In the driver's seat The life and work of Lansing's Michael Burton - Creative Circle Media Solutions

 
CONTINUE READING
In the driver's seat The life and work of Lansing's Michael Burton - Creative Circle Media Solutions
Locally owned                                    February 3 - 9, 2021

      www.lansingcitypulse.com                                                                           A newspaper for the rest of us

                                                       In the driver’s seat
                                                       The life and work of Lansing’s Michael Burton
                                                                                                                                   See page 15

City Pulse Ads.qxp_Layout 1 1/15/21 11:24 AM Page 10

 When it comes to Auto Accident and Personal Injury cases, you worry about getting better. We take care of everything else. Call Abood Law. 517.332.5900
In the driver's seat The life and work of Lansing's Michael Burton - Creative Circle Media Solutions
2                                              www.lansingcitypulse.com                  City Pulse • February 3, 2021

                                                                          Our Flower Shop

     Lansing                                                                   creates
                                                                          unique, beautiful
                                                                           arrangements!

       Gardens
                                                                          Delivery is available

                                                    Valentine’s Day is Sunday,
                                                           February 14!
                                                         GET YOUR
    We also have great services!                     HOUSE PLANTS
      • Lawn Clean Up • Mulching • Irrigation
                                                              AND
      • Landscaping • Lawn Care • Fertilizer
                                                      SUCCULENTS!
      • TLC for the beautiful space of relaxation
       and enjoyment for the whole family            SEASONAL
      • Mulch, Soil and Stone Delivery Available        HOURS
    Contact the office at 517-322-2671 for          MON-FRI 9-3
    Outdoor Beautification Services
    1434 E. Jolly Rd., Lansing • Garden Center 517.882.3115
In the driver's seat The life and work of Lansing's Michael Burton - Creative Circle Media Solutions
City Pulse • February 3, 2021                             www.lansingcitypulse.com              3

                                          Celebrating
           BLACK HISTORY MONTH!
                                                                                     Presents

                                                      Black History Month
                                                      Storytime Series
                                                      Featuring artist and author
                                                      Julian Van Dyke
                                                      Saturday, Feb. 6 at 11 a.m.
                                                      Celebrating African American
                                                      culture, stories and songs
                                                      for ages pre-schoolers and up

             The event will be posted
            on the CADL Facebook
                    page as well
             at vandykeart.com
               and will be available
            for viewing throughout the
                      month
                                (no account needed)
In the driver's seat The life and work of Lansing's Michael Burton - Creative Circle Media Solutions
4                   www.lansingcitypulse.com                                                                  City Pulse • February 3, 2021

                                                                                                                              VOL. 20
                                                                                                                            ISSUE 26
                                 (517) 371-5600 • Fax: (517) 999-6061 • 1905 E. Michigan Ave. • Lansing, MI 48912 • www.lansingcitypulse.com
                                                                                           ADVERTISING INQUIRIES:    (517) 999-5061
                                                                                           or email citypulse@lansingcitypulse.com
                                                                            PAGE           CLASSIFIEDS: (517) 999-6704

                                                                              12                EDITOR AND PUBLISHER • Berl Schwartz
                                                                                                  publisher@lansingcitypulse.com • (517) 999-5061
                                                                                                MANAGING EDITOR • Kyle Kaminski
                                        Mayor Schor gives his State of the City address tonight kyle@lansingcitypulse.com • (517) 999-6710
                                                                                                ARTS & CULTURE EDITOR • Skyler Ashley
                                                                                                   skyler@lansingcitypulse.com • (517) 999-5068
                                                                            PAGE                EVENTS EDITOR/OFFICE MANAGER • Suzi Smith
                                                                                                   suzi@lansingcitypulse.com • (517) 999-6704
                                                                              19                PRODUCTION • Abby Sumbler
                                                                                                 production@lansingcitypulse.com
                                                      Lansing’s hip hop academy gets rappin’ (517) 999-5066
                                                                                                 STAFF WRITER • Lawrence Cosentino
                                                                                                  lawrence@lansingcitypulse.com • (517) 999-5065

                                                                            PAGE          SALES EXECUTIVE
                                                                                           Lee Purdy • lee@lansingcitypulse.com • (517) 999-5064
                                                                              30          SALES ASSISTANT
                                                                                           Earlisha Scott • earlisha@lansingcitypulse.com
                                                                                          Contributors: Andy Balaskovitz, Justin Bilicki, Sean
                                                           Flash in the Pan: Short Rib Pho Bradley, Capital News Service, Bill Castanier, Ryan
                                                                                          Claytor, Mary C. Cusack, Tom Helma, Gabrielle
                                                                                          Lawrence Johnson, Terry Link, Kyle Melinn, Mark Nixon,
                                                                          Cover           Dawn Parker, Dennis Preston, Carrie Sampson, Nevin
                                                                                          Speerbrecker, Rich Tupica, Ute Von Der Heyden, David

                                                                            Art           Winkelstern, Paul Wozniak
                                                                                          Delivery drivers: Dave Fisher, Gavin Smith, Jack Sova

                                                                         Courtesy photo

NOW AT 10:00 A.M.
SUNDAYS on
In the driver's seat The life and work of Lansing's Michael Burton - Creative Circle Media Solutions
City Pulse • February 3, 2021                                                     www.lansingcitypulse.com                                                                                   5

 PULSE                                                                                                                                       NEWS & OPINION

          What a tangled web they weave.
                                                A dose of deceit                                                               be held accountable.
          Mayor Andy Schor, City Council President Peter                                                                          To their credit, we note that six of the eight City
      Spadafore and First Ward Councilman Brandon Betz                                                                         Council members either missed or had the good sense
      all got caught cutting the line for the COVID-19 vac-                                                                    to decline the opportunity to get the vaccination offered
      cine, putting themselves ahead of tens of thousands of                                                                   by Sparrow. Although we don’t often agree with her,
      frontline workers, vulnerable senior citizens and people                                                                 long-time At-Large Councilwoman Carol Wood was the
      with pre-existing conditions in getting the first of two                                                                 most forthright, noting that she declined the vaccina-
      injections that will protect them from the deadly dis-                                                                   tion because she thought of the many senior citizens
      ease. It was a profoundly selfish move. All three should                                                                 in Lansing who have yet to receive the shot. Kudos to
      know better. None has apologized. Instead, the three                                                                     Wood, who is eligible for the vaccine by virtue of her
      civic leaders chose to weave fanciful narratives and                                                                     age, for putting the people she serves ahead of her
      high-minded justifications to explain away their errors                                                                  own interests.
      in judgment. Even worse, their stories and excuses are                                                                      This debacle also gives rise to more serious con-
      mutating nearly as fast as the coronavirus itself.                                                                       cerns about the distribution of the COVID-19 vaccine
          After City Pulse spilled the beans on his secret vac-                                                                in our community and across the state. For folks who
      cination, Mayor Schor quickly dispatched his spokes-                                                                     don’t have privileged access to the vaccine, signing
      woman to issue a statement asserting that the mayor                                                                      up to get a shot requires navigating a complex system
      had received no “special treatment” even though it                                                                       involving multiple agencies and multiple waiting lists. It
      was obvious he got special treatment. Schor went on                                                                      is far more complicated than it needs to be. The lack
      to explain that he took the shot to set an example for                                                                   of a coordinated, transparent and accountable system
      others. Since he didn’t publicly disclose that he had                                                                    for vaccine distribution also contributed mightily to
      received the vaccine, we’re not sure who he thought                                                                      enabling high-ranking public officials to cut the line, a
      was going to see him setting that example.                                                                               practice that we suspect is far more widespread than
          Schor then claimed the vaccine that he and 199                                                                       the public is aware.
      other city employees received would have gone to                                                                            Michigan officials should look to West Virginia for
      waste if they did not use them “within hours.” This is                                                                   an example of how to do it right. Early on, the state
      plainly false. We now know that the vaccination offer                                                                    established a statewide pre-registry to sign up for
      from Sparrow Health System was extended to the city                                                                      shots. They recently rolled out a statewide appoint-

                                                                              The CP              Edit
      by email on a Wednesday. The shots weren’t adminis-                                                                      ment system that provides a one-stop shop for people
      tered until the following Saturday. There is no plausible                                                                seeking the vaccination. Distribution of the vaccine is
      scenario under which Sparrow could know that several                                                                     based on five regional hubs across the state and the
      hundred doses of the vaccine would be going bad                                     Opinion                              National Guard is tasked with distributing the vaccines
      three days ahead of time. Let’s call Schor’s claim what                                                                  to each hub. From there, a network of local pharma-
      it is — a lie.                                                                                                           cies works to get shots in arms, a process that began
          As for Council President Spadafore, because he           weren’t eligible for it. You also had a moral obligation    with the residents and staff of long-term care facilities
      refuses to identify who provided him his shot, we are        to ask your “private medical provider” to give the shot     and was completed before many states had even start-
      left to speculate about whether it was an urgent case        to a senior citizen or essential worker. You failed on      ed their vaccination programs. The efficiency of the
      of having to use an expiring vaccine, or if it was simply    both counts.                                                West Virginia system is the reason for its successful
      another case of preferential treatment. Spadafore’s             Sparrow Health System also has some explaining           approach.
      lack of transparency on this point is yet another dis-       to do. The idea that one of the region’s top health care       Whitmer would also be wise to counsel Lynn Sutfin,
      appointment, on top of his attempted deception over          providers had to turn to the mayor and City Council         a spokeswoman for the Michigan Department of Health
      having received a shot at all. After first denying to this   members for a vaccine “pilot project” is laughable. We      and Human Services, who glibly excused public offi-
      newspaper that he got the shot, Spadafore called us          presume their real motive was using their access to         cials cutting in line by saying it’s important to get shots
      back and changed his story. On his Facebook page, he         the vaccine to provide preferential treatment to pow-       in arms, even if it means going outside the priority
      then posted a lengthy rationalization — since deleted        erful public officials as a way to curry political favor.   system. This sends a dangerous message that vacci-
      — which included the thoroughly absurd claim that he         This sort of backroom dealing erodes public trust and       nations for the privileged few are just fine, so carry on.
      “ethically couldn’t say no” to taking the vaccine when       falls far beneath the standards of integrity that should       Let’s be clear: it is not fine. It is a travesty and it
      it was offered. Quite the opposite, Mr. President. You       govern the institution. Those who made the decisions        needs to stop.
      had an ethical duty to decline the shot because you          to enable the bad behavior of our public officials should

                                            Send letters to the editor to letters@lansingcitypulse.com.
                                                       Please limit them to 250 words
In the driver's seat The life and work of Lansing's Michael Burton - Creative Circle Media Solutions
6                                                                       www.lansingcitypulse.com                                             City Pulse • February 3, 2021

To become ‘the city on the hill,’ Racial equity requires risk,
we must fight systemic racism painful truths and compromise
By RON BACON                                                                          By RANDY WATKINS                           of non-minorities. Black and brown
                                           but we are definitely not receiving
Opinion                                                                               Opinion                                    drivers are still stopped and searched
                                           the most complete picture.
                   Ron Bacon was                                                                                                 at a rate higher than non-black and
                                              In 2021, we are experiencing a                             (Randy Watkins is
                   appointed last year                                                                                           brown drivers. We knew these things
                                           wave of people of color being the                             an associate pro-
                   to fill a vacancy on                                                                                          10 years ago.
                                           first to reach some new stations and                          fessor of political
                   the East Lansing                                                                                                 So why should this time be differ-
                                           heights in this country. This repre-                          science at Lansing
                   City Council,                                                                                                 ent?
                                           sentation demystifies and helps to                            Community
                   becoming the                                                                                                     One difference is the apparent
                                           unwrite some of the false and racist                          College, chairman
                   city’s first Black                                                                                            recognition by the government
                                           narrative that permeate our culture                           of the Mayor’s
                   councilman. Bacon                                                                                             that something finally needs to be
                                           and shape many of our systems even                            Inclusion and
                   is a Saginaw                                                                                                  done. The creation of the Mayor’s
                                           today. Many of these stations are                             Diversity Advisory
                   Valley State                                                                                                  Inclusion and Diversity Advisory
                                           arrived at with no clear path, with-                          Council, member
University graduate and a manager at                                                                                             Council and the Racial Justice and
                                           out firm mentorship and achieved           of the Mayor’s Racial Justice and
Genentech Inc. He has also chaired                                                                                               Equity Alliance are steps in the right
                                           through great personal risk and loss.      Equity Alliance and the first vice pres-
the East Lansing Human Relations                                                                                                 direction. Problems will be identi-
                                              I am always looking for ways to         ident of the Lansing NAACP branch.)
Commission and has served on the                                                                                                 fied and solutions proposed, but the
                                           bring greater equity, particularly
Martin Luther King Jr. Commission of                                                     When I was first asked to pen an        fundamental question remains: How
                                           for young people and those without
Mid-Michigan.                                                                         opinion piece on racism in Greater         do you convince residents this is a
                                           access to power. By this, I mean
                                                                                      Lansing, it was going to be optimis-       problem that affects all of us; and as
   How do you lead when a select           seeking ways to lower the opportuni-
                                                                                      tic. I had a belief that Lansing is        such, that we all need to work on a
group has decided that our common          ty cost and shorten the journey. That
                                                                                      not as “bad” as similarly sized cities.    solution?
rules, laws and norms do not apply         is why I tend to focus my energy on
                                                                                      Growing up, I always heard that               You can provide training to city
to them? This feels like the point of      the system rather than “hearts and
                                                                                      Lansing is subtle in how racism is         employees, but even they need to
inflection in history that we must         minds.”
                                                                                      practiced compared to other areas.         know why it’s important so the
meet with great intentionality and            Systemic racism and inequali-
                                                                                         As I began to work on my draft, my      training is not just window dressing.
an eye on the future. It appears that      ty so acutely damage the fabric of
                                                                                      intent was to provide a look at racism     Anyone who cares about the Lansing
the forces of the past and a very          the American dream and destroy
                                                                                      as a social construct — something          area needs to recognize that we are
dark history of America are literally      so much of our collective potential
                                                                                      invented so one group could feel           much better together. To achieve that,
on the march in this country. If we        — particularly in the Black commu-
                                                                                      superior over another, a means by          we have to be part of the solution.
choose to not meet this moment,            nity. If we as a people are spending
                                                                                      which various myths could be perpe-           However, we live in an age of mis-
I fear those forces will repeat the        all of our time trying to figure out
                                                                                      trated. However, an incident occurred      information and mistrust. How else
atrocities of the past.                    how to navigate systems of inequity,
                                                                                      that changed my direction.                 do you explain the armed intrusion
   Based on my perception of where         then we have squandered the oppor-
                                                                                         So, do Greater Lansing residents        of the Capitol and attempted kidnap-
we actually reside at this moment, I       tunity for that same ingenuity to
                                                                                      want to move the dial? Do they want        ping of our governor and the insur-
will speak to the role that I need to      solve some of America’s most daunt-
                                                                                      to see social equity?                      rection in D.C.?
play in my local community to pro-         ing challenges.
                                                                                         I’m sure many do, but I’m not so           Truth needs to be told, no matter
mote a fair and equitable system for          I also want this to be the final
                                                                                      optimistic. In any endeavor, people        how painful. We may be more aware,
those still willing to participate in      generation of firsts. As a nation, we
                                                                                      need to understand why it’s import-        but we are more fearful.
the system in an honest way that is        have a great affinity for firsts. We
                                                                                      ant to them and others. We can’t con-         Our country is more fractured now
also hinged in reality and facts.          celebrate them and demarcate them
                                                                                      vince people to wear a face mask for       than at any point I can remember.
   When I consider my primary func-        in our history. Unfortunately, some
                                                                                      their health and the health of others.     It would be easy to write a piece cel-
tions within my family and for the         firsts beg the question: How is this
                                                                                      How can we convince them to fight          ebrating the achievements of Black
community of Greater Lansing more          just now happening? If equity of
                                                                                      systemic racism?                           Americans and how through many
broadly, they are to lower the barri-      opportunity and representation are
                                                                                         I became further depressed when         adversities they carried on, how Black
ers to opportunity and to provide a        the critical gateways to the future,
                                                                                      I read that 999 people were shot           and white leadership in Lansing is
voice and representation for people        how do we clear that path for mem-
                                                                                      and killed by the police in 2020.          addressing the urgent issues facing
who do not have a seat at the table. I     bers of underrepresented groups to
                                                                                      We should all be outraged when one         us. The dial may have moved, and
take it rather literally that if you are   dream bigger and often to escape the
                                                                                      person is shot, but we’re not. We find     there may be more optimism. But we
not at the table, you are probably on      gravity of their current circumstanc-
                                                                                      ways to justify the shooting or say        have been here before.
the menu.                                  es?
                                                                                      “they deserved it’’ because of the indi-      The key with any problem is iden-
   It has also become abundantly              By lowering the systemic barriers
                                                                                      vidual’s history. Reports state that       tifying what the real problem is and
clear that power will cede nothing         to entry through representation,
                                                                                      3.9 million guns were purchased in         what information you need to resolve
without a concerted and focused            thus unleashing the untapped poten-
                                                                                      June 2020 during the height of the         that problem. Further, you have to
effort. Therefore, in many situations      tial of our diverse citizenry. Greater
                                                                                      Black Lives Matter protests.               be willing to take risks to resolve the
either in business or politics, I may      Lansing broadly and my constitu-
                                                                                         My heart sank further.                  problem. Compromise is a necessity.
be the lone representative for a dif-      ents in the city of East Lansing have
                                                                                         So, is Lansing moving forward?          If you’re not willing to compromise,
ferent racial or cultural perspective.     a beautiful history of being out front
                                                                                      Possibly. It is taking steps to recog-     then all the protests, councils or alli-
When a diverse orientation of people       in the quest for true equality. I hope
                                                                                      nize the problems and create solu-         ances will amount to nothing. And
is not represented in the halls of         we can all be more intentional in our
                                                                                      tions that should have been done           we will be protesting again and ask-
decision-making, the byproduct may         efforts and truly live out the creed of
                                                                                      years ago. Minorities are still unable     ing how we got here.
range from benign to catastrophic,         a “shining city upon a hill.”
                                                                                      to get home loans at the same rate
In the driver's seat The life and work of Lansing's Michael Burton - Creative Circle Media Solutions
City Pulse • February 3, 2021                                                   www.lansingcitypulse.com                                                                                    7

     Whither our congressional
                                                                                              Kildee, would be thrilled with his new       U.S. Rep. Jack Bergman’s Northern
                                                                                              bright blue district.                        Michigan 1st District is basically
                                                                                                 5. Midland and points north. This         immovable. Meijer’s district could go
                                                                                              is the most unlikely of the scenarios,       north into Newaygo and Mecosta —

             district?                                                                        but it’s not improbable that U.S. Rep.
                                                                                              John Moolenaar, R-Midland, sees his
                                                                                                                                           which is the same media market. That
                                                                                                                                           pushes Moolenaar into Lansing, at
  Five scenarios in play for                       Macomb County and the one held by          district pushed a little further north       least, potentially splitting the coun-
                                                   U.S. Rep. Rashida Tlaib further south      into Lansing from Clinton County,            ty. There’s no good direct route from
           Lansing                                 into Wayne.                                which is in his 4th District. If the West    Midland to Lansing, but it could be
   We’ve known U.S.                                   1. Lansing stays with Slotkin. Since    Michigan-based 2nd remains a shore-          done.
                                                                                              line district, as it is today, Moolenaar’s      (Kyle Melinn of the Capitol news ser-
                                        POLITICS
Rep. Elissa Slotkin                                at least the 1930s, Ingham County and
for two-plus years                                 Livingston County have been almost         district is limited in where it can go.      vice MIRS is at melinnky@gmail.com.)
here in Lansing, but                               always in the same district. Starting in

                                                                                                     LETTERS
what are the odds                                  the 1980s, northern Oakland County
we’ll get a chance to                              was added to the mix. The redis-                                                           Have something to say about
                                                                                                                                               a local issue or an item that
                                                                                                   to the editor
vote for her in 2022?                              tricting commission could use that
   The short answer                                model, but Slotkin would need to lose
is more unlikely than
                                                                                                                                                 appeared in our pages?
                                                   Rochester Hills and possibly other
                                                                                                                                             Now you have two ways to sound off:
likely.                                            parts of Oakland as Lawrence’s district     Not a joking matter
                  Every 10 years, after a          swells northward. Under this scenario,         Kyle Melinn should stop asking             1.) Write a letter to the editor.
  OPINION U.S. census is conducted,                Shiawassee and/or Clinton would need        public officials to joke about their          • E-mail: letters@ lansingcitypulse.
               states need to rejigger their                                                   power. Last week, Melinn criticized           com
                                                   to rejoin the 8th — as was the case in
                                                                                               former Secretary of the Department            • Snail mail: City Pulse, 1905 E.
congressional lines in a way that better           the 2001 maps.
                                                                                               of Health and Human Services                  Michigan Ave., Lansing, MI 48912
reflects where people live. That’s this               The question the commission will                                                       • Fax: (517) 371-5800
year.                                              need to answer, however, is whether         Robert Gordon for failing to chuckle
                                                                                                                                             • At lansingcitypulse.com
   Projections have Michigan losing one                                                        when Melinn asked if Gordon felt
                                                   northern Oakland County and Lansing                                                       2.) Write a guest column:
                                                                                               “like you’re the most powerful per-
of our U.S. House of Representatives               are “communities of interest.”                                                            Contact Berl Schwartz for more
                                                                                               son in the state.” Melinn’s question          information:
seats, going from 14 to 13. That would                2. Ingham, Jackson and Eaton are         was referring to Gordon’s signing
follow the downward trend we’ve seen                                                                                                         publisher@lansingcitypulse.com
                                                   roped in together. As Tlaib’s district      of orders to pause indoor enter-              or (517) 999-5061
since the 1970s as population has                  is pushed south, U.S. Rep. Debbie           tainment to prevent the spread of
increased in southern states. Michigan             Dingell’s district is pushed more into      COVID-19 after a decision by the              (Please include your name, address and
had 19 members of the U.S. House in                Washtenaw County, which is experienc-       Michigan Supreme Court had limited            telephone number so we can reach you.
                                                                                               the authority of Governor Whitmer             Keep letters to 250 words or fewer. City
1971, 18 in 1981, 16 in 1991, 15 in 2001           ing exploding growth. If Dingell’s dis-                                                   Pulse reserves the right to edit letters and
and 14 in 2011.                                    trict includes Monroe, the commission       (“Why the Gordon Era Came to an               columns.)
   Redistricting warhorse Ed Sarpolus                                                          End,” Jan. 27).
                                                   could rope Ingham into what is now
                                                                                                  On WKAR-TV’s “Off the Record”
a while ago drafted up a map of what               the 7th District. Jackson and Ingham
Michigan’s congressional lines could               are in the same media market, after
                                                                                               last week, Melinn asked a similar           LSMFT means bad
                                                                                               question of state Sen. Curtis Hertel,
look like with 13 districts. His first             all. Ingham and Jackson were together       who is married to Gordon’s succes-          news for CP
crack doesn’t have Slotkin representing            in the 1960s and ‘70s maps, too. Can’t      sor. Melinn asked if Hertel and his           I have been very impressed
Ingham County at all.                              imagine conservative U.S. Rep. Tim          wife were “the new power couple in          with the progressive stances and
   The 8th District would include Troy,            Walberg would like it, but he doesn’t       town.” Hertel did not laugh either.         hard-hitting reporting you have
Madison Heights and Oakland County’s                                                              As Melinn recognized in City             exhibited on your editorial pages.
                                                   get a vote … . Shoot, under this scenar-
                                                                                               Pulse, government officials are try-        But then you seem to undermine
most southeastern suburbs. Ingham                  io, his Tipton home might not be in the
                                                                                               ing to navigate a pandemic that has         them by accepting full-page
and Clinton counties would join U.S.               district anyway.                                                                        ads from, of all people, LUCKY
Rep. Peter Meijer’s 3rd Congressional                                                          killed thousands of Michiganders
                                                      3. Kent and Ionia grab Ingham            and put thousands more out of               STRIKE! My initial reaction was
District.                                          through Clinton. Under the first            work, not to mention extreme politi-        that this was a setup for a story
   It’s possible. The political consider-          Sarpolus map, Grand Rapids would            cal division and the continued threat       on the continuing influence of big
ations about saving specific members’              join Holland, Muskegon and Grand            of insurrection. There is no humor          tobacco. How wrong I was.
territories is out the window with this            Haven into a Super West Michigan dis-       here. Melinn should find other ways           As an old guy (83) I remember
new redistricting commission.                      trict. Suburban Kent County, Ionia and      to question public officials.               the ad campaigns for LSMFT.
   Instead, “communities of interest” is           Montcalm would stretch to the east and         Dusty Horwitt                            There was a reason that cig-
a central focus. Lansing, being located                                                           Lansing                                  arettes were known as “coffin
                                                   we’d all become the 3rd District, which                                                 nails,” even by those who were
in the center of the state will be swal-           is represented by Meijer. This would                                                    hooked on them. As the son of
lowed up by a districts to the north,              create a I96 district, which is a link.                                                 parents who died from emphy-
the west, the south, the east or even                 4. Flint and Lansing. As recently as     City Pulse compared                         sema, having been smokers all
the northeast. Lansing simply isn’t                the 1950s, Ingham and Genesee coun-                                                     of their lives, I cannot believe
large enough to anchor its own district            ties were in the same district through      to dictators                                that the fresh voice of reason in
without causing geographical problems                                                             The January 13-19 City Pulse             Lansing would bow to corporate
                                                   Livingston County. These days, that trio
                                                                                               opinion column “Only the beginning”         advertising of this nature. I realize
elsewhere.                                         would exceed the population threshold       is truly great literature!                  that finances are very tough, but
   Here are five scenarios that could              for a congressional district, but link-        It belongs next to several oth-
realistically play out as the commission                                                                                                   you can and must do a lot better
                                                   ing the two with Shiawassee County          er great writings such as “Mein             than this.
breaks up the state into 13 different              — creating an I69 district — would          Kampf,” “Das Kapital” and “Mao’s              Neil O. Leighton
areas. This assumes the commission                 probably not. Flint and Lansing has         Little Red Book”!                             Professor of Political Science
keeps the two predominately Black                  some similarities although, again, this        No quarter. No compromise. No            Emeritus
districts in adherence with the Voting             would merge a couple media markets.         mercy. Uncle Joe Stalin would be              University of Michigan-Flint
Rights Act, which splits Detroit in                Considering the other alternatives out      proud.
half and expands the district held by                                                             Earl Ruhf
                                                   there, our new U.S. representative, Dan
                                                                                                  Lansing
U.S. Rep. Brenda Lawrence north into
In the driver's seat The life and work of Lansing's Michael Burton - Creative Circle Media Solutions
8                                                                                       www.lansingcitypulse.com                                             City Pulse • February 3, 2021

                     CC             OF THE WEEK
                                                                    REWIND
                                    OF THE WEEK                  NEWS HIGHLIGHTS FROM THE LAST 7 DAYS
                                                                                                                                                                    By KYLE KAMINSKI

                                                              Bernero plans another mayoral run                            public health uncertainties remain to confidently plan an
                                                              FFormer Lansing Mayor Virg                                   in-person festival until later in the summer, according to a
                                                           Bernero said he plans to run for                                release.
                                                           a fourth term against Mayor Andy
                                                           Schor in November after his cam-                                Schor seeks vacant-land development
                                                           paign sent out a fundraising letter                                Lansing Mayor Andy Schor issued a request for develop-
                                                           over the weekend which included                                 ment proposals this week for projects on three city-owned
                                                                                                                           properties. The initiative aims to dispose of and meaningfully
        Campbell’s Market                                  the new catchphrase: “Together,
                                                                                                                           develop a vacant lot at 1020 W. Hillsdale St, two parking lots
                                                           a better Lansing.” Besides
            Basket                                         Schor and Bernero, Lansing City
                                                                                                                           at 500 E. Kalamazoo St and the former Life O’ Riley property
                                                                                                                           at 6726 S. Washington Ave. Development proposals are due
         547 E. Grand River Ave.,                          Councilwoman Patricia Spitzley                                  later this month.
              East Lansing                                 has also said she plans to run.
                                                           None has filed ahead of the April                               AG seeks sanctions for Trump lawyers
                                                                                               Bernero
       This month’s Eye Candy is                           27 primary election deadline. If                                  Michigan Attorney General Dana
    Campbell’s Market Basket on                            three or more candidates run,                                   Nessel filed motions for sanctions in fed-
    Grand River Avenue in downtown                         the top two vote-getters would face off against each other in   eral court against four lawyers, including
    East Lansing. The building in which                    November. Mayoral elections are nonpartisan.                    Scott Hagerstom of Lansing, who pushed
    the new grocery store is located is                                                                                    false narratives of election fraud in recent
    nondescript: a two-story painted                                 Report: QD dinged over sanitation                     legal proceedings, including a lawsuit
    brick structure built in the 1940s.                       A bombshell report from the                                  against Gov. Gretchen Whitmer that was
    However, the aesthetic flourishes                      Lansing State Journal shows that                                deemed frivolous. Besides Hagerstrom,
    that Campbell’s has added make it                                                                                                                                   Nessel
                                                           federal regulators warned Quality                               the motion requests Novi attorney Greg
    a standout. One of the first things                    Dairy last year to deal with unsan-                             Rohl, Detroit attorney Stefanie Junttila
    visitors notice are the wooden trel-                   itary conditions at its central pro-                            and Texas attorney Sidney Powell be disbarred. Hagerstrom
    lises framing the front window. In                     cessing facility after inspectors                               was the state director of Donald J. Trump’s campaign in 2016.
    better weather, these host flowering                   found insects, bacteria and unclean
    vines. The three panels of the store-                  conditions. Quality Dairy officials                             Groovy Donuts gears up for Fat Tuesday
    front window between the trellises                     said they’ve worked with the FDA to resolve shortcomings at        Groovy Donuts shops in East Lansing and Williamston
    are used to showcase what the busi-                    its plant on Diamond Reo Way in Lansing, which reportedly       are in the process of reorganizing their dining areas to allow
    ness offers. In a bright blue-green                    included cockroaches, flies and a dead mouse and traces of      for the largest socially distant amount of customers to pick
    script, the top states that it is a                    listeria in food preparation areas.                             up donuts on Fat Tuesday, Feb. 16. Last year, the company
    market; the grab-and-go offerings
                                                                                                                           produced about 5,000 packzis for the holiday. Orders can be
    are spelled out at the bottom of the                   Man freed after decades in jail for pot                         placed online at groovydonuts.com/products. Dine-in service
    window (sandwiches, soups and                            The Michigan Cannabis Freedom Coalition and Lt. Gov.          is not available.
    salads). In between these words,                       Garlin Gilchrist celebrated the release of Michael Thompson,
    the store’s wares--variously bushel                    an inmate who had served more than 23 years in prison on
    baskets of local produce, seasonally                                                                                   Charlotte church named as ‘hate group’
                                                           marijuana-related charges and was granted clemency by Gov.         A report from the Southern Poverty Law
    appropriate pumpkins and gourds,                       Gretchen Whitmer in December. Thompson was arrested for
    or a mass of houseplants--are on                                                                                       Center listed Christ the King Reformed
                                                           selling three pounds of cannabis to an informant in 1994 and    Church in Charlotte as a white national-
    display. It is almost like what is fea-                while no guns were used during the sale, officers later found
    tured is part of an exhibit in a side-                                                                                 ist group. Pastor Brett McAtee wrote in
                                                           guns locked in a safe at Thompson’s home — leading to a         a blog that the white race is “without dis-
    walk-level museum. But perhaps                         draconian sentence of 52-75 years in prison for the combined
    that’s because also reflected in the                                                                                   pute superior,” also describing indigenous
                                                           charges.                                                        groups as “cannabals” and African people
    window is the very real Broad Art
    Museum, designed by the iconic                                                                                         brought in during the slave trade as “sav-
                                                           Potterville receives $25K landscaping grant                     age,” reports FOX 47.                       McAtee
    Zaha Hadid, across the street. The
                                                             The city of Potterville received a $25,000 grant this week
    fluted-edge farmhouse-style hang-
                                                           that will fund a large landscape project along Vermontville     Lansing Council members dodge donations
    ing lights inside the store, that can
                                                           Highway. The funding will cover more than 100 ornamental          The Lansing City Council passed a nonbinding resolution
    be seen through the front window,
                                                           trees, shrubs and perennials that will be installed along the   last summer to donate 10% of their paychecks back to the city,
    and outdoors above the front door
                                                           boundary between the city and Lake Alliance Park.               but three of them have yet to do so, reports the Lansing State
    further connect the store to its mis-
    sion as a purveyor of locally pro-                                                                                     Journal. Council members Kathie Dunbar, Brian Jackson
    duced foods.                                           East Lansing postpones Art Festival                             and Brandon Betz hadn’t made those donations by Monday,
     — CARRIE SAMPSON                                        The East Lansing Art Festival has been                        which would have amounted to about an extra $8,000 for
                                                           postponed until the weekend of Aug. 7-8                         the city.
“Eye Candy of the Week” is our look at some of             “given the current status of the COVID-19
the nicer properties in Lansing. It rotates with Eyesore
of the Week and Eye for Design. If you have a sug-
                                                           pandemic and vaccination rollout,” city offi-
gestion, please e-mail eye@lansing                         cials said this week. The festival was origi-
citypulse.com or call Berl Schwartz at 999-5061.
                                                           nally scheduled for May, but far too many
In the driver's seat The life and work of Lansing's Michael Burton - Creative Circle Media Solutions
City Pulse • February 3, 2021                                                  www.lansingcitypulse.com                                                                                           9

COVID-19 Town Hall coincides with State of the City address
                                                ly as possible” while ensuring equitable
Ingham Co. Health                               access to shots and transparency in dis-
Department schedules                            tribution.                                                         CORONAVIRUS IN MICHIGAN
                                                   A batch of Moderna vaccines shipped
                                                                                                                             BY THE NUMBERS…                                  WEEK 47
vaccines for ages 65-69                         to Michigan in mid-January that was
   Representatives from the Ingham              believed to have been damaged after fall-
                                                ing outside of its temperature range was
                                                                                                                                  MICHIGAN
County Health Department will partic-                                                                                                                          WEEKLY
ipate in a “COVID-19 Town Hall” event           deemed viable this week, adding another                                      1/26/21        2/2/21             CHANGE
                                                8,900 doses back into Michigan’s supply
from 6 p.m. to 8 p.m. today (Feb. 3),
giving local residents something else to        amid concerns of a shortage.                                 CASES            552,556 562,510                    ^2%
watch instead of Lansing Mayor Andy             In related news…
Schor’s annual State of the City address           The East Lansing City Council adopt-                     DEATHS            14,405        14,672                  ^2%
at 7 p.m.                                       ed an emergency ordinance last week
   Hosted by the “Merica 20 to Life”            requiring compliance with public health
                                                                                                      GREATER LANSING                                          EATON CO.
show, which streams live on Facebook,           orders after officials accidentally allowed                           WEEKLY                                                           WEEKLY
the event will include a panel discussion       the existing ordinance to lapse. Those                 1/26/21 2/2/21 CHANGE                              1/26/21 2/2/21               CHANGE
on the coronavirus vaccine with Ingham          who violate a public health order from        CASES 23,552           24,169         ^3%        CASES 5,239                5,394         ^3%
County Medical Director Dr. Adenike             the state or county could also face a civil
Shoyinka, journalist Andrea King Collier        fine of $500 under the newly renewed          DEATHS                                           DEATHS
                                                                                                           431         455          ^6%                      127           137          ^8%
and Dr. Alane Laws-Barker, a top official       ordinance. This version is also set to
at Sparrow.                                     remain in place indefinitely.                                INGHAM CO.                                     CLINTON CO.
                                                                                                                                  WEEKLY                                               WEEKLY
   Questions will be answered live and             Michigan State University announced                    1/26/21 2/2/21          CHANGE                  1/26/21 2/2/21               CHANGE
can be submitted via email to meri-             a two-week “enhanced physical distanc-
                                                                                              CASES 14,123           14,511         ^3%        CASES 4,190                4,264         ^2%
ca20tolife@gmail.com.                           ing” period for both on- and off-campus
   The Health Department started offer-         students following reports of a rise in
ing COVID-19 vaccination appointments           cases on campus this week. Students are       DEATHS       245         255          ^4%        DEATHS         59            63          ^7%
to people 65 to 69 years old on Friday,         ordered to stay inside their homes and
but officials caution that the demand still     avoid gatherings until at least Feb. 13.
                                                                                                                                 CITY OF LANSING
outpaces current supplies.                         Local health officials reported a higher                                        SUMMARY OF
   The latest county data shows that            raw number of cases and rate of positive                                     ADOPTED ORDINANCE # 1272
about 12,500 vaccines have been distrib-        tests in East Lansing than anywhere else       Lansing City Council adopted an Ordinance of the City of Lansing, Michigan, to amend the
uted through the Health Department              in Greater Lansing on Tuesday. Most            Code of Ordinances of the City of Lansing by amending Chapter 1279, Appendix D of the
to first responders, teachers, healthcare       infected are ages 20-29.                       Zoning Ordinance to expand the W. Saginaw Street Overlay District.
workers and those ages 70 and old-                 Violations of the order could result in     Effective date:      February 24, 2021
er. Still, officials estimate there are still   $500 civil fines in the city and other dis-
                                                cipline from MSU.                              Notice:		            The full text of this Ordinance is available for review at the City Clerk’s
about 80,000 people eligible for the vac-                                                      		                   Office, 9th Floor, City Hall, Lansing, Michigan. A copy of the full text of
cine in Ingham County and the Health               Students on University of Michigan’s        		                   this Ordinance may be obtained from the City Clerk’s Office, 9th Floor,
Department can currently only vaccinate         Ann Arbor campus have also been told           		                   City Hall, Lansing, Michigan at a fee determined by City Council.
about 2,000 people each week.                   to stay home except to attend a reduced        Chris Swope, Lansing City Clerk, MMC/MiPMC
   People 65 to 69 and others who have          amount of in-person classes for at least       www.lansingmi.gov/Clerk
been waiting for appointments will              the next two weeks.                            www.facebook.com/LansingClerkSwope			                                               CP#21-021
receive emailed links to schedule an               Meanwhile, East Lansing Public
appointment on or after Feb. 9, provid-         Schools announced that preschool and                                         ABANDONED VEHICLE SALE
ed they registered to receive a shot. Visit     elementary students can begin return-                                        CITY OF LANSING, MICHIGAN
hd.ingham.org or call the vaccine hotline       ing to in-person classes on Feb. 22. High      Sealed bids marked S/21/059, ABANDONED VEHICLES will be accepted at the City of
at 517-887-4623 to set up an appoint-           school and middle school students are          Lansing Purchasing Office, 124 W Michigan Ave 8th floor, Lansing Mi. 48933 until but no later
ment.                                           also set to return to physical classrooms      than, 1:00 PM, local time in effect WED. MAR. 10, 2021.
                                                                                               Questions regarding this sale may be directed to Stephanie Robinson Buyer, at (517) 483-
   About 4,700 more people are expected         after several months of online learning        4128 or email: stephanie.robinson@lansingmi.gov- 30 DAY NOTICE – ALL VEHICLES
to be vaccinated in Ingham County with-         on March 1.                                    MUST BE TOWED OUT.
in the next week.                                  National public health experts — like       Vehicles may be inspected WED. MAR. 10, 2021, as follows:
   Gov. Gretchen Whitmer announced              Dr. Anthony Fauci — are now recom-             SHROYER’S, 2740 Eaton Rapids Rd., Lansing, MI 48911           8:30 AM
this week that the state has adminis-           mending people layer up on two or even         SWIFT TOWING, 2347 N. Cedar, Holt, MI 48842		                  9:30 AM
                                                                                               PJ’S, 1425 Rensen, Lansing, MI 48910                         10:00 AM
tered over 1 million COVID-19 vaccines          three masks to better protect themselves       NORTHSIDE TOWING, 226 Russell, Lansing, MI 48906             10:45 AM
to date, ranking Michigan seventh in the        against COVID-19 in the wake of sever-         H&H MOBILE TOWING, 1500 Haslett Rd., East Lansing, MI 48823 11:30 AM
country in vaccine distribution. In the         al more contagious variants of the virus
                                                                                                                   ABANDONED VEHICLE SALE MARCH 10, 2021
announcement, Whitmer also called on            from the United Kingdom, Brazil and            NORTHSIDE                     SHROYERS                    PJS TOWING
lawmakers to pass a $90 million appro-          South Africa. Guidance now suggests            YEAR      MAKE                YEAR    MAKE                YEAR      MAKE
priation of federal funds that would con-       that wearing two masks (or a KN95              2011      BUICK               1997    TOYOTA              2005      SATURN
                                                                                               2020      OTHER               2007    CHEVROLET           2019      MOPED
tinue to ramp up distribution in hopes of       mask) are better than wearing one.             2005      CADILLAC            2014    KIA                 1996      OTHER
giving 50,000 shots daily.                         A CDC order issued late last month          2003      BMW                 2012    NISSAN              2006      CHRYSLER
                                                                                               2010      FORD                                            2010      NISSAN
   The state’s newly formed Protect             also required face masks be worn on all        2009      DODGE
Michigan Commission also met for the            public transportation systems, including       2011      FORD
first time this week, unveiling the state’s     on rail, van, bus and motorcoach provid-       2004      GMC
                                                                                               2018      HONDA
strategy to get 70% of Michiganians             ers nationwide.                                2015      DODGE                                                         CP#21-022
ages 16 and older vaccinated “as quick-          — KYLE KAMINSKI
In the driver's seat The life and work of Lansing's Michael Burton - Creative Circle Media Solutions
10                                                                          www.lansingcitypulse.com                                                 City Pulse • February 3, 2021

200 city workers jump line, get vaccinated through Sparrow
None were eligible,                                                                                              cials.                    And while she “cannot guaran-
                                                                                                                   Hussain, 37,         tee” that some vaccines administered
says county health officer                                                                                       declined        the    through the Health Department also
   Two hundred city of Lansing employ-                                                                           offer but is eligi-    could have made their way to people
ees, including Mayor Andy Schor and                                                                              ble for the shot       who weren’t eligible to receive them,
two members of the City Council,                                                                                 through Waverly        she stressed that multiple “checks and
jumped the line in January to be vacci-                                                                          Community              balances” are in place to prevent those
nated against COVID-19, putting them                                                                             Schools.               errors.
ahead of 40,000 other Ingham County          Schor                  Betz                  Spadafore                Schor, Spadafore        The deep-cold-storage Pfizer doses
residents qualified to inoculate them.                                                                           and Betz have each     administered locally must be used in
   Schor said that he and 199 other          Greater Lansing are the only private                                described their pri-   five days once refrigerated and with-
city employees accepted private invita-      providers in Lansing with access to dos-     vate invitations as time sensitive — sug-     in seven hours once they reach room
tions last month from Sparrow Health         es of the vaccine. The other source is the   gesting doses would have been wasted          temperature, Vail said. Unlike Sparrow
Systems to receive a COVID-19 vac-           Ingham County Health Department.             if not for their willingness to receive       and possibly McLaren, the Health
cine. They did so despite failing to meet       Officials at both hospital providers      them. Schor said he also took one to set      Department hasn’t had any issues find-
any state eligibility criteria for a shot,   didn’t respond to questions about vac-       an example, though he never publicly          ing the right arms.
according to the Ingham County health        cine distribution irregularities.            announced his intention.                         Of late, the biggest concern has
officer.                                        Like Schor and Betz, 35-year-old             An email sent to Lansing employ-           instead been focused on fueling a
   Councilman Brandon Betz, who              Spadafore failed to check the boxes that     ees from the Human Resources                  steady supply of vaccine to meet the
represents the east side, and Council        would have made him eligible for a shot      Department appears to have offered            demand. At least 40,000 eligible
President Peter Spadafore, an at-large       last month. There is no specific carveo-     vaccine appointments on a first-come,         Ingham County residents were still
member, also received inoculations.          ut in state guidelines on administering      first-serve basis without regard for          waiting in line for their appointments
Betz was one of the 200 city employees       vaccines in the interest of continuity of    whether they were considered “front-          this week as state and federal officials
to receive it, while Spadafore apparent-     government. Accordingly, East Lansing        line essential workers” that had pro-         scrambled to ship more doses.
ly received his apart from the Sparrow       Mayor Aaron Stephens and other offi-         longed contact with the public.                  Sparrow officials told the Lansing
program for city employees.                  cials at Meridian Township said they            Schor has also said that list included     State Journal that the hospital system
   Sparrow officials told City Pulse last    haven’t yet had vaccines.                    parking enforcement and code enforce-         is doing its best to prioritize people
week that vaccines were offered to city         Meanwhile, the six other members          ment officers.                                who are actually eligible for the vac-
staff in a pilot program ahead of wide-      of the Lansing City Council — Kathie            In hindsight, city officials should        cine, which reports vaccinating more
spread distribution. Schor also said the     Dunbar, Jeremy Garza, Adam Hussain,          have sought out senior citizens and           than 22,000 people since December.
city was offered vaccines on a “use it or    Patricia Spitzley, Brian Jackson and         other at-risk people who had been             It’s unclear how many of those people
lose it” basis, claiming doses would have    Carol Wood — said they either didn’t         waiting in line for the shot, Schor told      fit priority guidelines.
otherwise gone wasted.                       receive or declined the recent invitation    Dave Akerly at 1320 WILS on Friday.              Sparrow officials told the Lansing
   Ingham County Health Officer Linda        from Sparrow to skip the vaccine distri-     Spadafore also expressed regret,              State Journal that the city “sent who
Vail has since labeled that invite-only      bution queue.                                though noting he incorrectly thought          they sent” to the clinic.
pilot program a “mistake,” noting that          Dunbar said she had issues with her       he was eligible at the time.                     Regardless, there also appears to
none of those 200 employees were             email and missed the invitation till it         Both have said that a shot in the arm      be no real oversight — and no conse-
properly classified as Priority 1B indi-     was too late but would have declined         — regardless of eligibility — is a shot       quences — from the state to ensure
viduals — like essential frontline work-     the offer. Spitzley said she was invited     put to good use.                              that healthcare providers bother to
ers and those over 75 — under federal        on Wednesday, Jan. 13, to schedule an           Before receiving the vaccine, all          stay in line with the current prioritiza-
guidelines.                                  appointment for the following Saturday,      healthcare providers signed a “provid-        tion schedule. A Department of Health
   Schor and Betz are decades from           but she didn’t check her inbox until         er agreement” with the U.S. Centers for       and Human Services spokeswoman,
senior status under vaccine distribu-        after the shots had already been admin-      Disease Control that spells out an obli-      Lynn Sutfin, explained:
tion guidelines. In Ingham County, the       istered to 200 employees.                    gation to administer doses “in accor-            “We do not want providers to waste
focus is specifically on those over age         Spitzley, 56, also said that she would    dance with all requirements and rec-          vaccines and would rather they pro-
70 because of the high mortality rate in     have tried to give her appointment to        ommendations” of the CDC — includ-            vide vaccines to someone outside of
that age group. Shots for those over 65      her senior citizen mother or frontline       ing the prioritization schedule. It also      the prioritization groups as opposed to
only just started last week. Vaccines are    employee sister and, at her younger age,     notes that federal funding will be with-      throwing it out if it comes down to it,”
otherwise only available for emergency       would have declined to take the shot.        held to any organization that fails to        Sutfin said in a statement, refusing to
first responders — like healthcare per-         “I wouldn’t have ever considered tak-     comply with those priority guidelines.        answer questions. “No shot in the arm
sonnel, firefighters, ambulance crews        ing the vaccine before either of them           Records show that nearly all of that       is ever wasted as getting this vaccine
and police officers — and “essential         could,” Spitzley said, labeling both the     clinic’s 1,000 appointments for second        is our way out of the pandemic and
employees” like teachers and grocery         Sparrow invitation and the city’s distri-    shots are booked.                             returning to some sense of normalcy.”
store staff.                                 bution plan as a “missed opportunity”           “I can’t speak to what they’re doing at       Betz said he also plans to start
   After that news broke, City Pulse con-    and expressing disappointment that           all,” Vail said of Sparrow and McLaren.       knocking on doors later this month to
tacted all Council members to ask if any     more effort was not taken to get those       “I don’t know what they’re doing or           discuss the economy with local resi-
had been vaccinated.                         shots in the right arms.                     how they’re handling their strategy,          dents after he receives the second dose
   Spadafore twice denied he’d been             Wood, 69, said that she declined the      but it’s imperative that we all stick to      of his vaccine. Health officials encour-
inoculated, then called a reporter to        shot and that she would “wait her turn.”     guidance on vaccine priorities for these      age everyone that received their first
“come clean,” as he put it. He said he       But as the executive order of the senior     groups. Usually, these doses are easy to      dose to receive their second, regardless
received early access through an entire-     citizens’ service organization RSVP, she     manage.”                                      of priority line. Those who have been
ly separate invitation from a “private       would have “moved heaven and earth”             Vail also said she doesn’t have insight    vaccinated are still advised to stay six
healthcare provider” that he declined to     to secure those vaccines for local senior    into why top city officials have been         feet from others under CDC guidelines.
identify by name. Sparrow and McLaren        citizens rather than the city’s top offi-    able to cut the line.                          — KYLE KAMINSKI
City Pulse • February 3, 2021                                          www.lansingcitypulse.com                                                                   11

COVID-19 forces Michigan to face another crisis: Racial inequity
                                                                                     down the systemic barriers that cre-      went from 30 percent to 20 percent,
Lt. Gov. Garlin Gilchrist                                                            ated an unequal health outcome in         even as the number of tests ramped
discusses state action                                                               the first place.                          up in October.
                                                                                       To address the crisis immediately,         But the task force also found that
to reduce disparities                                                                the task force drove recommenda-          communities of color were also more
   As the novel coronavirus began to                                                 tions to increase testing in commu-       likely to be facing food and housing
hit Michigan last spring, the disparity                                              nities of color by actually going into    insecurity, work low wage frontline
of whom it was killing quickly came                                                  those communities instead of rely-        jobs and to have less access to per-
into stark relief. Black Michiganians                                                ing on the communities to come to         sonal protection equipment to pre-
represented less than 14% of the                                                     them. Those neighborhood testing          vent getting coronavirus. Leveraging
state’s overall population, but in that                                              sites conducted nearly 25,000 tests       federal dollars, the state partnered
first month they represented at least                                                from the end of August and Nov. 16,       with 31 community organizations to
41% of the deaths.                                                                   when the task force interim report        leverage $32 million to address those
   “We were concerned about this dis-                                                was released. The red tape associated     needs.
parity potentially being present,” Lt.                                               with testing — such as cost, insur-          Data shows it is working. In the
Gov. Garlin Gilchrist said in an exclu-                                              ance and the requirement that a doc-      last three months of 2020, the task
sive interview with City Pulse, “and                                                 tor order the test — were all waived.     force’s interim report tracked far
that’s why Dr. Joneigh Khaldun, our                                                    “We did this partnership with Ford      fewer Black deaths than what was
chief medical executive, before we                                                   Motor Co. for these specially outfit-     reported at the onset in March and
even had our first case, she worked       Gilchrist                                  ted mobile vehicles that could drive      April. Gilchrist said that rate plunged
with local health departments and                                                    testing to a vulnerable community,        from 41% to less than 10% of deaths
hospital systems to outfit our public     calls and emails about friends, fam-       to a church, to a jail, to a park, to a   tracked among people of color.
health infrastructure to even track       ily, former colleagues, passing away       homeless shelter, a flexible platform,       “Michigan has shown that when
demographic data that included race       from COVID-19 every single day,”           to a farm where migrant workers           you focus on addressing racial dis-
and ethnicity. Then once we saw these     he said. “Throughout this pandemic,        needed to be tested,” Gilchrist said.     parities, you can improve them,”
disparities that were so rampant and      I’ve said goodbye to 27 people from          And that wasn’t all. Using the state    Gilchrist added. “So we’ve made
so deadly, Michigan became a leader       COVID-19. So it was important that         insurance program, the task force         progress. That progress is fragile.”
in the nation.”                           we actually recommended and enact-         developed systems to connect com-            Gilchrist noted that state officials
   Gov. Gretchen Whitmer quickly          ed interventions in real time to stop      munities of color with insurance          are working to push out demographic
realized the disparate outcomes and       people from getting sick and for sav-      coverage and primary care. By doing       data on vaccine distribution as well,
burden required a state response,         ing lives.”                                that, the disproportionate impact of      although no timeframe currently
leading to the creation of the               The task force moved with speed,        underlying diseases such as diabe-        exists, he said.
Michigan Coronavirus Task Force           identifying not only the underlying        tes, high blood pressure and asthma          “We have to remain vigilant,” he
on Racial Disparities. Gilchrist,         structural causes of the disparate         could be addressed, reducing the          said. “We are making sure that we’re
Michigan’s first black lieutenant gov-    outcomes, but finding ways to elim-        potential impact on a person if they      using the same source of targeting
ernor, was tapped to lead it.             inate or reduce those barriers.            got COVID-19.                             measures when it comes to social
   Task forces like this often move          Officials quickly realized they faced     In June, the task force pushed the      vulnerability and things like that
along doing the research and putting      a daunting task of addressing not only     Michigan Department of Health and         with our vaccine rollout that we were
together reports with recommenda-         the immediate inequities driving an        Human Services to highlight the race      using with our other strategies with
tions, but “people were dying in real     extraordinary disparity between out-       of people being tested and testing        the task force. We hope that that will
time,” he said. It required some quick    comes for people of color and white        positive for the virus in weekly sta-     bear fruit there as well.”
moves.                                    people in Michigan who contracted          tistical data updates. The percent         — TODD HEYWOOD
   “I was getting text messages and       COVID-19, but that it was staring          of people whose race was unknown
12                                                                       www.lansingcitypulse.com                                               City Pulse • February 3, 2021

It’s time for Schor’s fourth State of the City address.
How did 2020 pan out for him?
Analysis: Pandemic partially
stalls Schor’s progress since
the 2020 State of the City
address
  Lansing Mayor Andy Schor deliv-
ers his fourth annual State of the
City address today (Feb. 3). Officials
said only a very small, socially dis-
tanced crowd will be allowed to watch
the event live from the city’s South
Washington Street office complex.
  Two challengers have already sur-
faced as Schor faces the end of his first
term. And depending on how things
pan out in November, this could mark
his final State of the City speech.
  But before the mayor can take the
virtual stage, let’s look back at 2020.
Last year’s remarks were delivered
about one month before the COVID-19
pandemic arrived in Michigan. It also
included several major announce-
ments. Here’s an overview of how those
have panned out:                                                                                                                                                   Kyle Kaminski/City Pulse
                                            Mayor Andy Schor delivering is 2020 State of the City address at the old Michigan School for the Blind.
    The city hired an environmental         energy efficiency, reduced waste and       announced the creation of BOLD              local priorities, but the artistic culture
  sustainability manager. We haven’t        plans to “look at other areas” to save     Lansing. It was billed as a “break-         in Greater Lansing certainly hasn’t
            heard much since.               costs. Specific operational changes        through concept” that brings together       been lost in the fray.
   Last year, Schor emphasized that         were scarce. Schor is relatively skilled   city programs and local partners to            Schor’s wife, Erin Schor, has served
“something” still needed to be done to      at planning to make plans.                 provide step-by-step financial educa-       as chairwoman of the Mayor’s Arts and
address climate change in Lansing and          And like many other city issues, any    tion and planning for high school stu-      Culture Commission, which has been
hoped a full-time sustainability man-       real adjustments relied on recommen-       dents and their families.                   busy since 2018 awarding Arts Impact
ager would help figure it out.              dations and input from yet another            The program essentially amounted         grants and breathing new life into
   In April, Lori Welch, an environ-        mayoral advisory board. The plans also     to a website that aggregated resourc-       otherwise mundane concrete spaces
mental specialist for Capital Area          included an executive order in which       es for residents, like Lansing SAVE         throughout the city. That included 19
Recycling and Trash, was promoted           Lansing joined a “Global Covenant of       — a partnership with MSUFCU that            ARTpath installations over the last
to the new position to review, revise       Mayors for Climate and Energy” —           helps open savings accounts for kids        year, which stretched over three miles
and implement the city’s sustainabili-      an “alliance of more than 10,000 cit-      and links to free financial counseling      of the Lansing River Trail.
ty plans — like a grant-funded study        ies” that will reportedly help hold city   through the Cristo Rey Community               Among them: A portrait of George
commissioned in 2016 to help create         officials accountable to environmental     Center. Schor’s office reports that 19      Floyd by Isiah Lattimore that was later
an energy management plan. The posi-        goals.                                     students attended 29 sessions. Seven        damaged by graffiti.
tion pays $78,000 a year.                      Part of Welch’s role is tracking data   of those participants earned $90.              The Durant Park Tree Project was
   In July, Schor asked local residents     to better understand how the city can         In September, the city also              approved and initially set to proceed
to cut back on needlessly using water       adjust its operations to reduce green-     announced that 300 local high school        over the summer, but has since been
as part of a competition between other      house gas emissions. Much of that          graduates had been awarded scholar-         postponed until 2021. The commis-
cities that offered participants a chance   initial work is about assessing bench-     ships through the Lansing Promise           sion also worked with the Lansing
to win a new Toyota.                        marks and setting goals. Additional        program “in concert” with BOLD              Economic Area Partnership for a per-
   In October, the city rolled out a        details will be provided as they become    Lansing. Like sustainability efforts, the   manent art installation at Reutter Park
27-page “Action Plan” on climate            available, officials said.                 BOLD Lansing program wasn’t men-            that hasn’t yet materialized.
change and Schor announced the                 The only mention of the word “cli-      tioned in Schor’s annual report.               Other projects included a stunning
Mayor’s Advisory Commission on              mate” in Schor’s annual report in 2020                                                 scale projection mapping that was dis-
Sustainability to build on Welch’s          referenced the “heightened political           More public artwork arrived in          played downtown during an abbrevi-
planning efforts. It doesn’t appear that    climate and racial tensions” that kept                     Lansing.                    ated Capitol City Film Festival. Schor
Schor ever appointed anyone to the          Lansing in the headlines last year.           Last year, Schor said that artwork —     also announced the winner of the
commission. It may have never met.                                                     and especially public artwork — had         2020 Arts Impact grant for a ceramic
   The plan itself included broad goals        A flashy new program — BOLD             been a “significant focus” of his admin-    tile project that will cover parts of the
to reduce the city’s carbon footprint            Lansing — was announced.              istration. The pandemic and a tense
through obvious things like increased         At last year’s address, Schor            election might have shifted focus and                        See State of the City, Page 13
You can also read