The First 50 Years of Victoria University of Wellington Antarctic Expeditions

Page created by Amber Salinas
 
CONTINUE READING
The First 50 Years of Victoria University of Wellington Antarctic Expeditions
The First 50 Years of
                                             Victoria University of Wellington
Antarctic Research Centre                          Antarctic Expeditions
Victoria University of Wellington,
PO Box 600, Wellington, New Zealand
Phone +64-4-463 6587, Fax +64-4-463 5186
E-mail Antarctic-Research@vuw.ac.nz
www.vuw.ac.nz/antarctic
                                           Recollections and reunion programme

                                                                    Victoria University of Wellington
                                                                               30 June – 1 July 2007
The First 50 Years of Victoria University of Wellington Antarctic Expeditions
Table of Contents

                  inside front cover

                                                                              Welcome . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .2

                                                                              Recent Benefactors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .3

                                                                              Reunion programme . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .4

                                                                              Reunion participants . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .6

                                                                              The Birth of VUWAE . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .10

                                                                              Members of VUWAE: 1957-2007 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .12

                                                                              Recollections of the first 50 years . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .18

Victoria University of Wellington Antarctic Expeditions: The First 50 Years
The First 50 Years of Victoria University of Wellington Antarctic Expeditions
Welcome                                                                                                Recent Benefactors
Prior to my first departure for the Ice on a VUWAE expedition, I heard the                             Throughout the history of VUWAE,                 Harry Keys, Barry Kohn, Phil Kyle,
pre-season talk that ARC Director, Professor Peter Barrett claims to have inherited from Bob Clark.    organizations and individuals have sponsored     Judy Lawrence, Barrie McKelvey, John
                                                                                                       and supported the programme with equipment       Nankervis, Anthony Parker, Russell Plume,
    “ with
      There are basically only two things to remember”, he instructed. “Firstly, help out
           the boring jobs at Scott Base. This will put you in a good position with base
                                                                                                       and money. Most recently the Antarctic
                                                                                                       Research Centre has received a $1 million
                                                                                                                                                        Bryan Sissons, David Skinner, Tim Stern,
                                                                                                                                                        David Sugden, Tony Taylor, John Thurston,
       staff, which will make their job easier, and will help make the rest of your field              donation from former student Alan Eggers, who    Colin Vucetich, Trish Walbridge, Robin
       season go smoothly. Secondly, come back safely. While Antarctica can be a                       traveled to the Ice on VUWAE20 in 1975.          Williams, Ian Wright and Dan Zwartz.
       hazardous place, VUWAE has a proud record of having no major casualties; so
                                                                                                       We have also benefited from a series of three
       look after yourself and your colleagues. Apart from that, enjoy yourself.
                                                                                      ”                donations from Singaporean philanthropist        The S.T. Lee Lectures in
Peter Barrett's passion for making sure that history informs the way we move into the future           Lee Seng Tee. Dr Lee provided funds for the      Antarctic Studies:
guides both his scientific research and his directorship of the Antarctic Research Centre. His love    development of the S.T. Lee Library in the
of history has also made sure we would celebrate the first 50 years of Victoria University of          Antarctic Research Centre and established an       Antarctica and Climate Change
Wellington Antarctic Expeditions, and in that celebration leave a legacy for the next 50 years.                                                           in the Century Ahead - Causes,
                                                                                                       endowed fund for an exchange programme             Consequences and Surprises
Many thanks to the organising committee of Peter Barrett, Warren Dickinson, David Balham, Roger        with the University of Alaska. He also             Professor Robert Dunbar,
                                                                                                       provided endowment funding for the S.T. Lee        Stanford University, USA
Cooper and Mike Hannah for their work in bringing this reunion together. We hope you enjoy it!                                                            Inaugural Lecture - 8 August 2003
                                                                                                       Lecture Series in Antarctic Studies, which has
                                                                                    Tamsin Falconer    been held annually since 2003.                     Antarctica's Contribution to Abrupt
                                                VUWAE 50 & 51 and Antarctic Research Centre Manager,                                                      Global Warming Events -
                                                               for the Reunion Organising Committee    The students of the Antarctic Research Centre      Past and Future
                                                                                                                                                          Professor James Kennett,
                                                                                                       have also benefited from the establishment of      University of California Santa Barbara, USA
                                  ANDRILL Drill Site on the McMurdo Ice Shelf, November 2006
                                                                                                       an Endowed Development Fund for Antarctic          12 August 2004
                                                                                                       Research. Donors to the fund have                  How sensitive is the Antarctic Ice
                                                                                                       contributed more than $150,000. Silver             Sheet to climate change?
                                                                                                       donors include Antarctica New Zealand,             An earth-science perspective
                                                                                                                                                          David Sugden, Professor of Geography,
                                                                                                       Austral Pacific Energy Ltd, Peter Barrett,         School of GeoSciences,
                                                                                                       Warren Dickinson and Webster Drilling &            University of Edinburgh
                                                                                                       Exploration Ltd. Bronze donors include Tony        16 June 2005
                                                                                                       Allen, Jo Anderson & Matt Paterson, John           The Exploration of Antarctic Subglacial
                                                                                                       Anderson, Cliff Atkins, Dick Barwick, Daniel       Lakes: Science, Logistics and Politics
                                                                                                                                                          Martin Siegert, Bristol Glaciology Centre,
                                                                                                       Bayliss, Dave Bennett, Alan Beu, Colin Bull,
                                                                                                                                                          School of Geographical Sciences,
                                                                                                       Roger Cooper, Walter Cousins, Ray Dibble,          University of Bristol, UK
                                                                                                       Robin & Feriel Falconer, Isobel Gabites, John      20 July 2006
                                                                                                       Gamble, Graham Gibson, George Grindley,            The Ice Chronicles and
                                                                                                       Michael Hambrey, Monica Handler & Richard          Rapid Climate Change
                                                                                                       Wysoczanski, Mike & June Hannah, David             Paul Mayewski, Climate Change Institute,
                                                                                                                                                          University of Maine, USA
                                                                                                       Hatfield, Jan & Arnold Heine, John Hickman,        26 March 2007
                                                                                                       Chris Horne, David Kelly, Jim & Diana Kennett,

Victoria University of Wellington Antarctic Expeditions: The First 50 Years                                                                                                                             3
The First 50 Years of Victoria University of Wellington Antarctic Expeditions
Reunion Programme
                                    SATURDAY 30 JUNE                                                                                    SUNDAY 1 JULY
                                        2 - 4pm:                                                                                    10am - 12.30pm:
                             Meet and mingle, set up displays                                                                 Recollections & reminiscences
                             Location: Cotton Building, Room 217                                                               Location: Cotton Building, Room 217
                  Registration & payment, set up memorabilia and slide shows                            Presentation of recent and current work, Presentations by past VUWAE participants
                                  Afternoon tea available from 2pm                                                                Coffee/tea available from 9am

                                                                                                                  10am            Welcome and overview
                                             6pm - late:
                                                                                                                                  Peter Barrett (Antarctic Research Centre Director)
                                       Celebration dinner                                                                         and Tim Naish (ARC Deputy Director)
                   Location: VUW Staff Club, Rankin Brown (Library) Building                                      10.30am         Tony Allen & Graham Gibson (VUWAE 3: 1959-60)
                     Drinks & nibbles from 6-7pm, followed by buffet dinner                                       10.50am         MORNING TEA
                After-dinner talk by Richard Barwick, Colin Bull, Barrie McKelvey                                 11.20am         Vince Neall (VUWAE 11: 1966-67)
                                 and Peter Webb (VUWAE 1 & 2)                                                     11.40am         Chris Christoffel (VUWAE 11: 1966-67)
                   Response by Julia Bull and Rod Boys (VUWAE 51: 2006-07)                                        12.00pm         tba

                                                      Lower Victoria Valley looking towards Lake Vida                            12.30 - 1.30pm:
                                                                                                                         LUNCH & displays of current research
                                                                                                            Location: Antarctic Research Centre (Cotton Building, Rooms 505 & 508)

                                                                                                                                       1.30 - 4pm:
                                                                                                                              Recollections & reminiscences
                                                                                                                               Location: Cotton Building, Room 217
                                                                                                                            Presentations by past VUWAE participants

                                                                                                                  1:30pm          Barry Kohn (VUWAE 13: 1968-69)
                                                                                                                  1.50pm          Rosie Askin (VUWAE 15: 1970-71)
                                                                                                                  2.10pm          Tim Stern (VUWAE 21: 1976-77)
                                                                                                                  2.30pm          AFTERNOON TEA
                                                                                                                  3pm             Ian Wright (VUWAE 24: 1979-80)
                                                                                                                  3.20pm          Cliff Atkins (VUWAE 42: 1997-98)
                                                                                                                  3.40pm          VUWAE 1 & 2
                                                                                                                  4pm             Farewell & close

Victoria University of Wellington Antarctic Expeditions: The First 50 Years                                                                                                                 5
The First 50 Years of Victoria University of Wellington Antarctic Expeditions
Reunion Participants
Allen, Tony                         Bannister, Stephen                    Boys, Rod                           Cody, Rosie                         Dickinson, Warren                   Gibson, Graham
1959-60                             1980-81                               2006-07                             Antarctic Research Centre           VUWAE 38, 41, 42, 43, 44, 46, 47    VUWAE 3 (1959-60)
loisc@iinet.net.au                  s.bannister@gns.cri.nz                School of Geography,                Victoria University of Wellington   Warren.Dickinson@vuw.ac.nz          grahamgi@paradise.net.nz
Perth, AUSTRALIA                    GNS Science                           Environment & Earth Sciences        PO Box 600                          Antarctic Research Centre           36 Legacy Drive
                                    PO Box 30368                          Victoria University of Wellington   Wellington NZ                       Victoria University of Wellington   Henderson
Anderson, Jo                        Lower Hutt NZ                         PO Box 600                                                              PO Box 600                          Waitakere City, 0612 NZ
1997-98, 1998-99, 1999-2000                                               Wellington NZ                       Cole, Jim                           Wellington NZ
Wellington, NZ                      Barrett, Peter                                                            1964-65 (VUWAE 9)                                                       Hannah, Mike
                                    22 seasons between                    Bull, Colin                         Jim.Cole@canterbury.ac.nz           Dunbar, Gavin                       1997-98, 1998-99, 2006-07
Arnot, Malcolm                      70/71 and 02/03                       VUWAE 2 (1958-59) and               Dept of Geological Sciences         Gavin.Dunbar@vuw.ac.nz              Michael.Hannah@vuw.ac.nz
1989-90, 1990-91                    Peter.Barrett@vuw.ac.nz               4 (1960-61)                         University of Canterbury            Antarctic Research Centre           School of Geography,
m.arnot@gns.cri.nz                  10 Hanson St                          CBULL61328@earthlink.net            Private Bag 4800                    Victoria University of Wellington   Environment & Earth Sciences
GNS Science                         Wellington, 6121 NZ                   12818 Sunrise Drive                 Christchurch NZ                     PO Box 600                          Victoria University of
PO Box 30368                                                              Bainbridge Island                                                       Wellington NZ                       Wellington
Lower Hutt NZ                       Barwick, Richard                      Washington, 98110m USA                                                                                      PO Box 600
                                                                                                              Cooper, Roger
                                    VUWAE I (whilst attached to                                                                                   Falconer, Robin                     Wellington NZ
                                                                                                              1960-61
Ashby, Jeff                         NZTAE 1956-58) and VUWAE II           Carter, John                        r.cooper@gns.cri.nz                 Physics expeditions in
1984-85, 1986-87                                                                                                                                  1965-66, 66-67, 67-68, 68-69        Hansaraj, Dhiresh
                                    Richard.Barwick@anu.edu.au            1992-93                             GNS Science
Jeff@websterdrilling.com                                                                                                                          r.falconer@gns.cri.nz               2005-06, 2006-07
                                    45 Waite St                           John.Carter@vuw.ac.nz               PO Box 30368
Webster Drilling                                                                                                                                  GNS Science                         Dhiresh.Hansaraj@vuw.ac.nz
                                    Farrer, ACT 2607 AUSTRALIA            School of Geography,                Lower Hutt NZ
& Exploration Ltd                                                                                                                                 PO Box 30368                        Antarctic Research Centre
                                                                          Environment & Earth Sciences
PO Box 50-354                                                                                                                                     Lower Hutt NZ                       Victoria University of Wellington
                                    Bertler, Nancy                        Victoria University of Wellington   Crossland, Lisa                                                         PO Box 600
Wellington NZ                       1999-2000, 2000-01,                   PO Box 600                          Attending for Ken Woolfe
                                                                                                                                                  Falconer, Tamsin                    Wellington NZ
                                    2001-02, 2003-04, 2004-05,            Wellington NZ                       Lisa.Crossland@jcu.edu.au
Askin, Rosie                        2005-06, 2006-07                                                          School of Medicine                  2005-06, 2006-07
                                                                                                                                                                                      Haskell, Tom
VUWAE 15 (70/71), 16 (71/72)        Nancy.Bertler@vuw.ac.nz,              Carter, Lionel                                                          Tamsin.Falconer@vuw.ac.nz
                                                                                                              James Cook University                                                   1962-63 (VUWAE 6)
& 18 (73/74)                        Antarctic Research Centre             2002-03, 2005-06, 2006-07                                               Antarctic Research Centre
                                                                                                              Townsville, QLD 4811                                                    haskellsgeos@xtra.co.nz
askin@bresnan.net                   Victoria University of Wellington     Lionel.Carter@vuw.ac.nz                                                 Victoria University of Wellington
                                                                                                              AUSTRALIA                                                               60 Waterfall Rd
1930 Bunkhouse Dr                   PO Box 600                            Antarctic Research Centre                                               PO Box 600
                                                                                                                                                                                      Raumati South NZ
Jackson, WY 83001 USA               Wellington NZ                         Victoria University of Wellington                                       Wellington NZ
                                                                                                              Dibble, Ray
                                                                          PO Box 600                          1974-75, 78-79, 80-81, 82-83,                                           Hunt, Trevor
Atkins, Cliff                       Brown, Colin                          Wellington NZ                                                           Frost, Andy                         1972-1973 (VUWAE 17)
                                                                                                              86-87, 87-88, 88-89, 89-90
1997-98, 1998-99, 1999-             1974-75                                                                                                       1976-77                             rainbow@reap.org.nz
                                                                                                              r.dibble@actrix.co.nz
2000, 2002-03, 2006-07                                                                                                                            andy.frost@pernod-ricard-nz.com     41 Rainbow Drive
                                    cbrown@metservice.com                 Christoffel, David (Chris)          81 Oriel Ave
Cliff.Atkins@vuw.ac.nz              17 Herewini St                                                                                                99 Maxwell Rd                       Taupo NZ
                                                                          1966-67, 1974-75, 1978-79,          Tawa
2 Shannon St                        Titahi Bay NZ                                                                                                 Blenheim NZ
                                                                          1980-81, 1994-95                    Wellington, 5028 NZ
Mt Victoria
                                                                          Chris.Christoffel@clear.net.nz                                                                              Jackson, Nick
Wellington NZ
                                                                          98 Waerenga Rd
                                                                                                                                                  Gabites, Isobel                     1998-99
                                                                                                                                                  1982-83                             nick@irba.co.nz
                                                                          Otaki 5512 NZ
Balham, David                                                                                                                                     igabites@xtra.co.nz                 72 Buckley Rd
Ron Balham's Son                                                                                                                                  115 Kaitawa Rd                      Island Bay
davidbalham@hotmail.com                                                                                                                           RD1, Otaki NZ                       Wellington NZ

Victoria University of Wellington Antarctic Expeditions: The First 50 Years                                                                                                                                           7
The First 50 Years of Victoria University of Wellington Antarctic Expeditions
Kellett, Richard                     McKay, Rob                            Neall, Vince                        Ross, Alan                      Trummel, Betty                     Wood, Matt
1984-85                              1998-99, 2005-06, 2006-07             1966-67, 1969-70                    1979-80                         boop82@aol.com                     2003-04
richard.kellett@pxd.com              Robert.McKay@vuw.ac.nz                V.E.Neall@massey.ac.nz              dallross@netaccess.co.nz        7513 Inverway                      School of Geography,
Pioneer Natural Resources            Antarctic Research Centre             Institute of Natural Resources      102 Ellis Street                Crystal Lake, IL 60014 USA         Environment & Earth Sciences
Canada                               Victoria University of Wellington     Massey University                   Brightwater                                                        Victoria University of Wellington
2900, 255-5th Ave SW                 PO Box 600                            Private Bag 11 222                  Nelson, 7022 NZ                 Ward, Barbara                      PO Box 600
Calgary, Alberta CANADA              Wellington NZ                         Palmerston North NZ                                                 1980-81, 1981-82, 1984-85,         Wellington NZ
                                                                                                               Shirtcliffe, Tim                1987-88
Keys, Harry                          McKelvey, Barrie                      Palmer, Alan                        1962-63                         Pyne.Ward@xtra.co.nz               Wright, Ian
1972-73, 1973-74, 1974-75,           VUWAE 1, 2, 13, 24                    1975-76 and 1976-77                 Tim.Shirtcliffe@xtra.co.nz      30 Kaihuia St                      1979-80, 1984-85
1976-77 plus years to 1981           bmckelve@mail.une.edu.au              A.S.Palmer@massey.ac.nz             46 Upper Watt St                Northland                          ibwright@paradise.net.nz
fire.ice@xtra.co.nz                  Earth Sciences                        Soil and Earth Sciences             Wellington, 6012 NZ             Wellington, 6012 NZ                13 Scapa Tce
10 Waihora St                        School of Environmental               Massey University                                                                                      Karori
Taupo NZ                             Sciences & Natural Resources          Private Bag 11 222                  Smith, Gilbert                  Webb, Peter                        Wellington NZ
                                     Management                            Palmerston North NZ                 VUWAE 6 (1962-63)               1957-58, 1958-59, 1968-69
Kohn, Barry                          University of New England                                                 gilbert.smith@clear.net.nz      webb.3@osu.edu                     Wysoczanski, Richard
1968-69 and 1970-71                  Armidale, NSW 2351                    Paterson, Matt                      PO Box 173                      School of Earth Sciences           1991-92
b.kohn@unimelb.edu.au                AUSTRALIA                             1998-99 Wellington, NZ              Bay View 4149                   The Ohio State University          Richard.Wysoczanski@vuw.ac.nz
School of Earth Sciences                                                                                       Hawkes Bay NZ                   125 South Oval Mall                School of Geography,
University of Melbourne              McPherson, John                       Plume, Russell                                                      Columbus, Ohio 43210 USA           Environment & Earth Sciences
Melbourne                            1970-71, 1973-74                      1973-74                             Smith, Ian                                                         Victoria University of Wellington
Victoria, 3010 AUSTRALIA             john.mcpherson@exxonmobil.com         Plimmerton                          1965-66 and 1966-67                                                PO Box 600
                                     ExxonMobil Exploration                Wellington NZ                       (VUWAE 9 and 10)                                                   Wellington NZ
Kyle, Philip                         Company                                                                   ie.smith@auckland.ac.nz
VUWAE 14 (1969-70), 16               12 Riverside Quay                     Prebble, Joe                        Geology - School of               1974 Erebus expedition: from top right: Tazieff 5th, Kyle 7th,
(1971-72), 17 (1972-73), 18          Melbourne, VIC 3006                   joseph_prebble@URSCorp.com          Geography, Geology and                  Dibble 2nd; Bottom near placard: left, Shaun Norman
(1973-74) and 19 (1974-75)           AUSTRALIA                             17 Mahina Road                      Environmental Sciences                (NZ leader), above Le Guern, right Werner Giggenbach
kyle@nmt.edu                                                               Lower Hutt                          University of Auckland
Dept of Earth &                      Naish, Tim                            Wellington NZ                       PB92019
Environmental Science                2005-06, 2006-07                                                          Auckland Mail Centre, 1142 NZ
New Mexico Institute of              t.naish@gns.cri.nz                    Pyne, Alex
Mining and Technology                Antarctic Research Centre             1977-78 continuously to 2006-07     Stern, Tim
Socorro, NM 87801 USA                Victoria University of Wellington     Alex.Pyne@vuw.ac.nz                 1976-77
                                     PO Box 600                            Antarctic Research Centre           Tim.Stern@vuw.ac.nz
Mackay, Kevin                        Wellington NZ                         Victoria University of Wellington   School of Geography,
1988-89                                                                    PO Box 600                          Environment & Earth
k.mackay@niwa.co.nz                                                        Wellington NZ                       Sciences
NIWA                                                                                                           Victoria University of
Private Bag 14901                                                                                              Wellington
Kilbirnie                                                                                                      PO Box 600
Wellington NZ                                                                                                  Wellington NZ

  Victoria University of Wellington Antarctic Expeditions: The First 50 Years                                                                                                                                     9
The First 50 Years of Victoria University of Wellington Antarctic Expeditions
The Birth of VUWAE
                                                                              By Trevor Hatherton,
                                                     reprint from Tuatara, Journal of the Biological Society,        “Exploration is the Physical Expression
                                                                                                                             of the Intellectual Passion ”
                                                Victoria University of Wellington, Vol.15 (1967), pp100-102.

On December 30, 1957 I drove a tractor                 Webb and McKelvey the original students are
across the sea ice from Scott Base to meet             10 years older now, and approaching the peak                                                                         —Apsley Cherry-Garrard
H.M.N.Z.S. 'Endeavour', preparing to tie up            years of their professional life, no longer
about 9 miles from the base. I was naturally           students, though they can't convince me of               as it must in the New Zealand Antarctic           And what of the future? Every young man's
keen to begin unloading the ship and to meet           that. The success of their work and the                  Programme, the number of fields of enquiry        first expedition is an adventure so there
the members of the incoming party. After               subsequent VUWAE expeditions have been                   can only be increased at the cost of a loss in    should be no slackening in the attraction of
being introduced to the new party I noticed a          based on two things-their personal attributes            intensity in each field. At other times it        Antarctica. Scientifically, the problems are
couple of rangy youths to whom I had not               and the persistent character of R. H. Clark,             seemed that too many staff were spending too      even more interesting now that enough data
been introduced, and who were obviously not            Professor of Geology. If an unfavourable                 short a time down there, but this is probably a   has been gathered, enough ideas formulated,
members of either the wintering party or the           impression had been left by Webb and                     product of this fragmentation. However, I feel,   to allow the synthesis which is the art of
ship's crew. 'Who are these two young - - - -?'        McKelvey during that hectic summer of 1957-8             if possible, that University Expeditions should   science, and the testing of the model which is
I said. 'Them-oh they're university students',         subsequent Victoria University expeditions               consist of senior students left to their own      the science of science. We are no longer
says Lyn Martin the incoming leader, and               would have been hard to launch. As it was,               devices once the problem has been outlined        'stamp collecting' in Antarctica, and there
then seeing the look in my eyes hastily                their demeanour was exemplary. No scientific             by staff in consultation with the students. The   must be an exciting future there.
followed up with-'now-don't blame me'.                 studies are of any use until published, and as           ability to sustain a scientifically productive
                                                       prompt publication of research is insisted               season in the Ross Dependency unaided is a        But for the present, to the pioneers Webb
There they were, the first two of them,                                                                         tremendous test of self-reliance as well as of    and McKelvey, to the succeeding teams, and
                                                       upon by Professor Clark the first VUWAE Dry
uninvited, unheralded and unwanted. With a                                                                      research capacity. Admittedly some will drown     to the general, Professor Clark, I offer my
                                                       Valleys papers were among the earliest
limited base staff, unlimited American                                                                          through being thown into the deep-end, but        congratulations on a remarkably long-
                                                       substantial contributions to the records of
visitors, Hillary 'hell-bent for the pole' and                                                                  the list of those who have emerged with great     sustained endeavour in exploration
                                                       New Zealand's research effort in Antarctica.
four other parties in the field, unloading and                                                                  credit from VUWAE expeditions is impressive.      and research.
                                                       The first favourable impression, dependent
changeover problems and the possibility of
                                                       upon the attitude of Webb and McKelvey,
Bunny Fuchs and party having to winter over
                                                       backed by prompt publication, the fruit of
at Scott Base, neither I nor anyone else was
                                                       departmental (i.e. professorial) policy, was a
enthusiastic about supernumaries without
                                                       combination not to be denied. VUWAE
any place in the long prepared plans.
                                                       became established.
Somehow, and I have no clear recollection of
how they achieved it, these two students               Since 1957, ten other expeditions have gone
'infiltrated' a couple of non-geological parties       and come. Some didn't earn unqualified
intending to study the lakes of the so-called          approval from me for I thought their aims
dry valleys. As a result of their work during          fragmented, but the later expeditions have
the next few weeks the dry valleys became              had to investigate the ever-increasing
Dry Valleys, and during the next few years             number of problems that has arisen from the                Nansen, Tamworth
                                                       early surveys. Simple logic tells us that if the         and manhaul sledges
probably the most intensively studied parts
                                                                                                                at Scott Base ca.1995
of the Antarctic Continent.                            number of man-months of work has a limit,

Victoria University of Wellington Antarctic Expeditions: The First 50 Years                                                                                                                                  11
The First 50 Years of Victoria University of Wellington Antarctic Expeditions
Members of VUWAE: 1957-2007
VUWAE 1 - 1957/58                                                                                      Gorton, M.           Adams, J. E.         Palmer, A.
McKelvey, B. C.                                                                                        Murrell, B.          Shorland, J.         Anderson, J.
Webb, P. N.                                                                                            Cousins, W. J.                            Frost, A.
                                                                                                       Blong, R.            VUWAE 18 - 1973/74   Robinson, P.
VUWAE 2 - 1958/59                                                                                                           Crump, J. M.         Keys, J. R.
Bull. C. B. B.                                                                                         VUWAE 14 - 1969/70   Kyle, R. A.          Stern, T.
Barwick, R.                                                                                            Neall, V. E.         McPherson, J. G.     Nankervis, J.
McKelvey, B. C.                                                                                        Vucetich, C. G.      Plume, R. W.         Palmer, J.
Webb, P. N.                                                                                            Kyle, P. R.          Rowe, G. H.          Wicks, B.
Bull, C. B. B.                                                                                         Topping, W. W.       Blackwood, K.
*Clark, R. H.                                                                                                               Kyle, P. R.          VUWAE 22 - 1977/78
                                                                                                       VUWAE 15 - 1970/71   Keys, J. R.          McKelvey, B.
VUWAE 3 - 1959/60                                                                                      Barrett, P. J.       Luckman, P.          Pyne, A.
Balham, R. W.                                                        VUWAE8, Photo: Bruce Popplewell   Kohn, B. P.          Cooper, R.           Johnston, J. H.
*Wheeler, R. H.                                                                                        Grapes, R. H.                             Logan, N.
Allen, A. D.                         VUWAE 7 - 1962/63                    VUWAE 10 - 1965/66           Askin, R.A.          VUWAE 19 - 1974/75   Metson, J.
Gibson, G.                           Shirtcliffe, T.                      Ghent, E.                    McPherson, J. G.     Plume, R. W.         Robinson, P. H.
Willis, I. A. G.                     Benseman, R. F.                      Henderson, R. A.             Reid, D.             Saxby, E.            Hull, A.
                                     Popplewell, K. B.                    Hancox, G.                   Ritchie, A.          Keys, J. R.          Fowlie, W.
VUWAE 4 - 1960/61                                                         Smith, I.                    Young, G.            Kyle, P. R.          Nalder, N.
Wheeler, R. H.                       VUWAE 8 -1963/64                                                                       Dibble, R.
Blank, H. R.                         Prebble, W.                          VUWAE 11 - 1966/67           VUWAE 16 - 1971/72   Barrett, P. J.       VUWAE 23 - 1978/79
Bull, C. B. B.                       Wilson, A. T.                        *Wellman, H. W.              Laird, M. G.         Powell, R. W.        Christoffel, D. A.
Cooper, R.                           *Wellman, H. W.                      Christoffel, D. A.           Andrews, P. B.       Stevens, J.          Mroczek, C. R.
Willis, I. A. G.                     Henderson, R. A.                     Calheim, I. M.               Kyle, P. R.          Rainsbury, R.        Garden, P.
                                     Hoare, R.                            Duncan, A.                   Jennings, P.         Vucetich, C. G.      Pyne, A.
VUWAE 5 - 1961/62                    House, D. A.                         Neall, V.                    Barrett, P. J.       Robinson, P.         Dibble, R.
Wellman, H. W.                       Popplewell, K. B.                    Smith, I.                    Askin, R. A.         Christoffel, D. A.   Giggenbach, W.
Wilson, A. T.                                                                                          Bright, D.           Northey, D.          Tazieff, H.
*Clark, R. H.                        VUWAE 9 - 1964/65                    VUWAE 12 - 1967/68           Chinn, A.            Brown, C.            Fink, C.
*Wheeler, R. H.                      Prebble, W.                          *Wellman, H. W.              Bamford, D.                               Monteath, C.
                                     Vella, P. P.                         Vucetich, C.                                                           Barrett, P. J.
VUWAE 6 - 1962/63                    Cole, J.                             Wright, A.                   VUWAE 17 - 1972/73   VUWAE 20 - 1975/76   Robinson, P. H.
Willis, I. A. G.                     Ewart, A.                            Wilson, A. T.                Freeman, A.          Collen, J. D. C.     Bentley, P. N.
Rich, C. C.                          Frame, A.                            Hendy, C.                    Keys, J. R.          Eggers, A.           Pyne, A.
Haskell, T.                          Hoare, R.                            Calheim, I.                  Crump, J.            Barrett, P. J.       *Ross, S.
Kennett, J.                          Bradley, J.                          Cousins, W. J.               Allis, R.            Sillars, K. J.       Burgess, C.
Smith, G. J.                         Palmer, D.                                                        Hunt, T. M.          Palmer, A.           Anderson, J.
Prebble, W.                          Schafer, F.                          VUWAE 13 - 1968/69           Blackwood, K.        Robinson, P. H.      Keys, H.
                                     Zimmerman, D.                        Webb, P. N.                  Kyle, P. R.                               Cashman, K.
                                     Baker, A.                            McKelvey, B. C.              Cole, J. W.          VUWAE 21 - 1976/77   Höfle
                                     Bell, R.                             Kohn, B. P.                                       Burgess, C. J.       Grund

 Victoria University of Wellington Antarctic Expeditions: The First 50 Years                                                                                          13
The First 50 Years of Victoria University of Wellington Antarctic Expeditions
VUWAE 24 - 1979/80                  McKelvey, B.                         Pyne, A.             VUWAE 31 - 1986/87
Barrett, P. J.                      Walker, B.                           Barrett, P. J.       Falkner, K.
Pyne, A.                            Dibble, R.                           Macpherson, A. J.    Barrett, P. J.
Froggatt, P. C.                     Otway, P.                            Curry, P.            Pyne, A.
Sissons, B. A.                      Craddock, N.                         Watson, J.           Hall, K.
Waghorn, D. B.                      Kyle, P.                             Fitzgerald, P.       Chambray, M.
Ross, A.                            McIntosh, W.                         Webster, M.          Robinson, P.
Walker, B.                          Estes, S.                                                 Reick, H.
Wright, I.                          Marshall, D.                         VUWAE 29 - 1984/85   Wada, H.
White, P.                           Shibuya, K.                          Barrett, P.          Ashby, J.
McPherson, A.                       Terai, K.                            Pyne, A.             Hardy, E.
Williams, F.                        Okyama, M.                           Ashby, J.            Mills, C.
                                                                                                                                    Members of VUWAE 29 preparing for a GPR
McKelvey, B.                        Pyne, A.                             Macpherson, A.       Morris, B.
                                                                                                                                               traverse on the Campbell Glacier
Brady, H.                           Ward, B.                             Pillans, B.          Belgrave, V.
Fink, C.                            Barrett, P. J.                       Ward, B.             White, P.
                                    Alloway, B.                          Wright, I.           Davy, B.             McConchie, J.                   Atkinson, B.
VUWAE 25 - 1980/81                  Catterly, M.                         Neale, G.            Alder, G.            Winchester, D.                  Griffiths, C.
Reid, F.                            Gleadow, A.                          Haanen, A.           Pyne, A.             Dawson, P.
Simmons, S.                         Fitzgerald, P.                       Komura, K.           Alder, G.            Wilson, G.                      VUWAE 35 - 1990/91
Christoffel, D. A.                  Main, L.                             Olsen, J.            Dibble, R.           Pyne, A.                        Woolfe, J.
Iles, D.                                                                 Kellett, R.          Barrett, S.          Perrett, T.                     Arnot, M.
Bannister, S.                       VUWAE 27 - 1982/83                   Korsch, R.                                Sole, P.                        Barrett, P.
Dibble, R.                          Walker, B. A.                        George, A.           VUWAE 32 - 1987/88                                   Francis, J.
Kyle, P.                            Gabites, H. I.                       Gamble, J.           Dibble, R.           VUWAE 34 - 1989/90              Smith, N.
McIntosh, W.                        Hosted, M.                           Vincent, S.          Ball, T.             *Woolfe, K.                     Pyne, A.
Estes, S.                           Korsch, R.                           Belgrave, V.         Ellis, S.            Arnot, M.                       Dibble, R.
Kienle, J.                          Napp, B.                             Fitzgerald, P.       Lassky, S.           Zwartz, D.                      Beaglehole, D.
Osada, N.                           Dibble, R.                           Patterson,           Pyne, A.             Dibble, R.                      Carter, G.
Takanami, T.                        Paintin, I.                                               Ward, B.             O'Brien, B.                     Ryan, K.
Terai, K.                           Pyne, A.                             VUWAE 30 - 1985/86   Armstrong, B.        Shimizu, H.                     Exley, R.
Pyne, A.                            Barrett, P. J.                       K Palmer             Shane, P.            Pyne, A.                        Gamble, J.
Ward, B.                            Macpherson, A. J.                    P White              Blake, G.            Goodwin, I.
Fitzgerald, P.                      McLeod, M.                           Pyne, A.             Zurita, F.           Moller, P.                      VUWAE 36 - 1991/92
Garrick, B.                         Bell, L.                             Kelly, D.            Faloon, G.           McConchie, J.                   Pyne, A.
Fink, C.                            McLeod, M.                           Macpherson, A.       Anderson, B.         Winchester, D.                  Broughton, E.
Neale, G.                           Tinnely                              Dawkings, R.                              Hawke, R.                       Powell, R.
Mortimer, N.                        Hawke                                Fitzgerald, P.       VUWAE 33 - 1988/89   Campbell, H.                    Heaphy, S.
                                                                         *Woolfe, K.          *Woolfe, K.          Trodahl, J.                     Statham, D.
VUWAE 26 - 1981/82                  VUWAE 28 - 1983/84                                        Henare, J.           Riches, S.                      Falloon, G.
Barrett, P. J.                      Falkner, C.                                               Gillespie, G.        Gamble, J.                      Gamble, J.
Fitzgerald, P.                      Boteler, D.                                               Dibble, R.           Teeling, T.                     Brooker, J.
Walker, B.                          Welink, R.                                                Mackay, K.           Smellie, J.                     Wysoczanski, R.

Victoria University of Wellington Antarctic Expeditions: The First 50 Years                                                                                                   15
The First 50 Years of Victoria University of Wellington Antarctic Expeditions
VUWAE 37 - 1992/93                  Webb, P.                             Dickinson, Warren
Pyne, A.                            Dickinson, W.                        Holme, Phil
Anderson B.                         Goff, J.                             Hiemstra, John
Carter, J.                          Jennings, I.                         Mitchell, Jeremy
Gee, E.                             Cooper, P.                           Van der Meer, Jaap
Rennie, A.                          Devries, J.                          Hicock, Steve
Grube, P.                           Webster, B.                          Lloyd Davies, Mark
Trodahl, J.                                                              Prebble, Joe
Buckley, R.                         VUWAE 42 - 1997/98
Beaglehole, D.                      Barrett, P.                          VUWAE 45- 2000/2001
Henrys, S.                          Pyne, A.                             Pyne, Alex
Pyne, A.                            Anderson, Jo.                        Dickinson, Warren
Gamble, J.                          Atkins, C.                           Kingan, Tony
                                    Hannah, M.                           Cooper, Pat
VUWAE 38 - 1993/94                  Butler, E.                           Kingan, Glen
Wizevich, M.                        Lambeck, A.                          Pollard, Wayne
Thornley, S.                        Quinn, Julie.                        Hickock, Steve                                                      Members of VUWAE 29 at Campbell Glacier
*Woolfe, K.                         Bowman, Vanessa.                     Hose, Chris
Pyne, A.                            Schlüchter, C.                       Holme, Phil            Barrett, Peter           VUWAE 49 - 2004/05              Sletten, Ron
Rennie, A.                          Tcernio, S.                          Bornholdt, Carl        Dunbar, Gavin            Bayliss, Dan                    Williams, Gretchen
Singh, L.                                                                Bertler, Nancy         Robinson, Natalie        Bertler, Nancy
Leslie, R.                          VUWAE 43 - 1998/99                   Ayling, Bridget        Mason, Dougal            Cavanagh, Mike                  VUWAE 51 - 2006/07
Hackney, R.                         Barrett, P.                          Hendrikx, Jordy        Leitch, Johno            Kipfstuhl, Sepp                 Atkins, Cliff
                                    Butler, E.                                                  Niessen, Frank           Kingan, Tony                    Barrett, Peter
VUWAE 39 - 1994/95                  Anderson, J.                         VUWAE 46 - 2001/2002   Nixdorf, Uwe             Pyne, Alex                      Carroll, Dene
Christoffel, D.                     Atkins, C.                           Pyne, Alex             Dunker, Eric             Dickinson, Warren               Carter, Lionel
Wooler, A.                          Jackson, N.                          Balfour, Natalie       Pringle, Daniel          Hyland, Leigh                   Dunbar, Gavin
Bleakley, N.                        Pyne, A.                             Horgan, Huw            Trodahl, Joe             Mackintosh, Andrew              Falconer, Tamsin
Pyne, A.                            Patterson, M.                        Henderson, Ricky       Carter, Lionel           Zwartz, Dan                     Hannah, Mike
Anderson B.                         McKay, R.                            Bertler, Nancy         Riesselmann, Christina                                   Hansaraj, Dhiresh
Hackney, R.                         Hannah, M.                           Patterson, Nora        Giorgetti, Giovanna      VUWAE 50 - 2005/06              McKay, Rob
Quinn, J.                           Hiemstra, J.                         Hill, Matt                                      Carter, Lionel                  Naish, Tim
Haver, A.                           Van der Meer, J.                     Dickinson, Warren      VUWAE 48 - 2003/04       Dunbar, Gavin                   Pyne, Alex
                                                                         Tammick, Sarah         Bertler, Nancy           Falconer, Tamsin                Bertler, Nancy
VUWAE 40 - 1995/96                  VUWAE 44 - 1999/2000                 Hopkins, Karyn         Christie, Louise         Hansaraj, Dhiresh               Boys, Rod
Pyne, A.                            Anderson, Jo                                                Pyne, Alex               McKay, Rob                      Bull, Julia
                                    Atkins, Cliff                        VUWAE 47 - 2002/2003   Watson, Matt             Naish, Tim                      Kingan, Glen
VUWAE 41 - 1996/97                  Barrett, Peter                       Pyne, Alex             Wood, Matt               Pyne, Alex                      Kipfstuhl, Sepp
Pyne, A.                            Hannah, Mike                         Atkins, Cliff                                   Bertler, Nancy                  Robinson, Davie
Shulmeister, J.                     Jackson, Nick                        Dickinson, Warren                               Dickinson, Warren               Watson, Matt
Butler, E.                          Pyne, Alex                           Colebatch, Camilla                              Schiller, Martin
Quinn, J.                           Bertler, Nancy                       Wilson, Nicola                                                                  *Deceased

Victoria University of Wellington Antarctic Expeditions: The First 50 Years                                                                                                      17
Recollections of the first 50 Years
                                                                                                        my little tent still standing at the west end of   voice and CW we struggled to send. It was a
A 50 year trip with                                                                                     Lake Vanda. There they ate the meal I had left     wonderful experience. We never dreamed it
Barrie and Peter                                                                                        for them, stewed steak and vegetables, and         would continue for another 47 years…and more!
When Barrie McKelvey and Peter                                                                          then tinned pineapple. They rested for an hour
Webb stepped on board the                                                                               or two, and then sledged back across the lake
HMNZS Endeavour they had no                                                                             to Main Base, with their specimens. Barrie
                                                                                                        asked us to excuse the smoke coming from his
                                                                                                                                                           VUWAE 3 (1959/60) Tony Allen
idea of the legacy that was to
follow them. In 50 years since,                                                                         armpits. While they waited for the meal I was      The purpose of our 67 day expedition into the
much has changed but much has                                                                           cooking for them, they had a little snack,         Victoria Valley area was to extend the work of
remained. For most of us, our first                                                                     which started with 10 Weetabix each and 3/4        VUWAE 1 and 2 in geological mapping,
trip to Antarctica was a 'life                                                                          of a 2-pound tin of golden syrup between           surveying, palaeomagnetic sampling and
changing' experience, but each of                                                                       them. Well, one Weetabix makes a rather            biology. The expedition team comprised staff
us was infected in unique ways.                                                                         skimpy breakfast, but two of them are enough       and students from Victoria University: Ron
Antarctica has changed little in 50                                                                     for most folk. Dick and I watched open-            Balham (leader), Ralph Wheeler, Graham
years and still doggedly guards her                                                                     mouthed, with admiration and astonishment,         Gibson, Ian Willis, and Tony Allen. We formed
scientific secrets like never before.                                                                   as they demolished the lot. And then they had      an enquiring, happy team.
To some it may seem that the Dry                                                                        dinner! But it really was a remarkable walk!
                                                                                                        And, come to that, they also showed a totally      The work achieved by the expedition was
Valleys have been 'done to death',                       Peter Webb (left) and Barrie McKelvey
                                                                                                        commensurate ability to eat.                       mainly by field traverses from a base camp at
yet no where else is it so obvious that                                       (Photo: M.D.King)
                                                                                                                                                           Lake Vashka (Barwick Valley) and from three
the more we learn, the less we know.
                                                                                                        Well, John Glenn, first US earth circler, went     satellite food dumps near Lake Vida,
In Antarctica we no longer map and survey to learn what is there, but we now collect and analyse
                                                                                                        back with a very much later space mission. In      Apocalypse Peak, and Miller Glacier area,
micro samples to answer global questions. We are overjoyed to reflect back along with Barrie
                                                                                                        the same way I am now collecting volunteers        established by a U.S. Navy helicopter. The
and Peter, but we are humbled to realize that some who reflect in the following pages will be
                                                                                                        for a return visit to Wright Valley. Successful    traverses radiated from these areas and
doing so again in 50 years.
                                                          Warren Dickinson and Tamsin Falconer          applicants must be prepared to carry me back       covered an area extending from Purgatory
                                                                                                        up Peak 16, as it was before we named it.          Peak in the east to Mt Bastian in the west and
                                                                                                                                                           for up to 20km to the north and south, an area
                                                                                                                                                           of about 700 sq. km.
VUWAE 2 (1958-59) Colin Bull                           upper depot (on south shoulder of Wright
                                                       Valley, at 5300 feet altitude, near Wright       VUWAE 3 (1959-60) Graham Gibson                    The valleys are 3 to 6km wide and the valley
VUWAE 1 was a marvelous, serendipitous
                                                       Upper Glacier). They walked the 21 miles to      We had a great leader in Ron Balham and all        floors are veneered with glacial moraine,
jaunt by Peter (Webb) and Barrie (McKelvey).
                                                       Main Base in 6 hours and when Dick               worked as a great team. None of our work           glacial outwash deposits, pediments and local
VUWAE 2 was my fourth polar expedition, but
                                                       congratulated them on this achievement,          would have been possible if it had not been for    eolian dunes. They are relatively flat and vary
my first complete university expedition to the
                                                       Barrie explained that it had only been           the fantastic support that we got from the         from smooth to very rough. The valley walls
Antarctic. We can't pretend that we were an
                                                       possible by their choice of rest spots. They     Americans (and also the RNZAF). The Snowcat        were up to 1000m high, very steep and mainly
independent expedition because of the
                                                       only stopped where there was a shallow           accident on 20th November was very sad and         covered with coarse scree. Various small
necessary logistical help, but we did decide
                                                       puddle nearby and Barrie noted that when         sobering for us all, and also the Beaver crash.    glaciers and snowfields occurred in the areas
for ourselves what we wished to do.
                                                       they sat in the puddle there was always a                                                           flanking the valleys.
One day things were getting hectic. The boys           short, sharp sizzle. At Main Base they ate and   We would hope that the begging letters to get
(Barrie and Peter) were near the lower depot           slept for 6 hours and then pressed on to the     supplies have long since gone, and that            The traverses required exhausting physical
at the Wright Lower Glacier but felt that they         upper depot, another very long walk as well      modern technology has eliminated some of the       effort carrying heavy packs. The rough and
must retrieve their rock specimens from the            as a 5300 feet climb, and then back down to      problems with dodgy Skeds and the laboured         steep terrain limited the amount of work
                                                                                                                                                           achieved. Our work was further limited by the

Victoria University of Wellington Antarctic Expeditions: The First 50 Years                                                                                                                             19
developments in Antarctic geology. With a few     surveyor on the team, whilst my task was to
                                                                                                      reservations, I believe we made a small but       collect orientated paleo-mag samples for Colin
                                                                                                      useful contribution to Antarctic geology, as      Bull. The first night we pitched the two-man
                                                                                                      well as providing a link in the chain of VUWAE    pup tent, I offered to make Ralph a drink
                                                                                                      expeditions over the last 50 years.               flavoured with 'lemon crystals' which he
                                                                                                                                                        readily accepted. The drink was made to the
                                                                                                                                                        strength I like and a mug handed to Ralph. A
                                                                                                                                                        few seconds later there was a huge splutter
                                                                                                      VUWAE 3 (1959-60) Ian Willis                      and explosion with Ralph accusing me of
                                                                                                      In traveling to McMurdo on the 'Globemaster',     giving him battery acid. From there on out, I
                                                                                                      which had a huge Caterpillar bulldozer in the     made his as weak as p…..
                                                                                                      hold, we realized we were very much
                                                                                                      secondary cargo. Before take-off one of the       Our main base camp was established at the
                                                                                                      crew members came to demonstrate the use          western end of Victoria Valley with a subsidiary
                                                                                                      of the “survival suit”. His opening phrase was    food dump put in at the eastern end. After a
                                                                                                      “should anything go wrong before the point        brief acclimatization period it was decided to
Ron Balham, Ralph Wheeler, Tony Allen, Graham Gibson and Ian Willis                                   of no return, we will return to ChiChi, after     head east and then work back to base camp.
(left to right) in the Victoria Valley.                                                               that you will be required to put on this          Back-packing was the only means of transport
                                                                                                      survival suit”. Where-upon he proceeded to        and everything we might need was crammed
lack of suitable maps and aerial photographs           passing interest in Antarctic geology.                                                           into our packs (including rather useless items
                                                                                                      show us how to pull on the survival suit,
at appropriate scales for regional or detailed                                                                                                          such as mukluks) and off we set, tramping into
                                                       My participation in VUWAE 3 has formed less    which had a huge tear down one of the legs.
mapping.                                                                                                                                                a “fresh” head wind. After a couple of hours,
                                                       than 2% of my geological career. It has not    At the end of the demonstration he stated, “of
The work achieved was mainly of a                      greatly influenced what I have done but        course, yours will not have a tear in it, but     we could clearly see our objective site and
reconnaissance nature. Many features such              perhaps the seeds of my career in              does it matter? Survival time without a suit is   decided to stop for “lunch”. Mistake number
as stromatolites and other features observed           hydrogeology were sown when I studied frost    about a minute, with it maybe up to five          1, not appreciating the clarity of the
at Lake Vida, glacial geology and                      polygons and saline soils at Lake Vashka.      minutes. If you think we could get a
geomorphology, and the multiple intrusion              During field mapping in Western Australia I    rescue aircraft on site in that time, you                Ian Willis sun bathing in Miers Valley.
and differentiation within the lower dolerite          encountered an older but similar style of      are sadly mistaken. Best of luck”.
sill were noted and sampled but not studied.           geology in the Kimberley region and my
                                                                                                      On our first trip in the chopper over
In hindsight, it would have been very                  Antarctic experience undoubtedly influenced
                                                                                                      the Dry Valleys, my colleagues and I
rewarding to have studied these features               some of my work.
                                                                                                      were all amazed at the sheer grandeur
more closely.
                                                       Despite this, the expedition to and from       of the area. At one point, whilst flying
Following our expedition I did not continue            Antarctica and into the Dry Valleys has been   over one of the remnant glaciers, I
my interest in Antarctic geology. I seriously          one of the unforgettable experiences of my     remarked to the cabin crew member,
broke my leg in a sporting accident and it was         life. I feel privileged to have been amongst   “what a spectacular sight”. He opened
imperative to complete my MSc (the geology             the first to have set foot in the beautiful,   one bleary eye and said, “seen one,
of the Awatere Valley, New Zealand) to obtain          pristine, forbidding environment which we      seen 'em all!”. Where-upon said eye
work. In the latter case I made the very happy         found. It has had a profound effect on my      closed again.
choice of joining the Geological Survey of             views about life and nature. I regret not
                                                                                                      Once we left base camp, I was
Western Australia. As a result I retained only         maintaining contact with team members and
                                                                                                      partnered with Ralph Wheeler, the
limited contact with the team members, and             not keeping up to date with the exciting

Victoria University of Wellington Antarctic Expeditions: The First 50 Years                                                                                                                          21
atmosphere it was many, many more hours                After a comfortable night camped on the             VUWAE 4 (1960-61) Roger Cooper                     just as bold. The Christmas drambuie helped.
before we reached our goal, tired and                  glacier we set off in a straight line for the                                                          So we all ended up splashing about in the near
                                                                                                           On Christmas Day, 1960, Colin Bull, Ian Willis
extremely hungry. Before eating, mistake               peak with me in front “breaking step” in the                                                           freezing water. Ian Willis discovered that the
                                                                                                           and I were camped in the Miers Valley, Koettlitz
number 2 occurred when one of our party                softish snow cover. About five minutes away                                                            dark coloured moraine of the valley side had
                                                                                                           Glacier area. The other two members of our
(who will remain anonymous) decided to have            from our campsite and within a nanosecond                                                              absorbed enough heat from the sun to enable
                                                                                                           expedition (VUWAE 5), Ralph Wheeler and Dick
a pee. Moments later he was rolling on the             of putting my weight on my forward foot, my                                                            sun bathing and he lay there afterwards for
                                                                                                           Blank, had been out geologising for the day.
ground in agony - hot urine through a chilled          brain registered that the snow sagged a bit                                                            about 15 minutes, long enough for us all to get
                                                                                                           They returned to camp excited as puppies.
member - OUCH! (The female field workers               between two semi-parallel lines - you have                                                             photographic evidence. Was this the first
                                                                                                           They had just seen a “wall of water” coming
will no doubt be having a giggle!). After that         probably guessed what I realised that fraction                                                         “swim” in a flowing river in the Ross
                                                                                                           down the otherwise dry Miers Valley stream
we used to stuff one of our leather sledging           too late! A second or so later I was about 10                                                          Dependency? I suspect so. Not many people
                                                                                                           bed. Apparently, an ice dam had melted and
mits inside our fly when there was a head              to 12 ft below the surface on a snow bridge                                                            are that silly.
                                                                                                           melt water from the Miers Glacier was flowing.
wind.                                                  with no direct sunlight, a very limited view
                                                                                                           They had spent half an hour constructing a         In the early VUWAE expeditions, most supplies
                                                       and drop offs of several 10s of feet on each
Another trait of Ralph's was that he could fall                                                            dam across it, from rocks and sand. Being          had to be cadged from importers,
                                                       side (you must remember this was in the pre-
asleep anywhere at any time. To collect an                                                                 dedicated scientists, we all decided to take the   manufacturers and retailers, as funds for this
                                                       metric era!!). Given my initial shock and
orientated sample took about 20 minutes,                                                                   following day, Boxing Day, off and worked on       purpose were strictly limited. For VUWAE 5, a
                                                       expletives (which I won't repeat), my next
and once I had selected a convenient spot,                                                                 the dam. For research purposes, of course.         local tobacco firm supplied us with copious
                                                       thought was “s… our rope is several hours
Ralph would stretch out on the terrain, no                                                                 Then someone decided that we should go for a       quantities of tobacco. We found that it was
                                                       away”. About that moment Ralph's head
matter how rocky and fall asleep. This in itself                                                           swim in the pool of melt water. Once one           rolling tobacco so we took plenty of tobacco
                                                       popped over the topside followed by an
did not bother me, but his snoring was                                                                     person had stripped off his clothes and            papers. Needless to say, this was in the pre-
                                                       expletive and “thank goodness you are OK!”.
something to be believed and many a time I                                                                 jumped in, the rest of us had to prove we were     cancer scare era. Roll-your-own cigarettes
                                                       Small comfort! After a few minutes debate,
was tempted to throw a rock at him.                    during which the intense cold was starting to
                                                       strike, we realized the crevasse was just the       Dick Blank and Ralph Wheeler in the dammed up Miers River.
It is possible that I can claim one of the
                                                       right width to wedge our ice-axes across to
dubious “honours” of a VUWAE member - that
                                                       use as climbing rungs to get out, with Ralph
of being the only one to fall down a crevasse!
                                                       pulling like fury on my arm for that last few
About a week after a particularly physically
                                                       feet. Fate does not recall how we got the
tiring tramp with heavy backpacks from our
                                                       lower ice-axe out but the handles of both
main base camp at the head of Victoria Valley
                                                       were split. Needless to say we got off that
to a subsidiary camp at the seaward end of
                                                       glacier as quickly as possible and kept to
the valley, Ralph Wheeler and I set off to
                                                       visible hard rock for the rest of the trip. Ralph
triangulate a peak on our way back to base
                                                       and I joked about the episode later - his
camp. Given our experience of the outward
                                                       account being something like, “I was about
march we were travelling as light as we
                                                       100 ft behind you, looking down as I trudged
thought possible but decided to shed a few
                                                       along in your footsteps on a nice sunny day
unnecessary articles such as the field radio,
                                                       without a care in the world. Suddenly there
climbing rope, etc as we headed up a valley to
                                                       was a grunt and I looked up but you were
a remnant glacier which would give good
                                                       nowhere to be seen - but, oh s…, there was a
access to the peak chosen as a survey point.
                                                       hole in the snow! Damn (translation of
The diehards had advised that these remnant
                                                       expletive), I was glad to see you when I
glaciers did not have crevasses.
                                                       peered over the edge!!”.

Victoria University of Wellington Antarctic Expeditions: The First 50 Years                                                                                                                               23
turned out to be not too successful in the dry          southern Koettlitz area, draining east from       day to pick them up. This much was clear but
 and cold Antarctic climate. You had to                  Mount Huggins in the Royal Society Range,         then reception deteriorated. The last bit of the
 manipulate the tobacco, roll it in the paper,           the Pipecleaner Glacier. I can't recall what      message was that the rocks were to be “about
 then lick the gum strip and stick it down, with         reason we gave the Geographic Board for the       the size of an ordinary house brick”. However,
 freezing glove-less hands. But more often               name but it would not have been the real          reception failed altogether and we did not
 than not, the tobacco had dried out and just            reason.                                           hear the word, “brick”. We had no idea of
 crumbled to dust inside the paper roll. The                                                               what was wanted and spent some time in
 result was that after you put the cigarette in          In December 1960, about half way through the      amused debate about how to get a collection
 your mouth, but before you could get the                VUWAE 5 expedition to map the Koettlitz           of house-sized rocks into a helicopter. In the
 lighter to it, all the tobacco slid out of the          Glacier area, we were mapping in the plateau      end, we collected up hand specimen-sized
 paper tube and on to the ground. Ever                   country between Miers Valley and the Walcott      examples of Vanda porphyry and other               VUWAE8, Photo: Bruce Popplewell
 resourceful, we found the answer was to wrap            Glacier. We slept in standard, light-weight,      attractive rocks, which were eventually used
 a wad of tobacco in wet toilet paper and keep           alpine “pup” tents as all our gear, food etc.     for decoration of the memorial, built in the
 it in a plastic bag.                                    was back-packed and had to be light. Radio        shape of a polar tent, on top of Mount Vic. The    nasty looking black holes in the fragile snow
                                                         scheds were held regularly twice a week and       memorial was later refurbished with larger,        bridges is still very clear.
 Another item generously supplied free was               although we were only 100 km from Scott           more respectable, “brick-sized” Antarctic
 pipe cleaners. One of the “old hands” had               Base, we were in a “shadow” area. Using                                                              Exploring and mapping these two areas was
                                                                                                           rocks, and can be seen today.
 advised us that these were handy for tying up           heavy, and not very efficient, commando radio                                                        such fun: Amazing views at 2400m from
 plastic sample bags and we had requested 60             sets (no doubt cadged from the Army), our                                                            Midnight plateau of the Darwin and Hatherton
 dozen. When we unpacked our supplies down               reception was poor and we often could not                                                            nevees on totally clear minus 40oC evenings,
 south, we found we had been given 60 dozen              make clear contact. On this occasion we           VUWAE 6 (1962-63) Warwick Prebble                  sparkling ice crystals tumbling out of a clear
 packets of pipe cleaners. The result was we             received the message that we were to make a                                                          night sky on Christmas Eve 1962, elegant
                                                                                                           In 1962 we explored the hitherto largely
 had pipe cleaners coming out of our ears.               collection of rocks representative of the area,                                                      pyramid mountains of fractured chocolate
                                                                                                           unknown and untrodden Brown Hills and
 After every camp site clean-up, there was               to be used in the planned memorial to                                                                brown dolerite, honey coloured and bright pink
                                                                                                           Darwin Mountains around and through which
 always the inevitable pipe cleaner still lying          Admiral Byrd, which was to be constructed in                                                         layers of Beacon sandstone all warm and
                                                                                                           the Darwin Glacier flows at 79o south. These
 around. So we named a glacier in the                    Wellington. A helicopter was arriving the next                                                       inviting in the midnight sun, on all sides deep
                                                                                                           ice-free areas and well exposed mountain
                                                                                                                                                              blue ice falls and marble-like expanses of
                                                                                                           sides were very inviting amongst the maze of
                                                                                                                                                              gleaming white glaciers. We were a JATO
Travel on the Skeleton Neve with VUWAE 15                                                                  huge crevassed glaciers such as the Byrd to
                                                                                                                                                              expedition - some 32 or so bottles in all to lift
                                                                                                           the south and the Mulock to the north. At first
                                                                                                                                                              our loaded plane on its several flights. The raw
                                                                                                           sight I remember the Darwin Glacier looked
                                                                                                                                                              excitement of twin bank JATO blasts and
                                                                                                           fairly benign. We had hoped to haul our sledge
                                                                                                                                                              thundering motors hardly fades in the memory.
                                                                                                           across it to the Darwin Mountains from our
                                                                                                           base camp at a cosy place, which we called         Special moments regularly come to mind: the
                                                                                                           Erewhon by some frozen ponds in the Brown          first night in our little Meade tents on the
                                                                                                           Hills. From the top of Bastion Hill about 1000m    Touchdown Glacier when the fog which nearly
                                                                                                           above Erewhon I saw some enormous                  prevented our landing and certainly hastened
                                                                                                           crevasses partly concealed beneath thin snow       the Dak's swift departure rolled away after
                                                                                                           bridges and we decided not to attempt a very       midnight to reveal a silent, sunlit, breathtaking
                                                                                                           risky crossing on foot. Later were lifted across   vista of icy mountains, spangling snow fields
                                                                                                           by Dakota. I recall watching the shadow of our     and rocky nunataks; a motionless landscape
                                                                                                           plane take a perceptible time to pass over         and see-for-ever views; threading our way up
                                                                                                           each of these huge slots. The sight of the         through massive pink granites, tourmaline

  Victoria University of Wellington Antarctic Expeditions: The First 50 Years                                                                                                                                 25
We were led in the science by ourselves and        mires and salt ponds, the rich colours of the
                                                                                                        our mentors - there were the not-to-be             rocks and mountains, the contrast of the blue
                                                                                                        forgotten discussions between Harold Wellman       ice falls and white steep-walled glacier tongues
                                                                                                        and Alec Wilson. Their direction and example       which flowed over the valley side and floors
                                                                                                        was inspiring. Memories include the visits by      and the high and remote camp sites under the
                                                                                                        Brian Talboys, Minister of Science and Adrian      ever changing sky. It is tempting to compare
                                                                                                        Hayter, Leader of Scott Base. Their visit was      the feast of colour, topography and desert
                                                                                                        followed by several days of blizzard and strong    landforms to that of the Grand Canyon of the
                                                                                                        winds which lashed us on Brown Peninsula.          Colorado at twilight - but with the added
                                                                                                        Without snow piling up other ways of keeping       spectacle of eternal low lighting, dramatic
                                                                                                        your tents fixed down on rock and soil must be     clarity, views limited by distance only and the
                                                                                                        devised. Some of the new comers to Antarctica      total stillness and silence when the wind stops.
                                                                                                        did not sleep for a few days as the wind and
                                                                                                        drift shrieked past and the tent poles hummed      Other recollections are of the journeys to
                                                                                                        to the tune of the blast. Many of the team did     and from the ice in Hercules, the super
                                                                                                        not venture outside for some time. We even         constellation “Phoenix” and that veteran of
                                                                                                        managed to have an old polar tent, in spite of     the ice - the big old piston engine
                                                                                                        being pitched firmly, break a bamboo pole.         Globemaster. I shall not forget the
                                                                                                                                                           Globemaster having an engine failure one
                                                                                                        Another visit was from my brother Michael          hour out of Christchurch. Oil streamed from
VUWAE8, Photo: Bruce Popplewell                                                                         when we were moved to the Koettlitz. We were       the engine cowling and anxious flight crew
                                                                                                        lucky as siblings to share the experience of       peered at it with search lights. We treated it
pegmatites, pallisades of columnar dolerite            at night. Silence shattered by ice falls         being together in Antarctica. I shall always       all as fun especially the hearty meal of steak
and layers of conglomerate and sandstone;              avalanching off hanging glaciers. Some very      remember the heat wave which ensued in the         etc at the US base when we returned to fix it
the game of cricket on the glacier while               windy days with snow plumes streaming off        Koettlitz and the Dry Valleys. Water flowing in    up before taking off again. Then 11 hours later
waiting to fly back to Scott Base - extended           the tops.                                        stream channels, lake levels rising,               the magnificent sight of the mountains of
with the Dak crew who signed our bat;                                                                   temperatures of plus 3 and 4, sunny calm days      Northern Victoria Land. One also does not
sunbathing in dry still air at minus 10. Well          The Dry Valleys, Black Island, Brown             - it was difficult to find enough time to sleep.   forget the Hercules flight which ran into in bad
ahead of schedule, we were able to spend               Peninsula and Koettlitz were the territory for   Other memories are of the long traverses of the    weather - unable to return and landing so
January in the Taylor Valley.                          VUWAEs 8 and 9. Each team was a diverse          ice free areas, lots of drillholes in the lakes,   expertly in poor visibility at McMurdo.
                                                       and committed group of individuals from          and an occasion when two of us broke through
The Taylor is a magic place. Memories of the           many disciplines and with different tasks, all   the thin ice on the moat of Lake Bonney and        Antarctica was for me and probably for all of
24 hour traverse from the coast to the Taylor          driving towards a common plan. That in itself    floundered to shore. It was good to get into our   us in some way a milestone if not a turning
Glacier snout with Tom Haskell, Colin Bull and         was a fairly unique experience for us at the     spare clothing which we always had in our          point in our careers. The memories of
his gravity meter are special; The long cool           time. It was matched by novel scientific         packs and watch the wet clothes gel and set        friendships and teamwork achieved are many.
shadows of the Kukri Hills. Midnight on                objectives - solar heated lakes, their           solid. Hours later on our way back to camp the     The underlying trust and companionship
Nussbaum Reigel. Brilliantly sunlit mountains          chemistry, physics and biology; ground           wet set of gear had dried out by ablation.         experienced are precious. Lastly there are the
and icefalls on the other side of the valley,          hugging glaciers, Antarctic surficial geology,                                                      memories of those whose vision, enthusiasm,
Lake Bonney to the west and McMurdo sound              Polar Plateau snow balance and                   I remember the ease with which we moved            hard work and skills made it all possible in the
and Erebus to the East. Ice covered lakes and          carbonaceous chondrites, implications for the    around the Dry Valleys, the stunning landscape     first place. The person who immediately comes
ponds in the floor of the valley, wadis, dunes         history of the ice cap and glacial movements     of beautifully sculptured rock outcrops, the       to mind every time is Bob Clark, to whom I and
and lag pavements. Total silence and stillness         and more….                                       sand dunes and ventifact fields, the saline        others owe a lot.

Victoria University of Wellington Antarctic Expeditions: The First 50 Years                                                                                                                             27
VUWAE 11 (1969-70) Vince Neall                         into marine zoology. With the aid of an           when Adam Wooller said, “I think I'll ring        VUWAE 13 led by Peter Webb and Barrie
                                                       obliging Weddel seal, we caught a 50+kg fish,     Mum.” So he whipped out the hand held radio,      McKelvey, with myself (team medic) and fellow
One lasting memory I have was when Colin
                                                       which we identified from a 200mm long type        called Scott Base via a repeater in the Dry       student Mike Gorton (mechanic) completing
Vucetich and I spent Christmas 1969 in the
                                                       specimen as a Dissostichus mawsonii or now        Valleys and got patched through the satellite     the team, aimed to explore the Boomerang-
Lower Taylor Valley. On our meanderings
                                                       called a tooth fish, the first time found in      link to Mum's phone. A very sleepy voice          Warren Range-Lashly Mountains area. We
around the landscape we crossed a low
                                                       recent times in the Ross Sea. We gave it to the   answered. Mum was in Devon.                       were accompanied by two famous Italian
saddle, only to find in the pristine Antarctic
                                                       Natural History Museum, so I must check if                                                          mountaineers/journalists who guided us
atmosphere a pungent rotten odour attacking                                                              I've enjoyed my 38 years span in Antarctica -
                                                       it's still there.                                                                                   through dangerous areas - they were the
our nostrils. Further investigation revealed it                                                          the camaraderie - the blizzards - the brilliant   precursors to Italy setting up an Antarctic base
to be areas of very shallow water in which             The next VUWAE trip in 1975 saw us with           days and the times you can see forever - not to   in later years. With little English between
algae had been growing, but now as the                 Doug Northey, Eric Broughton, Colin Brown &       mention the scientific rewards.                   them, we soon found we could 'converse' fairly
season progressed, the waters were drying up           How Kin Wong from the University of                                                                 well without hands, especially when it came to
and the algae rotting. I suggested we called it        Michigan, carrying out a magnetic and seismic                                                       rationing fresh meat or alcohol we had taken
Lake Puhipuhi, when Colin turned to me and             survey of McMurdo Sound and Terra Nova
                                                                                                         VUWAE 13 (1968-69) Barry Kohn                     to break the monotony of freeze-dry rations.
nonchalantly said, “I think Hannibal came              Bay. At times our magnetometer was being                                                            We covered about 500 kilometres with our
through here with his elephants”. It was just          towed over the ice, but, unbelievably, still      I first landed in Antarctica in 1968 after a 14   Polaris toboggans and Nansen sledges that
one of those occasions when I well remember            gave reliable readings. Our measurements          hour flight in the US Navy Super Constellation -  season. Scientific highlights were many, but
cracking up with Colin's unexpected humour             helped determine optimum locations for the        Pegasus. After about 7 hours into our flight the  undoubtedly topped by the discovery of
of the moment.                                         MSSTS drill holes.                                pilot announced that he had both 'good news       Permo-Carboniferous tillites and rich deposits
                                                                                                         and bad news' - we had now passed the half        of beautifully preserved Devonian fossil fish.
                                                       The first venture on to terra firma was with      way mark, but had also reached the point of
                                                       Peter Garden on Mt Bastion collecting             no-return, so we would be landing at Williams       One of the main plans of VUWAE-15, under the
VUWAE 11 (1966-67) Chris Christoffel
                                                       samples for palaeomagnetic measurements,          Field no matter what the conditions. I was          leadership of Peter Barrett and myself as
My first visit to Antarctica was in 1958 when I        where we teamed up with Peter Barrett and         reminded rather vividly of how quickly              deputy leader was to take a large party,
was in the Navy and towed my magnetometer              Alex Pyne. Cloud conditions at McMurdo and        conditions could change on the ice during the       including Australian vertebrate
from the wooden ship HMNZS Endeavour                   Bastion were out of phase so that supplies        1970-71 season (VUWAE 15).
between New Zealand and Antarctica and                 were running low by the time we were              While at Scott Base, a few days
carried out an extensive survey in the Ross                                                                                                      Barry Kohn and Rodney Grapes relaxing during VUWAE15.
                                                       collected. Peter and I continued to Beacon        before setting out for our field
Sea, in conjunction with a biological survey           Heights, one of the most scenic locations in      season some of the staff
carried out by members of the Institute of             Antarctica. This was equalled in 1981, when       invited us out on a 'looting'
Oceanography. On the return trip we carried            we camped on the cirque near Mt Kempe and         expedition to check out what
VUWAE members including Colin Bull, Peter              could see 250 miles out over the Ross Sea         could be retrieved from
Webb & Barrie McKelvey. I didn't have much             beyond Mt Melbourne and Franklin Island. Mt       Pegasus before it was shoved
time to talk to them as I was too busy in the          Erebus seemed to be in touching distance.         off the ice into the sea. Pegasus
hold tending my magnetometer.                                                                            had slid off the 'runway' while
                                                       Communications with the outside world             landing in a whiteout resulting
That first trip got me hooked, and I                   changed drastically over the years. In the        in considerable damage (luckily
subsequently had another 15 to Antarctica,             60's, one had to book a time with the PO          no-one was seriously injured).
some in conjunction with VUWAE. The first of           operator weeks ahead and then for a half          That marked the end of the
these, with Ian Calhaem, in 1966, measuring            hour on the phone you'd be lucky to get five      Super Constellation era and on
heat flow through the bottom of McMurdo                minutes of intelligible conversation. But in      to the C-130 Hercules and
Sound by sending our probe through a US                1994, we were on the summit of Mt Feather at      C-141 Starlifters.
fishing hut hole was notable for our launching         10,000ft on the edge of the Polar Plateau

Victoria University of Wellington Antarctic Expeditions: The First 50 Years                                                                                                                             29
You can also read