WASTE DATA ALTERNATIVES TO SINGLE-USE COFFEE CUPS - LEARNING TEAMS - WasteMINZ

Page created by Johnnie Carlson
 
CONTINUE READING
WASTE DATA ALTERNATIVES TO SINGLE-USE COFFEE CUPS - LEARNING TEAMS - WasteMINZ
OFFICIAL MAGAZINE OF THE WASTE MANAGEMENT INSTITUTE NZ
                   SEPTEMBER 2019 \ ISSUE 173 \ $9.00

 ALTERNATIVES
TO SINGLE-USE                        OPT-IN FOR
  COFFEE CUPS                        ORGANICS
                                     COLLECTIONS
             WASTE                   LEARNING TEAMS
              DATA
  PRODUCT STEWARDSHIP | CONTAMINATED LAND MANAGEMENT
WASTE DATA ALTERNATIVES TO SINGLE-USE COFFEE CUPS - LEARNING TEAMS - WasteMINZ
WASTEMINZ MEMBERS
P L ATIN U M                              SILVER
                                          ADSTAFF PERSONNEL
                                          adstaff.co.nz
               AUCKLAND COUNCIL
               aucklandcouncil.govt.nz    AURECON NZ
                                          aurecongroup.com

                                          CIVIC CONTRACTORS
GO L D                                    civcon.co.nz

                                          COCO-COLA AMATIL
                                          ccamatil.co.nz
               3R GROUP
               3R.co.nz                   FOODSTUFFS NZ
                                          foodstuffsnz.co.nz

                                          GEOFABRICS NZ
               EARTHCARE ENVIRONMENTAL
                                          geofabrics.co.nz
               earthcarenz.co.nz
                                          MANCO
                                          manco.co.nz
               ENVIRONZ
                                          OJI FIBRE SOLUTIONS
               environz.co.nz
                                          ojifs.com

                                          OMARUNUI LANDFILL
               O-I NEW ZEALAND            hastingsdc.govt.nz
               o-i.com
                                          PATTLE DELAMORE PARTNERS
                                          pdp.co.nz

               SMART ENVIRONMENTAL        PLASBACK
               smartenvironmental.co.nz   plasback.co.nz

                                          PROGRESSIVE ENTERPRISES
                                          progressive.co.nz
               SULO
               sulo.co.nz                 SCION RESEARCH
                                          scionresearch.com

                                          SIMS RECYCLING SOLUTIONS
               TONKIN + TAYLOR            apac.simsrecycling.com
               tonkin.co.nz
                                          STANTEC
                                          mwhglobal.co.nz

               VISY RECYCLING NZ          THE PACKAGING FORUM
               visy.co.nz                 packagingforum.org.nz

                                          WASTENET SOUTHLAND
                                          wastenet.org.nz
               WASTE MANAGEMENT NZ
               wastemanagement.co.nz      WSP OPUS
                                          wsp-opus.co.nz
WASTE DATA ALTERNATIVES TO SINGLE-USE COFFEE CUPS - LEARNING TEAMS - WasteMINZ
ON THE COVER WAKING UP TO
  NEW WASTE REDUCTION IDEAS

                     CHIEF EXECUTIVE
   Janine Brinsdon \ +64 9 476 7172
         janine@wasteminz.org.nz
                                                                                              10
                                              10
       SECTOR PROJECTS MANAGER
           Nic Quilty \ +64 9 476 7167
              nic@wasteminz.org.nz
                                              ARE THE DAYS OF SINGLE-USE
       SECTOR PROJECTS MANAGER
                                              COFFEE CUPS NUMBERED?
    Jenny Marshall \ +64 9 476 7164
                                              The search for alternatives to
          jenny@wasteminz.org.nz
                                              single-use coffee cups is leading
   CORPORATE SERVICES MANAGER
                                              to innovative options from
          CJ Dooner \ +64 9 476 7162
                                              reuse systems to edible cups.
               cj@wasteminz.org.nz
           SUSTAINABILIT Y ADVISOR
Sarah Pritchett \ +64 21 0825 4606
                                              13
        sarahp@wasteminz.org.nz               AN OUTSIDER’S PERSPECTIVE
                                              ON WASTE DATA
        ACCOUNTS ADMINISTRATOR
  Justine Robinson \ +64 9 476 7163           Dr Rachel Chiaroni-Clarke reports
         justine@wasteminz.org.nz             on her analysis of the country’s
                                              waste data and the data collection
                      EDITOR, REVOLVE
       Kim Mundell \ +64 21 655 917           changes needed from industry
            wasteminz@gmail.com               to help solve our plastic crisis.

               SUB-EDITOR, REVOLVE
                       Julie O'Brien          17
              wasteminz@gmail.com             GIVING RATEPAYERS A CHOICE
                      DESIGN, REVOLVE
Leanne Lassman \ +64 21 267 3885
  leanne@electrichedgehog.co.nz
                                              Offering Waimakariri District Council
                                              ratepayers the choice of opting
                                              in for an organics collection got
                                                                                      28                               20
                                              complicated. Kitty Waghorn explains.    PROPOSED REGULATED PRODUCT
                         T +64 9 476 7162
                                                                                      STEWARDSHIP SCHEME
             PO Box 305426, Triton Plaza
                        North Shore 0757      20                                      The government’s consultation
                                                                                      on its proposed scheme to
     Unit 2, 5 Orbit Drive, Rosedale 0632     LEARNING TEAMS: A TOOL FOR
                             New Zealand                                              regulate product stewardship
                                              WORKPLACE IMPROVEMENT
                     wasteminz.org.nz                                                 gives WasteMINZ members an
                                              AND ENGAGEMENT                          opportunity to influence these
                                              Greg Dearsly uses a case study to       regulations.
  WasteMINZ is the leading professional
  body for waste management, resource
                                              illustrate how learning teams can
        recovery and contaminated land        be used to enhance organisational
management in New Zealand. We deliver         learning and worker engagement.         REGULARS
     value to our members through the                                                 02 MEMBERS
   shaping and sharing of policy and the
 development of industry good practice.
                                              24                                      04 FROM JANINE'S DESK
 WasteMINZ publishes revolve magazine
                                              A CONSULTANT’S PERSPECTIVE              05 YOUR BOARD
   four times a year, it plays a vital role   ON CONTAMINATED                         07 CONFERENCE
  in ensuring our members are up-to-          LAND MANAGEMENT                         08 MOVERS & SHAKERS
  date with the latest in industry news,
  policy and legislative changes as well
                                              Simon Hunt describes the challenge      32 FROM THE REGIONS
                                              that insufficient government
          as innovations and advances.                                                34 SECTOR GROUPS
 revolve magazine is a forum for positive
                                              policy, regulation and guidance
       sector debate and discussion. The      poses for providing advice on
     articles contained in revolve do not     contaminated land management.
       necessarily represent the views of
   WasteMINZ or the WasteMINZ Board.

              ISSN 2324-5417 (Print)
            ISSN 2324-5425 (Online)  

                                                                       17
WASTE DATA ALTERNATIVES TO SINGLE-USE COFFEE CUPS - LEARNING TEAMS - WasteMINZ
FROM
JANINE'S
DESK                                                                                                           Janine Brinsdon
                                                                                                    Chief Executive, WasteMINZ
Talk to me                                                                                           janine@wasteminz.org.nz
+64 9 476 7172

The time has come — our conference                                                         at which chair Darren Patterson
is now just weeks away. It has
                                                BUT WE ARE NOT                             and I will present the annual report
been an honour to work alongside                ALONE. THE SEARCH                          and future priorities for the 2019-
the WasteMINZ team and to see                   FOR IMPROVED                               2020 financial year. The AGM will
first-hand their extraordinary                  WASTE, RESOURCE                            also provide a chance for us to
commitment to the creation and                  RECOVERY AND                               collectively thank and acknowledge
delivery of a world-class event.
                                                CONTAMINATED                               the current WasteMINZ board,
    After months of planning and                                                           and to welcome three members
organising, it is almost time for
                                                LAND MANAGEMENT                            for the next two years as voted
our sectors to come together in
                                                SOLUTIONS                                  on by you. Please see below the
Hamilton, and to have the chance                EXTENDS BEYOND                             nominees standing for election to
to learn, listen and help shape our             OUR ISLANDS.                               the WasteMINZ Board.
collective future.                                                                             Now is the time for New
                                                At conference we will share and
    The consistent message I                                                               Zealand to define the future of our
                                                celebrate some of the amazing
hear from members is that the                                                              sectors. Thank you in anticipation
                                                initiatives, research and expertise
situation we find ourselves in now                                                         for your passion and commitment
                                                we have within New Zealand, while
is unique, due to the scale and pace                                                       to leaving a legacy we can all be
                                                taking the chance to challenge
of change we are experiencing.                                                             proud of. After all, toitū te whenua,
                                                and test our thinking through
Global commodity pricing and                                                               whatungarongaro he tangata, the
                                                international perspective and
export restrictions are forcing us to                                                      land remains when people have
                                                experience.
take greater responsibility for our                                                        disappeared.
                                                   WasteMINZ’s AGM will take
choices — be that as a consumer or
                                                place on 24 September in Hamilton,
within a commercial context.

31ST ANNUAL CONFERENCE                          2 3 - 2 6 S EPT EMB ER | H AM I LTO N

                             WASTEMINZ BOARD NOMINEES 2019

      DAVE BULL                  ALICE GRACE               ALEC MCNEIL              WAYNE PLUMMER          LAURENCE ZWIMPFER
HAIL Environmental               Morrison Low           Marlborough District      EnviroWaste Services      eDay New Zealand
                                                              Council                                             Trust

4
WASTE DATA ALTERNATIVES TO SINGLE-USE COFFEE CUPS - LEARNING TEAMS - WasteMINZ
YOUR
BOARD                                                        Simonne Eldridge
                                                 WasteMINZ Board deputy chair
                                                       seldridge@tonkin.co.nz

Kia ora tātou                              board of trustees meeting, one of
The WasteMINZ Conference is                my fellow trustees asked a group             HOW TO
almost upon us and the team has
been working hard to shape up an
                                           of students what advice they had
                                           for a presentation he was going to
                                                                                        CONTACT
interesting and thought-provoking          give to consulting engineers about           YOUR BOARD
programme. I’m looking forward to          generation gaps. They replied that
seeing as many of you there as can         “you have to start by listening to           MEMBERS
make it.                                   your children and understanding
   In the people management                their lives."
aspect of my day job I strive to keep          To be successful in an
at the forefront of my mind the            increasingly volatile, uncertain,
following:                                 complex, ambiguous world, we
   He aha te mea nui o te ao. He           need people who can provide vision,
   tāngata, he tāngata, he tāngata         understanding, clarity and agility.
   What is the most important              If we focus on agility, there is a
   thing in the world? It is people, it    need for a collaborative approach
   is people, it is people.                to rapid change and adaptation.
Through the WasteMINZ conference           Rapid trust is also important. Think
theme, it is also great to be              how much easier it is to get things
reminded of the following:                 done when you are working with
   Toitū te whenua                         someone you trust.
   whatungarongaro he tāngata                  I am looking forward to robust
   The land remains when people            debate at this year’s conference
   have disappeared.                       around some of the challenges
WasteMINZ provides the perfect             facing not only the waste industry
place to come together to solve            (which tends to look to solve
today’s problems in a way that will        problems created by others)
                                                                                        left-to-right top, middle, bottom
not jeopardise the future. What we         but also waste producers. These              Darren Patterson CHAIR
leave behind us, our legacy, is te taiao   include container deposit schemes,           darren@pattersonenvironmental.co.nz

(the environment), but it is also the      expansion of the waste levy, in-             Simonne Eldridge DEPUT Y CHAIR
future guardians of the environment,       country processing needs and                 seldridge@tonkin.co.nz

te tāngata (the people). How do we         industry-led collaboration as an             Wayne Plummer
                                                                                        wayne.plummer@environz.co.nz
want to guide the next generation to       essential role in the transition to the
equip them for the future? Equally         circular economy.                            Parul Sood
                                                                                        parul.sood@aucklandcouncil.govt.nz
importantly, what do we need to                Let’s collectively put our heads
                                                                                        Ian Stupple
learn from across the generations to       together to solve the problems of
                                                                                        ianstupple@gmail.com
influence what we do now?                  tomorrow before we create them.
   At a recent intermediate school             Mā te wā

                                                                                  SEPTEMBER 2019 \ WASTEMINZ.ORG.NZ \         5
WASTE DATA ALTERNATIVES TO SINGLE-USE COFFEE CUPS - LEARNING TEAMS - WasteMINZ
Experience the Progress.

                                                                                              Find your
                                                                                              Liebherr-contact

   Liebherr Wheel Loaders L 550 XPower® -
   L 580 XPower® for industrial applications
   XPower ® is the new generation of Liebherr’s large wheel loaders. Liebherr              Visit us at:
   XPower ® is an integrated, innovative machine concept that sets new standards
                                                                                           WasteMINZ
   in terms of reliability, performance, robust design and comfort. For industrial use,
                                                                                           Conference &
   the optional industrial lift arm is the best solution, as it allows large attachments   Expo
   to be fitted for transporting heavy loads. The XPower ® power-split driveline with      23–26/09/2019
   Liebherr-Power-Efficiency (LPE) achieves a reduction in fuel consumption of             Venue: Claudelands
                                                                                           Hamilton, Waikato
   up to 30 percent - so you handle more, faster.                                          Stand No: 48

Liebherr New Zealand
sales-em.lnz@liebherr.com
www.facebook.com/LiebherrConstruction
www.linkedin.com/company/liebherr
www.liebherr.com
WASTE DATA ALTERNATIVES TO SINGLE-USE COFFEE CUPS - LEARNING TEAMS - WasteMINZ
WASTEMINZ CONFERENCE FEATURED SPEAKERS
         Never has a conference been so topical. If you want to help shape the future
         of New Zealand's waste, resource recovery and contaminated land sectors,
          you need to be in Hamilton, 23-26 September 2019. Full programme and
               event details are available here: wasteminz.org.nz/conference

            Dan Hikuroa                              Robert Kelman                                    Dru Marsh
    Ngāti Maniapoto, Waikato-Tainui,                President, Reloop Pacific,          Senior Legal Policy Officer, Environmental
     Senior Lecturer, Te Wananga o                         Australia                         Protection Authority, Australia
    Waipapa, University of Auckland                 Best practice container             A new approach to an old issue: Victoria’s
   Toitū te whenua, whatungarongaro                deposit schemes – lessons              transformed contaminated land laws
  he tangata – insights from indigenous               from over the ditch                and legal implications for development
       ways of knowing and doing                                                          and management of brownfield sites

        Hon. Eugenie Sage                              Kiri Hannifin                              Nicky McIndoe
            Associate Minister                 General Manager, Corporate Affairs,             Partner, Kensington Swan
           for the Environment                   Quality, Safety & Sustainability,            An RMA perspective on waste
                                                   Countdown Supermarkets                 management and contaminated land:
                                                       Rebel with a cause                 The Northern Corridor Improvements
                                                                                                 Project as a case study

       Douglas Woodring                                Kelli Sullivan                                Mark Bayer
   Founder + Managing Director, Ocean          Communications and Stakeholder          President, Bayer Strategic Consulting, USA
      Recovery Alliance, Hong Kong              Manager, NZ Transport Agency             Connect before you communicate: Keys
Plastic – the material that binds the planet    How to plan and deliver effective         for mastering difficult conversations
                                                   engagement strategies

                            WELCOME TO OUR NEW MEMBERS
              SILVER                                SMALL BUSINESS                                     INDIVIDUAL
         Coca-Cola Amatil                          Acticycle Environmental                             Laura Banasiak
         CORPORATE                                      Ashbec Trading                                 Vicktoria Blake
            CRL Energy                                    e3scientific                                     Todd O'Hara
      Kaipara District Council                           Earth Starch                                  Gregory Selman
                Spark                                Earthtech Consulting                                  STUDENT
                                               Envirokiwi Community Enterprise                             Deron Sharma
                                                Position Partners New Zealand
                                                      TRS Tyre & Wheel

                           31ST ANNUAL CONFERENCE             2 3 - 2 6 S E P TE M B E R | H A M I LTO N                          7
WASTE DATA ALTERNATIVES TO SINGLE-USE COFFEE CUPS - LEARNING TEAMS - WasteMINZ
MOVERS & SHAKERS

                      NIGEL DONOVAN                                                    SHAUN LEWIS
KAIARATAKI MATUA/SENIOR POLICY ANALYST WITHIN HONO TĀTAKI,                        DIRECTOR, MANA HONOHONO
          RESOURCE EFFICIENCY & INNOVATION TEAM                                - INVESTMENTS AND PARTNERSHIPS
    Nigel Donovan has recently joined the Ministry for the         Shaun Lewis leads the Ministry for the Environment’s
      Environment and works with Scott Priestley in the                work programme to accelerate New Zealand’s
Ministry’s compliance monitoring and enforcement team.                transition to a circular economy. His directorate
     Nigel is a key contact for councils and disposal facility         takes an innovative approach to policy-making
     operators when dealing with the requirements of the            utilising regulatory levers, strategic investments, and
Waste Minimisation Act 2008. Nigel moved from Auckland               partnering with stakeholders and change-makers.

Council where he was a senior consents monitoring officer.          Prior to working at the Ministry for the Environment,

     He has worked closely with all classes of landfill and           Shaun worked for the Environmental Protection
                                                                   Authority as a project leader within the resources team
    landfill operators, communities impacted by large scale
                                                                    responsible for managing the consenting process for
 landfills and clean fills, and local and central government
                                                                             Proposals of National Significance.
     stakeholders. He is also part of the team working on
     the landfill levy expansion and will also be involved in
       the Ministry’s compliance assurance programme.

                        TRISH HURLEY                                                 ROWAN LATHAM
      Trish has recently taken over the role of operations          Rowan recently joined Christchurch City Council as
 manager at Waitaki Resource Recovery Trust. Previously           contract and projects lead with their solid waste team.
    she was the site administrator/manager. She has been             Rowan brings his international local government
     working at WRRT for 12 years in a variety of roles and      experience (Australia and UK) to the role, along with three
 has recently completed her level 5 National Certificate in        and a half years as a senior advisor at the Canterbury
 Adult Literacy and Numeracy. WRRT works closely with            Regional Council, Environment Canterbury. His experience
    the local council and schools to help reduce, reuse and        delivering complex waste minimisation and resource
 recycle as much as they can. WRRT are undergoing a site            recovery projects will help develop the scope of this
     redevelopment to enhance customers’ enjoyment of            newly established position, with a number of interesting
visiting their Get Sorted Shop and new garden centre. They          initiatives in development. CCC are delivering a new
run a variety of programmes, including the Bike Project for        waste minimisation and management plan this year
children and are the lead agency in the workplace literacy         and investigating options for an innovative inner-city
    programme in North Otago. Trish can be contacted at          collection programme. Rowan has been an active member
                 Trish@resourcewaitaki.co.nz.                    of the Canterbury Waste Joint Committee staff group and
                                                                  WasteMINZ, regularly presenting at conference, and as a
                                                                  member of the WasteMINZ Sector Group for Disposal to
                                                                             Land. Rowan can be contacted at
                                                                                rowan.latham@ccc.govt.nz.

8
WASTE DATA ALTERNATIVES TO SINGLE-USE COFFEE CUPS - LEARNING TEAMS - WasteMINZ
SCOTT PRIESTLEY                          RODERICK BOYS                                 STUART MCKAY
           KAIWHAKAHAERE /MANAGER,               KAIARATAKI MATUA/SENIOR POLICY                  KAIWHAKAHAERE /MANAGER,
        HONO TĀTAKI, RESOURCE EFFICIENCY       ANALYST WITHIN HONO TĀTAKI, RESOURCE           HONO TĀTAKI, RESOURCE EFFICIENCY
                 & INNOVATION                      EFFICIENCY & INNOVATION TEAM                        & INNOVATION
          Scott Priestley manages the            Roderick Boys joined the Ministry            Stuart McKay manages the Waste
        Ministry’s compliance monitoring         for the Environment in February            Minimisation Fund and has been with
        and enforcement team. He brings        and is lead on the National Resource           the Ministry for the Environment
       20 years experience in operational           Recovery work programme.                 since September 2018. Stuart has
            regulation, investigation,            This work programme is to be                20 years + experience working for
       enforcement and strategic planning        implemented over the next three              governments in Australia, the UK
       at a state, federal and international        years. It includes: a national            and New Zealand across health,
       level to the compliance, monitoring       infrastructure analysis, review of         environment and housing portfolios.
                                                kerbside services, feasibility studies
       and enforcement functions for the                                                    His experiences range from business
                                                for on-shore processing of plastics
       Waste Minimisation Act 2008. Scott                                                   matching environmental expertise to
                                                   and fibre, examining product
      has contributed to the development                                                     companies looking to improve their
                                                stewardship and other regulatory
       and implementation of regulatory                                                     environmental performance in South
                                                 options for single use packaging,
         programmes across protected                                                         East Asia, to managing investment
                                                   running a national education
         area management, biodiversity,                                                      in health infrastructure, to leading
                                               campaign to reduce contamination,
        forestry, native vegetation, water,                                                  delegations to the Commission on
                                                developing model contracts for the
         minerals, coal and natural gas                                                       Sustainable Development at the
                                               sector and developing a sustainable
       reforms in NSW, Australia including                                                  United Nations headquarters in New
                                                   procurement plan/guideline.
       the former Department of Climate                                                     York in the lead up to Rio +20. Stuart
                                               Roderick has come from Wellington
        Change at the Australian Federal        City Council where he was the co-           has been on both sides of the funding
       Government and the development          chair of the Wellington Region Waste         process – prior to joining the Ministry
      of Environmental Crime Programme         Minimisation and Management Plan              he worked closely with community
                  for INTERPOL                  steering group, and he was on the           groups in his home town of Carterton
                                                        WasteMINZ Board.                      to help them access community
                                                                                                   development funding.

                                 EPS1800 POLYSTYRENE SOLUTION
                                  Ideal for businesses | transfer stations | community networks

                                                                                40:1 volume reduction on EPS6
                                                                                compacts up to 70kg per hour
                                                                                reduce transpoation and disposal costs
                                                                                simple and easy to operate
                                                                                side or top fed

0508 MILTEK (645835)                                                            lean compaction
SALE | LEASE | RENT
miltek.co.nz
Nationwide sales & service
WASTE DATA ALTERNATIVES TO SINGLE-USE COFFEE CUPS - LEARNING TEAMS - WasteMINZ
THE RISE &
FALL OF THE                                    S
                                                         INGLE-USE SHAMING (verb):
                                                         the act of stigmatising a

SINGLE-USE
                                                         person for failing to take
                                                         their own reusable bag,
                                               coffee cup or water bottle, or for failing

CUP
                                               to refuse a plastic straw, stirrer or
                                               other single-use item.
                                                   You may not be familiar with
                                               the term but many of you will be
                                               familiar with the sentiment. It’s the

The search for replacements to single-         time you bumped into a friend at
                                               the local farmer’s market and they
use coffee cups is on, with cup libraries,     couldn’t quite meet your eyes and
plastic-free and edible cups vying for first   kept their hands out of sight behind
place as credible alternatives.                their back.

10
Enter the cup library
                                        If you have ever rushed out between
   Suddenly they blurted out, “I’m
                                        meetings for a coffee and realised
sorry, I forgot my reusable cup! I
                                        your reusable coffee cup is still at            Edible options
know how you feel about these,”                                                         For those of you who like a sweet
                                        home, you can avoid being single-use
as they sheepishly brought their                                                        treat with your coffee, an edible cup
                                        shamed by your colleagues if your
disposable coffee cup into sight.                                                       by Kiwi family business Twiice will
                                        favourite cafe has a coffee cup library.
“Hey, no judgement here,” you said.                                                     hit the spot. It has taken them four
                                            From walls and crates of
But you both knew that not-so-                                                          years but they have now developed
                                        eclectic ceramic mugs to regionally
secretly you were in fact judging                                                       a tasty cup that lasts as long as
                                        based models using a standardised
them — your friend had just been                                                        your coffee does and can be eaten
                                        cup, there is a system for almost
single-use shamed.                                                                      or composted. It’s the coffee cup
                                        everyone, apart from those cafes
   While single-use shaming may                                                         equivalent of the ice cream cone and
                                        that have no sterilising system and
be on the rise, with an estimated                                                       it may just revolutionise takeaway
                                        are therefore not licensed to sell
295,000,000 disposable coffee                                                           coffee — as long as Kiwis can wean
                                        coffee in reusable cups.
cups used per year in Aotearoa,                                                         themselves off the ubiquitous coffee
                                            A recent development has been
the search has also been on for a                                                       cup lid.
                                        the regionally based coffee cup reuse
better vessel.
                                        systems CupCycling™ and Again
   Fibre cups with a plastic lining                                                     Single-use cups – are
                                        Again. CupCycling™ was started by
and lid initially seemed to be a good
                                        New Zealand reusable-cup pioneers
                                                                                        they here to stay?
solution, until it became apparent                                                      There is a lot of passionate
                                        Stephanie and Nick Fry of the
that coffee dregs contaminated                                                          opposition to single-use coffee cups,
                                        Motueka-based Ideal Cup. This system
other recyclables and separating                                                        and with good reason. Some brave
                                        is available for single cafes, corporate
the plastic lining for recycling was                                                    cafes have chosen to do without
                                        cafes or a cluster of cafes in a street,
uneconomic.                                                                             them already (Otago Polytech’s Eden
                                        suburb, town or region.
   Compostable cups hold                                                                Cafe, Sign of the Kiwi in Christchurch
                                            Again Again was started by
promise but have also proven to                                                         and Indies in Raglan), but it is
                                        Wellingtonian Nadia Piatek and is
be problematic, as composting                                                           difficult to envisage a time when all
                                        available on a region-only basis.
facilities cannot always process                                                        cafes just simply refuse to use them,
                                        For both systems cafes pay a
them. There was quite the                                                               unless it was legislated.
                                        monthly fee and customers pay a
storm in a single-use coffee                                                                So while we should encourage
                                        membership or cup fee to borrow
cup when Wellington’s Capital                                                           innovative single-use cups with
                                        a cup.
Compost recently announced it                                                           better waste outcomes, supporting
                                            To avoid customers stockpiling
could no longer accept certified                                                        cup reuse systems and encouraging
                                        cups, both systems require another
compostable coffee cups because                                                         coffee cup libraries is a better bet.
                                        cup fee or deposit if the original cup
its organic certification precludes                                                     If we can do without our single-
                                        is not returned and another cup
any bioplastic inputs.                                                                  use shopping bags, we can likewise
                                        is borrowed. This should provide
   Thus the search continues and                                                        learn to live without our single-use
                                        an incentive to remember to take
in 2018 the international OpenIDEO                                                      cups. And if we do, one day that bin
                                        cups back — if not it could become
issued a NextGen Cup Challenge                                                          overflowing with coffee cups will
                                        an expensive way of avoiding
for recoverable fibre-based cups.                                                       become a relic of the past that we
                                        single-use shaming. Cafes can opt
This resulted in eight winners in the                                                   look back on in disbelief. R
                                        to use reusable or disposable lids
cup liner category, including some
                                        for CupCycling™; Again Again cups
plastic-free options that may be                                                        References
                                        require a heat-proof disposable
acceptable to composting facilities                                                     bit.ly/nextgencupchallenge
                                        cardboard sleeve.
in Aotearoa that have organic                                                           bit.ly/findcoffeecuplibrary
                                            These schemes obviously
certification, so watch this space.
                                        work, with the recorded number
                                        of cups diverted from landfill for
                                        CupCycling™ so far sitting at 76,763.

                           31ST ANNUAL CONFERENCE          2 3 - 2 6 S E P TE M B E R | H A M I LTO N                           11
WASTE DATA
AN OUTSIDER'S PERSPECTIVE
Dr Rachel Chiaroni-Clarke of the Office of
the Prime Minister’s Chief Science Advisor
has been analysing New Zealand’s waste
data. She shares what data is needed to truly
understand and solve our plastic crisis.

I
    ’VE BEEN ON A mission to            Systematic data                                We need to know more
    find out how much plastic           collection is needed                           than gross tonnages
    comes into Aotearoa New             As members of the waste industry,              The majority of available data
    Zealand and where it ends up.       I’m sure it comes as no surprise               on landfilled or recycled plastic
My hunt for data forms part of the      to you that we are lacking an                  is limited to a tonnage value.
Rethinking Plastics project by the      aggregated national dataset housing            Capturing additional data has
Office of the Prime Minister’s Chief    the information I’m hunting for. This          the potential to support better
Science Advisor, which will provide     urgently needs to change. Aotearoa             management of plastic in Aotearoa
government with a summary of            New Zealand needs accurate, high-              New Zealand by better supporting
the evidence and accompanying           quality data as the foundation of our          evidence-informed decisions.
recommendations on ways to              system-wide rethink of how we use                  Because all plastic products
mitigate the issues related to          and dispose of plastic.                        aren’t equally recyclable, knowing
plastics.                                  The waste industry’s role here              which resin types and colours
   Our project is guided by a panel     is crucial. Coordinated, systematic            are used is key. The best publicly
of experts from wide-ranging            and ongoing collection and sharing             available data on kerbside recycling
disciplines, and is further supported   of data for recovered and waste                composition differentiates by
by a broader group that has helped      plastic is essential to inform and             clear PET, natural HDPE and mixed
us through consultation and peer        prioritise policy decisions, including         plastics. This makes practical sense
review. Ahead of the full report,       infrastructure investment.                     for the day-to-day business of
we’ve published the draft of Part          I’ll briefly explain what I                 recycling because of the nature
1 of To what extent can we quantify     think the waste industry can do                of how bales are currently sold,
Aotearoa’s plastics footprint? New      to help fill some of those gaps,               but doesn’t allow us to really
Zealand’s data challenge, which         and highlight some of the initial              understand how much and which
provides a current snapshot of          recommendations from our panel.                types of plastic need to be managed
the available data and highlights                                                      differently.
knowledge gaps for plastic material
flow through Aotearoa New Zealand.

                           31ST ANNUAL CONFERENCE         2 3 - 2 6 S E P TE M B E R | H A M I LTO N                        13
Soon our country won’t be able           The same goes for non-               Now is the time
to rely on shipping mixed bales          household waste plastic. Data
                                                                                 to start collecting
offshore, so more granular data is       collection efforts need to include
                                                                                 better data
needed to inform decisions such          the amount, types, colours,
                                                                                 A national data framework for
as whether government should             contaminants and diversion
                                                                                 plastic is needed, but it won’t
restrict use of certain resin types      potential of plastic in commercial
                                                                                 happen overnight and Aotearoa
or colours, invest in infrastructure     recycling streams and non-
                                                                                 New Zealand simply cannot wait for
for secondary sorting, or move to a      municipal landfills, making sure that
                                                                                 a perfect dataset before initiating
waste-to-energy approach to deal         data is captured for other high-use
                                                                                 change. Our panel recommends that
with plastic at its end-of-life.         industries such as construction and
                                                                                 a series of audits are undertaken
   The diversion potential of plastic    agriculture.
                                                                                 across the plastics supply chain
sent to landfill is useful information      But beyond individual measures,
                                                                                 to give us a better baseline
that is often not recorded or            what’s really needed is a co-
                                                                                 understanding of the plastics
disclosed. The current WasteMINZ         ordinated approach across the
                                                                                 material flow through Aotearoa New
study auditing a nationally              plastic value chain to capture data
                                                                                 Zealand. Particular effort should be
representative sample of household       and make it accessible. That will
                                                                                 made to address knowledge gaps,
refuse and recycling streams is a        require data collection throughout
                                                                                 such as how much plastic waste
great first step to address this data    the full product lifecycle.
                                                                                 goes to non-municipal landfill and
gap. It would also be informative           Measurements also need to
                                                                                 how much plastic that is sent for
for educational campaigns and            include information about recycled
                                                                                 recycling actually ends up in landfill.
policy decisions to have data on         content, reuse potential for multi-
                                                                                    From there, a framework
the types of plastic that commonly       use systems, industry, source and
                                                                                 for the ongoing collection of
contaminate the recycling stream         end market (local or overseas),
                                                                                 information on plastics across the
and are then sent to landfill.           location and average lifetime of the
                                         product.
value chain should be built. One             Aotearoa New                                We’re at a pivotal point where we
   way to approach this could be for                                                     can rethink how we use plastics to
                                                Zealand’s plastic data
   stakeholders to disclose their data                                                   reduce the negative impacts while
                                                can guide our shift to a
   to an independent third party,                                                        retaining its many benefits. Let’s
   to be aggregated into a national
                                                new plastics economy                     seize the opportunity!
                                                I think one of the biggest
   dataset that is easily accessible for                                                    Look out for our full report later
                                                opportunities for better data on
   policymakers and the public.                                                          in the year. R
                                                plastic use and disposal in Aotearoa
      An aggregated national dataset
                                                New Zealand is that it can support
   will also allow government to
                                                and guide the transition to a circular
   supply more accurate waste data to
                                                economy for plastics. The waste
   the OECD and other international
                                                industry has an important role here
   organisations, and hold ourselves
                                                — you can support manufacturers
   accountable to targets related
                                                and brand owners to establish             Dr Rachel Chiaroni-Clarke is the research
   to plastic use and waste, such as
                                                circular solutions for products,          analyst and writer leading the Rethinking
   those agreed to in the NZ Plastics                                                     Plastics in Aotearoa New Zealand project
                                                particularly with your knowledge
   Packaging Declaration and the                                                         for the Office of the Prime Minister’s Chief
                                                of the various recovery techniques          Science Advisor. Through this project,
   New Plastics Economy Global
                                                available for different types of         Rachel has taken a deep dive into the issue
   Commitment. The National Waste                                                        of plastics, spending months analysing the
                                                plastic materials in circulation, and      evidence, consulting with stakeholders
   Data Framework is a great start
                                                their associated environmental             across Aotearoa, and working with the
   for data collection for the waste                                                                project’s expert panel.
                                                impacts.
   industry that should be built on.

TO INFINITY
& BEYOND
Infinitely recyclable glass

      For more visit: bit.ly/2J4rFP6

                       O-I New Zealand
                       www.recycleglass.co.nz       +64 9 976 7127
ENVIRONMENTAL

Visit us at WasteMINZ
To see Australasia’s first fully

                                   51
                                   STAND
encapsulated hygienic hot water
multibin washer unveiled.
GIVING RATEPAYERS
A CHOICE
AN OPT-IN OPTION FOR ORGANICS COLLECTION

Kitty Waghorn describes what happened when
Waimakariri District Council gave their ratepayers
the choice of opting in for an organics collection and
switching from rubbish bags to rubbish bins.

T
         WO YEARS AGO the                Tendering                                          We also wanted to minimise the
                                                                                        safety risks of providing a manual
         Waimakariri District            uncertainties
         Council embarked on                                                            collection service, to be able to track
                                         Without any solid evidence of
         an ambitious journey to                                                        trucks and bin pickups, and ideally
                                         potential uptake, we estimated that
tender for our kerbside collection                                                      to be able to see via a recording why
                                         50 per cent of serviced properties
services and solid waste facilities                                                     a bin might not have been picked up,
                                         would opt in for rubbish and
operations.                                                                             so that our call centre staff could
                                         organics bins, and the rest would
   It was ambitious because we                                                          respond to customer complaints
                                         continue to use bags or private
chose to offer an opt-in rubbish and                                                    from a position of certainty.
                                         collectors.
organics bin service to ratepayers, in                                                      In short, we needed a contractor
                                            To minimise the uncertainty,
addition to the existing rubbish bag                                                    with the flexibility to manage
                                         bands of bin numbers were created
and recycling bin collections, with a                                                   uncertainties and fluctuations, who
                                         to allow the contractors to price
choice of three bin sizes for organics                                                  had a strong customer and health
                                         different levels of resourcing for
and two bin sizes for rubbish.                                                          and safety focus, was responsive to
                                         each scenario, so they wouldn’t
   An opt-in service was chosen as                                                      changes in technology and diversion
                                         carry all the risks if the predicted
many of the private collectors are                                                      markets and committed to working
                                         uptake differed from actual uptake.
local businesses and the council                                                        with the council to minimise waste.
                                         This also allowed the council to
wanted to ensure they could stay in      ascertain the cost implications from
business.
                                                                                        Managing residents
                                         an increase or drop in bin numbers
                                                                                        While tendering documents were
                                         and bag use.
                                                                                        being prepared, the council got

                            31ST ANNUAL CONFERENCE         2 3 - 2 6 S E P TE M B E R | H A M I LTO N                         17
on with seeking the householders’        auditor, providing the opportunity       •   58 per cent of eligible households
preliminary choices. Owners of all       for reciprocal questions. We used            opted in for rubbish bins, which
18,050 properties were sent a post-      the Price Quality Method, in which           was more than we had budgeted
paid multi-choice barcoded card to       assessments are made by using                for, with 42 per cent sticking
tick and return within six weeks, or     weightings of 70 per cent for non-           with bags or private collectors or
they could go online and enter their     price attributes and 30 per cent for         dealing with their own waste.
choice with their unique code from       pricing. The non-price assessment        •   Our initial estimate for additional
the card.                                was completed before the price               bins was 10 per cent of those
     The scanned cards and the           envelopes were opened.                       initially requested, but to date
online submissions were linked               The collection and facilities            it is an additional 53 per cent
to a database with property              contracts were both awarded                  increase for organics bins and
addresses and their service choices.     to Waste Management in early                 households and a 62 per cent
We received responses for 9680           December 2018, and then the real             increase for rubbish bins.
properties with the following            complications set in.
                                                                                  An opt-in service provides a
choices:                                     Property owners were reminded
                                                                                  challenge for councils and their
•    5650 organics bins                  early in February of their choice, or
                                                                                  contractors. One of the downsides
•    6785 rubbish bins                   lack of choice, and invited to change
                                                                                  is that it doesn’t necessarily cater to
•    2920 status quo for rubbish.        their selection, if required, by
                                                                                  rental properties, whose landlords
However, we did not receive              1 March. Waste Management then
                                                                                  may not opt in on tenants’ behalf.
completed forms for 46 per cent of       received the details so they could
                                                                                      If a compulsory system is not
properties.                              finalise bin orders, prepare their
                                                                                  being implemented, perhaps an
     While this gave us an indication,   delivery schedules and deliver bins
                                                                                  opt-out service is the next best
we still had no firm idea of final       before 1 July.
                                                                                  option, as this means only those
numbers, so another 10 per cent was          For the contractor this was a
                                                                                  opposed to getting or paying for
added into the tender document,          district-sized jigsaw, with some
                                                                                  bins will choose not to have them.
along with the band we expected to       properties not getting bins and
                                                                                  This reduces the risk to the council
start with for each waste stream,        some getting one or other of the
                                                                                  by having more certainty about the
container type and bin size, and a       bin types. When you throw in two
                                                                                  number of properties that will be
higher and lower band for bin and        different bin sizes for rubbish and
                                                                                  rated for the service. R
bag numbers. Tenderers were invited      three for organics, it gets really
to suggest different bands if that       complicated.
better reflected when resource levels
                                         And the final results?
would change for them.
                                         •   48 per cent of eligible households
     Four tenderers provided
                                             opted in for an organics bin,
competitive two-envelope bids
                                             which was more or less what was
and were invited to present to the
                                             budgeted for.
assessment panel and probity
                                                                                    Kitty Waghorn is the Waimakariri District
                                                                                  Council’s solid waste asset manager. Her role
                                                                                    in Waimakariri has changed considerably
                                                                                    over the past 20 or so years and she now
                                                                                      concentrates on solid waste contracts
                                                                                      and asset management, and on waste
                                                                                   minimisation projects and education. She is
                                                                                  involved in steering groups that cover waste
                                                                                   management and minimisation projects in
                                                                                  Canterbury, which included management of
                                                                                  post-earthquake demolition and hazardous
                                                                                   wastes after the Canterbury earthquakes,
                                                                                    and New Zealand-wide projects (e.g., Love
                                                                                     Food Hate Waste), and is a trustee of the
                                                                                        Sustainable Living Education Trust.

18
PR OT E CT I N G N EW Z EA L A N D’ S E N V IR O N ME NT IS A PR IO R ITY F O R E NVIR O NZ .
FOR T HI S R EAS O N , W E A RE C O M M IT T ED TO DE L IVE R ING A R ANG E O F SAF E AND
S U STA I N A BL E T E C H N ICA L S E RV IC E S INCLUDING :

Contaminated Site Remediation                             Dredging and Dewatering
EnviroNZ provides specialist remediation                  Ponds or retention basins, used by industrial sites,
services to consultants and landowners who have           stormwater systems, sewage and water treatment
contaminated sites. We take responsibility for            plants, often accumulate solids over time. EnviroNZ
all health, safety and environmental compliance           carries out sludge removal using specialised
aspects of the remediation project, as well as            dredging equipment and dewatering methods to
budget and programme management.                          improve operational or environmental performance.

Emergency Response Services                               Wastewater Treatment Systems
We have responded to a number of significant              Our Technical Services team designs, builds and
emergencies over the past ten years. Our services         operates wastewater plants for large and long term
include waste logistics, transport, disposal              construction projects, and provides mobile water
and tracking, resource recovery and recycling,            treatment plant/equipment to sites requiring short
water management, personnel and equipment                 term solutions. The equipment enables construction
decontamination services, wastewater treatment,           companies to meet their environmental compliance
beach surveillance, debris recovery and data              requirements, whilst enabling site work to continue
management.                                               during wet weather.

Liquid and Hazardous Waste Services
Our team of qualified professionals, work with
customers to identify, manage and dispose of
hazardous and liquid waste, while ensuring we meet
all corporate, regulatory and social responsibilities.

If you would like to know more about our services and how we can work together for a greener tomorrow,
please visit www.environz.co.nz or give us a call on 0800 240 120.
USING LEARNING
     TEAMS TO
     ENHANCE
     ORGANISATIONAL
     LEARNING
     AND WORKER
     ENGAGEMENT

20
Greg Dearsly explains what a learning                                                came about. Stakeholders from
                                                                                           the industry, territorial authorities,
      team is and describes a learning team                                                community groups and, most
      process initiated by the WasteMINZ                                                   importantly, workers involved in the

      Health and Safety Sector Group Steering                                              use of these vehicles, were invited to
                                                                                           participate.
      Committee in response to an incident
      involving a waste collection truck.                                                  What is a
                                                                                           learning team?
                                                                                           A learning team is a facilitated

      I
                                                                                           conversation between those who
          T’S FAIR to say that workplaces      behaviour and point of view about           do the work and those who design
          have a level of commitment to        how work happens. These different           the work to enable the sharing of
          ensuring the health and safety       perspectives change what you look           operational intelligence between
          of all stakeholders exposed to       at in the work environment and what         the two groups and improve system
      the work that is done as part of the     you do to make problems go away.            design.
      organisation’s activities, but what          As a result of an incident                  The learning team process
      knowledge do we have about how           involving a waste collection truck,         recognises that team-based learning
      work happens?                            WorkSafe NZ provided the industry           is the best way to understand a
         We all look at work through           with some guidance about what               particular problem and that a
      a different lens. If you are in a        could be done to improve safety             significant contributor to such a
      management role you’re viewing           in relation to these vehicles. The          team must include the workers who
      work from the perspective of             industry agreed it could come up            are involved in the work.
      organisational success, contractual      with other approaches that would                For learning teams to deliver
      obligations and logistics; if you’re     have more impact on reducing risk           the best results the following is
      a front-line worker your context is      with these vehicles.                        important:
      that the organisation is the place           During discussions at a                 •   Learning teams should be
      where you perform your duties to         WasteMINZ Health and Safety                     an unstructured and organic
      enable you to make a living.             Sector Group Steering Committee                 process.
         Or you might be another type          meeting in late 2018, the group             •   Understanding is needed that
      of stakeholder, maybe an industry        considered these risk reduction                 ‘work as done’ is not a linear
      association, territorial authority       methods and a suggestion was made               process but a dynamic activity
      or community safety group                to engage a group of stakeholders to            and that the best way to
      representing the interests of the        discuss the safety issues related to            understand the complexities of
      community, ratepayers or road            these vehicles. It was here that the            work is to have open discussions
      users. Your context drives your          proposal to facilitate a learning team          about those complexities.

                                                                                WASTE MANAGEMENT SOLUTIONS
                                                                                 Visit us at site one, WasteMINZ 2019 conference

                                             • Balers    • Compactors           • Shredders     • Strapping         • Bins and more...

INNOVATION ENGINEERED BY KNOWLEDGE                                            SEPTEMBER
                                                           www.pioneergroup.co.nz   05082019  \ WASTEMINZ.ORG.NZ
                                                                                         474 663                  \ 21
                                                                                                     sales@pioneergroup.co.nz
The most beneficial phase of a            question, from both the perspective
LEARNING ABOUT                                 learning team is when the group is            of the drivers and members of the
NORMAL WORK                                    in discovery mode; this is when the           public. The knowledge that was
FROM THOSE                                     focus is solely on learning. It is not an     obtained from the process was
WHO DO THE                                     environment to edit or argue about            gained through the power of asking

WORK CAN NOT                                   what is right or wrong – the group is         better questions.

ONLY HELP WITH                                 simply in a situation of discovery.              There were learnings about
                                                   If the group jumps from learning          conditions in the workplace
ORGANISATIONAL                                 mode to problem-solving mode,                 experienced by drivers and
PERFORMANCE, IT                                learning stops. The intent of this            bystanders on collection day. The
WILL MAKE YOUR                                 process is to help the organisation           group learnt about mistakes that
BUSINESS MORE                                  become wiser. Not knowing about               operators made; remember, error
KNOWLEDGEABLE                                  aspects of how work happens is a              is a normal part of the human

AND BETTER AT                                  powerful position to be in: it means          condition.

MAKING DECISIONS.                              the business has the potential                   Attendees were asked to discuss
                                               to find out more and knowing is               situations where they had to be
•    Before trying to resolve issues,          more powerful, making learning a              extra vigilant or where they had
     we first need to understand work          deliberate improvement strategy.              to innovate or improvise. These
     as done.                                                                                questions are designed to enable
While learning teams achieve the
                                               Learning team                                 a better understanding of work as
best outcomes when they are                    example                                       actually done.
unstructured, there are some key               The learning team that was                       When the discussions were
components to consider, starting               facilitated for the WasteMINZ Health          transcribed, there were five areas
with having a clear understanding              and Safety Sector Group Steering              where trends had developed in
and agreement about the goals for              Committee identified a number                 relation to the operation of these
the process.                                   of areas where there was more to              vehicles. Those included capacity
                                               learn about operating the vehicles in

                                                                                                                                          S T E MI
                                                                                                                                     WA              N
                                                                                                                                 E

                                                                                                                                                     Z
                                                                                                                                      Hamilton
                                                                                                                     YOU AT TH

                                                                                                                                                         CO
                                                                                                                                     23-26 Sept

                                                                                                                                     SITE
                                                                                                                                     #
                                                                                                                                      54                 N FERE N
                                                                                                                        EE

    GIVING NEW
                                                                                                                                                         C
                                                                                                                                 S                   E

    MEANING TO
    CUSTOMER
    SERVICE
      ENVIRONMENTAL SOIL TESTING
    Our dedicated contaminated soil Client Services
    team not only manage your account, but they
    also handle all your technical queries.
    It means you know exactly who you’re dealing
    with, and you get a level of personal service that
    makes the whole process easier and better.
    
      %                        MORE                FREEPHONE 0508 HILL LAB (44 555 22)
                                                                                       www.hill-laboratories.com
and capability of operators;            Making the process                       great aspirational goal, but what is
   behaviour and awareness of the                                                   actively being done to achieve this?
                                           a success
   public; environmental conditions,                                                You need to be prepared to hear
                                           Some key takeaways that make sure
   road conditions and configuration;                                               good and bad news, or that change
                                           a learning team is a success are as
   the rules, regulations and                                                       is required. Learning is a deliberate
                                           follows:
   procedures that have to be followed;                                             action that needs to be taken to
                                           •   A learning team needs to be
   and the equipment itself.                                                        understand what you don’t already
                                               conducted in a manner where
      After this first session the group                                            know. R
                                               all contributions are valued,
   was sent away to think, process and
                                               without judgement.
   reflect on what had been learnt, and
                                           •   The sessions need to be safe         Reference
   the group reconvened a week later
                                               environments where everyone          Conklin, T. (2016). Better questions: An applied
   for session two.
                                               is free to communicate their         approach to operational learning.
      This second session needs to
                                               context without fear of
   start in learning mode. Its purpose
                                               repercussion.
   is to refresh and remember what
   had been learnt in session one, then    •   Learning is a corrective measure;

   brainstorm possible solutions for           it makes us smarter and more

   the areas that had been identified as       informed and has value.

   needing further development.            •   When you get better at learning
      As a result of this process,             you have more knowledge and           Greg Dearsly is the owner of First 4 Safety
                                                                                     Ltd and has been providing business with
   WasteMINZ is prioritising the               therefore you make better
                                                                                       workplace safety and health advice for
   opportunities and looking at                decisions. It is vital and primary      18 years. He holds a Graduate Diploma
   potential sources of funding to             to fixing problems.                    in Occupational Safety and Health from
                                                                                        Massey University and in 2018 began
   assist with the development of          Many businesses say they are a                studying for a Master’s in Advanced
   these improvements.                     learning organisation and that’s a                   Leadership Practices.

TechCollect’s e-waste recycling service is
convenient, sustainable and free!
Take your e-waste to any of our OfficeMax
partner retail stores, and we’ll ensure it’s
recycled responsibly.
Go to www.techcollect.nz to find out more.
CONTAMINATED
                      LAND MANAGEMENT
                         FRAMEWORK
                   A CONSULTANT’S PERSPECTIVE
                Simon Hunt outlines the challenge of providing
             contaminated land advice in the absence of sufficient
                 government policy, regulation and guidance.

S
           ELLING TECHNICALLY          A tricky task                           a consistent national level playing
           accurate and commercially   Depending on the nature of the work     field in the form of a coherent
           focused contaminated land   being undertaken, providing the         contaminated land management
           management advice is the    correct advice can be a tricky task     framework. This lack of consistency
life blood of a contaminated land      because of the absence of strong        creates confusion and typically
consultant. The advice given takes     government policy and regulation        generates a case-by-case situation
many forms, including due diligence    (and mixed enforcement), operating      that is time consuming and costly
supporting property purchase or        standards that are current and up-      for all involved.
sale, investigation and remediation    to-date guidance.
of sites as part of redevelopment,
                                                                               Progress made
                                          Unfortunately, the New Zealand
regulatory compliance and liability    contaminated land industry (which
                                                                               in the 1990s
management for corporates.                                                     These issues are not new in
                                       includes a range of stakeholders
   Most of the advice given aims                                               the context of management of
                                       and practitioners) doesn’t have all
to minimise the cost of dealing                                                contaminated land in New Zealand.
                                       the necessary policy directives and
with contaminated land issues and                                              I fell off the proverbial boat and
                                       management tools available to
achieve regulatory compliance –                                                landed in Auckland in 1993 and, from
                                       deliver what would be considered
rarely are there real human health                                             a contaminated land perspective,
                                       best practice and fit-for-purpose for
and/or environmental risks, with                                               it was an exciting time. I felt New
                                       the New Zealand market.
much of the work undertaken being                                              Zealand was ahead of the United
                                          Some readers may disagree or
routine.                                                                       Kingdom, from where I originated.
                                       ask why is this the case? My answer
                                       is simple – because we don’t have

24
The Resource Management                   Contaminants in Soil to Protect
   Act had just been enacted, an                 Human Health (NES-CS) that was                THIS STOP WORK
   integrated series of contaminated             regulated in 2011 and gave us Soil            SITUATION
   land guidance was being developed,            Contaminant Standards (SCSs) for              AND ABSENCE
   liability issues were being                   a select number of contaminants               OF ‘JOINED UP
   considered, the building regulations          and the term 'suitably qualified and
                                                                                               THINKING’ BETWEEN
   had taken steps to address                    experienced practitioner' (SQEP).
   contaminated site issues and central
                                                                                               THE MANAGEMENT
   government was actively focused on            Foundations built                             OF CONTAMINATED
   contaminated land management                  but work stalled                              LAND AND RAFT OF
   and showed strong leadership.                 This initial work, as I understand it,        OTHER VARIABLES
   Things weren’t perfect, but there             was meant to be the first building            THAT INFLUENCE
   was change and a roadmap.                     blocks and foundation for a national
                                                 contaminated land management
                                                                                               THE DECISION-
       As a benchmark, I recommend
                                                 framework; however, work seems
                                                                                               MAKING PROCESSES
   reading Michael Szabo’s 1993 article
   in the New Scientist, New Zealand’s           to have stopped on this building              ON HOW BEST
   Poisoned Paradise, or consider the            project.                                      TO MANAGE
   positive effects the sequence of                  This stop work situation and              CONTAMINATED
   guidelines developed by central               absence of ‘joined up thinking’               SITES HAS CREATED
   and local government and the                  between the management of                     PERVERSE
   oil industry in the 1990s had on              contaminated land and raft of
                                                 other variables that influence the
                                                                                               OUTCOMES AND
   standardising work and minimising
                                                 decision-making processes on how
                                                                                               FRUSTRATED
   effects.
       The move towards establishing a           best to manage contaminated sites             STAKEHOLDERS, AND
   coherent management framework                 has created perverse outcomes and             OFTEN RESULTED
   waned in the early 2000s. There               frustrated stakeholders, and often            IN POOR DECISION
   was a revised focus in 2006/2007              resulted in poor decision making.             MAKING
   with the release of the Ministry for              At the same time, as an
   the Environment’s Working towards             industry, I sense we are kicking the
   a comprehensive policy framework              ‘contaminated land can’ down the
   for managing contaminated land                road, and all too often are focused
   in New Zealand – Position paper.              on dealing with de minimis issues
   This was the catalyst for the                 rather than addressing the more
   National Environmental Standard               significant ones.
   for Assessing and Managing

EHS Support New Zealand Ltd – Local Experts. Global Partners.
Services include:
• Contaminated land management – PSIs, DSIs, human health risk assessment, and remediation.
• Landfill gas and vapour investigations, assessment, and mitigation.
• Asbestos management – licensed assessors, surveyors, asbestos management plans, asbestos in soil.
• Environment, health and safety management support – resource consenting, auditing,
  process/control development, strategic advice, and compliance.
• Spill and emergency response.

Meet the New Zealand Team
Dave Dangerfield • david.dangerfield@ehs-support.com • Tel: 0275 577 342
Hiram Garcia • hiram.garcia@ehs-support.com • Tel: 0221 050 085
Rebecca Cleghorn • rebecca.cleghorn@ehs-support.com • Tel: 021 518 420
Simon Hunt • simon.hunt@ehs-support.com • Tel: 021 402 997
Mike Mechaelis • mike.mechaelis@ehs-support.com • Tel: 021 399 451 SEPTEMBER 2019 \ WASTEMINZ.ORG.NZ \ 25
Issues to address                               contaminants and emerging                    the form of the Certified

 Improvements can be made through                contaminants.                                Environmental Practitioner —

 addressing issues such as the               •   More frequent use of Tier 2                  Site Contamination Specialist),

 following:                                      human health risk assessment                 but it really needs central and

 •   Better policy, regulation                   needs to be undertaken and                   local government to endorse

     and advice on landfilling of                documented in accordance                     the scheme and for industry to

     contaminated soil – New                     with specific protocols. While               back it through procurement

     Zealand’s preferred remedial                available overseas, they are                 initiatives.

     method because of cost, but is              not necessarily followed in              •   Existing regulation and guidance
     it sustainable? Doesn’t it seem             New Zealand, hence guidance                  are principally focused on soil
     odd to place large volumes of low           to direct practitioners on best              impacts (other than several
     level asbestos-contaminated                 practice and assist regulators is            regional council groundwater
     topsoil into engineered landfills?          needed.                                      rules) rather than the ultimate
     A change in the landfill levy would     •   The NES-CS introduced the                    receiving environment
     drive more sustainable outcomes,            term SQEP to improve the                     (groundwater, surface water and
     significantly change the industry           quality of the work and assist               sediment). Better guidance and
     approach and hopefully save a               regulators in understanding                  regulation are needed to address
     valuable resource.                          who is competent. The wider                  the interactions between

 •   New Zealand’s specific guidance             contaminated industry                        these media and protect these

     has served us well over the                 stepped up (through a                        receiving environments —

     years, but it needs a refresh to            WasteMINZ initiative) and                    particularly given their ecological

     make it current. The list of SCSs           facilitated the generation of                and cultural importance.

     needs expanding to address the              a trans-Tasman practitioner              •   Improvements to the NES-CS
     more volatile/soluble organic               certification scheme (in                     and Hazardous Activities and

SCARLETT EQUIPPED TRANSFER STATION
                                           SCARLETT SAFE
                                           REFUSE TIPPER
                SCARLETT
              RECYCLING BINS
                                                                                                             SCARLETT HOOKLIFT
                                                                                                                CONTAINER

                                                                                                                       SCARLETT
                                                                                                                      WEIGHBRIDGE
                                                                                      SCARLETT STATIC
                                                                                     COMPACTOR 350-3

visit scarlett.co.nz | call us today 03 688 2900
Industries List are believed to     A road map to
                                                                                 References
    be in the pipeline — we just need   the future                               Ministry for the Environment. (2007).
    them to be released!                Dealing with these issues creates a      Working towards a comprehensive policy
•   Retrospective liability and         challenge in providing contaminated      framework for managing contaminated land
    polluter pays approaches            land advice and making informed          in New Zealand – Position paper.
    are always fraught topics           decisions, not just for consultants,     Resource management (National
    of discussion for central           but for all interested stakeholders      environmental standard for assessing and
    government and industry, as         – regulators, landowners, industry,      managing contaminants in soil to protect
    is the duty to report concept.      insurers, banks, suppliers, vendors,     human health) regulations 2011.

    However, our current liability      etc. Hence there is a need for           Szabo, M. (1993). New Zealand’s poisoned
    approach of buyer beware,           a national contaminated land             paradise. New Scientist.
    coupled with historic loose         management framework to provide
    assessment or remediation of        a road map and keep us honest.
    contaminated sites, effects-           But then if it was easy, life would
    based legislation, lack of          be boring; dealing with a challenge
    reporting and remediation           gets you out of bed in the morning.
    principally driven by               One last wish would be one central
    redevelopment is likely to create   agency dealing with contaminated          Simon Hunt is a founding member of EHS
                                                                                     Support New Zealand Ltd. He has over
    future management problems as       land management – but probably             30 years of international contaminated
    regulation and guidance become      not in my working lifetime. R               land experience gained as a consultant,
                                                                                     in industry and as a contractor. He has
    stricter, particularly when you
                                                                                     been intimately involved in developing
    throw emerging contaminants                                                    central and local government policy and
    or changes to contaminant                                                     regulation on contaminated sites and has
                                                                                  contributed to the preparation of various
    toxicities into the mix.                                                              contaminated land guidelines.
GOVERNMENT
                           PROPOSED
                       REGULATED PRODUCT
                       STEWARDSHIP SCHEME
                         HAVE YOUR SAY!
             The consultation process provides an opportunity for
             WasteMINZ members to shape the future direction of
                     product stewardship in this country.

C
             ONSULTATION                      WasteMINZ's Product                   WasteMINZ members can add
             HAS opened on the             Stewardship Sector Group              value throughout this process, from
             government’s proposed         is looking forward to this            the submission stage to future co-
             regulated product             opportunity. In 2018, 96 per cent     creation and working collaboratively
stewardship programme, which               of WasteMINZ members surveyed         with the government.
will put greater accountability on         voted in favour of regulated
producers for what happens to              product stewardship. A decisive       Ministerial
products at the end of their life cycle.   approach to product stewardship       announcement
                                           is what some members have             At the launch of the consultation on
   Consultation runs from
                                           been seeking for some time and        9 August, Associate Environment
9 August until 4 October and
                                           the Ministry has clearly indicated    Minister Eugenie Sage’s message was
WasteMINZ encourages members
                                           that consultation is the first step   clear: the focus is on partnership.
to take part in the process. "This
                                           towards regulation.                   Producers of priority products,
is the ideal chance for members
                                              The outcome from the current       stakeholders involved in the product’s
to become informed, and to share
                                           consultation will be the setting      life cycle and other interested parties
their thoughts with the Ministry
                                           of a framework for regulated          should make submissions with a view
for the Environment regarding
                                           product stewardship, the potential    to actively being involved in potential
the proposed priority products
                                           declaration of certain products as    next steps.
and how these products will be
                                           priority products, the issuance of       The Associate Minister said that
managed through a regulated
                                           guidelines which set expectations     New Zealand has not yet used the
product stewardship scheme" says
                                           for accredited product stewardship    regulated product stewardship tools
WasteMINZ CE Janine Brinsdon.
                                           schemes, and the chance to work       in the Waste Minimisation Act.
   The relevant WasteMINZ sector
                                           with stakeholders to co-design,          “Product stewardship has so
groups will be making submissions
                                           monitor scheme outcomes and           far been voluntary and while it has
and members are also encouraged
                                           make and enforce any necessary        produced some benefits it has not
to make their own individual or
                                           regulations.                          significantly reduced the risk of
company submission.
                                                                                 harm from these products.”

28
You can also read