Proposed variations to the Otago Southland Regional Land Transport Plans 2015 - 2021 Summary of submissions received Sorted by topic

Page created by Philip Hawkins
 
CONTINUE READING
Proposed variations to the Otago Southland Regional
        Land Transport Plans 2015 – 2021

         Summary of submissions received

                  Sorted by topic

                         1
Proposed variations to the Otago Southland Regional Land Transport Plans 2015 – 2021
Summary of Submissions – sorted by topic
Note, the numbering of submissions indicates the RC receiving the submission, not the RLTP on which the submission is being made. The
RLTP on which the point submission is being made is shown in the “Region” column.

                                                  Page of
                                                  Proposed                                                                                          [To be]
Submitter       No    Topic        Subtopic                    Region       Submission point                          Staff Recommendations
                                                  Variations                                                                                        Heard?
                                                  document
                                                                            Supports the proposed variations.         Note submission.              Yes
                                                                            Supports statements that recognise        No change to the Proposed
                                                                            transport services need to support        Variations.
                                                                            multiple community requirements
                001   General                     pp 33-38,                 while responding to growth.
QLDC                                                           Both
                ES    support                     50-52
                                                                            Supports development growth
                                                                            areas that recognise national
                                                                            importance of Queenstown/Central
                                                                            Otago Lakes areas.
                                                                            There is no planning for new roads        Note submission.              Yes
                                                                            and associated infrastructure to be       No change to Proposed
Southland                                                                   built on conservation lands, e.g.         Variations.
                002   General
Conservation                                      -            Both         national parks, conservation parks
                ES    support
Board                                                                       and stewardship lands in the RLTP.
                                                                            The Board supports this policy
                                                                            position.
                                                                            Generally supports the main               Note submission.              Yes
Gore District   007   General                                               objectives within the document.
                                                  -            Both                                                   No change to the Proposed
Council         ES    support
                                                                                                                      Variations.
                                                                            Asks the RTCs to await the updated        Note that the new timeline    Yes
                                                                            GPS before finalising this revision       proposed for completing
                                                                            of the RLTP. Does not consider the        the review/variation of the
                                                                            proposed variations are in keeping        RLTPs allows for the
                                                                            with the directions signalled late last   engagement draft of the
Alexandra                          The RLTP
                037                                                         year by the Minister.                     new GPS before the
Macmillan             General      variations     p. 3, 26     Both
                ORC                                                                                                   Hearing Committee
LATE                               process
                                                                                                                      deliberates and makes
                                                                                                                      recommendation on these
                                                                                                                      submissions.
                                                                                                                      Update the timeline in
                                                                                                                      Figure 3 in the final RLTP.

                                                                        2
Page of
                                                          Proposed                                                                                        [To be]
Submitter          No    Topic            Subtopic                     Region       Submission point                          Staff Recommendations
                                                          Variations                                                                                      Heard?
                                                          document
                                                                                    Supports the collaborative approach       Note the support for the    No
                                                                                    between Otago and Southland, the          text of the foreword.
Doug                                                                                recognition that journeys do not          No change to the Proposed
Davidson, AA       007   Introduction     Chairmen’s                                stop at administrative boundaries,        Variation.
                                                          pp 1-3       Both
Southland          ORC   and summary      foreword                                  and the acknowledgment that the
District Council                                                                    prosperity of our regions depends
                                                                                    on good quality infrastructure and
                                                                                    services.
                                                                                    Supports Table 1 - Top priority           Note submission:            Yes
                   001   Introduction &   What is being                             projects.
QLDC                                                      p. 16        Both                                                   No change to the Proposed
                   ES    Summary          updated?
                                                                                                                              Variation
                                                                                    Page 15 of draft under second             Southern Penguin Route is   Yes
                                          Building on                               yellow bullet point –states the           the term used in the
Real Journeys      020   Introduction &                                                                                       present RLTP. Include
                                          progress made   p.15         Both         “Southern Penguin Route” – this
Ltd                ORC   Summary                                                                                              Southern Scenic Route in
                                          since 2015-16                             should read “Southern Scenic
                                                                                    Route”.                                   parentheses.

                                                                                    Assessment of the appropriate             Note submission.            Yes
                                                                                    level of funding to maintain              No change to Proposed
                                                                                    regional competitiveness.                 Variations.
                                                                                    Consideration should be given to
                                          Overall                                   greater alignment of revenue
Venture            014   Introduction &   projected                                 generated within a region with
                                                          pp 19-20     Both
Southland          ES    summary          expenditure                               regional investment. Additional
                                          level                                     funding for roading projects would
                                                                                    in turn lead to greater employment
                                                                                    opportunities, one of the priorities of
                                                                                    the Regional Development
                                                                                    Strategy.

                                                                                3
Page of
                                                 Proposed                                                                                         [To be]
Submitter   No    Topic            Subtopic                      Region       Submission point                       Staff Recommendations
                                                 Variations                                                                                       Heard?
                                                 document
                                                                              Asks the RTCs to re-balance the        Note that the final          Yes
                                                                              proposed transport investment in       proposed RLTP
                                                 -- (the draft                the RLTPs, by spending a larger        expenditure depends on
                                                 does not                     proportion (more than 50%) of the      what projects and
                                   Overall
Alexandra   037   Introduction &                 summarise                    RLTP budget on public and active       expenditure each AO
                                   projected     expenditure
                                                                 Both
Macmillan   ORC   summary                                                     transport investments (in response     proposes - including any
                                   expenditure   by activity                  to signals in the Minister’s late      changes that AOs seek,
                                                 class)                       December letter).                      before the RTCs finalise
                                                                                                                     the RLTP variations (eg as
                                                                                                                     AOs finalise their LTPs.)
                                                                              Suggests the RLTPs have                Refer to ORC public          Yes
                                                 -- (the draft                chronically under-invested in public   transport planning and to
                                   Overall       does not                     transport and requests the RTCs        Connecting Dunedin and
Alexandra   037   Introduction &   projected     summarise                    urgently address this.                 Queenstown Lakes multi-
                                                                 Both
Macmillan   ORC   summary          expenditure   expenditure                                                         agency transport group for
                                   level         by activity                                                         consideration.
                                                 class)                                                              No change to Proposed
                                                                                                                     Variations.
                                   Overall                                    Submits that it would be helpful to    Show, in the final RLTP,     Yes
Alexandra   037   Introduction &   projected                                  report on the total expenditure by     the total expenditure by
                                                 --              Both
Macmillan   ORC   summary          expenditure                                activity class.                        activity class.
                                   level

                                                                          4
Page of
                                                        Proposed                                                                                            [To be]
Submitter      No    Topic            Subtopic                       Region       Submission point                           Staff Recommendations
                                                        Variations                                                                                          Heard?
                                                        document
                                                                                  The budget forecast, suggests a            Note that QLDC advises         No
                                                                                  very heavy load on QLDC                    that it aware of this issue
                                                                                  ratepayers, particularly from 2020.        and has assumed
                                                                                  For four of these five years, the          significant NZTA
                                                                                  amount to be funded by QLDC                assistance. It advises that
                                                                                  ratepayers is greater than the total       QLDC’s share of the $309k
                                                                                  cost facing all of Dunedin city - and      is $149k (48%) which will
                                                                                  would be more than double. in              be loan funded &
                                                                                  2022. Submits that this is not viable      recovered over time by
               038   Introduction     Overall                                     without substantial central                parking revenue ($46m);
Cath Gilmore                                            p. 20
               ORC   and summary      expenditure                                 government support. Presumes               development contributions
                                                                                  these cost estimates do not include        ($34m) & rates ($70m).
                                                                                  rebuild of a community venue in            QLDC’s draft LTP
                                                                                  downtown Queenstown if the                 demonstrates that this
                                                                                  Queenstown Memorial Centre is              work can be financed
                                                                                  demolished; suggests that in order         through QLDC borrowing
                                                                                  for this to be an honest appraisal,        and rates increases.
                                                                                  the costs of that project must be          No change to the Proposed
                                                                                  included. Alternatively, change the        Variations.
                                                                                  alignment and save that cost.
                                                                                  While the document recognises the          Ask TAG to focus, during       Yes
                                                                                  need to achieve modal shift to meet        early preparation of the
                                                                                  NZ’s climate change                        next RLTP, on ways to
                                                                                  responsibilities, the budget is not        achieve further mode shift
                                      Overall                                     sufficient to deliver on this. Potential   as identified in the
                     Introduction &
                                      projected                                   opportunities are missed including         Opportunities section of the
Daniel         013   summary
                                      expenditure       p 53         Both         reintroduction of a passenger train        proposed Variations
Windwood       ORC
                                      level for Otago                             service between Christchurch and           document (p. 53), and to
                                      and Southland                               Invercargill, funding support for Port     report back and discuss
                                                                                  Otago to shift its container and           with the RTCs.
                                                                                  timber traffic onto an alternative         No change to the Proposed
                                                                                  mode such as rail, and better              Variation.
                                                                                  cycling and Public transport .

                                                                              5
Page of
                                                         Proposed                                                                                          [To be]
Submitter          No    Topic         Subtopic                       Region       Submission point                       Staff Recommendations
                                                         Variations                                                                                        Heard?
                                                         document
                                                                                   Would like to see further              Note that the South Island       No
                                                                                   commentary on the RLTP about           RTC chairs groups
                                                                                   how the variable levels of service     (through the officials group)
                                                                                   provided by tourist roads in           are developing a tourism
                                                                                   Southland will be addressed in         and transport project; one
                                                                                   future.                                of the results of this project
                                                                                                                          will be the identification of
Doug                                   Characteristics                                                                    what fit-for-purpose tourist
Davidson, AA       007   The current   of our economy                                                                     routes, that enhance visitor
                                                         p. 31        Southland
Southland          ORC   situation     and transport                                                                      experience and safety,
District Council                       network                                                                            would look like. The results
                                                                                                                          of this project will provide
                                                                                                                          guidance about
                                                                                                                          improvements to tourist
                                                                                                                          routes in both Southland
                                                                                                                          and Otago.
                                                                                                                          No change to Proposed
                                                                                                                          Variations.
                                                                                   Tourist Journeys: For decades the      Note submission.                 Yes
                                                                                   route from Te Anau to Dunedin and      No change to proposed
                                                                                   some cases on to Oamaru has            variations.
                                                                                   been an important tourist route
                                                                                   especially for coach touring, for
                                                                                   tourists overnighting in Te Anau.
                                       Characteristics                             Most of the coach tour business
Real Journeys      020   The current   of our economy                              that overnights in Dunedin uses
                                                         p. 28        Both
                                                                                   SH1 and SH94 when travelling to or
Ltd                ORC   situation     and transport
                                       network                                     from the Southern Lakes.
                                                                                   The Southern Scenic Route is used
                                                                                   primarily by FITs but the tour group
                                                                                   business does not use this route as
                                                                                   tour groups run to tight timeframes
                                                                                   and the Southern Scenic Route is
                                                                                   too time consuming.

                                                                               6
Page of
                                                      Proposed                                                                                         [To be]
Submitter       No    Topic         Subtopic                       Region       Submission point                        Staff Recommendations
                                                      Variations                                                                                       Heard?
                                                      document
                                                                                The Stewart Island Ferry service        Include mention of the         Yes
                                    Characteristics
                                                                                and the “Foveaux Freighter” provide     Stewart Island ferry and air
Real Journeys   020   The current   of our economy
                                                      pp 32-33     Both         an essential transport link between     services, and the freight
Ltd             ORC   situation     and transport
                                                                                Bluff and Oban and as such should       service, in Section 2.1 of
                                    network
                                                                                be at least mentioned in the RLTPs.     the final RLTP.
                                                                                The coach tours, shuttle buses and      In the final RLTP,             Yes
                                                                                courtesy coaches operated by            acknowledge the role of
                                                                                companies such as Real Journeys /       coach tours, shuttle buses
                                                                                Go Orange need to be adequately         and courtesy coaches in
                                                                                recognised in Otago Southland           manage traffic volumes
                                                                                RLTPs 2015-2021 because these           reduce traffic congestion in
                                                                                vehicle operations significantly        and around Queenstown
                                                                                reduce traffic congestion especially    and on SH6, SH97 and
                                                                                in and around Queenstown and on         SH94.
                                                                                SH6A, SH6, SH97 and SH94.
                                                                                China has been the fastest growing
                                                                                visitor market, over 400,000 in
                                    Characteristics                             2017. This market is undergoing a
                                    of our economy                              very rapid shift away from travelling
                                    and transport                               in coaches towards Free
Real Journeys   020   The current
                                    network           -            Otago        Independent Travellers (FIT) (non–
Ltd             ORC   situation
                                                                                tour) where now more than half of
                                    Drivers of                                  Chinese visitors are travelling
                                    change                                      around NZ in rental vehicles (refer
                                                                                graph).
                                                                                Both roads around the tourism “hot
                                                                                spots” are being hit by a double
                                                                                whammy with the increase in
                                                                                Chinese visitors and the move away
                                                                                from coach touring to FIT. In this
                                                                                context operators such as Real
                                                                                Journeys who endeavour to get
                                                                                visitors to travel via coach rather
                                                                                than rental car should be valued
                                                                                and acknowledged in this planning
                                                                                framework.

                                                                            7
Page of
                                                  Proposed                                                                                           [To be]
Submitter   No    Topic         Subtopic                       Region       Submission point                           Staff Recommendations
                                                  Variations                                                                                         Heard?
                                                  document
                                                                            Supports recognition of significant        Note submission.              Yes
                                                                            and escalating issues faced by             No change to the Proposed
            001   The current   Drivers of
QLDC                                              p. 36        Both         QLDC in Table 9 – Expected                 Variations.
            ES    situation     change
                                                                            growth in Queenstown Lakes
                                                                            District
                                                                            Regional economic development              Include this information in   Yes
                                                                            initiatives. Consideration should be       Section 2.1 of the final
                                                                            made of the impact on regional land        RLTP, Characteristics of
                                                                            transport through any change in            our economy and transport
                                                                            services provided from Invercargill        network.
                                                                            Airport. Recent research
                                                                            undertaken on behalf of the
                                                                            Invercargill Airport and Venture
                                Characteristics
                                                                            Southland has revealed
Venture     014   The current   of our economy
                                                  pp 27-33     Both         considerable suppressed demand,
Southland   ES    situation     and transport
                                                                            as well as demand for direct flight
                                network
                                                                            connections to Auckland. At present
                                                                            there is significant road traffic out of
                                                                            Southland, driven by use of other
                                                                            regional airports at Queenstown
                                                                            and Dunedin. Development of the
                                                                            cruise industry and the associated
                                                                            cruise strategy for the region should
                                                                            also be considered.
                                                                            Our Regions: Population.                   Note submission.              Yes
                                                                            Lumsden is beginning to                    No change to Proposed
                                                                            experience relocation from                 Variations.
Christine   009   The current   Drivers of
                                                  pp 33-41     Both         Queenstown and Arrowtown so
Henderson   ES    situation     change
                                                                            static situation is showing signs of
                                                                            change for financial or life-style
                                                                            reasons.

                                                                        8
Page of
                                          Proposed                                                                                           [To be]
Submitter   No    Topic      Subtopic                  Region       Submission point                        Staff Recommendations
                                          Variations                                                                                         Heard?
                                          document
                                                                    Primary sector opportunities.           Note submission.                 Yes
                                                                    Consideration should be given to        No change to Proposed
                                                                    undertaking a cost benefit analysis     Variations.
                                                                    for upgrades of certain routes for
                                                                    freight transport, which Venture
                                                                    Southland would support.
Venture     014              Drivers of                             Consideration should be given to
                  Strategy                pp 33-41     Both         developments in land transport
Southland   ES               change
                                                                    requirements around changing land
                                                                    use such as proposals for a food
                                                                    processing hub, including increased
                                                                    oat production and sheep milk
                                                                    production and shipment of these
                                                                    developing product groups to
                                                                    market.
                                                                    Consideration to include touring        Note that the South Island       Yes
                                                                    routes for tourism for example the      RTC chairs groups
                                                                    Southern cluster, Southland (SH6,       (through the officials group)
                                                                    SH90, SH96, SH98, SH99).                are developing a tourism
                                                                                                            and transport project; one
                                                                    Changing technology – EV
                                                                                                            of the results of this project
Venture     014              Drivers of                             charging stations and
                                                                                                            will be the identification of
                  Strategy                p. 40        Both         infrastructure. To enable and
Southland   ES               change                                                                         what fit-for-purpose tourist
                                                                    support tourism, the Southland          routes, that enhance visitor
                                                                    regional energy strategy identifies     experience and safety,
                                                                    opportunities for the use of electric   would look like.
                                                                    vehicles and infrastructure. This       No change to Proposed
                                                                    provides an asset to the region         Variations.
                                                                    which can be built on.

                                                                9
Page of
                                                  Proposed                                                                                         [To be]
Submitter        No    Topic         Subtopic                  Region        Submission point                        Staff Recommendations
                                                  Variations                                                                                       Heard?
                                                  document
                                                                             Submits that greater attention          Note that QLDC is             Yes
                                                                             needs to be given to the Wanaka         currently investigating
                                                                             area, given the rate of growth          planning for growth in the
                                                                             projected and the desire to avoid       Wanaka area.
                                                                             the sorts of problems that              Note that the RLTP
                                                                             Queenstown has experienced.             Proposed Variations
                                                                             Planning for growth needs to take       already mention the effect
Norman                                                                       into account the proposal to            of the airport proposal (on
                 019                 Drivers of
Oakley, AA             Strategy                   33-41        Otago         upgrade Wanaka airport and to           p. 37).
                 ORC                 change
Otago District                                                               operate a dual airport system with      No change to the Proposed
                                                                             Queenstown as this will put stress      Variation.
                                                                             on the Crown Range Rd, Kawarau
                                                                             Gorge and local roads around
                                                                             Wanaka. Planning of future arterial
                                                                             links, bypass routes, and setting
                                                                             aside land for future park and rise
                                                                             facilities are all needed.
                                                                             Changing awareness and                  Include this information in   Yes
                                                                             expectations of risk including          the Final RLTP, section
                                                                             climate change: Most of the focus       2.2.
                                                                             in this document relates to coastal
                                                                             effects of climate change and
                                                                             overlooks the other likely impacts
                                                                             such as flooding which could have
                                                                             impacts inland. Specifically: more
                                                                             frequent intense rainfalls events are
                                                                             expected to increase the likelihood
Real Journeys    020   The current   Drivers of
                                                  p. 41        Both          of rivers flooding, landslides,
Ltd              ORC   situation     change
                                                                             erosion and flash flooding when
                                                                             urban drainage systems become
                                                                             overwhelmed. Also hotter summers
                                                                             may damage elements of transport
                                                                             infrastructure causing buckled
                                                                             railway lines and damaged roads,
                                                                             with associated disruption and
                                                                             repair costs. Both of these impacts
                                                                             could be significant for Otago and
                                                                             Southland

                                                                        10
Page of
                                                 Proposed                                                                                            [To be]
Submitter       No    Topic         Subtopic                  Region        Submission point                        Staff Recommendations
                                                 Variations                                                                                          Heard?
                                                 document
                                                                            Disappointed that only Queenstown       Include, in the RLTP             Yes
                                                                            and Dunedin are referenced in the       Drivers of Change section,
                                                                            Proposed Variations document as         reference to Wanaka as
                                                                            demonstrating a strong groundswell      being part of the strong
                                                                            of support for prioritising active      groundswell of support for
                                                                            transport. Wants to make Wanaka.        prioritising active transport.
                                                                            The region’s ‘shining star’ both in
Active Wanaka   025   The current   Drivers of   pp 41, 57-
                                                              Otago         active transport and in the uptake of
Transport       ORC   situation     change       58
                                                                            new technologies. Wanaka is
                                                                            growing faster than anywhere else
                                                                            in the region. Gridlock is projected.
                                                                            Forward planning is required.
                                                                            Cycling is a key mode of travel that
                                                                            can address these challenges.
                                                                            Immediate action is required.
                                                                            Supports the Proposed Variation         Accept QAC’s invitation to       No
                                                                            and considers that it captures some     share information about its
                                                                            of the most pressing issues facing      passenger growth
                                                                            the Queenstown Lakes                    forecasts; and use this
                                                                            transportation network including the    information to review the
                                                                            significant growth in air passenger     growth assumptions used
                                                                            numbers forecast for Queenstown.        in the Proposed Variation,
                                                                            Submits in support of an integrated     in partnership with the
                                                                            transport solution that provides a      Queenstown Lakes multi-
Queenstown                                                                  range of offerings to passengers        agency transport group.
                027                 Drivers of
Airport               Strategy                   pp 33-41     Otago         visiting the district, including a      No change to the Proposed
                ORC                 change
Corporation                                                                 combination of active, public and       Variation.
                                                                            private transport. QAC will look for
                                                                            opportunities to work with the RTCs
                                                                            to provide logical connections to
                                                                            these networks.
                                                                            QAC is keen to share information
                                                                            about its passenger growth
                                                                            forecasts to assist with revision of
                                                                            the assumptions used in the
                                                                            proposed variation.

                                                                       11
Page of
                                                          Proposed                                                                                         [To be]
Submitter          No    Topic         Subtopic                        Region        Submission point                       Staff Recommendations
                                                          Variations                                                                                       Heard?
                                                          document
                                                                                     Wishes to clarify that QAC’s           Clarify this in the final      No
                                                                                     currently-consented hours of           RLTP.
Queenstown
                   027                 Drivers of                                    operation are from 6am to 10pm
Airport                  Strategy                         pp 33-41     Otago
                   ORC                 change                                        daily and that QAC does not have
Corporation
                                                                                     any plans to extend these hours of
                                                                                     operation.
                                                                                     Reword the final RLTPs to include      Reword the Drivers of          Yes
                                                                                     electric bike technology, and          Change section of the final
                                                                                     autonomous vehicle and electric        RLTPs to include reference
                                                                                     public transport technologies in the   to electric bike technology,
Alexandra          037                 Drivers of                                    consideration of future technologies   and autonomous vehicle
                         Strategy                         pp 33-41     Both
Macmillan          ORC                 Change                                        as these will have greater benefits    and electric public
                                                                                     for health and fairness, as well as    transport technologies in
                                                                                     creating greater transport             the consideration of future
                                                                                     efficiencies than electric private     technologies.
                                                                                     vehicles.
                                                                                     Supports timing of investment          Note submission.               Yes
                                       Key problems
                   001   The current                                                 prioritisation and decision            No change to the Proposed
QLDC                                   facing the         pp 42-49     Both
                   ES    situation                                                   making in relation to future           Variations.
                                       transport system
                                                                                     proofing.
Doug                                                                                 Considers the three problem            Note submission’s support      No
                                       Key problems
Davidson, AA       007   The current                                                 statements identified in the RLTPs     for these statements.
                                       facing the         pp 42-49     Both
Southland          ORC   situation                                                   accurately reflect the issues facing   No change to the Proposed
                                       transport system
District Council                                                                     the two regions.                       Variation.
                                                                                     Asks that two problems added to        Note that NZTA advises         No
                                                                                     the list of problems faced on the      that flax removal is
                                                                                     state highways in Otago Southland:     currently underway on the
                                                                                     (1) dead flax killed by spraying       Otago Southland state
                                                                                     needs to be removed; and (2)           highway network. NZTA
Doug                                   The key
                                                                                     surface texture issues including       also advises that various
Davidson, AA       007   The current   problems facing
                                                          pp 48-49     Both          small repairs, temporary fixes and     surfacing issues mentioned
Southland          ORC   situation     the transport
                                                                                     flush seals need to be addressed       are an operational matter
District Council                       system
                                                                                     e.g. on SH99.                          which are being addressed
                                                                                                                            through routine
                                                                                                                            maintenance.
                                                                                                                            No change to Proposed
                                                                                                                            Variations.

                                                                                12
Page of
                                                        Proposed                                                                                            [To be]
Submitter          No    Topic         Subtopic                       Region        Submission point                        Staff Recommendations
                                                        Variations                                                                                          Heard?
                                                        document
                                                                                    Increased tourism, lack of public       Refer submission to TAG         Yes
                                                                                    transport choices, heavy vehicles       for advice on whether
                                                                                    servicing the dairy and timber          changes in maintenance
Christine          009   The current                                                industries, have put increased          and renewals is evidence
                                       Key problems     Pp 42-49      Both
Henderson          ES    situation                                                  pressures on the physical road          that this is either unsafe or
                                                                                    system, forced to 'patch and hope'      inefficient.
                                                                                    many main roads instead of
                                                                                    reinforcing them.
                                                                                    Asks for the RLTP’s articulation of     No change to Proposed           Yes
                                                                                    key problems to be reconfigured to      Variations The three
                                                                                    reflect the real issues of urgency.     problem statements, have
                                                                                    Asks that for problem statement 2,      been widely consulted on
                                                                                    road traffic injuries by mode be        and this is the only
                                                                                    included. Submits that there is a       stakeholder / submitter
                                                                                    need to recognise the resilience        requesting a change.
                                                                                    benefits of providing for a range of    In the final RLTP,
                                                                                    modes, especially active transport.     recognise the opportunity
Alexandra          037   The current                                                                                        to reduce the rates of road
                                       Key problems     pp 42-49      Both
Macmillan          ORC   situation                                                                                          trauma by shifting motor
                                                                                                                            vehicle trips to safer
                                                                                                                            modes; include a graph of
                                                                                                                            road traffic injuries by
                                                                                                                            mode in the final RLTP;
                                                                                                                            and recognise the
                                                                                                                            resilience benefits of
                                                                                                                            providing for a range of
                                                                                                                            modes, especially public
                                                                                                                            and active transport.
                                                                                    Suggests that the RLTP should           Include this                    Yes
                                                                                    acknowledge the role that mode          acknowledgement in the
Alexandra          037   The current                                                share plays in road traffic injury,     final RLTP.
                                       Key problems     pp 42-49      Both
Macmillan          ORC   situation                                                  report injury rates rather than crude
                                                                                    numbers and plan to reduce injuries
                                                                                    through mode shift
Doug                                   Longterm goal                                Pleased to see concise objectives       Note submission’s support       No
                                                        pp 50-52;
Davidson, AA       007                 and results                                  and policies and intention to monitor   for these statements.
                         Strategy                       59-60; 137-   Both
Southland          ORC                 Land transport                               the results of RLTP investment.         No change to the Proposed
                                                        141
District Council                       policies                                                                             Variation.

                                                                               13
Page of
                                                    Proposed                                                                                        [To be]
Submitter        No    Topic      Subtopic                       Region        Submission point                       Staff Recommendations
                                                    Variations                                                                                      Heard?
                                                    document
                                                                               Changing awareness and                 That, the RTCs, at the        Yes
                                                                               expectations of risk including         same time as they talk with
                                                                               climate change. A summary of the       DCC about the Global
                                                                               Zero Carbon Southland framework        Covenant of Mayors for
                                                                               is attached to this submission.        Climate and Energy, also
Venture          014              Longterm goal     pp 50-52,
                       Strategy                                  Both                                                 examine the Zero Carbon
Southland        ES               and results etc   138
                                                                                                                      Southland framework, and
                                                                                                                      consider the potential
                                                                                                                      implications for transport,
                                                                                                                      and appropriate transport
                                                                                                                      strategy.
                                                                               Feels the overall goal could be        The intended longterm         No
                                                                               more encompassing of the diverse,      results in the Proposed
                                                                               multi-modal aspects of regional        Variations already
                                                                               transport such as transport            encompass all these
                                                                               providing individuals and whanau       concepts, and amending
WellSouth                                                                      with access to their basic needs.      amending Intended
                 017              Longterm goal
Primary Health         Strategy                     p. 50        Both          Seeks a more holistic goal which       longterm result R7 (on pp
                 ORC              and results
Network                                                                        encompasses a safe, resilient,         50-51 and the diagram in
                                                                               environmentally sustainable            Appendix 4) to read:
                                                                               transport system that protects         “Enhanced community
                                                                               public health and is accessible for    resilience, health and
                                                                               everyone in Otago and Southland.       wellbeing” would make this
                                                                                                                      clearer.
                                                                               Recommends that the RTCs have          Amend Intended longterm       No
                                                                               as a key consideration the             result R7 (on pp 50-51 and
                                                                               protecting and promoting of public     the diagram in Appendix 4)
                                                                               health as this would have many         to read: “Enhanced
WellSouth
                 017              Longterm goal                                positive outcomes. Asks that the       community resilience,
Primary Health         Strategy                     pp 50-52     Both
                 ORC              and results                                  RTCs create and improve                health and wellbeing”.
Network
                                                                               infrastructure and social
                                                                               environments that enable all the
                                                                               community to be physically active in
                                                                               day-to-day life.

                                                                          14
Page of
                                                    Proposed                                                                                          [To be]
Submitter        No    Topic      Subtopic                       Region        Submission point                        Staff Recommendations
                                                    Variations                                                                                        Heard?
                                                    document
                                                                               Recommends considering urban            Add the need to recognise      No
                                                                               form and the way that landuse           that urban form and
                                                                               patterns and the transport system       landuse patterns influence
                                                                               interrelate, as this plays a            the effectiveness and
WellSouth
                 017              Longterm goal                                fundamental role in influencing the     efficiency of transport and
Primary Health         Strategy                     pp 50-52     Both
                 ORC              and results                                  effectiveness and efficiency of         health as a RLTP policy, to
Network
                                                                               transport and health.                   provide guidance to RMA
                                                                                                                       planning and consenting
                                                                                                                       and to business case
                                                                                                                       preparation.
                                                                               Considers the strength of the review    Note submission.               No
                                                                               document is its recognition by the      No change to Proposed
                                                                               Both councils that social and           Variations.
                 023              Longterm goal     pp 50-52,
Jane Ashman            Strategy                                  Both          environmental aspects of transport
                 ORC              and results       138
                                                                               issues need to be considered,
                                                                               rather than limiting the analysis to
                                                                               within narrower parameters.
                                                                               Suggests there is a failure of          Add to the RLTP, as a          Yes
                                                                               leadership around how transport         policy, the need to
                                                                               can redirect where people live to       recognise that urban form
                                                                               maximise value for money and            and landuse patterns
                                                                               minimise environmental and health       influence the effectiveness
                                                                               impacts of transport and landuse        and efficiency of transport
                                                                               infrastructure, as well as ensuring     and health; this policy to
                                                                               the viability of high quality public    provide guidance to RMA
                                                                               transport.                              work and to business case
Alexandra        037              Longterm goal     pp 50-52,                  Suggests that the RTCs need to          preparation.
                       Strategy                                  Both
Macmillan        ORC              and results etc   138                        play a part in shaping future growth.   Note that the Queenstown
                                                                               Asks the RTCs to take a more            multi-agency transport
                                                                               integrated, visioning and               group and the Connecting
                                                                               backcasting method to landuse and       Dunedin group are playing
                                                                               transport planning that recognises      a role in shaping growth;
                                                                               the role that transport investments     support and inform this
                                                                               play in shaping population growth,      work through closer liaison.
                                                                               land use and where that happen,
                                                                               and future value for money of
                                                                               transport investments.

                                                                          15
Page of
                                                      Proposed                                                                                          [To be]
Submitter         No    Topic      Subtopic                         Region        Submission point                        Staff Recommendations
                                                      Variations                                                                                        Heard?
                                                      document
                                                                                  Asks the RTCs put at the heart of       Amend Intended longterm       Yes
                                                                                  the RLTP, population wellbeing and      result R7 (on pp 50-51 and
                                                                                  fairness, including the rights of all   the diagram in Appendix 4)
Alexandra         037              Longterm goal      pp 50-52,                   sectors to affordably access            to read “Enhanced
                        Strategy                                    Both
Macmillan         ORC              and results etc    138                         education, jobs and health services,    community resilience,
                                                                                  and opportunities for high quality of   health and wellbeing”.
                                                                                  life to attract high value residents,
                                                                                  tourists and businesses.
                                                                                  Suggests that the RTCs are              As a way of starting this     Yes
                                                                                  negligent in ignoring the existing      strategic conversation, ask
                                                                                  and impending strategic and             DCC – after its concludes
                                                                                  legislative imperatives to address      its present consultation on
                                                                                  climate pollution from the transport    potential citywide
                                                                                  sector. Asks the RTCs to urgently       greenhouse gas emissions
                                                                                  address the absence of strategic        reduction targets – to
Alexandra         037              Longterm goal      pp 41, 50-
                        Strategy                                    Both          planning required to meet our           discuss with the RTCs, the
Macmillan         ORC              and results etc    52
                                                                                  obligations under the Agreement by      Global Covenant of Mayors
                                                                                  including healthy, equitable            for Climate and Energy,
                                                                                  solutions to transport climate          focusing on the potential
                                                                                  pollution, with a target of zero        implications for transport.
                                                                                  carbon transport system by 2050
                                                                                  that is also resilient to climate
                                                                                  impacts
                                                                                  Supports active transport solutions     Note support.                 No
                                                                                  as they will improve physical,          No change to the Proposed
                                   Long-term goal
                                                      pp 55-58,                   mental, social, and environmental       Variation.
                                   and results.
Southern                                              60, section                 health outcomes, through (1)
                  010              Benefits sought
District Health         Strategy                      4             Both          encouraging people to be more
                  ORC              from the next 3-
Board                                                 generally,                  physically active, and (2) improving
                                   10 years
                                                      pp 131-135                  road safety, air quality and
                                   investment
                                                                                  producing fewer greenhouse gas
                                                                                  solutions
                                   Long-term goal                                 Encouraged to see new projects          Note the support for these    No
                                   and results.                                   focusing on safety and resilience.      projects.
Southern
                  010              Benefits sought    p. 16,                      The latter will help ensure access to   No change to the Proposed
District Health         Strategy                                    Both
                  ORC              from the next 3-   section 4                   goods and services in times of          Variation.
Board
                                   10 years                                       emergency.
                                   investment

                                                                             16
Page of
                                                   Proposed                                                                                          [To be]
Submitter      No    Topic      Subtopic                           Region        Submission point                       Staff Recommendations
                                                   Variations                                                                                        Heard?
                                                   document
                                                                                 Supports, particularly mode            Note submission.             Yes
                                Opportunities                                    integration and mode shift and cycle   No change to the Proposed
               001
QLDC                 Strategy   the RTC’s intend   pp 52-55        Both          network for Queenstown – supports      Variations.
               ES
                                to pursue                                        QIT Active Travel network
                                                                                 outcomes.
                                                                                 Notes that connecting Queenstown       Note submission.             Yes
                                Opportunities
               001                                                               Trails with commuter cycling in        No change to the Proposed
QLDC                 Strategy   the RTC’s intend   p. 55           Both
               ES                                                                Wakatipu Basin will assist in          Variations.
                                to pursue
                                                                                 delivering QIT outcomes.
                                                                                 Te Anau-Milford Highway.               Note submission. Refer to    Yes
                                                                                 Questions the sustainability of        those undertaking the
                                                                                 vehicle numbers in this area.          South Island tourism and
                                                                                 Seriously concerned about capacity     transport project.
Southland                       Opportunities                                    of the infrastructure at Milford to    Add the issue to the RLTP,
               002                                                               accommodate increased traffic and      under Problem Statement
Conservation         Strategy   that RTC’s         p. 54           Both
               ES                                                                parking at Milford. If Milford is to   1.
Board                           intend to pursue
                                                                                 remain a high-quality visitor
                                                                                 experience, controls on vehicle
                                                                                 numbers will be required. Suggests
                                                                                 ‘park and ride’ for the majority of
                                                                                 visitors as a strategic direction.
                                                                                 Off-road cycle network: the jury is    The final RLTP should put    Yes
                                                                                 still out regarding the Around the     the same level of emphasis
                                                                                 Mountains cycle trail, given its       on cycling route and trail
                                                   Cycle
                                Opportunities                                    expense and fraught planning           opportunities in Southland
Christine      009                                 trails/ rides
                     Strategy   that the RTCs                      Southland     procedures.                            as in the Queenstown and
Henderson      ES                                  = pp 55-
                                intend to pursue                                                                        Dunedin, while noting that
                                                   58-
                                                                                                                        AOs need to submit
                                                                                                                        projects for consideration
                                                                                                                        by NZTA as co-funder.

                                                                            17
Page of
                                                      Proposed                                                                                         [To be]
Submitter         No    Topic      Subtopic                        Region        Submission point                       Staff Recommendations
                                                      Variations                                                                                       Heard?
                                                      document
                                                                                 Encouraged to see opportunity to       Note support. Ask TAG to       No
                                                                                 better integrate road and coastal      focus, during early
                                                                                 shipping into the transport network    preparation of the next
                                                                                 has been identified. Supports          RLTP, on ways to achieve
                                                                                 moving freight from road to rail and   further mode shift as
Southern                           Opportunities                                 shopping to increase network           identified in the
                  010
District Health         Strategy   that the RTCs      p. 53        Both          resilience, improve road safety and    Opportunities section of the
                  ORC
Board                              intend to pursue                              reduce emissions                       Proposed Variations
                                                                                                                        document (p. 53), and to
                                                                                                                        report back and discuss
                                                                                                                        with the RTCs.
                                                                                                                        No change to the Proposed
                                                                                                                        Variation.
                                                                                 Encouraged to see opportunity to       Note the support and refer     No
                                                                                 create a network of cycle rides has    the submission to the
Southern                           Opportunities                                 been identified. Urges the RTCs to     Connecting Dunedin group.
                  010
District Health         Strategy   that the RTCs      pp 55-58     Both          ensure a safe and enjoyable            No change to the Proposed
                  ORC
Board                              intend to pursue                              experience for all cyclists e.g.       Variation.
                                                                                 through separated cycleways in
                                                                                 high-volume traffic areas.

                                                                            18
Page of
                                                     Proposed                                                                                         [To be]
Submitter        No    Topic      Subtopic                        Region        Submission point                         Staff Recommendations
                                                     Variations                                                                                       Heard?
                                                     document
                                                                                Would like their programme and           Include this                 No
                                                                                strategy to be included in the plan      acknowledgement in the
                                                                                and any cycling related projects to      final RLTP, section 3.4.
                                                                                be highlighted and given priority.       The final RLTP should put
                                                                                Requests an addition to the section      the same level of emphasis
                                                                                “The opportunity to create a             on cycling route and trail
                                                                                network of cycle rides”                  opportunities in Southland
                                                                                acknowledging the formation of the       as in the Queenstown and
                                                                                Ride Southland Governance Group          Dunedin, while noting that
                                                                                and its Vision Statement: “To            AOs need to submit
                                                                                provide quality safe cycling             projects for consideration
                                                                                infrastructure and increase cycling      by NZTA as co-funder.
Alex Crackett,                    Opportunities                                 participation so that the people of
                 012                                                            Southland will gain in health, quality   Note that the multi-agency
Ride                   Strategy   that RTCs          pp 55-58     Both                                                   governance group Ride
                 ES                                                             of life and appreciative use of their
Southland                         intend to pursue                                                                       South is preparing an
                                                                                outstanding natural environment”.
                                                                                                                         overall strategy and
                                                                                                                         business case for cycling
                                                                                                                         facilities in Southland,
                                                                                                                         which should lead to AOs
                                                                                                                         preparing detailed
                                                                                                                         business cases for
                                                                                                                         individual facilities.
                                                                                                                         Ask the Ride Southland
                                                                                                                         group to engage with the
                                                                                                                         RTCs and TAG, as the
                                                                                                                         RTCs refine their strategy
                                                                                                                         over the next three years.

                                                                           19
Page of
                                                Proposed                                                                                              [To be]
Submitter   No    Topic      Subtopic                        Region        Submission point                          Staff Recommendations
                                                Variations                                                                                            Heard?
                                                document
                                                                           Milford Sound and related transport       Note that the South Island       Yes
                                                                           routes: asks for consideration to be      RTC chairs groups
                                                                           given to improving the management         (through the officials group)
                                                                           of visitor dispersal in response to       are developing a tourism
                                                                           increased numbers of visitors into        and transport project; one
                                                                           Milford Sound, including                  of the results of this project
                                                                           investigating options such as a Park      will be the identification of
                                                                           and Ride scheme from Te Anau.             what fit-for-purpose tourist
                             Opportunities                                                                           routes, that enhance visitor
Venture     014                                                                                                      experience and safety,
                  Strategy   that RTCs          pp 53-54-    Otago
Southland   ES                                                                                                       would look like. The results
                             intend to pursue
                                                                                                                     of this project will provide
                                                                                                                     guidance about
                                                                                                                     improvements to tourist
                                                                                                                     routes in both Southland
                                                                                                                     and Otago.
                                                                                                                     No change to Proposed
                                                                                                                     Variations.

                                                                           Mapping regional transport                Refer to South Island            Yes
                                                                           patterns: asks for consideration to       tourism project manager.
                                                                           be given to the need for automatic        No change to Proposed
                                                                           traffic counters that would               Variations.
                             Opportunities                                 accurately record traffic numbers,
Venture     014
                  Strategy   that RTCs          pp 53-54     Both          the type of vehicle (truck, caravan,
Southland   ES
                             intend to pursue                              car) and travel direction in real time.
                                                                           Venture Southland would work with
                                                                           stakeholders to identify nodes. It is
                                                                           likely that 6-8 traffic counters and 2
                                                                           mobile counters would be required.

                                                                      20
Page of
                                                Proposed                                                                                       [To be]
Submitter   No    Topic      Subtopic                        Region        Submission point                   Staff Recommendations
                                                Variations                                                                                     Heard?
                                                document
                                                                           Tourism opportunities.             Note that the South Island       Yes
                                                                           Consideration should be given to   RTC chairs groups
                                                                           reviewing further investment       (through the officials group)
                                                                           requirements required by new       are developing a tourism
                                                                           tourist products in the region.    and transport project; one
                                                                                                              of the results of this project
                                                                                                              will be the identification of
                                                                                                              what fit-for-purpose tourist
                                                                                                              routes, that enhance visitor
                                                                                                              experience and safety,
                                                                                                              would look like. The results
                             Opportunities                                                                    of this project will provide
Venture     014
                  Strategy   that RTCs          pp 53-54     Both                                             guidance about
Southland   ES
                             intend to pursue                                                                 improvements to tourist
                                                                                                              routes and journeys in both
                                                                                                              Southland and Otago and
                                                                                                              may also result in new
                                                                                                              tourism products being
                                                                                                              identified (with business
                                                                                                              cases for these developed
                                                                                                              by the partner tourism
                                                                                                              organisations).
                                                                                                              No change to Proposed
                                                                                                              Variations.

                                                                      21
Page of
                                                    Proposed                                                                                           [To be]
Submitter       No    Topic      Subtopic                        Region        Submission point                         Staff Recommendations
                                                    Variations                                                                                         Heard?
                                                    document
                                                                               Page 52 – The opportunity to take a      Note that this is the          Yes
                                                                               South Island–wide approach: Real         approach that the South
                                                                               Journeys suggests that the RTCs          Island RTC Chairs, and
                                                                               should be considering a broader          their officials, group is
                                                                               approach including working with          taking on their tourism and
                                                                               Destination Queenstown and               transport project; the group
                                                                               Venture Southland (Destination           is working with tourism
                                                                               Fiordland) to shape the mode of          industry partners. Refer
                                                                               travel adopted by overseas visitors      submission to this group.
                                 Opportunities                                 when travelling around the region to
Real Journeys   020                                                                                                     No change to the Proposed
                      Strategy   that RTC’s         p. 52        Both
                                                                               address the poor journey
Ltd             ORC                                                                                                     Variations.
                                 intend to pursue                              experience for visitors in some parts
                                                                               of Otago and Southland and
                                                                               specifically the traffic congestion in
                                                                               and around Queenstown.
                                                                               Real Journeys is sceptical about the
                                                                               development and use of a South
                                                                               Island-wide model of tourism flows
                                                                               because the flow of visitors around
                                                                               the South Island is so variable.
                                                                               It should be noted that the              Note submission.               Yes
                                                                               promotion of self-driving by the         No change to the Proposed
                                                                               tourism industry with respect to         Variations.
                                                                               campervans has been a necessary
                                                                               evil to increase the sector’s
                                 Opportunities                                 productivity because there are
Real Journeys   020                                                            insufficient hotel / motel beds in the
                      Strategy   that RTC’s         p. 54        Both
Ltd             ORC                                                            Southern Lakes region to support
                                 intend to pursue
                                                                               the local Tourism Industry.
                                                                               Supports the creation of more safe
                                                                               stopping areas and slow vehicle
                                                                               bays to improve road safety and the
                                                                               reliability of road journeys.

                                                                          22
Page of
                                                    Proposed                                                                                           [To be]
Submitter       No    Topic      Subtopic                        Region        Submission point                        Staff Recommendations
                                                    Variations                                                                                         Heard?
                                                    document
                                                                               Asks the RTCs to improve and            Note that the potential for     Yes
                                                                               protect health and wellbeing            freight mode shift is part of
                                                                               through investment in the freight       a South Island RTC Chairs
                                                                               network that prioritises expanding      project (which is about to
                                 Opportunities                                 and electrifying the rail network,      commence).
Alexandra       037
                      Strategy   that the RTCs      p. 53        Both          followed by enabling greater coastal    No change to Proposed
Macmillan       ORC
                                 intend to pursue                              shipping. Asks the RTCs to partner      Variations.
                                                                               with central government and
                                                                               KiwiRail to ensure there is a shift
                                                                               from road freight to an improved,
                                                                               electrified freight network.
                                                                               Supports getting more freight going     Note support for the focus      No
                                                                               to rail and coastal networks and off    on resilience.
                                 Opportunities                                 the roads; more coordination across     No change to Proposed
                038
Cath Gilmore          Strategy   that the RTCs      p. 53        Otago         the South Island; more dispersal of     Variations.
                ORC
                                 intend to pursue                              tourism benefits, and creation of the
                                                                               cycle network, and in particular, the
                                                                               identified initial priorities.
                                                                               Submits that Figure 7 showing           QLDC advises that this          No
                                                                               Queenstown’s proposed town              matter is being addressed
                                                                               centre cycleway needs to include a      as part of the master
                                                                               north–south linkage between the         planning and most CBD
                                                                               blue and green routes for cyclists      areas are envisaged as
                                 Opportunities
                038                                                            e.g. on Beach Street. Submits that      being shared surfaces
Cath Gilmore          Strategy   that the RTCs      p. 58        Otago
                ORC                                                            to not have any way of accessing        (although Figure 7 does
                                 intend to pursue
                                                                               the actual town centre as part of the   not show this detail).
                                                                               town centre cycle network makes         No change to Proposed
                                                                               no sense and would not encourage        Variations.
                                                                               people to bike to work/ shop/
                                                                               recreate in town.
                                                                               Supports QIT outcomes particularly      Note submission.                Yes
                001              Land transport                                public transport and active travel.
QLDC                  Strategy                      pp 59-60     Both                                                  No change to the Proposed
                ES               policies
                                                                                                                       Variations.
                                                                               Supports proposed policies and in       Note submission.                Yes
Real Journeys   020              Land transport
                      Strategy                      pp 59-60     Both          particular: supporting and enabling     No change to the Proposed
Ltd             ORC              policies
                                                                               tourism and visitor travel.             Variations.

                                                                          23
Page of
                                                     Proposed                                                                                       [To be]
Submitter          No    Topic      Subtopic                      Region        Submission point                        Staff Recommendations
                                                     Variations                                                                                     Heard?
                                                     document
                                                                                Supports QIT outcomes                   Note submission.            Yes
                                    RTC’s proposed
                   001                                                          particularly public transport and
QLDC                     Strategy   advocacy         p. 61        Both                                                  No change to the Proposed
                   ES                                                           active travel.
                                    programme                                                                           Variations.
                                                                                Supports the proposed advocacy          Note submission’s support   No
Doug                                                                            programme, especially that              for these statements.
                                    RTCs’ proposed
Davidson, AA       007                                                          concerned with the minimisation of      No change to the Proposed
                         Strategy   advocacy         p. 61        Both
Southland          ORC                                                          road trauma; and the provision for      Variation.
                                    programme
District Council                                                                mode choice and integration of
                                                                                modes.
                                                                                With respect to advocating for          Note submission.            Yes
                                                                                alternative funding mechanisms,         No change to the Proposed
                                                                                beyond development contributions,       Variations.
                                                                                to ensure those directly benefiting
                                    RTC’s proposed                              from tourism-oriented facilities,
Real Journeys      020
                         Strategy   advocacy         p. 61        Both          infrastructure and services
Ltd                ORC
                                    programme                                   associated with transport, contribute
                                                                                fairly to their funding. GST from
                                                                                overseas visitors should be directed
                                                                                to funding infrastructure and
                                                                                services associated with transport.

                                                                           24
Page of
                                                  Proposed                                                                                       [To be]
Submitter       No    Topic      Subtopic                      Region        Submission point                       Staff Recommendations
                                                  Variations                                                                                     Heard?
                                                  document
                                                                             Any extensions to the regions’ cycle   The final RLTP should put    Yes
                                                                             trails need to be more thoughtfully    the same level of emphasis
                                                                             planned and offer users a              on cycling route and trail
                                                                             worthwhile, enjoyable journey          opportunities in Southland
                                                                             experience and include all the         as in the Queenstown and
                                                                             requisite infrastructure such as       Dunedin, while noting that
                                                                             toilets.                               AOs need to submit
                                                                                                                    projects for consideration
                                 RTC’s proposed                                                                     by NZTA as co-funder.
Real Journeys   020
                      Strategy   advocacy         p. 61        Both                                                 Note that the multi-agency
Ltd             ORC
                                 programme                                                                          governance group Ride
                                                                                                                    South is preparing an
                                                                                                                    overall strategy and
                                                                                                                    business case for cycling
                                                                                                                    facilities in Southland,
                                                                                                                    which should lead to AOs
                                                                                                                    preparing detailed
                                                                                                                    business cases for
                                                                                                                    individual facilities.
                                                                             More thought needed regarding          Note submission.             Yes
                                                                             promotion of touring routes within     No change to the Proposed
                                                                             Both. All too often we hear from       Variations.
                                                                             visitors in Te Anau and Milford
                                 RTC’s proposed
Real Journeys   20                                                           Sound that they do not have
                      Strategy   advocacy         p. 61        Both
Ltd             ORC                                                          enough time to travel across to
                                 programme
                                                                             Dunedin because they believe they
                                                                             must to travel to Dunedin via the
                                                                             Southern Scenic Route or travel to
                                                                             Dunedin via Queenstown.

                                                                        25
Page of
                                                     Proposed                                                                                           [To be]
Submitter        No    Topic       Subtopic                       Region        Submission point                         Staff Recommendations
                                                     Variations                                                                                         Heard?
                                                     document
                                                                                Asks the RTCs to prioritise              Add new policy to the          Yes
                                                                                pedestrian safety.                       RLTP, recognising the
                                                                                Points out that prioritising             need to prioritise
                                                                                pedestrian safety through safety         pedestrian safety.
                                                                                and improvements to public               Refer the issue of
                                                                                transport is a great way to facilitate   pedestrian safety to TAG to
                                                                                the future-proofing required to          address in the strategy and
                                                                                address the mobility user demands        programme for the next
Dunedin                                              Key                        of our aging population, to improve      RLTP.
                 028
Pedestrian             Strategy    Walking           problems =   Both          transport safety and to reduce the
                 ORC
Action Network                                       pp 42-49                   climate-related risks arising from
                                                                                excessive fossil fuel consumption.
                                                                                Submits that pedestrians need
                                                                                separate footpaths and walkways.
                                                                                Shared paths are dangerous and
                                                                                unpleasant places for the elderly
                                                                                and disabled pedestrians and a
                                                                                source of conflict between cyclists
                                                                                and pedestrians.
                                                                                Submits that we need to cherish          Add statement to this effect   Yes
                                                                                and beautify our footpaths and           to the RLTP section on the
                                                                                parks as important safe, and             appropriate role of each
Dunedin
                 028                                                            democratic public spaces where           mode (the walking and
Pedestrian             Strategy    Walking           --           Both
                 ORC                                                            people of all cultures, religions and    cycling sub-section)
Action Network
                                                                                walks of life can mix and mingle and
                                                                                enjoy being out in a genuinely
                                                                                inclusive society.
                                                                                The one lane bridge at Falls Creek       Note submission on this        Yes
                                   Projects with
Hudson           034   Southland                                                is difficult for a 50 plus seat coach    committed project.
                                   funding already   p. 62, 118   Southland
Turnbull         ORC   projects                                                 to negotiate. The new bridge needs       No change to the Proposed
                                   approved
                                                                                to be two-lane.                          Variation.

                                                                           26
Page of
                                                    Proposed                                                                                           [To be]
Submitter       No    Topic       Subtopic                       Region        Submission point                       Staff Recommendations
                                                    Variations                                                                                         Heard?
                                                    document
                                                                               Current situation with the Mataura     Note that NZTA advises           Yes
                                                                               Intersection presents key safety       that this project is still a
                                                                               concerns on a regionally strategic     priority to progress as a
                                                                               intersection (freight movements).      Low Cost Low Risk activity;
                                                                               Points out there are potentially       and that investigation into a
                                  Changes to
                                                                               indirect effects on rail network and   number of improvement
Gore District   007   Southland   Southland
                                                    p. 118       Southland     rail safety. Seeks reassurance that    options and consultation
Council         ES    projects    projects in the
                                                                               these improvement works remain a       with key stakeholders is
                                  present RLTP
                                                                               priority and that some time frames     ongoing.
                                                                               around its                             No change to the Proposed
                                                                               commencement/completion are            Variations.
                                                                               provided to ensure action, now it is
                                                                               a ‘Low Cost/Low Risk activity.’
                                                                               Submits that the Pyramid Bridge        Note that the business           Yes
                                                                               replacement needs to be two-way:       case for replacing the
                                  Changes to                                   Appendix 1: Table 13.                  bridge is currently in
                                  Southland                                                                           progress, final decisions
Christine       009   Southland   projects in the                                                                     have not been made nor
                                                    p. 116       Southland
Henderson       ES    projects    present                                                                             agreement yet reached
                                  RTLP                                                                                with NZTA.
                                                                                                                      No change to Proposed
                                                                                                                      Variations.
                                                                               Submits that Wilsons Crossing          Note that NZTA have re-          Yes
                                  Changes to                                   passing lane needs siting - right      prioritised this project so it
                                  Southland                                    hand turn off main road to             is now further into the
Christine       009   Southland   projects in the                              Invercargill at Ryal Bush garage       future than the 2018-21
                                                    p. 119       Southland
Henderson       ES    projects    present                                      problematical: Appendix 1: Table       State Highway Investment
                                                                               13.                                    Proposal. Refer the
                                  RTLP                                                                                request for a right-turn bay
                                                                                                                      to NZTA for consideration.

                                                                          27
Page of
                                                          Proposed                                                                                            [To be]
Submitter        No    Topic            Subtopic                        Region        Submission point                         Staff Recommendations
                                                          Variations                                                                                          Heard?
                                                          document
                                                                                      Notes the proposed Eastern               Refer to Connecting            No
                                                                                      freight bypass project (Dunedin)         Dunedin group for
                                                                                      has been suspended while                 consideration. Ask DCC to
                                        Changes to                                    investigation and data collection are    note that the submitter
University of    003
                       Otago projects   projects in the   pp 122        Otago         carried out. Points out that the         wishes to be involved as a
Otago            ORC
                                        present RLTP                                  alignment of SH88 besides the            stakeholder in this project.
                                                                                      Hocken library on Anzac Avenue           No change to the Proposed
                                                                                      has caused significant problems for      Variation.
                                                                                      access to this facility.
                                                                                      Submits that the proposed Eastern        Refer to Connecting            Yes
Norman                                  Changes to                                    freight bypass project (Dunedin)         Dunedin group for
                 019
Oakley, AA             Otago projects   projects in the   pp 122        Otago         should be progressed with some           consideration.
                 ORC
Otago District                          present RLTP                                  expedition.                              No change to the Proposed
                                                                                                                               Variation.
                                                                                      Disappointed that proposed               Note that NZTA advises         No
                                                                                      improvements to the intersection         that this project is
                                                                                      of Pine Hill Rd/ Great King St has       programmed for detailed
                                                                                      been delayed.                            business case preparation
                                                                                      Points out that this intersection is a   and pre-implementation in
                                                                                      critical one for many staff and          2018-21; construction is
                                        Changes to
University of    003                                                                  students on their journey to/from the    programmed for 21/22.
                       Otago projects   projects in the   p. 114, 128   Otago
Otago            ORC                                                                  campus.                                  Before the RLTP Variation
                                        present RLTP
                                                                                      There are traffic delays and safety      is concluded, ask NZTA
                                                                                      risks.                                   and DCC to advise on
                                                                                      The submitter would like to see          whether or not this project
                                                                                      these improvements completed in          should be added to the
                                                                                      2018-21.                                 present State Highway
                                                                                                                               Investment Proposal.

                                                                                 28
Page of
                                                            Proposed                                                                                       [To be]
Submitter        No    Topic            Subtopic                         Region        Submission point                      Staff Recommendations
                                                            Variations                                                                                     Heard?
                                                            document
                                                                                       Submits that with increasing HPMV     Note that NZTA advises        Yes
                                                                                       movements, ongoing problems with      that this project is
                                                                                       the intersection of Pine Hill Rd/     programmed for detailed
                                                                                       Great King St and the impending       business case preparation
                                                                                       announcement of a new location for    and pre-implementation in
                                                                                       Dunedin Hospital, it is time to       2018-21; construction is
                                                                                       undertake a review of the Dunedin     programmed for 21/22.
                                                                                       state highway strategy.               Before the RLTP Variation
                                        Projects that the                                                                    is concluded, ask NZTA
Norman
                 019   Proposed         RTCs would like                                                                      and DCC to advise on
Oakley, AA                                                  p. 114       Otago
                 ORC   programme        to see in future                                                                     whether or not this project
Otago District
                                        RLTPs                                                                                should be added to the
                                                                                                                             present State Highway
                                                                                                                             Investment Proposal.
                                                                                                                             Refer to Connecting
                                                                                                                             Dunedin group and ask
                                                                                                                             them to advise the RTCs
                                                                                                                             on the need to review the
                                                                                                                             review the Dunedin state
                                                                                                                             highway strategy.
                                                                                       Strongly supports the completion of   Note that NZTA advises        No
                                                                                       the SH88 cycle and walking route      that this project is in the
                                                                                       between the city and Port             State Highway Investment
                                                                                       Chalmers.                             Proposal and is
                                                                                                                             programmed for
                                        Changes to
University of    003                                        pp                                                               completion in 2018-21.
                       Otago projects   projects in the                  Otago
Otago            ORC                                        63,121,129                                                       Ask NZTA to note the
                                        present RLTP
                                                                                                                             University’s views on the
                                                                                                                             importance of completing
                                                                                                                             this walkway/cycleway.
                                                                                                                             No change to the Proposed
                                                                                                                             Variation.
                                                                                       Suggests improvements to the          Note that NZTA expects to     No
                                        Changes to                                     junction of Tucker Beach Road and     complete this work in
                 006
Gerry Spencer          Otago projects   projects in the     p. 127       Otago         SH6 near lower Shotover River to      December 2018.
                 ORC
                                        present RLTP                                   allow traffic to turn out of Tucker   No change to the Proposed
                                                                                       Beach Road more easily.               Variation.

                                                                                  29
Page of
                                                     Proposed                                                                                     [To be]
Submitter   No    Topic            Subtopic                       Region        Submission point                      Staff Recommendations
                                                     Variations                                                                                   Heard?
                                                     document
                                                                                Strongly supports Project number      Note submission. It         Yes
                                                                                38 – Wakatipu Basin Public            supports the proposed
                                   The way that                                 Transport remaining as priority one   project 38 (which is
            001
QLDC              Otago projects   Otago projects    p. 71        Otago
                                                                                project.                              proposed priority 1).
            ES
                                   are prioritised
                                                                                                                      No change to the Proposed
                                                                                                                      Variations.
                                                                                Strongly supports Project number      Note submission. It         Yes
                                                                                39 – Wakatipu Further Small           supports the proposed
                                   The way that                                 Ferry Services remaining as           project 39 (which is
            001
QLDC              Otago projects   Otago projects    p. 72        Otago
                                                                                priority one project.                 proposed priority 1).
            ES
                                   are prioritised
                                                                                                                      No change to the Proposed
                                                                                                                      Variations.
                                                                                Strongly supports Project number      Note submission. It         Yes
                                                                                40 – Wakatipu Public Transport        supports the proposed
                                   The way that                                 Hub Improvements Support              project 40 (which is
            001
QLDC              Otago projects   Otago projects    p. 72        Otago
                                                                                remaining as priority one projects.   proposed priority 1).
            ES
                                   are prioritised
                                                                                                                      No change to the Proposed
                                                                                                                      Variations.
                                                                                Strongly supports Project number      Note submission. It         Yes
                                                                                30 – Queenstown Town Centre           supports the proposed
                                   The way that                                 Pedestrianisation remaining as        project 30 (which is
            001
QLDC              Otago projects   Otago projects    p. 72        Otago
                                                                                priority one project.                 proposed priority 1).
            ES
                                   are prioritised
                                                                                                                      No change to the Proposed
                                                                                                                      Variations.
                                                                                Strongly supports Project number      Note submission. It         Yes
                                                                                31 – Wakatipu Active Travel           supports the proposed
                                   The way that                                 Network remaining as priority one     project 31 (which is
            001
QLDC              Otago projects   Otago projects    p. 73        Otago
                                                                                project.                              proposed priority 1).
            ES
                                   are prioritised
                                                                                                                      No change to the Proposed
                                                                                                                      Variations.

                                                                           30
Page of
                                                     Proposed                                                                                        [To be]
Submitter   No    Topic            Subtopic                       Region        Submission point                     Staff Recommendations
                                                     Variations                                                                                      Heard?
                                                     document
                                                                                Strongly supports Project number     Note submission. It             Yes
                                                                                41 – Public Transport                supports the proposed
                                   The way that                                 Improvements – Hubs remaining        project 41 (which is
            001
QLDC              Otago projects   Otago projects    p. 73        Otago
                                                                                as priority one project.             proposed priority 1).
            ES
                                   are prioritised
                                                                                                                     No change to the Proposed
                                                                                                                     Variations.
                                                                                Strongly supports Project number     Note submission. It             Yes
                                                                                42 – Park and Ride Transport         supports the proposed
                                                                                Services (Queenstown) remaining      project 42 (which is
                                                                                as priority one project.             proposed priority 1).
                                   The way that
            001                                                                                                      Change the RLTP policy
QLDC              Otago projects   Otago projects    p. 73        Otago
            ES                                                                                                       on mode choice to include
                                   are prioritised
                                                                                                                     policy on the provision of
                                                                                                                     park and ride facilities: see
                                                                                                                     recommendation at the end
                                                                                                                     of this document.
                                                                                Strongly supports Project number     Note submission. It             Yes
                                                                                43 – Water Taxi Service/Ferry        supports the proposed
                                   The way that                                 Network (Queenstown) remaining       project 43 (which is
            001
QLDC              Otago projects   Otago projects    p. 74        Otago
                                                                                as priority one project.             proposed priority 1).
            ES
                                   are prioritised
                                                                                                                     No change to the Proposed
                                                                                                                     Variations.
                                                                                Strongly supports Project number     Note submission. It             Yes
                                                                                61 – Ballantyne Road Seal            supports the proposed
                                   The way that                                 Extension (Wanaka) remaining as      project 61 (which is
            001
QLDC              Otago projects   Otago projects    p. 74        Otago
                                                                                priority one project.                proposed priority 1).
            ES
                                   are prioritised
                                                                                                                     No change to the Proposed
                                                                                                                     Variations.
                                                                                Strongly supports Project number     Note submission. It             Yes
                                                                                64 – Housing Infrastructure Fund     supports the proposed
                                   The way that                                 Project – Ladies Mile remaining as   project 64 (which is
            001
QLDC              Otago projects   Otago projects    p. 74        Otago
                                                                                priority one project.                proposed priority 1).
            ES
                                   are prioritised
                                                                                                                     No change to the Proposed
                                                                                                                     Variations.

                                                                           31
Page of
                                                          Proposed                                                                                     [To be]
Submitter        No    Topic            Subtopic                       Region         Submission point                     Staff Recommendations
                                                          Variations                                                                                   Heard?
                                                          document
                                                                                      Strongly supports Project number     Note submission. It         Yes
                                                                                      65 – Housing Infrastructure fund     supports the proposed
                                        The way that                                  Project – Quail Rise remaining as    project 65 (which is
                 001
QLDC                   Otago projects   Otago projects    p. 74        Otago
                                                                                      priority one project.                proposed priority 1).
                 ES
                                        are prioritised
                                                                                                                           No change to the Proposed
                                                                                                                           Variations.
                                                                                      Strongly supports Project number     Note submission. It         Yes
                                                                                      70 – Queenstown Town Centre          supports the proposed
                                        The way that                                  Arterial remaining as priority one   project 70 (which is
                 001
QLDC                   Otago projects   Otago projects    P .75        Otago
                                                                                      project.                             proposed priority 1).
                 ES
                                        are prioritised
                                                                                                                           No change to the Proposed
                                                                                                                           Variations.
                                                                                      Strongly supports Project number     Note submission. It         Yes
                                                                                      71 – Queenstown Traffic              supports the proposed
                                        The way that                                  Management Facilities remaining      project 71 (which is
                 001
QLDC                   Otago projects   Otago projects    p. 75        Otago
                                                                                      as priority one project.             proposed priority 1).
                 ES
                                        are prioritised
                                                                                                                           No change to the Proposed
                                                                                                                           Variations.
                                                                                      Strongly supports Project number     Note submission. It         Yes
                                                                                      72 – Shotover River Bridge           supports the proposed
                                        The way that                                  (Arthurs Point) Duplication          project 72 (which is
                 001
QLDC                   Otago projects   Otago projects    p. 75        Otago
                                                                                      remaining as priority one project.   proposed priority 1).
                 ES
                                        are prioritised
                                                                                                                           No change to the Proposed
                                                                                                                           Variations.

                                                                       Otago &        Supports recognition that a multi-   Note submission. No         No
Queenstown       009                    Queenstown
                       Otago projects                     pp 15-18                    modal transport system will be       change to the Proposed
Central Ltd      ORC                    generally                      Southland
                                                                                      required in Queenstown.              Variations.
Norman                                                                                Endorses the proposed Priority One   Note submission.            Yes
                 019                    Queenstown,
Oakley, AA             Otago projects                     pp 65-66     Otago          projects, including Queenstown       No change to the Proposed
                 ORC                    generally
Otago District                                                                        projects.                            Variation.

                                                                                 32
Page of
                                                    Proposed                                                                                            [To be]
Submitter       No    Topic            Subtopic                  Region        Submission point                         Staff Recommendations
                                                    Variations                                                                                          Heard?
                                                    document
                                                                               Concerned about traffic congestion       Note submission.                Yes
                                                                               especially in and around                 Refer to Queenstown
                                                                               Queenstown, slows down traffic           Lakes multi-agency
                                                                               speed and makes the coach                Transport Group for their
                                                                               journey between Queenstown and           information
                                                                               Milford Sound or Manapouri longer.       No change to proposed
                                                                               Pushes coach drivers to the limit of     variations.
Real Journeys   020                    Queenstown                              their driver log book hours. If the
                      Otago projects                -            Otago
Ltd             ORC                    generally                               travel delays caused by traffic
                                                                               congestion are not addressed this
                                                                               will compromise ability to operate
                                                                               coach tours ex Queenstown and to
                                                                               and from Milford Sound / Manapouri
                                                                               which in turn, will exacerbate traffic
                                                                               congestion by putting more rental
                                                                               vehicles on the road.
                                                                               Supports the Priority One projects       Note submission.                Yes
Real Journeys   020                    Queenstown
                      Otago projects                p. 65        Otago         for Queenstown.                          No change to the Proposed
Ltd             ORC                    generally
                                                                                                                        Variations.
                                                                               Supports the programme of Priority       Note support for the            No
                                                                               One projects for Queenstown on           integrated programme of
                                                                               page 65, especially expanding the        improvements for
                                                                               water taxi to a full ferry service for   Queenstown.
                                                                               Kelvin Peninsula. Pleased to see         Change the RLTP policy
                                                                               the increase in emphasis on public       on mode choice to clarify
                                                                               transport for Queenstown.                the role of public transport,
                                                    For PT =
                038                    Queenstown                                                                       to support growth in public
Cath Gilmore          Otago projects                pp 67, 71-   Otago
                ORC                    generally                                                                        transport patronage and to
                                                    72, 98-100
                                                                                                                        highlight the need to
                                                                                                                        consider the end to end
                                                                                                                        journey requirements of
                                                                                                                        those using the transport
                                                                                                                        network: see
                                                                                                                        recommendation at the end
                                                                                                                        of this document.

                                                                          33
Page of
                                                         Proposed                                                                                              [To be]
Submitter          No    Topic       Subtopic                         Region        Submission point                          Staff Recommendations
                                                         Variations                                                                                            Heard?
                                                         document
                                                                                    Asks that two more resilience             Before the proposed              No
                                                                                    projects added to the list of those       variation to the RLTP is
                                                                                    the RTCs want to see developed in         finalised, ask TAG to
Doug                                 Projects that the
                                                                                    future RLTPs:                             investigate and advise
Davidson, AA       007   Proposed    RTCs would like
                                                         p. 114       Southland     - Riverton one lane bridge                whether these two projects
Southland          ORC   programme   to see in future
                                                                                    - SH1 between Bluff and                   should be added to the list
District Council                     RLTPs
                                                                                    Invercargill.                             of those projects the RTCs
                                                                                                                              want to see developed in
                                                                                                                              future RLTPs.
                                                                                    Asks that, as a minimum, planning         Refer the suggestion of          Yes
                                                                                    commence for replacement of the           traffic lights to Queenstown
                                                                                    one-lane bridge over the Clutha           Lakes multi-agency
                                     Projects that the                              River at Albert Town and that traffic     transport group for
Norman
                   019   Proposed    RTCs would like                                lights be installed in the interim to     consideration.
Oakley, AA                                               p. 114       Otago
                   ORC   programme   to see in future                               mitigate the bottlenecks that are         No change to the Proposed
Otago District
                                     RLTPs                                          occurring.                                Variation as the item is
                                                                                                                              already listed as a project
                                                                                                                              that the RTCs want to see
                                                                                                                              developed in future RLTPs.
                                                                                    Concerned about growing numbers           Note that the South Island       Yes
                                                                                    of visitors/traffic and safety of local   RTC chairs groups
                                                                                    people travelling on roads.               (through the officials group)
                                                                                    Travelling from Te Anau to                are developing a tourism
                                                                                    Mossburn – wants passing lane/s           and transport project; one
                                                                                    installed on Gorge Hill Road.             of the results of this project
                                                                                    Travelling from Mossburn to Te            will be the identification of
                                                                                    Anau – wants passing lane/s               what fit-for-purpose tourist
                   004   Proposed    New safety work                                installed somewhere around ‘So            routes, that enhance visitor
Mary Chartres                                            -            Otago
                                                                                                                              experience and safety,
                   ES    programme   requested                                      Big’ farm. Install a second passing
                                                                                    lane past Chewings road around            would look like. The results
                                                                                    bends with double yellow lines            of this project will provide
                                                                                    (before Gorge Hill).                      guidance about
                                                                                                                              improvements to tourist
                                                                                                                              routes in both Southland
                                                                                                                              and Otago.
                                                                                                                              No change to Proposed
                                                                                                                              Variations.

                                                                               34
You can also read