Are macro and micro-plastics impacting mediterranean marine organisms? - M. Cristina Fossi - University of Siena

Page created by Dustin Delgado
 
CONTINUE READING
Are macro and micro-plastics impacting mediterranean marine organisms? - M. Cristina Fossi - University of Siena
Are macro and micro-plastics
 impacting mediterranean
     marine organisms?

    M. Cristina Fossi - University of Siena - Fossi@unisi.it
Are macro and micro-plastics impacting mediterranean marine organisms? - M. Cristina Fossi - University of Siena
Impact of marine litter on Mediterranean
           marine organisms
Are macro and micro-plastics impacting mediterranean marine organisms? - M. Cristina Fossi - University of Siena
Plastic production

                 Annual plastic production has
                  increased dramatically from
                 1.5 million tonnes in the 1950s
                         to approximately

                 280 million tonnes in 2011
                       (PlasticsEurope, 2012).
Are macro and micro-plastics impacting mediterranean marine organisms? - M. Cristina Fossi - University of Siena
Long time life in sea
Are macro and micro-plastics impacting mediterranean marine organisms? - M. Cristina Fossi - University of Siena
Emerging Issue of

  Microplastics
Are macro and micro-plastics impacting mediterranean marine organisms? - M. Cristina Fossi - University of Siena
Microplastics
Microplastics have a range of compositions and can be
demarcated by usage and origin as (Arthur et al. 2009).
i) Primary - pellets used as a feedstock in the plastics industry,
and in certain applications such as abrasives;
ii) Secondary - fragments resulting from the degradation and
breakdown of larger items.
Are macro and micro-plastics impacting mediterranean marine organisms? - M. Cristina Fossi - University of Siena
Spatial distribution of
 Microplastics
They have been accumulating in oceans worldwide over the last four decades
(Carpenter et al., 1972) are present on beaches, in surface waters, throughout the
water column and within the benthos, microplastics have pervaded even the most
remote marine environments

                                                                   .

                                                         Gyres are particular
                                                       hotspots for microplastic
                                                            accumulation
Are macro and micro-plastics impacting mediterranean marine organisms? - M. Cristina Fossi - University of Siena
Microplastics increase
    A significant relationship between microplastic abundance and
      human population-density was found (Browne et al., 2011)

Thus as the human population continues to increase, the prevalence
of microplastics will also most probably increase (Wright et al 2013)
Are macro and micro-plastics impacting mediterranean marine organisms? - M. Cristina Fossi - University of Siena
Impact of Microplastics
on marine organisms
Recent studies have identified potential
effects of plastic particles in
invertebrates and fish, including:
1- transport of persistent,
bioaccumulating and toxic (PBT)
substances from plastics
2- leaching of additives from the
plastics such as phthalates
3- physical harm (Wright, et al. 2013)
Are macro and micro-plastics impacting mediterranean marine organisms? - M. Cristina Fossi - University of Siena
Marine Litter: a Global Challenge
The main legal and institutional frameworks affecting
the Mediterranean on this topic are:
(1) Local Agendas 21;
(2) national legislation on waste management and environmental protection;
(3) the Barcelona Convention and its Protocols;
(4) the Mediterranean Strategy for Sustainable Development (MSSD);
(5) MEDPOL of UNEP;
(6) the EU Environmental Strategy for the Mediterranean and Horizon 2020;
(7) the EU Marine Strategy Directive;
(8) the EU Thematic strategy on the Prevention and Recycling of Waste;
(9) the IMO MARPOL 73/78 Convention – Annex V;
(10) the GPA and the Regional Seas Programme of UNEP;
(11) the Basel Convention
                                                                  GAP
                                                  There is a general lack of
                                              available data on marine wildlife
                                               affected by marine litter in the
                                                       Mediterranean.
Gap
 Information are required about macro-plastic and
micro-plastic inputs, Mediterranean distribution and
     the potential effects on marine organisms.

         ? BEST INDICATOR SPECIES ?
How can the effects of Macro and
  Micro-plastics be detected?
The Solution: PLASTIC-BUSTERS
     To evaluate the presence and effects of marine debris,
 particularly microplastics, in Mediterranean environment using
              marine organisms as sentinel species
Marine organisms as sentinel
       species: micro-plastic
Case studies: Mediterranean fin whale and basking shark
Aim: exploring the toxicological effects of micro-plastics in large filter
feeders species
Further implication: indicators of micro-plastics in the pelagic
environment in the implementation of the EU Marine Strategy
Framework Directive (Descriptor 10)
Aim of the Project

Do microplastics threat
the Mediterranean Sea ?

Are baleen whales
exposed to microplastic
threat?
Balaenoptera physalus
300 liters of water daily

 70,000 liters of water
        with each mouthful
Microplastics and contaminants

 Adsorption of POPs on
  microplastics surface
                          Plastic additives released in
                                the environment
Experimental work
    The work is implemented through four steps:
     Step 1- collection/count of microplastics in Pelagos
    Sanctuary (Mediterranean Sea);
     Step 2- detection of phthalates in superficial
    neustonic/planktonic samples;
     Step 3 - detection of phthalates in stranded
    Mediterranean fin whale;
     Step 4 - detection of phthalates and biomarkers
    responses (CYP1A1, CYP2B, lipid peroxidation) in skin
    biopsies of fin whales collected in the Pelagos
    Sanctuary (n=18) and Sea of Cortez (n=7).
Do Microplastics threat
    the Mediterranean Sea?                                                                               Yes!
                                         LIGURIA
Microplastics
 (Items/m3)
                                                                                               Microplastic     particles    in
                                                         MPM14 MPM15
      0-0.1                          MPM13                                                     superficial neustonic/planktonic
                                                                MPM16
     0.11-1                          MPM12
                                    MPM11
                                                Ligurian Sea                                   samples (items/m3) collected in
                        MPM8
     1.01-5
                                MPM7            MPM5                                           the Pelagos Sanctuary (Ligurian
     5.01-10                 MPM9            MPM6

                            MPM10
                                                              MPM3                             Sea and Sardinian Sea) and mean
                                                       MPM4
                                                                                               DEPH and MEPH concentrations
                        MPM18
                                                                                               (ng/g).
                MPM23                Sardinian Sea
                        MPM24

                                MPM25
                               MPM17
                   MPM26                                                Phthalates concentration in superficial neustonic/planktonic samples
                    MPM19
                                 MPM21
                                                                                               DEHP (ng/g)                MEHP (ng/g)
                        MPM20
                                               SARDINIA                    AREA
                                                                                          n     mean         s.d.   n    mean         s.d.

                                                                        Ligurian Sea      14    18.38    44.39      14   61.93      124.26
                                                                        Sardinian Sea     9     23.42    32.46      9    40.30       41.55
Are baleen whales exposed
to microplastics threat?
                                                                                    Yes!
                MEHP concentration in stranded fin whales                     DEHP concentrations (ng/g) in
                                                                             blubber samples of five stranded
                    SPECIES                 TISSUE        Mean MEHP (ng/g)     fin whales collected along the
                                                                              Italian coasts during the period
           Balaenoptera physalus           Blubber              57.97           July 2007 – June 2011 in five
                                                                                     different locations.

     San Rossore PI (Male)
       MEPH 53.98 ng/g
                    Orbetello GR (Male)
                     MEPH 51.84 ng/g

                          Castelsardo SS (nd)
                           MEPH 1.00 ng/g
                                  Amalfi SA (Female)
                                  MEPH 99.93 ng/g
                                                 Palinuro SA (nd)
                                                MEPH 83.12 ng/g
Presence and effects of
contaminants in fin whale skin biopsies
Contaminants in fin whale
      skin biopsies

        90                   MEHP                        30000
                                                                                     OCs
        80                                               25000
        70

        60                                               20000

                                                    ng/g d.w.
ng/g d.w.

        50
                                                         15000
        40

        30                                               10000

        20
                                                                5000
        10

            0                                                      0
                Pelagos Sanctuary   Sea of Cortez                      Pelagos Sanctuary   Sea of Cortez
Endocrine interference
in fin 12whale skin biopsies
    Normalized fold expression

                                 10           **

                                 8                       Estrogen Receptor α               Males
                                                                                           Females
                                 6
                                                                                           (** = p< 0.05)

                                 4
                                                                        **
                                 2

                                 0
                                          Pelagos Sanctuary           Gulf of California
                                      Undesirable Biological Effect
Are other
 large filter feeders
     exposed to
microplastics threat?
BASKING SHARK

Approx. 12600 items/day!
MEHP concentration in basking sharks

                 SPECIES         TISSUE   Mean MEHP (ng/g)

              Basking sharks    muscle        12.97

Phthalate as plastic tracer
Marine organisms as sentinel
      species: macro-plastic
Case study: the Mediterranean Loggerhead turtle (Caretta caretta)
Aim: exploring the toxicological effects of macro-plastics
Further implication: indicators of macro-plastics in the marine
environment in the implementation of the Descriptor 10 of MSFD
found 483 pieces of
 marine litter with a
total mass of 62.37g

 22 loggerhead
turtles out of 31
  animals had
ingested marine
  debris (71%)
MSFD objective: to achieve the Good Environmental status for
 the marine environment for 2020
Caretta caretta has been proposed as a target species in the Mediterranean sea in
the MSFD (Descriptor 10) to evaluate indicator IV of GES: trends in the amount
and composition of litter ingested by marine animals (e.g stomach analysis)

                                        2020
 Stomach content in                Plastic items = ?
                                                           Stomach content in
 sea turtles in 2013
                                                           sea turtles in 20XX

                                  Time scale
Take Home Message
The workshop recommended that baleen whales and
other large filter feeders should be considered in national
and international marine debris strategies (e.g. Descriptor
10 (marine litter) in the EU Marine Strategy Framework
Directive) as critical indicators of the presence and
impact of microplastics in the marine environment.
The Solution: PLASTIC-BUSTERS
     To evaluate the presence and effects of marine debris,
 particularly microplastics, in Mediterranean environment using
              marine organisms as sentinel species
                                                    Mitigate and reduce
                                                   the impact of marine
                                                        litter in the
                                                    Mediterranean Sea

                                                     Harmonize
                                                   monitoring and
                                                 mitigation activities
                                                 in the entire basin
                                           Implementation of
                                        Descriptor 10 (marine
                                       litter) of the EU Marine
                                          Strategy Framework
                                            Directive (MSFD)
PLASTIC-BUSTER expedition: the route and the towns
_________________________________________________________

                              Marselle                   Venice

                                          Leghorn
                Barcelona

                                                      Naples           Dubrovnik

                        Algiers
                                                                                                 Antalya

    Gibraltar
                                                                                   Athens                           Larnaca
                                                         La Valletta
                                  Tunis

                                                                                                           Beirut
                                                                                     Heraklion

                                            Tripoli                                                        Tel Aviv

                                                                                                                    Alexandria
Networking establishment
_________________________________________________________
Thank you for your attention!

             Welcome in Siena!
Acknowledgements
This project was supported by the Italian
 Ministry for Environment and Territory
Assessing the Impacts of Marine Debris
       Woods Hole, 13-17 May 2013
…The workshop also commended the work of
   researchers at the University of Siena and
    encouraged further work of this kind….

  …Therefore, the workshop encouraged further
non-lethal research on the individual and potential
population-level impacts of ingestion of debris and,
   noting the promising research on biomarker
     development, the group recommended
            further work in this field….
By Cristina Panti

       Skin biopsy – organotypic cultures

         Organotypic cultures of skin biopsy and treatment with
                            BPA/Phthalates
Incubation 24 h with:

Ethanol/methanol 0,1%   0,1 µg/ml   1 µg/ml     10 µg/ml          100 µg/ml
        control
By Cristina Panti

                                    Gene expression in organotypic cultures
                                          Phthalates treatment

                                                                              Fin whale

HKGs: YWHAZ, GAPDH, SDHA (Spinsanti et al., 2008)
By Cristina Panti

                                       Gene expression in organotypic cultures
                                         BPA and Phthalates treatment

HKGs: YWHAZ, GAPDH (Spinsanti et al., 2008)
Effects of litter in free-ranging turtles?
                                                  Comet assay (Frenzilli et al., 1999)
                                                 ENA assay (Pacheco & Santos 1997)
                                                  Diffusion assay (Singh et al., 1988)
                                       Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (Marsili et al., 1997)
                                             Organochlorines (Marsili & Focardi, 1996)
                                                       WHOLE BLOOD
                                                                                     EXCRETA
                                                                     Porphyryns (Grandchamp et al., 1980)
                                                                              Plastic fragments

                                                                             PLASMA
                                                            LPO, Lipid peroxidation (Bird & Draper, 1984)
                                                              γGT, ALT, AST (commercial kits, Polymed)
                                                               VTG, Vitellogenin (Goksoyr et al., 1991)
                                                                   EST, Estradiol (Abraham, 1969)
                                                           BChE, Butyrylcholinesterase (Ellman et al., 1961)
       CARAPACE
                                                           AChE, Acetylcholinesterase (Ellman et al., 1961)
 Trace elements (Hg, Pb, Cd)
(Stoeppler & Backhaus, 1978)
                                          SKIN BIOPSY
                     Protein expression of CYP1A (Fossi et al., 2008, modified)
                    Biopsy slices treated with PAHs and PBDEs (Fossi et al., 2009)
You can also read