      JD Sports, whose concepts are designed for larger shops, have noticeably increased
      their pace of expansion in 2018.

   ▸▸ O
       utside the fashion sector, the expanding trio of eyewear suppliers Ace & Tate, VIU
      and Mister Spex as well as the Danish furniture store Søstrene Grene, the Dutch
      department store chain Hema and the Swedish watch brand Daniel Wellington were
      also able to expand their branch network.

                                                                                                  2|3
GERMANY PROPERTY REPORT 2019 - RESEARCH - BNP Paribas Real Estate
MACROECONOMIC OVERVIEW
  	RETAIL SALES HAVE CONTINUED TO GROW                           DEVELOPMENT OF GROSS DOMESTIC PRODUCT (GDP) IN GERMANY
Despite a relatively weak overall economic development in         in % (price-adjusted)

                                                                                                                                1.1
the second half of the year, retail sales also increased in

                                                                                                        0.9
                                                                  1.0
2018, recording the ninth consecutive increase. According
to initial calculations by the Federal Statistical Office, they   0.8

                                                                                      0.6

                                                                                                                                            0.6
                                                                                                  0.6

                                                                                                                                                                                   © BNP Paribas Real Estate Retail Services, December 31, 2018
have increased nominally by between 3.1 % and 3.3 % and by

                                                                                                                                      0.5

                                                                                                                                                  0.5

                                                                                                                                                              0.5
                                                                  0.6

                                                                                                                          0.4
                                                                                                              0.4

                                                                                                                                                        0.4
between 1.4 % and 1.5 % in price-adjusted terms. Although

                                                                                            0.3
                                                                  0.4
growth was somewhat lower than in the last three years, it

                                                                                                                    0.2
nevertheless underscored the overall stability of consumer        0.2

                                                                                                                                                                           0,0
confidence. At the same time, the result also reflects the
                                                                  0.0
strong economy in the first half of the year and, above all,

                                                                               -0.1
                                                                  -0.2
the continuing rise in employment accompanied by falling

                                                                                                                                                                    -0.2
unemployment. To a large extent the income effects result-        -0.4
ing from this are of direct benefit to the retail industry. As
                                                                                Q1 Q2       Q3    Q4     Q1 Q2      Q3    Q4     Q1 Q2      Q3    Q4     Q1 Q2      Q3     Q4
expected, the Internet and mail order business again grew                      2015                     2016                    2017                    2018

disproportionately, increasing its share of total sales. E-       Source: Destatis

commerce is therefore becoming increasingly important and
will continue its success story in the coming years.

  	ECONOMIC GROWTH SLOWS BUT REMAINS INTACT
According to the provisional figures for 2018, the Ger-
man economy grew by 1.5 % in real terms. This repre-
sents a smaller increase than in the two previous years.
While the first half of the year was still extremely good,
the third quarter even saw a decline. Since GDP picked up         GDP DEVELOPMENT IN INTERNATIONAL COMPARISON
again in the final quarter, a so-called technical recession       in %
was avoided. The automotive industry was one of the main                 Germany              France            United Kingdom
contributors to the weak second half of the year, having to              USA                  Spain
contend with new emission tests introduced in the wake
of the diesel scandal. Some manufacturers have therefore           6.0

                                                                                                                                                                                     © BNP Paribas Real Estate Retail Services, December 31, 2018
sold little or no new cars for months. This special situa-
                                                                   4.0
tion must be taken into account when analysing economic
                                                                   2.0
developments. Growth impetus came primarily from the
domestic market. Both private and public consumer spend-            0
ing has increased. Above-average contributions were also
                                                                  -2.0
made by the segments ICT, construction, as well as trade,
transport and hospitality. Exports rose by 2.4 %, while im-       -4.0

ports increased by 3.4 %, thus slowing GDP growth in purely       -6.0
arithmetical terms.
                                                                            2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018                               2019    2020
                                                                                                                                                               Forecast Forecast
                                                                  Source: Eurostat, forecast BNP Paribas
GERMANY PROPERTY REPORT 2019 - RESEARCH - BNP Paribas Real Estate
RETAIL MARKET GERMANY 2019 OVERVIEW

  	LABOUR MARKET REMAINS VERY DYNAMIC                         DEVELOPMENT OF UNEMPLOYMENT RATE IN GERMANY
In 2018, the labour market impressively continued the up-      in % 
ward trend of recent years. On average, 2.34 million peo-
                                                               8.0
ple were registered as unemployed. This corresponds to a

                                                                        6.8

                                                                                                 6.5
decline of 193,000 or almost 8 % compared with the pre-

                                                                                     6.2
                                                                              6.2

                                                                                           6.1

                                                                                                                          6.0

                                                                                                                                                                                  © BNP Paribas Real Estate Retail Services, December 31, 2018
                                                                                                       5.9
                                                                                                             5.9
                                                                                                                    5.8
vious year. Accordingly, the unemployment rate fell by 50

                                                                                                                                                      5.5
                                                                                                                                 5.5
                                                                                                                                        5.5
                                                               6.0

                                                                                                                                               5.3

                                                                                                                                                             5.0
                                                                                                                                                                    5.0
basis points to an average of 5.2 %. As a result, employment

                                                                                                                                                                           4.9
continued to increase and, at 44.83 million, reached its
highest level since reunification. In total, around 562,000    4.0

more people were in employment than in 2017. Particu-
larly noteworthy is the fact that this growth took place
above all in employment subject to social insurance con-       2.0

tributions, which rose by 705,000 to 32.87 million in June
2018. In contrast, part time employment as well as self-
employment have decreased. The positive development                      Q1 Q2
                                                                        2015
                                                                                     Q3    Q4     Q1 Q2
                                                                                                 2016
                                                                                                             Q3     Q4     Q1 Q2
                                                                                                                          2017
                                                                                                                                        Q3     Q4      Q1 Q2
                                                                                                                                                      2018
                                                                                                                                                                    Q3     Q4

therefore extends not only to absolute figures, but also to    Source: Labour market statistics of the Federal Labour Agency

structural aspects relating to the social security of newly
created jobs. Since the number of job vacancies has also
increased by 66,000 to an average of 796,000, everything
points to the fact that the labour market will continue its
success story in 2019.

  	CONSUMER CLIMATE REMAINS ACTIVE
The consumer climate index produced by GfK forecasts
a value of 10.4 points for January, the same level as in
December 2017. Although it is 0.4 lower than a year ago,       DEVELOPMENT OF THE GFK CONSUMER CLIMATE INDEX
this is still a high value in a long-term comparison. The
                                                               12.0                                                                                   10.8

                                                                                                                                                                    10.5
                                                                                                                                        10.9

different development directions of the sub-indicators are                                                                                                   10.7
                                                                                                                                               10.7

                                                                                                                                                                           10.4
                                                                                                                                 10.4
                                                                              10.2

                                                                                                             10.2

                                                                                                                          10.0

remarkable. Economic expectations fell sharply to 14.1
                                                                                     9.9

                                                                                                       9.8

                                                                                                                    9.8
                                                                        9.7

                                                                                                 9.5
                                                                                           9.3

                                                               10.0
points, the lowest level since February 2017. This shows

                                                                                                                                                                                  © BNP Paribas Real Estate Retail Services, December 31, 2018
that consumers cannot escape the lower GDP forecasts
                                                                8.0
and, above all, the many global risks. On the other hand,
consumers are noticeably more optimistic about their
                                                                6.0
personal situation. The partial indicator of income devel-
opment even increased in December 2018 and climbed
                                                                4.0
to 53.8 points. Some uncertainty about external risks is
nevertheless reflected in the propensity to buy, which has
                                                                2.0
fallen by a few points to 53.1 points. Nevertheless, the
propensity to consume remains at a very high level and
underlines the good economic framework. The retail in-                   Q1 Q2
                                                                        2015
                                                                                     Q3    Q4     Q1 Q2
                                                                                                 2016
                                                                                                             Q3     Q4     Q1 Q2
                                                                                                                          2017
                                                                                                                                        Q3     Q4      Q1 Q2
                                                                                                                                                      2018
                                                                                                                                                                    Q3     Q4

dustry will also continue to benefit from this.

                                                                                                                                                                              4|5
ECONOMY MORE SKEPTICAL THAN CONSUMERS                        DEVELOPMENT OF THE IFO BUSINESS CLIMATE INDEX
For the companies, the impact of the emerging economic           Index values (2005 = 100)
clouds on sentiment indicators is greater than for con­

                                                                                                                                                                 104.6
                                                                                                                                                         103.9

                                                                                                                                                                          103.8

                                                                                                                                                                                          103.8
                                                                                                                                                 103.0
                                                                 120.0

                                                                                                                                                                                  102.3
sumers. This statement is clearly expressed in the most

                                                                                                                                        101.9
                                                                                                                        100.8
                                                                                                                                100.8

                                                                                                                                                                                                  101.0
                                                                                                 100.5
                                                                                 100.6
                                                                                         100.2

                                                                                                                100.4
                                                                          99.2

                                                                                                         99.1
important sentiment indicator of the German economy, the

                                                                                                                                                                                                          © BNP Paribas Real Estate Retail Services, December 31, 2018
                                                                 100.0
Ifo Business Climate Index. After a short-term recovery in
August 2018, it fell steadily to only 101 points in December.
                                                                  80.0
This downward trend is also reflected in the two sub-indi-
cators. The value used to assess the current business situ-       60.0
ation fell from 109.1 to 104.7 over the course of the year.
The difficult year for the German automotive industry is un-      40.0
doubtedly one of the reasons for this, but in other areas of
the German economy, too, things are no longer quite mov-          20.0

ing as smoothly as in previous years. At the end of 2018, the
                                                                           Q1 Q2         Q3       Q4      Q1 Q2          Q3     Q4       Q1 Q2           Q3      Q4       Q1 Q2           Q3      Q4
sub-indicator for future expectations was only 97.3 points.               2015                           2016                           2017                             2018

However, this is not surprising given the many unresolved        Source: CESifo GmbH

and smouldering risks to the global economy. Not only is
the trade conflict between the USA and China worrying,
leaving its first traces in the Chinese economy, but above all
the Damocles sword of an unregulated Brexit.

  	WHERE THE JOURNEY 2019 IS HEADING
    IS UNCERTAIN
How the economy will develop in 2019 is still uncertain and
posed with many question marks. On the one hand, there
are positive impulses from a continuing flourishing labour       DEVELOPMENT OF INFLATION RATE
market, from which the retail industry should benefit. GDP       in %
growth, which is slowing down but should be above the
long-term average according to current forecasts, is also an     2.5
                                                                                                 2.1

important framework condition for the retail industry. On
                                                                                                            2.0

                                                                                                                                                                                     2.0

                                                                                                                                                                                                          © BNP Paribas Real Estate Retail Services, December 31, 2018
the other hand, there are the external risks of a noticeably     2.0
                                                                                                                                                                          1.7

                                                                                                                                                                                                  1.7

cooling global economy, which would affect Germany as an
                                                                                                                        1.5

export country and further unsettle both companies and           1.5
consumers. However, the greatest risk, both economically
                                                                                    1.1

                                                                                                                                    0.9

and psychologically, results from an unregulated and cha-        1.0
otic Brexit without any mandatory rules. This would further
                                                                                                                                                            0.5

fuel concerns and fears about the future, both in businesses
                                                                          0.3

                                                                 0.5
                                                                                                                                                0.2

and among consumers. Against this background, a serious
forecast for 2019 can hardly be made at the beginning of
                                                                         2009      2010          2011     2012          2013      2014          2015       2016          2017      2018       2019
the year. It remains to be hoped, however, that reason will                                                                                                                                  Forecast
                                                                 Source: Destatis, forecast: BNP Paribas
ultimately prevail in the case of key risks, which would then
set the course for the successful development of the Ger-
man retail industry next year as well.
RETAIL MARKET GERMANY 2019 OVERVIEW

RETAIL INVESTMENT
  	WEAKER THAN 2017, BUT ABOVE THE                            RETAIL INVESTMENTS IN GERMANY IN 2017 AND 2018
    LONG-TERM AVERAGE                                                 Single investments in million €
Although the retail investment market, with a transaction             Portfolio investments in million €
volume of 11.2 bn €, remains just under 19 % behind the
previous year’s result, it exceeded the ten-year average by    15,000

                                                                                                                                                                                     © BNP Paribas Real Estate Retail Services, December 31, 2018
a good 7 %. In view of the fact that the 10 bn € mark was
broken for the fourth time in a row, while the results be-     12,000
tween 2012 and 2014 fell short of this hurdle, it can be                                          6,042

said that the overall balance is moderate in times of fun-      9,000                                                             4,922

damental transformation processes in the retail landscape.
A look at the size classes shows that the reduction can be      6,000

localised particularly in the segment up to 50 m €, where                                         7,767
                                                                                                                                  6,283
turnover was 26 % lower than in 2017. The most notewor-         3,000

thy transactions, primarily large-volume highstreet proper-
ties in A-cities, include the ensemble Leipziger Platz 14-16                                      2017                            2018
and the shopping centre Das Schloss in Berlin as well as
the Hanseviertel and Karstadt Sports in Hamburg. In addi-
tion to these prominent deals, the merger of Karstadt and      RETAIL INVESTMENTS BY TYPE OF PROPERTY
Kaufhof also had a significant impact on the result. In sum-   in %
mary, single investments accounted for 6.28 bn € (56 %),
while 4.92 bn € (44 %) were invested in portfolios.
                                                                                   12.9

  	DISCOUNT STORES / SUPERMARKETS AHEAD OF RETAIL /                                                                                       	Discount store /
                                                                                                                                             supermarket, discounter
    OFFICE BUILDINGS AND DEPARTMENT STORES                                                                        39.2
                                                                  23.5                                                                       Retail / office building
Compared to the previous year, only the department stores
                                                                                                                                             Department store
emerged as winners in the distribution of turnover among
                                                                                                                                             Shopping centre
the various uses: pushed by the merger of Karstadt and
Kaufhof, they increased by 151 % to 2.64 bn € and thus ac-
                                                                                          24.4
count for almost 24 %. All other types of property could
not build on their results from 2017 and have to accept
reductions of 30 to 40 %. Nevertheless, discount stores and                                                              © BNP Paribas Real Estate Retail Services, December 31, 2018

supermarkets (a good 39 %) and retail / office buildings (a
good 24 %) maintained their positions within the ranking
ahead of department stores. Shopping centres (just under
13 %) settled for fourth place due to the increasing uncer-    RETAIL INVESTMENTS BY € CATEGORY
tainty in this segment.                                               Single investments in %, total 6,283 million €
                                                                      Portfolio investments in %, total 4,922 million €

   	DEALS BELOW AND ABOVE 100 M € BALANCE
                                                                                                                                                      53.5

                                                               60.0
                                                                                                                                                                                  © BNP Paribas Real Estate Retail Services, December 31, 2018

     EACH OTHER OUT
                                                               50.0
The overall balanced development of the retail investment
market is underlined by the fact that, as in the previous
                                                               40.0
year, transactions under and over – 100 m € each account
                                                                                                                                                  26.8

for half of the total result. In the sales segment with at
                                                                                                           23.7

                                                                                                                                                                         23.5
                                                                                           23.4

                                                               30.0

least half a billion euros (a good 10 %), only the merger of
                                                                                                                                   15.2

                                                               20.0
Karstadt and Kaufhof can be reported. The two midrange
                                                                          10.9

                                                                                                                               10.5
                                                                                                               7.9

categories between 25 and 100 m € together have a share        10.0
                                                                                              3.5
                                                                             1.1

of 30 %, while smaller transactions up to 25 m € generate a
                                                                                                                                                                     0.0

fifth of the volume.                                                     < 10         10 – < 25           25 – < 50          50 – < 100          100 – < 500          ≥ 500
                                                                       million €      million €           million €          million €            million €          million €

                                                                                                                                                                           6|7
A-LOCATIONS WITH HIGHER SHARE OF TURNOVER                   RETAIL INVESTMENTS IN THE A-LOCATIONS 2017 AND 2018
In contrast to the overall market, the A-locations (Berlin,           2017 in million €, total 4,149 million €
Cologne, Düsseldorf, Frankfurt, Hamburg, Munich, Stuttgart)           2018 in million €, total 4,007 million €
were almost able to maintain their previous year’s results:
With an investment volume of 4.0 bn €, their result is only     2,000

                                                                                                                                                                   © BNP Paribas Real Estate Retail Services, December 31, 2018
3 % lower than in 2017, with Berlin (1.43 bn €) and Hamburg

                                                                            1,430
(911 m €), the two largest German cities, leading the way.
                                                                1,500
For Hamburg, this is even the best result in recent years.
Cologne (390 m €), Munich (358 m €), Stuttgart (355 m €)

                                                                         995

                                                                                                                              911
                                                                                                                             874

                                                                                                                                     837
and Düsseldorf (345 m €), where more than 300 m € was           1,000

invested each, follow some way behind. Only the Main me-

                                                                                      570

                                                                                                                533
tropolis Frankfurt, with 217 m €, achieved a significantly

                                                                                        390

                                                                                                                                           358

                                                                                                                                                          355
                                                                                                      345
                                                                 500
lower volume compared to the other cities.

                                                                                                                  217

                                                                                                                                                       177
                                                                                                    163
                                                                         Berlin      Cologne   Düsseldorf Frankfurt      Hamburg    Munich            Stuttgart
  	LIVELY MARKET ACTIVITY ALSO IN SMALL TOWNS
    THANKS TO RETAIL PARK SEGMENT
In terms of single investments, smaller cities with up to       SINGLE INVESTMENTS BY CITY CATEGORY
100,000 inhabitants are and remain the second-strongest         in %
category after A-locations (just under 42 %)with a share of
almost 29 %. This is a clear indication that not only high-     100

street properties but also conveniently located retail parks
                                                                                      34.6
as well as supermarkets and discounters with tenants of          80
                                                                                                                                    41.7

                                                                                                                                                                   © BNP Paribas Real Estate Retail Services, December 31, 2018
high credit rating offer attractive investment opportunities
                                                                                                      A-locations
outside the metropolises. One of the most significant trans-
                                                                 60                                   	>250,000 inhabitants
actions of a retail park is Kauf Park Göttingen, which for                            21.4
                                                                                                                                    11.4
                                                                                                       00,000–250,000
                                                                                                      1
this type of use represents one of the largest investments                                            inhabitants
of recent years. By contrast, major cities between 100,000       40
                                                                                      20.0
RETAIL MARKET GERMANY 2019 OVERVIEW

of just under 35 %, international investors remained at the      DEVELOPMENT OF NET PRIME YIELD
level of the previous year and below the value reported for      in %
the entire commercial real estate market (41 %).                       Retail / office buildings*       Shopping centres
                                                                       Specialist retail centres        Specialised discount stores

  	STABLE PRICE DEVELOPMENT AFTER THE                           8.0

                                                                                                                                                                        © BNP Paribas Real Estate Retail Services, December 31, 2018
    YIELD COMPRESSION
                                                                 7.0
After the continuous yield compression of the previous
years and the already very high prices, the net prime yields     6.0
for highstreet properties initially reached their peak and
have been correspondingly stable over the past 12 months.        5.0

Berlin and Munich, which are the only locations below the
                                                                 4.0
3 % limit with 2.90 %, remain at the top of the city compari-
son. Hamburg (3.00 %) and Frankfurt (3.10 %) follow closely      3.0
behind. The two metropolises Düsseldorf and Cologne, as
well as Stuttgart, are quoted at 3.20 %.                                 2009    2010     2011   2012   2013   2014       2015       2016       2017       2018
                                                                 * Ø A-locations (Berlin, Cologne, Düsseldorf, Frankfurt, Hamburg, Munich, Stuttgart)

In the other market segments, only retail parks and single
specialised discount stores have become more expensive
since the middle of the year. In both cases, yields have fall-   RETAIL INVESTMENTS BY ORIGIN OF CAPITAL
en by 10 basis points to 4.50 % and 5.30 %, respectively, and    in %
a further yield compression cannot be excluded. Shopping
                                                                                     1.5 0.8
centres, on the other hand, are just as expensive as they
were 12 months ago at a peak of 4.00 %, and slightly falling                        3.6

prices cannot be ruled out here.                                                                                                   Germany
                                                                                                                                   Europe
                                                                       28.7
                                                                                                                                   North America
  	FURTHER TRANSFORMATION PROCESSES:                                                                                              Middle East
    YES, SENSE OF CRISIS: NO                                                                                                       Others
                                                                                                        65.4
Even if the result of the retail investment market in 2018
does not come close to the results of previous years, there
are no signs of real erosion processes. Both highstreet
properties and retail parks continue to be very attractive
to a wide range of investors – provided that criteria such                                                     © BNP Paribas Real Estate Retail Services, December 31, 2018

as location, letting situation and use adaptability are right
to meet future requirements. Especially, the shopping cen-
tre segment in particular demonstrated that the framework
conditions for a successful sales process must be right.
Whether a good result can be reported by the end of 2019
depends in particular on larger portfolio deals, which are
essential for a positive outcome.

                                                                                                                                                                8|9
THE GERMAN RETAIL MARKETS
    RETAIL IN THE MIDST OF CHANGE                                   lease durations demanded by tenants or the structuring of
In no other market segment of the German real estate market         leases that involve risk sharing between tenants and land-
are structures changing as quickly as in the retail sector. The     lords, e. g. through turnover-based rental components, are
situation is characterised on the one hand by real adjustment       now also playing an important role, particularly in the case
processes, but on the other hand also by many uncertainties         of larger units.
and sometimes even fears regarding the future of the high
street. The main driver for many developments and discus-
sions is e-commerce, which is continuing to increase its share          OVERALL DEMAND REMAINS GOOD
of total retail sales and at the same time recording above-         The developments on the letting markets must be viewed in
average growth rates. The online business scores not only           the same differentiated way as the socio-economic framework
with a comfortable order and fast delivery times, but in many       conditions. For example, the top 10 German locations in 2018
cases also with very fair exchange or return conditions. What       with an inner-city take-up of almost 193,000 m² and almost
it does not offer, however, is the emotional shopping expe-         430 lettings / openings exceeded their previous year’s results
rience of shopping, combined with upstream or downstream            by 14 % and 3 % respectively, whereas the nationwide result
activities, which as an overall package result in a pleasant        with 608,000 m² (-8 %) and around 1,170 deals (-11 %) shows
and interesting leisure time organisation. This will not change     declines. In a more ambitious competitive environment, larger
in the future. Nevertheless, the increasing competitive pres-       shopping metropolises with a wide range of complementary
sure from e-commerce is leading to adjustments – whether            catering and leisure facilities appear to be better off than
in terms of rents, contract terms and conditions, re-letting        many B- and C-cities. But this development does not apply
opportunities or retail concepts. But changes always offer op-      across the board, as many smaller markets also offer attrac-
portunities, which the high street must and will face, just like    tive framework conditions and are therefore the focus of re-
other sectors in the past.                                          tailers. Evidence of this is that B-cities are increasingly being
                                                                    considered in the expansion plans of brands such as Zalando
                                                                    (e. g. Münster) or the Dutch department store chain Hema
    TOP RENTS STABLE TO FALLING                                     (e. g. Dortmund and Bonn). In the e-commerce age the trend
As already observed last year the pressure on rents has con-        for catering to continue stirring up the letting market, which
tinued and reflects the increasing competition from online          was clearly dominated by clothing in the past, continued in
business. However, a differentiated picture emerges here.           2018. Against this background, catering was able to increase
Many locations were also able to maintain the rent level, as        its share of contracts concluded in 2018 by 4 percentage
the pressure on demand that had been built up for a long time       points to more than 18 % over the last five years. Among the
has remained unchanged due to the very limited supply in the        most prominent players in this sector are Hans im Glück and
top locations and retailers absolutely being keen to occupy         L’Osteria, as well as the Cafe Extrablatt, which is not hesi-
these specific locations. In 38 of 64 cities regularly analysed     tant towards opening premises in small towns. Nevertheless,
by BNP Paribas Real Estate, the top rent has not changed.           the fashion sector dominated in 2018 with a good 30 % of all
However, 24 cities showed decreases. The reductions in the          recorded lettings / openings in city centre locations and thus
individual locations range between 2 and 11 %. In contrast          remains the most important player in the retail landscape.
to the previous year, two cities (Saarbrücken and Düsseldorf)
also recorded slightly rising top rents. The Rhineland metrop-
olis in particular was right at the top of the expansion list for     	GERMANY REMAINS A SAFE HAVEN ON
many chain stores. Across all the cities analysed, prime rents          EXPANSION LISTS
fell by just under 2 % compared to the year before. The only A-     When addressing e-commerce as an antagonist of high street
locations that recorded slight declines were Berlin (-3 %) and      retailing, it should not be forgotten that digitisation is chang-
Hamburg (-2 %). The most expensive location remains Munich          ing retail landscapes not only in Germany but globally, which
(370 €/m²), followed by Berlin (310 €/m²), Frankfurt (300 €/        is having a very different impact at national and even city lev-
m²), Düsseldorf (280 €/m²), Stuttgart (275 €/m²), Hamburg           el. Against this background, Germany, with its numerous well-
(270 €/m²) and Cologne (265 €/m²). It should be noted, how-         positioned inner cities that are characterised by the popula-
ever, that the top rent by definition only applies to a 100 m²      tion but also by tourists and students, continues to be valued
standard shop with ideal conditions and thus represents only        by international retailers as an economic engine in Europe.
a very small market segment. Other trends, such as shorter          A particular feature of the 2018 letting activities was that a
RETAIL MARKET GERMANY 2019 OVERVIEW

large number of renowned retailers such as Uniqlo, Topshop,                           ment store giants Karstadt and Kaufhof will use to present
Arket, Zalando and JD Sports, whose concepts are designed                             themselves after the merger, on the other hand, remains as
for larger shops, noticeably increased their pace of expansion.                       uncertain as it is exciting.
If one speaks about active labels, the way quickly leads to De-
cathlon, whereby the French sports manufacturer, unlike the
aforementioned players, is not primarily focused on central                               OUTLOOK
locations, but primarily on shopping centres as well as retail                        The many changes and adaptations to which city centre re-
park locations and city districts. The fact that fashion labels                       tail will continue to be confronted with do not only contain
in particular are pushing their way into Germany from abroad                          risks but also opportunities. The shopping experience itself
does not mean that brands from other sectors are not also                             will continue to be of great importance to many customers
continuing to expand their branch network in Germany: in this                         in the future and will stand for leisure quality that cannot be
context, the expansive trio of eyewear suppliers Ace & Tate,                          offered by even the best organised online trade. This fact is
VIU and Mister Spex, as well as the Danish furniture store                            underlined by the fact that more and more online retailers are
Søstrene Grene, the Dutch department store chain Hema and                             also opening high street shops, as they have recognised that
the Swedish watch brand Daniel Wellington are worth men-                              the future of retail is likely to lie in an intelligent combina-
tioning. In addition to retailers who have pushed ahead with                          tion of vertical distribution structures in order to satisfy the
their expansion, there are also those who are withdrawing                             differentiated needs and expectations of consumers. It must
from Germany or closing branches: Clas Ohlson and Stadium                             also be borne in mind that it is not only retail that has to face
will no longer be represented in Hamburg and thus in Ger-                             changing ways of working and living. The office markets are
many in the future, while retailers such as Esprit, Tom Tailor                        also confronted with major challenges, for example in con-
and Habitat are increasingly giving up shops. The fact that a                         nection with the rapidly growing importance of coworking
restructuring can also mean a new beginning is proven by the                          concepts. The fundamental demand on the part of retailers
clothing company SinnLeffers, which is not afraid to reposi-                          remains strong enough to actively and successfully develop
tion itself as SiNN. The joint new concept that the depart-                           city centre retail.

INDEX DEVELOPMENT OF TOP RENTS BY CITY CATEGORY* (2009 = 100)
      A-locations      >500,000        250,000–500,000           100,000–250,000
KEY MARKET FIGURES FOR THE MOST IMPORTANT RETAIL LOCATIONS IN GERMANY

                                     Purchasing      Turnover                                                         Top rent          Top rent           Purchase price
                       Population
           City                     power index        index                 Prime shopping streets                     (net)             (net)              multiplier
                       01.01.2018
                                        2018           2018                                                            2017¹)            2018¹)           retail property²)

                                    per inhabitant per inhabitant
                        absolute                                                                                   in € / m² / month in € / m² / month   from            to³)
                                      (DE = 100)     (DE = 100)
Aachen                   246,272         94.3          118.2        Adalbertstrasse, Krämerstrasse                       110               100           17.0           20.5
Augsburg                 292,851         98.1          124.1        Annastrasse                                          100                90           17.0           20.0
Bad Homburg               53,884        149.9          120.7        Louisenstrasse                                        60                55           16.5           18.0
Berlin                 3,613,495         91.2          102.6        Tauentzienstrasse, Kurfürstendamm,                   320               310           23.5           31.0
                                                                    Friedrichstrasse, Alexanderplatz, Hackescher
                                                                    Markt, Schlossstrasse
Bielefeld                332,552         92.9          124.7        Bahnhofstrasse                                       135               135           16.5           19.0
Bochum                   365,529         94.0          116.3        Kortumstrasse                                         80                80           14.5           16.5
Bonn                     325,490        110.5          115.9        Remigiusstrasse, Sternstrasse                        130               120           17.5           22.0
Braunschweig             248,023        106.4          150.8        Hutfiltern, Damm, Schuhstrasse, Sack                  95                90           17.0           20.0
Bremen                   568,006         92.4          110.4        Obernstrasse, Sögestrasse                            120               115           17.5           20.5
Chemnitz                 246,855         88.4          105.2        Strasse der Nationen                                  50                50           13.0           15.0
Cologne                1,080,394        105.4          130.4        Schildergasse, Hohe Strasse, Neumarkt,               265               265           23.5           29.0
                                                                    Ehrenstrasse, Breite Strasse, Mittelstrasse,
                                                                    Wallrafplatz
Darmstadt                158,254        108.3          118.7        Ernst-Ludwig-Strasse                                  75                75           15.0           18.0
Dortmund                 586,600         91.5          114.8        Westenhellweg, Ostenhellweg                          230               230           18.0           22.0
Dresden                  551,072         90.9          108.1        Prager Strasse, Seestrasse                           100               100           18.0           22.0
Duisburg                 498,110         82.8           92.7        Königstrasse, Kuhstrasse                              45                40           13.0           15.5
Düsseldorf               617,280        117.1          133.7        Königsallee, Schadowstrasse, Flinger                 275               280           23.5           29.0
                                                                    Strasse, Mittelstrasse, Grabenstrasse
Erfurt                   212,988         91.8          105.1        Anger                                                 90                90           17.0           20.0
Erlangen                 110,998        119.7          128.4        Nürnberger Strasse, Hauptstrasse                      65                60           15.0           18.0
Essen                    583,393         96.4          113.5        Kettwiger Strasse, Limbecker Strasse                  90                80           17.0           21.5
Flensburg                 88,519         89.0          159.6        Holm                                                  85                85           15.0           18.0
Frankfurt am Main        746,878        113.9          116.9        Zeil, Grosse Bockenheimer Strasse,                   300               300           23.5           29.5
                                                                    Goethestrasse, Biebergasse, Steinweg,
                                                                    Kaiserstrasse/Rossmarkt
Freiburg im Breisgau     229,636         96.5          146.1        Kaiser-Joseph-Strasse                                180               180           17.5           20.5
Gelsenkirchen            260,305         79.3           90.7        Bahnhofstrasse                                        40                40           12.5           15.5
Göttingen                119,529         94.8          133.8        Weender Strasse, Groner Strasse                       90                90           15.0           17.0
Hagen                    187,730         90.1          111.5        Elberfelder Strasse, Mittelstrasse                    40                40           12.5           15.0
Halle (Saale)            239,173         83.2           84.9        Leipziger Strasse                                     70                65           12.5           15.5
Hamburg                1,830,584        109.7          122.6        Spitalerstrasse, Mönckebergstrasse,                  275               270           24.5           30.5
                                                                    Neuer Wall, Gerhofstrasse, Poststrasse,
                                                                    Grosse Bleichen, Jungfernstieg,
                                                                    Hohe Bleichen, Gänsemarkt
Hannover                 535,061        101.4          128.4        Grosse/Kleine Packhofstrasse, Georgstrasse,          200               195           19.0           23.5
                                                                    Bahnhofstrasse, Karmarschstrasse,
                                                                    Luisenstrasse
Heidelberg               160,601         97.9          117.6        Hauptstrasse                                         120               115           19.5           22.5
Ingolstadt               135,244        118.3          174.4        Ludwigstrasse                                         70                65           15.5           19.0
Karlsruhe                311,919        102.4          121.8        Kaiserstrasse                                        100                95           19.0           22.0
Kassel                   200,736         92.7          134.8        Obere Königsstrasse                                  115               115           15.0           17.5
Kiel                     247,943         87.8          123.0        Holstenstrasse                                        70                70           15.0           17.5
Koblenz                  113,844         98.4          170.1        Löhrstrasse                                           80                75           14.0           16.0
Krefeld                  226,699         99.0          130.2        Hochstrasse                                           50                50           14.0           16.5
Leipzig                  581,980         87.4           93.4        Petersstrasse, Grimmaische Strasse,                  120               120           18.5           23.0
                                                                    Nikolaistrasse, Hainstrasse, Neumarkt
Leverkusen               163,577        102.9          110.3        Wiesdorfer Platz                                      35                35           18.0           22.0
Lübeck                   216,318         91.1          141.0        Breite Strasse, Holstenstrasse                        90                90           18.0           21.5
Magdeburg                238,478         88.1          106.1        Breiter Weg                                           30                30           14.0           15.5
Mainz                    215,110        106.3          115.5        Am Brand, Schusterstrasse, Stadthausstrasse          110               110           17.0           20.0
Mannheim                 307,997         99.6          151.0        Planken, Kurpfalzstrasse                             160               150           18.5           22.5
Moers                    103,949         99.0          112.3        Steinstrasse                                          60                60           13.0           15.0
Mönchengladbach          262,188         93.0          115.7        Hindenburgstrasse                                     40                40           13.5           15.5
Munich                 1,456,039        134.3          149.3        Kaufingerstrasse, Marienplatz, Neuhauser             370               370           24.5           31.5
                                                                    Strasse, Maximilian-, Wein-, Theatiner-,
                                                                    Residenzstrasse, Sendlinger Strasse, Tal,
                                                                    Hohenzollernstrasse, Leopoldstrasse
Münster                 313,559         102.6          140.0        Ludgeristrasse, Prinzipalmarkt, Salzstrasse,         190               190           18.5           22.0
                                                                    Rothenburg
Neuss                   153,810         106.9          121.0        Büchel, Niederstrasse, Oberstrasse                    50                50           13.0           15.5
Nuremberg               515,201         104.0          135.4        Karolinenstrasse, Breite Gasse,                      150               150           19.0           22.5
                                                                    Kaiserstrasse, Königstrasse
Offenbach am Main       167,081          93.0           97.8        Frankfurter Strasse                                   40                40           13.5           15.5
Oldenburg               167,081         100.4          144.6        Achternstrasse, Lange Strasse                        100                95           14.5           17.0
Osnabrück               164,374          96.7          147.2        Grosse Strasse                                       135               130           17.0           20.0
Paderborn               149,075          94.7          106.5        Westernstrasse, Marienplatz                           90                90           14.5           16.5
Potsdam                 175,710          98.2           94.3        Brandenburger Strasse                                 70                70           17.0           20.0
RETAIL MARKET GERMANY 2019 OVERVIEW

                                                Purchasing        Turnover                                                        Top rent          Top rent            Purchase price
                               Population
            City                               power index          index                Prime shopping streets                     (net)             (net)               multiplier
                               01.01.2018
                                                   2018             2018                                                           2017¹)            2018¹)            retail property²)

                                              per inhabitant per inhabitant
                                absolute                                                                                       in € / m² / month in € / m² / month   from              to³)
                                                (DE = 100)     (DE = 100)
 Recklinghausen                 113,360             94.8            100.0      Breite Strasse, Markt, Kunibertistrasse                30                30           12.5             14.5
 Regensburg                     150,894            111.8            166.6      Pfauengasse, Weisse-Lilien-Strasse,                    70                65           16.0             19.0

                                                                                                                                                                                                 © BNP Paribas Real Estate Retail Services, December 31, 2018
                                                                               Königsstrasse
 Rostock                        208,409             86.3             96.3      Kröpeliner Strasse                                     80                75           15.0             17.5
 Saarbrücken                    180,966             92.0            140.4      Bahnhofstrasse                                         75                80           14.0             16.5
 Schwerin                        95,797             90.3            107.4      Marienplatz                                            30                30           12.5             15.0
 Siegen                         102,337             92.4            154.8      Bahnhofstrasse                                         40                40           12.5             15.0
 Stuttgart                      632,743            113.2            130.9      Königstrasse, Stiftstrasse, Calwer Strasse,           275               275           23.5             29.0
                                                                               Schulstrasse, Kirchstrasse
 Trier                          110,013             88.4            185.5      Simeonstrasse, Hauptmarkt, Brotstrasse,               125               125           17.5             21.5
                                                                               Grabenstrasse, Fleischstrasse
 Ulm                            125,596            110.7            144.7      Bahnhofstrasse, Hirschstrasse                         135               135           15.5             18.5
 Wiesbaden                      278,654            110.9            122.9      Kirchgasse, Langgasse, Marktstrasse,                  140               135           18.0             22.5
                                                                               Wilhelmstrasse
 Wuppertal                      353,590             94.0             93.5      Poststrasse, Alte Freiheit                             75                70           14.5             16.5
 Würzburg                       126,635            103.0            201.4      Schönbornstrasse, Kürschnerhof                        135               135           18.0             21.5

¹) Applies to typical 100 m² standard shop with following quality features:                     ²) Applies to prime area
    ▸▸ most frequented area in the city                                                              ▸▸ at least 50 % of rental income from retail premises
    ▸▸ single-storey rectangular ground-plan
    ▸▸ step-free entrance                                                                        ³) In individual cases, these multipliers can sometimes be considerably higher as the result
    ▸▸ at least 6m frontage                                                                          of special circumstances.

                                                                                                 Sources: GfK Geomarketing GmbH, BNP Paribas Real Estate, Einwohner- / Gemeindeverzeichnis

DEFINITIONS
    GFK PURCHASING POWER INDEX                                                                    of residence is used to calculate the GfK retail turnover. It
The GfK purchasing power provides information on the dis-                                         therefore reflects retail consumer spending at the point of
posable income of consumers by place of residence. The GfK                                        sale.
purchasing power can be described in simplified terms as the
sum of all net income which is available to the population in                                     The index value always relates to the national average. An
a year and region. It is therefore the most important indicator                                   index of 110 means that retail turnover per inhabitant in
for consumption potential in this region.                                                         this region is 10 % above the national average. An index of
                                                                                                  90 means that retail turnover per inhabitant in this region is
The index value always relates to the national average. An                                        10 % below the national average.
index of 110 means that inhabitants in this region have 10 %
more purchasing power than the national average. An index                                            GFK CENTRALITY INDEX
of 90 means that the purchasing power of inhabitants in this                                      The GfK centrality index provides retailers with an objective
region is 10 % below the national average.                                                        benchmark to identify which cities are managing to attract
                                                                                                  and retain a particularly high level of purchasing power with
    GFK RETAIL TURNOVER INDEX                                                                     their existing range of retail services. A centrality index of
The GfK retail turnover shows the forecasted retail turnover                                      100 means that a city’s inflow and outflow of purchasing
in the individual regions. In contrast to GfK purchasing power,                                   power are in balance. The index is therefore of great impor-
retail spending by the place of purchase and not by the place                                     tance for location planning and assessment.

                                                                                                                                                                                     12 | 13
MOST ACTIVE
                                                              RETAILERS 2018
                                                                       Different sectors –
                                                                       different
                                                                       expansion profiles*

                 INTERNATIONAL FASHION LABELS                                     CATERING COMPANIES

Hunkemöller                                                   15   Hans im Glück                              12
         Only                                                 15   Cafe Extrablatt                        9
 Jack & Jones                               7                             L’Osteria                   6
    TK Maxx                                 7                         dean&david                  5
Boggi Milano                          5                                    Subway                 5
   JD Sports                          5                                 Five Guys             4
        Levi’s                        5                                 Starbucks             4
                                                                   Kentucky Fried​​ 
  Vero Moda                           5                                  Chicken          3
       Norah                      4                                 Mia Gelateria         3
        Arket                 3                                           Nordsee         3

  *Number of leases / openings nationwide in city locations
RETAIL MARKET GERMANY 2019 OVERVIEW

             BODYCARE / HEALTH                                       SELECTED RETAILERS
                                                                     OF OTHER SECTORS

   Rossmann                                        12     Søstrene Grene                              11
          dm                                     11                Hema                           8
       Rituals                                 10               Osiander                          8
    Ace & Tate                             6                        Rewe                          8
    Fielmann                               6                   Decathlon                      7
          VIU                              6            Daniel Wellington                 6
    Sephora*                           5                     Hugendubel                   6
 Mister Spex                       4                               Depot              5
     Douglas                  3                             Doc Martens           3
  eyes + more                 3                           Lindt & Sprüngli        3

*including shop-in-shop-concepts

                                                                             50 %
                                                                             of the most active
                                                                             retailers in the
                                                                             bodycare / health
                                                                             segment are
                                                                             eyewear labels.

                                                                                                           14 | 15
AACHEN
                   “Aachen achieves the second-highest footfall in the
                     city category of 100,000 to 250,000 inhabitants.”

Aachen lies in an exposed location, borders on the Nether-                                                    and repeatedly puts the Karlstadt in an international spotlight.
lands and Belgium and has always played an important role                                                     The city and the retail industry benefit from this reputation, as
in the history of Europe. This was last made clear in 2019 with                                               the tourists attracted are an important economic factor.
the signing of the Aachen Treaty between Germany and France

OVERVIEW OF A-LOCATIONS

 Location                           Category              Length                    Footfall / h               Top rent         Chain-store ratio     Selected new leases / openings

 Adalbertstrasse                   Mass market             550 m                        5,054                  100 €/m²               85 %            Fielmann (600 m²)

 Holzgraben                        Mass market             110 m                        1,631                   35 €/m²               60 %            Brax (280 m²)

                                                                                                                                                              © BNP Paribas Real Estate Retail Services, December 31, 2018

    RENTS IN DOWNTOWN UNDER PRESSURE                                                                          several lettings which prove that retailers in Aachen continue
Uncertainties about the further development of the city centre                                                to see potential in the long term. The relocation of the tex-
are causing demand to be restrained in some areas. Although                                                   tile company SiNN to the former Horten building (Komphaus-
the top location Adalbertstrasse is still in demand, especial-                                                badstrasse) planned for 2021, for example, is likely to vitalise
ly in the area around the Aquis Plaza shopping centre, the                                                    the Dahmengraben. Overall, owners in many places are now
maximum rent (100 €/m²) is coming under noticeable pres-                                                      trying to retain tenants by offering discounts or finding new
sure (-9 %). In particular, uncertain development sites, such                                                 users. This in turn offers smaller and young concepts in par-
as the old Wehmeyer House, are weighing down sentiment                                                        ticular the opportunity to secure new shops in the cathedral
both in Aachen’s main shopping mile and in other locations.                                                   city. The retail landscape is therefore in a state of upheaval
In several places, retail space is also vanishing in favour of                                                and consolidation, which at the same time offers opportunities
alternative use concepts. All the more pleasing are therefore                                                 for innovation and further development.

DEVELOPMENT OF TOP RENT AND PURCHASE PRICE MULTIPLIER                                                         TOP RENT – INTER-CITY COMPARISON
   Top rent in € / m²            Purchase price multiplier                                                          in €/m²

250 €                                                                                                25.0     150
                                                                                                                       130

                                                                                                                                    125

                                                                                                                                                120

200 €                                                                                                20.0     120
                                                                                                                                                                            95

                                                                                                                                                            100
                                                                                                                                                                                              90

150 €                                                                                                15.0      90
                                                                                                                                                                                                                80

100 €                                                                                                10.0      60

 50 €                                                                                                 5.0      30

            2009   2010   2011   2012   2013   2014     2015       2016 2017 2018                                   Osnabrück      Trier       Bonn        Aachen       Karlsruhe           Braun­            Essen
                                                                                                                                                                                           schweig
                                               © BNP Paribas Real Estate Retail Services, December 31, 2018                                                   © BNP Paribas Real Estate Retail Services, December 31, 2018
RETAIL MARKET GERMANY 2019 AACHEN

A-LOCATIONS WITH THE MOST IMPORTANT KEY INDICATORS

                                                                                                                                                                                Top rents € / m² / month
                    Footfall / h
                                                                                                                                                                                Adalbertstrasse                         100
                                                                                                                                                                                Holzgraben                               35
                    Mass market

                                                                                                                      N      BE
                                     Rathaus

                                                                                                                    DAHMENGRA
                                                                                                         1,631
                                                                                                                                                        H&M
                                                KRÄMERSTR.

                                                                                                                                    5,054
                                                                                                 BEN
                                                                                                   A
                                                                                               ZGR
                                                                                            HOL

                                                                                                                                   ADALBERTSTR.
                                                                                                                                                                          Aquis Plaza
                                                   Dom                                                               Galeria
                                                                                                                     Kaufhof
                                                                           Elisengarten

                                                                                                      Elisengalerie
          Day of count: 09.06.2018

   NEW LETTINGS PROVIDE FOR REVITALISATION                                                                                that opened in the old town. In Adalbertstrasse, Fielmann’s
The lively area between the catering dominated Markt and                                                                  enlargement is particularly striking: the optician has moved to
Münsterplatz squares is dynamic. In the Krämerstrasse, which                                                              the neighbouring store and operates a shop of around 600 m²
connects both squares, four leases from different sectors could                                                           there. Despite the continuing uncertainties, we can therefore
be observed. In addition, the Café Isabella (Münsterplatz) and                                                            look back on an overall pleasing year.
the restaurant Karl’s (Markt) are two new catering concepts

SOCIO-ECONOMIC DATA                                                                                                       REGISTERED LETTINGS

                                                      Aachen                           Germany                                                                                 Top sector                   Chain-store ratio
                                                  2018     Trend                    2018     Trend                                                Number       Take-up
                                                                                                                                                                                (take-up)                   (internationality)

                                                                                                                                                                            Bodycare / Health
 Population (000)                                 246                             82,792                                     A-locations total      7          1,570 m²        (1,030 m²)                     100 % (29 %)
                                                                                                                                                                            Bodycare / Health
 Employees subject to social insurance (000)      133                             32,870                                     Adalbertstrasse        2           680 m²          (680 m²)
                                                                                                                                                                                                               100 % (50 %)

 Unemployment rate (%)                             7.0                               5.2                                     Holzgraben             1           280 m²      Clothing (280 m²)                   100 % (0 %)
                                                                                                                                                                            Bodycare / Health
 Purchasing power index                           94.3                             100.0                                     Other A-locations      4           610 m²          (350 m²)                       100 % (25 %)

 Turnover ratio                                  118.2                             100.0
                                                                                                                             Other locations        12        21,380 m²    Clothing (10,530 m²)                  67 % (8 %)
 Centrality ratio                                 1.25                              1.00                                                                                     © BNP Paribas Real Estate Retail Services, December 31, 2018

 Overnight stays 2017 (million)                    1.0                             459.5

                                        TREND 2019

 Top rent                                      Demand total

 Supply                                        Demand international

 Key money                                     Chain-store ratio

                                                     © BNP Paribas Real Estate Retail Services, December 31, 2018

                                                                                                                                                                                                                        16 | 17
BERLIN
                    “Nowhere were more shops let and opened in 2018
                         than in the capital’s prime locations.”

Like no other German city, Berlin is in the focus of retailers.                                                  are being brought into play more and more frequently and
Nevertheless, there are also signs of a shift in the capital from                                                extensively, e.g. as expansion costs or rent-free periods. And
a landlord to a tenant market. The letting market is booming                                                     lease durations are also tending to become shorter.
in principle, but the balance of power has changed: incentives

OVERVIEW OF A-LOCATIONS

 Location                            Category                Length                    Footfall / h               Top rent       Chain-store ratio     Selected new leases / openings

 Tauentzienstrasse                  Mass market               500 m                        6,061                  310 €/m²             97 %            Hugendubel (1,500 m²)

                                    Mass market                                            5,948                  220 €/m²                             Arket (1,800 m²), Muji (1,720 m²),
 Kurfürstendamm                      Upmarket                3,500 m                                              190 €/m²             89 %            Five Guys (330 m²), Rimowa (200 m²),
                                      Luxury                                               1,473                  185 €/m²                             LIU JO (110 m²), Pikolinos (70 m²)

 Alexanderplatz                     Mass market               300 m                        4,670                  190 €/m²             89 %            Uniqlo (820 m²)

 Rosenthaler Strasse                Mass market               500 m                        3,370                  110 €/m²             73 %            Hunkemöller (200 m²), Oro Vivo (160 m²)

                                                                                                                                                       Arket (570 m²), Brax (170 m²),
 Neue Schönhauser Strasse           Mass market               200 m                        1,909                  110 €/m²             94 %
                                                                                                                                                       Daniel Wellington (75 m²), Dr. Martens (60 m²)
                                   Mass market/                                                                                                        Marcell von Berlin (860 m²), Vapiano (520 m²),
 Friedrichstrasse                                            3,300 m                       3,729                   85 €/m²             91 %
                                    Upmarket                                                                                                           Stadtsalat (400 m²), Lush (200 m²)

 Schlossstrasse                     Mass market              1,700 m                       3,208                   85 €/m²             84 %            HIT (2,500 m²), Hema (1,300 m²)

 Wilmersdorfer Strasse              Mass market              1,900 m                       4,685                   75 €/m²             80 %            Decathlon (3,000 m²)

 Münzstrasse                        Mass market               230 m                           –                    70 €/m²             72 %            New Era (220 m²), Ivy & Oak (70 m²)

                                                                                                                                                                © BNP Paribas Real Estate Retail Services, December 31, 2018

    TOP RENTS DECLINING IN SEVERAL LOCATIONS                                                                     are quoted for Tauentzienstrasse at its peak. Kurfürsten­
The pressure on high street retailers does not leave the rents                                                   damm is also on a high long-term level with 220 €/m² (-8 %)
untouched. In several locations the top rent could not main-                                                     in the mass market location, 190 €/m² in the upmarket seg-
tain its level. However, it must also be taken into account that                                                 ment (-12 %) and 185 €/m² for the luxury part (stable). In
this is still at a high level and that Berlin is, after Munich, the                                              this respect, a normalisation can be assumed in this context.
country’s most expensive city. For example, 310 €/m² (-3 %)                                                      The Alexanderplatz, where the renovated Alexanderhaus has

DEVELOPMENT OF TOP RENT AND PURCHASE PRICE MULTIPLIER                                                            TOP RENT – INTER-CITY COMPARISON
   Top rent in € / m²             Purchase price multiplier                                                            in €/m²
                                                                                                                          370

350 €                                                                                                   35.0     400

300 €                                                                                                   30.0     350
                                                                                                                                                 300

                                                                                                                                    310
                                                                                                                                                              280

                                                                                                                                                                              275

                                                                                                                                                                                                270

                                                                                                                 300
                                                                                                                                                                                                                  265

250 €                                                                                                   25.0
                                                                                                                 250
200 €                                                                                                   20.0
                                                                                                                 200
150 €                                                                                                   15.0
                                                                                                                 150
100 €                                                                                                   10.0
                                                                                                                 100
 50 €                                                                                                    5.0      50

            2009    2010   2011   2012   2013   2014       2015       2016 2017 2018                                    Munich     Berlin     Frankfurt   Düsseldorf      Stuttgart         Hamburg           Cologne

                                                  © BNP Paribas Real Estate Retail Services, December 31, 2018                                                  © BNP Paribas Real Estate Retail Services, December 31, 2018
RETAIL MARKET GERMANY 2019 BERLIN

A-LOCATIONS WITH THE MOST IMPORTANT KEY INDICATORS

                                                                                                                                                                                                       TR.
                                                                                           Zoologischer
                    Footfall / h

                                                                                                                                                                                                  SER S
                                                                                             Garten

                                                                                                                                                                                                HAU
                                                                                                                                                                                    1,909
                                                                                                                                                               ROSENTHALER STR.

                                                                                                                                                                                                   N
                                                                                                                                                                                              SCHÖ
                    Mass market                      Stilwerk
                                                                                       Bikini
                                                                                       Berlin

                                                                                                                                                                                            ALTE
                                                                          Zoom
                    Upmarket
                                                                                                                                                                                            MÜN
                                                                                                  6,061                                                  Hackesche Höfe                                     Galeria Primark
                                                                                                                                                                                               ZSTR
                    Luxury
                                                                                                   TAU                                                                                             .
                                                                 5,948                                                                                                                                      Kaufhof

                                                                                                       ENTZ
                                                                                                           IENS

                                                                                                                                                                                                                             ATZ
                                                                                                               TR.

                                                                                                                                                                                                                               PL
                            1,473

                                                                                                                                                                                                                           DER
                                                                                                                                                                                  3,370

                                                                                                                                                                                                                       XAN
                                                                                   Karstadt

                                                                                                                                                                                                                    ALE
                                                MM
                                         STENDA
                                                           Neues                                                                             3,729
                                   KURFÜR
                                                           Kudamm Carré
                                                                                                   KaDeWe                                                                                  Fernsehturm
                                                                                                                                                                                                                4,670
                                                                                                                                                                                                                          Alexa
                                                                                                                                                     Upper East
                                                    Schloss-Strassen-
                                                               Center                                                                                Rosmarin Karree
                                                     Forum Steglitz
                                                                                                                                                                                          Top rents € / m² / month
                                                                                                                                FRIEDRICHSTRASSE      Galeries Lafayette
                                                                              SE
                                                                           RAS

                                             Boulevard Berlin
                                                                          SST

                                                                                                                                                                                          Tauentzienstrasse                    310
                                                                         L0S

                                                                                                                                                       The Q                                                                   220
                                                                     SCH

                                                                                                                                                                                          Kurfürstendamm
                                                                                                                                                                                          Alexanderplatz                       190

                                       Das Schloss
                                                                         3,208                                                                                                            Rosenthaler Strasse                  110
          Day of count: 09.06.2018                                                                                                                                                        Friedrichstrasse                      85

r­ ecently opened with Foot Locker, the Japanese fashion chain                                                                LOTS GOING ON ON THE KU’DAMM
 Uniqlo or the make-up brand Nyx, has a stable top rent of                                                                Of the 53 registered lettings or openings, 18 are in Ku’damm
 190 €/m². Catering is currently keen to expand, targeting                                                                alone, which speaks for the strong demand on the one hand,
 tourists and office workers in particular and looking for high-­                                                         but also for the comparatively larger supply available on the
 frequency spots. With this in mind, the Austrian Vegan-Burger                                                            other. New deals in this location include the H&M concept
 chain Swing Kitchen, as well as Cafe Einstein and Vapiano,                                                               ­Arket (1,800 m²), the Japanese furnishing chain Muji (1,720 m²)
 have chosen Friedrichstrasse as their new location.                                                                       and the luxury luggage brand Rimowa (200 m²).

SOCIO-ECONOMIC DATA                                                                                                       REGISTERED LETTINGS

                                                                Berlin                       Germany                                                                                  Top sector                   Chain-store ratio
                                                         2018         Trend               2018     Trend                                              Number      Take-up
                                                                                                                                                                                       (take-up)                   (internationality)

 Population (000)                                        3,613                          82,792                             A-locations total            53        23,930 m²       Clothing (7,190 m²)                   92 % (57 %)

 Employees subject to social insurance (000)             1,476                          32,870                             Kurfürstendamm               18        7,360 m²        Clothing (4,010 m²)                 100 % (61 %)

                                                                                                                           Friedrichstrasse              8        2,460 m²        Catering (1,270 m²)                   88 % (50 %)
 Unemployment rate (%)                                    8.1                              5.2
                                                                                                                                                                                   Bodycare / Health
                                                                                                                           Alexanderplatz                7        3,020 m²             (950 m²)                       100 % (57 %)
 Purchasing power index                                  91.2                            100.0
                                                                                                                           Schlossstrasse                5        6,520 m²          Food (2,980 m²)                     80 % (20 %)
 Turnover ratio                                          102.6                           100.0
                                                                                                                           Neue Schön-
                                                                                                                           hauserstrasse                 5          990 m²         Clothing (740 m²)                  100 % (80 %)
 Centrality ratio                                        1.12                             1.00
                                                                                                                           Rosenthaler
                                                                                                                           Strasse                       3          610 m²         Catering (250 m²)                  100 % (67 %)
 Overnight stays 2017 (million)                          31.2                            459.5
                                                                                                                           Münzstrasse                   2          290 m²         Clothing (290 m²)                    50 % (50 %)
                                               TREND 2019                                                                  Wilmersdorfer                                          Department stores
                                                                                                                           Strasse                       1          590 m²            (590 m²)                       100 % (100 %)
                                                                                                                           Tauentzien­                                            Household articles /
 Top rent                                             Demand total
                                                                                                                           strasse                       1          150 m²        furnishings (150 m²)                   0 % (0 %)

 Supply                                               Demand international                                                 Other A-locations             3        1,940 m²         Leisure (1,000 m²)                   100 % (67 %)

 Key money                                            Chain-store ratio                                                    Other locations              126    101,270 m²           Food (22,490 m²)                    83 % (25 %)
                                                           © BNP Paribas Real Estate Retail Services, December 31, 2018                                                             © BNP Paribas Real Estate Retail Services, December 31, 2018

                                                                                                                                                                                                                               18 | 19
BONN
        “Within the B-cities, Bonn has the second-highest number
               of lettings / openings in A-locations in 2018.”

As the former federal capital, Bonn continues to enjoy a high                                                 largest contiguous pedestrian zones in Germany due to the
degree of popularity and has a large number of cultural, ­leisure                                             high number of old buildings, the possibility of round trips and
and educational facilities. The attractiveness of the city on the                                             the almost complete liberation from car traffic, and provides a
Rhine is also reflected in the positive population trend and the                                              unique flair for strolling and shopping.
rising number of overnight stays. The city centre is one of the

OVERVIEW OF A-LOCATIONS

 Location                           Category              Length                    Footfall / h               Top rent        Chain-store ratio      Selected new leases / openings

 Remigiusstrasse                   Mass market             200 m                        5,302                  120 €/m²              90 %             Topshop (750 m²)

                                                                                                                                                      Only & Sons (310 m²), VIU (290 m²),
 Sternstrasse                      Mass market             300 m                        4,524                  120 €/m²              83 %
                                                                                                                                                      Daniel Wellington (50 m²)
                                                                                                                                                               © BNP Paribas Real Estate Retail Services, December 31, 2018

   DEMAND SHIFTS FOCUS                                                                                        and the extensive renovation of the main railway station, this
The transformation in the German inner cities is not leaving                                                  micro-location will present itself as a new entrance gate to
Bonn untouched either and is causing significant shifts in the                                                the city centre in the future. As the development progresses,
retail market. The increasing focus of customers on conve­                                                    the adjacent Poststrasse is already gaining in importance: for
nience, quality of stay and mixed-use can also be seen in the                                                 many chain stores in particular, the mass market location
new lettings in the pedestrian zone. With Aldi and Rewe, two                                                  is becoming more and more interesting, as they expect the
food retailers have secured space here. While Aldi took space                                                 opening of Primark to generate a higher frequency. This shift
in the Poststrasse near Karstadt as part of a marketplace                                                     in demand is at the expense of other prime locations: both
concept, Rewe will open in the Maximilian-Center, which will                                                  in Remigiusstrasse (-8 %) and Sternstrasse (-4 %), the prime
be launched in autumn 2019 with Primark as an anchor ten-                                                     rent fell to 120 €/m².
ant. Together with the mixed-use development “Urban Soul”

DEVELOPMENT OF TOP RENT AND PURCHASE PRICE MULTIPLIER                                                         TOP RENT – INTER-CITY COMPARISON
   Top rent in € / m²            Purchase price multiplier                                                          in €/m²

250 €                                                                                                25.0     150
                                                                                                                       135

                                                                                                                                   130

                                                                                                                                               125

                                                                                                                                                                             115

                                                                                                                                                                                               115

                                                                                                                                                                                                                 110

200 €                                                                                                20.0     120                                           120

150 €                                                                                                15.0      90

100 €                                                                                                10.0      60

 50 €                                                                                                 5.0      30

            2009   2010   2011   2012   2013   2014     2015       2016 2017 2018                                   Würzburg   Osnabrück      Trier         Bonn          Bremen          Heidelberg           Mainz

                                               © BNP Paribas Real Estate Retail Services, December 31, 2018                                                    © BNP Paribas Real Estate Retail Services, December 31, 2018
RETAIL MARKET GERMANY 2019 BONN

A-LOCATIONS WITH THE MOST IMPORTANT KEY INDICATORS

                                                                                                                                                                             Top rents € / m² / month
                    Footfall / h
                                                                                                                                                                             Remigiusstrasse                         120
                                                                                                                                                                             Sternstrasse                            120
                    Mass market                                                                         Beethoven-
                                                                                                           Haus

                                                                           MediaMarkt
                                                                                                           4,524

                                                                                                                     WENZELGASSE
               Alter Friedhof                                                              STERNSTR.                                    Altes Rathaus

                                                                                                          MARKT
                                                                                        DR

                                                                                                                             Zara
                                                                                          EIE
                                                                                             C
                                                                                             K

                                                                                       Galeria                                                        Stadtgarten

                                                                                                              R.
                                                                                       Kaufhof                SST       5,302
                                                                Karstadt
                                                                                                          IGIU
                                                                                                                                     Kurfürstliches
                                                                                                       REM

                                                                  H&M                                                                Schloss
                                                                                      .
                                                                                  TSTR
                                                                               POS

                                                            Maximilian-                             Bonner
                                                                center                              Münster
                                                                                                                                                        Akademisches
                                                                                                                                                        Kunstmuseum
                                                                                                                                    Hofgarten
                                                                                                                   Kreuzkirche

          Day of count: 09.06.2018                                                                                                                                  Rheinufer

  	MOVEMENT IN THE CITY – VARIOUS                                                                                  strasse has taken the lead, including the expansive watch la-
     LOCATIONS INVOLVED                                                                                             bel Daniel Wellington. In addition to the aforementioned Post-
In the preferred locations, 2018 saw a very lively letting activ-                                                   strasse, A-locations such as Wenzelgasse were also pleased
ity, so that a total of 11 contracts were recorded, 82 % of which                                                   to welcome new retailers. Here the Dutch department store
were concluded by chain stores. With four new tenants, Stern-                                                       Hema opened its doors directly on Markt (500 m²).

SOCIO-ECONOMIC DATA                                                                                                 REGISTERED LETTINGS

                                                         Bonn                         Germany                                                                               Top sector                   Chain-store ratio
                                                  2018           Trend             2018     Trend                                          Number        Take-up
                                                                                                                                                                             (take-up)                   (internationality)

 Population (000)                                 325                            82,792                               A-locations total         11       4,910 m²       Clothing (1,190 m²)                 83 % (50 %)

 Employees subject to social insurance (000)      177                            32,870                               Sternstrasse              4        1,150 m²        Catering (500 m²)                   75 % (75 %)

 Unemployment rate (%)                             6.4                              5.2                               Remigiusstrasse           1          750 m²        Clothing (750 m²)                 100 % (100 %)

 Purchasing power index                          110.5                            100.0                               Other A-locations         7        3,010 m²         Food (1,000 m²)                    86 % (29 %)

 Turnover ratio                                  115.9                            100.0
                                                                                                                      Other locations           17      12,230 m²         Food (5,710 m²)                    88 % (18 %)
 Centrality ratio                                 1.05                             1.00                                                                                   © BNP Paribas Real Estate Retail Services, December 31, 2018

 Overnight stays 2017 (million)                    1.6                            459.5

                                        TREND 2019

 Top rent                                      Demand total

 Supply                                        Demand international

 Key money                                     Chain-store ratio

                                                    © BNP Paribas Real Estate Retail Services, December 31, 2018

                                                                                                                                                                                                                     20 | 21
BRAUNSCHWEIG
                   “Braunschweig achieves the third-highest turnover
                              index within the Top 27.”

Only a few kilometres from the state capital Hannover and                                                     nomic data, continuously growing employment figures and a
standing out with a turnover index of 151, the third highest                                                  high quality of life. The local retail industry reaches far into
level among the considered locations: The Lion City Braun­                                                    the peripheral area, which underlines the centrality index of
schweig manages to unite this. At the same time, Lower                                                        more than 1.4.
Saxony’s second largest city convinces with outstanding eco-

OVERVIEW OF A-LOCATIONS

 Location                           Category              Length                    Footfall / h               Top rent       Chain-store ratio     Selected new leases / openings

 Damm                              Mass market             250 m                        4,084                   90 €/m²             75 %            –

 Hutfiltern                        Mass market             100 m                           –                    90 €/m²             60 %            –

 Sack                              Mass market             150 m                        3,814                   80 €/m²             55 %            Decathlon (2,900 m²), Rewe (1,600 m²)

                                                                                                                                                            © BNP Paribas Real Estate Retail Services, December 31, 2018

    TOP RENTS SLIGHTLY DECLINING                                                                              by recent deals and openings, among which there are also
As in other locations, the competition with e-commerce in the                                                 some true heavyweights. Shortly before Christmas, the French
Braunschweig shopping miles does not leave the rents for re-                                                  sporting goods discounter Decathlon opened a store of almost
tail shops unaffected. In addition, visible vacancies in some                                                 2,900 m² in the former City-Point and the future Robert-Koch
of the A-locations are also depressing prices. Accordingly,                                                   quarter. In March, Rewe will also open a sales area there of
the top rents were not quite able to maintain the previous                                                    around 850 m². The Burggasse development, which plans to
year’s level. They fell in the shopping streets Damm as well                                                  convert the former Burgpassage into an open shopping street,
as in Hut­filtern by 5 €/m² to now 90 €/m² and by 5 €/m² to                                                   could prove to be ground breaking for the further develop-
80 ­€/m² in the micro-location Sack. However, shops in pedes-                                                 ment of inner-city retail.
trian precincts are certainly interesting for retailers, as shown

DEVELOPMENT OF TOP RENT AND PURCHASE PRICE MULTIPLIER                                                         TOP RENT – INTER-CITY COMPARISON
   Top rent in € / m²            Purchase price multiplier                                                          in €/m²

250 €                                                                                                25.0     140
                                                                                                                       110

                                                                                                              120
200 €                                                                                                20.0
                                                                                                                                  100

                                                                                                                                              100

                                                                                                                                                           95

                                                                                                              100
                                                                                                                                                                                            90

                                                                                                                                                                          90
                                                                                                                                                                                                              80

150 €                                                                                                15.0
                                                                                                               80

100 €                                                                                                10.0      60

                                                                                                               40
 50 €                                                                                                 5.0
                                                                                                               20

            2009   2010   2011   2012   2013   2014     2015       2016 2017 2018                                    Mainz      Aachen     Dresden      Karlsruhe       Braun­            Erfurt            Essen
                                                                                                                                                                       schweig
                                               © BNP Paribas Real Estate Retail Services, December 31, 2018                                                 © BNP Paribas Real Estate Retail Services, December 31, 2018
You can also read