Eradication project of invasive alien mongooses in Japan - Okinawa and Amami-oshima Island-Masato Morikawa

Page created by Cindy Cunningham
 
CONTINUE READING
Eradication project of invasive alien mongooses in Japan - Okinawa and Amami-oshima Island-Masato Morikawa
Eradication project of invasive alien
        mongooses in Japan
- Okinawa and Amami-oshima Island-

 Office for Alien Species Management, Wildlife Division,
               Nature Conservation Bureau,
                Ministry of the environment
                 Masato Morikawa
                                                           1
Eradication project of invasive alien mongooses in Japan - Okinawa and Amami-oshima Island-Masato Morikawa
Ryukyu Archipelago
               - one of biodiversity hot spots of the world

                        Tokyo                                   Amami-oshima
                                                               Island (712 km2)
                                                              Population: 70,000
            Kagoshima

           Amami-oshima
         Okinawa
                                                     Okinawa Island (1,208 km2)
Taiwan                                               Population: 1,200,000
                                                                            2
Eradication project of invasive alien mongooses in Japan - Okinawa and Amami-oshima Island-Masato Morikawa
Ryukyu Archipelago
                    - one of biodiversity hot spots of the world

• Biogeographically, border of Palearctic and Oriental region.
• Isolated from the continent about 2 - 1.7 million years ago.
    c.f. Mainland Japan : isolated about 10 000 – 20 000 years ago.
• Many endemic species inhabit with limited predator species
                                                       Korea

                                                                       Kyusyu
                                                         Watase line

                                      Taiwan
   Islands of poisonous snake, habu                                             3
Eradication project of invasive alien mongooses in Japan - Okinawa and Amami-oshima Island-Masato Morikawa
Native wildlife in the Ryukyus evolved in the
             absence of predatory mammals

                                                                      Amami-group
                                                                       Amami-oshima Is.
                                                                      Tokunoshima Is.
        Iriomote cat                                                                                 Amami rabbit
 (Prionailurus bengalensis                                                                        (Pentalagus furnessi)
       iriomotensis)                                    Okinawa-group

   Crested Serpent Eagle                                                                            Amami woodcock
(Spilornis cheela perplexus)                                          Okinawa Is.                    (Scolopax mira)
                               Yaeyama-group
                                                            Miyako-group
                                                         Miyako Is.
                                              Ishigaki Is.
                               Iriomote Is.

                                                                           Yambaru long-armed
  Okinawa woodpecker                Okinawa rail                                                      Amami thrush
                                                                              scarab beetle
 (Dendrocopos noguchii)        (Gallirallus okinawae)                                             (Zoothera dauma major)
                                                                           (Cheirotonus jambar)
                                                                                                                           4
Eradication project of invasive alien mongooses in Japan - Okinawa and Amami-oshima Island-Masato Morikawa
Small Indian Mongoose
             (Herpestes auropunctatus)

• A small, slim-bodied predator native
  to areas from Iran, through India to
  Myanmar, VietNam.                                                          Small Indian mongoose

• It has been introduced to many
  islands to control rats, particularly in
  sugar cane fields of tropics.
• The mongoose has had a major
  impact on native species in the areas
  where it has been introduced.

                                                                                            5
                                        100 of the worst invasive alien species by ISSG, IUCN
Eradication project of invasive alien mongooses in Japan - Okinawa and Amami-oshima Island-Masato Morikawa
More than 70 islands/areas introduced

                            (Hays & Conant, 2007)
                                                    6
Eradication project of invasive alien mongooses in Japan - Okinawa and Amami-oshima Island-Masato Morikawa
1910: First introduction to Japan
                                                         (300km2)
• Dr. Watase, the famous biologist
                                                     (2004年)
                                                       2004
  in Japan was advised by foreign
  scientists to import mongooses
  to control poisonous snake Habu
  and harmful black rat
                                     (1978年)
                                        1978
• Released around southern part                                 1990

  of Okinawa and settled and
  spread gradually
• 1990s: Expand to Yamabaru
  region(northern Okinawa) , the             O kinaw a Is.
                                              (1,206km2)
  hotspot of wildlife
• Mongoose Control measure
  launched by Okinawa Prefectural
  Government & MOE launched
  from 2000
                                      released in 1910                 7
Eradication project of invasive alien mongooses in Japan - Okinawa and Amami-oshima Island-Masato Morikawa
Starting control efforts
• In 2000, the Okinawa Prefectural Government began cull efforts.
• In 2005, control efforts began with the enforcement of
  the Invasive Alien Species Act.
• The mongoose population continued to expand until 2006, causing the
  Okinawa rail population to retreat.
• Mongoose proof fence installed in 2006 in SF line to prevent mongooses
  from spreading north.

                SF line

     FY 2000                  FY 2003                  FY 2006             8
Eradication project of invasive alien mongooses in Japan - Okinawa and Amami-oshima Island-Masato Morikawa
Outline of control measures
• Control initiatives began with cage-type live traps, which required daily
  checking. Trappers installed traps along logging roads.
• The introduction of tube-type kill traps for which checking frequency can
  be set as desired (usually every two to four weeks) and the use of kill traps
  and live traps as required brought about a drastic increase in the number of
  traps managed.
• Trappers began related work in forests in FY 2007.

                                              2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
                  Live trap
                      Forest work
                  Kill trap
                  Sensor cameras
                  Sniffer dogs
                  Native species monitoring                                                                    9
Eradication project of invasive alien mongooses in Japan - Okinawa and Amami-oshima Island-Masato Morikawa
Preventing damage of indiscriminate capture
  • Kill traps were first introduced in 2003
  • Deploy endemic rats are absent and/or
    in low density.
                                                       Amami spiny rat
                                                         (Tokudaia
              ■ Live trap                                osimensis)
              …Everyday checking is necessary
              …Used in habitat of endangered native species            Ryukyu long-
                                                                         haired rat
                                                                     (Diplothrix legata)

              ■ Kill trap (Pipe- trap)
              …Efficient (Lightweight, Set for 2-4 weeks)
              …Birds : discriminable
               Rats : indiscriminable
                                                                         Okinawa rail
                    trigger

           Simulation and trial to decide trap shape
                                                                         Amami 10
                                                                               jay
           for preventing endemic birds
Changes in capture status
                                              Distribution of mongooses have decreased
Capture number of mongooses                Capture number of mongooses                   Capture number of mongooses                 Capture number of mongooses
                                   2006                                         2007                                          2008                                        2009
Location of trap installation              Location of trap installation                 Location of trap installation               Location of trap installation

   Capture number of                            Capture number of                             Capture number of
   mongooses                                    mongooses                                     mongooses
                                    2010                                          2011                                           2012
   Location of trap installation                Location of trap installation                 Location of trap installation

                                                                                                                                                                     11
Changes in capture status
                                                        Mongooses have steadily decreased

1,000                                                                           2,500,000   0.500
                                                                                                                  0.43
                                Mongooses                                                                                                CPUE(Mongooses/100Trap-days)
                                                                                                                                         CPUE (C/100TD)
 800                                                                            2,000,000   0.400
                                Trap-days
                                            619
                                573                                                                                      0.29
 600                                  549         560                           1,500,000                  0.27
                    520   543                                                               0.300

                                                        396
                                                                                                                                0.20
                                                                                                                                       0.19
                                                                                                                                                                   Okinawa
 400                                                                            1,000,000   0.200   0.16                                      0.17
              284
                                                                    255
        208                                                   230         202
 200                                                                            500,000     0.100                                                    0.06
                                                                                                                                                            0.03                0.014
                                                                                                                                                                   0.02 0.016

   0                                                                            0           0.000

    • Since the Yambaru Mongoose Busters started its activities, there has been a
      drastic increase in the total number of traps (see the line graph). The total
      number of trap days has kept around 1.5 million every year since 2011. The
      number of mongooses caught (see the bar graph) has shown a declining
      trend since 2008, and been a significant drop in the number in recent years.
    • CPUE, an indicator of mongoose population size, has continued to decrease.
                                                                                                                                                                            12
1979: Introduction into Amami
                 from Okinawa Island
• There are few records about
  introduction into Amami
• Mongooses were brought in from
  Okinawa Island (Sekiguchi               released in 1979
                                                                (2004年)
  et.al.,2001)
• Mongooses successfully settled on         (1990年)
  Amami and expanded their            (2004年)
  distribution
• Damages on farming and poultry
  gradually appeared from 1983
• Some research by Amami
  Mammalogical Society from 1989
                                                        A m am i-oshim a Is.
• Pest control by local government                           (712 km2)
  began from 1993

                                                                           14
Strong negative impacts on native vertebrates
 Partial extinction of mammals and amphibians in range of mongooses
      :distribution of native vertebrates          :core area of range of mongooses

                                  Amami rabbit                               Amami Ishikawa s frog

                          Ryukyu long-haired rat

                                                                                        Otton frog

                               Amami spiny rat                                Amami tip-nosed frog

                                                                                              15
                           Amami Wildlife Conservation Center from 2000 to 2006
1993-: Pest control by local government

• Pest animal that causes harm to crops
  and chicks
• Local government launched control to
  reduce damages of crops
• Licensed trapper were paid JPY 2,200
  for a mongoose
• 8,234 mongooses were captured in          ⒸAmami city
  seven years (1993-1999)
• Most of them captured around the
  center of distribution, high density
  area

                                                    16
2000-2004: Control program by bounty trapper
                                                                        Live trap

• At the beginning, mongooses were live trapped
  by one hundred bounty trappers
• To keep incentive to trap, bounty increased
  from JPY 2,200 (2000) to JPY 4,000 (2001-02)
                                                         Seminar for
  and JPY 5,000 (2003-04)                                bounty trapper
• Trapping data of bounty trappers were
  collected with using standard grid square
  (about 1 km2 mesh)
• A small number of trappers were employed to
  set traps at low density area and in bushes. 1
  trapper in 2002, 4 in 2003, and 6 in 2004        120                         Bounty trapper
• 14,558 mongooses were caught in this five        100
                                                                               Full time trapper

  year trapping 2000-2004                           80

                                                    60

                                                    40

                                                    20                                         12
                                                                                  4      6
                                                                          1
                                                     0
                                                                                              17
                                                          2000   2001   2002   2003   2004   2005
2005- Organizing Amami Mongoose Busters (AMB)
      • Invasive Alien Species Act was enforced in 2005
      • MOE launched a mongoose eradication project,
        hiring trapping experts, “Amami Mongoose
        Busters (AMB)”.
120
        Bounty trapper
100
        Full time trapper, AMB
 80
 60
 40
 20
  0

                                                          18
2013: AMB and trained sniffer dogs

                                     19
32,357 mongooses caught in 20 years
4,500
                                                                                                                        Project by MOE
                                                                                                                        Pest control
4,000
                                                                                        Trapping data set
3,500

3,000
                                                                                                                        AMB

2,500

2,000

1,500

1,000

 500

   0
        1992
               1993
                      1994
                             1995
                                    1996
                                           1997
                                                  1998
                                                         1999
                                                                2000
                                                                       2001
                                                                              2002
                                                                                     2003
                                                                                            2004
                                                                                                   2005
                                                                                                          2006
                                                                                                                 2007
                                                                                                                        2008
                                                                                                                               2009
                                                                                                                                      2010
                                                                                                                                             2011
                                                                                                                                                    2012
        10,351 mongooses by pest control
                                                                22,006 mongooses by MOE project
                                                                                                                                                           20
CPUE (Capture/1000trap-days) distribution

                                        FY2001

                                                 21
CPUE (Capture/1000trap-days) distribution
          2001                            2002   2003

           2004                          2005    2006

           2007                          2008    2009

                                                        22
2012
                                                      2010

            Log_CPUE (C/1000TD)
                                  10.00
                                             100.00

     0.01
             0.10
                           1.00

                    2001
                    2002
                    2003
                    2004
                    2005
                                                      2011

                    2006
Year

                    2007
                    2008
                    2009
                    2010
                    2011
                    2012
23
FY2012: 197 mongooses captured
In37,000
   FY2012,       179are
              traps  mongooses
                        deployed were caught
with 2.26 million trap-days. 18 mongooses
were      caught with sniffer dogs and handler.
    Live trap
   Kill trap
   Modified kill trap

                                                         24
Abundance dynamics of mongooses

                         10000
                                        Estimated
                                         推定個体数    population
                                        Number
                                         捕獲数 of capture
     (Population size)
                         1000
Log10個体数
                         100

                                                               Hierarchical Bayes Model

                                 1980            1990             2000          2010
                                                          year                            25
(B) Black rat

                                                  10

                                                                                                              10
                               ycpue.rat.dis

                                                                                           ycpue.rat.dis
                                                                      2002:2009                                                2002:2009
                                                                                                                                      Fukasawa et al., 2013a
    Recovery of native species 1                                                                                                          Proc. R. Soc. B

                                                  5

                                                                                                              5
                                                  0                     Alien                                                  Native

                                                                                                              0
                                                            (A) Amami
                                                            (C) Small Indian
                                                                        Spinymongoose
                                                                              rat                                    (C) Amami Spiny rat
                                                     15
                                                  10 15

                                                                                                              15
                               ycpue.toge.nat

                                                                                           ycpue.toge.nat
                                                                      2002:2009
                                ycpue.mon

                                                                                                                               2002:2009
         CPUE(animals /1000trap-days)

                                                  10

                                                                                                              10
                                                  55

                                                                                                              5
                                                  00

                                                                                                              0
                                                            (D) Ryukyu
                                                            (B) Black ratlong-haired rat                             (D) Ryukyu long-haired rat
                               ycpue.kenaga.nat

                                                                                           ycpue.kenaga.nat
                                                  10
                                                   2

                                                                                                              2
                                 ycpue.rat.dis

                                                                      2002:2009
                                                                      2002:2009                                                2002:2009
                                                  51

                                                                                                              1
                                                  00

                                                                                                              0

                                                             (C) Amami
                                                          2002    2004 Spiny
                                                                         2006rat 2008                              2002   2004       2006   2008
                                                  15
                               cpue.toge.nat

Figure 2. Temporal changes in catch2002:2009
                                      per unit effort .
For the rat species, the solid and dashed lines indicate                                          Year
                                                  10

the areas of mild (habitat alteration index, HAI0) habitat alteration, respectively.
Watari et al., 2013
      Recovery of native species 2                                     Ecology and Evolution

 Scientists surveyed the population densities along logging road of four endangered
 species threatened by the mongoose.

                                  Amami rabbit          Amami tip-
                                                        nosed frog

                                  Otton frog
                                                                 Amami
                                                                 Ishikawa’s
                                                                 frog

Figure 3. Temporal changes in numbers of four species                                  27
         observed per site per survey (mean SE).
Probability of eradication success
• This simulation shows the current capture efforts of 2010 is the most
 cost-effective way to eradicate mongooses in this island.
 The eradication success might be feasible if eradication action same
 capture efforts of 2010 is continued over the next decade.
• However, we think that the most difficult point of eradication of
 mongooses is one final push (Trapping final 10 mongooses ).
 Therefore we are also considering alternative measure.
Fukasawa et al., 2013b
  J. Applied Ecology
                                                                                The eradication feasibility of
                   1.0                                                          mongooses was estimated
                   0.8                                                          using trapping data. (see
                    0.6                                                         black circle which indicate
                    0.4
                     0.2
                                                                                eradication feasibility.)
                     0.0
                           7.0                                            2050
                              6.5                                      2040
                                    6.0                            2030
                                          5.5                       0.0   0.2   0.4   0.6   0.8   1.0
                                                5.0         2020
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                    ―
                                                                                                             28
                                                      4.5
Eradication action plan by 2022

• New ten year mongoose                                        Monitoring area
  eradication plan was
  settled on from FY2013                                   Priority area
  to 2022.
• The challenges are to
  eradicate small number
  of mongooses scattered
  in a large area, and to
  ensure that no mongoose
  survives in every area,
  with using sniffer dogs,
  camera traps and hair
  traps.

            http://kyushu.env.go.jp/naha/wildlife/data/gairai/boujyo/130425b.html   29
Education & Awareness
                Pamphlet for the mongoose eradication measure

                                                                       30
http://kyushu.env.go.jp/naha/wildlife/data/gairai/boujyo/131017a.pdf
Thank you for your attention

                               31
You can also read