Turkey Commercial Real Estate Market Overview - H1 2018

Page created by Holly Yates
 
CONTINUE READING
Turkey Commercial Real Estate Market Overview - H1 2018
Research Report

Turkey Commercial Real Estate
Market Overview
H1 2018
Turkey Commercial Real Estate Market Overview - H1 2018
Turkey Commercial Real Estate Market Overview - H1 2018
Economic Outlook
Turkey Commercial Real Estate Market Overview - H1 2018
Economic Outlook
                  Political Agenda

                  •    The ruling Justice and Development Party (AK Party) decided to hold
                       early presidential and parliamentary elections on 24 June
                       2018. Following the constitutional change of April 2017, these
                       were the first elections of the executive presidency system.

                  •    According to the official result of the elections, the current
                       President, Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, who has ruled the country for
                       sixteen years, won the first executive presidential election in the first
                       round, entitling him to hold the reins of power for a new
                       five-year term. Moreover, Erdoğan's AK Party and the Nationalist
                       Movement Party (MHP), which constitute the Nation Alliance, retained
                       their parliamentary majority by acquiring 53.7% of the vote.

                  •    According to President Erdoğan's election pledges during his
                       campaign, certain political and economic topics are anticipated to be
                       top of the agenda. The slowdown in the investment climate is expected
                       to be overcome by lifting the state of emergency, which was extended
                       for the seventh time in April. The highways, bridges, airports, power
                       plants and other mega projects are also envisaged to remain on the
                       new government's schedule.

                  •    A European Union-Turkey summit was held in March in the Bulgarian
                       port city of Varna to discuss a wide range of topics – such as migration,
                       visa liberalization and the customs union – affecting EU-Turkey
                       relations, which have worsened in recent years.

                  •    Political developments remained a key factor in the economic outlook,
                       and the economy was in ‘wait-and-see’ mode during H1 2018.

                  Economic Agenda
                  •    The Central Bank of the Republic of Turkey (CBRT) Monetary Policy
                       Committee Decisions:

                          *   18 January: Marginal funding rate (9.25%), overnight
                              borrowing rate (7.25%), one-week repo rate (8%).

                          *   7 March: Marginal funding rate (9.25%), overnight borrowing
                              rate® (7.25%), one-week repo rate (8%).

                          *   25 April: The CBRT kept its main interest rates on hold;
                              however, it decided to increase its late liquidity window lending
                              rate from 12.75% to 13.50% on the back of the rising inflation
                              rate and upside movements in import prices.

                          *   23 May: The CBRT kept its main interest rates on hold; however,
                              it decided to increase its late liquidity window lending rate from
                              13.50% to 16.50% on the back of the rising inflation rate.

2
Turkey Commercial Real Estate Market Overview - H1 2018
* 7 June: The CBRT decided to increase its late
         liquidity window lending rate from 16.50% to
         17.75% due to elevated levels of inflation and
         inflation expectations that continue to pose
         risks on pricing behaviour.

•   The Federal Reserve (Fed) twice raised its benchmark
    interest rate by 25 basis points, in March and June,
    and the rate reached 2%.

•   The European Central Bank (ECB) decided on 8 March
    that the interest rate on the main refinancing
    operations and the interest rates on the marginal
    lending facility and the deposit facility will remain
    unchanged. The ECB also confirmed that net asset
    purchases, at the current monthly rate of €30 billion,
    are intended to run until the end of September 2018.

•   Aside from inflation, which has shown a strong
    upward tendency, Turkish Lira (TRY) has continued
    to show weak prospects in the first half of the year.

•   The current account deficit recorded USD 5,885
    million in May 2018, bringing the five-month rolling
    deficit to USD 27,724 million, indicating an increase of
    circa USD 10,250 million compared to the first five
    months of 2017.

GDP Growth

The annual GDP growth rate for 2017 was             GDP Growth Comparison
announced as 7.4%. Moreover, Turkey’s
growth momentum continued with the                  10%
contribution of household consumption (11%)
and gross fixed capital formation (9.7%), and
the GDP growth figure for the first quarter of      5%
2018 was recorded as 7.4%. The Ministry of
Development’s 2018–20 Medium-Term
Programme (MTP) projects that the growth            0%
rate will be realized at 5.5% for 2018, while the            2015          2016           2017         2018*   2019*   2020*
IMF and World Bank projections indicate
growth rates at 4.4% and 4.5% respectively.                       G7 Economies
                                                                  Euro Area
                                                                  Emerging Market And Developing Economies
                                                                  Emerging And Developing Europe
                                                                  Turkey
                                                    *Forecast
                                                    Source: IMF, World Economic Outlook Report, April 2018
                                                                                                                               3
Turkey Commercial Real Estate Market Overview - H1 2018
FX Rates

    The Turkish Lira (TRY) hit a record low against USD and EUR in June 2018, mainly driven by the
    Fed’s tightening monetary policy, the widening of the current account deficit and political uncertainty
    provoked by the early election.

    FX Rates (Monthly Average)

                                                                                                                                                       EUR/TRY
    5.60
    5.20
    4.80
    4.40

                                                                                                                                                       USD/TRY
    4.00
    3.60
    3.20
    2.80

                                                                                                            May -18
                                                                                                            Mar -18

                                                                                                                                     Jun -18
                                                                                                            Apr -18
                                                                                                            Feb -18
                                                                                                            Jan-18
            May-17

                                                                                                  Nov-17
            Jan-17

                                                                                                  Dec-17
            Mar-17
            Sep-16

                                                                                       Sep-17
            Nov-16

            Feb-17

            Apr-17

                                                                    Jun-17
            Aug-16

                                                                             Aug-17
            Dec-16
            Oct-16

                                                                                       Oct-17
             Jul-16

                                                                              Jul-17

                                                                 EUR/TRY                        USD/TRY

    Source: CBRT

    Inflation

    CPI has shown a considerable decrease, falling to 10.9% during Q1 2018; in November 2017 it had
    reached the highest level (13%) since 2003. However, starting in April, CPI showed a considerable
    increase and reached 15.4% as of June 2018, mainly stemming from a drastic rise in oil prices and FX
    rates.

    CPI & PPI
                                                                                                                                     23.7%      PPI (y-o-y)
    25%
    20%
    15%
    10%
                                                                                                                                     15.4%     CPI (y-o-y)
     5%
     0%
           Jun-16

                                               Feb-17

                                                                  Jun-17

                                                                                                                            Jun-18
                    Aug-16

                                                                              Aug-17
                                      Dec-16

                                                                                                 Dec-17
                             Oct-16

                                                                                       Oct-17
                                                        Apr-17

                                                                                                          Feb-18

                                                                                                                   Apr-18

                                                 CPI (y-o-y)                   PPI (y-o-y)

    Source: TurkStat

4
Turkey Commercial Real Estate Market Overview - H1 2018
Consumer Confidence

The consumer confidence index indicates the consumer’s expectations for the overall economic outlook,
household finances and unemployment rates for the next twelve months. The index was on the rise in
January 2018, and reached the level of 72. However, it has shown a slight decrease in Q2 2018, due mainly
to increasing political and economic concerns.

Consumer Confidence Index
90
80
70
60
50
        Jan-18

       May-18
       Nov-17
       Nov-16

       May-17

       Mar-18
       Mar-17

       Sep-17
       Sep-16

       Feb-17

       Oct-17
       Aug-17
       Aug-16

       Jan-17

       Jun-18
       Jun-17

       Dec-17
       Dec-16

       Apr-17
       Oct-16

       Apr-18
        Jul-17
        Jul-16

       Feb-18

Source: TurkStat

Foreign Direct Investment

Based on the World Investment Report 2017, prepared by the United Nations Conference on Trade and
Development (UNCTAD), Turkey accounted for more than a quarter of total inflows to the sub-region –
West Asia – during 2007-2015. According to the report, political instability has had a negative impact on
the Turkish economy and on FDI since July 2016. The FDI inflow between January and April 2018
showed a significant decrease (19.3%) compared to the same period in 2017.

 FDI Inflows (Billion USD)
 25,000

 20,000

 15,000

 10,000

  5,000

       0
               2007-2000

                                                2011
                           2008

                                  2009

                                         2010

                                                       2012

                                                              2013

                                                                     2014

                                                                            2015

                                                                                   2016

                                                                                                         2017
                                                                                                 (Jan. - Apr.)
                                                                                                                         2018
                                                                                                                 (Jan. - Apr.)
                                                                                          2017
                Average

 Source: Ministry of Economy

                                                                                                                                 5
Turkey Commercial Real Estate Market Overview - H1 2018
Investment Market

    The investment market performed below average in the               In terms of the residential market, there are some
    first half of 2018 due to political and economic uncertainty,      prominent issues determining the preferences of foreign
    mainly stemming from early presidential and                        investors. Above all, security and education come to the
    parliamentary elections as well as TRY’s weak prospects.           forefront in European markets. For some foreign investors,
    Until the end of June, most investors were waiting for the         however, a higher Euro-based income and return rate –
    outcome of the elections, delaying their investment                mainly in Germany – is particularly attractive, along with
    decisions. Compared to the first half of 2017, the price           gaining the right to freedom of movement – Portugal
    levels of various asset classes – such as shopping centres,        notably requires fewer prerequisites – in the Euro Zone.
    offices, industrial and logistics facilities and hotels, as well
    as land – have shown a slight decrease as of H1 2018,              Foreign investors’ interest in the Turkish real estate market
    although there has been an increase in the rate of return          has shown a significant decrease over the last three years.
    for such properties, from 7-8% to 7.75-8.5%.                       What’s more, there is not a large number of domestic
                                                                       investors with a strong appetite for real estate investment
    As for the retail market, some European markets are                either. That said, the price level is envisaged to decrease
    offering a satisfactory yield level (4–5%) to shopping             further thanks to some large companies facing financial
    centre investors. Aside from such competitor markets,              constraints and needing to sell properties in their
    there are some key issues that are inducing investors to           portfolios to meet their short-term capital requirements.
                                                                       Considering the lack of foreign capital and very expensive
    remain cautious, such as the pressure of high interest
                                                                       debt financing, the investment market has no solution in
    rates – mainly driven by the increasing inflation rate,
                                                                       the near future other than to reduce the price level and
    which surpassed 15% as of June – as well as an oversupply          increase the rate of return in order to attract foreign
    risk with pipeline retail developments.                            investors watching for an opportunity in the market.

    The office market has continued to be tenant-friendly on
    the back of the shrinkage in demand in the Istanbul office
    market, mainly stemming from a decrease in foreign
    companies’ interest in Turkey. That demand shrinkage has
    also triggered a considerable increase in vacancy rates
    over the last few years. In addition to such domestic issues,
    global competition has an adverse effect on the office
    market in terms of global attractiveness. Along with the
    other countries in the region, the Istanbul office market has
    to compete with advanced European markets that are
    offering global office investors low credit risks and
    promising Euro-based returns.

6
Turkey Commercial Real Estate Market Overview - H1 2018
Retail Market

7
Turkey Commercial Real Estate Market Overview - H1 2018
Retail Market
               Market Notes

                •   The positive outlook in the market – mainly stemming from a stable trend
                    in economic indicators during the first quarter of the year – has given way
                    to a wait-and-see tendency due to the sharp decline in the value of TRY
                    and the early presidential and parliamentary elections held on 24 June.
                    Some shopping centres that previously planned to open in the first half of
                    the year postponed their opening dates to H2 2018 or 2019.

                •   Demands such as TRY-based rent contracts, exchange rate fixing and
                    turnover rent remained at the top of the agenda.

                •   Shopping centres that opened in secondary cities without considerable
                    shopping centre supply invigorated the retail market in these cities. Given
                    the size of the population of the cities, these shopping centres attained a
                    considerable level of visitor numbers, with high domestic interest.

                •   Parking areas in shopping centres will be increased within the scope of
                    the newly published ‘Carpark Regulation'. Renovation projects will lead
                    to amendments to licences. In this regard, the necessity of expanding
                    parking areas in existing shopping centres will bring additional costs to
                    investors.

                •   Retailers have not had an appetite for opening new stores. Even
                    brands that have pursued aggressive new store-building strategies in
                    recent years have shown a tendency towards protecting their current
                    positions, undergoing an optimization process based on in-store
                    efficiency and turnover levels. However, certain retailers in a strong
                    financial position have looked at these conditions as growth
                    opportunities and have opened new stores with lower rent levels
                    compared to the past few years.

               Sector Notes

                •   Leasing processes have slowed down in the F&B sector, whose rent
                    levels and decoration costs are considered higher than those of other
                    sectors. F&B’s area share, which has reached almost 40% in shopping
                    centres, should be determined by taking the location, concept and
                    socioeconomic class of the relevant shopping centre into consideration.

                •   Electronics markets, which have gone through the optimization process
                    regarding product portfolio and leased area, and have closed inefficient
                    stores over the past two years, have shown a tendency towards opening
                    new stores.

                •   The growth momentum of cosmetics/personal care and home products
                    brands has slowed down compared to recent years. However, in H1 2018,
                    these brands have retained the performance level achieved over the last
                    few years.
8
Retail Supply

Shopping Centre Development: GLA & Unit
                                            Active      Under Construction*         Total
  Istanbul          Unit                        118                18                 136
                    GLA (sq m)            4,627,633           676,638           5,304,271
  Ankara            Unit                         39                 9                  48
                    GLA (sq m)            1,572,629           322,500           1,895,129
  Rest of           Unit                        254                16                 270
  Turkey            GLA (sq m)            6,420,870           597,280           7,018,150
  Total             Unit                        411                43                 454
                    GLA (sq m)           12,621,132         1,596,418          14,217,550
*To be completed by end-2021
Source: JLL

Rental Outlook

Prime Rent (EUR/sq m/month)

                   90                         81                75                          70
 90                            81                         75                        70

 Q1 2014 → Q2 2016             Q3 2016                    Q4 2016                   Q1 2017 → Q2 2018
Source: JLL

Retail Density
Retail Density (sq m per 1,000 inhabitants)
       313 sq m                             294 sq m                           158 sq m
         Q2 2018                              Q2 2018                            Q2 2018

        Istanbul                              Ankara                            Turkey

The Cities with the highest retail density growth (y-o-y)

                          286 sq m                                                89 sq m
                          Q2 2017                                                 Q2 2017

                          313 sq m                                                180 sq m
                          Q2 2018                                                 Q2 2018
        Istanbul                                                    Nevşehir
                                                                                                 Source: JLL   9
H2 2018 Outlook

      •     Following the removal of political uncertainty, the course of FX rates and
             the consumer's propensity to save will shape the retail market,
             particularly ready wear and leather and shoe retailers.

      •     A new era will begin in the retail market, with specialized shopping
            centres to be opened in the second half of 2018. The trend, starting with
            furniture centres, might continue with centres mainly focusing on children
            and young people as well as entertainment units.

      •     Considering the lower rent income, some investors have a cautious
            approach to arts and sports schools in their shopping centres. However,
            the number of those units is expected to increase, mainly to generate a
            significant footfall in those shopping centres.

      •     The retail market will be diversified by an increase in retail areas in
            train/bus terminals, sports stadiums, universities and A-class office
            buildings.

      •     Retailers are advised to build a retail strategy for expanding their
            businesses overseas, to improve cash flow and raise profit margins by
            getting foreign exchange turnover.

      •     Defining the discount period clearly may also increase the consumer’s
            interest in seasonal products and increase retailers’ turnover levels.

     H2 2018 Outlook
          Retail Market - Shopping Centres                            H2 2018 Outlook

               Retailer Demand

               Supply

               Prime Rent

               Retail Density

     Source: JLL

10
Office Market

11
Market Notes
     Office Market
                 Istanbul Office Sub-Markets
                                                                                                              SARIYER

                                                                                                          ŞİŞLİ
                                                                     SULTANGAZİ                      Seyrantepe
                                                                                                        rant pe            Maslak                         BEYKOZ

                                                                                                                                                                                                KUZEY MAR. OTO YOLU
                                                                                      TEM
                                                                                                   K ıthane
                                                                                                   Ka                                               Kavacık
                                                           ESENLER           G.O.P                                      Levent
                                                                                                                          Be ikta
                                                  Ba ak ehir                                                                                           TEM
                                                                                                                                                                                          ÇEKMEKÖY

                                                                                                              Zincirlikuyu
                                                                           B.PAŞA
                                                                Basın Express                         i li Mecidiyeköy
                                  KÜÇÜKÇEKMECE
                                                                                                Beyo lu                                                       Ümraniye
                                                                                                                                    Üsküdar
                                                                                           E5
                      AVCILAR                            Ba cılar
                                                                    GÜNGÖREN
                                                                                                                                         Altunizade
                                                                                       FATİH
                                                                                                                                               E5                                      SANCAKTEPE
                                                 BAHÇELİEVLER

                                                                                                                                                                 Ata ehir
                                                                                  NBURNU
                                                                             ZEYTİNBURNU                                             Göztepe
                                                      Airport Area
                                                  BAKIRKÖY                                                                       KADIKÖY                 Kozyata ı

                                                                                                                                                                                               SULTANBEYLİ
                                                                                                                                                                    Maltepe

                                                                                                                                                                              Kartal
                                                                                                                                                                                              Pendik
                                  CBD
                                                                                                                                                                                                                          1
                                  Non-CBD Europe                                                                                                          ADALAR

                                  Asia                                                                                                                                                                         Tuzla- Kurtköy

                                 Kaynak: JLL

                 Source: JLL

                       •        Transactions in the office market in the first half of 2018 were not the
                                result of new companies entering the country nor of growth in the
                                market. Rather, in addition to cutting down operations and lowering
                                the number of employees, companies are demanding an increase in
                                productivity (sq m per person) and a decrease in rent value, which has
                                caused mobility in the market.

                       •        TRY-based rent contracts are the most prominent change in the
                                Istanbul office market. Landlords have shown a positive attitude towards
                                this incentive, taking into account the vacancy rate of above 20% even in
                                the CBD (Central Business District). TRY-based rent contracts have
                                reduced rent levels in Grade-A offices and increased the vacancy rate in
                                Grade-B office buildings.

                       •        Demand for the Levent sub-region in CBD, which has been favoured by
                                institutional tenants for reasons of prestige over the past few years, has
                                shown a decrease in H1 2018. Companies wishing to reduce their office
                                rent costs started seeking out new office buildings at lower rent levels in
                                sub-regions of Non-CBD Europe, such as Kağıthane and Ayazağa.

                       •        Cost-effective workplace solutions had a significant impact on office
                                design. Some corporate office tenants have taken a decision to reduce
                                the space assigned to social facilities in their workplaces to a minimum
                                level in order to lower expenses.

12
Prime Rent (USD/sq m/month)

     45                 43                 40                  37              30
Q1 2013 → Q1 2016   Q2 2016 → Q3 2016      Q4 2016      Q1 2017 → Q3 2017   Q4 2017 → Q2 2018

Source: JLL

Vacancy

Vacancy Rate (%), CBD
          15.2%                   15.2%

                                                      21.9%                       20.9%

         Q2 2015                 Q2 2016             Q2 2017                    Q2 2018

Source: JLL

                                                                                                13
Take - Up

     Take-up Volume (sq m)
       70,000
       60,000
       50,000                                                                          Along with Levent in the CBD, Ataşehir and
       40,000                                                                          Kozyatağı on the Asian Side have become
       30,000                                                                          prominent in terms of take-up transactions in
                                                                                       H1 2018.
       20,000
       10,000
            0
                      CBD           Non CBD             Asia             Total
                                     Europe
                               H1 2017               H1 2018
     Source: JLL

     Major Leasing Transactions, H1 2018
           Occupier                                                      Location      GLA (sq m)
           Tekfen Engineering                                           Kağıthane        4,400
           3M                                                            Ataşehir        4,100
           Amazon                                                         Levent         2,700
           White & Case                                                   Levent         2,500
           Medina Turgul                                                  Levent         2,500
           ACT Airlines                                                  Kurtköy         2,400
           Ewe Energy                                                   Ümraniye         1,700
           Getir                                                              Etiler     1,600
           Kowork                                                       Kozyatağı        1,600
           KFC                                                           Ataşehir        1,400
           Pernod Ricard                                                  Maslak         1,300
           Akfel Energy                                                 Ümraniye         1,300
           Credit Suisse                                                  Levent         1,200
           Eurozen                                                    Mecidiyeköy        1,200
           Huawei                                                         Maslak         1,200
           Dijital İletişim                                               Maslak         1,000
           Softtech                                                       Levent         1,000

     Transactions with GLA higher than 1,000 sq m are included in the list.

     Source: JLL

14
Istanbul Office Property Clock, H1 2018
Kozyatağı - Içerenköy                                               Küçükyalı - Maltape

                                                                    Etiler - Levent
                                                                    Şişli- Z.kuyu- Beşiktaş
                                                                    Kavacık- Kartal- Kağıthane
                          Rental Growth Rents                       Ümraniye
                                Slowing Falling                     Maslak

                          Rental Growth    Rents
                            Accelerating   Bottoming Out

Source: JLL

Existing Supply and Development Market

Existing and Pipeline Grade-A Office Supply
                                                    Active    Under Construction*    Total
                    CBD             Unit             92               2                94
 Europe
                                 GLA (sq m)       1,972,862         124,400         2,097,262
                  Non-CBD           Unit             54               3                57
                                 GLA (sq m)       1,530,435         255,000         1,785,435
 Asia                              Unit              108              13               121
                                 GLA (sq m)       1,984,595        1,315,000        3,299,595    *To be completed
                                                                                                 by end-2020
 Total                             Unit              254              18               272
                                 GLA (sq m)       5,487,892        1,694,400        7,182,292    Source: JLL, Q2 2018

In 2018, existing Grade-A office stock in Istanbul showed an increase of 482,500 sq m (9.6%)
compared to year-end 2017.

                                                                                                                 1915
H2 2018 Outlook

     •    The completion momentum of pipeline projects is envisaged to decrease in the second
          half of 2018. However, the office market is expected to continue to be tenant-friendly.
          Ataşehir is expected to continue to be prominent in terms of take-up transactions.

     •    It is expected that rents that have fallen over the last three years will gradually recover
          by 2021.

     •    Serviced offices, which offer corporate solutions to small-scale companies as well as large
          corporates that need small satellite offices, are envisaged to maintain their prominence in
          the second half of the year. Landlords’ positive attitude towards serviced offices stems from
          their contribution to footfall and to a lower rate of vacancy, despite turnover-based rent
          contracts.

     H2 2018 Outlook
              Office Market                                        H2 2018 Outlook

             Take-up

             Vacancy Rates

             Supply

             Prime Rent

     Source: JLL

16
Logistic Market

17
Logistic Market
                  Overview

                  The primary logistics market is located in Turkey’s Marmara region, which
                  includes the Istanbul and Kocaeli provinces. Hadımköy and Esenyurt on the
                  European Side, Tuzla on the Asian Side in Istanbul, and Gebze, Çayırova and
                  Dilovası in Kocaeli remained the primary logistics markets of the Marmara region.

                                                                        Hadımköy
                                                          Çatalca

                                  Silivri                                                   İkitelli
                                                                    Kıraç
                                                                             Esenyurt
                                                                                            İSTANBUL                                    Sancaktepe
                   Botaş                                                         Haramidere                                Dudullu
                                                                                                                                     Samandıra

                                                                                                           Haydarpaşa
                                                                            Ambarlı              Zeyport                                                   Tepeören
                                                                                                                                       Pendik      Tuzla
                                                                                                                                               Orhanlı    Balçık Pelitli
                                                                                                                                                    Şekerpınar
                                                                                                                                                                                                        KOCAELİ

                                                                                                                                       Tuzla       Çayırova                                                                                     SA
                                                                                                                                                                Gebze              Dilovası                           İzmit
                                                                                                                                                                                                                         Tepecik
                                                                                                                                                                                              Yarımca                                 Kartepe
                                                                                                                                                                  Yalova
                                                                                                                                                                                                          Derince     İzmit
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   Aslanbey
                                                                                                                                                                             Altınova
                                                                                                                                                     Çifliköy
                                 July 15 Martyrs Bridge                      3. Airport                                 Northern Marmara Highway                           Marmaray                Primary Markets
                                FSM Bridge                                    Atatürk Airport                           E5 Highway                                         Eurasia Tunnel          Secondary Markets

                                Osmangazi Bridge                             Sabiha Gökçen Airport                      TEM Highway                                        Ports                   Tertiary Markets

                                 Yavuz Sultan Selim Bridge                   Roads Under Construction                   İstanbul-İzmir Highway                                                     Sub-Markets

                  Source: JLL

                  Market Notes

                           •   The logistics market has experienced a half-year of shrinkage in terms
                               of leasing demand, caused by economic and political uncertainty.
                               Realized transactions have mainly stemmed from cost-saving goal and
                               operational change rather than from growth-oriented investments.

                       •       In the first half of 2018, sales processes became more prominent than
                               leasing transactions.

18
•      Beylikdüzü, İkitelli, Dudullu and Samandıra, which were previously regarded as the outskirts of the city,
                                         started to be considered as ‘city centre’ on the back of increased housing density. In addition to Sakarya
                                         and Düzce on the east side, Çatalca, Silivri and Çerkezköy on the west side have shown development in
                                         terms of industry and logistics.

                              •         TRY-based leasing transactions in the logistics and industrial market, which started to be seen in the
                                        second half of 2017, continued to be more prominent in H1 2018. The rent level, which remained stable
                                        in TRY, recorded a considerable decline due to a fall in the value of TRY against USD.

         Adapazarı
                              Prime Rent (USD/sq m/month)
rifiye
                     Akyazı

                                                        6.5                                 7                              6.5                           6.25
                                                     Q1 2010                Q2 2010 → Q4 2016                Q1 2017 → Q3 2017                Q4 2017 → Q2 2018

                              Source: JLL, Q2 2018

                              Take-Up

                              Take-Up (sq m)
                                                                                                    During H1 2018, 153,000 sq m of logistics leasing
                              1,000,000                                                             transactions were realized, a considerable decrease
                                                                                                    (66%) compared to the same period in 2017.
                                      800,000

                                      600,000

                                      400,000

                                      200,000

                                           0
                                                2014     2015    2016     2017 H1 2018

                              Source: JLL, Q2 2018
                                                                                                                                                            19
During H1 2018, the most active industries in terms of leasing transactions were 3PL logistics compa-
     nies with 57%, automotive with 14%, and retail companies with 12% GLA share. Manufacturing,
     plastics and textiles were the other sectors that had a share of leasing transactions.

     Major Leasing Transactions (sq m)

         Occupier                      Sector              City           District       Leased Area (sq m)

         Mars Logistics               Logistics          Istanbul          Tuzla              27,000

         Tatko Tire                  Automotive          Istanbul       Arnavutköy            20,000

         Yurtiçi Logistics            Logistics          Istanbul       Arnavutköy            20,000

         Bilin Logistics              Logistics          Kocaeli          Gebze               20,000

         LCW                            Retail           Istanbul        Esenyurt             12,450

         Cantaş Cooling             Manufacturing        Kocaeli          Gebze                8,350

         DHL                          Logistics          Istanbul         Bağcılar             6,500

         MFK Plastic                   Plastic           Istanbul          Tuzla               6,500

         BTM                          Logistics          Istanbul     Küçükçekmece             6,000

         Lufian                         Retail           Istanbul        Esenyurt              5,000

     Source: JLL, Q2 2018

20
Supply

Major Logistics Sub-Markets in Istanbul-Kocaeli

4,000,000
3,000,000
2,000,000
1,000,000
          0
                   Europe           Asia
                         Istanbul              Kocaeli

       Existing Stock          Under Construction*       Planned

*To be completed by end-2020

Source: JLL, Q2 2018

Regional Distribution of Vacancy

                                6%
                                                     Istanbul Europe
                                 3%
      87%                                            Istanbul Asia
                                 4%
                                                     Kocaeli
                                                     Occupied Area

  Source: JLL, Q2 2018

                                                                       21
H2 2018 Outlook

     Considering the negative impact of the lack of
     foreign investors in recent years, the logistics
     market is envisaged to remain stable unless the
     market cannot attract foreign investors.

                                                        Most large-scale companies have completed the
                                                        consolidation process that has come to the fore
                                                        over the past few years. In this regard, it is not
                                                        expected that the consolidation trend will remain
                                                        on the market’s agenda in the near future.

                                                        Domestic e-commerce firms have continued
                                                        to grow in H1 2018. There will be a revival in the
                                                        logistics market if global companies such as
                                                        Amazon and Alibaba, which entered Turkey in
                                                        recent years, make new logistics investments.

                     H2 2018 Outlook
                             Logistics Market                    H2 2018 Outlook

                             Demand

                             Supply

                             Land Values

                             Prime Rent

                             Take-up Transactions

                             Vacancy (Grade A Supply)

                     Source: JLL

22
Hotel Market

23
Market Notes
     Hotel Market
               The tourism and hotel market in Turkey has shown great resilience to the crisis of
               the past two years. In the first half of the year, the market recovered almost to
               the level of 2015 figures after seeing a sharp decline in performance measures in
               2016 and 2017. The economic crisis is felt strongly within Turkish households, with
               increasing inflation rates, diminishing purchasing power and the devaluation of
               TRY. This local negativity is, however, reflected favourably in terms of foreign
               visitors, providing them with a strong currency to spend on vacationing and
               shopping in Turkey.

               The major foreign markets that supported the rejuvenation of demand have been
               identified as the Russian Federation, Germany, Iran, Georgia and Bulgaria.
               Additionally, it’s been observed that China holds an important stake within the
               visitors mix, with a 96% increase compared to the previous year due to the
               China-Turkey Tourism Year announced by the Chinese and Turkish governments
               at the beginning of 2018.

               Hotel trading performances were augmented by the rejuvenated tourist demand
               compared to the previous two years. As a result, occupancy levels have surpassed
               the 2015 figures and average daily rates have increased slightly across the market in
               the first half.

               Tourism

               The number of international visitors increased to 11.46 million in YTD May 2018, a
               31% increase compared to 2017.

                Number of International Visitors to Turkey
                                            40,000
                 Foreign Visitor Arrivals

                                            35,000
                                            30,000
                                            25,000
                                            20,000
                       (000s)

                                            15,000
                                            10,000
                                             5,000
                                                 0
                                                     2011

                                                                                 2015

                                                                                               2017

                                                                                                      2017

                                                                                                                  2018
                                                            2012

                                                                   2013

                                                                          2014

                                                                                        2016

                                                                                                        YTD May

                                                                                                                     YTD May

                 Source: Ministry of Culture and Tourism
24
Demand

Airport arrivals have increased consistently over the past decade. In 2018 YTD May, total
passenger arrivals in Istanbul via Atatürk International Airport and Sabiha Gökçen
Airport increased by 14% compared to the same period in 2017, with the total
passenger count being c. 40.4 million.

Passenger Arrivals: Istanbul Atatürk and Sabiha Gökçen Airports
                     80,000
  Passenger (000s)

                     60,000
                     40,000
                     20,000
                         0
                              2011

                                                                          2017

                                                                                   YTD May

                                                                                                YTD May
                                     2012

                                            2013

                                                    2014

                                                           2015

                                                                   2016

                                                                                 2017

                                                                                             2018

                                 Atatürk           Sabiha Gökçen

Source: General Directorate of State Airports Authority

Performance

In 2018 YTD May, the occupancy levels increased by 17% to 65%, ADR increased by 5.3% to
EUR 62, which resulted in a 23% increase on the RevPAR to EUR 40.25 compared to the same
period in 2017.

Supply

Istanbul has 548 graded hotels, with over 54,600 rooms, which are traditionally dominated
by the upscale and upper-upscale hotel segments. Five-star hotels hold a market share in
excess of 47%.

The rapid growth in hotel supply in Istanbul has added further rooms; if all pipeline and hotel
projects are completed, the total room supply in Istanbul is expected to increase by 7–8%
by the end of 2019.

                                                                                                          25
Investment

         Turkey produced some quality stock of sellable properties and continues to add to this each year. However,
         the considerable volatility in the country and risk factors for potential investment firms do not pass the necessary
         thresholds. Contrary to that, the yield level of Turkish bonds reached a high level, offering an appealing alternative
         investment for foreigners in the first half. There are a few highly opportunistic firms that continue to believe in and
         watch the Turkish market but which have not yet concluded any notable investments.

         H2 2018 Outlook

         Hotel key performance indicators are expected to excel during 2018 compared to
         previous years. However, the market will take some time to come back to
         competitor market thresholds. In the absence of geopolitical turmoil and terror
         incidents, it is likely to remain resilient in the long run.

         Quick Facts

d
                            31               % 11.4 million
                                               International Arrivals

                            14 %                   40.4 million
                                                   Passengers at IST & SAW

                            17 %                 %65
                                                 Occupancy

                            53 %                             EUR 62
                                                             Average Rate

                            23 %                            EUR 40.2
                                                            RevPAR

                % change over 2017 YTD May – 2018 YTD May
    26
27
Notes
.................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................
JLL Turkey
Maslak Link Plaza, Ayazağa Mah. Eski Büyükdere Cad.
No: 3/5 34398 Maslak - İstanbul, Türkiye
Tel: +90 (212) 350 0800
Faks: +90 (212) 350 0806

Avi Alkaş, MRICS, CSM, CLS, CRX                           Dora Şahintürk                                         Tarkan Ander
Country Chairman                                          Regional Director                                      Regional Director
+90 (212) 350 0710                                        Board Member                                           Board Member
avi.alkas@eu.jll.com                                      +90 (212) 350 0740                                     +90 (212) 350 0850
                                                          dora.sahinturk@eu.jll.com                              tarkan.ander@eu.jll.com

Authors
Yavuz Can Parlar                                               Serhat Çetin
Head of Research                                               Senior Analyst
Marketing & Research                                           Marketing & Research
+90 (212) 350 0808                                             +90 (212) 350 0816
yavuz.parlar@eu.jll.com                                        serhat.cetin@eu.jll.com

www.jll.com.tr

COPYRIGHT © JONES LANG LASALLE TURKEY, 2018.
This report has been prepared solely for information purposes and does not necessarily purport to be a complete analysis of the matters in relation to the subject of the report, which are inherently unpredictable. It has been
based on sources which are deemed to be reliable, but we do not guarantee that the information taken from these sources in the report is accurate or complete. It should be considered that the parameters based during the
preparation of the report may change after the date of the report and the statements that are forward-looking involve known and unknown risks and uncertainties. No investment or other business decisions should be made
based solely on the views expressed in this report.
You can also read