News Vol.43 / no.5 May 2021 - Teachers' Union of Ireland

Page created by Tina Harmon
 
CONTINUE READING
News Vol.43 / no.5 May 2021 - Teachers' Union of Ireland
new s
teachers’ union of ireland / AONTAS MúiNTeOirí éireANN

                                                         Vol.4 3 / no.5
                                                              May 2 0 2 1
News Vol.43 / no.5 May 2021 - Teachers' Union of Ireland
A Word from the
     tui neWs

    contents:
    p.2 A Word from the President
                                                  President – Martin Marjoram
    p. 4 Annual Congress 2021 –
         General Secretary’s Address          Dear Members,                                      and support, particularly Vice
    p. 6 Annual Congress 2021 –                                                                  President Liz Farrell who took on a
         President’s response to              The conclusion of TUi’s Annual
                                                                                                 large portion of the Chairing duties.
         Minister Harris                      Congress has been followed by still
                                                                                                 While hoping fervently for a return to
                                              further intense work and activity, both
    p.8 Annual Congress 2021 –                                                                   a physical setting next easter, there
         President’s response to              by you the members in your
                                                                                                 may be lessons and potential
         Minister Foley                       classrooms, laboratories and homes,
                                                                                                 improvements to be taken from
                                              and by your representatives and
    p.10 Post-Primary and Further                                                                our experience of remote
                                              officials in intensive negotiations and
         education and Training survey                                                           Congresses.
                                              representations on your behalf.
         findings
                                              Across all sectors, TUi members
    p.14 Third level survey findings          continue to exemplify the finest                   Pay discrimination
    p.16 Annual Congress 2021 -               values and traditions of the irish                 Congress 2021 reaffirmed some of
         Minister Foley acknowledges          Public Service in maintaining quality              TUi’s most important policy positions,
         Accredited Grades system             education and support for our                      most significantly with regard to our
         does not represent a                 students.                                          abhorrence against, and determination
         precedent                                                                               to end, the scandal of pay
    p.17 Annual Congress 2021 –
                                              tui congress 2021
                                                                                                 discrimination a full decade after it
         Minister Harris becomes first                                                           was first inflicted. We remain
         DFHeriS Minister to address          i wish to record my thanks to the
                                                                                                 committed to supporting the
         conference p.18 TUi in the           hard-working TUi team, to the
                                                                                                 provision of a quality education
         media                                Standing Orders Committee, and to
                                                                                                 service across multiple sectors
    p.21 Annual Congress 2021 –               our service providers for delivering a
                                                                                                 through securing in the first instance
         Full report                          professional and successful remote
                                                                                                 permanent employment on decent
    p.34 Update on Curriculum                 Congress; to the many delegates who
                                                                                                 terms and conditions for the
         Development                          gave generously of their time during
                                                                                                 committed, hard-working and highly
                                              the most intense year of our working
    p.35 rMA News                                                                                qualified educators we are proud to
                                              lives; and to my colleagues on the
    p.36 Crossword with €250 prize                                                               have in our membership.
                                              executive Committee for their work

    eDiTOriAL                    Annette Dolan                     John MacGabhann                        PrODUCTiON
                                 Deputy General Secretary          Assistant General Secretary
    Martin Marjoram              adolan@tui.ie                     jmacgabhann@tui.ie                     TUi News is published by the
    President                                                                                             Teachers’ Union of ireland.
    president@tui.ie             Declan Glynn                     Seamus Lahart
                                                                  Assistant General Secretary             Aontas Múinteoirí éireann,
                                 Assistant General Secretary
    Liz Farrell                  dglynn@tui.ie                    slahart@tui.ie                          73 Orwell road, rathgar,
    Vice President                                                                                        Dublin 6, D06 YP89.
    vicepresident@tuimail.ie     Aidan Kenny                      Anne Howard
                                 Assistant General Secretary      Assistant General Secretary
    Michael Gillespie            akenny@tui.ie                    ahoward@tui.ie                          T: 01 - 492 2588 F: 01 - 492 2953
    General Secretary                                                                                     e: tui@tui.ie    W: www.tui.ie
    mgillespie@tui.ie            Colm Kelly                       David Duffy
                                 Assistant General Secretary      education & research Officer
                                                                  dduffy@tui.ie                           Printed by:
                                 ckelly@tui.ie
                                                                                                          Typecraft Ltd.
                                                                  Patricia Keating
                                 Joanne irwin
                                                                  Administrative Officer
                                 Assistant General Secretary
                                                                  pkeating@tui.ie
                                 jirwin@tui.ie
                                                                  Conor Griffin
                                 John O’reilly
                                                                  Press & information Officer
                                 Assistant General Secretary
                                                                  cgriffin@tui.ie
                                 joreilly@tui.ie

2   May 2021 - TUi NeWS
News Vol.43 / no.5 May 2021 - Teachers' Union of Ireland
tui neWs

Processes are continuing and will           Ministers for education
hopefully deliver positive results for      For the first time, TUi Congress was
members including Adult Literacy            addressed by two Ministers for
tutors, researchers, and Youthreach         education. While honoured to respond
coordinators and resource persons.          to the Ministers on your behalf, i am
Precarious employment, crushing             acutely conscious that speeches are
workloads, bureaucratic overload, the       just one important element in the
unacceptable continuation of                ongoing and detailed engagements and
numerous austerity measures, and the        negotiations which advance your
all-prevailing shortage of the funding      interests. We were delighted that both
necessary to deliver the education          Ministers accepted our invitation and
system this nation needs and deserves       look forward to welcoming them to a
returned as key themes. TUi’s absolute      corporeal Congress next year.
commitment to education as the most
effective response to economic
disadvantage and our determination to       Vaccinations
campaign hardest for those in greatest      The unheralded and abrupt change to
need, especially those with Special         the vaccine allocation groups, and the
educational Needs, were as always           poor Government communications              TUi PreSiDeNT, MArTiN MArJOrAM

central to our debates and                  around that decision, cast an unwanted
deliberations.                              shadow over our Congress. As with         sources regarding extraordinary
                                            the rank ordering data for Calculated     additional workload and changes to
Surveys of members prior to                 Grades, previous commitments and          work practices necessitated by the
Congress confirmed and highlighted          understandings from the Department,       COViD-19 crisis. The ending of
your deep and ongoing concerns with         on which TUi members in good faith        disgraceful pay discrimination is our
regard to significant elements of the       based their decisions and cooperation,    key focus with regard to the use of
Congress agenda, including pay equality     were unceremoniously overthrown.          the 1% sectoral bargaining fund
and the extraordinary measures              We have made clear our dissatisfaction    provided for in the agreement –
adopted on a no-precedent basis as          with the unpredictable and disorderly     discussions with other unions and
part the COViD-19 response. TUi has         approach of Government to the             Government Departments will
expressed its disagreement with the         formulation and communication of          commence shortly.
Government decision to offer                policy on vaccinations. in concert with
Accredited Grades as a choice for this      the iNTO and the ASTi we have             This issue provides a full record of the
year’s Leaving Certificate class, as well   sought high-level engagement, with a      decisions of Congress 2021 which
as our disappointment that the              particular focus on risks related to      your executive Committee will now
externally assessed additional              pregnancy and non-standard classroom      bring into negotiation and
components of assessment will not           settings such as special schools and      implementation. i extend my best
factor into the Accredited Grades           special classes.                          wishes for the health and happiness of
process. We remain hopeful that a                                                     you and your families for the
large proportion of students will sit                                                 remainder of the academic year
the examinations in June. it is vital       Building Momentum                         and a well-earned rest over the
between now and then that every             Plans are advancing with regard to the    summer.
member of school communities                formulation of Building Momentum
adheres to COViD-19 mitigation              Action Plans for various sectors of the
measures and that no needless risks         Public Service. TUi will insist on
are taken, such as in the organising of     absolute adherence to the oft-
unnecessary gatherings or large group       repeated no-precedent assurances
activities.                                 from Government and Department

                                                                                                  www.tui.ie - TUi NeWS          3
News Vol.43 / no.5 May 2021 - Teachers' Union of Ireland
tui neWs

    ‘tui members showed by action and
    accomplishment that they were capable of adapting,
    learning new skills and responding to the needs of
    our students and learners during the pandemic’
    In his address to Annual Congress 2021, TUI General Secretary
    Michael Gillespie outlined the Union’s key priorities across a range of issues.
    Some key messages are set out in the summary below.
    introduction                                  targeted investment that is required to
    Once again, we meet in a virtual setting      make the changes that a new deal would
    owing to COViD-19. However, it is great       deliver.
    to see Congress return to its traditional
    post-easter slot this year. All going well,   Something else we learned from the
    the TUi will return to a corporeal            pandemic is that broadband must be
    Congress in 2022 with the in-person           provided to every household. Being
    debate and the social interactions that we    connected has its challenges but not
    all miss and now appreciate more than         being connected is a new species of
    ever.                                         disadvantage, an impediment to progress
                                                  at an individual, family and community
    Pandemic                                      level. Broadband must be a national asset
    The increased workload, the systemic          rather than a private asset to be
    change, adoption of new emergency work        monetised. Dependency by the state on
    practices and changes in our physical         the private sector has authored failure in
    workplaces all happened almost                housing, health care, and now in
    overnight. However, TUi members               broadband. A fundamental reappraisal of
    showed by action and accomplishment           this approach is overdue.                       TUi GeNerAL SeCreTArY MiCHAeL
    that they were capable of adapting,                                                           GiLLeSPie
    learning new skills and responding to the     no Precedent
    needs of our students and learners during     An absolute commitment that Leaving
    the pandemic as those needs arose.            Certificate and Junior Certificate           from their own homes. This experience
                                                  examinations will run in 2022 and a clear    will influence how TUi engages and
    For that, you should all be complimented.     acknowledgement that this year's             interacts with members in the future.
                                                  examination arrangements are being
    inequality magnified                          carried out by teachers on a no              lack of career Progression
    The pandemic has taught us many lessons,      precedent basis is expected from Minister    Apart from the administrative and
    one being that inequality is endemic in       Foley.                                       bureaucratic overload that is swamping
    our society. The pandemic did not create                                                   function for our Principal teachers and
    inequality, but it did magnify it. This did   emergency measures only                      Deputy Principals, the suppression of
    not surprise our members - we have seen       Teachers have shown commitment,              posts of responsibility has created a
    it and worked against it for years. Maybe     adaptability, and resilience. They did so    barren landscape for teachers in terms of
    we might be listened to now. To tackle        on the basis that these emergency            career progression. Putting it simply, for
    educational inequality effectively and        arrangements would not set a precedent.      most teachers there is no career
    decisively, society must invest in            This “no precedent” approach was agreed      progression. This has caused an entirely
    education as a public service and a key       by Government and by the Department.         predictable and justifiable anger and
    aspect for our future wellbeing.              We note the chorus of consultants now        dissatisfaction amongst our members.
                                                  calling for the temporary arrangements       The TUi expects a real and measurable
    school design                                 to be made permanent.                        process of restoration of posts of
    There must also be a fundamental                                                           responsibility to be put in place and one
    reappraisal and a new conceptualisation       Let me tell you: they will be waiting. We    that will operate to a quick timeline.
    of what a school should look like. School     are not here to allow opportunistic
    design will now have to take account of       dreams to come to fruition. We will not      new entrants/Pay inequality
    what we have learned.                         be fooled into accepting as permanent        Delegates and guests, i want you to
                                                  what we agreed to be temporary. We will      consider the effects of pay discrimination
    We always knew that ventilation and air       not countenance the abandonment of the       against those who entered the profession
    quality were important. We now know           written, state certified exams, externally   since 2011. A palpable anger at this gross
    just how important. Students learn            set and assessed. TUi will not yield to      injustice remains in place. Politicians of all
    better and teachers teach better when         demands for a year-round, 24/7 work          parties bemoaned the injustice but have
    air quality in the teaching space is of a     pattern.                                     done nothing to eliminate it. The victims
    good standard. it has never been a                                                         of this injustice are our members, your
    requirement in our classes, but it must be    Branch Meetings – moved online               colleagues, friends, and relatives. New
    now. This is a structural problem which       The way TUi interactions occur has           entrants worry about precarious work,
    can and must be addressed.                    changed this year. As in other areas,        are anxious about bills and loans that
                                                  Branch meetings went online and, very        must be paid, the extortionate rents that
    education – a ‘new deal’                      notably, attendance has increased. TUi       are demanded and feel a deep sense of
    Today on your behalf and on behalf of the     purchased Zoom licenses and Zoom has         frustration that reasonable and legitimate
    students we serve i am calling for a “new     become the TUi platform of choice. At        life decisions cannot be taken or must be
    deal” for education and the sustained         Zoom Branch meetings members attend
4    May 2021 - TUi NeWS
News Vol.43 / no.5 May 2021 - Teachers' Union of Ireland
tui neWs

delayed. These victims are intelligent,        our members in Dundalk institute of            Maintaining and enhancing staffing and
highly educated professionals, many of         Technology and iADT. expeditions into          allocation in Fe colleges is a priority.
whom, entirely logically, make the             the wilderness by certain Presidents have      When the Pandemic ends there will be
decision not to stay victims. They decide      delayed and impaired progress for these        obvious demands for Further education
- because they have transferable skills - to   institutes. Both DKiT and iADT must be         opportunities and the Government has
leave the profession or to leave the           accommodated and assisted by the HeA           already committed to this in terms of
country.                                       and the Department to become part of           financial support needed. Fe needs to be
                                               Technological Universities. No                 well placed to respond to the
teacher supply crisis                          President's delusions of grandeur must be      opportunities and needs when the
This scandal of discrimination has created     allowed to scupper legitimate aspirations      pandemic is over.
the crisis in teacher supply and retention.    or to impede the hopes of an entire
There is a clear cause and effect. There is    region.                                        adult education
a clear remedy: end the discrimination                                                        TUi has long-standing issues in relation to
and end the crisis. Pay the same               TUi will not accept theories about             Adult Literacy Tutors. The Department
professional rate; establish pay equality.     institutional autonomy that seek to            refuses to provide our members in Adult
Do it now because it is the right thing to     dismantle centralised processes for ir         education services with an appropriate
do.                                            bargaining. This is, of course, not to         and fair career structure and pathway.
                                               suggest that the functioning of the            There has been an appalling unwillingness
Minister Foley should state unequivocally      current ir forums is smooth and efficient.     to recognise the critical importance of
that pay equality will be reinstated and       it is not.                                     adult education for so many of our
must say when this will happen.                                                               neighbors and citizens.
                                               disregard tui at your peril
Building Momentum                              TUi is clear in warning managements of         international Studies such as PiAAC make
The executive Committee recommended            both recently formed and soon to be            clear that ireland needs to prioritise
that the “Building Momentum - Public           formed Technological Universities not to       Adult education. Minister Harris can
Service Agreement 2021-22” not be              seek to disregard TUi. We will not be          make a real and lasting difference. i urge
accepted because it does not end the           swept aside by a new broom                     him to seize that opportunity. There
injustice of pay discrimination against our    management. There are agreements that          needs to be a conclusion of the process
members appointed since 2011. The              management must respect and                    agreed under the LrA Chairman’s Note
TUi’s campaign for pay equality will           implement; procedures that have been           for all Adult Tutors.
therefore continue. The TUi did                negotiated and that must be applied.
recognise that the agreement provides          There is engagement that must occur if         Youthreach and Vtos
the first actual pay increases for public      respectful relationships are to be built       The TUi has lost patience with the
servants in more than 10 years.                and maintained between the TU                  Department and SOLAS regarding the
                                               management and the academic staff              unconscionable delay in providing
The Public Services Committee of iCTU,         represented by the TUi. if not, TUi will act   assurances about the future of Youthreach
by the aggregate vote of affiliate unions,     and act decisively.                            and of VTOS provision. These
has recorded that it is accepting the                                                         programmes deserve and need official
Building Momentum Public Service               review of lecturing                            affirmation from the new Department
Agreement 2021-22.                             The Third level workload and contact           and sustainable structures. Mr. Harris has
                                               time is unsustainable given increased          quite rightly been complimentary of
The position notified by the TUi is that       student numbers and the changes in             Youthreach and has met them virtually.
we agree to be encompassed by and will         process. A clear path for advancing the        That must be welcomed.
not repudiate the “Building Momentum           review of lecturing, building on the first
Public Service Agreement” and TUi              module completed by Prof. Tom Collins, is      in relation to Youthreach, there is a need
members will therefore benefit from the        needed.                                        now to recognise explicitly that what our
pay increases.                                                                                members provide to learners is
                                               apprenticeships                                education, that those providing it are
Building Momentum – sectoral                   TUi welcomes the recently announced            teachers and are teaching. it is up to the
Bargaining                                     move into the CAO process of                   new Department now to show that the
A Sectoral Bargaining process will             apprenticeship applications but must be        disdain for and the neglect of this group
commence shortly which will allocate the       and wants to be consulted about future         are over.
equivalent of 1% of pay to a fund that is      development of the plan.
available within the agreement. This 1% is                                                    additional funding/supports for
in addition to the two 1% pay increases        TUi is the only organisation involved          students who have fallen behind
that will be paid in October 2021 and          across the whole process of                    because of coVid-19
October 2022. TUi is committed to the          apprenticeships - from encouraging it as a     it makes no sense to TUi that students
elimination of pay discrimination against      pathway in our post primary schools and        are supported in Post Primary Schools
new entrant teachers and lecturers.            other education facilities to providing        with resource hours and other supports,
Therefore, as far as teachers are              training in eTBs, ioTs and TUs.                but that this does not follow them into
concerned, TUi has unambiguously                                                              Further and Higher education. The new
prioritised the payment of the HDip/ PMe       further education issues                       Department has an opportunity to
allowance to new entrants as a key             The TUi represents a variety of grades in      provide enhanced links between Fe and
demand from the sectoral bargaining            eTBs, including AeO, CeF,Youth Officer,        iOTs/TUs- to facilitate access, transfer,
negotiations. if our colleagues in other       Adult education Guidance Counsellor,           and progression.
unions have a different priority that is       eTB Directors. Therefore, the current
their business.                                negotiations on Organisation Design of         Membership increases
                                               eTBs are important to our members.             Our membership has grown to where
technological universities                     The slow approach and questions as to          TUi now has more than 20,000 members
There are problems associated with             how this fits into DFHeriS are                 and that is also thanks to you and your
moving from institute of Technology to         concerning but be assured, we will push        involvement in the recruitment of new
Technological University status. However,      for structures that appropriately reflect      members. This membership is the reason
there are far bigger problems associated       the roles and responsibilities.                that the Annual accounts show that the
with not moving to TU status. Just ask                                                        Union is in a sound financial position.

                                                                                                           www.tui.ie - TUi NeWS            5
News Vol.43 / no.5 May 2021 - Teachers' Union of Ireland
tui neWs

    ‘there were extraordinary efforts by our members
    in the very abrupt switch to emergency remote
    teaching’
    Some excerpts from President Martin Marjoram’s response to Minister for
    Further and Higher Education, Research, Innovation and Science, Simon Harris,
    on Tuesday, 6th April.

    Welcome                                         Another workload issue, and one we are
    Like you Minister, we are optimistic about      familiar with in TUi, is to do with
    your new Department. if your new                semesterisation in Further education. We
    Department is successful, we think that         know in Third Level the additional
    will mean it is on the basis of our             burdens that come with semesterisation
    colleges, our ioTs, our TUs, our Centres,       – it was railroaded through on us, and it
    our Youthreach, our VTOS – that these           did massively increase our workload.
    will also be successful. We see the
    potential value of two education voices at      The newly adopted practices that we
    Cabinet.                                        took on in response to the pandemic –
                                                    they are on a strictly no-precedent basis.
    We will keep an eye on the rate of              We will not permit any slippage or any
    progress; we will welcome what is in            complacent assumptions to be made. We
    keeping with our policies; but we will          will insist on being consulted on all
    argue and oppose and, at times, criticise.      proposals affecting our work.
    You have already seen both sides of us,                                                           MArTiN MArJOrAM reSPONDiNG
    and in truth it is not really two sides –                                                         TO MiNiSTer HArriS
    it is the one side because in both              Parity of esteem
    elements we are fighting for what we            it is worth saying that many of your key
    believe in.                                     points resonate with ours. indeed, if there   shortfalls, and your determination to
                                                    was to be an over-arching theme which i       make progress. We will expect detailed
                                                    intended in my remarks to you, it was to      reports at next year’s Congress. Given
    Workload – no-Precedent                         be inclusion, removal of disadvantage, if     our experience over many years, you will
    We acknowledge the thanks that you              you like parity of esteem across              forgive us for waiting to see how you get
    have expressed for the enormously hard          education. in which regard you have           on before passing judgement. We know
    work of our members in response to the          highlighted much that is dear to TUi. Our     there are huge challenges that you face,
    crisis. Our members faced such hard             beginnings were in the Vocational             and that is because we have faced them
    work, to an extent, because they are            education Sector and we have long             for many years.
    carrying such a burden of decades of            championed Adult education, Further
    under-investment. That is a huge gap in         education,Youthreach, Apprenticeship and      You touched on the €168m of additional
    the legacy before us all, that it now falls     widening of access to Third Level. We         COViD funding; while happy that that was
    to you to take leadership in trying to          have no time for elitism or for exclusion     provided, we did not get the consultation
    address. We will be pushing you                 in TUi.                                       we would like to see. We had put forward
    extremely hard in that direction.                                                             what we saw as a vital element in what
                                                    You speak of a single integrated Tertiary     needed to be done, certainly in Third
    There were extraordinary efforts by our         system, and this would be valued by us,       Level, with regard to the COViD
    members in what was a very abrupt               particularly if it does give the correct      response: and that was additional staffing.
    switch to emergency remote Teaching.            value that should always have been there      That did not land favourably with
    There were already enormous workloads,          for Apprenticeship, for Further education,    Government and that was a mistake. The
    there were already huge problems. Some          and all of the other options which are        lack of consultation with regard to the
    of this is purely bureaucratic, a distraction   traditionally overlooked or undervalued.      additional funding, and the lack of clarity
    from teaching and learning. either                                                            for us as to where that funding went,
    measures need to be taken to reduce             We are pleased in the emphasis you            remains a difficulty.
    that burden, or else to hire the extra staff,   placed on consultation with us and that is
    bring forward the extra posts to relieve        the key in dealing with TUi. When
    it. The supports provided to those              properly engaged, we are not found            adult education
    working at home simply were not                 wanting. But if the engagement does not       We are hugely supportive of what you
    adequate, and that goes both to what            happen, then needless problems arise.         have said with regard to additional
    employers made available by way of                                                            funding in Adult education. We are only
    materials and equipment, but also the                                                         too familiar with the value of supporting
    enormous increase in utility bills.             funding                                       adults in literacy, in numeracy, in digital
                                                    We are pleased to hear your focus on          skills and the enormous boost to
                                                    funding, your recognition of the current      confidence that can result. Parity of

6    May 2021 - TUi NeWS
News Vol.43 / no.5 May 2021 - Teachers' Union of Ireland
tui neWs

esteem extends to staff also, and to be        Managerial Work-to-rule                       make sure that it is robust and is proofed
properly valued staff have every right to      One thing which we find frustrating is a      against financial shocks and the
expect proper terms and conditions and         sort of managerial work-to-rule – of          vulnerability of a solely employer-led
an incremental scale. Our Adult Literacy       finding the absolute minimum that a           approach.
Tutors are waiting more than a year now        management can do in order to tick a
after the Labour Court recommendation          box with regard to consultation or
for an offer. We would hope, given the         implementation of an agreement.               Pay equality
emphasis you have placed on this in what       Sometimes, indeed, that minimalism is         You did mention the new Pay Agreement,
you have presented, that there will be a       hard to bear, but it goes further in not      Building Momentum, which absolutely
generous offer and that their enormous         even going to the minimum but breaching       obliges me to mention equal pay for equal
contribution will receive the value that it    the agreement.                                work and the fact that we have many
deserves.                                                                                    members who are earning less simply
                                               An instance of astonishingly poor             because they were appointed after 2011.
                                               consultation, indeed no consultation in       We want to see that matter addressed
third level                                    advance, recently occurred with regard to     and, frankly, the Building Momentum
You have mentioned Technological               the setting up of the new Mayo College        Agreement does not do that.
Universities. Again, i will mention funding.   of Further education. We are very
Also the position of iADT and DkiT. The        disappointed and will seek to resolve the
agreed framework is how the sector             deep concerns that have arisen for TUi        research
should move forward and we do not              members.                                      Across the world, researchers seem to be
want to see madcap schemes outside                                                           among the most exploited workforces.
what has been properly through the             You mentioned the COViD-19 Steering           What we would like to see is no
processes of consultation and agreement.       Committee attended by our Deputy              exploitation, proper value given to those
i want to pay tribute to the TUi teams         General Secretary. We need Union              colleagues who are now in employment
who are negotiating on the ground, and         representation on other forums and            and future colleagues; research and
you have made reference to the progress        there are important bodies such as            lecturing to go hand-in-hand; the closest
that has been made.                            SOLAS on which we have long                   alignment possible in terms and
                                               campaigned to have that necessary             conditions and pay so that it would be
There is a desperate need to advance the       representation. For all the success of the    possible to move between the two
work begun by Tom Collins with regard          COViD-19 Steering Committee, we have          seamlessly.
to workload. We note the OeCD                  less successful industrial relations
initiative. We will engage. We must stress,    Forums such as the eTB ir Forum, the
however, the absolute need to negotiate        ioT ir Forum, and the National                Youthreach
with TUi. No report from no matter how         Negotiating Forum which rarely seem to        That leads me on to Youthreach. One of
exalted a body will be allowed to make         actually solve anything. By contrast we       our fears with regard to researchers is of
inroads into our terms and conditions or       could look at the FeT Stakeholders’ and       ending up with two workforces side-by-
damage our interests. To be clear, we          Third Level Stakeholders’ Forums which        side, doing almost the same thing, but
want a unified Third Level strategy that       TUi pushed to have formed. TUi’s              with massive differences in their terms
delivers a coherent and cohesive sector.       position and approach was the same in         and conditions and their pay. That is the
We fully agree with you on the need for        these as in other forums but astonishingly,   situation that has developed in
negotiation of new academic posts or           from our point of view, agreement was         Youthreach. We are trying to address it;
roles.                                         reached on many vexed and difficult           we have long-standing policy with regard
                                               issues extremely quickly.                     to the recognition of teaching as really
What is currently proposed with regard                                                       teaching and we have brought forward a
to amending the HeA legislation does fall      i would also point to a difficulty with       conversion process and there is an
foul of the May 2017 Agreement, would          employers refusing to jointly refer           engagement at the WrC. in these days
overturn what was agreed with regard to        matters on and we have recently seen          when we do talk about mental health and
Governance structures. Those                   instances of this in the Labour Court.        wellbeing, i am acutely conscious, having
Governance structures had much                                                               spoken to many of our members in
discussion to protect regional interests. in   Both in Third Level and in Further            Youthreach, of the severe distress that
MTU there is a breach in what was              education, we are deeply concerned that       they feel, precisely because they feel
agreed in May 2017 with regard to              we may move into a very fractured             undervalued.
representation on the first Governing          environment. We are seeing difficulties in
Body. TUi offered a certain ad hoc             the inability of TU Dublin and THeA to
approach to meet some of the concerns,         reach joint positions; and we have seen       conclusion
but we were disappointed with the              similar difficulties with sixteen eTBs        in closing Minister, i again want to thank
response and we want that matter to be         operating sixteen different paths.            you for addressing our Congress. i wish
addressed not only in MTU, but for future                                                    you the very best and we in TUi look
TUs.                                           We are fully supportive of what you have      forward to working with you. As well as
                                               said with reference to the development        being partners, we know we will
We would also point to the need for an         of apprenticeship. We are the experts.        occasionally be adversaries, but always
agreement with regard to online lecturing      Possibly no other body has such a             from our perspective with a view to the
and the massive workload implications          breadth of experience and knowledge.          greater good, and with a view to securing
that go with that.                             We look forward to engaging with you in       not just decent terms and conditions for
                                               driving on what can be done to further        our members but the best educational
                                               develop that very important pathway.          service that we can possibly provide.
                                               Whatever is developed, we should try to

                                                                                                          www.tui.ie - TUi NeWS           7
News Vol.43 / no.5 May 2021 - Teachers' Union of Ireland
tui neWs

    ‘if education really has the value we all agree it
    does, then as a nation let us put our money where
    our mouth is’
    Some key points from President Martin Marjoram’s response to Minister for
    Education Norma Foley on Wednesday, 7th April.

    there is much we agree on                     allocation in the same light. We learned
    There is much we agree on. Most               about it from leaks and distressed texts
    especially on the great power of              and emails from members. it directly
    education to bring about equality and to      overthrew previous direction to the
    combat disadvantage. We look forward to       system from your Department on which
    working collaboratively with you in           we had been consulted in advance. This
    advancing that joint ambition.                came from your Department to us in
                                                  good faith, we recognise, and we in good
                                                  faith consulted with our members on that
    We hate surprises…                            basis. The balance of confidence on which
    Minister, TUi hates surprises.                all COViD matters hinge has suffered
                                                  hugely.
    We first met on 1st July 2020, my opening
    day as President of TUi and very shortly
    after your appointment as Minister. One       We never sought priority before
    point i stressed to you, and on which you     other groups in terms of                        MArTiN MArJOrAM reSPONDiNG TO
    gave a firm commitment, was that there        vaccination                                     MiNiSTer FOLeY
    would not be surprises – that all             We never sought to advance ourselves
    significant decisions and policy changes      before other groups in terms of
    affecting members would be notified in        vaccination and we fully support that        provision over the Summer – where
    advance.                                      those most vulnerable to serious illness     hours are assigned to an individual
                                                  should clearly be prioritised, as well as    student but a fully registered teacher
    TUi is justly proud of our professionalism.                                                does this work, meaning entering a
                                                  those in health.
    You and your officials will be accustomed                                                  student’s family home.
    to TUi’s detailed submissions and             For all of the science you state is at the
    presentations and know the extent to          heart of the change, and which we fully      in all the above cases it tends to be
    which that improves your Department’s         respect, nothing makes it sensible for me    younger teachers doing this valuable and
    outputs. Our comprehensive advices to         (who spend my days on Zoom or Webex)         necessary work.
    members are widely admired, even              to be vaccinated before any teacher going
    outside our own organisation. We take                                                      if not vaccinated now, how can they in
                                                  into a crowded classroom every day.
    great care to be accurate and, for all of                                                  confidence do it? All of this, and indeed
                                                  indeed, the NiAC advice regarding risks
    the inevitable and at times necessary                                                      the Leaving Certificate examinations in
                                                  arising from severe disease is premised
    disagreement that might arise, there is a                                                  June, may be impacted by failing to do
                                                  on having already been infected – let us
    delicate mechanism between TUi and the                                                     what we believe is right.
                                                  not overlook the increased probability of
    Department of trust and confidence, built     catching the disease in the first place
    on correct information and guidance. This     because of operating in particular           Bureaucratic overload
    is vital in our role as a representative      environments.                                We acknowledge the thanks that you
    body. Hammer blows against that careful
                                                                                               have extended to us. Certainly, in TUi, we
    balance are damaging.                         Leaving aside the standard crowded
                                                                                               know only too well the enormous
                                                  classroom, let us consider the other
    For example, you will know that the                                                        contribution of teachers to their students
                                                  particular areas of concern.
    information we sent to our members on                                                      through this unprecedented crisis. We
    last year’s Calculated Grades was             Special Schools: TUi have teachers in        have indeed, as you have generously
    checked with Department officials             Home economics, Maths, Woodwork,             acknowledged, moved heaven and earth.
    beforehand, which made it all the more        other subjects; resource teachers in         We have taken on an enormous
    disappointing when the highly sensitive       special schools in close contact in a        additional workload. We would point out,
    rank order data was treated                   different environment than the standard      though, that there was a high workload
    fundamentally differently from what was       classroom; resource teachers in special      there already, due to high class sizes,
    agreed, something we first learned about      classes; teachers doing Summer provision:    bureaucracy and initiative overload. And
    in the media.                                 these are second level teachers who          we would like your help, Minister, in the
                                                  work in June and July dealing with           future in removing as much of this as can
    We see the reversal regarding vaccine         students with additional needs; home         be done, in order to focus on the key

8    May 2021 - TUi NeWS
News Vol.43 / no.5 May 2021 - Teachers' Union of Ireland
tui neWs

priorities – on the key priorities of           a decade on, pay discrimination                  nothing without high calibre teachers in
teaching and learning.                          continues                                        those classrooms.
                                                Minister, i’m going to read you a motion
                                                from Congress:                                   it may be said, as you have pointed out,
leaving certificate                                                                              that the Building Momentum pay
issues                                          Congress instructs the Executive that            agreement, with its additional incremental
We acknowledge your recognition that            Government plans that new entrants to the        skip, and with its sectoral bargaining fund,
the new arrangements are on a no                public service will have a reduced salary        provides a mechanism to address
precedent basis and we certainly look           are wholly unacceptable. Congress instructs      outstanding issues. Minister, the new
forward hopefully to a return to                                                                 measure and the available 1% are not
                                                the Executive to resist this disgraceful plan,
normality in the coming year. if, as seems                                                       enough to close the remaining gap. We
likely, there need to be adjustments to
                                                nationally through cooperation with other        also need, and i point this out very
accommodate the difficulties faced by this      public sector Unions, and in TUI                 importantly, because it is not in the text, a
year’s fifth years for their Leaving            workplaces through industrial action if          cast-iron assurance that this limited
Certificate, we will look forward to early      necessary up to and including strike action.     measure will apply to future entrants.
engagement on that and, hopefully, early                                                         Please Minister do not oversee the
indications to the system of what may           This is a motion that was carried                creation of a new discrimination.
come forward.                                   unanimously. it is a motion i proposed to
                                                TUi Annual Congress 2011 – when it had           if this continued inequality is not
With regard to Senior Cycle review, we          become apparent that the protections in          addressed, the profession suffers. in our
certainly welcome your comments. We             the Croke Park Agreement (which were             view, if addressed using the sectoral
are committed to positive engagement            later broken anyway) against further             bargaining mechanism, which would need
and will continue to engage as we have          pay-cuts for public servants did not             several iterations in order to fully take
already done. And we re-iterate our             extend to colleagues to be appointed in          care of the difficulty, then a gap will open
commitment and see the need for a re-           the future. Congress 2011 was appalled           up between teachers and the rest of the
iteration all round to the Statement of         and spoke with one voice against a               public sector because we will be forgoing
Principles and the implementation               measure it found disgraceful. Numerous           pay rises over the course of time in order
document on the new Junior Cycle. And           other motions decried the measure,               to address an issue which we did not
we would point to the need for the              some spelling out in gruesome details            create.
Junior Cycle reforms to be fully                what was about to be inflicted. Little
reviewed, in order to inform what               could i have imagined that 10 years later i      We believe this issue, and all of our
may come forward for the Leaving                would stand here, in a haircut i gave            research with the assistance of our
Certificate.                                    myself, referring to this motion as though       Principals’ and Deputy Principals’
                                                it had just been submitted because it is         Association – it points to the direct
                                                still as relevant today.                         connection between this inequality and
                                                                                                 the recruitment and retention crisis in
‘devastating effect’ of posts of                Minister, this attack on those then              our Post-Primary schools. We do not
responsibility cuts and historic                entering teaching was an act of vandalism        believe that the Teacher Supply Action
lack of investment                              against the profession. it must be ended.        Plan can address that crisis unless the pay
We point out, as we have done before,           is not a decade of discrimination enough?        inequality issue is addressed properly.
the devastating effect of the enormous
reduction in Posts of responsibility in         While the poison afflicts other
schools through the austerity years and         recruitment grades, for our second level
we would hope to see the full restoration       members about 40% are suffering under            We want to work
of those posts in the coming years.             this gross inequity. Their morale                constructively
Teachers are leaving the profession for         undermined, their mortgage options               Minister, with the exception of certain
other reasons, but certainly this is one –      limited, their professionalism next to           family milestones, it has been the honour
the lack of a career progression; and           their colleagues undervalued and                 of my life to be in a leadership position of
there is also the difficulty of Principal and   degraded. in our most recent survey of           extraordinary educators at this very
Deputy Principal teachers being                 members, a third of our lower paid               difficult time, and this is something i think
appointed with no middle management             colleagues see the removal or not of this        i may well share with you. i look forward
experience.                                     discrimination against them as the               Minister to continuing to work
                                                determining factor in whether or not             constructively with you. We have laid out
ireland found itself in a particularly          they will remain in the profession.              our agenda and we recognise that there
difficult position regarding the return to                                                       are areas of disagreement, as there always
school in the pandemic because of our           These members of ours, these teachers            must be. But Minister, we commit to
abnormally large class sizes. Surely, we        up and down the country, are the                 being constructive and to engaging and
must learn a lesson from the experience.        foundation on which the next several             we do wish you well in your continued
it is essential that we begin to plan           decades of irish education will rest.            time as Minister of education.
immediately for corrective measures.            inheritors of one of the nation’s proudest
if education really has the value               and deepest traditions, they are also key
we all agree it does, then as a nation          creators of its future. All the investment
let us put our money where our                  in the world in bricks and mortar, in iT
mouth is.                                       and lab equipment, in the classrooms
                                                appropriate for the 21st century,
                                                necessary as that will be, will count for

                                                                                                               www.tui.ie - TUi NeWS             9
News Vol.43 / no.5 May 2021 - Teachers' Union of Ireland
tui neWs

10   May 2021 - TUi NeWS
tui neWs

    www.tui.ie - TUi NeWS   11
tui neWs

                                                                   TUICU Online
                                                                   Membership
                                                                   A Quick & Easy 5 Step Process

                                                                                      Download our app from
                                                                                      your App Store / Google
                                                                                      Play Store

               JOIN US
                 ON                                                                   &ŝůůŝŶĂůůLJŽƵƌŝŶĨŽƌŵĂƟŽŶ

               MOBILE!                                                                Upload your photo ID,
                                                                                      ĂĚĚƌĞƐƐĚŽĐƵŵĞŶƚĂƟŽŶΘ
                                                                                      picture

                                                                                      ^ƵďŵŝƚLJŽƵƌĂƉƉůŝĐĂƟŽŶ

                                                                                      ^ŝƚďĂĐŬΘǁĂŝƚĨŽƌŽŶĞŽĨ
                                                                                      the team to contact you
                                                                                      with your membership
                                                                                      details

                       EXCELLENCE IN PROVIDING
                    FINANCIAL SERVICES WITHIN THE
                         EDUCATIONAL SECTOR
                       AWARD WINNERS 2020
                           No 8 The Exchange, Calmount Park, Ballymount, Dublin 12, D12 W354
                                        01-4266060 info@tuicu.ie www.tuicu.ie

12   May 2021 - TUi NeWS
tui neWs

                                               It’s Back!
  Our Special Home Improvement Loan is available at the rate of 4)778

 THINKING OF RENOVATING?
 We’ve got the
 &
 improvement loan
 '#

                                           SPECIAL PROMOTIONAL
         l                                       LOAN RATE

 r
  Specia n
   o m otio                                              4)638
P                                                      +4)778                           ,                     ##!.1/(///) &#!0/' )
                                                                                                                              - " ')
         Loan Amount                                          APR                             Monthly Repayment                         Total amount repayable

      €30,000                                         4)778                                     .22/)5/                                 .27(55/)/5
         Over 10 years
  %#  ##  $#   "  & #  #   $"  ##  #    &
# # # #  &     ! &   #& '      #   &

    !#" !#
   Monthly Draw Winners
   MARCH 2021
    1st Prize               Helen Kenny Murphy, Co. Kildare
    2nd Prize               Gerard McNulty, Co. Galway
    3rd Prize               Sarah McNally, Co. Meath
   APRIL 2021
    1st Prize               Alan Kelly, Dublin 24
                                                                                                         April’s car draw winner Alan
    2nd Prize               Margaret Dorney, Dublin 14                                                    %

                                                                                                                    ONLY €5 PER MONTH!
    3rd Prize               Paul McMullan, Dublin 14
    4th Prize               Roslyn Flood, Co. Kildare

$")$! )
%!!!!! )
  • Access your eStatements online 24-7
  • Save and print eStatements from your home computer
  • Receive an email when new eStatements are available
 !*  '( ! #%!!!!
                                    Sign up today!
                                                                                                                                                  www.tui.ie - TUi NeWS                        13
tui neWs

14   May 2021 - TUi NeWS
tui neWs

    www.tui.ie - TUi NeWS   15
tui neWs

     Minister acknowledges that calculated Grades
     and accredited Grades systems do not
     represent a precedent

     in her address to TUi’s Annual Congress    The Minister described teacher
     on 7th April, Minister for education       conferences as a celebration of the
     Norma Foley confirmed that, as TUi has     ‘energy, enthuasiasm, talent and
     always made clear, the Calculated Grades   commitment that is at the very heart of
     and Accredited Grades systems ‘do not      the education sector’ and outlined the
     represent a fixed precedent for future     often ‘grimly hard’ experiences in
     senior cycle reform.’                      schools in recent times as a result of the
                                                pandemic.
     The Minister acknowledged that TUi ‘have
     been advocates for carefully considered    She outlined the terms for ‘new entrant’
     reform of the Senior Cycle’ and            teachers in the Building Momentum
     emphasised the ‘need to make sure          agreement – an agreement which the
     Senior Cycle provides a sound              Union’s executive Committee
     educational experience for students.       recommended not be accepted because
     Senior Cycle needs to build on the         of its failure to end pay discrimination –
     strengths of what works well now, and it   stating that she recognised that TUi            MiNiSTer FOLeY ADDreSSiNG
     also needs to address the current and      members ‘would like to see further action       ANNUAL CONGreSS 2021
     future learning needs of all types of      on pay’ and that her Government
     learners and schools.’                     ‘remains committed to making
                                                                                             The Minister concluded that it was
                                                further progress over its term.’ Her
     Minister Foley said that while Senior                                                   ‘nothing short of remarkable, in the face
                                                Department would be engaging directly
     Cycle arrangements will evolve and                                                      of an unprecedented pandemic, the
                                                with the TUi on ‘some of the issues they
     change, they must do so in a way that                                                   manner in which school staff have
                                                wish to see advanced’ as part of the
     commands the confidence and support of                                                  successfully readjusted, reconfigured and
                                                sectoral bargaining aspect of the
     teachers, other stakeholders and wider                                                  reimagined the traditional teaching and
                                                agreement.
     irish society.                                                                          learning experience.’

16    May 2021 - TUi NeWS
tui neWs

simon harris becomes first Minister for
further and higher education, research,
innovation and science to address tui’s
annual congress
Simon Harris became the first Minister         pointing this out for decades but it
for Further and Higher education,              remains undone. This means we have yet
research, innovation and Science to            to reach our full potential.
address TUi’s Annual Congress on 6th
April. in his opening comments, the            it has allowed a points race get out of
Minister said that the establishment of        control and place appalling levels of
the new department provides a massive          pressure and stress on young people in
opportunity to apply a new focus to            our country. it has allowed an almost
further and higher education and also to       elitist mindset emerge which defines
the research agenda.                           success in some people’s mind on where
                                               you went to college rather on what you
‘in my nine months in this role,’ the          want to do in life and how best to get to
Minister said, ‘i have heard first hand from   that point. it has failed to recognise the
TUi members across the country and i           brilliance of further education and
have heard from students and learners as       training and how this should not just be a      MiNiSTer HArriS ADDreSSiNG
i have been making virtual visits to           fall back option for students but for many      ANNUAL CONGreSS 2021
colleges, adult education centres,             should and can be a first choice. it has
Youthreach and eTBs. And today i wanted        allowed skills shortages in key areas to
to be here to say thank you. Thank you         develop. it has ignored the worrying         huge value of Youthreach
for your flexibility, dedication and agility   dropout rates from higher education.         ‘i could not finish an address to your
during the COViD-19 pandemic.’                 So things must change. They must change      Congress without paying particular
                                               quickly.’                                    tribute to all of you who work in
Some of the issues addressed by the                                                         Youthreach. i am aware we have issues to
Minister are set out below:                    apprenticeships                              work through and that must advance
                                               ‘We have so much more to do.                 quickly. But today, i just wanted you to
funding                                                                                     know that some of the most incredible
‘We have made some progress in recent          Our plan will seek to continue to expand     meetings i have had in recent months
years and investment levels have               apprenticeships across a wider range of      have been with staff and students in
increased but it is not where it needs         industries alongside supporting and          Youthreach. This is an initiative i want to
to be.                                         growing the traditional craft                champion as Minister. it has turned the
                                               apprenticeships. We will take specific       lives of so many people around. it has
This new dedicated department will seek        actions to ensure more female                rebuilt people after a difficult experience.
to rectify that. We expect the final report    participation in apprenticeships, more       it has supported people going through
on the future funding of the sector in the     apprenticeships in the regions and           challenges. it has provided education,
next few months and i want you to know         crucially, more apprenticeships in the       opportunity, respect and hope to so many
two things: i don’t intend to be dusting it    public service.’                             people and their families and their
or seeking a shelf to stick it on. i intend                                                 communities. it is an example of ireland
to act on it with government colleagues        technological universities                   at its best. We must build on it. We must
and to engage with our stakeholders.’          ‘i know many members here are                cherish it.’
                                               currently engaging on the issue of
adult education                                Technological Universities in their own      conclusion
‘The days of adult education being             areas.                                       ‘The work of this new department – and
overlooked are over. i am here to provide                                                   i am proud to be its first Minister – is the
a focus, an energy and a priority in           i look forward to engaging with the TUi      building block of everything we want to
Government and in policy making that is        on how funding models can be improved        see for the future economic and social
urgently needed, long overdue and              to recognise the unique situations faced     life of the country when we have
essential to our future wellbeing as a         by Technological Universities and i          emerged from the pandemic.Your work
country.’                                      commit to a programme of investment in       and that of your students and learners
                                               new Technological Universities including     means there is hope for the future.’
need for integrated third level                expansion of campuses in Waterford,
sector                                         Carlow and Wexford.’
‘We need a fully integrated third level
sector in ireland. People have been

                                                                                                          www.tui.ie - TUi NeWS            17
tui neWs

     tui in the media
     The following is a sample of issues recently addressed by TUI representatives
     in the national media
                                                                                                          ‘I’m down €80,000 over a career...
                                                                                                          doing same job for less pay is kick in
                                                                                                          the gut’ - TUI Executive Committee
                                                                                                          member David Waters discusses pay
                                                                                                          discrimination in Irish Independent -
                                                                                                          5/4/21
                                                                                                          At current reckoning, the teacher of english
                                                                                                          and history will end up being paid about
                                                                                                          €80,000 less over his career than, for instance,
                                                                                                          someone who started in the classroom two
                                                                                                          years before he joined in 2012.
                                                                                                          “i am nearly 10 years in the job, and doing the
                                                                                                          same job as another teacher, might even be
                                                                                                          teaching the same students, but you don’t feel
                                                                                                          as valued. it’s a kick in the gut,” he said. David
        TUi PreSiDeNT MArTiN MArJOrAM ADDreSSeS NATiONAL MeDiA AT ANNUAL
                                                                                                          is one of the growing number of teachers
        CONGreSS 2021                                                                                     recruited after January 2011 who are being
                                                                                                          paid less than those who joined before the
                                                                                                          austerity-era salary cuts that were imposed
     The Teachers’ Union of ireland has called for       they would have spent on face-to-face            that month.
     the provision that has allowed pregnant             delivery.
     teachers to work remotely during the Covid-                                                                        ________________
     19 pandemic to be continued after the easter                                                         'Our Annual Congess is not a
                                                         ‘Pay parity still not achieved… post-2011        whingefest...' Opinion editorial by TUI
     break. TUi President Martin Marjoram said           teachers still down €80,000 in career
     pregnant members of the union were finding                                                           General Secretary Michael Gillespie in
                                                         earnings – this will also be a major issue at    Irish Times on 5/4/21 in which he
     the lack of clarification extremely stressful.      our Congress… United Nations and World
     “We are calling today on the Department of                                                           identified and explained key issues of Annual
                                                         Health Organisation have called for              Congress 2021 including COViD-19 related
     education to alleviate the serious worry and        prioritisation of teachers in vaccination
     concern that this is causing by announcing that                                                      matters, pay discrimination, third level funding,
                                                         programmes.’ TUI General Secretary               issues in the FeT sector and general
     these teachers will continue to be allowed to       Michael Gillespie discussed pay
     work remotely, should they choose to do so”,                                                         underfunding of education.
                                                         equality issues and the vaccination
     he said. Call for pregnant teachers to              programme on RTE's Today With Katie              ‘The 8 per cent fall in applications for second
     continue remote working - RTE                       Hannon 3/4/21                                    level teaching courses through the CAO this
     30/3/21                                                                                              year shows the damage that a decade of pay
                                                                      ________________                    discrimination has inflicted on the profession’s
                                                         Calls for more teachers and funding              attractiveness, as does the huge struggle
     ‘The position of the TUi has always been that       in schools ‘to help pupils catch up' -
     the most vulnerable in society should be                                                             school principals continue to face in terms of
                                                         Irish Independent 5/4/21                         teacher recruitment and retention across the
     vaccinated first, including the elderly and those   Schools are going to need more resources
     with underlying health issues…we’re                                                                  country and across the breadth of subject
                                                         next year to help students catch up with what    areas. With student numbers set to rise
     disappointed that the [promised] prioritisation     they lost in the pandemic, according to a
     has gone… We have a very young teaching                                                              sharply in the coming years at second level,
                                                         teachers’ union. More than nine in 10 (93pc)     resolution of this gross injustice must take on
     profession, they will now be very far down the      teachers have noticed disengagement by some
     list based on age profile.Yet Government has                                                         a new urgency.’
                                                         pupils since the switch to remote learning,                    ________________
     prioritised the opening of schools, so they are     according to a survey by the Teachers’ Union
     working in one of the few areas in the State        of ireland (TUi). While 75pc of teachers         ‘We want equal pay for equal work. New
     opened.’ TUI General Secretary Michael              reported that student engagement was better      entrant pay was cut in 2011, and while it has
     Gillespie criticises revision of                    in 2021 than in 2020, there is much concern      improved over the years, these teachers are
     vaccination roll-out on RTE's Morning               about the extent of the learning loss over the   still down €80,000 over the course of a
     Ireland programme 31/3/21                           past year.                                       career, and most of this is frontloaded in the
                                                                                                          early years of their career. This is a
     Policing online cheating is adding to                                                                fundamental principle – two people doing the
     workload, lecturers say - Irish Times                                                                same work should get the same pay.’ TUI
     2/4/21                                                                                               General Secretary Michael Gillespie
     Lecturing staff in third-level educational                                                           previewed TUI's Annual Congress
     institutions have experienced a significant                                                          including issues around vaccine rollout
     increase in workload following the move to                                                           and pay discrimination on RTE's
     remote teaching during the pandemic, the                                                             Drivetime programme 5/4/21
     Teachers’ Union of ireland (TUi) has said.                                                                         ________________
     Survey findings released by the union ahead of                                                       how Zoom revitalised teachers'
     its annual conference next week found 92 per                                                         unions - irish times 6/4/21
     cent of lecturers saying they were spending                                                          Zoom can’t necessarily replace the benefits of
     more time preparing and providing remote                                                             face-to-face meetings, says Liz Farrell, a TUi
                                                            rTe NeWS, 7TH APriL 2021                      member and teacher at Coláiste eoin in
     classes and carrying out associated work than

18    May 2021 - TUi NeWS
tui neWs

                                                      Third-level system places 'appalling'               entering teaching was “an act of vandalism
                                                      stress on young people, says minister -             against the profession”.
                                                      Irish Examiner 6/4/21
                                                      Martin Marjoram, president of the TUi,              Secondary teachers to consider strike
                                                      welcomed the minister’s proposal to make            action unless there is end to pay
                                                      access to third-level more equitable, adding        inequality - Irish Times 8/4/21
                                                      that an integrated system would be “valued”         Teachers have renewed their call for an end to
                                                      by the union.                                       unequal pay scales, which sees those
                                                      “We have long championed adult education,           appointed after 2011 paid less than their
                                                      further education,Youthreach, apprenticeships,      colleagues for the same work. Delegates at
   rTe NeWS, 6TH APriL 2021                           and widening of access to third-level. We have      the Teachers Union of ireland’s annual
                                                      no time for elitism or for exclusion,” he said.     conference agreed that unless measures to
                                                      “in an earlier address to Congress, i decried       end pay equality are put in place, they would
Hacketstown, Co Carlow.                               the obsession with CAO points. indeed, i            consider strike action. The union previously
“You can’t read the room, feel the atmosphere         would welcome a reform to take some of that         took a one-day strike action on February 4th,
or respond to people’s reactions, and there           pressure away from students and which also          2020, over the issue.
can be distractions online: dogs barking,             highlights, for them, their other options.” He      “The last strike demonstrated true solidarity
children fighting, bad wifi.” she says. “But it has   said it now falls to the minister to address        with our members who suffer the outrage of
been useful for people who might have                 “decades of underinvestment” in higher              pay discrimination,” said David Waters of the
hesitated to travel in the depths of winter,          education.                                          TUi’s executive committee. “We seemed to be
especially if a colleague could bring them back                     ________________                      making progress last year - before Covid-19
the information. if it’s as easy to Zoom in, that     Third-level funding ‘ducked and                     struck. Schools are reaching a crisis point in
changes things.”                                      dodged’ for too long, says Harris -                 hiring staff, and pay inequality is at the crux of
                                                      Irish Times 7/4/21                                  the issue. The pay discrimination was brought
Teachers believe remote learning has                  Mr Harris said that he wanted to see                in as a result of the financial crash, but more
led some students to disengage - Irish                increased investment and expansion of the           than ten years have passed.”
Times 6/4/21                                          technological universities which have formed        Karen Gernon, a teacher with the Dublin
The long-standing issue of pay discrimination         from merging institutes of technology.              C&C branch, is on the lower pay scale. “Last
has also emerged as a concern given that              responding to Mr Harris’s speech, TUi               year’s strike action was a success. There was
recession-era pay cuts have not yet been fully        president Martin Marjoram said that teachers        an appetite for change, and while it was stalled
restored. A significant proportion said they did      and lecturers were carrying the burden of           by Covid-19, we need to get the momentum
not believe they would be in the profession in        “decades of underinvestment”. He said that          going.”
10 years’ time. However, if pay discrimination        the TUi was not adequately consulted on the                       ________________
were to be fully resolved, 74 per cent believed       additional Covid-19 funding and how it was
they would still be in the profession in a            allocated.
decade.                                               “TUi members already faced huge workloads
TUi president Martin Marjoram said that               before Covid-19, some of which was purely
although progress had been made in tackling           bureaucratic, and measures need to be taken
pay inequality, there was still an €80,000 loss       to hire extra staff to relieve that burden,” said
in career earnings, with the largest differences      Mr Marjoram.
in salary in the early years of employment.                         ________________
              ________________                        ‘We’re not arguing with the advice in terms of
‘The dynamic has altered and that’s what              the high additional risk faced by people
teachers and students are finding difficult.          depending on age, but we would point out the
                                                                                                             MiCHAeL GiLLeSPie ON VirGiN
Because there’s no interaction, no movement,          additional risks faced by people operating in
                                                                                                             MeDiA NeWS, 12TH APriL 2021
because we’re wearing masks, everybody has            specific environments and certainly a special
adjusted and everybody has done their best.           school, for example, would be one such
But of course it’s difficult to understand, to        environment.’ TUI President Martin
hear, to read facial expressions, to know             Marjoram discusses position on                      ‘Now more than ever, adherence to physical
whether you’re getting through, these are             vaccine rollout on Virgin Media News                distancing is absolutely essential, and anybody
issues that we’re all facing, but i think students,   7/4/21                                              who has COViD symptoms or is a close
communities, schools, teachers and principals                       ________________                      contact of a confirmed case must stay at
have done a tremendous job.’ Vice                     Education minister pledges 'further                 home.’ - Michael Gillespie discussing
President Liz Farrell on the current                  action' on second level pay - Irish                 final phase of schools re-opening on
challenges of teaching and learning -                 Examiner 7/4/21                                     Virgin Media News, 12/4/21
RTE's Today With Claire Byrne 6/4/21                  education Minister Norma Foley has pledged
                                                      to make “further progress” on pay issues in         Move to sanction students who lobby
‘it is particularly disappointing that the placing    the second-level sector over the course of the      teachers welcomed – Irish Times
of staff essential to education in the first third    Government’s lifetime. Over the past decade,        19/4/21
of the population for vaccine allocation was          the TUi has consistently campaigned against         “We believe it hugely important that a
reversed so abruptly and so disrespectfully…          pay inequality, which sees teachers appointed       canvassing ban is put into legislation this year
We have never sought to be advanced above             after 2011 being paid less than their               as not only will it reduce the pressure on
those most vulnerable to infection or the             colleagues.                                         individual teachers, but it will also ensure
most serious consequences thereof, but we             “The department will be engaging directly           fairness for all students by protecting the
must insist that commitments made on such             with the TUi on some of the issues that they        integrity of the system,” TUi said.
sensitive issues be honoured.’ Martin                 wish to see advanced. This is an area where i
Marjoram's address to Annual                          believe we can make progress over the
Congress 2021 featured on RTE's Six                   coming weeks,” she added.
One News 6/4/21                                       in response to the minister, union president
              ________________                        Martin Marjoram said pay inequity for those

                                                                                                                          www.tui.ie - TUi NeWS                19
You can also read