How to Invest in Medtech - In the age of AI - plus...

Page created by Emma Mack
 
CONTINUE READING
How to Invest in Medtech - In the age of AI - plus...
Issue 57 – december 2019                            www.masterinvestor.co.uk

The UK's no.1 free investment publication

How to Invest in
Medtech
In the age of AI

plus...
Greggs on the go
CAN THE BAKER CONTINUE TO RISE?

The best and worst funds of 2019
CAN THEY PROVIDE ANY POINTERS FOR 2020?

I’m an investor get me out of here!
CAN ITV’S WOES BE OVERCOME?

Mellon on the Markets
WHY THE MASTER INVESTOR IS BUYING DIVIDEND STOCKS
How to Invest in Medtech - In the age of AI - plus...
MASTER INVESTOR SHOW 2020

                                                                      TICKET
                                                                    AVAILA S
                                                                          BLE
                                                                      NOW

                 CONNECTING COMPANIES WITH investors

              GET INSPIRATION
                FOR YOUR INVESTMENT PORTFOLIO AT                           BOOK YOUR
                                                                              free
              MASTER INVESTOR SHOW 2020                                      TICKET
                        SATURDAY, 28 MARCH 2020                          (reg. price £20)
HOSTED IN
              • Join up to 5,000 fellow investors at our flagship
LONDON          investment event.
                                                                           Enter discount
BUSINESS
              • Talk directly to CEOs of companies you can invest in.       code: Mag12
DESIGN
              • Hear the UK‘s leading entrepreneurs and fund managers       http://ow.ly/
CENTRE,         speak about future trends.                                 cXxq50wWioM
ISLINGTON
N1 oQH

            FIND OUT MORE ABOUT THE SHOW AT www.masterinvestorshow.co.uk
How to Invest in Medtech - In the age of AI - plus...
WELCOME
                                         Dear Reader,

                                 Last month, I was lucky enough to be able to
                                 interview Lord Lee of Trafford, the UK's first
                                 recorded ISA millionaire. Before switching to the Lib
                                 Dems and becoming a peer, Lord Lee was a minister
                                 in Margaret Thatcher's government, and outside
                                 politics he has had a very interesting and successful
                                 career in finance and investment. A lifelong investor,
   Lord Lee is also probably one of the most successful private investors I've ever
   met.
       I would heartily recommend Lord Lee's book, How to Make a Million Slowly,
   to anyone who is serious about investing. Lee reminds us that investing – real                                    CONTACTS
   investing as opposed to day trading or speculating – is a marathon not a sprint.
                                                                                                                     Advertising
   Moreover, and perhaps most encouragingly for those of us who struggle with                                        amanda@masterinvestor.co.uk
   numbers, one needn't be overly clever to be a successful investor; but what is
   needed is patience and common sense – in that order, says Lee.                                                    Editorial Enquries
       Lord Lee favours what he terms "proprietorial" businesses where                                               james.faulkner@masterinvestor.co.uk
   management and/or the founding family have a large shareholding and can
   help "steward" the business through good times and bad. The implication is
   that owner-managers with "skin in the game" often do a much better job when
                                                                                                                     FOLLOW US
   it comes to making decisions in the long-term interests of shareholders – with
   whom their interests are obviously very well aligned.
       To me, Lord Lee's investing style is a reminder that as investors we should
   play the long game and try not to get distracted by short-term movements, fads
   or indeed political gyrations. Understand what you're investing in, what makes
   it special and why you're holding it; buy at a good price; and sit back, relax and
   wait for value to out.
       You can listen to the full interview with Lord Lee here.
       As always, I wish you the best of luck for the month ahead.                                                   exclusive book offer
   Best regards,                                                                                                                                         To get 20% off on
                                                                                                                                                         Derivatives in a
   J Faulkner                                                                                                                                            Day
   Editor                                                                                                                                                CLICK HERE
                                                                                                                                                         and use the
                                                                                                                                                         promo code:

                                                                                                                                                         MASTERBOOK

                                                                                                                     Code can only be used on the Harriman House
                                                                                                                     website. Minimum order of £5 required. P&P will
                                                                                                                     be added at the checkout.

                   CLICK HERE TO                                               WANT TO                                If you think you have what takes to be a
                                                                                                                      Master Investor contributor then email us at
                   SUBSCRIBE                                                   CONTRiBUTE?                            admin@masterinvestor.co.uk

   Master Investor Ltd.                    Editorial Contributors              Disclaimer
   Unit 2, The IO Centre                   Filipe R. Costa      Mark Watson-
                                                                               Material contained within the Master Investor Magazine and its website is for general information
   Salbrook Industrial Estate                                                  purposes only and is not intended to be relied upon by individual readers in making (or refraining
                                           Richard Gill, CFA    Mitchell       from making) any specific investment decision. Master Investor Magazine Ltd. does not accept any
   Salbrook Road                           James Henderson                     liability for any loss suffered by any user as a result of any such decision. Please note that the prices
   Salfords                                Victor Hill                         of shares, spreadbets and CFDs can rise and fall sharply and you may not get back the money you
   Redhill RH1 5GJ                                                             originally invested, particularly where these investments are leveraged. Smaller companies with a
                                           David Jones                         short track record tend to be more risky than larger, well established companies. The investments
   United Kingdom                          John Kingham                        and services mentioned in this publication will not be suitable for all readers. You should assess the
                                           Andrew Latto, CFA                   suitability of the recommendations (implicit or otherwise), investments and services mentioned in
                                                                               this magazine, and the related website, to your own circumstances. If you have any doubts about the
   Editorial                               Jim Mellon                          suitability of any investment or service, you should take appropriate professional advice. The views and
   Editorial Director James Faulkner       Tim Price                           recommendations in this publication are based on information from a variety of sources. Although
   Sub Editor Fiona Nicolson               Robert Stephens, CFA                these are believed to be reliable, we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information
                                                                               herein. As a matter of policy, Master Investor Magazine openly discloses that our contributors may
   Creative Director Alexandra Mueller     Nick Sudbury                        have interests in investments and/or providers of services referred to in this publication.

www.masterinvestor.co.uk | Master Investor is a registered trademark of Master Investor Limited ISSUE 57 – DECEMBER 2019 | 3
How to Invest in Medtech - In the age of AI - plus...
CONTENTS
       Issue 57 – december 2019                            www.masterinvestor.co.uk

                                                                                       ISSUE 57 – DECEMBER 2019
       The UK's no.1 free investment publication

       How to Invest in
       Medtech
       In the age of AI                                                                 CoVER FEATURE
       plus...
       Greggs on the go
                                                                                      010     Medical technology in the age of AI
       CAN THE BAKER CONTINUE TO RISE?
                                                                                      Victor Hill explains how the future of healthcare might belong to the engineers
       The best and worst funds of 2019
       CAN THEY PROVIDE ANY POINTERS FOR 2020?
                                                                                      rather than the medics.
       I’m an investor get me out of here!
       CAN ITV’S WOES BE OVERCOME?

       Mellon on the Markets
       WHY THE MASTER INVESTOR IS BUYING DIVIDEND STOCKS

  on the cover
006        Mellon on the Markets

Inside the mind of the Master Investor:
Influential British investor Jim Mellon
reveals his latest thoughts on the
markets.

046        Funds and Trusts in
           Focus – The best and
           worst performing funds
           of 2019

After another roller coaster year, Nick
Sudbury examines the best and worst                                                     All other topics
performing funds of 2019 to see if they
can provide any pointers for 2020.
                                                                                      020     Portfolio Intelligence – The IPO market: Alive and kicking
                                                                                              or barely breathing?

062        Quality Investor –
           Greggs on the go                                                           The IPO market has had a tough time of late. But there are some interesting
                                                                                      goings-on that investors should be aware of. Mark Watson-Mitchell investigates.
Greggs has shown a remarkable
trading and share-price performance of
late – but can it continue? Andrew Latto
investigates.

070        Stocks in Focus – ITV:
           challenges and
           opportunities

Robert Stephens discusses how ITV's
ongoing financial challenges could
provide long-term investors with a
buying opportunity.

                                                                                      026     From Acorns to Oak Trees – Choice IPOs to boost your
                                                                                              portfolio

                                                                                      Regardless of the dearth of new listings, there are still a number of recent issues
                                                                                      which are worthy of consideration. Richard Gill, CFA, looks at two of them.

4 | ISSUE 57 – DECEMBER 2019 Master Investor is a registered trademark of Master Investor Limited | www.masterinvestor.co.uk
How to Invest in Medtech - In the age of AI - plus...
032     PARTNER CONTENT – Is the UK doomed without big tech
          players?
                                                                                            074     Book Review –
                                                                                                    Derivatives in a Day

  Fund manager James Henderson challenges the consensus that the UK is destined to          Richard Gill reviews Derivatives in a
  lag behind the US, owing to the absence of large-cap tech companies.                      Day, a book which provides investors
                                                                                            and finance professionals with an
                                                                                            introduction to what can often be seen
  034     The Macro Investor – How to play the steepening of the
          yield curve
                                                                                            as a complicated market.

  As the cycle lengthens, investors should prepare to jump ship from the equity
  market towards the safety of bonds. In the meantime, they can set a curve-
  steepener trade.

                                              Country Gate Productions / Shutterstock.com

  040     Chart Navigator – How to read the most basic charting
          signals

  Trend following is the core principle of charting but so many traders and investors       078     The Final Word –
                                                                                                    A great deal of ruin
  seem to forget just how powerful it can be, writes David Jones.
                                                                                            The December General Election will
                                                                                            arguably be the most important in
 052      Dividend Hunter – Marks & Spencer: the destroyer of
          shareholder value
                                                                                            our lifetime. Its implications, both
                                                                                            economically and politically, will be
                                                                                            profound, argues Tim Price.
 John Kingham of UK Value Investor explains why Marks & Spencer has been a
 long-term destroyer of shareholder value and reveals how you can avoid investing
 in similar situations.

                                                                                            082     Investor Events Diary

                                                                                            All the hottest upcoming investor
                                                             Sorbis / Shutterstock.com      events in December and beyond.

  058     Forensic Forex – Has gold lost its shine?

  The summer saw some sharp moves in precious metals, as investors fretted about            084     Markets in Focus

  economic uncertainty – but since then these markets have drifted. Is there still a        Market data for the month of
  reason for investors to buy gold?                                                         November.

www.masterinvestor.co.uk | Master Investor is a registered trademark of Master Investor Limited ISSUE 57 – DECEMBER 2019 | 5
How to Invest in Medtech - In the age of AI - plus...
BY JIM MELLON

            mellon on
           the markets
    Inside the mind of the Master Investor: influential British investor, Jim Mellon, reveals his
    latest thoughts on the markets.

    It's been a busy old month, what               But while we wait for sufficient         Janus Henderson, the fund
    with Longevity Week and in                  companies to become investible           managers, have pointed out that
    particular the Longevity Forum in           in these areas – and they will – we      global dividends have continued
    London, the MoneyWeek Wealth                need to make some money for our          to rise, even as earnings have
    Summit and a shareholder meeting            daily bread.                             stalled. Globally, they forecast
    for Juvenescence. Coupled with                                                       that dividends will grow a shade
    some stuff on Agronomics, it's              Earning our daily bread                  under 9% in 2019, to £1.1 trillion
    been exhausting and I am looking            Regular readers will know that I         – approximately a payout of 46%
    forward to a week of gentle book            favour dividend yielding stocks          of total global earnings. This is a
    editing in Berlin. After that, I'm off to   over internet-based growth stocks        comfortable ratio but disguises
    the US for two conferences – then           currently; that I disdain low yielding   some examples of companies
    the Christmas round of joy and              bonds; and that I am a big fan           where so-called dividend cover,
    (mostly) happiness!                         of gold and silver. Unless there         which is the capacity of companies
        At the MoneyWeek summit, and            is a collapse in earnings across         to continue paying generous
    at our own company's quarterly              the board, due to some massive           dividends, is perilously close to
    meeting in Berlin, I explained that         economic recession (and although         being exhausted. In fact, in the UK,
    I am becoming particularly keen             there are macro clouds, this isn't       the ratio isn't particularly wonderful,
    on thematic investment, with the            likely in the short term), most big      which is why investors have to be
    three major investible themes being         companies with juicy dividend yields     careful.
    climate change, clean meat and the          should be able to maintain their            Companies with ridiculously
    modern agricultural revolution – as         payouts, and are therefore a good        high yields are usually (not always)
    well as, of course, the biggie which        buy.                                     stressed and likely to cut their
    is likely to affect everything − the                                                 payouts – or even get rid of them.
    science of longevity.                                                                Companies with excessively high
        Climate change is hard, because                                                  debt are to be avoided, especially if
    returns are being compressed, but                                                    the debt is keyed to adverse macro
    the other two should be included                                                     trends (eg to retail property).
    in everyone's portfolio. As part of                                                     This will narrow the field
    London Longevity Week, Master                                                        considerably – even amongst the
    Investor held a sold-out day on                                                      biggest companies. It is instructive
    longevity, and they will be doing one                                                that over a quarter of FTSE 100
    on agritech and clean meat in the                                                    companies yield over 6%, indicating
    near future.                                                                         either massive mispricing of

6 | ISSUE 57 – DECEMBER 2019 Master Investor is a registered trademark of Master Investor Limited | www.masterinvestor.co.uk
How to Invest in Medtech - In the age of AI - plus...
MELLON ON THE MARKETS

                                                               “WE ARE GRADUALLY
                                                                 BUILDING UP OUR
                                                               DIVIDEND PORTFOLIO,
                                                                WITH A MIXTURE OF
                                                                 UK AND OVERSEAS
                                                                     SHARES.”

www.masterinvestor.co.uk | Master Investor is a registered trademark of Master Investor Limited ISSUE 57 – DECEMBER 2019 | 7
How to Invest in Medtech - In the age of AI - plus...
MELLON ON THE MARKETS

      “NO, YOU WON’T GET RICH WITH THEM, BUT YOU
    SHOULD GET A RETURN THAT IS SIGNIFICANTLY ABOVE
    INFLATION AND A BIT OF CAPITAL GAIN THROWN IN.”

 equities versus bonds, or something
 fundamentally wrong with the
 companies. Most likely, it's a bit of
 both.
    For our own part, we are gradually
 building up our dividend portfolio,
 with a mixture of UK and overseas
 shares. We bear in mind that many
 UK big companies get the bulk of their
 earnings overseas so are effectively
 international. It should also be noted              Fasttailwind / Shutterstock.com
 that on holdings in US stocks, there is
 a withholding tax of 30% on dividends       effectively) is cheap, well-run and
 – on Japanese stocks it's 15% − which       although uncomfortable to fly on, a
 should be taken into account when           good place to park cash. Similarly, IAG
 making your final cut.                      (LON:IAG), owner of BA, is cheap and
                                             is at long last getting better planes
 Building a dividend                         and, hopefully, an improved service.
 portfolio                                   Many is the time I have vowed to                   Willy Barton / Shutterstock.com
 AJ Bell suggests that the FTSE 100          never fly BA again, only to have to trot
 currently yields 4.8% and is covered        back onto one of their aircraft due to     with them, but you should get a return
 about 1.6x, which is a little tight. This   a lack of viable alternatives. I'm not     that is significantly above inflation and
 is a significant reduction in coverage      keen on long detours.                      a bit of capital gain thrown in.
 over the past few years. But there             Marston's (LON:MARS), the pub              Rio Tinto (LON:RIO) and BHP
 are still safe havens with dividends of     company, looks similar to Greene           (LON:BHP) are excellent dividend
 significance out there, and I will give     King (recently acquired) to me, and        yielders and I would hold them, as
 you a few examples which I favour.          with a yield above 6% and surely           inflation is surely going to rise. But
    BP (LON:BP.) is one, as is Lloyd's       the prospect of a takeover, it is an       the main thing for inflation is – you
 Bank. We are not going totally green        interesting one to hold. Other US          guessed it – gold, and any opportunity
 any time soon and BP looks the best         holdings include GM (NYSE:GM) and          to load up on it, its derivatives or
 of the oil majors to me, with a near 6%     Gilead (NASDAQ:GILD), the big drug         anything related to it that isn't run by
 yield. Lloyds (LON:LLOY) has a similar      company with a yield approaching           fraudsters – well, I'd go for it.
 yield and with PPI almost behind it,        4%. I also retain a position in Avation       I would also load up on sterling,
 and both a very strong balance sheet        (LON:AVAP), the aircraft-leasing           particularly against the US dollar.
 and position in the UK domestic             company listed in the UK.                  Boris will romp the election and the
 market, along with almost no overseas          I think all of these, along with        pound will go up 5% overnight.
 exposure, I am a happy holder.              BT (LON:BT.A), Shell (LON:RDSA),
    Delta Airlines (NYSE:DAL) in the         British Land (LON:BLND) and Great          Happy Hunting!
 US (with a very valuable frequent-flyer     Portland Estates (LON:GPOR) are
 franchise business – selling points         useful 'bankers'. No, you won't get rich   Jim Mellon

    About Jim

    Jim is an entrepreneur with a flair for identifying emerging global trends enabling him to build a worldwide
    business empire. He is amongst the top 10% in the "Sunday Times Rich List" (Britain's equivalent to the Forbes
    list). He is often described as the British Warren Buffett and he predicted the Credit Crunch of 2007-08 in a book
    entitled Wake Up! Survive and Prosper in the Coming Economic Turmoil. Jim followed this with The Top 10 Investments
    for the Next 10 Years (2008) and subsequently Cracking the Code (2012), Fast Forward (2014) and, most recently,
    Juvenescence (2017). His monthly "Mellon on the Markets" column in Master Investor Magazine has gained him cult
    status among investors. He holds a master's degree in Politics, Philosophy and Economics from Oxford University.
    He is on the Board of Trustees of the Buck Institute in California, a trustee of the Biogerontology Institute, and a
    Fellow of Oriel College, Oxford.

8 | ISSUE 57 – DECEMBER 2019 Master Investor is a registered trademark of Master Investor Limited | www.masterinvestor.co.uk
How to Invest in Medtech - In the age of AI - plus...
THE EDGE
            AUTUMN 2019 EDITION

     FREE
    O W N L OA D
  D

READ ONLINE: masterinvestor.co.uk/magazine
How to Invest in Medtech - In the age of AI - plus...
BY VICTOR HILL

                                                 cover feature

             medical
           technology
         in the age of AI
    Victor Hill explains how the future of healthcare might belong to the engineers rather than
    the medics.

    New approaches to old                   awaiting approval from the UK's        have any of the toxic side effects
    maladies                                Medicines and Healthcare Products      associated with radiotherapy and
    New technologies are emerging           Regulatory Agency. According           chemotherapy.
    rapidly to help us improve our          to one report, these are likely to         Malaria naturally becomes
    understanding of what is going on       start next year. Tests will begin in   magnetic when it enters the body
    inside our bodies – and then to treat   2020, followed by trials to see if     because it targets iron-rich red
    what is wrong.                          the device can eliminate sepsis-       blood cells. But cancer cells do not
       Dr George Frodsham, founder          causing bacteria. But, in principle,   all circulate in the blood, as some
    and chief executive of MediSieve        anything that can bind to the          reside in bone marrow and lymph
    − a spin-off from University            magnetic nanoparticles, such as        nodes. The only way to cure blood
    College, London, has proposed           poisons, pathogens, viruses and        cancers such as leukaemia is to
    a revolutionary new approach            bacteria could be removed from the     eliminate these cells completely.
    to the treatment of a range of          bloodstream in a process akin to           Dr Frodsham won the
    conditions, including leukaemia,        dialysis.                              Biotechnology and Biological
    sepsis and malaria. While studying         Essentially, the patient's blood    Sciences Research Council
    how magnetic nanoparticles can be       would be extracted and infused         Innovation of the Year award.
    bound to cells in the body so that      with microscopic magnetic particles    He hopes that a new generation
    they can show up on scanners, he        which bind to target disease           of engineers will find technological
    realised that if it were possible to    cells. Those substances are then       solutions to medical problems
    magnetise cells for imaging, it might   extracted and the purified blood       rather than simply relying on
    also be possible to suck them out of    is pumped back into the patient's      pharmacology. So, the future
    human blood.                            body. The whole process would          of healthcare might belong to
       The first human trials of this       be likely to take between two          the engineers rather than the
    medical technology are currently        to four hours and would not            medics.

10 | ISSUE 57 – DECEMBER 2019 Master Investor is a registered trademark of Master Investor Limited | www.masterinvestor.co.uk
COVER FEATURE

                       “THE FUTURE OF HEALTHCARE THEN
                        MIGHT BELONG TO THE ENGINEERS
                          RATHER THAN THE MEDICS.”

www.masterinvestor.co.uk | Master Investor is a registered trademark of Master Investor Limited ISSUE 57 – DECEMBER 2019 | 11
COVER FEATURE

     The African swine fever pandemic: a UK biotech player is on the case

     Animal healthcare never attracts the same level of publicity as the human type. It hasn't been headline news in the
     UK but it has dominated the media across Asia. The outbreak of so-called African swine fever has caused mayhem
     in China and Vietnam. Last month the World Health Organisation (WHO) warned that one in four pigs worldwide
     might die in this epidemic. Fortunately for us, unlike in the case of bird flu, African swine fever poses no risk to
     humans. (Or so we are told: genetically speaking, humans have much in common with pigs).
        The mortality rate for infected pigs is 100 percent and there is no available vaccine. It is easily transmitted via
     live animals or through parasites but can even survive several months in processed meats. The animals die within
     a few days of being infected.
        China has, or rather had, an estimated 700 million pigs – many of which are kept in the back yards of rural
     households. Pork is the main source of animal protein in the Chinese diet. The price of pork in China has nearly
     tripled in the last 12 months, as about 45 percent of the pig population has perished.
        The disease has manifested itself in 50 countries across Europe and Asia, including Belgium and Northern
     Ireland. British biotech company Genus (LON:GNS), based in Hampshire, is on the case. Genus specialises in
     improving the quality of breeding herds. Its website states: "We provide farmers with superior genetics that enable
     them to produce higher quality animal protein more efficiently". They do that by analysing animals' DNA and
     looking for markers linked to desirable characteristics. They then select animals with the strongest genetic profile
     and breed them to produce better offspring, in a continuous cycle. They distribute these genetically superior
     animals to customers in the form of breeding animals, semen or embryos.
        Getting the Chinese pig population back to where it was will take at least three years. When Russia was afflicted
     by an equivalent outbreak 10 years ago, the authorities used the crisis to modernise the industry and to raise
     standards. If the Chinese take the same approach, that could be good news for Genus and others.

 Google enters the
 healthcare data bonanza
 Last month it was revealed that Google
 has been collecting the personal
 healthcare information of millions
 of Americans under a scheme called
 Project Nightingale (presumably named
 after the iconic 19th century clinician,
 Florence Nightingale). Google has
 partnered with Ascension, the second-
 largest healthcare provider in the US,
 to gather data on 20 million patients
 in 21 states. Another 30 million patient
 records may be next. One outcome
 of Project Nightingale is likely to be
 that Google will be able to build a
 healthcare search engine for hospitals.
    The controversy arises because
 patients and doctors were not told
 that the data was being passed on.
 According to the Wall Street Journal,
 at least 150 Google employees
 have access to this data. A cache of
                                                “LAST MONTH IT WAS REVEALED THAT
 documents relating to the project was           GOOGLE HAS BEEN COLLECTING THE
 anonymously posted on the internet           PERSONAL HEALTHCARE INFORMATION OF
 by a whistle-blower who stated
                                              MILLIONS OF AMERICANS UNDER A SCHEME
 that: "Google is secretly transferring
 data to its own servers without                   CALLED PROJECT NIGHTINGALE.”
 patient knowledge or consent". But
 Google and Ascension issued a joint
 statement to the effect that the project   will not be combined with any Google      on 1 November. When Google bought
 did not breach the Health Insurance        customer data".                           the smartphone company Nest five
 Portability and Accountability Act,           What makes these revelations           years ago it made no mention of what
 which governs the management of            more concerning is that they follow       it would do with customers' data. But,
 medical data in the US. Google added       on from Google's purchase of Fitbit       on buying Fitbit, Google thought it
 that patient information "cannot and       (NYSE:FIT) for $2.1 billion, announced    necessary to go to lengths to dispel

12 | ISSUE 57 – DECEMBER 2019 Master Investor is a registered trademark of Master Investor Limited | www.masterinvestor.co.uk
COVER FEATURE

       “DEEPMIND USED THE MEDICAL RECORDS OF OVER 700,000
       US VETERANS TO DEVELOP AN ALGORITHM THAT SPOTS 60
        PERCENT OF THOSE WHO WILL GO ON TO DEVELOP AKI.”

                                                                                          down projects which are not working.
                                                                                          One example was the tech giant's
                                                                                          disastrous acquisition of Motorola in
                                                                                          2011. Google sold the company three
                                                                                          years later for a fraction of the $12.5
                                                                                          billion that it paid. For this reason,
                                                                                          consumers should be cautious about
                                                                                          Google's purchase of Fitbit.
                                                                                              Fitbit was one of the first players
                                                                                          in the wearable-technology space
                                                                                          and has possibly the most vibrant
                                                                                          brand. Fitbit grew partially through
                                                                                          acquisition – it bought Silicon Valley
                                                                                          'star' Pebble and then Vector, a
                                                                                          Romanian rival. But it suffered after
                                                                                          Apple (NASDAQ:AAPL), Samsung
                                                                                          (KRX: 005930) and Huawei brought
                                                                                          out competing devices. By the time
    users' fears that the medical data         working with Imperial College, London      that Google swooped, Fitbit's shares
    collected by their smartwatches would      to devise a similar alert app for sepsis   had fallen to just over $3 – down
    not be used inappropriately.               (formerly termed blood poisoning).         from a peak of around $50 in 2015.
        Also of concern: last year Google      The number of people developing            If Google had not made the move,
    announced plans to absorb the health       sepsis is increasing, with around          no doubt one of the other tech
    division of DeepMind Technologies,         123,000 cases each year in England         behemoths would have bought
    the British AI laboratory that it bought   and an estimated 37,000 deaths             the company. Indeed, Fitbit tells
    in 2014, into a new unit called Google     according to NHS England.                  a cautionary tale for any investor
    Health. This move broke a previous            DeepMind has also worked with           interested in the tech sector.
    promise that patient data would never      Moorfields Eye Hospital, in London, to         It is probable that Google may wish
    be integrated with Google's other          develop a system that can anticipate       to integrate some of Fitbit's fitness-
    services.                                  the onset of macular degeneration.         tracking technology into its Android
        DeepMind has collaborated with         In July 2017, however, the UK              smartphone operating system. In
    the Royal Free Hospital in London,         Information Commissioner ruled that        that way, smartphones of the future
    amongst others, in order to develop        the agreement between DeepMind             will no doubt collect all kind of health
    an app called Streams that detects         and the Royal Free did not comply          metrics – from blood pressure to body
    kidney injury two days before it           with the UK's Data Protection Act.         composition – in real time. The big
    happens. The app texts the patient's          Google is notoriously ruthless          question is what the company will do
    doctor an alert if there is any            about changing strategy or closing         with all the data generated thereby.
    imminent deterioration in the patient's
    condition. That could save the lives
    of up to 30,000 British citizens a year
    given that around 100,000 people
    in the UK die each year from Acute
    Kidney Injury (AKI). This occurs when
    organs stop functioning correctly and
    there is a build-up of waste material in
    the blood.
        DeepMind used the medical
    records of over 700,000 US veterans
    to develop an algorithm that spots
    60 percent of those who will go on to
    develop AKI. The NHS reckons that 30
    percent of AKI deaths are preventable
    if caught early – hence the 30,000
    figure. The DeepMind team is now                                                                  PixieMe / Shutterstock.com

www.masterinvestor.co.uk | Master Investor is a registered trademark of Master Investor Limited ISSUE 57 – DECEMBER 2019 | 13
COVER FEATURE
 Why medical data is                        maintaining patient records by the
 valuable                                   million since it was first set up in 1948
 Today a test for Parkinson's               – and digitally for more than 20 years.        “THE NHS,
 disease developed by Medopad,              Few countries have large numbers of
 a London-based start-up and                cradle-to-grave health records that          POTENTIALLY,
 Chinese technology giant Tencent           could be used for medical research. If       COULD BE THE
 (SEHK:700) takes just a few minutes.       this data could be effectively mined,
 A smartphone camera can scan a             then it could be established precisely         GREATEST
 patient's hand and body movements.         which risk factors are associated            REPOSITORY OF
 Then an algorithm will determine if        with particular health outcomes.
 the disease is present based on those      And the relative effectiveness of           MEDICAL DATA ON
 movements.                                 pharmaceutical products could be             THE PLANET.”
    But in order to develop that            exactly evaluated.
 algorithm, it was necessary to analyse         According to a recent report
 millions of images of how people with      from consultants EY, the NHS could
 Parkinson's disease move. In this case,    generate £10 billion a year in revenues        Last month New Scientist revealed,
 the data did not come from the NHS;        and cost savings, by opening up             following a Freedom of Information
 rather it was collected by Tencent in      its 55 million plus medical records         request, that numerous NHS trusts
 China. Furthermore, a drug called          to researchers. This, however, is           (which are the operators of one or
 Terazosin was also found to prevent        controversial. Although any such            more hospitals in each locality) had
 or mitigate the death of nerve cells       data would naturally be anonymised,         agreed to sign five-year data-sharing
 during the progression of Parkinson's      opinion polls suggest that many             agreements with Google. It is likely
 − even though this drug was originally     NHS patients do not trust the NHS           that under these agreements, Google
 developed to treat benign prostate         to keep their data safe as a result of      will make its Streams kidney-disease
 enlargement.                               past leaks. Further, some people fear       detecting app available for free (up to
    Yet the NHS, potentially, could be      the consequences of medical data            a certain use limit).
 the greatest repository of medical         getting into the hands of insurance            Amazon (NASDAQ:AMZN) secured
 data on the planet. It has been            companies. I can quite imagine that         a deal with the NHS in July this year,
                                            by using our medical data, each             to enable patients to answer simple
                                            one of us could be attributed an            health questions (probably over the
   The UK's NHS: poor                       estimated life expectancy. No doubt         telephone) posed by an Alexa-type
   outcomes                                 pension companies (especially annuity       virtual assistant.
                                            providers) would be keen to see such           Under the pro-tech Health
   A recent World Health                    data.                                       Secretary Matt Hancock, the NHS
   Organisation report placed Great             Given that there is a general           has launched a new technology
   Britain at the bottom of the league      election underway in the UK as I write      programme called NHSX which will,
   of seven advanced nations in             this, and with the NHS being one of         in due course, operate an AI lab.
   terms of cancer survival rates. The      the dominant campaign issues, the           The sum of £250 million in funding
   study looked at cancers affecting        idea that the NHS might sell data           has been pledged towards this
   the oesophagus, stomach, colon,          to third parties would offend those         end. Prospectively, NHSX will try to
   rectum, lungs and ovaries in             whose mantra is that the NHS is "not        generate revenues by cooperating
   Australia, Canada, New Zealand,          for sale" (and especially not to the        with the private sector. These would
   Norway, Denmark, Ireland and the         Americans!). And who owns that data?        be reinvested in front-line services.
   UK. It is regrettable that this in not   Does it really belong to the NHS, or to     One issue, voiced by some insiders, is
   more to the fore in the current          its patients?                               that NHS management is not equal in
   general-election campaign.
      One factor behind the
   underperformance of the NHS is
   that cancer care must compete
   with other maladies. There is now
   an epidemic of Type 2 Diabetes
   driven partially by a rise in
   obesity. One eighth of the entire
   NHS drugs budget in 2018-19 was
   spent on diabetes drugs. That
   amounted to £540 million. One
   in 10 of all patients now admitted
   to hospital suffer from Type 2
   diabetes. As a result, hundreds of
   thousands of people have been
   put on the Diabetes Prevention
   Programme.

14 | ISSUE 57 – DECEMBER 2019 Master Investor is a registered trademark of Master Investor Limited | www.masterinvestor.co.uk
COVER FEATURE

                                                                                           Fitness trackers and the
                                                                                           fight against diabetes

                                                                                           In August, the NHS announced
                                                                                           that overweight patients at risk
                                                                                           of developing diabetes are to be
                                                                                           given Fitbit-style tracker devices
                                                                                           to help stave off the disease. Over
                                                                                           40,000 people were provided
                                                                                           Nujjer wristband trackers as
                                                                                           part of the Diabetes Prevention
                                                                                           Programme. These devices
                                                                                           monitor activity, sleep patterns
                                                                                           and eating frequency. Nearly four
                                                                                           million people in England alone
                                                                                           suffer from diabetes and the
                                                                                           condition is responsible for over
                                                                                           9,000 limb amputations per year.

    negotiating skills to the slick execs of   Neuropeptides – an                        six amino acids, can be rubbed into
    the tech titans. Their main concern is     alternative to drugs?                     the skin. Neuropeptides are small
    to avoid any controversy that would        Neuropeptide dihexa (ND) was              protein-like molecules which help
    open the NHS up to criticism.              developed by Washington State             neurons in the brain to communicate
       But the potential is huge. Soon         University to combat Alzheimer's          with one another. They are the focus
    diagnostic apps will be able to            disease and cognitive impairment.         of a new branch of medicine called
    predict how long patients are likely       It works by slowing cell death and        biologics which uses small molecules,
    to remain in hospital and, in the case     suppressing enzymes that destroy the      particularly strings of amino acids,
    of for example a flu epidemic, how         brain chemicals which are associated      which are already present in the
    many admissions will take place            with memory and learning. It has          human metabolism. Using these, the
    over coming weeks and months. In           been granted initial approval by the      body can heal itself without resorting
    this way hospital management will          Food and Drug Administration (FDA)        to drugs.
    become much more efficient and cost-       in the US further to clinical trials.         While ND was developed to treat
    effective.                                 The peptide, which consists of just       dementia and traumatic brain injury,
                                                                                         it has also been shown to increase
                                                                                         the cognitive power of normally
      Facebook, Apple and the                  fitness and health. More than half        abled people. For example, if you
      newbies...                               of the audience put up their hands.       are learning to play a new musical
                                               US sports manufacturer Under              instrument or learning a new
      Facebook recently launched its           Armour is one of many providers           language, they could help you make
      own "preventive healthcare"              which are integrating gym wear with       more rapid progress.
      mobile app in the US. And Apple          gadgets – for example, T-shirts that          A biotech company by the name of
      has added health-detection               measure your fitness levels and           Apeiron Biologics is working on this
      features to its Apple Watch which        running shoes that analyse your           product. Apeiron is a privately held
      give users, amongst other things,        gait. Sensoria, a start-up based in       European biotech company based in
      the ability to conduct their own         Redmond, Washington state, in the         Vienna. It focuses on the discovery
      electrocardiogram (ECG) test.            US, has developed smart socks for         and development of novel cancer
         The 'wearables' market –              joggers which provide real-time           immunotherapies. Currently, peptides
      which covers fitness wristbands,         feedback on your running style.           are only legally prescribed in the US.
      smartwatches and smart clothing          (This writer would find that most         They are illegal in the UK and Europe.
      (including a MasterCard inserted         irritating – I just need a device which       As well as ND, other neuropeptides
      in a cufflink – yes, it's happening      congratulates me for running at           prescribed to boost brain power
      thanks to a start-up called              all!).                                    include cerebrolysin which is
      DressCode) is expected to be                 Seriously, though, e-textiles (ie     apparently derived from pigs' brains.
      worth £40 billion worldwide in           garments that measure muscle              This is claimed to reduce amyloid
      2022 – up from £16 billion in 2016.      activity, body temperature and            beta – the sticky plaques found in
      At a recent Master Investor event        respiration, and which send that          the brains of Alzheimer sufferers.
      in London I asked the audience           data to a central database) are           A neuropeptide nasal spray, FGL, is
      which of them were wearing a             surely just around the corner. Check      currently in second-phase clinical
      wearable device to track their           out Id TechX.                             trials. This can help repair the myelin
                                                                                         sheaths around nerve cells which are

www.masterinvestor.co.uk | Master Investor is a registered trademark of Master Investor Limited ISSUE 57 – DECEMBER 2019 | 15
COVER FEATURE
                                                                                   damaged by multiple sclerosis. Also,
                                                                                   the brain molecule RG3 increases the
   Sensyne                                 trusts can be used to develop
                                                                                   body's ability to manage free radicals
                                           new apps or research projects by
                                                                                   – unstable atoms that damage cells,
   The health-technology firm              third parties. NHS trusts which
                                                                                   causing illness and ageing.
   Sensyne Health PLC (LON:SENS)           sign up with Sensyme receive a
                                                                                      Fabian Foelsch of BRAINEFFECT,
   was launched on AIM last year           share of any revenues generated
                                                                                   a company that sells supplements
   where it raised £60 million.            by their data. They also become
                                                                                   which enhance mental capacity, told
   Sensyme was founded by serial           shareholders in Sensyme (about 10
                                                                                   the Biohackers Summit in Helsinki last
   medical-technology entrepreneur         percent of the shares are owned by
                                                                                   month that people will increasingly
   Paul (Lord) Drayson who was             NHS trusts). Lord Drayson claims
                                                                                   need brain drugs in the future, in
   also the founder of PowderJect          that Sensyne is already a world
                                                                                   order to keep up with the pace of
   Pharmaceuticals, which was              leader in computer science and
                                                                                   change of technology.
   acquired by Chiron Corp in 2003.        artificial intelligence. The initial
   (Chiron was acquired by Novartis        launch price in November 2018 was
   (VXP:NOV) in 2006). Sensyme has         185 pence. At the time of writing,
                                                                                   The little known biotech
   developed a technology 'sandbox'        the shares are trading at 102.5
                                                                                   hub blazing a trail in
   where patient data from NHS             pence.
                                                                                   cancer research
                                                                                   When we think about the biotech
                                                                                   sector in the UK we think of
                                                                                   Cambridge (which is home to about
                                                                                   430 life-science companies) – not
                                                                                   Stevenage. But Stevenage for the last
                                                                                   year has been home to the Cell and
                                                                                   Gene Therapy Catapult. This body has
                                                                                   been tasked by government, to the
                                                                                   tune of £50 million, to facilitate the
                                                                                   commercialisation of cell-and-gene
                                                                                   therapy (CGT) treatments, many of
                                                                                   which have been in development
                                                                                   for decades. There are already
                                                                                   five companies using the centre
                                                                                   – four British and one American
                                                                                   (the US-listed TCR2 Therapeutics
                                                                                   (NASDAQ:TCRR), which has its
                                                                                   headquarters in Boston). More are
                                                                                   likely to follow.
                                                                                      Gene therapy, cell therapy and
                                                                                   gene editing are three different
                                                                                   techniques which share the same
                                                                                   goal; to cure diseases by altering our
                                                                                   genomes. While gene editing is still
                                                                                   in the early stages and will use new
                                                                                   advances in CRISPR technology, gene
                                                                                   and cell therapy are now taking off. In
                                                                                   fact, both the FDA and the European
                                                                                   Medicines Agency have boosted staff
                                                                                   numbers in order to cope with the
                                                                                   expected flood of new applications.

                                                                                     Babylon Healthcare

                                                                                     Babylon provides an online
                                                                                     consultation service and an app
                                                                                     that evaluates symptoms. It sells
                                                                                     its services to the NHS through
                                                                                     a business called GP at Hand.
                                                                                     Although the service has been
                                                                                     praised by UK Health Secretary
                                                                                     Matt Hancock, others have
                                                                                     claimed that Babylon is creating a
                                                                                     funding imbalance.

16 | ISSUE 57 – DECEMBER 2019 Master Investor is a registered trademark of Master Investor Limited | www.masterinvestor.co.uk
COVER FEATURE

      “IT IS ESTIMATED THAT IN EUROPE, CGT ATTRACTED
    $2.2 BILLION IN INVESTMENT LAST YEAR – A 40 PERCENT
    RISE ON THE PREVIOUS YEAR. THERE ARE NOW 241 GENE-
    THERAPY DEVELOPERS ACROSS THE EU, 70 OF WHICH ARE
                 HEADQUARTERED IN THE UK.”

                                                It is estimated that in Europe, CGT   therapy was approved by the FDA in
      Cambridge UK: an                       attracted $2.2 billion in investment     May. Analysts believe that it could
      international biotech                  last year – a 40 percent rise on the     generate revenues of $2 billion a
      hub                                    previous year. There are now 241         year for Novartis. Similarly, earlier
                                             gene-therapy developers across the       this year, Bristol Myers Squib
      As a biotech hub, Cambridge is         EU, 70 of which are headquartered
      surpassed only by Silicon Valley       in the UK. Their targets are firstly
      and Boston. The Babraham               people who suffer from debilitating        The Hundred Thousand
      Research Campus is home                genetic conditions (cystic fibrosis,       Genome Project
      to a host of start-ups which           Huntingdon's etc.) and secondly
      work alongside Cambridge's             cancer patients. At present, the focus     The UK government has
      two great research hospitals           in Stevenage is on research and            sponsored a project called the
      (Addenbrooke's and Papworth).          the challenge will be to scale up for      100,000 Genomes Project. This is
      The biggest near-unicorn at            production.                                sequencing the genomes that
      Babraham is Kymab which is                Many of those CGT-therapy               have been decoded for a similar
      working on antibody-based              developers will be snapped up              number of NHS patients (with
      therapies. On a smaller scale,         by the pharmaceutical giants               their consent). The database is
      Closed Loop Medicine has               as their therapies get closer to           open only to approved scientists.
      developed technology that tracks       commercialisation. Last year Novartis      Dame Sally Davies, Chief Medical
      how a drug affects a patient           (VTX:NOVN) paid $9 billion to acquire      Officer, has described it as "a
      and evaluates whether the              Avexis, the producer of Zolgensma,         reading library, not a lending
      prescription should be altered.        a gene therapy for children with           library".
                                             spinal muscular atrophy. That

www.masterinvestor.co.uk | Master Investor is a registered trademark of Master Investor Limited ISSUE 57 – DECEMBER 2019 | 17
COVER FEATURE

                                                                                   (NYSE:BMY) paid $74 billion to buy
   IBM: Now a healthcare                   healthcare outcomes. That said, a       Celgene which has numerous cancer
   play, too                               lot of Americans are ultra-sensitive    cell therapies in the pipeline. Roche
                                           (quite naturally) about admitting       (VTX:RO) of Switzerland and Biogen
   Possibly the biggest medical            to a drug habit and particularly        (NASDAQ:BIIB) in the US have also
   database of all is the IBM              opioid abuse (which is rife). Many      purchased gene-therapy developers
   (NYSE:IBM) Watson database              Americans argue that you cannot         this year.
   which contains about 240 million        anonymise health records – each             Here in the UK, there are
   medical records. This was deployed      one identifies its owner as does a      a number of companies with
   to compare the path of 2,880            fingerprint. Even your vaccination      exciting CGT pipelines. Freeline
   Parkinson's sufferers who took          history will place you in time and      Therapeutics, based at the Catapult
   Terazosin (see previous reference)      space in ways that the algorithms       in Stevenage, is developing gene
   and compared their progress to          will interpret.                         therapy for haemophilia. Autolus
   those who took another drug.               The other problem is that, as        (NASDAQ:AUTL) (a spin-out of UCL),
   Terazosin won out.                      we know, cyber-security risks are       Adaptimmune (NASDAQ:ADAP) (a
      In America there is – arguably –     one of the major challenges of          spin-out of Oxford University) and Cell
   more widespread popular support         our time and will only get worse.       Medica are all developing cancer cell
   for the systematic data mining of       However securely we construct our       therapies. Another British unicorn is
   healthcare databases than in the        healthcare databases, we can be         Oxford Biomedica which supplies the
   UK and in Europe. This is because       sure that someone out there will try    virus vectors that Novartis uses for
   there is a strong perception            to hack them.                           its gene therapies. All told, the UK is
   that, over time, this will benefit                                              well-positioned to ride the wave of
                                                                                   regenerative medicine which I have
                                                                                   written about recently.

                                                                                   The AI blood test that
                                                                                   can detect brain tumours
                                                                                   more quickly
                                                                                   Scientists at the University of
                                                                                   Edinburgh have developed a blood
                                                                                   test which detects tumours, and which
                                                                                   might first be used to identify brain
                                                                                   cancer much sooner than is currently
                                                                                   possible. The research team applied
                                                                                   the test to blood samples taken from
                                                                                   400 patients with suspected brain
                                                                                   tumours at the Western General
                                                                                   Hospital in Edinburgh. In the case
                                                                                   of the most common form of brain
                                                                                   tumour, glioma, the test was 92
                                                                                   percent accurate.
                                                                                      Unfortunately, brain cancer is most
                                                                                   often diagnosed in the emergency
                                                                                   department. However, this test

18 | ISSUE 57 – DECEMBER 2019 Master Investor is a registered trademark of Master Investor Limited | www.masterinvestor.co.uk
COVER FEATURE

             “PHARMACEUTICAL COMPANIES WILL HAVE TO
           REINVENT THEMSELVES AS MEDICAL-TECHNOLOGY
           COMPANIES – AND THAT IS ALREADY UNDERWAY.”

    enhances an existing technique called
    infrared spectroscopy which analyses       Suspended animation                     that a team of medics had placed
    the chemical make-up of a patient's        has arrived                             at least one patient in suspended
    blood. Combined with AI, this                                                      animation. The technique, officially
    technique can identify chemical clues      New Scientist reported in late          called emergency preservation and
    which, cumulatively, may indicate a        November that doctors have placed       resuscitation (EPR), is being carried
    brain tumour. The technique has the        humans in suspended animation           out on people who arrive at the
    potential to be applied to ovarian,        for the first time as part of a trial   Medical Centre in Baltimore with
    pancreatic, bowel and prostate             in the US that aims to make it          acute trauma – eg a gunshot or
    cancer.                                    possible to fix traumatic injuries.     stab wound – and have experienced
                                               The University of Maryland School       cardiac arrest and lost more than
    Action                                     of Medicine, told New Scientist         half their blood.
    As usual, the early-stage gains in
    CGT-therapy developers will be
    harvested by the most adept venture      Companies cited in this article
    capital and private equity companies.
    There are a number of listed entities     Company                                               Ticker/status
    in this space (see the table of
                                              MediSieve                                             Start-up
    companies).
       BB Biotech is a Swiss-based            Genus                                                 LON:GNS
    investment fund which allocates to        Alphabet Inc. (Google)                                NASDAQ:GOOGL
    companies engaged in gene therapy         Apple Inc.                                            NASDAQ:AAPL
    and cell therapy. Don't overlook
                                              MedoPad                                               Start-up
    the mature medical technology
    companies such as Smith &                 Tencent                                               SEHK:700
    Nephew (LON:SN) and Intuitive             Amazon                                                NASDAQ:AMZN
    Surgical (NASDAQ:ISRG). Companies         Apeiron Biologics                                     Private
    which collect medical data like           Facebook                                              NASDAQ:FB
    Google, Facebook and Amazon are
                                              Babylon Healthcare                                    Private
    now, by that very fact, healthcare
    companies.                                Sensyne                                               LON:SENS
       Over the medium to long term the       TCR2 Therapeutics                                     NASDAQ:TCRR
    rise of gene therapy, cell therapy,       Novartis                                              VTX:NOVN
    gene editing and biologics may entail
                                              BB Biotech (investment fund)                          VTX:BION
    a significant shift away from classic
    pharmacology (ie the production of        Bristol Myers Squibb                                  NYSE:BMI
    drugs). That could be bad news for        Roche                                                 VTX:RO
    the pharmaceutical giants – but we        Freeline Therapeutics                                 Private
    already knew that this was a mature
                                              Autolus                                               NASDAQ:AUTL
    sector and that returns on capital in
    that space are in long-term decline.      Adaptimmune                                           NASDAQ:ADAP
    Therefore, pharmaceutical companies       Closed Loop Medicine                                  Start-up
    will have to reinvent themselves as       IBM                                                   NYSE:IBM
    medical-technology companies – and
                                              Kymab/ Under Armour/ Sensoria/ Id TechX               Start-ups
    that is already underway.

       About Victor

       Victor is a financial economist, consultant, trainer and writer, with extensive experience in commercial and
       investment banking and fund management. His career includes stints at JP Morgan, Argyll Investment Management
       and World Bank IFC.

www.masterinvestor.co.uk | Master Investor is a registered trademark of Master Investor Limited ISSUE 57 – DECEMBER 2019 | 19
BY MARK WATSON-MITCHELL

    portfolio intelligence

    The IPO
    Market
    Alive and kicking or barely breathing?
    The IPO market has had a tough time of late. But there are some interesting goings-on
    that investors should be aware of. Mark Watson-Mitchell investigates.

    With the world's biggest float now     What is the IPO process?
    underway, there is a fresh focus       A company informs the market that
    on how the market for Initial Public   it is intending to float either through
    Offerings (IPOs) is faring.            an IPO or as a new issue.
       Just looking at the funds raised        A prospectus is prepared and
    on the Alternative Investment          verified before release. This should
    Market (AIM) in the third quarter of   carry total details of the company
    this year shows a lack of investor     and its markets, directors, potential
    interest or appetite.                  and risks etc. It will also contain
       New and further issues on AIM in    details of the company's capital
    Q3 totalled £638m, which was 52%       structure, and its corporate and
    below the corresponding figure in      profit history, as well as information
    2018. In fact, for the period from     on how and why the funds are
    January to end-September only          expected to be raised.
    £2.84bn was raised, a massive 42%          Alongside the document's
    down on the corresponding period       release, a period of publicity will
    in 2018.                               help the investing public to gauge
                                           the investment possibilities.

20 | ISSUE 57 – DECEMBER 2019 Master Investor is a registered trademark of Master Investor Limited | www.masterinvestor.co.uk
PORTFOLIO INTELLIGENCE

           The IPO will then be open for      Prices can go up or down                subscription levels can take months,
        application, within a specific time   There are no guarantees of making       years or may never happen.
        period, before the offer period       profits. Investors can so often be          There is, of course, a high
        closes, and ahead of allocation.      sucked into new issues through          dependence on the corporate
           The first day of dealings sees     either heavy financial-press activity   performance of the floated
        the shares then admitted to the       or fee-earning advisers over-egging     companies.
        market, often called the secondary    values – or even a combination of           Hoped-for profit levels upon which
        market.                               both.                                   new issue pricing is based may not
           From then onwards, the value          Unfortunately, it is very common     be achieved. Suddenly turnover may
        of the shares are subject to the      for a company to raise funds            fall within months of the float and
        vagaries of investor fashion and      on pricing levels that may never        profits forecasts will then be slashed,
        reaction.                             be seen again. Price recovery to        with investors being left high and dry.

www.masterinvestor.co.uk | Master Investor is a registered trademark of Master Investor Limited ISSUE 57 – DECEMBER 2019 | 21
PORTFOLIO INTELLIGENCE
 Win or lose                                                                              the market. Those reserves are said
 Recent UK floats that are well                                                           to last some 52 years, based on the
 under water include Aston Martin                “FAR AND AWAY                            company's own acquired research.
 (LON:AML), Airtel Africa (LON:AAF)
 and Funding Circle (LON:FCH),                  THE ARAMCO ISSUE                          $1tn or $2.5tn valuation?
 while others have swum away from               WAS PREDICTED TO                          When the company was marketing
 their float price – just like online                                                     the possibility of a float around the
 stockbroking company, AJ Bell.                  BE THE WORLD’S                           world's capital markets, it was said
    Conversely, a big performer in the            BIGGEST IPO.”                           to be looking to float 5% of its capital
 last year has been one of my February                                                    with a $2.5tn valuation.
 profile companies – Manolete                                                                To put that into some comparative
 Partners (LON:MANO), which                                                               context, the biggest IPOs to date
 floated last December at 180p and                 The valuations being put on the        would be dwarfed. Alibaba was
 subsequently peaked at 620p.                   company by the Saudis themselves          $21.8bn of stock, ABC Bank was
                                                was north of $2tn. The Crown Prince,      $19.2bn, ICBC Bank raised $19bn, NTT
 IPOs are not just a way of                     Mohammed bin Salman, was pumping          DoCoMo was $18bn, Visa $17.8bn,
 getting in                                     the presentation, emphasising that it     Facebook $16bn, General Motors
 Do remember that companies                     must rate a valuation at a premium to     $15.7bn and Nippon Tel was $15.3bn.
 float their shares not only to raise           the marketplace.                             In terms of its profitability, its net
 development or working capital, but                                                      income is almost twice that of Apple;
 also to let existing shareholders get          The world's lowest-cost                   three times that of Samsung, Alphabet
 out of or reduce their positions in the        scale producer                            and JP Morgan Chase; and five times
 float company's equity.                        Aramco has some 227bn barrels of oil      that of Shell and also Exxon Mobil.
     Of late, a number of private equity        reserves declared and it is one of the       Yes, Aramco is mega in everything.
 houses have been taking advantage              lowest-cost producers in the world.
 of public floats to unload all or part of         It is the world's most profitable      Too clever?
 their funding positions.                       company, with a net income of             Is Aramco being too clever, though?
     It is always worth checking to             $111bn in 2018, which is bigger           Certainly, its valuation is staggering,
 see how much new stock is being                than that of Google and Facebook          so many oil industry analysts and
 marketed on issue, compared to                 combined.                                 other players are finding it hard to get
 existing holdings. Also, reading finer            Estimates of its proved                their minds around the anticipated
 details in the prospectus will identify        conventional oil reserves are even as     numbers. Several of their estimates
 whether the vending shareholders are           high as 261bn barrels. Its production     hover around $1tn, while fees-inspired
 paying part or the whole of the new            capacity is 12.5m barrels a day and it    bankers are saying that perhaps
 issue costs.                                   is actually producing 10.3m a day.        $2.5tn is the right figure.
     But there has been a sign of                  It is already assumed that the             We have already seen that its net
 investor lethargy of late. It certainly        demand for oil will peak some time        profits fell by the third quarter to
 inspired stockbroking group Shore              in the next decade, with estimates        just $21.3bn, compared to $30.3bn a
 Capital to scrap any current ideas             suggesting that by 2030 to 2040 it will   year earlier. Already the company has
 that it had for maintaining its London         be showing a real tail off.               promised to pay $75bn in dividend
 listing. It had been listed for some 20           But that does not seem to worry        over the next five years and it is
 years, but recently it has not enjoyed         Aramco. It has around 15% of the          believed that the Saudi state reduced
 good stock liquidity and its valuation         world market, which, because of its       its royalty income from $20 down to
 was poor enough for its board to               cheaper production, may well see that     $15 per barrel – another measure to
 delist from London, while maintaining          figure swelling to 20% of the global      make its investment appeal that much
 its Bermuda listing.                           market, especially as the higher-cost     more alluring.
                                                competitors start to pull back from           But will it be enough to pull in the
 Just look at Aramco                                                                      buyers?
 The mega-float of Saudi-Arabian
 energy company, Aramco, is quite                                                         Bad feelings
 defying in all its aspects. It all feels too                                             The murder of a journalist in Turkey,
 manufactured to me.                                                                      corruption in the purchase of arms
    Since 2016, it has been touting                                                       and defence equipment, together
 itself around the world's leading                                                        with involvement in battles in Yemen,
 markets, tickling corporate-banker                                                       do not help engender good feelings
 appetites with big fees in the offing.                                                   towards the Saudi Arabian state.
 Tokyo, Hong Kong, New York, London                                                          And attacks on its oil facilities in
 and other European capitals were                                                         September do not help balance ill-
 standing on tiptoe trying to be seen                                                     feeling, but instead create big doubts
 as the only place to float such a                                                        as to the company's stability.
 monolith. Far and away the Aramco                                                           Morgan Stanley, Goldman Sachs
 issue was predicted to be the world's                                                    and HSBC are amongst the corporate
 biggest IPO.                                             rafapress / Shutterstock.com    advisers in on the fee division

22 | ISSUE 57 – DECEMBER 2019 Master Investor is a registered trademark of Master Investor Limited | www.masterinvestor.co.uk
PORTFOLIO INTELLIGENCE
    from the IPO. I understand that as          of that amount of money draining out    transparency about contract and
    the Kingdom owns Aramco, it is              of capital markets.                     reserve issues.
    underwriting all of the fees itself and        The institutional investors had          I can foresee several sovereign
    will reimburse the company on the           until 4 December to make up their       wealth funds needing to be big
    float.                                      minds.                                  investors in Aramco, either for
        The funds raised through the IPO,          In total, around 2% of the           investment potential or diplomatic
    expected to be more than $25bn, will        company's equity is up for sale.        calm.
    be used to help to diversify the Saudi      Thursday 5 December is the day              On looking at this IPO and the way
    Arabian economy's dependence upon           that final pricing will be announced.   that it is being handled, I must say that
    oil, as part of the Crown Prince's 2030     And that is four times more money       I have some very strong doubts.
    plan for the future.                        draining out of global markets.             I do realise, however, that given
                                                                                        the way that the global investment
    First a local quote then the                But who will invest?                    institutions work today, it means that
    world?                                       There have been strong whispers        it is almost compulsory that they have
    The way the IPO is being handled            that the Chinese are prepared to        a sizeable holding of their portfolios
    provides us with an indication of the       invest up to $10bn in the Aramco        invested in what will be the world's
    company's intentions. First of all, it is   IPO, while the Japanese are said        biggest and most profitable publicly
    being floated on the Tadawul, Saudi         to be reluctant to invest due to        quoted company.
    Arabia's own stock exchange.
       In due course, I would expect the
    company will seek listings in one
    or two of the international capital
    markets. That is when the Kingdom
    could sell down another 3%, 5% or 7%
    of the equity, raising over $100bn in             “ON LOOKING AT
    the process.
                                                     THIS IPO AND THE
    Massive prospectus short                           WAY THAT IT IS
    on detail
    The 658-page prospectus issued in
                                                     BEING HANDLED, I
    mid-November was declared to be                   MUST SAY THAT I
    quite short on detail.
       Retail investors were given the
                                                      HAVE SOME VERY
    opportunity to invest, from 17                   STRONG DOUBTS.”
    November to 28 November. Assuming
    say, at a $1.5tn valuation, retail
    investors, were offered 0.5% of the
    company's equity – well, that alone is a
    whopping $7.5bn of funding. Just think

       Other London IPOs being considered

       I am grateful to Hargreaves Lansdown for a list of IPOs that could be due to be launched. Those companies are
       listed below:
           Jaguar Land Rover Automotive − the UK's largest vehicle manufacturer, which sells more than one car every
       minute.
           Tesco Bank is rumoured to be considering an IPO, following the supermarket group's decision to focus on its
       core business − either an IPO or a straight sale of its banking operation.
           Vue Cinema, which has over 200 cinemas across the globe, could be seeking to float. Some 85 of its cinemas are
       in the UK and Ireland. The company entertains 90m filmgoers annually.
           Crawford Healthcare, the advanced wound-care maker has apparently been inspired to look at an IPO after
       ConvaTec successfully listed.
           Darktrace, the cybersecurity start-up that was set up by some Cambridge academics and GCHQ 'spooks', has
       been informing early-stage investors that it will be seeking a quote.
           CompareTheMarket.com is rumoured to be considering an early quote. As one of the UK's largest price-
       comparison sites it would certainly gain attention.
           McLaren, the premium, high-performance vehicle maker, could well be looking to go public in the next few
       years.
           O2, which has over 25m customers, is one of the UK's largest mobile operators. It also owns 50% of Tesco
       Mobile. It is suggested that an early listing is on the cards.

www.masterinvestor.co.uk | Master Investor is a registered trademark of Master Investor Limited ISSUE 57 – DECEMBER 2019 | 23
You can also read