My Big Bird Year Fly Free, Subaraj The International and Domestic Parrot Trade

Page created by Andy Montgomery
 
CONTINUE READING
My Big Bird Year Fly Free, Subaraj The International and Domestic Parrot Trade
Official Magazine of Nature Society (Singapore)   Volume 28 No 1 Jan-Mar 2020 S$5.00

                                                          My Big Bird Year

                                                          Fly Free, Subaraj

                                                          The International
                                                             and Domestic
                                                              Parrot Trade

                                                                       MCI (P) 064/04/2019
My Big Bird Year Fly Free, Subaraj The International and Domestic Parrot Trade
Message from the Editors
              NATURE SOCIETY

                                                   T
                  (SINGAPORE)
                                                             his issue has serendipitously turned into a year-end celebration of the
                                                             many generations that make up the nature loving community and
                                                             Nature Society (Singapore) (NSS) members in our tiny island country,
2019, 2018, 2017, 2016
                                                   and the continuity of commitment.
                                                          Our cover photo shows a young team competing in NSS’ 35th Singapore
                    Patron                         Bird Race. This event attracted the largest number of teams and participants
             Professor Tommy Koh
                  President
                                                   ever, thanks not only to the many keen young primary and secondary
                Dr Shawn Lum                       school participants, but also the slightly older groups of photographers and
                Vice-President
               Dr Ho Hua Chew
                                                   birdwatchers who took part. And the few even older ones. And the youngsters
          Immediate Past President                 needed a solid core of “middling-age” types, teachers and NSS volunteers, to
                Dr Geh Min
                                                   keep them safe as they roamed around the southern ridges.
              Honorary Secretary
              Mr Morten Strange                           At the core of the Bird Race organisation was Lim Kim Chuah, now
             Honorary Treasurer                    Chair of the NSS Bird Group, and one of those who had competed in the first
            Mr Bhagyesh Chaubey
                                                   Bird Race in 1984 – a two team event. He was one of the young generation of
         Honorary Assistant Secretary
                Ms Evelyn Ng                       Singaporeans who gave the Society, then the Singapore Branch of the Malayan
         Honorary Assistant Treasurer              Nature Society, a power surge in the 1980s. A photo of him at that time,
                      -
                                                   along with four others of that influential generation, appears in this issue. Very
        Executive Committee Members
         Mr Goh Si Guim, Mr Albert Liu             tragically one of them, Subaraj Rajathurai, is no longer with us. Morten Strange
      Finance Advisory Group Members
        Mr Peter Connell, Ms Trixie Tan,
                                                   pays tribute to Subaraj’s life which was dedicated to nature and its conservation
              Mr Yip Yew Chong                     in Singapore – a life cut short too soon, but with a solid legacy passed on to his
          Co-opted Council Members
    Assoc Prof P.N. Avadhani, Ms Margie Hall,
                                                   sons and to the wider community of Singapore.
Mr Ben Szeto, Dr Liew Kai Khiun, Dr Ngo Kang Min          Nature races rely on skills of identification and knowledge of species’
          Advisory Council Members
    Mr Warren Khoo, Prof Koh Kheng Lian,
                                                   behaviour and preferred habitats – Big Years likewise, with the addition of
       Mr Lim Jim Koon, Mr Liu Thai Ker,
    Prof Ng Soon Chye, Mr Sim Wong Hoo,
                                                   reliance on community. Geoff Lim’s account of his Big Year is much longer
                Mr Mason Tan                       than the articles we usually publish, but it contains such an appreciation of
      BirdLife International Coordinator
              Mr Lim Kim Keang
                                                   the birdwatching and bird photography community, as well as the problems of
              IUCN Coordinator                     fitting hobbies with family life, that we did not wish to cut it too short.
               Ms Ng Bee Choo                             On the conservation front, recent graduate Sung Mei Yee reports on
         Green Corridor Coordinator
              Dr Liew Kai Khiun                    her first attendance at an international conference, whilst some of our other
         COMMITTEE CHAIRPERSONS                    youngish science-trained members Anuj Jain and Yong Ding Li, together
          Conservation Committee
            Mr Leong Kwok Peng                     with recent graduate Aloysius Scott and with Jessica Lee of Wildlife Reserves
            Education Committee                    Singapore, initiate a preliminary consideration of the connectedness of the
              Mr Goh Ter Yang
                                                   international and local parrot trades. More work needs to be done to find the
    Membership & Fundraising Committee
               Mr Albert Liu                       connections, and we look forward to future updates and articles.
 SPECIAL INTEREST GROUP CHAIRPERSONS                      Readers may notice that various of the contributions mentioned above
               Bird Group
            Mr Lim Kim Chuah                       appear in a new section, NSS Kaleidoscope. This section specifically features
           Butterfly & Insect Group                Society news and updates. It is intended to incorporate items that would have
                       -
                                                   appeared in the previous format of the Society’s newsletter Nature News. In this
              Jalan Hijau Group
              Mr Tan Hang Chong                    way Nature Watch will now cover a wider range of materials.
          Marine Conservation Group                       As ever, we thank all our contributors, welcome articles from both new
               Mr Stephen Beng
                                                   and regular contributors, and wish all our readers, young, old and anywhere in
                 Plant Group
                 Mr Bian Tan                       between, the very best for New Year 2020.
           Nature Ramblers Group
           Mr Pandian Parthasarathy
                                                   Margie Hall & Gemma Koh
           Vertebrate Study Group
             Mr Tony O’Dempsey                     December 2019
              NSS Secretariat
                 Mr Joseph Lim                     We welcome your stories, articles, surveys, observations and photographs. Please
       (Accounts & Membership Officer)
                 Mr Kerry Pereira                  discuss your story ideas with us by emailing a proposal to contact@nss.org.sg. Do
   (Member Programme & Outreach Officer)           include samples of your photographs (maximum 20 images per submission). We
                Ms Sung Mei Yee                    require good quality, high resolution JPEG images (ideally uncropped) in the largest
   (Project Officer for the Every Singaporean      size available, labelled with a descriptive file name.
        A Naturalist (ESN) Programme)

   2 Nature Watch        Jul - Dec 2014
My Big Bird Year Fly Free, Subaraj The International and Domestic Parrot Trade
Contents
                 Vol 28 No 1 January – March 2020

                                                                                              Editor

  2
                                                                                            Gemma Koh

                                                                                          Assistant Editor
                                                                                            Margie Hall

                                                                                              Designer
                                                                                              S.T. Leng

                                                                                            Contributors
                                                                                   Geoff Lim, Keita Sin, Liz How,
                                                                               Morten Strange, Tan Gim Cheong, Lim
                                                                                Kim Chuah, Francis Chia, Con Foley,
                                                                              Sung May Yee, Anuj Jain, Scott Aloysius,
                                                                              Yong Ding Li, Jessica Lee, Bjorn Olesen,
                                                                                 Brice Li, Sean Yeat, Yann Muzika &
                                                                                             Norman Lim

                                                                                       MCI (P) 064/04/2019
                                                                                         ISSN: 0218-6853

                                                                                Printing by Mainland Press Pte Ltd

                            My Big Bird Year                                 Copyright belongs to the authors. All rights
                                                                              reserved. No part of this publication may
                                                                              be reproduced in any form or any means
                                                                               without prior permission in writing from
                                                                                Nature Society (Singapore). The views

                                          18
                                                                               and opinions expressed or implied in this
                                                                               publication are those of the authors and
                                                                               contributors only and do not necessarily
                                                                              reflect the official views of Nature Society
                                                                                      (Singapore) or its members.

                                                                                Advertisements
                                                                                To advertise in Nature Watch, contact:

                                                                                Nature Society (Singapore) office at:
                                                                                510 Geylang Road
                                                                                The Sunflower #02-05

                           13                                                   Singapore 389466
                                                                                Tel: (65) 6741 2036
                                                                                Fax: (65) 6741 0871
                                                                                E-mail: contact@nss.org.sg
Singapore’s International and                 Subaraj Rajathurai
                                                                                Website: www.nss.org.sg
  Domestic Parrot Markets                16 April 1963 - 22 October 19
                                                                                Advertising rates (full colour):
                                                                                Full page: S$2,000

                                 20                                             1/2 Page: S$1,000
                                                                                2/3 page: S$800
                                                                                1/3 page: S$500
                                                                                15% discount for four insertions.

                                                                               Nature Watch is printed on LumiArt
                                                                               paper from Stora Enso Europe
                                                                               with ISO 14001 Environmental
                                                                               Management Certification. Mainly
                                                                               recycled paper is used, the rest is
                                                                               pulp from sustainable and controlled
                                                                               sources in Finland, Brazil and other
                               ON THE COVER
                                                                               European countries.
   Young participants of the 35th Singapore Bird Race. Photo: Francis Chia
My Big Bird Year Fly Free, Subaraj The International and Domestic Parrot Trade
B i r d L i f e

                  As part of his rehabilitative regime following
                  a traffic accident in April 2015, Geoff Lim
                                   returned to walking in Singapore parks
                                   to look at birds. The former participant in
                                   bird races could no longer compete as he
                                   could not walk and ride in cars for prolonged
                                   periods. What emerged in 2016 was a 365-
                                   day marathon of endurance birding known
                                   as a Big Year, with the goal of seeing as many
                                   species as possible. Here are highlights.

                                Photos by Con Foley,
                                Geoff Lim, Keita Sin &
                                Liz How

2 Nature Watch Jan – Mar 2020
My Big Bird Year Fly Free, Subaraj The International and Domestic Parrot Trade
Pittas are magical balls of exquisitely coloured
feathers that have the power to subvert the minds
of grown men and cause them to abandon sense
and sensibility, driving many to dive into the
deepest and dankest forests to search for them.
Mangrove Pitta. Photo: Geoff Lim
Facing page: Mangrove Blue Flycatcher (left), Red-crowned Barbet.
Photos: Con Foley (left), Geoff Lim

                                                                    Jan – Mar 2020 Nature Watch 3
My Big Bird Year Fly Free, Subaraj The International and Domestic Parrot Trade
cat, determined to have my mouthful                 I succumbed to temptation and
 17 JAN 2016                                of feathers. I suddenly saw an odd stick     took leave from work to visit the park.

I
                                            that stuck out perpendicular from a          As I was packing to leave my office,
         made my way quickly towards        branch.                                      Uncle Fai, an engineering professor,
         the knoll. Ominous grey clouds            When I applied my binoculars to       sent me a text every birder dreads:
         swirled overhead. A photogra-      my eyes, I was rewarded by the sight of      “Bird flown”. According to friends
         pher laden with gear stumbled      the Grey Nightjar (Caprimulgus jotaka)       and social media, the boobook had
         towards me. “It’s drizzing,” he    looking at the world with half-opened        previously flown off when it got weary
said, stating the obvious. “No bird.” I     eyes. The bird, soaked by the drizzle,       of the circus below, but would return
nodded, but pressed ahead to my target.     shifted its position momentarily for         to another bough nearby. I believed it
       Several weeks ago, another wind-     a stretch. After shaking off the water       would do the same on the day of my
borne migrant visited this same corner      from its mottled mantle, Bird #60            outing.
of Bidadari and saw the object of my        turned back to sit parallel to the branch,          After wandering around the
quest. He was Noah Strycker (author         disappearing from the naked eye.             park with my companions and having
and researcher from the United States),                                                  procured seven ticks, we returned to
and for him, it was Bird #5,987 of his                                                   the platform to rest from the heat. I
record-setting international Big Year         2 FEB 2016                                 then heard a di-syllabic hu-hu, hu-hu,
2015, in which he saw 6,042 of the                                                       hu-hu… from the tangle of mangrove
world's estimated 10,400 species.           When I started birding in 1990, 90% of       branches behind me. The resident
       Several bare limbs reached out to    us could not afford a camera and long        Brown Hawk Owl tends to live in
the heavens, as if imploring the clouds     lens. Today, when a rarity appears, its      the core and fringes of our Central
to strike them with bolts of lightning. I   image is instantly uploaded on social        Catchment and makes a hoo-woot,
examined the gnarled branches with my       media and a hundred envious followers        hoo-woot, hoo-woot, with an upward
binoculars. Silas, a teacher, taught me     can only drool from their offices while      inflexion in the woot.
to look for lumps that ran against the      those lucky few in the drizzle savour               A quick check on the Xeno-
grain of the wood. No matter how hard       every feather.                               Canto website of bird calls confirmed
I tried, I could see no bird.                     The occurrence during the final        my suspicions that it was the Northern
       Nearby, the haunting notes of        days of January 2016 of the rarely           Boobook. We redoubled our effort to
a White-rumped Shama (Copsychus             encountered Northern Boobook (Ninox          locate the bird. However, the vegetation
malabaricus) emanated from the dark         japonica), a bird that resembles a cast      was too dense and the boobook turned
depths of a dense shrub. Better a bird in   member from Star Wars, was one               silent.
hand, I told myself, and trotted over to    such instance. Conventional wisdom                  As the evening approached, only
the tangle of branches and leaves.          indicates that they are very much            I remained at the mangroves, hoping
       Originally a denizen of the          indistinguishable from our resident          against hope. As night fell, Tan Gim
rainforest, the shama’s sleek black head    Brown Hawk Owl (Ninox scutulata),            Cheong, our local raptor expert,
and upper parts help the bird melt into     except by their DNA and calls. For           appeared. Then, the unseen boobook
shadows, while its chestnut underside       reasons lost to me, someone had divined      called again. G.C. cocked his head and
resembles dead leaves stripped of their     that the boobook in the park was an          listened intently as he peered briefly
chlorophyll. The bird called briefly, and   intrepid northerner that had flown all       into the dark branches before casually
I saw the tell-tale sign of its splendid    the way from Japan or Taiwan, thereby        sauntering away.
long tail bob in the effort. My Bird #59    sparking off a mad race to see it. As the           The sun dipped beneath the
was in the bag.                             bird had perched itself at an impossibly     horizon and a distant Sunda Scops Owl
       I returned to the tree.              acute angle in the mangroves, there          (Otus lempiji) began to pooh!. Light
Accomplishments are only achieved           was only a small window from which it        failed completely and the mangrove
through patience and persistence.           could be seen. Friends at ground zero        trees became misshapen threatening
Lesser mortals often give up just before    informed me through text messages of         ogres. As I left the woods, the family
they arrive at the cusp of victory. I       sharp verbal exchanges between jostling      of Spotted Wood Owls (Strix seloputo)
was determined to achieve greatness. I      photographers refusing to move from          living further away began to bark
circled the base of a tree like a hungry    their spots.                                 and hoot.

4 Nature Watch Jan – Mar 2020
My Big Bird Year Fly Free, Subaraj The International and Domestic Parrot Trade
Above: Northern Boobook. Photo: Keita Sin Below: White-rumped Shama. Photo: Geoff Lim Inset: Oriental Darter. Photo: Keita Sin

                                                                     When I started birding
                                                                     in 1990, 90% of us could not
                                                                     afford a camera and long lens.
                                                                     Today, when a rarity appears,
                                                                     its image is instantly uploaded
                                                                     on social media and a hundred
                                                                                   envious followers
                                                                                   can only drool
                                                                                   from their offices
                                                                                   while those lucky
                                                                                   few in the drizzle
                                                                                   savour every
                                                                                   feather.

                                                                                                Jan – Mar 2020 Nature Watch 5
My Big Bird Year Fly Free, Subaraj The International and Domestic Parrot Trade
My Big Strategy
                                                                       As the weeks pass
                                                                                                 ed, I encountered var
                                                                       a term used to descr                                ious dips,
                                                                                               ibe missing a target
                                                                       birders, like most bir                          bird. Big Year
                                                                                              ders, generally take
                                                                      mornings when birds                             flight in the
                                                                                                are most hungry, voc
                                                                      They scour the island                               al and visible.
                                                                                               ’s birding hotspots and
                                                                      updates on Faceboo                                     post their
                                                                                              k. These are the top
                                                                            I considered myself                       predators.
                                                                                                    a bottom-feeding bir
                                                                     and parenting respo                                      der. Work
                                                                                             nsibilities meant tha
                                                                     three hours on weeke                           t I had only
                                                                                               nd afternoons to pu
                                                                     I turned to my Bird                              rsue my craft.
                                                                                            Race experience to
                                                                     Year strategy.                                inform my Big
                                                                           There were 8 abunda
                                                                                                     nt species, 91 commo
                                                                    uncommon and 147                                           n, 146
                                                                                            rare birds that could
                                                                    Singapore. Spectacu                              be found in
                                                                                            lar rarities make gre
                                                                    bragging rights. Howe                           at ticks and
                                                                                              ver, the value of a rar
                                                                    conditions is the sam                               ity under race
                                                                                             e as a ubiquitous bir
                                                                   Javan Myna (Acridoth                              d such as the
                                                                                             eres javanicus).
                                                                           As the game was to
                                                                                                   increase my species
                                                                   I just had to ensure                                      counts,
                                                                                          I checked off all the
                                                                   common tickables to                            abundant and
                                                                                             put 99 species in my
                                                                  could be seen on my                                  bag. These
                                                                                            way to work, during
                                                                  my way home. I only                                lunch or on
                                                                                            needed a hundred un
Indian Pond Heron. Photo: Liz How                                 birds and one rare spe                              common
                                                                                             cies to score two hu
                                                                  This meant that I had                              ndred birds.
                                                                                            to curb my instincts
                                                                  one rare tick to focus                             to run for that
                                                                                            on the dozen I could
                                                                                                                      easily have.

                                                                                              Kim brothers, had commented that
                                                                                              his last Indian Pond Heron sighting was
                                                                                              in 1994, underscoring the rarity of
                                                                                              this heron.
                                                                                                     Pond herons are hunch-backed
                                                                                              egret-like birds that congregate around
                                                                                              rain-filled fields during the year-end
                                                                                              to feed on the hapless frogs, fish and
                                                                                              water-dwelling insect larvae living in
                                                                                              these temporary basins. During the non-
Great Knot at Seletar Dam. Photo: Geoff Lim
                                                                                              breeding season, every pond heron looks
                                                                                              exactly the same — a drab, brownish bird
  9 APR 2016                                and peel away into the sky.
                                                   Herons and egrets, even bitterns,
                                                                                              with white wings and underparts. Often
                                                                                              it is hard to tell if it is a Chinese, Javan or
Bidadari continued to surprise birders      are able to perch in trees. I recall seeing       Indian Pond Heron. As they acquire their
even though the authorities had begun       flocks of Little Egret (Egretta garzetta)         breeding plumage, the common Chinese
to reclaim chunks of it to build a new      festooning trees adjacent to the prawn            Pond Heron (Ardeola bacchus)’s head and
Housing and Development Board               ponds of Senoko in the mid-1990s. I               neck become a deep chocolate brown.
(HDB) town. I paid the patch a visit        remarked about my sighting to Andrew              The rarer Javanese Pond Heron (Ardeola
during the afternoon, wending my            Chow, a digital artist who draws                  speciosa) sports a rich tea-coloured head
way past the opening in the fence-line      beautiful renditions of the birds, soon           and neck; in local parlance, it is a “teh-c”
to find myself wandering beneath the        after. With a glistening eye, he confided         coloured bird. The Indian Pond Heron is
shade of several mature trees shaking off   that he had just seen an Indian Pond              rarer still. The tea on its head and neck is
water droplets from the recent rain. As     Heron (Ardeola grayii) in the trees near          a whole lot milkier, and the mantle has a
I looked up, I was surprised to see the     the columbarium.                                  maroon sheen.
shape of a heron leap from the tree-top            Kim Seng, the older of the Lim                    A cluster of trees formed a small

6 Nature Watch Jan – Mar 2020
My Big Bird Year Fly Free, Subaraj The International and Domestic Parrot Trade
wood at the base of the field. I scanned           The clatter of a camera shutter     announced along the coasts of the
the treetops and was rewarded with a        suddenly broke the silence as a            Yellow Sea, the outcome did not appear
Chinese Pond Heron trying to dry itself;    photographer spotted something             optimistic for this species, and myriads
the dark rich brown contrasting nicely      moving along the grass 10m away.           of other shorebirds, that are dependent
against the bright green foliage. I could   Everyone strained to see what the          on these refuelling stops to survive their
barely make out the shape of a paler bird   sharp-eyed shooter had seen, cameras       gruelling journey. I might not see the
further away in the glaring afternoon       activating as they spotted the drab,       bird again if I did not go.
sun that peeked out of the large rain       brown bird making its way to feed on              My wife and daughter watched
clouds. As the bird turned sideways,        the millet.                                me stew as I contemplated my chances
I could see that it had a pale milk-tea            Bird #150 had large yellow feet     of getting the bird after completing my
wash to its head and neck, and a deep       and a white-streaked back, and pale        duties. “Since it’s so rare, why don’t you
maroon back. The rare Indian vagrant,       belly. It also had an orange streak        just go for it first?” my wife gently said.
Bird #135, was now mine.                    above its boot-black button eyes as its           Thus released, I raced to Yishun
                                            dark beak worked furiously to pick up      Dam, where a sliver of exposed mud
                                            seeds on the wet ground.                   during the low tide attracted a good
 12 JUN 2016                                                                           number of plovers, red and greenshanks
                                                                                       and the knot. While driving, I was filled
Punggol Barat, an island created by land     14 AUG 2016                               with the usual dark thought every birder
reclamation just off Seletar Airport, is                                               regardless of age and nationality has when
a haven for seed-eating escapees from       “The Knot has landed.” Software            racing for a terrific rarity: will I dip it?
the caged bird trade. Waxbills and Red      engineer and fellow birder K.C.                   To reach the spot where the
Avadavats (Amandava amandava) are           Ling’s terse post on Facebook set me       mudflats could be surveyed required a
commonly encountered, taking to the         stewing. IUCN had just published           walk of 5 to 6 minutes from where I
skies with feeble peeps and trills, along   that the Great Knot (Calidris ten-         would park. A passing raptor could flush
with native munias, pipits and cistico-     uirostris) population had declined         the feeding shorebirds during this brief
las. Several Pin-tailed Whydahs (Vidua      drastically by 77.8% over three            period. I made the journey in 4 minutes
macroura) in their resplendent long tail    generations, with 98% of the entire        and joined several photographers. One
plumes are also frequently seen making      global population restricted to the East   or two friendlier ones pointed forward.
hovering courtship flights to impress       Asian-Australasian Flyway, of which        No verbal communication was needed.
drab-looking females. On one occasion,      Singapore is a part.                              I scanned the mud dotted with
a Jackson’s Widowbird (Euplectes jack-                                                 plovers, greenshank and redshank,
soni) flew over my head.                                                               straining madly to see a different-
       The King Quail (Excalfactoria                                                   looking bird. And there it was, a pale
chinensis) is a resident bird that is                                                  creature with a mottled back stood out
reclusive and difficult to spot. Birders                                               from the brilliantly coloured plovers
and photographers assured me that                                                      with their bandit masks and rufous
the island was the best place to see it.                                               breast bands. It was probing into the
However, these birds seem to be hobbits                                                substrate with its almost-dagger like
of the avian world, melting away unseen                                                black beak. It stopped and strode a
and unheard. My previous attempts to                                                   few steps forward before searching for
see one failed miserably.                                                              invertebrates hidden in the gooey muck.
       It had just rained that afternoon,   King Quail. Photo: Geoff Lim                      I spent a total of 11 minutes and
leaving the mimosa and lallang wet                                                     914 shots, on Bird #157. This would
from the heavy deluge. Someone had                The reason for such drastic          easily be the Bird of the Year.
left a quantity of millet on the ground,    declines lies in habitat loss along the           I posted photos of the bird on
attracting a number of waxbills and         coasts where shorebirds stop to refuel     my Facebook page and five minutes
avadavats. The small party of birders and   along this gigantic flyway. Research       into my drive home, I heard a ping on
photographers told everyone in quiet        showed that reclamation works just         my phone. I pulled over and checked
tones that the quail was likely to appear   at Saemangeum in South Korea               the message. It was Danny, a retired
to feed after the rain. The tension was     accounted for a decline of 25% of          IT professional, enquiring if I had just
palpable as we waited silently in the       the entire population of Great Knot.       seen the bird. I quickly provided him
failing light.                              With more reclamation projects being       with details.

                                                                                                 Jan – Mar 2020 Nature Watch 7
My Big Bird Year Fly Free, Subaraj The International and Domestic Parrot Trade
Some time later, I learned that
Danny grabbed his gear, jumped into his
car and drove like mad to the dam. He
was amply rewarded, and I was glad to
have been of some help.

 28 SEP 2016
In any winning Big Year, the strategy
must include at least one pelagic trip.
Mine was an add-on, after my classmate
Alvin invited me to join him on a boat
to the waters off Singapore. A fellow
companion was David Tan, the young
scientist who collects dead birds all over
Singapore for analysis.
      We were led by the late R. Subaraj,
wildlife consultant extraordinaire and
one of my mentors when I started             Lesser Crested Tern. Photo: Geoff Lim
birding. Along with other local birding
legends like Lim Kim Keang, the Lim
Kim brothers (Kim Seng and Kim
Chuah) and the intrepid Dr Yong Ding
                                             In any winning Big Year, the strategy must
Li, Subaraj was a walking encyclopaedia      include at least one pelagic trip.
of birding knowledge. (Subaraj was also
a national icon, his likeness adorning
banners along Orchard Road, as an
ambassador marketing Singapore as a
                                             their summer breeding programme.               24 OCT 2016
                                                    “Caspian Tern!” someone
tourist destination.)                        whooped. The large tern (Hydroprogne          When word came of a Grey-headed
      The boat chugged out into the          caspia) with a massive beak nonchalantly      Lapwing (Vanellus cinereus) appearing at
calm sea. But we were soon pelted by         glided away towards Sentosa as we             Kranji Marsh on a Sunday morning, I
rain. The wind, sea spray and raindrops      pushed on towards the South China Sea.        took the unprecedented risk of heading
turned an otherwise mild journey into a             The terns were joined by               out as soon as I finished my duties to
mini roller coaster ride.                    Swinhoe’s Storm Petrels (Oceanodroma          pursue this rarity. I had previously tried
      When the rain became a gentle          monorhis) — dark, pigeon-sized birds          to avoid taking to the field to chase just
drizzle, everyone turned out in force        — that drifted low over the tossing           one single rarity. However, by now, I
along the boat’s gunwale to peer into        sea. I read about Bird #174 as a boy.         had swept up most of the common and
the sky. There were terns everywhere         Scientists like Gibson Hill and F.N.          not-so-common species. I was left with
– ordinary-looking Bridled Terns             Chasen mentioned these sea-hugging            the difficult ones. The Grey-headed
(Onychoprion anaethetus), Swift Terns        birds in their reports. As I leafed           Lapwing is considered an accidental
(Thalasseus bergii) with their orange        through the yellowed pages in the old         occurrence. The bird breeds in northeast
beaks and roguish crests and Lesser          National Library at Bras Basah Road in        China and Japan, and winters in north-
Crested Terns (Thalasseus bengalensis)       the 1980s, I would imagine the birds          eastern India and northern Southeast
with their dagger-like yellow bills.         appearing as if they were walking on the      Asia. The southernmost limit of this
      I was greatly surprised to hear        water with outstretched wings; for this       bird is China. This bird could have been
someone call out “Aleutian Tern!” I had      was how the birds were described.             blown off-course as it made its way out
always thought these terns (Onychoprion             September is the best time to look     from its summer grounds.
aleutica) could only be seen off the         for these birds as they traverse the oceans         When I arrived at the marshes
coasts of Alaska. However, recent            and make their way northwards from            at about the same time as NSS Bird
research has shown that these birds fly      the southern oceans. Someone counted          Group stalwart Alan Owyong, we
through our waters after completing          till he saw 99 birds and stopped.             were told that we were five minutes

8 Nature Watch Jan – Mar 2020
late. I have known Alan since I was         the grounds of the Singapore Zoological      “Are you sure this is an Asian Paradise
an undergraduate. He had pursued            Gardens, the zoo’s coffers became            Flycatcher? It has an inverted U band…
this bird since the 1990s. I could          enriched as photographers and bird-          why don’t you ask for opinions?” Such a
commiserate with his angst. We              ers paid their dues – some paying for        message from Francis cannot be ignored.
trundled along the path next to the         year-long membership fees for photos         After all, my ex-classmate has evolved
drain where the bird was last seen.         of the uncommon beauty at the Douc           into one of the top birders of Singapore,
Everyone we met told us we missed the       Langur’s enclosure.                          if not the region. I did as Francis had
bird. Then, someone suggested taking               It was about a week after the bird    suggested and went to bed.
a look at the fields along Harvest Lane     was no longer seen that I found time to            The next day, I saw a string of
and Turut Track. We followed this piece     visit the Zoo. Armed with a corporate        comments by expert birders from
of advice, sloshing our way across the      pass from my office, I trooped to the        around the region. Each had affirmed
rain-sodden field without any real hope.    enclosure with three other birding           that my dark and drab Paradise
       Suddenly, a medium sized bird        friends without much hope.                   Flycatcher was a female Japanese. I
took to the air, screaming and hurling             We saw the resident Blue-eared        was elated. As a birder on a Big Year,
abuse. It had a grey body and longish       Kingfisher (Alcedo meninting), and had a     it didn’t matter whether I had seen
wings that had a white trailing edge and    good view of a Rufous-tailed Tailorbird      the resplendent male or the drab and
black primaries. Alan could not contain     (Orthotomus sericeus) that spent an          obscure female. All that mattered was
his excitement. Like fumbling guards        uncharacteristically long time in the open   that I secured my tick and Bird #192.
trying to apprehend an escaped prisoner,    for us to take sufficient photographs
we raised our cameras and fired away        before we lazily walked to the Douc
desperately, hoping that the settings       Langur enclosure. Several Asian Paradise       3 DEC 2016
were correct as the Lapwing flew away.      Flycatchers (Terpsiphone paradise) were
Alan laughed. The look on his face          lounging around in the vegetation and        The day I crossed the 200th mark.
was priceless. He had finally nailed his    took to the wing when they saw us.           Reports of a confiding Dark-sided
nemesis, my Bird #185.                      I took a few photos of one bird that         Flycatcher (Muscicapa sibirica), a non-
                                            appeared darker, and after ensuring that     descript brown bird, wafted over social
                                            the Japanese Paradise Flycatcher was         media during the week. The bird was
 14 NOV 2016                                absent, left the zoo’s grounds.              last found on Friday at Bidadari’s hill-
                                                   I posted the photo of the             ock, where a large arch of creepers grew
The male Japanese Paradise Flycatcher       aberrant flycatcher on Facebook              over what seemed to be part of a tree.
(Terpsiphone atrocauda) is an attractive    that evening, labelling it as an Asian       I dutifully made my way to the former
creature with a blue ring around its eyes   Paradise Flycatcher. As I shut down          cemetery on Saturday morning.
and its mantle is a rich purplish hue.      the computer, I received a text message             I spotted several other hunters
When one specimen appeared inside           from Francis Yap, who cryptically wrote:     near the misty hillock, all converging

Grey-headed Lapwing. Photo: Keita Sin                              Japanese Paradise Flycatcher, female. Photo: Con Foley

                                                                                                   Jan – Mar 2020 Nature Watch 9
on the bird’s last known spot. Everyone          11 forDEC
                                               estate         2016
                                                        Singaporeans.                    size of a small-built Javan Myna. The
I passed quietly shook their heads.                                                      subspecies (P.s. sordida) that inhabits
Above us, sunbirds and other small birds       With 200 birds in my pocket, and the      our shores during the northern winter
stirred and chirruped as they foraged in       year coming to an end, I was desperate    has a jet-black head topped with a
the damp morning. An orange-yellow             to press as far as I could before New     deep chocolate brown crown, and a
spark high up in the trees caught my           Year’s Eve ended at 2359 hours. There     body set in shimmering green. A bright
attention. The fiery colours turned out        was, however, a hitch.                    red pair of pants completes this Pitta’s
to be a migrating Mugimaki Flycatcher                During my perambulations around     magnificent outfit.
(Ficedula mugimaki)! The males are jet         Bidadari, I accumulated more than 20             It was Saturday evening when I
black above, with a snowy white spot           mosquito bites. Besides conferring me     managed to stagger out of home. The
behind the eye, a flash of white across        with an insatiable desire to scratch,     short walk out from my flat, down the
black wings and white panels on the            the insects also gave me a sensation of   lift and to the car took a lot from me. I
outer tail feathers, and a brilliant orange-   weakness and a dull ache that radiated    felt dizzy as I started the car engine and
yellow underside. Everyone was happy           from the bones.                           drove at 50km/h for what felt like an
with the sighting.                                   As waves of chills broke over my    eternity to the Botanic Gardens. I made
       I continued stumbling about             head, I received news of the arrival of   my way painfully towards the Ginger
until I saw someone hunched over his           a Hooded Pitta (Pitta sordida) at the     Garden. With my energy waning, I
camera. Others nearer him followed             Singapore Botanic Gardens. Pittas are     knew I could not spend more than 30
suit. There was something low on the           magical balls of exquisitely coloured     minutes outside. I scanned the environs
ground that caught their attention. The        feathers that have the power to subvert   for bird photographers — the fastest
bird flitted about and perched on snags        the minds of grown men and cause          way to find any rarity in Singapore.
to sally after insects for breakfast. Then,    them to abandon sense and sensibility,           To my relief, I spotted the lanky
ironically, it landed on one of the many       driving many to dive into the deepest     form of Eric. We first met during
metal rods inserted into the hillock to        and dankest forests to search for them.   National Service. According to him,
mark out spots for destruction. It was a       Several of my friends have succumbed      I was responsible for selling his soul
poignant moment as Bird #200 sat there         to this disease. One Englishman, Chris    to birds and bird photography. While
pondering its next meal, with Bidadari         Gooddie, gave up his job in London for    serving NS, I discovered a family
on the cusp of destruction and remaking        one year because of this condition.       of Oriental Dollarbirds (Eurystomus
from a haven for birds into a housing                The Hooded Pitta is about the       orientalis) behind our camp and would

As a birder on a Big Year, it didn’t matter whether I had seen the
resplendent male or the drab and obscure female. All that mattered was
that I secured my tick.

Dark-sided Flycatcher. Photo: Keita Sin        Mugimaki Flycatcher. Photo: Con Foley     Hooded Pitta. Photo: Geoff Lim

10 Nature Watch Jan – Mar 2020
spend my free time watching them. Eric
joined me and we would share an old
pair of binoculars I brought from home.
It was years later when we met again
that I made the bizarre discovery about
his Mephistophelian moment.
       Beckoning me quietly to come
over, Eric moved his tripod-mounted
behemoth so that I could creep over to
his side. A few other souls squatted or
stood quietly, ringing the clearing full of
dried leaves. Eric peered at me from his
Coke-bottle glasses and said, “Wait for it
to come out. The bird is hungry and it’s
dinner time.”
       I looked into the gloomy
undergrowth but could not see
anything. Despite their brilliant colours,
the bright hues of the pitta allow
them to fade into the darkness of the
understory where they usually lurk to
feed and rest. Moments later, a gentle
rustle emerged from the undergrowth
and a small bejewelled bird hopped
on both legs into view. It cocked its
head to check the sky – for regular
patrols by the local Brahminy Kites
(Haliastur indus), Changeable Hawk
Eagles (Nisaetis cirrhatus) and Crested
Goshawks (Accipiter trivirgatus) –
before coming into the open to forage.
The cameras erupted in a full fury of
clattering shutters. I took about 1,280
photographs of Bird #201 and left at
6.15pm, satisfied but feeling far worse
                                              Oriental Darter. Photo: Con Foley
than I had begun.
                                              France to spend her year-end holidays     Flycatcher (Cyornis rufigastra), the Black
                                              with our daughter. One evening, I         Hornbill (Anthracoceros malayanus)
 23 DEC 2016                                  casually asked if she wanted to visit     and the Oriental Darter (Anhinga
The illness left me on my back and I          Pulau Ubin. Her equally casual reply of   melanogaster).
lost a precious 11 days, which includ-        “Why not?” set me in motion as I began          We arrived at Ketam and spread
ed a visit to a hospital Emergency            to text my usual posse of birding kakis   ourselves along the road, straining our
Department. The unusual infection had         my battle plan.                           ears to hear the faintest call of the Pitta.
somehow taken hold of my heart and                   The plan was simple – catch              (Backtrack to the mid 1990s when
caused it to pound madly at the slightest     the first ferry to increase our chances   I accompanied Subaraj during an Ubin
exertion. Vials of blood taken from my        of spotting birds and scurry to the       bird survey to a patch of mangroves. As
veins ruled out Chikugungya, Dengue           mangroves of Ketam, near the shrine of    we paused to catch our breath under the
and Zika. Before we could proceed with        the German girl, before visiting Chek     hot afternoon sun, the wildlife expert
further tests, I recovered.                   Jawa, and Pekan Quarry. I only had        pointed to a spot where the Mangrove
       By this time, Apolline, our            four target birds – the Mangrove Pitta    Pitta was last seen ten years before.
goddaughter flew over from faraway            (Pitta megarhyncha), the Mangrove Blue    Barely seconds after that, a faint and

                                                                                                  Jan – Mar 2020 Nature Watch 11
distant tu-whill, tu-whill! rang out from    about 300m away from the Chek Jawa            for a Siberian Blue Robin (Larvivora
the mangroves. Subaraj went mad with         Visitor Centre.                               cyane), Turut Track for anything
excitement. We did not manage to see                After determining that the             unticked, and the southern coastline to
the bird, but it had clearly announced its   Flycatcher was nowhere to be found, we        check out the rumour of a Mangrove
return to Singapore’s shores.)               returned to meet Ah Teik, our appointed       Blue Flycatcher (Cyornis rufigastra).
      As we savoured the sulphurous          taxi driver, who drove us to Pekan                   At Venus Drive, there was not
fragrance emanating from the sticky          Quarry. By then, the sun was hotter and       even a single photographer present
substrate around us, we were unsure if       a bright shimmer reflected off the waters     when we reached the “studio” – an
we would spot the bird. Several anxious      of the disused granite quarry. I scanned      overhang comprising tangled branches
minutes passed in silence. Then we           the tall trees beyond the quarry, hoping      and creepers shading a floor as clean as a
heard it – the distant two-note call. I      to see the solitary Black Hornbill on         bowerbird’s display. At Turut Track and
made feeble attempts to mimic the bird       the island. Alas, the hornbills that flew     Kranji, we scanned for the Black-backed
with whistles that matched its tones,        around had the distinctive white under        Swamphen (Porphyrio indicus), wagtails
unsure if the ruse would work. Then we       parts of the Oriental Pied Hornbill           and harriers. I decided to take a pot shot
saw a moderately sized bird hurtle into      (Anthracoceros albirostris).                  at a flock of feeding egrets dotting the
the mid-canopy of a nearby tree. The                Tired from the heat, I scanned the     greenery in the distance. Then, we left
creature paused and hopped into denser       far side of the quarry, hoping to spot the    for the southern coast. Our arrival at
foliage, and a loud tu-whill, tu-whill       scrawny, black Oriental Darter. Related       the appointed spot revealed only silent
rang out from within.                        to cormorants, the darter hunts for fish      trees swaying in the wind. Though I had
      I was surprised to see the bird        by swimming half-submerged. Only its          bagged nothing, I was nevertheless glad
so high up in the tree; I had expected       snake-like neck and head are seen above       for Ben’s kind gesture.
to see it skulking and low in the            the waterline, making it difficult to spot.          While waiting for New Year’s Eve
undergrowth like other Pittas. Little        But if it perched to dry its wet feathers,    dinner to be ready, I combed through
did I know that this was its hallmark.       it would be fairly visible. It was Alvin’s    the photographs taken that morning,
By calling from mid-canopy, the bird         eagle eyes that spotted the thin bird         quite sure I would not have anything
ensured that its song would reverberate      perched far away on dead branches. I          new. I came to the photographs of the
far and wide across the mangroves,           strained my eyes to locate it. And there      feeding egrets at Kranji. Among the
thereby informing other interlopers to       Bird #204 was – its pale, sinuous neck        Little Egrets, one stood out.
keep clear of its territory.                 resembling one of the branches, while                It was larger than the Little Egrets,
      The Mangrove Pitta superficially       its black body melted into the shadows        which were also distinguishable by their
resembles the Blue-winged Pitta (Pitta       behind it.                                    black beaks, black legs and yellow feet.
moluccensis), another gem that migrates             At the end of the day, our             Mine was slightly larger, had a yellow
into Singapore during the tropical           goddaughter Apolline agreed that our          beak with a little dark colouration at
winter. The Blue-winged has a black          madcap hunt produced an adrenaline            the tips, and black legs. After conferring
mask across its eyes and bears a mixture     rush even for a non-birder like her. I        with a few seasoned watchers, I
of sandy colours along with a brilliant      was mollified.                                concluded that I had managed to end
panel of blue across the wings, and                                                        the year with an Intermediate Egret
an obligatory pair of red pants. This                                                      (Egretta intermedia), my Bird #206. I
Mangrove Pitta feeds on mangrove              31 DEC 2016                                  shut down the computer and joined my
                                                                                           family for a much-needed break from
crabs, and is armed with a massive bill
that would cause grief to any crustacean.    The year drew to a wet close. I had           the crazed chase.
      Flushed with success, we raced         managed to spot #205, a Black-capped
towards Chek Jawa, where we heard a          Kingfisher (Halcyon pileata) when we          Geoff Lim started birding when he was
White-rumped Shama singing from the          had taken Apolline to the zoo the pre-        10. He read Zoology at the National
dark trees outside the gates, and hoped      vious day.                                    University of Singapore, and is a rabid
to see the Mangrove Blue Flycatcher                Dawn arrived on New Year’s Eve,         birder. Family and career as a civil
amongst the mangroves closer to the          2016, accompanied by a drizzle. Ben,          servant took its toll for about two decades.
coast. After much effort, we only            an old friend who had been banging            Possibly due to his influence, his wife now
managed to see another Mangrove              away at his PhD dissertation in England,      looks out for birds, while their daughter
Pitta, as well as several Grey Plover        said he wanted to take me on a spin to        has written two picture books about birds
(Pluvialis squatarola) perched with          improve my score. In his Landrover, we        and is now a life sciences undergraduate.
other shorebirds at Seduku Rocks,            drove to familiar locations – Venus Drive

12 Nature Watch Jan – Mar 2020
W I L D L I F E         T R A D E

Singapore’s domestic
and international
parrot markets
Does the international parrot trade coming through Singapore feed the growth of
parrot hobbyists? A recent peer-reviewed article* attempted to pull together and
evaluate relevant data. Here Anuj Jain, Scott Aloysius, Yong Ding Li and Jessica
Lee outline some of the findings.

African Grey Parrot (Psittacus erithacus). Photo: Jessica Lee

* Aloysius S.A., Yong D.L., Lee J. and Jain, A. (2019). Flying into extinction: Understanding the role of Singapore’s international parrot trade in
  growing domestic demand. Bird Conservation International, 1 – 17. doi:10.1017/S0959270919000182.
 Readers can access this paper online at https://www.researchgate.net/publication/333786246_Flying_into_extinction_Understanding_the_role_of_
 Singapore%27s_international_parrot_trade_in_growing_domestic_demand

                                                                                                                     Jan – Mar 2020 Nature Watch 13
S
                outheast Asia’s bird trade                                               as captive-bred, some imports had been
                has been of global conser-                                               declared as wild-caught. Earlier studies
                vation concern for many                                                  have presumed that the differences in
                years as it is known to have                                             overall numbers must lie in problems
                massively depleted wild                                                  with certification or with the trade
populations of many species. Parrots                                                     data, and some birds being retained
(Order Psittaciformes) have become espe-                                                 for breeding stock. But the recent
cially vulnerable — they are the most                                                    visibility of local parrot hobbyist groups,
heavily traded group of birds globally                                                   particularly when flying their birds out
under the Convention on International                                                    in public parks, suggests that possibly
Trade in Endangered Species (CITES)                                                      the explanation lies in the demand for
lists. At the same time, Singapore’s                                                     parrots in the local trade.
involvement as a transhipment hub                                                               A number of past surveys of bird
in this global pet bird trade has been                                                   shops exist, although each carried out
equally well known and documented,                                                       with different methods. The general
and again particularly for parrots.                                                      findings were that the majority of birds
       What has not always been so well                                                  sold by volume in Singapore’s pet shops
documented or consistently quantified is                                                 were songbirds, but that various species
                                               Indian Ring-necked Parakeets
the extent of local bird trading, although     (Psittacula krameri). Photo: Anuj Jain
                                                                                         of parrots made up around 40% of
some studies of birds in pet shops have                                                  total bird species recorded in the shops.
been made in the last decade. Even             The reduction of bird                     The most common parrots, in terms of
less is known about the links between          trade in Europe now                       quantity sold, included the Budgerigar
the international trade in and out of                                                    (Melopsittacus undulatus), Cockatiel
Singapore and the domestic trade in            makes Singapore                           (Nymphicus hollandicus) and Monk
birds kept for personal hobby purposes.        far more important                        Parakeet (Myiopsitta monachus), which
The present study attempts to quantify                                                   are all not CITES-listed. However, the
                                               in the global trade                       majority of parrot species on sale were
this relationship by comparing bird
trade data on the CITES database with          further strengthening                     CITES-listed.
the past market surveys of pet shops,          Singapore’s position                             Furthermore, parrots comprised
and then complement this quantitative                                                    a substantial proportion (44.4%) of
analysis with semi-structured interviews
                                               as a transhipment hub                     threatened birds recorded in pet shops
with 30 parrot owners in Singapore.            as more and more                          that have possibly been wild caught and
       We first reviewed the Singapore         trade is channelled                       trafficked into the country. They include
import and export data of CITES-listed                                                   the Yellow-crested Cockatoo (Cacatua
birds for the period 2005 to 2016. We do       into the region.                          sulphurea) and African Grey Parrot
not often expect to hear good news about                                                 (Psittacus erithacus).
international wildlife trade, but in fact,     Singapore’s position as a transhipment           In addition, a study of wildlife
due to actions taken by the European           hub as more and more trade is             trade advertisements on online
Union (EU) in 2005 to ban all trade            channelled into the region.               platforms by Animal Concerns
in wild-caught birds, there has been a               Over the same period, because of    Research and Education Society
huge decline in the total imports into         the EU ban and similar bans in other      (ACRES) found that a significant
Singapore and exports from Singapore of        countries globally, the major countries   proportion (273 out of 655; 41.7%)
CITES-listed species of birds from 2005        from which imports originate have         involved were CITES-listed birds.
to 2016 (see Figure 1A and B).                 varied each year and may well continue
       However, the vast majority of the       to do so. The top three import and        Interviews with parrot owners
birds that are now traded are parrots          export countries for Singapore from       Between January and August 2017, we
and the proportion of parrots in the           2005 – 2016 is shown in Figure 2.         conducted 30 semi-structured interviews
total trade has increased year on year.              Of additional concern is the        with parrot owners. They included two
So, whilst the decline gives hope for          difference between the import and         local parrot breeders, a founder of a
the future, there is still much to be          export figures for Singapore. Over the    local parrot hobbyist group and two
concerned about. In fact, the reduction        period 2005 – 2016, 54,207 fewer          parrot sitters. The interviews explored
of bird trade in Europe now makes              birds were exported than imported,        the factors that drive the demand for
Singapore far more important in the            and although all CITES-listed birds       parrots in Singapore by asking the fol-
global trade, further strengthening            exported from Singapore were declared     lowing questions:

14 Nature Watch Jan – Mar 2020
1. Why do you think parrots are
                                            Figure 1: (a)
   increasingly popular as pets in
   Singapore? If you belong to a parrot     Imports and exports of CITES-listed birds and CITES-
   hobbyist community, please elaborate     listed parrots from 2005 to 2016
   how you were introduced and the
   activities conducted?

2. Which factors motivate you to keep
   parrot(s)?

3. What are your main considerations
   when purchasing a parrot?

       A detailed description of the
interview results and analysis will be
covered in a separate study. Here, we
present results that explore the changing
ownership trends in Singapore and how       Figure 1: (b)

it relates to the country’s international   Imports minus exports of CITES-listed birds and
trade of parrots. Interviewees were         CITES-listed parrots from 2005 to 2016
numbered from 1 to 30 based on the
date of the interview. Selected quotes by
parrot owners who were interviewed are
listed in the box on page 17.
       Interviews with parrot owners in
Singapore revealed that pet shops and
hobbyist groups in Singapore function
as key platforms that influence the
public to keep parrots, and sometimes
on impulse. Parrot hobbyist group
events such as the free flying of parrots
in the open are especially effective at
attracting interest from passers-by.        A local breeder shared that although the majority
These groups also leverage social media
to draw attention and recruit members.
                                            of parrots sold consist of the smaller, non-CITES
Hobbyist group members agreed that          listed parrots such as budgerigars and cockatiels,
the number of hobbyist groups and           the demand for larger parrots has also increased.
membership within these groups have
increased over the past five years.         (Anodorhynchus hyacinthinus) — have         data in a separate article, we hope
       A local breeder who we               increased by 50% in Singapore from          that the authorities continue to
interviewed shared that although the        2001 to 2016. Furthermore, some             tighten checks on import and export
majority of parrots sold consist of the     owners purchase additional parrots as       certifications to have a firmer grasp on
smaller, non-CITES listed parrots           companions for their first parrots.         the present trade and to ensure that
such as budgerigars and cockatiels,               Local breeders also state that        wild-caught birds are not traded locally
the demand for larger parrots has also      parrots are the most expensive birds sold   or internationally through Singapore.
increased. Interviewees also shared         in Singapore, with their price ranging      The domestic demand for parrots may
that some parrot owners keep smaller        from SGD200 to SGD40,000. This              have been previously underestimated
parrots to gain handling experience         is consistent with anecdotal records        and it needs to be more comprehensively
before progressing to larger parrots.       that suggest the Hyacinth Macaw             documented. We suggest that to
The breeder confirmed the growing           was the most expensive bird, priced         manage Singapore’s international and
anecdotal evidence which suggests           between SGD35,000 (USD26,170) to            domestic pet bird trade, there needs
that macaw sales — including that           SGD40,000 (USD30,000) in 2014.              to be a more regulated licensing and
of threatened species such as the                  While we will present a              records system to track the movement of
globally vulnerable Hyacinth Macaw          comprehensive analysis of the interview     all traded birds.

                                                                                                 Jan – Mar 2020 Nature Watch 15
Figure 2

Singapore's top import and export countries/territories for CITES listed parrots
from 2005 to 2016

Tanimbar Corella (Cacatua goffiniana) and Sun Conures (Aratinga    A Hyacinth Macaw (Anodorhynchus hyacinthinus) can
solstitialis) on display at a parrot hobbyist group gathering in   fetch up to S$40,000 in Singapore. Photo: Bjorn Olesen
Singapore. Photo: Anuj Jain

16 Nature Watch Jan – Mar 2020
The Nature Society (Singapore)
                                                                                     is currently producing a position
Selected quotes from parrot owners, interviewed
                                                                                     paper, with support from BirdLife
during the study, highlighting their motivations and                                 International, on the state of Singapore’s
perceptions towards parrot keeping in Singapore                                      parrot trade. The paper raises concerns
Note: Quotes have been deliberately left unedited.                                   over the growing trade and parrot
                                          “Birds, can fly and come back, the         keeping trends and offers specific
                                           thrill of that got people interested,     recommendations for stakeholders
                                           they think it is very cool.”              to ensure the sustainability of parrot
                                                                                     populations for future generations.
                                             Use of social media
                                          “Through social media many are
                                           introduced and made aware of a            Acknowledgements
                                           parrot’s capability and how cute,         The authors thank Margie Hall who
                                           adorable, and intelligent they are.”
                                                                                     helped produce this shortened version of
                                          “There is greater awareness on             the original paper for Nature Watch.
                                           parrots because of the Facebook
                                           group created, more parrot                Anuj Jain has a passion for birds,
                                           owners can get together, it is like a     butterflies and biomimicry. He obtained
                                           community.”
                                                                                     his doctorate in conservation biology from
                                                                                     the National University of Singapore. Anuj
                                             Upgrading to larger parrots
                                          “Some people start off with small          currently works for BirdLife International
                                           parrots, to train their ability to care   on Asia’s threatened birds impacted by the
                                           for parrots then upgrade to bigger        illegal wildlife trade. He has been involved
                                           parrots”.                                 in many conservation and education
                                                                                     projects through NSS for over a decade.
                                             Purchasing companion pets
Blue-fronted Amazon (Amazona              “I wanted to find a male companion
                                           for my female bird”                       Scott Aloysius studied Environmental
aestiva). Photo: Jessica Lee
                                                                                     Biology at the National University of
                                          “To have only one bird is quite sad        Singapore. His research interests include
   Role of pet shops                       so I got a second one, to accom-
“My friend brought me to a pet
                                                                                     ecology, conservation and wildlife trade. He
                                           pany my first one”                        is an editorial contributor for Earth.Org
 shop and I ended up buying two
 cockatiels.”                                                                        and The Economist Intelligence Unit (EIU).

“When I went to the pet shop I had                                                   Yong Ding Li obtained his doctorate in
 no intention to buy the parrot but
                                                                                     conservation biology from the Australian
 the longer I was there, I knew I would
 come out buying something.”                                                         National University. He currently works
                                                                                     full time for BirdLife International
   Impulse buying                                                                    coordinating work on migratory birds
“I went to the bird shop to buy                                                      in Asia. Ding Li has been involved
 bird food, I actually had zero                                                      with the NSS’s bird group for 20 years,
 intention of getting a bird but
                                                                                     and currently coordinates its annually-
 then saw one at a bird shop and it
 looked so cute.”                                                                    organised Singapore Parrot Count.

“People in the parrot community use                                                  Jessica Lee spent most of her life
 the word “poison”. They play up the                                                 growing up with parrot adoptees. Her
 positive aspects of the birds and                                                   passion for parrots led her to a PhD in
 not the negatives, like the cost”
                                                                                     parrot conservation in Australia and her
   Getting passers-by interested
                                                                                     work with BirdLife Australia. She now
 “When parrot owners meet non-                                                       works for Wildlife Reserves Singapore,
parrot owners during events, the                                                     coordinating research and wildlife
non-parrot owners will get to see         African Grey Parrots (Psittacus            conservation efforts in Singapore and
the parrots start getting interested      erithacus) are popular for their           across Southeast Asia, with a particular
in keeping parrots.”                      ability to mimic human voices.
                                                                                     focus on parrots, hornbills and songbirds.

                                                                                               Jan – Mar 2020 Nature Watch 17
I N   M E M O R I A M

                   Subaraj Rajathurai
                                              16 April 1963 – 22 Oct 2019

                       Text by Morten Strange Photos courtesy of the Subaraj family

    14 March 1986, a Singapore                       I travelled with Subaraj many    some PhDs, not just about birds but
    birdwatching team were on their           times after that first expedition: to   about every type of animal you can
    way back from Endau-Rompin in             Batam Island, Fraser’s Hill, Kuala      think of including insects, mammals,
    Johor, Malaysia, where we had spent       Gula, Kukup and more trips to Panti     reptiles, frogs, freshwater fishes as well
    a week or so surveying the rainforest     forest, Johor, than I can remem-        as the environment they live in. He
    and preparing a bird checklist for the    ber. Throughout the years, I saw        was also an accomplished scuba diver
    future national park. I took this photo   how Subaraj’s knowledge and skills      who could competently identify fish,
    (below, right) as we were about to        improved; he was a poster boy for the   crustaceans and nudibranches on the
    leave the jungle camp; I was the only     lifelong learning concept. Without      coral reefs in the region.
    one in jeans, the others wore shorts      a formal degree, he knew more than            Subaraj turned his passion into
    for the hike across rivers and streams
    back to the main road. The other team
    members were Lim Kim Chuah, Lim
    Kim Seng, R. Subaraj, See Swee Leng
    and Sunny Yeo. Several decades later,
    this image “went viral” because one of
    us had become famous. In the years
    following the Endau-Rompin expedi-
    tion, each one of us contributed in
    important ways to nature appreciation
    and conservation through photog-
    raphy, book publishing, authorship,
    event management, handcraft making,
    teaching and guiding. Subaraj went on
    to become one of the most prominent       The then Malaysian Nature Society (Singapore Branch) Bird Group team at
    contemporary naturalists in Singapore.    Endau-Rompin, Johor, in 1986. Photo: Morten Strange

18 Nature Watch Jan – Mar 2020
his job, and way ahead of his time           tancy and international film projects.          VIPs. He treated everyone the same
became Singapore’s first licensed nature           At some stage during the early            way, with humility, humour and
guide. Through the years, and with his       2000s, Subaraj was short of a driver            respect, and he simply just loved to
company Strix Wildlife Consultancy, he       to take him out with clients, and I             be out there and share his incredible
established himself as one of the most       would sometimes step in as chauffeur            knowledge and experience. Subaraj
respected wildlife consultants in the        and assistant bird guide. Subaraj was           was an ardent conservationist, an
country. He managed to provide well          incredible at this. He had exceptional          active founding member of Nature
for his family, but he did not distinguish   people skills and could get along with          Society (Singapore)’s Vertebrate Study
between business and pleasure; he mere-      everyone: eco-tourists of all races             Group and he offered his time freely to
ly did what came naturally to him and        and ages (some a bit demanding and              surveys and campaigns during virtually
reached thousands through his work           difficult in my view, but never in              every NSS nature conservation effort
with guiding, teaching, surveys, consul-     Subaraj’s!), as well as school kids and         since the 1980s.

From left: Subaraj with one of his 1980s Singapore Bird Race teams: Dr Rexon Ngim, Iain Ewing and Sutari bin Supari; with
Emeritus Senior Minister Goh Chok Tong and Minister for Social and Family Development and Second Minister for National
Development Desmond Lee; at Fraser’s Hill with son Serin.

BIG HEART FOR NATURE
Just back from a hospital check-up the day before,               “I was privileged to meet him a few times, and enjoyed our conver-
Subaraj died peacefully in his sleep on 22 October 2019,          sations. His passing is a great loss to nature lovers in Singapore.”
                                                                  Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong
while his wife Shamla had stepped out to get lunch. He
was only 56 years old; the big heart simply stopped. The         “His advocacy was gentle yet persuasive. Many natural habitats
whole nature community in Singapore was in a state of             have survived and thrived because of his work – Sungei Buloh,
utter shock; the funeral the next day was dignified and           Pulau Ubin, Bukit Timah Nature Reserve.”
                                                                  Former Minister Mah Bow Tan
amazingly organised, but also one of the saddest occa-
sions I have ever participated in. Subaraj’s passing was         “He was a dear friend of NParks, and I am honoured and blessed
such a sudden loss to all of us who knew him.                     to call him my friend as well. For over 35 years, Subaraj worked
                                                                  tirelessly towards the conservation of Singapore’s natural heritage.
    You cannot mention Subaraj without mentioning his
                                                                  Rest assured we will continue your good work.”
devoted wife and lifelong friend and business partner             Minister Desmond Lee
Shamla, as well as their two amazing sons Saker (19) and
Serin (24). The three of them organised a memorial event         “Singapore and nature lovers have lost a great asset and we a very
                                                                  dear friend.”
at Sungei Buloh Wetland Reserve on 24 November. It was            D r W e e Y e o w C h i n & R i ch a r d H a l e
attended by a selected group of family, friends, naturalists
and nature conservationists from Singapore and Malaysia.         “His heart was always about protecting Singapore’s nature.”
                                                                  Ad r i a n L o o N ational P ar k s B oard
While the funeral had been sombre and heartbreaking,
the memorial was uplifting and joyful, a serious, yet jubi-      “Each teacher who had the pleasure to watch him work his magic
lant and at times elated celebration of Subaraj’s life and        learned from him. His gift to thousands of students and hundreds
accomplishments. Even though the event was graced by              of teachers will be passed forward to future generations.”
                                                                  Al i c e a n d S t e v e E a r ly Sin g apore A meri c an S c hool
Minister Desmond Lee and former Minister Mah Bow Tan
as well as other VIPs, there was a refreshing lack of proto-     “He loved Singapore, a patriot who wanted to help create a balance
col during the proceedings with everyone mingling freely          between development and preservation.”
on a first-name basis – completely in Subaraj’s spirit.           Sh a m l a S u b a r a j

    For the occasion, the family had printed a marvellous
                                                                 “I will uphold his legacy and I will ensure that the knowledge he
68-page illustrated booklet about Subaraj and his life.           passed on to me will be passed on to the next generation.”
Here are a few selected quotes from the book:                     Serin Subaraj

                                                                                                         Jan – Mar 2020 Nature Watch 19
You can also read