STATES OF CONTROL: COVID, CUTS AND IMPUNITY - SOUTH ASIA PRESS FREEDOM REPORT 2019-20

Page created by Clinton Wells
 
CONTINUE READING
STATES OF CONTROL: COVID, CUTS AND IMPUNITY - SOUTH ASIA PRESS FREEDOM REPORT 2019-20
STATES OF CONTROL:
COVID, CUTS AND IMPUNITY
SOUTH ASIA PRESS FREEDOM REPORT – 2019-20
STATES OF CONTROL: COVID, CUTS AND IMPUNITY - SOUTH ASIA PRESS FREEDOM REPORT 2019-20
2       I FJ P R E S S F R E E D O M R E P O R T 2 0 1 9 – 2 0 2 0

JOURNALISTS DETAINED IN SOUTH ASIA
(MAY 1, 2019 – APRIL 30, 2020)

T
     he IFJ documented cases of 50 journalists detained or jailed in              450ml of liquor and 100g of hemp           for illegally carrying US dollars and
     South Asia from May 2019 to April 2020.                                      by a mobile court after a midnight         dealing in currency exchange. He was
        In Afghanistan, ten journalists were arrested or detained for             raid. The court sentenced him to           detained after he allegedly received US
     short periods for crimes such as criticism of government or                  one year in prison and a fine of BDT       currency for a provided IT service to a
alleged links to the Taliban but most were released within hours                  50,000 (USD 560).                          client who was a relative of a member
after the intervention of media advocacy groups, unions and the                   Status: Currently in jail.                 of parliament for the ruling Awami
joint committee on government and media. In the period, 29                                                                   League. He was charged with digital/
                                                                                                                             electronic fraud and for publishing
journalists were detained for 24 hours or less, highlighting issues of            INDIA                                      or sending of offensive, false or fear
threat and intimidation to silence journalist reporting in the region.            Name: Aasif Sultan                         inducing or defamatory information.
   India again was the region’s leader in detention and incarceration             Gender: Male                               Status: Released on bail on July 3,
of journalists for longer periods, with ten journalists detained or               Detained: August 27, 2018 (Sultan          2019
jailed in the year, compared to eight the previous year, including                was held in police lock-up from
the ongoing incarceration of Asif Sultan from 2018. Concerningly,                 August 27 until being formally
a large number of journalists continued to be charged for sharing                 arrested on August 31)                     INDIA
content on social media platforms, with an overwhelming majority                  Job: Assistant editor, Kashmir             Name: Anuj Shukla (M) & Ishita
of cases relating to politicians or political media coverage.                     Narrator                                   Singh (F)
   Four journalists currently remain behind bars in the region; two in            Location: Srinagar, Jammu and              Detained: June 8, 2019
Bangladesh, one in India and one in Pakistan. The case of Pakistan’s              Kashmir, India                             Job: Journalists, Nation Live News
Mir Shakil-ur-Rehman remained in news headlines in March and                      Accusation: Sultan was charged under       Location: Uttar Pradesh, India
April 2020. The editor-in-chief of the Jang and Geo Media Group was               the Unlawful Activities (Prevention)       Accusation: Shukla and Singh were
arrested on March 12 on a case dating back 34 years.                              Act, an anti-terror law which has          arrested for sharing a video on Twitter
                                                                                  come under sharp criticism for             which was deemed to defame the
   Bangladesh still sits on a critical watch list for the IFJ with six
                                                                                  curtailing freedom of expression. The      chief minister of Uttar Pradesh, Yogi
journalists detained or in continuing incarceration in the period.
                                                                                  journalist was charged for publishing      Adityanath. The video contained
   Detainment and arrests increased drastically in Nepal, from four
                                                                                  a feature story in July 2018 on the        claims made by a woman against the
the year prior to 24 in the current period. This was largely a result of
                                                                                  second anniversary of the death of the     minister.
police propensity to round up and detain journalists at protests.                 young Kashmiri militant Burhan Wani,       Status: Released on bail on June 19,
   Of the 50 detained, at least 10 journalists were released on bail.             a killing that sparked months of strife    while Shukla was released on bail on
Nasrullah Chaudhry, who was arrested in Karachi on allegations of                 on the streets.                            July 21.
carrying journals and booklets about Afghan Jihad and the Punjabi                 Status: Currently in jail.
Taliban on December 11, 2019, was acquitted by the Sindh High                                                                Name: Qazi Shibli
Court on April 9, 2020.                                                                                                      Gender: Male
                                                                                  PAKISTAN                                   Detained: July 25, 2019
                                                                                  Name: Mir Shakil-ur-Rehman                 Job: News editor, The Kashmiriyat
                                                                                  Gender: Male                               Location: Kashmir, India
  TOTAL JAILED                             JAILED JOURNALISTS -                   Detained: March 12, 2020                   Accusation: Shibli was arrested after
                                                                                  Job: Editor in chief, Jang & Geo
  OR DETAINED:                             CURRENTLY IN JAIL                      Media Group
                                                                                                                             tweeting an official order regarding
                                                                                                                             the deployment of paramilitary
  Currently in jail: 4                     BANGLADESH                             Location: Karachi, Pakistan                troops across the Kashmir region
  Detained for more                        Name: Abul Asad                        Accusation: Rehman was arrested            that allegedly leaked crucial details
  than one week: 13                        Gender: Male                           following an investigation by the          about imminent troop movements in
  Detained for less than                   Detained: December 13, 2019            National Accountability Bureau (NAB)       Jammu and Kashmir. He was charged
  one week: 4                              Job: Editor, Daily Sangram             into allegations that a property he        under the Public Safety Act.
                                           Accusation: Asad was arrested for      purchased 34 years prior had been
  Detained for one day                                                                                                       Status: Released on April 23, 2020.
                                           describing an executed opposition      bought illegally. Jang & Geo Media
  or less: 30
                                           leader convicted for war crimes        Group is one of the largest media
  Women jailed: 1                                                                                                            Name: Santosh Jaiswal
                                           as a “martyr” in a Bengali-            groups in Pakistan and is famous for       Gender: Male
  TOTAL: 51                                language newspaper published on        its critical investigations of Pakistani   Detained: September 6, 2019
                                           December 12. The article referred      politicians.                               Job: Journalist, Jansandesh Times
                                           to Abdul Quader Molla, who was         Status: In solitary confinement in         Location: Uttar Pradesh, India
                                           hanged over crimes committed           a NAB facility. Yet to be formally         Accusation: Arrested for taking
                                           during Bangladesh’s 1971 war of        charged.
  TOTAL JAILED OR                          independence. When the article was
                                                                                                                             photos and videos of children
                                                                                                                             mopping floors at a local primary
  DETAINED BY COUNTRY                      published, Hatirjheel Police Station   JOURNALISTS JAILED FOR                     school in Uttar Pradesh on September
                                           filed a case against Asad under the
  IN SOUTH ASIA                            Digital Security Act.                  MORE THAN ONE WEEK
                                                                                                                             6 and sending them to police to
                                                                                                                             bring to notice the illegal practice.
  Afghanistan: 10
  Bangladesh: 3
                                           Status: Currently in jail.             BANGLADESH                                 Jaiswal was arrested over accusations
                                                                                  Name: Mohammad Abdul Kaium,                of “extortion and obstructing public
  Bhutan: 0                                Name: Ariful Islam
                                                                                  Gender: Male                               servants from doing their duty”.
  Nepal: 24                                Gender: Male                                                                      Status: Released on bail on
                                                                                  Detained: May 12, 2019
  India: 10                                Detained Date: March 13, 2020                                                     November 20, 2019.
                                                                                  Job: Editor, Mymensinghlive
                                           Job: Journalist, Bangla Tribune
  Maldives: 0                                                                     Location: Mymensingh District,
                                           Location: Kurigram, Bangladesh                                                    Name: Zubair Ahmed
  Pakistan: 3                                                                     Bangladesh
                                           Accusation: Islam was charged and                                                 Gender: Male
  Sri Lanka: 1                                                                    Accusation: Kaium, a journalist
                                           convicted with alleged possession of                                              Detained: April 27, 2020
                                                                                  and IT professional, was arrested
STATES OF CONTROL: COVID, CUTS AND IMPUNITY - SOUTH ASIA PRESS FREEDOM REPORT 2019-20
3

                                                                                                  IN THE PERIOD, 29 JOURNALISTS
                                                                                                  WERE DETAINED FOR 24 HOURS
                                                                                                  OR LESS, HIGHLIGHTING ISSUES
                                                                                                  OF THREAT AND INTIMIDATION
                                                                                                  TO SILENCE JOURNALISTS
                                                                                                  REPORTING IN THE REGION.

Job: Freelance journalist               Detained: August 23, 2019              journals and booklets about Afghan          •	Rahul Kulkarni (M), 14-
Location: Andaman, India                Job: Editor, janasanchar.com           Jihad and the Punjabi Taliban.                 16/04/20, Osmanabad, India:
Accusation: Freelance journalist        Location: Pokhara, Nepal               The items were said to include                 Arrested over a report on the
Zubair Ahmed is arrested and taken      Accusation: Charged with sedition      materials that help sow disharmony             recommencement of trains in
to Aberdeen police station for his      for allegedly supporting the banned    on sectarian grounds and motivate              Bandra after it allegedly prompted
tweet asking why a family has been      Communist Party of Nepal led by        people to take part in jihad. The              mass gathering of migrants during
put under quarantine for a phone        Netra Bikram Chand.                    charge-sheet alleged Chaudhry had              the Covid-19 lockdown. Released
call with Covid-19 quarantine           Status: Released on September 10,      links with al-Qaeda leader Khalid              on bail.
patients. Police charged Zubair         2019.                                  Mukshi.
under the Disaster Management Act                                              Status: Acquitted by the Sindh High
for obstruction, disobedience and the   Name: Jitendra Maharjan                Court on April 9, 2020.                     JOURNALISTS DETAINED 24
publishing of information that may      Gender: Male
                                        Detained: April 9, 2019
                                                                                                                           HOURS OR LESS
cause alarm to the public.
Status: Released on bail on April       Job: Editor, Nhugu Jwojoloppa          SRI LANKA                                   •	Nine (9) journalists detained
                                                                               Name: Mohammed Rizvi Maharoof                  together at a protest in
28, 2020                                Location: Kathmandu, Nepal
                                                                               Gender: Male                                   Dhanusha, Nepal – 12/06/19 -
                                        Accusation: Police arrested and
                                                                               Detained Date: May 27, 2019                    RN Biswas (M), Shyam Sundar
                                        charged Maharjan under crimes
NEPAL                                   connected to state and organised       Job: Journalist                                Yadav (M), Baidhanath Yadav (M),
                                                                                                                              Nabin Kumar Gupta (M), Bhusan
Name: Khem Thapaliya                    crime. He was alleged to have close    Location: Anuradhapura, Sri Lanka
Gender: Male                                                                   Accusation: Maharoof was                       Kumar Singh (M), Bindu Yadav
                                        relations with the Netra Bikram
Detained: August 10, 2019                                                      arrested on suspicion regarding the            (M), Dharmapal Raut (M), Gopal
                                        Chand-led Communist Party of
Job: Editor-in-chief, Jaljala                                                  possession of 326 CDs alleged to               Gupta (M),Parish Karna (M).
                                        Nepal, which was branded a
Location: Kathmandu, Nepal              criminal outfit by the government in   contain sermons and other publicity         •	Asadullah Samim, Paktika,
Accusation: Police arrested             March 2020.                            material of the National Thowheed              Afghanistan, 23/07/19 (M)
Thapaliya for alleged involvement       Status: Released on bail on April      Jamath, which was accused of                •	Sajan Saud, Pokhara, Nepal –
in the outlawed Chand-led Nepal         30, 2019                               carrying out the Easter Sunday                 02/08/19 (M)
Communist Party after the party                                                attacks in April 2019.                      •	Nine (9) journalists detained
was declared a criminal outfit by                                              Status: Released on bail after one
the government and all its activities
                                        PAKISTAN                               week.
                                                                                                                              together at a protest in
                                        Name: Azhar-ul Haq Wahid                                                              Kathmandu Nepal – 16/09/19
banned in March 2019.                                                                                                         – Ram Prasad Dahal (M), Ajaya
                                        Gender: Male
Status: Released on August 26,
2019.
                                        Detained: January 16, 2020             JOURNALISTS DETAINED FOR                       Babu Shiwakoti (M), Janmadev
                                        Job: Reporter, Channel Five TV &                                                      Jaisi (M), Yam Prasad Sharma
                                        Khabrain
                                                                               LESS THAN ONE WEEK                             (M), Min Bam (M), Dilip Paudel
Names: Rabi Lamichhane &                                                       •	Gawhar Safi (M), 08-10/4/20,                (M), Chakra Kuwar (M), Yogendra
                                        Location: Karachi, Pakistan
Yubaraj Kandel                                                                    Kunar Province, Afghanistan:                Balayar (M), Prakash Bahadur
                                        Accusation: Wahid was detained for
Gender: Male                                                                      Arrested for criticizing the Kunar          Bam (M).
                                        criticising the Pakistani government
Detained: August 15, 2019                                                         governor’s office about its use of
                                        for comments on Facebook, that                                                     •	Six (6) journalists from Taleem-
Job: Journalists, News24                                                          the of the ‘anti-corona’ budget.
                                        were alleged to be ‘anti-state’ and                                                   Ul-Islam radio arrested for
Location: Chitwan, Nepal                                                          Released after intervention from
                                        defamatory, including comments                                                        alleged links to the Taliban in
Accusation: Lamichhane and                                                        media advocacy groups.
                                        against former military general                                                       Farah, Afghanistan, 25/09/19
Kandel were arrested for their          Pervez Musharraf. He was also          •	Prashant Kanojia (M), 08-
                                                                                                                              - Noorul Haq Mazhari (M),
alleged connection to the suspicious    accused of sharing an offensive           11/06/19, Uttar Pradesh, India:
                                                                                                                              Bismellah Amini (M), Habibullah
death of journalist Shalikram           version of Pakistan’s national            Arrested for sharing a video
                                                                                                                              Amini (M), Abdul Qahar Hanif
Pudasaini, who was found hanging        anthem on social media.                   deemed as ‘defaming’ the chief
                                                                                                                              (M), Abdullah Taeb (M),
in a hotel of Chitwan on August 5.      Status: Released on bail on March         minister of Uttar Pradesh, Yogi
                                                                                                                              Mohammadullah Imran (M).
The journalist had accused them         26, 2020.                                 Adityanath, on Twitter. Released
                                                                                  on bail.                                 •	Abdul Rahim Sekandari, Khost,
and others for the suicide in a
                                                                                                                              Afghanistan, 02/10/19 (M)
video that was said to be taken by      Name: Nasrullah Chaudhry               •	Ghulam Jeelani Qadri (M),
Pudasaini before killing himself.                                                 24-25/06/19, Kashmir, India:             •	Habib Kamran, Khost,
                                        Gender: Male
Status: Released on bail on August      Detained: December 11, 2019               Arrested for alleged involvement            Afghanistan, 02/10/19 (M)
26, 2019.                               Job: Journalist, Nai Baat                 in terrorist and disruptive activities   •	Kamran Yousuf, Kashmir, India –
                                        Location: Karachi, Pakistan               27 earlier linked with his news             16/02/2020 (M)
Name: Om Bahadur Hamal                  Accusation: Chaudhry was arrested         agency JAK News. Released on             •	Gawhar Safi, Kunar Province,
Gender: Male                            on the allegations of carrying            bail.                                       Afghanistan, 08/04/20 (M)
STATES OF CONTROL: COVID, CUTS AND IMPUNITY - SOUTH ASIA PRESS FREEDOM REPORT 2019-20
4       I FJ P R E S S F R E E D O M R E P O R T 2 0 1 9 – 2 0 2 0

MEDIA RIGHTS VIOLATIONS IN SOUTH ASIA BY JOURNALISTS’ SAFETY INDICATORS (JSI)
MAY 1, 2019 – APRIL 30, 2020
IFJ-SAMSN violations monitoring is undertaken by the IFJ Asia-Pacific, together with IFJ affiliates in South Asia. IFJ mapping provides
specific categorisation of violations of journalists’ rights across the region by UNESCO Journalists’ Safety Indicators (JSIs). These
indicators are further categorised by IFJ classifications.

  SOUTH ASIA VIOLATIONS BY
  JOURNALIST SAFETY INDICATORS (JSIS)
  1.	THREATS AGAINST THE LIVES OF
      JOURNALISTS – 19
  2.	OTHER THREATS TO JOURNALISTS –
      80
  3.	NON-FATAL ATTACKS ON
      JOURNALISTS – 65
  4. KILLINGS OF JOURNALISTS – 16
  5.	THREATS AGAINST MEDIA
      INSTITUTIONS – 35
  6.	ATTACKS ON MEDIA INSTITUTIONS –
      4
  TOTAL: 219 VIOLATIONS RECORDED

  ** IFJ INDICATORS:
  A. ARRESTS/JAILING: 52
  B.	ATTACKS/THREATS AGAINST                                           Mina Mangal, parliamentary adviser and former journalist is shot dead on May 11 in Kabul on
      FREELANCERS: 2                                                    her way to work. Mangal received death threats for months before her murder. CREDIT: AIJA
  C.	ATTACKS/THREATS ON RURAL,
      REGIONAL OR MINORITY
      JOURNALISTS: 81                                             May 19, 2019: Takhar (C)                              January 18, 2020: Kabul
  D. DEFAMATION CASES/THREATS: 4                                  Irfan Bazgar and Shafiqullah Poya journalists         Najib Payman, the editor-in-chief of radio and
  E. DISAPPEARANCES: 2                                            of Salam Watandar radio and Khorshid TV are           television channel Music Afghanistan, receives
  F. GENDER-BASED ATTACKS: 8                                      threatened by the provincial commander of Takhar      threats over the telephone.
  G. LEGAL CASES: 3                                               for sharing news without coordination with the
  H.	LEGISLATION/GOVERNMENT                                      commander.
      CONTROLS: 8                                                 July 6, 2019: Uruzgan (C)
                                                                                                                        OTHER THREATS TO JOURNALISTS
  I.	ONLINE ATTACKS/INTERNET                                     Fazal Ahmad Basharmal and Sardar Wali                 May 15, 2019: Semangan (C)
      SHUTDOWNS: 9                                                Samsoor, radio reporters with Paiwastoon Ghag,        Abdul Rahman Saeed, a journalist with
  Notes: Internet shutdowns for the purpose of                    are threatened by the Taliban.                        Shahrwand radio in Samangan province, is
  monitoring are recorded as an attack on the media.                                                                    insulted by the assistant governor.
  Intimidation and harassment are considered as                   July 7, 2019: Ghazni (C)
  threats to journalists. The shutdowns recorded here             Ramizullah, manager of Samaa radio, is                June 18, 2019: Kabul
  indicate those where IFJ has issued statements.                 threatened by the Taliban.                            Photographer and comedians Naweed Nayel,
  A more detailed listing of shutdowns is recorded                                                                      Qudratullah and Qais, of Maiwand and Khorshid
  on the IFJ Shutdown Listing. Arrests and jailing                November 5, 2019: Baghlan (C)
                                                                                                                        TV, are beaten by the locals of Mir Bacha Kot
  are listed under threats to journalists but further             Adiburahman Fazli, a publisher at a local
  detailed under the IFJ indicators above.                                                                              district of Kabul after they were accused of
                                                                  television station in the Baghlan province is
                                                                                                                        insulting and humiliating a number of elders in a
                                                                  threatened by unknown armed men.
                                                                                                                        program.
                                                                  December 2, 2019: Logar (C)
AFGHANISTAN                                                       Matiullah Sarwar, manager of Paiwand Milli radio,
                                                                  is threatened by Shahpor Hasanzai, a member of
                                                                                                                        July 4, 2019: Nangarhar (C)
                                                                                                                        Mikael Farooqi, a reporter for the Farhat news
1.	THREATS AGAINST THE LIVES OF                                                                                        agency, is assaulted and threatened by police
                                                                  parliament from Logar.
    JOURNALISTS – 11                                                                                                    soldiers while trying to film. While trying to film
2. OTHER THREATS TO JOURNALISTS – 19                              December 7, 2019: Uruzgan (C)                         a protest at the Pakistan embassy, a police solder
3.	NON-FATAL ATTACKS ON JOURNALISTS –                            Sharifullah Sharafat, reporter with Azadi radio,      grab the journalist and deletes his images and
    25                                                            is threatened by local scholars for publishing a      footage. He is also prevented from interviewing
4. KILLINGS OF JOURNALISTS – 6                                    report about an unregistered madrassa in Uruzgan      visa clients.
5.	THREATS AGAINST MEDIA                                         province.
                                                                                                                        July 11, 2019: Takha (C)
    INSTITUTIONS – 5                                              December 15, 2019: Nangarhar (C)
                                                                                                                        Journalists are prevented from entering a prison
TOTAL: 66 VIOLATIONS RECORDED                                     Hamid Ahmadi, a reporter with Enekaas Radio
                                                                                                                        in Takhar province during a prison strike. Prison
** IFJ INDICATORS:                                                Television, is threatened by the Taliban. Local
                                                                                                                        authorities say this is to prevent injuries.
A. ARRESTS/JAILING: 5                                             officials provided temporary security.
C	ATTACKS/THREATS ON RURAL, REGIONAL                                                                                   July 23, 2019: Herat (C)
                                                                  January 18, 2020: Badghis (C)
    OR MINORITY JOURNALISTS: 48                                                                                         A publisher for Baran radio, Asadullah Samim, is
                                                                  Sayed Abdul Rahim, editor-in-chief of Haniza
    F. GENDER-BASED ATTACKS: 5                                    Radio, is threatened by unidentified men. A           arrested by the National Directorate of Security
                                                                  protection plan is put in place.                      (NDS).

THREATS AGAINST THE LIVES OF                                      January 27, 2020: Farah (C)                           July 23, 2019: Balkh (C) (F)
                                                                  Mohammad Ibrahim, a reporter for Uroj TV;             Rahima Yazdani, a reporter for the Afghan Women
JOURNALISTS                                                       Ahmad Shah Fikrat, editor-in-chief of Dunya           Awareness Association (AWAA), is insulted by
May 9, 2019: Puli Khumri (C)                                      Radio; and Hamidullah Hamidi, editor-in-chief         the head of Salam Telecommunications and a
Ismail Sadat, from Sima radio, is threatened by                   of Neshad Radio receive death threats over the        company guard. She directs her complaint to the
armed men.                                                        telephone.                                            crime management office.
STATES OF CONTROL: COVID, CUTS AND IMPUNITY - SOUTH ASIA PRESS FREEDOM REPORT 2019-20
5

August 4, 2019: Kabul                                                                                          January 7, 2020: Herat (C)
Reporter Omid Nabizada and videographer Nawid         NON-FATAL ATTACKS ON                                     Sunam Nikzad, the host of local TV entertainment
Muhammadi, of 8AM News Press, are insulted by                                                                  program, is injured and police open an inquiry into
the president’s protection service on the first day
                                                      JOURNALISTS                                              the case. Sonam Nikzad, was stabbed by two
of election campaigning in Loya Jarga.                May 13, 2019: Faaryab (C)                                motorcyclists when he left the university at 8 am
                                                      Muhammad Ayub Amini, a photographer at Ayena             and tried to cross the public road. The perpetrators
August 20, 2019: Zabul (C)                            TV, is beaten by members of National Directorate         fled. The case was pursued by the police.
Abdul Qayom Ajez, a reporter in Zabul, is insulted    of Security (NDS) forces.
and humiliated by the director of women’s affairs.                                                             January 18, 2020: Paktia (C)
                                                      May 25, 2019: Jalalabad (C)                              A group of journalists from Shamshad TV, headed
August 31, 2019: Kabul                                Imran lemar, a journalist of Mazal local radio           by Delsouz Safi, are abducted by anti-government
Members of the media are insulted by Roohullah        station, is injured by unknown assailants and is         militants. Local police and intelligence agency
Ahmadzai, a spokesperson of the ministry of           admitted to hospital intensive care with serious         officers intervene to rescue the journalists.
defence.                                              injuries.
                                                                                                               January 18, 2020: Herat (C) (F)
September 14, 2019: Kandahar (C)                      June 2, 2019: Kabul                                      Female journalists lodge a complaint about lack of
Faiz Muhammad and Qudratullah Rezwan,of               Journalists Jawed Kargar and Muhammad Faseh              security and gender discrimination in a letter to the
Warangi local radio, are insulted by unknown          Motawakkel of Peshgo news agency and Killid              Afghanistan Federation of Journalists. An inquiry
people.                                               radio station, are wounded while reporting on an         is instigated.
                                                      attack for which ISIS claimed responsibility. The        January 27, 2020: Kabul
September 3, 2019: Samangan (C)
                                                      perpetrators were killed in an operation by security     Fazal Haq Haydari, a program officer at Maaref TV,
Journalists are verbally abused by guards of the
                                                      forces.                                                  is threatened over the phone.
vice governor office, who is also head of the
Afghanistan Journalists’ Protection Committee.        July 4, 2019: Nangarhar (A) (C)                          February 12, 2020: Kabul
                                                      Michael Farooqi, a reporter of Farhat news agency,       Zabihullah Jahanmal and Bahis Mujadadi,
September 25, 2019: Farah (A) (C)
                                                      is beaten and insulted by the police. Farooqi is         reporters for Tolo TV, are insulted and their
Six employees of Taleem-Ul-Salam radio station
                                                      arrested but the case is dismissed.                      recorded videos are forcibly deleted by a guard
are arrested by National Directorate of Security
(NDS) forces on charges of alleged links to the       August 28, 2019: Uruzgan (C)                             commander from Afghanistan’s finance ministry.
Taliban. Twelve computers, nine telephones and        Reporter Muhammad Nasim Watandost is beaten              March 8, 2020: Kunduz (C)
three recorders are searched. They are released       by a soldier for the national army in Uruzgan.           Noor Rahim Atif, editor-in-chief of Kaihan Radio in
after 12 hours with no charges laid or evidence                                                                Kunduz province, is kidnapped nearly 10 km from
                                                      August 30, 2019: Kabul
found.                                                                                                         the city by the Taliban.
                                                      Farid Toghri, of Uzbek News at Noor TV, is beaten
September 28, 2019: Parwan (C)                        in Kabul. The attackers are arrested.                    March 12, 2020: Kunduz (C)
Maqbool Noori, a reporter from Salam Watandar                                                                  Noor Rahim Ateef, editor-in-chief of Kayhan Radio,
                                                      September 27-29, 2019: National –
radio, is insulted and humiliated by the brother of                                                            is abducted by the Taliban and later released.
                                                      Afghanistan (C)
the head of the provincial assembly.
                                                      At least three journalists are attacked during the       March 5, 2020: Parwan (C)
September 29, 2019: Helmand (C)                       fourth round of Afghanistan’s presidential elections     A group of journalists for various media outlets are
Journalists Abdul Aziz Safdari (Sheen Hawa            held on September 28. Rahmatullah Nikzad, a              forced to leave the office of Shah Wali Shahed,
news agency), Sefatullah Zahidi (Salam Times),        reporter for Al Jazeera TV, is injured when a bullet     a deputy for Parwan governor. Shayeq Qasimi.
Abdullah Hamim (Tolo News), Rafiullah Pashton         hit him in his leg in Ghazni province on September       A freelance journalist is directly insulted by the
(Zhwandon TV), and Abdul Wali Tawhidi (Melma          27, a day before the election. Abdul Rahman              Parwan governor.
local radio) are insulted by the chief of police of   Hamad, of Kawoon Ghag Radio, is wounded in an
                                                                                                               March 5, 2020: Ghor (C)
Helmand Province.                                     attack on September 28 in Baghlan province. On
                                                                                                               Reporters in the province are insulted by members
                                                      September 29, journalist Maqbol Noori, of Salam
October 2, 2019: Khost (A) (C)                                                                                 of the health department of the province.
                                                      Watanda is threatened verbally attacked and his
Abdul Rahim Sekandari, a reporter for Salam           phone confiscated.                                       March 6, 2020: Uruzgan (C)
Watandar, and Habib Kamran, a reporter for                                                                     Sharifllah Sharaft, a reporter for Radio Azadi,
Sahar news, are arrested by National Directorate      November 7, 2019: Kabul                                  receives a death threat from local mullahs.
of Security (NDS) forces on charges of weakening      Jamshed Yama Amin, the manager of Keshwar
the system and insulting the president.               news agency, is beaten by a police officer while         March 6, 2020: Kabul
                                                      preparing a report on an election rally.                 Kabul News TV’s reporter Mansour Nikmal
November 7, 2019: Takhar (C)                                                                                   and cameraperson Najim Sultani are wounded
Najeebullah Nazari, manager of Maahe Naw TV,          November 30, 2019: Lashkar Gah, Helmand (C)              when members of the Islamic State attack a
is insulted during an address by the governor.        A roadside bomb seriously injures Sardar                 commemorative event in Kabul when the ceiling at
                                                      Mohammad Sarwari, a reporter with Shamshad               the program venue collapses after IS gunman open
December 6, 2019: Balkh (C)                           TV, who is travelling in a military convoy from          fire in the hall. At least 32 people were killed and
Yaqoob Azorda, a reporter from Tamadon TV, is         Lashkargah to Marjah. Sarwari sustains severe            another 58 civilians wounded in the attack.
insulted by the director of Balkh University.         injuries to his head and leg from a Taliban attack
                                                      on the convoy. Sardar is one of three civilians          March 8, 2020: Zabul (C)
March 12, 2020: Kabul                                                                                          Mohammad Esa Qalamyar, reporter for National
                                                      injured in the attack. Two security officials are also
Zahra Rahimi, a reporter for Tolo News, is                                                                     TV, is abducted by the Taliban. He is released the
                                                      killed.
insulted by local police in the second police                                                                  following night.
district.                                             December 11, 2019: Faryab (C)
                                                      Qutbudin Kohi, a reporter from the Pajhwak news
March 12, 2020: Samangar (C)
                                                      agency, is kidnapped by the Taliban near Faryab-         KILLINGS OF JOURNALISTS
Local radio reporters Shamsudin Merzai, Slahudin
                                                      Andkhoy highway.                                         May 11, 2019: Kabul (F)
Bawar and Mahboob Al Rahmani Sahi, are
insulted by local government officials.                                                                        Mina Mangal, parliamentary adviser and former
                                                      January 1, 2020: Takhar (C) (F)
                                                                                                               journalist is shot dead on May 11 in Kabul
                                                      Musamat Arezo, a reporter for Berlik Radio, is
April 8, 2020: Kunar (A) (C)                                                                                   on her way to work. Mangal, who served as
                                                      allegedly raped by Mohammad Ehsan. Authorities
Gawhar Safi, the editor-in-chief of Zula Radio, is                                                             television presenter for more than 10 years,
                                                      are investigating the case.
arrested by National Directorate of Security (NDS)                                                             was working as an adviser to the Cultural
forces under the orders of the Kunar governor for     January 1, 2020: Nangarhar (C)                           Commission of Wolesi Jirga when the incident
criticizing his performance on the use of the anti-   A police officer beats and insults five journalists in   happened. She had received death threats in the
Corona budget.                                        Nangarhar province.                                      months preceding her murder.
STATES OF CONTROL: COVID, CUTS AND IMPUNITY - SOUTH ASIA PRESS FREEDOM REPORT 2019-20
6        I FJ P R E S S F R E E D O M R E P O R T 2 0 1 9 – 2 0 2 0

June 9, 2019: Zabul (C)                                           statement against the media portal khabarial.
Sakhi Baloch, a technical assistant of the National               com, signed by the spokesperson Zabihullah            NON-FATAL ATTACKS ON
Radio Television in Zabul province, is abducted by                Jujahed. After the Taliban’s statement, 80 per
unknown people on his way home. He is found                       cent of khabarial.com staff quit their jobs because
                                                                                                                        JOURNALISTS
dead the next day in Qalat city                                   of the ongoing punitive Taliban threats.              May 12, 2019: Mymensingh (A)
                                                                                                                        Mohammad Abdul Kaium, the editor of news
July 1, 2019: Kabul (F)                                                                                                 portal Mymensinghlive is arrested and allegedly
Abdul Rauf Eymal Zay, a security guard of                                                                               tortured in custody. He is released on bail on
Shamshad TV, is shot dead while another seven
Samshad TV workers are injured in a car bomb
                                                                  BANGLADESH                                            July 3.
                                                                  1. THREATS AGAINST THE LIVES OF
explosion. The guard was shot dead as he walked                                                                         August 3, 2019: Dhaka (E)
                                                                  JOURNALISTS – 0
onto the street where Afghan security forces and                                                                        Mushfiqur Rahman, a senior reporter of Mohona
                                                                  2. OTHER THREATS TO JOURNALISTS – 6
foreign troops were deployed. Five men and two                                                                          TV is allegedly abducted after boarding a Mirpur-
                                                                  3. NON-FATAL ATTACKS ON JOURNALISTS – 7
women media workers from Shamshad TV were                                                                               bound bus from Gulshan. The abductors were
injured in car bomb attack which is reported to                   4. KILLINGS OF JOURNALISTS – 1
                                                                                                                        said to spray a liquid substance on his face and
have been targeting defence and government                        5.	THREATS AGAINST MEDIA
                                                                                                                        beat him severely. He had earlier received threats
offices in the area. The Taliban claimed                              INSTITUTIONS – 5
                                                                                                                        for his news coverage.
responsibility for the blast.                                     6. ATTACKS ON MEDIA INSTITUTIONS – 1
                                                                  TOTAL: 20 VIOLATIONS RECORDED                         December 18, 2019: Jamalpur
July 12, 2019: Gardiz (C)                                         ** IFJ INDICATORS:                                    Shelu Akondo, a correspondent for Bangla Bazar
Editor-in-chief for Radio Gardez Ghar, Nader Shah                 A. ARRESTS/JAILING: 5                                 Patrika and Polly Kontho Protidin, is severely
Sahebzadeh, disappears after leaving his home                     C. 	ATTACKS/THREATS ON RURAL, REGIONAL               beaten and his legs broken by a local leader of the
in Gardiz city to visit a friend. His body is found                   OR MINORITY JOURNALISTS: 5                        Bangladesh Chhatra League, the student wing of
the next day. The case was investigated and the                   E. DISAPPEARANCES: 2                                  ruling party. He is attacked with metal bars while
person accused of the murder is prosecuted.                       F. LEGAL CASES: 1                                     on his regular evening walk near the Brahmaputra
September 24, 2019: Kandahar (C)                                  G. LEGISLATION/GOVERNMENT CONTROLS: 2                 river.
Abdul Hamid Hotaki, a political talk show                         H.	ONLINE ATTACKS/INTERNET
                                                                                                                        February 1, 2020: Dhaka
host at the Hewad independent public media                            SHUTDOWNS: 3
                                                                                                                        At least nine cases of attacks on journalists and
group, is critically injured in an explosion near                                                                       obstruction to reporting are documented during
the campaign office of President Ashraf Ghani,
in the southern city of Kandahar. He dies from                    OTHER THREATS TO JOURNALISTS                          the Dhaka North and South city elections.
                                                                                                                        Media workers across Dhaka from Agami News,
his injuries the next day. Afghanistan’s Interior                 May 26, 2019: Jamalpur (C)
                                                                                                                        Bangla Daily, The Daily Star, Banglavision TV,
Ministry blamed Taliban militants for the attack.                 Mustafa Monju, Kaler Kantho’s Jamalpur
                                                                                                                        Press Bangla Agency, Bangladesh Partidin,
Hotaki was on his way to pick up medicine from                    correspondent is attacked and seriously injured
                                                                                                                        Business Standard, Poribortan.com, Jugantor
a clinic when he was caught in the bombing.                       in an attack by a group of people while was
                                                                                                                        Daily, Daily Nayadiganta and Daily Inqilab are
The explosion also killed three other people,                     investigating the use of forged documents for
                                                                                                                        assaulted at polling booths. Some journalists are
including a child. Seven others were wounded                      land registration at the Sadar sub-registrar
                                                                                                                        denied entry into polling stations. Dipon Dewan,
in the blast.                                                     office. The attack is allegedly led by the ward
                                                                                                                        of Banglavision Television, is barred from entering
                                                                  councillor of Jamalpur 2 and stamp vendor
January 1, 2020: Lashkar Gah, Helmand (C)                                                                               polling booths at Uttara High School.
Safar Mohammed Atal, a technical worker at                        Hasanuzzaman Khan Runu.
Samoun Radio, goes missing. His body is found                                                                           March 10, 2020: Dhaka (E)
                                                                  December 13, 2019: Dhaka (A) (H)
the next day in Safiyan area of Lashkar Gah. The                                                                        Shafiqul Islam Kajol, a photographer and editor
                                                                  Police in Dhaka arrest Abul Asad, editor of           of Pakkhakal Shafiqul, goes missing after
motive of the murder remains unknown.                             Daily Sangram, after the newspaper referred           being accused by the ruling Awami League of
                                                                  to Abdul Quader Molla hanged over crimes              disseminating false information. A day before his
THREATS AGAINST MEDIA                                             committed during Bangladesh’s 1971 war of
                                                                  independence, as a “martyr”. A case is filed
                                                                                                                        disappearance, Kajol is accused of publishing
                                                                                                                        false information under the Digital Security Act,
INSTITUTIONS                                                      under the Digital Security Act.                       along with 31 others including Matiur Rahman
July 7, 2019: National – Afghanistan                              January 5, 2020: Khulna                               Chowdhury, the editor-in-chief of the Bangla
The Taliban threatens media outlets Tolo TV,                      Staffers of a Chinese company working on water        daily Manab Zamin.
Aryana TV, Khama agency press, Khorshid TV,                       supply and sewerage (WASA) project harass
Negaah TV, Farda TV, Zhwandon TV, Killid Radio                                                                          March 13, 2020: Kurigram (A) (C)
                                                                  Ekattor TV’s Khulna Bureau Chief Rakib Uddin          Ariful Islam, Kurigram-based journalist at Bangla
and Shamshad TV after the broadcast of footage                    Pannu for reporting on the project. His camera
that could lead to the targeting or arrest of its                                                                       Tribune, is arrested for alleged possession of
                                                                  equipment is also damaged.                            450ml of liquor and 100g of marijuana and
members.
                                                                  February 11. 2020: Dhaka                              sentenced within a few hours by a “mobile
July 15, 2019: Ghazni (C)                                         Reporter Fakhrul Islam and cameraman                  court”. He is taken to the Kurigram deputy
Samaa radio is suspended due to security threats                                                                        commissioner’s office and reportedly tortured.
                                                                  Sheikh Jalal of News24 are attacked when
by the Taliban in Ghazni province. After the crime                                                                      He is convicted and sentenced by the mobile
                                                                  covering a raid by the Customs Intelligence and
management department intervenes, the radio                                                                             court to one year in prison and fined BTD
                                                                  Investigation Directorate (CIID) at Noyabazar
recommences operation.                                                                                                  50,000 (USD 560). His family and members
                                                                  area. The attackers snatch their camera and
                                                                  backpack.                                             of the media accuse police of convicting him in
April 8, 2020: Daikundi (C)
                                                                                                                        retaliation to an article on the misuse of power
Mirza Hassani Subhani Allah, a member of the
                                                                  March 12, 2020 : Dhaka (A)                            by Kurigram deputy commissioner Sultana
provincial council, threatens to close down Aftab
                                                                  A case against television journalist Mahbub           Pervin.
Radio and Radio Rasana following a news report
                                                                  Alam Lavlu is filed by Shiqur Rahman, a
on the mismanagement of the budget for fighting                                                                         April 23, 2020: Narsingdi (C)
                                                                  resident of Hosni Dalan Road, on the allegation
Covid-19.                                                                                                               Sajal Bhuiyan, Narsingdi district correspondent
                                                                  of spreading false and defamatory news through
                                                                  his YouTube channel. He is arrested under the         for SA Television is beaten by men wielding
January 18, 2020: Baghlan Province (C)
                                                                  Digital Security Act.                                 batons while collection information at the office
Arman Shahr Radio faces security threats. The
                                                                                                                        of Amirganj Union Parishad chairman Nasir
local police develop a plan to protect the radio
                                                                  April 13, 2020: Bogra (A) (C)                         Uddin Khan’s. Sajal was investigating the
station.
                                                                  Shahjahan Ali Babu and Mazed Rahman,                  chairman in connection to the alleged
February 9, 2020: Kabul                                           district correspondents for Ekattor Television and    embezzlement of relief rice marked for public
After a series of threats directed at Afghanistan’s               Somoy Television are harassed and detained by         distribution to assist Bangladeshi households
independent media, the Taliban issues a                           a police officer.                                     during the Covid-19 lockdown.
STATES OF CONTROL: COVID, CUTS AND IMPUNITY - SOUTH ASIA PRESS FREEDOM REPORT 2019-20
7

                                                                                                             Journalist leaders join a protest rally in front of
                                                                                                           the National Press Club in Dhaka about ongoing
                                                                                                             violations against the journalists community in
                                                                                                                                  Bangladesh. CREDIT: BMSF.

                                                      local correspondents, Shawon Amin and Rahim
KILLING OF JOURNALISTS                                Shuvo are also sued by Mominul for sharing the     OTHER THREATS TO JOURNALISTS
May 22, 2019: Jamalpur                                story on Facebook.                                 May 2, 2019: Leh (D)
The body of Ishan Ibn Reza Fagun, the sub-editor                                                         Two BJP leaders attempt to bribe journalists for
of the online news portal Priyo.com is found near                                                        favourable poll coverage and then threaten them
the railway track in Jamalpur. It is reported that    ATTACKS ON MEDIA INSTITUTIONS                      with a defamation suit for “fake propaganda’. The
unknown persons beat the journalist to death and      December 13, 2019: Dhaka                           incident is recorded on social media.
dumped his body. The motive for the killing is        Members of Muktijoddho Mancho (Freedom
unknown.                                              Fighters Platform) and Bangladesh Chhatra          June 8, 2019: Uttar Pradesh (A) (B) (D)
                                                      League burn copies Daily Sangram and vandalise     Three journalists - freelance journalist Prashant
                                                      its Dhaka office for a report referring to Abdul   Kanojia and Nation Live journalists Anuj Shukla
THREATS AGAINST MEDIA                                 Quader Molla, who was hanged over crimes           and Ishita Singh - are arrested for sharing a
                                                                                                         video deemed as ‘defaming’ Chief Minister Yogi
INSTITUTIONS                                          committed during Bangladesh’s 1971 war of
                                                                                                         Adityanath.
                                                      independence, as a “martyr”.
May 19, 2019: Dhaka (H) (I)
Access to Poriborton.com is blocked by                                                                   June 24, 2019: Jammu & Kashmir (A)
                                                                                                         Ghulam Jeelani Qadri, editor of Daily Afaaq,
Bangladesh authorities. The website had earlier
received a threat from an incumbent minister to       BHUTAN                                             is arrested in late night raid over a 27-year-old
remove a news story or face a shutdown.                                                                  terrorism case. He is later released on bail by the
                                                      1.	THREATS AGAINST THE LIVES OF
                                                                                                         Chief Judicial Magistrate, Gowhar Majeed, when
December 28, 2019: Bangladesh / Sweden (I)                JOURNALISTS – 0
                                                                                                         police are unable to provide any clear details and
Access to the Sweden-based investigative              2. OTHER THREATS TO JOURNALISTS – 0
                                                                                                         specific justification for his arrest.
journalism website Netra News is blocked for 72       3. NON-FATAL ATTACKS ON JOURNALISTS – 0
hours after publishing a report alleging corruption   4. KILLINGS OF JOURNALISTS – 0                     July 25, 2019: Jammu & Kashmir (A)
by Obaidul Quader, an influential party leader and    5.	THREATS AGAINST MEDIA                          Qazi Shibli, news editor of The Kashmiriyat, is
a minister in the Awami League government. The            INSTITUTIONS – 0                               arrested after tweeting an official order regarding
report alleged the minister had “received a luxury    6. ATTACKS ON MEDIA INSTITUTIONS – 0               the deployment of paramilitary troops that
brand watch in exchange for awarding a lucrative      TOTAL: 0 VIOLATIONS RECORDED                       allegedly leaked crucial details about imminent
contract”.                                                                                               troop movements in Jammu and Kashmir. He is
                                                                                                         charged under the Public Safety Act.
March 9, 2020: Dhaka (G)
Saifuzzaman Shikhor, ruling party lawmaker for
                                                      INDIA                                              August 14, 2019: Jammu &Kashmir
                                                      1.	THREATS AGAINST THE LIVES OF
Magura 1, files a case against Matiur Rahman                                                             Irfan Malik, of Greater Kashmir, is picked from his
                                                           JOURNALISTS – 0
Chowdhury, editor-in-chief of Manab Zamin daily,                                                         residence from Tral in south Kashmir at midnight.
                                                      2. OTHER THREATS TO JOURNALISTS – 19
its staff reporter Al Amin and 30 others under the                                                       He is released after spending one night in custody.
                                                      3. NON-FATAL ATTACKS ON JOURNALISTS – 8
Digital Security Act on charge of publishing and                                                         No reason is given for his arrest.
                                                      4. KILLINGS OF JOURNALISTS – 4
sharing of false news.
                                                      5.	THREATS AGAINST MEDIA                          September 6, 2019: Uttar Pradesh (A) (C)
April 2, 2020: Dhaka (I)
                                                           INSTITUTIONS – 6                              Journalist Santosh Jaiswal working with
The Bangladesh government blocks domestic
                                                      TOTAL: 37 VIOLATIONS RECORDED                      Jansandesh Times is arrested for taking photos
connections to BenarNews.org, an online
                                                      ** IFJ INDICATORS:                                 and videos of children mopping floors at a local
affiliate of Radio Free Asia, for alleged spread of
                                                      A. ARRESTS/JAILING: 14                             primary school in Azamgarh district.
misinformation amid the Covid-19 pandemic.
                                                      B.	ATTACKS/THREATS AGAINST
April 18, 2020: Thakurgaon (C)                             FREELANCERS: 1                                September 8, 2019: Uttar Pradesh
Mominul Islam Bhashani, president of Baliadangi       C.	ATTACKS/THREATS ON RURAL, REGIONAL             A complaint against STV Haryana journalist
upazila Swechchha Sebak League, an associate               OR MINORITY JOURNALISTS: 3                    Anoop Khundu is registered by the State Food
body of the Awami League political party, files a     D.	DEFAMATION CASES/THREATS: 4                    Civil Supplies & Consumer Affairs Department
case against Toufique Imrose Khalidi, the editor-     G.	LEGAL CASES: 1                                 official. The complaint states a report aired in July
in-chief of bdnews24.com; and Mohiuddin Sarker,       H.	LEGISLATION/GOVERNMENT CONTROLS: 2             featured an alleged fake video of the warehouse
acting editor of agonews24.com, for publishing        I. 	ONLINE ATTACKS/INTERNET                       aimed at “spoiling the image of the department
news defaming him and the Awami League. Two                SHUTDOWNS: 6                                  and the official.”
8      I FJ P R E S S F R E E D O M R E P O R T 2 0 1 9 – 2 0 2 0

September 20, 2019: Jharkhand                                    April 18, 2020: Jammu & Kashmir                        March 3, 2020: Tamil Nadu
Evidence is revealed of the Jharkhand government                 Police in Srinagar charge photojournalist Masrat       M Karthi, a reporter with Kumudam, sustains
efforts to influence media reportage by inviting                 Zahra under the Unlawful Activities Prevention         serious head injuries following an attack in
journalists to write about its welfare schemes and               Act (UAPA) Zahra for social media posts allegedly      Sivakasi. Karthi loses eight teeth after being set
offering them money in return. The Jharkhand                     promoting “anti-national posts with criminal           upon by two men brandishing iron rods. He had
Working Journalists Union, says the BJP                          intention to induce the youth and promote              earlier received harassing calls from a minister and
Government of Raghuvar Das issued advertisement                  offences against tranquillity”. She is summoned to     others regarding a story. Two men are arrested in
in various online and print newspapers by inviting               the police station for questioning.                    connection with the assault.
articles on its public welfare schemes, wherein 30
journalists were selected to be paid Rs 15,000                   April 19, 2020: Jammu & Kashmir                        April 23, 2020: Arunachal Pradesh (I)
(USD 197) each.                                                  A First Information Reports (FIR) is filed against     Tongam Rina, associate editor of The Arunachal
                                                                 special correspondent for The Hindu Peerzada           Times, files a FIR with the crime branch after
November 1, 2019: Delhi (I)                                      Ashiq over a report. He is summoned for                continued online trolling for an article on the
Revelations emerge that several journalists,                     questioning within six hours in police stations        alleged rise in cases of wildlife hunting in the state
activists, lawyers and senior government officials               located in two different districts.                    during the Covid-19 lockdown
have been targeted by Israeli spyware in a hacking
spree in May 2019. Those targeted were subject                   April 21, 2020: Jammu & Kashmir                        April 23, 2020: Mumbai
to surveillance for a two-week period until May,                 Journalist and author Gowhar Geelani is booked         Senior journalist Arnab Goswami and his wife are
when the general election was held.                              under the Unlawful Activities Prevention Act           attacked by two thugs as they returned home from
                                                                 by the Cyber Police Station Kashmir Zone for           the Mumbai office of Republic TV. The attackers
December 19, 2019: Uttar Pradesh (A)                             allegedly “indulging in unlawful activities” through   threw objects at the car and were later caught by
Journalist Omar Rashid, of The Hindu, is taken to                social media that was “prejudicial to the national     his security. The day before, the Congress party
Hazratgani police station with activist Robin Verma              integrity, sovereignty and security of India”.         and its supporters launched an extensive social
and accused and threatened as being part of a                    Geelani moved the Jammu and Kashmir High               media campaign demanding his arrest over his
group of arsonists who vandalised police property                Court to quash the FIR against him.                    comments criticising party president Sonia Gandhi.
and engaged in violence during a protest against
the Citizenship Amendment Act. He and Verma are                  April 27, 2020: Andaman and Nicobar Islands (A)        April 24, 2020: Tamil Nadu (A)
released without charge.                                         Freelance journalist Zubair Ahmed is arrested          Andrew Sam Raja Pandian, founder and chief
                                                                 and taken to Aberdeen police station for his           executive of Simplicity news portal, is arrested on
February 8, 2020: Jammu & Kashmir                                tweet asking why a family has been put under           grounds of violating the Epidemic Diseases Act
Police summon media workers, Naseer Ahmad                        quarantine for a phone call with Covid-19              and two sections of the Indian Penal Code. Police
Ganie, from Outlook Magazine, and Haroon Nabi,                   quarantine patients. Police charged Zubair under       allege corruption in food distribution during the
from the news agency CNS, for questioning for                                                                           Covid-19 pandemic and attempting “to bring a
                                                                 the Disaster Management Act for obstruction,
allegedly publishing a statement from the banned                                                                        bad name to the state government” and creating
                                                                 disobedience and the publishing of information
Jammu Kashmir Liberation Front (JKLF) and                                                                               unrest among government officials.
                                                                 that may cause alarm to the public.
sharing a post on WhatsApp.
February 16, 2020: Jammu & Kashmir (A) (D)
Kamran Yousuf, a multimedia journalist with                      NON-FATAL ATTACKS ON                                   KILLINGS OF JOURNALISTS
                                                                                                                        June 19, 2019: Madhya Pradesh (G)
Newsclick, is detained by Pulwama police                         JOURNALISTS                                            Chakresh Jain, journalist with a Hindi daily,
and interrogated for several hours. Yousuf is
                                                                 May 6, 2019: West Bengal (C)                           dies after sustaining burns under mysterious
taken by police van to the office of the Deputy
                                                                 Journalists from NewsX, ABP Ananda and Zee             circumstances in Madhya Pradesh’s Sagar district.
Superintendent of Police where he is accused of
                                                                 News are attacked, allegedly by Trinamool              His family accuses agricultural officer Aman
running a Twitter account under the name Kamran
                                                                 Congress (TMC) workers, during voting in the           Chowdhary and his supporters of setting him
Manzoor to post a video of Syed Ali Geelani, a
                                                                 fifth phase of India’s national elections in seven     ablaze. Jain and Chowdhary had been involved in
pro-Pakistan freedom leader in Kashmir. It is later
established to be a case of mistaken identity.                   constituencies in West Bengal. Journalists             a legal dispute and the case was in its final stages
                                                                 are physically assaulted and media vehicles            of hearing when the incident took place.
March 23, 2020: Delhi and Hyderabad (H)                          vandalised.
Police assault at least four journalists as India                                                                       October 14, 2019: Andhra Pradesh
begins a nationwide lockdown in efforts to contain               September 1, 2019: West Bengal (C)                     Journalist K Satyanarayana is stabbed and killed
the Covid-19. In New Delhi, police stop Naveen                   Police assault several journalists covering violent    by unidentified assailants, just a month after he
Kumar, a reporter with Hindi news channel Aaj                    clashes between supporters of Bharatiya Janata         was attacked in a separate incident. The 45-year-
Tak. In Hyderabad, three police officers attack                  Party (BJP) and the ruling Trinamool Congress          old worked as a reporter for Andhra Jyothi. He had
Ravi Reddy, the Hyderabad bureau chief for The                   (TMC) in West Bengal. The deputy commissioner          previously filed a report to police concerning an
Hindu, when he asks police to allow him through                  of police in Barrackpore, Ajay Thakur, is caught       attack in September. Six persons were arrested.
a barricade on his way home from work. Police in                 on camera as he hits a journalist. Several other
                                                                 journalists also say they were assaulted during the    February 18, 2020: Coimbatore
Hyderabad also beat and insult Mendu Srinivas,
                                                                 incident.                                              B Chandrasekar, 36, who worked as a reporter
political bureau chief of Andhra Jyothy, and hit
                                                                                                                        for Captain TV, is killed in a car accident with
Mohammed Hussain, a reporter for news site                       February 25, 2020: Delhi                               university student, R Kishore, 19. Both died after
Siasat, for alleged lockdown violations while they               Akash Napa, a journalist with JK 24×7 is shot          the car rammed into a road barrier.
were returning from work.                                        and at least four other journalists injured during
                                                                 communal unrest in Delhi over the country’s            April 21, 2020: Karnataka
April 2, 2020: Delhi and Uttar Pradesh
                                                                 controversial Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA).         Hanumanthu, 21, of Kannada news channel
Police in Uttar Pradesh file a First Information
                                                                 Journalists came under attack while covering           Public TV, is killed in a road accident in
Report (FIR) against The Wire editor, Siddharth
                                                                 the communal violence in northeast Delhi over          Ramanagara district on his way back to Bangalore
Varadarajan, for alleged ‘defamatory’ comments
                                                                 several days from February 23. Attacks are             from Ramanagara jail after covering a story related
against the Uttar Pradesh chief minister, Yogi
                                                                 made on journalists Arvind Gunasekar, Saurabh          to Covid-19.
Adityanath. The police notice requests he appear
at the Ayodhya police station, 700 km from his                   Shukla, Mariyam Alavi and Sushil Rathi. There
home in Delhi despite a nationwide Covid-19                      are also reports of mob members checking the           THREATS AGAINST MEDIA INSTITUTIONS
lockdown.                                                        religious identities of journalists covering the
                                                                 protests.                                              July 18, 2019: Delhi (H)
April 14, 2020: Osmanabad (A)                                                                                           Finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman imposes
Journalist Rahul Kulkarni is arrested over a report              March 4, 2020: Jammu & Kashmir                         restrictions on journalists from accessing the
on the recommencement of trains in Bandra after                  Police bar two journalists from reporting on an        ministry’s office. Journalists are also barred
it allegedly prompted mass gatherings of migrants                operation in Hakripora village in Pulwama district     from entering the offices in an attempt to control
during the Covid-19 lockdown.                                    and confiscate their equipment.                        reporting.
9

                                                                                                                       Cartoonists in Nepal protest the country’s
                                                                                                                                 Media Council Bill. CREDIT: FNJ

July 23, 2019: Delhi (H)
The Government of India introduces two
controversial labour codes, namely Code on Wages
                                                       MA LDIVES                                              NEPAL
and the Code on Occupational Safety, Health and        1.	THREATS AGAINST THE LIVES OF                        1.	THREATS AGAINST THE LIVES OF
Working Conditions (OSH). The codes repeal                 JOURNALISTS – 0                                         JOURNALISTS – 3
the Working Journalists and other Newspaper            2. OTHER THREATS TO JOURNALISTS – 0                     2. OTHER THREATS TO JOURNALISTS – 21
Employees (Conditions of Service) and the              3. NON-FATAL ATTACKS ON JOURNALISTS – 0                 3.	NON-FATAL ATTACKS ON JOURNALISTS – 12
Miscellaneous Provisions Act of 1955, and the          4. KILLINGS OF JOURNALISTS – 0                          4. KILLINGS OF JOURNALISTS – 0
Working Journalist (Fixation of rates of wages) Act,   5.	THREATS AGAINST MEDIA                               5.	THREATS AGAINST MEDIA INSTITUTIONS –
1958 along with 11 other labour laws. The code             INSTITUTIONS – 3                                        3
on wages is passed by both houses of parliament        TOTAL: 3 VIOLATIONS RECORDED                            6. ATTACKS ON MEDIA INSTITUTIONS – 3
with the president’s assent to become the Code                                                                 TOTAL: 41 VIOLATIONS RECORDED
on Wages Act, 2019. The Code on Occupational                                                                   ** IFJ INDICATORS:
Safety, Health and Working Conditions (OSH) is         THREATS AGAINST MEDIA INSTITUTIONS                      A. ARRESTS/JAILING: 20
sent to the Standing Committee on Labour and is        July 11, 2019: Male                                     C. ATTACKS/THREATS ON RURAL, REGIONAL
submitted its recommendations to both Houses of        Maldivian Democracy Network (MDN)                            OR MINORITY JOURNALISTS: 8
Parliament in February 2020.                           representatives are denied entry as observers at        F. GENDER-BASED ATTACKS: 1
                                                       the eighth hearing of Yameen Rasheed’s murder
August 16. 2019: Meghalaya
                                                       case. The MDN was urging the Criminal Court of
Meghalaya police pressures news portal Northeast
                                                       Maldives to uphold its obligation to conduct a fair
                                                                                                               THREATS AGAINST THE LIVES OF
Now to remove a news item and disclose its sources.
The item dealt with a BJP membership drive.
                                                       and transparent hearing in line with the Maldivian      JOURNALISTS
                                                       Constitution and the International Covenant on          September 11, 2019: Kathmandu
October 1, 2019: Tripura (H)                           Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR).                     Journalist Prahlad Rijal, editor of Arthik Dainik,
The registration of the Daily Desher Katha is                                                                  receives a death threat from Royal Casino operator
                                                       November 5, 2019: Male
cancelled by the Registrar of Newspapers India                                                                 Bed Prasad Kapri after it published news about
                                                       The Maldivian Ministry of Youth, Sports and
(RNI) within hours of issuing fresh registration due                                                           conflicts associated with the casino.
                                                       Community Empowerment – which regulates
to a “change of management”.
                                                       the activities of NGOs – announced the decision         April 5, 2020: Khotang
October 16, 2019: Andhra Pradesh (D) (H)               to shut down the operations of the Maldives             Nepali Congress (NC) Khotang district president,
The Andhra Pradesh government submits a                Democracy Network. The decision was linked to           Naresh Kumar Shrestha, issues a death threat
proposal to allow department secretaries to sue        a 2015 report on radicalisation in the Maldives.        to Uttam Chaulagain over a news report on
media organisations for alleged “fake news”.           The closure came against the backdrop of threats        prabhavnews.com about Shrestha’s obstruction of
The cabinet of Jagan Mohan Reddy in Andhra             to the MDN’s staff, including its director, Shahinda    a quarantine facility in Durchhim Village.
Pradesh aims to empower secretaries of various         Ismail, from religious hardliners.
departments to file defamation cases against print,                                                            April 15, 2020: Kathmandu
                                                       January 2020: Male                                      Dilip Poudel, a reporter for Nagarik, is threatened
electronic, digital and social media.
                                                       Maldives Independent’ formerly Minivan News             via Facebook and mobile for a story on violence by
March 6, 2020: Delhi (H)                               suspends operations. The online platform was an         a houseowner to a female tenant for her frequent
Malayalam-language news channels Asianet               influential voice promoting democracy and human         hospital visits amid the Covid-19 lockdown.
News and Media One are banned for 48-hours for         rights in the country since 2004. In its wake,
alleged “bias” while covering the Delhi protests       Minivan Radio, once anchored from Colombo by
amidst the climbing death toll. The ministry claims    exiled journalists, also closed operations ostensibly   OTHER THREATS TO JOURNALISTS
the coverage has potential to “incite violence and     because the premises had to be vacated. Local           April 29, 2019: Kathmandu (A)
pose danger to maintenance of law and order”.          associates said that political pressure had been        Jitendra Maharjan, editor of Nhugu Jwojoloppa,
The ban is lifted within six hours.                    exerted to shut the station down.                       is arrested and charged under crimes connected
10      I FJ P R E S S F R E E D O M R E P O R T 2 0 1 9 – 2 0 2 0

to state and organised crime. He is alleged to                   surveillance after publishing his exclusive report    journalists can be fined for publishing content
have close relations with Netra Bikram Chand-                    on the alleged rape of a female employee of           found to be tarnishing the dignity or reputation of
led Communist Party of Nepal.                                    Nepal’s Federal Parliament by speaker, Krishna        any individual.
                                                                 Bahadur Mahara.
May 22, 2019: Sunsari (C)
Mayor of Itahari in Sunsari district, Dwarika                    October 20, 2019: Achham (C) (I)                      NON-FATAL ATTACKS ON
Lal Chaudhary, verbally abuses journalists after                 Kantipur Daily journalist Menaka Dhungana is
being questioned on his involvement in the                       subjected to online harassment on social media        JOURNALISTS
physical assault of a district employee.                         sites after publishing a story on the tender          May 5, 2019: Kailali (C)
                                                                 process for the construction of two schools.          Janak Bista, from Dinesh FM 98.3 in
June 4, 2019: Sunsari (C)
                                                                                                                       Dhangadhi, far-western Nepal, is physically
Mayor of Itahari in Sunsari district, Dwarika Lal                November 2, 2019: Kathmandu (I)
                                                                                                                       and verbally assaulted by local businessman
Chaudhary, threatens journalist Birat Anupam                     Shiva Lamsal, news chief at YoHo Television,
                                                                                                                       Tejendra Thapa while covering a story on school
after being question on why the mayor posted                     is threatened after broadcasting a story on a
                                                                                                                       rental space. Bista received treatment at the
derogatory statements about a journalist on his                  scandal regarding a patient who died at Blue
                                                                                                                       local hospital for his injuries.
Facebook page.                                                   Cross Hospital in Kathmandu. Lamsal is
                                                                 threatened on social media by the hospital’s          June 20, 2019: Bhaktapur (C)
June 12, 2019: Dhanusha (A)                                      administrative representative, Rajat Shrestha.        Editor of Salleri News, Dinesh Basnet, is
Police arrested nine journalists padlocked to
                                                                                                                       attacked by a group of locals in Lokhanthali,
the District Post Office, Dhanusha, who were                     November 27, 2019: Chitwan
                                                                                                                       Bhaktapur. Basnet sustained serious injuries
demanding the refund of funds by Dhanusha                        Cadres of ruling Nepal Communist Party (NCP)
                                                                                                                       to the head and other parts of his body and
after it deducted 40 per cent to 100 per cent                    abuse journalists, Raju Sapkota, Mahendra
                                                                                                                       was admitted to Annapurna Neuro Hospital,
of the distribution of funds in public service                   Shrestha and Krishna Sunuwar, and delete
                                                                                                                       Kathmandu.
advertisement. Journalists arrested were R N                     footage recorded while covering the by-election
Biswas (Kantipur TV), Shyam Sundar Yadav                         in Bharatpur.                                         July 3, 2019: Surkhet (C)
(Nepal TV), Baidhyanath Yadav (Avenues TV),                                                                            Officials and employees of Surkhet Valley
Nabin Kumar Gupta (ABC TV), Bhusan Kumar                         December 4, 2019: Saptari
                                                                                                                       Drinking Water Consumers’ Organisation are
Singh (Radio CPM) and Bindu Yadav (Local                         Police raid the house of journalist Abadesh
                                                                                                                       physically and verbally attack journalists Buddhi
Purwa Prabhat Daily), Dharmapal Raut (Rajbiraj                   Kumar Jha from the Kantipur Daily in Tilathi
                                                                                                                       Singh Thakuri and Nawaraj Rolkaya and
Today), Gopal Gupta (Biruwa weekly) and Paris                    Koiladi village, Saptari.
                                                                                                                       cameraperson, Bhim Pariyar, of Deuti HD TV, as
Karna (Green Madhesh daily). Later, they were                    December 4, 2019: Siraha                              they reported on a water dispute.
released after an hour of detention.                             A customs office official in Jatahi threatens
                                                                                                                       July 6, 2019: Sindhuli (C)
July 26, 2019. Tanahu                                            journalists Santosh Baraili Shuvender Das,
                                                                                                                       Journalists Hom Kumar Karki and Min Kumar
Deputy mayor of the Sukhla Gandaki                               confiscates their cameras and verbally abuses
                                                                                                                       Dahal are beaten by constable Salam Singh
Municipality in Tanahu verbally abuses                           them after they filmed the officer taking bribes.
                                                                                                                       Lama for not deleting a video.
journalists Samundra Poudel and Damber                           February 26, 2020: Kathmandu
Adhikari, editors of Khabarpati Saptayik,                                                                              August 2, 2019: Kathmandu
                                                                 Journalist Ajaya Babu Shiwakoti is threatened
for a news report on her involvement in the                                                                            Journalist Prakash Chandra Dahal is attacked
                                                                 for exposing various corruption cases involving
construction of a playground.                                                                                          by an unknown group in Bagbazar, Kathmandu.
                                                                 cabinet ministers. Shiwakoti, the editor of
                                                                                                                       Dahal, who is an editor of the online portal
August 10, 2019: Kathmandu (A)                                   hamrakura.com, is threatened by unknown
                                                                                                                       sancharkhabar.com, is attacked by a group of
Police arrest poet and journalist Khem Thapaliya                 men following a story about Rs 700 million in
                                                                                                                       four people wearing helmets.
for his alleged involvement in the outlawed                      commission sought by the sitting minister for
Chand-led Nepal Communist Party.                                 communication and information technology,             September 27, 2019: Banke
                                                                 Gokul Banskota, for the procurement of printing.      Journalist Liyakat Ali is attacked by an
August 23, 2019: Kaski (A)                                                                                             unidentified group of people on his way home.
Journalist and anti-corruption activist Om Hamal                 March 26, 2020: Itahari
                                                                                                                       The unidentified assailants physically assaulted
is arrested in the Kaski district. Journalist Hamal,             Journalist Rajan Katwal, of Arena Television,
                                                                                                                       and seized his mobile phone before fleeing.
the editor of janasanchar.com, is arrested by                    is verbally abused by Dwarik Lal Chaudhari,
security personnel for his alleged association                   the mayor of Itahari sub-metropolitan city,           December 7, 2019: Kaski
with the Biplab-led Maoist group. Hamal is also                  after inquiring about the city’s preparedness to      News 24 journalist Prasad Adhikari is physically
known for his anti-corruption investigative reports              mitigate the impact of Covid-19.                      and verbally assaulted by plain clothes police
in the Kaski district.                                                                                                 officers under orders from the Kaski District
                                                                 22 April, 2020: Kathmandu
                                                                                                                       Police Chief Dan Bahadur Karki after Adhikari
August 15, 2019: Chitwan (A)                                     Nepal Republic Media, Avenues Television,
                                                                                                                       reported on police collusion in a gambling
Police arrest two journalists, Rabi Lamichhane                   Rajdhani daily and Annapurna Media Group fail
                                                                                                                       operation in Pokhara.
and Yuvaraj Kandel, in connection with the                       to pay outstanding journalist salaries dating back
suspicious death of journalist Shalikram                         several months. Kantipur Media Group (KMG)            December 10, 2019: Kathmandu
Pudasaini. The arrest came nine days after                       requests journalists to take unpaid leave but later   Suman Chapagain, a journalist with the Nagarik
journalist Shalikram Pudasaini found dead after                  revokes the decision.                                 Daily, is beaten by police during the reporting
posting a suicide video message blaming the                                                                            of the 13th South Asian Games (SAG) in
                                                                 27 April, 2020: Chitwan
journalists for driving him to take his own life.                                                                      Kathmandu. Chapagain was taking photos of
                                                                 Police detained Binodbabu Rijal, the editor of
                                                                                                                       angry football fans when he was caught in the
September 16, 2019: Kathmandu                                    Kayakairan Daily, and Arjun Adhikari, of Radio
                                                                                                                       clashes with police.
Nine NPU union leaders are detained for                          Triveni, for breach of Nepal’s lockdown. They
protesting against the arbitrary sacking of three                are taken to the quarantine and their photos and      December 12, 2019: Sunsari
journalists from Radio Nepal. Those arrested                     videos deleted.                                       News 24 journalist Santosh Kafle is attacked on
were including Ajaya Babu Shiwakoti, Ram                                                                               the pretext of arriving late at a press conference
                                                                 May 9, 2019: Kathmandu
Prasad Dahal, Janmadev Jaisi, Yam Birahi, Min                                                                          by the press conference organizers. After
                                                                 A Bill to Amend and Integrate the Media
Bam, Dilip Paudel, Chakra Kuwar, Yogendra                                                                              sustaining injuries to his face, he is admitted to
                                                                 Council Act is registered by the Ministry of
Balayar and Prakash Bam.                                                                                               hospital.
                                                                 Communications and Information Technology
October 4, 2019: Kathmandu (F)                                   with a provision of fine up to NPR 1 million          December 22, 2019: Banke
Nepali journalist and union leader Ajaya Babu                    (USD 8,850) for publishing content in violation       Journalist Sangeen is seriously injured in
Shiwakoti receives threats and is put under                      of the media code of ethics. Section 18 of the        a physical assaulted by two unidentified
                                                                 bill provides that publishers, editors and/or         assailants.
You can also read