Promoting integrated healthcare - The Faculty of Homeopathy has
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
The Faculty of Homeopathy Newsletter May 2020
Promoting integrated healthcare
T
he Faculty of Homeopathy has knowledge and understanding
become a founding member Dr Gary Smyth
of complementary, traditional and
of the Integrated Healthcare natural healthcare
Collaborative (IHC), which is a • encourage whole-person,
collection of leading organisations individualised healthcare
within complementary, traditional • raise issues in integrated
and natural healthcare. healthcare with government and
The IHC was formed following decision makers
a recommendation in a report by • develop co-ordinated strategies
the former All-Party Parliamentary to help patients access accurate
Group for Integrated Healthcare information on integrated
entitled Integrated Healthcare: healthcare
putting the pieces together. It said that • support the development of a
“professional associations representing robust and appropriate evidence
complementary, traditional and base
natural healthcare should work more • facilitate better access to, and
closely together on common issues, choice of, appropriate
to share knowledge and experience.
complementary, traditional and
A formal collaborative should be
natural healthcare within the NHS
established which brings together
• advocate collaboration with
major associations to take the field
conventional Western healthcare
forward collectively.”
professionals.
Shared belief
Commitment
IHC members believe that an
Faculty president Dr Gary Smyth
integrated healthcare service would
said: “As a member of the IHC the
improve patient experience, bring
Faculty is showing its commitment
about better patient outcomes, and
provide a framework for a more to working collectively with other
cost-effective delivery of healthcare key organisations to increase access
services. to homeopathy and other therapies,
Their shared belief is also outlined promote greater integration with
collaboration between the former conventional Western medicine, and
in the parliamentary report. “The
All-Party Parliamentary Group improve patient outcomes.”
future of healthcare lies in our health
for Integrated Healthcare and Along with homeopathy, many
system recognising that physical,
organisations in the field. other forms of complementary,
emotional and mental health are
intrinsically linked and that only by Objectives traditional and natural healthcare
treating the patient as a whole person The new group is bringing together are represented in the collaborative,
can we tackle the root cause of illness leading professional associations and including reflexology, medical
and deal with the problem of patients stakeholders from complementary, herbalism, traditional Chinese
presenting with multiple and complex traditional and natural healthcare, medicine and acupuncture, reiki,
conditions.” with the aim of working on common craniosacral therapy and naturopathy.
The founding of the IHC builds areas of interest. Its objectives include: To find out more about the IHC
on over 30 years of work and • increase public awareness, visit https://www.theihc.org.uk/
Royal Patron HRH The Prince of Wales
EDITORIAL
I
n these uniquely challenging times, When things are difficult there We hope that this will encourage
we thought that we would break with is always something to be learned you to reopen your Organon and
tradition and write a joint editorial from returning to our roots, in gain inspiration from the words of
from all three of us: your president, Hahnemann’s Organon. Time and Hahnemann and the knowledge that
vice-president and operations again one can discover inspiring we are all guardians of a system of
manager. clarity just when it is needed, and medicine that has stood the test of
We have heard from many of you the depth and beauty of his words time.
and are well aware how much good never cease to surprise and delight. We trust that you are keeping well,
work is going on in your practices. It is beyond frustrating that we are and as you continue to provide care for
We know that you are supporting and not allowed to claim the ability to your patients and your loved ones, that
advising your patients, not only about cure anything, but maybe we can you also look after your own health
the management of the coronavirus think of the “gentle and permanent and well-being. If you do feel unwell,
infection itself but also for the many restoration of health” in the “least don’t forget to contact a colleague for
emotional and physical symptoms disadvantageous way” as a worthy homeopathic advice and support, as
which arise because of the fear goal. Perhaps we should be using more well as following the government’s
generated by the pandemic, the effects of the wise words of Hahnemann, advice. And if you are not sure how to
of isolation – resulting in reduced such as “restoration of health” and do this, please feel free to contact the
opportunities for contact with loved “sustainer of health” when we write Faculty and we will be happy to help.
ones and for exercise – and sadly also about homeopathy rather than the We look forward to keeping in
in the mourning of bereaved friends somewhat two dimensional and far contact with all members and to
and relatives. less profound “helping to manage healthier and happier times ahead.
Homeopathy has a proud tradition symptoms”.
in pandemics and we are heartened Hahnemann has plenty to say Dr Gary Smyth,
to know that this good work is still about epidemics as well. “In the President
carrying on. We do of course wish to investigation of the symptom complex Dr Patricia Ridsdale,
harvest as much evidence as possible of epidemic diseases … it makes no Vice-president
and there are a number of case difference if something similar has Dr Sara Eames,
collection initiatives and projects to ever appeared before under the same Operations Manager
offer homeopathy in a wider context. or any other name.” The physician
Those of you who receive the “... must explore it for himself from the
Faculty’s E-News will already have ground up if he wants to be a genuine,
been alerted to information about thorough medical-art practitioner who
these projects. If you use email and never puts conjecture in the place of
do not yet receive the E-News, please perception and never assumes (without
contact Alison Davies our digital carefully spying out all of the disease
communications officer at adavies@ manifestations) that the treatment for
facultyofhomeopathy.org and she can a case of disease entrusted to him is
add you to our circulation list. As news either entirely or partially known.”
is fast moving at present, we are trying Hahnemann also stresses that “the
to contact you every week via the symptom complex of an epidemic Editor: John Burry
E-News and hope that this is proving disease only comes to light through the Consultant Editor: Sara Eames
helpful and supportive. observation of several cases involving Faculty of Homeopathy
As many of you will already know, different bodily constitutions”; and
CAN Mezzanine , 49-51 East Road
we have started a COVID-19 page only when this has been thoroughly
London, N1 6AH
on the Members Only part of the done does “the carefully investigating
Tel: 020 3640 5903
Faculty website, and this is constantly physician become alive to the
E: simile@facultyofhomeopathy.org
updated with the latest news both characteristic image of the disease”.
W: www.facultyofhomeopathy.org
from conventional medicine and It is easy to wonder about the many
our homeopathic colleagues. We different homeopathic medicines All the material in this publication is copyright and may
are particularly keen to receive any being suggested around the world as a not be reproduced without permission. The publishers
coronavirus-related information “genus epidemicus” and maybe there do not necessarily identify with or hold themselves
that you think will be of interest. will be more consensus by the time responsible for contributors’, correspondents’ or
This includes case reports which are this edition of simile lands on your advertisers’ opinions.
instructive, unusual or heartening, and doormat. However, in the meantime
any other tips you might have gleaned. it seems we have a lot to ponder
We feel sure that your own personal about “the characteristic image of the Design, print and mail fulfilment by
experiences, whether in the UK or disease” and the meaning of it for the HMCA Services Ltd.
abroad, will be of great interest to all of whole of our society and the way we Tel: 01423 866985
our members. have all allowed it to develop. Email: enquiries@hmca.co.uk
2
NEWS simile • May 2020 • The Faculty of Homeopathy
99th Faculty of Homeopathy Political support
in the European
Congress, 8 - 11 October 2020 parliament
Given the current restrictions and uncertainties caused by the coronavirus
A French politician has made a
pandemic, the Faculty council has recently held an emergency meeting to discuss
commitment to ensuring homeopathy
whether or not the congress can proceed as planned in October.
and anthroposophic medicine are
We are currently involved in discussions with the venue and are considering a
available within European healthcare
range of possible options. To ensure flexibility, the current deadlines for abstract
systems.
submissions and registrations can be disregarded until further notice and we will
Michèle Rivasi is an MEP
provide another update on the congress in the near future.
representing a coalition of Green parties
at Brussels. She pledged her support
International speaker at
in a foreword she wrote for a report
published by ECHAMP (European
Midlands’ group CPD event
Coalition on Homeopathic and
Anthroposophic Medicinal Products)
that looked at the current state of these
therapies in Europe and their potential
for growth.
In her foreword she says the report
confirms the high levels of awareness
and long-established use of these
medicines in many EU countries. She
acknowledges they have an excellent
safety profile, a high level of patient
satisfaction and an emerging evidence
base.
The MEP goes on to recognise how
the ECHAMP report offers up-to-date
data on the industry that highlights the
Dr Sujata Naik addresses the Midland’s Group “added value these therapies offer to
society in terms of safety, effectiveness,
The Faculty of Homeopathy’s Midlands’ discussions about different approaches cost-effectiveness and the environment”.
group welcomed two international to developing homeopathy to suit Ms Rivasi concludes: “As a long-
guests to its CPD event in January. patients’ needs all across the globe. time attentive user and observer
Dr Sujata Naik and Dr Sayali Joglekar- Dr Smyth said: “The presentation of homeopathic medicines, I have
Tilak flew in from Mumbai, India, was excellent and the associated direct personal experience of the
to deliver a seminar on the use of discussions were very helpful, with important role these therapies play
homeopathy in the treatment of skin Dr Naik providing many useful tips within complementary and integrative
disorders with a particular focus on and practical advice throughout. We medicine. I am committed to ensuring
psoriasis. all left inspired, enthused and looking that they take their rightful place within
Also attending the event was forward to putting some of the advice European health care.”
Faculty president, Dr Gary Smyth, into practice.” Homeopathic and Anthroposophic
who welcomed Dr Sujata Naik and Dr Kulwant Singh Uppal, the Medicinal Products in the EU –
Dr Joglekar-Tilak to the country and Faculty’s international members Spotlight on an Industry can be
said it was great to be reminded again representative, thanked Dr Naik for downloaded from www.echamp.eu/
of how homeopathy can help in the making the long journey to the UK to
treatment of many skin disorders, deliver her presentation. He said it was
including psoriasis, and to hear about another successful CPD event in the
how these conditions are being treated Midlands.
at Dr Naik’s clinic in Mumbai. When the Faculty introduced its
Dr Naik said skin disorders are new rules for membership eligibility in
the bane of modern life, with psoriasis 2018, Dr Naik became its first affiliate
in particular causing great distress to member. She said she looked forward
patients. “Homeopathy,” she added, to contributing more to the Faculty and
“has great potential for treating or that it was “an honour to belong to this
managing cases of psoriasis.” prestigious family”.
The event was very interactive with Read Dr Naik’s approach to treating Michèle Rivasi MEP
those in attendance taking part in lively musculoskeletal disorders on page 14.
3
NEWS
The Faculty issues important
advice for the coronavirus outbreak
The Faculty of Homeopathy has worked To help increase immunity:
with 4Homeopathy – a group of • eat healthily, including at least
leading UK homeopathic organisations five portions of fruit and
– to produce a set guidelines for vegetables a day
homeopaths to follow and disseminate • stay well hydrated
to their patients during the coronavirus • take regular, moderate exercise
outbreak. • ensure you get enough sleep.
Since the the first cases were
reported in China at the beginning of Additional measures for which there is
the year, Coronavirus – or COVID-19 some evidence for reducing the length
– has become a global pandemic sneezes is also emphasised. It’s and/or severity of upper respiratory
responsible for tens of thousands important to catch coughs and sneezes tract infections include taking regular
deaths. It causes cold or influenza- in a clean tissue where possible. This supplements of probiotics, vitamins C
like symptoms and pneumonia. It greatly reduces the spread of droplets and D and Zinc.
appears to have the most severe effect and any infective organisms. Tissues Can homeopathy help?
on the elderly and people with existing should be disposed of thoughtfully so Homeopathic medicines have been
medical conditions, particularly those others do not come into contact with used extensively for flu-like symptoms
with respiratory problems. them. Avoid touching other people or and in epidemics around the world.
Much of the advice issued by objects until you are able to wash or If you decide to take a homeopathic
the Faculty comes from the British sanitise your hands again. medicine, this should be in addition to
government’s chief medical officer It is also important to avoid the various measures outlined above
and is based around hygiene and touching your face, especially when and should not be your only approach.
prevention. you are out and haven’t recently washed Selection of the most appropriate
Faculty president Dr Gary Smyth your hands. Viruses can survive on homeopathic medicine is based on
said: “We cannot stress strongly enough objects or on our own hands and can an individual’s unique symptoms.
that these measures are of the utmost enter our systems through the mouth, However, Gelsemium 30C and Bryonia
importance and everyone should be nose and eyes. So avoid touching or 30C are commonly used for flu-like
advised to follow them. They are vital rubbing your face with unclean hands. symptoms and have a long-established,
both for our own health, and also for Avoid contact with large numbers of traditional usage over many years.
those with whom we come into contact.” people, and refrain from close physical Homeopathic options can form one
The advice includes frequent hand contact with associates and colleagues part of your approach to the current
washing with warm soapy water or such as handshakes or hugs. COVID-19 outbreak but should always
high alcohol-based hand sanitisers. It is Self-isolate if you are concerned you be used alongside other measures. If
particularly important to wash hands may have contracted the virus. Do not you have symptoms or are concerned
after travelling and after blowing your go to your GP or other medical service. that you may have been exposed to
nose. Practitioners should always wash Instead, UK members should phone coronavirus, it is important to seek
their hands before and after contact with NHS 111 for guidance and maintain appropriate medical advice in keeping
patients. Avoid anti-bacterial washes self-isolation until they are advised with current guidelines.
without high alcohol content as they otherwise. For further information see
do not eradicate viruses. Look for hand There are no scientific trials official guidance from the UK
sanitisers containing 65-95% alcohol. available for homeopathic or any other government, the NHS and World
Basic hygiene for coughs and treatment for COVID-19. Health Organization.
Liverpool’s charitable clinic moves to a new location
Liverpool Homeopathy, the charitable and the Alliance of Registered clinics can be found in Edinburgh,
clinic run by the British Homeopathic Homeopaths. The clinic is now Bath, Bristol, Monmouth, Norwich,
Association (BHA) in partnership with located at: Winchester and Street in Somerset.
the North West Friends of Homeopathy, 47 Rodney Street, Liverpool, L1 9EW. There are plans to open additional
has moved to a new address in the Liverpool Homeopathy is one of clinics later this year. You can find out
city centre. The service is staffed by eight clinics currently supported by more at the BHA website or by calling
practitioners from the Faculty of the BHA, offering free and low-cost 0203 640 5903.
Homeopathy, Society of Homeopaths homeopathic treatment. The other www.liverpoolhomeopathy.org/
4
NEWS simile • May 2020 • The Faculty of Homeopathy
Coronavirus claims the life of a
dedicated doctor and Faculty member
It is with great sadness that we report the he is still remembered fondly in the hearts
death of Faculty member Dr Syed Haider, and minds of many of his colleagues. He was
who died from COVID-19 in April. a very special doctor, with a quiet charm, a
Dr Haider studied medicine in Pakistan wonderfully mischievous smile, unlimited
but devoted almost his whole career to reserves of patience and kindness, and an
service in the NHS. He was a GP principal incredible work ethic. We need more people
in Romford and worked at the Royal like him, and the world will be a poorer place
London Hospital for Integrated Medicine without him.”
for 30 years as an associate specialist. He His son, also a doctor, described his father
obtained his MFHom in 1988 and had been as “a selfless man driven by his passion for his
a loyal Faculty member ever since. It was profession”.
so typical of him that at the age of 79 he He added: “Even whilst in hospital
was still supporting his patients in general breathing his last, he was urging doctors and
practice. nurses to pay attention to other patients rather
Many of you who have passed through than him.
the hospital in London will remember him “Many at his age would have retired, yet his
fondly as he quietly worked his way through huge numbers dedication to his profession was immeasurable.”
of patients, in his uniquely modest and good natured way. We have been in touch with his family on behalf of
Former colleague Dr Sara Eames said: “Although Syed you all and if any of you would like to send any personal
retired from the hospital a number of years ago, I know that messages to them, please contact the Faculty.
Homeopaths attack sceptics with their own prize
Every year in Austria a sceptic group in truth an attempt to raise questions studies that support the efficacy of
called the Society for the Scientific about who these sceptic groups homeopathy beyond placebo.
Investigation of Parasciences (GWUP) represent and their real aims. The homeopaths accuse the
announces the winner of the Golden The Austrian Society of Medical sceptic group of fanatical and
Board in Front of the Head Award Homeopathy and the Veterinary aggressive lobbying and media work
for what they deem as “unscientific Society for Homeopathy justify to discredit proven methods of
nonsense”. Their award frequently the award on the grounds that the complementary medicine, which
goes to a representative of Austria’s GWUP is trying to agitate against are successfully used by a large
homeopathy community. complementary medicine and number of people around the world.
However, it now appears Austrian homeopathy without disclosing their Their aim, claim the homeopaths,
homeopaths have turned the tables true motives and donors. They say is to position complementary
on their antagonists by bestowing the that under the guise of science and medicine in an “esoteric, frivolous
2019 Award for Pseudoscience to the purported “scientific truths” these corner, to curtail plurality and
GWUP. “all-knowing” activists, many of whom freedom of choice in healthcare, and
But what seems on the surface to are without any medical qualifications, to hinder progress towards inclusive
be a light hearted tit-for-tat gesture is deliberately misrepresent scientific medicine”.
The Faculty fully adopts remote working during the pandemic
The coronavirus pandemic has affected every aspect of Faculty’s business continues as normal we have invested
our lives, including how we work. To comply with the in Zoom – the online video conferencing service – which
government’s social distancing guidance the Faculty of we’ll use for meetings, enabling us to continue with our
Homeopathy is conducting its business remotely with all its core activities, even though the situation seems far from
staff working from home. normal.”
For the Faculty this was quite easy to set up, as most All the Faculty’s telephone numbers and email addresses
members of staff and its officers were already working some remain the same. If you have any urgent queries please
days at home, but there has also been investment in new contact Dr Sara Eames at seames@facultyofhomeopathy.org
technology. or lpeacock@facultyofhomeopathy.org
Operations manager, Dr Sara Eames, said: “To ensure the Telephone: +44 (0)203 640 5903
5
NEWS
Sceptic group drops its legal challenge against the PSA
A leading sceptic group has dropped
its legal challenge against the
Professional Standards Authority
(PSA) for renewing the Society of
Homeopaths’ accreditation. The
PSA is the government body that
aims to improve the regulation and
registration of people who work in
health and care.
Earlier this year, the Good
Thinking Society launched a judicial
review into the PSA’s decision to
reaccredit the Society of Homeopaths,
claiming it validated what they believe Emily Buttrum, chief executive any implications on health policies.
to be unproven remedies, particularly of the Society of Homeopaths, said: In response Helen Whately MP,
in connection with the use of CEASE “Accreditation by the PSA ensures that junior minister at the Department
therapy. patients can choose to see a homeopath of Health and Social Care, said the
Complete Elimination of Autistic belonging to a register that upholds department “does not maintain a
Spectrum Expression (CEASE) therapy robust standards. position on any complementary or
was developed by Dr Tinus Smits who “We therefore question the logic alternative medicine treatments”.
claims to have discovered a possible of recent calls for the society not to be She continued: “The Professional
link between many cases of autism and reaccredited, as accredited professional Standards Authority is an independent
vaccinations. He says he has for many bodies offer greater protection for the organisation who has responsibility
years been successfully treating autistic public, ensuring consistent standards for the accredited registers scheme.
children using isotherapy, a form of care. The society is pleased that The PSA is clear that accreditation is
of homeopathy using the causative the report and outcome issued by the not an endorsement of a particular
substances which are administered in PSA recognise the progressive plans treatment or therapy or its efficacy
homeopathic preparation. Although we have put in place to uphold our but ensures that practitioners are part
supporters of CEASE therapy say high professional standards and those of a body that works to good practice
there is growing anecdotal evidence required by the accredited registers and is committed to protecting the
to support Dr Smit’s claims, the scheme.” public.”
conventional medical world remains Publicity surrounding the PSA’s Following the PSA’s announcement
unconvinced his approach has any decision to reaccredit the society even that conditions were now in place
genuine therapeutic value. saw a question raised in the British preventing members of the Society
The use of homeopathy as parliament. Conservative MP Andrea of Homeopaths from advertising or
part of the therapy has seen many Jenkyns asked the Secretary of State practising CEASE therapy or offering
homeopaths around the world train as for Health and Social Care whether the advice on vaccinations, the Good
CEASE therapists, including members PSA’s decision to renew the Society of Thinking Society withdrew its legal
of the Society of Homeopaths. Homeopaths’ accreditation would have challenge.
A legal victory for homeopathy in Germany
A German pharmacy has been cleared constituted a misleading claim. see this differently; however, this group
of misleading consumers by selling a However, a court in the German of people is unlikely to use such products.
particular homeopathic product. town of Darmstadt dismissed the claim. Therefore, there is no case to answer.”
The claim was brought under In throwing out the case the judge The judge also stated that, if the
Germany’s consumer protection said: “The fact that, due to the extreme ruling had come out in favour of the
legislation by opponents of dilution, the material cannot be claimants, it would have affected
complementary medicine. identified using current methodologies, further homeopathic products. And
The claimants wanted the does not mean that one can assume this, the court argued, would not be in
homeopathic preparation HCG C30 – that the material is not, in fact, the interest of the consumer.
derived from a protein-based hormone contained in the homeopathic drug. The whole case hinged on whether
produced during pregnancy – banned “As consumers who buy or not the label HCG C30 was
from sale on the grounds that there is homeopathics are open to its tenets, misleading under German consumer
no measurable amount of the hormone they are not being misled by this protection law. The judge asserted that
in the product. This, they argued, product. Critics of homeopathy may it is not.
6
The Faculty of
Homeopathy’s Facebook
page has 10,000 followers. The Faculty’s Twitter
account has
Why not join them and keep up to
date with all the latest Faculty news, 7,804 followers
share your news and stay in touch Keep up with the conversations
with other members. Log on to
www.facebook.com/ http//twitter.com/fohhomeopathy
facultyofhomeopathy/
EVENT
Impressions from
attending my first Faculty
of Homeopathy AGM
Nurse Florentina who trained in homeopathy at the
same time as I did and who is now
Beta-Popescu is one preparing to take the MFHom exam.
of the Faculty’s newest She was also attending her first Faculty
Being able to meet
AGM, so it was nice seeing a familiar
members. She gives a face; for although everyone was very all these people and
personal account of the welcoming, as a new member I could
knowing that they
easily have felt slightly lost among a
Faculty’s AGM. crowd of people who I didn’t really
share my passion
A
fter recently passing the know.
MFHom exam and becoming I was also delighted to meet and commitment to
a member of the Faculty of another of my lecturers, Dr Russell
Homeopathy, I had the privilege of Malcolm. He also provided excellent homeopathy was for
meeting many Faculty members, support during my training and while me both inspiring and
lecturers and colleagues at the I was preparing for the MFHom exam.
organisation’s Annual General Another person I met was Dr Susan moving.
Meeting (AGM) which took place in Dreher-Brogan, a very dedicated and
February at the Thistle City Barbican experienced homeopathic physician
Hotel in central London. who is a long-standing member of the of the Faculty to give their reports,
As a new member who had never Faculty. “Like most people,” she told which can be read in February’s
been to a Faculty AGM, I must admit me, “when I first started to practise edition of simile. The different
I was looking forward to the occasion homeopathy I had underestimated officers had their own individual style
with great excitement. Being able to how much of an impact it would have of doing this, which combined to
meet all these people and knowing on my patients and consequently on make it interesting, informative and
that they share my passion and my career as a doctor. The Faculty entertaining. What struck me while
commitment to homeopathy was for contributes so much each year to listening to their reports was their
me both inspiring and moving. ensuring that high quality training in shared commitment to homeopathy
My involvement with homeopathy homeopathy is available to healthcare and the work they do on behalf of
began more than three years ago, professionals.” the Faculty. And it’s important to
when I first met the Faculty’s The Faculty family remember that these officers do this
operations manager, Dr Sara Eames, Faculty president Dr Gary Smyth work for the Faculty membership
who subsequently became one of warmly welcomed everyone to the in addition to running busy clinical
my lecturers. It was Dr Eames who AGM, before going on to announce practices.
whetted my appetite for homeopathy the names of those who had become The Faculty’s accounts for the
through an introductory one-day MFHoms, VetMFHoms and Fellows previous financial year were approved
course, and I can say that she played a over the last 12 months. Dr Smyth and Dr Lee Kayne was elected
notable role in my decision to follow commented that the MFHom is more unopposed as treasurer. It was then
this path and I’m so grateful for all her than a world renowned qualification announced that earlier that day the
support during my years of study. – it is also an indication of an ongoing members’ committee had met and held
Old friends and new relationship and membership of the a secret ballot to elect a new convener.
The evening began with a drinks Faculty family. I was really quite That vote resulted in two members
reception, allowing people to meet, emotional when my name was called receiving the same number of votes.
network and catch up with colleagues out and I was invited to the front Following discussions and subsequent
in a relaxed, convivial atmosphere. of the audience to be personally approval by the Faculty council, a
Incidentally, as I walked into the congratulated by Dr Smyth. decision was made to share this role
reception area for the AGM, I had the In presenting the annual review, between Dr Edward Thompson and
pleasant surprise of meeting a doctor Dr Smyth called upon several officers Ms Karen Hooton.
8
simile • May 2020 • The Faculty of Homeopathy
The president’s address totally new path in
In his address Dr Smyth reflected on her own life. And how
some of the activities of the previous this self-discovery
year. He said without doubt the has led her to seeing
highlight was the announcement patients as individuals
in June 2019 of HRH The Prince of and not just as a set
Wales as Patron of our organisation. of symptoms. This,
This is an enormous honour and has of course, reinforced
generated considerable interest both in one of the main
the UK and abroad. tenets of homeopathic
Dr Smyth then referred to a speech case taking that
given by Sir John Weir (1879 – 1971) at requires the L to R: Dr Sara Eames, Dr Gary Smyth
a previous Faculty AGM. Sir John Weir practitioner to be and Dr Patricia Ridsdale
is one of the Titans of homeopathy concerned with and
and was Faculty president from 1943 pay attention to the
– 1945. Speaking all those years ago whole person.
he said: “I would like to appeal to you After the lecture
all for loyalty to the Faculty and all there was a further
that it stands for. It means much to the opportunity to
president and council of any society socialise when drinks
to have the sympathetic interest and and canapés were
co-operation of its members, and served.
the presence of a full gathering is I learned a lot
stimulating not only to the individual from attending my
but to others.” first Faculty AGM.
Dr Smyth spoke about the heritage The Faculty is not like
we have received from Faculty other professional Members take their seats at the AGM
members and great homeopaths of the membership
past, and repeating Sir John’s words organisations;
he “ … urged us at all costs to preserve it is more of a
that heritage, enlarge and develop it community made
for the future generations of medical up of very special
men”. and committed
Quoting another excerpt from individuals who
Sir John’s speech, Dr Smyth said: through some turn of
“It should be the intention of every fate have discovered
member to take some active part in homeopathy and
the business of the organisation, and it its power to relieve
brings out the best that is in him.” suffering and heal
Dr Smyth stated that as we look the sick. Dr Julie Geraghty delivering the
forward to another year together, I’m proud to be Richard Hughes’ Memorial Lecture
these words are as applicable today a member of the
as when Sir John first delivered them Faculty. As well as
and should be a challenge to all providing education
Faculty members and to anyone who and training in
is associated with the discipline of homeopathy, I believe
homeopathy. it brings like-minded
A memorial lecture
people together Quoting another excerpt from
The AGM was followed by the annual
to give them the
strength to overcome
Sir John’s speech, Dr Smyth
Richard Hughes’ Memorial Lecture
which was given by Dr Julie Geraghty,
the challenges we as said: “It should be the intention
homeopaths face and
who until recently was the Faculty’s
enable us all to make
of every member to take some
medical dean. She reflected on 25
years of homeopathic practice and
a real difference to active part in the business of the
people’s health and
what homeopathy has taught her about
the world we live in. It was a very
lives. organisation, and it brings out the
personal and moving lecture in Florentina best that is in him.”
which Dr Geraghty talked about Beta-Popescu
how homeopathy had opened up a MFHom
9
15
CASE STUDY
Between life
and death
Dr Ghizlaine Case analysis
Tuesday 26 Sept: Before going to
Ghallab is an the hospital I decide to take some
ophthalmologist and remedies with me. I make a quick
repertorisation with the symptoms
president of HUMA, the described by the girl’s aunt.
Hahnneman Unicist • Eyes, yellow
• Face, yellow
Moroccan Association. • Skin, yellow – jaundice icterus
Here she shares a • Abdomen, inflammation – liver
hepatic
remarkable and • Stomach, vomiting yellow
inspiring case. • Generalities, coldness, lack of
vital heat
T
his is the short case history of
a five-year-old girl hospitalised Dr Ghizlaine Ghallab If I cross all these rubrics I get the
with acute fulminant hepatitis B following 18 remedies: Phosphorus,
with encephalopathy. The medical eat anything. Her fatigue worsens with Chelidonium, Arsenicum album,
prognosis was very serious and she the appearance of an icterus, diarrhoea China officinalis, Bryonia, Natrum
needed a liver transplant or die. The and vomiting. sulfuricum, Sepia, Mercurius,
history of the disease was related to me Hydratis, Aconite, Iodum, Crotalus
Friday 22 Sept: She is hospitalised
by the girl’s aunt on the tenth day of horridus, Carduus marianus,
in the department of infectious
the illness. Homeopathy allowed her to Kalium bichr, Plumbum, Phytolacca,
paediatrics.
heal quickly without sequela. Leptandra virginica and Arsenicum
Saturday 23 Sept: The doctor tells iodatum.
The family is very poor and live
the parents that the diagnosis is I go through them one by one
in the countryside. On a journey to
fulminant hepatitis B with hepatic reading Phatak’s repertory and I
Casablanca to visit the five-year-old’s
encephalopathy. They cannot give any decide only to take those that have a
older sister the girl became very tired.
drugs, her liver has been destroyed by strong affinity for the liver.
Her condition quickly worsened and
the virus and probably her only hope is I take with me five remedies:
she was diagnosed with fulminant
to go abroad for a liver transplant. Phosphorus, Chelidonium, Natrum
hepatitis B. She soon found herself
The family is devastated by this sulfuricum, Leptandra virginica and
between life and death.
news, and almost in mourning as they Carduus marianus. At around 5pm I
Here is how it happened. don’t have the means for such a therapy. go to the hospital.
Sunday 17 Sept 2017: The little girl The doctor is reluctant to tell the I go directly to see the girl in her
travels with her parents from her home parents that their daughter will die hospital room without meeting the
in the countryside to visit her older Monday 25 Sept: I met the girl’s aunt doctors or nurses caring for her. On
sister in the city of Casablanca. who tearfully told me her story. At first entering the room I see a prostrate
Monday 18 Sept: She begins to be tired I am sad and sympathise. From what little girl, lying in her bed, with a
and to vomit. I’m told I believe the girl’s condition simple infusion of saline or glucose.
is beyond any therapeutic remedy. She is almost unable to move, too weak
Tuesday 19 Sept: Her condition does Then I said to myself that I must try to answer or to open her eyes, almost
not improve. She is very weak with homeopathy – after all she has nothing in a pre-coma. Her skin from head to
no appetite. Her parents take her to a to lose. I proposed to the aunt that I toes is a yellow-orange colour, along
doctor who diagnoses hepatitis, tells go to the hospital to see her niece the with the conjunctiva, the tongue and
her to rest and gives some vitamins following day at the end of my private the mouth.
Wednesday 20 Sept: The girl cannot ophthalmology consultations. I read the medical report: hepatitis B
10simile • May 2020 • The Faculty of Homeopathy
fulminant, hepatic encephalopathy Furthermore, for 95% of patients therapeutic approach of all doctors.
with high level of transaminase ALAT/ I had only a few categories of drugs to Key words: Fulminant hepatitis B,
ASAT 3540 (normal less than 35 UI/L). prescribe, juggling between antibiotics, Hepatitis, jaundice, transplant
On my smart phone I take a look anti-inflammatory corticosteroids or
Dr Ghizlaine Ghallab
at the application Complete Dynamics antihistamine drugs.
Ophthalmologist
and read what Phatak writes about In this acute stage 1 case, the most
the five remedies that I had brought urgent need was to find a remedy with
with me. a strong affinity for the affected organ Leptandra virginica
I read about Leptandra virginica. It (here the liver). I didn’t really ask about It affects the right side of the liver,
affects the right side and liver, causing her sleep, dreams, food preferences, as causing haemorrhages due to liver
haemorrhages due to liver affections. this was an acute case and the patient affections. Burning in hepatic region.
Burning, in hepatic region. Bilious was comatose. It is possible that the Bilious states. Weakness, hardly able to
state. Weakness, HARDLY ABLE TO other remedies that I quoted would stand and walk. Jaundice.
STAND or WALK, jaundice. have worked too – homeopathy is Aggravation: Worse: Cold drinks.
I did not have a valid argument to really generous. Motion. Periodically. Wet weather.
eliminate Chelidonium or Natrum- Amelioration: Better: Lying on
sulfuricum, but this last sentence made abdomen; on side.
me decide on Leptandra virginica. Mind: Hopeless; despondent and
I put some pellets of Leptandra drowsy; with hepatic affections.
200C in a small bottle of water and Head: Dull frontal headache; with
asked the mother to give two spoons aching navel.
per a day for three days. To reassure Eyes: Smarting and aching in eyes.
myself more than anything, I tell the Mouth: Tongue, yellow, or black
aunt that if the young girl has any vital down centre.
force left, it may help. Stomach: Craving for cold drinks
which worse burning and aching in
Wednesday 27 Sept: I am very worried
Leptandra virginica stomach. Sinking at the pit of stomach.
about this poor young child, so early
Meat and vegetables disagree.
in the morning I call the aunt who tells
Abdomen: Sore or dull burning
me that this morning her little niece This case reflects what Burnett
ache over liver or near gall bladder;
opened her eyes and asked for an apple says: “Death is often, at the start, in
extending down over bowels to
and a banana, when previously she had a particular organ, i.e. local, and if
navel or towards left scapula or
not eaten for six days. For the family the part be saved in time life may be
along spine, which feels chilly. Liver
it was a miracle and I knew that the preserved. In the acute process the
swollen transversely. Acute liver
game was won. value of a particular organ strikes one conditions. Gallstones. Constant dull
Sunday 1 October: I call the aunt who often very forcibly, there may be no aching in umbilical region. Stools;
tells me that the little girl has recovered need of any constitutional treatment; muddy, watery; TARRY OR BLACK;
well. The doctors have authorised her the one suffering part may be the FOUL. Stingy, waxy or spurting,
discharge from the hospital because whole case, and in many chronic cases in the morning; with pain at navel.
of the normalisation of the blood test certain organs claim and must have Dysentery; after diarrhoea. Prolapsing
(transaminases), and the general state special attention.” piles; with haemorrhages. Jaundice,
of her health. They didn’t understand The other point is that this little with clay coloured stools. Feeling as
what had happened. The family didn’t girl was saved by an inexpensive if something was passing out of the
say anything about the homeopathy. remedy. If the parents had had the rectum.
Two years later, I hear the girl enormous means to travel abroad Urinary organs: Red or orange
is fine and developing and playing to try to get a liver transplant for coloured urine, with dull aching in
normally. She didn’t even have the their daughter, it would have been lumbar region.
six months of tiredness that patients necessary to find a compatible donor; Female: Menses; suppressed
usually suffer after hepatitis. then she would have spent her whole or retarded, with liver affection.
life on immunosuppressors and Leucorrhoea; warm, watery; runs down
Discussion
corticosteroids, suffering all the sides- the limbs; from ulceration of the os.
This very severe case of acute hepatitis
effects associated with the long-term Heart: Soreness at. Pulse slow and
that was treated successfully in
use of these drugs. full.
five days has convinced me that
homeopathy is the most powerful Conclusion Extremities: Pain in Sciatic nerve
medicine. Homeopathy is an ecological and (left); worse on sitting. Nails very thin,
As an ophthalmologist who has economic medicine, able to treat the soft and splitting.
practised allopathic medicine for 20 entire planet at little cost; to treat the Fever: Chilly along the spine and
years, I realised that patients were majority of the poor population; to down the arm.
mostly not cured from acute episodes, make savings for governments around Relations: Related remedies: Bapt;
but just revert to chronic disease. the world. It should be a part of the Card-m; Chion. Complementary: Phos.
11INTERVIEW
Working towards the
greater integration of
homeopathy in the
healthcare systems
of Europe
The Faculty of physicians and pharmacists, advised
me to study homeopathy. I am still
already, but not enough in our view,
not enough to express its potential
Homeopathy is thankful for this excellent advice, fully.
without it I would probably have
a member of the changed my job.
The World Health Organization
(WHO) has recognised this and this
European Committee As a general practitioner I use was the reason it issued its strategic
homeopathy in my daily prescriptions plan 2014 to 2023 for traditional and
of Homeopathy (ECH). because it gives good results for most complementary medicine (TCM),
Dr Hélène Renoux of the conditions I have to treat. But urging its member states to facilitate
of course I still use conventional and supervise the integration of TCM
is a French GP and medicine when needed. I see myself as by setting quality rules regarding their
president of the ECH. an artisan with valuable extra tools in practice and training.
my bag. At European level, the ECH was
Here she talks about exactly on the same wavelength when
What are the aims of the ECH?
her career and the The European Committee for endorsing the European Standard
CEN - EN 16872, which specifies the
work of the ECH. Homeopathy (ECH) represents
minimum requirements for medical
medical doctors with an additional
qualification in homeopathy doctors with additional qualification in
How did you first become interested
throughout Europe. It comprises homeopathy and their services.
in homeopathy and what made you
pursue it professionally? around 40 associations in 25 countries. How does the ECH ensure the highest
After graduating as a medical doctor Other members are pharmacists, standard of homeopathic practice and
I first spent several months as a researchers or scholars sharing professionalism is being delivered by
humanitarian doctor in Pakistan, our goal which is the integration its members?
working with Afghan refugees. On of homeopathy within the global For many years the ECH has issued
returning to France it seemed no healthcare system. guidelines on how homeopathy should
longer possible for me to continue ECH partners also work with be taught at post-graduate level.
practising medicine in the usual way. EFHPA, which represents European ECH accredited schools have to fulfil
For in Pakistan I had experienced associations of patients/users of demanding criteria which constitute
strongly committed and meaningful homeopathy. This means ECH strives a real guarantee that the diploma-
medical practice, and I needed to give to support good quality training and holders have a real and sufficient
more sense to my work as a physician. research in homeopathy, and helps to knowledge.
I wanted to meet the expectations protect the availability of high quality The ECH guidelines for training
of my patients, and I was looking homeopathic medicinal products have been used as a basis for the mirror
for a way to do it. The “ready-made across the whole European continent. committees that worked on the CEN
recipes” that I had learned from my What steps are being taken to see document in 2015/2016. They are the
medical training and was applying homeopathy fully integrated into the result of many years of shared work
daily were not always helping my health systems of Europe? and experience among the most skilled
patients and therefore not satisfying to Actually homeopathy is integrated homeopathic teachers throughout
me as a doctor. Friends of mine, both in the European heathcare system Europe.
12simile • May 2020 • The Faculty of Homeopathy
agencies from the European Economic
Dr Hélène Renoux
Area.
Despite the hostility towards
homeopathy from some medical
professionals and scientists, are you
optimistic for its future and, if so, why?
At times it is difficult to remain
optimistic in the face of the terrible
challenges the world is facing
regarding health and the environment.
We cannot be pleased with the
current situation which is causing the
deaths of so many people. Obviously
this questions the choices that have
been made in terms of health and
environment management.
What have been the ECH’s main researchers in the field of homeopathy Hopefully, this should create
achievements in recent years? in Europe. It supports their work, awareness among our governments,
Apart from the CEN project, which is which is crucial as much for clinical policy makers and scientists that
indeed one the ECH’s greatest recent validation as for the exploration of the the current paradigm has failed. In
achievements, other important projects mode of action of homeopathy. this regard homeopathy has its role
are ongoing. The pharmacy sub-committee to play, which has been for too long
The ECH operates a number of is currently working to establish impeded by prejudices. Homeopathy is
important sub-committees. The guidelines for the homeopathic a sustainable, environmentally friendly
provings sub-committee has developed, training for pharmacists, and is medicine, and the moment has come to
together with the other main cooperating with a number of recognise it.
homeopathic associations, guidelines other organisations, such as the
Dr Hélène Renoux
for homeopathic proving that should Homeopathic Medicinal Products
President of the European
be used by regulators when registering Working Group (HMPWG) under the
Committee for Homeopathy
homeopathic medicinal products. European umbrella of HMA (Heads
The research sub-committee brings of Medicines Agencies), a network of For more information about the ECH
together some of the most prominent both human and veterinary medicines’ visit www.homeopathyeurope.org
Have you something to say?
If you have news or an interesting case study to share.
Or if there is something you want to get off your chest.
Why not contribute to simile?
simile is your newsletter, so we would like to hear from you.
Please contact the editor John Burry at
jburry@facultyofhomeopathy.orgCASE STUDY
Using homeopathy for
musculoskeletal
disorders can deliver
significant results
Dr Sujata Naik is a Clinical progression and prognosis
depends on the following key
First aid
Certain homeopathic remedies could
leading international factors: be helpful as first aid in management
homeopath and • Does the problem arise from the
of injuries, sprains or spasms through
symptom amelioration and reducing
researcher, and the first
•
joint, tendon, ligament or muscle?
Is the condition acute or chronic?
the inflammation, swelling and
ecchymoses. Here, choose a remedy
affiliate member of the • Is the condition inflammatory or
having a sphere of action specifically
Faculty of Homeopathy.
•
non-inflammatory?
What is the pattern of affected
on the musculoskeletal system
and having clinically proven its
Here she provides a areas/joints? efficacy in the said condition.
synopsis of her talk •
What is the impact of the
condition on the patient’s life?
Remedies like:
on “Musculoskeletal • Arnica montana – first remedy
Homeopathic approach to MSDs
Disorders and Musculoskeltal disorders include a
following falls, blows, contusions,
concussions, after traumatic
Homeopathy” which wide range of ailments from traumatic injuries, sprains.
she delivered to the to degenerative, inflammatory,
infective to autoimmune. A multi-
• Hypericum perforatum – for
injuries to nerves, punctured
Faculty of Homeopathy dimensional approach tailored to incised or lacerated wounds, arrests
Midlands group in treat the particular condition could be
implemented. While individualisation
ulceration and sloughing.
• Rhus toxicodendron – spraining or
September 2019. based on totality of symptoms remains straining tendons, affection of
the cornerstone of homeopathic fibrous tissue.
T
he term musculoskeletal prescription, certain specific remedies • Ruta graveolens – lameness after
disorders (MSDs) covers any may need to be administered in certain sprains especially of wrists and
injury, damage or disorder of the conditions especially mechanical ankles.
joints or other tissues in the upper/ injuries. • Symphytum officinale – acts on
lower limbs or the back. MSDs include: The following broad classification joints, tendons and periosteum.
upper limb disorders, lower limb could prove helpful in determining the Useful in non-union of fractures
disorders and back pain. MSDs are line of homeopathic treatment and the and after blows from obtuse objects .
common and the risk of developing remedies prescribed under different Very useful for traumatic injuries to
them increases with age. circumstances: the eye.
Classification of MSDs
Origin Nature Duration Distribution
Articular Inflammatory Acute Localised
Non-articular Non-inflammatory Chronic Wide-spread (Systemic)
14simile • May 2020 • The Faculty of Homeopathy
• Bellis perennis – useful in injuries
to deeper tissues after surgery,
associated with muscular soreness
and lameness. Useful for exudation,
Pathology of cervical spondylosis
stasis and cellulitis.
Acute
In acute exacerbations of chronic
disorders – for example: rheumatoid Degeneration of intervertebral disc
arthritis, gout, muscle spasm in
cervical spondylosis – it is important
to give symptomatic relief to the
patient. Here the indicated remedy
is based on the presenting totality. Reduction in Disc Spaces Peripheral Osteophyte
The acute homeopathic remedy helps Formation
give symptom relief to the patient
and may open up the case for further
constitutional prescribing on the next
follow up.
• Colchicum autumnale – for gout.
• Bryonia alba – for acute pain, Secondary Involvement Impingement Pressure
inflammation of affected joint > of Posterior on Nerve on
by rest Intervertebral Joints Root Spinal Cord
• Nux vomica – in acute muscle
spasm from cervical spondylosis.
Chronic
In chronic conditions, constitutional
prescribing is the hallmark for true Neck Radicular pain in Signs of Cord
homeopathic similimum. Only pain Upper Limbs Compression
detailed case taking, analysis and
repertorisation can result in accurate
prescribing. Several autoimmune
conditions like psoriatic arthritis,
systemic lupus erythematosis, It helps to maintain general well-being
ankylosing spondylitis have periods including appetite, thirst and sleep. It
of natural exacerbations and natural may also help to restrict the need of
remissions. The discerning homeopath NSAIDS and analgesics.
must work around these modalities
when selecting the remedy. Cervical spondylosis
A remedy that covers the Cervical spondylosis is a
constitutional totality of the patient common chronic condition of
and also has an affinity for the the neck involving:
musculoskeletal system could give • The vertebral bodies
long-term relief and could also slow (osteophyte
down disease progression. formation),
Supportive • Intervertebral
Homeopathy could be used in discs (deformation,
conjunction with the conventional disc herniation),
mode of treatment in conditions and
of advanced pathologies like • Adjacent ligaments.
severe rheumatoid arthritis,
spondyloarthroses, psoriatic arthritis, It is osteoarthritis of cervical spine.
seropositive ankylosing spondylitis According to the 2010 Global Burden
and advanced prolapsed intervertebral of Disease study neck pain was the
disc. fourth leading cause of years lost to
It helps to reduce post-surgical disability. It is more prevalent among
symptoms like nausea, acidity, sleep women and the prevalence of neck
disturbances and urinary complaints. pain peaked in middle age.
15CASE STUDY
Homeopathic treatment for Siblings healthy. The patient lives with
cervical spondylosis wife and a seven-year-old daughter in
The homeopathic remedy should be Mumbai.
aimed not only at giving symptomatic The patient has a strong desire for
relief, but to also slow down the eggs and sweets. He’s been a heavy
degenerative progression of the smoker for more than seven years,
cervical spine and to help strengthen smoking two packets of cigarettes a
the ligaments of the neck. day. Thermal state: chilly (showers with
hot water and needs a thick blanket
Calcarea carbonica
A case of even in summer).
Life situation and mind
cervical Patient had inter-state love marriage.
Three-month follow up – Nov 2015
spondylosis Patient is originally from Tamil Nadu
Had one episode of acute pain and
stiffness following physical exertion at
A 34 year-old-male, executive head of while his wife hails from Rajasthan.
work. Pain > by rest 3+, >> hot fomentation.
in August 2015 with pain in the neck disputes in marriage. This causes
region which he had suffered for three immense stress to patient. Has become Treatment: Bryonia 30C, four pills
years. Pain at nape of the neck with irritable and short tempered of late. three times a day for three days was
stiffness and tingling and numbness He is not able to concentrate at work, prescribed. Experienced relief within
in both upper extremities. Has been leading to anxiety and restlessness and 24 hours. Was monitored on Sac
taking NSAIDs for one year without sensation of internal chilliness. Patient lac for six months during which the
significant relief. also worries a lot about his health. patient reported no episodes of pain or
Says even after surgery his complaint discomfort.
of rhinitis did not improve. And now Six-month follow up – Feb 2016
he also suffers from neck pain. Gets Pain and stiffness at nape of neck
anxious when neck pain starts as it reduced significantly. Anxiety had
further affects his work and routine reduced remarkably and recurrent
Repertorisation episodes of rhinitis have also decreased
The repertorisation was based on the considerably.
following rubrics: Observation
1. Complete, Mind, Anxiety health Calcarea carbonicum has a special
about affinity for glands, skin and bones. For
2. Complete, Mind , handle things chilly, overweight individuals with
anymore cannot, overwhelmed low bone health, chronic deficiency
by stress of calcium and low vitality. Profuse
3. (Murphy) Clinical, colds tendency perspiration, scrofulous tendency
to catch and taking cold easily are some of the
4. Complete, General coldness, lack important characteristics. Rheumatic
Cervical spondylosis of vital heat pains from exposure to cold damp
5. Complete, Extremities, pain weather, needs coveringYou can also read
