How to Take Running Records
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
How to Take Running
Running Records are
taken to: Records
•guide teaching (adapted from Alphakids Assessment Kit Teacher’s Guide)
•match readers to
appropriate texts Running Records capture what children know and understand about
•document growth the reading process. They capture children’s thinking. Running Records
overtime provide you with an opportunity to analyze what happened and plan
•note strategies used appropriate instruction. From Running Records, you have evidence of
•group and regroup what the child is able to do, ready to learn, and learning over a period
children for instruction of time. Noted researcher Marie Clay designed this very effective and
widely used tool.
A Running Record is not just the recording of right and wrong words.
It requires observing all behaviours to help determine the “thinking
process” children are using as they read the text. A correct response
does not necessarily reveal the thinking a child is using unless they have
verbalized or shown through body language (e.g., eyes go to the
picture, finger moves back across the text) their mental processing. A
Running Record provides you with a playback of an entire oral reading
conference, including the smallest details on the reader’s attitude,
demeanour, accuracy, and understanding.With this information, you
can analyze behaviours, responses, competencies, initiatives taken, and
in turn, determine instructional needs.You are therefore encouraged to
record all behaviours children display during reading conferences.
Running Records are also a critical piece of assessment for the
formation of dynamic (changing regularly) guided reading groups, and
allow for the selection of “just right” texts and the teaching of
appropriate strategies. Running Records allow you to document
progress over time when an initial or baseline record is compared to a
more recent one.
Taking a Running Record
To take a Running Record, sit beside a child as he or she reads a selected
portion of the text aloud in a natural and relaxed environment. It is
necessary to select a time when you can hear the child read without
interruptions, such as when children are engaged in quiet reading or
on independent literacy activities. Observe and record everything the
child says and does during the reading.You will find yourself noticing
more and more about children’s reading behaviours each time you take
a Running Record. Because there is a set code for recording, all teachers
can understand and then discuss, analyze, and plan teaching strategies for
the child or small groups of children.
Recording
The following conventions provide a consistent approach to recording
reading behaviours. (Based on Clay 1993, Kemp 1987, and Goodman &
Burke 1972) With these notations, every effort the child makes is
recorded in detail. For a readily available recording sheet, see page 12.
Behaviour Notation Example
Correct response Mark every word read correctly with a ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔
check mark. Can you see my eyes?
Substitution Write the spoken word above the word ✔✔ ✔ the ✔
in the text. Can you see my eyes?
Omission Place a dash above the word left out. ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔
Can you see my eyes?
Insertion Insert the added word and place a dash ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔big ✔
below it (or use a caret). Can you see my eyes?
Attempt Write each attempt above the word ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ e-ey
in the text. Can you see my eyes?
Repetition Write R after the repeated word/phrase
and draw an arrow back to the ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔R ✔
beginning of the repetition. Can you see my eyes?
Appeal* Write A above the appealed word. ✔ ✔ ✔ A ✔
(asks for help) Can you see my eyes?
Told word Write T beside the word supplied ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔
for the reader. Can you see my T eyes?
Self-correction Write SC after the corrected word. ✔ ✔ ✔ the/SC ✔
Can you see my eyes?
*An appeal for help from the child is turned back to the child for further effort
(e.g., Say: You try it. If the child is unsuccessful, the word is teacher-given (told word).
Scoring a Running Record
You can use the following scoring to assess a child’s performance.
Note
Insertions add errors. A reader 1. Count only the running words in a text. Running words do
could have more errors than not include titles, subtitles, captions, and so on.
there are words on a line.
However, a reader cannot have 2. Count as one error: Do not count:
more errors than words
on a page.
◆ a substitution ◆ self-corrections
◆ an omission ◆ repetitions
◆ an incorrect attempt ◆ a correct attempt
◆ an unsuccessful appeal ◆ a successful appeal
◆ a told word ◆ words pronounced
differently in a child’s
◆ an insertion dialect or accent
3. Count each word in a skipped line as an error.
4. ount a skipped page as one error and subtract the word count
C
for that page from the total word count.
5. Count proper nouns read inaccurately only once. Count other
words read inaccurately each time.
6. Calculate the Percent of Accuracy for a record by subtracting the
total number of errors made from the number of running words
in the text. The answer will then be divided by the number of
running words.
Calculating Percent of Accuracy
1. Running Words – Total Errors = Score
– =
2. Score Running Words 100 = % Accuracy
100 = %
7. Determine the Self-Correction Rate for a record. The Self-
Correction Rate indicates how well a child self-monitors his or
her reading. Calculate this rate by adding the total number of
errors to the total number of self-corrections and dividing this
sum total by the total number of self-corrections. For example,
six total errors plus two self-corrections equals eight. If you divide
eight by the total number of self-corrections, the answer is four.
The self-correction rate is then recorded as 1:4, which shows the
child self-corrected one time for every four words misread.
A Self-Correction Rate of up to 1:5 shows the child is self-
monitoring and using decoding strategies.
Calculating Self-Correction Rate
1. Total Errors + Total Self-Corrections = Sum Total
=
2. Sum Total ÷ Total Self-Corrections = Rate
=1:
8. Once you have calculated the Percent of Accuracy and the Self-
Correction Rate, you can determine whether the reading level
for that book is easy, instructional, or hard for for a particular
reader.
Understanding Percentages
Easy Text Appropriate Challenging Hard Text
(96-100%) Instructional Text Instructional Text (Below 90%)
(93-95%) (90-92%)
Move child to higher A comfortable Child may require more Move child to lower
text level. instructional direct support. level.
text level.
Easy Texts
(96-100%)
When children read an easy text, they are able to read for enjoyment
and meaning. There are no decoding challenges. Easy texts are
appropriate for independent reading.
Appropriate Instructional Texts
(93-95%)
These texts are selected by you, and have many supports and very few
challenges for the reader. They are at the higher-end of what Clay
has identified as Instructional Texts (90-95%). Because you are usually
working with a group of children and not individuals, it is difficult
to match texts appropriately to the background knowledge and
instructional strategies of an entire group. These texts are appropriate
for guided reading.
Challenging Instructional Texts
(90-92%)
These texts can be more challenging for a child or group of children.
A text at this percentage may require too much work. A guided
reading text should provide only one or two challenges and be a
supported, comfortable read.
Self-Monitoring Strategies
• ignored
obvious errors Hard Texts
• paused/stopped
(Below 90%)
• repeated word(s) These texts have too many challenges for children to read.
• tried something else
• self-corrected Analyzing Reading Behaviours
• self-corrected and Once a record of a child’s reading has been taken, it is necessary to
re-read to confirm analyze the strategies, cues, and behaviours he or she is using (or not
• integrated cueing systems using).
( M, S , V)
When analyzing a child’s reading performance, it is your “best guess”
(using all the knowledge gathered about the child) of the process or
“reading thinking” that is happening. To acquire a useful analysis, it
is important to determine whether readers are using meaning cues,
structural cues, or visual cues.
Integrating the Cueing Systems
Meaning
Maker
Does it
make sense?
Structural Visual
Code Code
Breaker Breaker
Does it Does it
soundright? look right?
M Meaning Cues
Meaning cues relate to a reader’s ability to gather a book’s basic
message by making meaning of it at the text, content, and word
level. If readers are using meaning cues, they think and evaluate
what they read. They check whether the sentence “makes sense.”
Meaning-appropriate errors (miscues) do not interrupt the general
comprehension of the sentence or paragraph. A meaning miscue
may be syntactically appropriate, but may not have a letter-sound
correlation.
When analyzing a Running Record or Record of Reading
Behaviours, it is important to look at all the errors the child makes.
For each error, answer the following question: Does the child’s attempt
make sense considering the story background, information from pictures, and
meaning in the sentence? If the answer is yes, the child has used meaning
cues, and is M circled in the error column.
Note When dealing with self-corrections, consider what caused the child
The same cue can be used
while making and self-correcting to make the error in the first place. If meaning cues were being used
an error. while the error was made, M is circled in the error column. Then
consider what cues the child used to self-correct. If meaning cues were
used for the self-correction, M is circled in the self-correction column.
Cues Used
✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ woods M S V
There are many trees in the forest.
In this example, the reader substituted woods for forest. With this
substitution, the sentence still makes sense and sounds right. Therefore,
the reader used both meaning M cues and structural S cues. However,
the reader did not use visual cues since the words do not resemble
each other in any way.
S Structural Cues
Readers who use structural cues are relying on their knowledge of the
grammar and structure of the English language to make the text sound
right. Using this knowledge, readers check whether or not the word or
sentence sounds right.
When analyzing a Running Record or Record of Reading
Behaviours, it is important to look at all the errors the child makes.
For each error, answer the following question: Does the child’s attempt
sound right considering the structure and syntax of the English language? If
the answer is yes, the child has used structural cues, and S is circled in
the error column.
When dealing with self-corrections, consider what caused the child
to make the error in the first place. If structural cues were being
used while the error was made, S is circled in the error column.
Then consider what cues the child used to self-correct. If structural
cues were used for self-correction, S is circled in the self-correction
column.
V Visual Cues
Visual information includes the way letters and words “look.” Readers
use their knowledge of the visual features of words and letters and
then connect these features to their knowledge of the way words and
letters sound when spoken.
When analyzing a Running Record or Record of Reading
Behaviours, it is important to look at all the errors the child makes.
For each error, answer the following question: Does the child’s attempt
visually resemble in any way the word in the text (e.g., begins and/or ends in
the same letter)? If the answer is yes, the child has used visual cues, and
V is circled in the error column.
When dealing with self-corrections, consider what caused the child
to make the error in the first place. If meaning cues were being used
while the error was made, V is circled in the error column. Then
consider what cues the child used to self-correct. If visual cues were
used for self-correction, V is circled in the self-correction column.
Cues Used
poor
M S V
I swim in a pool.
In this example, the reader substituted poor for pool. With this
substitution, the sentence does not make sense nor does it sound right
based on the grammar and syntax of the English language. However,
the two words resemble one another visually, so the reader used visual
V cues.
The goal for readers is to integrate the cueing systems while reading
for meaning. For example, a child might look at a word, make the
sound of the first letter, think of a word that would make sense, sound
Note right, and match the visual features of the word. This child has initially
Readers should be using more
than one cueing system at a used visual information, thought about meaning and structure, and
time. then checked the prediction against visual information. This happens
quickly, and the child’s focus remains on meaning.
Self-Monitoring Strategies
Strategies To Look for After all errors and self-corrections are analyzed, you should also
While Children Are reflect on the following to help assess a reader’s self-monitoring
Reading: strategies to guide further instruction:
• Looking at the pictures.
• Questioning whether 4Does the reader repeat what he or she has read as if to confirm the
it makes sense, sounds reading so far?
right, and looks right. 4Does the reader notice when cues do not match?
• Finding little words in
big words. 4Does the reader pause as if he or she knows something does not
• Reading to the end of match but seems to not know what to try?
the sentence. 4Does the reader request help (appeal) frequently? after several
• Looking at the attempts?
punctuation marks.
4Does the reader rely on only one cue, or does the reader integrate
cues?
4Does the reader check one cue against another?
4Does the reader read with phrasing and fluency?
Diagnostic Reading
Conferences
Diagnostic Reading Conferences allow you to determine the cues
children are using to read, the appropriate text level for them, their
interests and understanding of a text, and their ability to make
inferences. This information is gathered before, during, and after a
child’s reading.
Conducting a Diagnostic Reading
Conference
4Select the text. First, select a text from an appropriate level for a
child by looking at the concepts or strategies the text assesses. If a
child does not use most of these concepts or strategies to read, the
text level will be too hard. If the child uses some of these concepts
or strategies, the text level may be “just right.” If the child uses and
integrates these concepts or strategies consistently, the text level
may be too easy.
4Introduce the text. The introduction is important for developing
the background information each child needs to read the text. The
text introduction is brief and natural. After introducing the text, let
the child preview the book. (To ensure consistency of assessment, it is
important that each child is introduced to the text in the same way).
4Take a Running Record. Indicate where the child should begin
reading aloud. If the text is a short one, the child should read the
whole selection (even if the recording is not done on the last few
pages) and complete the conference right after. For a longer text,
pre-select a logical starting and stopping place of at least 150 words.
The child then goes off to complete the reading on his or herown and later returns to complete the conference. Before the child
begins reading, remind him or her that you will be asking for a
retelling once the reading is complete. Then ask the child to begin
reading aloud. Take a Running Record or use a Record of Reading
Behaviours to record the child’s reading. (Only the pages the child
is asked to read aloud are recorded.)
4Ask for a retelling/summary. Comprehension can never be
Retelling details based onreading performance alone; therefore, retelling is a vital
Fiction: part of the Diagnostic Reading Conference. Unaided retelling
• characters consists of children retelling the story/facts any way they choose.
• plot and setting Simply introduce the retelling session with: Tell me all you remember
• problem/solution
about the story.With this prompt, most children re-create the story
• vocabulary from text
by including characters, setting, and/or the underlying theme. If
Non-fiction:
children need encouragement, provide non-contented related
• main ideas prompts, such as: What else do you remember? Tell me more. If children
• important facts are still non-responsive, content-related prompts are required.
• supporting details When assessing a child’s retelling, listen for:
• specialized vocabulary – general understanding of the story
– accurate reporting of events (non-fiction)
– sequencing of events
– words and phrases used from the text
– connections to personal knowledge and experience
– use of effective vocabulary
– elements of character and setting
– supporting details (non-fiction)
4Check comprehension/higher-level thinking. Following the
Comprehension oral reading session and the retelling, conduct an interview with the
Strategies child to assess his or her understanding of the text. This interview
• making personal consists of questions related directly to the events/facts in the story,
connections inference questions, and critical-thinking questions. This helps
• making inferences children develop their roles as text users and text critics.
• being a text critic
• understanding author’s 4Conduct an interest survey. Motivation is strongly linked to
purpose attitude; therefore, it is important to note the books children enjoy
• gaining information and reading, their favourite authors, whether they like to read at home,
details from non-fiction and if someone reads to them outside of school. Conducting
texts an interest survey is important in choosing texts for guided and
independent reading. Note that an interest interview does not have
to be conducted during each conference, perhaps just two or three
times a year.
104Check fluency. Fluency is a critical factor in reading control.
Fluency and accuracy are all highly related to comprehension.
Comprehension is affected if children read slowly, attending too
much to working out words and taking long pauses. Fluent reading
means solving problems on the run, something all children must
do if they are to gain understanding of a text. Children who
read accurately, quickly, and in phrased units have much better
comprehension and are more likely to read for pleasure.
While taking the Running Record, record any relevant notes about
a child’s reading fluency for reference when completing the scale.
4Analyze the record. After the conference is completed (and
while the class is still working independently), go over the record
while it is still fresh in your mind. Fill in any observations (e.g.,
looked at pictures, read through punctuation) you want to include,
and calculate and circle the percent of accuracy of the child’s
reading. If the child has made errors and/or self-corrections, analyze
the cues ( M , S , V ) he or she used. This information guides the
text selection for instructional and independent reading.
4Analyze the interview. Assess the child’s personal connections,
responses to the comprehension questions, and his or her retelling.
This will help you determine whether the child has understood
the text, made personal connections, and what the child’s interests
are in reading. If the child was able to decode the text but unable
to comprehend the story, the text level needs to be dropped to the
point at which the child understands the story. Specific emphasis
on comprehension through all components of a balanced literacy
program becomes the focus of instruction.
4Make instructional decisions. Instructional decisions are critical
in terms of building children’s ability to read increasingly difficult
text. A child should not be held too long in a level, when they
could be reading more complex texts. Moving them ahead before
they integrate the needed strategies will make it more difficult for
the child to read and comprehend the text easily. Text difficulty
usually affects the fluency rate as well.
You can use the analysis chart to help make instructional decisions
for the child. After analyzing the reading record and reflecting on
the conference, instructional decisions need to be made. Using the
completed analysis charts, you can decide on strategies for specific
children to consolidate or learn next. A strategy should be taught
in a shared context and then practised in guided and independent
reading. Guided reading continues to scaffold for the children
before independence occurs. The self-monitoring strategies are best
taught through shared reading practices.
1112
You can also read
