Hutt Valley FOCUS ON LEGAL PRACTICE IN THE - New Zealand Law Society

Page created by Dawn Wade
 
CONTINUE READING
Hutt Valley FOCUS ON LEGAL PRACTICE IN THE - New Zealand Law Society
I S S U E 9 3 1 · A u g us t 2 0 1 9

                                       FOCUS ON LEGAL
                                       PRACTICE IN THE
                                       Hutt Valley

                                       Professor          Can we improve   Disclosure of      Supporting
                                       Penelope Mathew,   jury trials      information to     someone who
                                       Auckland Law                        beneficiaries of   has a mental
                                       School Dean                         family trusts      illness

                                       Page 16            Page 23          Page 34            Page 42
Hutt Valley FOCUS ON LEGAL PRACTICE IN THE - New Zealand Law Society
fortyeightshortland.co.nz

 An opportunity has arisen
 for additional members
 to join our chambers.
 FortyEight Shortland Barristers       To enquire or obtain more information about us,
 is a leading civil and commercial     please contact Kellie Arthur on +64 9 972 2052,
 set located in Auckland’s             +64 21 784 080, or email kelliearthur@fortyeightshortland.co.nz,
 Vero Centre.                          or contact a member directly.

 Our members have a wealth of          We look forward to hearing from you: Kellie, Steve, Mark,
 expertise across civil, commercial,   Bret, Greg, Rob, Tim and Carole.
 regulatory law and equity.
                                       Level 34, Vero Centre, 48 Shortland Street, Auckland.

Healthy                                               Law is a fulfilling profession, but it can

Mind
                                                      also be a stressful one. Practising Well
                                                      aims to provide a starting point for any
                                                      lawyer who is concerned about their
                                                      own welfare or that of their colleague.
                                                      The New Zealand Law Society has
Healthy                                               three partners involved in its Practising

Body                                                  Well programme. They are:
                                                      • Lifeline Aotearoa – healthy mind
                                                      • Vitality Works – healthy body
                                                      • Business Mentors – healthy practice
Healthy

Practice
                                                     lawsociety.org.nz/practising-well
Hutt Valley FOCUS ON LEGAL PRACTICE IN THE - New Zealand Law Society
Our
commitment
At MAS, we’re committed to doing what we can to
make a positive impact on the health and wellbeing
of future generations of New Zealanders, and to a
more sustainable country.
It’s why we’ve implemented a socially responsible investing approach
across $1.4 billion of superannuation funds and insurance reserves
and do not invest in the manufacture and sale of armaments, tobacco,
or the exploration, extraction, refining and processing fossil fuels.

Talk to us about our socially responsible
Retirement Savings and KiwiSaver plans today
by calling 0800 800 627 or visit mas.co.nz

                    A BEQUEST TO THOSE
                    WHO NEED IT MOST
                    A Bequest to the Society of St Vincent              The Society is a Catholic organisation
                    de Paul is a lasting way to help the                which recently celebrated 150 years
                    most disadvantaged and needy in                     of compassion and service to the
                    our community.                                      people of New Zealand. Your
                                                                        Bequest will ensure the Society’s
                    We have a nationwide network of
                                                                        vital work of charity and justice
                    workers and helpers who provide
                                                                        continues to thrive.
                    practical assistance every day to people
                    in desperate situations. Help is offered            Be assured it will make a huge
                    to all, regardless of origin, cultural              difference where the need is greatest.
                    background or religious belief.

                                                                                Society of St Vincent de Paul
                    If you would like to discuss a                              Freepost 992, PO Box 10-815
                     Bequest with us, please give                                    Wellington 6143
                    us a call or send us an email.                                    TEL:04 499 5070
                                                                                      national@svdp.org.nz
                                                                                 EMAIL:
                                                                                    WEB: www.svdp.org.nz
Hutt Valley FOCUS ON LEGAL PRACTICE IN THE - New Zealand Law Society
16
                                                    9

                                                                      New Zealand Law Society                              23 · Can we improve jury trials?
                                                                6 · From the Law Society                                        ▹ BY CHRIS MACKLIN
                                                                7 · New Zealand Law Society                                27 · Further developments in
                                                                                                                                franchising restraint of trade
                                                                      People in the Law                                         clauses ▹ BY DEIRDRE WATSON
                                                              11 · On the move                                             30 · Domestic violence and
                                                              16 · Professor Penelope Mathew                                    immigration policy
                                                  68
                                                  31               ▹ BY TEUILA FUATAI                                           ▹ BY POOJA SUNDAR
                                                              19 · Law firm tips the scales and                            31 · Finding international consensus
                                                                   takes out gender diversity                                   on ISDS ▹ BY MICHAEL HANSBY
                                                                   award ▹ BY NICK BUTCHER                                 34 · Perspectives on the disclosure
                                                              20 · The Innovators: Michael                                      of information to beneficiaries of
                                                                   Heron QC ▹ BY ANDREW KING                                    family trusts ▹ BY HENRY BRANDTS-
                                                                                                                                   GIESEN AND DAVID WERDIGER
                                                                      Update                                               37 · “ Ten dollar” trusts
                                                              22 · Animal welfare watchdog                                      ▹ BY ALISON GILBERT
                                                                   needed, study finds
                                                                   ▹ BY LYNDA HAGEN

                                                  88
                                                  54

A B O U T L AW TA L K
                                                              Society is required to assist and promote the reform of      practising lawyers each month after publication. Receipt
LawTalk is published monthly by the New Zealand Law           the law, for the purpose of upholding the rule of law and    of the hardcopy LawTalk may be cancelled by emailing
Society for the legal profession. It has been published       facilitating the administration of justice in New Zealand.   subscriptions@lawsociety.org.nz and stating “please
since 1974 and is available to every New Zealand-based                                                                     cancel LawTalk hardcopy” and advising name, lawyer ID
                                                              S U B M I S S I O N O F M AT E R I A L
lawyer who holds a current practising certificate.                                                                         (lawyer login), workplace and address.
                                                              All contributions, letters and inquiries about submission
DISCLAIMER                                                                                                                 SUBSCRIPTIONS
                                                              of articles should be directed to the Managing Editor,
Unless it is clearly indicated, the views expressed in        editor@lawsociety.org.nz.                                    Non-lawyers and lawyers based outside New Zealand
LawTalk are not to be taken as those of, or endorsed by the                                                                may subscribe to LawTalk by emailing subscriptions@
                                                              ADVERTISING
New Zealand Law Society. No responsibility whatsoever is                                                                   lawsociety.org.nz. Annual subscriptions in New Zealand
accepted by the New Zealand Law Society for any opinion,      Advertising inquiries should be directed to advertising@     are NZ$145 for 11 issues (GST and postage included).
information, or advertisement contained in LawTalk.           lawsociety.org.nz. Information on rates, deadlines and       Overseas rates are available on request.
                                                              conditions is available on the Law Society website under
A B O U T T H E L AW S O C I E T Y                                                                                         E N V I R O N M E N TA L S TAT E M E N T
                                                              News and Communications/LawTalk. The Law Society
The New Zealand Law Society was established on                has a strict policy of not publishing articles in exchange   LawTalk is printed on Sumo Matte. This is an
3 September 1869. It regulates the practice of law in         for advertising.                                             environmentally responsible paper. Forestry Stewardship
New Zealand and represents lawyers who choose to be                                                                        Council (FSC) certified, it is produced using Elemental
                                                              L AW TA L K O N L I N E
members. The powers and functions of the Law Society                                                                       Chlorine Free (ECF) Mixed Source pulp from Responsible
are set out in the Lawyers and Conveyancers Act 2006. As      An online version of LawTalk is available on the New         Sources and manufactured under the strict ISO14001
well as upholding the fundamental obligations imposed         Zealand Law Society’s website at www.lawsociety.org.         Environmental Management System. The FSC is an
on lawyers who provide regulated services, the Law            nz. A link to the latest online LawTalk is emailed to all    international non-profit, multi-stakeholder organisation

4
Hutt Valley FOCUS ON LEGAL PRACTICE IN THE - New Zealand Law Society
Contents
        Alternative Dispute                                   52 · In-house legal – A force                                               Classifieds
        Resolution                                                 to be reckoned with                                           70 · Will notices
38 · Cognitive biases: challenging                                 ▹ BY GABRIELLE O'BRIEN                                        71 · Legal Jobs
     the way we think, part 4                                 54 · The court system grinds on                                    73 · CPD Calendar
     ▹ BY PAUL SILLS                                               slowly… ▹ BY JOHN BURN
40 · How do you start a relationship                                                                                                      Lifestyle
     property arbitration?                                            Sustainable Practice                                       76 · A New Zealand Legal
     ▹ BY ROBERT FISHER QC                                    56 · Some thoughts from a new                                           Crossword ▹ SET BY MĀYĀ
                                                                   EV owner ▹ BY GEOFF ADLAM                                     77 · One man’s Celtic
        Practising Well                                                                                                               Crusade …▹ BY JOCK ANDERSON
42 · Being a supporter: what it’s                             58 ·    Lawyers Complaints                                         82 · Civil rights in the United States:
     like to live with someone                                        Service                                                         using the law to get around
     who has a mental illness                                                                                                         the law ▹ BY JOHN BISHOP
                                                              	Technology
        Practice                                              61 · Libra rising ▹ BY DAMIAN                FUNNELL               86 ·     Tail end
44 · Focus On … The Hutt Valley                               62 · Digital forensics
     ▹ BY CRAIG STEPHEN                                            ▹ BY ADRIAN HAYES
50 · The importance of goals in
     civil litigation planning and                                    Legal History
     management by in-house                                   64 · Memories of the Auckland
     counsel ▹ BY JOHN MAASSEN                                     Magistrates’ Courts
                                                                   ▹ BY SIR IAN BARKER QC

which promotes responsible management of the world’s
forests. FSC certification is internationally recognised as   PEOPLE
the most rigorous environmental and social standard
for responsible forest management. The paper used to          P R E S I D E N T Tiana Epati              D I G I TA L C O N T E N T E D I T O R     SENIOR DESIGNER
produce LawTalk meets FSC requirements at all stages                                                     Craig Stephen · 04 463 2982                Andrew Jacombs · 04 463 2981
                                                              VICE PRESIDENTS
along the production cycle. The shrink wrap used for                                                     craig.stephen@lawsociety.org.nz            andrew.jacombs@lawsociety.org.nz
                                                              Nerissa Barber (Wellington)
delivery of LawTalk is 27 micron biodegradable film
                                                              Herman Visagie (Central North Island) L E G A L W R I T E R                           DESIGNER
manufactured in New Zealand. This degrades naturally.
                                                              Tim Jones (Auckland)                  Tracey Cormack · 04 463 2936                    Sophie Melligan
If you wish to discard LawTalk, please recycle it. The
                                                              Andrew Logan (South Island)                tracey.cormack@lawsociety.org.nz           sophie.melligan@lawsociety.org.nz
wrapping may be composted.
                                                              EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR                         C O M M U N I C AT I O N S A D V I S O R   JUNIOR DESIGNER
C O N TA C T D E TA I L S
                                                              Helen Morgan-Banda                         (SOCIAL MEDIA)                             Nina Gillanders
 PO Box 5041, Wellington 6140, New Zealand                                                             Jamie Dobson                               nina.gillanders@lawsociety.org.nz
                                                              MANAGING EDITOR AND
   DX SP 20202                                                                                           jamie.dobson@lawsociety.org.nz
                                                              C O M M U N I C AT I O N S M A N A G E R                                              A D V E RT I S I N G
                                                              Geoff Adlam · 04 463 2980                  WEBMASTER                                  Maria Pirela · 04 463 2905
                                                              editor@lawsociety.org.nz                   Miranda Kaye · 04 463 2990                 advertising@lawsociety.org.nz
                    ***** FPO *****                                                                      miranda.kaye@lawsociety.org.nz
                    Placeholder for                           SENIOR                                                                                PRINTING AND DISTRIBUTION
                                                              C O M M U N I C AT I O N S A D V I S O R   D I G I TA L C O N T E N T S P EC I A L I S T Blue Star, Petone, Wellington
                    FSC Certificate
 PLEASE                                                       Nick Butcher · 04 463 2910                 Angela Ludlow                              ISSN 0114-989X (Print)
                    ***** FPO *****
RECYCLE                                                       nick.butcher@lawsociety.org.nz             angela.ludlow@lawsociety.org.nz            ISSN 2382-0330 (Digital)

                                                                                                                                                                                        5
Hutt Valley FOCUS ON LEGAL PRACTICE IN THE - New Zealand Law Society
N E W Z E A L A N D L AW S O C I E T Y                                                A ugust 2 0 1 9 · L AW TA L K 9 3 1

        NEW ZEALAND LAW SOCIETY

From the Law Society

                                                                                       Other recommendations made
The Minister of Justice’s inde-                                                     by the Family Law Section and
pendent panel evaluating the 2014                                                   supported by the independent
reforms to the family justice system                                                panel included the appointment
has adopted almost all of the rec-                                                  of more Family Court judges and
ommendations made by the Law                                                        establishing the roles of the family
Society’s Family Law Section.                                                       justice service coordinators and
    The panel released its report to                                                senior Family Court registrars.
Minister of Justice Andrew Little on                                                   The Care of Children Act applica-
16 June, which included 70 recom-                                                   tions to the Family Court for par-
mendations to significantly improve                                                 enting and/or guardianship orders
the current family justice system.                                                  makes up a large percentage of the
The panel had consulted widely and                                                  work of the Family Court.
issued two discussion documents on                                                     The Family Court deals with
proposed changes before presenting                                                  cases that touch the lives of more
its final report to Mr Little.                                                      New Zealanders than any other
    The Family Law Section said in                                                  court. The significant delays in
both its submissions that imple-                                                    the Family Court that people
menting three key changes would                                                     experience are both frustrating
have an immediate positive effect                                                   and unacceptable so the appoint-
of the Family Court.                                                                ment of more Family Court judges
    First, making the Family Court                                                  as recommended will help to
responsible again for pre-court                                                     alleviate the current pressure on
processes, reinstating a limited                                                    the Family Court and increase the
number of counselling sessions                                                      amount of judge time available to
and making the Family Dispute                                                       hear cases, as will creating senior
Resolution service free, voluntary                                                  Family Court registrars and family
and more accessible.                                                                justice service coordinators.
    Second, parents must be allowed                                                    Looking forward, it’s important to
to have lawyers represent them in         This is all about   stress that whatever solutions emerge, they will only
all matters relating to parenting and     access to justice   work if there is adequate resourcing of the whole family
guardianship disputes at all stages       and any reforms     justice system. This includes attention to judicial hearing
if they wish. The availability of legal   or changes          time, registry staff, social workers, legal aid providers,
aid needs to be increased.                which result will   court-appointed lawyers and mediators.
    And thirdly, it is important that a   only succeed          We cannot provide an effective means of resolving
robust triage and case management         if we accept        family disputes on a shoestring. This is all about access
system is implemented. The track          the need to         to justice and any reforms or changes which result will
system should cease and appli-            make a realistic    only succeed if we accept the need to make a realistic
cations filed in the Family Court         commitment          commitment and investment to achieve a family justice
should be made either on notice           and investment      system that works for all New Zealanders.
or on a without notice basis where        to achieve a          The Minister has asked officials to develop a workable
matters are urgent and there are          family justice      programme for change by the end of this year. ▪
safety risks involved. The number of      system that
court events should be significantly      works for all       Kirsty Swadling
reduced.                                  New Zealanders      Chair, Family Law Section

6
Hutt Valley FOCUS ON LEGAL PRACTICE IN THE - New Zealand Law Society
L AW TA L K 9 3 1 · A ugust 2 0 1 9                                                                      N E W Z E A L A N D L AW S O C I E T Y

                     Justice response to sexual
                     violence – Law Society
                     releases confidential input
                                                             relevant stakeholders including the      of evidence,” it says.
                     The Law Society has released a          legal profession will be needed if the      The committee says the Court of
                     submission it made to the Ministry      government decides to proceed with       Appeal in M v R [2011] NZCA 303
                     of Justice on 11 October 2018 on        the Commission’s recommendations.”       noted concerns around the issues
                     aspects of the Law Commission’s                                                  with disclosure including that pre-re-
                     2015 response for improving the         Specialist training                      cording should not take place before
                     justice response to sexual violence.    On the specified Law Commission          full disclosure has been made.
                     This follows release in July 2019 of    recommendations, the committee              “The committee agrees with
                     details of the Government’s plans       says it agrees that some form of spe-    this observation. If pre-recording
                     to introduce law changes relating       cialist training for defence counsel,    takes place before full disclosure
                     to sexual violence cases. At the time   including legal aid counsel, who         has been made, the defence may
                     the Law Society’s submission was        appear in sexual violence trials, may    lose the opportunity to question
                     made on a confidential basis at the     be helpful and appropriate.              a complainant on relevant aspects
                     ministry's request.                        “Such training may help minimise      of the prosecution’s case which are
                        Releasing the planned actions,       the risk of oppressive or inappro-       only subsequently disclosed to the
                     Parliamentary Under-Secretary to        priate questioning of vulnerable         defence.”
                     the Minister of Justice, Jan Logie,     witnesses, while ensuring the               After considering other issues
                     noted the input from the Law Society    defendant is able to mount an            around pre-recording, the commit-
                     on some matters. This referred to the   effective defence.”                      tee says that overall it is significantly
                     October 2018 submission.                   The committee considers that          concerned that presumptive pre-re-
                        The submission was sought on         specialist training should be            cording of cross-examination will
                     three Law Commission recommen-          encouraged, rather than being            erode defendants’ right to silence
                     dations: experience and competence      made a mandatory prerequisite for        and fair trial rights. ▪
                     requirements for defence counsel,       appointment as legal aid counsel in
                     alternative options for presentation    sexual violence trials.
                     of evidence by adult complainants,
                     and the pre-recording of cross-ex-      Pre-recording of evidence
                     amination evidence before trial.        The committee considers that
                        In its submission the Law            pre-recording evidence, particu-         HAYS LEGAL
                     Society’s Criminal Law Committee        larly cross-examination, for com-        PARTNER WITH
                     says it is concerned at the lack of     plainants in sexual violence cases       THE EXPERTS
                     adequate consultation of the legal      should remain available on a case        Are you considering a new opportunity
                                                                                                      within the legal sector? Are you looking
                     profession and other stakeholders       by case basis and not via a statutory    for more responsibility or have you
                     on the 2015 recommendations. It         presumption.                             been thinking about giving in-house
                                                                                                      opportunities a go?
                     says the tight timetable followed         “While complainants in sexual
                     precluded public consultation.          violence cases (similar to child         Hays Legal is seeking local candidates
                                                                                                      for positions including:
                        The committee says its preferred     witnesses) should be eligible to have    • Litigator – national firm
                     approach is for open consultation.      their evidence pre-recorded, we          • Senior Solicitor – private client/
                                                                                                        commerical property
                     This provides an opportunity for full   remain of the view that the prose-       • Staff Solicitor – commercial law/
                     input from the profession and makes     cutor should have to apply on a case       resource management
                     for better policy and legislation.      by case basis rather than via a stat-    To find your
                        “Early, informed consultation        utory presumption. Judges should         local office, visit
                                                                                                      hays.net.nz
                     with those working in the field         continue to decide on a principled
                     helps to ensure effective and work-     basis whether evidence in chief or
                     able reforms and an effective justice   cross-examination should be pre-
                     system. The Law Society considers       sented by way of pre-recorded video      hays.net.nz
                     that public consultation with           interview and/or the prerecording

                                                                                                                                                 7
Hutt Valley FOCUS ON LEGAL PRACTICE IN THE - New Zealand Law Society
N E W Z E A L A N D L AW S O C I E T Y                                           A ugust 2 0 1 9 · L AW TA L K 9 3 1

                                                         Annette Gray
                                                         elected Wellington
                                                         branch President
                                                         Family lawyer Annette Gray has been elected
                                                         President of the New Zealand Law Society’s Wellington
                                                         branch. Ms Gray was admitted as a barrister and solicitor
                                                         in February 1986 and is a partner with Wellington firm
                                                         Buchanan Gray. As well as her Family Court practice
                                                         she is an experienced property lawyer and a trained
                                                         and qualified mediator. Ms Gray replaces David Dunbar.
                                                         The branch Council elected at the AGM on 19 June is:

                                                         President: Annette Gray.

                                                         Vice-Presidents: Arti Chand, Christopher Griggs.

                                                         Council: David Dunbar, Julius Maskell, Monique van
                                                                   Alphen Fyfe, Mark Wilton, Christian Jorgensen
                                                                   (Wairarapa), Bridget Sinclair (Young Lawyer),
                                                                   Nerissa Barber (Law Society Board Member). ▪

Law Society                                              Terry Singh is new
                                                         Waikato Bay of Plenty
moves out of                                             branch President
national office                                          Hamilton Public Defence Service lawyer Terry
                                                         Singh has been elected President of the Waikato Bay of
The New Zealand Law Society moved out of its             Plenty branch of the New Zealand Law Society. Mr Singh
national office at 26 Waring Taylor Street, Wellington   was admitted as a barrister and solicitor in September
after receiving a Detailed Seismic Assessment which      1996. He succeeds Russell Boot as President. A new
showed that part of the building was earthquake prone.   Council was elected at the Biennial General Meeting
The Law Society’s immediate focus is on ensuring staff   on 19 June.
safety and maintaining essential services while alter-
native accommodation is secured. Our services outside    President: Terry Singh.
of Wellington will continue as normal. National office
employees will work from home and temporary offices      Vice-President: Johan Niemand.
until new premises are secured.
  We will keep you updated on developments as we         Council: L
                                                                   isa Awatere, Tim Braithwaite, Phillip Cornegé,
work through this period of disruption and trust that             Brendan Cullen, James Gurnick, Emma Miles,
you will be patient with staff and the Law Society if             Erin Reilly, Jesse Savage, Gene Tomlinson,
some services are temporarily affected. ▪                         Marise Winthrop. ▪

8
Hutt Valley FOCUS ON LEGAL PRACTICE IN THE - New Zealand Law Society
L AW TA L K 9 3 1 · A ugust 2 0 1 9                                                   N E W Z E A L A N D L AW S O C I E T Y

More streamlined                                                                   Keep local
                                                                                   authority
approach suggested                                                                 liability
in civil aviation reform                                                           unchanged
                                        Civil Aviation Act 1990.
The Law Society has told the              “The empowering provisions have          Current liability settings for
Ministry of Transport that it           evolved and been amended over              building consent authorities should
supports the proposal to amal-          many years, and the bill would be          be retained and no cap for liability
gamate and restructure the Civil        more accessible if these provisions        should be introduced, the Law
Aviation Act 1990 and the Airports      were rationalised.”                        Society says in comments on MBIE’s
Authorities Act 1966 into a Civil         The Law Society also says that           discussion paper Building system
Aviation Bill. The Law Society says     clause 43 sets out a very broad            legislative reform, Paper 4: Risk and
setting out the statutory purposes      power for the making of rules,             Liability.
in clauses 3 and 4 of the bill will     allowing a rule to be made that               “The question of the appropriate
reduce inconsistencies and improve      relates to any of the specified pur-       liability model in New Zealand was
accessibility for users and those       poses, which are generally stated.         given comprehensive consideration
affected by the legislation.              “Any such rule could have signifi-       in the Law Commission’s review in
   In comments on the Civil Aviation    cant legislative effect. Although clause   2013, and the Law Society’s view
Exposure Draft Bill, the Law Society    43 is similar to the broadly worded        at that time was that ‘the current
suggests that the ministry also con-    rule-making power in section 28 of         system of joint and several liability
sider a more streamlined approach       the Civil Aviation Act 1990, it would      in New Zealand is preferable to lia-
to the empowering provisions relat-     be prudent to review it to ensure          bility models adopted in other juris-
ing to the making of rules in clauses   the power is appropriate, because it       dictions’ and should be retained,”
44 – 51. It says these clauses appear   involves a significant delegation of       it says.
to be a direct extraction from the      Parliament’s law-making power.” ▪             “The Law Society’s view remains
                                                                                   unchanged … The joint and several
                                                                                   liability model works. It is under-
  New Zealand Law Society law reform submissions                                   pinned by sound and well-tested
  Copies of submissions made by the New Zealand Law Society’s law                  principles relating to duty of care,
  reform committees are available on the Law Society website www.                  causation and remoteness. In the
  lawsociety.org.nz in the section News & Communications/Law reform                case of local authorities, the Law
  submissions. Information on submissions and the opportunity to provide           Society does not consider there
  input on submissions which are being prepared is provided in the                 is any compelling justification for
  weekly e-newsletter LawPoints.                                                   departing from the current joint and
                                                                                   several liability model.” ▪

       iP experience and expertise that
       shines bright amongst the best
       AJ Park is proud to employ brilliant minds and promote bold leaders.
       Congratulations to our new principals and senior associates.

       To find out more about how our IP experts are helping to support
       New Zealand’s innovation community, visit www.ajpark.com.

                                                                                                                          9
Hutt Valley FOCUS ON LEGAL PRACTICE IN THE - New Zealand Law Society
N E W Z E A L A N D L AW S O C I E T Y                                                                    A ugust 2 0 1 9 · L AW TA L K 9 3 1

Comments on draft
guidelines for refugees with
serious mental health issues
                                                                in the draft guidelines that they are
Draft guidelines for refugees with serious mental               not a strict code of procedure.
health issues would have greater utility if they clearly           The Law Society notes that
stated their underlying objective of being an important         the term “serious mental health
tool to prevent injustice to psychologically vulnerable         issues” is used in the title and
applicants and to ensure the merits of their claims are         throughout the draft guidelines,
fairly considered, the Law Society says.                        but the term is not defined in the
   The Law Society has provided comments to Immigration         Definitions section or elsewhere.
New Zealand’s Refugee Status Branch on its draft guide-         It says the Guidelines should not
lines for persons presenting with serious mental health         use undefined terminology, and
issues. It notes that these are to to assist refugee and        for consistency with the UNHCR
protection officers in assessing the refugee and protection     Guidance Note, the Guidelines
status of people presenting with serious mental health          should apply to “psychologically
issues. The Law Society says it supports the statement          vulnerable claimants”. ▪

Amended insurance contract
provisions supported
                                                                – is likely to produce the fairest out-
The Law Society says it now supports the objec-                 come for consumers and insurers.
tives of a review of the law relating to insurance contracts    It would enable New Zealand to
which is being carried out by the Ministry of Business,         maintain equivalent provisions to
Innovation and Employment (MBIE).                               other common law jurisdictions.
   In comments on MBIE’s April 2019 Options Paper:                 The second option – a duty to
Insurance Contract Law Review, the Law Society says             disclose what a reasonable person
changes have been made to the objectives since MBIE’s           would know to be relevant – would
May 2018 issues paper, to acknowledge the unique                take New Zealand’s law in a differ-
nature of insurance contracts and insurance business.           ent direction from that of other
It supports the amended objectives of the review as set         common law jurisdictions, leading
out in the options paper.                                       to potential uncertainty and the
   The Law Society comments on two options posed by the         need for the courts to intervene to
paper for disclosure by consumers. It says the first – a duty   provide guidance on the meaning
to take reasonable care not to make a misrepresentation         of the terms. ▪

  Legal research —
  let us do the hard
  work for you                                            www.lawsociety.org.nz/law-library

10
L AW TA L K 9 3 1 · A ugust 2 0 1 9                                                               P E O P L E I N T H E L AW · O N T H E M O V E

        PEOPLE IN THE LAW
        ON THE MOVE

Chief District Court                              visible and therefore accessible. She has      from 17 June. Tania is a
Judge appointed to                                received several AIJA Incorporated Awards      Whangārei local and
High Court bench                                  for Excellence in Judicial Administration.     has been with WRMK
                                                  Her contribution has been significant. The     Lawyers since 2002.
Chief District Court                              legal community wishes her well in her         She has a strong general
Judge J a n ‑ M a r i e                           work as a member of the High Court and         commercial practice,
D o o g u e has been                              recognises the leadership and innovation       with particular exper-
appointed a Judge of                              she has shown as Chief District Court          tise in trusts and asset
the High Court.                                   Judge.”                                        planning. Before her focus on trusts, she
   Justice Doogue                                                                                worked for several years as a successful
graduated with an LLB                             Acting Associate                               civil litigator.
from the University                               Judge appointed
of Auckland in 1980 and began her legal                                                          Council of Legal
career at Auckland law firm Holmden               John Gordon Matthews, retired Associate        Education appointments
Horrocks the same year. In 1983 she joined        Judge of Christchurch, was appointed an
Cairns Slane in Auckland and became a             acting Associate Judge of the High Court       Justice Gerardus Jacobus van Bohemen
partner of the firm in 1986, before leaving to    for a period commencing 4 June 2019 and        of the High Court has been appointed a
join the partnership of Morrison Morpeth          ending on 3 August 2019.                       member of the New Zealand Council of
in 1990. In 1992 Justice Doogue joined                                                           Legal Education for a term from 26 June
the independent Bar and spent two years           Two join Walker                                2019 to 27 May 2022. David Ross Green,
practising out of William Martin Chambers         Street Chambers                                barrister and solicitor of Auckland, has
in Auckland before her appointment as a                                                          been appointed for a term from 14 June
District and Family Court Judge in 1994.          Walker Street Chambers in Christchurch         2019 to 6 May 2022.
   She was subsequently designated as             has welcomed two junior employed
a Family Violence Court Judge in 2005,            barristers.                                    Anita Killeen chair of
granted a Jury Warrant in 2007, and was             Angela Lee was                               Amenities Funding Board
appointed an alternate Environment                admitted to the bar
Court Judge in 2011. Justice Doogue was           in October 2014 after                          The Auckland Council
appointed Chief District Court Judge in           graduating with an LLB                         has appointed Auckland
2011.                                             from the University of                         barrister Anita Killeen
   Justice Doogue will be sworn in on 19          Canterbury. Before                             Chair of the Auckland
August 2019 and will sit in Wellington.           joining Walker Street,                         Regional Amenities
   Her appointment will mark the end of           Angela worked at the                           Funding Board. The
eight years of strong and committed lead-         Public Defence Service and for Weston          Board was established
ership of New Zealand’s largest court, the        Ward & Lascelles. Angela specialises in        through the Auckland
New Zealand Law Society says.                     family law and criminal defence work.          Regional Amenities Funding Act 2008 and
   “Her appointment is a fitting recognition        Shawn McManus                                distributes grants to organisations that
of her judicial strengths. It is important        was admitted to the                            deliver arts, culture, recreational, heritage,
to pay tribute to her time as leader of           bar in March 2017                              rescue and other facilities and services to
the District Court judiciary,” Law Society        after graduating from                          the Auckland region.
President Tiana Epati says.                       Victoria University of
   “Chief Judge Doogue has overseen               Wellington with an                             Michael Stephens
a period of important change, with 59             LLB and BSc majoring                           joins Urban Art
District Courts combined into one District        in psychology. Shawn                           Foundation Board
Court in 2017. The jurisdiction of the District   previously worked as a junior lawyer at
Court has also increased and there have           the Public Defence Service in both the         Wellington media and commercial lawyer
also been important developments such             Wellington and Christchurch offices, and       Michael Stephens has joined the board
as the Alcohol and Other Drug Treatment           specialises in criminal defence.               of the Urban Art Foundation Ltd. The
Court, the New Beginnings Court and the                                                          Foundation operates as The Urban Art
Matariki Court.                                   Tania Beckham becomes                          Agency and is a not-for-profit company
   “Judge Doogue has also been a strong           WRMK Lawyers director                          committed to making art accessible on
advocate for increased diversity in the                                                          streets and in public gateways to enrich
makeup of the judiciary. She has made the         WRMK Lawyers has appointed Tania               New Zealanders’ experience of their urban
workings of the court and its judges more         Beckham as a director of the firm, effective   environment.

                                                                                                                                             11
O N T H E M O V E · P E O P L E I N T H E L AW                                                            A ugust 2 0 1 9 · L AW TA L K 9 3 1

Jen Crawford to chair                            joining the firm she worked as an associate   after working as a senior associate in the
Ashton Wheelans                                  at a Dunedin firm, a case manager at the      banking, finance and regulatory litigation
                                                 Institute of Chartered Accountants, and as    team at Allen & Overy LLP, London for
Former Anderson Lloyd partner Jen                a Crown Prosecutor in Wellington.             seven years. He has acted for financial
Crawford has been appointed independ-               Melissa Hammer                             institutions and other corporates in many
ent Chair of Ashton Wheelans Chartered           joins as a senior asso-                       international and domestic matters.
Accountants. Admitted as a barrister and         ciate in the litigation
solicitor in October 1996, Jen is now a con-     team and is based out                         Jess Keating joins
sultant with Anderson Lloyd’s Christchurch       of the Queenstown                             Kennedys partnership
office. She has expertise in due diligence       office. Melissa is a spe-
and transactional work, infrastructure           cialist dispute resolu-                       Jess Keating has joined
projects, urban redevelopment and                tion lawyer with broad                        the partnership of inter-
agribusiness.                                    expertise having worked as both a Crown       national insurance law
                                                 prosecutor and civil litigator. Melissa has   firm Kennedys from 1
New partners and senior                          extensive experience acting on criminal       July. Jess is based in
hires at Anderson Lloyd                          and regulatory prosecutions, as well as       the Auckland office and
                                                 insolvency, insurance, contractual, and       has more than 13 years’
Anderson Lloyd has announced two                 equity related disputes.                      experience in insurance
internal promotions to partner and has                                                         and civil litigation. Her core practice com-
welcomed two new senior members to               Two senior associates                         prises professional indemnity, public/product
its litigation department.                       join Bell Gully                               liability, directors’ and officers’ insurance,
   S a r a h Ev e l e i g h                                                                    statutory liability and recovery actions.
in the Christchurch                              Bell Gully has welcomed two new senior
resource management                              associates to its corporate and litigation    Vanessa Baakman
team has been pro-                               teams.                                        becomes Saunders
moted to partner. Sarah                             Tom Gillespie is                           Robinson Brown
specialises in resource                          rejoining the corporate                       associate
management and                                   team after working as
local government law.                            a senior associate in                         Saunders Robinson Brown has promoted
She advises clients on a broad range of          the Singapore office of                       Vanessa Baakman to
matters including consenting, compliance,        Linklaters for the past                       associate from 1 July.
planning processes and due diligence.            three years. He has                           Vanessa is a member
   Dan Williams in the                           advised on a number                           of the firm’s litigation
Auckland commercial                              of high profile and                           team and specialises in
property team has been                           complex cross border                          family and employment
promoted to partner.                             private M&A and ven-                          matters. She graduated
Dan has expertise                                ture capital transac-                         from the University of
in all facets of com-                            tions during his time                         Canterbury in 2002 with an LLB and BA
mercial property law,                            in Singapore.                                 (Classics) and has lived and worked exten-
with a particular focus                             Blair Keown joins                          sively overseas. Vanessa joined Saunders
assisting clients with forestry acquisitions     the litigation team                           Robinson Brown in 2018.
and disposals, mixed-use developments,
commercial and industrial leasing, and
advising clients on Overseas Investment
Act 2005 applications.
   Sarah McClean
has joined Anderson
Lloyd as an associate
in the litigation team
and is based out of the
Dunedin office. Sarah
specialises in dispute
resolution, employ-
ment, and health and safety law. Before

12
L AW TA L K 9 3 1 · A ugust 2 0 1 9                                                         P E O P L E I N T H E L AW · O N T H E M O V E

Wynn Williams                                 based in Wellington and a member of the      2009 as a law clerk
appoints new partner                          environment and planning team. She has       and was admitted
                                              been at Kensington Swan for four years and   in October 2009. He
Phoebe Davies has                             has extensive experience on large infra-     has developed a wide
joined Wynn Williams                          structure projects, including advising on    breadth of experi-
as a partner in the                           state highway projects and social housing    ence, especially in the
firm’s corporate and                          development.                                 areas of property law,
commercial team.                                                                           trusts and succession
She is based in the                           Juno Legal welcomes                          planning.
Christchurch office.                          Saki Hannah                                     Daniel Kruger
Phoebe has worked for                                                                      becomes an immi-
international firms in the United Kingdom     Thomas “Saki”                                gration partner in
and is qualified to practise in New Zealand   Hannah has joined                            Auckland. Daniel has
and England and Wales. She advises on         newlaw firm Juno                             worked in the Auckland
corporate and commercial law, including       Legal in Wellington.                         office since its incep-
overseas investments, mergers and acquisi-    He has joined the firm                       tion in 2015. Admitted
tions, corporate structuring, shareholders’   from Todd Corporation                        in New Zealand in
agreements, corporate governance and          where he was Associate                       December 2014, he holds an LLM from
commercial contracts.                         General Counsel with                         North-West University, South Africa and
                                              responsibility for corporate and M&A         has experience across a wide range of
Kensington Swan                               matters. He has over 25 years’ experience    immigration matters. He provides advice to
promotes two                                  in law and governance working at a senior    corporate clients, individuals and families.
senior associates                             level in-house and in private practice in
                                              New Zealand and overseas. His previous       Two promotions
Kensington Swan has                           roles include Associate General Counsel      at Lane Neave
promoted two staff to                         for Meridian Energy leading several work-
senior associate, from                        streams for the IPO; and General Counsel     Lane Neave has promoted two lawyers,
1 July.                                       Corporate at NZX managing a range of         effective from 1 July.
   Renee Butler is a                          acquisition activity and the governance         Rosemary Gibson
member of the firm’s                          arrangements for multiple boards.            was promoted to asso-
employment team and                                                                        ciate in the Auckland
is based in Wellington.                       Two new partners                             office building and
Her expertise includes                        at Lane Neave                                construction team.
working on several                                                                         Rosemary has BA(Hons)
significant health and                        Lane Neave has welcomed two new              and LLB degrees from
safety and employment                         partners.                                    the University of Otago
cases as well as leading                        Chris Anderson becomes a lifelaw           and was admitted in September 2013. She
the workplace immigra-                        partner in Christchurch. After graduating    specialises in civil litigation and dispute
tion team.                                    with BA and LLB from the University of       resolution and has acted for a range of cli-
   Barbara Dean is                            Canterbury, Chris joined Lane Neave in       ents in building and construction disputes.
                                                                                              Mary Zhou was pro-
                                                                                           moted to senior solic-
                                                                                           itor in the Auckland
                                                                                           immigration team.
                                                                                           Mary holds BHSc and
                                                                                           LLB(Hons) degrees
                                                                                           from the University
                                                                                           of Auckland and was
                                                                                           admitted in September 2016. Specialising
                                                                                           in immigration she has experience in all
                                                                                           aspects of immigration law, including
                                                                                           medical issues as part of the immigration
                                                                                           process.

                                                                                                                                       13
O N T H E M O V E · P E O P L E I N T H E L AW                                                             A ugust 2 0 1 9 · L AW TA L K 9 3 1

PwC Legal New Zealand                                                                                                 Tripp.
promotes two principals                                                                                                  Henry Benson-
                                                                                                                      Pope will complete
PwC Legal New Zealand has promoted two                                                                                a Master of Laws
principals from 1 July.                                                                                               specialising in crim-
   Tom Logan is based                                                                                                 inal law and human
in Auckland and is a                                                                                                  rights at New York
specialist corporate and                                                                                              University. He gradu-
transactional lawyer.                            ▴ The 11 2019 Fulbright General                ated with an LLB(Hons) and a BA in Politics
He has a focus on merg-                             Graduate Award winners.                      from the University of Otago in 2014. After
ers and acquisitions,                                                                            working as a Judge’s Clerk for Chief Justice
overseas investment,                             years ago, was formerly the president of the    Sian Elias, Henry joined Manukau Crown
reorganisations, joint                           Pacific Islands’ Law Students Association,      Solicitor Kayes Fletcher Walker.
ventures and capital raising transactions.       and helped establish the MALOSI Project
Tom also provides general corporate and          (Movement for Action and Law to                 Lisa McKeown joins
legal advice across a wide range of matters.     Overcome Social Injustice).                     Duncan Cotterill
   M a tt Ke e n a n is                            Sarah Alawi will specialise in dispute
based in Auckland and                            resolution for a Master of Laws at Harvard      Lisa McKeown has joined Duncan
has co-led the corpo-                            Law School in Cambridge, Massachusetts.         Cotterill’s Wellington litigation team as an
rate and commercial                              Sarah graduated with a BA and LLB(Hons)         associate. Lisa was admitted as a barrister
practice of PwC Legal                            from the University of Auckland in 2015.        and solicitor in May 2005. She specialises
since its launch in 2016.                        She was admitted as a barrister and solici-     in trust and estate claims and is also expe-
Matt has extensive                               tor in April 2016 and joined Gilbert Walker     rienced in other family law, employment,
experience advising                              after completing two years as a Judges’         professional disciplinary and medico-legal
businesses across the spectrum from              Clerk at the High Court at Auckland. She        matters.
start-ups and privately owned businesses         maintains her links with the university
right through to large multinationals. He        as a tutor in equity. Sarah is a committee      Russ + Associates
has worked in New Zealand, the UK and            member of the Auckland Women Lawyers’           specialist tax and AML
the Cayman Islands.                              Association and the NZLS Auckland Young         firm established
                                                 Lawyers.
Young Fulbright                                    Robert (Rob) Schultz will specialise in       The former head of Buddle Findlay’s tax
Award winners head                               dispute resolution for a Master of Laws         practice, Neil Russ, has established a spe-
to United States                                 at Columbia University in New York City.        cialist tax and AML firm, Russ + Associates,
                                                 He graduated with a BA and an LLB(Hons)         based in Auckland.
Lawyers made up five of the 11 young New         from the University of Auckland in 2014            Neil Russ was a partner at Buddle
Zealanders awarded 2019 Fulbright General        and worked as a Judge’s Clerk at the Court      Findlay for more than 24 years. He has also
Graduate Awards. The US awards, valued           of Appeal before joining LeeSalmonLong          practised in London, and is currently the
at up to US$40,000 (plus NZ$4,000 travel         in 2015. “Columbia’s LLM offers a wide          convenor of the New Zealand Law Society’s
funding), are for promising New Zealand          range of papers. I’m hoping to take some        Tax Law Committee. Neil specialises in cor-
graduate students to undertake postgrad-         papers in arbitration, litigation and alter-    porate and international income tax issues,
uate study or research at US institutions        native dispute resolution,” Rob says. “I also   and has extensive experience in relation
in any field.                                    want to get some perspective on United          to GST matters and a multi-jurisdictional
   Auckland University Law School                States law – including US constitutional        background in banking, capital markets,
Teaching Fellow Fuimaono (Dylan)                 law – media and privacy law.”                   structured finance, venture capital and
Asafo will move to the United States in            Jack Davies will study for a Master of        private equity transactions. He advises
August to undertake a Masters of Law at          Laws at New York University, specialising       clients, other law firms and accounting
Harvard. Of Samoan heritage, Dylan plans         in international business regulation, lit-      practices in relation to transactions, new
to study Critical Race Theory and minority       igation and arbitration. Jack graduated         business structures and products, and is
rights. He graduated with an LLB/BHSc            with an LLB(Hons) and BA in political           one of New Zealand’s leading AML/CFT
conjointly in 2017 from the University of        studies and international relations at the      practitioners and presenters.
Auckland and an LLM (First Class Hons)           University of Auckland. He was admitted            Alexandra Tunnicliffe has joined the
from the University of Auckland in 2019.         as a barrister and solicitor in March 2017      firm as a senior associate. Alexandra
Dylan began tutoring law students several        and works as a solicitor at Chapman             specialises in all aspects of New Zealand

14
L AW TA L K 9 3 1 · A ugust 2 0 1 9                                                              P E O P L E I N T H E L AW · O N T H E M O V E

tax law, particularly in assisting with      Law Centre. He worked there until 1993          Gisborne/Tarawhiti Rugby League since
binding rulings, tax investigations and      when he moved to practise as a criminal         2007, and is a member of the New Zealand
tax disputes, and FATCA, AEOI/CRS, and       barrister. He was appointed a District Court    Rugby League Board.
AML/CFT compliance. Before joining Russ +    Judge in 1996 and was based in Whanganui
Associates, she spent four years at Buddle   until 2001 when he became Principal             Buddle Findlay welcomes
Findlay, having worked previously in the     Youth Court Judge. He was appointed             Tom Montgomerie
tax team at a “Big 4” accounting firm, and   the Children’s Commissioner for an initial
in the legal team at Inland Revenue.         two-year period from June 2016.                 Tom Montgomerie has
  Charlotte Beale has joined the firm as                                                     joined Buddle Findlay’s
a senior associate. Charlotte is a tax and   Race Relations                                  Auckland office as a
private wealth practitioner with over a      Commissioner appointed                          senior associate in the
decade of experience at Buddle Findlay                                                       corporate and commer-
and TGT Legal. Charlotte advises on all      Retiring Gisborne Mayor Meng Foon has           cial team. Tom advises
aspects of New Zealand tax law and FATCA,    been appointed the next Race Relations          on a range of corporate
AEOI/CRS and AML/CFT matters and has         Commissioner.                                   matters, with a particu-
particular expertise in asset structuring,      Mr Foon will take up his new appoint-        lar focus on capital markets and securities
trusts, charities, wills and relationship    ment on 26 August 2019 and will be respon-      transactions, mergers and acquisitions as
property. Charlotte is a member of the       sible for leading the work of the Human         well as general commercial contracting.
Society of Trust and Estate Practitioners    Rights Commission in promoting positive         Before joining Buddle Findlay, Tom worked
and a member of the New Zealand Law          race relations.                                 for a global asset manager based in London.
Society Property Law Reform Panel.              Justice Minister Andrew Little says Mr
                                             Foon has an outstanding record as a rela-       Rainey Collins plans
Judge Becroft’s                              tionship builder and walks comfortably          100-year reunion
term as Children’s                           in the pākehā world, the Māori world, the
Commissioner extended                        Chinese community and other communi-            Wellington law firm Rainey Collins is cel-
                                             ties making up New Zealand.                     ebrating its 100th year and as part of those
Children’s Commissioner Judge Andrew            Meng Foon was first elected onto the         celebrations a reunion event is planned
Becroft has had his appointment extended     Gisborne District Council in 1995 and           for 11 October 2019. The event is open to
until 30 June 2021.                          became mayor in 2001. He is one of a            all former partners, staff (both legal and
  “Judge Becroft has been doing an           handful of people of Chinese descent to         support) and their guest.
exemplary job as an advocate for the         have become a mayor in New Zealand. He             The reunion will be held at the
wellbeing of children and young people       is fluent in English, Cantonese and te reo      Wellington Club, 75 The Terrace, Wellington
since 2016,” Social Development Minister     Māori. As of 2019, he is still the only mayor   from 5:30 to 7:30pm. Registrants are also
Carmel Sepuloni says. “I am pleased that     in New Zealand who is fluent in Te Reo.         invited to visit the firm’s current offices
he has agreed to stay on as Children’s          He is a member of a number of com-           at Level 19, 119 The Terrace from 4pm that
Commissioner.”                               munity organisations including the Ngā          day for pre-event drinks and nibbles plus
  Judge Becroft graduated BA and             Taonga a nā Tama Toa Trust, the New             a tour of the offices.
LLB(Hons) from the University of Auckland    Zealand Chinese Association, Aotearoa              Registration is required by 1 September,
in 1981 and practised until 1986 when he     Social Enterprise Trust and MY Gold             to Alan Knowsley aknowsley@raineycollins.
helped establish the Mangere Community       Investments Ltd. He has been chair of           co.nz or ph (04) 473 6850.

               Grant Allan LLB
      Mediator (Resolution Institute - Advanced Mediator Panel)
     · Over 500 lawyer referred mediations
                                                                                             M                              a   r
     · No charge for travel costs or time to mediations anywhere in NZ                           edi
                                                                                                       a t o r o f t h e Ye
     · For referees contact any of the 75+ lawyers listed on website

     grantallan.co.nz                           0800 400 411  grant_allan@xtra.co.nz

                                                                                                                                            15
P R O F I L E · P E O P L E I N T H E L AW   A ugust 2 0 1 9 · L AW TA L K 9 3 1

16
L AW TA L K 9 3 1 · A ugust 2 0 1 9                                              P E O P L E I N T H E L AW · P R O F I L E

        PEOPLE IN THE LAW
        PROFILE

Professor Penelope Mathew
Refugees and the University of Auckland
BY TEUILA
   FUATAI

                                                                           “I think we need to do more in terms
Perched among the human rights law books in Professor                    of teaching students about how things
Penelope Mathew’s office is a silver motorcycle helmet.                  are changing in the profession and
   “I ride a Vespa”, she says cheerfully. “But, I still have to get it   ensuring they’re aware of those develop-
through compliance over here – that’s what I’m going to do next.”        ments and may be able to capitalise any
   The Australian export took over the deanship at the University        opportunities.”
of Auckland’s law school in April. It has been a busy four months.         She readily admits there is no “crystal
   Sorting vehicle registration, and even permanent accommoda-           ball”. However, proper consideration of
tion, are still on her to-do list. Hobbies like surfing and playing      technological developments which will
the fiddle have also been put on the backburner.                         challenge business models and student
   Professor Mathew, an internationally renowned academic in             learning must occur.
refugee law and human rights, was headhunted for the Auckland              Related to that is better student exposure
job. She received a call from the university while on sabbatical.        to workplace practice.
Prior to that, she was Dean of the Griffith University Law School          “It’s another area where I think we could
in Queensland.                                                           probably do more as a law school – the
   “I took a sabbatical, as you are entitled to after a period of        Americans call it Clinical Legal Education,
deanship, and really got to pay attention to my area of research.        which is really exposing the students
The UN High Commissioner for Refugees was doing a lot of work            through work-based learning,” she says.
on the Global Compact on Refugees,” Professor Mathew says.               “You get them working in practical settings,
   “I had six weeks in Geneva, then came back. I had moved to the        whether it’s in a barrister’s chamber or
Gold Coast – Mermaid Beach – which is beautiful. I’m learning how        community legal service.”
to surf and writing up all of my things on the Global Compact on           Improvements in those areas will help
Refugees, thinking I’d have a couple of years’ research-intensive,       graduates, she believes.
and then I heard from Auckland [University].”
   It was an opportunity too good to pass up, she says.                  Women in the law: ‘Easy
                                                                         to slide backwards’
Law students and emerging technologies                                   Professor Mathew also discusses the
Unlike Griffith, Auckland’s law school is as an independent faculty.     “constant process” of achieving gender
The dean works closely with the Vice-Chancellor and university           parity at the profession’s top levels. She
senior leadership team. The role offered new challenges, she says.       has taught feminist legal theory at the
   The city’s beauty and multicultural communities was another           Australia National University,
draw card.                                                                 “It is frustrating that 30 years ago when I
   “Australia is multicultural but in different ways to Auckland.        graduated, it was probably half and half in
I’ve really been struck by Māori and Pasifika communities and            terms of men and women at the University
just how incredibly diverse it is.                                       of Melbourne Law School.
   “At some point, when I’ve unpacked my boxes perhaps, I’d                “And 30 years on, we’re still talking about
really like to do a Te Reo course and try and learn some Māori.”         the same kinds of issues in terms of reach-
   So far, Professor Mathew has prioritised meeting faculty staff        ing the top echelons of the profession.”
and members of the profession. A comprehensive planning session            When asked if things had changed
with the department is also not far off.                                 during her career, she smiles reservedly
   One subject warranting attention is the role of artifical intelli-    and offers some earnest comments.
gence in legal services.                                                   Real progress, including the appoint-
   “There’s a question about making sure the law degree that you’re      ment of two, successive, female Chief
graduating your students with is actually appropriate," she says.        Justices, is something to take pride in,

◂  University of Auckland                                                                                             17
P R O F I L E · P E O P L E I N T H E L AW                                                     A ugust 2 0 1 9 · L AW TA L K 9 3 1

she says. However, a significant shift in culture and                 improve things for people.”
understanding of the value of women in the workplace                    Professor Mathew eventually returned to New York to
requires critical mass.                                               earn a Doctor of the Science of Law (JSD) from Columbia
  “Clearly, there have been changes in society. I think               University.
some of the law firms are doing better in trying to allow
people to have a proper work-life balance. Recognising                US civil rights movement and parents
that lawyers do work in teams anyway, which is a really               Looking back, her parents and family background set
important part of legal practice, and allows some flexi-              strong foundations for a career in human rights law.
bility will help in the longer term.                                     “My dad was a doctor and … my mother was a social
  “That said, it’s never going to be done. Young men and              worker for a while. Both were very interested in civil
women may have a different outlook on the world today,                rights,” Professor Mathew says.
but it’s so easy to slide backwards. It’s incumbent on all               “I was actually born in Boston. It was at the time of the
of us to keep working away at these issues.”                          civil rights movement. My parents, as young Australians,
                                                                      were deeply affected by what African Americans were
Working with refugees                                                 fighting for. They realised there were things that really
Another issue which has paralleled Professor Mathew’s                 weren’t right at home for indigenous Australians.
career is the mandatory detention of refugees and                        “I think that has definitely stayed with me [and
asylum seekers.                                                       developed] an interest in human rights law.”
   Hanging on her wall are a pair of black and white                     Several impressive teachers, including leading
photos taken at the Jesuit Refugee Service camps in                   Australian human rights professors Hilary Charlesworth
Hong Kong in the early 90s. A much younger Penelope                   and Gillian Triggs, also left their mark.
Mathew features in one of images. Behind her is a cor-                   Professor Mathew’s first refugee client, while a young
rugated iron building and tall barbed wire fences. The                volunteer lawyer with the Refuge Advice and Casework
other image is a group of young, smiling children. The                Service in Melbourne, was another important influence.
photos were from a three-month volunteer stint at the                    “He was a Somali refugee and he was trying to get his
camps, she explains.                                                                       mother out. Just him describing the
   “They’re kind of like airport hangars with three levels                                 things that he’d seen in Somalia. You
on it,” she says of the camps’ makeshift buildings.                                        could even see some of the signs of
   “A family of four would have a 2m x 2m platform to                                      torture on this man. His story was
sleep on. And they would be there for years. I often                                       so terrible but compelling, and once
look at them [photos] and think about what happened                                        you’ve listened to a story like that,
to the families. The stories that you heard were pretty                                    you think: ‘Yes, I would really like
heartbreaking.”                                                                            to be able to do something’.”
   She recalls when Australia introduced its mandatory                                        For Professor Mathew, that dedi-
detention laws in 1992. It was just before she left for                                    cation to her beliefs has been pivotal
Hong Kong.                                                                                 to her 30-year-career. She has held
   “I, as a young academic, had written my first con-                                      senior teaching and administrative
ference paper on it, arguing that this was a violation                                     roles at Melbourne University, the
of Article 9 of the International Covenant on Civil and                                    Australia National University and
Political Rights.                                                                          the University of Michigan. There
   “I certainly became convinced that detaining people                                     was also an advisory role for the
is not appropriate.”                                                                       Australian Capital Territory Human
   Subsequently, the UN Human Rights Committee                                             Rights Commission.
– which supervised the treaty – found Australia vio-          Young men                       Now, from the dean’s office at the
lated its terms. The decision was based on the case           and women                    University of Auckland, she takes a
of a Cambodian asylum seeker. He was detained by              may have                     moment to reflect.
Australian authorities for four years, Professor Mathew       a different                     “I’ve moved around a lot,” she
says.                                                         outlook on the               says. “I’ve looked for things that
   The case also featured in the next phase of her career.    world today,                 are interesting and challenging. I
While studying for a master’s degree at Columbia              but it’s so                  think you need to find an area of
University, New York, she volunteered at the Lawyers’         easy to slide                specialisation that you’re just really
Committee for Human Rights. She assisted with the             backwards.                   passionate about, and for me it is
organisation’s submission on the arbitrary detention          It’s incumbent               refugee law.” ▪
of Vietnamese refugees for the United Nations.                on all of us to
   “It was all coincidental, but it all came together. It’s   keep working                  Teuila Fuatai  teuila.fuatai@
a great feeling when you’re developing expertise and          away at these                 gmail.com is an Auckland-based
you’re able to use it to try and push things along and        issues.                       journalist.

18
L AW TA L K 9 3 1 · A ugust 2 0 1 9                                                 P E O P L E I N T H E L AW · P R O F I L E

        PEOPLE IN THE LAW
        PROFILE

Law firm tips
the scales and
takes out gender
diversity award
BY NICK
   BUTCHER

                                         review. You don’t stop the work just
It’s a significant achievement           because you’ve been recognised as a
when a law firm gains a major            leader in this area,” she says.
award for gender diversity in the
workplace, particularly when the         What have they done?
culture of law firms has been a big      Ms Fox credits the forward thinking
talking point over the past year or      of the founding law firm partners,
so.                                      Geoff Saunders, Lee Robinson and
   At June’s Women in Governance         Bill Brown, saying that the result
awards, Canterbury law firm              doesn’t happen overnight but is
Saunders Robinson Brown                  the product of a philosophy that
took home the Gender Diverse             has long been embedded in the firm.
Organisation of the Year Award.              As managing partner, Anna Fox
They weren’t competing against           worked alongside People Manager           ▴ Nikki Harkerss (SRB People
law firms, but were up against           Nikki Harkerss on various initiatives        Manager), Hon Julie Anne
many non-law or mainstream               that would enhance the workplace             Genter (Minister for Women),
organisations.                           culture and equality. This included          Anna Fox (SRB Managing
   Reviewing the workplace culture       making changes that would opti-              Partner).
and creating strategies that cele-       mise partner leadership with rela-
brate equality is something many         tion to gender equity.
law firms have been working on               “We don’t make it a barrier if a         Each person in the firm is assigned
over the past year, so being judged      woman is a part-time employee. So,        someone who will be responsible for
the best when it comes to gender         if they have a family and work, per-      their professional development and
diversity against other non-law          haps four days a week, partnership        wellbeing, meaning they essentially
organisations is somewhat of a           is still achievable. We’ve been clear     have a mentor.
milestone for the profession.            in setting our guiding principles and        The programme was developed
   As Saunders Robinson Brown            our vision and one of the principles      by Sean Larkan, principal of Edge
managing partner Anna Fox                is a commitment to diversity in its       International, which specialises in
explains, law firms have been            wider sense. It’s not just about          strategies for law firms of all sizes.
through a lot of negative publicity so   gender. It’s about diversity in a range      “So, people are professionally
this award should mean a lot to the      of areas including background, eth-       trained in positive leadership and
profession, perhaps even serve as        nicity and religion,” she says.           coaching skills. They use those skills
an inspirational message to others.          Having someone to look up to          to help the person they are mentor-
   “We’re really proud. We’ve worked     that inspires an employee has many        ing achieve their goals in relation to
really hard on this. It’s one part of    benefits including staff retention.       progression as a lawyer within the
a journey we’ve been on for some         Saunders Robinson Brown has               firm,” Anna Fox says.
time. Gender diversity is something      implemented an initiative they call          She says if an employee is facing
you have to continue to work on and      the Responsible Partner Programme.        challenges at work, the Responsible

                                                                                                                          19
You can also read