AGSAIRLINE GROUND SERVICES

Page created by Melanie Navarro
 
CONTINUE READING
AGSAIRLINE GROUND SERVICES
SUMMER/AUTUMN 2015

 AGS
                                                AIRLINE
                                                GROUND
                                                SERVICES

www.ags-airlinegroundservices.com

MERGERS AND                SAFE GROUND     CONSIDERING       WORLDWIDE DIRECTORY
ACQUISITIONS               HANDLING:       AVIATION          OF GROUND SERVICE
ROUND-UP                   BEST PRACTICE   INSURANCE         PROVIDERS
AGSAIRLINE GROUND SERVICES
From XS to XXL.
Fraport provides the perfect service tailored to every plane.
Every airline customer is unique – and should expect customized service. A ground handling partner with years of
experience and expertise, Fraport AG knows exactly what each airline needs. Together, we develop the right solutions
designed to meet your specific requirements. Flexibility is a major advantage, especially when we have to get late
arriving planes out even faster. We know the processes on the ground and can move into action with speed, precision
and efficiency. We put performance first, not size. Let us be your flexible ground handling partner.

Contact the Fraport ground services: phone +49 (0) 69 690-71101 / handling@fraport.de / www.fraport.com

Fraport. The Airport Managers.
AGSAIRLINE GROUND SERVICES
EDITOR’S LETTER | SUMMER/AUTUMN 2015

LETTER FROM                                                                      AGS
                                                                                                                                AIRLINE
                                                                                                                                GROUND
                                                                                                                                SERVICES
                                                                                                                                         SUMMER/AUTUMN 2015

THE EDITOR
                                                                                www.ags-airlinegroundservices.com

                                                                                MERGERS AND                SAFE GROUND     CONSIDERING       WORLDWIDE DIRECTORY
                                                                                ACQUISITIONS               HANDLING:       AVIATION          OF GROUND SERVICE
                                                                                ROUND-UP                   BEST PRACTICE   INSURANCE         PROVIDERS

W
                   elcome to the Summer/Autumn 2015 edition of AGS
                   magazine. In this issue, we look at consolidation            PARVEEN RAJA
                   among both airlines and handlers, as mergers and             Publisher
                                                                                parveen@evaint.com
                   acquisitions continue to shape the aviation industry.
                       Meanwhile, carriers are thinking creatively, using
partnerships to build better networks and expand their reach into new           IAN TALBOT
                                                                                Sales Executive
markets around the world.                                                       ian@evaint.com
    We hear from underwriting executive Simon Abbott on the
subject of ground damage – and who pays for it. The consequences
                                                                                BHAVI PATEL
of ground damage are far from insignificant, and Abbott suggests                 Events Coordinator
                                                                                bhavi@evaint.com
greater regulation of GSPs could be the way to improve safety on the
ramp. This theme is picked up again as AGS examines developments
relating to IATA’s Ground Operations Manual – and looks ahead to the            SHOBHANA PATEL
                                                                                Head of Finance
imminent 28th IGHC.                                                             finance@evaint.com
    Two articles look at IT in this edition: James Graham considers how
IT-based services benefit numerous sectors of the aviation world, while
                                                                                CHARLOTTE WILLIS
David Smith examines the role of IT and logistics in airline catering.          Events and Circulation
    We also take an overview of developments in the Asia Pacific                 charlotte@evaint.com
handling market, and we hear from TCR, which recently expanded its
presence in Scandinavia.                                                        SHELDON PINK
    Finally, having reintroduced our directory of ground service                Creative Director
                                                                                mrpinktoo@gmail.com
providers in the last edition, we welcome any updates to that section.
Please advise us of any changes or omissions.
    AGS welcomes your feedback and any interest in contributing an              Address changes and subscription orders to:
                                                                                circulation@evaint.com
article or interview. I hope you enjoy this issue of the magazine. Q            ISSN 2040-476X

                                                                                EDITORIAL CONTRIBUTORS
                                                                                Simon Abbott, Bernard Fitzsimons,
                                                                                James Graham, Megan Ramsay
                                                                                and David Smith

                                                                                PUBLISHED TWICE A YEAR BY
                                                                                EVA International Media Ltd
                                                                                Boswell Cottage, 19 South End
                                                                                Croydon, London CR0 1BE
                                                                                Tel: + 44 (0) 20 8253 4000
                                                                                Fax: + 44 (0)20 8603 7369
                                                                                Website: www.evaint.com

                                                                                PRINTED BY
                                                                                Headley Brothers
                                                                                The Invicta Press, Lower Queens Road
                                                                                Ashford, Kent, TN24 8HH, UK

                                                                                DISTRIBUTED BY
                                                                                Ascendia

                                                                                                                                                                   EVA INTERNATIONAL MEDIA LTD
                                                                                                                                                                   PUBLISHERS & EVENTS SPECIALISTS

                       KIRSTY POWELL                                            Is s u e 1 9 © 2 0 1 5 | w w w. e v a i n t . c o m
                       Editor                                                   Content may not be reproduced in any
                                                                                format without written permission from
                       kirsty@evaint.com                                        EVA International Media Ltd

www.ags-airlinegroundservices.com                                           SUMMER/AUTUMN 2015 Airline Ground Services 1
AGSAIRLINE GROUND SERVICES
CONTENTS | SUMMER/AUTUMN 2015

 4
                                               CONTENTS
                                               1   Editor’s letter

                                               4   Working together
                                                   The aviation sector has gone through numerous changes in the past, not least of which
                                                   has been a trend for consolidation among carriers. Looking at Europe in particular, how
                                                   have mergers and acquisitions among airlines filtered down to affect the handlers that
                                                   serve them?

                                               6   Carriers think smart
                                                   Tough times call for more creative approaches to developing route networks. Airlines
                                                   are increasingly exploiting partnerships and using each others’ hubs to penetrate into
                                                   new territory.

                                               12 Handlers start to get it together
                                                   Once highly fragmented, the airline handling industry is showing strong merger and
                                                   acquisition activity as companies strive to offer their customers a truly global service.

                                               18 Ground damage – who pays?
                                                   Simon Abbott, underwriting executive for worldwide aviation insurance provider Global
                                                   Aerospace, looks at who bears the cost of ground damage to aircraft.

                                               20 The fusion of catering and logistics
                                                   Airline catering is a huge undertaking. David Smith looks at how airlines and catering
                                                   companies are employing logistical and IT solutions to support the operation.

                                               26 "TJB1BDJlDSPVOEVQ
                                                   Bernard Fitzsimons reviews recent activity in the world’s most dynamic
                                   18              air transport region.

                                               32 IT connects aviation
 32                                                Whether an organisation is an airport, air navigation service provider (ANSP), ground
                                                   handler or airline, IT-based services deliver tangible benefits to the organisation, discovers
                                                   James Graham

                                               37 Scandinavian expansion
                                                   Brussels-headquartered GSE provider TCR began operations in Norway in 2011 – and it is
                                                   continuing to grow its footprint in the surrounding region.

                                               39 Sharing best practice
                                                   Efficient, safe airline ground handling services are the bedrock of the modern aviation
                                                   system. To ensure continued improvement, the industry is focusing on safety, quality,
                                                   transparency and sustainability across all its operations.

                                               43 Worldwide Directory of Ground Service Providers

2 Airline Ground Services Summer/Autumn 2015                                                                 www.ags-airlinegroundservices.com
AGSAIRLINE GROUND SERVICES
Your trusted partner
Available at 27 airports in the kingdom
of Saudi Arabia, Saudi Ground Services
Company is determined to provide its
client airlines the best services for a
smooth & efficient operation with safety
and on-Time performance                   sgsaviation.com.sa
AGSAIRLINE GROUND SERVICES
FEATURE | CARRIERS & HANDLERS

WORKING TOGETHER:
MERGERS AND ACQUISITIONS
The aviation sector has gone through numerous changes in the past, not least of which has
been a trend for consolidation among carriers. Looking at Europe in particular, how have
NFSHFSTBOEBDRVJTJUJPOTBNPOHBJSMJOFTlMUFSFEEPXOUPBGGFDUUIFIBOEMFSTUIBUTFSWFUIFN

T
             here are four large, pri-                                                       as well as at Malabo and Bata airports in
             marily full-service airline                                                     Equatorial Guinea. Customers include
             groups in Europe. Air                                                           IAG airlines BA, Iberia and Vueling.
             France-KLM, Internation-
             al Airlines Group (IAG),                                                        MUTUAL STRENGTHS
Lufthansa Group and SAS Group                                                                Air France-KLM came into being in
have all grown over the years through                                                        2004, with the merger of Air France and
mergers and/or acquisitions.                                                                 KLM Royal Dutch Airlines. The group
    IAG is the most recently formed air-                                                     also includes Martinair, which provides
line grouping in Europe, having started                                                      cargo-carrying services in addition to
trading in early 2011. It comprises the                                                      the freighter flights offered by the two
UK’s British Airways (BA), Spanish car-                                                      other airlines. Air France and KLM each
rier Iberia and low-cost carrier Vueling,                                                    run their own operations from their
plus short and medium-haul subsidiary                                                        respective hubs in Paris and Amsterdam
Iberia Express, the cargo-carrying arms        Peter Schelvis, group chief procurement
                                                                                             but their procurement divisions –
of BA and Iberia, and UK domestic and          officer at Air France-KLM                      including the procurement of handling
short-haul carrier British Midland In-                                                       services – have been merged.
ternational (bmi) – the latter formerly        2014, adding a new station to the han-            According to Peter Schelvis, group
part of the Lufthansa Group.                   dler’s network.                               chief procurement officer at Air France-
    In the months following the creation            BA itself provides ground handling       KLM, the procurement organisations of
of IAG, while handling costs rose, joint       services both for its own flights and for      Air France and KLM “were combined in
airport handling procurement offset these      external clients. In September last year      September 2008, taking full advantage
increases to some extent, as the Group         it was selected to provide technical han-     of their mutual strengths”. Air France-
synergy programme took effect.                 dling services for Qatar Airways B787         KLM Procurement is responsible for the
    BA flights at Heathrow, Glasgow,            flights at Edinburgh; BA also began            acquisition of goods and services for the
Manchester and Edinburgh are handled           providing maintenance services for the        whole Group.
by UK-based Menzies Aviation, which            Middle Eastern carrier’s A380 flights at           Schelvis explains: “The procurement
began passenger services, ramp han-            Heathrow in October 2014. (Qatar Air-         organisation generates added value
dling and lounge and ticketing services        ways bought a 10 percent stake in IAG         through cost-effective solutions direct-
for BA and BA CityFlyer at these loca-         earlier this year.)                           ed at connecting internal departments
tions in 2012 – adding an extra 19,500              Iberia Airport Services, meanwhile,      and external suppliers. Our mission is
flights per year to its portfolio.              is the handling arm of BA’s sister carrier.   to secure a sustainable competitive ad-
    Menzies was already well established       It provides ramp, passenger, operations       vantage for the group, derived from cost
with other carriers at all four stations,      and cargo handling services for over          leadership and procurement profession-
and had in fact been providing ground          200 clients at 41 airports across Spain,      alism. Our suppliers play a vital role in
handling services for bmi at Heathrow
since 2010 – but once bmi was converted
to the BA AOC (air operator certificate)
it was by no means guaranteed that the
existing contract there would be re-
tained. Andy Boyd, senior vice president
UK and Ireland at the handler, said after
the award of the contract: “It’s a testa-
ment to our operations department, and
the talent of the LHR (London Heath-
row) ramp team, that has consistently
delivered great service to bmi, that BA
has had the confidence to award us its
business in T1.”
    More recently, Menzies began a
three-year passenger handling contract
for IAG’s Vueling in Madrid on 5 August

4 Airline Ground Services Summer/Autumn 2015                                                          www.ags-airlinegroundservices.com
AGSAIRLINE GROUND SERVICES
FEATURE | CARRIERS & HANDLERS

achieving our corporate goals. Forging
                                                PARALLEL DEVELOPMENTS
beneficial supplier relations, contribut-
ing innovative solutions and reducing           The trend for consolidation, of course, has been just as noticeable in the
overall costs serve as a solid foundation       handling sector as among airlines in recent years, and Swissport’s stake in
to optimise benefits for the group.”             SAS Ground Handling is just one example of this tendency for handlers to
     In July 2014, Air France awarded a         buy into each other, if not take each other over outright.
five-year cargo and mail handling con-             0UIFSEFBMTUIBUBSFQFSIBQTNPSFTJHOJlDBOUJODMVEFUIFBDRVJTJUJPOPG#SVT
tract to Paris-headquartered Worldwide          TFMTIFBERVBSUFSFE IBOEMFS "WJBQBSUOFS CZ 8'4 JO   XJUI FBDI DPNQBOZ
Flight Services (WFS) at the French capi-       DPOUJOVJOHUPPQFSBUFVOEFSJUTPXOFTUBCMJTIFEBOEXFMMSFDPHOJTFECSBOE
tal’s Orly airport, adding to a further four      .PSF SFDFOUMZ   TBX 4XJTTQPSU BDRVJSF .BODIFTUFST 4FSWJTBJS  FY
contracts gained with the airline over the      QBOEJOHJUTOFUXPSLUPDPWFSTUBUJPOTJODPVOUSJFT*OUIJTDBTF JU
preceding 12-month period (Nice, Bor-           appears that Servisair is being rebranded under the Swissport identity.
deaux, Strasbourg and Marseille). WFS
                                                  "DDPSEJOH UP "VTUSBMJBCBTFE $"1" n $FOUSF GPS "WJBUJPO  XIJDI QSP
began cargo handling for Air France at
                                                vides aviation market intelligence, analysis and data services: “we aren’t
EuroAirport Basel-Mulhouse-Freiburg
                                                ZFU EPXO UP B IBOEGVM PG GVMM TFSWJDFOFUXPSL BJSMJOFT BOE B TJOHMF -$$
in October last year as well.
                                                 MPXDPTUDBSSJFS JOEJGGFSFOUHMPCBMSFHJPOT BTIBTMPOHCFFOGPSFDBTUFE
                                                neither has there been a similar degree of consolidation in the ground
NEW OPPORTUNITIES
                                                IBOEMJOH XPSME  XIFSF B AUPQ  UIBU XPVME IBWF B TUSBOHMFIPME PO UIF
Lufthansa      Group      includes      the
                                                segment was predicted.
German flag-carrier, Lufthansa, as
well as Swiss International Airlines               h1BSU PG UIF SFBTPO GPS UIBU  BDDPSEJOH UP 5JN 0SOFMMBT
AGSAIRLINE GROUND SERVICES
FEATURE | ROUTE DEVELOPMENT

                                                              Tough times call for more creative approaches to
                                                            developing route networks. Airlines are increasingly
                                                            exploiting partnerships and using each others’ hubs
                                                                                 to penetrate into new territory

CARRIERS THINK SMART
T
               his is the age of the alli-     to feed its own network. It will also use        From Bishkek, Pegasus Asia already
               ance. A handful of Mid-         current special pro-rate agreements          operates four direct scheduled routes to
               dle Eastern carriers apart,     (SPAs) to expand its network reach.          Osh in Kyrgyzstan, Moscow and Kras-
               most airlines in the world      It adds that the upgrade of Brunei In-       noyarsk in Russia and Delhi in India.
               don’t have unlimited budg-      ternational Airport has come at a good       There are connections to 18 destina-
ets and fleets of spare aircraft with          time, with the ASEAN Open Skies 2015         tions in Turkey plus 39 other interna-
which to pursue their route develop-           on the horizon – which is expected to        tional destinations in Europe and else-
ment plans. It’s no longer a matter of         generate greater competition between         where, making a total of 57 points in
putting planes onto a route, and hop-          airports in the region. The government       the network.
ing to fill them. Even if money was no         of Brunei Darussalam has ratified all             Lufthansa is another carrier that has
object, in many airports and countries         the main multilateral agreements asso-       found a partner with which to develop a
slot constraints and traffic right issues      ciated with this, which opens up mar-        remote hub and so open up a new region,
often prevent headlong expansion.              kets in the ASEAN region.                    without having to go to the expense and
     Instead, most of the world’s airlines         Another example is Turkish low-cost      difficulty of laying on new direct flights
have had to think smarter in order to ex-      carrier Pegasus’s Pegasus Asia arm, born     from its home territory. It will offer year-
tend their reach into new markets and          out of its partnership with Kyrgyz airline   round flights from Frankfurt to Panama
territories. This is particularly true of      Air Manas. This deal has given Pegasus a     City five days a week, from November 16,
some of the smaller carriers.                  useful second hub at Bishkek with which      2015. Part of the attraction is the Ger-
     Take Royal Brunei, for example,           to develop into Central Asia and connect     man airline’s partnership with the Pana-
which resumed services to Denpasar and         the region with Europe, the Middle East,     manian airline Copa, which will allow its
Ho Chi Minh City in July and October           Russia and the Far East.                     passengers to reach a further 50 destina-
2014 respectively and is now codeshar-             The first new route for 2015 is a         tions in Central and South America and
ing with Malaysian Airlines on selected        twice-weekly service between Bishkek         the Caribbean. Lufthansa service times
key domestic Malaysian cities, as well         and Delhi. And, following the granting       will be coordinated with Copa’s connect-
as having added a codeshare to Phnom           of bilateral air transport agreements        ing flights.
Penh. It also sees new market opportu-         with Russia, other planned new routes            Finding a partner with a ready-made
nities in Australia, India and North Asia,     in 2015 include Yekaterinburg and No-        network like this is a much quicker and,
and plans to add more flights to key cap-       vosibirsk, respectively twice weekly and     arguably, lower risk approach than try-
ital cities in the latter two areas.           once a week.                                 ing to do it all yourself.
     In its route development strategy,            Pegasus Asia has also submitted ap-          For carriers with a limited home
Royal Brunei takes into account traf-          plications for permission to further ex-     market, a hub approach is essential if
fic flow from feeder markets with ad-            tend its flight network to include routes     there is to be any meaningful expansion.
ditional codeshare points, particularly        to Urumqi (China), Dushanbe, Khujand         Like many airlines, Air Canada’s strate-
into the Indian subcontinent, helping          and Tashkent in 2015.                        gy is to look beyond the specific country

6 Airline Ground Services Summer/Autumn 2015                                                          www.ags-airlinegroundservices.com
AGSAIRLINE GROUND SERVICES
FEATURE | ROUTE DEVELOPMENT

market and consider the connectional
possibilities. For instance, the Toronto/
São Paulo service also offers some of the
quickest travel times from many north-
eastern US cities and is also timed for
convenient connections over Toronto
Pearson to many Asian cities, including
Tokyo-Haneda, Hong Kong, Beijing and
Shanghai, further expanding Air Cana-
da’s global reach.
    Air Canada has meanwhile started
a three-days-a-week, year-round 767-
300ER service between Toronto Pear-
son and Rio de Janeiro-Galeão Inter-
national Airport. It complements the
carrier’s daily non-stop service from To-
ronto to São Paulo and, Air Canada says,
is evidence of its international expansion
strategy and also reinforces its position
as the only non-stop carrier between
Canada and South America.

DEEP POCKETS                                 opportunity to adjust their schedules to     wide-body aircraft on behalf of Alitalia
Of course, there are still a handful of      improve connections with each other          or Alitalia receiving aircraft from Eti-
airlines with deep pockets, most of          and with their partners. As well as links    had’s existing fleet order book. Alita-
them in the Middle East. While they          with the Skyteam alliance, and in partic-    lia, meanwhile, is relocating 14 Airbus
have been adding to their fleets and          ular Air France–KLM and Delta, there         A320s to airberlin.
launching new services from their home       are new partnerships with airberlin and           Etihad Aviation Group president
hubs, the troubles of Europe and the rest    NIKI and plans to work more closely          and chief executive officer and Alitalia
of the world have also thrown up new         with Air Serbia and Etihad Regional.         vice chairman James Hogan said that, in
opportunities.                                   Both airlines will also increasingly     an extremely tough southern European
    The most prominent example is            operate a common fleet, which could           aviation market, “rapid, decisive change”
Abu Dhabi’s Etihad and its major cash        include Etihad acquiring additional          was needed. “We’ve invested in the new
injection into ailing Italian state car-
rier Alitalia.
    Naturally, the alliance gives Etihad
a strong entry into Italy, but more im-
                                                W E P R I D E O U R S E LV E S O N B E I N G D I F F E R E N T
portantly perhaps it helps reinforce the
Middle Eastern presence in the wider
European market.
    As far as Italy itself is concerned,
there will be a three-pronged strategy for
long-haul routes based on hubs at Milan
Malpensa, Milan Linate and Rome Fiu-
micino, all of which will see an increase
in flights. Long-haul services from Ven-
ice, Bologna and Catania on the island
of Sicily to Etihad’s main Abu Dhabi hub               Premiere Handling is the only independent
will also be stepped up to daily.                    Handling company based at Manchester Airport
    New routes available from Rome
now include Berlin, Dusseldorf, San                     Flight operations ō Passenger services
Francisco, Mexico City, Santiago (Chile),          Ramp services ō Cargo handling ō Business aviation
Beijing and Seoul and there will also be
an increase in services to New York, Chi-        We are there for you 24 hours a day 7 days a week.
cago, Rio de Janeiro and Abu Dhabi.
    An extra 13 weekly flights from Mi-
lan Malpensa will include daily routes to
Abu Dhabi, four flights a week to Shang-
hai and increased flights to Tokyo.
    But by strengthening links via Italy
into its home hub, Etihad can offer a
whole host of onward connections avail-
                                                 P R E M I E R E H A N D L I N G . C O M
able to other destinations in the Middle         e : o p e r a t i o n s @ p r e m i e r e h a n d l i n g . c o m
East, Africa, the Indian subcontinent,
Southeast Asia, China and Australia.                       Members of the IATA Ground Handling Council
    The two carriers have also taken the

www.ags-airlinegroundservices.com                                                        Summer/Autumn 2015 Airline Ground Services 7
AGSAIRLINE GROUND SERVICES
FEATURE | ROUTE DEVELOPMENT

Æ
Alitalia because we believe it can flour-
ish again. The coming months and next
few years will not be easy, but if everyone
pulls together as one team, Alitalia can
grow again.”
    Etihad expects Alitalia to be profit-
able again by 2017.
    In addition, Etihad has announced
an increase in its Tehran service from
three times weekly to daily. The new
schedule will establish important con-
nections to key markets in the US, in-
cluding Los Angeles, which is home to
the world’s largest Iranian population
outside the country.
    Qatar Airways, meanwhile, is using
its codeshare with Bangkok Airways to
reach 10 more destinations in Asia via
                                                                                                           The Air France–KLM
Bangkok, together with Koh Samui to
                                                                                                        Group has inched up its
Singapore, Phuket to Kuala Lumpur and
                                                                                                       capacity for the 2014-15
Phuket to Chiang Mai. The Arabian car-
                                                                                                                  winter season
rier already has quite a network of code-
shares from Bangkok in Asia, including
Chiang Mai, Phuket, Mandalay, Yangon                Route highlights include KLM’s in-     Pointe Noire (Congo) with a sixth week-
and Phnom Penh.                                crease in capacity to Atlanta, from seven   ly frequency.
    European airlines don’t have the lux-      to 12 weekly flights, in response to mar-         In East Africa, KLM is reorganis-
ury of being able to take a major stake        ket demand and to facilitate connections    ing its network to adapt it to the market
in a rival carrier and with the Eurozone       with partner Delta Air Lines. Services to   with increased capacity to Dar es Salaam
financial woes set to continue most have        Panama City will go up from three to        (Tanzania) and Entebbe (Uganda) now
had to take a very cautious approach.          five weekly frequencies by B777-200;         served direct three times a week and on
    The Air France–KLM Group has               again, the attraction is that the airport   other days via Kilimanjaro (Tanzania)
inched up its capacity for the 2014-15         is a main hub for Copa with which, as in    and Kigali (Rwanda). KLM has sus-
winter season which runs from 26 Oc-           the case of Lufthansa, Air France–KLM       pended direct service to Harare (Zim-
tober 2014 to 28 March 2015. Total ca-         has formed an alliance.                     babwe) and Lusaka (Zambia) but these
pacity is scheduled to increase by 0.7%,            Like many carriers, Air France is      cities are still served by partner Kenya
but with an increase of only 0.1% for          showing increased willingness to flex       Airways via Nairobi.
passenger operations (Air France, KLM          services up and down, according to de-           Air France, like most carriers, needs
and HOP!) but 13.3% for the Transavia          mand. It is increasing capacity to take     to keep costs under control, especially
low-cost leisure operation, with most of       advantage of seasonal travel peaks, for     on its medium-haul network. One way
the growth concentrated on the French          instance offering one flight per day        it is doing this is to maximise connect-
market (+56%).                                 to Bangkok (Thailand) between mid-          ing opportunities and, again, adjusting
    Taking each region in turn, there          December and mid-March, and adding          capacity according to winter or summer
are capacity gains for North America           a fourth frequency to Kuala Lumpur          demand. So, for example one daily fre-
(+2.4%), Central and South America             (Malaysia). Wuhan, China gains an ex-       quency is being suspended to Munich,
(+1.1%) and Asia (+0.7%).                      tra weekly frequency while Guangzhou        Bucharest, Moscow, Rome and Bremen.
    In Africa, capacity is slightly down by    will be served by four weekly flights.            Domestic flights from Paris-Orly
-0.8% and the biggest fall, predictably             And while Africa capacity is down      to Bordeaux and to Toulouse have
perhaps, is in the Middle East (-5.2%).        overall, services have been increased on    been trimmed back, as have several
                                               the most buoyant routes such as Abid-       flights from the provincial airports of
                                               jan (Ivory Coast), with the entry into      Toulouse and Marseille to Europe and
                                                              service of the A380, and     North Africa.
                                                                                                In contrast, the low-cost Transavia
                                                                                                                   arm will operate

8 Airline Ground Services Summer/Autumn 2015                                                         www.ags-airlinegroundservices.com
Delivering operational excellence below
    the wing. Enhancing passenger
    experience above.

       Aircraft         Service      Fleet          Resource   Contract    Web         ,QYHQWRU\    Financial      Business
     Turnaround
       Aircraft         Capture
                        Service   Management
                                     Fleet          Planning
                                                    Resource   & Asset
                                                               Contract   Portal
                                                                           Web          & Stock
                                                                                       ,QYHQWRU\   Management
                                                                                                    Financial    Intelligence
                                                                                                                   Business
     Turnaround         Capture   Management        Planning   & Asset    Portal        & Stock    Management    Intelligence

    The MOST comprehensive aviation service management solution available:
         Complete service capture leading to accurate billing and fewer disputes
    The MOST comprehensive aviation service management solution available:
        5HVRXUFHRSWLPLVDWLRQLQFOXGLQJSHRSOHVNLOOVÁHHWDQGHTXLSPHQW
         Complete service capture leading to accurate billing and fewer disputes
        0RELOLVHJURXQGFUHZV LQFUHDVHHIÀFLHQF\ZLWKSRZHUIXOLQWXLWLYHPRELOHVROXWLRQV
        5HVRXUFHRSWLPLVDWLRQLQFOXGLQJSHRSOHVNLOOVÁHHWDQGHTXLSPHQW
        7RWDOFRQWURORIKLJKYROXPHWLPHFULWLFDOWDVNVIRUWLPHO\WXUQDURXQGV
        0RELOLVHJURXQGFUHZV LQFUHDVHHIÀFLHQF\ZLWKSRZHUIXOLQWXLWLYHPRELOHVROXWLRQV
        $QHDV\WRXVHFRVWHIIHFWLYHFORXGEDVHGVROXWLRQ
        7RWDOFRQWURORIKLJKYROXPHWLPHFULWLFDOWDVNVIRUWLPHO\WXUQDURXQGV
      $QHDV\WRXVHFRVWHIIHFWLYHFORXGEDVHGVROXWLRQ
      7RWDOFRQWURORIKLJKYROXPHWLPHFULWLFDOWDVNVIRUWLPHO\WXUQDURXQGV
    Contact     the Zafire team today:
        $QHDV\WRXVHFRVWHIIHFWLYHFORXGEDVHGVROXWLRQ
     T   +44 (0) 1295 701 810                  E   DYLDWLRQ#]DÀUHFRP         Find us on                    2UVFDQKHUH

    Contact the Zafire team today:
    www.zafire.com/aviation
     T   +44 (0) 1295 701 810
Advert 215X275.indd 1
                                               E   DYLDWLRQ#]DÀUHFRP         Find us on                    2UVFDQKHUH
                                                                                                                 28/01/2014 15:21:23

    www.zafire.com/aviation
FEATURE | ROUTE DEVELOPMENT

Æ
nine new routes in the winter season            route at the end of the winter flight         ers are Bordeaux, Porto, Stavanger and
from Paris-Orly to Istanbul, Tel Aviv,          schedule in 2015.                            Liverpool – the latter marking the first
Budapest, Madrid, Malaga, Barcelona,                 Despite the grim headlines, Ukraine     time the airline has served the UK since
Athens, Pisa and Prague and there is            remains an important market for Aus-         withdrawing five years ago. Czech Air-
also a new service from Lyon to Tel Aviv.       trian, insists chief commercial officer       lines has already announced other new
                                                Andreas Otto. “Ukraine continues to be       routes in the Autumn including Bilbao,
GEOPOLITICAL FACTORS                            one of the most important markets for        Billund, Bologna, Cork and Oslo.
Politics and economics also continue            Austrian Airlines in Eastern Europe, not         Meanwhile Greek carriers, frustrat-
to shape the world’s air networks.              to mention the fact that most of these       ed by the lack of opportunity at home,
Occasionally, routes are curtailed or           passengers transfer to other flights in       are looking beyond their home territory
altered as a result of direct government        our network to destinations in Western       for new opportunities. Start-up carrier
intervention – for instance, Etihad             Europe, the Middle East or on North At-      SkyGreece Airlines is starting a twice-
suspended all flights to Baghdad until           lantic routes. Although the crisis has led   weekly service between Budapest and
further notice in late January to comply        to weakened demand over the past year,       Toronto from 21 May. This will comple-
with the UAE General Civil Aviation             we continue to see considerable poten-       ment Air Transat’s weekly service be-
Authority ban on operation to and from          tial in this market.”                        tween the two cities set to begin later in
Baghdad on security grounds. Emirates                This isn’t the carrier’s only (per-     the summer.
also suspended its services to Baghdad          haps apparently) unlikely destination.
                                                                                             ROOM TO GROW
                                                                                             There is still plenty of growth potential
                                                                                             in Asia and Africa and it is these regions
                                                                                             of the world that have seen some of
                                                                                             the most active route development
                                                                                             lately. Singapore Airlines has a network
                                                                                             planning team that looks after its new
                                                                                             routes, with decisions made based on
                                                                                             market assessment with a strategic and
                                                                                             long-term view and affected by factors
                                                                                             such as air traffic, routing rights and
                                                                                             airport capacity.
                                                                                                  For example, Asia is a fast-grow-
                                                                                             ing market and this is reflected in the
                                                                                             changes to its network in recent years.
                                                                                             The carrier increased the frequency of
                                                                                             flights to Tokyo Haneda to 21 times
                                                                                             a week in March 2014, compared
                                                                                             with the previous 14 times a week. Its
                                                                                             wholly-owned subsidiary SilkAir also
                                                                                             launched daily services to Denpasar,
                                                                                             Bali’s capital, in December 2014 and
  Another new service to Athens comes from CSA Czech Airlines, one of                        will launch services to Cairns in Aus-
   a clutch of five additional European destinations for its 2015 summer                     tralia in May 2015.
 schedule, in addition to another five which were announced last autumn                           But it also suspended flights to Ri-
                                                                                             yadh and Cairo in September 2014 as
due to “operational” reasons, along with        In response to growing demand, it ex-        a result of the sustained weak perfor-
those to Peshawar in Pakistan. Flights to       panded its flights to the Moldavian capi-     mance of both routes.
Sana’a in Yemen have been halted due to         tal, Chisinau, from seven to 10 flights per        Singapore is proving another mag-
increased security concerns.                    week in November 2014.                       net for foreign carriers. Qatar Airways
     More usually, though, political trou-           Austrian Airlines’ route network is     announced in early February that it
bles lead to a fall-off in demand and it        particularly dense in Central and East-      would launch an additional daily flight
is this that prompts the carriers to cut        ern Europe, with 39 destinations. The        there, in addition to its existing twice-
back or curtail services. Reflecting the         carrier sees its hub at Vienna Interna-      daily service. All services will be operat-
troubles in Russia and its neighbours,          tional Airport as a gateway between East     ed by its new A350 XWB aircraft, now
easyJet initially cut its London/Mos-           and West.                                    coming into service with the Middle
cow services from 13 to 11 a week from 1             And another place it is willing to go   Eastern carrier.
February, eventually decreasing to once         where many others still fear to tread is          As might be expected, Asia/Africa
daily from 29 March.                            Athens. From 20 April it will offer four     routes, linking two of the more dynamic
     But other carriers managed to in-          additional night flights per week from        areas of the world, have seen some activ-
crease their services to this part of the       Vienna, bringing the total to 11 services    ity. China Southern is to launch a thrice-
world. Austrian Airlines actually added         a week on this route.                        weekly service between Guangzhou and
a new destination in Ukraine, flying to               Another new service to Athens           Nairobi from 5 August using A330-200
Odessa from 30 March, although the              comes from CSA Czech Airlines, one           aircraft. Air China will meanwhile take
explanation is that Austrian Airlines           of a clutch of five additional European       over the Beijing – Johannesburg route
still has a codeshare on flights from and        destinations for its 2015 summer sched-      in June from South African Airways af-
to Odessa with Ukraine International,           ule, in addition to another five which        ter a two-and-a-half-month suspension.
which is terminating its service on this        were announced last autumn. The oth-         It will operate three times weekly using

10 Airline Ground Services Summer/Autumn 2015                                                          www.ags-airlinegroundservices.com
FEATURE | ROUTE DEVELOPMENT

a Boeing 777-300. Ethiopian Airlines,                                                        domestic and global network. Recent
however, has shelved its planned ser-                                                        initiatives include restructuring its Pa-
vice resumption to Singapore, due on 2                                                       cific entity to favour long-haul service,
April. It had planned to operate three                                                       upgrading the short-haul network, and
times a week to Addis Ababa with a Boe-                                                      rebanking several hubs. United has a
ing 787-8.                                                                                   suite of industry-standard network
    Qatar Airways is also planning a ma-                                                     planning and aircraft scheduling tools
jor expansion of its South African servic-                                                   that are tailored to its specific needs.
es with the launch of flights to Durban                                                           Recently launched or announced
in December and an increase in frequen-                                                      year-round long-haul routes include
cies to Johannesburg. There will be four                                                     San Francisco-Taiwan, San Francisco-
new weekly flights to Durban via Johan-                                                       Chengdu, Los Angeles-Melbourne,
nesburg bringing the total frequency to                                                      Houston-Santiago (Chile) – plus season-
Johannesburg up from 10 weekly flights                                                        al services connecting Newark-Venice,
to double-daily. From 1 October, Qatar                                                       Newark-Newcastle, Chicago-Rome and
Airways will also up its services to Cape                                                    Chicago-Dublin.
Town from five times a week to daily. All                                                         Nowadays, most airlines employ so-
three routes will be operated with a Boe-                                                    phisticated market analysis techniques
ing 787 Dreamliner.                                                                          to try and gauge demand for new routes
    It has also announced a clutch of                                                        before launch. There is, though, still
new services to Pakistan – starting in                                                       scope for a more direct approach. De-
July-August to fly four times weekly to           rier can liven things up a bit. Branson     veloping services from small regional
Sialkot, where it already operates dedi-         AirExpress has introduced a clutch of       airports can be a hit-and-miss affair but
cated freighter services three times a           new routes including services to Cincin-    pharmaceutical firm AstraZeneca has
week. This will be its first new passen-          nati, New Orleans, Orlando Sanford and      provided seat guarantees to get a new
ger route to Pakistan since 2004. From           Cancun served three times a week each,      scheduled air link between Cambridge
1 August 2015, it will offer three flights a      with an Orange Air MD83 aircraft oper-      International Airport in the UK and
week to Multan.                                  ating on an Orlando Sanford – Cancun        Sweden’s Gothenburg Landvetter off
    In more mature markets, like North           – New Orleans – Branson – Cincinnati        the ground, operated by Scandinavian
America, it is more a matter of adjust-          and vice-versa circuit.                     regional carrier Sun-Air. Sun-Air will
ment and infilling than major develop-                In the US, United Airlines says it      operate the route from the end of March
ment, though the occasionally new car-           continues to maintain and grow its          this year.

      /Ground Services
         Powered by AeroGround, aerogate and Cargogate

         Living ideas – Connecting lives

         Your experts in Ground Handling: We are ground handling professionals. With
         our many years of experience we ensure safe and punctual handling operations
         - regardless of the aircraft type or the customer’s business model.

                                                                                                        Visit our Website
                                                                                                        to find out more
                                                                                                        about our Ground
                                                                                                        Services:

www.ags-airlinegroundservices.com                                                           Summer/Autumn 2015 Airline Ground Services 11
FEATURE | HANDLERS

HANDLERS START
TO GET IT TOGETHER
The airline handling industry is showing strong merger and acquisition activity as companies
strive to offer their customers a truly global service

O
              nce highly fragmented,                                                      The December 2011 proposal would
              and in many respects                                                        have required airports to allow a larger
              one of the hidden sec-                                                      number of providers to offer services
              tors of aviation, the air-                                                  such as cargo and baggage handling.
              port ground handling                                                        While the plan had the support of
industry has started to coalesce in                                                       airlines, the European Parliament
the last few years. A recent report by                                                    was very lukewarm and considerably
the CAPA Centre for Aviation sug-                                                         watered down the text which, moreover,
gests that globally it could be worth                                                     now applied only to a handful of major
US$80-100bn, which would make                                                             airports handling over 15 million
it a sizeable chunk of the estimated                                                      passengers a year.
US$700bn world aviation industry                                                              On the other hand, mergers and
as a whole. It would also appear to be                                                    acquisitions have swallowed up some
a growing sector. Not only is ground                                                      players. Ground handling was in many
handling benefiting from the general                                                      respects quite a fragmented, localised
global increase in flying, but it’s also                                                  industry, with many small or family-
an activity that many of the world’s                                                      owned players competing with the big
airlines are increasingly outsourc-                                                       international groups. Now the latter
ing – particularly outside their home                                                     have started to acquire the former, al-
markets, though in some cases even in                                                     though there is still plenty of scope for
their home countries.                                                                     more M&A activity. And there has also
    Lately, the industry has been pulled        Olivier Bijaoui, executive chairman,      been one major merger at the top lev-
                                                president and chief executive, WFS
in a number of directions. On the one                                                     el with the sale of UK-headquartered
hand there has been an increase in the          each other. Some airports that were       Servisair to Swissport in December
level of competition in many airports           previously monopolies have become         2013 to create the world’s largest han-
as governments – notably the Euro-              competitive free-for-alls.                dling company. The industry hasn’t yet
pean Union (EU) – have opened up                    However, the European Commission      quite reached the point where there are
hitherto closed handling markets to             (EC) has since drawn in its horns,        very large, globally spread companies
competition; the EU now insists that            withdrawing on 17 December a proposed     able to handle airlines in any corner of
airports above a certain size have at           directive to further liberalise ground    the world, but it is a goal that many of
least two handlers in competition with          handling services at European airports.   the larger firms are working towards
                                                                                          through a combination of acquisi-
                                                                                          tion and organic growth. Swissport is
                                                                                          currently the nearest to a global han-
                                                                                          dler, with 260 stations in 45 countries
                                                                                          around the world.
                                                                                              Other countries in other parts of
                                                                                          the world have watched the EU liber-
                                                                                          alisation process with interest. There is
                                                                                          a feeling that, in some markets at least,
                                                                                          the EU went too far too fast and the
                                                                                          number of competing handlers in some
                                                                                          airports has become unsustainable.
                                                                                          There is evidence that Brussels is having
                                                                                          second thoughts on forcing airports too
                                                                                          quickly towards liberalisation and it has
                                                                                          since introduced a ‘social’ dimension to
                                                                                          the process.
                                                                                              There is evidence, too, that many
                                                                                          ground handlers are becoming increas-
                                                                                          ingly dissatisfied with the low margins
                                                                                          available in many instances.

12 Airline Ground Services Summer/Autumn 2015                                                      www.ags-airlinegroundservices.com
FEATURE | HANDLERS

WFS CHIEF IS OPTIMISTIC
Olivier Bijaoui, executive chairman, president and chief
executive at global handler WFS, is confident that the
market will see at least some growth in 2015. “Last year,
2014, was much better than 2013, when we saw some nice
growth,” he told AGS in an interview. “Confidence is there.”
The UK and Northern Europe in particular saw good
growth, as did cargo handling, which accounts for 60% of
WFS’s global business.
     Bijaoui also predicts that the rest of Europe – including
recession-hit Spain and Italy – will get back on track. Busi-
ness in WFS’s home country, France, is also progressing nice-
ly especially with new contracts from the Air France-KLM
group’s Transavia subsidiary in Paris.
     Globally, WFS is following the trend of buying up local
players. In October last year, for instance, it acquired Brazil’s
Orbital, “a well-run, family-owned company”, which gives
WFS an entry into 19 airports in the country. Bijaoui sees
South America as particularly fertile ground, along with Af-
rica, where the handler has started out on a contract man-
agement basis in Tanzania and Kenya but is looking for more
business there, as well as in South Africa.
     In the Middle East, WFS recently opened a VIP passen-
ger terminal in Amman in partnership with Royal Jordanian.
     Asia – specifically, Thailand, Singapore and Hong Kong
– is also a good market but in the latter WFS has gone in an
interesting new direction, having become the manager of the
new Hong Kong Cruise Terminal in a joint venture with Roy-
al Caribbean. This might seem surprising for an airline han-
dler but, as Bijaoui points out: “There are a lot of similarities,
particularly in areas such as check-in and baggage handling
– it’s just that the numbers, in terms of the passengers on any
one arrival or departure, are much bigger.”
     WFS’s involvement in the Hong Kong cruise market was
partly a response to limited opportunities in the local airline
industry, but Bijaoui would welcome the chance to set up
other cruise (or ferry) related businesses in other parts of
the world. “When you first do something like this, you cre-
ate credentials. The difficult stage is getting into the market.”
     Even in its airline handling, WFS takes a different ap-
proach compared with some of its competitors, Bijaoui
believes. “For example, we can check bags in for passengers
going to the airport on the Mass Transit Railway.”
     He sees the process of takeover and consolidation in the
airline handling industry continuing. “I think we, for instance,

www.ags-airlinegroundservices.com                                    Summer/Autumn 2015 Airline Ground Services 13
FEATURE | HANDLERS

                                                                                             certainly consider opportunities in Ger-
                                                                                             many and elsewhere.
                                                                                                 “It’s hard to say what the right bal-
                                                                                             ance is, but personally, I think it is better
                                                                                             if there are some limits on the number
                                                                                             of players.” He points out that handling
                                                                                             companies have to make often large in-
                                                                                             vestments in very specialised ground
                                                                                             support equipment and it takes time to
                                                                                             get a return on capital invested.

                                                                                             COMPETITIVE PRESSURES INCREASE
                                                                                             IN GERMANY
                                                                                             The     three     affiliated   companies,
                                                                                             AeroGround, Aerogate and Cargogate,
                                                                                             say they maintained their position
                                                                                             as the only full-service provider at
                                                                                             Munich Airport in 2014. Nevertheless,
                                                                                             the competitive environment for
                                                                                             AeroGround “will continue to be
                                                                                             challenging and exciting in the future,”
are getting to the point where the global           However, he does see some govern-        they predict – mainly because of the
offering to airlines is there. And the air-     ments drawing back from allowing the         competitive pressure on German
lines are starting to outsource – even          total free-for-all competition that has      aviation companies in particular (for
their hub operations in some cases              occurred in some markets such as Italy,      example through civil aviation tax) and
– because they can see that they have           where life has become unsustainable          the resultant cuts which have a great
partners like us who are able to employ         for handlers at many airports. Ironi-        influence on price competition for
massive numbers of staff, as we do in           cally, it is countries where monopolies      ground handling services.
Paris, for example.” Airlines are taking        were tolerated but then thrown open              Both low-cost and network carriers
a back-to-basics approach in which they         to competition that have suffered the        are putting high cost pressure on ground
concentrate on what they really do best –       most, whereas the UK and northern            handling companies, while at the same
flying planes – and nothing is sacrosanct        Europe, where competition has always         time the requirements on quality and
– even home hub handling operations.            been allowed and has evolved over            on-time-performance are continuously
    There are also quite a few family-          time, are the most mature markets,           rising. Success depends on ensuring a
owned handlers in many parts of the             in his opinion. “WFS has stayed away         high flexibility in response to constantly
world, Bijaoui considers. “Yes, in Eu-          from a number of markets, because of         changing market needs; continuous, ef-
rope, it’s beginning to consolidate, in the     the sheer amount of competition.” That       ficient cost control; and improvement
USA possibly a bit more, but even there,        said, it will be bidding for opportunities   and adaptation of processes and services
there are opportunities.”                       at all 42 Spanish airports and would         according to customer needs.

Cargo handling accounts for 60%
of WFS’s global business

14 Airline Ground Services Summer/Autumn 2015                                                          www.ags-airlinegroundservices.com
Aviation - The ISS Way

Service performance that facilitates our customers’
purpose through people empowerment

To ISS this means we care for your aircraft and airport facility
as if it were our own. This is why we continuously aim for
improved service performance that facilitates your purpose
through greater people empowerment.
When we enter into a new relationship, we make a big
effort to understand your culture, the airport facility and the
needs of the passengers, staff and visitors passing through.
By doing so, we are able to develop a service solution
customized to meet their requirements and align the training
and support of our employees to make a difference in your
organization.
Because, in the end, we want our people to take care of
your people, your passengers, and your facilities – so you
can focus on what you do best.

www.at.issworld.com/aviation
FEATURE | HANDLERS

                                                                                                  As for the LCCs, there is no longer
                                                                                              a homogeneous model, Angus believes,
                                                                                              with different new-generation airlines
                                                                                              carving their own product point in the
                                                                                              market as they evolve. A growing num-
                                                                                              ber of new-generation airlines recognise
                                                                                              service differentiation is an important
                                                                                              tool to maximise yield.
                                                                                                  Crucially, for a short-haul airline op-
                                                                                              erating an 80-minute sector, product dif-
                                                                                              ferentiation on the ground is as impor-
                                                                                              tant as in the air. This creates a growing
                                                                                              scope for handlers to genuinely add value
                                                                                              to new-generation airlines, rather than
                                                                                              simply being a commoditised supplier.
                                                                                                  Angus concludes: “We have been told
                                                                                              by several observers our cargo complex at
                                                                                              Heathrow dnata City is the most technol-
                                                                                              ogy-enabled airport cargo facility in the
                                                                                              world. We are also working on several

Æ
                                                                                              projects to use mobile technology to im-
    Despite this, AeroGround Flughafen          handlers to grow their business in part-      prove efficiency and reduce turnaround
München sees further growth opportu-            nership with the network carriers.”           times. As a company, we recognise the
nities in the satellite extension project           But he adds a word of caution:            important role technology plays in our
at Terminal 2. Physical completion              “There are several examples recently          operations and work to be ahead of the
of the scheme, which will give 27 ad-           where outsourcing has gone wrong, with        industry standard, rather
ditional aircraft parking positions, is         significant reputational damage to the         than catching up to
scheduled for end of 2015 and prom-             airlines involved. This does not mean         our competitors.”
ises extra ground handling volume for           the outsourcing model is flawed, rather
the airport’s own ground handling op-           a reflection that their hub handling is
erators. In 2014, AeroGround extend-            a vital element of their product and
ed its strategic focus on off-campus ac-        brand. Airlines need to think carefully
tivities and signed a strategic alliance        about whether their chosen handler is          Stewart Angus,
agreement with the Greek Goldair                deploying sufficient resources to ensure        divisional senior
                                                                                               vice president,
Handling and AAS Airline Assistance             safety and on-time performance.”               international airport
Switzerland under the name of ground.               Angus predicts that it is likely that      operations, dnata
net. The agreement covers close co-op-          several companies will change hands
eration in marketing and sales at the           in the next few years and acquisition
airports that all three ground handlers         of smaller handlers is also probable.
currently operate.                              He says: “The ground handling market
    According to AeroGround, “the               seems to be following the same path as
added value for our customers is repre-         the in-flight catering industry during
sented by simplified administrative pro-         the past decade, which left two main
cedures, a centralised key contact man-         players through consolidation. I don’t
agement and the comprehensive use of            think the ground handling market will
operational know-how for innovation             necessarily follow the same ‘two-player’
and cost reduction.” With the creation of       model, but I believe we are in for a pe-
a European ground handling network of           riod of significant consolidation.”
local and regional experts, it is planned           But as for new players enter-
to add further members in 2015.                 ing the market, “if you look at the
                                                margins of the ground handlers,
DNATA – OUTSOURCING IS VIABLE                   it is difficult to imagine anyone
BUT TAKE CARE                                   would want to enter this market – if
At Middle East-owned global group               anything, as noted above, we are more
dnata, divisional senior vice president,        likely to see consolidation,” he considers.
international airport operations Stewart            Dnata has targeted growth in the
Angus sees “a definite trend by major            Middle East and Asia Pacific – its home
carriers to outsource their hub handling.       regions, which are displaying strong
The low-cost carriers (LCCs) have               growth. In mature markets such as
always worked to this model, but there is       Europe and North America, the tide is
a growing realisation amongst the major         turning. “We sense a mood change from
network carriers that they are carrying         many in the airline community who
legacy costs in an area that is not their       have suffered the consequences of de-
core expertise – an investment which            teriorating handling service for several
could be better deployed elsewhere.”            years, including flight delays, aircraft
    So: “There is real scope for the major      damage and poor passenger perception.”

16 Airline Ground Services Summer/Autumn 2015                                                           www.ags-airlinegroundservices.com
A better tomorrow
   begins today

  We won’t just turn around your aircraft
We will turn around how you feel about cargo,
        passenger and ramp handling.
           To find out about how we can help you
    call: +1 303 376 6908 or email: pweir@casusa.com

            Consolidated Aviation Services
                    www.casusa.com
                 Lets do something better
FEATURE | INSURANCE

GROUND DAMAGE
 – WHO PAYS?
                                            I
Simon Abbott, underwriting                             was fortunate enough to speak      destroyed as it dramatically jumps its
executive for worldwide                                last year at the Preventing Air-   chocks. Aircraft are expensive assets
                                                       craft Damage (PAD) conference      and damage to them by a vehicle on
aviation insurance provider                            in Dublin, about the contribu-     the ground can be substantial. In ad-
Global Aerospace, looks                                tion aviation insurance makes      dition, the increasing complexity of
                                                towards the huge costs incurred by        modern aircraft with features such
at who bears the cost of
                                                the aviation industry in respect of       as composite fuselages means repairs
ground damage to aircraft                       damage to aircraft on the ground. In      can be expensive. A direct result of
                                                this article I hope to expand more on     the aircraft being AOG (aircraft on
                                                this subject to clear up the misconcep-   ground) is the business interruption
                                                tion that the aviation insurance mar-     costs which is a whole new ball game,
                                                ket picks up the bill. Nothing could be   and can be very subjective. These can
                                                further from the truth.                   be costs incurred by the airline due
                                                    Firstly, I think it would be help-    to disruptions to the schedule, repo-
                                                ful to understand how big a problem       sitioning of aircraft and crews, re-
                                                ground damage to aircraft actually        placement aircraft, compensation to
                                                is. Of course ground damage can be        passengers – to say nothing of more
                                                anything from ‘hangar rash’ – dam-        unquantifiable ramifications, such as
                                                age caused to an aircraft while it is     reputational impact on the airline.
                                                towed out of the hangar – to colli-           In 2007, the International Air
                                                sions between aircraft or even engine     Transport Association (IATA) esti-
                                                run-ups, leading to the aircraft being    mated that ground damage is running

18 Airline Ground Services Summer/Autumn 2015                                                      www.ags-airlinegroundservices.com
FEATURE | INSURANCE

at US$4 billion a year and the Flight                                                     FSF with its Ground Accident Preven-
Safety Foundation (FSF) estimate                                                          tion programme and IATA with ISA-
in 2006 was US$7 billion a year. In            Aircraft are expensive assets              GO (IATA Safety Audit for Ground
2002 the National Business Aviation               and damage to them by                   Operations). Part of the ISAGO audit
Association (NBAA) estimated that                 a vehicle on the ground                 is a requirement for SMS (Safety Man-
for business aircraft in North Ameri-                can be substantial                   agement System) to be implemented
ca, annual ground damage costs were                                                       by the GSP. SMS has been a game
running at around US$100 million a                                                        changer for the airline and airport in-
year; and finally, at PAD in Dublin last                                                  dustries but the point here is that it
year, numbers were cited at US$7 bil-       covers the deductible. The point, how-        has been a regulatory requirement, so
lion. The reality is it’s anybody’s guess   ever, is that the cover is only available     it’s mandatory and applies to all.
and nobody actually knows. What is          for property damage and not for busi-              There is, of course, another angle
clear is that it has a massive effect       ness interruption or consequential            here. Profit margins in the ground
on the bottom line for airlines and         losses. So if the property all risks cov-     handling industry are low, and typi-
to some extent ground handlers. As          er is not triggered (that is, the damage      cally GSP personnel are poorly moti-
mentioned these unaccounted costs           is below the deductible amount), then         vated with a high turnaround of staff
are growing, due to a number of fac-        any subsequent business interruption          who are operating around some very
tors such as increasing cost to repair      is not covered.                               expensive real estate. SMS would help
aircraft, the frequency of these losses         Based on the various industry es-         raise the minimum safety standards
due to congestion on the ramp and           timates, if we took a figure of US$5.5        of the GSPs but the implementation
claims inflation which we estimate for      billion as an average of the annual           of SMS and its continued certification
property damage runs at 2% a year.          cost arising from ground damage,              is costly.
Using the 2% claims inflation takes         how much of this is covered by insur-              Ground damage is a major issue.
FSF’s estimate to just shy of USD8.4        ers? Taking into account GSPs’ own            The majority of the losses fall onto the
billion in 2015.                            insurance coverage and airlines’ hull         airline’s balance sheet, an extraordinary
    Some of this cost is contractually      and liability cover, then I estimate          item they can ill afford. Regulators need
picked up by the ground service pro-        that aviation insurers only pick up           to step in, as they have done with the air-
viders (GSPs) themselves. According         about 15% of the annual cost. Some            lines and airports, in requiring the im-
to IATA’s standard ground handling          airlines do purchase consequential            plementation of SMS by GSPs to enforce
agreement, GSPs are liable up to            loss cover from insurers; however this        a minimum universal standard of safety
US$1,500,000 for physical damage            is typically subject to a deductible of       on the ramp, thereby putting the GSPs
– but that does not cover consequen-        say 15 to 30 days, with a maximum             on the same footing as the airlines and
tial losses unless the GSP intended         payout per day and with an aggre-             the airports.
the damage or was deemed reckless.          gate cap per policy year. Now insurers
But, how many contracts are standard        could pick up all of the shortfall via
IATA contracts? And which standard          consequential loss cover to provide
IATA contract is being used, as there       insurance up to the US$5.5 billion
have been a number of revisions over        but the airlines would then
the years? What is clear is that some       be faced with an insurance
of the cost is defrayed by the GSPs.        bill of some 400% of what
    So what about the amounts in-           they are paying today! In-
curred over and above the GSP’s             surance is not the solution.
amount or where contractually the               There are several worthy
amount paid by the GSP is differ-           industry initiatives such as
ent? Aviation insurers provide ‘hull
all risk’ cover to the airlines, which
covers property damage to the hull of       Abbott: “Regulators need to
the aircraft arising from an accident.      step in, as they have done
The cover is broad, as the term ‘hull       with the airlines and airports
                                            ... to enforce a minimum
all risk’ suggests, subject to some fair-   universal standard of safety
ly standard exclusions such as war/         on the ramp”
terrorism or pollution. The cover is
subject to deductibles which vary de-
pending on the size of the aircraft, so
a narrowbody carries a deductible of
US$500,000, a hybrid US$750,000
and a widebody US$1,000,000. In
other words in the event of partial
damage to the aircraft, insurers will
only pay repair costs over and above
the deductible unless the aircraft is a
total loss, in which case no deductible
applies. Without wishing to get into
too much detail a specific deductible
insurance is purchased by a number of
carriers which, as the name suggests,

www.ags-airlinegroundservices.com                                                       Summer/Autumn 2015 Airline Ground Services 19
You can also read