The Adjunctive Use of Ketamine in Severe Alcohol Withdrawal - September 14, 2018 Hope Randle, PharmD PGY1 Pharmacy Resident Seton Healthcare ...

Page created by Marc Norris
 
CONTINUE READING
The Adjunctive Use of Ketamine in Severe Alcohol Withdrawal - September 14, 2018 Hope Randle, PharmD PGY1 Pharmacy Resident Seton Healthcare ...
The Adjunctive Use of Ketamine in
   Severe Alcohol Withdrawal
          September 14, 2018

         Hope Randle, PharmD
        PGY1 Pharmacy Resident
        Seton Healthcare Family
     Christina.randle@ascension.org
The Adjunctive Use of Ketamine in Severe Alcohol Withdrawal - September 14, 2018 Hope Randle, PharmD PGY1 Pharmacy Resident Seton Healthcare ...
Conflict of Interest
 ASCENSION TEXAS

                                                                The author of this presentation has no conflicts of interest to
 The Adjunctive Use of Ketamine in Severe                       disclose.
 Alcohol Withdrawal

 Hope Randle, PharmD
 PGY1 Pharmacy Resident
 Seton Healthcare Family
 September 14, 2018

                                                                 2

Objectives                                                      Patient Case

• Review the pathophysiology of and current treatment           DD is a 28 yo caucasian male, presenting to
  recommendations for Alcohol Withdrawal Syndrome
  (AWS)                                                         the ED from home with increased agitation
                                                                and new onset hand tremor
• Discuss the pharmacologic properties of ketamine as an
  adjunctive agent to current treatment therapies
                                                                • HPI: Patient drinks 12 Lone Stars per day and started a
                                                                  cleanse 3 days ago. His wife brought him to the hospital
• Analyze current literature evaluating the use of ketamine       because he was shaking and seeing things.
  in severe AWS
                                                                • He is diagnosed with alcohol withdrawal in the ED and
                                                                  started on a symptom-triggered benzodiazepine therapy
• Evaluate the potential role of ketamine in the treatment of
  severe AWS

 3                                                               4

                                                                Alcohol Withdrawal

                                                                • Alcohol related disorders affect 7% of the US population

                                                                • 25% of adults had at least one heavy drinking day in the
                                                                  past year
        Alcohol Withdrawal Syndrome
                   (AWS)                                        • 500,000 episodes of alcohol withdrawal requiring
                                                                  treatment each year

                                                                • Estimated cost per year: $223.5 billion

                                                                     CDC 2015 National Health Interview Summary
                                                                     Stehman et al. Am J Emerg Med. 2013;31:734-42 .
 5                                                               6
                                                                     Mayo-Smith et al. Arch Intern Med. 2004;164:1405-11.
                                                                     Walker et al. J Trauma Acute Care Surg. 2013;74(3):926-31.
The Adjunctive Use of Ketamine in Severe Alcohol Withdrawal - September 14, 2018 Hope Randle, PharmD PGY1 Pharmacy Resident Seton Healthcare ...
Alcohol                                                                        Pathophysiology of Alcohol Withdrawal

• CNS depressant
                                                                                                           NMDA receptors                                              GABA receptors

• Gamma-amino-butyric acid (GABA)
  proliferation
      - Increased inhibitory effects
                                                                                                                GABA                                                     GABA
• N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) inhibition                                                                      inhibition                                               receptors
      - Decreased excitatory action

• Manifestations: sedation, impaired
  decision making, loss of balance,
  dizziness, nausea, vomiting

 7    Valenzuela, Fernando, MD. Alcohol Health and Research                     8                   Littleton, J, MD. Alc Health and Research World; 1998, 22(1).
      World; 21 (2), 1997.

Pathophysiology of Alcohol Withdrawal                                          Alcohol Withdrawal

              NMDA receptors                                  GABA receptors
                                                                                Symptom Intensity

                   NMDA                                         NMDA
                 excitation                                   receptors

 9     Biology of the NMDA Receptor Chapter 4: The NMDA                        10
       Receptor and Alcohol Addiction                                                               Jose R Maldonado, MD. Crit Care Clin, 2017, Jul; 33(3); 559-599.

Assessment of Alcohol Withdrawal Severity                                      Management of Alcohol Withdrawal
• Clinical Institute Withdrawal Assessment (CIWA-Ar)
      - Scored 0 – 67 based on symptoms                                        • Supportive care: electrolytes, IV fluids, folic acid, thiamine
      - Agitation, anxiety, visual/auditory disturbances
      - < 8 (mild), 8 – 15 (moderate), > 16 (severe)
      - Also used to monitor withdrawal progression                            • Benzodiazepines (BZD)
                                                                                         - Symptom-triggered (based on CIWA score)
• Withdrawal Assessment Scale (WAS)                                                      - Fixed tapered dosing regimen
     - Scored 0 – 96 based on symptoms
     - Temperature, heart rate, respiratory rate, blood pressure
     - Protocol attaches directions to scores                                  • Adverse effects of BZDs
          • < 10 no action needed
          • 10 – 14: prn BZD                                                             - Respiratory depression
          • > 14: prn BZD, call physician for reassessment                               - Sedation
                                                                                         - Delirium
  • Motor Activity Assessment Scale (MAAS)
       - Scored 0 (unresponsive) to 6 (agitated, uncooperative)
       - Based on patient responsiveness and activity
 11   See Appendix C, D, and E                                                 12                   Jose R Maldonado, MD. Crit Care Clin, 2017 July; 33(3): 559-599
      British Journal of Addiction
The Adjunctive Use of Ketamine in Severe Alcohol Withdrawal - September 14, 2018 Hope Randle, PharmD PGY1 Pharmacy Resident Seton Healthcare ...
Management of Alcohol Withdrawal                                                           DD

Refractory Alcohol Withdrawal (RAW)                                                        • Hospital Course:
• Requirement of > 40 mg of diazepam (or diazepam                                            - HPI: alcohol abuse
  equivalents) within 1 hour                                                                 - Admitted to ICU with diagnosis of AWS with delirium tremens (DTs)
                                                                                             - Tremor significantly worsened
• Treatment options
                                                                                              - CIWA Score: 25
       Agent                                 Mechanism of      Concerns                       - 50mg diazepam in the last 60 minutes
                                             action
                                                                                              - Symptoms largely unimproved at this time
       Phenobarbital                         GABA agonist      Respiratory depression,
                                                               bradycardia, hypotension
       Dexmedetomidine                       α2 agonist        Hypotension, bradycardia,         -What's next?
                                                               lacks seizure protection
       Propofol                              GABA agonist      Hypotension, respiratory
                                             NMDA antagonist   depression

 13   See Appendix B                                                                        14
      Gold et al. Crit Care Med. 2007; 35: 724 – 730

                                                                                                   What's wrong with the current
                                                                                                 treatment of alcohol withdrawal?
                                                                                                                        BZD over-usage
                                                                                                                        → Risk of over-sedation
                                                                                                                        → Mechanical ventilation
                                                                                                                        → Longer ICU/hospital stay
                                                                                                                        → Increased cost of treatment
                                                                                                                        → Increased risk of infection

 15   September 7, 2018                                                                     16

                                                                                           Ketamine
                                                                                           Mechanism of action: NMDA receptor antagonist
      Can adjunctive use of ketamine in
      severe AWS improve outcomes?

                                                                                                                           ketamine

 17                                                                                         18    Abdallah et al. Depression Anxiety, 2016 Aug; 33(8); 689-97
The Adjunctive Use of Ketamine in Severe Alcohol Withdrawal - September 14, 2018 Hope Randle, PharmD PGY1 Pharmacy Resident Seton Healthcare ...
Ketamine                                                          Clinical Concerns
Onset: IV effect within 30 seconds
Duration: 5 – 10 minutes
                                                                  Could the dissociative effects of ketamine
Metabolism: hepatic via N-dealkylation
                                                                  worsen symptoms?
Elimination: urine (91%)

Side effects: hypertension, tachycardia, dissociative reactions   Could ketamine’s activating side effects be
Contraindications: known or suspected schizophrenia               offset by BZD use?

Pros:
• Novel, disease state specific mechanism of action
• Short half life
                                                                  How would ketamine use affect CIWA scoring?
• No respiratory depression

 19    Per the American College of Emergency Physicians            20
       Ketamine Package Insert. Par Pharmaceuticals. 2012.

                                                                  Literature Summary
                                                                                    Wong et. al. (n=23)                   Shah et. al. (n=30)   Pizon et. al. (n=63)
                                                                  Population

                                                                  Initiation
                                                                  Duration
        Evidence for adjunctive ketamine                          Dose

                      use
                                                                  Adjunctive
                                                                  agents

                                                                  Outcomes

                                                                  Side
                                                                  Effects

 21                                                                22    Wong et al. Ann Pharmacother, Jan 2015; 49(1):14-9
                                                                         Shah et al. Journ of Med Tox. Sept 2018; 14(3), 229 – 236..
                                                                         Pizon et al. Crit Care Med, aug 2018. 46(8); e768-e771.

Wong et. al.                                                      Wong et. al.

• Single center retrospective cohort study (n=23)                 • RAW: 40mg diazepam / 1 hour
• Purpose: Evaluate the safety and efficacy of ketamine for       • Symptom-triggered BZD dosing for WAS score > 10
  the management of AWS
• Baseline characteristics:                                       Procedure
      - Primarily caucasian, middle aged, males                   • Ketamine initiation
      - 75% experienced DTs                                         - 34hr after first treatment of AWS
                                                                    - 12hr after RAW designation
      - 26% intubated
                                                                    - Continued for ~ 56 hrs
      - 100% required ICU admission for management of AWS
                                                                  • Dose: optional LD 0.3 mg/kg, continuous IV infusion (CIVI)
• Assessment scales                                                 0.2 mg/kg/hr
      - Withdrawal assessment scale (WAS)
                                                                  • Additional agents:
      - Simplified acute psychology score (SAPS)                        - Dexmedetomidine, phenobarbital, haloperidol, propofol

 23   Wong et al. Ann Pharmacother, Jan 2015; 49(1):14-9           24   Wong et al. Ann Pharmacother, Jan 2015; 49(1):14-9
The Adjunctive Use of Ketamine in Severe Alcohol Withdrawal - September 14, 2018 Hope Randle, PharmD PGY1 Pharmacy Resident Seton Healthcare ...
Wong et. al.                                                                                                Wong et. al.

                                                                                                            • Strengths:
Outcome                                                                                   Ketamine                - 83% of patients qualified with BZD resistance
Change in diazepam equivalent at 12 hrs, mg                                          - 40 (-106.7 – 21.7)         - Specialized team to handle ketamine initiation/administration
                                                                                                                  - First study assessing ketamine use in AWS
Change in diazepam equivalent at 24 hrs, mg                                           -13.3 (-86.7 - 50)
Change in WAS score                                                                     + 1 (-4.5 – 2)      • Weaknesses:
                                                                                                                  - Retrospective cohort study
Length of stay, mean days (SD)
    ICU                                                                                   6.3 (3)                 - No control group for comparison
    Hospital                                                                             12.4 (6.6)               - Lack of protocol
                                                                                                                  - Use of other adjunctive agents
Adverse events, n                                                                     1 (over-sedation)
Values reported as median (interquartile range), unless otherwise specified
ICU: intensive care unit; SD: standard deviation; WAS: withdrawal assessment scale                          • Take home points:
                                                                                                                  - No change in WAS score or sedation level from baseline
                                                                                                                  - No AWS side effects observed after ketamine initiation

 25   Wong et al. Ann Pharmacother, Jan 2015; 49(1):14-9                                                     26   Wong et al. Ann Pharmacother, Jan 2015; 49(1):14-9

Literature Summary                                                                                          Shah et. al.
                  Wong et. al. (n=23)                   Shah et. al. (n=30)      Pizon et. al. (n=63)
Population        •    26% intubated
                  •    100% admitted to                                                                     • Single center retrospective review (n=30)
                       ICU
                                                                                                            • Purpose: Evaluate the effect of adjunctive ketamine CIVI
Initiation        •    34h from diagnosis
Duration          •    56h                                                                                    on symptom control and lorazepam infusion requirements
Dose              •    LD: 0.3 mg/kg (n=8)                                                                    for BZD-resistant AWS patients in the ICU
                  •    Initial MD: 0.2

                  •
                       mg/kg/hr
                       Median: 0.2 mg/kg/hr
                                                                                                            • Baseline characteristics:
Adjunctive        •    Dexmedetomidine                                                                            - Male, average age ~ 45 years,
agents            •    Phenobarbital                                                                              - Median CIWA score 23 (non-intubated), MAAS 4.6 (intubated)
                  •    Haloperidol
                  •    Propofol                                                                                   - 72% intubated
Outcomes                  No change in
                          sedation level                                                                    • Scales used:
Side              •    Over-sedation (n=1)                                                                        - CIWA
effects
                                                                                                                  - MAAS

 27    Wong et al. Ann Pharmacother, Jan 2015; 49(1):14-9                                                    28    See Appendix B and D
       Shah et al. Journ of Med Tox. Sept 2018; 14(3), 229 – 236..                                                 Shah et al. Journ of Med Tox. Sept 2018; 14(3), 229 – 236..
       Pizon et al. Crit Care Med, aug 2018. 46(8); e768-e771.

Shah et. al.                                                                                                Shah et. al.
• Severe AWS: CIWA > 20                                                                                      Outcome                                                                Ketamine
• ICU severe AWS protocol:
                                                                                                             Average lorazepam infusion rate, mg/hr
      - 8mg lorazepam IV q15min x 3 doses
                                                                                                                Initiation of ketamine                                                 14
      - Phenobarbital 260 mg IV, then 130 mg q15min x8
                                                                                                                Post initiation of ketamine                                            10
      - Lorazepam CIVI
                                                                                                             Time to initial symptom control, hours
The Adjunctive Use of Ketamine in Severe Alcohol Withdrawal - September 14, 2018 Hope Randle, PharmD PGY1 Pharmacy Resident Seton Healthcare ...
Shah et. al.                                                                              Literature Summary
                                                                                                            Wong et. al. (n=23)                   Shah et. al. (n=30)             Pizon et. al. (n=63)
• Strengths:
                                                                                          Population        •    26% Intubated                    •    72% intubated
      - Inclusion of intubated and non-intubated patients                                                   •    100% admitted to                 •    100% admitted to ICU
      - Utilized higher doses of ketamine                                                                        ICU for AWS                           for AWS
                                                                                          Initiation        •    34hr from diagnosis              •    41hr from diagnosis
      - Assessed length of intubation and ICU stay after ketamine infusion                Duration          •    56hr                             •    54hr
                                                                                          Dose              •    LD: 0.3 mg/kg (n=8)              •    Bolus: None
• Weaknesses:                                                                                               •    Initial MD: 0.2
                                                                                                                 mg/kg/hr
                                                                                                                                                  •
                                                                                                                                                  •
                                                                                                                                                       Initial MD: 0.5 mg/kg/hr
                                                                                                                                                       Average max dose: 1.6
  - Retrospective study                                                                                     •    Median: 0.2 mg/kg/hr                  mg/kg/hr

  - Other adjunctive agents used                                                          Adjunctive        •    Dexmedetomidine                  •    Diazepam
                                                                                          agents            •    Phenobarbital
  - No control group to assess resulting data                                                               •    Haloperidol
                                                                                                            •    Propofol
                                                                                          Outcomes                  No change in
• Take home points:                                                                                                 sedation level                         BZD requirements
      - Ketamine reduced lorazepam requirements                                                                                                            Withdrawal
      - All patients achieved symptom control within 1 hour of ketamine                                                                                    symptoms
      - All CIVI off within 48 hrs                                                        Side              •    Over-sedation (n=1)              •    Hypertension (n=2)
                                                                                          effectcs
 31    Shah et al. Journ of Med Tox. Sept 2018; 14(3), 229 – 236..                         32    Wong et al. Ann Pharmacother, Jan 2015; 49(1):14-9
                                                                                                 Shah et al. Journ of Med Tox. Sept 2018; 14(3), 229 – 236..
                                                                                                 Pizon et al. Crit Care Med, aug 2018. 46(8); e768-e771.

Pizon et. al.                                                                             Pizon et. al.
                                                                                          Control group
• Prospective observational cohort study (n=63)
                                                                                          • Symptom-triggered BZD
                                                                                          • Intubation
• Purpose: Determine if treatment guidelines using                                           - Propofol
  adjunctive ketamine infusion improves patient suffering                                    - Dexmedetomidine
  from severe AWS
                                                                                          Ketamine group
                                                                                          • Symptom-triggered BZD
• Severe AWS: presence DTs                                                                • IV ketamine initiated immediately upon diagnosis of DTs
                                                                                          • Dosing
                                                                                                - LD: 0.3 mg/kg (optional)
                                                                                                - CIVI: 0.15 – 0.3 mg/kg/hr
                                                                                                - Average dose: 0.19 mg/kg/hr
                                                                                          • Additional agents:
                                                                                                - Propofol, phenobarbital, dexmedetomidine
 33    Pizon et al. Crit Care Med, aug 2018. 46(8); e768-e771.                             34    Pizon et al. Crit Care Med, aug 2018. 46(8); e768-e771.

Pizon et. al.                                                                             Pizon et. al.

Outcome                                           Control            Ketamine   p value   • Strengths:
                                                  (n=29)              (n=34)                    - Control group that did not receive ketamine
Mean ICU (days)                                       11.2             5.7      < 0.01          - Assessed length of stay, BZD use, and intubation requirements
                                                                                                - Addressed confounding elements
Mean hospital length                                 16.6              12.5      0.03
of stay (days)
                                                                                          • Weaknesses:
Mean diazepam                                       2,500             1,500      0.02           - No standardized ketamine protocol
equivalent (mg)                                                                                 - Variation of admission diagnoses
Intubations (number)                                   22              10
The Adjunctive Use of Ketamine in Severe Alcohol Withdrawal - September 14, 2018 Hope Randle, PharmD PGY1 Pharmacy Resident Seton Healthcare ...
Literature Comparison

Population
                 Wong et. al. (n=23)
                 •    26% Intubated
                                                        Shah et. al. (n=30)
                                                        •    72% intubated
                                                                                        Pizon et. al. (n=63)
                                                                                        •   100% admitted to ICU for
                                                                                                                               Can adjunctive use of ketamine in
                 •    100% admitted to
                      ICU for AWS
                                                        •    100% admitted to ICU
                                                             for AWS
                                                                                            treatment of DTs
                                                                                                                               severe AWS improve outcomes?
Initiation       •    34hr from diagnosis               •    41hr from diagnosis        •   Immediately on diagnosis
Duration         •    56hr                              •    54hr                       •   47hr
Dose             •    LD: 0.3 mg/kg (n=8)               •    Bolus: None                •   LD: 0.3 mg/kg (n=19/34)
                 •    Initial MD: 0.2                   •    Initial MD: 0.5 mg/kg/hr   •   Initial MD: 0.15 mg/kg/hr
                      mg/kg/hr                          •    Average max dose: 1.6      •   Average dose: 0.19
                 •    Median: 0.2 mg/kg/hr                   mg/kg/hr                       mg/kg/hr

Adjunctive       •    Dexmedetomidine                   •    Diazepam                   •   Dexmedetomidine
agents           •    Phenobarbital                                                     •   Propofol
                 •    Haloperidol                                                       •   Phenobarbital
                 •    Propofol
Outcomes
                         No change in                           BZD requirements              Risk of intubation
                         sedation level
                                                                Withdrawal symptoms           ICU length of stay

                                                                                              BZD requirements
Side effects     •    Over sedation (n=1)               •    Hypertension (n=2)         •   Over sedation (n=1)
  37    Wong et al. Ann Pharmacother, Jan 2015; 49(1):14-9                                                               38
        Shah et al. Journ of Med Tox. Sept 2018; 14(3), 229 – 236..
        Pizon et al. Crit Care Med, aug 2018. 46(8); e768-e771.

Ketamine Advantages / Disadvantages                                                                                     Application: What dose to give?
                                                                                                                        Study Doses:
   Advantages                                                         Disadvantages
                                                                                                                                                           Wong et. al.                Shah et. al.        Pizon et. al.
   • NMDA antagonistic properties                                     • Hypertension                                    Bolus:                             0.3 mg/kg                   N/A                 0.3 mg/kg
                                                                                                                        Initial dose:                      0.2 mg/kg/h                 0.5 mg/kg/h         0.15 mg/kg/h
   • Short duration of action                                         • No consistent protocol
                                                                         Difficult to assess existing                   Average dose:                      0.2 mg/kg/h                 1.6 mg/kg/h (max) 0.19 mg/kg/h
   • Use does not require                                                data
     intubation
                                                                      • Optimal dosing unknown                          Recommended dosing in critically ill patients:
   • May decrease BZD usage
                                                                                                                        Source                                            Bolus                   Dosing
   • May decreased risk of                                                                                              PAD Guidelines (2013)                             0.1 - 0.5 mg/kg         0.05 - 0.4 mg/kg/hr
     respiratory failure                                                                                                PADIS Guidelines (2018)                           0.5 mg/kg               0.06 – 0.12 mg/kg/hr
                                                                                                                        PAD: Pain, Agitation, Delirium
                                                                                                                        PADIS: Pain, Agitation/Sedation, Delirium, Immobility, Sleep Disruption

  39                                                                                                                     40    Barr et al. Crit Care Med, 2013 Jan; 41(1); 263-306
                                                                                                                               Devlin et al. Crit Care Med, 2018 sep; 46(9); e825-73

DD

• Received 50 mg lorazepam over last 60 minutes
• Symptoms largely unimproved at this time

What therapy to recommend next?

  41                                                                                                                     42   September 7, 2018
Recommendation                                                             Conclusion: Ketamine in Severe AWS
                       Symptom-triggered
AWS Diagnosis
                             BZD                                           • Ketamine offers logical mechanistic benefit for adjunctive
                                                                             treatment of severe AWS
                          Does patient                                     • Limited studies investigating clinical outcomes
                        require > 40mg
                       diazepam in 1 hr?                                   • Available data suggest a benefit of adjunctive ketamine
                                                                             treatment
             No                             Yes
                                                                                 - Decrease BZD requirements
                                                                                 - Decrease ICU length of stay
                                                                                 - Decrease risk of intubation
          Continue                     Increased risk of
                                                                                 - Few adverse effects
          symptom-                  respiratory depression
       triggered BZD                     / hypotension
           dosing

                                                       Consider ketamine
 43                                                                         44

Acknowledgements
                                                                             ASCENSION TEXAS
• Evaluator: Merry Daniel, PharmD, BCCCP
                                                                            The Adjunctive Use of Ketamine in Severe
• Molly Curran, PharmD, BCPS, BCCCP                                         Alcohol Withdrawal

• Emily Hodge, PharmD, BCCCP
                                                                            Hope Randle, PharmD
                                                                            PGY1 Pharmacy Resident
                                                                            Seton Healthcare Family
                                                                            September 14, 2018

 45
Appendices

Appendix A.   Abbreviations
Appendix B.    Benzodiazepine dosing equivalents
Appendix C.    Clinical Institute Withdrawal Assessment Score
Appendix D.   Withdrawal Assessment Scale
Appendix E.    Motor Activity Assessment Scale
Appendix F.    Wong et. al. Outcomes
Appendix G.   Shah et. al. Outcomes
Appendix H.    Pizon et. al. Outcomes
Appendix I.    Literature Comparison
Appendix A. Abbreviations

 Abbreviation           Meaning
 AWS                    Alcohol Withdrawal Syndrome
 BZD                    Benzodiazepine
 CIVI                   Continuous IV Infusion
 CIWA-Ar                Clinical Institute Withdrawal Assessment in Alcohol - Revised
 DTs                    Delirium Tremens
 ED                     Emergency Department
 GABA                   Gamma-amino-butyric acid
 ICU                    Intensive Care Unit
 MAAS                   Motor Activity Assessment Scale
 NMDA                   N-methyl-D-aspartate
 PAD                    Pain, Agitation, Delirium
 PADIS                  Pain, Agitation, Delirium, Immobility, Sleep Disruption
 RAW                    Resistant Alcohol Withdrawal
 SAPS                   Simplified Acute Psychology Score
 WAS                    Withdrawal Assessment Scale
Appendix B. Benzodiazepine Dosing Equivalents

 Benzodiazepine                  Equivalent dose
 Alprazolam                      0.5 mg
 Diazepam                        5 mg
 Lorazepam                       1 mg

Clinical Handbook of Psychotropic Drugs, 4th revised edition, Bezchlibnyk-Butler et al. editors Hogrefe & Huber.
Appendix C. Clinical Institute Withdrawal Assessment (CIWA-Ar) Score

Procedure:
1. Assess and rate each of the 10 criteria of the CIWA scale. Each criterion is rated on a
        scale from 0 to 7, except for “Orientation and clouding of sensorium” which is rated on
        scale 0 to 4.
     2. Add up the scores for all ten criteria. This is the total CIWA-Ar score for the patient at
        that time. Early intervention for CIWA-Ar score of 8 or greater provides the best means
        to prevent the progression of withdrawal.

Total Score Interpretation
Score          Severity
 16           Severe

Sullivan et al. Brit J Addict, 1989 Nov; 84(11):1353-7.
Appendix D. Withdrawal Assessment Scale (WAS)

                                                 WITHDRAWAL ASSESSMENT SCALE

      Name __________________________________                           Hospital number ______________________________________
 Temperature (per axilla)
1 37.0-37.50 C                           2 37.5-38.ooc                          3 Greater than 38.00C
  Pulse (beats per minute)
                                        3 100-105                              5 110-120
2 95-100                                4 105-110                               6 Greater than 120
 Respiration rate (inspirations per minute)
1 20-24                                                        2 Greater than 24
 Blood pressure (diastolic)
 1 95-100 mmHg 3 103-106 mmHg               5 109-112 mmHg
 2 100-103 mmHg 4 106-109 mmHg              6 Greater than 112 mmH
 Nausea and vomiting (Do you feel sick? Have you vomited?)
 O None                                                        4 Intermittent nausea with dry heaves
  2 Nausea with no vomiting                                    6 Nausea, dry heaves, vomiting

 Tremor (arms extended, fingers spread) O
 No tremor                                                       4 Moderate with arms extended
   2 Not visible — can be felt fingertip to fingertip            6 Severe even with arms not extended

 Sweating (observation) O
  No sweat visible                                               4 Beads of sweat visible
  2 Barely perceptible, palms moist                              6 Drenching sweats

 Tactile disturbances
 O None
 2 Mild itching or pins and needles or numbness
 4 Intermittent tactile hallucinations (for example, bug crawling)
 6 Continuous tactile hallucinations                               s
 Auditory disturbances (loud noises, hearing voices)
 O Not present
 2 Mild harshness or ability to frighten (increased sensitivity)
4 Intermittent auditory hallucinations (appears to hear things you cannot)
6 Continuous auditory hallucinations (shouting, talking to unseen persons)
Visual disturbances (photophobia, seeing things)
O Not present
2 Mild sensitivity (bothered by the lights)
4 Intermittent visual hallucinations (occasionally sees things you cannot) 6
Continuous visual hallucinations (seeing things constantly)
Hallucinations
O None                                                            2 Non-fused auditory or visual
1 Auditory, tactile or visual only                                3 Fused auditory and visual
Clouding of sensorium (What day is this? What is this place?)
O Orientated
 2 Disorientated for date by no more than two days
 3 Disorientated for date
 4 Disorientated for place (re-orientate if necessary)
 Quality of contact
 O In contact with examiner
 2 Seems in contact, but is oblivious to environment
 4 Periodically becomes detached
6 Makes no contact with examiner

  Anxiety (Do you feel nervous?) (observation)

O No anxiety; at ease                                        4 Moderately anxious, or guarded

2 Appears anxious                                            6 Overt anxiety (equal to panic)

   Agitation (observation)
O Normal activity                                           4 Moderately fidgety and restless
2 Somewhat more than normal activity                        6 Pacing, or thrashing about constantly

  Thought disturbances (flight of ideas)
  0 No disturbance
  2 Does not have much control over nature of thoughts
  4 Plagued by unpleasant thoughts constantly
  6 Thoughts come quickly and in a disconnected fashion
  Convulsions (seizures or fits of any kind) O
No                                                          6 Yes
  Headache (Does it feel like a band around your head?) O
Not present                                                 4 Moderately severe
2 Mild                                                      6 Severe

  Flushing of face
O None                                                                    2 Severe
                                                                                                  Total
                                                                                                  Date
                                                                                                  Time

 FIGURE: The alcohol withdrawal assessment scale (adapted from Shaw et al).
 Shaw et al. J Clin Psychopharmacol, 1984; 1: 382-389
Appendix E. Motor Activity Assessment Scale

 Score            Description                           Definition
 0                Unresponsive                          Does not move with noxious stimuli
 1                Responsive only to                    Opens eyes or raises eyebrows or turns head toward
                  noxious stimuli                       stimulus or moves limb with noxious stimuli
 2                Responsive to touch or                Opens eyes or raises eyebrows or turns head toward
                  name                                  stimulus or moves limb when touches or name loudly
                                                        spoken
 3                Calm and cooperative                  No external stimulus is required to elicit movement
                                                        and patient is adjusting sheets or clothing
                                                        purposefully and follows commands
 4                Reckless and cooperative              No external stimulus is required to elicit movement
                                                        and patient is picking at sheets or tubes or uncovering
                                                        self and following commands
 5                Agitated                              No external stimulus is required to elicit movement
                                                        and attempting to sit up or moves limb out of bed and
                                                        does not follow commands
 6                Dangerously agitated,                 No external stimulus is required to elicit movement
                  uncooperative                         and patient is pulling at tubes or catheters or
                                                        thrashing side to side or striking at staff or trying to
                                                        climb out of bed and does not calm down when asked

Devlin et al. Crit Care Med. 1999, Jul; 27(7): 1271-5

Appendix F. Wong et. al. Outcomes

  Outcome                                                                 Ketamine

  Change in diazepam equivalent at 12 hrs, mg                                - 40 (-106.7 – 21.7)

  Change in diazepam equivalent at 24 hrs, mg                                 -13.3 (-86.7 - 50)

  Change in WAS score                                                           + 1 (-4.5 – 2)
Length of stay, mean days (SD)                         6.3 (3)
      ICU                                               12.4 (6.6)
      Hospital

  Adverse events, n                                  1 (over-sedation)

Wong et al. Ann Pharmacother, Jan 2015; 49(1):14-9
Appendix G. Shah et. al. Outcomes

  Outcome

  Average lorazepam infusion rate, mg/hr Prior
        to initiation of ketamine                                            14
        Upon discontinuation of ketamine                                     10

  Time to initial symptom control, hours
Mean        diazepam                    2,500          1,500   0.02
  equivalent (mg)

  Intubations (number)                      22            10
Appendix I. Literature Review

                    Wong et. al. (n=23)                     Shah et. al. (n=30)         Pizon et. al. (n=63)

  Population        •    26% Intubated                      •   72% intubated           • 100% admitted to ICU for
                    •    100% admitted to                   •   100% admitted to ICU       treatment of DTs
                         ICU for AWS                            for AWS

  Initiation        •    34hr from diagnosis                •   41hr from diagnosis     •   Immediately on diagnosis
  Duration          •    56hr                               •   54hr                    •   47hr

  Dose              •    LD: 0.3 mg/kg (n=8)                •   Bolus: None             •   LD: 0.3 mg/kg (n=19/34)
                    •    Initial MD: 0.2                    •   Initial MD: 0.5         •   Initial MD: 0.15 mg/kg/hr
                         mg/kg/hr                               mg/kg/hr                •   Average dose: 0.19
                    •    Median: 0.2                        •   Average max dose: 1.6       mg/kg/hr
                         mg/kg/hr                               mg/kg/hr

  Adjunctive        •    Dexmedetomidine                •       Diazepam                •   Dexmedetomidine
  agents            •    Phenobarbital                                                  •   Propofol
                    •    Haloperidol                                                    •   Phenobarbital
                    •    Propofol

  Outcomes          No change in sedation                       BZD requirements             Risk of intubation
                    level                                                                    ICU length of stay
                                                                 Withdrawal symptoms         BZD requirements

  Side              •    Over sedation (n=1)            •       Hypertension (n=2)      •   Over sedation (n=1)
  effects

Wong et al. Ann Pharmacother, Jan 2015; 49(1):14-9
Shah et al. Journ of Med Tox. Sept 2018; 14(3), 229 – 236
Pizon et al. Crit Care Med, aug 2018. 46(8); e768-e771
You can also read