Clean Energy/Clean Tech - Canadian Politics and Public Policy www.policymagazine.ca - Policy Magazine

Page created by Cynthia Wagner
 
CONTINUE READING
Clean Energy/Clean Tech - Canadian Politics and Public Policy www.policymagazine.ca - Policy Magazine
www.policymagazine.ca                        September—October 2018

               Canadian Politics and Public Policy

        Clean Energy/Clean Tech

$6.95                                                Volume 6—Issue 5
Clean Energy/Clean Tech - Canadian Politics and Public Policy www.policymagazine.ca - Policy Magazine
Through its various tree planting initiatives, including EcoConnexions – From
the Ground Up, CN has planted 1.8 million trees across North America
since 2012.

This makes CN the leading private non-forestry company tree planter
in Canada.

                                                              w w w.cn.c a
Clean Energy/Clean Tech - Canadian Politics and Public Policy www.policymagazine.ca - Policy Magazine
Soaring to new heights. We didn’t use
it to fly a kite. Or spend an afternoon at
the beach with the family. But we did
recognize the potential of wind as a
source of renewable energy. That’s
why we invest in renewable energy that
helps generate enough electricity to
power more than 750,000 homes. When
our energy meets the energy from the
wind, harnessing the future happens.
Clean Energy/Clean Tech - Canadian Politics and Public Policy www.policymagazine.ca - Policy Magazine
4

    Peerless Clothing is the largest supplier of
    men’s and boy’s tailored clothing to most
    major department stores and speciality retail-
    ers in both the United States and Canada.

    Proudly Canadian / Fièrement canadien

      The largest manufacturer of men’s and
      boy’s tailored clothing in the world.
                                               www.peerless-clothing.com 1.800.336.9363
Clean Energy/Clean Tech - Canadian Politics and Public Policy www.policymagazine.ca - Policy Magazine
5
                                           In This Issue
                                           9     From the Editor / L. Ian MacDonald
                                                 Clean Energy/Clean Tech

   Canadian Politics and
                                           11David McLaughlin
                                           	Climate at the Crossroads
      Public Policy                        15Dan Woynillowicz and Merran Smith
                                           	Clean Growth is More Than a Goal—It’s a Reality
             EDITOR
        L. Ian MacDonald
 lianmacdonald@policymagazine.ca
                                           18    Dan Gagnier
                                                 In Clean Tech, Consumers Will Set the Pace of Change
        ASSOCIATE EDITOR
          Lisa Van Dusen                   20Janet Drysdale
                                           	Rail—Pulling Toward a Cleaner Future
   lvandusen@policymagazine.ca
       CONTRIBUTING WRITERS                23 Nathalie Pilon
                                           	Digitalization: The Path to Sustainability
          Thomas S. Axworthy,
    Andrew Balfour, Yaroslav Baran,
   Derek H. Burney, Catherine Cano,        27    Karen Hamberg
                                                 A Clean Tech Case Study
    Margaret Clarke, Celine Cooper,
    Rachel Curran, Susan Delacourt,
      Graham Fraser, Dan Gagnier,          30    Derek Nighbor
                                                 Forestry: A Success Story in Clean Tech
   Martin Goldfarb, Sarah Goldfeder,
     Patrick Gossage, Frank Graves,
      Brad Lavigne, Kevin Lynch,
                                           32    Guest Column / James Scongack
                                                 Clean Nuclear Power and Lower GHG Emissions
Jeremy Kinsman, Andrew MacDougall,
   Carissima Mathen, Velma McColl,         33    Tim McMillan
                                                 Keeping Canada Competitive: A Petroleum Industry Perspective
  David McLaughlin, David Mitchell,
     Don Newman, Geoff Norquay,
  Fen Osler Hampson, Robin V. Sears,       35    Guest Column / Elizabeth May
                                                 Renewable Energy as Reconciliation
  Gil Troy, Lori Turnbull, Jaime Watt,
        Anthony Wilson-Smith
            WEB DESIGN                     Canada and the World
            Nicolas Landry
       policy@nicolaslandry.ca             36    Geoff Norquay
                                                 The Ontario Campaign that Went from Time for a Change to
       SOCIAL MEDIA EDITOR                       Throw the Bums Out
          Grace MacDonald
      grace@policymagazine.ca              39    Patrick Gossage
                                                 Ontario’s Ford Fiesta: Liberals and Media Didn’t Get It
 GRAPHIC DESIGN & PRODUCTION
         Monica Thomas
    monica@foothillsgraphics.ca            41    Graham Fraser
                                                 The Quebec Election: A Primer
               Policy
  Policy is published six times annually
                                           44
                                           	
                                              Chand Sooran
                                              The Future of Government Procurement is Virtual
  by LPAC Ltd. The contents are
  copyrighted, but may be reproduced       47    Kevin Lynch
                                                 The Financial Crisis Ten Years On: Is the Repair Job Finished?
  with permission and attribution in
  print, and viewed free of charge at
  the Policy home page at                  50    Jeremy Kinsman
                                                 Moving On: The West Adjusts to a Rogue U.S. President
  www.policymagazine.ca.
  Printed and distributed by St. Joseph
                                           BOOK REVIEW
  Communications, 1165 Kenaston
  Street, Ottawa, Ontario, K1A 1A4
                                           53    Review by Anthony Wilson-Smith
                                                 Capturing What Makes PMs Tick
  Available in Air Canada Maple Leaf
  Lounges across Canada, as well                 J.D.M. Stewart
  as VIA Rail Lounges in Montreal,
  Ottawa and Toronto.                      54    Column / Don Newman
                                                 Trudeau’s Energy/Environment Pre-election Peril
  Now available on PressReader.

  Special thanks to our sponsors
                                                                                               facebook.com/
         and advertisers.                  Connect with us:           @policy_mag
                                                                                               policymagazine

                                                                                            September/October 2018
Clean Energy/Clean Tech - Canadian Politics and Public Policy www.policymagazine.ca - Policy Magazine
Clean Energy/Clean Tech - Canadian Politics and Public Policy www.policymagazine.ca - Policy Magazine
The
                                         future
                                         is on
                                         board

More than ever, VIA Rail wants to connect Canadians to a sustainable future.
Maximize your                                                                 Reduce your                                                                  Smarter value                                                                 Connect
productivity                                                                  carbon footprint                                                             for taxpayers                                                                 communities
With Wi-Fi, power outlets,                                                    Making the smart choice                                                      It’s good for your bottom                                                     VIA Rail connects
use of your cellphone and                                                     today helps contribute                                                       line and Canada’s, too.                                                       4 million travellers
comfy seats—you just                                                          to a greener tomorrow.                                                                                                                                     and 400 communities
might like the train more                                                                                                                                                                                                                across Canada.
than the office.

                  Route                               # of daily                        Distance                    Productive                  Non-productive                         Cost of                       Cost of                       Taxpayer savings
                                                      departures                                                    train time                    car time*                           travelling                  travelling by                      by choosing
                                                                                                                                                                                       by car**                 train (as low as)                    train travel***

 Ottawa             Toronto                             Up to 20                        450 km                      4 h 23 min                      4 h 34 min                           $467                              $44                                $423

 Ottawa             Montréal                            Up to 12                        198 km                      1 h 55 min                      2 h 27 min                           $227                              $33                                $194

 Ottawa             Québec City                          Up to 8                        482 km                      5 h 23 min                      4 h 39 min                           $488                              $44                                $444

 Toronto              Montréal                          Up to 13                        541 km                      5 h 25 min                      5 h 30 min                           $562                              $44                                $518

Government of Canada employees enjoy a 10% discount on personal travel booked directly with VIA Rail.
Government of Canada employees can take advantage of specially negotiated rates for business travel available through the Shared Travel Services HRG Portal.
The discount does not apply to Prestige class or Escape fares.
  *30 minutes was added to the total travel time by car in order to account for traffic and bad weather en route.
 **The total cost to the taxpayer of travelling by car is calculated based on the following formula: $ cost of travelling by car (Treasury Board kilometric rate for Ontario of $0.55/km for car travel by a government official X total distance travelled) + $ employee-related cost
   (average hourly rate of $48/h for a government employee, based on a salary of $100,000 per year including employee benefits X travel time) = $ total cost to taxpayer.
***The value of travelling by train is calculated based on the following formula: $ cost of travelling by car – $ cost of travelling by train = $ taxpayer savings.
Fares and conditions are subject to change without notice. TMTrademark owned by VIA Rail Canada Inc.
Clean Energy/Clean Tech - Canadian Politics and Public Policy www.policymagazine.ca - Policy Magazine
Power
at a lower
cost to the
environment
and you.                    Clean
                            nuclear
                            power

  www.brucepower.com/poweringmore
Clean Energy/Clean Tech - Canadian Politics and Public Policy www.policymagazine.ca - Policy Magazine
9

                           From the Editor / L. Ian MacDonald

                          Clean Energy/Clean Tech
W
           elcome to our special issue     clean technology in a material way to     Liberals outside Montreal, with the
           on Clean Energy/Clean           diversify our economy.” Derek Nigh-       Parti Québécois a distant third. How
           Tech, one of the defining       bor of the Forest Products Association    to explain it? “For the first time since
economic and environmental issues          of Canada writes of the Canadian          1970,” Fraser writes, “Quebec inde-
of the day.                                forestry industry as a success story in   pendence is not on the ballot.”
David McLaughlin, former president         clean tech. In a guest column, James      Government procurement can be un-
of the National Round Table on the         Scongack of Bruce Power writes of         wieldy at the best of times, with un-
Environment and the Economy, sets          nuclear power as a clean energy alter-    known challenges ahead in the digital
the table with a survey piece on cli-      native, notably to coal. And Tim Mc-      age, particularly for small business.
mate change and how the conversa-          Millan, president of the Canadian As-     Procurement consulting executive
tion has changed, notably on carbon        sociation of Petroleum Producers, sees    Chand Sooran offers his thoughts on
pricing: “Canada has swung from a          a world that will need “more energy in    SMEs doing business with large corpo-
seeming inevitability on climate ac-       every form, including more Canadian       rations and government.
tion with carbon pricing to a pitched      oil and more Canadian natural gas.”
                                                                                     Ten years after the financial crisis of
battle between Liberals and Conser-        Finally, Green Party Leader Elizabeth     2008-09, Kevin Lynch looks back at
vatives, some provinces and Ottawa,        May sees the development of renew-        those dark days and asks if the repair
challenging the very notion of carbon      able energy as a path to reconciliation   job is finished. As clerk of the Privy
and climate action at all.”                with Canada’s Indigenous Peoples.         Council during the crisis and now as

                                           I
Dan Woynillowicz and Merran Smith                                                    a vice-chair at BMO, Lynch considers
                                               n Canada and the World, we take
of Clean Energy Canada write that                                                    some of the challenges facing both
                                               a look at the Ontario election, and
clean growth is more than a goal, it’s a                                             government and the private sector.
                                               the changes upcoming under
reality. For example, they point out “a                                              Our foreign affairs writer Jeremy Kins-
record-setting 1.1 million electric cars   Premier Doug Ford. Geoff Norquay
                                           writes that “by any measure, the PC       man, a former senior Canadian dip-
were sold in 2017.” Canada saw a 68
                                           victory on June 7 was both decisive       lomat, looks at the chaotic world of
per cent increase in EV sales over 2016.
                                           and strong.” He also notes that Ford      Donald Trump, who is shaking the
Dan Gagnier, ex-chair of the Interna-      wasted no time in holding a sum-          multilateral institutions of western de-
tional Institute on Sustainable Devel-     mer sitting of the Legislature, mov-      mocracies created and led by the U.S.
opment, looks at clean tech and writes     ing quickly to “cancel Ontario’s          From the G7 in Quebec to the NATO
that consumers will drive the pace of      cap-and-trade program on carbon           summit in Brussels, it’s been a sum-
change, in an environment where dis-                                                 mer of discontent.
                                           emissions.” Veteran Liberal strategist
ruption is the new normal.
                                           and media consultant Patrick Gos-         In a book review, Historica Canada
Janet Drysdale, vice president respon-     sage writes that both pundits and         President Anthony Wilson-Smith
sible for CN’s sustainability strategy,    pols were wrong about the June elec-      looks at J.D.M Stewart’s Being Prime
makes the case for rail as a choice for    tion. “How could the media have got       Minister, and finds the author captures
clean energy. Transportation accounts      it so wrong?” he asks. The obvious        what makes Canadian PMs tick, in
for 28 per cent of Canada’s GHGs, but      answer—a state of denial.                 their private as well their public lives.
rail only 1 per cent.
                                           With an October 1 Quebec election         Finally, columnist Don Newman
ABB Canada President Nathalie Pilon        on the horizon, veteran journalist        considers the conundrum of Justin
writes that “never has there been a        and author Graham Fraser offers a         Trudeau as he heads into an election
better time for leaders to adopt sus-      primer on the campaign. By all the        trying to balance his environmental
tainable business practices by taking      leading economic indicators and fis-      promises with the energy file, partic-
ownership of the digital space…” in        cal frameworks, the re-election of        ularly the Trans Mountain pipeline
the Fourth Industrial Revolution.          Philippe Couillard’s Liberals should      project, of which the government
Karen Hamberg of Westport Fuel Sys-        be a slam-dunk. But it’s not. Going       has taken ownership. Newman writes
tems in Vancouver writes of the op-        into the campaign, François Legault’s     that the Liberals have also taken po-
portunity to “deploy made-in-Canada        Coalition avenir Québec easily led the    litical ownership.

                                                                                                  September/October 2018
Clean Energy/Clean Tech - Canadian Politics and Public Policy www.policymagazine.ca - Policy Magazine
—
Digital innovation
at ABB is about people

We are living through an information technology revolution set against a context of sustainability,
energy concerns, and the fourth industrial revolution – the meshing of the digital world of people and
machines as internet meets production. This is our ever-evolving workspace, where technology
accelerates growth and innovation like never before and more than ever we aim to create a Canada
whose people, technology and innovation ecosystem can compete on the global scale abb.com/future
11

The Tuktoyaktuk Winter Road, an ice road in the Northwest Territories, whose operations could be effected by winter warming. Wikipedia photo

Climate at the Crossroads
Canada’s climate change efforts have reached a cross-                                               David McLaughlin

                                                                                                    I
roads. Mounting opposition from some provinces to the                                                    t began and ended with two new
Trudeau government’s carbon pricing policy has serious-                                                  cabinets and two new words: cli-
ly dented any guarantees that the Pan-Canadian Frame-                                                    mate change.
work on Clean Growth and Climate Change will endure.                                                They were added to the title of Prime
                                                                                                    Minister Justin Trudeau’s first Minis-
The federal government is facing an uncomfortable but                                               ter of the Environment and Climate
unavoidable choice. Does it impose carbon pricing on                                                Change in 2015; and taken away
recalcitrant provinces in an election year or not? Acting                                           from the new title for Ontario Pre-
                                                                                                    mier Doug Ford’s first Minister of
risks a carbon tax backlash by voters. Not acting risks                                             the Environment, Conservation and
alienating the federal Liberals’ own voting base on a key                                           Parks in 2018.
policy issue.                                                                                       Those two cabinet changes mark
                                                                                                    the high- and low-water marks of
                                                                                                    climate change progress in Canada.
                                                                                                    With the first, the Trudeau govern-
                                                                                                    ment set about creating the Pan-Ca-

                                                                                                                   September/October 2018
12
     nadian Framework on Clean Growth                                                                                2005 levels by 2030, he just as effec-
                                                                               If Harper effectively
     and Climate Change (PCF) in Decem-                                                                              tively boxed-in future government
     ber, 2016. With the second, the Ford                                      poisoned the                          action. Thinking this target would
     Progressive Conservative government                               political well on using a                     be politically bullet-proof from their
     repealed its cap-and-trade system and                             carbon tax, he bequeathed a                   Conservative opponents, the Liber-
     commenced a legal challenge to Ot-                                poisoned chalice to both his                  als adopted it with alacrity in 2015.
     tawa’s plan to require provinces to                                                                             Andrew Scheer, the new Conserva-
     implement carbon pricing regimes
                                                                       own party and the Trudeau                     tive party leader, then drank from it
     by 2019.                                                          government: his Paris                         earlier this year with a public com-
                                                                       2030 targets.                                 mitment to reach the Paris target but
     In just over two years, Canada has                                                                              without a carbon tax.
     swung from a seeming inevitability
     on climate action with carbon pricing                                                                           Yet, this target is proving just as resis-
     to a pitched political battle between                                                                           tant to actual achievement as every
     Liberals and Conservatives, some                                                                                other Canadian climate target from

                                                                       F
     provinces and Ottawa, challenging                                       rom that moment on, federal             Kyoto onwards. Now owning it, the
     the very notion of carbon and cli-                                      Conservatives became unalter-           Liberals are criticized for instituting a
     mate action at all. Climate policy has                                  ably opposed to formal carbon           modest carbon tax to help achieve it
     reached a crossroads in Canada. Next                              pricing as a tool to reduce emissions,        (it is either too much or not enough,
                                    240
     year’s federal election looks now as                              despite their own, soon-to-be-dis-            say the same critics). Meanwhile,
     the deciding event.            200                                carded cap-and-trade plan known as            the Conservative position will be ex-
                                   160                                 Turning the Corner. A slow, sector-           tremely difficult, if not outright im-
     Despite the federal Liberal govern-                                                                             possible, to accomplish with a regula-
                                                                       by-sector regulatory approach was ad-
     ment’s avowed commitment to     glob-
                                   120                                                                               tory approach alone.
                                                                       opted instead. But the high-emitting
     al and Canadian climate action un-
                                    80                                 oil and gas sector was consistently
                                                                                        The basis, then, for sound climate
     der the slogan “Canada is Back”,  the
                                                                       left out and Canada’s emissions rose
                                                                                        public policy in this pre-election year
     terrain for what became the PCF40was
                                                                       until the 2008-09 recession caused
     tilled by “the two Stephens”: Harper                                               is increasingly looking like a re-run of
                                     0                                 them to drop, before rising again.
     and Dion. The 2008 federal election2017        2020                     2025       the 2008 campaign.
                                                                                                     2030
     put paid to the notion of a carbon But if Harper effectively poisoned the

                                                                                                                     T
                                          PLDVs–BEV   PLDVs–PHEV    LCVs–BEV    LCVs–PHEV    Buses–BEV
     tax to reduce emissions. Then Lib- political well on using a carbon tax,                   he Trudeau government’s ini-
                                         Buses–PHEV   Trucks–BEV    Trucks–PHEV
     eral leader Stéphane Dion promoted he bequeathed a poisoned chalice to                     tiative to knit together a pan-
     his Green Shift carbon tax. Prime both his own party and the Trudeau                       Canadian climate approach
     Minister Stephen Harper castigated government: his Paris 2030 targets. By was based on the realism of feder-
     it as a “tax on everything”, winning setting yet another ambitious GHG alism and the state of climate play
     an increased minority government.        reduction target of 30 per cent below when he took office. Under the

     Canada’s GHG Emissions 1990–2016

                                     800
                                                                                                   732         745
                                                                                                                                             707         716         704
                                                                                                                                 694
                                     700
                                                                                                         723         724                           716         714
                                                                                                                           682         700
      Megatonnes of CO2 equivalent

                                     600

                                     500

                                     400

                                     300

                                     200

                                     100

                                      0
                                           1990   1992   1994   1996   1998    2000    2002    2004      2006        2008        2010        2012        2014    2016

     Policy
13
Harper government, provinces had
                                                 The Ford government’s withdrawal from the
been the leaders in climate action,
from British Columbia legislating                climate sphere can be seen as either a brake or
the country’s first-ever carbon tax to    an accelerator to a truly pan-Canadian climate policy for
Ontario closing down its coal-fired       the country.
electricity plants to Quebec bring-
ing in cap-and-trade. Any national
policy had to realistically account
.1Here’s a thought experiment: if
the Liberals took office today de-
termined to bring in a national cli-      agreement, Ottawa should not sun-            up receiving rebates totalling more
mate policy, would they bring in          der it.                                      than a thousand dollars.
their current PCF plan? The answer        Second, bring in a national carbon tax       Fifth, bring in output-based carbon
is very likely “no”. With dimming         floor of $25 or $30 per tonne (or 5-7        pricing for large emitters as current-
provincial support for climate ac-        cents per litre of gasoline) for all other   ly being implemented in Alberta,
tion, it would be up to the federal       provinces at once. Instead of just do-       and planned for Saskatchewan and
government to impose a uniform            ing this for two provinces now and           Manitoba. This system of industrial
carbon price and the elements of a        presumably Alberta later, apply it to        performance standards reduces the
pan-Canadian climate plan. In less        all of them. Provinces could have a          cost of carbon pricing for emitters
than two years, Canada has moved          higher price if they so desired, but they    by returning a portion of their pay-
from a provincially-led, federally-       could not have a lower price. This is        ments in the form of a subsidy. This
backstopped climate policy to one
                                          higher than the current $20 per tonne        prevents carbon leakage and reduced
that looks more and more ‘federally-
                                          price set for 2019 but not unduly so.        production for trade-exposed sec-
led, provincially-backstopped’.
                                          A higher price would also incent more        tors. The recent adjustments by the
In that vein, the Ford government’s       emissions reductions at the outset.          federal government to its proposed
withdrawal from the climate sphere                                                     output-based system actually eased
                                          (A $30 per tonne “carbon price col-
can be seen as either a brake or an ac-                                                the cost burden even further on in-
                                          lar” was in fact recommended by the
celerator to a truly pan-Canadian cli-                                                 dustry; smart recognition that indus-
                                          now-defunct National Round Table
mate policy for the country. Carbon                                                    try needs more transition support to
                                          on the Environment and the Econ-
pricing opponents are framing it as                                                    implement carbon pricing, even if
                                          omy in 2010 as a competitiveness
unstoppable momentum to ending                                                         the politics of doing so has left the
                                          measure to allow Canada to move on
the “Trudeau carbon tax”—the brake.                                                    Trudeau government open to largely
                                          climate action without getting too far
Seen another way, it actually creates                                                  specious charges of back-tracking on
                                          ahead of the U.S.)
an opportunity for the federal gov-                                                    its carbon policy.
ernment to re-cast its pan-Canadian       Third, keep that price flat until the

                                                                                       A
climate policy and bring about the        2022 review. Business is worried                    t one bold stroke, the federal
carbon price uniformity and certain-      about escalating carbon prices and a                government would take the
ty sought in the PCF—an accelerator.      “layering” of regulations on top of it,             policy responsibility to go
The tool to do so: revenue recycling      and this would give a pause to busi-         with the political responsibility it
to people.                                nesses’ benefit while NAFTA is settled       has for all practical purposes already
                                          with the United States.                      assumed for its carbon and climate

T
       here is today a window to                                                       approach. The effect of hundreds
                                          Fourth, recycle all of the carbon tax
       implement a truly national                                                      of dollars in rebate cheques going
                                          revenue directly back to residents in
       PCF that fits more directly into                                                into peoples’ pockets is the best, and
                                          each jurisdiction in the form of divi-
a federally-mandated carbon and cli-                                                   frankly, only way at this juncture to
                                          dend or rebate cheques. Better still,
mate policy. One that does not focus                                                   ease carbon pricing into place for all
                                          do it for individuals, not households,
on price stringency to achieve envi-                                                   Canadians.
                                          to maximize the size and visibility
ronmental outcomes. Here are the el-
                                          of the dividend. For those provinces         The federal government’s legal au-
ements that could make it up:
                                          with revenue recycling systems al-           thority to tax and distribute is wide-
First, leave Quebec alone to imple-       ready in place, they could have the          ly agreed. By having an equal carbon
ment its cap-and-trade system with        choice of retaining their current            floor price across the country, all
California under the Western Cli-         system or withdrawing in favour of           jurisdictions are being treated the
mate Initiative. There is no move-        the federal government’s dividend            same. A uniform carbon price for the
ment currently in Quebec to with-         cheques, which would actually be             country takes root. Since the effect
draw from carbon pricing or climate       worth $200-$300 for each person. A           of the legal challenge from Saskatch-
action. As this is an international       four-person household could wind             ewan and Ontario is to curtail fed-

                                                                                                   September/October 2018
14
      Province/Territory   Carbon Pricing Regime                                          Compliance with Federal Benchmark

      British Columbia     Carbon tax. $35/tonne. Rising by $5/tonne annually.            Yes

      Alberta              Carbon tax. $30 per tonne. Future increases beginning          Yes to 2020.
                           in 2020 paused pending outcome of Trans-Mountain               No in 2019 if United Conservative
                           pipeline dispute with B.C.                                     Party wins Spring election and repeals
                           Output-based carbon pricing for large industrial emitters.     carbon tax.

      Saskatchewan         No. Legal challenge via Saskatchewan Court of Appeal
                                                                                          No. Eligible for federal backstop in
                           reference. Published Prairie Resilience climate plan with
                                                                                          2019.
                           form of output- based carbon pricing.

      Ontario              No. Cap-and-trade regime being repealed.
                                                                                          No. Eligible for federal backstop in
                           No alternative plan at present.
                                                                                          2019.
                           Legal challenge via Ontario Court of Appeal reference.

      Quebec               Cap-and-trade regime.                                          Yes

      New Brunswick        Plan not finalized. Stated intent not to introduce new
                           carbon pricing but convert existing fossil fuel taxes to       No. Unless deemed equivalent.
                           climate change fund.

      Nova Scotia          Internal cap-and-trade regime for electricity.                 Yes, due to deemed equivalency in
                           No formal carbon tax or output based pricing system.           outcomes.

      PEI                  Plan being developed.                                          Uncertain

      Newfoundland
                           Plan being developed.                                          Uncertain
      & Labrador

     eral action period on climate, it can                                                 based industrial pricing, revenues
     be seen as a necessary but limited                 Ottawa has lost                    kept in each jurisdiction, a 2022
     assertion of federal authority in this             control of the                     review, and provincial flexibility to
     important field.                          climate narrative in the                    do more.
     The effect of this would be to impose     country. 2018 is not 2015                   Next year—an election year—is likely
     a carbon price on the following prov-     or 2016 in terms of its                     to determine whether Canada will act
     inces: Alberta (if there is a change in   political authority and                     as one on climate or reanimate the
     government), Saskatchewan, On-                                                        fragmented approach of the recent
     tario, New Brunswick, PEI, and New-
                                               willingness of provinces to
                                                                                           past. If elections matter, this next one
     foundland and Labrador. The floor         collaborate on climate.                     promises to be consequential.
     carbon price is modest enough not         Only a bold move will                       David McLaughlin is Director of
     to create significant economic dif-       suffice to salvage it. But to               Climate Change, Canada at the
     ferentials between provinces. The
     flat rate ensures the political impact
                                               bite the bullet on climate, it              International Institute for Sustainable
     is equally modest as consumers and        must water its wine too.                    Development. He is the former
     businesses are not hit with rising fuel                                               President and CEO of the National
     bills each year. And, it requires gov-                                                Round Table on the Environment
     ernments to look at more politically-                                                 and the Economy. He has been a
     acceptable non-pricing measures to                                                    deputy minister in the New Brunswick
     close the Paris gap.                      to salvage it. But to bite the bullet on    government and is a former
                                               climate, it must water its wine too.        Conservative chief of staff to the prime
     Ottawa has lost control of the cli-       A revised national carbon floor price       minister of Canada, premier of
     mate narrative in the country. 2018       with full revenue recycling cheques         New Brunswick, and federal
     is not 2015 or 2016 in terms of its       back to individuals does just that.         finance minister.
     political authority and willingness
     of provinces to collaborate on cli-       It still features key elements of the
     mate. Only a bold move will suffice       current PCF: carbon pricing, output-

     Policy
15

Clean Growth is More Than a
Goal—It’s a Reality

Just as social media upended communications, the transi-                                    So, why is China all-in on EVs?
tion to clean energy is rapidly undoing century-old expec-                                  As Amy Myers Jaffe of the Council
                                                                                            on Foreign Relations wrote recently,
tations around electricity, transportation and oil—and it’s                                 “China is banking on clean energy
happening faster than most Canadians realize.                                               technologies as major industrial ex-
                                                                                            ports that will compete with U.S.
                                                                                            and Russian oil and gas and make
                                                                                            China the renewable energy and
Dan Woynillowicz and                             The costs of renewable electricity—        electric vehicle superpower of a fu-
                                                 such as wind and solar power—are
Merran Smith                                     falling year after year, while more
                                                                                            ture energy world.”

P
                                                 and more projects are seeing massive       Anthony Milewski of Pala Invest-
                                                 investments. But electricity isn’t the     ments put it even more simply: “Chi-
                                                 only chapter in this transition’s story.   na, unabashedly, wants to be the De-
         rotests. Politics. Polarization.                                                   troit of electric vehicles.”
                                                 The tale unfolding in transportation
Whether you’re reading a newspa-                 promises to be just as disruptive.         And this push to electrify isn’t lim-
per, tuning into the news, or scroll-                                                       ited to passenger vehicles. There are a
                                                 Consider this: A record-setting 1.1
ing through Twitter, you’ll notice a             million electric cars were sold in 2017,   growing number of electric buses, bi-
common theme: coverage of energy                 and roughly half of those were sold        cycles, garbage and transport trucks,
and climate change is dominated by               in China, which saw a 73 per cent in-      even ferries.
pipelines.                                       crease in EV sales over 2016. There are    Last year, China put 90,000 fully elec-
Are pipelines a serious matter? Cer-             now more than three million electric       tric buses on its roads, and in Decem-
tainly. And yet the time and atten-              cars cruising roads around the world,      ber the city of Shenzhen announced
tion they consume risks distract-                and over a million of those are in a       that all 16,359 vehicles in its fleet
ing Canada’s business and political              single country.                            were electric. To put that in perspec-
leaders from the much broader and                China is now also the world’s biggest      tive, New York City has one-third as
deeper shifts occurring in the world’s           manufacturer of electric cars and is       many buses, period.

                                                                                            A
energy system.                                   home to an incredible 487 EV makers.
                                                                                                    nd by no means is this tran-
                                                                                                    sition confined to China.
Number of Electric Cars in Circulation                                                              Britain, France, Germany,
                                                                                            Norway, the Netherlands, Scotland—
                                                                                            and yes, China—have all announced
             3.5
                                                                                            they will eventually prohibit the sale
              3                                                                             of gas- and diesel-fuelled vehicles.
             2.5                                                                            The transportation transition is hap-
              2.
                                                                                            pening here in Canada, too, albeit
  millions

                                                                                            more slowly. While we’re trailing
             1.5                                                                            leading jurisdictions, Canada saw a 68
              1                                                                             per cent increase in electric car sales
                                                                                            in 2017 over the previous year. The
              .5                                                                            Toronto Transit Commission, mean-
              0                                                                             while, recently placed an order for ten
                   2013         2014           2015           2016          2017            electric buses from New Flyer’s Cana-
                   China      Europe        United States         Others                    dian subsidiary in Winnipeg, with an
                                                                                            option for another 30. This was fol-
Source: International Energy Agency, Global Electric Vehicle Outlook 2018                   lowed by an order for 40 more from

                                                                                                         September/October 2018
16
     Electric Vehicles 30@30 Scenario                                                                                It’s a smart move, according to a re-
                                                                                                                     cent report from Wood Mackenzie,
                                                                                                                     which says oil and gas companies
                   240
                                                                                                                     that adopt renewables early will be
                   200                                                                                               at a competitive advantage, while
                                                                                                                     slow adopters could find themselves
        millions

                   160
                                                                                                                     at a structural disadvantage. Their
                   120                                                                                               analysts—among the financial com-
                                                                                                                     munity’s most respected—have pro-
                    80
                                                                                                                     jected that oil demand could peak by
                    40                                                                                               2036, the result of a “tectonic” shift
                     0
                                                                                                                     in transportation toward electric and
                         2017               2020                              2025                            2030   autonomous vehicles.

                                                                                                                     W
                         Passenger battery electric vehicle     Passenger plug-in hybrid electric vehicle                        hile Canada’s oil and gas
                         Light duty battery electric vehicle     Light duty plug-in hybrid electric vehicle
                         Buses battery electric vehicle     Buses plug-in hybrid electric vehicle                                sector remains focused on
                         Trucks battery electric vehicle     Trucks plug-in hybrid electric vehicle                              doing what they’ve always
                                                                                                                     done, other businesses are moving ag-
     Source: International Energy Agency, Global Electric Vehicle Outlook 2018                                       gressively to seize part of the growing
                                                                                                                     global market for low-carbon goods
     BYD, China’s leading EV maker. (BYD                                the number of available models will          and services—now worth $5.8 trillion
     will also supply Seattle with electric                             grow to 217. And that number will            and growing by 3 per cent a year.
     garbage trucks early next year.)                                   keep ticking up as more and more             Toronto-based     Hydrogenics     and
     As momentum      builds, so too do pro-                            vehicle companies set new targets for        Vancouver-based Ballard Power, for
           3.5                                                          model offerings and electric car sales.
     jections for the rapid uptake of EVs                                                                            example, produce fuel cells that con-
     around3 the world. In its most recent Evolution is also underway among                                          vert hydrogen into clean electricity.
     outlook,
           2.5 the International Energy         the world’s largest publicly traded oil                              Growing Chinese and European de-
     Agency projected there could be as and gas companies. Total, a top play-                                        mand have been a boon for them, in
     many 2.
        millions

             as 228 million EVs on the road er in solar and battery power, aims for                                  applications ranging from forklifts to
     by 2030,
           1.5 including passenger vehi-        low-carbon business to account for                                   trains and buses.
     cles, commercial vehicles, buses and 20 per cent of its portfolio by 2035.                                      Also based in Vancouver, all-electric
             1
     trucks. Counting electric two- and Statoil has made big investments in                                          bus company GreenPower has joined
     three-wheelers—which
            .5                 are incredibly offshore wind power, drawing on its                                    traditional Canadian bus companies
     popular in developing countries— experience with offshore oil drilling;                                         including Lion and New Flyer in of-
             0
     that would add2013another 585
                                 2014million 2015
                                                the company  2016         2017 roughly
                                                                plans to invest                                      fering electric buses to the growing
     vehicles. TheChina
                     sum total?   Closing
                               Europe      in   C$16
                                            United     billion in
                                                   States          renewables by 2030.
                                                                Others                                               number of transit agencies around
     on a billion EVs on the road in a little And BP is once again investing heav-                                   the world that are looking to clean
     over a decade.                             ily in solar, wind and biofuels.                                     up their fleets.
     It’s little wonder these projections                               Perhaps most significant are the             And Canada’s two largest auto parts
     are sending shockwaves through the                                 moves by Shell, whose CEO, Ben               makers—Magna and Linamar—have
     auto and oil sectors—driving an ac-                                van Beurden, put it bluntly last year:       both diversified into EVs. Just this
     celerating evolution of their business                             “Societal acceptance of the energy           past June, Magna signed a deal with
     models and product offerings.                                      system as we have it is just disap-          China’s BAIC Group—the parent
                                                                        pearing.” His next car, he said, will        company of Beijing Electric Vehicle
                                                                        be electric, but that’s just the tip of      Co.—to build electric cars in China.
                                                                        the melting iceberg. Shell announced         While this accelerating transition
                                                                        last year that it will be investing up       poses challenges to oil companies, it
     General Motors        As of 2019, all        Volkswagen has
     will introduce 20     new Volvo cars         pledged 20 electric   to $2 billion annually in clean energy       offers new opportunities for the min-
     new EVs over the      will be fully          models by 2020
     next six years.       electric or hybrids.   and 300 by 2030.      by 2020—while also divesting all of          ing industry due to growing demand
                                                                        its Canadian oilsands assets. These          for a range of metals needed for EVs
                                                                        investments and acquisitions span            and their batteries. As the CEO of the

     B
            y Bloomberg New Energy Fi-                                  EV charging networks in the U.K., hy-        Mining Association of Canada re-
            nance’s count, at the end of                                drogen refuelling stations—including         cently noted, “For the mining sector,
            2017 there were 156 electric                                here in Canada—and wind, solar and           a shift to a low-carbon economy has
     car models to choose from, up from                                 other renewable energy technologies          a lot of potential upsides because the
     just 97 at the start of 2016. By 2020,                             around the world.                            kinds of materials that are going to

     Policy
17
       Global Metals and Materials Demand from EV Lithium-Ion Batteries                      What does all this boil down to for
                                                                                             Canada?
            2500K                                                                            The very real risk of falling behind.
                                                                                             Not fully seizing a world-shifting
                                                                                             opportunity.
                                                                                             Clean growth is more than an goal—
            1500K                                                                            it’s a reality. As the world combats cli-
                                                                                             mate change, growth is shifting away
         tons

                                                                                             from century-old fuels and technolo-
                                                                                             gies toward clean energy solutions.
                500K                                                                         We would be wise to prioritize pres-
                                                                                             ent trends over past ones—with an
                                                                                             eye to the future.
                       2015 ’16 ’17 ’18 ’19 ’20 ’21 ’22 ’23 ’24 ’25 ’26 ’27 ’28 ’29 2030
                                                                                             Whether or not more pipelines
                  Graphite    Nickel   Aluminum    Copper    Lithium   Cobalt   Manganese    should be pursued, the global energy
                                                                                             transition is happening with or with-
       Source: Bloomberg New Energy Finance                                                  out us. And Canadians don’t want to
                                                                                             be left behind.
       be needed will grow exponentially.”            thirds said Canada should prioritize   Dan Woynillowicz is the policy director
       Canadians understand the need to               other ways of growing our economy.     of Clean Energy Canada at Simon
       transition. When asked about the best          In a follow-up survey, 74 per cent     Fraser University.
       way forward for Canada’s economy in            agreed that the pace of innovation     dan@cleanergycanada.org
       an Abacus Data public opinion sur-             in new forms of energy is quick, and   Merran Smith is the executive director of
       vey last year, just one third suggested        Canada must be part of this new en-    Clean Energy Canada and serves on the
       Canada should prioritize promoting             ergy revolution—and not fall behind    board of the Canadian Climate Forum.
       the use of Canada’s oil and gas. Two-          because of a reliance on oil.          merran@cleanenergycanada.org

                                                                                   LEADING BY EXAMPLE
                                                                                   The Canadian forest products
                                                                                   industry has been leading the way
                                                                                   to advance the development of
                                                                                   clean technology innovation for a
                                                                                   clean energy, zero-waste
                                                                                   bioeconomy future.

                                                                                   Learn more at fpac.ca

THE FOREST PRODUCTS ASSOCIATION OF CANADA (FPAC) provides a voice for Canada’s wood, pulp, and paper
producers nationally and internationally in government, trade, and environmental affairs.
18

     In Clean Tech, Consumers Will
     Set the Pace of Change
     The last decade has seen myriad political and regulatory re-                           systems is proving more difficult. The
                                                                                            reality, when we look at type of extrac-
     sponses attempting to address population anxiety provoked                              tion, is that it is here to stay (U.S. un-
     by increasingly dire scientific assessments of environmental                           conventional-oil production—frack-
     realities. At the same time, global demand for fossil fuels has                        ing, oil sands and other non-drilled
                                                                                            product—rose from almost nothing
     in-creased as people in developing countries accede to middle                          in 2007 to 3.7 million barrels a day in
     class consumption habits. As our energy landscape adjusts                              2014) but it is vehemently opposed in
                                                                                            many jurisdictions for fear of ground
     to these competing forces, choices made by consumers will
                                                                                            water and aquifer contamination.
     decide which new technologies thrive and which do not.
                                                                                            The great hope 10 years ago was for
                                                                                            energy efficiency as the greater mitiga-
                                                                                            tor. Innovation has come faster than
                                                                                            McKinsey predicted and the deter-
     Dan Gagnier                                “Photovoltaic (PV) installations [so-
                                                                                            mining factor underlying this faster
                                                lar panels] have taken off much faster

     W
                                                                                            pace is consumer behaviour; cheap
                 ith the political and trade    than we expected,” according to McK-
                                                                                            mobile communications, for example,
                 realms in disarray, disrup-    insey. In fact, the compression of costs
                                                                                            are enabling the connected home. In
                 tion is the new normal.        happened throughout the solar-energy
                                                system, from sourcing raw materials to      addition, hardware costs have fallen.
     Add to this the impacts of climate
                                                manufacturing to installation and ser-      For example, LED bulbs now cost
     change and the dizzying pace of tech-
                                                vice. McKinsey expected costs to fall       about $12 each, down by 80 per cent
     nological innovation and it’s little
                                                to $2.40 per watt by 2030 but weren’t       from 2010.
     wonder that people are increasingly
     exercising their ability to choose what    bullish enough; “in fact, they are on       In fact, people are already making
     they can; the way they want to con-        course to hit $1.60 per watt by 2020.”      clean-tech choices as they build/
     nect, the manner in which they con-        On wind-generated power and tur-            renovate and rent accommodations
     sume their news and watch every-           bines, the projected global base of         and professional space. And why
     thing from movies to each other.           94 gigawatts installed in 2007 would        not? These systems are re-liable, user
                                                expand to 800 gigawatts by 2030. As         friendly and in line with peoples’ in-
     Clean tech falls into that burgeoning                                                  creasing expectations for an inter-con-
                                                with solar, growth has been faster
     array of choice. It is a term generally                                                nected world.
                                                than expected—another proof point
     used to define a set of technologies

                                                                                            W
                                                demonstrating the ability of consum-
     that either reduce or optimize the
                                                ers, with or without state incentives,
     use of natural re-sources, while at the
                                                to move to new technology. By 2014,                   hat about the future?
     same time reducing the negative effect
                                                McKinsey estimated a 22 per cent in-
     that technology has on the planet and      crease or—370 gigawatts—of installed        In the International Energy Agency’s
     its ecosystems.                            capacity compared to its prediction         latest outlook for renewable energy, it
     A 2007 Study by McKinsey & Compa-          for 2014. The same consumption/             projects renewables growing by about
     ny looked at a number of potentially       cost trajectory has applied to batteries,   1,000 gigawatts—or 43 per cent—by
     disruptive technologies and assessed       electric and hybrid cars. Lower costs,      2022. The report points out that this
     their prospects. It is worth noting just   improved manfacturers’ maintenance          equals about half of the current global
     how accurate these forecasts were by       protocols and turbine efficiency have       capacity in coal power, which took 80
     the end of 2017. Many jurisdictions        combined to push adoption rates for         years to build.
     without the resources or infrastructure    clean tech.                                 Part of the IEA’s analysis leads us to
     enjoyed by countries such as Canada        With both traditional and unconven-         consider the probability that renew-
     encourage and incentivize the instal-      tional oil and gas production encoun-       able energy could replace 25 per cent
     lation of solar panels with the grid       tering ground level as well as policy       of the world’s coal power within half
     buying surplus to supply and increase      protests, demand for oil and gas is         a decade—a growth rate that should
     generation capacity.                       still rising but delivering new delivery    worry coal investors. (See Next Gen-

     Policy
19
eration. Renewable Energy Comes at You      mercialization of new technology in-      made be-tween a healthy environ-
Fast, by Liam Denning, 2017.)               creases our competitiveness and im-       ment and a healthy economy—both
                                            proves our living standard.               of which depend on well-defended
Similarly, IEA projects the share of re-

                                            S
                                                                                      and managed IP.”
newable energy in the world’s electric-           o, how does Canada stack up? It
                                                                                      While policies and regulations can set
ity mix to rise from about 24 per cent            will surprise few to learn that
                                                                                      the stage for new or better choices re-
in 2016 to 29 per cent by 2022. This              Denmark, Finland and Sweden
                                                                                      garding how we use energy, transport
is still bigger than the entire electric-   take the gold, silver and bronze med-
                                                                                      and house ourselves, in the final anal-
ity consumption of China, India and         als on clean tech in the WWF 2017
                                                                                      ysis, consumers have to exercise their
Germany combined.                           Index. Canada and the U.S. complete
                                                                                      prerogatives. Technology and applica-
                                            the top five. Canada and Nor-way do
                                                                                      tions that turn our home appliances,
                                            get favorable mention as coming from
          IEA projects the share            18th and 25th respectively to amongst
                                                                                      lighting at a distance and intelligent
                                                                                      security systems are an easy jump for
          of renewable energy               the top four for improvements in driv-
                                                                                      a population on tablets, smart phones
in the world’s electricity mix              ing their national clean tech ecosys-
                                                                                      and computers. Businesses and insti-
                                            tems forward.
to rise from about 24 per                                                             tutions push us into internet banking
                                            As an ex-board member of Sustainable
cent in 2016 to 29 per cent                                                           and using our tablets/phones to pay
                                            Development Technology Canada             for goods, services and even for pro-
by 2022. This is still bigger               (SDTC) I was fortunate to see over a      cessing our cheques and receivables.
than the entire electricity                 decade the evolution in how we orga-      As a majority of people sign on, disrup-
consumption of China, India                 nized ourselves and came to grips with    tion will impact the poor, elderly and
and Germany combined.                       the challenges around innovation,         other minorities who exist off these
                                            research and commercialization of         systems. There are already two types
                                            promising energy technologies. SDTC       of people left behind by disruption:
                                            clean tech companies now employ           Those who have problems grasping
                                            more than 180,000 Canadians and           and adapting to technology, and the
In studies such as the Word Wildlife        generate some $26 billion in goods        economically disadvantaged who can-
                                            and services. When combined with          not afford today’s technology, never
Fund’s Clean Tech Survey, certain
                                            other agencies and providers, it is a     mind facing fast-paced introduction
trends jump out in terms of both appli-
                                            welcome reality that at fourth in over-   of new applications. With inequality
cability, economic/investment choices
                                            all scoring, Canada has strong results    already a growing problem, the issue
and sustain-ability options. There is
                                            for clean tech.                           of technological disenfranchisement
still a considerable space open to large
                                            We need to continue to create clean       will likely only exacerbate it.
public transit projects such as sustain-
able and energy-independent office          tech funds, provide public funding to     As we move through the next decade
complexes. Developers are erecting          supplement private sources from all       the introduction of more and more
buildings that serve as urban agricul-      levels, and encourage and facilitate      impressive clean technology har-
                                            early entrepreneurship. Our weak-         nessed by entrepreneurs and venture
tural producers and CO2 mitigators.
                                            ness is our limited number of clean       capitalists will pro-vide new, better
The natural advantage in terms of in-       tech organizations and clusters. My       and more numerous choices at differ-
frastructure enjoyed by renewable en-       take-away from looking at many suc-       ent price segments. How Canadians
ergy projects employing clean tech lies     cess stories in this sector is that we    exercise choice will create business
in the ability to expand through mod-       have the ability, the brains and the      opportunities and drive investments.
ular applications. These projects, wind,    entrepreneurs. We need to increase        In our regulatory world legislators will
solar, tidal, biomass etc. are capable of   our efforts and increase our ability to   have a challenge keeping up. Con-
starting on one scale and moving to         commercialize the offerings of our in-    sumer consumption and purchasing
expansion by adding modules.                novators and entrepreneurs.               decisions will determine the pace of
                                            The 2018 SDTC Clean tech Leader-          that direction as well as its economic
It would have seemed like science fic-      ship Summit Report says it eloquent-      underpinnings.
tion a decade ago but the technology        ly: “A record 13 Canadian clean tech      Dan Gagnier was a deputy minister as
exists today to deliver these options       companies made the 2017 Global            well as a chief of staff to Liberal premiers
and will only improve as innovators         Clean tech Innovation Index, earning      in Ontario and Quebec. He was also
and entrepreneurs continue innovat-         the country a top-four ranking. Those     Senior VP of Alcan for Environment,
ing. The role of municipal, provincial/     achievements in a highly competitive      Health and Safety, a board member
state and national governments is to        global marketplace are testament to       of SDTC (Sustainable Development
facilitate change and encourage the         the innovation power of clean tech        Technology Canada) and ex-chair of
right choices. Incentivizing research,      firms and to the government’s as-         the IISD (International Institute for
demonstration projects and com-             sertion that there is no choice to be     Sustainable Development).

                                                                                                    September/October 2018
20

     Ship to rail at Halifax Harbour. Intermodal transport significantly reduces GHG emissions. CN photo

     Rail—Pulling Toward a
     Cleaner Future
     Transportation accounts for 28 per cent of Canada’s                                                   Janet Drysdale

                                                                                                           A
     GHG emissions, but railways generate only 5 per cent of                                                      s one of the most efficient and
     that, or just 1 per cent of the country’s emissions. CN,                                                     environmentally friendly ways
     North America’s largest railway, leads the industry with                                                     to move goods, rail has tre-
                                                                                                           mendous potential to reduce the en-
     fuel consumption 15 per cent below the industry aver-                                                 vironmental impact of freight trans-
     age. In 2017 alone, renewable fuels resulted in the rail-                                             portation by offering sustainable
                                                                                                           transportation solutions today and
     way producing 79,000 tonnes less carbon. Rail is clearly                                              into the future. On average, freight
     a sustainable choice in transportation.                                                               trains are approximately four times
                                                                                                           more fuel efficient than trucks. Rail
                                                                                                           can move a tonne of freight more than
                                                                                                           200 kilometers on a single litre of fuel

     Policy
21
and a single train can remove more                Intermodal helps lower transportation costs by
than 300 trucks from our congested
road and highway network.
                                                  allowing each mode to be used for the portion
                                          of the trip to which it is best suited. But it goes beyond
Canada’s transportation sector gen-       cost savings. Effective intermodal service also helps
erates approximately 28 per cent
of the country’s GHG emissions,
                                          reduce emissions by up to 75 per cent by shifting long
however railways produce just 5 per       haul truck traffic to rail.
cent of that total, and one per cent
of the country’s overall GHG emis-
sions. Intermodal freight shipping
combines the resources of different
transportation modes, such as truck-
ing and rail, to move products from       controllers are continuously being       Tonnage Analyzer (HPTA). Leverag-
the manufacturing site to their final     trained on best practices for fuel       ing data from locomotive telemetry
destination. Intermodal helps lower       conservation, including locomotive       systems, the HPTA tool was built
transportation costs by allowing          shutdowns in our yards, streamlined      in-house and gives crews instruc-
each mode to be used for the portion      railcar handling, train pacing, coast-   tions and real-time monitoring al-
of the trip to which it is best suited.                                            lowing them to use only the loco-
                                          ing and braking strategies. For ex-
But it goes beyond cost savings. Ef-                                               motive power needed during that
                                          ample, in 2016, we decreased train
fective intermodal service also helps                                              trip, by optimizing a locomotive’s
                                          idling by 14 per cent.
reduce emissions by up to 75 per cent                                              horsepower-to-tonnage ratio. In ad-
by shifting long haul truck traffic to                                             dition, we use Trip Optimizer, which
rail. According to the Railway As-                 With approximately              regulates the speed of a train by
sociation of Canada, “A 10 per cent                84 per cent of our              controlling the locomotive throttle
shift in truck traffic to rail would      carbon emissions                         and braking system, and computes
translate to a 3.7-megatonne reduc-       generated from rail                      the most efficient manner to handle
tion in carbon emissions in Canada,                                                the train. The Locomotive Telemetry
while 15 per cent would result in a
                                          operations, our focus is
                                                                                   System collects data to drive im-
5.6-megatonne reduction.”                 to continuously improve                  proved locomotive and train perfor-
                                          locomotive fuel efficiency.              mance, including fuel conservation.
We recognize our responsibility to
provide a more sustainable transpor-
                                          Operating efficiently has                The use of distributed power, where
                                                                                   a locomotive is placed further back
tation service to our customers while     been the hallmark of our
                                                                                   in the train, is another technology
minimizing the impacts of our op-         success and CN continues                 used to improve train handling and
erations. With approximately 84 per       to lead the North American               fuel efficiency.
cent of our carbon emissions gener-
                                          rail industry, consuming
ated from rail operations, our focus is                                            Our rail fuel efficiency innovative
to continuously improve locomotive        approximately 15 per cent                mindset extends to all aspects of
fuel efficiency. Operating efficiently    less fuel per gross tonne                our business. For example, routing
has been the hallmark of our success      mile than the industry                   protocols facilitate the movement
and CN continues to lead the North        average.                                 of customer shipments in the most
American rail industry, consuming                                                  efficient way. We also collaborate
approximately 15 per cent less fuel                                                with ports and terminal operators
per gross tonne mile than the indus-                                               to minimize dwell times and fur-
try average.                                                                       ther drive efficiency. Together with
                                          Furthermore, the installation of fuel-   other technologies and initiatives,
Our unique operating model allows                                                  we have achieved fuel efficiency im-
us to move more freight in a tight, re-   efficient technologies and big data
                                          management analytics capabilities        provements between 2008 and 2017
liable and efficient operation for our                                             that have avoided 5 million tonnes
customers. We continue to purchase        are helping us reduce our carbon
                                                                                   of carbon emissions.
new locomotives that meet stricter        footprint. Our Fuel Productivity
regulatory emissions standards, pro-      team uses a variety of technologies      The growth of the renewable fuel
ducing less air contaminants while        to improve locomotive fuel effi-         market has presented an impor-
being more fuel efficient. In 2018,       ciency and a key focus of this strat-    tant opportunity for CN to further
we announced the purchase of 200          egy is putting just the right amount     reduce our emissions by using bio-
new high-horsepower locomotives,          of locomotive power on each train        diesel blends in our locomotive fleet.
and our train crews and rail traffic      using what we call our Horsepower        In 2017, the use of renewable fuels

                                                                                               September/October 2018
22

                                                 O
     saved over 79,000 tonnes of carbon.                  ne example is Kruger Prod-      build our homes, the cars we drive,
     In the coming years, we look forward                 ucts, Canada’s largest pro-     the appliances that make our lives
     to working with our suppliers to ex-                 ducer of consumer tissue        easier, the products that improve
     plore the use of renewable fuels.           brands. John O’Hara, Kruger’s Vice       our quality of life, and the energy to
                                                 President of Business Planning and       power our activities. Many of these
     As we prepare for the future, our con-      Logistics has said: “Our ecological      goods are being transformed into
     nections with our customers, supply         footprint is linked with our cor-        more sustainable products, enabling
     chain partners and governments are          porate strategy. CN’s leadership in      us to play a key role as the backbone
     enabling us to deliver sustainable          sustainable practices, like the Eco-     of the clean economy. We also con-
     and profitable business that drives         Connexions program, allows us to         tinue to engage with our customers
     economic prosperity in a low carbon         partner with them to reduce our car-     to strengthen our position within
     environment. As a true backbone of          bon footprint and eliminate waste        cleaner energy markets and thanks
     the economy, CN is committed to             in our supply chains. As a result, our   to innovation by our customers,
     playing a key role in the transition        partnership has grown dramatically
                                                                                          we are now moving cleaner energy
     to a lower carbon economy. Over the         over the last five years.”
                                                                                          products like wood pellets, wood
     past 25 years, we have reduced our
                                                                                          chips, wind turbine components, so-
     locomotive emission intensity by 40
                                                          Routing protocols               lar panels, as well as biofuel.
     per cent, resulting in the avoidance
     of over 30 million tonnes of carbon,                 facilitate the                  Through the use of greener and
     while achieving record growth in            movement of customer                     cleaner technologies and more
     the volume of freight we move. Our
     approach is to reduce the carbon in-
                                                 shipments in the most                    efficient operating practices, rail-
                                                                                          roads are constantly improving and
     tensity of our business progressively       efficient way. We also
                                                                                          committed to even greater environ-
     over time and at a pace that’s consis-      collaborate with ports and               mental excellence in the years to
     tent with the objective of stabilizing      terminal operators to                    come. By moving sustainable prod-
     global temperature.
                                                 minimize dwell times and                 ucts, including cleaner energy sourc-

     W
                 e are also working with
                                                 further drive efficiency.                es, we are playing an important role
                                                                                          as a backbone of the clean econo-
                 many of our customers to        Together with other
                                                                                          my and the lifeblood of healthier
                 measure and help them           technologies and initiatives,            communities.
     reduce their transportation supply          we have achieved fuel
     chain GHG emissions by leveraging                                                    Janet Drysdale is a Vice-President at
                                                 efficiency improvements                  CN with responsibility for providing
     rail for the long haul and trucking
     over shorter distances. The greater
                                                 between 2008 and 2017                    strategic direction and leadership for the
     use of combined transport helps low-        that have avoided 5 million              company’s sustainability strategy.
     er transportation costs by allowing         tonnes of carbon emissions.              deliveringresponsibly@cn.ca
     each mode to be used for the portion
     of the trip to which it is best suited
     and also helps reduce emissions,
     traffic congestion, accidents and the
     burden on overstressed transporta-          These efforts reach much further as
     tion infrastructure.                        great strides have been made over
                                                 the years engaging our employees,
     Launched in partnership with Tree
                                                 customers and communities through
     Canada in 2014, CN’s EcoConnexions
                                                 our EcoConnexions program to con-
     partnership program aims to both
                                                 serve energy, reduce waste and im-
     partner with and recognize custom-
                                                 prove biodiversity through reforesta-
     ers who are committed to building an        tion. In recent years, we have been
     efficient and more sustainable future.      responsible for planting 1.8 million
     Each year, customers are invited to         trees and shrubs in Canada and the
     partake in the program and submis-          U.S., making us the leading private
     sions are evaluated based on sustain-       non-forestry company tree planter
     able policies, energy efficiency, report-   in Canada.
     ing to the CDP, and modal shift. Since
     2015, we have planted 310,000 trees         Furthermore, every year, we handle
     to recognize 32 of our customers for        over 300 million tonnes of cargo
     their sustainable business practices.       from the food we eat, the wood to

     Policy
23

Digitalization:
The Path to Sustainability
As Canada adapts to the Fourth Industrial Revolution,                               tically across the globe. We should
                                                                                    focus on using all the digital tools
the necessities of clean growth, sustainability and global                          at our command to expand the ben-
competitiveness demand the innovation and implementa-                               efits of earlier industrial revolutions
                                                                                    to even more people while revers-
tion of connected solutions. ABB is a technology leader in                          ing any negative consequences. That
power grids, electrification products, industrial automa-                           means greening the grid, electrifying
tion and robotics, serving customers in utilities, industry                         transportation and combating cli-
                                                                                    mate change with smarter infrastruc-
and transport and infrastructure.                                                   ture. As the digital wave progresses,
                                                                                    we should all embrace it as it becomes
                                                                                    the new normal.

Nathalie Pilon                            current (HVDC) connection, enables
                                                                                             We should focus on
                                          clean, renewable energy, generated

W
             e are living through a so-   in Newfoundland and Labrador to be                 using all the digital
             cioeconomic revolution       transmitted to the North American         tools at our command to
             amid competing pressures     grid in Nova Scotia reducing depen-       expand the benefits of earlier
of sustainability, energy concerns,       dence on fossil fuels. The link made
and the fourth industrial revolu-         history on December 8, 2017, by con-
                                                                                    industrial revolutions to even
tion—the meshing of people and ma-        ducting the first exchange of electric-   more people while reversing
chines as internet meets production.      ity between the islands of Newfound-      any negative consequences.
Never has there been a better time for    land and Cape Breton, Nova Scotia.        That means greening the
leaders to adopt sustainable business     The stabilizing features of ABB’s solu-
practices by taking ownership of the      tion allow Nova Scotia to integrate
                                                                                    grid, electrifying trans-
digital space and becoming connec-        additional renewables such as wind        portation and combating
tors, and for the federal government      power and contribute to Canada’s          climate change with smarter
to support our digital economy and        emission-reduction efforts.               infrastructure.
its players.
                                          Technology innovation has been the
Canada has what it takes to become a      core mission of ABB for more than
digital champion, and our industrial      130 years and year after year, ABB

                                                                                    D
sectors are flowing with untapped         generates digital solutions for its                igital systems that run
potential. Energy is a foundational       partners worldwide, all in the name                industrial plants and instal-
pillar of our economy. Ten per cent       of clean energy. The rationale behind              lations to maximize uptime,
of Canada’s gross domestic product        this is simple. ABB supports clean        speed, production and quality, indus-
is due to hydroelectric clean power,      economy and sustainability with a         trial automation products are specifi-
while the balance of the energy needs     unified, cross-platform digital offer-    cally designed to deliver collaborative
of our economic players in industrial     ing. Our technology solutions envi-       operations, cyber security solutions
and infrastructure relies increasingly    sion ways to take our customers and       and digital systems to manage entire
on power sustainability. The clean        stakeholders in public infrastructure     plants and factories.
electricity that hydropower supplies      to the next level.
                                                                                    Canada is one of the largest mining
to Canadians supports the growth of
                                          As society adjusts to the Fourth In-      nations in the world. As such, it is
industry, commerce, infrastructure
                                          dustrial Revolution, which merges         only normal that the Canadian min-
and communities.
                                          the physical and digital worlds, it’s     ing industry turns to digitalization
In May 2018, ABB commissioned a           our collective responsibility to build    to increase its productivity and join
historic power interconnector in Can-     on the accomplishments of previous        our country’s commitment to reduce
ada. The Maritime Link project, a 500     industrial revolutions, which over        carbon emissions. ABB is helping
megawatt (MW) high-voltage direct         the last century improved life dras-      to build the first electric and digital

                                                                                                 September/October 2018
You can also read