2020 Tropical Cyclone Operations and Research Forum Tuesday, February 25, 2020 - 74th Interdepartmental Hurricane Conference - Interagency Council ...

Page created by Isaac Bates
 
CONTINUE READING
2020 Tropical Cyclone Operations and Research Forum Tuesday, February 25, 2020 - 74th Interdepartmental Hurricane Conference - Interagency Council ...
2020 Tropical Cyclone Operations and Research Forum
    74th Interdepartmental Hurricane Conference

           Tuesday, February 25, 2020

           Tom Renkevens        Thomas.Renkevens@noaa.gov
                 Division Chief
                 Satellite Products and Services Division
                 NOAA / NESDIS / OSPO
                                                            1
2020 Tropical Cyclone Operations and Research Forum Tuesday, February 25, 2020 - 74th Interdepartmental Hurricane Conference - Interagency Council ...
Agenda
•Satellite Status and Updates
  –GOES Constellation
     •GOES-15 termination and future use
        –Support during hot periods in August
        –No more RSO
     •Direct Readout
     •GOES-17 Loop Heat Pipe Status
     •GOES-R Product Status
  –Jason
  –Himawari
  –Meteosat
  –Polar Updates

•Product Status
  –Tropical Product Status
  –SAR (Synthetic Aperture Radar) uses for tropics

•SAB – Satellite Analysis Branch
  –Tropical Review
  –Branch Overview
  –Looking towards the future
  –Status on SAB Dvorak Analysis

•Questions and Comments
                                                Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 2
2020 Tropical Cyclone Operations and Research Forum Tuesday, February 25, 2020 - 74th Interdepartmental Hurricane Conference - Interagency Council ...
GOES-R Series Overview
    • NOAA’s latest generation of Geostationary Operational Environmental Satellites (GOES)
    • GOES-R satellites provide advanced imagery and atmospheric measurements of Earth’s weather,
    oceans and environment, real-time mapping of total lightning activity, and improved monitoring of solar
    activity and space weather
    • Benefits and Applications:
         – Improved hurricane track and intensity forecasts           – Better fire detection and intensity estimation
         – Increased thunderstorm and tornado warning lead time       – Improved detection of low cloud/fog
         – Earlier warning of lightning ground strike hazards         – Improved transportation safety and aviation route
                                                                      planning
         – Better detection of heavy rainfall and flash flood risks
                                                                      – Improved warning for communications and navigation
         – Better monitoring of smoke and dust
                                                                      disruptions and power blackouts
         – Improved air quality warnings and alerts
                                                                      – More accurate monitoring of energetic particles
                                                                      responsible for radiation hazards
The GOES-R ABI provides three times more spectral
information, four times the spatial resolution, and more than
five times faster temporal coverage than the previous
system

                                                                             Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 3
2020 Tropical Cyclone Operations and Research Forum Tuesday, February 25, 2020 - 74th Interdepartmental Hurricane Conference - Interagency Council ...
4
Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 4
2020 Tropical Cyclone Operations and Research Forum Tuesday, February 25, 2020 - 74th Interdepartmental Hurricane Conference - Interagency Council ...
Current GOES Constellation
              GOES-West       Tandem GOES-West            Standby                          GOES-East
               GOES-17            GOES-15                 GOES-14                           GOES-16
              137.2° West         128° West              105° West                         75.2° West

 • GOES-15 to continue tandem GOES-West operations, ending on March 2, 2020 and then
 transition to on-orbit storage
    –NEW INFORMATION…. Plans are to use GOES-15 to support the GOES-17 during the hot period next
    August (exact dates TBD). Beyond that will depend on other possible mitigation approaches of AI and
    other….
    –Effective February 10, a recent schedule change to GOES-15 where NESDIS has suspended the daily
    generation of the GOES-15 rapid scan and full disk schedules in the workflow. These schedules can be
    put back into rotation (if needed) in a matter of hours. NWS hasn't called an RSO with GOES-15 since
    September 2018. If for some reason we need to call an RSO we can do this in a few hours during
    normal business hours and a few hours longer on the weekend or overnight.
 • Transitioned to 10 minute full disk schedules last April                                             5
 •GOES-T (GOES-18) scheduled for launch December 2021 and after post-launch checkout will
 transition to on-orbit storage
                                                                   Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 5
2020 Tropical Cyclone Operations and Research Forum Tuesday, February 25, 2020 - 74th Interdepartmental Hurricane Conference - Interagency Council ...
February 7, 2020 Memo

                        Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 6
2020 Tropical Cyclone Operations and Research Forum Tuesday, February 25, 2020 - 74th Interdepartmental Hurricane Conference - Interagency Council ...
GOES-T and GOES-U Status

 GOES-T
 • Spacecraft assembled, awaiting ABI and GLM
   deliveries
 • Launch vehicle selection to be announced
   November 2019
 • Launch planned December 2021
 GOES-U
 • Integration underway
 • Preparing to add the Naval Research Laboratory’s
   Compact Coronagraph (CCOR) for coronal mass
   ejection detection                                                                  GOES-T at Lockheed

 • Launch planned 2024

  Coronal Mass
    Ejection
                                   CCOR Concept
                                                Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 7
2020 Tropical Cyclone Operations and Research Forum Tuesday, February 25, 2020 - 74th Interdepartmental Hurricane Conference - Interagency Council ...
Geostationary Operational Environmental Satellite (GOES)
                  Performance Status
                                       January 23, 2020

                                                 GOES-16                        GOES-17
                                                    (East)                          (West)
                                                Launch: Nov 16                Launch: Mar 18
 Payload Instrument                            Activation: Dec 17            Activation: Feb 19
 Advanced Baseline Imager (ABI)                       G                               Y(2)                                   Key
                                                                                                                         Operational
 Space Environment I-Situ Suite (SEISS)               G                                 G
                                                                                                                               G
 Solar Ultraviolet Imager (SUVI)                      G                                 G
                                                                                                                        Operational
 EUV and X-ray Irradiance Sensors                                                                                      with limitations
                                                      G                                 G
 (EXIS)
                                                                                                                               Y
 Magnetometer                                        Y(1)                               G
                                                                                                                       Non-operational
 Geostationary Lighting Mapper (GLM)                  G                                 G
                                                                                                                               R
 Spacecraft Subsystems
 Command Data & Handling (CD&H)                       G                                 G
 Guidance Navigation Control (GNC)                    G                                 G
 Electrical Power Subsystem (EPS)                     G                                 G
 Propulsion                                           G                                 G
 Mechanisms                                           G                                 G
 Electrical Power                                     G                                 G
 Thermal Control                                      G                                 G
 Communications Payloads                              G                                 G
                                                                    Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 8
2020 Tropical Cyclone Operations and Research Forum Tuesday, February 25, 2020 - 74th Interdepartmental Hurricane Conference - Interagency Council ...
Geostationary Operational Environmental Satellite (GOES)
                                Performance Status
                                                    January 23, 2020

                                      EWS-G1                  GOES-14                    GOES-15
                                       (Transit)               (Backup)               (West Backup)
                                     Launch: May 06          Launch: Jun 09            Launch: Mar 10
Payload Instrument                  Activation: Apr 10         Activation:            Activation: Dec 11
Imager                                     G                       G                             G                                     Key
                                                                                                                                   Operational
Sounder                                   R (4)                    G                           Y (3)
Magnetosphere Proton and Electron                                                                                                        G
                                           G                       G                           Y (5)
Detectors (MAGPD/MAGED )
                                                                                                                                  Operational
Magnetometers                              G                       G                             G                               with limitations

Energetic Proton, Electron, and                                                                                                          Y
                                           G                       G                             G
Alpha Detectors (EPEAD/HEPAD)
X-Ray/EUV Sensors (XRS/EUV)               Y (1)                    G                             G                               Non-operational

Solar X-Ray Imager (SXI)                  Y (2)                    G                             G                                       R
Spacecraft Subsystems
Telemetry, Command & Control               G                       G                             G
Attitude and Orbit Control                 G                       G                             G
Fuel for Inclination Control               G                       G                             G
Propulsion                                 G                       G                             G
Mechanisms                                 G                       G                             G
Electrical Power                           G                       G                             G
Thermal Control                            G                       G                             G
Communications Payloads                     G                      G                             G

                                                                              Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 9
2020 Tropical Cyclone Operations and Research Forum Tuesday, February 25, 2020 - 74th Interdepartmental Hurricane Conference - Interagency Council ...
GOES-R Series Products on GRB

 Level 1b Products:
 Radiances from the Advanced Baseline
 Imager: 16 Bands; Full Disk, CONUS, and
 Mesoscale
 Solar imagery from the Solar Ultraviolet
 Imager
 Solar flux from the Extreme Ultraviolet and
 X-ray Irradiance Sensors
 Energetic heavy ions from the Space
 Environment In-Situ Suite
 Space environment magnetic field from the     Level 2 products:
 Magnetometer                                     Geostationary Lightning Mapper

                                                          Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 10
GRB User Group

 • GRB User Group has over 160 members and it met 4 times during 2019
 • Aligned to NESDIS Strategic Objective: Provide consistent ongoing enterprise-wide
 user engagement to ensure timely response to user needs
 • Univ. of Wisconsin SSEC/CIMSS provided CSPP Geo software patches prior to the
 GOES-R Ground System going live so that CSPP Geo users would have a smooth
 transition
 • Non-federal Government GRB users filed comments on the FCC webpage in regards
 to the Notice of Proposed Rulemaking for Sharing the 1675-1680 MHz Band
 • Members participated in a GRB Monitoring Workshop in December 2019
 • Includes vendors, manufacturers, and system integrators:
 https://noaasis.noaa.gov/ORGANIZATION/manu_list.html

                                                    Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 11
Community Satellite Processing Package
for Geostationary Data (CSPP Geo)
• Funded by NOAA GOES-R Program to create and distribute software to process direct broadcast data
  from geostationary satellites, generating products in real-time. CSPP Geo software is available at:
  http://cimss.ssec.wisc.edu/csppgeo/
• All CSPP Geo software is free to download and use. Capabilities include:
   – Process the GOES-16 and GOES-17 GRB data streams, reconstructing the products that were
       generated on the ground system
   – Further process GOES-16 and GOES-17 ABI data to generate Level 2 products
         ABI L1 Quicklooks                 ABI true color

                                                                 Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 12
•   There are 61 GRB sites.
    Some sites have more than 1
    receive station
•   There are 89 receive stations
    (antennas)                                                       NOAA NWS National Centers receive GOES-16 and
                                                                     GOES-17.
                                                                     • Aviation Weather Center (AWC) Kansas City, MO
                                                                     • NOAA Center for Weather and Climate Prediction
                                                                        (NCWCP) College Park, MD
                                                                     • Storm Prediction Center (SPC), Norman, OK
                                                                     • Space Weather Prediction Center (SWPC) Boulder,
                                                                        CO
                                                                     • National Hurricane Center (NHC) Miami, FL
                                                                     GRB is the primary source of GOES-16 and GOES-17
                                                                     data for AWC, SPC, SWPC, and NHC

                                     Example of a GRB Site: NASA Marshall Space Flight Center at
                                    Huntsville, AL has 2 GRB receive stations to receive GOES-16 and
                                                                GOES-17

                                                                         Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 13
1/13/2020
             Background LHP (Loop Heat Pipe)
             Anomaly on GOES-17
     •GOES-17 suffered an on-orbit anomaly with the one of the two
     loop heat pipes that is used to pass heat from the cryocooler to
     the radiator for rejection
     •This anomaly causes the two of the three focal planes to rise to
     temperatures observable by the infrared imaging sensors causing
     saturation in certain bands
     •This is most pronounced around the two eclipse seasons annually
     and during those days most severe at local spacecraft midnight,
     this is when the instrument is most directly pointing toward the
     sun

                                             Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 14
Background LHP Anomaly

•Level 1b radiance impacts are easily relatively characterized and
a Data Quality Flag (DQF) state has been added to identify when
the product is saturated due to Focal Plane Temperature (FPT)
•Different bands saturate at different times
•Level 2 products are impacted by the LHP anomaly which causes
saturation of IR bands
•Impacts to Level 2 products vary widely from product-to-product.
Some daytime-only products such as snow will see minimal
degradation while products such as cloud mask are more
impacted

                                         Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 15
16
                          GOES-17 ABI Loop Heat Pipe (LHP) Anomaly

 • The higher the ABI focal plane                                Diurnal Cycle of Predicted Daily Maximum ABI focal
                                                                                        plane
   temperature, the more saturated
   imagery becomes
 • Temperatures approaching band
   thresholds (black horizontal
   lines) cause marginal saturation
 • Temperatures exceeding band
   lines cause unusable saturated
   imagery
      Annual Cycle of Predicted Daily Maximum ABI focal
                          plane

                                                                             Graphic by David
                                            Version July, 2019
                                                                             Pogorzala
                                                                             Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 16
17
            LHP Anomaly L2 Algorithm Mitigations

 Three possible approaches to mitigation impacts will be used
     –DQF flags will be used to indicate when the product is degraded due to
     the focal plane temperature
     –In some cases channels will be substituted (e.g., apply a correction to
     channel 14 and using that as a proxy for channel 13 when saturated)
     –In other cases channels will be dropped from consideration in the
     algorithm logic

                                                  Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 17
18
1/13/2020

            What’s Next? Exploring Cooling Timelines
                                              30-min Full Disk cooling timeline

                                                                                                     Graphic by
                                                                                                     L3Harris
                                       Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 18
GOES-17 ABI Cooling Tests

•   During test, nominal Mode 6 (10min FD, 5min CONUS, 1min MDS) was changed to a
    combination of Mode 4 (continuous full disk, no CONUS, no MDS) for 5 minutes and
    a new engineering test Mode 14 with extended space-look time periods for 25
    minutes.
•   Total of a 30 minute test period.
•   Phase 1: 30 minute test period repeated twice to assess any unintended data
    operations impacts at 1100-1200 UTC on October 15, 2019
•   Phase 2: 30 minute test period repeated continuously from 0600-1200 UTC for four
    days on October 18-21, 2019
                                     Promising
                                   initial results
                                         (see
                                     channels
                                   8,9,10,12,16)

                                 Oct 17    Oct 18
                                 1030       1030
                                 UTC        UTC      Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 19
Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 20
21

     GOES-16 L2+ Science Product Validation Status

                                                                                                          Was 2/13/20

                                  Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 21
Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 22
Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 23
Jason-2 Status
 No Safe Holds
97.56% data capture within 3 hours, requirement 75% within 3 hours
(May 27 – Oct 1, 2019)
   June 17, 2019: Began Site Acceptance Testing of new NJGS.
   July 12: The first proactive gyro swap was performed. Until the end of September, Jason-2
    will be running on gyros 2 and 3, letting gyro 1 rest for a while.
   July 15: Cabling between ESPC and SOCC for the NJGS Refresh completed.
   July 31: Station-keeping maneuver over land
   Aug 13: Began receiving yellow alarms, potentially due to PCE (Power Conditioning
    Equipment) section failure (investigations are currently on-going).
   Sept 4: Meeting with Law on Space Operations (LOS) bureau was held at CNES.
   Sept 11: Exceptional Joint Steering Group held to discuss Jason-2 end-of-life.
   Oct 1: End of Jason-2 science data (no more OGDRs)
   Oct 10: Official end of Jason-2 mission
   Apr 20-21, 2020: Jason-2 closeout at annual Jason Exploitation Review (REVEX) meeting

                                                              Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 24
Jason-3 Status
 Spacecraft nominal.
      Safe Hold from January 31 – February 5, 2020 (triggered by gyro3 anomaly)
      Brief Safe Hold recovery (5 orbits) on February 5 before reentering Safe Hold
       Mode
      Full Safe Hold recovery on February 13

 97.63% data capture within 3 hours, requirement 75% within 3
  hours (May 27, 2019 – Feb 9, 2020)
   June 16, 2019: Braking maneuver performed. One OGDR impacted.
   June 17: Began Site Acceptance Testing of new NJGS.
   July 15: Cabling between ESPC and SOCC for the NJGS Refresh completed.
   August 6: Station-keeping maneuver over land. No impact.
   December 3: Station-keeping maneuver. No impact. One OGDR was impacted.

                                                               Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 25
Himawari-8/9 Constellation

 Himawari-8 is operational at 140E
 Himawari-9 is in standby at 140.7E
     Planned for prime 140E operations in 2022
     Himawari-9 end of life around 2030

                                        Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 26
NOAA’s Himawari-8 Operational Plans

   •Phase 1 (Current)
     –NESDIS provides Himawari Level 2 products via the Center for Satellite
     Applications and Research (STAR) ftp server with 24/7 monitoring capability
     provided by the Office of Satellite Products and Operations (OSPO) and 24/7
     troubleshooting capability provided by STAR.
         •Current Himawari L2 products available from STAR
              –Cloud Products: Cloud Mask, Cloud Phase, and Cloud Height
              –DMW’s
         •L1b data also available in native HSD format from
         STAR via JMA’s HimawariCloud service

                                                        Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 27
NOAA’s Himawari-8 Operational Plans
  •Phase 2 (2020-2021)
    –NESDIS will move L2 PG to cloud service – L2 products
    will flow from NESDIS cloud to PDA and from PDA to
    customers
    –Distribution of level 1b HSD data also from PDA
    –Himawari L2 products planned for generation and
    distribution:
       •Cloud and Moisture Imagery
       •Rainfall Rate
       •Sea Surface Temperature
       •Cloud Products
           –Cloud Top Height, Clear Sky Mask, Cloud Top Phase
  •Initial demonstration of capability ~ March 2020
  (Level 1b products only)
  •Full operational capability ~ September 2021 (Level 1b
  and L2 products)

                                                    Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 28
HimawariRequest to Support NOAA Operations

•NESDIS in collaboration with NWS established an account with JMA to use
HimawariRequest, a service for NOAA operational offices to request
relocations of the Himawari-8 (140E) 2.5 min Target Area (floating) sector
   –Enables rapid scanning of hazardous events in the Pacific Region to support NOAA
   operations
   –Target Area covers 1000 km x 1000 km every 2.5 min in all 16 AHI bands at full
   spatial resolution
   –NWS/SDM will be the point of contact for NOAA operations
      •All requests will be coordinated with SDM; analogous to NOAA GOES-R MDS coordination
      procedure
      •JMA website provides real-time location and schedule of Target Area for current operations
   –Requests for Target Area relocation will be sent via email to JMA for review and
   approval/disapproval
      •Requests limited to a 48 hour period; extensions are considered in extreme events
   –Target Area coverage of typhoons and active volcanoes will have priority

                                                              Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 29
Himawari Scanning Sectors including Floating 2.5 min
               Target Area (Region 3)

*Only Full Disk and Target Area/Region 3
scans will be processed at
NOAA/NESDIS*

                                           Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 30
SATELLITE         LIFETIME                    POSITION                         SERVICES
Current MSG Constellation                 15/07/2015 –                                              0º SEVIRI Image
                            Meteosat-11   Availability lifetime                    0°               Data. Real-time
                                          is until 2024                                             Imagery.
                                                                                                    Rapid Scan Service
                                                                                                    gap filling spacecraft
                                          22/12/2005–Fuel
                            Meteosat-9    lifetime is until 2024
                                                                               3.5° E               and back-up to
                                                                                                    prime Met-11
                                                                                                    spacecraft
                                          05/07/2012–                                               Rapid Scan Service
                                          Availability lifetime                                     Real-time Imagery.
                            Meteosat-10   is until 2024
                                                                               9.5° E

                                          28/08/2002 – Fuel                                        Full IODC service
                            Meteosat-8    lifetime is until 2022
                                                                             41.5° E

                                                                             Primary Imaging
                                                                            Operations

  Meteosat-11 FD
  Image                                             Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 31
Future Meteosat Third Generation (MTG) Satellites

•MTG-I1 (imager mission)
  –Projected launch date Q3/CY2021, operational by October
  2022
  –16 channel imager and lightning mapper
    •Temporal and spatial resolutions similar to GOES-R series
•MTG-S1 (sounder mission)
  –Projected launch date Q3/CY2023
  –Two Spectral bands: MWIR (4.44–6.25 µm) and LWIR
  (8.26–14.70 µm)
  –Spatial resolution of 4 km x 4 km at nadir

                                             Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 32
S-NPP & NOAA-20 Status

 Spacecraft                   Suomi-NPP                              Spacecraft                               NOAA-20
 Launch Date                  Oct 28, 2011                           Launch Date                            Nov 18, 2017
 Mission                  LTAN 1325 (PM)                             Mission                              LTAN 1325 (PM)
 Category              Operational (secondary)                       Category                     Primary Satellite in PM orbit

                     S-NPP                                                                     NOAA-20
 Payload - Instruments                  Status                       Payload - Instruments                                       Status
 ATMS                                        G                       ATMS                                                            G
 CERES                                       G                       CERES                                                           G
 CrIS                                        G                       CrIS                                                            G
 OMPS – Nadir                                G                       OMPS – Nadir                                                    G
 OMPS – Limb                                 G                       VIIRS                                                           G
 VIIRS                                       G

Operational (or capable of)                      Operational with degraded performance
                                                                                                              Functional but turned off
Operational with limitations (or in standby)     Not functional

                                                                          Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 33
PRE-DECISIONAL   Polar Operational Environmental Satellite (POES)                                                                        PRE-DECISIONAL
DATA NOAA USE
     ONLY
                 Performance Status                                                                                                      DATA NOAA USE
                                                                                                                                              ONLY
                 January 24, 2020
  Spacecraft
                          METOP-A          METOP-B      METOP-C       NOAA-19              NOAA-18                   NOAA-15
  Subsystems
  Launch Date                Oct 2006       Sept 2012    Nov 2018       Feb 2009             May 2005                  May 1998
  Operational Date          May 2007       April 2013    April 2019     Jun 2009             Aug 2005                  Dec 1998
  Mission Data Category
                                                                                                                                          Operational              G
                                            Primary     Operational   Prime Services
                          Secondary (AM)                                                 Secondary (PM)            Secondary (AM)
                                             (AM)         (AM)        Mission (PM)

  Payload Instruments                                                                                                                     Spacecraft
                                                                                                                                          Issue but No            S/C
  AVHRR                         G              G             G              G                    G                       Y(19)            User Impact
  HIRS                        Y(40)           P(32)        N/A            O (31)              R (3,43)                    Y (5)
  AMSU-A1                     O (30)         Y(36)        P (44)            G                  P (33)                    Y(20)            Investigating
                                                                                                                                          Performance
  AMSU-A2                       G              G             G              G                    G                                        Issue which              P
                                                                                                                                          will Impact
  AMSU-B                       N/A                         N/A             N/A                  N/A                      R (11)           Users

  MHS                           G              G           P(45)          Y (6)                R(42)                      N/A
                                                                                                                                          Operational
  SEM                         Y(38)            G             G            Y(39)                Y(37)                       G              with                     Y
                                                                                                                                          Limitation
  SBUV                         N/A                         N/A           S/C (9)               R(27)                      N/A
  Spacecraft Subsystems                                                                                                                   Operational
                                                                                                                                          with                     O
  Telemetry, Command                                                                                                                      Degradation
  & Control                     G              G             G              G                    G                         G

   ADACS                        G              G             G              G                  Y (41)                    O (10)           Non-
                                                                                                                                          Operational
                                                                                                                                                                   R
   EPS                          G              G             G              G                    G                          G
   Thermal Control              G              G             G              G                    G                       Y(21)            Not
                                                                                                                                          Applicable
   Communications             Y (1)            G             G              G                    G                       Y(22)
   APT/LRPT                   R (2)           R (2)        R (2)            G                    G                         G
  DCS                          N/A            N/A          N/A             N/A                   G                         G
  ADCS                          G            O(29)           G            Y(34)                 N/A                       N/A
  SAR: SARR & SARP              G            Y(35)         N/A              G                    G                       Y(23)

                                                                                       Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 34
Polar Payload Instrument Acronyms

AVHRR        Advanced High Resolution Radiometer
HIRS High Resolution Infrared Radiometer
AMSU-A1      Advanced Microwave Sounding Unit
AMSU-A2      Advanced Microwave Sounding Unit
AMSU-B       Advanced Microwave Sounding Unit
MHS Microwave Humidity Sounder
SEM Space Environment Monitor
SBUV Solar Back Scatter UV Spectral Radiometer
DCS          Data Collection System
ADCS Advanced Data Collection System
SAR          Search And Rescue: SARR and SARP

                                   Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 35
NOAA-20 Science Product Validation &
                   Readiness for Operations (1 of 2)
                                                                                               SPSRB Declared
                                                        Beta              Provisional             Ready for                     Validated
                                                                                                 Operations
ATMS Level 1 Products
Temperature Data Record (TDR)*                     08-Dec-2017           23-Jan-2018              28-Feb-2018                  14-Jun-2018
Sensor Data Record (SDR)                           08-Dec-2017           23-Jan-2018              28-Feb-2018                  14-Jun-2018
CrIS Level 1 Product
SDR*                                                17-Jan-2018          16-Feb-2018              28-Feb-2018                  2-Oct-2018
VIIRS Level 1 Product
VIIRS SDR                                           1-Feb-2018           16-Feb-2018              28-Feb-2018                  15-Jun-2018
OMPS Level 1 Products
Total Column                                        5-Jan-2018           18-Apr-2018              7-Mar-2019                    Sep-2019
Nadir Profile                                       5-Jan-2018            2-Jul-2018                Sep-2019                    Mar-2020
VIIRS Level 2 Products(s)
VIIRS Imagery*                                      1-Feb-2018           16-Feb-2018              28-Feb-2018                 22-Aug-2018

 Validation Maturity Levels          Not Validated              Beta Maturity                Provisional Maturity          Validated Maturity

 Ready for Operations                SPSRB Declaration

 *Key Performance Parameter (KPP)
 Product quality documentation available: https://www.star.nesdis.noaa.gov/jpss/AlgorithmMaturity.php
                                                                             Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration //   36
                                                                                                                   Updated: Lihang Zhou, 01/27/20
NOAA-20 Science Product Validation &
                                    Readiness for Operations (2 of 2)
                                                           Available in                                                                                    Available in
                                  Beta     Provisional                    Validated                                       Beta          Provisional                               Validated
                                                              Ops                                                                                             Ops
VIIRS Level 2 Products                                                                   VIIRS Level 2 Products
Cloud Height                23-Jul-2018     2-Oct-2018      7-Mar-2019    16-May-2019    Green Vegetation
                                                                                                                 22-Aug-2018            21-Mar-2019           4-Jun-2019           Mar-2020
Cloud Properties (night)   21-Mar-2018 21-Mar-2019         10-Apr-2019    16-May-2019    Fraction (GVF)
Cloud Properties (day)      23-Jul-2018    27-Nov-2018      7-Mar-2019    16-May-2019    Vegetation Index (VI)   22-Aug-2018            21-Mar-2019           4-Jun-2019           Mar-2020
Cloud Type/Phase            2-Oct-2018      2-Oct-2018      7-Mar-2019    16-May-2019    Vegetation Health (VH) 22-Aug-2018             21-Mar-2019           4-Jun-2019         21-Mar-2019
Cloud Mask                 18-Apr-2018      2-Oct-2018      7-Mar-2019    16-May-2019    Volcanic Ash            27-Nov-2018            27-Nov-2018          7-Mar-2019          16-May-2019
Aerosol Optical Depth                                                                    Ocean Color             27-Nov-2018            27-Nov-2018            Jun-2020             Jun-2020
and Particle Size          18-Apr-20181    18-Apr-20181     7-Mar-2019    16-May-2019    Sea Surface Temperature 18-Apr-20181           18-Apr-20181         7-Nov-2018          16-May-2019
Parameter                                                                                VIIRS Polar Winds        2-Oct-2018              2-Oct-2018         7-Mar-2019          16-May-2019
Aerosol Detection          18-Apr-20181 18-Apr-20181        7-Mar-2019    16-May-2019    CRIS/ATMS Level 2 Products
Ice Surface Temperature     15-Jun-2018 16-May-2019        20-Jun-2019    16-May-2019    NUCAPS: AVTP,
                                                                                                                 15-Jun-20181           15-Jun-20181         7-Mar-2019            Oct-2019
Sea Ice Concentration                                                                    AVMP
                            15-Jun-2018 16-May-2019        20-Jun-2019    16-May-2019    NUCAPS: Ozone, CO,
and Ice Thickness                                                                                                15-Jun-20181            2-Oct-2018          7-Mar-2019            Oct-2019
                                                                                         OLR
Snow Cover (Binary
Map & Snow Cover            15-Jun-2018 16-May-2019        20-Jun-2019     Apr-2020
                                                                                         NUCAPS: CH4             15-Jun-20181              Oct-2019          7-Mar-2019            Mar-2020
Fraction)                                                                                NUCAPS: CO2                 15-Jun-20181         Mar-2020           7-Mar-2019            Dec-2020
Active Fire                18-Apr-2018 18-Apr-2018         13-Aug-2018     Feb-2020      ATMS Level 2 Products
Land Surface                                                                             MiRS: AVTP, AVMP,
                            23-Jul-2018    21-Mar-2019       Sep-2019      Nov-2019                                  18-Apr-20181 18-Apr-20181               7-Mar-2019            Sep-2019
Temperature                                                                              TPW
Land Surface Albedo         23-Jul-2018    21-Mar-2019       Sep-2019      Nov-2019      MiRS: Snowfall Rate         18-Apr-2018 16-May-2019                 7-Mar-2019          16-May-2019
GST (Global Gridded                                                                      MiRS: Other EDRs            18-Apr-20181       18-Apr-20181         7-Mar-2019            Sep-2019
                             Sep-2019        Sep-2020           --         Sep-2020
Surface Type)                                                                            OMPS Level 2 Products
Land Surface                                                                             Ozone EDR: NP               18-Apr-2018           Sep-2019            Jan-2020            Apr-2020
                            15-Jun-2018 21-Mar-2019        23-Apr-2019     Apr-2020
Reflectance                                                                              Ozone EDR: TC               18-Apr-2018         2-Oct-2018          7-Mar-2019            Sep-2019

              Validation Maturity Levels                Not Validated             Beta Maturity           Provisional Maturity                 Validated Maturity
              Operational                               Available in Operations
                                                                                                            Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 37
               1 Scientifically   mature pending verification of NDE implementation.                                                        Updated: Lihang Zhou, 01/27/20
HRD Sites

The NOAA X/L Band antennas at Honolulu,
Anchorage, Fairbanks, Madison, Miami,
Mayaguez, and Guam provide real-time imagery
from VIIRS, AVHRR, and MODIS via onsite
processing. Images are converted to AWIPS
format and delivered to National Weather
Service Forecast Offices

                                                  Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 38
HRD Sites

            Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 39
Operational Tropical Cyclone
 Satellite Products Available
  from NOAA/NESDIS/OSPO
ADT (Advanced Dvorak Technique)

eTRaP(Ensemble Tropical Rainfall Potential)

TCFP (Tropical Cyclone Formation Probability)

MTCSWA (Multi-Platform Surface Wind Analysis)

Microwave Sounder-based Tropical Cyclone Products

                                                    Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 40
ADT (Advanced Dvorak Technique)
  The ADT is a computer-based technique to objectively
  determine tropical cyclone (TC) intensity using operational
  geostationary satellite infrared imagery.
  Satellite: GOES-15/16, Himawari-8, METEOSAT, GPM, GCOM,
  SSMI/SSMIS,
  Formats: ASCII, PNG, ATCF
  Distribution: ATCF/PDA, ASCII and PNG/web
  Product webpage: https://www.ssd.noaa.gov/PS/TROP/adt.html

ADT will be upgraded to ADTv9.0 around June 2020. ADTv.9.0 will use GOES-16/17 and HIMAWARI-8
original high resolution data.

                                                                Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 41
eTRaP(Ensemble Tropical Rainfall Potential)
Ensemble Tropical Rainfall Potential (eTRaP) is an application that
combines TRaP forecasts from multiple satellite sensors in a "simple
ensemble" to produce improved deterministic and probabilistic
guidance for heavy rainfall in landfalling tropical cyclones.
Satellite: SNPP, NOAA-18/19, Metop-A/B, GPM, GCOM, DMSP F-
17/18, GOES-15/16, HIMAWARI, METEOSAT
Formats: ASCII, PNG, Mcidas
Distribution: ASCII and Mcidas/PDA, PNG/Web
Product webpage:
https://www.ssd.noaa.gov/PS/TROP/etrap.html                                           Storm Micheal: 24hr rain amount

 Storm Michael:24hr total Pop>50mm    Storm Michael: 24hr total Pop>100mm              Storm Micheal: 24hr total Pop>150mm

                                                                            Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 42
. eTRaP was updated to include NOAA20 RR data on 08/21/2019. It is good to see both SNPP and
NOAA20 TRaPs which are around 50 minutes apart.

. eTRaP will be migrated to the cloud in 2021.

         N20 0-6 HR Rainfall 23 AUG 19 17:48      SNPP 06 HR Rainfall 23 AUG 19 16:59

                                                                   Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 43
TCFP (Tropical Cyclone Formation Probability)
    6 hour objective probability estimates of the tropical cyclone formation within the next 48
    hours.
    Satellite: GOES-15/16, HIMAWARI, METEOSAT
    Formats: ASCII, PNG
    Distribution: web
    Product webpage: https://www.ssd.noaa.gov/PS/TROP/etrap.html

Project plan to upgrade TCFP to use GOES-16/17, HIMAWARI original high resolution data was
approved. NESDIS started working on the project plan and the new TCFP will be running in NDE
around September 2020.

                                                                      Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 44
Microwave Sounder-based Tropical Cyclone Products
    Provide estimates of tropical cyclone maximum wind speed,
    minimum sea level pressure, radii of 34, 50, and 64 knot winds in 4
    quadrants relative to the storm center, and balanced horizontal
    winds from 1000 to 200 mb within 600 km of the storm center. The
    balanced wind is used by MTCSWA.
    Satellite: SNPP, NOAA-18/19, Metop-A/B
    Formats: NetCDF, ATCF
    Distribution: PDA
                                                                                            SNPP/ATMS
    Product webpage: https://www.ssd.noaa.gov/PS/TROP/amsutc.html

         Metop-A/AMSU              Metop-B/AMSU               NOAA-18/AMSU                                   NOAA-19/AMSU

Microwave Sounder-based Tropical Cyclone Products will be upgraded to include NOAA20 data around
June 2020. And it will be upgraded to include Metop-C data as well (TBD date)

                                                                          Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 45
MTCSWA (Multi-Platform Surface Wind Analysis)
            The multiplatform tropical cyclone surface wind analysis (MTCSWA) product produces six-
            hourly estimates of the surface (10-m, 1-minute averaged) wind fields centered on active
            global tropical cyclones. It combines information from several data sources to create a mid-
            level wind analysis which is then adjusted to the surface.
            Satellite: NOAA-18/19, Metop-A/B, GOES-15, METEOSAT
            Formats: ASCII, PNG, ATCF

            Distribution: ATCF/PDA, ASCII and PNG/web
            Product webpage:
            https://www.ssd.noaa.gov/PS/TROP/mtcswa.html
                                                                                                           Final surface wind field for storm WUTIP
Combined AMSU balanced wind in slide 5

             AMSU wind analysis for storm WUTIP    CDFT for storm WUTIP
                                                                                    IRWD for storm WUTIP                  SCAT orbit over storm WUTIP

       MTCSWA will be upgraded to include GOES-16/17, HIMAWARI, SNPP/NOAA20 in July 2020.
       Upgrade to include Metop-C (TBD)

                                                                                                     Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 46
STAR Sentinel-1 Tropical Storm Winds

               NOAA/NESDIS/STAR has developed and implemented a fully
               automated system to produce near real-time TC ocean surface wind
               speed products:              • Collect global hourly tropical storm reports (from
                                              SAB)
                                            • Checks for corresponding S1 imagery
                                            • Process through SAROPS system, producing
                                              cross-pol products (wind speed images, wind
                                              speed contours, NRCS, KMZ, 500m-sampled
                                              netCDF)
                                            • Determines if the storm “eye” is in the scene.
                                               • Produces a refined storm center location
                                               • Produce additional TC specific products (radial
                                                 wind plots per quadrant, ATCF/radial text files,
                                                 3km-sampled wind netCDFs)
Sentinel 1A SAR Cross-Pol Winds for Typhoon
                   Halong                   • Send to web and push ATCF FIX file and 3km-
            5 Nov 2019 19:58:02Z              sampled netCDF to NRL, to be sent to NHC and
                                              JTWC
                                                              Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 47
STAR Sentinel-1 Tropical Storm Winds

  Detailed Output for Typhoon Halong (2019)
     Sentinel 1A - 5 Nov 2019 19:58:02Z

Radial wind values over all 4 quadrants                   Contours of 34kt, 50kt, and 64kt wind

                                                           Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 48
STAR Sentinel-1 Tropical Storm Winds

 •Created a web portal to display the products grouped
 by tropical storm identifier, date, and season.
     –Reprocessed all available storms from April 2018-present
     –Archive contains 70 unique storms, 321 total scenes (~90
     with additional analysis)
 •Products include:
     –surface wind speed images (500-m /3-km) (netCDF/KMZ)
     –Normalized radar cross section images (NRCS)
     –Radial wind plots per quadrant
     –ATCF/radial text files
 •Collaborated with TC experts to tailor products suited
 for operational use, incl. Dr. John Knaff (RAMMB/CIRA)
 and Buck Sampson (NRL)
https://www.star.nesdis.noaa.gov/sod/mecb/sar/AKDEMO
_products/APL_winds/tropical

                                                                 Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 49
SAR Derived Tropical Cyclone Surface Winds

       2018

              Future Tasks:
              • Aim to become the primary hub for near real-time
                satellite borne SAR tropical winds data
              • Process storms prior to April 2018 2018/201
              • Continue to validate results of algorithm for a variety of
                                                            9
2018            storm cases (high intensity vs low intensity,
                                                         (partial)
                strengthening vs weakening, basin, etc.)
              • Send output products to more customers (JTWC, NHC,
                Navy)

                                 Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 50
STAR Sentinel-1 Tropical Storm Winds

                    Mean winds by quadrant:                                        Output from NRL’s system using STAR SAR results:

  ATCF FIX file:
WP, 24, 201911051958, 70, SEN1,        CIR, , 2044N, 15056E,   10 ,    , 128, 1,     , , SEN1, 34, NEQ,      60,    0,                56,   67, , , , ,                  ,      ,
, W, STAR, SAR, SAR, 201911051957, 201911051958,   ,     ,                SENTINEL-1A, STAR Synthetic Aperture Radar 3KM              Wind Speed Analysis
WP, 24, 201911051958, 70, SEN1,        CIR, , 2044N, 15056E,   10 ,    , 128, 1,     , , SEN1, 50, NEQ,      39,   35,                33,   41, , , , ,                  ,      ,
, W, STAR, SAR, SAR, 201911051957, 201911051958,   ,     ,                SENTINEL-1A, STAR Synthetic Aperture Radar 3KM              Wind Speed Analysis
WP, 24, 201911051958, 70, SEN1,        CIR, , 2044N, 15056E,   10 ,    , 128, 1,     , , SEN1, 64, NEQ,      27,   24,                22,   25, , , , ,                  ,      ,
, W, STAR, SAR, SAR, 201911051957, 201911051958,   ,     ,                SENTINEL-1A, STAR Synthetic Aperture Radar 3KM              Wind Speed Analysis

                                                                                              Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 51
NESDIS – Satellite Analysis Branch

        Tropical Cyclone Operations and
        Research Forum
        74th Interdepartmental Hurricane
        Conference

            Current Applications and Future Plans

                           Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 52
2019 Performance Review

                    Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration53
                                                                                              // 53
SAB Analysts: More Inexperienced than 2019

Initials       Years of Experience
               (as of 1 JUNE 2020)

MT             26

JK             17

ER             8

JV             5
                                      8 analysts are meteorologists
VK             4

JF             3                      4 analysts are physical scientists
PL             3
                                      (non-meteorologists)
BZ             2
                                      *Expect 2 additional physical
KH             2                      scientists to be operational by 1
JL             1                      June.
MC             0

AS             0

Average        5.9 (5.1*)

Median         3.0 (2.5*)

                                           Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration54
                                                                                                                     // 54
Quality Has Slowly Declined

                       Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration55
                                                                                                 // 55
Satellite Analysis Branch

              Current Overall Functions and Future Plans
                                                                                               • Ongoing discussions to
                                                                                                 rehost topical analysis
                                                                                                 in an NCEP Center that
                              Current Operational 24 x 7 x 365                                   has more commitment
                                                                                                 to it, better mission
Legacy                            • Snow role
                                                                                                 alignment and more
functions                           eliminated
                                                                                                 appropriate skillsets
                                                                                                 (meteorologists) .
                                  • Most rain
                                    functions
                                                                                               • Challenge Areas of the
                                    transitioned
                                                                                                 W. Pac., S., Pac and
            Heavy Rain and          to WPC                      Tropical Position
                                                                                                 Indian Ocean products.
            Snow Detection                                        and Intensity
                                                                  Classification

Existing product
areas that are
undergoing                                                          Oi
growth/enhancement                                                  l

                                                   © ESA 2010

                 Fire and Smoke                    Oil Spill and Marine                   Volcanic Ash Detection
                    Detection                           Pollution                              and Forecast

                                                                         Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 56
NEW FUNCTIONS: SAB is being redesigned to
   serve as a center for NOAA’s specialized
  satellite imagery and analysis needs.

These include:
1. Satellite analysis support for major
disasters and events of concern to
NOAA HQ, LOs, NCEP and field offices.

2. Support of NWS and other
operational components of NOAA by
serving as a liaison to acquire on their
behalf or help them acquire specialized    High resolution imagery, especially when
                                           including shortwave IR, can “see” through
imagery for major event response.          smoke and represent some of the many new
                                           satellite capabilities becoming available.
3. Disaster Charter Support

                                               Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 57
NOAA is a signatory to and often benefits from the “Disaster
Charter,” (more formally the International Charter for Space and
Major Disasters), but is not fully prepared to execute its role
supporting Charter activities. When staffing permits, SAB will be
able to address this shortfall.

        US Charter Activations
        (in the past 3 yrs)
        include:
        • California Fires
        • Hurricane Michael
        • Hurricane Florence
        • Kilauea Eruption
        • Hurricane Irma
        • Hurricane Harvey           GOES image of the largest eruption to ever
                                     affect US airspace, the 1980 eruption of St.
                                     Helens.

                                                Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 58
59
     Current planning…

     •SAB is undergoing an 18 month complete system
     rearchitecture to support this new role, especially
     acquisition of high resolution and other specialized
     satellite imagery.
     •SAB manpower is focused on new skillsets supporting
     these new roles, often meaning that personnel with more
     remote sensing experience but less meteorology
     experience are on duty.
     SAB is reducing its emphasis on its legacy weather watch
     missions:
       its an NWS mandated responsibility
       SAB’s new staffing, skillsets, systems capabilities, etc., do not
       align with these missions
        need to free up staff to perform new functions.
                                               Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 59
Current Status / History (1 of 2)
•   History - Barazotto (2005) and Benner (2011) pushed forward for retirement of tropical program

•   Summer-Fall 2016 – email sent to several users directly (Eastern / Southern Hemisphere) on initial plans

•   October 2016 – announcement and surveys out to users for comments, following SPSRB retirement process

•   2016-2018: Surveys and Feedback on retirement of some or all of SAB Tropical Dvorak products

•   February 2017 – With NWS coordination, followed NWS AOP process to initiate proposal in NWS FY18 plans to retire products, with a
    goal to be complete by end of Nov 2017

•   March 2018 – inquires received from the NWS on status of the tropical program – no decisions at that time

•   Early June 2018 – Dr. Uccellini and Dr. Volz discussed SAB tropical Dvorak products, and feedback was provided to NESDIS
    management in mid June

•   May 2018 – Briefing given to the NWS MDC (Mission Delivery Council) on SAB’s plans to terminate Dvorak and Precipitation products.
     • Action from minutes: “MDC will pass the tropical requirement need to the PIC for evaluation if there’s an alternative organization
         that can provide a second look to meet NHC need.”
           • Did the PIC provide an alternate organization?

•   Late June 2018 - Memo received from Dr. Uccellini sent to Dr. Volz – NWS opposing NESDIS Dvorak Divestiture

•   July 2018 - Draft Memo from OSPO for Dr. Volz to Dr. Uccellini – replying to NWS memo, but not disseminated to the NWS

•   July 2018 – NWS asked for list of SAB interpretive products.

•   July/ August 2018 - Survey of NWS WFOs in regards to usefulness of SAB interpretive products. Note that the survey had a them
    Asked with the theme around aviation.
      • “If I could bother you for just a bit of time, could you please take a look at the following Satellite Analysis Branch products and give
          me an idea of how your offices use these products from an Aviation perspective/in support of which aviation products?”

•   Nov 2018 – action in NESDIS to “Identify criteria to determine types, and by extension – levels, of interpretive products NESDIS should
    produce operationally”

                                                                                         Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration60
                                                                                                                                                                   // 60
Current Status / History (2 of 2)
•   Dec 18 2018 – Draft memo from Dr. Volz to Dr. Uccellini to continue the Dvorak products noting NWS concerns. Indicates
    a review of interpretive products as well to be done in 2019. (unsure if this memo was every sent…)
      • This memorandum documents the National Environmental Satellite and Information Services’ (NESDIS) response to
         the National Weather Service (NWS) concerning the potential operational impacts of eliminating the Dvorak analyses
         as well as other interpretative products. I acknowledge your concern and have decided to continue providing the
         Dvorak analyses for the near term. In response to this request, and your priorities for the Satellite Analysis Branch, I
         have initiated a review of all interpretative products to identify the organization best suited to produce them. I expect
         this to be completed by xxxx, 2019, at which time I would like to engage you, and the other Assistant Administrators
         to set priorities for NESDIS’ products.

•   Memo from Uccellini to Volz October 2018
     • Does not support SAB removing Dvorak analyses
         • Received again November 2019

•   March 26, 2019 – memo from Dr. Volz to Dr. Uccellini stating SAB would stop doing non NHC/CPHC areas within 120
    days.
      • SPSD received memo in May 2019
      • Telecon w/ Ray Tanabe on June 3, 2019 to discuss Dvorak and impact to Pacific Region
      • NWS provided feedback within NWS management chain

•   June 25 2019 – memo from Dr. Volz to Dr. Uccellini rescinding prior memo and stating 2019 SAB will continue to provide
    Dvorak analysis
      • The memo discussed a review of all interpretative products to “identify the organization best suited to product them”
        and then to “engage you and other AA to discuss NESDIS’ provision of interpretive products and for NESDIS to set
        priorities for those products”
          • Expected completion Q4 2019

•   After this memo, action expanded to include all NESDIS products (IPL) beyond interpretive
      • Unknown at this time status of review and next steps and timing.

•   Tom Renkevens (NESDIS) and Eli Jacks (NWS) met on Dec 19 to discuss status and options.

•   Davida Street (NESDIS SAB) continues informal dialog with Dave Novak and Greg Carbin (NWS WPC)
                                                                              Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration61
                                                                                                                                                        // 61
Regional Specialized Meteorological Centers

                                              Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 62
Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 63
64

     Questions and Comments

                     Department of Commerce // National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration // 64
You can also read