Are miscarriages more common during COVID-19? - British ...

 
CONTINUE READING
Are miscarriages more common during COVID-19? - British ...
April 2022: 64:3
                                                                                  Pages 97–144

                                            Are miscarriages more
                                         common during COVID-19?
                                     An analysis of in vitro fertilization pregnancies in BC
In this issue:
In situ simulation training for
in-office anaphylaxis preparedness
Innovations in early interventions
for people with eating disorders
Global decline of male
fertility: Fact or fiction?

                                                                                      bcmj.org
Are miscarriages more common during COVID-19? - British ...
RBC Dominion Securities Inc.

Wealth guidance for
physicians’ unique
financial needs
Build financial health
at every stage of your career

            Should I incorporate                                    With over 30 years of combined experience working exclusively
            my medical practice?                                    with physicians and their families, our team would be proud
                                                                    to be your partner as you navigate your career milestones,
                           Will I be able
                                                                    complex challenges, and plan for the future you envision.
                        to retire in the way
                             I imagine?                             By tapping into our industry-leading RBC network, we can
                                                                    help you address all manner of financial, tax, retirement and
            Should I have                                           legacy planning concerns. Whether your next chapter involves
         a separate Will for                                        incorporation, growing your practice or planning for retirement,
          my corporation?
                                                                    meet it with confidence and peace of mind.

                                                                    For more information, or to arrange a complimentary
                    How should I save
                 between my Corporation,                            consultation, contact us today.
                    RRSP and/or TFSA?

                                                                    Ronneng Galperin Wealth Management
        Am I saving
         enough?
                                                                    of RBC Dominion Securities
                                                                    Vadim Galperin, CFP, CIM                                Mikayla Michaud
                                                                    Portfolio Manager                                       Administrative Assistant
                                                                    vadim.galperin@rbc.com                                  604-257-7680
                                                                    604-665-9813 | vadimgalperin.com                        mikayla.michaud@rbc.com

                                                                    Tom Ronneng, CFA, CFP                                   Toll-Free: 1-800-427-7766
                                                                    Portfolio Manager
                                                                    tom.ronneng@rbc.com
                                                                    604-665-3236 | tomronneng.com

 RBC Dominion Securities Inc.* and Royal Bank of Canada are separate corporate entities which are affiliated. *Member-Canadian Investor Protection Fund. RBC Dominion Securities Inc.
 is a member company of RBC Wealth Management, a business segment of Royal Bank of Canada. ® / ™ Trademark(s) of Royal Bank of Canada. Used under licence. ©2022 RBC Dominion
 Securities Inc. All rights reserved. 22_90803_THO_003
Are miscarriages more common during COVID-19? - British ...
April 2022
    Volume 64 | No. 3
    Pages 97– 144

Drs Bron Finkelstein (left) and Jodie Graham (right), from Chetwynd, population 3000, often use the Real-Time Virtual Support pathways for providers. Story begins on page 110.

102 Editorials                                                           n   The current gender-affirming care                            109 News
      n   Musings about the state of the world                               model in BC is unvalidated and                                      n   Book review: Patients at risk:
          David R. Richardson, MD                                            outdated, Joanne Sinai, MD                                              Exposing Canada’s health-care crisis
      n   Quest for Superdoc, Version 2.0                                n   Re: The value of ancillary testing                                      David Esler, MD
          Jeevyn K. Chahal, MD                                               in amniotic fluid infection/                                        n   Real-Time Virtual Support:
                                                                             inflammation-related early pregnancy                                    Much-needed rural and remote
104 President’s Comment                                                      loss…, Andrew Kotaska, MD                                               assistance during the pandemic
          Prioritizing physician health and                              n   Author replies, Jefferson Terry, MD                                 n   Prescribing nature to improve health
          safety, Ramneek Dosanjh, MD                                    n   Improving planetary health in BC:                                   n   Physician health and wellness: Doctors
                                                                             Taking small but important steps                                        of BC 2021 Report to Members
105 Letters                                                                  Eric M. Yoshida, MD, Alison                                         n   Free online mental health and
      n   Where have all the family doctors                                  Harris, MBBCh, Ka Wai Cheung,                                           substance use supports for your
          gone? Suzanne Montemuro, MD                                        MD, Michael Nimmo, MD, John                                             patients
                                                                             Ridley, MD, Hui-Min Yang, MD
                                                                         n   Editor replies                                                                             Contents continued on page 100

Environmental impact                                               Postage paid at Vancouver, BC. Canadian Publications Mail, Product Sales Agreement #40841036. Return undeliverable copies
The BCMJ seeks to minimize its negative impact on the              to BC Medical Journal, 115–1665 West Broadway, Vancouver, BC V6J 5A4; tel: 604 638-2815; email: journal@doctorsofbc.ca.
environment by:
• Supporting members who wish to read online with an               Advertisements and enclosures carry no endorsement of Doctors of BC or BCMJ.
  e-subscription to bcmj.org                                       © 2022 by article authors or their institution, in accordance with the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0) license.
• Avoiding bag use, and using certified-compostable plant-based
                                                                   See creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/. Any use of materials from the BCMJ must include full bibliographic citations, including
  bags when needed
                                                                   journal name, author(s), article title, year, volume, page numbers. If you have questions, please email journal@doctorsofbc.ca.
• Working with Mitchell Press, ranked third in North America for
  sustainability by canopy.org                                        Statements and opinions expressed in the BCMJ reflect the opinions of the authors and not necessarily those of Doctors of BC or the
• Printing with vegetable-based inks                               institutions they may be associated with. Doctors of BC does not assume responsibility or liability for damages arising from errors or omis-
• Using FSC-certified paper                                        sions, or from the use of information or advice contained in the BCMJ.
• Printing locally in British Columbia                                The BCMJ reserves the right to refuse advertising.

                                                                                                                                                BC Medical Journal vol. 64 no. 3 | april 2022               99
Are miscarriages more common during COVID-19? - British ...
ARE MISCARRIAGES MORE COMMON
                                                               DURING THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC?
                                                                                                                                           We analyzed two cohorts of IVF pregnancies to
                                                               An analysis of IVF pregnancies                                         assess whether miscarriages were more common
                                                               in British Columbia.                                                   during the pandemic.

                                                                                                                 Clinical pregnancy rates were similar during the pandemic compared to
                                                                                                             prepandemic, as were the biochemical miscarriage rates per positive bHCG.

                                                                                                               We sought to determine whether intangible factors* occurring during the
                                                                                                        pandemic were associated with changes in IVF pregnancy and miscarriage rates.
On the cover
Clinical pregnancy rates and
miscarriage rates in IVF patients
do not appear to be affected
by the COVID-19 pandemic.                                                                                                                      *changes in            *asymptomatic
                                                                                                                         *stress
                                                                                                                                          disinfection protocols     COVID infections

                                                                                                 Women planning to conceive do not need to delay their plans as a result of the pandemic.

                                                                                                 Pregnancy and miscarriage rates do not appear to be changed in IVF treatment outcomes.

                                                          ReadRahana
                                                               the full article
                                                                     Harjee,     by Harjee,
                                                                             MD, Jason Au, MSc,Au,
                                                                                                MayTian,  andCaitlin
                                                                                                    Tian, MSc, Dunne,   beginning
                                                                                                                     Dunne, MD, FRCSCon page 116.
The BCMJ is published by Doctors of BC. The                   BCMJ 2022;64:116-119.
journal provides peer-reviewed clinical and review
articles written primarily by BC physicians, for
BC physicians, along with debate on medicine
and medical politics in editorials, letters, and
                                                          Contents continued from page 99
essays; BC medical news; career and CME listings;
physician profiles; and regular columns.
                                                          113 Premise                                                         126 BCMD2B
Print: The BCMJ is distributed monthly,
other than in January and August.
                                                                    Innovations in early interventions for                               Global decline of male fertility: Fact
Web: Each issue is available at www.bcmj.org.
                                                                    people with eating disorders, Karen                                  or fiction? Nora Tong, BDSc, Luke
Subscribe to print: Email journal@doctorsofbc.ca.
                                                                    Trollope-Kumar, MD                                                   Witherspoon, MD, Caitlin Dunne,
Single issue: $8.00                                                                                                                      MD, Ryan Flannigan, MD
Canada per year: $60.00                                   CLINICAL
Foreign (surface mail): $75.00
Subscribe to notifications:
                                                                                                                              131 College Library
To receive the table of contents by email, visit          116 Are miscarriages more                                                      Three best point-of-care tools
www.bcmj.org and click on “Free e-subscription.”                    common during the COVID-19                                           available, Karen MacDonnell
Prospective authors: Consult the
“Guidelines for authors” at www.bcmj.org
                                                                    pandemic? An analysis of in
for submission requirements.                                        vitro fertilization pregnancies                           132 Obituaries
                                                                    in British Columbia, Rahana                                      n   Dr John O’Brien Bell
                                                                                                                                     n   Dr Peter Michael Rees
                                                                    Harjee, MD, Jason Au, MSc, May
                                                                                                                                     n   Dr Barrie Humphrey
                                                                    Tian, MSc, Caitlin Dunne, MD
Editor                           Proofreader
                                                                                                                              134 CME Calendar
David R. Richardson, MD          Amy Haagsma
                                                          120 In situ simulation training
Editorial Board                  Web and social media
                                                                    for in-office anaphylaxis
Jeevyn K. Chahal, MD             coordinator                                                                                  135 Classifieds
David B. Chapman, MBChB          Amy Haagsma                        preparedness, Sean Duke, MD,
Brian Day, MB
Caitlin Dunne, MD
                                 Cover concept and                  Victoria E. Cook, MD                                      138 Guidelines for Authors
                                 art direction
David J. Esler, MD
                                 Jerry Wong,
Yvonne Sin, MD
Cynthia Verchere, MD
                                 Peaceful Warrior Arts    125 WorkSafeBC
                                 Design and production              Post-acute-COVID-19 Visiting
Managing editor
Jay Draper
                                 Laura Redmond,                     Specialist Clinic, Michelle Tan, MD
                                 Scout Creative
Associate editor
                                 Printing
Joanne Jablkowski
                                 Mitchell Press
Editorial and
                                 Advertising
production coordinator
                                 Tara Lyon
Tara Lyon
                                 604 638-2815
Copy editor, scientific          journal@doctorsofbc.ca
content
Tracey D. Hooper                 ISSN: 0007-0556
                                 Established 1959

100 BC Medical Journal vol. 64 no. 3 | april 2022
Are miscarriages more common during COVID-19? - British ...
COM M I T T E D TO
                                                                                                                                               PHYS I C I A N S

Fit in a mortgage when it’s
convenient for you.
The Scotiabank Healthcare+ Physician Banking Program has flexible mortgage solutions
designed for your busy schedule. Our mobile Home Financing Advisors are available to meet
whenever it’s convenient for you – by phone, email, online, or in-person. With eHOME, you
can apply and be approved for a mortgage all online. And with the Scotia Total Equity Plan®,
you have the flexibility to unlock your home equity to access funds when you need them most.
Let us help you get a mortgage on your terms.

Visit scotiabankhealthcareplus.com

All banking and credit products and services available through the Scotiabank Healthcare+ Physician Banking Program are offered by
The Bank of Nova Scotia (Scotiabank). Credit and lending products are subject to credit approval by Scotiabank.

® Registered Trademark of The Bank of Nova Scotia.

                                                                                                                                     BC Medical Journal vol. 64 no. 3 | april 2022 101
Are miscarriages more common during COVID-19? - British ...
Editorials

Musings about the state of
the world

A
           s this editorial is being crafted, Russia   part of Italy was liberated from the Germans can also be kind, caring, and generous. Focusing
           has invaded Ukraine and we are into         in World War II. It was as if this event had on people’s potential for goodness can help us
           year 2 of a global pandemic. People         happened recently and was fresh in the minds deal with the uncertainty and negativity found
are discouraged and tired. Public patience is          of the local townspeople. I wonder how they in the world today.
being tried, as demonstrated by recent free-           felt about the world during the worst of that         By the time this editorial is in print, the
dom convoys and the occupation of Ottawa (as           global conflict.                                   pandemic may have subsided and the war in
an aside, it wouldn’t be possible to have such             There are certainly other times in history Ukraine will likely have been decided. As trou-
demonstrations in a country that wasn’t free).         when the future seemed                                                  bling as these events have
    Public health guidance would seem to be            dark and uncertain. Com-                                                been, a great deal of good-
apolitical, but lines have been drawn between          ing out of the Great War             Disease, violence, and             ness has also been demon-
right-leaning conservatives/republicans and            (World War I) and being             war have been a part of             strated. There has been an
left-of-centre liberals/democrats. It amazes me        struck by the deadly Span-            the human condition               outpouring of well-wishes
how polarizing mask and vaccine mandates               ish flu pandemic would                                                  and support for the people
have become. Vitriol often spread by social me-        have caused many to de-
                                                                                               since time began.               of Ukraine from millions
dia is divisive and inflammatory. A crisis that        spair. Living through the                                               of regular citizens around
many would think should unite us has become            bubonic plague during the 14th century, when the world. So many health care workers, neigh-
a lightning rod for vehement disagreements             100 million souls perished, would have been bors, family, and friends have lifted those around
even among family members.                             dark days indeed. I was born in 1963, shortly them during this tiresome pandemic. For a local
    The current state of the world is discourag-       before President John F. Kennedy was assassi- example of decency, look no further than to the
ing and brings up questions about the humanity         nated. My parents likely questioned their deci- people of British Columbia, who mobilized to
of humankind and its future.                           sion to bring a new life into this troubled world. support the farmers affected by flooding and the
    One month after 9/11, partly in defiance of            Disease, violence, and war have been a residents devastated by fires in the recent past.
terrorism, I went to Europe on a long-planned          part of the human condition since time be-            Good and evil exist in each of us, but in
vacation. I distinctly remember strolling into         gan. Charles Dickens started his novel A Tale the end, I have faith that our basic humanity
a small Tuscan village and noticing a war me-          of Two Cities with the line: “It was the best of will triumph. n
morial in the central square with fresh flowers        times, it was the worst of times.” While true —David R. Richardson, MD
on it. It was erected in honor of the day that         that humans are capable of the despicable, they

    Available for streaming on
    all podcast platforms
                                                         BURNOUT AND COVID-19
                                                                                                     Warning signs
                                                                                                   and when to act

                                                                  with guests
                                                                  Dr Jennifer Russel
                                                                  and Dr Lawrence Yang                            A Doctors of BC Podcast

102 BC Medical Journal vol. 64 no. 3 | april 2022
Are miscarriages more common during COVID-19? - British ...
Editorials

Quest for Superdoc, Version 2.0

I
      n 2016 I wrote an editorial titled “Quest               living and community well-being in            colleagues, and my cat (in that order), and the
      for Superdoc.”1 During the past 5 years,                addition to primary care.                     advice was the same: the benefits outweighed
      I have been on the brink of burning out,             3. Community-governed: CHCs are                  the risks. They had seen through my “it’s all
so I decided to revisit my quest and see where                governed by community members                 good” mask. They knew I was burning out.
it went sideways.                                             and focused on community priorities.              I joined STEPS on 1 September 2021, and
    Even before COVID-19 reared its virulent               4. Working upstream: CHCs actively               it has been a seamless transition. My EMR
spikes, I was feeling overwhelmed. Working                    address the “social determinants of           was integrated with STEPS, allowing all of
as a solo family physician, I was on my EMR                   health,” like access to food, housing,        the clinicians to access and make notes in the
for 12 hours a day, managing my office, and                   education, and the supports needed            same EMR; therefore, the continuity of care
juggling spending time with my family, three                  to thrive.                                    is amazing. We have monthly team meetings
dogs, cat, chickens, and friends (in that order).          5. Justice-based: CHCs demonstrate a             that include the medical office assistants and
I told myself and everyone around me that “it’s               commitment to fairness, and to the            all the allied health care clinicians. Commu-
all good.” After all, wasn’t I just a family physi-           values of health equity and social            nication is key.
cian? I wasn’t an ER doc or an internist in the               justice.2                                         My patients are thrilled. They have time-
ICU. And aren’t all docs supposed to be super              The Canadian Association of Community            ly and increased access to a variety of health
resilient? I just had to patch and dry-clean my       Health Centres is working on initiatives such         care services. The team-based care is amazing.
cape, and all would be well.                          as investing in CHCs, establishing universal          Everyone on the team is genuinely interested
    My family practice was so busy that on many       Pharmacare, investing in oral health and dental       in working together to provide the best out-
days I would have to send patients to the ur-         health care, and investing in affordable housing      comes for our patients. As part of this team,
gent care clinic or the ER because I couldn’t         and ending homelessness.3                             I feel supported, respected, and valued. “Just
see them in a timely manner. I felt like I was             CHCs are funded by MSP, the Ministry of          a family doctor” is becoming a phrase of the
failing them. My staff was working with their         Health, municipalities, community fundraising,        past. With CHCs, the province is moving to-
hair straight back. I felt like I was failing them.   primary care networks, and health authori-            ward allowing physicians to choose between
I wasn’t visiting my parents as much, and when        ties. In exchange for a percentage of my MSP          salaried and fee-for-service payment models.
I did visit, I was always rushing to get back         earnings, my patients and I would be part of a        The fee-for-service model that exists today for
home because I had “lots of work to finish.” I        unique team-based care concept.                       family physicians needs to be modernized. Our
felt like I was failing them. Many of my col-              The Supporting Team Excellence with Pa-          governing bodies are well aware of this fact and
leagues were feeling the same way. We would           tients Society (STEPS)4 is a Kamloops-based           are starting to engage in conversations that will
chat on the phone, vent, and then carry on as         not-for-profit CHC. The STEPS team consists           help make these changes.
before. There were no obvious solutions.              of a volunteer board of directors, a compassion-          Joining the STEPS CHC has renewed my
    Then one day I was introduced to the idea         ate executive director, a diligent clinic manager,    love for family medicine and is allowing me to
of the community health centre (CHC) model:           caring medical office assistants, nurses, a social    spend quality time with my patients, family,
    Community Health Centres are cre-                 worker, a counselor, a pharmacist, an occupa-         friends, and cat.
    ated by not-for-profit organizations and          tional therapist, a nurse practitioner, a diabetes        My quest for Superdoc is finally becoming
    co-operatives that are committed to pro-          nurse educator, a women’s sexual health services      a reality; it just needed a Superteam. n
    viding comprehensive, accessible, afford-         clinic, a transgender clinic, a respiratory thera-    —Jeevyn K. Chahal, MD
    able, and culturally-appropriate services         pist, a dietitian, a billing clerk, and family phy-
    through a collaborative team approach.            sicians. There is increased access to locums and      References
    CHCs adhere to five key principles:               “doctor of the day” physicians who are able to        1.   Chahal JK. Quest for Superdoc. BCMJ 2016;58:495.
    1. Interprofessional care: CHCs pro-              accommodate the urgent needs of our patients          2.   British Columbia Association of Community Health
                                                                                                                 Centres. About CHCs. Accessed 1 March 2022. https://
        vide collaborative services through           when our schedules are full.                               bcachc.org/about-chcs.
        an integrated multidisciplinary                    I was apprehensive at first. Would I lose        3.   Canadian Association of Community Health Centres.
        team-based primary health care                my autonomy? Would I lose the trusting rela-               Policy and advocacy. Accessed 1 March 2022. www
        team.                                         tionships with my patients? Would I earn less?             .cachc.ca/policy-advocacy.
                                                                                                            4.   Supporting Team Excellence with Patients Society.
    2. Wrap-around approach: CHCs of-                 Was I giving up? I consulted with my fam-                  About STEPS. Accessed 1 March 2022. www.steps
        fer programs and services for healthy         ily, my friends, my accountant, my lawyer, my              health.ca.

                                                                                                                 BC Medical Journal vol. 64 no. 3 | april 2022 103
Are miscarriages more common during COVID-19? - British ...
president’s comment

                                 Prioritizing physician
                                 health and safety

S
        ignificantly more influences our health       peer support initiative that will train doctors to   .ca/your-benefits/physician-health-safety/
        than whether or not we are free of dis-       deliver one-on-one emotional peer support to         memorandum-agreement.
        ease. Our holistic health—physical,           their colleagues, and a physician wellness net-
mental, spiritual, and emotional—as individual        work to bring together those of us who have          Addressing physician burdens
physicians and the collective health of us as a       leadership responsibilities for the health and       To further support physician health and well-
profession is influenced by many internal and         wellness of physicians.                              ness, we must address the challenges in the
external factors. Now more than ever we must                                                               health care system that are adding to physician
make our health and well-being a priority; with-      Addressing physical and                              burdens and contributing to stress and burnout.
out it, our profession has no chance of healing       psychological safety                                 Doctors of BC recognizes that there are more
and promoting health in others.                       An increase in concerns around violence,             demands on doctors than ever before in today’s
    We can assert control over some of the fac-       threats, and stressful work environments due         increasingly complex health care system. The
tors immediately, while others come with sig-         to the pandemic has highlighted the importance       volume and pace of change is overwhelming and
nificant barriers or challenges that lead to issues   of safe working environments for physicians          is negatively impacting physician health and
such as burnout, an overwhelming workload,            to be able to provide patient care. At the same      wellness. We are advocating to the Ministry of
and a lack of physical and psychological safety.      time, the support mechanisms to address these        Health, health authorities, WorkSafeBC, ICBC,
The pandemic has only exacerbated experiences         issues for both hospital and community-based         the College of Physicians and Surgeons, and
of burnout, stress, and even violence and bul-        physicians are far behind the supports available     other health system partners to recognize and
lying, leading to increased mental and physical       for nurses and other staff working in hospitals.     reduce burdens on physicians. For more infor-
health concerns for physicians.                       Doctors of BC is taking significant action to        mation, check out our Physician Burdens policy
    So, how do we heal ourselves while also           address this through a Memorandum of Agree-          statement in the Policy Database section of our
healing the system in which we operate? Doc-          ment on Physical/Psychological Safety in our         website (www.doctorsofbc.ca/policy-database).
tors of BC is taking a leadership role to pro-        Physician Master Agreement.                              Our health and safety matters. Our patients’
vide physicians with the programs, systems, and           This agreement has created opportuni-            health depends on the health and well-being of
supports to address concerns about physician          ties at the provincial level and in every health     our profession and our health care system. If we
health and safety.                                    authority for Doctors of BC to discuss phy-          want to foster a culture that promotes health, we
                                                      sician safety, influence policy and programs,        need to scrutinize the profession’s structures and
Physician Health Program’s expanded                   and undertake projects and efforts to improve        clinical environments and be aware of the po-
mandate                                               working conditions for physicians. Working           tential implications to our health. It will take a
Our Physician Health Program, which provides          with medical affairs departments and occupa-         multifaceted approach to confront the systemic
confidential advocacy, support, and referral as-      tional health and safety departments within          barriers that challenge our health; however, we
sistance for physicians, physicians in training,      health authorities, for the first time Doctors       owe it to ourselves to recognize the problem
and their families, is expanding its programs         of BC is able to engage on these matters and         areas and commit to finding solutions. n
and services to better address challenges before      influence policy and decision making. These          —Ramneek Dosanjh, MD
they become crises. Members will soon learn           efforts have already delivered programs related      Doctors of BC President
about new initiatives, including a program to         to COVID-19 support, improvements in vio-
help attach physicians to their own family doc-       lence prevention, respectful workplace incidents,
tors, a cognitive behavioral therapy skills train-    and blood and body fluid exposure support.
ing program to support doctors with mild to           This is just the beginning of this important
moderate mental health challenges, a physician        work. You can learn more at www.doctorsofbc

104 BC Medical Journal vol. 64 no. 3 | april 2022
Are miscarriages more common during COVID-19? - British ...
Letters to the editor                                        We welcome
  original letters of less than 300 words; we may edit them for clarity
  and length. Letters may be emailed to journal@doctorsofbc.ca, submitted
  online at bcmj.org/submit-letter, or sent through the post and must include
  your mailing address, telephone number, and email address. Please disclose any
  competing interests.

Where have all the family                                Consider a young man who injured his neck            Some are moving to other provinces. The
doctors gone?                                        and back in a motor vehicle accident. He waited      average remuneration for family doctors in On-
                                                     at walk-in clinics and looked on Medimap for         tario is $300 000; in Alberta it is $250 000 to
Try to find a family doctor in BC and you will
                                                     4 days. No access. He eventually went to emer-       $300 000. BC lags far behind.
be sadly disappointed. Patients are now asking
                                                     gency and waited there for hours.                        The first step our government needs to take
any specialist they see to help them with general
                                                         To emergency they go, for minor as well          is to settle the unequal payments physicians
medical issues, but specialists have neither the
                                                     as major health issues. As a result, emergency       receive, and they need to do it now.5-7 The in-
time nor the training to help. Nurse practitio-
                                                     rooms are overloaded. A Kamloops woman died          equities in the medical funding model need to
ners have a completely different skill set; they
                                                     in the waiting room of Royal Inland Hospital’s       be addressed.6 Only our provincial government
are not equipped to take over the role of a fam-
                                                     emergency department last September.3                can do this. The rest of Canada has tackled this
ily physician. Where are the family doctors we
                                                         In the past, the health care system worked       problem with some success. BC needs to get
were promised in the “A GP for Me” initiative?
                                                     because family physicians kept patients with         on board.
It hasn’t happened.
                                                     minor ailments out of hospital emergency             —Suzanne Montemuro, MD, CCFP
     The following are but a few examples of
                                                     rooms. Serious medical issues were attended          Clinical Instructor, Faculty of Medicine, UBC
the problem.
                                                     to expeditiously. What has happened?                 This letter endorsed by:
     Linda Swain from Malahat wrote to the
                                                         Look no further than physician remu-             Darlene Hammell, MD, CCFP
Times Colonist about access to urgent and pri-
                                                     neration. Why do ophthalmologists make               Past President, College of Physicians and
mary care centres:
                                                     $1 000 000 per year and family physicians make       Surgeons of BC
     “Each UPCC is geographically based. To
                                                     $163 000 per year? Most other specialists make       Assistant Dean, Island Medical Program
even apply to become a patient, two pieces of
                                                     over $500 000 per year. Consider that overhead       Clinical Professor, Faculty of Medicine, UBC
ID are required to prove residency within the
                                                     for a family physician’s office is 35% to 40% of     Lorelei Johnson, MD, CCFP
established boundaries of each UPCC. And
                                                     gross income. Their net income is in the range       Family Physician, Victoria
if the Westshore UPCC is anything to go by,
                                                     of less than $100 000.4
this taxpayer-funded system is a dismal failure.
                                                         Where can a family doctor make a better          References
I needed an X-ray requisition and dutifully ar-                                                           1.   Swain L. A dismal failure of the medical system. Times
                                                     living? As a hospitalist. In the past 10 years,
rived at 7:15 a.m. and lined up with 20 other                                                                  Colonist [letters]. 24 July 2021. Accessed 7 March 2022.
                                                     hospitals have been hiring family physicians to
people to wait for the 8 a.m. opening, only to                                                                 www.timescolonist.com/opinion/letters/letters-july
                                                     take care of complicated patients in the hospital.        -24-pros-and-cons-of-urgent-care-clinics-virus-puts
be told at 8 a.m. that the facility was ‘at capac-
                                                     They are paid $240 000 to $280 000 per year,              -health-dollars-at-risk-4690889.
ity’ because only one doctor had shown up for                                                             2.   Palmer V. NDP politicians yawn as doctors call it quits.
                                                     with no overhead costs. In Victoria, 72 family
work that day! How can a sick person get the                                                                   Vancouver Sun. 27 January 2022. Accessed 7 March
                                                     doctors have recently become hospitalists. In
care they need when no one seems to care?”1                                                                    2022. https://vancouversun.com/opinion/columnists/
                                                     the Fraser Health region that number is 110.              vaughn-palmer-ndp-politicians-yawn-as-doctors-call
     Since Swain wrote this letter, three more
                                                     The population in Victoria, especially in the             -it-quits.
clinics in Victoria have closed. My own family                                                            3.   Brend Y. Death of 70-year-old waiting for care in BC
                                                     western communities, continues to grow but
physician, Dr G. Zabakolas, an excellent doc-                                                                  emergency room to be reviewed, minister says. CBC
                                                     family doctors are getting out of the business
tor, has quit.2                                                                                                News. 9 September 2021. Accessed 7 March 2022. www
                                                     as fast as they can.                                      .cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/70-year-old
     Consider a 93-year-old friend of mine who
                                                         Other family physicians are leaving practice          -patient-in-kamloops-emergency-room-1.6169654.
signed up to become a patient of the James Bay
                                                     to become surgical assistants or to practise vir-    4.   BC Ministry of Health, Health Sector Information, Anal-
Urgent and Primary Care Centre 2 years ago.                                                                    ysis and Reporting Division. Physician resource report
                                                     tual medicine. Others are taking early retire-
She still has no family physician. She never                                                                   2011/2012–2020/2021. October 2021. Accessed 7 March
                                                     ment or simply quitting from stress.2                     2022. www2.gov.bc.ca/assets/gov/health/practitioner
received an intake call.
                                                                                                               -pro/medical-services-plan/msp_physician_resource
                                                                                                               _report_20112012_to_20202021.pdf.

                                                                                                               BC Medical Journal vol. 64 no. 3 | april 2022 105
Are miscarriages more common during COVID-19? - British ...
letters

5.   Corbella L. Canada’s health care system overrun by       WPATH have gone on record stating their                            3.   Society for Evidence-Based Gender Medicine. The
     administrators and lacks doctors. Calgary Herald. 24     concerns. Dr Marci Bowers, a trans wom-                                 signal—and the noise—in the field of gender medicine.
     January 2022. Accessed 7 March 2022. https://calgary                                                                             31 January 2022. Accessed 17 February 2022. https://
     herald.com/opinion/columnists/corbella-canadas
                                                              an surgeon, publicly disclosed her concerns                             segm.org/flawed_systematic_review_puberty
     -health-care-system-overrun-by-administrators-and        about puberty blockers, particularly the age                            _blockers.
     -lacks-doctors.                                          at which they are started.4 Psychologists Drs                      4.   Shrier A. Top trans doctors blow the whistle on “slop-
6.   CBC News. Fee-for-service model is deterring as-         Laura Edwards-Leeper and Erica Anderson                                 py” care. Common Sense. 4 October 2021. Accessed
     piring family doctors from setting up practice: Re-                                                                              17 February 2022. https://bariweiss.substack.com/p/
     port. 12 November 2021. Accessed 7 March 2022.
                                                              (a trans woman), have raised questions about                            top-trans-doctors-blow-the-whistle.
     w w w.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/               the significant rise of gender-dysphoric youth,                    5.   Edwards-Leeper L, Anderson E. The mental health es-
     fee-for-service-model-family-doctors-1.6247049.          particularly adolescent girls. They have advo-                          tablishment is failing trans kids: Gender-exploratory
7.   Change.org. Bring back our family doctors and our        cated for thorough psychological assessment                             therapy is a key step. Why aren’t therapists providing
     walk-in clinics [petition]. Accessed 7 March 2022. www                                                                           it? Washington Post. 24 November 2021. Accessed 17
                                                              and questioned the potential harm of not pro-
     .change.org/p/bring-back-our-family-doctors-and                                                                                  February 2022. www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/
     -our-walk-in-clinics.                                    viding exploratory therapy.5                                            2021/11/24/trans-kids-therapy-psychologist.
                                                                  While WPATH SOC8 may provide an
The current gender-affirming                                  opportunity for evidence-based guidelines, a                       Re: The value of ancillary testing
                                                              review of the draft raises concerns. For example,
care model in BC is unvalidated                               the section on “eunuchs,” presented as a unique
                                                                                                                                 in amniotic fluid infection/
and outdated                                                  gender identity, was bewildering. I question the                   inflammation-related early
As a psychiatrist, I have seen an explosion of                evidence for this category, and particularly the                   pregnancy loss and perinatal
gender-dysphoric youth and young adults in                    recommendation to “affirm” and refer for surgi-                    death in British Columbia
recent years. These vulnerable groups deserve                 cal castration lest they attempt self-castration.                  I thank Dr Terry for his informative article
compassionate, evidence-based care. I am con-                     For those hesitant to agree, I urge you to                     [BCMJ 2021;63:383-387]. Of the many causes
cerned that the recent BCMJ content on gender                 watch the Swedish Trans Train documentaries                        of preterm birth, finding an infectious agent
dysphoria presents gender-affirming care as                   (part 1: https://youtu.be/sJGAoNbHYzk). Ca-                        gives hope that treatment might prevent re-
evidence-based1 and as the only appropriate                   nadian physicians should not ignore the poten-                     currence. However, most bacteria identified
model of care. This premise forms the basis for               tial risks of the affirmation model when there                     during autopsies are commonly found in the
the three articles that follow on the medicalized             is international evidence of harm to vulnerable                    lower female genital tract. Their culture from
treatment of gender dysphoria.                                youth. Distressed youth deserve diligent, nu-                      fetal surfaces, lung, and stomach may repre-
    The World Professional Association for                    anced care favoring psychological assessment                       sent colonization during transit through the
Transgender Health (WPATH) Standards of                       and care over medical harm. Concerningly, Bill                     maternal vagina rather than pathogenicity. The
Care Version 7 (SOC7) are not evidence-based.                 C-4 (banning conversion therapy) was recently                      most common bacteria cultured was Group B
The WPATH website clearly states that SOC8                    passed by the Senate. Without a clear definition                   Streptococcus, a commensal found in the lower
is the first version being developed using an                 of what constitutes exploratory therapy versus                     genital tract of 20% of women. The second was
evidence-based approach. In addition, a sys-                  conversion therapy, therapists risk being charged                  E. coli, which is ubiquitous. Although occasion-
tematic review of its clinical practice guidelines            under this bill and may be dissuaded from treat-                   ally pathogenic, sometimes aggressively so, we
states that SOC7 “contains no list of key rec-                ing people with gender dysphoria at all.                           cannot eradicate either from a woman’s gut and
ommendations or auditable quality standards.”2                    We are in a unique position to rethink the                     vaginal flora for the duration of a future preg-
Furthermore, “many recommendations are flex-                  treatment model for gender dysphoria. I hope                       nancy. How helpful are these culture results?
ible, disconnected from evidence and could not                we can begin a dialogue, so that our youth can                     Do they explain the index preterm birth? Can
be used by individuals or services to benchmark               get the treatment they need and deserve. Gen-                      they help prevent a future one?
practice.”2                                                   der affirmation is not a one-size-fits-all model.                       Why do commensal organisms some-
    Finland, Sweden, Norway, and the UK are                   To allow ideology to prevail over sound medi-                      times become pathogenic? The relationship
re-evaluating care of gender-dysphoric youth                  cine is negligent at best.                                         between bacteria, fetal membranes, and the
due to concerns about medical harm and the                    —Joanne Sinai, MD, MEd, FRCPC                                      intra-amniotic cavity is dynamic and poorly
uncertainty of benefit.3                                      Victoria                                                           understood, as is the maternal immune response
    I find it disconcerting that the validity of                                                                                 to those organisms.1 Amniocentesis during pre-
SOC7 and the gender-affirming model are                       References                                                         term labor frequently detects inflammatory
wholeheartedly accepted and promoted by                       1.   Knudson G. Gender-affirming care in British Columbia,         cytokines without a positive culture, meaning
these articles. There is no balanced discourse                     Part 1. BCMJ 2022;64:18-19.
                                                                                                                                 invasion of the amniotic cavity is not required
                                                              2.   Dahlen S, Connolly D, Arif I, et al. International clinical
of reported negative outcomes or alternative                                                                                     to cause inflammation and preterm birth. Of
                                                                   practice guidelines for gender minority/trans people:
approaches.                                                        Systematic review and quality assessment. BMJ Open            all the commensal organisms suspected to play
    Further, some high-profile members of                          2021;11:e048943.                                              an etiological role in infectious/inflammatory

106 BC Medical Journal vol. 64 no. 3 | april 2022
letters

preterm birth and bacterial vaginosis, Urea-                    The practice at BC Children’s and BC Wom-            for molecular testing. The genomes of Myco-
plasma and Mycoplasma species are perhaps                       en’s Hospitals is to sample for bacteria from        plasma and Ureaplasma may also be visualized
the most amenable to treatment.2 Identifying                    areas that are unlikely to be artifactually con-     fluorescently in the cytoplasm of infected cells,
them during a preterm loss may help direct care:                taminated at or after delivery, such as the lung     although this approach is more suitable to a
screening and treatment for bacterial vaginosis                 and stomach contents. This study was not in-         research environment.
early in a future pregnancy and eradication of                  tended to assess the sensitivity and specificity     —Jefferson Terry, MD, PhD, FRCPC
Ureaplasma and/or Mycoplasma in a woman and                     of bacterial culture in the setting of AFII and      Vancouver
her partner before or early in a future pregnancy.              as such a non-AFII cohort was not included
    Treatment of atypical bacteria to decrease                  for comparison; anecdotally, however, bacterial      Improving planetary health in
preterm birth has not been adequately studied.3                 cultures from non-AFII cases at BC Chil-             BC: Taking small but important
Treatment of bacterial vaginosis with clindamy-                 dren’s and BC Women’s Hospitals are mostly
                                                                                                                     steps
cin appears to have better preventive effect than               negative, which demonstrates the low level of
metronidazole, perhaps because clindamycin                      detectable delivery and tissue sampling–related      It is becoming increasingly clear that our fu-
also covers Ureaplasma and Mycoplasma, whereas                  contamination.                                       ture health, as well as the health of future gen-
metronidazole does not.2,4 We have not typi-                        Dr Kotaska makes the excellent point that        erations, is linked to global planetary health,
cally performed fetal cultures for Ureaplasma                   the relationship between microbes, inflam-           including the preservation of the natural en-
and Mycoplasma, and they require Universal                      mation, and delivery continues to be poorly          vironment, appropriate use of resources, and
Transport Medium for identification. Can Dr                     understood. A robust relationship between            engagement of sustainable systems.1 The Board
Terry comment on whether Ureaplasma and                         intra-amniotic microbes and AFII has been            of the Vancouver Medical, Dental, and Allied
Mycoplasma cultures were done in any of the                     established; however, the recent application         Staff Association/Vancouver Physician Staff
included autopsies? Might he suggest a suitable                 of highly sensitive molecular techniques for         Association is very supportive of Vancouver
fetal site if a clinician were to test for them?                bacterial detection has failed to demonstrate        Coastal Health’s formal adoption of planetary
                                                                detectable microbial DNA in all AFII cas-            health as a strategic priority via the creation of
—Andrew Kotaska, MD, FRCSC
                                                                es; conversely, the presence of intra-amniotic       an official planetary health portfolio, with Dr
Obstetrician and Gynecologist, Stanton
Territorial Hospital                                            microbes (particularly Mycoplasma and Urea-
Assistant Professor, Department of Obstetrics                   plasma) without any appreciable maternal in-
and Gynecology, University of Manitoba                          flammatory response has been convincingly
Adjunct Professor, School of Population and                     shown. Thus, bacterial culture by itself is a poor
Public Health, University of BC
                                                                diagnostic test for AFII but can be diagnosti-
Adjunct Professor, Department of Obstetrics
                                                                cally useful in the context of histological AFII        Secure cloud-based clinical
and Gynecology, University of Toronto
Yellowknife, NT
                                                                where bacteria are not seen microscopically. Dr             speech recognition
                                                                Kotaska also makes the important practical
References
                                                                point that bacterial culture presently has no               Dictate into your EMR from
1.   Combs CA, Gravett M, Garite TJ, et al. Amniotic fluid      predictive value as there is no robust data to              almost anywhere
     infection, inflammation, and colonization in preterm       support treatment to decrease preterm birth,
     labor with intact membranes. Am J Obstet Gynecol           although this is also not well studied.                     Install within minutes across
     2014;210:125.e1-125.e15.
2.   Morency A-M, Bujold E. The effect of second-trimester
                                                                    Testing for Mycoplasma and Ureaplasma is                unlimited computers
     antibiotic therapy on the rate of preterm birth. J Ob-     difficult as these obligate intracellular micro-
     stet Gynaecol Can 2007;29:35-44.                           organisms are fastidious and require special                One synchronized user
3.   Kotaska A, Paulette L. Genital mycoplasma and pre-         handling, as Dr Kotaska points out. Myco-                   profile
     term birth: A difficult puzzle to solve. BJOG 2022. doi:
                                                                plasma and Ureaplasma culture is presently
     10.1111/1471-0528.17069.
                                                                not performed in British Columbia and the                   Stunningly accurate with
4.   Donders G, Van Calsteren K, Bellen G, et al. Predictive
     value for preterm birth of abnormal vaginal flora, bac-    only locally available Mycoplasma/Ureaplasma                accents
     terial vaginosis, and aerobic vaginitis during the first   testing is molecular based and not validated
     trimester of pregnancy. BJOG 2009;116:1315-1324.           on placental tissue, so testing for Mycoplasma              Contact us today for a free trial!
                                                                and Ureaplasma in the setting of AFII, or preg-
Author replies                                                                                                            604-264-9109 | 1-888-964-9109
                                                                nancy loss in general, is not routinely done at
I appreciate Dr Kotaska’s comments on the                       our centre. If I were to test a clinical sample        speakeasysolutions.com                       SY SOLU
                                                                                                                                                                  EA
amniotic fluid infection/inflammation (AFII)                    for Mycoplasma or Ureaplasma I would submit
                                                                                                                                                                           T

                                                                                                                                                                  21
                                                                                                                                                              K

                                                                                                                                                                                IO
                                                                                                                                                          SPEA

                                                                                                                         Professional Speech
                                                                                                                                                                                  NS

autopsy quality assurance study recently pub-                   lung and stomach contents for culture-based
                                                                studies or lung and stomach contents and tissue
                                                                                                                        Technology Specialists            YEARS OF EXCELLENCE

lished in the journal [BCMJ 2021;63:383-387].
                                                                                                                                                                  2000 - 2021

                                                                                                                        BC Medical Journal vol. 64 no. 3 | april 2022 107
letters

Andrea MacNeill leading the clinical services              role on this issue, we suspect that other associa-            •   Working with an environmentally advanced
component. Dr MacNeill has given outstand-                 tion journals (e.g., CMAJ) may follow.                            printer, Mitchell Press, certified by www
ing lectures on the subject to our membership              —Eric M. Yoshida, OBC, MD, FRCPC                                  .canopy.org.
at our annual general meeting in December,                 Past President, VMDAS/VPSA                                    • Printing with vegetable-based inks.
and more recently to our Board. It is clear that           —Alison Harris, MBBCh, FRCPC                                  • Using FSC-certified paper.
what may be perceived as small steps locally               President, VMDAS/VPSA                                         • Printing locally.
can lead to long-lasting positive consequences.            —Ka Wai Cheung, MD, FRCPC                                         Our recently completed member survey
    With this in mind, we strongly recommend               Vice President, VMDAS/VPSA                                    ( January 2022) again asked about members’
that the BC Medical Journal consider publishing            —Michael Nimmo, MD, FRCPC                                     attitudes toward print versus online. As in previ-
only online and cease publishing in print. Given           Secretary, VMDAS/VPSA                                         ous years, a strong majority of members asked
the popularity and convenience of online medi-             —John Ridley, MD, CCFP                                        that we continue with print, and this prefer-
cal journals in general, and the fact that Doctors         Treasurer, VMDAS/VPSA                                         ence holds when stratified for age and other
of BC’s services and communications have long              —Hui-Min Yang, MD, FRCPC                                      demographic factors. The number of readers
been conducted electronically, we suspect that             Member at Large, VMDAS/VPSA                                   who favor print has diminished somewhat since
the Doctors of BC membership will quickly                                                                                the previous survey in 2016; this trend seems
adapt to accessing and reading the BCMJ on-                Reference                                                     likely to continue, and perhaps in the future the
line. Reducing the carbon footprint associated             1.   Whitmee S, Haines A, Beyrer C, et al. Safeguarding hu-   BCMJ will become an online-only publication.
with printing the journal (i.e., saving paper, ink,             man health in the Anthropocene epoch: Report of the          The BCMJ’s mission is to provide a forum
                                                                Rockefeller Foundation–Lancet Commission on plan-
metal staples, and plastic wrappers, not to men-                                                                         for clinical education, medical news, opinion,
                                                                etary health. Lancet 2015;386(10007):1973-2028.
tion the production and distribution resources)                                                                          and resources for BC physicians, and we—along
will contribute positively to planetary health.                                                                          with the majority of our colleagues from around
It will also most likely result in cost savings to
                                                           Editor replies                                                BC—believe that this mission is best accom-
Doctors of BC. If the BCMJ takes a leadership              Thank you for your letter. We agree with the                  plished with a combination of print and online
                                                           small-steps approach and have been working to                 formats.
                                                           lessen our environmental impact for many years.                   To cease your subscription to the paper
                                                           The small steps that we have taken include:                   edition, please email your request to journal@
                                                           • Supporting doctors who wish to read online-                 doctorsofbc.ca. To remain informed about
                                                               only by canceling their paper subscrip-                   new BC-relevant medical content, subscribe
                                                               tion and encouraging them to subscribe                    to BCMJ Headlines, a notification emailed when
  British Columbia
                                                               to BCMJ Headlines, a notification emailed                 a new issue is posted on our website, by going
  Medical Journal
  @BCMedicalJournal
                                                               when a new issue is posted on www.bcmj                    to www.bcmj.org and clicking on the “Free
                                                               .org. This action directly reduces the                    e-subscription” button. You will be asked to
  British Columbia Medical Journal                             number of copies we print.                                provide only your name and email address.
  @BCMedicalJournal                                        • Avoiding bag use, and using recyclable paper
                                                                                                                         —Ed
  Community-based specialists: No-cost access to               envelopes when needed.
  UpToDate
  Community-based specialists with no active hospital
  privileges now have free access to UpToDate, a
  subscription-based online clinical decision support
  resource that provides physicians with clear clinical
  guidance to complex questions with the latest evidence                                                       Switching from print to
  and best practices.
  Read the story: bcmj.org/news/community-based
                                                                                                               online BCMJ
  -specialists-no-cost-access-uptodate                                                                         Switching from our print edition to online is a
                                                                                                               simple 2-step process:
                                                                                                               1. Email “stop print” to journal@doctorsofbc.ca,
                                                                                                                  providing your name and address.
                                                                                                               2. Go to bcmj.org and click on the
                                                                                                                  “Free e-subscription” button on the right,
                                                                                                                  providing only your name and email address.
                                                                                                                  You will receive the table of contents via email
                                                                                                                  notices, letting you know when a new issue is
                                                                                                                  online (10/year).
  Follow us on Facebook for regular updates

108 BC Medical Journal vol. 64 no. 3 | april 2022
News           We welcome news items of less than 300 words; we
may edit them for clarity and length. News items should be emailed to
journal@doctorsofbc.ca and must include your mailing address, telephone
number, and email address. All writers should disclose any competing interests.

                                            Book review: Patients at risk:                       Act in 1984 (public administration, comprehen-
                                                                                                 siveness, universality, portability, and accessibili-
                                            Exposing Canada’s health-care                        ty) represent tragic myths when viewed from the
                                            crisis                                               patient’s perspective. She touches on the history
                                            By Susan D. Martinuk. Winnipeg: Frontier             of publicly funded health care in Canada, then
                                            Centre for Public Policy, 2021. ISBN: 978-1-         reviews two legal challenges to medicare, be-
                                            7776577-4-1. Paperback, 264 pages.                   ginning with the successful Chaoulli v. Quebec
                                                Susan Martinuk is a Vancouver-based jour-        decision (Supreme Court of Canada, 2005). She
                                            nalist and research fellow in health care for        then proceeds to an in-depth analysis of the
                                            the Frontier Centre for Public Policy, an in-        ongoing case of Cambie Surgeries Corporation
                                            dependent Winnipeg-based think tank. This            v. BC, initially unsuccessful in the BC Supreme
                                            book, published by the Frontier Centre in 2021,      Court in 2020, currently awaiting a decision by
                                            begins with the stories of five patients who         the BC Court of Appeal, and expected by all
                                            endured prolonged suffering and poor out-            players to be ultimately decided by the Supreme
                                            comes while waiting for specialized medical          Court of Canada. Martinuk is uncompromising
                                            care, and lays blame squarely at the feet of a       in her support for Cambie surgeon Dr Brian
                                            “‘system’ that has lost sight of its raison d’etre   Day and condemns what she sees as the mis-
                                            and now functions more to constrain medical          guided role played by the government of BC,
                                            care than provide it.”                               the defendant in this ongoing litigation; hence
                                                The author argues that the tenets of Cana-       the title of Chapter 20: “The BC Government
                                            dian medicare enshrined in the Canada Health         v. Common Sense.”

Available for streaming on
all podcast platforms

                                                              PUTTING INDIGENOUS
                                                                CULTURAL SAFETY
                                                                    INTO PRACTICE
                                                                                                              with guests
                                                                                            Dr Terri Aldred and Len Pierre

                                                                                                           A Doctors of BC Podcast

                                                                                                    BC Medical Journal vol. 64 no. 3 | april 2022 109
NEWS

    Martinuk’s two final chapters, “How to                   those who fear that any venture into hybrid                vaccination rates lower than in other areas of
Make Health Care Better” and “Where Do                       public/private care will lead to the extinction            the province, a higher percentage of the popu-
We Go from Here,” detail in broad strokes                    of a system that represents the very cornerstone           lation is at risk of getting critically ill from the
her prescription for reform, which involves                  of the Canadian identity.                                  fifth wave.
acknowledging medicare’s failings; abandon-                  —David Esler, MD, CCFP(EM)                                     The impact on health care workers in a
ing rigid ideology; and separating politics                  Dr Esler has practised emergency medicine in and           remote community like Chetwynd (popula-
from health, care, and planning for the long                 around Vancouver for 34 years. He is also a clinical       tion just over 3000) is far-reaching. The help
term, including the establishment of a Cana-                 associate professor of emergency medicine at the           being offered by Real-Time Virtual Support
dian hybrid public/private system embraced                   University of British Columbia and a member of the         (RTVS) physicians, who are available 24/7 over
by other countries with better-ranked health                 BCMJ Editorial Board.                                      Zoom, has been welcomed with open arms. And
care systems.                                                                                                           physicians are reporting that RTVS is having
    Patients at Risk is eloquently written, moves                                                                       an impact on outcomes and helping alleviate
along quickly, and is carefully referenced by an             Real-Time Virtual Support:                                 the challenges of rural medicine during the
experienced journalist who presents a compel-                Much-needed rural and                                      pandemic.
ling argument for a major refit in Canadian                                                                                 RTVS virtual providers are physicians with
medicare. The patient anecdotes are especially
                                                             remote assistance during the                               experience in rural medicine and are dedicated
poignant, and while necessarily subjective, they             pandemic                                                   to offering shoulder-to-shoulder support to
continually remind the reader that health care               The COVID-19 pandemic continues to impact                  physicians, residents, nurse practitioners, and
exists to serve patients, and that a system that             rural and remote regions in Northern BC at a               nurses—any rural health care worker—over
places ideology ahead of patient care is destined            disproportionate rate compared with the rest               Zoom. The RTVS physicians, who are based
for failure.                                                 of the province. More than 100 patients have               throughout the province, can help with urgent
    Martinuk’s book is a concise and worthwhile              had to be transferred out of Northern Health               and non-urgent cases and questions, including
read. It will elicit applause from readers frustrat-         since the start of the fourth wave to hospitals            case consultations, second opinions, ongoing
ed by their experience with Canadian medicare                with more ICU capacity. The vast majority of               patient support, point-of-care ultrasound, and
and eager for change, and condemnation from                  those have been COVID-positive. And with                   simulations.

                                                                                                                          Doctors
                                                                                                                          Helping
       Travel insurance                                                                                                   Doctors
                                                                                                                          24 hrs/day,
       that’s ready to go.                                                                                                7 days/week
                                                                                                                          The Physician
                                                                                                                          Health Program of
                                                                                                                          British Columbia offers
                                                                                                                          help 24/7 to B.C. doctors
    With MEDOC® you can enjoy an unlimited number of trips1 during                                                        and their families for a
    the policy year, including coverage for COVID-19 related medical                                                      wide range of personal and
    costs during your trip for up to $5 million.                                                                          professional problems: physical,
                                                                                                                          psychological and social.
    Contact Johnson today.                                                                                                If something is on your mind, give
                                                                                                                          us a call at 1-800-663-6729 or visit
    1.855.473.8029                                                                                                        www.physicianhealth.com.
    or visit Johnson.ca/MEDOC
  Johnson Insurance is a tradename of Johnson Inc. ("JI"), a licensed insurance intermediary, and operates as Johnson
  Insurance Services in British Columbia and Johnson Inc. in Manitoba. MEDOC® is a Registered Trademark of JI.
  MEDOC® Travel Insurance is underwritten by Royal & Sun Alliance Insurance Company of Canada ("RSA") and
  administered by JI. Valid provincial or territorial health plan coverage required. Travel Assistance provided by
  Global Excel Management Inc. JI and RSA share common ownership. 1Maximum duration of 17 or 35 consecutive
  days applies to each trip outside of Canada, depending on your plan selection.

110 BC Medical Journal vol. 64 no. 3 | april 2022
NEWS

Drs Bron Finkelstein (left) and Jodie Graham (right), from Chetwynd, are frequent users of the Real-Time Virtual Support pathways for providers.

    When a critically ill patient cannot be man-           Alberta, the Northwest Territories, and Yukon,              encountered someone who was unwilling or
aged at a rural site, RTVS physicians can also             and agrees that RTVS is the best thing to hap-              unhappy to talk. Providers throughout the prov-
step in to coordinate their transfer to a larger           pen to rural medicine.                                      ince are encouraged to reach out for support.
centre through the Patient Transfer Network                    Dr Matt Petrie is an RTVS physician who                    For more information on how to get start-
run by BC Emergency Health Services. The                   has helped coordinate patient transfers for                 ed with RTVS, visit https://rccbc.ca/rtvs/
transfer is made to a centre with available ICU            the Chetwynd team, pointing out that it is                  getting-started.
capacity. In recent months, due to critically ill          sometimes difficult for doctors in urban cen-
COVID-19 patients, patient transfer has be-                tres to understand the situation on the ground              Prescribing nature to improve
come more common.                                          in a rural centre. As a member of the RUDi                  health
    Dr Bron Finkelstein, a new-to-practice doc-            (emergency) team in RTVS, he understands                    PaRx is Canada’s first national, evidence-based
tor in Chetwynd, where the hospital has just five          that part of his job is to advocate for rural               nature prescription program, an initiative of the
beds, says RTVS physicians have been instru-               providers who may not be able to advocate                   BC Parks Foundation driven by health care
mental in making stressful situations manage-              for themselves and their community during                   professionals. Each prescriber who registers
able with advice, guidance when a colleague is             a stressful situation.                                      with PaRx receives a nature prescription file
needed, and taking on patient transfers during                                                                         customized with a unique provider code, and
the depths of a difficult situation. With RTVS             Call early and call often                                   instructions for how to prescribe and log na-
support, the patient can be stabilized while a             Dr Finkelstein urges health care providers to               ture prescriptions. Doctors and other licensed
transfer is being arranged.                                call RTVS early—before they get too busy to                 health care professionals in BC can now pre-
    Dr Jodie Graham, chief of staff at Chet-               call—and to call often—when they have a sig-                scribe Parks Canada Discovery Passes to pa-
wynd Hospital, has trained and worked in rural             nificant case, a challenging case, a case where a           tients through PaRx. For more information,
medicine for over a decade, including in rural             second opinion would be beneficial. He’s never              visit www.parkprescriptions.ca/en/prescribers.

                                                                                                                           BC Medical Journal vol. 64 no. 3 | april 2022 111
NEWS

     Physician health and wellness:
     Doctors of BC 2021 Report to
     Members
     Doctors of BC has released its 2021 Report to
     Members, with a focus on physician health and
     wellness. To illustrate some of the ways the as-
     sociation has been working to support physi-
     cians throughout the pandemic, the report looks
     at health and wellness advances made by the
     Physician Health Program, by the Rural Coor-
                                                                                               2021 REPORT TO MEMBERS
     dination Centre of BC, and through divisions of
     family practice, the Joint Collaborative Commit-
     tees, and the Council on Health Economics and
     Policy. The report also contains:
     • A summary of the year from 2021 President
         Dr Matthew Chow, Chair of the Board
         Dr Adam Thompson, Speaker of the Rep-
                                                                  1                                                                                                                     2021 REPORT TO MEMBERS

         resentative Assembly Dr Eric Cadesky, and
         Acting CEO Mr Jim Aikman.
     • Reports from committees, sections, societies,      A fresh take on physician wellness: New leadership                          Grassroots physician wellness solutions
                                                          and funding for the Physician Health Program                                from divisions and MSAs
         councils, coordinating and working groups,
         and external committees and aff iliated
         organizations.
     • A full list of all the doctors who served on the
         association’s many committees in the year.
     The report is available now at www.doctorsofbc
     .ca/about-us/report-members.
                                                                                                 READ MORE                                                                  READ MORE

                                                          7   Back to Main Table of Contents                 2021 REPORT TO MEMBERS   30   Back to Main Table of Contents                              2021 REPORT TO MEMBERS

Free online mental health and
substance use supports for your
patients
In April 2020, Health Canada launched Wellness To-
gether Canada in response to a rise in mental health
and substance use concerns due to the COVID-19
pandemic. The free, online platform provides 24/7 ac-
cess to mental health and substance use supports to
all Canadians.
    A free companion app (PocketWell) is now available
for download to help users better track their mental
health status. Additional resources include everything
from self-assessment and peer support, to free and
confidential sessions with social workers, psycholo-
gists, and other professionals. Find out more at www
.wellnesstogether.ca. PocketWell is available from the
Apple App Store and the Google Play Store.

112 BC Medical Journal vol. 64 no. 3 | april 2022
You can also read