Office EMEA Office Investment Perspective 2018 - JLL

Page created by Marjorie Benson
 
CONTINUE READING
Office EMEA Office Investment Perspective 2018 - JLL
Office
EMEA Office
Investment Perspective
2018
Office EMEA Office Investment Perspective 2018 - JLL
2                                                                          EMEA Office Investment Perspective 2018

Contents
A letter from Peter Hensby                                                  3

2017 – Record investment across continental European office markets         4

Four key themes                                                             6

Where are we in the cycle?                                                  8

International capital                                                      10

2017 Hotspots - a review                                                   12

2018 Hotspots - supply-led growth: an introduction                         14

Spotlight on Amsterdam - Europe’s newest global city                       18

Workplace - powered by Human Experience: an investor perspective summary   20

Contacts                                                                   23
EMEA Office Investment Perspective 2018                                                                                       3

A letter from
Peter Hensby
As we move quickly through Q1 2018,       on record. Particularly striking was        landscape differently as, against a
the future already appears bright for     the fact that, after lagging behind         background of record pricing, you
real estate investment after what was     the Americas for the last ten years,        seek to gain best value and achieve
a very strong year in 2017 – in fact      EMEA was the most active real estate        your investment ambitions. The focus
the best on record. EMEA investment       region globally.                            for investors for 2018 should be on
volumes were up 20% on 2016                                                           seeking out income driven returns
reaching a post-GCF high of €264bn.       Going forward, the continued weight         and rental growth. To help with this,
                                          and increasing diversity of capital         we look at some of the key trends
This was powered by Continental           attracted to real estate, underpinned       expected in 2018, review our hotspots
Europe’s largest markets of Germany       by strong GDP predictions across            predictions for 2017 and importantly,
and France and alongside a major          most markets, means that we foresee         set the scene for further rental growth
return to form of the UK after the 2016   investor demand for real estate             hotspots across the region.
post Brexit vote dip.                     remaining robust. Whilst investors          We hope you find our Office
                                          are inevitably seeking out wider            Perspective useful and informative.
The signs were there for the UK at        opportunities across new property           Please contact myself or anyone in
the end of 2016 and, as we predicted,     classes, the office sector has remained     the team if you would like to discuss
returning investor demand particularly    strong. However, also dominating            any of our findings and ideas.
from overseas investors, meant that       many an investor debate is where we
the UK regained its title as Europe’s     are in the cycle and can it continue?
                                                                                      Best wishes,
largest investment market. Strong         Will concerns over pricing, interest rate
                                                                                      Peter
growth was also seen in the Nordics,      rises and politics impact demand?
the Netherlands and Southern Europe
with Portugal and Italy recording their   In this report we offer some ideas
largest total office investment volume    for looking at the office investment

“Dominating many an investor
 debate is where we are in the cycle
 and can it continue?”
  Peter Hensby
  Head of Offices Pan-EMEA Capital Markets
4                                                                                     EMEA Office Investment Perspective 2018

2017 - Record investment
across continental European office markets

                                                    Office investment surged above
                                                    2016’s post referendum lull in 2017.                    UK
    €121.7bn                                        Asian investors continue to favour
                                                    the UK market taking a 34% share               €31.9bn
                                                                                                      33%
    Europe (including UK)                           of total office investment. However
        16% Ç y-o-y                                 there was also a noticeable uptick
                                                    in activity from other sources of              +
                                                    capital including German, US and
                                                    global funds.

                 € 89.7 bn
              Continental Europe
                 11% Ç y-o-y
                                              After 9 months, total
                                              investment in the French
                                              office market was 41% down
                                              on 2016. However, a record
                                              Q4 saw investment in
                                              France surpass the UK and
                                              Germany for the quarter and
                                              took 2017 total investment              France
                                              5% above 2016. The post
                                              election potential “Macron”           €19.4bn
                                                                                    +5%
                                              effect has boosted H2
                                              investment and provides
                                              good momentum going
                                              forward.

             Belgium and Luxembourg
             reported relatively flat year
             on year movements in total
                                             Benelux
             office investment, however,     €11bn
                                             +26%
             the Netherlands reported
             a 43% increase. Better                                                                         Spain, Italy,
             than expected economic                                                                          Portugal
             performance is feeding                                                                             €7bn
             through into strong real
             estate fundamentals placing
                                                                                                                -3%
             tailwinds behind the Dutch
                                                                     Politcal events in Spain stifled overall
             market.
                                                                     investment in the region in 2017.
                                                                     However, excluding Spain, the region
                                                                     would have posted a 5% increase
                                                                     year on year with both Portugal and
                                                                     Italy reporting their largest total
                                                                     office investment on record.
EMEA Office Investment Perspective 2018                                                               5

                                                                               7%

                                                                                        11%

                             Nordics                                 2017
                            €15.7bn                   51%         investment                 8%

                            +55%                                      by purchaser           4%
   The Nordic region                                                  and by region
   recorded the highest
   office investment
   figures since 2006.                                                                 19%
   Finland and Norway
   were the largest and                              n Americas           n Middle East & Africa
   second largest markets
   in the region for the                             n Asia Pacific       n European (Cross Border)
   first time in history                             n Global             n European (Domestic)
   and both markets saw
   the highest amount of
   investment on record.                             Occupier context
                                                             Demand to remain well above 10-
                                                             year average
                                                             • Europe 11%
                                                             • Berlin 39%
                                                             • Milan 18%
                                                             • Frankfurt 10%
                                                             • Paris 4%
                                           Germany           (FY 2018-19 v 10-year average take-up)
   2017 saw Germany report
   the second largest amount               €23.8bn           Office development modest

                                           +3%
   of investment on record,
                                                             across most of Europe
   since 2007. While year on
   year growth in investment                                 • Europe +5%
   has slowed, investor appetite                             • Paris -19%
   remains strong. This has                                  • Hamburg -16%
   driven office yields to                                   • Amsterdam -40%
   amongst the lowest in the                                 • Madrid -55%
   European market.                                          (FY 2018-19 v 10-year average
                                                             completions)

                                                             Grade A vacancy at record low
                                                             • Stockholm 2.7%
                                                             • Hamburg 2.3%
                                                             • Munich 1.3%
                                                             • Berlin 0.7%
                                                             • Paris CBD: 0.5%

                                             CEE             Recovering markets continue
                                            €3.8bn           to provide upside

                                           -24%
                The CEE market                               • Madrid 5.1%
                reported an expected                         • Barcelona 4.3%
                drop in total office                         • Lisbon 3.9%
                investment following                         • Prague 2.5%
                a record breaking                            • Brussels 1.7%
                2016. However, in a
                historic context, 2017’s
                total investment is the                      Continued opportunity in
                third highest for total                      “next to best” locations
                investment on record.                        Amsterdam – Sloterdijk / Teleport
                                                             Munich – East
                                                             Prague – Prague 1
                                                             Stockholm – Solna / Sundbyberg
                                                             Stuttgart – Vaihingen-Möhringen
6                                                                               EMEA Office Investment Perspective 2018

    Four key themes
    for 2018

          1. Cashflow focused investment
          With pricing at record lows, investors will increasingly focus on income as the
          main driver for returns. Performance is unlikely to come via yield compression
          and therefore will target rental growth. Underpinned by tenant quality, supply /
          demand dynamics and location will inform decision making.

          2. Greater risk appetite
          Underpinned by improving economic growth and strong real estate
          fundamentals, investors will look to increase their risk exposure seeking higher
          returns. Institutional capital is unlikely to compromise on asset quality and
          location and will look to focus on funding developments / refurbishments in
          central locations rather than moving to new geographies in search for yield.

          3. Increased regulation
          While real estate markets are not directly affected by the new European
          MiFID II Directive, we believe its impact will be felt in 2018. For investment
          firms MIFID 2 is expected to result in higher governance costs. Size matters
          and therefore, we wouldn’t be surprised if we will see more consolidation
          in the real estate fund management industry as we recently saw between
          Aberdeen and Standard Life and also the recent mergers in Finland between
          Etera and Ilmarinen as well as Varma and Elo.

          4. Future proofing investment
          Will existing assets today be as relevant in 10 years and continue to attract
          occupiers? Investment strategy is focusing on “Future Proof” assets that look
          at city / location and asset specific criteria. Analysis of current real estate
          holdings will also result in repositioning of portfolios as investors sell-off
          assets most at risk of future obsolescence.
EMEA Office Investment Perspective 2018                                                                                    7

2018 – The search for growth in a highly
competitive landscape

Despite a divisive political climate globally and               In 2018 we expect both prime office yields and policy
throughout Europe, the real estate market in 2017 has           rates in Europe to be broadly stable. In the Eurozone,
continued to outperform. The weight of capital seeking          we do not expect to see rates rise before the end
to access the sector remains significant and, despite being     of 2019 and when Central Banks do start to tighten
deep into the cycle, investors are actively looking for new     monetary policy it will be a slow reversion rather
ways to deploy funds. Total European commercial real            than swift hikes. As a result, we expect the effect on
estate investment in 2017 was €264bn, which represents a        real estate yields to be marginal. If we look to the US,
20% increase on 2016, making it the largest ever on record,     where policy rates have increased by 100bps, the
surpassing the €245bn reported in 2007. Reporting a 34%         effect on prime office yields has been only a 10bps
increase in activity on 2016 levels, the UK seems to have       outward shift. However, due to strong rental growth,
shrugged off some Brexit concerns and remains Europe’s          capital values have continued to increase. In Europe,
largest investment market. The Netherlands recorded             rental growth is improving due to record low vacancy
€18bn of investment which represents a growth rate of           rates across European cities, limited development
81% year on year while Germany was 4% up on a post              response and an improving outlook in the European
financial crisis record of €50bn in 2016.                       pipeline. Therefore, we expect to see income growth
                                                                offsetting any interest rate movements and positive
Appetite for real estate shows no sign of abating and
                                                                growth in capital values to continue.
we expect similar levels of investment activity in 2018.
A combination of manipulated monetary policy, real
estate’s relative performance versus other asset classes        How will investors approach 2018?
and record levels of dry powder raised by global real           Investors will need to be more creative in accessing
estate funds will underpin activity in 2018. Total capital      deals and look beyond the traditional sectors and
raised has continuously reached new peaks throughout            gateway cities. We will also see a continued focus
2017 as a result of institutional investors globally            on larger asset sizes as it allows investors to deploy
allocating more money to real estate. With many pension         significant amounts and rapidly increase exposure to
funds, insurance companies and sovereign wealth funds           the sector or certain markets. With pricing at record
still under allocated, this is likely to continue for some      highs the focus will be on income driven returns and
time. As a result, the European real estate market will         rental growth; whether this be in growth markets,
continue to be a crowded and highly competitive market.         growth sectors or growth of AUM via the acquisition of
                                                                real estate platforms.
Will inflationary pressures impact investment
decisions in 2018?
Potential interest rate rises could have significant impact
on the real estate sector and investment demand. It is
clear that the Global Central Banks are slowly paving
the way towards higher interest rates for the first time
since the financial crisis. With the Bank of England raising
interest rates for the first time in a decade in 2017 and the
European Central Bank slowing down their Quantitative
Easing programme, it is an issue that investors are
watching closely.
8                                                                                                            EMEA Office Investment Perspective 2018

Where are we in the cycle?
Where are we in the cycle?                                                    enabling investors to arbitrage between markets as
                                                                              the improving global economy is spreading to more
While investors are starting to feel uneasy now that
                                                                              markets.
we are entering the 10th year of this cycle, we haven’t
seen the traditional red flags that would signal we are
                                                                              However, this should be seen in context: bond yields
nearing the end.
                                                                              are even lower and the spread between prime real
Further complicating this is the de-coupling of regions                       estate yields and real interest rates is much higher
and markets; i.e. Italian banks are still offloading NPLs                     than in previous cycles offering some protection.
while the US banks finished this years ago.
                                                                              But maybe the biggest difference compared to 2007 is
                                                                              in the capital structure:
What are the major differences in
                                                                              •     Firstly regulation has limited leverage, while the
comparison to previous cycles?
                                                                                    low long-term rates have led to owners extending
Simply put, there is a lot more money chasing real                                  debt maturities
estate investment, which is combined with low
                                                                              •     Secondly the global search for yield, combined
interest rates, low inflation and more restrictions on
                                                                                    with restrictions on development, have resulted
debt financing resulting in record low yields.
                                                                                    in an increase in (semi-)permanent capital real
                                                                                    estate owners from all over the world
JLL’s view
                                                                              In short, the foundation of market liquidity and
We may be more than half way through the current                              pricing in this cycle seems to be built on much
cycle but what we see is a mid-cycle rotation.                                steadier ground than in 2001-2008.
Not all markets are at the same stage of the cycle

How long can Europe hold out?
Policy rates (%)

7
                                                                                           ECB, BoE vs FOMC policy rate lag
6

5

4

3

2

1

0

-1     6m           3m                        18m                     18m                                                                   27m...
  98

          99

                 00

                           01

                                  02

                                         03

                                                04

                                                       05

                                                                06

                                                                       07

                                                                               08

                                                                                      09

                                                                                               10

                                                                                                       11

                                                                                                               12

                                                                                                                      13

                                                                                                                                14

                                                                                                                                       15

                                                                                                                                              16

                                                                                                                                                       17
19

        19

               20

                         20

                                20

                                       20

                                              20

                                                     20

                                                              20

                                                                     20

                                                                             20

                                                                                    20

                                                                                             20

                                                                                                     20

                                                                                                             20

                                                                                                                    20

                                                                                                                              20

                                                                                                                                     20

                                                                                                                                            20

                                                                                                                                                     20

Source: Bloomberg                                           FOMC            ECB            BoE
EMEA Office Investment Perspective 2018                                                                                                9

Uncertainty around European interest rate rises lead                                           Stages of the cycle
investors to rotate up the risk curve                                                          Stage 1 – Yield compression as
•        Typically the ECB tracks FOMC movement by 18 months; yet we are                       investors buy into “yield” assets
         currently at 27 months and counting. While this reflects the more                     Stage 2 – Improving economy
         advanced stage of the US market, it also shows the disparity of                       increases demand for space and
         markets within the Eurozone                                                           rents which creates cash flow
•        Despite recent market activity driving up bond yields and inflation                   growth
         numbers coming in higher than expected, consensus is for a                            Stage 3 – Prime yields trade
         continuation of the current low interest rate environment, although                   at or below previous peaks
         potentially at slightly elevated levels                                               while adjacent fringe locations
•        Nevertheless, even if rates rise there is no evidence that prime                      and regional cities still
         yields will follow at the same pace. This will be driven by tight                     have a significant discount:
         supply and rental growth exceeding inflation; therefore the relation                  Investors rotate into these
         is likely to be with real interest rates rather than nominal rates                    late-cyclical markets
•        Additionally, the spread over real rates is still significantly high so               Stage 4 – in anticipation of an
         the impact is more likely to be a shrinking spread rather than rising                 economic slowdown and with
         property yields                                                                       assets fully priced, investors return
                                                                                               to defensive positions
•        But what does this mean for real estate investors? We expect to see
         more investors targeting opportunities to move up-the-risk-curve
         directing investments towards these late-cyclical markets
         (or sub-markets).

Value add not yet priced below last peak
Prime office yields (%) – cyclical low and high

                    Prime CBDs                     Core cities               City submarkets                       Value add markets
    10
                   Defensive     Yield                 Early Cyclical   Cyclical                         Late Cyclical
     9
     8
     7
     6
     5
     4
     3
     2
                                                           n

                                                rc o

                                                 Du a

                                                sb m
                                    n he H en

                                                 ice e
                           Ba n Ant o
                                  el ila rp
                                                          n
                                                          h
                                              ris lin
                                           Fr CBD

                                                M rt
                                                          h

                                       or n f
                                               -e E

                                              st lm

                                                M m
                                                        rid

                           re re Par blin

                                     Loeg Neg F
                                              onio io
                                   rid Br ity

                                    rid co ls
                                              er ry

                                    ris ch y
                                             ut ter

                                               tte m

                                                er i
                                                        ria
                                           - P or
                                   - N ndo or

                                           em agu
                                                       on
                                           Ba Osl

                                                         r
                                                       ila
                                         St ster

                               Pa an her
                                                        D
                                          th - W
                                                      ric

                                         Du nic

                                         W rda
                                                        e
                                                        u

                                                      nt
                              rc - M we
                                         ndoc oc

                                         - P da
                                                     da

                                          Ro r Ri

                                                     ad
                                         Pa er

                                                    -C
                                       Am kho

                                  de de - L

                                                    ife
                                        a ofi
                                                    ad

                             M - S ss
                              ris Lo seld

                                        - O es
                                                    kf

                                                    M

                                                    el
    Zu

                                                   u

                                                  ip
                                                   n
                                                   B

                                                 er
                                                   -

                                                   a

                                                  u
                                                an

                                                 e

                                    on n
                             as as is
                                            oc
                                              s

                                             ie
                               ad e

                                          T
                                      -S
                                       M
                                      N

                                 ila
                                ila
                              ad
                         sÁ sÁ

                             M
                             M
                            M
                           Pa

                       va va
                     ue ue
                   -N -N
                 a a
               on on
             el el

                                                                            Last peak      Last trough        Q4 2017
           rc rc
         Ba Ba

Source: JLL                                                                 Last peak      Last trough        Q4 2017
10                                                                       EMEA Office Investment Perspective 2018

 International capital

                                                            Americas
                                                            €8.1bn
“As we observe the rise of the
 nation state, property industry
 trends underpin a continued
 endorsement of globalisation”
Peter Hensby
                                                                               Global*
Head of Offices Pan-EMEA Capital Markets                                      €10bn
Cross-border purchaser by source of capital

                                                          2017: $65bn
                                  13%

                                   13%
                                                          2007: $102bn

                  17%                               39%

                          29%                 51%

                     7%
                                    4% 3%                            Asia-Pacific
                                                                   buyers increase
                                   24%                              by 21% from
                                                                     2007-2017

 n Americas       n Middle East
 n Asia Pacific   n EU
 n Global
EMEA Office Investment Perspective 2018                                                                                                11

                                    Cross-border purchasers by source of capital in Europe

                                                      South                Hong                  South                         Other
                                    Global    USA      Korea     China     Kong    Singapore      Africa    Israel    UAE     Mid East
                                    €7.9bn   €4.0bn   €2.2bn    €2.1bn    €1.6bn    €1.4bn       €0.8bn    €0.7bn    €0.7bn   €0.6bn

                                                      Asia
                                               €13.3bn

                                                                                          Total office
                                                                                          investment volumes
           Africa                    Middle East                                          in Europe in 2017:
        €2.8bn                            €7bn
                                                                                          €121.7bn
  Middle East private-sector                     Reforms in China mean                           Hong Kong and South
  participation grows through                    capital will remain                             Korean capital focused
 £11.2bn
  sophisticated syndicators of                £11.2bn
                                                 consistent but specialised                    £11.2bn
                                                                                                 on the office sector
  capital and the introduction
  of public REITs

  New REIT laws in Saudi Arabia                  Established Chinese groups                      Chinese investors with Hong Kong
  provide a new channel for private              may divest from existing office                 subsidiaries will be constrained
  investment into real estate. Limited           holdings to align investment                    by new regulation, providing a
  supply of domestic institutional-              strategies with their core                      competitive advantage to the
  grade real estate could accelerate             business. This may lead new                     mature and experienced Hong
  the need to invest overseas and                groups to explore gateway                       Kong investors who seek yield
  with a 25% allowance, we could                 and strategic locations from a                  and diversification in Europe. With
  see a resurgence of private Middle             business perspective.                           significant exposure to the London
  Eastern capital.                                                                               market, we expect the wave of
                                                                                                 Hong Kong capital to move out
                                                                                                 into mainland Europe.
12                                                                 EMEA Office Investment Perspective 2018

     2017 Hotspots                                                 Berlin
                                                                   Proximity to growth sector talent
                                                                   pools and strong demand for new
     - a review                                                    office development areas.

                                                                                   % Annual Rental
                                          Germany                                     Growth 2017
                                          Hauptbahnhof-Europacity                  +6.4
          Hotspots                        Mediaspree                              +27.5
                                          Mitte                                    +7.5
        Average Rental
        Growth +7.2%
                                                                   Stockholm
                 European Average                                  Affordability vs CBD and a lack
                                                                   of suitable options elsewhere in
                  Rental Growth                                    Stockholm.
                   +4.1%
                                                                                   % Annual Rental
                                          Sweden                                      Growth 2017
     At the start of the year we used     Solna /
                                                                                    +14.3
                                          Sundbyberg - Arenastaden
     our in-depth market insights to
     identify 10 office submarkets that
     we expected to outperform in a
     European context. With average                                Stuttgart
     rental growth of +7.2% y-o-y in                               Record low vacancy and a modest
     2017 (compared to the European                                development pipeline.

     average of +4.1%), our predictions
     were on track.                                                                % Annual Rental
                                          Germany                                     Growth 2017
     These locations all featured         City Centre                                +4.7
     robust property fundamentals,        City Centre Edge                          +10.5
     strong occupier demand and a
     catalyst which differentiated the
     market, which in turn drove solid                             Barcelona
     rental growth.                                                Urban renewal, improved
                                                                   transport connections and a
     These drivers of growth are still                             thriving TMT sector.
     relevant at the start of 2018 and
                                                                                   % Annual Rental
     we expect this to underpin rental    Spain                                       Growth 2017
     growth in these submarkets in
                                          22@ - Placa de las Glories                +8.5
     the foreseeable future.
EMEA Office Investment Perspective 2018                                                                                         13

                            Munich                                                        Madrid
                            New high quality office and                                   Connectivity and cost
                            residential developments and                                  effectiveness.
                            affordability.

                                             % Annual Rental                                                % Annual Rental
  Germany                                       Growth 2017          Spain                                     Growth 2017

  East                                        +13.5                  Mendez Alvaro                            +7.0

                            Amsterdam                                                     Luxembourg
                            & Utrecht                                                     City
                            Demand spill from prime submarkets                            New tram route unlocks
                            in Amsterdam. Redevelopment of                                improved demand. Limited
                            Utrecht Central Station. As incentives                        new development.
                            decrease in Amsterdam South-East we
                            expect headline rental growth to be
                            stronger in 2018.

                                            % Annual Rental                                                % Annual Rental
 Netherlands                                   Growth 2017           Luxembourg                               Growth 2017
 South-East                                  +0.0
                                                                     Kirchberg                              +2.9
 Utrecht                                     +9.1

                            Frankfurt                                                     Paris
                            Slight uptick in 2017 on the back                             The end of 2017 saw exceptional
                            of improving demand and office                                take-up levels across Paris, with
                            withdrawals. We expect rental                                 the central submarkets expected
                            growth in the banking district                                to see healthy growth in 2018. The
                            to accelerate as Grade A supply                               benefits of Grand Paris will be felt in
                            tightens in 2018.                                             the future.

                                            % Annual Rental                                                % Annual Rental
 Germany                                       Growth 2017           France                                   Growth 2017
 Banking District                             +2.7                   Paris 3/4/10/11                         +2.7
 City                                         +0.0                   Southern Inner Rim                      -1.5
14                                                                          EMEA Office Investment Perspective 2018

     2018 Hotspots
     supply-led growth: an introduction

     In the context of a modest                 2021 Forecast
     development cycle and record low           Where will supply be in 2021 compared to the steady
                                                state vacancy rate?
     vacancy across many European office
     markets, the supply side is likely to
                                                 City                                  Rank           Score
     play an increasingly important role
                                                 Amsterdam                               1              1
     in driving rental growth over the next
                                                 Munich                                  2            0.97
     3-4 years. JLL’s Supply Sensitivity         Dublin                                  3            0.94
     Index provides new insights into            Bucharest                               4            0.91
     market performance by exploring             Utrecht                                 5            0.88
     the relationship between vacancy            Stuttgart                               6            0.85
     rates and net effective rents. This         Stockholm                               7            0.82
     is a different and forward-looking          Manchester                              8            0.79
     alternative to traditional forecasts,       Dusseldorf                              9            0.76

     which allows us to identify potential       Hamburg                                 10           0.74
                                                 Birmingham                              11           0.71
     (supply-led) rental growth hotspots
                                                 Frankfurt am Main                       12           0.68
     across Europe. In this section, we
                                                 Prague                                  13           0.65
     introduce two of seven metrics that         Barcelona                               14           0.62
     we have developed for analysis              Glasgow                                 15           0.59
     purposes.
                                                Source: JLL

     Initially, our Index identifies a steady
     state vacancy rate for each market         Amsterdam:             Stockholm:                 Frankfurt:
                                                As at Q4 2017          Even with demand           Development
     (i.e. the vacancy rate at which net        vacancy stands         at record high levels      pipeline has picked
     effective rents are stable). From its      700bps below           there is no sign of a      up significantly in
     steady state, the Index then looks at      the stable rate        substantial supply         the last 18 months.
                                                equivalent. Net        response. Market           Nevertheless,
     future vacancy (2021 Forecast), rental     effective rents        wide vacancy to            vacancy to remain
     sensitivity to vacancy (Sensitivity) and   were up 10% in         remain between             around 270bps
                                                2017 alone. By         7.5% – 8%. Lowest          below the stable
     five other metrics that will dictate       2021 vacancy is        in 15 years.               rate equivalent.
     rental growth prospects. Please            forecast to drop to
     contact us for further information on      around 1100bps
                                                below the stable
     the full analysis or to request a copy     rate equivalent,
     of our forthcoming full Rental Growth      indicating plenty of
                                                growth to come.
     Hotspots 2018 report.
EMEA Office Investment Perspective 2018                                                                                                               15

    Sensitivity
    In which market do rents respond strongest to changes in vacancy?
     City                                                     Rank           Score
     Leeds                                                     1               1                    Budapest:
     Budapest                                                  2             0.97                   Budapest records substantial rental changes
                                                                                                    on the back of vacancy fluctuations. Prime
     Prague                                                    3             0.94                   rents jumped 10% when vacancy dropped
     Stockholm                                                 4             0.91                   230bps to 11.3% between Q3 2016 – Q1 2017.
     Stuttgart                                                 5             0.88
     Moscow                                                    6             0.85                   Warsaw:
                                                                                                    High levels of supply in recent years (2013-16)
     Bristol                                                   7             0.82                   have muted rental growth. Supply constraints
     Warsaw                                                    8             0.79                   in 2006-08 and again in 2012 were followed by
     Berlin                                                    9             0.76                   a substantial rental response.
     The Hague                                                 10            0.74
                                                                                                    Edinburgh:
     Dublin                                                    11            0.71                   As a relatively small market (in a European
     Birmingham                                                12            0.68                   context) supply changes usually trigger
     Edinburgh                                                 13            0.65                   a strong response in rents. As vacancy
                                                                                                    dropped below 7% in 2014, Edinburgh
     Amsterdam                                                 14            0.62                   rental growth has since outperformed the
     London - City                                             15            0.59                   UK regional average.
    Source: JLL

    Rental growth upside
    Final ranking (total score - weighted)

                                                                                                    1. Amsterdam                  8. Dublin
                                                                                                    0.81                          0.62
                                                                    3
                                                                                                    2. Stuttgart                  9. Utrecht
                                7                                                                   0.80                          0.61
                                    12
                          8    11                    13                                             3. Stockholm                  10. Warsaw
                                    14       1                          10
                                                 9
                                                                                                    0.74                          0.61
                                                     2         5
                                                          4                                         4. Munich                     11. Manchester
                                                                                                    0.65                          0.55
                                                                                                    5. Prague                     12. Leeds
                                         6                                                          0.63                          0.54
                              15
                                                                                                    6. Barcelona                  13. Hamburg
                                                                                                    0.63                          0.54
                                                                                                    7. Edinburgh                  14. Birmingham
                                                                                                    0.62                          0.53
   Source: JLL
   Weighted Index Score: Q4 2017 distance from Intercept (vacancy rate at which net                                               15. Madrid
   effectives rents are stable), 2021 distance from intercept, rental sensitivity to vacancy, Net
   additons as % of stock, rental growth forecast (‘18-19) and current to 2021 vacancy rate.
                                                                                                                                  0.53
16                                                EMEA Office Investment Perspective 2018

 Spotlight on Amsterdam
 Europe’s newest global city

 Across 2017, Amsterdam continued to
 demonstrate its huge appeal to a broad
 range of corporate occupiers and real
 estate investors from across the globe. It is
 clear that the city’s real estate markets are
 in a healthy position, and that this is set to
 continue across 2018. However, the bright
 outlook for the Dutch capital goes well
 beyond the current cycle. This small city,
 with a population of just 1.5 million people,
 is set to punch well above its weight on the
 global stage for the foreseeable future.
EMEA Office Investment Perspective 2018                                                                                                                          17

Amsterdam – ‘established world city’?

We believe that Amsterdam is in the middle of a                                         Based on this all-round offer, it is considered one of
transformation from a mid-sized European city to a                                      a handful of global ‘Contenders’ which are gaining
sought-after hub for international businesses, capital                                  enough global visibility, reach and functions to begin
and talent, presenting a challenge to rival cities many                                 to challenge the ‘Big Seven’ global cities. Amsterdam
times its size. Burgeoning strengths in the key sectors                                 is now viewed as a peer of San Francisco, Toronto,
of finance, technology and creative industries are                                      Sydney and Madrid, despite its comparatively
combined with a high quality of living and a smart,                                     small size.
sustainable development framework.

The order of ‘established world cities’

                                   London
               The ‘Big Seven’

                                   New York

                                   Paris

                                   Singapore

                                   Tokyo

                                   Hong Kong

                                   Seoul

                                   Los Angeles

                                   Shanghai

                                   Beijing

                                                                                                             More cities are now
               The ‘Contenders’

                                   Amsterdam

                                   Chicago                                                                    competing with the
                                   San Francisco                                                           ‘Big Seven’ for talent,
                                   Toronto
                                                                                                            capital and business
                                   Madrid

                                   Sydney

                                   Washington DC
                                                                                                                                        Score

                                  40               50           60                 70                 80                 90                100

Scored from 44 indices selected on the basis of range, robustness and currency. Cities ranked by percentile performance in each index. Equal weighting between
each of seven categories (corporate presence, gateway functions, market size, infrastructure platform, talent, specialisation and innovation, and soft power).
Source: The Business of Cities, JLL, 2017
18                                                                EMEA Office Investment Perspective 2018

Amsterdam’s global strengths

Both physically and digitally, Amsterdam
                                                                            Attracted over
is positioning itself as a major global
centre for flows of people, information                                        $10bn
                                                                     of real estate investment
and business:
                                                                             since 2015

1.     International connectivity
       The world-class Schiphol Airport is one of Europe’s
       leading ‘hub’ airports, while there are also
       international rail links to Belgium and Germany. This
       allows Amsterdam to act as a ‘gateway to Europe’ for
       multi-national companies.                                     Office take-up
                                                                   reaches c.400,000

2.     Digital infrastructure
       Amsterdam hosts the world’s largest internet
       exchange, a growing number of data centres and fast
       broadband. This digital offer has attracted a number of
                                                                   sq m for the second
                                                                      year in a row.

                                                                        60%
       international tech giants, as well as helping to nurture
       the city’s own start-up ecosystem. Local success
       stories include Booking.com, TomTom and WeTransfer.

3.     Talent attraction
       As talent becomes increasingly important in
       corporate decision-making, Amsterdam’s diverse
       and highly-skilled population is a key draw. The city
                                                                        of real estate deals
                                                                      involved a cross-border
                                                                           buyer or seller
                                                                            (2015-2017)
       combines a strong local education offer and a highly
       internationalised workforce, which is drawn to the city
       by its reputation for cosmopolitan living and a wide
       range of cultural options.

                                                                         7th globally
                                                                    for ‘Investment Intensity’
                                                                    (a measure of real estate
                                                                  investment in proportion to
Rated as a ‘Highly Transparent’ market in                                 economic size)
JLL’s Global Real Estate Transparency Index.
EMEA Office Investment Perspective 2018                                                                                    19

Future-ready city

Amsterdam’s current position is strong, but it is clear that the city’s leadership also has a vision for its future. Its
reputation as a highly attractive, liveable and relevant city should be secure for years to come.

              1. ‘Smart city’                                                  2. Building for the future

Amsterdam is leading the way as a ‘smart city’. The              In 2018, the city’s Noord district will be connected to
city has developed a successful programme utilising              the Metro system for the first time. This will involve
its digital and innovation strengths to ensure the city          expansion of Amsterdam Zuid station, part of a raft
responds to the changing needs of its citizens and               of infrastructure upgrades improving the city’s major
businesses. This covers areas from the ‘circular’ and            business district at Zuidas. Housing is another high
‘sharing economies’ to issues of energy, water and               priority, and the city continues to develop innovative
sustainability.                                                  housing solutions.

The ‘Holland Metropole’

Amsterdam should not be viewed in isolation. With the
Netherlands’ three other major cities within an hour’s
journey, Amsterdam is able to leverage the unique
strengths of these cities, which include:

1. Rotterdam
Europe’s largest seaport
2. The Hague                                                                 Amsterdam

Home to numerous international institutions and                                     2
key decision-making functions                                                               3
3. Utrecht                                                                              1
A cultural hub, and home to one of the Netherlands’
largest universities.

Together, this region of around 7 million people plays
host to a number of Europe’s best universities, a globally
competitive pool of skilled talent and outstanding
international connections by land, air and sea.
20                                                                              EMEA Office Investment Perspective 2018

Workplace
powered by Human Experience:                                                  Top 5             innovative
                                                                                                workplaces
an investor perspective summary
The future of real estate is more human than you think                        An ideal work environment is a mixture
                                                                              of collaborative space and support
In an age of automation, flexible working and the gig economy, physical
                                                                              services. Our research lists 5 types of
workspace is being re-evaluated. With offices continuing to be in
                                                                              space currently being most provided,
demand, albeit in new ways, investors need to begin to look beyond
                                                                              tried and tested, and which employees
the corporate occupier and towards its employees. The satisfaction and
                                                                              need and expect their office to provide.
productivity of the people who are using the workspace day in, day out
are new markers of business success for both occupiers and investors.
JLL’s extensive occupier research, Future of Work: powered by Human                       1. Community spaces
Experience based on 7,350 completed surveys by office occupiers,              56%         For example: coffee / tea
explores how real estate can be used to influence employee experience                     areas, lounges, etc.
in the workplace. JLL has now looked at what these workplace changes
mean for developers and investors and some of our findings are
summarised here. For the full report, please visit https://capitalmarkets.                2. Spaces dedicated to
jll.com/report/human-experience-investors/.                                   50%         collaborative working
                                                                                          For example: internal,
    1.     Flexibility: employees want it, tenants need it,
           can you offer it?
                                                                                          informally arranged
                                                                                          co-working spaces or
                                                                                          dedicated project rooms.
Lease terms will become more flexible
Tech enabled dispersed employees are becoming increasingly mobile                         3. Service desks
and will therefore demand greater choice on where, how and when               33%         For example: concierge,
they work. Landlords offering greater flexibility will have the upper hand.               IT desk, dry cleaning
•        Under-utilised common areas can serve as on-demand coworking                     service, etc.
         spaces. Establish your own flexible space concept or collaborate
         with existing operators
•        The
EMEA Office Investment Perspective 2018                                                                                                                                   21

   2.       Putting people at the centre of
            portfolio strategy
                                                                                                     3.      Employee satisfaction: A new
                                                                                                             measure of success
   Companies expect their real estate to help attract                                                Traditional measures, such as occupancy and cost
   and retain talent. Despite workforces becoming more                                               savings, will no longer tell the full story. These
   dispersed, the office environment will remain the                                                 periodic measurements should be supplemented
   focal point of most organisations. Investors can help                                             with real-time data which gauges employee
   future-proof buildings by concentrating on:                                                       satisfaction (i.e. space usage, health and wellbeing,
                                                                                                     and community and experience). This will enable
   Community and experience
                                                                                                     investors to measure the impact of a building on
   Creating a community spirit and a unique experience                                               the human experience, which in turn influences
   at work that attracts and retains talent is key. To                                               occupancy, rental income and capital / operating
   enhance the human experience, landlords should                                                    expenses.
   consider practical office layouts, including community
   spaces, collaborative environments, service desks,                                                Conclusion
   creative spaces and incubator / accelerator space.                                                The most forward-thinking businesses today are
   Health and wellbeing                                                                              using their corporate real estate, whether they own
                                                                                                     or rent it, as a way to improve staff engagement. For
   Health and wellbeing is crucial to the human                                                      investors, building in flexibility, focusing on space
   experience. Future-proofed offices will need to cater                                             that enables a positive human experience, and being
   for this. Investors should consider providing space /                                             able to present companies with measurable impact
   facilities such as gyms, meditation rooms, yoga                                                   is an opportunity to boost net operating income.
   classes, medical consultation rooms, nutritionists,                                               By moving to a more service-oriented and flexible
   etc. WELL certification can help quantify the health                                              lease model, tenants are likely to become stickier,
   and wellbeing performance.                                                                        with ancillary services providing more income and
                                                                                                     shortened voids. For the full report visit: https://
                                                                                                     capitalmarkets.jll.com/report/human-experience-
                                                                                                     investors/.

   Swapping enclosed offices for access to innovative                                                Adoption of agile working
   environments

   80      76%                                                                                       80

                      60%
   60                                 54%                                                            60       58%
                                                       %
                                                  49                                                                   49%
                                                                       44%
                                                                                   43%                                           41%      40%
   40                                                                                          37%   40
                                                                 25%         24%                                                                    26%
                                                                                         23%                                                                 22%
                                                           18%                                                                                                          19%
   20                       16   %                                                                   20
                                            10%
                 2%
   0                                                                                                 0
             CN        US              ESP         UK             GER         FRA         NL                  CN        US       UK       ESP       GER       NL        FRA

         Global average:     42%                                 25%                                      Percentage of respondents who work at least one day or more
                                                                                                          per month in other places outside traditional workspace.
                                     Completely ready             Certainly not ready
22                                                                                                    EMEA Office Investment Perspective 2018

See the world Differently

Our EMEA office capital markets specialists combine experience,
financial expertise, insights and perspectives to help clients seek out
new opportunities and achieve their investment ambitions.

Pan European

Peter Hensby                Gemma Kendall                Alexandra Bryant            Matt Richards               Chris Staveley
+44 207 399 5422            +44 207 087 5226             +44 207 087 5277            +44 207 399 5458            +44 207 399 5340
peter.hensby@eu.jll.com     gemma.kendall@eu.jll.com     alexandra.bryant@eu.jll.com matthew.richards@eu.jll.com chris.staveley@eu.jll.com

EMEA Debt

Chris Holmes                Ben Roger-Smith              Graeme Parry                Alberto Segurado              Linus Ericsson
London                      London                       Milan                       Madrid                        Stockholm
+44 207 399 5728            +44 207 087 5043             +39 02 85 86 86 98          +34 91 789 11 00              +46 70-952 54 05
chris.holmes@eu.jll.com     ben.roger-smith@eu.jll.com   graeme.parry@eu.jll.com     alberto.segurado@eu.jll.com   linus.ericsson@eu.jll.com

Corporate Finance

Christian Hepp              Dan Jones                    Peter Evans                 Matilde Attolico              Zeynep Fetvaci
+44 207 087 5197            +44 207 087 5146             +44 207 399 5026            +44 207 087 5094              zeynep.fetvaci@eu.jll.com
christian.hepp@eu.jll.com   dan.jones@eu.jll.com         peter.evans@eu.jll.com      matilde.attolico@eu.jll.com   +44 (0)7922 582773

Research

Robert Stassen              Alex Colpaert                Benjamin Russell            Daniel Bumpstead
+44 203 147 1117            +31 65 06 71 152             +44 207 852 4402            +44 207 852 4140
robert.stassen@eu.jll.com   alex.colpaert@eu.jll.com     benjamin.russell@eu.jll.com daniel.bumpstead@eu.jll.com
EMEA Office Investment Perspective 2018                                                                                                     23

Belgium                     Czech Republic              Finland                      France                       Germany

Adrian Glatt                Mike Atwell                 Christian Hohenthal          Francois Blin                Marcus Luetgering
+32 25 50 26 28             +420 227 04 3191            +358 40 737 5050             +33 1 40 55 18 54            +49 89 290088 158
adrian.glatt@eu.jll.com     mike.atwell@eu.jll.com      christian.hohenthal@         francois.blin@eu.jll.com     marcus.luetgering@eu.jll.com
                                                        eu.jll.com

Hungary                     Ireland                     Italy                        Luxembourg                   MENA

Benjamin Perez-             John Moran                  Silvio Sancilio              Vincent Van Bree             Gaurav Shivpuri
Ellischewitz                +353 1 6731 637             +39 0285868646               +32 25502665                 +971 4 426 6957
+36 1 8026 242              john.moran@eu.jll.com       Silvio.Sancilio@eu.jll.com   vincent.vanBree@eu.jll.com   gaurav.shivpuri@jll.com
benjamin.perez@eu.jll.com

Netherlands                 Poland                      Portugal                     Romania                      Russia

Dré van Leeuwen            Tomasz Puch                  Fernando Ferreira            Silviana Badea               Evgeniy Semenov
+31 20 5407912             +48 22 167 0025              +351 213 58 3239             +40 2 1302 3426              +7 495 737 8000
dre.van-leeuwen@eu.jll.com tomasz.puch@eu.jll.com       fernando.ferreira@eu.jll.com silviana.badea@eu.jll.com    evgeniy.semenov@eu.jll.com

Spain                       SSA                         Sweden                       Switzerland                  UK

Paola Erhardt               Anthony Lewis               Tom Lindahl                  Jan Eckert                   Alistair Meadows
+34 91 789 11 21            +27 11 507 2200             +46 0 702 40 72 05           +41 442 157 510              +44 207 852 4092
paola.erhardt@eu.jll.com    anthony.lewis@eu.jll.com    tom.lindahl@eu.jll.com       jan.eckert@eu.jll.com        alistair.meadows@ eu.jll.com

UK

Julian Sandbach             Rob Jackson
+44 207 399 5973            +44 207 399 5029
julian.sandbach@ eu.jll.com robert.jackson@eu.jll.com
Locations
Belgium                                               Italy                                                  Romania
Avenue Marnixlaan 23                                  Via Agnello 8                                          Victoria Centre,
B-1000 Brussels                                       20121 Milano                                           145 Calea Victoriei
+32 2 550 25 25                                       +39 02 85 86 861                                       10th Floor, Sector 1
                                                                                                             010072 Bucharest 1
Czech Republic                                        Luxembourg
                                                                                                             +40 21 302 3400
Myslbek, Na Příkopě 21                                Atrium Business Park
11000 Praha 1                                         41, rue du Puits Romain                                Russia
+420 2 2423 4809                                      L-8070 Bertrange                                       2 Letnikovskaya St.
                                                      +352 46 45 40                                          Bldg. 1, 115114 Moscow
Finland
                                                                                                             +7 495 737 8000
Eteläesplanadi 22 A                                   MENA
FI-00130 Helsinki                                     Emaar Square                                           Spain
+358 20 7619 960                                      Building 1 Office 403                                  Paseo de la Castellana 79–4ª
                                                      Sheikh Zayed Road                                      28046 Madrid
France
                                                      PO Box 214029                                          +34 91 789 11 00
40-42 rue la Boétie
                                                      Dubai UAE
75008 Paris                                                                                                  South Africa
                                                      +971 4 426 6999
+33 1 40 55 15 15                                                                                            Office 303, 3rd Floor, The Firs
                                                      Netherlands                                            Cnr Biermann and Cradock
Germany
                                                      Kantoorgebouw Atrium                                   Avenue Rosebank,
Wilhelm-Leuschner-Strasse 78
                                                      Strawinskylaan 3103                                    Johannesburg, 2196
60329 Frankfurt am Main
                                                      1077 ZX Amsterdam                                      +27 11 507 2200
+49 69 2003 0
                                                      +31 20 540 54 05
                                                                                                             Sweden
Office capital markets
                                                      Poland                                                 Birger Jarlsgatan 25
also in Berlin, Cologne,
                                                      Warsaw Spire                                           111 41 Stockholm
Düsseldorf, Hamburg,
                                                      Plac Europejski 1                                      +468 453 50 00
Leipzig, Munich and
                                                      00-844 Warsaw
Stuttgart                                                                                                    Switzerland
                                                      +48 22 167 0000
                                                                                                             Prime Tower, Hardstrasse 201
Hungary
                                                      Portugal                                               8005 Zurich
1054 Budapest
                                                      Edifício Heron Castilho                                +41 44 21575 00
Szabadság tér 14. 4. Emelet
                                                      Rua Braamcamp,
+36 1 489 0202                                                                                               UK
                                                      n.º 40–8º Esq.
                                                                                                             30 Warwick Street
Ireland                                               1250-050 Lisboa
                                                                                                             London W1B 5NH
Styne House                                           +351 213 583 222
                                                                                                             +44 20 7493 4933
Upper Hatch Street
Dublin 2
+ 353 1 673 1600

capitalmarkets.jll.com
© 2018 Jones Lang LaSalle IP, Inc. All rights reserved. The information contained in this document is proprietary to Jones Lang LaSalle and shall be used
solely for the purposes of evaluating this proposal. All such documentation and information remains the property of Jones Lang LaSalle and shall be kept
confidential. Reproduction of any part of this document is authorized only to the extent necessary for its evaluation. It is not to be shown to any third party
without the prior written authorization of Jones Lang LaSalle. All information contained herein is from sources deemed reliable; however, no representation
or warranty is made as to the accuracy thereof.
You can also read