Airspace Review of Hamilton Island - July 2009 - Trim Ref: ED09/60075 File Ref: EF09/3472

 
CONTINUE READING
Airspace Review of Hamilton Island - July 2009 - Trim Ref: ED09/60075 File Ref: EF09/3472
Trim Ref: ED09/60075
 File Ref: EF09/3472

Airspace Review of
  Hamilton Island
                July 2009
Airspace Review of Hamilton Island - July 2009 - Trim Ref: ED09/60075 File Ref: EF09/3472
Office of Airspace Regulation                                Page 2 of 39

     DOCUMENT SPONSOR: Office of Airspace Regulation (OAR)

     Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009            Final
Airspace Review of Hamilton Island - July 2009 - Trim Ref: ED09/60075 File Ref: EF09/3472
Office of Airspace Regulation                                                                                  Page 3 of 39

     Contents

1.    INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................. 4
      1.1 Overview of Australian Airspace ............................................................. 4
      1.2 Purpose................................................................................................... 4
      1.3 Scope ...................................................................................................... 4
      1.4 Objective ................................................................................................. 5
2.    AIRSPACE ......................................................................................................... 6
3.    AERODROME AND INFRASTRUCTURE ................................................................... 7
      3.1 Background ............................................................................................. 7
      3.2 Aerodrome .............................................................................................. 7
4.    STAKEHOLDER CONSULTATION ......................................................................... 12
      4.1 Internal .................................................................................................. 12
      4.2 Aerodrome Operator ............................................................................. 12
      4.3 Passenger Transport Operators............................................................ 12
      4.4 Military................................................................................................... 13
      4.5 Airservices Australia.............................................................................. 13
5.    SUMMARY OF INCIDENTS AND ACCIDENTS .......................................................... 14
6.    MODELLING METHODOLOGY AND RISK ASSESSMENT .......................................... 15
      6.1 Methodology Outline ............................................................................. 15
      6.2 Airspace Risk Assessment.................................................................... 15
7.    FINDINGS ........................................................................................................ 21
8.    RECOMMENDATIONS ........................................................................................ 21
      Annex A – Acronyms..................................................................................... 23
      Annex B – Australian Airspace Structure ...................................................... 25
      Annex C – Stakeholder input provided by: .................................................... 26
      Annex D – Aerodrome Operator Data ........................................................... 27
      Annex E – Airservices Australia Data............................................................ 28
      Annex F – BITRE Data.................................................................................. 31
      Annex G – ATSB Data .................................................................................. 33
      Annex H – Jetstar information flyers ............................................................. 36

 Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009                                                                    Final
Airspace Review of Hamilton Island - July 2009 - Trim Ref: ED09/60075 File Ref: EF09/3472
Office of Airspace Regulation                                                Page 4 of 39

1. Introduction
1.1 Overview of Australian Airspace
The Office of Airspace Regulation (OAR)1 within the Civil Aviation Safety Authority
(CASA) has sole carriage of the regulation of Australian-administered airspace, in
accordance with section 11 of the Airspace Act 2007 (Act). Section 12 of the Act
requires CASA to foster both the efficient use of Australian-administered airspace
and equitable access to that airspace for all users. CASA must also take into
account the capacity of Australian-administered airspace to accommodate changes
to its use.
In line with the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) Annex 11 and as
described in the Australian Airspace Policy Statement (AAPS), Australian airspace is
classified as Class A, C, D, E and G depending on the level of service required to
manage traffic safely and effectively. Class B and F are not currently used in
Australia. The classification determines the category of flights permitted and the
level of air traffic services (ATS) provided. Annex B provides details of the classes
of airspace used in Australia. Within this classification system aerodromes are
either controlled (i.e. Class C or Class D) or non-controlled.
Non-controlled aerodromes in Australia are subject to either Common Traffic Area
Frequency (CTAF) or designated CTAF (radio required) (CTAF(R)) procedures; the
latter requiring all aircraft operating at the aerodrome to be equipped with a
serviceable Very High Frequency (VHF) radio.

1.2 Purpose
The purpose of this Airspace Review was to conduct a risk assessment of the
airspace within the vicinity of Hamilton Island, Queensland. The review forms part of
the OAR Work Program as required by the Act.

1.3 Scope
The scope of the review includes identification and consultation with stakeholders to
gather necessary data and information related to airspace issues around the
Hamilton Island aerodrome. As a minimum this includes consultation with regular
passenger transport operators, charter aircraft of non-freight carrying operations,
flying training schools, military operators, emergency services operators and the
aerodrome operator.
The scope of this review is not intended to examine aerodrome facilities and
infrastructure issues unless any weakness or failings in these areas have a
significant impact on the safety of airspace operations the vicinity of Hamilton Island.

1
 A full list of acronyms used within this report can be found at Annex A
Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009                                 Final
Airspace Review of Hamilton Island - July 2009 - Trim Ref: ED09/60075 File Ref: EF09/3472
Office of Airspace Regulation                                                   Page 5 of 39

1.4 Objective
The objective of this Review is to examine the airspace around Hamilton Island
aerodrome to determine the appropriateness of the current airspace classification
and the level of aviation services provided. This was accomplished by:
     a. Analyses of current traffic levels and mix of aircraft operations within the
        existing airspace in relation to the level of services provided;
     b. Identifying any threats to the operations, focussing as a priority on the safety
        and protection of Passenger Transport Services (PTS);
     c. Identifying appropriate and acceptable risk mitigators to the known threats;
     d. Carrying out a qualitative and quantitative risk assessment of the current
        airspace environment and the expected impact of any changes;
     e. Investigating through stakeholder consultation, the appropriateness of the
        current airspace classification, access issues, expected changes to the
        current traffic levels and mix of aircraft operations within the existing airspace.
     f. Reviewing extant Aeronautical Information Publications (AIP) entries for
        applicability;
     g. Ensuring that the issues are passed onto the relative stakeholder group for
        their consideration; and
     h. Providing assurance to the Group General Manager (GGM) OAR of the levels
        of airspace risk associated with Hamilton Island. The review will provide
        guidance to OAR management on the requirements for an Aeronautical
        Study.

Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009                                    Final
Airspace Review of Hamilton Island - July 2009 - Trim Ref: ED09/60075 File Ref: EF09/3472
Office of Airspace Regulation                                                        Page 6 of 39

2. Airspace
During hours of tower operation, the airspace within 22 nautical miles (nm) of the
Hamilton Island aerodrome (hereafter referred to as “Hamilton Island”) is
predominately controlled airspace, (either Class C or Class D) from the surface
(SFC) to Flight Level (FL) 180. Class A airspace exists above FL180.

Outside 9nm to the east of Hamilton Island, Class G (i.e. uncontrolled airspace)
exists from the surface to 8,500 feet (ft) Above Mean Sea Level (AMSL). Class E
airspace exists from 8,500ft AMSL to FL180. Class A airspace exists above FL180.

Outside 6nm to the west of Hamilton Island, Class G airspace exists from the
surface to 4,500ft AMSL. Class C airspace exists between 4,500ft AMSL and
FL180. Class A airspace exists above FL180.

Outside tower hours, Class D airspace below 4,500ft AMSL is reclassified as
Class G (i.e. uncontrolled) airspace.

Outside tower hours, CTAF(R) procedures apply at the aerodrome.

   Figure 1: Extract from the Mackay / Whitsunday Visual Terminal Chart (VTC) showing the area
                        around Hamilton Island and Proserpine aerodromes.

Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009                                         Final
Airspace Review of Hamilton Island - July 2009 - Trim Ref: ED09/60075 File Ref: EF09/3472
Office of Airspace Regulation                                                         Page 7 of 39

3. Aerodrome and Infrastructure
3.1 Background
Hamilton Island is a certified aerodrome, owned and operated by Great Barrier Reef
Airport Pty Ltd. It is located adjacent to the Hamilton Island resort, and constructed
on mostly reclaimed land. The aerodrome has an elevation of 15ft.

The aerodrome offers direct services, daily through Jetstar Airways (Airbus A320),
Virgin Blue Airlines (Boeing 737) and QantasLink Airways (Dash 8) to all major cities
on the east coast of Australia.
The aerodrome has a control tower with operating hours as specified in the
En Route Supplement of Australia (ERSA) or by a Notice To Airmen (NOTAM).

                          Figure 2: Diagram of Hamilton Island aerodrome
       (from the Departure and Approach Procedures (DAP) Chart – effective 30 August 2007)

3.2 Aerodrome
3.2.1. Runways
Hamilton Island has one runway (designated as 14/32). It is 1764 metres long, 45
metres wide and has a grooved, bitumen surface. The pavement strength is suitable
for operations by medium sized aircraft (Airbus A320; Boeing 737 and Dash 8).

Aerodrome lighting is available with prior notification to the aerodrome operator. The
lighting system activates the white runway lights; the blue taxiway lights and
illuminates the wind direction indicators.

Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009                                          Final
Airspace Review of Hamilton Island - July 2009 - Trim Ref: ED09/60075 File Ref: EF09/3472
Office of Airspace Regulation                                                           Page 8 of 39

3.2.2. Aprons and Taxiways
Hamilton Island has one main apron, located in front of the terminal building and a
number of secondary parking areas.

The aerodrome has a network of five taxiways (designated as Alpha; Bravo; Charlie;
Delta and Echo). Taxiways Alpha and Bravo lead directly from the runway to the
main terminal apron. Taxiway Echo leads to a separate apron referred to as the
northern apron or area Echo.

                 Figure 3: Diagram of Hamilton Island aerodrome depicting apron,
      terminal building and taxiway network (from the DAP Chart – effective 30 August 2007)

The taxiway network has a number of limitations. Taxiway Charlie is not available to
aircraft above 5,700 kilograms (kg) Maximum Take Off Weight (MTOW). Taxiway
Delta is not available to aircraft above 36,000 kg MTOW. Taxiway Echo is not
available to aircraft with a wingspan greater than 15 metres. The absence of a full
length, parallel taxiway results in traffic entering and backtracking the runway prior to
departure (if using runway 32) and to backtrack after landing (if using runway 14).

A Passenger Transport (PT) aircraft may occupy the runway for up to 4 minutes
whilst it backtracks and prepares to take-off. Turning nodes are provided at each
threshold, and must be used by aircraft over 23,000kg MTOW.

3.2.3. Automatic Weather Information Service
Current meteorological information can be obtained through the Automated Weather
Information System (AWIS). The AWIS information can be acquired by telephoning
the service on: 07 4946 9043.
3.2.4. Navigational Aids
Hamilton Island is serviced by the following navigational aids (NavAids):

  •    A Non-Directional Beacon (NDB).
  •    A VHF Omni-Directional Radio Range (VOR).
  •    A Distance Measuring Equipment (DME) system.

The NDB is located on the aerodrome, on the western side of the runway. The VOR
and DME are located on top of the hill, to the East of the aerodrome.

Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009                                            Final
Airspace Review of Hamilton Island - July 2009 - Trim Ref: ED09/60075 File Ref: EF09/3472
Office of Airspace Regulation                                               Page 9 of 39

3.2.5. Landing Aids
  • Precision Approach Path Indicator (PAPI) system is installed on both sides of
     Runway 14 and Runway 32.
  • Two illuminated Wind Direction Indicators (WDI), located on the left hand side
     of the runway, adjacent to each threshold.
  • Numerous red beacons have been installed on surrounding hills and islands to
     warn pilots of high terrain.

3.2.6. Instrument Approaches
  • Runway aligned, NDB and Area Navigation (RNAV) Global Navigation Satellite
     System (GNSS) approaches are published for runway 14.
  • Non-runway aligned, VOR approaches are published for runway 14 and 32.
  • Non-runway aligned, Area Navigation (RNAV) Global Navigation Satellite
     System (GNSS) approach is published for runway 32.
  • Circling instrument approaches are also published for DME and Global
     Positioning System (GPS) arrivals.

3.2.7. Radio Communications / Facilities
The Hamilton Island tower utilises the radio frequency of 118.7 megaHertz (MHz).
The frequency of 127.85 MHz is used outside tower hours to facilitate CTAF (R)
procedures at the aerodrome.

The current operational hours for the tower are 2300-0000 and 0100 - 0515
Coordinated Universal Time (UTC) daily. The UTC time equates to 0900 – 1000
and 1100 –1515 (Local time).

The air traffic services / flight information area frequency of 135.5 MHz can be
received on the ground and in the circuit, outside tower hours.

An Automatic Terminal Information Service (ATIS) is broadcast on the frequency
114.4 MHz.

3.2.8. Improvements / Developments
The aerodrome operator has stated that there are no plans for any major works or
for an increase in capacity at the aerodrome, as the current economic crisis has
resulted in a small drop in passenger numbers.

3.2.9. Local Traffic Regulations
  • Right hand circuits are required when operating on runway 14.
  • Due to pavement disturbance, aircraft above 23,000kg MTOW must use
     runway turning nodes for 180 degree turns, unless directed by air traffic control.
  • Transient yacht masts may infringe both runway approach slope clearances.
  • Training approval must be gained for operations during tower hours.
  • Parachute operations take place within 5 nm of the island, up to 10,000 ft
     AMSL.
  • Skeet shooting range adjacent to runway 32 threshold.
  • Bird hazard exists.

Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009                                Final
Airspace Review of Hamilton Island - July 2009 - Trim Ref: ED09/60075 File Ref: EF09/3472
Office of Airspace Regulation                                                        Page 10 of 39

3.2.10. Radar Coverage and Surveillance
The OAR investigated the level of radar coverage surrounding Hamilton Island and
the option of classifying the airspace as Class E. Radar coverage below 3,000 ft
AMSL is not adequate to provide the necessary level of surveillance required. The
installation of additional infrastructure or technologies – such as “Multi-Lateration”
stations or ADS-B, would be required before Class E airspace could be classified
and introduced to the circuit height at Hamilton Island.

     Figure 4: Diagram showing radar coverage at 2,000 feet AMSL surrounding Hamilton Island

3.2.11. Additional aerodromes and helipads
There are numerous helicopter landing areas (helipads) within the Whitsunday
islands, many of which service island resorts. Some of the resorts with helipads,
within 20 nm of Hamilton Island are:
     • South Mole island
     • Daydream Island
     • Hayman Island
     • Happy Bay (Long Island)
     • Edward Island
     • Lindeman Island

There are two aerodromes within 20 nm of Hamilton Island. These are:
    • Shute Harbour / Whitsunday (Airlie Beach).
    • Lindeman Island.

Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009                                           Final
Office of Airspace Regulation                                               Page 11 of 39

The Shute Harbour / Whitsunday aerodrome is an uncertified aerodrome, operated
by the Whitsunday Airport Service. The aerodrome has one runway (designated as
14/32) which is 1100 metres long, and has an unrated, grass/gravel surface.

The aerodrome is not serviced by any land based navigational aids. Aerodrome
lighting is not available.

During hours that Hamilton Island tower is active, the airspace around the Shute
Harbour aerodrome is Class G from the surface to 1,500ft AMSL. Class D airspace
exists between 1,500ft AMSL and 4,500ft AMSL. Class C airspace exists between
4,500ft AMSL and FL180. Class A airspace exists above FL180.

Outside Hamilton Island tower hours, Class D airspace below 4,500ft AMSL is
reclassified as Class G (i.e. uncontrolled) airspace. CTAF procedures are in
operation at the aerodrome utilising the frequency 127.85 MHz. The aerodrome
utilises an Aerodrome Frequency Response Unit (AFRU) which is also known as a
"beepback" unit. The AFRU automatically responds to a radio broadcast to notify
the pilot of the frequency used.

The aerodrome has extensive ultralight and parachute operations.

The Lindeman Island aerodrome is an uncertified aerodrome, operated by the
Club Med Lindeman Island resort. The aerodrome has two runways. The main
runway (designated as 18/36) is 1097 metres long, and has an unrated, grass
surface. The second runway (designated as 13/31) is 680 metres long, and has an
unrated, grass surface.

The aerodrome is not serviced by any land based navigational aids. Aerodrome
lighting is not available. The runways are not maintained and the aerodrome is not
available to commercial aircraft.

During hours that Hamilton Island tower is active, the airspace around Lindeman
Island is Class D from the surface to 4,500ft AMSL. Class C airspace exists
between 4,500ft AMSL and FL180. Class A airspace exists above FL180.

Outside Hamilton Island tower hours, Class D airspace below 4,500ft AMSL is
reclassified as Class G (i.e. uncontrolled) airspace. CTAF procedures are in
operation at the aerodrome utilising the frequency 127.85 MHz.

The Proserpine / Whitsunday Coast aerodrome is approximately 24 nm West South
West of Hamilton Island. Whilst this is outside the scope of this review, the following
details are included for completeness.

The Proserpine/Whitsunday Coast aerodrome (hereafter referred to as “Proserpine”)
is a certified aerodrome, operated by the Whitsunday Regional Council. The
aerodrome has two runways. The main runway (designated as 11/29) is 2073
metres long, 45 metres wide and has a bitumen surface. The secondary runway
(designated as 06/24) is 1100 metres long, 30 metres wide and has an unrated,
bitumen surface. The runway 06/24 is not available to aircraft above 5,700 kg
MTOW.

Proserpine is serviced by NDB, VOR and DME Navigational Aids. An AWIS is
available by telephoning 07 4945 5938 or via the radio on frequency 126.25 MHz.

Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009                                Final
Office of Airspace Regulation                                              Page 12 of 39

Pilot Activated Lighting is available on frequency 120.6 MHz. A PAPI system is
installed for use on the 11/29 runway. Lighting is not available on runway 06/24.

The airspace around Proserpine is Class G from the surface to 4,500ft AMSL. Class
C airspace exists between 4,500ft AMSL and FL180. Class A airspace exists above
FL180.

CTAF (R) procedures are in operation at the aerodrome. The aerodrome utilises an
Aerodrome Frequency Response Unit (AFRU) which is also known as a "beepback"
unit. The AFRU automatically responds to a radio broadcast to notify the pilot of the
frequency used.

The aerodrome is serviced by Virgin Blue Airlines and Jetstar Airways, with daily
flights to Brisbane.

4. Stakeholder Consultation
OAR representatives sought input from a number of stakeholders who operate in
and around Hamilton Island aerodrome. Stakeholder interviews were conducted
over the period of April and May 2009.

4.1 Internal
CASA employs Aviation Safety Advisors (ASA) throughout Australia as an integral
mechanism for providing safety promotion and educational material to the various
industry segments. CASA Aviation Safety Advisors liaise with local operators, and
discuss airspace issues. Feedback from the Aviation Safety Advisors is included in
this report.

4.2 Aerodrome Operator
The operator has reported that Jetstar has recently dropped one of its two daily
flights to Sydney. Jetstar have also recently dropped its flights to Melbourne on
Tuesdays and Wednesdays. It is understood that Virgin Blue will pick up one of
these flights. Virgin Blue plan to commence a daily flight to Sydney from the 4th July
this year. The operator has no plans for any major works or to increase the capacity
of the aerodrome, due to the current economic crisis, which has resulted in a small
drop in passenger numbers.

4.3 Passenger Transport Operators
OAR representatives sought input from the Passenger Transport (PT) operators who
operate in and around Hamilton Island aerodrome. Stakeholder interviews were
conducted over the period of April and May 2009.

4.3.1 VIRGIN BLUE AIRLINES
The controlled airspace in and around Hamilton Island is adequate for the
company’s operations. The airline is satisfied with the facilities provided by the
Great Barrier Reef Airport Pty Ltd.

Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009                               Final
Office of Airspace Regulation                                                 Page 13 of 39

4.3.2 JETSTAR AIRWAYS
The company are satisfied with the ground facilities at the aerodrome (taxiways /
apron / NavAids) and understand limitations due to the confined area available.

The company raised a number of traffic management issues and have implemented
a few company procedures to manage these:

     •    DME arrival from the South: Flights have planned for a DME arrival for a
          circling approach to runway 14 and at times the cloud base was lower than
          advertised. The resulting low level circling lead to some Ground Proximity
          Warning System (GPWS) alerts. The company therefore only descend to
          3,000ft on this DME arrival. If not visual by 3,000ft the flight would continue
          overhead the aerodrome, for the VOR approach.
     •    Dent Island: Jetstar have included information in their route manual to avoid
          Dent Island whilst in the circuit area of Hamilton Island.
     •    Yacht masts: The masts of transient yachts infringe the approach slope
          clearance for runways 14/32 which has resulted in aircraft conducting missed
          approaches. Jetstar have worked with the yacht club to educate sailors on
          the effects of their masts being inside the approach splay and the effects of
          wake turbulence/jet blast on them. An information pack has been developed
          and is available at the yacht club. A selection of Jetstar Airlines information
          flyers are attached in Annex H.

4.3.3 QANTASLINK
The airline is satisfied with the airspace surrounding Hamilton Island. They
experience some frustration with regard to the operating times of the tower, but
understand the hours are linked to the ferry service timetable to the mainland.
The morning flight to and from Cairns operates prior to the Hamilton Island tower
opening.

4.3.4 OTHER AIRLINES
A number of airlines are able to operate into Hamilton Island, but do not have
regular flights. These airlines include:
     • Air National (New Zealand)
     • Alliance Airlines Pty Ltd
     • AirNorth
     • National Jet Systems Pty Ltd

4.4 Military
The Military have no significant aviation activities at Hamilton Island.

4.5 Airservices Australia
The only issue raised was the occasional yacht transiting in and out of the marina
and the mast getting close to the aircraft approach paths. The situation is known to
the Airservices Australia (Airservices) tower staff; the Hamilton Island Marina
management and the airlines. It is being appropriately managed.

The OAR was able to access the Electronic Safety Incident Reports (ESIR) held by
Airservices and the records of flight information relating to Hamilton Island.

Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009                                  Final
Office of Airspace Regulation                                                        Page 14 of 39

5. Summary of Incidents and Accidents
5.1 Electronic Safety Incident Reports
During the 2008 calendar year, 49 Electronic Safety Incident Reports (ESIR) were
submitted to Airservices for the airspace surrounding Hamilton Island. Of the
reported incidents, five groups are related to airspace issues:

                                                                        Number of
                                  Type of Incident
                                                                        Incidents
            Violation of Controlled Airspace                                16
            Failure to comply with ATS instructions or procedures           8
            TCAS Resolution                                                 3*
            Go around                                                       3
            Runway Incursion                                                2
            Loss of Separation Assurance                                     1
    Table 1: Breakdown of ESIRs at Hamilton Island (1st January 2008 – 31st December 2008)

*Note: Seven “Traffic Alert and Collision Avoidance System (TCAS) Resolution”
reports were recorded which included duplicate reports (multiple entries) of the same
incident.

26 of the 49 incidents relate to failure of the pilot to comply with instructions or
procedures (Violation of Controlled Airspace/ Runway Incursion/ Failure to comply
with ATS instructions or procedures). While this represents over half of all of the
incidents reported, it should be noted that 49 reported incidents equates to 0.37% of
the total movements into Hamilton Island.

Three go-around (missed approaches) were recorded during the 2008 calendar
year. Two were initiated due to wind sheer and one was due to the mast of a
transient yacht infringing the approach slope clearance for runway.

Each incident has been investigated, or is currently being investigated by Airservices
or CASA. In each case, the pilot in command will be contacted and educated
regarding the correct procedures relating to the incident.

5.2 Air Safety Incident Reports
All accidents and incidents involving Australian registered aircraft, or foreign aircraft
in Australian airspace must be reported to the Australian Transport Safety Bureau
(ATSB). The ATSB maintains its own database (Occurrence Analysis and Safety
Information System) in which all reports assessed by the ATSB as an accident,
incident or serious incident are recorded. Each individual report is known as an Air
Safety Incident Report (ASIR) and for identification purposes is allocated its own
serial number.

During the calendar year, 34 Aviation Safety Incident Reports (ASIR) were submitted
to the ATSB for the airspace surrounding Hamilton Island.

                                                                         Number of
                                      Type of Incident
                                                                         Incidents
              Violation of Controlled Airspace                               19
              Failure to comply with ATS instructions or procedures          4
              Loss of Separation Assurance                                    1
    Table 2: Breakdown of ASIRs at Hamilton Island (1st January 2008 – 31st December 2008)

Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009                                         Final
Office of Airspace Regulation                                                    Page 15 of 39

The difference in numbers between ESIRs and ASIRs can be attributed to the
different way in which incidents are categorised. For example: if a pilot is given a
clearance to taxi to the runway holding point, but continues and takes off, the ESIR
may classify the incident as a “Failure to comply with ATS instructions or
procedures”, as this was the first error made. The ASIR may class the incident as a
“Violation of Controlled Airspace”, as this was the end result of the error.

A summary of the ASIRs can be found in Annex G.

6. Modelling Methodology and Risk Assessment
6.1 Methodology Outline
The OAR used the Airspace Risk Model (ARM) to model the airspace surrounding
the Hamilton Island aerodrome. The ARM and a FN-curve was developed by CASA
and utilised by the OAR.

CASA has developed ‘acceptable risk’ criteria with regard to the risk of midair
conflicts within regional aerodrome terminal areas. The collision risk model,
developed by CASA in 1996, is focused on a non-radar controlled terminal area
model and no significant changes have been made since its development and
presentation to the Review of the General Concept of Separation Panel, now the
Separation and Airspace Safety Panel of the International Civil Aviation Organization
(ICAO).

This method includes the ARM, which is used to calculate benefits in terms of
fatalities avoided by implementing safety measures. The ARM presumes that there
is a ‘Potential Conflict Pair’, i.e. a pair of aircraft whose manoeuvres are such that if
no intervening action is taken, the aircraft will reach a point where it will be too late to
take evasive action and chance becomes the determining factor in whether the
aircraft collide or not. This is called the Loss of Control point in this review.

The ARM model is based on the Linear Criterion concept which stipulates that the
frequency of an accident should be inversely proportional to its severity, i.e. an
accident involving one fatality may happen ten times as often as an accident
involving ten fatalities.

6.2 Airspace Risk Assessment
6.2.1. Assumptions
The operational environment referred to in the model is controlled non-radar,
Class D terminal area. It has a radius of 15 nautical miles and extends to 5,000 ft
above ground level.
6.2.2. Summary of Movement Data
A summary of aerodrome operator passenger movements is given in Table 1.
Aircraft movement data and passenger movements in charter or private aircraft is
not recorded by the airport operator. The total passenger numbers recorded by the
aerodrome operator each year only represents those passengers that transit through
the airport on RPT, this data being provided by the airlines on a monthly basis.
Therefore the aerodrome operator passenger movement data is statistically similar
to the Bureau of Infrastructure, Transport and Regional Economics (BITRE) data
recorded for the same periods.

Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009                                     Final
Office of Airspace Regulation                                                            Page 16 of 39

BITRE passenger movement and aircraft movement numbers summarised in Table
1 and 2 was sourced from their website2, an extract of which can be found at
Annex F. This data is similar to the aerodrome operator data in that it only captures
passenger and aircraft movement numbers from scheduled RPT services at the
subject airport. As with the aerodrome operator it is not thought that this data
accurately takes into account private or charter passenger aircraft movements.

Airservices data was sourced using their Aerodrome Research Application (ARA)
tool. Detailed ARA data for the 12 months ending October 2008 can be found at
Annex E.

The ARA data differs from the previously mentioned sources in that it generally
involves a more comprehensive data gathering process that includes assessment
and use of BITRE data. ARA data captures passenger and traffic movements
involved in private and charter flights, plus includes circuit movements in the overall
movement totals.

                                 Year            Year       Year           Year           Year
      Data Source
                                2003/04         2004/05    2005/06        2006/07        2007/08
      Aerodrome
       Operator                 343,277         365,009    443,143        476,917        473,611
     % growth on
                                21.06%           6.33%     21.41%          7.62%         -0.69%
     previous year
         BITRE                  338,978         357,370    432,051        465,941        463,845
     % growth on
                                20.43%           5.43%     20.90%          7.84%         -0.45%
     previous year
      Airservices
                                   -                   -       -              -          452,452
       Australia
                 Table 3: Passenger numbers for Hamilton Island – previous 5 years.

                                 Year            Year       Year           Year           Year
    Data Source
                                2003/04         2004/05    2005/06        2006/07        2007/08
       BITRE                     4,798           3,982      4,723           4,605         4,372
    % growth on
     previous                   14.98%         -17.01%     18.61%          -2.50%         -5.06%
        year
    Airservices
                                   -                   -      -               -           6,681
     Australia
             Table 4: Passenger Transport Service movements for Hamilton Island – previous 5 years.
The above Table 3 and Table 4 show clearly that passenger numbers remain steady
whilst the PTS movements have declined. The average number of passengers per
PTS movement has increased from approximately 70.6 in 2003/04 to 106.1 in
2007/08, indicating that the capacity of aircraft flying into Hamilton Island has
increased.

For the purpose of this review the Airservices data set for the 12 months up to
October 2008 has been used, as it more accurately represents the true total air
transport service movements inclusive of circuits.

2
    To view http://www.bitre.gov.au/publications/91/Files/Airport%20traffic%20tables%20Web.xls
Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009                                             Final
Office of Airspace Regulation                                                                 Page 17 of 39

6.2.3. Estimated Traffic Mix
A brief summary of the estimated traffic mix utilising Airservices data at Hamilton
Island is shown in Table 5. The data differentiates between VFR flights and those
conducted under Instrument Flight Rules (IFR).

                                                         No of             % of
                          Traffic Type
                                                       movements        movements
                           VFR Light                      6,225          47.30%
                            IFR Light                     2,708          20.58%
                          IFR Medium                       203            1.54%
                           IFR Heavy                      4,024          30.58%
                              Total                      13,160          100.00%

                       Table 5: Traffic mix for Hamilton Island aerodrome

                                Traffic Mix for Hamilton Island

                                                                                    VFR
                                                                                    IFR - L
                                                                                    IFR - M
                                                                                    IFR - H

                Figure 5: Graphical breakdown of traffic mix at Hamilton Island aerodrome

As can be seen from Table 5 and Figure 5 the majority of aircraft movements are by
VFR aircraft with IFR light and medium aircraft.

Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009                                                  Final
Office of Airspace Regulation                                                            Page 18 of 39

6.2.4. Collision pairs were calculated applying the CASA collision formula
Conflict pairs were grouped into 16 categories and are listed in Table 6:

                                                                            Collision
                                      Collision Types
                                                                             Pairs
                      VFR - VFR                                                45
                      IFR( L) - VFR                                            17
                      IFR(L) - IFR(L) in VMC                                    7
                      IFR(L) - IFR(L) in IMC                                    2
                      IFR (M) - VFR                                             1
                      IFR(M) - IFR(L) in VMC                                    0
                      IFR(M) - IFR(L) in IMC                                    0
                      IFR(M) -IFR(M) in VMC                                     0
                      IFR(M) -IFR(M) in IMC                                     0
                      IFR(H) - VFR                                             26
                      IFR(H) - IFR(L) in VMC                                    9
                      IFR(H) - IFR(L) in IMC                                    2
                      IFR(H) - IFR(M) in VMC                                    1
                      IFR(H) - IFR(M) in IMC                                    0
                      IFR(H) - IFR(H) in VMC                                   15
                      IFR(H) - IFR(H) in IMC                                    4
                                Table 6: Estimated collision pairs for Hamilton Island

                                VFR including gliders and helicopters
                                IFR (L) = IFR Light - less than 10 passengers
                                IFR (M) = IFR Medium - 10 to 38 passengers
                                IFR (H) = IFR High - more than 38 passengers

The conflict pairs were grouped in proportion to traffic and in addition the following
assumptions were made:
            •    Factor up like pairs by 1½
            •    Factor down unlike pairs by ⅔
            •    IFR-IFR pairs are 80% in VMC and 20% in IMC
            •    In total 129 collision pairs were estimated.

6.2.5. Evaluation of Airspace Models and Data Analysis Results
Annualised total traffic movement data was applied to the ARM developed by CASA.
The results are shown in Figure 6 – Risk Model.

The following scenarios were considered for Hamilton Island:

            •    CTAF (R) procedures (pink line)
            •    Class D tower (blue line)

Class E airspace was not considered because of the higher Class D classification
that was in place.

Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009                                             Final
Office of Airspace Regulation                                               Page 19 of 39

The blue line represents a Class D tower service for Hamilton Island. This line is well
below the scrutiny line and it is reasonable to assume that if all services applicable
to a Class D tower are in place, that Hamilton Island can be considered to be as low
as reasonably practicable (ALARP). Therefore the risks associated with Hamilton
Island are tolerable.

It should be noted that CTAF(R) procedures are in place at Hamilton Island during
periods of reduced RPT activity. During periods of decreased activity, the CTAF(R)
procedures offer adequate safety mitigation measures for the aerodrome.

The modelling results estimate that with a Class D tower service approximately,
0.006549 fatalities per annum can be expected. In addition, it is estimated that
Hamilton Island has a likelihood of having one midair collision approximately every
10,707 years with an estimate of 70 fatalities.

Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009                                Final
Office of Airspace Regulation                                                                                                                           Page 20 of 39

                                                                                                                                           Acceptable Risk
                                                                                           Hamilton Island
                                                                                                                                               Criteria

                                                                  1

                                                                                                                                      1
                                                                                                                                    0.1
                                                                                                                                    0.01
                                                                 0.1
                                                                                                                                  0.001
                                                                                                                                 0.0001
                                                                                                                               0.00001
                                                                                                                              0.000001

                                                                0.01
      Annual Frequency of N or More Fatalities (Likelihood)

                                                               0.001

                                                                                                                                                Intolerable Risk Line

                                                              0.0001

                                                                                                                                                  Scrutiny Risk Line
                                                   0.00001

                    0.000001
                                                                                                                                                 Middle ALARP Line

     0.0000001
                                                                                                                                               Acceptable Risk Line
                                                                       1                  10                 100                    1000
                                                                                         Fatalities (Consequence)

                                                                       D Tower                                      CTAF(R)

                                                                           Figure 6: Results of the Airspace Risk Model for Hamilton Island

Note: The Scrutiny Line for CTAF(R) procedures depicted in Figure 6 assumes that
CTAF (R) procedures are in place 24 hours a day.

Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009                                                                                                              Final
Office of Airspace Regulation                                              Page 21 of 39

7. Findings
7.1 Feedback from the RPT stakeholders was positive toward the facilities and
    airspace architecture.
7.2 The application of the Airspace Risk Model (ARM) revealed that the current
    situation lies close to the ‘as low as reasonably practicable’ (ALARP) region and
    that Class D airspace (and CTAF (R) procedures outside tower hours), should
    be the minimum service level maintained at the Hamilton Island aerodrome.
7.3 The introduction of Class E airspace to the circuit height is not acceptable with
    the current level of radar coverage. The installation of additional infrastructure
    or technologies would be required before Class E airspace can be lowered to
    the circuit height.

8.     Recommendations
8.1 The report makes the following recommendations:

     1. Based on current aircraft movements, no change be made to the airspace
        structure surrounding Hamilton Island.

     2. The OAR maintain a watch of activity at Hamilton Island aerodrome during
        the bi-annual review of movement data, and, if total aircraft movements
        significantly increase, or after five years, whichever occurs first, an
        aeronautical study should be conducted to reassess the risk to passenger
        transport operations.

Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009                               Final
Office of Airspace Regulation                                            Page 22 of 39

Annexes:
     A.   Acronyms
     B.   Australian Airspace Structure
     C.   Stakeholders
     D.   Aerodrome Operator Data
     E.   Airspace Research Application (ARA) Data
     F.   Bureau of Infrastructure Transport and Regional Economics (BITRE) Data
     G.   Australian Transport Safety Bureau (ATSB) Data
     H.   Jetstar Airlines information flyers

Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009                             Final
Office of Airspace Regulation                                                     Page 23 of 39

  Annex A – Acronyms
      AAPS                      Australian Airspace Policy Statement, 28 June 2007
      ACAS                      Airborne Collision Avoidance System
      ACP                       Airspace Change Proposal
      Act                       Australian Airspace Act 2007
      AIP                       Aeronautical Information Publication
      AIRPROX                   Close proximity event between two aircraft
      Airservices               Airservices Australia
      ALARP                     As Low As Reasonably Practicable
      AMSL                      Above Mean Sea Level (in feet)
      ARA                       Airspace Research Application
      ARM                       Airspace Risk Model
      ASA                       Aviation Safety Advisor (CASA)
      ASIR                      Aviation Safety Incident Report
      ATC                       Air Traffic Control
      ATI                       Air Transport Inspector
      ATIS                      Aerodrome Terminal Information Service
      ATOG                      Air Transport Operations Group (CASA)
      ATS                       Air Traffic Services
      ATSB                      Australian Transport Safety Bureau
      AWIS                      Automatic Weather Information Service
      BITRE                     Bureau of Infrastructure, Transport and Regional Economics
                                (Department)
      CAR                       Civil Aviation Regulations 1988
      CASA                      Civil Aviation Safety Authority
      CASR                      Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998
      CBA                       Cost Benefit Analysis
      CBS                       Checked Baggage Screening
      CHTR                      Charter
      CTAF                      Common Traffic Advisory Frequency
      CTAF(R)                   Common Traffic Advisory Frequency (Radio Required)
      CTA                       Controlled Airspace
      CTR                       Control Zone
      DA                        Danger Area
      DAP                       Departure and Approach Procedures (AIP)
      DCEO                      Deputy Chief Executive Officer
      Defence                   Department of Defence
      DME                       Distance Measuring Equipment
      ERSA                      En Route Supplement of Australia
      ESIR                      Electronic Safety Incident Report
      FIDS                      Flight Information Display System
      FIR                       Flight Information Region
      FIS                       Flight Information Service
      FL                        Flight Level
      FN Curve                  Frequency /Severity Risk Curve
      FOI                       Flying Operations Inspector
      ft                        Feet
      GA                        General Aviation
      GAAP                      General Aviation Aerodrome Procedures
      GAOG                      General Aviation Operations Group (CASA)

  Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009                                      Final
Office of Airspace Regulation                                                            Page 24 of 39

      GGM                       Group General Manager
      GNSS                      Global Navigation Satellite System (Navigational Aid)
      GPS                       Global Positioning System
      GPWS                      Ground Proximity Warning System
      IAS                       Indicated Airspeed
      ICAO                      International Civil Aviation Organization
      IFR                       Instrument Flight Rules
      IFR (H)                   IFR Heavy - more than 38 passengers
      IFR (L)                   IFR Light - less than 10 passengers
      IFR (M)                   IFR Medium - 10 to 38 passengers
      IMC                       Instrument Meteorological Conditions
      kg                        kilograms
      kts                       knots ( nautical miles per hour)
      MAC                       Mid-Air Collision
      MBZ                       Mandatory Broadcast Zone
      MHz                       megaHertz
      MOS                       Manual of Standards
      MTOW                      Maximum Take Off Weight
      NavAid                    Navigational Aid
      NDB                       Non-Directional Beacon (Navigational Aid)
      nm                        nautical miles
      NOTAM                     Notice to Airmen
      OAR                       Office of Airspace Regulation (CASA)
      OCTA                      Outside of Controlled Airspace
      PA                        Prohibited Area
      PAL                       Pilot Activated Lighting
      PAPI                      Precision Approach Path Indicator
      PT                        Passenger Transport
      PTS                       Passenger Transport Service
      QNH                       An altimeter subscale setting to obtain elevation or altitude
      R/T                       Radio Telephony
      RA                        Restricted Area
      REX                       Regional Express Airlines
      RGCSP                     Review of the General Concept of Separation Panel
      RIS                       Radar Information Service
      RNAV                      Area Navigation
      RPT                       Regular Public Transport
      RWY                       Runway
      SAR                       Search and Rescue
      SFC                       Surface
      SVFR                      Special Visual Flight Rules
      TCAS                      Traffic Alert and Collision Avoidance System, a type of ACAS
      TWR                       Tower
      VFR                       Visual Flight Rules
      VHF                       Very High Frequency (radio)
      VIS                       Visibility
      VMC                       Visual Meteorological Conditions
      VOR                       Very High Frequency (VHF) Omni-directional Radio Range
      VTC                       Visual Terminal Chart (AIP)
      WDI                       Wind Direction Indicator

  Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – May 2009                                              Final
Office of Airspace Regulation                                                                                                                                  Page 25 of 39

     Annex B – Australian Airspace Structure
 Class             Description                          Services/Procedures/Rules
              All airspace above Fight Level            IFR only, all separated by Air Traffic Control (ATC), no speed limitation, continuous two-way radio required.
    A             (FL) 180 (East Coast) or              Clearance required from ATC to enter airspace.
                           FL245
    B         Not currently used in Australia
                                                        IFR separated from IFR, VFR and Special VFR (SVFR) by ATC, no speed limitation for IFR operations,
                                                        continuous two-way radio required. Clearance required from ATC to enter airspace.
               In control zones (CTRs) of               VFR receives traffic information on other VFR but not separated from each other by ATC. Speed limited to
                 defined dimensions and                 250knots (kts) Indicated Air Speed (IAS) below 10,000ft AMSL*, continuous two-way radio required. Clearance
    C         control area steps associated             required from ATC to enter airspace.
               with controlled aerodromes               Special VFR separated from Special VFR when visibility (VIS) is less than VMC. Speed limited to 250kts IAS below
                                                        10,000ft AMSL*, continuous two-way radio required. Clearance required from ATC to enter airspace.
                                                        Transponder required within radar coverage.
                                                        IFR separated from IFR and Special VFR. Traffic information provided on all VFR. Speed limited to 250kts IAS
                                                        below 10,000ft AMSL*, continuous two-way radio required. Clearance required from ATC to enter airspace.
                Regional locations such as              VFR receives traffic on all other aircraft but not separated by ATC. Speed limited to 250kts IAS below 10,000ft
    D            Hobart and Alice Springs               AMSL*, continuous two-way radio required. Clearance required from ATC to enter airspace.
                                                        Special VFR separated from Special VFR when VIS is less than VMC. Speed limited to 250kts IAS below 10,000ft
                                                        AMSL*, continuous two-way radio required. Clearance required from ATC to enter airspace.
                                                       GAAP:
                                                       • In VMC all operations are VFR, traffic information only. Speed limited to 250kts IAS, continuous two-way radio
                                                         required. Clearance required from ATC to enter airspace.
    D         High density General Aviation
                                                       • In IMC, IFR separated from all traffic. Speed limited to 250kts IAS, continuous two-way radio required. Clearance
(GAAP)                aerodromes
                                                         required from ATC to enter airspace.
                                                       • Special VFR separated from Special VFR when VIS is less than VMC. Speed limited to 250kts IAS, continuous
                                                         two-way radio required. Clearance required from ATC to enter airspace.
                                                        IFR separated from IFR by ATC, traffic information on known VFR. Speed limited to 250kts IAS below 10,000ft
                  Controlled airspace not               AMSL*, continuous two-way radio required. Clearance required from ATC to enter airspace.
                 covered in classifications             VFR provided with Flight Information Service (FIS), search and rescue (SAR), weather update service, on request,
    E             above (above 8,500ft or               within radar coverage and workload permitting. Speed limited to 250kts IAS below 10,000ft AMSL*, continuous
                          FL180)                        two-way radio required. Clearance from ATC to enter airspace not required.
                                                        Transponder required for VFR aircraft with continuous electrical power
    F         Not currently used in Australia
                                                        IFR receives FIS on IFR and known VFR traffic. Speed limited to 250kts IAS below 10,000ft AMSL*, continuous
                                                        two-way radio required. Clearance from ATC to enter airspace not required.
                                                        VFR provided with FIS, SAR, weather update service and Radar Information Service (RIS) subject to availability.
    G                   Non-controlled
                                                        Speed limited to 250kts IAS below 10,000ft AMSL*. Clearance to enter airspace from ATC not required. VHF radio
                                                        required above 5,000ft AMSL and at aerodromes where carriage and use of radio is required. VHF radio for
                                                        operations in VMC.
     * Not applicable to military aircraft

     Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009                                                                                                               Final
Office of Airspace Regulation

       Annex C – Stakeholder input provided by:
                           Position                                            Organisation

      Aerodrome Manager                                Great Barrier Reef Airport Pty Ltd (Aerodrome Operator)

      Aerodrome and Airways Manager                    Jetstar Airways

      Manager Regulatory Affairs                       QantasLink Airways

      E-Jet Fleet Standards Manager                    Virgin Blue Airlines

      Information and Co-ordination Officer            Australian Transport Safety Bureau

      Senior Defence Advisor                           Department of Defence

      Regulatory Services Manager                      Airservices Australia

       Aviation Safety Advisor (ASA)                   Deputy Chief Executive Officer, Operations, CASA

       Flying Operations Inspector (FOI)               General Aviation Operations Group, CASA

Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009                                                        Final
Office of Airspace Regulation                                                                                                    Page 27 of 39

     Annex D – Aerodrome Operator Data

                                 2003 / 2004           2004 / 2005          2005 / 2006           2006 / 2007          2007 / 2008
                           ARRIVALS DEPARTURES ARRIVALS DEPARTURES ARRIVALS DEPARTURES ARRIVALS DEPARTURES ARRIVALS DEPARTURES
                   July       12,696         13,307 14,421        15,322 16,443         17,418 20,763        22,017 19,174         20,275
                August        14,720         14,498 15,971        15,281 17,556         17,466 19,930        19,339 21,213         20,256
             September        16,862         15,358 18,564        17,142 20,989         18,948 23,692        22,126 23,684         22,807
               October        17,221         18,669 19,346        20,590 22,139         23,340 24,429        25,478 24,445         25,560
             November         15,801         16,081 15,543        16,195 19,605         20,099 21,681        22,148 22,481         22,618
             December         15,679         13,863 16,152        14,002 20,061         17,942 20,982        19,500 21,334         20,171
               January        16,182         18,987 15,857        18,274 21,329         24,435 20,724        23,899 19,716         22,921
              February        11,005         11,422 11,462        11,347 14,449         14,355 15,400        15,021 15,431         15,410
                 March        12,801         12,686 15,361        14,422 17,770         17,452 18,665        18,443 19,667         19,248
                  April       14,257         14,297 14,899        15,127 19,927         20,052 18,802        19,355 18,162         18,623
                   May        10,922         11,381 11,971        12,928 14,990         15,648 15,737        15,826 15,328         16,106
                  June        12,746         11,836 13,339        11,493 16,124         14,606 16,648        16,312 15,130         13,851

     Sub Total                  170,892       172,385    182,886   182,123   221,382   221,761   237,453   239,464    235,765    237,846
     Total Movements                           343,277             365,009             443,143              476,917              473,611

Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009                                                                                       Final
Office of Airspace Regulation                          Page 28 of 39

     Annex E – Airservices Australia Data

Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009               Final
Office of Airspace Regulation                           Page 29 of 39

     Annex E – Airservices Australia Data (Continued)

Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009                Final
Office of Airspace Regulation                           Page 30 of 39

     Annex E – Airservices Australia Data (Continued)

Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009                Final
Office of Airspace Regulation                               Page 31 of 39

     Annex F – BITRE Data

     Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009              Final
Office of Airspace Regulation                                                                                                                                                               Page 32 of 39

Annex F – BITRE Data (Continued)
                                                                                                                          HAMILTON ISLAND
                                                                                     500
                                                                                     450

                                                      Total Revenue Passengers
                                                                                     400
                                                                                     350
                                                                                     300

                                                              (thousand)
                                                                                     250
                                                                                     200
                                                                                     150
                                                                                     100
                                                                                         50
                                                                                         0
                                                                                                1997-    1998-    1999-    2000-    2001-   2002-   2003-   2004-   2005-   2006-   2007-
                                                                                                 98       99       00       01       02      03      04      05      06      07      08
                                                                                                                                     Financial Year

                                                                                                           Passenger numbers 1997 - 2008

                                                                                                                          HAMILTON ISLAND
                                                                                 6,000
                                              Total Aircraft Movements

                                                                                 5,000

                                                                                 4,000

                                                                                 3,000

                                                                                 2,000

                                                                                 1,000

                                                                                    0
                                                                                              1997-     1998-    1999-    2000-    2001-    2002-   2003-   2004-   2005-   2006-   2007-
                                                                                               98        99       00       01       02       03      04      05      06      07      08
                                                                                                                                    Financial Year

                                                                                                        Air Transport movements 1997 - 2008

  Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009                                                                                                                                                 Final
Office of Airspace Regulation                                                                                                                                                             Page 33 of 39

     Annex G – ATSB Data
     ATSB
                    Occurrence    Airspace    Airspace      Aircraft
   Reference                                                                                     ATSB Summary                                              Incident Type
                       Date         Type        Class        Model
    Number

   200800128         04-Jan-08       CTR          D          Vehicle            A vehicle entered the runway without a clearance.               Failure to comply with ATS instructions

   200800494         03-Feb-08       CTR          D          R44 II    The helicopter became airborne from the apron without a clearance.          Violation of Controlled Airspace

   200800781         07-Feb-08       CTR          D         A320-232            During the landing roll, the aircraft struck a duck.                          Birdstrike

                                                                        On opening of the tower, multiple failures of tower equipment was
   200803279         10-Feb-08       CTR          D           n/a                                                                                 Information Delivery/Display Error
                                                                                                   observed.

                                                                       Just prior to commencing an instrument approach, the crew noticed
                                                                       that the number one primary flight display showed an incorrect IAS.
   200800951         16-Feb-08       CTA          C         A320-232                                                                                            Misc.
                                                                         The instrument was restored using an alternate source and the
                                                                                             aircraft landed safely.
                                                                         The helicopter entered the CTR without a clearance and was first
   200801104         21-Feb-08       CTR          D          R44 II    noticed on short final by the tower controller. No broadcasts or other      Violation of Controlled Airspace
                                                                                            calls were made by the pilot.

                                                                          The aircraft entered the CTR without a clearance and the pilot
   200801497         08-Mar-08       CTR          D          R44 II                                                                                Violation of Controlled Airspace
                                                                              contacted ATC when on final approach to runway 14.

   200801665         13-Mar-08       CTR          D          Vehicle      A line-marking vehicle entered runway 14 without a clearance.         Failure to comply with ATS instructions

                                                                       The Hamilton Island PAPI (Precision Approach Path Indicator) failed
   200801786         15-Mar-08       CTR          C         A320-232       while the aircraft was on final. The crew conducted a visual                         Misc.
                                                                                                    approach.
                                                                        The aircraft was observed turning final as the pilot contacted the
                                                                       ADC to advise that they thought the aerodrome was operating as a
   200801815         20-Mar-08       CTR          D          M20M                                                                                  Violation of Controlled Airspace
                                                                        CTAF. No other calls had been heard on the CTAF(R) or Hamilton
                                                                                     Island tower frequencies from the pilot.
                                                                         After the pilot reported inbound on the CTAF frequency, the ADC
                                                            47G3B-
   200802330         07-Apr-08       CTR          D                       advised that the controlled airspace was active. The helicopter          Violation of Controlled Airspace
                                                             KH4
                                                                          subsequently entered controlled airspace without a clearance.

     Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009                                                                                                                                            Final
Office of Airspace Regulation                                                                                                                                                         Page 34 of 39

                                                          DHC-2
   200802611         19-Apr-08      CTR          D                           The aircraft entered the CTR without a clearance.                 Violation of Controlled Airspace
                                                          MK 1

                                                                       The pilot commenced the take-off run on runway 14 without a
   200803291         18-May-08      CTR          D         A36                                                                                 Violation of Controlled Airspace
                                                                                               clearance.

                                                                     During the landing roll on runway 14, the aircraft struck a magpie
   200803437         22-May-08      CTR          D       A320-232                                                                                         Birdstrike
                                                                                                      lark.
                                                                     During the landing roll, the aircraft struck a swallow that impacted
   200803597         30-May-08      CTR          D       A320-232                                                                                         Birdstrike
                                                                                                 the radome.
                                                          PA-23-
   200803600         02-Jun-08      CTR          D                          During the take-off run, the aircraft struck a plover.                        Birdstrike
                                                           250

                                                          PA-32-      The aircraft was observed by ATC to have joined a right circuit,
   200803601         02-Jun-08      CTR          D                                                                                          Failure to comply with ATS instructions
                                                           300                           contrary to instructions.

                                                                    The pilot did not comply with the line up clearance and the aircraft
   200803946         16-Jun-08      CTR          D         208                                                                              Failure to comply with ATS instructions
                                                                                   became airborne without a clearance.

                                                                    During the approach, the crew of an Airbus A320 reported receiving
   200804029         18-Jun-08      CTA          D       A320-232                                                                               Loss of Separation Assurance
                                                                          a TCAS RA after a VFR aircraft passed below the A320.

                                                                    The aircraft entered controlled airspace before the pilot requested a
   200804721          19-Jul-08     CTR          D        C130                                                                                 Violation of Controlled Airspace
                                                                                                  clearance.

   200804984          30-Jul-08     CTR          D        R44 II    The helicopter was observed by ATC to take off without a clearance.        Violation of Controlled Airspace

                                                                    The aircraft was observed by ATC to have commenced the take-off
   200805168         10-Aug-08      CTR          D        206L-3                                                                               Violation of Controlled Airspace
                                                                                         run without a clearance.

                                                         DHC-8-
   200805210         13-Aug-08      CTR          D                         During the initial climb, the aircraft struck a swallow.                       Birdstrike
                                                          315

                                                                      The unidentified aircraft was observed by ATC to have entered
   200805262         14-Aug-08      CTA          D       Unknown                                                                               Violation of Controlled Airspace
                                                                                controlled airspace without a clearance.

   200805287         15-Aug-08      CTR          D        R44 II                The helicopter took off without a clearance.                   Violation of Controlled Airspace

  Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009                                                                                                                                           Final
Office of Airspace Regulation                                                                                                                                                          Page 35 of 39

                                                                       The aircraft was observed by ATC to have entered controlled
   200805444         21-Aug-08      CTR          D        172M                                                                                  Violation of Controlled Airspace
                                                                                       airspace without a clearance.

   200805465         24-Aug-08      CTR          D        206L-1    The helicopter was observed by ATC to take off without a clearance.         Violation of Controlled Airspace

                                                                    On short final approach, the crew commenced a go-around due to a
   200805578         26-Aug-08      CTR          D       A320-232                                                                                          Go Around
                                                                                yacht moving through the undershoot area.

                                                                     The helicopter entered controlled airspace prior to requesting an
   200805541         26-Aug-08      CTR          D        R44 II                                                                                Violation of Controlled Airspace
                                                                                            airways clearance.

                                                                      The helicopter was observed by ATC to have entered controlled
   200805644         30-Aug-08      CTR          D        R44 II                                                                                Violation of Controlled Airspace
                                                                                 airspace and landed without a clearance.

                                                                    During the descent, the aircraft was cleared to 3,900 ft. The aircraft
                                                         DHC-8-
   200806011         13-Sep-08      CTA          D                   was subsequently observed by ATC to have descended to 2,200 ft          Failure to comply with ATS instructions
                                                          315
                                                                                           without a clearance.

                                                         47G3B-       The helicopter was observed by ATC to have entered controlled
   200806601         11-Oct-08      CTR          D                                                                                              Violation of Controlled Airspace
                                                          KH4                         airspace without a clearance.

                                                                        While on descent, the pilot declared a PAN due to an engine
   200807017         07-Nov-08      CTA          C        182P                                                                                      Emergency Operations
                                                                            problem. The aircraft was landed at Shute Harbour.

                                                                       The aircraft was observed by ATC to have entered controlled
   200807617         25-Nov-08      CTR          D        R44 II                                                                                Violation of Controlled Airspace
                                                                                       airspace without a clearance.

                                                         DHC-8-      During the landing roll, the aircraft struck a bird that impacted the
   200807873         08-Dec-08      CTR          D                                                                                                         Birdstrike
                                                          402                              left wing leading edge.

  Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009                                                                                                                                            Final
Office of Airspace Regulation                            Page 36 of 39

     Annex H – Jetstar information flyers

  Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009              Final
Office of Airspace Regulation                            Page 37 of 39

  Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009              Final
Office of Airspace Regulation                            Page 38 of 39

  Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009              Final
Office of Airspace Regulation                            Page 39 of 39

  Airspace Review – Hamilton Island (YBHM) – July 2009              Final
You can also read