AN ENIGMATIC GIANT GEOSCIENCE DIPLOMACY IN NORTH KOREA - GEOSCIENTIST

Page created by Roberta Adkins
 
CONTINUE READING
AN ENIGMATIC GIANT GEOSCIENCE DIPLOMACY IN NORTH KOREA - GEOSCIENTIST
T H E   M A G A Z I N E   O F   T H E    G E O L O G I C A L    S O C I E T Y   O F      L O N D O N

                                                                           SPRING 2021

  AN ENIGMATIC GIANT
  GEOSCIENCE DIPLOMACY IN NORTH KOREA

TAKING THE                  BLACK IN                    DECOLONISING                  ALL THAT
NEXT STEP                   GEOSCIENCE                  COLLECTIONS                   GLITTERS
The pros and cons of        Initiatives to              Historical links              Tales of fortunes
post-doctoral research      confront invisibility       assessed                      made and lost
AN ENIGMATIC GIANT GEOSCIENCE DIPLOMACY IN NORTH KOREA - GEOSCIENTIST
AN ENIGMATIC GIANT GEOSCIENCE DIPLOMACY IN NORTH KOREA - GEOSCIENTIST
Editor’s welcome
SPRING 2021

                                                                    W
                                                                                  elcome to the                            linked to our science
                                                                                  first edition                            features.
The magazine of the Geological Society of London                                  of the                                      We appreciate that
                                                                    new-look, quarterly                                    some readers are
The Geological Society              Trustees of the Geological      Geoscientist magazine.                                 disappointed to lose the
Burlington House                    Society of London               We’ve had great fun                                    monthly print issues and
Piccadilly                          2020-2021                       putting the issue                                      question whether they’ll
London W1J 0BG                      Dr Michael Daly (President)     together, working                                      engage as much digitally
T +44 (0)20 7434 9944               Mrs Joanna Alexander            with our new publishers, James            (p. 19). This was a difficult decision
enquiries@geolsoc.org.uk            Mr Thomas Backhouse             Pembroke Media, and we hope you           for us to make and was, of course,
(Not for Editorial – Please         Mr Andrew Bloodworth            find it stimulating and entertaining.     partly motivated by the need to
contact the Editor)                 Mr John Booth (Vice                This issue takes us from volcanic      make financial savings. Likewise,
                                    President)                      peaks in enigmatic North Korea            tough choices have had to be
Publishing House                    Dr Jennie Gilbert               (p. 22), to the Californian and           made across the Society as we
The Geological Society              Dr Joel Gill (Secretary,        Australian gold rushes of the 19th        face a period of considerable
Publishing House                    Foreign & External Affairs)     Century (p. 40). It also touches          uncertainty (p. 6).
Unit 7                              Mr Graham Goffey (Treasurer)    on the critical issues of diversity,         But there are also positive motives
Brassmill Enterprise Centre         Dr Kathryn Goodenough           equality and inclusion, with reports      behind the change. Many of you
Brassmill Lane                      Prof James Griffiths            and opinion pieces that highlight         have written to us with questions
Bath BA1 3JN                        (Secretary, Professional        the immense and persistent                about the sustainability of print, and
T +44 (0)1225 445046                Matters)                        barriers faced by many, including         some have chosen to opt out of print
E sales@geolsoc.org.uk              Dr Michael Kehinde              Black (p. 30) and LBGTQ+ (p. 16)          entirely, in favour of a digital offering.
                                    Prof Chris King                 geoscientists, as well as outlining       We want to communicate afresh
Library                             Mr Andrew Moore                 the actions we can all take to help       in print and digitally and, in doing
T +44 (0)20 7432 0999               Prof Bryne Ngwenya              remove these barriers and make            so, retire our outdated and poorly
E library@geolsoc.org.uk            Dr John Perry                   our community more inclusive.             functioning website, which was
                                    Mr Nicholas Reynolds (Vice                                                unloved and rarely used.
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF:                    President)                                                                   At a time when both Fellowship
Prof. Andy Fleet                    Mrs Sarah Scott                                                           and geoscience student numbers
DEPUTY EDITOR-IN-CHIEF:             Ms Gemma Sherwood                  Geoscientist                           are in decline, it is essential to widen
Mr David Shilston                   Miss Jessica Smith              magazine will                             our reach, and we truly believe
EDITORS:                            (Vice President)                continue to serve                         that by focusing our efforts on
Dr Amy Whitchurch                   Dr Helen Smyth                                                            both print and digital, we can place
Ms Sarah Day                        Prof Robin Strachan
                                                                    as a welcoming and
                                                                                                              Geoscientist magazine – a showcase
E geoscientist@geolsoc.org.uk       (Secretary, Publications)       inclusive forum                           for the activities of the Society and
                                    Dr Alexander Whittaker                                                    of geoscientists – into more hands.
EDITORIAL ADVISORY                  (Secretary, Science)                                                      Those readers may be people who
PANEL                               Mrs Lucy Williams                  It is no secret that diversity is an   have not found us before, those
Mrs Natalyn Ala                     Dr Keith Myers (co-opted        issue both within the geoscience          who perceive the Society as elitist
Mr Steve Branch                     – Treasurer designate)          community and in our Society.             and outdated, or those who view the
Dr Robin Cocks                                                      Change is slow, but the Society           field of geoscience as simply dirty
Dr Howard Falcon-Lang               The Geological Society          is taking steps to rectify this. For      and polluting, rather than a key part
Dr Hazel Gibson                     of London is a Registered       example, Council recently asked           of the journey towards net zero.
Prof. Tony Harris                   Charity, number 210161.         for an evaluation of the Society’s           We hope that by providing a range
Mr Edmund Nickless                  ISSN (print) 0961-5628          historical links to slavery and           of options for accessing content, we
Dr Alan Roberts                     ISSN (online) 2045-1784         colonialism, and our Archivist,           will reach a more diverse audience,
Prof. Peter Styles                                                  Caroline Lam, reports the findings        and that Geoscientist magazine will
Dr Colin Summerhayes                Subscriptions: for non-         on page 36. The research will be          continue to serve as a welcoming
Prof. Frances Wall                  member subscriptions, please    used to determine Society policies        and inclusive forum for both long-
Dr Jan Zalasiewicz                  contact the Publishing House.   and we will ensure that updates are       term and new readers.
                                                                    provided in the future.                      Our new print and online offerings
Cover image: Chonji (Heaven Lake) on the summit of Mount Paektu        All of the articles in this issue      are works in progress, and we would
                                                                    are available online, via our newly       love to hear your thoughts and
Geoscientist is published four times per year on behalf of          launched and mobile-device                suggestions – you can get in touch
The Geological Society of London by                                 friendly website www.Geoscientist.        with us at geoscientist@geolsoc.org.
www.jamespembrokemedia.co.uk                                        Online. The site features additional      uk or via Twitter @geoscientistmag.
                                                                    content, including more in-depth
© 2021 The Geological Society of London                             reports and letters, as well as videos    AMY WHITCHURCH, EDITOR

                                                                                                              GEOSCIENTIST.ONLINE | SPRING 2021       3
AN ENIGMATIC GIANT GEOSCIENCE DIPLOMACY IN NORTH KOREA - GEOSCIENTIST
AN ENIGMATIC GIANT GEOSCIENCE DIPLOMACY IN NORTH KOREA - GEOSCIENTIST
CONTENTS
VOL . 31       |    NO. 01          |    SPRING 2021

 12                                                           30                                                   3                                                         UNEARTHED

                                                                                                                   EDITOR’S WELCOME
                                                                                                                                                                        42
                                                                                                                                                                        LIFE AFTER PHD
                                                                                                                   6                                                    The pros and cons of
                                                                                                                                                                        post-doctoral research
                                                                                                                   NEWS
                                                                                                                   Updates from the Society
                                                                                                                   and the community
                                                                                                                                                                          40
                                                                                                                   16
                                                                                                                   VIEWPOINT
                                                                                                                   Safe and inclusive fieldwork,
                                                                                                                   Reverse the decline, Black

                                                                                      36                           underrepresentation in the
                                                                                                                   minerals industry, Quarterly
                                                                                                                   dismay and more…

                                                                                                                      F E AT U R E S

                                                                                                                   22
                                                                                                                   WHERE SCIENCE
                                                                                                                   AND DIPLOMACY MEET
                                                                                                                   A unique collaboration provides                      45
                                                                                                                                                                        BOOKS & ARTS
                                                                                                                   insights into Mount Paektu
                                                                                                                                                                        Latest recommendations
                                                                                                                                                                        from Fellows
                                                                                                                   30
                                                                                                                   WHERE ARE THE BL ACK
                                                                                                                   GEOSCIENTISTS?                                       48
                                                                                                                   Grassroots initiatives to                            O B I T UA R I E S
                                                                                                                   confront invisibility                                Norman John Snelling
                                                                                                                                                                        Peter George Fookes

                                                                                                                   36                                                   50
                                                                                                                   DECOLONISING THE
                                                                                                                   GEOLOGICAL SOCIET Y’S                                COUNCIL ELECTIONS
                                                                                                                   COLLECTIONS                                          All the information you need
                                                                                                                   Assessing the Geological                             for the upcoming elections
                                                                                                                   Society’s historical links
                                                                                                                   to slavery and colonialism
                                                                                                                                                                        54
                                                                                                                                                                        FIVE MINUTES WITH….
                                                                                                                   40                                                   Kathryn Goodenough,
                                                                                                                                                                        Principal Geologist with the
                                                                                                                   A L L T H AT G L I T T E R S
                                                                                                                   Tales of fortunes made and lost                      BGS and Chief Editor of ES3

  The Geological Society of London accepts no responsibility for the         Every effort has been made to trace copyright holders of material     All advertising material is expected to conform to ethical
  views expressed in any article in this publication. All views expressed,   in this publication. If any rights have been omitted, the publisher   and trading standards, and reasonable care is taken to ensure
  except where explicitly stated otherwise, represent those of the           offers their apologies.                                               that advertisers are reputable and reliable. However, inclusion
  author, and not the Geological Society of London. All rights reserved.                                                                           in this publication or as an insert does not constitute a guarantee
                                                                             No responsibility is assumed by the Publisher for any injury          or endorsement of the quality or value of such products or
  No paragraph of this publication may be reproduced, copied or              and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products          services, or of the claims made by its manufacturer. Geoscientist
  transmitted save with written permission. Users registered with            liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation      and the Geological Society of London can give no assurance
  Copyright Clearance Center: the Journal is registered with CCC,            of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained             that an advertiser will fulfil its obligation under
  27 Congress Street, Salem, MA 01970, USA.                                  in the material herein.                                               all circumstances.

                                                                                                                                                                    GEOSCIENTIST.ONLINE | SPRING 2021                    5
AN ENIGMATIC GIANT GEOSCIENCE DIPLOMACY IN NORTH KOREA - GEOSCIENTIST
NEWS
S O C I E T Y A N D CO M M U N I T Y U P D AT E S

Society’s Burlington House
tenure remains uncertain
Steeply rising rent threatens our tenure at Burlington House.
Two initiatives are underway to ensure a long, sustainable and relevant
future for our Society, writes Richard Hughes, Executive Secretary

IN LATE JANUARY 2021 the President,                 concessionary rent (as granted to
Mike Daly, updated the Fellowship                   the Royal Academy of Arts > 150 years
on behalf of Council on the situation               ago); and
regarding the Society’s future occupancy         • The acquisition by the Society of
of Burlington House. Fellows will be                a long lease or virtual freehold
aware that since then a public awareness            arrangement either through purchase
and political engagement campaign has               or on the basis of a government grant                  The root cause
been underway in an effort to persuade              reflecting the considerable societal             of the uncertainty
Government to reconsider its position. In           value of the LS.
                                                                                                     surrounding the Society’s
parallel, a project has also begun to look at       Communications with the landlord (the
potential alternative options for the Society,   Ministry of Housing, Communities and
                                                                                                     future occupancy of
should it have to relocate.                      Local Government, MHCLG) continue.                  Burlington House
   A summary of the background to the            However, an affordable solution that would          is unaffordability
situation is provided below. Further details     allow the Society to remain at Burlington           due to steeply
are available at www.geolsoc.org.uk/             House for the long-term remains out of              rising rents
burlingtonhouse.                                 reach. Discussions have led only to the
   The root cause of the uncertainty             offer of a lease on the same terms as the
surrounding the Society’s future occupancy       current one, with a rate of rent increase
of Burlington House is unaffordability due       fixed at 8% per annum for the first five years      rights to sub-let would be in the region
to steeply rising rents. The Burlington          of the term. To illustrate the effects of an        of £17.6m. The landlord also ruled out
House Learned Societies (the LS: the             8% annual rent increase, Burlington House-          payment ‘in kind’, that is through transfer
Geological Society, Royal Society of             related costs in 2020 (excluding Covid              title of collections.
Chemistry, Royal Astronomical Society,           impacts) total £570k, of which £217k is                 The Geological Society is self-financing
Linnean Society, and the Society of              rent. Total costs are forecast to increase to       and a financially neutral outcome is
Antiquaries) entered an arbitration process      £710k in 2025 and £900k in 2030, the rent           forecast for 2021. An 8% or greater
with the landlord in 2014-15, and since          components of which are £320k in 2025               escalation of our already significant annual
then several avenues have been pursued to        and £470k in 2030.                                  rent will turn neutrality into an escalating
secure our future at Burlington House on            The enquiry into the purchase of a               annual loss over the coming years. Despite
an affordable long-term basis. The avenues       long lease was rebuffed by the landlord,            the current rent being approximately 1/3 of
pursued by the LS include:                       who saw ‘no scope’ for entering                         the landlord’s targeted market rent levels,
• Renegotiation of the current                   such discussions. It should                                  the large footprint (almost 14,000 sq.
   unsatisfactory lease and rent escalation      be noted that on the basis                If you have a        ft.) and substantial other facilities-
   formula;                                      of recent valuations the                query relating          related costs mean that our
                                                                                           to the lease,
• The pursuit of a political solution that       cost of a long lease for the               please email          occupation accounts for almost
   might provide for a long lease with           Society’s premises with no             burlingtonhouse@          10% of the Society’s annual
                                                                                         geolsoc.org.uk

6   GEOSCIENTIST | SPRING 2021
AN ENIGMATIC GIANT GEOSCIENCE DIPLOMACY IN NORTH KOREA - GEOSCIENTIST
NEWS

                                                                                                     RENEWALS
                                                                                                     REMINDER
                                                                                                     RICHARD HUGHES, Executive
                                                                                                     Secretary, writes: I would like
                                                                                                     to remind Fellows who have
                                                                                                     not yet done so to renew their
                                                                                                     Fellowship for the current
                                                                                                     year. Non-renewal may result
                                                                                                     in the discontinuation of your
                                                                                                     Fellowship with the subsequent
                                                                                                     inconvenience of having to then
                                                                                                     re-apply. Moreover, late payments
                                                                                                     result in additional costs and
                                                                                                     administration for the Society.
                                                                                                     To continue your support, please
                                                                                                     renew your Fellowship today,
                                                                                                     preferably online via the website.
                                                                                                     Note that you now have the
                                                                                                     option of a monthly or quarterly
                                                                  Costly rent and falling revenues   direct debit to spread your
                                                                 have put the Geological Society’s   payments. If you wish to discuss
                                                              future at Burlington House in doubt
                                                                                                     any aspect of your renewal, please
                                                                                                     call the Fellowship Department.

income. In addition, the Society forecasts          campaign to gain Government support
falling revenues in the medium term due to          to remain at Burlington House. Should                        MORE ONLINE
a substantial Open Access-driven reduction          Government be unwilling to re-consider                        Keep up-to-date with
in publishing income. Falling Fellowship            their stance we would seek their                              the latest news and
                                                                                                                  discussion, and view
numbers of between 1-3% per annum since             assistance in supporting a move.                 additional geoscience-related
2017 are expected to continue, given the            Council has directed the commencement            reports, videos and more at
reduction in the national oil industry and       of two initiatives. Firstly, a public awareness     www.Geoscientist.Online
falling numbers of students choosing to          and political engagement campaign,
study Earth sciences. These challenges           managed by www.april6.com. The primary
have forced the Society, for the first time,     objective of this campaign is to influence
to reduce its staffing levels, in part through   Her Majesty’s Government to achieve                    President’s
a redundancy programme, to achieve a             an equitable outcome that extends the                  Day Awards
neutral out-turn in 2021.                        Society’s future at Burlington House on                The Awards will be
   With no further realistic options available   affordable rent terms and under a new                  presented on President’s
for negotiation with the landlord, Council       lease that gives the Society freedom to                Day on 25 June 2021.
discussed the situation in August 2020.          pursue its strategic and business objectives.          It is likely that some
Three conclusions were forthcoming from             Secondly, a project to examine the                  restrictions will be in
the discussion:                                  Society’s options for relocation from                  place in June, so we are
1. The escalating rents are an                   Burlington House began in January, chaired             planning a virtual event.
   unsustainable burden on the Society’s         by past-President David Shilston.                      Further updates on
   finances, and continued residence                While many Fellows have a strong                    President’s Day will follow
   at Burlington House threatens its             attachment to the building where the Society           in newsletters and on the
   future existence.                             has enjoyed continuous occupation since                website, so please keep
2. The time has come to face up to the           1874, a large number of Fellows feel little or         an eye out. On the day,
   long-standing lease issue, with us            no attachment to it. Whatever the outcome,             talks will be given by some
   since 2005, and consider seriously the        the Fellowship can be assured that Council             of the senior medallists,
   options for alternative premises and          is committed to seeking the best possible              which Fellows will be able
                                                                                                        to attend virtually.
   our relocation.                               solution to guarantee a long, sustainable and
3. The Society should launch a final             relevant future for our Society.

                                                                                                       GEOSCIENTIST.ONLINE | SPRING 2021   7
AN ENIGMATIC GIANT GEOSCIENCE DIPLOMACY IN NORTH KOREA - GEOSCIENTIST
NEWS

Fellowship categories                                                                                                     TURN
                                                                                                                         TO PAGE 50
                                                                                                                          Read the

and benefits review project                                                                                               supporting
                                                                                                                          statements
                                                                                                                          from the
                                                                                                          nominees to be new Geological
An in-depth review of the current fellowship categories, fee structure, and                               Society Council members
membership benefits is underway, writes Richard Hughes, Executive Secretary

                                                        not to adversely impact the Society’s overall
                          The Society aims to attract
                           and retain more members      financial position, and its important policy,
                                                        outreach, education, communications and
                                                        advocacy work on behalf of the profession.
                                                           Any new proposed fellowship
                                                        categories, fees, and membership benefits will
                                                        need the approval of the Society’s Professional
                                                        & Chartership and Finance & Planning
                                                        Committees before being considered by our
                                                        governing Council in April 2021. Under the
                                                        Society’s bye-laws, any proposals to change          COUNCIL
OUR CURRENT, largely age-based structure                fees must also be approved at our Annual             MEETINGS,
is complex compared to other learned                    General Meeting, scheduled for late June
                                                                                                             OGMS AND
societies/professional bodies, and seen                 2021. Any changes will therefore not come
by some as divisive and discriminatory.                 into effect until the 2022 renewal cycle, which
                                                                                                             AGM 2021
The Society needs a simpler, more                       will start in the autumn of 2021.                    The dates for
appealing structure that enables it to more                Fellows’ views were sought in an online           meetings of Council
successfully attract and retain members                 survey published in December 2020, and I             and Ordinary General
from all parts of our community, especially             am very grateful to those who took the time          Meetings are:
underrepresented groups. Any new structure              to respond. Further information will be made         7 April, 23 June,
                                                                                                             22 September and
will need to be broadly cost-neutral so as              available before the Annual General Meeting.
                                                                                                             24 November.
                                                                                                                The Annual General
                                                                                                             Meeting will be held
Society Awards                                                                                               virtually on Friday
The Society is delighted to announce the names of the winners of its medals                                  25 June, 11am –
and funds and offers all its wholehearted congratulations.                                                   12.30pm. The agenda
NAME                     AFFILIATION                                        AWARD
                                                                                                             and further details
Prof David Pollard       Stanford University                                Wollaston Medal                  of the arrangements
Prof Nicholas White      University of Cambridge                            Lyell Medal                      will be communicated
Prof Graham Pearson      University of Alberta                              Murchison Medal                  via our newsletters,
Dr Phil Christie         Schlumberger Cambridge Research                    William Smith Medal              website and in the
Prof Sanjeev Gupta       Imperial College London                            Prestwich Medal                  summer issue of
Prof Kenneth McCaffrey   University of Durham                               Dewey Medal                      Geoscientist.
Prof Chris Jackson       Imperial College London                            Coke Medal                          For details on the
Dr Helen Reeves          Jacobs                                             Coke Medal                       elections to Council,
Dr Sheila Peacock        Blacknest (AWE)                                    Distinguished Service Award      the list of continuing
Dr Anjana Khatwa         Wessex Museums, UK                                 R H Worth Medal                  and retiring Council
Prof Marie Edmonds       University of Cambridge                            Bigsby Medal                     members, as well
Dr Caroline Gill         Shell U.K. Limited                                 Aberconway Medal                 as the supporting
Dr Emma Liu              University College London                          Wollaston Fund                   statements for the
Dr Luke Parry            University of Oxford                               Lyell Fund                       President Designate
Dr Andrew Thomson        University College London                          Murchison Fund                   and Council nominees,
Dr Fabian Wadworth       University of Durham                               William Smith Fund
                                                                                                             please see story, facing
Dr Finnigan Illsley-Kemp Victoria University of Wellington                  President’s Award
                                                                                                             page, and page 50.
Dr Scarlett Jazmin		                                                        President’s Award

8   GEOSCIENTIST | SPRING 2021
AN ENIGMATIC GIANT GEOSCIENCE DIPLOMACY IN NORTH KOREA - GEOSCIENTIST
NEWS

                                                   PLEASE NOTE
                                                  ONLY FELLOWS

ELECTIONS
                                                  OF THE SOCIETY
                                                   ARE ELIGIBLE
                                                     TO VOTE

TO COUNCIL
2021-2022
GEOSCIENTIST’S OCTOBER issue
and subsequent email newsletters
invited Fellows to nominate new
members of Council to succeed those
who will be retiring at the Annual
General Meeting on 25 June 2021.
   One nomination was received for
the post of President Designate and a
further 14 nominations for the seven
remaining vacancies. The process for
the election of members of Council
is set out at section 6 of the Bye-laws
and the process for the election of
President is set out at section 7.
   The preliminary ballot is in
progress, the results of which will       ballot pack. If you have not heard from        It is important that Council is
determine the list for the formal         CES via email or post, or would prefer      representative of the views and
vote at this year’s Annual General        to receive a postal ballot pack, or have    diversity of all the Fellowship, so
Meeting on Friday 25 June 2021.           any other difficulties casting your         Fellows are urged to participate
As in past years, Civica Election         vote, please contact Christina Marron       in the preliminary ballot, which
Services (CES) is administering this      (christina.marron@geolsoc.org.uk) at        will determine the list for the
year’s Council ballot on behalf of        the Society.                                formal vote at the Annual General
the Society. CES is the UK’s leading        The Council elections are your            Meeting. The closing date for
independent ballot services provider      opportunity to choose who should            voting, online or postal, is 23.59 on
and has an extensive experience of        serve on Council to best represent the      Wednesday 31 March 2021. Postal
overseeing ballots for a wide range       interests of all Fellows and to shape the   ballot forms must be sent to CES (not
of organisations.                         future of the Society. Fellows may wish     to the Society) and must arrive by
   In February, Fellows should have       to make their choices having regard to      Wednesday 31 March.
received an email from CES with           the area of expertise of the continuing        Graham Goffey, Treasurer, is retiring
instructions for how to vote online.      and retiring members of Council that are    from Council and Keith Myers was
If you have not heard to date, please     shown on the tables on page 53. Their       co-opted by Council in April 2020 as
check your spam emails before             biographies are at www.geolsoc.org.         Treasurer-designate. His nomination
contacting the Society. Fellows           uk/biographies. Council is particularly     for election is endorsed by Council.
for whom we do not have an email          keen to strengthen representation from      See page 50 for supporting statements
address will have received a postal       experienced academics.                      of the Council nominees.

              Queen’s New Year Honours List 2021
              Dr Malcolm Butler, Chair of the UK Onshore Geophysical Library, was awarded an OBE
              for services to education, research and development, and Dr Alison Monaghan, Principal
              Geologist at the British Geological Survey was awarded an MBE for services to geology.
              The Society offers both our sincere congratulations.

                                                                                                GEOSCIENTIST.ONLINE | SPRING 2021   9
AN ENIGMATIC GIANT GEOSCIENCE DIPLOMACY IN NORTH KOREA - GEOSCIENTIST
A Special
NEWS                                                                                                                        Publication
                                                                                                                             celebrates
                                                                                                                                 female
                                                                                                                             geologists

                                                             The journal will engage
                                                             early career researchers

                                                                                        Special Publications
                                                                                        launched
                                                                                        The Geological Society’s
                                                                                        Publishing House is happy
                                                                                        to announce the publication
                                                                                        of two new books in early 2021
Launch of Earth Science,                                                                Celebrating 100 Years of Female

Systems and Society journal                                                             Fellowship of the Geological Society:
                                                                                        Discovering Forgotten Histories
                                                                                        Due to be published in March 2021,
In January, the Geological Society officially launched its first fully
                                                                                        this Special Publication celebrates the
gold open access journal, Earth Science, Systems and Society
                                                                                        centenary of the first female Fellows
(ES3), writes David Boyt, Head of Editorial Development                                 elected to the Society – 112 years after
                                                                                        its formation. It presents the often-
ES 3 COVERS the spectrum of Earth         will be used to support a programme           untold stories of pioneering women
science, with a particular focus          of discounts and waivers aimed at             geoscientists from across the world who
on interfacing, cross-disciplinary        increasing access for those without           navigated male-dominated academia
research related to sustainability in     funding. Standard APC discounts               and learned societies, and it uncovers
society. In addition to publishing        are available for Fellows of the              important female role models in the
high-calibre research, the journal        Geological Society and authors from           history of science.
aims to encourage inclusivity and         developing countries.                         Available online at https://
diversity in publishing, engage              As the Society’s first fully OA journal,   sp.lyellcollection.org/online-first/506
directly with early career researchers,   ES3 builds on the hybrid open-access          and via the Special Publications series
and embody principles of openness         options available via the Society’s           at www.geolsoc.org.uk/sp506.
and transparency in science.              existing journals and Special Publications
   The journal’s Chief Editor, Dr         to provide authors with a dedicated           Geoethics: Status and Future
Kathryn Goodenough (British               route to open-access publication,             Perspectives
Geological Survey; see ‘Five              which aims to be compliant with               This book is a significant step forward in
minutes with…’, page 54), heads           mandates from the key funders and             the development of geoethical thinking,
an international Editorial Board          institutions, both now and in the future.     its theoretical foundations and practical
of researchers and professionals             ES3 is owned and published by the          applications. Geoethics is now ready to
representing a broad range of subject     Geological Society, using the systems         be introduced outside the geoscience
knowledge and experience.                 and services of Frontiers Media.              community as a platform for global
   Under the journal’s open access        • ES3 is live online and welcomes             ethics, addressing anthropogenic
(OA) publishing model, all accepted          submissions at www.EScubed.org             changes and the responsible interaction
articles will be subject to an article    • Authors can also choose to submit           between humans and the Earth system.
processing charge (APC), which               work to one of the journal’s three live    Available online at https://
supports the costs associated                Special Issues, which include ‘Earth       sp.lyellcollection.org/online-first/508
with publication. The Society has            Sciences and the Race to Net Zero’.        and via the Special Publications series
established ES3 as a not-for-profit       • For any queries, please contact:            from April.
publishing endeavour. Any surplus            david.boyt@geolsoc.org.uk

10   GEOSCIENTIST | SPRING 2021
NEWS

2020 statement on climate change
in the geological record
The Geological Society has published an updated scientific statement,
writes Alicia Newton, Director of Science & Communications

                                                                      jointly convened a panel of               climate assessments. They also
 The paper reviews the
 evidence of climate change                                           experts to review the Geological          received questions raised by
 in the geological record                                             Society’s existing statements             Fellows following the Society’s
                                                                      and to create a revised version           Annual General Meeting in
                                                                      that reflects the current state of        2019. This information was
                                                                      scientific research. The resulting        distilled into a comprehensive
                                                                      paper is published in the Journal         publication that documents four
                                                                      of the Geological Society (Lear           billion years of Earth history, and
                                                                      et al. (2020) J. Geol. Soc. 178(1):       explores how previous episodes
                                                                      jgs2020-239; https://doi.                 of greenhouse gas-induced
                                                                      org/10.1144/jgs2020-239).                 warming can inform our
                                                                         As part of their process,              understanding of Earth’s future.
THE GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY             addendum in 2013. Because          the expert panel reviewed                    A related conference will be
published its first statement on   this is a fast-moving field of     nearly 200 peer-reviewed                  held 26-27 May. Visit www.
the geological record of climate   science, in 2018 the Society and   publications, as well as white            geolsoc.org.uk/05-GSL-Climate-
change in 2010, followed by an     the UK Paleoclimate Society        papers and international                  Change for more information

                                                                                                                         Image credit: Natashia Mattocks

Mary Anning                                                            Fossil enthusiast Evie Swire sparked
                                                                       the campaign when she asked her

Rocks campaign
                                                                       mother, ‘Why isn’t there a statue to
                                                                       Mary, Mummy?’

The Geological Society honours Mary
Anning by supporting statue campaign
THE GEOLOGICAL Society             renowned throughout the
has become an official             scientific world in the early
supporter of the campaign          19th century. Mary’s work
to acknowledge the life and        was groundbreaking within
work of Mary Anning (1799          palaeontology, however
- 1847) through a statue to        because Mary was a woman
be erected in her honour on        and from a working-class             The Mary Anning Rocks                   with-author-tom-sharpe-
the Jurassic Coast. Aiming         background, she didn’t receive     campaign coordinator says, “We            tickets-139642324953
to commemorate Mary’s              the recognition she deserved       see the statue as an inspirational           Visit our online exhibition:
contribution and inspire           during her life. Regrettably,      presence in the landscape                 www.geolsoc.org.uk/Library-
future fossil-hunters with her     Mary was never able to             where she worked.”                        and-Information-Services/
unique story, this support is      join the Society because             To find out more about                  Exhibitions/Women-and-
in line with the Society’s goal    women were not considered          the campaign, visit www.                  Geology/Mary-Anning
to promote Earth science           for Fellowship until 1919.         maryanningrocks.co.uk/                       Download our KS3 factsheet:
education and awareness.           However, the foundations             Join the Library on 9 March             www.geolsoc.org.uk/~/
   Mary Anning was a fossil        to our science were laid by        for an online talk by Tom                 media/shared/documents/
hunter and collector, who          countless dedicated and            Sharpe ‘Mary Anning and                   education%20and%20careers/
made many incredible               passionate geologists, just        the men of learning’. www.                Resources/FactSheets/
discoveries in her home town       like Mary, who deserve to be       eventbrite.co.uk/e/gsl-library-           Mary%20Anning%20factsheet.
of Lyme Regis, becoming            remembered and celebrated.         event-mary-anning-talk-                   pdf?la=en

                                                                                                              GEOSCIENTIST.ONLINE | SPRING 2021     11
NEWS

The Discussion Group aspires to attract
a diverse audience and attendance is
open to all – Fellows and guests

                                                                                           PARTNERSHIP
                                                                                           WITH THE JP
                                                                                           MORGAN FORCE
                                                                                           FOR GOOD
                                                                                           PROGRAMME
                                                                                           Building a community
                                                                                           platform to connect
                                                                                           geoscience educators
                                                                                           and practitioners
                                                                                           We recently announced that the
                                                                                           Geological Society is launching
                                                                                           the Geoscience Education and
                                                                                           Outreach Network (GEON),

Geological Society                                                                         an online platform for sharing
                                                                                           education initiatives and discussion

Discussion Group 2021                                                                      across the geoscience community.
                                                                                           We are thrilled to have been
                                                                                           chosen as a recipient of the
THE DISCUSSION GROUP fosters                     Meetings are open to all – Fellows,       prestigious JP Morgan Force
wide-ranging scientific discussion in a       their guests and non-Fellows. To make        for Good programme. Through
social setting on a variety of geoscience     a reservation, contact Becky.Goddard@        the programme, JP Morgan will
topics. It has roots in the Geological        geolsoc.org.uk                               provide pro bono technical support
Society Dining Club, which dates back            The programme for 2021, including         to develop the online platform.
to 1824, becoming a formal part of the        talks related to the Society’s ‘Year of         GEON will represent a
Society as one of the Specialist Groups       Space’ theme, includes:                      significant opportunity to increase
in 2016. Since 2018, a summary of the         • 14 Apr. Stac Fada impact deposit.          collaboration and best practice
meetings has been available on the               Dr Ken Amor, University of Oxford         across the geoscience community.
Society’s website, with topics ranging        • 9 Jun. The Mars 2020 Mission.              The ultimate aim will be to inspire
from masonry repairs, the critically             Prof Caroline Smith, Natural              a skilled and diverse community of
stressed Earth, deep continental                 History Museum                            future geoscientists.
subduction, and how life began on             • 14 Jul. Summer outing. Gilbert White       To find out more and register
Earth, to the future of the Society itself.      Museum, Selborne                          your interest, please get in touch:
   Traditionally, meetings take place            Fellows are invited to join the           GEON@geolsoc.org.uk
in the evening at a range of venues in        Discussion Group as part of the annual
London, when a topical subject is raised      membership renewal process.
by an invited speaker and debated over        For more information, please contact
dinner. However, events in 2020 have          John Bennett (Honorary Secretary)                    J O I N T H E D E B AT E
                                                                                                   Has a news item got you thinking?
been held with equal success by Zoom,         via the website: www.geolsoc.
                                                                                                   We welcome readers’ letters and
without travelling and with a convivial       org.uk/Groups-and-Networks/                          feedback. Share your views by
glass of wine to hand from the comfort        Specialist-Groups/Geological-Society-     emailing geoscientist@geolsoc.org.uk
of your own home!                             Discussion-Group/

12   GEOSCIENTIST | SPRING 2021
NEWS

Energy
Transition
Theme
                                                   Geological knowledge informs
We are excited to announce the                     energy projects such as Krafla
launch of the Geological Society’s                 Geothermal Power Plant, Iceland

Energy Transition Theme, write                    Image credit: Ásgeir Eggertsson, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Dr Nick Gardiner (University of                   between academia, business, government                        in caverns meeting’. For more information
St Andrews and Lead, Energy                       and public communities, and aim to inspire                    visit: www.geolsoc.org.uk/Hydrogen-
Transition Theme) and Dr Alex                     a new generation of geoscientists.                            Storage-in-Caverns
Whittaker (Imperial College London
                                                  Energy Transition Theme events                                Energy Transition Discussion Meeting
and Chair, Science Committee)
                                                  and activities                                                (April 2022)
                                                  A number of events and activities are                         A multi-day conference in Burlington
THE SHIFT to a low/neutral carbon economy,        planned for 2021-22, to support and align                     House, London, in April 2022 will bring
which is essential to tackle climate change, is   with the Energy Transition Theme.                             together geoscientists, the energy transition
now a pressing international effort. November                                                                   communities, and policymakers, with an aim
2021 marks the UK-co-hosted United                2021 Webinar Series:                                          of assessing the on-going directions and
Nations Climate Change summit (COP26),            • 13 April (13.00-16.30) Geosciences                          priority roles for the geosciences in the energy
which is expected to drive new international        and the Energy Transition: How can                          transition, following the COP26 meeting.
agreements for decarbonisation.                     the Geosciences contribute to the
   Geosciences will play a pivotal role in          Energy Transition?                                          Decarbonisation Working Group
enabling the increasingly urgent energy           • 7-8 June (13.00-16.30) Geosciences and                      The Decarbonisation Working Group, chaired
transition. Earth resource stewardship              the Energy Transition: Energy Transfer,                     by Prof. Mike Stephenson, continues to work
will also be critical to the development of         Injection and Storage                                       on key issues at the interface of geoscience
circular economies, reducing waste and            • 6-7 September (provisional) Geosciences                     and public policy, developing resources and
environmental impact, driving innovation, and       and the Energy Transition: Mineral                          initiatives to highlight and communicate key
supporting business. Geological solutions           Supplies on a Finite Planet                                 enabling decarbonisation technologies to
will underpin responsible resource and waste        These seminars are being coordinated                        policymakers and the wider public. More
management, new innovative technologies           by Prof. Jon Gluyas (Durham University),                      information about their work can be found
for both storage (H and He) and capture (CO2,     Prof. Stuart Haszeldine OBE (University                       at www.geolsoc.org.uk/Policy-and-Media/
radioactive waste), and geothermal energy         of Edinburgh), Prof. Rob Knipe (University                    issues/decarbonisation/working-group
production. Geological knowledge will allow       of Leeds), Dr David Reiner (University of
the sourcing of essential raw materials, in       Cambridge), Prof. Frances Wall (University                    Special issue of ES3: Earth Sciences
particular critical metal resources, to support   of Exeter), Jo Coleman OBE (Shell), Dr                        and the Race to Net Zero
new technologies in energy storage and            Nick Gardiner (University of St Andrews and                   The Geological Society’s new OA journal,
transmission, transportation, construction,       Theme Leader), Dr Jen Roberts (University                     Earth Science, Systems and Society (ES3,
and engineering.                                  of Strathclyde) and Prof. Mike Stephenson                     see page 10) will publish a special issue on
   Geoscientists are therefore uniquely           (British Geological Survey).                                  the theme of Earth Sciences and the Race
placed to support policy makers,                                                                                to Net Zero. Submissions are welcomed on
stakeholders and industry in the                  Hydrogen Storage in Caverns Meeting                           all aspects of this topic: www.escubed.org/
management of Earth resources that are            (12 April 2021, virtual event)                                research-topics/2/earth-sciences-and-
fundamental to the energy transition. The         This meeting is being organised in                            the-race-to-net-zero
Society’s Energy Transition Theme will            collaboration with Energy Research
champion this goal, support communication         Accelerator. If you would like to contribute,                    In addition, a number of outreach events
                                                  participate or help shape how the event                       will be planned throughout 2021 and 2022
                                                  might proceed, please email Seamus.                           aligned with the theme. Further information
                                                  Garvey@nottingham.ac.uk or mhste@bgs.                         can be found at www.geolsoc.org.uk/ET
                                                  ac.uk with the title ‘About Hydrogen storage                  and www.geolsoc.org.uk/events

                                                                                                                          GEOSCIENTIST.ONLINE | SPRING 2021   15
VIEWPOINT
S EN D YO U R L E T T ER S TO G EO S C I E N T I S T@ G EO L S O C .O RG .U K A N D T W EE T U S AT @ G EO S C I E N T I S TM AG .
F O R G U I DA N CE O N S U B M I T T I N G A CO LU M N , S EE G EO S C I E N T I S T.O N L I N E

 COLUMN
                                                                                                                               Field courses are vital,

“Some                                                                                                                          but they must be safe

barriers
are invisible”
Fieldwork is important, but
we must recognise the
manifest risk it poses to
LGBTQ+ people, argues
Prof. Chris Jackson
                                                                                                     Want to join
                                                                                                     the debate?
                                                                                                        Email

A      s the old saying goes,
       “the best geologist has
seen the most rocks!” This
                                          Why might sexual orientation
                                      be a barrier to fieldwork? Queer
                                      people are as able to deal with
                                                                            stress felt by
                                                                            LGBTQ+ people
                                                                            in these locations
                                                                                                     geoscientist
                                                                                                    @geolsoc.org.uk
                                                                                                                            students who run into
                                                                                                                           trouble overseas. Such
                                                                                                                          restrictions highlight the
statement superficially makes         cold weather and boulder-strewn       is not conducive to                         fact that many institutions
sense; if you’ve seen many            slopes as non-queer people,           teaching and learning,                  do not have field-course risk
rocks, you can draw on those          aren’t they? I’m not questioning      presenting further barriers.          assessments explicitly covering
experiences to... erm... identify     this, but rather highlighting that       Holding field courses in           LGBTQ+-specific risks; even
and interpret more rocks. But         there are still about 70 countries    such countries presents an            where such assessments and
geoscientists rely on numerous        where being gay, lesbian,             unnecessary risk. In most cases,      related evacuation policies are
skills to determine the structure,    bisexual, and/or transgender          other suitable field locations        in place, they remain untested.
composition, and evolution of         is illegal, and many more with        exist that support attainment            Like many geoscientists,
Earth and other planets – skills      minimal protections against           of the learning objectives. We        I do not see a future where
that span a bewildering range         discrimination towards LGBTQ+         must select such alternatives to      fieldwork is not a core element
of disciplines and scales.            people. This is nothing to do with    promote an inclusive learning         of the geoscience toolkit.
   Fieldwork is undoubtedly           having sex; this discrimination       environment, to the benefit of an     However, we must be aware
important and is a core element       exists simply for being (or           individual course and the wider       of and work to remove the
of many Earth science courses.        perceived as being) a member          community that our graduates          barriers to fieldwork placed
There are, however, numerous          of the LGBTQ+ community.              will join. Deciding not to hold a     in front of all members of the
barriers to fieldwork. Some are           For example, in 2014 a British    field course in a location that is    geoscience community.
obvious, such as those related to     tourist was arrested in Morocco       unsafe for LGBTQ+ geoscientists
coping with the sheer physicality     after authorities searched his        is not a political or value
of fieldwork. Many more are less      phone and found images used           statement on a country or its
obvious, such as the requirement      to prosecute him, while the           citizens. We have a duty of care
for safe conditions under which       arrest, torture, exile to Canada,     to our colleagues and students.
to change sanitary protection.        and eventual suicide in 2020             Additionally, universities
And some barriers are perhaps         of activist Sarah Hegazi was          or staff in the field may not         P R O F. C H R I S J A C K S O N
invisible, such as sexual             triggered by her waving a             be able to immediately assist         Chair in Sustainable Geoscience,
orientation and gender identity.      rainbow flag in Egypt. The            or repatriate employees or            University of Manchester

16   GEOSCIENTIST | SPRING 2021
VIEWPOINT

                                                                                                               old-fashioned perceptions
                                                                                                               of what geology is and what
                                                                                                               geologists do, as you rightly
                                                                                                               point out, especially around
                                                                                                               geology’s association with the
                                                                                                               extractive industries.
                                                                                                                  This complex problem
                                                                                                               is not one the Society can
                                                                                                               fix alone. We are therefore
                                                                                                               partnering with a number
                                                                       Geologists are forensic detectives,
                                                                                                               of other organisations and
                                                                              gathering data on location
                                                                                                               stakeholders to widen the
                                                                                                               appeal of geology. Two
 LET TER
                                                                      in the media, and little or              notable organisations are:

Reverse the decline                                                   no specific mention of the
                                                                      term geology in schools, is
                                                                      it any wonder that many are
                                                                                                               ∞ University Geoscience UK,
                                                                                                               the subject association of
                                                                                                               geoscience departments based
DEAR EDITORS,                      concerned that these will          unaware of the tremendous                within British universities. We
Geology’s popularity is in         largely become point-and-see       opportunity geology offers               co-organised the June 2020
decline for many reasons.          exercises that do not instil       for employment, intellectual             student enrolment summit,
A big one is that, as a            sound recording techniques         challenge and personal                   which led to the development
community, we have allowed         or stimulate the kind of mind      fulfilment, as well as its key           of a strategy and a plan of
it to become widely regarded       that seeks out answers.            role in locating essential               action is currently being
as just the study of some             Safety and inclusivity in the   resources and helping                    pursued to increase interest.
dusty old rocks. Geologists        field are vital, but difficult     Earth’s environment?                     ∞ Diversity in Geoscience UK,
know it is far more than that      issues. Thankfully many               A hard task lies ahead,               a recently established charity
– it is Earth Science. Another     classic localities already have    but we must hurry to fully               looking at ways to improve
reason is the name change to       suitable access and it wouldn’t    convince the public that                 diversity and inclusion for
Earth sciences or geoscience       take much work to improve          first-class geologists are, and          all within the community.
– this only creates confusion      many more field locations.         always will be, absolutely vital.        They are currently assessing
and dilutes our message.           Some sites even offer for hire                                              potential projects and
The Geological Society             off-road mobility scooters.        RICHARD ARTHUR                           fundraising opportunities,
urgently needs to be more          Would the Geological Society                                                and we can work together
proactive in encouraging           be interested in helping to set        George Jameson,                      with them to improve access
extra mural courses and            up a database of such places       Diversity and Inclusion Project          to field locations throughout
spreading the word.                and help raise funding to          Lead, Geological Society of              the country.
   Clearly, we must embrace        improve matters?                   London, writes in response:                 Our goals may not be
diversity and inclusivity,            True geologists are             The Society is acutely aware of          realised overnight, but they
while eliminating racism,          like forensic detectives.          the decline in the popularity of         will go some way to dusting
but we cannot give in              They must think across             geology over recent years. This          off the perception of geology
to those clamouring to             disciplines to understand          is most noticeable in the drop           as just the study of old rocks.
remove traditional fieldwork       the complexities of Earth’s        in student numbers applying              Given the gravity of the
requirements. It should            natural processes and its          for and studying geology                 situation, it is essential for the
be crystal clear why it is         many human-made problems.          at undergraduate level,                  community to address this
ridiculous to think the            The combination of a less          something we are genuinely               task together and we welcome
personal experience gained         outdoorsy generation and           concerned by.                            additional support.
through fieldwork is not           geology’s toxic association           Ideally, we want every
absolutely essential, and it       with destructive and polluting     person to be familiar with
worries me that anyone could       extractive industries are major    geology as an area of
think they can become a real       barriers to be overcome if         study and aware of the                   To anyone who wishes to
‘geologist’ without it.            geology’s popularity is to         applications of geology to our           continue this conversation,
   Virtual field trips are great   be improved. With so little        everyday lives. However, this            please get in touch by emailing
for inclusivity, but I am          coverage of accurate geology       ideal is nuanced. There are              diversity@geolsoc.org.uk

                                                                                                             GEOSCIENTIST.ONLINE | SPRING 2021   17
VIEWPOINT

 COLUMN
                                                                                                          still ingrained, and where Black

“We have accepted lack                                                                                    underrepresentation is not seen
                                                                                                          as an issue.

of diversity as normal”
                                                                                                             It is time for us to do more
                                                                                                          than speak up. We must go
                                                                                                          beyond wearing t-shirts, using
Why are Black geoscientists underrepresentated in the                                                     hashtags and glossy Corporate
minerals industry, asks Dr Andrew P.G. Abraham                                                            Social Responsibility reports. We
                                                                                                          need to take action to create
                                                                                                          truly diverse and welcoming

G     eology (and all its
      incredible subfields) is
an amazing science to learn.
                                      Even though most of us,
                                   who are white, have rarely met
                                   Black geoscience students,
                                                                        Silence is a
                                                                     form of complicity,
                                                                                                          workplaces in academia and
                                                                                                          the minerals industry. This will
                                                                                                          not happen overnight, but we
                                                                     and the minerals
The integral importance of         professors, geoscientists and                                          can make a start through open
geoscience and the minerals        corporate leaders, we have
                                                                     industry gives the                   dialogue on inclusivity, equity,
industry to global economies       rarely voiced concern, and        impression that it                   and breaking down barriers.
should make it a strong choice     mostly accepted the lack of       does not care                        We need to create intern
for developing future careers.     diversity as something normal.                                         programmes, more scholarships
So, why does it not attract more      It should not have taken the                                        and bursaries, and mentorship
Black students and why are         horrific murder of George Floyd   boardrooms are an echo               and outreach programmes
there so few Black geoscientists   to create the unprecedented       chamber insulating them from         to attract Black high-school
and corporate leaders?             global change in corporate        reality. This should shame us all.   students into geoscience. We
   The scarcity of Black           attitudes. But the minerals          The industry’s Black              need to encourage them to
geoscientists is not a function    industry, to a large extent,      underrepresentation starts           continue in academic research
of Black students finding          has stood silent. Silence is a    with the education system            and work in the minerals
geoscience and careers             form of complicity, and the       that has not yet stepped up          industry. How can we do this?
in the minerals industry           minerals industry gives the       to changing its predominantly        By creating a paradigm shift in
uninteresting, it is a function    impression that it does not       white complexion. This is a          culture and attitude, celebrating
of over 40 years of white          care. Why? Because it does not    major global issue, especially in    Black role models, recognising
geoscientists and corporate        understand nor feel connected     primarily white countries where      Black student’s abilities and
leaders happily content with       to the Black community            colonial attitudes and systemic      achievements, encouraging them
the status quo.                    and its predominantly white       racism are                           to become leaders, accepting
                                                                                                          them for who they are, and
                                                                                                          nurturing their desires to succeed.
                                                                                Visit Geoscientist.       • This opinion piece links to
                                                                                  Online to read
                                                                                     the latest              the feature ‘Waiting for a
                                                                                   discussions               paradigm shift:
                                                                                       in full
                                                                                                             Black underrepresentation in
                                                                                                             geoscience and the minerals
                                                                                                             Industry’, available
                                                                                                             at www.Geoscientist.Online
                                                                                                          • See also feature, page 30.

                                                                                                          D R A N D R E W P. G . A B R A H A M
                                                                                                          An independent consultant who
                                                                                                          serves as volunteer Director External
                                                                                                          Engagement for the Canadian
                                                                                                          Federation of Earth Sciences

18   GEOSCIENTIST | SPRING 2021
VIEWPOINT

                                                                        the danger in that? The power           Society activities, Geoscientist
                                                                        of print is that ‘it comes to you’,     has to be affordable,
                                                                        so you read it. Online letters,         particularly in these difficult
                                                                        as now, hide in plain sight, free       times, and staff were tasked
                                                                        for all the world to read if they       with finding ways to become
                                                                        can be bothered – and cynically         more sustainable. The editorial
                                                                        put there in the full knowledge         team drew up a variety of
                                                                        that nobody will. They will go          options for the production of
                                                                        as unread in future as they do          Geoscientist. These detailed
                                                                        now, and for the same reason            options were assessed by
                                                                        – one that no amount of web             the Finance and Planning
                                                                        design can ever overcome.               Committee and agreed by
                                                                                                                Council, which decided on
                                                                        P R O F. E M E R . P E T E R            enhanced online presence
                                                                        STYLES, DR TED NIELD                    and quarterly publication.
                                                                                                                This decision reflected both
                                                                        DEAR EDITORS,                           costs and the best use of the
                                                                        I am saddened to hear the               time of the editors and others
                                                                        society is reducing the number          producing Geoscientist.
  LET TER
                                                                        of magazine issues per year.               Peter and Ted forcefully

Quarterly dismay                                                           From my perspective, all
                                                                        this will mean is that I engage
                                                                        less with the magazine and
                                                                                                                argue that having letters
                                                                                                                initially and immediately
                                                                                                                online will “hide [objections
DEAR EDITORS,                       loathing that characterised         the Society, as I already               and dissent] in plain sight”.
We write, as a former President,    ‘reunification’, members of         receive a torrent of digital            This may be true for some
Professional Secretary,             the Institution (practising         communications and                      cohorts of Fellows, but others
Editor-in-Chief and Editor of       geoscientists) were not willing     offerings – getting the print           will doubtless be far more at
Geoscientist, to express our        for academics, who then             magazine cuts through this              home finding or expressing
sadness and dismay that this        dominated, with steely resolve,     and means I actually read it.           views online. We hope that
fine magazine is to become a        the Old Lady of Piccadilly,            A move towards digital               putting more resources into
quarterly, with promises of an      to hold any editorial sway. It      provision will result in less of        timely online news and debate
enhanced online presence.           seems hardly coincidental that      my attention, I’m afraid.               will serve a broad range of the
   You attempt to put a brave       this present measure is being                                               Fellowship and help attract
a face on it, but beyond that       taken just as the worst fears of    CHRIS JACK                              new Fellows.
– and some questionable             our own times are coming true.                                                 Geoscientist continues to
greenwash – we detect two              We are sure that the new            Prof. Andy Fleet,                    be ‘by and for the Fellows’
real motives: saving money,         quarterly will be a thing           Editor-in-Chief; David                  and, as ever, we encourage
and stifling dissent. In the        of beauty; but quarterlies          Shilston, Deputy Editor-in-             our community to voice any
right circumstances in these        cannot be topical. High             Chief; Dr Amy Whitchurch,               concerns and share their
straitened times, we approve of     production values and long          Editor; Sarah Day, Editor,              opinions – email your letters
the former, but never the latter!   intervals lead to blandness         Geoscientist magazine,                  to geoscientist@geolsoc.org.
   Geoscientist is unique among     and inconsequentiality. One         write in response: In making            uk. Indeed, our problems
learned body magazines in that      knows there will never be           changes to Geoscientist, we             are usually that we do not
it belongs to the Fellowship        anything piquant in these           are trying to provide the best          hear from all sides of a
and not ‘the Society’ (whatever     organs – even in Letters,           service to the full spectrum of         debate, especially those who
THAT is). It owes this ‘Fourth      assuming there are any.             Fellows that we can, given the          agree rather than dissent,
Estate’ status to its history –        So where will Fellows, in        resources available to us, and          and in hearing a variety of
being formed from the merger        the last resort, go to voice        improve how we provide news             views rather than the same
of the Society’s anaemic            any objections to the way           and debate in exciting, varied          argument repeated.
newsletter and the Institution      Trustees and staff or others are    and timely ways.                           Dare we end by saying
of Geologists’ far superior         misconducting the Society’s           As Peter and Ted highlight,           that we have published
British Geologist. In the           business? They will go online,      money was a key factor in               a fuller response on
climate of suspicion, fear and      we are told. Result! For where is   making the changes. Like all            Geoscientist Online?

                                                                                                              GEOSCIENTIST.ONLINE | SPRING 2021   19
VIEWPOINT

                                                                      We should be doing more
  LET TER                                                             to ensure that geology is
                                                                      taught in schools

Inspirational geoparks
need investment
DEAR EDITORS,                            Would education help
I read Melvyn Giles’ article          increase public awareness and
about The Scottish Geology            thereby funding of geoparks?
Trust (Geoscientist 30(10), 28-       In pre-university science,
29, 2020) with great sympathy         geology is incorporated as a
for the cause – that public           minor component, though
interest in dramatic Scottish         perhaps too fleetingly to
landscapes is not matched by          impress young minds. We
investment in our geoparks.           should instead exploit the
   There is a perception that the     geography curriculum, but
public is unwilling to engage         here the window might be
with lengthy explanations. TV         closing – even geomorphology         LET TER

documentaries often open              may be fighting a rear-guard
with sequences on plate
tectonics, floods or icecaps,
                                      action to preserve its long-
                                      standing space as relative
                                                                        Capturing young
before rapidly giving way to
the urge to feed public interest
                                      newcomers such as climate
                                      change and environmental          imaginations
in animal behaviour. Many             despoliation crowd out the
film directors seem to believe        time available.                   DEAR EDITORS,                  issues like climate change
the physical world is merely a                                          I am most concerned by         and geohazards. The
setting for the organisms that        P R O F. E M E R I T U S ,        recent articles citing the     profession has always
inhabit it.                           IAN REID                          decline in the teaching        changed as it moved
                                                                        of geology, its adverse        forward, not only for the
The dramatic landscapes of Scotland                                     impact on the profession       few, but for the many.
can inspire interest in geology                                         which, in my view, is to the   Indeed, the comment
                                                                        detriment of society.          from the Editor’s desk in
                                                                           A geological degree         the October issue that
                                                                        gives one a wonderful          “Geology has a way of
                                                                        start to a career. In my       capturing the imagination,
                                                                        school, geology was not        whatever level of detailed
                                                                        taught, but it seemed an       understanding you reach”
                                                                        obvious degree choice,         should be exploited to its
                                                                        given it combined the          full potential.
                                                                        subjects I studied at A           The profession must
                                                                        Level: physics, chemistry,     reach out beyond the
                                                                        botany and zoology. I          known world of geology
                                                                        went on to enjoy a career      and be more proactive.
                                                                        in civil engineering, not      Perhaps the slogan for
                                                                        in geotechnics, but as a       universities should be
                                                                        maritime civil engineer.       ‘Kick Start your Career
                                                                           Geology as a subject has    with a Geology Degree’,
                                                                        developed and continues        reinforcing the view that
                                                                        to do so. It has much to       geology is a broad church.
                                                                        contribute to our future,
                                                                        including tackling major       DR ROG E R MADDR E L L

20   GEOSCIENTIST | SPRING 2021
VIEWPOINT

  David wearing one
  of the face
                                                                                       Follow us @geoscientistmag
  coverings

                                   YOUR TWEETS
                                                    @Volcanologist: It’s ‘crewed’ not ‘manned’.
                                                    (E.g. see here ourplnt.com/please-use-crewed
                                                    -not-manned/#axzz6gtiTOMfr)
                                                    @geoscientistmag: Thank you for flagging this.
                                                    We’re disappointed we didn’t pick this up during
                                                    our editing process and will endeavour to be more
                                                    thorough in the future.

 LET TER                                            @Volcanologist: Excited to see the latest
                                                    @geoscientistmag on Mars with a great interview with

Geo                                                 Divya Persaud. Mini-volcanologist is a bit obsessed
                                                    with the Mars Rovers, she’s going to love flicking
                                                                                                                          FEATURE

                                                                                                                          Decolonising
                                                                                                                          geosicence
face
                                                    through the pics in this mag: geolsoc.org.uk/
                                                    Geoscientist/December-2020                                            The harrowing deaths of George
                                                                                                                          Floyd and Breonna Taylor in the

coverings
                                                                                                                          United States, and the subsequent rise
                                                    @NEURISA: Who doesn’t want to read about                              of the Black Lives Matter movement
                                                    #Megalodon and #DataEthics? Looks like a great issue                  profoundly affected much of society
                                                    @geoscientistmag!                                                     last summer. One of the most notable
                                                                                                                          outcomes has been organisations,
DEAR EDITORS,                                                                                                             such as our own, investigating the
To my delight the Société                           @Leannes_space: Great article in @geoscientistmag
                                                    about geological data gathering for the Normandy
Géologique de France sent me
                                                    landings, I wonder if ‘auger-gate’ would have meant
their geologically themed face
                                                    requisitioning any of these @BritGeoSurvey augers to
coverings (€5 each or €15 for                       cover their tracks?
all four, and around €3 postage
to the UK). Designed for non-                       @alpeacegeo: why are you cancelling ‘Sticks & Stones’               NEW ONLINE HOME
medical use they can be worn                        from Geoscientist? This is literally the only thing I read        If you enjoy reading Geoscientist
                                                    consistently in the whole magazine!                               magazine, why not visit
for four hours and are machine
                                                                                                                      www.Geoscientist.Online to
washable at 60° C.                                           @geoscientistmag: We miss it too! After
                                                                nearly 20 years our cartoonist decided to             access even more debate,
   Designs include a pair of
                                                                  lay down his pen. You can follow the                news and science? Our newly
cream on black illustrations                                                                                          launched website features an
                                                                   adventures of Dalston and friends at
of the ammonite laevigatus                                                                                            array of additional content,
                                                                    www.stonechatproductions.co.uk
(James Sowerby) from                                                                                                  including geoscience-related
southern England.                                                     @fktodd: Starting young in this                 reports, videos and more. The
                                                                     household #GeoKid #GeologyRocks                  site is mobile-device-friendly,
DAVID NOWELL                                                                                                          so you can read on the go.

      LET TER

   What makes a geologist?
   DEAR EDITORS,                                 was 1/4 of the first year,           The chemistry, physics          Being able to
   With respect to your                          2/3 of the second year,           and maths that took up           communicate is a rare
   editorial piece in October’s                  and full time only in the         the rest of the teaching         skill too, something that
   issue (Geoscientist 30(9),                    last year (this adds up to a      time have been very useful       my English master at
   October 2020), what is a                      little less than two years).      in a commercial career           school stressed.
   geologist anyway? You’ve                      But my last year contained        as a hydrogeologist,               So I’d recommend a
   met the requirements to be                    no palaeontology                  before broadening out            broad first degree – you
   a Fellow of our Society, so I                 whatsoever (my choice) and        into the contaminated            don’t know at that stage
   think you are. I did my first                 I concluded correctly that        land aspects of nuclear          where your career might
   degree at Cambridge, in                       I could avoid answering           decommissioning, and even        take you.
   Natural Sciences, which is                    any exam questions                some of the finer points of
   also modular. Earth science                   about sandstone.                  reactor dismantling.             J O H N H E AT H C O T E

                                                                                                                    GEOSCIENTIST.ONLINE | SPRING 2021              21
You can also read