Going Up - William Hood and Company

Page created by Floyd Wright
 
CONTINUE READING
Going Up - William Hood and Company
ISSUE
                                                                                       #17
                                                                                       JULY 10, 2020

                                                                A Publication of WWD

                         Going Up
Investor interest in wellness deals is accelerating thanks to the global pandemic,
    but their approach is shifting in light of the Black Lives Matter movement.
   For more,see pages 13 and 14. PLUS: Lady Gaga’s new gig and an exclusive look
                      at Patrick Starrr’s soon-to-launch brand.
                           ILLUSTRATION BY MATTHEW BILLINGTON
Going Up - William Hood and Company
THE BUZZ                                                                                                                                                                2

                                                                                                                                                     JULY 10, 2020

                                           Beauty Bulletin
                                                                        Sue Y. Nabi    better position to do so.”
                                                                                          Still, Coty is a very different
                                                                                       company than L’Oréal. “It’s one thing
                                                                                       to have success at L’Oréal, where        By the
                                                                                       you have a very well-oiled machine,”
                                                                                       said Ilya Seglin, managing director      Numbers:
                                                                                       at Threadstone LP. “But she has
                                                                                       no record of a turnaround, which         Skin Care's
                                                                                       is what Coty is. Reviving a brand
                                                                                       is a different skill set than running    Clean
                                                                                       a brand that has momentum and
                                                                                       taking it to the next level.”            Product
                                                                                          Nabi takes the reins at a
                                                                                       moment of change for Coty, which         Claims
                                                                                       inked a deal with KKR in May to          Data suggests a blurring
                                                                                       sell 60 percent ownership of its         line between skin care and
                                                                                       professional and retail hair-care        dermatological trends.
                                                                                       businesses. She will need to             BY JAMES MANSO
                                                                                       manage that transition, as well
                                                                                                                                AS CONSUMER INTEREST grows
                                                                                       as the cost-cutting restructuring
                                                                                                                                in clean beauty, the claims that are
                                                                                       efforts that have been ongoing.
                                                                                                                                most resonant in that category are
                                                                                          In terms of what to turn around,      rippling out to other sectors of skin
                                                                                       analysts agree that her first order      and health care. According to new
                                                                                       of business should be fixing Coty’s      data from Euromonitor International,
                                                                                       Consumer Beauty division, whose          the increased focus on health and
                                                                                       brands include CoverGirl, Max            product safety is impacting the
                                                                                       Factor and Sally Hansen. “The big        dermatological sector in particular,
                                                                                       question is how do you make [those       which encompasses products used

Coty's New CEO:                                                                        brands] relevant,” said Astrachan.
                                                                                       “If you try to dissect the value of
                                                                                                                                to treat conditions like lice. “Given
                                                                                                                                the growing convergence between

Analysts Weigh In                                                                      the stock, most would tell you that      health and beauty, identifying claim
                                                                                                                                overlaps from adjacent categories
                                                                                       the luxury business, the licensed
                                                                                                                                can help players seeking to expand,”
                                                                                       fragrances, is what’s worth the most.
¬ Coty’s   announcement last               Freda of the Estée Lauder Cos. Inc.,                                                 said Kayla Villena, senior beauty
                                                                                       You’re getting the mass consumer         analyst, Euromonitor International.
week that it had signed a deal with        who took home $21.4 million.                business for close to nothing, so if
Kim Kardashian West didn’t come               Analysts laud Nabi’s experience,         she’s able to improve that, you can
as a big surprise to beauty insiders,      but note the executive, who was at          improve the value of the business.”       TOP CLEAN PRODUCT CLAIMS,
but when it named Sue Y. Nabi chief        L’Oréal for 20 years before launching          She will also need to build out                SKIN CARE
executive officer two days later —         her own skin-care brand in 2017,            and internationalize the KKW and           1. no parabens 8.6 percent
now that was a bombshell.                  certainly has her work cut out for          Kylie businesses, for which Coty              2. natural 7.8 percent
  Nabi succeeds Peter Harf, a              her when it comes to transforming           has spent collectively $800 million
founding partner of Coty’s majority        the troubled Coty into the industry                                                   3. fragrance-free 3.4 percent
                                                                                       thus far, as well as strengthen the
owner, JAB, who has moved up to the        leader that Harf and his team               company’s existing relationships           4. no phthalate 2.5 percent
role of executive chairman of Coty.        envisioned five years ago.                  with key licensees.                       5. no mineral oil 1.5 percent
  Nabi is Coty’s ninth ceo in 10 years,       “The market is uncertain, but it’s          As one analyst who spoke not            6. no sulphates 1.5 percent
and its sixth since the company            because of the perpetualness of             for attribution said, “She will have
acquired P&G’s beauty brands in            the change,” said Steph Wissink,                                                     7. no artificial preservatives
                                                                                       to maintain the momentum of the                      1.1 percent
2015 for $12.5 billion. She’s also the     managing director of Jefferies.             luxury business and figure out pretty
only one with significant beauty           “Each new executive brings a                                                              8. no gmo 0.9 percent
                                                                                       quickly why [Gucci parent company]
experience, and the only woman.            slightly different twist to the story.      Kering keeps trashing Coty publicly.        9. no silicone 0.9 percent
  Coty is paying a premium for Nabi’s      Peter’s twist was to get these big          If Kering pulls Gucci, Coty is in deep      10. no artificial colors
experience. She is to receive a base       deals done. The question is, what will      trouble, because that is by far their                0.8 percent
salary of 3 million euros and 10 million   be her thumbprint? What will she do         best brand and the one they have                                      Tk Caption
shares a year in August 2021, 2022         that is unique and different?”              the most ambition for.”                  TOP CLEAN PRODUCT CLAIMS,
and 2023, with half being contributed         On the plus side is Nabi’s                  For her part, Wissink sees the            DERMATOLOGICALS
by JAB, according to a research            background heading up both L’Oréal          first few years of Nabi’s tenure           1. no parabens 4.6 percent
report written by Stifel analyst           Paris and Lancôme. “She’s a graduate        spent on the nuts and bolts of
Mark Astrachan, who examined the           of the University of L’Oréal,” said                                                       2. natural 3.0 percent
                                                                                       the business. Years four and five,
company’s 8-K filings in depth.            Wissink. “What I hear from folks who                                                 3. fragrance-free 2.8 percent
                                                                                       provided she lasts that long, will be
  At Coty’s current stock price, that      have been part of Coty’s organization       the true litmus test. “That’s when         4. no phthalate 1.9 percent
means Nabi’s total compensation            is that there is a hunger to win, but not   we’ll see the new Coty with two          5. no artificial preservatives
over the next three years will equal       necessarily a structure to win.             distinct divisions — consumer and                    1.4 percent
or exceed $140 million.                       “L’Oréal has perfected both,”            luxury — with a reconstituted cost            6. no gmo 0.6 percent
  That puts her in the upper range         Wissink said. “I would expect some          base more aligned with the duality
of beauty ceo salaries, according          of that to shake off on the culture                                                   7. no mineral oil 0.6 percent
                                                                                       of the revenue model,” Wissink said.
to an analysis by WWD Beauty Inc.          at Coty.”                                   “The business should be growing            8. no steroids 0.6 percent
For 2019, the highest-paid ceo was            “She’s a positive relative to what       at that point. Whether it is above or         9. no talcum powder
Alex Gorsky of Johnson & Johnson,          Coty has had,” agreed Astrachan.            below the industry average — that's                 0.5 percent
whose total compensation was               “She has her work cut out for her,          what her scorecard will be ultimately     10. no sulphates 0.4 percent
$25.4 million, followed by Fabrizio        but if anyone can do it, she is in a        graded on.” — Jenny B. Fine
Going Up - William Hood and Company
Going Up - William Hood and Company
NEWS FEED                                                                                                                                                                             4

                                                                                                                                                                  JULY 10, 2020

-EXCLUSIVE-

Lady Gaga to Front Valentino’s New Perfume
The songstress will appear in advertising for the Voce Viva fragrance starting in September. BY JENNIFER WEIL

Lady Gaga                                                                              PARIS — Lady Gaga has landed a                    Lady Gaga said: “Be yourself, love
                                                                                       new, very fashionable, gig — as the             who you are and never give up your
                                                                                       face of Valentino’s upcoming perfume,           dreams.”
                                                                                       WWD Beauty Inc. has learned.                      Garance Delaye, Valentino Beauty
                                                                                         The Voce Viva fragrance, due out              global brand president, told WWD
                                                                                       in September, was conceived by the              Beauty Inc. that the singer was
                                                                                       Valentino fashion house’s creative              their first choice, since she not only
                                                                                       director Pierpaolo Piccioli and the             embodies the values of Valentino —
                                                                                       Valentino Beauty team at L’Oréal.               inclusivity and individuality — but
                                                                                         “Lady Gaga means freedom,                     also the story of Voce Vive, which
                                                                                       self-consciousness, pure heart,”                translates into Living Voice.
                                                                                       Piccioli said in a statement. “Her                Further, Lady Gaga has a strong
                                                                                       participation in this campaign                  personality, Italian roots, is generous
                                                                                       elevates the symbolic power of the              and committed, continued Delaye,
                                                                                       project to the highest level.                   calling her “a great world citizen.”
                                                                                         “She is the icon of a generation,”              Both Valentino and Lady Gaga are
                                                                                       he continued, of the only artist ever           about free personal expression, the
                                                                                       to win in the same year an Oscar,               executive said.
                                                                                       Grammy, BAFTA and Golden Globe,                   Voce Viva is meant to celebrate one’s
                                                                                       for her work in the film “A Star Is             own voice, life, self and style. It is a
                                                                                       Born.” “Her message of freedom,                 perfume for everyone — no specific
                                                                                       passion for art, self-consciousness             gender — according to Delaye, adding
                                                                                       and equality is the same [as what]              Piccioli “doesn’t talk about women or
                                                                                       our Valentino community stands for.”            men, he talks about individuals.”

La Bouche Rouge
Expands Makeup Line
The French label known for its luxury, plastic-
free lipsticks will debut a whole range of eco-chic
cosmetics starting from August. BY SANDRA SALIBIAN
LA BOUCHE ROUGE IS ready to                made of castor bean oils. The wiping
offer its customers more than just         ring is crafted from plant-based
“red lips.”                                materials and a cap of recyclable metal.
   Known for its eco-luxury take on           This was the most challenging
lipsticks, the Paris-based cosmetics       product to realize. “We did not want
brand founded by L’Oréal veteran           to use recycled plastic for the bottle
Nicolas Gerlier in 2017 will expand        or even the brush, as recycled plastic
                                                                                       clockwise from left:
                                                                                                        La Bouche Rouge line; One of the powder refills offered by La Bouche Rouge;
its range starting in August to include    is the exact opposite of sustainability,”   Le Sérum Noir mascara; La Bouche Rouge is expanding its line with eye products and powders.
makeup essentials for eyes as well         Gerlier said. “It is a material that
as powders.                                is still poorly transformed: Most             Prices for the new products range               One of the powder refills offered by
   The products will be developed in       recycling methods still pollute and         from 28 euros for pencils to 59 euros           La Bouche Rouge.
its laboratories near Orléans, France,     create waste.”                              for the compacts.                                 La Bouche Rouge’s core consumers
respecting the label’s sustainable            Other new eye products include Le          The line will be available worldwide          are sophisticated Millennials and
positioning both in terms of natural       Crayon à Sourcil eyebrow pencil and         on La Bouche Rouge's online store               women aged 25 to 45, who Gerlier said
and microplastics-free formulations,       Le Khôl Noir eyeliner, both crafted in      and in niche perfumeries, concept               “aspire to consume differently and are
and refillable and recyclable packaging.   cedar wood and containing castor oil        stores and retailers such as Le Bon             aware of their impact on the planet.”
   “After the lipstick, I wanted to        and squalane, while Le Sérum Sourcil        Marché, Galeries Lafayette and Dover              He would not discuss company
create beautiful, desirable objects        eyebrow serum comprises caviar              Street Market Parfums in Paris;                 sales, but industry experts estimate
that are made to endure and                extract, Japanese microalgue and            Harrods in London; Isetan in Tokyo,             La Bouche Rouge generates net
accompany women all throughout             pistachio oil.                              and Bergdorf Goodman and The                    revenues of 1.5 million euros yearly.
their lives,” said Gerlier, explaining        Another standout item is a               Webster in the U.S.                               The brand’s top markets are France,
the development has taken two years.       universal compact in heavy recyclable         To mark the launch, La Bouche                 Japan and the U.S. It is gearing up to
   “One of our cherished values is to      metal. The single, refillable case can      Rouge will collaborate with fashion             debut in China via the retailer SKP and
be a positive economy project: Luxury      contain powders, such as La Terre           photographer Viviane Sassen for a               to launch on Tmall and in Dubai next.
                                                                                                                                                                                          Gaga photograph by Getty Images

companies should have a positive social,   bronzer, La Lumière highlighter and         “militant shooting project.”                      La Bouche Rouge aims to further
human and environmental impact,” he        Les Ombres eye shadows.                       Collaborations with cool players              expand its product categories in the
continued, underscoring the importance        Like the brand's signature lipsticks,    in beauty and fashion have helped               future.
of eliminating the use of plastic.         the mascara and metal compact can           catapult the brand’s appeal. The label            “From the beginning, we’ve actually
   Among the new products are Le           be covered by polished leather cases,       launched limited-edition lipsticks with         considered makeup as skin care —–
Sérum Noir mascara made of 99              crafted from French company Tanneries       the Self Service and i-D magazines and          we created the first pigmented lip
percent natural ingredients, such as       du Puy's scraps, in various colors. Both    fashion label the Attico, among others.         serum with our lipstick. So naturally,
carnauba wax, that comes in a glass        those and the vegan alternative can be        Gerlier revealed an upcoming project          our next line will be around skin-care
bottle featuring an innovative brush       customized with initials.                   will involve a high jewelry brand.              essentials,” Gerlier said.
Going Up - William Hood and Company
Going Up - William Hood and Company
NEWS FEED                                                                                                                                                                     6

                                                                                                                                                           JULY 10, 2020

Branding Experts Weigh In on ‘Whiteners’
Most say merely changing descriptives of such skin-care products is not enough to educate consumers
about the beauty of diversity. BY JENNIFER WEIL
NOTHING IS ENTIRELY black
and white, especially when it comes
to skin care.
   It might seem otherwise, given how
in the wake of the growing Black Lives
Matter movement, sparked by the
killing of George Floyd in late May, a
number of major multinational beauty
companies quickly announced they
are changing the descriptives of their
brightening and lightening products,
bestsellers today in Asia and other
western markets, like the U.K. and U.S.
   Such adjectives most often
appear on creams and treatments
formulated to make people’s skin
lighter and more even-toned. To
some, this is viewed as conforming
to a western ideal of beauty — often
seeded during colonial times, and
denoting wealth and social status.
   But a number of industry experts
wonder whether it’s enough to
educate consumers about the beauty
of diversity, especially in markets
where there’s a long-standing,
                                                                                                                                                    Fenty's tie-in with Hey Tea.
homogenous ideal and huge appetite
for products that lighten skin tone.
   For beauty companies, such products          Unilever also announced it is           of beauty, but it shouldn’t hurt your       white for Le Blanc skin care and
make up a massive business. The              retooling language used to describe        skin. You should be proud of your skin      light-corrector makeup ranges or
global skin-lightening products market       “whitening” or “lightening” products.      color, whatever complexion you have.        even blue for Le Bleu perfume by
generated $4.08 billion in 2017 and is          Johnson & Johnson said it is            We have this product, but use it in         Chanel,” said the spokeswoman.
expected to practically double, to reach     changing its wording, too, to promote      moderation,” continued Roll. “Leave it         “We therefore have no plans to
$8.01 billion by 2026, according to          “a more inclusive vision of beauty”        to the Asian women to decide.”              change the name of the Le Blanc
Stratistics Market Research Consulting.      and will stop selling the Neutrogena          “The discussion is important for         range, this reference being an
   By country based on skin-lightener        Fine Fairness product line, which          inclusivity, so that the pressure on        integral part of the iconic color
ingredient volume consumption, this          had been marketed in Asia and the          these people, on these kids — the           palette of the Maison Chanel,” she
year China ranks first, with 1,036.2         Middle East, and Clean & Clear             younger girls and boys — goes away,         continued. “Please also note that Le
tons. In Asia, Japan is second, with         Fairness, which was carried in India.      and it becomes a personal choice at         Blanc is never translated into other
745.2 tons, followed by India, with             “It’s actually bringing, more than      the end,” agreed Khera.                     languages, [the same] as Le Rouge,
175.7 tons, Euromonitor International        anything else, at least awareness             She also suggested that brands,          Coco Noir, Bleu and Les Beiges.”
statistics show.                             [of the racism issue],” said Kunika        alongside saying they’ll stop advertising      Advertising is probably the most
   Among the beauty behemoths                Khera, a New Delhi-based director of       whitening products as they had before,      powerful tool to broadcast a beauty
evaluating this category is the Estée        Grail Insights consultancy, referring      possibly instigate outreach actions, like   brand’s inclusive message.
Lauder Cos. Inc.                             to the name changes. “People are           they’ve done with those linked to the          Fenty, the makeup label known for its
   In a statement Wednesday, the             starting to talk about it. So that’s       Black Lives Matter movement.                wide shade palette, has garnered praise
group said its brands “are doing             actually a step in the right direction.”      “They’re setting up donations,           for a recent co-branded line done with
a full review of their products to              Industry experts say it is              they’re helping that community,”            the Hey Tea tea drink chain in China.
ensure they are respectful, inclusive        understandable beauty behemoths            she said. “Similarly, do something          While raising its own visibility, it’s
and culturally sensitive in each of the      responded so fast.                         positive for the narrative to change.”      bolstered awareness about inclusivity.
markets where we do business.”                  “Brands do not want to be caught           Some beauty brands are eschewing            “That’s basically how Chinese
   “Inclusion and diversity are essential    on the wrong side of the fault line,”      adjectives such as “whitening” or           consumers got more familiar with
to our ability to serve consumers            said Martin Roll, a business and           “lightening,” shifting instead to the       this term,” said Remi Blanchard
everywhere they are in the world,”           brand strategist with an expertise         likes of “brightening” and “glow.”          project leader at Daxue Consulting in
said Fabrizio Frieda, president and          in Asia, adding that’s particularly           Chanel describes its Le Blanc            Shanghai. He called the strategy, which
chief executive officer of Estée Lauder.     true today, when factors such as the       beauty products as for unifying             is novel in China, effective in changing
“They are at the center of our values        digital revolution and vocal young         complexions by fighting against             people’s perception of beauty.
and a key enabler of our success. We         consumers make a possible fallout          brown spots and enhancing radiance.            Michael Nolte, creative director
are focused on creating authentic            more magnified and swift than before.         “[It’s] in no case a range of            of BeautyStreams in Paris, referred
products that are locally relevant and       “So they take a stand pretty quickly.”     skin whitening,” said a company             to the Indonesian beauty brand
tailored for many different consumers           Still, more might be done from a        spokeswoman.                                Sariayu’s advertising that featured
around the world based on unique             branding perspective.                         Chanel is not considering changing       two Asian models — one with lighter
desires and preferences, with deep              “I would be very open and very          the line’s moniker, which translates        skin than the other.
respect for celebrating differences          transparent, even before you               to The White.                                  “There are initiatives now where the
around the globe.”                           get into something near crisis                “Many Chanel product lines bear          acceptance of natural skin tones seems
   Less than two weeks prior, L’Oréal        communication,” said Roll.                 the names of Gabrielle Chanel’s             to become more important,” he said.
said it was removing the words “white/          “Maybe for younger consumers,           favorite colors: red for Rouge                 Beauty brands, added Nolte, have
whitening, fair/fairness, light/lightening   it’s to say you have to be careful with    Coco lipsticks, beige for Les Beiges        a responsibility “to tell consumers:
from all of its skin-evening products.”      whitening — we know it’s a notion          makeup range, black for Coco Noir,          ‘You are beautiful the way you are.’”
Going Up - William Hood and Company
P R E S E N T E D        B Y :

                                                                                                                                                                   Aptar Beauty + Home
                                                                                                                                                                        wide selection of
                                                                                                                                                                     dispensing solution
                                                                                                                                                                  products provide value
                                                                                                                                                                    and convenience for
                                                                                                                                                                end-users by anticipating
                                                                                                                                                                    market expectations.

  UNBOXING THE FUTURE
     OF PACKAGING
     Amid rising demand for sustainable solutions and shifts to online retail, Aptar Beauty +
      Home is helping brands offer an improved and more satisfying consumer experience.

D
                  riven by a vision for a        unboxing personal care items.                        “E-commerce has unique potential to        for Aptar Beauty + Home is a two-prong,
                  sustainable future and an         For many consumers, this unboxing              reduce waste in the environment by elim-      meaning expectations of both consumers
                  ever-evolving omnichannel      served as the first impression of a brand. And    inating excessive packaging,” said Erhart.    and brands must be met. Moreover, each
                  world, Aptar Beauty + Home     while this remains true, excess of packing        “For example, expensive ‘romance’ pack-       brand has its own needs as it navigates om-
                  has been a leader behind       paper is now met with disappointment for          aging is no longer required. Products, not    nichannel packaging. Collaboration, there-
                  innovations in dispensers,     a brand’s sustainable values. In fact, Aptar’s    packaging, displayed to consumers, without    fore, is essential.
pumps and other packaging solutions used         consumer survey found 80 percent of con-          visual size comparison, perception across        While brands hold the key to consum-
by many of the world’s leading beauty            sumers felt frustrated with the amount of         products or theft prevention packaging fea-   er communication, Aptar Beauty + Home
brands. Aptar Beauty + Home’s commitment         overwrapping they have received when un-          tures, product reviews and star ratings are   leverages technology expertise to provide
to research and development has also proven      boxing personal care items.                       able to guide the customers first moment of   brands with unique custom dispensing ca-
to be a vital piece for consumers and brands        Still, consumers expect brands to deliv-       seeing the product, or what P&G calls the     pabilities. “We look to our brand partners
as the industry works together to care for       er on a beautiful presentation that has not       ‘Zero moment of truth’.”                      as they are a critical part of our innovation
the planet.                                      undergone a compromise during travel.                                                           development,” said Erhart. “They are the
   And as online sales continue to soar in the   And when a brand sacrifices quality, it can       LUXURY WITHOUT EXCESS                         first line of communication – though not
wake of the COVID-19 outbreak, discerning        result in excessive chargebacks and returns,      When discussing product package develop-      just communication, but interaction, en-
online shoppers are judging not only the         negative reviews, and ultimately a damaged        ment with brands, Erhart said the approach    gagement, touch points – with consumers
quality of a product, but its container and      relationship with retailers and consumers.                                                      and are able to help us understand what
packaging as well. As a result, dispensing and   The challenge is one that has required                                                          the needs and the expected benefits are.
packaging solutions that prevents leakage,       brands to move quickly, as consumers                                                            We also do consumer research, [includ-
disassembly, damages or accidental opening,      have become adept at sharing frustrations                                                       ing] online surveys, in-person and virtu-
has now emerged as white space in the
market where Aptar Beauty + Home is a
                                                 through social media.
                                                    “Your first impression can set a negative
                                                                                                         The panelists                           al studies, and market trend analyses, to
                                                                                                                                                 provide brands with value-added insights
dominating force.                                or positive tone for the rest of the experience
                                                 with the brand,” said Philippe Erhart, presi-
                                                                                                          agreed that                            that may be outside of their scope. The
                                                                                                                                                 mindshare during our meetings truly goes
CONSUMER-DRIVEN DEMAND                           dent of Beauty + Home, North America, at                 the “human                             both ways.”
Years ago, it was common practice for con-       Aptar. “Think of it like a job interview – if                                                      With expectations becoming higher and
sumers to receive luxury beauty products         you show up unpolished, you will most likely           connection” is                           higher, the beauty industry has made bold
wrapped in ample amounts of “protective
packaging” to ensure an uncompromised
                                                 not get a second chance.”
                                                    And further omnichannel packaging has                most critical                           statements and taken on very ambitious goals
                                                                                                                                                 in terms of sustainability and well-rounded
delivery. To better understand these prac-
tices, the demand for leak-proof dispensing
                                                 been found to build trust with customers
                                                 in traditional retail outlets. According to
                                                                                                        in establishing                          omnichannel experiences. And to be sure,
                                                                                                                                                 each company has needs specific to its brand
solutions, and the perception of overpack-
aging experiences with e-commerce unbox-
                                                 Aptar, this is because the omnichannel pack-
                                                 aging delivers leak free functionality with a
                                                                                                           the initial,                          DNA and corporate mission as well as its
                                                                                                                                                 relationship to its consumers.
ings, Aptar surveyed 1168 consumers asking       convenient, single SKU. For brands, omni-                  base-line                               “First and foremost, brands are consid-
for feedback on the unboxing experience.         channel packaging eliminates prep charges,                                                      ering the consumer experience, especially
The survey found that an overwhelming 77         while delivering on consumer expectations,              relationship.”                          now with the huge shift to online retail,”
percent of consumers have experienced this       further optimizing overall growth in the                                                        said Erhart. “It is their first impression –
overwrapping or excessive packaging when         e-commerce channel.                                                                             good or bad– to who they are. This heavily
Going Up - William Hood and Company
P R E S E N T E D         B Y :
                                                                     P R E S E N T E D   B Y :

impacts brands from a perception and cost
value perspective.”
   Brands are also considering supply chain                                                          INNOVATION                                             DISC TOP GO features a
costs. “The traditional supply chain has an
average of four touchpoints through the
                                                       The panelists                                                                                        unique three-piece closure
                                                                                                     Aptar Beauty + Home
process, while an e-commerce supply chain
can increase touchpoints,” said Erhart.
                                                        said social                                  holds many industry
                                                                                                                                                            design and prevents
                                                                                                                                                            accidental actuation in transit

“There is a lot more room for issues to                 media and                                    “firsts.” Here are five
                                                                                                     notable ones:
                                                                                                                                                            with a lockable on-off feature.

occur. Overwrapping, excess packaging and
larger shipping boxes can lead to higher an-            marketing
cillary costs.”
   As a global organization with manufactur-               works
ing facilities in 18 countries, Aptar Beauty +
Home is able to offer global brands dispens-
                                                        best when
ing components where they are formulating
and filling, cutting supply chain costs.
                                                      customers are
                                                      fully engaged.”
RECONSIDERING THE DELIVERY
It is important to note that working with                                                                                   First to market, Aptar’s
some large-scale retailers brands are subject                                                                               LOCK + GO technology is an
to additional new challenges. Amazon, for        lines. Brands are able to utilize the com-                                 e-commerce capable tube top
                                                                                                                            closure with a built-in finger recess.
example, requires that brands maintain cer-      pany’s testing facility to understand what
tain shipping guidelines. The Amazon pack-       potential issues they are facing and learn
aging mission is to have products designed       about dispensing products that will miti-
to reduce waste where Amazon Overbox is          gate any issues.
not required, to use 100 percent recyclable         “We have a unique opportunity to rein-
packaging, to make the consumer experience       vent the packaging that delights consum-             E-CLIP prevents traditional
optimal with “easy to open” gestures, and        ers, reduce waste, and minimize costs,”              dispensing pumps from                    EASY CLIP
to protect products against damage without       said Erhart.                                         breaking in transit or                 is designed to
preparations made by Amazon. Notably, a             As part of its deep commitment to inno-           actuating by accident.                hold a fragrance
package’s carbon footprint can also offset the   vation, Aptar Beauty + Home invests 3 per-                                                     sample in
use of sustainable packaging.                    cent of total revenue back into research and                                                     place.
   In April of 2020, Aptar Beauty + Home         development to continuously provide new
opened its on-site ISTA-6 lab testing fa-        solutions to brand partners. The company
cility to help brands meet Amazon’s guide-       currently holds hundreds of international
lines for ISTA-6 Overbox Testing through         patents on dispensing technology and has                                                                    GLIDE AND APOLLO are
                                                                                                                                                           hoodless aerosol actuators with
the APASS program. Aptar Beauty + Home           launched over 70 new products in the last
                                                                                                                                                               a twist to lock mechanism.
also has pre-qualifying dispensing solu-         three years to meet every brand and retailer
tions to ensure they meet Amazon’s guide-        where they need to be.

PRESTIGE
                                                                                                                                                   WWD Studios: Can you speak to the
                                                                                                                                                   movement away from excess packaging?
                                                                                                                                                   PE: Sustainability at this point is the

PRESENTATION
                                                                                                                                                   norm, an expectation of the consumer.
                                                                                                                                                   Over the past few months, we’ve had the
                                                                                                                                                   opportunity to see our direct impact on
                                                                                                                                                   the environment first-hand. It is critical
                                                                                                                                                   brands look at the unique opportunities
                                                                                                                                                   this provides them to play a part in their
                                                                                                                                                   day-to-day lives.
Through Aptar Beauty + Home, brands are able to walk their                                                                                         WWD Studios: In your own words, how
                                                                                                                                                   does a superior packaging product work
sustainability talk, while meeting consumer’s evolving needs.                                                                                      to maintain trust and loyalty between

F
                                                                                                                                                   brands and their consumers?
      OR PHILIPPE ERHART, president                                                              online orders. The increase of retail pickup      PE: Trust and loyalty are built through
      of Beauty + Home, North America,                                                           and delivery makes it crucial for brands to       extensive interaction between two parties.
      at Aptar, partnering with brands                                                           take every potential touchpoint into con-         Consumers do not have immediate inter-
for a sustainable future goes far beyond                                                         sideration.                                       action with the people behind the brands
dispensing products. With innovation at                                                                                                            – so their products are the representation
its core, Aptar is continually evaluating                                                        WWD Studios: Why is investing in                  or extension of who they are.
manufacturing practices and the impact                                                           higher-quality packaging, created with               Consumers are continually more
on global and local eco-systems, and as                                                          e-commerce in mind, necessary for                 educated and skeptical of advertising
a company has positioned itself to be                                                            brands, especially now?                           and influencers and rely on experiences
well equipped to support partners in the                                                         PE: It is important for brands to take into       from their peers or themselves to make
beauty industry to meet sustainability                                                           consideration the full cradle-to-grave            purchasing decisions. When a brand
goals as well.                                                                                   customer experience. Yes, there is an             considers each component – packaging,
   Excess packaging is no longer a                                                               increase in needs for omnichannel capa-           formula, etc. – as a unique extension of
viable solution for today’s savvy beauty                                                         ble packaging, but also consider – what           who they are it can build credibility that
consumers who demand brands to                                                                   happens after that? How are they being            their story is authentic.
be actively, and transparently, work-                                                            used in and outside the home? How will
ing towards sustainability. And with             Philippe Erhart, president of Beauty +          consumers perceive the value of your              WWD Studios: How can Aptar play a
e-commerce on the rise investing in              Home, North America, Aptar                      brand? Formula and performance are a              role in a brand’s marketing?
high-quality packaging to ship without                                                           key part of this, but high-quality packag-        PE: We pride ourselves on being a
compromise has become table stakes in            beauty brands face are: how to identify         ing is equally important.                         B-to-B-to-C company and put extensive
staying ahead.                                   and execute their needs in regard to sus-                                                         resources and revenues back into under-
   As sustainable and omnichannel                tainability and the need for omnichannel        WWD Studios: How does Aptar part-                 standing how we can provide consumers
product packaging becomes even                   ready packaging. In regard to sustainabil-      ner with brands to address reducing the           with a better-quality experience with their
more crucial to a beauty brand’s growth          ity, each brand has unique needs spe-           waste stream?                                     products – thus in return helping brands
in today’s market, Erhart shares his             cific to their DNA. Some of those needs         PE: We are continually evaluating our             develop value beyond the cost.
perspective and insights into brands’            shared with us include recyclability, reduc-    own products and processes through                   Aptar is also able to help brands sub-
evolving packaging needs, addressing             ing, and repurposing plastics as it relates     the use of life cycle assessments and the         stantiate packaging claims through our
consumer demands, and his vision for a           to the waste stream or how to create reus-      implementation of eco-design. For all             extensive technical capabilities and part-
sustainable future in beauty.                    able packaging platforms.                       innovation moving forward we look at two          nerships with external resources. Some
                                                    The most important component of the          critical components: how do we make the           examples of these are ECO-CERT certi-
WWD Studios: What are the key problem            package for omnichannel needs tends to          product more sustainable and how do               fication, life cycle assessments, e-com-
areas and challenges from a packaging            be the dispensing mechanism. If a pump          we make sure it is e-commerce capable.            merce Capable, and ISTA-6 over box
perspective that beauty brands are facing        breaks in transit or a closure acciden-         Brands are also able to partner with us to        certifications. We are continually expand-
today?                                           tally opens, it can lead to poor customer       perform their own life cycle assessments          ing and evaluating how these capabil-
Philippe Erhart: The two main challenges         experience and costly chargebacks to            and ISTA-6 certifications through our             ities are uniquely used by brands and
Aptar Beauty + Home continually hear             the brand. This applies to more than just       internal programs.                                what we can do to help them.
Going Up - William Hood and Company
NEWS FEED                                                                                                                                                                  9

                                                                                                                                                            JULY 10, 2020

                                                                                                     Mulan lead actress Liu Yifei    are not trying to turn a Black or Asian
                                                                                                     is the global ambassador of     person into a white person. What
                                                                                                        Shiseido. She is holding a
                                                                                                           bottle of White Lucent    most whitening products are doing
                                                                                                    Illuinaing Micro-Spot Serum      is to override the damage caused by
                                                                                                                 in the campaign.
                                                                                                                                     ultraviolet light and internal health
                                                                                                                                     reasons, and prevent the formation of
                                                                                                                                     unnecessary melanin,” he said.
                                                                                                                                        Mia Zhang, editor in chief of
                                                                                                                                     Meiya, a Chinese beauty social
                                                                                                                                     commerce platform with 20
                                                                                                                                     million active users, observes there
                                                                                                                                     are trends within the whitening
                                                                                                                                     category that help to even skin tone,
                                                                                                                                     antioxidation and antiwrinkle on top
                                                                                                                                     of achieving a fairer skin in China.
                                                                                                                                        “The idea of Asians all wanting to
                                                                                                                                     have fairer skins is a bit dated. In
                                                                                                                                     recent years, beauty brands no longer
                                                                                                                                     bluntly say this product will whiten
                                                                                                                                     your skin. Instead, they are using
                                                                                                                                     more technical terms and offering
                                                                                                                                     more targeted solutions. I think if
                                                                                                                                     a brand has to deliver a universal
                                                                                                                                     message across all markets, this is the

Chinese Beauty Industry Experts
                                                                                                                                     way to go. They can use terms like
                                                                                                                                     ‘glowy’ ‘high shine,’ ‘soften dark spots’
                                                                                                                                     and ‘lift up skin tones,’ etc.,” she said.

Defend Whitening Products
                                                                                                                                        Still, nothing will stop Chinese
                                                                                                                                     beauty consumers from finding
                                                                                                                                     ways beyond skin-care products
                                                                                                                                     to look a shade lighter, even if the
The word "whitening" in the West is being discontinued, but in China                                                                 motive behind it is deeply rooted in
consumers are still pursuing the category with vigor despite conversations                                                           uncorrectable colorism.
around colorism. BY TIANWEI ZHANG                                                                                                       “Our users love to discuss what
                                                                                                                                     color of clothes will make them look
LONDON — Major beauty brands                at Vogue China, thinks whitening        from 2021, will further punish                   whiter and which shade of lipstick
are changing how they describe              products’ dominance in China is         mislabeling and tighten                          will complement their fair skin
whitening and lightening skin-              unlikely to change, ever.               new ingredients approval on                      more,” Zhang said.
care products, but is that what                "Due to the racial equality          whitening products.                                 Beauty influencer Scarlett Wei, who
the consumer wants in China, the            movement, the word 'whitening'             It's generally agreed that the all-time       has more than one million followers
category’s largest Asian market?            has become a taboo in the West.         whitening bestsellers in China are               on Xiaohongshu, also believes it's
  “I will still buy 'whitening' or          But for the Chinese market, the         Procter & Gamble's SK-II Genoptics               unnecessary for brands to remove
'brightening' products because I prefer     situation is quite different. Talking   Aura Essence and Genoptics Spot                  these words in China for now.
looking fairer and I don't like the way I   about whitening your skin in China      Essence, and Olay's “little white                   “Skin-whitening is still a hot topic in
look when I am tanned. It has nothing       is just a demand to make the skin       bottles,” ProX Correctiv-White Spot              first-tier cities. With more discussions
to do with me wanting to assimilate         more glowy, translucent and spotless,   Fading Essence, and White Radiance               around skin care than ever on social
to the Western ideal of beauty, wealth      without involving too many social       Light-Perfecting Essence.                        media and the advancement of
and social status, it's just my personal    and historic factors. From my              Chinese brands are catching                   aesthetic medicine, Chinese consumers
preference,” said Fiona Liu, a product      observation, brands have not made       up in this category. Brands like                 know where the limit is with
designer in Shanghai. She is also an        obvious changes with regard to their    HomeFacialPro, Proya and Jala                    whitening skin-care products. They are
amateur beauty vlogger who spends           promotion wording in China, and         Group's Chando, which focus on                   more willing to go through medical
a good amount of her salary on              it now has passed the promotion         emphasizing effective and less                   procedures to achieve an instant and
skin-care products.                         period. So we will have to wait and     harmful whitening ingredients, such              more reliable effect,” Wei said.
  “Reading about what brands are            see what change will be made in the     as niacinamide, vitamin C, kojic acid               And even if Western beauty brands
doing to not seem racist makes              future,” said Zhang.                    and arbutin, also manage to find                 remove whitening products from the
me want to roll my eyes. While I               Brands usually heavily promote       success amid stiff competition.                  shop floor worldwide, the majority
sympathize with women in South Asia         whitening products in China in             Christopher Bu, celebrity makeup              of Chinese consumers are unlikely to
and Africa, or women from minority          March and April. There is an            artist and stylist who has a strong              resonate with this decision and their
backgrounds in Europe and North             old saying in Chinese: “A white         tie with Chinese celebrities like                Chinese and other Asian competitors
America using toxic chemicals for           complexion is powerful enough           Fan Bingbing and Zhang Yuqi, said                will just gratefully take over the
extreme skin bleaching to fit into          to hide seven faults,” and that has     HomeFacialPro's Three Percent                    market share from there.
the unrealistic beauty standard, the        become the gold standard of beauty      Niacinamide Essence has capitalized                 That said, is there room for a more
Chinese beauty standard is very             since ancient times. Many brands        on the livestreaming trend in China              diverse beauty standard in China?
achievable. Most of the Chinese people      introduce Asia-only products to cater   to generate sizable online buzz.                 Makeup artist and beauty influencer
are naturally born with fair skin,” she     to the strong demand.                      Bu added that brands shouldn't                Melilim Fu believes so. She observes
continued. “With the right amount of           While the word whitening is not      rush their decision to remove                    that there is indeed a rising number
sunscreen, hydration and skin-care          a taboo, some have been adjusting       whitening labels just to be politically          of consumers who are beginning
products, you can easily sustain that.”     terms due to updates in regulations.    correct and let the Chinese                      to embrace their natural skin tone,
  China is the largest market for skin-     Advertising Law of the People's         consumers feel they become the                   and even willing to experiment with
whitening products and is projected         Republic of China now rules that        casualty because of this.                        tanning products.
to reach an estimated size of $2.5          skin-care product labeling cannot          Andy Koh, a makeup legend with                   “I personally believe one's beauty
billion by 2027, with a compound            include any suggestive description      decades of experience in the Chinese             should not come from just one shade
annual growth rate of 8 percent,            or claim to have medical effects, and   beauty industry, agrees with Bu.                 of skin tone, she said. “But the
according to Global Industry Analysts.      the new Cosmetics Supervision and       “There are so many misconceptions                Chinese beauty market as a whole is
  Valerie Zhang, beauty director            Administration Regulation, effective    around the whitening products. They              unlikely to change anytime soon.”
Going Up - William Hood and Company
The most comprehensive
text message marketing solution
Make personalized text messaging one of your top 3
revenue sources in just 3 months with Attentive®

    99%                          30%+                             25x+
     Open rates                 Click-through rates                     ROI

           Join Attentive at Beauty Inc’s Wellness Virtual Conference on July 15th
           Learn how beauty & wellness brands are using SMS to create authentic
           connections and drive revenue during a changing consumer landscape.

          1,000+ leading brands and organizations rely on Attentive
WEEKLY ROUNDUP                                                                                                                                                        11

                                                                                                                                                        JULY 10, 2020

                           The Latest From WWD                  Fashion.Finance.Media.Retail.

                                                                                                       Brooks Brothers Files
                                                                                                       For Bankruptcy
                                                                                                       ¬ Brooks   Brothers                Brooks’ largest creditor is
                                                                                                       succumbed to its debts             Swiss Garments Co., which
                                                                                                       and filed for bankruptcy in        is owed $5.2 million.
                                                                                                       Delaware.                             In addition to WHP Global,
                                                                                                          The company listed both         sources have said Authentic
                                                                          FACEBOOK'S                   its assets and liabilities         Brands Group, in partnership

                                                                           NEW CIVIL                   as ranging between $500
                                                                                                       million and $1 billion. Brooks
                                                                                                                                          with Simon Property Group
                                                                                                                                          and Brookfield Property
                                                                            RIGHTS                     Brothers entered the               Partners, is also interested in
                                                                             AUDIT                     process with $75 million
                                                                                                       in debtor-in-possession
                                                                                                                                          acquiring the business.
                                                                                                                                          “Prior to COVID-19, we
                                                                             ¬ Facebook’s own          financing obtained from            were already conducting
                                                                            auditor on civil rights    WHP Global, the newly              an evaluation of various
                                                                           and related issues like     formed brand management            strategic options to position
                                     The Burdifilek designed Shinsegae
                                                                           hate speech has found       firm headed by Yehuda              the company,” said Claudio
                                                Chicor in Daegu, Korea.
                                                                                                       Shmidman that is interested        Del Vecchio, chairman and
                                                                              the platform to be
                                                                                                       in acquiring the business.         ceo. — WWD Staff
Intercos Group Takes Over                                                  lacking in meaningful
                                                                             change, and to have
Shinsegae Joint Venture                                                        even harmed the
                                                                           progress of civil rights
¬ Leading cosmetics                the area and a global center                    in the U.S.
manufacturer Intercos Group        of excellence for categories               The statement came
said Wednesday it has              including foundations and
                                                                          amid an ad boycott over
taken over the joint venture       skin care.
                                                                           Facebook’s allowance
it created with fashion and           The equal joint venture
                                   was formed in 2015 to allow
                                                                              and promotion of
beauty retailer Shinsegae
International by acquiring         Intercos to enter the market               hate speech on its
the remaining 50 percent           and build local manufacturing              platforms, and just
of Shinsegae Intercos Korea        activities and to enable                one day after founder

                                                                                                       Levi Strauss Lays Off 15

                                                                                                                                                                            Levi's photograph by George Chinsee; Facebook by Lodi Franck/SIPA/Shutterstock; Penny's by Lennihan/AP/REX/Shutterstock
Inc. Financial details were        Shinsegae to strengthen the             Mark Zuckerberg met
not disclosed.                     position and innovation rate of           with the civil rights
   The operation mirrors
Intercos’ strategy of further
                                   its brands. The two companies
                                   said they are committed to
                                                                              groups behind the
                                                                              boycott (which the
                                                                                                       Percent of Corporate Staff
investing in the country,          maintaining their collaboration           groups claimed was        ¬ Levi  Strauss & Co. is           fact that we know we’re going
leveraging Intercos Korea as       by continuing to develop and             essentially pointless).    preparing for a long slog          to be a smaller business as
a key hub for Asia since it will   launch products under the                  The auditor Laura        through the coronavirus,           we go through this crisis,”
become its main research           Shinsegae brands.                                                   cutting 15 percent of its          Chip Bergh, ceo, told WWD.
                                                                          Murphy, is disappointed
and development center for         — Sandra Salibian                                                   corporate workforce.               “We’re expecting that the
                                                                            in Facebook’s lack of
                                                                                                          The denim giant will have       recovery could potentially
                                                                           progress on issues like
                                                                                                       fewer designers as it tightens     take a number of quarters.”
                                                                          the proliferation of hate
Nordstrom Streamlines;                                                       speech, racism and
                                                                                                       its product offering and
                                                                                                       wholesale operations will
                                                                                                                                             The company burned
                                                                                                                                          through $160 million in cash,
                                                                              voter suppression.
J.C. Penney Shutters Stores                                                     “While the audit
                                                                                                       shrink, while a quickly growing
                                                                                                       e-commerce business
                                                                                                                                          but has sold new bonds,
                                                                                                                                          enhancing its liquidity to $2
¬ The pandemic is                                                              process has been        means more spending on             billion, according to chief
accelerating change                                                          meaningful, and has       artificial intelligence and data   financial officer Harmit Singh.
at Nordstrom Inc.                                                          led to some significant     analytics and the company’s           In June, the company was
  Executives see Nordstrom’s                                                improvements in the        own retail business will           cashflow positive once more
full-line department stores                                                platform, we have also      continue to be a priority.         and has enough cash to last
representing a smaller but                                                 watched the company            “This is particularly           through 12-plus months.
still big piece of its pie; Rack                                                                       difficult, but it reflects the     — Evan Clark
                                                                           make painful decisions
off-price stores adopting                                                      over the last nine
services and conveniences          through our physical stores            months with real-world
seen at full-line stores, and a    given the sensibilities people          consequences that are
holiday 2020 assortment with       have around COVID-19.”                 serious setbacks for civil
a greater proportion of lower-        Also making changes is
priced goods.
                                                                            rights,” Murphy said.
                                   J.C. Penney Co. Inc., which
  For Christmas, “We are                                                      Facebook is also said
                                   has added its New York City
going to have more inventory       Manhattan Mall store to
                                                                          to be starting this year a
at lower prices.” said Pete        its list of closures amid its           separate independent
Nordstrom, president and chief     bankruptcy proceedings,                    audit of its current
brand officer. “The wild card is   which started on May 15.                  system for handling
going to be the traffic we get     — David Moin                            hate speech. — Kali Hays
Digital Event

Keeping Pace:
How to Build, Nurture, and Evolve
Strategy in the Age of Ecommerce

Tuesday, July 14 | 3:00pm BST / 10:00am EDT

Social media is now an essential ecommerce avenue. To effectively reach and connect with
consumers across touchpoints, brands need to innovate—whether by embracing and doubling
down on popular channels like Instagram and TikTok, pivoting content to reflect cultural shifts,
or streamlining digital offerings to best meet demand. Join Dash Hudson and The Inkey List for
an in-depth discussion on how to strike the perfect balance between community and commerce
in the online economy.

Here’s What You’ll Learn:

• Tactics brands can execute now to thrive in this fast-paced ecommerce environment

• How to adopt data analysis and AI technology in the content creation process
   for rapid insights you need to succeed

• How to build community and lead the way on social through creativity, authenticity,
   and innovation

     Register Now

                                                         Built for the discerning. Create, measure, predict, and publish photos and videos.
                                                         See trends, analyze, and enhance performance across organic and paid
                                                         marketing channels.
DEEP DIVE                                                                                                                                  13

                                                                                                                           JULY 10, 2020

                                                                                        Tk Caption
                                                                                                     “I want the venture
                                                                                                       community to do
                                                                                                      the work, and that
                                                                                                        is giving access
                                                                                                      to Black founders
                                                                                                     within wellness. The
                                                                                                      talent is there, the
                                                                                                       product is there,
                                                                                                       the founders are
                                                                                                       there, so there's
                                                                                                      really no excuse.”
                                                                                                        ‑kelly dill , imaginary ventures

                                                                                                        Experts agree that COVID-19
                                                                                                     isn’t the only major shift in 2020
                                                                                                     that’s going to affect M&A in the
                                                                                                     traditionally white-dominated wellness
                                                                                                     world. The surge in the Black Lives
                                                                                                     Matter movement prompted by the
                                                                                                     police killing of George Floyd is also
                                                                                                     changing the landscape — shifting
                                                                                                     both consumer dollars and investor
                                                                                                     attention to Black-owned wellness
                                                                                                     businesses, but also consumer
                                                                                                     consciousness around business
                                                                                                     practices like diversity and inclusion.
                                                                                                        “The movement has exposed
                                                                                                     how under-represented the [Black]
                                                                                                     community is from multiple
                                                                                                     directions — the number of Black-
                                                                                                     owned businesses, the number of
                                                                                                     Black employees in companies, the

During
                                                           THE CORONAVIRUS pandemic                  number of brands truly serving the
                                                           has put a damper on a lot of things,      Black consumer and so forth — and
                                                           but wellness M&A is not one of them.      is holding companies accountable for

Coronavirus,
                                                             Consumer interest in being healthy      effecting change,” said Janki Gandhi,
                                                           has never been higher, experts agree,     managing director at Goldman Sachs.
                                                           and during the COVID-19 pandemic          “It has already triggered a major push

Investment
                                                           that has translated into higher sales     to invest in and spend money with the
                                                           in categories like supplements, at-       types of businesses mentioned and we
                                                           home fitness and self-care. Deals         anticipate that diversity will remain

Money Floods
                                                           have followed, with Lululemon             top of mind for investors and buyers
                                                           paying $500 million for Mirror, an        going forward and will become a part
                                                           interactive at-home fitness service,      of how they assess an opportunity.”
                                                           Grove Collaborative acquiring                Where consumers go, investors

Into Wellness
                                                           Sundaily, a gummy supplement brand        follow, pointed out Robin Tsai, a
                                                           centered around skin health, and          general partner at private equity firm
                                                           Nestlé Health Science agreeing to         VMG, which backs better-for-you
COVID-19 isn’t the only thing changing the way investors   buy a majority stake in Vital Proteins,   food, beverage and beauty businesses,
look at wellness deals — the Black Lives Matter movement   which makes collagen supplements,         including Briogeo.
                                                           beverages and food products.                 “Strategics and private equity and
also has some reassessing their investment strategies.       “Wellness has become the number-        everybody follows consumers, so I’d
BY ALLISON COLLINS AND ELLEN THOMAS                        one priority for consumers through        expect that there’s going to be more
ILLUSTRATION BY MATTHEW BILLINGTON
                                                           COVID-19, and likely to remain            activity in the [wellness] space,” Tsai
                                                           the top priority for consumers            said. “There’s beauty wellness, but
                                                           after COVID-19,” said William S.          there’s also physical-fitness wellness.
                                                           Hood, founder and chief executive         Wellness sits in a Whole Foods, it sits
                                                           officer of William Hood & Co., an         in a GNC, it sits in Sephora and Ulta
                                                           investment bank that specializes          — there aren’t that many categories
                                                           in the supplements space. “Any            that do that.”
                                                           consumer product that functions as           COVID-19 "has created a
                                                           an ingredient to a healthy lifestyle      structural change in the amount of
                                                           has generally performed well              interest in the space," agreed Coye
                                                           through COVID-19 and is positioned        Nokes, partner at OC&C Strategy
                                                           to perform very well [going               Consultants. And while other
                                                           forward]. Obviously supplements           consumer-facing categories have
                                                           are one ingredient, but others [are]      struggled due to retail closures and
                                                           functional food and home fitness.”        changes to consumer spending,„
DEEP DIVE                                                                                                                                                                                14

                                                                                                                                                                       JULY 10, 2020

wellness has “been pretty resilient, if                                                  demonstrated staying power in                      role in dealmaking processes. Some
not growing, as a result of the COVID                                                    consumer consciousness, data shows.                experts say that M&A activity may get
situation,” Nokes said.
   Sources said there are a number
                                                Key                                      Searches for vitamin D, for example,
                                                                                         are holding steadily above where
                                                                                                                                            tougher for brands that may not have
                                                                                                                                            had a hard time getting a deal done
of deals in the market right now.
Two names being cited are Tonal,                Takeaways                                they were at this time last year,
                                                                                         Google Trends data compiled by
                                                                                                                                            pre-COVID-19.
                                                                                                                                               “Brands that have grown rapidly
another at-home fitness system and                                                       Jefferies shows.                                   through COVID-19 will generate strategic
service, and nutritional supplement             1. Wellness M&A has                         Data from Jefferies also showed                 valuations,” said Hood. “Even though
                                                continued through COVID-19 and
manufacturer Adaptive Health. Tonal                                                      a massive spike in Google searches                 it’s explainable, a brand that flatlined
                                                is only expected to accelerate,
declined to comment for this story.             especially in categories such as         for “Black-owned brands” in June,                  or declined during the pandemic is not
While dealmaking in other consumer              supplements, online fitness and          and that brands like Briogeo and                   considered a strategic asset — those
categories stalled in the early days            better-for-you consumer goods            Golde, which are both Black-owned                  businesses will be impacted.”
of the pandemic, wellness was not               geared toward Millennial moms.           and wellness-oriented, saw web visit                  A different financial source added
one of them, sources said, and many                                                      upticks in early June.                             that companies that decide to go
                                                2. The Black Lives Matter
transaction conversations that would                                                        Some investors said that the Black              through deal processes this year will
                                                movement is expected to have
normally have been held in person               a lasting effect on the wellness         Lives Matter movement is likely to                 be left defending their numbers no
have merely transitioned onto Zoom.             category. Consumers are                  shift the way brands are scrutinized,              matter what — prospective investors
   Interest in wellness-oriented                paying attention to company              as well as the way private equity                  are likely to attribute both sales
companies is broad, sources said, and           practices around diversity and           firms and venture capitalists allocate             spikes and declines to COVID-19,
spans supplements, immunity, over-              inclusion, and investors say they        money in the wellness community,                   and to be looking for an idea of what
the-counter medications, telemedicine,          will do more to invest in Black-            It’s no longer enough for businesses            steady-state figures may look like.
                                                owned wellness brands.
fitness services and products and                                                        to simply use Black models. “It has                   The distribution investors are
Millennial mom products, meaning                3. Brands with a strong digital          to be 360 — you cannot just rely on                looking for has changed, too, with
cleanly formulated versions of                  presence and online sales are            representation in imagery or people                less of a focus on retail distribution,
motherhood staples, like Frida Mom’s            going to be more attractive              will be talking on Instagram and                   according to Franklin Isaacson,
post-partum care kits and Natalist’s            to investors as consumers                Twitter, said Lucie Greene, trend                  founding partner at Coefficient
prenatal vitamins and pregnancy tests.          continue to be wary of in-store          forecaster and strategist. “Are there              Capital. Even as wellness trends have
                                                shopping throughout the global
   Strategic buyers are focused on                                                       any people of color on your board                  taken off, vitamin and supplements
                                                pandemic.
consumer health, and wellness,                                                           or in your executive leadership? Is                retailer GNC filed for bankruptcy
broadly speaking, continues to be a                                                      there a pay disparity? With this era of            earlier this year with plans to close
high priority to them as it relates to                                                   hyper-transparency, this has already               up to 1,200 stores.
where they're looking to do deals and        encourage repeat visits will be more        started to go even further, given the                 Isaacson said he’ll be looking for
where they're going to invest dollars,       attractive to investors, the source         core consumer is more ethnically                   consumer wellness brands that don’t
said Susan Roddy, managing director          noted. “How sustained is the loyalty?       diverse than ever.”                                solely rely on retail, have affordable
at Houlihan Lokey.                           These [platforms] need to create               “Wellness is one of those things that           price points, and have proven efficacy,
   “For strategics, getting access to that   real businesses, or you’ll see that         doesn’t discriminate. Everyone’s trying            in anticipation of a consumer with
Millennial mom is so critical,” Roddy        same switching behavior you see in          to be a little better,” Tsai said. “We in          less disposable income and little
said, noting that moms are behind            boutique fitness.”                          general would love to be supportive of             desire to shop in-store.
most household purchasing decisions             A fitness industry report from           the [BLM] movement, be supportive of                  “We want brands that are doing a
and are often the first entry point into     Houlihan Lokey noted that there’s a         founders, be supportive of consumers               good job overcoming all the barriers
a family. “Many strategics have very         strong possibility of fitness enthusiasts   along that bent, too.”                             that exist today,” said Isaacson. “The
old, tired brands that resonate with         trading down for both COVID-19                 “I'm optimistic with an asterisk,”              consumer is going to think twice
50- and 60-year old women but not            safety and financial reasons. “There        Dill said, when asked about the role               about that $80 jar of supplements
with 20- and 30-year old women...that        is also a possibility that consumers        the BLM movement will have on the                  that promises to firm up skin.”
younger demographic is much more             will shift away from more expensive         wellness industry in dealmaking. “I                   Hood noted that having experienced
educated and focused on wellness for         boutique offerings or full-service gyms     want to do the work to make sure that              founders who are “strong” and
herself and her family than anyone           to those offering a high-value, low-        happens. I want Imaginary to do the                “disciplined” is going to be critical
was prior to her.”                           price model,” the report states.            work. I want the venture community to              for deal-seeking brands, especially
   Brands to watch in that space                That shift is likely to result in        do the work, and that is giving access             in an era where accountability at the
include SmartyPants, a vitamin               restructuring and bankruptcies, as          to Black founders within wellness. The             hands of the consumer has never
business; Mommy's Bliss, a mom-              well as consolidation. “We believe          talent is there, the product is there, the         been higher. “Are they doing the
and-baby medication business, and            certain fitness providers and/or            founders are there, so there's really no           right things and able to manage the
Beekeeper's Naturals, which makes            financial investors will seize the          excuse,” Dilll said.                               business the right way?”
honey-oriented throat sprays and             opportunity to acquire companies               How brands have navigated                          “Mission-driven businesses are going
other products, sources said.                at discounted valuations when               through 2020 is likely to play a big               to perform very well,” Hood said. ■
   More broadly in wellness, sources         compared to those observed before
called out brands like superfood             the crisis,” the Houlihan report states.
blend brand Golde, adaptogenic                  While consumers may be
wellness brand Moon Juice,                   temporarily ditching their gyms, they
Wellements baby vitamins, and Nuun           aren’t ditching wellness routines
hydration tablets, as potentially            overall, experts agree.
interesting to investors or buyers.             “Consumer behavior is changing.
   Many investors also vocalized             The one place they’re going to
interest in online fitness platforms,        continue to invest and not pull back
like Obe.                                    on likely is wellness,” said Kelly Dill,
   “Fitness will be forced to come back      principal at venture capital firm
in a different manner, largely at the        Imaginary Ventures, which backs
expense of gyms and boutique studios”        supplements line Hum Nutrition,
said an investor whose portfolio             baby food offering Cerebelly and
includes chain fitness studios. “There       fitness app Fitplan. “We’ve realized
may be no more 60-seat spin studios.”        how important immunity and self-
   While a plethora of online fitness        care and taking care of yourself is in
options has emerged since mid-               all of this, so if you’re going to pull
March, when many in the U.S.                 back on one thing, it’s probably not
started working from home, the ones          your health and wellness.”
that are able to foster loyalty and             Supplements in particular have           Vital Proteins is one of several wellness brands to have scored a major investment deal recently.
You can also read