An Evaluation of Digital Marketing Pertaining to Birmingham City Football Club - Appraising the Application of CRM, AI and SEM as Potential ...

Page created by Jon Tyler
 
CONTINUE READING
An Evaluation of Digital Marketing Pertaining to Birmingham City Football Club - Appraising the Application of CRM, AI and SEM as Potential ...
An Evaluation of Digital Marketing Pertaining to
         Birmingham City Football Club

Appraising the Application of CRM, AI and SEM as Potential
                    Digital Approaches

                                -
               Rosanna Embley and Sem Visser
                        December 2021
             UD7004 – Digital marketing for Football
An Evaluation of Digital Marketing Pertaining to Birmingham City Football Club - Appraising the Application of CRM, AI and SEM as Potential ...
An Evaluation of Digital Marketing

Pertaining to Birmingham City Football

Club: Appraising the Application of CRM, AI

and SEM as Potential Digital Approaches

Executive summary

  •   The purpose of this report is to evaluate the potential applications of digital marketing
      techniques for Birmingham City Football Club (BCFC) with a focus on customer
      relationship management (CRM), artificial intelligence (AI), and search engine marketing
      (SEM).
  •   CRM as a whole is investigated in relation to the sports industry, a fan relationship
      management (FRM) framework is applied to identify BCFC’s areas of development, and
      the spotlight is ultimately put on the application of chatbots to enhance CRM through
      improved personalization and more engagement.
  •   The application of AI for football clubs is then evaluated with dynamic pricing at its
      center. The potential high cost and more negative sides of AI are also briefly explored.
  •   Eventually SEM is explored with a focus on the two main techniques: search engine
      optimization (SEO) and paid per click (PPC). The advantages of these inbound
      marketing techniques are addressed and examples of how this could help BCFC are
      provided.
  •   Finally, recommendations regarding the application of these techniques and important
      financial considerations are presented. The report ends with a conclusion.
An Evaluation of Digital Marketing Pertaining to Birmingham City Football Club - Appraising the Application of CRM, AI and SEM as Potential ...
Table of Contents
1.      Introduction ............................................................................................................... 4
2.      Customer relationship management (CRM) .......................................................... 5
3.      Artificial Intelligence (AI) .......................................................................................... 8
4.      Search Engine Marketing (SEM) ........................................................................... 10
5.      Recommendations .................................................................................................. 13
6.      Conclusion ............................................................................................................... 14
References ...................................................................................................................... 15
Appendices ..................................................................................................................... 19
     Appendix A: Key concepts to understand ranking processes and improve the SERP
     position .................................................................................................................................... 19
     Appendix B: SEO explained as an ongoing process ......................................................... 20
     Appendix C: Birmingham FC investment in SEO compared to competition .................. 21
     Appendix D: Email content BCFC based subscriber access ............................................ 22
     Appendix E: Application of the fan relation management framework (FRM) for BCFC . 24

Table of Figures

Figure 1 CRM initiative implementation (Adamson, et al., 2005) ............................... 5
Figure 2 Fan relationship management (FRM) framework.......................................... 6
Figure 3 Modified customer engagement cycle using chatbots (Ramaul, 2021) ..... 7
Figure 4 communications mix for traffic building ...................................................... 10
Figure 5 Birmingham FC website store ....................................................................... 12
Figure 6 Google result for search word 'football club merchandise' ...................... 12
Figure 7 stages involved in search engine listing ..................................................... 19
Figure 8 SEO as an on-going process ......................................................................... 20
Figure 9 Leading websites of professional football clubs in the English
Championship with highest SEO visibility 2019 (Statista, 2019) ............................. 21
Figure 10 Example emai BCFCl .................................................................................... 22
Figure 11 Example email BCFC .................................................................................... 23
An Evaluation of Digital Marketing Pertaining to Birmingham City Football Club - Appraising the Application of CRM, AI and SEM as Potential ...
1. Introduction

This report aims to evaluate relevant digital marketing techniques for Birmingham City

FC (BCFC). BCFC is a football club playing in the Championship with many domestic

and international supporters clubs (Birmingham City FC website, 2021). A previous

attempt by the club to globalise and gain on the Chinese football market has failed,

matches are attended by a core group of local fans (May, 2019).

Football lags behind other industries in implementing customer relationship

management (CRM) because most clubs take fan loyalty for granted, however, recent

research highlights different fan segments that are not loyal to just one team (Adamson,

et al., 2005). For this reason, CRM will be inspected. Also, the report delves into the

emerging artificial intelligence (AI) technology that can provide a more personalised

customer experience (Ramaul, 2021) and offer immersive viewer experiences to fans at

home (Peel, 2020).

Furthermore, the emergence of the Internet has disrupted global markets and changed

customers’ buying behaviours (Bezhovski, 2015). Searching behaviour became a

buyer’s first step (Ranga & Ranga, 2014), and due to growth, the online marketplace

has become more competitive (Yang, 2007). This causes difficulties for online shops to

direct traffic to their sites. This also applied for the BCFC-webstore which is why search

engine marketing (SEM) is evaluated.
An Evaluation of Digital Marketing Pertaining to Birmingham City Football Club - Appraising the Application of CRM, AI and SEM as Potential ...
2. Customer relationship management (CRM)

   The football industry is potentially a sector in which CRM would work well (Adamson,

   et al., 2005). The essence of CRM is understanding customers to improve loyalty

   and long-term profitability (Chen & Popovich, 2003; Stringfellow, et al., 2004).

   Successful implementation of CRM activities rests on the cross-functional integration

   of processes, people, operations and marketing capabilities, figure 1 below provides

   a perspective of the extensive scope (Adamson, et al., 2005).

 Figure 1 CRM initiative implementation (Adamson, et al., 2005)

Classic CRM models need to be adapted to match the unique characteristics of sport

like supporter loyalty and segmentation, therefore, (Adamson, et al., 2005) developed

the fan relationship management (FRM) framework (Figure 2 below).
An Evaluation of Digital Marketing Pertaining to Birmingham City Football Club - Appraising the Application of CRM, AI and SEM as Potential ...
Figure 2 Fan relationship management (FRM) framework

Having applied the FRM-framework to BCFC, identified areas of development are

formulating a clear CRM-strategy, improving social media usage as a tool for

engagement, segmentation and targeting of fans (Appendix E includes the FRM-

analysis which expands on this).

Customer retention is an important result of CRM which depends on customer loyalty

and this can be enhanced by personalisation (Arab, et al., 2010). Appendix D looks

more in depth at some of BCFC’s current CRM practices, and impersonalised email

messages can be considered a limitation. As a solution to improve personalisation, AI-

driven chatbots can be used as they provide quick automated personalised

communication resulting in engagement with customers, in contrast to traditional

mediums like email, they also aid in the value creation process (Ramaul, 2021). The

CRM performance is affected by engagement through interactions with instant

messaging (Marino & Presti, 2018). Thus, AI chatbots are useful for BCFC to improve
An Evaluation of Digital Marketing Pertaining to Birmingham City Football Club - Appraising the Application of CRM, AI and SEM as Potential ...
CRM as they ensure connection, interaction and satisfaction which are important

aspects of customer engagement (Ramaul, 2021).

     Figure 3 Modified customer engagement cycle using chatbots (Ramaul, 2021)

By utilising chatbots, BCFC could enhance their CRM strategy to build stronger

relationships with their customers through the acquisition of knowledge regarding their

needs and wants (Ado, et al., 2015). (Ramaul, 2021) highlights a modified engagement

cycle which clearly points out the chatbot role (see Figure 3). Chatbot driven by AI

processes can help strengthen the relationship between club and customer through the

timely provision of accurate customer support, which indicates a dedication to improving

the customer experience.
An Evaluation of Digital Marketing Pertaining to Birmingham City Football Club - Appraising the Application of CRM, AI and SEM as Potential ...
3. Artificial Intelligence (AI)

Artificial Intelligence, which can be best understood using (Kaplan & Haenlein, 2019)

definition: “a system’s ability to correctly interpret external data, to learn from such data,

and to use those learnings to achieve specific goals and tasks through flexible

adaptation”, is a contemporary business trend that’s usage can be applied to the

football industry, with our focus on marketing activities.

The scope for the application of AI within the football industry as a whole is extensive.

While football as an industry has historically been slow to welcome technology (Kidd,

2019), insights derived from AI processes can help the growth of the sport across a

multitude of avenues. Liverpool Football Club can be heralded as an organisation that

have integrated AI and human intelligence in recent years and seen upturns in both

their sporting and financial performance (Lichtenthaler, 2020). AI can assist in the

following areas, with other opportunities yet to be fully explored:

   •   Player recruitment/transfers

   •   Pricing and ticketing strategy

   •   CRM & fan engagement

   •   Refereeing

   •   In-game decision making, predictions, and analysis

One particular exploration of AI includes its usage in dynamic pricing setting, and how

this might be applied in football. Dynamic pricing, as described by (Kotler, et al., 2016)
An Evaluation of Digital Marketing Pertaining to Birmingham City Football Club - Appraising the Application of CRM, AI and SEM as Potential ...
is the concept of flexibly setting pricing based on current market demand as well as

capacity utilisation. AI can be used to set dynamic ticket prices well in advance through

the creation of databases collating information about variables such as fixture popularity

and previous attendance patterns (Rathi, et al., 2020). (Rietveld, 2020) discusses a

dynamic pricing pilot with Dutch club Vitesse Arnhem in collaboration with Convious,

whose AI capabilities allowed them to set individualistic prices for fans based on factors

such as willingness to pay, in a bid to drive attendance figures. Insights can be derived

from AI captured data such as time of the season, fixture importance/popularity, team’s

form, as well as customer’s previous purchasing habits, to set dynamic prices. The pilot

experiment generated positive feedback, with 52% of ticket purchasers stating they

were swayed to buy a ticket based on the personal offer they could take up.

It should be noted that there are potential limitations with AI methods. A clear problem

for a club like Birmingham City, who operate in the Championship on a relatively low

budget compared to Premier League clubs (Ajadi, et al., 2021), is the high cost that

these applications would require. Furthermore, AI cannot replicate a human’s ability to

be creative and think innovatively, which is necessary, particularly in a marketing

context (Keshav, et al., 2020).
An Evaluation of Digital Marketing Pertaining to Birmingham City Football Club - Appraising the Application of CRM, AI and SEM as Potential ...
4. Search Engine Marketing (SEM)

To build more traffic, SEM can be applied, which is a form of Internet marketing that

includes the promotion of websites by increasing visibility in search engine result pages

(SERP) through optimisation and advertising (Ranga & Ranga, 2014). It is part of the

communications mix for traffic building to websites (Figure 1) and the most important

digital marketing channel for customer acquisition, (Chaffey & Smith, 2017) (e.g. Google

(Dwyer, 2016)) but BCFC is not using yet using it (Statista, 2019) (Appendix C).

        Figure 4 communications mix for traffic building

(Chaffey & Smith, 2017) confirm that the main challenge of SEM is gaining visibility and

highlight two techniques:

   1. Search engine optimisation (SEO): the practice of optimising web pages to

      improve their ranking in SERP which are known as organic results because they

      reflect relevancy to searchers, marketers often turn to SEO specialised firms to
execute these activities (Xing & Lin, 2006). Understanding the ranking processes

         for marketers to boost the SERP position compared to competitors (Chaffey &

         Smith, 2017) (see Appendix A). SEO for sport websites can be improved by

         defining goals, finding keywords, using content marketing, and leveraging social

         media (Schäferhoff, 2017). Appendix B expands on the SEO-process.

   2. Paid per click (PPC): PPC allows advertiser to bid on specific keywords or

         phrases so that their advertisements are shown in the SERP alongside organic

         search engine results (Boughton, 2005).

Both are inbound marketing methods (Kim, 2019), which is a strategy that attracts

prospects to a website, convert them to leads, and ultimately to brand promoters; this

differs from interruptive marketing which is pushed to users (e.g. emails) (Bezhovski,

2015). Benefits of this are that a direct and long-term relationship is created, buyer

persona profiles produced, and it enables a content strategy based on keywords

identified with SEO. Its complexity can be considered a disadvantage (Patrutiu-Baltes,

2016).
Applying these techniques can increase the visibility of the site and web store (see

 figure below) through higher Google ranking on specific search words like ‘football club

 merchandise’.

              Figure 5 Birmingham FC website store

 The current SERP for ‘football club merchandise’ only finds other clubs’ web stores (e.g.

 Watford FC) (Figure 5).

Figure 6 Google result for search word 'football club merchandise'
BCFC can best simultaneously apply SEO and PPC as they complement each other

which improves SERP outcomes (Dod, 2020). Collaboration between SEO and PPC is

critical to encourage engagement (Dod, 2020; DiNardi, 2021), a holistic approach allows

the SEO team use keyword data from PPC to make optimisation decisions (Lincoln,

2018). These benefits could potentially increase traffic to the retail web shop which can

increase sales, but competition for the keywords will be fierce (Shewan, 2021).

   5. Recommendations

The following proposed recommendations would require significant investment from

BCFC, and it should be taken into consideration that the current financial state of the

club means that the implementation of these techniques would likely be deemed a risk

(Dick, 2021). Thus, it is important to highlight the potential ROI and additional

opportunities these strategies and methods could lead to.

Regardless of many football clubs considering supporter loyalty a given, BCFC should

invest in CRM strategies because this can improve loyalty and long-term profitability

(Chen & Popovich, 2003; Stringfellow, et al., 2004). Given the identified areas of

development through the FRM-framework, applying AI-powered chatbots on social

network sites and club website is recommended. This will improve CRM because of an

increase in engagement (Ramaul, 2021), and strengthened relationships with fans (Ado,

et al., 2015). Furthermore, the club should explore AI-methods to set ticket pricing, thus

maximising revenues for popular matches and increasing attendances on less-desirable

matchdays (Rietveld, 2020). And, hiring a specialised firm to execute SEM techniques

such as SEO and PPC should be considered by BCFC (Xing & Lin, 2006). Especially
since web searching behaviour is becoming the norm and the BCFC web shop is not

immediately visible when searching on Google. Improvements can be made by defining

clear goals, finding keywords, using content marketing, and leveraging social media

(Schäferhoff, 2017). This can increase website traffic and potentially sales (Chaffey &

Smith, 2017).

   6. Conclusion

A combination of the three evaluated digital marketing techniques would be a beneficial

in addition for football clubs such as BCFC. The evidence suggests that BCFC’s current

digital marketing practices result in impersonalised advertisements and interactions.

Higher levels of personalisation could be realised by enhancing CRM methods, which

can be done by applying AI-powered chatbots on the website and social network site

accounts. AI can also be used to optimise profitability by applying dynamic pricing

strategies. Finally, SEM can help BCFC to achieve more digital visibility in search

engines through SEO and PPC which will impact web store traffic and potentially

increase online sales. However, digitally transforming the club’s marketing efforts may

pose financial risks, and these relatively new inventions are largely unproven,

particularly in the football industry. At the same time, the potential ROI development

which might be worth the initial offset should be considered.
References

Adamson, G., Jones, W. & Tapp, A., 2005. From CRM to FRM: Applying CRM in the
football industry. Database Marketing & Customer Strategy Management, 13(2), pp.
156-172.
Adamson, G., Jones, W. & Tapp, A., 2005. From CRM to FRM: Applying CRM in the
football industry. Database Marketing & Customer Strategy Management, 13(2), pp.
156-172.
Ado, A. B., Hassan, H. & Nasir, M., 2015. Ado, A.B., Hassan, H., & Nasir, M. (2015).
Electronic customer relationship management (E-CRM) features: Comparing two
football clubs (Manchester United & Chelsea FC)..
Ajadi, T. et al., 2021. Riding the challenge Annual Review of Football Finance 2021, s.l.:
Deloitte.
Arab, F., Selamat, H., Ibrahim, S. & Zamani, M., 2010. An overview of success factors
for CRM. In 2010 2nd IEEE International Conference on Information and Financial
Engineering, pp. 702-705.
Bezhovski, Z., 2015. INBOUND MARKETING - A NEW CONCEPT IN DIGITAL
BUSINESS. JEL (Journal of Economic Literature), Volume M31, M37, M15, pp. 27-34.
Birmingham City FC website, 2021. WE ARE PROUD OF OUR RELATIONSHIP WITH
OUR FANS.. [Online]
Available at: https://www.bcfc.com/club-and-fans/fans/supporters-clubs/
[Accessed 6 December 2021].
Boughton, B. S., 2005. Search Engine Marketing. Perspectives in business, 2(1), pp.
29-33.
Bowers, C., n.d. 5 Benefits of Using SEO and PPC Together. [Online]
Available at: https://www.kanukadigital.com/2018/10/using-seo-and-ppc-together/
[Accessed 27 November 2021].
Chaffey, D. & Smith, P., 2017. Digital marketing excellence : planning and optimizing
your online marketing. 5 ed. Oxon: Routledge.
Chen, I. J. & Popovich, K., 2003. Understanding customer relationship management
(CRM). Business Process Management Journal, 9(5), pp. 672-688.
Dick, B., 2021. 'Worrying' - Birmingham City's growing debts outlined by football finance
expert. [Online]
Available at: https://www.birminghammail.co.uk/sport/football/football-news/worrying-
birmingham-citys-growing-debts-20528440
[Accessed 6 December 2021].
Dick, M., 2011. Search Engine Optimisation in UK News Production. Journalism
Practice, 5(4), pp. 462-477.
DiNardi, G. N., 2021. 7 Ways SEO & PPC Can Work Together in 2021. [Online]
Available at: https://blog.hubspot.com/marketing/seo-and-ppc-alignment
[Accessed 27 November 2021].
Dod, R., 2020. How SEO and PPC strategies can work together to drive business goals.
[Online]
Available at: https://searchengineland.com/how-seo-and-ppc-strategies-can-work-
together-to-drive-business-goals-332496
[Accessed 27 November 2021].
Dwyer, D., 2016. Top 12 Best Search Engines in The World. [Online]
Available at: https://www.inspire.scot/blog/2016/11/11/top-12-best-search-engines-in-
the-world238
[Accessed 27 November 2021].
Kaplan, A. & Haenlein, M., 2019. Siri, Siri, in my hand: Who’s the fairest in the land? On
the interpretations, illustrations, and implications of artificial intelligence. Business
Horizons, 62(1), pp. 15-25.
Keshav, R., Aditya, K. V., Priyam, S. & Manu, K. S., 2020. Applications of Artificial
Intelligence in the Game of Football: The Global Perspective. International Refereed
Social Sciences Journal, 11(2), pp. 2229-4686.
Kidd, R., 2019. Man Vs. Machine: Is Soccer Ready For Artificial Intelligence?. [Online]
Available at: https://www.forbes.com/sites/robertkidd/2019/08/02/man-vs-machine-is-
soccer-ready-for-artificial-intelligence/?sh=20c6fa6b6955
[Accessed 7 December 2021].
Kim, L., 2019. News Flash: PPC Is Inbound Marketing. [Online]
Available at: https://www.wordstream.com/blog/ws/2013/05/29/what-is-inbound-
marketing
[Accessed 27 November 2021].
Kotler, P., Kartajaya, H. & Setiawan, I., 2016. Marketing 4.0: Moving from Traditional to
Digital., s.l.: Wiley.
Krabec, T. & Venegas, P., 2015. Fields: On the Visibility of Flows in Digital Business.
Financial Assets and Investing, Volume 3, pp. 5-22.
Lichtenthaler, U., 2020. Mixing data analytics with intuition: Liverpool Football Club
scores with integrated intelligence. Journal of Business Strategy.
Lincoln, L., 2018. How SEO and PPC can work together. [Online]
Available at: https://www.merkleinc.com/emea/blog/how-seo-and-ppc-can-work-together
[Accessed 27 November 2021].
Marino, V. & Presti, L. L., 2018. Engagement, satisfaction and customer behavior-based
CRM performance An empirical study of mobile instant messaging. Journal of Service
Theory and Practice, pp. 2055-6225.
May, A., 2019. Football and the ‘mysterious nature of global capital’: A case study of
Birmingham City FC and Birmingham International Holdings. International Review for
the Sociology of Sport, 54(8), pp. 957-970.
Patrutiu-Baltes, L., 2016. Inbound Marketing - the most important digital marketing
strategy. Bulletin of the Transilvania University of Braşov Series V: Economic Sciences,
9(58 No. 2), pp. 61-68.
Peel, J., 2020. Streaming, VR and AR – what does the future of sport look like in 2021
and beyond?. [Online]
Available at: https://www.marketingmag.com.au/hubs-c/opinion-streaming-vr-and-ar-
what-does-the-future-of-sport-look-like-in-2021-and-beyond/
[Accessed 6 December 2021].
Pohjanen, R., 2019. The Benefits of Search Engine Optimization in Google for
Businesses, Oulu: Unpublished master’s thesis. University of Oulu.
Raby, A., 2019. 5 Simple and Fundamental Ways to Improve SEO for Your Sports Club.
[Online]
Available at: https://www.themeboy.com/blog/5-simple-fundemental-ways-to-improve-
sports-seo/
[Accessed 27 November 2021].
Ramaul, L., 2021. ROLE OF AI IN MARKETING THROUGH CRM INTEGRATION
WITH SPECIFIC REFERENCE TO CHATBOTS. Jyväskylä University School of
Business and Economics Master’s Thesis 2021.
Ranga, M. & Ranga, S., 2014. Search engine marketing-a study of marketing in digital
age. International Journal of Management and Social Sciences Research, 25(6), pp. 24-
26.
Rathi, K., Somani, P., Koul, A. V. & Manu, K. S., 2020. Applications of artificial
intelligence in the game of football: The global perspective.. Researchers World, 11(2),
pp. 18-29.
Rietveld, J., 2020. Dynamic Ticket Pricing: Does it work for Football Clubs?. [Online]
Available at: https://jobsinfootball.com/blog/dynamic-ticket-pricing-does-it-work-for-
football-clubs/
[Accessed 7 December 2021].
Saleh, K., 2021. Online Consumer Shopping Habits and Behavior. [Online]
Available at: https://www.invespcro.com/blog/online-consumer-shopping-habits-
behavior/
[Accessed 27 November 2021].
Schäferhoff, N., 2017. SEO for Sports Teams and Sports Team Websites – How to Do
It Right. [Online]
Available at: https://www.themeboy.com/blog/seo-for-sports-teams-websites/
[Accessed 30 November 2021].
Shewan, D., 2021. 25 Ways to Increase Traffic to Your Website. [Online]
Available at: https://www.wordstream.com/blog/ws/2014/08/14/increase-traffic-to-my-
website
[Accessed 6 December 2021].
Singh, H., 2006. The Importance of Customer Satisfaction in Relation to Customer
Loyalty and Retention. Academy of Marketing Science, 60(193-225), p. 46.
Statista, 2019. English Championship club websites with highest SEO visibility as of
2019 Published by David Lange , Oct 19, 2021 According to the source Searchmetrics,
Leeds had the highest SEO visibility index on their website, concluding the 2018/19
season of the En. [Online]
Available at: https://www.statista.com/statistics/1057491/leading-websites-with-highest-
seo-visibility-in-england-championship/
[Accessed 30 November 2021].
Stringfellow, A., Nie, W. & Bowen, D. E., 2004. CRM: Profiting from understanding
customer needs. Business Horizons, 47(5), pp. 45-52.
Xing, B. & Lin, Z., 2006. The Impact of Search Engine Optimization on Online Adverting
Market. Proceedings of the 8th international conference on Electronic commerce: The
new e-commerce: innovations for conquering current barriers, obstacles and limitations
to conducting successful business on the internet, pp. 519-529.
Yang, H.-e., 2007. Assessing the effects of e-quality and e-satisfaction on website
loyalty. INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTERS IN
SIMULATION, Volume 1, pp. 288-294.
Appendices

Appendix A: Key concepts to understand ranking processes and improve
the SERP position

  Four key concepts to understand are: 1) Crawling (the activity of robots called

  spiders that are identifying relevant pages for indexing by retrieving a reference URL

  for later analysis), 2) Indexing (indexes are created so that the search engine can

  rapidly find relevant pages to the typed query), 3) Ranking (websites are ranked in

  the index so that the most relevant sites are visible in the SERP), and 4) Query

  request and result serving (searcher’s query is accepted, user location assessed via

  the IP address and the relevant sites are displayed based on the ranking). The figure

  below visualised these aspects.

   Figure 7 stages involved in search engine listing
Appendix B: SEO explained as an ongoing process

 SEO enables one to compare performances of different domains in search engines

 allowing for the identification of positive and negative changes (Krabec & Venegas,

 2015). (Pohjanen, 2019) highlights that SEO is an ongoing process (see figure below).

 First, you must choose effective keywords, secondly, on-page elements like metatags,

 page content and site navigation must be made attractive to search engine spiders.

 Thirdly, the website must be in the search engine index by submitting URLs, the fourth

 step is link building, this means creating external and internal links.

Figure 8 SEO as an on-going process
Appendix C: Birmingham FC investment in SEO compared to competition

         Birmingham FC is not among the teams that invest much in SEO.

Figure 9 Leading websites of professional football clubs in the English Championship with highest SEO visibility 2019 (Statista, 2019)
Appendix D: Email content BCFC based subscriber access

Over 25 emails from BCFC were looked at over the course of the opening 3 months of

the 21/22 season - these were the notable findings:

   •   Fans are not addressed directly by first name (not personalised)

   •   Emails are mass-marketing ads, with no personalisation to specific customer

       (nothing based on what their website viewing history was, what they previously

       purchased, or games they had attended).

   •   The communication of stand closures was done initially by email and were not

       done well in advance of the season starting

   •   Season ticket holders were notified that they would be unable to attend matches

       due to ongoing disruption with the stadium. Fans had to enter a ballot to see if

       they could get tickets to certain games, and not in the seats they had season

       tickets for. If you were successful in the raffle for tickets to Bournemouth (H), that

       meant you couldn’t get a ticket for Stoke (H), and vice-versa.

   •   Fans are yet to receive refunds for those initial games that they were unable to

       attend.

 Figure 10 Example emai BCFCl
Figure 11 Example email BCFC
Appendix E: Application of the fan relation management framework (FRM)
for BCFC

  1) Strategic vision and leadership
     - Board speaks of a ‘fan first philosophy’
        (https://bcfc.com/media/32236/final_supporters_forum_minutes-2.pdf)
     - Commitment not there from leadership – ground neglected, customers
        neglected (see appendix D)

  2) Fan Loyalty Strategy
     - Membership – points for loyalty (Blues loyalty scheme in place)
     - Season ticket holders – silver, platinum, bronze sections – (priority ticketing
        for certain matches including away games)

  3) Fan-centric approach
     - Customer problems with stadium and match day experience have been put
        forth to the club with no response
        (https://almajir.net/2021/12/06/wheres-the-money-gone-st-andrews/)

  4) Understanding fan needs
     (https://bcfc.com/news/articles/2021/blues-welcome-supporters-clubs-back-to-st-
     andrew-s/) – ‘Fan Forum’ held at the beginning of the season

  5) Database marketing
     - There is no evidence to suggest there is segmentation and targeting of
        customers. No personalised communication with fans, no evidence of data
        collection (knowledge of google analytics is required for Digital Marketing
        Exec role (based on job description research, see Appendix F), so
        presumption that some kind of data is being collected
6) Appropriate technology
   - Very limited communication one-to-one with fans over social media (twitter –
     limited replies, see images below – following link takes you to ‘Twitter Table’
     documenting clubs’ number of replies
     (https://tables.theonlinerule.com/twitter-table/championship/)), digital ticketing
     taken up by over 50% of fans (info from fans forum), ticketing queries are still
     dealt with over the phone
Appendix F: BCFC Digital Marketing Assistant job description

                   Digital Marketing Assistant
 Location: St Andrew’s Trillion Trophy Stadium, Birmingham, B9
                               4RL
                      Salary: Competitive
                   Expires: 25/11/2021 23:59
                                              Apply
Department: Brand & Marketing
Term: Permanent, Full Time
Location: St. Andrew's Trillion Trophy Stadium, Cattell Road, Birmingham, West Midlands, B9 4RL
Salary: Competitive
Application Closing Date: 29/06/2021 (Due to the urgency of filling this vacancy, suitable
candidates will be interviewed as and when they apply and the role will be closed as soon as a
suitable candidate has been sourced).
We are currently looking for a self driven and motivated Digital Marketing Executive to work with the
Digital Marketing Manager to enhance the Club’s marketing and digital strategy across all platforms,
developing creative campaigns that engage the fanbase, builds the Club’s reputation and maximises
commercial success.
JOB DESCRIPTION
CORE RESPONSIBILITIES

                        •   Create and deliver marketing plans and campaigns for a wide range of
                            products, events and services.
                        •   Write creative marketing copy for the website and all forms of marketing
                            materials.
                        •   Lead on the day-to-day development of bcfc.com, uploading content and
                            reporting on analytics.
                        •   Work closely with the Digital Marketing Manager to develop the Club’s
                            CRM database and activity.
                        •   Build and schedule all email and SMS campaigns.
                        •   Work closely with the Digital Marketing Manager to develop the Official
                            Club App.
                        •   Build and schedule all push notifications.
                        •   Providing monthly and weekly e-comms plans and publishing schedules
                            for content activities.
                        •   Work closely with the Social Media Executive to enhance digital
                            marketing initiatives such as paid search and paid advertising
                            campaigns.
                        •   Work closely with the commercial team to activate the Club’s partnership
                            deals.
•   Contribute innovative ideas for all marketing (online and offline) relevant
                           to the target audience.
                       •   Contribute innovative ideas to increase the monetization of the Club’s
                           digital channels.
                       •   Produce regular analytics and reports, analysing the success of
                           campaigns.
                       •   Maintain administration for all print quotations and purchase orders.
                       •   Act as the point contact in the absence of the Digital Marketing Manager.
                       •   Ensure compliance with all the Policies and Procedures contained within
                           the Staff Handbook, paying particular regard to the Equality & Diversity,
                           Safeguarding and Health & Safety Policies and procedures at all times.
                       •   Any other duties as deemed necessary by your Line Manager or Head of
                           Department.

PERSON SPECIFICATION
Qualifications
Essential Requirements

                       •   Educated to at least degree level in a marketing or sport management
                           course (or similar) or qualified by suitable experience.

Desirable Requirements

                       •   Digital Marketing qualification or further study 3D Drawing skills.

Skills and Abilities
Essential Requirements

                       •   Must possess excellent written and verbal communication.
                       •   Understanding of effective email communications.
                       •   Able to think and write creatively.
                       •   Able to work to tight deadlines and on multiple projects.
                       •   Must possess excellent attention to detail.
                       •   Knowledge of CRM.
                       •   Knowledge of Google Analytics.
                       •   Strong organisational skills.
                       •   Excellent proof-reading skills.

Desirable Requirements

                       •   Previous experience with CRM, email marketing, and marketing
                           planning.
                       •   Previous experience using CMS.
                       •   Previous experience working within a sporting environment preferably
                           within football.

Personal Requirements
Essential Requirements
•   Must adhere to confidentiality and data protection procedures at all
                            times.
                        •   A confident and outgoing personality, self-motivation and positive
                            attitude.
                        •   Imaginative, creative and customer focused.
                        •   Hands on approach, and willingness to get ‘stuck in’.

Applicants must be eligible to live and work in the UK.
Only applicants that demonstrate within their application that they meet the above criteria will be
considered for the role.
You can also read