The History of Homeopathic Medicine in Mexico (1849-2001)

Page created by Herman Lowe
 
CONTINUE READING
The History of Homeopathic Medicine in Mexico (1849-2001)
                                                                                     Fernando Dario Francois Flores

                                                                                     Zusammenfassung
                                                                                     Geschichte der homöopathischen Medizin in Mexiko (1849-2001)
                                                                                     Im folgenden soll versucht werden, einhundertfünfzig Jahre Geschichte der Homöopathie
                                                                                     in Mexiko in groben Zügen darzustellen. Nach einer kurzen historischen und kontextuellen
                                                                                     Einführung werden im ersten Abschnitt (1849-1893) die Anfangsjahre untersucht, die
                                                                                     durch isoliertes Arbeiten homöopathischer Ärzte charakterisiert sind. Die Zeit zwischen
                                                                                     1893 und 1921 steht für die Jahre der offiziellen Anerkennung und dem daraus folgenden
Open Access Download von der Verlag Österreich eLibrary am 11.05.2022 um 14:36 Uhr

                                                                                     Aufschwung der Verbände und Schulen. Die Periode von 1921 bis 1940 beinhaltet die
                                                                                     wichtigsten Konflikte mit den Behörden. Der Zeitraum von 1940 bis 1960 ist
                                                                                     gekennzeichnet durch ein langsames Wachstum der Schulen und Studiengruppen. Der
                                                                                     letzte Abschnitt (1960-laufend) schließlich beschäftigt sich mit der Periode, in der es
                                                                                     gelang, die postgraduierten Studien in Mexiko weiterzuentwickeln.

                                                                                     The Historical Framework of Homeopathic Medicine in Mexico since
                                                                                     18491
                                                                                     The coming to Mexico of the first homeopathic doctors in 18492 coincides
                                                                                     with the loss of more than half of its territory (2.1 million square km) after
                                                                                     the war with the United States and the end of the 10th presidency of Anto-
                                                                                     nio Lopez de Santa Anna. Many military governments took power in a
                                                                                     chaotic nation between 1848 and 1853, until Santa Anna returned and in-
                                                                                     stalled his 11th and last presidency. The War of Reform, the War of Consti-
                                                                                     tution of 1857, the Three Years War (1858-1860), and the European inter-
                                                                                     vention, the ephemeral empire of Maximilian and Carlota (1864-1867) and
                                                                                     the re-establishment of the Republic were the events which characterised the
                                                                                     first years of homeopathy in Mexico.
                                                                                     The long period of peace and prosperity from the Porfiriato (1876-1911)
                                                                                     finally allowed academic study to prosper so that homeopathic schools and
                                                                                     hospitals could be established.3 The brief period of fifteen months of
                                                                                     democratic government of Francisco I. Madero was followed, once again,
                                                                                     by war and destruction. The Mexican Revolution, a fratricidal and fateful
                                                                                     war, lasted more than a decade thereby isolating the country. After the
                                                                                     assassination of Alvaro Obregon in 1924, the General Plutarco Elias Calles
                                                                                     was the dominant figure of Mexican politics. His government, characterised
                                                                                     by a Marxist tendency and by religious persecution, led to the Cristeros
                                                                                     War (1927-1929) which involved greater popular participation than the
                                                                                     Mexican War. The period known as “Maximato” started in 1928 as Calles

                                                                                     1   Pazos (1993).
                                                                                     2   Martínez Camargo (1972).
                                                                                     3   Salinas Ramos (1984).

                                                                                     MedGG 23  2004, S. 219-241
                                                                                      Franz Steiner Verlag Wiesbaden GmbH, Sitz Stuttgart

                                                                                                                          Franz Steiner Verlag
220                                                     Fernando Dario Francois Flores

                                                                                     proclaimed himself the “Maximum Chief of the Revolution”. After the brief
                                                                                     government of Emilio Portes Gil and of Pascual Ortiz Rubio, General
                                                                                     Lazaro Cardenas (1934-1940) became the last member of the military to be
                                                                                     President of the Republic. Social order was established and Calles was re-
                                                                                     moved from all political influence. It was during this period that homeo-
                                                                                     paths fought their most intense battles, leading to the defeat of the President
                                                                                     of the Republic when he tried to close the Free School of Homeopathy. Af-
                                                                                     ter a trial of two year’s duration, the school remained open.4
                                                                                     The country started a long period of recovery under the majority govern-
                                                                                     ments of Adolfo Ruiz Cortines (1952-1958), Adolfo Lopez Mateos (1958-
                                                                                     1964), and Gustavo Diaz Ordaz (1964-1970). This epoch, known by the
Open Access Download von der Verlag Österreich eLibrary am 11.05.2022 um 14:36 Uhr

                                                                                     economists as a period of “stabilising development”, allowed Mexico to
                                                                                     achieve economic stability. However, during the next period (1970-1976)
                                                                                     the economy started to deteriorate and a huge devaluation of the peso (from
                                                                                     12.50 to 20 pesos to the dollar) took place and the parity of the peso was
                                                                                     removed. This was the first of many crises to occur. Recent years have been
                                                                                     characterised by many monetary devaluations, representing continuing
                                                                                     economic problems. In January 1994 guerrilla activity was initiated in the
                                                                                     south of Mexico, under the leadership of the Ejercito Zapatista de Lib-
                                                                                     eración Nacional; a conflict which remains unresolved.

                                                                                     The First Homeopathic Practitioners (1849-1893)
                                                                                     The introduction and the practice of homeopathic medicine correspond to
                                                                                     the Spanish doctors who came from Cuba to Mexico. There are many ver-
                                                                                     sions of who was the first but it appears that Dr. Cornelio Andrade y Baz
                                                                                     was the first, arriving on the Mexican coast in 1849. He came as the family
                                                                                     doctor of the Bringas family and remained for six years, residing in
                                                                                     Orizaba, Veracruz.5 It is not clear if he was invited specifically as a homeo-
                                                                                     path or just as a general doctor. The entry of Dr. Ramon Comellas was
                                                                                     registered in 1850. He was a Catalan, a former professor at Valencia Uni-
                                                                                     versity and amongst other distinctions, founder of the Instituto Medico
                                                                                     Valenciano.6 He is the author of the first homeopathic publication in Mex-
                                                                                     ico, “Reseña sobre la homeopatía dedicada a los mexicanos” (A brief de-
                                                                                     scription about homeopathy dedicated to Mexicans).7 The twenty four
                                                                                     pages of this publication contain a brief historical introduction and the
                                                                                     principal indications for the homeopathic patient. As the author of the first
                                                                                     homeopathic publication and as the first to teach his disciples, Julian Gon-

                                                                                     4     Pirrón Q. Leonardo 1er Secretario del Juzgado 1° de distrito. Juicio de amparo 161-
                                                                                           939.
                                                                                     5     Martínez Camargo (1972).
                                                                                     6     Salinas Ramos (1984).
                                                                                     7     Comellas (1853).

                                                                                                                           Franz Steiner Verlag
The History of Homeopathic Medicine in Mexico (1849-2001)                221

                                                                                     zalez and Rafael Degollado, make him the initiator of homeopathy in
                                                                                     Mexico.
                                                                                     Dr. Salvador Riera, also a Spaniard, holding degrees from the universities
                                                                                     of Madrid and of Havana, arrived in Merida, Yucatan in 1851, where he
                                                                                     publicised homeopathy for the first time in Yucatan.8 The entry of Dr. Jose
                                                                                     Maria Carbo was registered in 1854. He was a Catalan doctor who came
                                                                                     from Cuba specifically to fight an epidemic of yellow fever which was dev-
                                                                                     astating Veracruz.9 His distinguished work with the sick in the Castillo of
                                                                                     San Juan Ulua was recognised by the President, Santa Anna, and he be-
                                                                                     came the first who was allowed to practice homeopathy officially in the
                                                                                     Mexican Republic.10 Dr. Narciso Sanchiz arrived in 1855 and instructed
Open Access Download von der Verlag Österreich eLibrary am 11.05.2022 um 14:36 Uhr

                                                                                     the first Mexican practitioners, Alfredo Dominguez Ugalde and Pablo
                                                                                     Fuentes Herrera.11 These two doctors founded in 1861 the first
                                                                                     homeopathic association in Mexico, the “Sociedad Homeopática de
                                                                                     México”, with the intention of testing the national flora and fauna to create
                                                                                     a Mexican “Materia Medica”. The magazine edited by this society, “La
                                                                                     Gaceta”, was the first of its kind in Mexico.12 Unfortunately, political
                                                                                     conditions prevented the institution from lasting for more than a few
                                                                                     months.13 The first Mexican doctor converted to homeopathy was Dr.
                                                                                     Cresencio Colín. He was converted in 1870 by Dr. Jose Puig, a man of
                                                                                     exemplary dedication who can be seen as the principal promoter and
                                                                                     propagator of homeopathy in Mexico in these early days.14
                                                                                     The controversial figure of Julian Gonzalez played an important role. Some
                                                                                     authors consider him a doctor15 others consider him a practitioner16. He
                                                                                     was born in Burgos, Spain in 183217, became the first disciple of Dr.
                                                                                     Comellas and the second to publish on homeopathy in Mexico. His book
                                                                                     “Tratado práctico de homeopatía y guía de las familias” was published in
                                                                                     two editions in 187118 and 187919. This textbook contains a “Materia
                                                                                     Medica” with clinical references and an index of 656 remedies which he

                                                                                     8   Romero (1977).
                                                                                     9   Pulido Alvarez (1998).
                                                                                     10 Oseguera (1995).
                                                                                     11 Hill (1942).
                                                                                     12 Hill (1942).
                                                                                     13 Fuentes y Herrera (1942).
                                                                                     14 Martínez (1980).
                                                                                     15 Martínez (1980).
                                                                                     16 Such as Ignacio Fernandez de Lara. See Martínez Camargo (1972).
                                                                                     17 Martínez Camargo (1972).
                                                                                     18 Martínez (1980).
                                                                                     19 González (1879).

                                                                                                                        Franz Steiner Verlag
222                                                      Fernando Dario Francois Flores

                                                                                     kept in his pharmacy. He occasionally saw the residents in his pharmacy
                                                                                     and he dealt with dwellers in the countryside by mail.20 Julian Gonzales
                                                                                     also established the first homeopathic pharmacy in Mexico in 1867. The
                                                                                     pharmacy under the charge of Dr. Joaquin Salas was installed at 12, San
                                                                                     Francisco Street in 1869. Later on, the pharmacy moved to 17, Avenue 5
                                                                                     de Mayo, then to Tacubaya and, finally, to 47, Belisario Dominguez.21
                                                                                     The principal homeopaths of the time, thanks to the efforts of Fuentes
                                                                                     Herrera and Julian Gonzalez, got together during 1869 with the aim of
                                                                                     founding a new homeopathic organisation. There is no evidence of any dis-
                                                                                     putes between allopaths and homeopaths and on 18th August 1869, the
                                                                                     formation of the “Instituto Homeopático Mexicano” was announced. This
Open Access Download von der Verlag Österreich eLibrary am 11.05.2022 um 14:36 Uhr

                                                                                     group started its activities on 10th April, 1870 having not only the objective
                                                                                     of study and dissemination but also of scientific and rational discussion.
                                                                                     The results were published in “El Propagador Homeopático” edited by Drs.
                                                                                     Francisco Perez Ortiz and Jose T. Hidalgo.22
                                                                                     In 1871, Dr. Rafael Degollado founded the first homeopathic hospital in
                                                                                     Mexico in San Miguel de Allende, Guanajuato. Unfortunately his life was
                                                                                     short.23 Organised resistance from allopaths was difficult as the political
                                                                                     situation was very uncertain.24 Homeopathy was practised in many parts of
                                                                                     the Republic. Dr. Francisco Marchena in Puebla; Miguel Cruz y Canto in
                                                                                     Toluca; Nemesio de los Santos Rubio in Yucatan; and Dr. Ismael Talavera
                                                                                     in Veracruz continued with the work initiated by Ramon Comellas in
                                                                                     1851.25 The “Sociedad Médico Homeopática Mexicana” was founded in
                                                                                     Mexico City in 1874.26 It was initiated, amongst others, by Drs. Enrique
                                                                                     Carrera Lardizabal, Valdes y Morales, Barona, Medina, Chavez, Antonio
                                                                                     Salas, Ramirez de Arellano, Jose T. Hidalgo, Rafael Navarrete and Pablo
                                                                                     Fuentes y Herrera. They established a consulting room where they gave
                                                                                     8,947 consultations during the first year.27 As in other homeopathic prac-
                                                                                     tices, the patients were ambulatory. The journal of the institution was “El
                                                                                     Faro Homeopático” which was first published on 15th April, 1874.28 Al-

                                                                                     20 González (1879).
                                                                                     21 Oseguera (1995).
                                                                                     22 Salinas Ramos (1984).
                                                                                     23 Oseguera (1995).
                                                                                     24 Although the building remains at Diez de Sollano and 15, Davalos, there are no records of
                                                                                        the hospital under Dr. Julián Gonzàlez. In 1980, the “Asociación de Médicos Homeópatas
                                                                                        Cirujanos y Parteros del Centro A. C.”, placed a commemorative plaque on the building.
                                                                                        See Barbosa (1998).
                                                                                     25 Márquez San Juan (1990).
                                                                                     26 Márquez San Juan (1990).
                                                                                     27 Oseguera (1995).
                                                                                     28 Hill (1942).

                                                                                                                            Franz Steiner Verlag
The History of Homeopathic Medicine in Mexico (1849-2001)                    223

                                                                                     though there are no further references to the journal, the institution re-
                                                                                     mained in existence until 1917.
                                                                                     The autumn of 1874 marks the re-organisation of the “Mexican Homeo-
                                                                                     pathic Institute” under new statutes and a co-ordinated programme for the
                                                                                     diffusion of homeopathy. The conferences were reinstated on 21st Novem-
                                                                                     ber 1874.29 Its new publication, “La Reforma Médica”, appears for the first
                                                                                     time in January, 1875 as the second version of the “Propagador Ho-
                                                                                     meopático”. The diplomas granted by the Mexican Homeopathic Institute
                                                                                     were beautifully designed. They contained, in the upper part, the image of
                                                                                     Samuel Hahnemann, enclosed in a square; in the lower part, an eagle with
                                                                                     extended wings; two columns at the sides with, on the left side, the legends
Open Access Download von der Verlag Österreich eLibrary am 11.05.2022 um 14:36 Uhr

                                                                                     of “Materia Medica” and Enfermedades Cronicas and on the right side,
                                                                                     physiological experimentation. It contained also the seal of the institution,
                                                                                     and the names of the president and the secretary as on the frontispiece of
                                                                                     the formal register.30 Two provincial legislatures officially recognised
                                                                                     homeopathic medicine in 1879 as a result of the efforts of two homeopathic
                                                                                     pioneers in the provinces, Francisco Marchena in Puebla and Ismael Talav-
                                                                                     era in Veracruz. Juan Crisostomo Bonilla, Governor of Puebla31 and Gen-
                                                                                     eral Luis Mier y Teheran, the Governor of Veracruz32 issued decrees
                                                                                     instituting the teaching and the practice of homeopathy in their states.
                                                                                     The Mexican Homeopathic Institute and the Mexican Medico Homeo-
                                                                                     pathic Society had fallen into a long decline and inactivity by 1885. No
                                                                                     homeopathic magazines were published between 1880 and 1885, possibly
                                                                                     indicating that all homeopathic activity had decreased. However, a new
                                                                                     stage of homeopathy emerged because of the interest of a French doctor
                                                                                     Cresencio Colin, Dr. Oriard, and a young aristocratic doctor Joaquin
                                                                                     Segura y Pesado.33 Dr. Segura y Pesado had been in contact already with
                                                                                     homeopathy through the “Organon” lecture and some of the writings of
                                                                                     Leon Simon. He travelled to Germany and France to learn about the new
                                                                                     medicine although he had prescribed previously homeopathic remedies
                                                                                     passed to him by Cresencio Colin.34 Dr. Segura was the first doctor to go to
                                                                                     Europe though it is not known whom he met. After Dr. Colin visited all the

                                                                                     29 Advertencia. In: La Reforma Médica 1 (1875).
                                                                                     30 Instituto Homeopático Mexicano. Diploma expedido al Dr. Luis Zaragoza el 10 de
                                                                                        abril de 1877.
                                                                                     31 Bonilla (1879).
                                                                                     32 Mier y Terán Luis, Gobernador Constitucional del Estado Libre y Soberano de
                                                                                        Veracruz Llave, Diciembre 15 de 1879 Archivo General del Estado de Veracruz.
                                                                                        Leyes y Decretos.
                                                                                     33 Formación del Círculo Homeopático Mexicano. In: La Reforma Médica. (Secunda
                                                                                        Epoca) 1 (1885).
                                                                                     34 Fuentes y Herrera (1942).

                                                                                                                      Franz Steiner Verlag
224                                                  Fernando Dario Francois Flores

                                                                                     homeopaths who lived in Mexico City35, the formation of a new group was
                                                                                     proposed. The new association, the “Circulo Homeopático Mexicano”, was
                                                                                     intended to bring together all the followers of homeopathic medicine in
                                                                                     Mexico and with the intention of creating ties of fellowship between them.
                                                                                     Seventeen homeopathic doctors were the founders. The journal of this
                                                                                     group, “La Reforma Medica”, was given the same name as the first publica-
                                                                                     tion of the “Mexican Homeopathic Institute”. Each publication included a
                                                                                     record of the meetings of the members from the “Circulo”, together with
                                                                                     homeopathic articles and communications from homeopathic doctors from
                                                                                     all parts of the country and from overseas. The use of high potencies in
                                                                                     Mexico is discussed for the first time in the first issue of 1st July, 1885, util-
                                                                                     ising the case of 200 ch given by Dr. Joaquin Segura y Pesado in different
Open Access Download von der Verlag Österreich eLibrary am 11.05.2022 um 14:36 Uhr

                                                                                     respiratory illnesses. The new society quickly fulfilled all its objectives as, in
                                                                                     each session, new members were proposed and the role of the “Circulo”
                                                                                     grew. When cholera again threatened the coast of Veracruz the homeo-
                                                                                     pathic doctors published a pamphlet and were prepared to use homeo-
                                                                                     pathic remedies.36 Many personalities of homeopathic society in Mexico,
                                                                                     such as Bernardo de Mendizabal, collaborator and participator in homeo-
                                                                                     pathy since the foundation of the “Mexican Homeopathic Institute” by Drs.
                                                                                     Puig and Perez Ortiz met together on 11th April, 1886, during the 131st an-
                                                                                     niversary celebration of Samuel Hahnemann’s birth and the first year of
                                                                                     existence of the group. Mr Mendizabal inaugurated the foundation of the
                                                                                     homeopathic hospital in the Architects colony, a quarter of old Mexico
                                                                                     City.37 All homeopathic doctors agreed with the idea of crystallising the
                                                                                     ideals and efforts of the pioneers of homeopathic medicine in Mexico and
                                                                                     the final toast of the celebration was dedicated to them.38 There was a surge
                                                                                     in affiliation to the “Circulo” and a great desire to promote homeopathy
                                                                                     resulting from this celebration.
                                                                                     The next issue of “La Reforma Medica” appeared in July 1886. However, it
                                                                                     was no longer the organ of the “Circulo”, once again the name of the
                                                                                     “Mexican Homeopathic Institute” appeared on the cover. The magazine
                                                                                     publishers, Joaquín Segura y Pesado, Joaquin Gonzalez, and Juan N. Ar-
                                                                                     riga, gave an explanation in the editorial entitled “Ave Fenix”.39 At the re-
                                                                                     quest of Francisco Aguilar with the objective of restoring the name of the
                                                                                     prestigious institution, recognised by the legislations of Puebla and Ve-
                                                                                     racruz, all the members of the “Circulo Homeopatico Mexicano” following
                                                                                     the same rules, decided to name once again the group as “The Mexican

                                                                                     35 Arriaga (1889).
                                                                                     36 Círculo Homeopático Mexicano. In: La Reforma Médica (Segunda Epoca) 3 (1885).
                                                                                        Círculo Homeopático Mexicano. In: La Reforma Médica (Segunda Epoca) 4 (1885).
                                                                                     37 Colín (1886).
                                                                                     38 Colín (1886).
                                                                                     39 Ave Fénix (1886).

                                                                                                                        Franz Steiner Verlag
The History of Homeopathic Medicine in Mexico (1849-2001)                               225

                                                                                     Homeopathic Institute”. The homeopaths, in defending their doctrine in
                                                                                     this editorial, appealed to the Superior Court to resolve the legal restrictions
                                                                                     on homeopathic practice. This renaissance had the objective of a civilised
                                                                                     appeal to help the future of homeopathic medicine in Mexico. There was a
                                                                                     selective translation of “Materia Medica”, in addition to the normal mate-
                                                                                     rial, though there were no records of meetings from their members.40 Dr.
                                                                                     Francisco Felix Mendoza published “El Articulo 3º y el ejercicio de la
                                                                                     Medicina” in the July 1887 issue of “La Reforma Medica”. After summa-
                                                                                     rising previous studies and thoughts on homeopathic medicine in other
                                                                                     parts of the world, he proposed the establishment of an homeopathic medi-
                                                                                     cal school by the doctors of the “Mexican Homeopathic Institute”, to be
                                                                                     recognised by the government. The last two paragraphs stated that:
Open Access Download von der Verlag Österreich eLibrary am 11.05.2022 um 14:36 Uhr

                                                                                         Mexican Government it is not your mission to impose the sciences but it is your mis-
                                                                                         sion to protect their liberty; achieve with this constitutional precept only this way you
                                                                                         will do as the epoch requires.
                                                                                         Mexican Homeopathic Institute, go on build as early as you can schools where you
                                                                                         can teach with perfection our doctrine and from there will be born truly Mexican ho-
                                                                                         meopathic doctors, with the official guarantee provided by the government as the only
                                                                                         law in this country, be the Alma Mater.41
                                                                                     At the beginning of 1888 the “Mexican Homeopathic Institute” inaugurated
                                                                                     a free dispensary under the auspices of Dr. Ignacio Fernandez de Lara. The
                                                                                     location of the dispensary was provided by Dr. Panfilo Carranza in his
                                                                                     own house.42 The patients were poor like those of all the homeopathic
                                                                                     dispensaries. Unfortunately, no records of this dispensary were published.
                                                                                     The project for the school was to crystallise under the second presidency of
                                                                                     Dr. Joaquin Segura y Pesado in 1889 with the establishment of a medical
                                                                                     academy to provide lessons on general medicine and to teach homeopathy.
                                                                                     The school initiated its classes with Dr. Segura y Pesado as director and Dr.
                                                                                     Bernabe Hernandez as secretary. The lessons were taught by: Joaquin
                                                                                     Segura y Pesado, Anatomy; Ignacio Fernandez de Lara, Clinical Medicine;
                                                                                     Pablo Fuentes y Herrera, Materia Medica; Juan N. Arriaga, Pathology;
                                                                                     Miguel Bachiller, Hygiene; Joaquin Gonzalez, Surgery; Pablo Barona,
                                                                                     Physiology; and Manuel M. de Legarreta, Pharmacology.43 The Medical
                                                                                     Academy initially started its work at 6 and 7 Canoa (now Donceles) Street
                                                                                     and later at 18 Santa Teresa Street (now Republica de Guatemala). Its first
                                                                                     student was Fidel de Regules.44 Although there are no extant records of this
                                                                                     first stage it is likely that it had few students as, ten years later, there were
                                                                                     only six graduates. The role of the “Mexican Homeopathic Institute” and

                                                                                     40 Ave Fénix (1886).
                                                                                     41 Mendoza (1887).
                                                                                     42 La Reforma Médica (Segunda época) Bd. III 6 (1888).
                                                                                     43 Salinas Ramos (1984).
                                                                                     44 Salinas Ramos (1984).

                                                                                                                         Franz Steiner Verlag
226                                                      Fernando Dario Francois Flores

                                                                                     its academy had become very important by 1892. Dr. Segura y Pesado at-
                                                                                     tended a great number of patients, without charge, at a small private hospi-
                                                                                     tal in Tacubaya. He recorded carefully its clinical files, and established the
                                                                                     efficiency of homeopathic medicine.45 It was a homeopathic cure which
                                                                                     predisposed the President of Mexico, General Porfirio Diaz, to help homeo-
                                                                                     pathy. The President was treated for an old osteomyelitis by Dr. Joaquin
                                                                                     Segura y Pesado. The injury was a consequence of the battle of Veracruz
                                                                                     and it healed in ten days.46
                                                                                     1893 was a key year in the history of homeopathy in Mexico. The most
                                                                                     important event was the foundation of the National Homeopathic Hospi-
                                                                                     tal.47 The foundation of the “Hahnemann Society”, replacing the “Mexican
Open Access Download von der Verlag Österreich eLibrary am 11.05.2022 um 14:36 Uhr

                                                                                     Homeopathic Society”, was also of significance.48 This new organisation
                                                                                     was formed by Drs. Luis Alva, Juan N. Arriaga, Pablo Barona, Rafael V.
                                                                                     Castro, Manuel Cordoba y Aristi, Feliciano Gomez Puente, Lino Mora,
                                                                                     Jose I. Muñoz, Librado Ocampo, R. C. de los Rios, Amalio Romero and
                                                                                     Mariano Valdez.49 Soon they were joined by new members from Mexico
                                                                                     City and from many states of the Republic, such as Chihuahua, Guerrero,
                                                                                     Michoacan, Sinaloa, Guadalajara, Guanajuato, Queretaro, Mexico, Hidalgo
                                                                                     and Tlaxcala.50 There were forty-five members by the end of the first year.51
                                                                                     The journal of the organisation, “La Homeopatía”, deserves a special men-
                                                                                     tion because of its contents and its continuity. It was edited, without inter-
                                                                                     ruption, until 1913 when political conditions made further publication im-
                                                                                     possible as Mexico was engaged in war.52 The editors during 1893 were
                                                                                     Juan N. Arriaga, Rafael V. Castro and Amalio Romero. The magazine con-
                                                                                     sisted of a social directory, family section, scientific section, clinical notes
                                                                                     and other matters. It was accompanied by supplements for doctors includ-
                                                                                     ing the second edition of the “Materia Medica” of Farrington, the facsimile
                                                                                     of a “Marvellous City” (illustrated chapters of anatomy and physiology)
                                                                                     written by Juan N. Arriaga, “Characteristics of the Materia Medica” of Al-
                                                                                     len, and “Characteristics of Homeopathic Therapy” by Nash. The first edi-
                                                                                     tion of “La Homeopatía” was recognised with a diploma and a medal and
                                                                                     was exhibited at the University of Paris in 1900.53 The second stage of the
                                                                                     magazine was initiated in 1933, and the third in June 1941, when the

                                                                                     45 Salinas Ramos (1984). There are no extant records of this short-lived practice.
                                                                                     46 According to an account of one of his daughters. Flores Toledo (1995).
                                                                                     47 To be discussed later.
                                                                                     48 Gacetilla (1893).
                                                                                     49 Directorio Social (1893).
                                                                                     50 Directorio Social (1895).
                                                                                     51 Salinas Ramos (1984).
                                                                                     52 La Homeopatía Jg. XVI 11 (1913).
                                                                                     53 Salinas Ramos (1984).

                                                                                                                            Franz Steiner Verlag
The History of Homeopathic Medicine in Mexico (1849-2001)                     227

                                                                                     “Similia Laboratories” reinstated the publication. It took the name of “La
                                                                                     Homeopatía de México” in July 1941.54 The “Hahnemann Society” worked
                                                                                     hard for the practice and diffusion of homeopathic medicine under the title
                                                                                     of “Constancia y estudio”.55 It was widely known and the magazine acted
                                                                                     as an interchange with many countries in the world. “La Homeopatía”, the
                                                                                     scientific sections and the work of their associates was suspended at the end
                                                                                     of 1913 because of the Revolutionary War.56 The “Mexican Medico
                                                                                     Homeopathic Society” functioned continuously until 1917. The last direc-
                                                                                     torate consisted of Juan N. Arriaga as the president, Luis G. de Legarreta as
                                                                                     the secretary and Manuel A. Lizama as pro-secretary.
Open Access Download von der Verlag Österreich eLibrary am 11.05.2022 um 14:36 Uhr

                                                                                     Towards Official Recognition (1893-1921)
                                                                                     Four doctors of the Homeopathic Medicine Academy, Joaquin Segura y
                                                                                     Pesado, Ignacio Fernandez de Lara, Ignacio Maria Montaño and Fernando
                                                                                     Gomez Suarez made a request to Romero Rubio, the responsible minister,
                                                                                     to acquire a place where they could practice homeopathy and prove its effi-
                                                                                     cacy. They provided extensive written evidence of the benefits of the Hah-
                                                                                     nemanian method and of the international standing of homeopathy. They
                                                                                     requested specifically the granting of a building, recently equipped and
                                                                                     ready to use as a hospital.57 The government finally paid for the “Viejo Pol-
                                                                                     vorín” or “Polvorín del Virreinato” which had been equipped to face the
                                                                                     epidemic which was devastating Mexico City. 58 The building, bearing the
                                                                                     emblem of a lion and a castle, had a façade of quarried stone. It was
                                                                                     located in the area of “Cuartelito” and the government ordered a bridge to
                                                                                     be constructed to link with Resguardo Street.59 The four doctors initiated
                                                                                     the work of the hospital, using their own money, and in October 1893, 48
                                                                                     beds were occupied. The hospital would be inaugurated officially on July
                                                                                     15th, 1894 in the presence of the President of the Republic, General Porfirio
                                                                                     Diaz; Manuel Romero Rubio; and the Governor of the Federal District,
                                                                                     Jose Ives Limantour.60 It would be known in the future as the “Hospital
                                                                                     Nacional Homeopatico”. Two years later, the government analysed the
                                                                                     results of the project, which were overwhelmingly in favour of homeopathic
                                                                                     medicine. Once again homeopathy had demonstrated its merits in practical

                                                                                     54 La Homeopatía de México (Tercera época) 2 (1941).
                                                                                     55 Gacetilla (1895).
                                                                                     56 La Homeopatía Jg. XVI 11 (1913).
                                                                                     57 Segura y Pesado, Joaquín u. a.: Solicitud de apertura del Hospital Nacional
                                                                                        Homeopático. 26 de junio de 1893. Archivos del Hospital Nacional Homeopático de
                                                                                        la Secretaría de Salud. México D. F.
                                                                                     58 Archivo Histórico de la S. S. A: F-BP, S-EH, Sc-HNH, Lg-1, Exp-1.
                                                                                     59 Archivo Histórico de la S. S. A: F-BP, S-EH, Sc-HNH, Lg-1, Exp-1.
                                                                                     60 Peréz Vargas (1943).

                                                                                                                       Franz Steiner Verlag
228                                                     Fernando Dario Francois Flores

                                                                                     terms. There followed the establishment of an official school for the first
                                                                                     time when General Porfirio Diaz issued the presidential decree in favour of
                                                                                     the “Escuela Nacional de Medicina Homeopatica” on June 31st, 1895.61 He
                                                                                     also formulated the school regulations.62 The school was established at the
                                                                                     National Homeopathic Hospital after a solemn inauguration ceremony on
                                                                                     January 4th, 1896.63 Both institutions functioned, under the direction of Dr.
                                                                                     Segura y Pesado, without any problems under governmental protection.
                                                                                     The “Mexican Homeopathic Academy” was built in 1909 with the stated
                                                                                     ideal of the practice and diffusion of orthodox homeopathy according to
                                                                                     Hahnemann’s teachings. The founders were Higinio G. Perez, Alfredo
                                                                                     Ortega, Francisco Castillo and Luis F. Porragas. The presidency and vice-
                                                                                     presidency were granted to Joaquin Segura y Pesado and Ignacio
Open Access Download von der Verlag Österreich eLibrary am 11.05.2022 um 14:36 Uhr

                                                                                     Fernandez de Lara respectively.64 Soon new members such as Rafael Isaias
                                                                                     y Fernandez, Jose M. Nicoli, Rafael Conde Perea, Manuel Machado Sosa
                                                                                     and Manuel Lizama enrolled in the academy and joined in its work.65 The
                                                                                     group functioned for less than a year; its final act being the sorrowful
                                                                                     commemoration of Samuel Hahnemann’s death on July 2nd, 1910.66
                                                                                     Although it is not known why the “Mexican Homeopathy Academy”
                                                                                     disappeared, its members would play an important role in the history of
                                                                                     homeopathic medicine in the future.
                                                                                     Dr. Higinio G. Perez founded the “Escuela Libre de Homeopatia” on Octo-
                                                                                     ber 12th, 1912 with the motto of “Por la verdad y por el bien”. The end of
                                                                                     the dictatorship of General Porfirio Diaz saw a spirit of freedom and de-
                                                                                     mocracy in Mexico and an accompanying period of renewal.67 Dr. Perez
                                                                                     was a professor at the “National Homeopathic School of Medicine”, a state
                                                                                     school. After his retirement he was visited by a group of ex-students and
                                                                                     was asked to give his thoughts on homeopathic medicine. As the years
                                                                                     passed, the idea emerged of founding a homeopathic school independent of
                                                                                     government and specifically orientated towards the working class. Dr.
                                                                                     Perez, together with a group of homeopathic doctors, initiated such a pro-
                                                                                     ject.68 The “Free Homeopathic School of Medicine” was established with
                                                                                     the objectives of free professional teaching, the possibility of the working

                                                                                     61 Decreto Presidencial número 13, 137.
                                                                                     62 Decreto Presidencial número 13, 143.
                                                                                     63 La Homeopatía Jg. III 6 (1896). The book of activities ends on this date.
                                                                                     64 Libro de Actas de la Academia Homeopática de México. Archivos de la Escuela
                                                                                        Libre de Homeopatía de México I. A. P. Mexico D. F.
                                                                                     65 Libro de Actas de la Academia Homeopática de México. Archivos de la Escuela
                                                                                        Libre de Homeopatía de México I. A. P. Mexico D. F.
                                                                                     66 La Homeopatía Jg. XVI 10 (1910).
                                                                                     67 Pazos (1993).
                                                                                     68 Delgado Crespo (1979).

                                                                                                                           Franz Steiner Verlag
The History of Homeopathic Medicine in Mexico (1849-2001)                 229

                                                                                     class acquiring a high level education and the attaching to the orthodox
                                                                                     canons of the teaching and practice of homeopathic medicine. The opera-
                                                                                     tion of the school was very special. It was established by Dr. Higinio G.
                                                                                     Perez at 6 Sta. Lucia in the populous district of Peralvillo, and was sup-
                                                                                     ported at his expense. The professors did not charge for their classes and
                                                                                     the low fees paid by the students were used to defray the expenses of the
                                                                                     institution. The classes started in January 1913, a few days after the
                                                                                     “Decena Tragica” and continued throughout the whole period of the
                                                                                     Mexican Revolution.69 The schedules were orientated towards the working
                                                                                     class as the classes were from 6.30a.m. to 9.00a.m. and from 6.00p.m. to
                                                                                     10.00p.m. The dissection exercises took place at the Dolores cemetery
                                                                                     amphitheatre, where the students of the “Free Homeopathic School of
Open Access Download von der Verlag Österreich eLibrary am 11.05.2022 um 14:36 Uhr

                                                                                     Medicine” also practiced. A characteristic of the school was the unity and
                                                                                     fellowship of teachers and students. A preparatory establishment annexed
                                                                                     to the institution was initiated in 1917. This regularised the studies of the
                                                                                     students as it was a requirement for preparatory studies to be completed
                                                                                     before entering the “Free Homeopathic School of Medicine”; a requirement
                                                                                     not required by all schools at the time.70 The legal background was the 3rd
                                                                                     Article of the 1857 Constitution which guaranteed the freedom of teaching.
                                                                                     During the difficult years of the Mexican Revolution, the students of the
                                                                                     “Free Homeopathic School of Medicine”, guided by Pastor G. Rocha
                                                                                     visited Venustiano Carranza’s encampment, before he entered the Mexico
                                                                                     City. They emphasised the necessity of specific legislation for the “Free
                                                                                     Homeopathic School of Medicine”. He received them and promised
                                                                                     support in preparing the new constitution which was issued on February
                                                                                     5th, 1917. Section XXVII, Article 73 of the 1917 Constitution supported the
                                                                                     existence of higher education though it did not provide for financial
                                                                                     support from the state.71 In the same year, Dr. Alfredo Ortega founded the
                                                                                     “Free Homeopathic Institute of Mexico” which merged with the “National
                                                                                     Homeopathic School of Medicine” in 1946 as it was unable to gain official
                                                                                     recognition.72 The first monument to Hahnemann was unveiled on 2nd July,
                                                                                     1918 because of the efforts of Higinio G. Perez and the “Free Homeopathic
                                                                                     School of Medicine”. It was a bust on a decorated column by Dr. Trinidad
                                                                                     Alvarado who had graduated from the Free School and placed in the
                                                                                     National Academy of Bellas Artes. The name of Hahnemann was put
                                                                                     between two triumphant lictors.73 Throughout the Mexican Revolution,
                                                                                     both the school and the hospital functioned without any problems, though
                                                                                     the difficult political situation with governmental reorganisation prevented

                                                                                     69 Moheno (1924).
                                                                                     70 Jaramillo (1934).
                                                                                     71 De la Barrera (1961-1962).
                                                                                     72 Salinas Ramos (1984).
                                                                                     73 Moheno (1924). Lictors were the Roman guardsmen who protected the principal
                                                                                        magistrates. They carried fasces as a symbol of the office.

                                                                                                                     Franz Steiner Verlag
230                                               Fernando Dario Francois Flores

                                                                                     the Secretary of Health from observing directly the homeopaths and their
                                                                                     practice.

                                                                                     The War Years (1918-1940)
                                                                                     These twenty-two years are characterised by terrible conflict and persecu-
                                                                                     tion against homeopathic doctors and their doctrine. Unfortunately, it was
                                                                                     characterised also by conflicts between homeopaths themselves, since the
                                                                                     two schools did not have a good relationship with each other. The doctors
                                                                                     of the National School never accepted the Free School nor its students as
                                                                                     the Free School had been established by teachers and students who were
                                                                                     defectors from the National School. The Free School was of a particularly
Open Access Download von der Verlag Österreich eLibrary am 11.05.2022 um 14:36 Uhr

                                                                                     orthodox character whilst the National School had official approval and
                                                                                     followed poli-pharmacy.
                                                                                     The first attack was against the Free School of Puebla in 1918, when the
                                                                                     Governor, the allopathic doctor Alfonso Cabrera, issued a decree to punish
                                                                                     and to close the school. He forbade the practice of homeopathy in the state
                                                                                     whilst Dr. Juan Ollivier defended the name of all homeopaths against such
                                                                                     an injustice. The case went to the Supreme Court of Justice of Mexico and,
                                                                                     after two years of legal argument, the Governor was defeated.74 The role of
                                                                                     the patients during this trial is not known. The Free School in Mexico City
                                                                                     was in trouble from 1921, when the XXVIIth section of the 73rd Article of
                                                                                     the Constitution was derogated. The death certificates issued by the doctors
                                                                                     from the Free School were declared invalid, alluding they did not have any
                                                                                     official status. Querido Moheno, a substantial personality in the juridical
                                                                                     field, took the judge to the Supreme Court of Justice75 and won a judgement
                                                                                     in favour of the doctors from the Free School. The new sanitary codes of
                                                                                     1926 required the Free School to register its degrees with the National
                                                                                     Autonomous University of Mexico. However, the university denied the
                                                                                     registration even though the doctors from the Free School fulfilled the re-
                                                                                     quirements for practice in the United States of America. Doctors such as
                                                                                     Dr. Eliud Garcia Treviño were members of North American homeopathic
                                                                                     institutions.76 The Free School was inspected by distinguished Mexican
                                                                                     politicians, such as the Principal, Jose Vasconcelos, who offered to incorpo-
                                                                                     rate it into the National University in 1920 in the famous phrase: “The
                                                                                     University is disposed to support the Free Homeopathic School of
                                                                                     Medicine any moment it requires”. However, the Director, Dr. Higinio G.
                                                                                     Pérez did not accept. His was a prophetic vision, since the National School
                                                                                     was incorporated in 1923 and was about to disappear.77 The words of
                                                                                     Vasconcelos were insignificant ultimately as Dr. Alfonso Pruneda, Principal

                                                                                     74 López (1998).
                                                                                     75 Moheno (1924).
                                                                                     76 De la Barrera (1961-1962).
                                                                                     77 Oseguera (1995).

                                                                                                                     Franz Steiner Verlag
The History of Homeopathic Medicine in Mexico (1849-2001)                  231

                                                                                     of the University in 1926, did not even accept the request by doctors from
                                                                                     the Free School to be examined in order to obtain their degrees.78 President
                                                                                     Plutarco Elias Calles sympathised with the problems of the homeopaths
                                                                                     and sent the Minister of Education, Dr. Jose Manuel Puig Casauranc, to
                                                                                     inspect the school. However, the government took no action to solve the
                                                                                     problem despite the report being completely favourable to the school.
                                                                                     Despite these problems, the Free School organised the first International
                                                                                     Homeopathic Congress in a Latin American country during the centenary
                                                                                     of Samuel Hahnemann from 10th to 16th August, 1929. Previously the cele-
                                                                                     brations had taken place only in Europe.79 This event was supported by the
                                                                                     Public Education Secretary and the main events took place in the Pan-
Open Access Download von der Verlag Österreich eLibrary am 11.05.2022 um 14:36 Uhr

                                                                                     American Room of the National Palace. The speakers were from Spain,
                                                                                     France, Brazil, USA, Yugoslavia, Cuba, India, Germany, Puerto Rico,
                                                                                     Holland, and England. It is not known how many participants attended.
                                                                                     It was in October of the same year when Emilio Portes Gil, a graduate of
                                                                                     the Free School of Law and Provisional President issued a decree support-
                                                                                     ing the existence of the Free School, and a further decree gave legal status to
                                                                                     the institution in 1930.80 The Representative Chamber ratified the 4th
                                                                                     Article of the Constitution in 1933. There was a campaign against
                                                                                     homeopathy and the legislators were about to succeed.81 However, the
                                                                                     campaign was frustrated thanks to the vigorous response of the
                                                                                     homeopaths, and one of the representatives, Dr. Castro.82 At the same time,
                                                                                     the Free School of Puebla was taken over by a group of students, coming to
                                                                                     blows with the school porter and the principal, Dr. Victor Manuel Oropeza
                                                                                     who seized the flag of the institution from the attacking students.83 The
                                                                                     National School also suffered hardship after dependence on the Secretary of
                                                                                     Health ceased in 1923. It was incorporated into the UNAM where, initially,
                                                                                     it was given a budget which was managed badly by its members.84
                                                                                     Homeopathy was made a specialty subject in the Higher Studies Faculty.
                                                                                     However, the principals did not move to help homeopathy.85 The school
                                                                                     formed part of the Secretariat of Public Education from 1928 under a
                                                                                     decree of President Calles.86 First, it was located at the Homeopathic

                                                                                     78 De la Barrera (1961-1962).
                                                                                     79 Rodríguez/Emygdio (1936).
                                                                                     80 De la Barrera (1961-1962).
                                                                                     81 De la Barrera (1961-1962).
                                                                                     82 Flores Toledo (1995).
                                                                                     83 López (1998).
                                                                                     84 Flores Toledo (1995).
                                                                                     85 Oseguera (1995).
                                                                                     86 Flores Toledo (1995).

                                                                                                                     Franz Steiner Verlag
232                                                     Fernando Dario Francois Flores

                                                                                     National Hospital and then, without any support, moved to the houses of
                                                                                     the principals, Fidel de Regules and Jose Mayoral Pardo. The school, after
                                                                                     multiple attacks from allopaths and from the authorities, was about to close
                                                                                     in 1934 when the suspension of the classes was ordered. However, a group
                                                                                     of students, who had formed a civil association in 1933, used legal pressure
                                                                                     to prevent this disaster. The leaders of the group were Luis R. Salinas
                                                                                     Ramos, Pedro Castellanos del Saz and Juan Manuel Ortiz de Zarate.87 This
                                                                                     conflict involved legal costs and the Workers Trades Union and the
                                                                                     professional organisation together mobilised strike action against the
                                                                                     technical schools. This resulted in the National School, under the leadership
                                                                                     of Ing. Juan de Dios Batiz, moving from the Technical Teaching
                                                                                     Department in 1935. It finally formed one of the foundation institutions of
Open Access Download von der Verlag Österreich eLibrary am 11.05.2022 um 14:36 Uhr

                                                                                     in 1937.88
                                                                                     However, the closure of the Homeopathic School of Medicine in Yucatan
                                                                                     and of the Hahnemann Hospital by the arbitrary action of the Governor,
                                                                                     Ing. Canto Echeverria, on February 11th, 1938 were achieved without going
                                                                                     against the authorities. Nevertheless, there was a decree from the state legis-
                                                                                     lature and a trial of the principals, Drs. Rafael Colome and Alonso V.
                                                                                     Gamboa, who were attacked and threatened with death as the Governor
                                                                                     wanted to close the school and the hospital.89 Unfortunately, the politicians
                                                                                     behaved like gangsters and both principals offered no resistance, resulting
                                                                                     in the disappearance of the school and the hospital. Indeed, in 1939, the
                                                                                     President himself, influenced by enemies of the Free School, tried to abolish
                                                                                     the decree which gave legal support to the institution and, thereby, de-
                                                                                     stroyed it. This is notable as at the school principals were invited to the in-
                                                                                     auguration of General Cardenas who, later, would issue a presidential de-
                                                                                     cree to close the school.90 All kinds of actions were taken to defend the
                                                                                     institution, from a trial of protection and the idea of closing and hanging
                                                                                     the strike flags on the doors to prevent official closure. The supposed strik-
                                                                                     ing teachers would not require a payment. In the most critical moments the
                                                                                     students moved on to the roof armed with bricks and stones to defend the
                                                                                     school. There were no public or press reactions as the President had abso-
                                                                                     lute power and a free press was in the future. After a year of difficulty and
                                                                                     pain, Dr. Julio Ulloa, the school principal, and members of the Technical
                                                                                     Administrative Council obtained a judgement in favour of the school. Un-
                                                                                     der the Protection Judgement no. 161-939 issued in 1940, the anti-constitu-
                                                                                     tional acts of the President, the Secretary of Public Education and the chief

                                                                                     87 Oseguera (1995). The number of students involved is not known.
                                                                                     88 Oseguera (1995).
                                                                                     89 Flores Toledo (1995).
                                                                                     90 Diario Oficial de la Federación. 23 de Enero de 1939. Decreto por el cual se deroga el
                                                                                        que otorgó el reconocimiento y los privilegios de ley, a la Escuela Libre de
                                                                                        Homeopatía de Mexico.

                                                                                                                           Franz Steiner Verlag
The History of Homeopathic Medicine in Mexico (1849-2001)                        233

                                                                                     of the Federal District Police were declared illegal.91 Once again homeopa-
                                                                                     thy had won.

                                                                                     Stability and Progress (1940-1960)
                                                                                     These years are characterised by homeopathic congresses being held in
                                                                                     Mexico and a quiet and slow period of growth and reconstruction of the
                                                                                     institutions.
                                                                                     The National School brought to Mexico the first Pan-American Medico-
                                                                                     Homeopathic Congress on its XIth celebration in October 1940. The Free
                                                                                     School celebrated the centenary of Hahnemann's death with the First Na-
                                                                                     tional Congress of Homeopathic Medicine in July 1943.92 The Lth anniver-
Open Access Download von der Verlag Österreich eLibrary am 11.05.2022 um 14:36 Uhr

                                                                                     sary of the National Homeopathic Hospital was celebrated on July 15th,
                                                                                     1943. Another festivity was the construction of a monument dedicated to
                                                                                     the four founders of the hospital.93 The monument was a beautiful obelisk,
                                                                                     on which was placed a plate alluding to homeopathy and a further bronze
                                                                                     garland which encircled the date of the institution’s foundation. The IInd
                                                                                     National Congress was celebrated in Michoacan in 1944 and ended in
                                                                                     Mexico City in 1949, under the auspices of the Free School. The XVIIth
                                                                                     Pan-American Medico-Homeopathic Congress was celebrated in Oaxaca.94
                                                                                     Although the worst had passed, problems still remained. The National
                                                                                     School moved to many places, including the National Homeopathic Hospi-
                                                                                     tal in 1949 where it remained for some time.95 In the State of Jalisco the
                                                                                     history of official institutions was unfortunate.96 The officially recognised
                                                                                     institutions of the Free Homeopathic School of Guadalajara, founded in
                                                                                     1925 by Dr. Higinio G. Perez, and the Homeopathic Institute of Jalisco,
                                                                                     founded in 1930 by Dr. Luis Jauregui, were merged in 1945 to form the
                                                                                     Homeopathic Medicine School of the Occident. This new institution was
                                                                                     subordinated to the National School to provide a solution to solve their
                                                                                     requirements which were being increasingly restricted by the Secretary of
                                                                                     Public Education. Unfortunately, the new school lasted only four years be-
                                                                                     cause of internal instability and of the requirements of the National
                                                                                     School.97 The act of dissolution was put into effect on August 22nd, 1949
                                                                                     and the teaching of official homeopathy in Jalisco disappeared.98 The Med-

                                                                                     91 Pirrón Q. Leonardo 1er Secretario del Juzgado 1° de distrito. Juicio de amparo 161-
                                                                                        939.
                                                                                     92 Primer Congreso Nacional de Homepatìa en México (1943).
                                                                                     93 Peréz Vargas (1943).
                                                                                     94 La Homeopatía de México (4a. Epoca) 4 (1946).
                                                                                     95 Salinas Ramos (1973).
                                                                                     96 Michel (1994).
                                                                                     97 Flores Toledo (1995).
                                                                                     98 Formación del Círculo Homeopático Mexicano (1885). Michel (1994).

                                                                                                                       Franz Steiner Verlag
234                                                    Fernando Dario Francois Flores

                                                                                     ico-Homeopathic and Surgery Association of the Centre A.C. was estab-
                                                                                     lished in 1951, the first institution to allow doctors from both the Free
                                                                                     School and the National School to come together, a situation not consid-
                                                                                     ered previously.99 This group still functions as a college, it being one of the
                                                                                     most durable permanent postgraduate institutions in Mexico. A new stage
                                                                                     starts at the Free Homeopathic School in 1951, when Dr. Leonardo
                                                                                     Jaramillo stands down from the office of principal. He was the last disciple
                                                                                     of Dr. Higinio G. Perez who was to lead the school. His departure led to
                                                                                     detrimental changes within the institution as all the other directors were
                                                                                     surgeons and did not maintain homeopathic orthodoxy.
                                                                                     The IIIrd National Congress was celebrated in November 1951 under the
Open Access Download von der Verlag Österreich eLibrary am 11.05.2022 um 14:36 Uhr

                                                                                     auspices of the two schools.100 However, the IVth National Congress in July
                                                                                     1954, under the same auspices, was the last to be celebrated for 17 years.101
                                                                                     The XXVIIth Pan-American Medico-Homeopathic Congress, was cele-
                                                                                     brated in Mexico City in October 1956.102 The celebration of the XXXIst
                                                                                     Pan-American Medico-Homeopathic Congress in Mexico City in 1960 is a
                                                                                     suitable conclusion to this stage of the history.103

                                                                                     The Postgraduates (1960- )
                                                                                     The fifth stage of homeopathic medical history in Mexico is characterised
                                                                                     by the flourishing of schools, congresses and study groups, especially at
                                                                                     postgraduate level. More meetings are held and many more schools
                                                                                     opened. Six monuments are constructed in Mexico and the existing two
                                                                                     reconstructed.
                                                                                     However, there are conflicts with the authorities and between homeopathic
                                                                                     doctors. The expulsion of the last orthodox homeopaths from the Free
                                                                                     School in 1962 by the directors, who were surgeons and did not want the
                                                                                     opposition of the orthodox homeopaths, had the consequence of enforce-
                                                                                     ment by “Homeopatia de Mexico A.C.” which had been founded on Sep-
                                                                                     tember 23rd, 1960 by Proceso Sanchez Ortega, David Flores Toledo and
                                                                                     Ranulfo Romero Moreno. It had the objectives of the diffusion, study and
                                                                                     practice of Hahnemannian homeopathy. After 1962, “Homeopatìa de
                                                                                     México A.C.” remained and remains as the last fortress of Hahnemannian
                                                                                     homeopathy in Mexico. The study group, founded with the intention of
                                                                                     keeping alive the flame lit by Perez in 1912 was the first to teach homeo-
                                                                                     pathic medicine at a postgraduate level. Thus, a solid foundation is given to
                                                                                     the area of study which characterises the very nature of the school world-

                                                                                     99 Barbosa (1998).
                                                                                     100 Informes del III Congreso Nacional de Medicina Homeopática (1951).
                                                                                     101 La Homeopatía en el Mundo Jg. 5-II 3 (1954).
                                                                                     102 La Homeopatía en el Mundo Jg. Año 7-IV 2 (1956). Editorial y Noticiero.
                                                                                     103 La Homeopatía de México 242 (1960).

                                                                                                                          Franz Steiner Verlag
The History of Homeopathic Medicine in Mexico (1849-2001)                     235

                                                                                     wide. “Homeopatia de Mexico A.C.” also promoted the return of Mexican
                                                                                     homeopathy to the international field by organising general assemblies and
                                                                                     two congresses of the “Liga Medicorum Homeopathica Internationalis” in
                                                                                     1980 in Acapulco, Guerrero104, and in Oaxaca105 in 1995. In addition, their
                                                                                     teachers participated in courses in other countries in Latin America. The
                                                                                     general assemblies of “Homeopatia de Mexico A.C.” were initiated in 1964.
                                                                                     These meetings involved international participation and have been cele-
                                                                                     brated on twenty-two occasions, including the world congresses of 1980
                                                                                     and 1995. Twelve meetings, involving foreign groups together with national
                                                                                     participants, have been celebrated which, for many years, were the only
                                                                                     homeopathic events celebrated regularly at a national level. The Pan-
                                                                                     American Congress was celebrated once again in Mexico in Merida, Yuca-
Open Access Download von der Verlag Österreich eLibrary am 11.05.2022 um 14:36 Uhr

                                                                                     tan in 1964, as their XXXVth meeting.106 The XXXIXth meeting was cele-
                                                                                     brated in Mexico City in 1968.107 It has been celebrated a further eight
                                                                                     times in different states of the Republic: XLIst in Mexico City, 1970108,
                                                                                     XLIIIrd in Puerto Vallarta, Jalisco, 1972109, XLIVth in Mexico City,
                                                                                     1973110, XLVIth in Mexico City, 1978111, XLIXth in Guanajuato, Guana-
                                                                                     juato, 1981112, LIst in Monterrey, Nuevo Leon, 1984113, LIInd in Monterrey,
                                                                                     Nuevo Leon, 1987114, and the LIIIrd in Monterey, Nuevo Leon, 1991115.
                                                                                     The National Homeopathic Medicine Congress was reinstated in 1971116

                                                                                     104 Ecos del XXXV Congreso Internacional y la IX Asamblea General de Homeopatía
                                                                                         de México A. C. (1980).
                                                                                     105 Memorias del 50 Congreso de la Liga Medicorum Homeopathica Internationalis
                                                                                         (1995).
                                                                                     106 La Homeopatía de México 271-272 Vol. XV (1964).
                                                                                     107 La Homeopatía en el Mundo (6a. Epoca) 30. Vol. XV (1968).
                                                                                     108 La Homeopatía de México (6a. Epoca) 330 Vol. XV (1970).
                                                                                     109 La Homeopatía de México (6a. Epoca) 350 Vol. XVI (1972).
                                                                                     110 La Homeopatía de México (6a. Epoca) 351 Vol. XVI (1972).
                                                                                     111 La Homeopatía de México (6a. Epoca) 412 (1979). Informe del XLVI Congreso
                                                                                         Médico Homeopático Panamericano.
                                                                                     112 La Homeopatía de México (6a. Epoca) 443 (1981).
                                                                                     113 La Homeopatía de México (6a. Epoca) 464 (1984). Informes del LI Congreso Médico
                                                                                         Homeopático Panamericano.
                                                                                     114 La Homeopatía de México (6a. Epoca) 508, 509 (1987). Premiaciones en el LII
                                                                                         Congreso Médico Homeopático Panamericano y XI Congreso Nacional de Medicina
                                                                                         Homeopática.
                                                                                     115 La Homeopatía de México (6a. Epoca) 547 (1987), 558 (1992). Informes del LIII
                                                                                         Congreso Médico Homeopático Panamericano y XIV Congreso Nacional de
                                                                                         Medicina Homeopática.
                                                                                     116 La Homeopatía de México (6a. Epoca) Vol. XVI 332 (1971).

                                                                                                                      Franz Steiner Verlag
236                                                  Fernando Dario Francois Flores

                                                                                     with the Vth, and in 1973 the VIth meetings117. Subsequently, their celebra-
                                                                                     tions were irregular until 1996, after which they became annual meetings
                                                                                     with the twentieth meeting being celebrated in Tepic, Nayarit in October,
                                                                                     1999. Other international congresses celebrated in Mexico, have been the
                                                                                     First International Homeopathic Meeting organised by the National School
                                                                                     in 1976 and the O.M.H.I Congress celebrated in 1990, both in Mexico
                                                                                     City. Three National History Fora were held during 1994, 1996 and 1998.
                                                                                     At the present time, there are eight monuments of Hahnemann and of his
                                                                                     followers: Hahnemann’s monument at the Santiago Tlatelolco park
                                                                                     (1973)118, the Mausoleum to Higinio G. Perez at the Free Homeopathic
                                                                                     School (1978)119, Hahnemann’s monument at the Escuela Nacional de
Open Access Download von der Verlag Österreich eLibrary am 11.05.2022 um 14:36 Uhr

                                                                                     Medicina y Homeopatia (1985)120, Hahnemann’s monument in Oaxaca
                                                                                     (1991)121, Hahnemann’s monument in Guadalajara (1992)122 and the
                                                                                     Centenary monument at the Escuela Nacional de Medicina y Homeopatia
                                                                                     (1997)123.
                                                                                     The nineteen-eighties proved to be rich in problems and difficulties, par-
                                                                                     ticularly at the National Homeopathic Hospital. A general health law was
                                                                                     formulated in 1984 to regulate all sanitary politics in Mexico. Homeopathic
                                                                                     medicine was not included and an intention of closing the hospital was
                                                                                     mentioned. Marches, standstills, protests and newspaper publicity organised
                                                                                     by approximately three hundred students, doctors and patients together
                                                                                     with the doctors of the hospital and school pressured the authorities into
                                                                                     including homeopathic medicine in the law.124 This conflict initiated the
                                                                                     formation of one organisation which would unite all the existing homeo-
                                                                                     pathic institutions in Mexico, the “Consejo Consultivo Nacional Medico
                                                                                     Homeopatico A.C.”. This grouped together all homeopathic schools, labo-
                                                                                     ratories, colleges and associations, and is directly responsible for all dia-
                                                                                     logue with the Mexican authorities.125 The hospital was threatened once
                                                                                     again in 1986. After the earthquake of 1985 and the subsequent destruction
                                                                                     of hospitals, the government pretended to install allopathic equipment and
                                                                                     personnel, thereby, losing the special character of the institution. Doctors
                                                                                     and other personnel guarded the hospital day and night to prevent the

                                                                                     117 La Homeopatía de México (6a. Epoca) Vol. XVI 348 (1972).
                                                                                     118 Hermoso Monumento al descubridor de la homeopatía (1973).
                                                                                     119 Francois Flores (1998).
                                                                                     120 Nuestra Portada (1985).
                                                                                     121 Francois Flores (1998).
                                                                                     122 Monumento a Hahnemannn (1992).
                                                                                     123 Francois Flores (1998).
                                                                                     124 Salinas Ramos (1985).
                                                                                     125 Consejo Consultivo Nacional Médico Homeopático (1984).

                                                                                                                        Franz Steiner Verlag
The History of Homeopathic Medicine in Mexico (1849-2001)                             237

                                                                                     diminution of their hospital, while they organised protest movements and
                                                                                     publications against the abuse. Finally, the government denied their inten-
                                                                                     tion of installing personnel and equipment from the Juarez Hospital in the
                                                                                     National Homeopathic Hospital.126 The Free School suffered the worst cri-
                                                                                     sis of its history in the same year as the slow process, initiated in 1951, con-
                                                                                     cluded with its students not having a registrable qualification. There was
                                                                                     anarchy and violence in the school at the time as the institution’s authorities
                                                                                     were not fulfilling the requirements of the General Education Law which
                                                                                     prevented the registration of the professional titles. The internal conflicts
                                                                                     and the conflicts with the health and education authorities culminated in an
                                                                                     assault on its students which provoked total chaos. Further attacks and con-
                                                                                     flicts left the school without any recognised authority. Nevertheless, the stu-
Open Access Download von der Verlag Österreich eLibrary am 11.05.2022 um 14:36 Uhr

                                                                                     dents achieved an agreement with the government in order to gain a title at
                                                                                     the National School. Thus, many students could gain legal recognition.127
                                                                                     Finally, after thirteen years of conflicts, the Free School moved into a
                                                                                     period of reconstruction. The relationship with the Secretaries of Health
                                                                                     and Education have been normalised and the title procedures have been
                                                                                     newly re-opened, so the school now enjoys all the rights from the decree
                                                                                     issued by President Emilio Portes Gil on January 18th, 1930.
                                                                                     The numerous postgraduate institutes, which are significant in the final
                                                                                     stage of homeopathic medicine in Mexico, are spread throughout Mexico.
                                                                                     Those that have official recognition from the authorities and offer classes at
                                                                                     a specialty level produce about seventy graduates every year. The Escuela
                                                                                     Nacional offers postgraduate studies on homeopathic therapy and has been
                                                                                     officially recognised since 1982.128 The Instituto de Estudios Superiores of
                                                                                     Oaxaca provides classes with homeopathy as a specialty and was legally
                                                                                     recognised in 1985.129 El Instituto Superior de Medicina Homeopatica, En-
                                                                                     señanza e Investigacion of Monterrey, Nuevo Leon obtained official recog-
                                                                                     nition at the end of 1988.130 The Instituto de Estudios Tecnologicos y
                                                                                     Superiores “Matatipac” A.C. of Tepic, Nayarit obtained official recognition
                                                                                     of its courses in 1991.131 Finally, the Escuela de Posgrado of Homeopatia

                                                                                     126 Salinas Ramos (1986).
                                                                                     127 Diario Oficial de la Federación. Secretaría de Educación Pública. Acuerdo número
                                                                                         162 por el que se establecen las normas para la titulación de los egresados de la
                                                                                         Escuela Libre de Homeopatía A. C. 31 de julio de 1992.
                                                                                     128 Pulido Alvarez (1994).
                                                                                     129 Periódico Oficial del Gobierno del EStado de Oaxaca. Acuerdo No 24. 8 de
                                                                                         Noviembre de 1985.
                                                                                     130 Flores (1994).
                                                                                     131 Periódico Oficial del Estado de Nayarit. 10 de Abril de 1991. Decreto N 7403. Se
                                                                                         autoriza y reconoce validez oficial a los estudios realizados en técnica y rediología y
                                                                                         terapéutica homeopática en el Instituto de Estudios Tecnológicos y Superiores
                                                                                         “Matatipac” A. C.

                                                                                                                         Franz Steiner Verlag
238                                                     Fernando Dario Francois Flores

                                                                                     de Mexico teaches the specialty of homeopathy, being officially recognised
                                                                                     in 1996.132

                                                                                     Bibliography

                                                                                     Sources
                                                                                     Advertencia. In: La Reforma Médica 1 (1875).
                                                                                     Ave Fénix. In: La Reforma Médica (Segunda Epoca) 11 (1886).
                                                                                     Archivo Histórico de la S. S. A: F-BP, S-EH, Sc-HNH, Lg-1, Exp-1.
                                                                                     Decreto Presidencial número 13.
Open Access Download von der Verlag Österreich eLibrary am 11.05.2022 um 14:36 Uhr

                                                                                     Diario Oficial de la Federación. 23 de Enero de 1939. Decreto por el cual se deroga el que
                                                                                     otorgó el reconocimiento y los privilegios de ley, a la Escuela Libre de Homeopatía de
                                                                                     Mexico.
                                                                                     Diario Oficial de la Federación. Secretaría de Educación Pública. Acuerdo número 162
                                                                                     por el que se establecen las normas para la titulación de los egresados de la Escuela Libre
                                                                                     de Homeopatía A. C. 31 de julio de 1992.
                                                                                     La Homeopatía 3. Jg. 6 (1896).
                                                                                     La Homeopatía 16. Jg. 10 (1910).
                                                                                     La Homeopatía 16. Jg. 11 (1913).
                                                                                     La Homeopatía de México (Tercera época) 2 (1941).
                                                                                     La Homeopatía de México (4a. Epoca) 4 (1946).
                                                                                     La Homeopatía de México 242 (1960).
                                                                                     La Homeopatía de México 271-272 Vol. XV (1964).
                                                                                     La Homeopatía de México (6a. Epoca) 330 Vol. XV (1970).
                                                                                     La Homeopatía de México (6a. Epoca) 332 Vol. XVI (1971).
                                                                                     La Homeopatía de México (6a. Epoca) 348 Vol. XVI (1972).
                                                                                     La Homeopatía de México (6a. Epoca) 350 Vol. XVI (1972).
                                                                                     La Homeopatía de México (6a. Epoca) 351 Vol. XVI (1972).
                                                                                     La Homeopatía de México (6a. Epoca) 443 (1981).
                                                                                     La Homeopatía en el Mundo. 5. Jg. 3 (1954).
                                                                                     La Homeopatía en el Mundo. 7. Jg. 2 (1956).
                                                                                     La Homeopatía en el Mundo (6a. Epoca) 301 Vol. XV (1968).
                                                                                     Instituto Homeopático Mexicano. Diploma expedido al Dr. Luis Zaragoza el 10 de abril
                                                                                     de 1877.
                                                                                     Libro de Actas de la Academia Homeopática de México. Archivos de la Escuela Libre de
                                                                                     Homeopatía de México I. A. P. Mexico D. F.

                                                                                     132 Secretaría de Educación Pública, Acuerdo N          963093 del 22 de Julio de 1996.
                                                                                         Archivos de Homeopatía de México A. C.

                                                                                                                           Franz Steiner Verlag
You can also read