Army's Precision Fires Study - US ARMY FIELD ARTILLERY CENTER Major General David P. Valcourt Chief of the Field Artillery FORT SILL, OK

 
CONTINUE READING
Army’s Precision Fires
               Study

               Major General David P. Valcourt
                  Chief of the Field Artillery
Create the
             US ARMY FIELD ARTILLERY CENTER
 Thunder               FORT SILL, OK             1
Transforming Army Indirect Fires
• Robust mix of fire support systems is required to address the full spectrum of requirements and
  mitigate against surprise
• Volume, precision, responsiveness (24/7, all weather, all terrain), and range remain critical
  attributes of a fire support system
• Networked and precision fires offer opportunity to disrupt/destroy enemy capabilities at
  extended ranges and with greater precision

                                               Networked through battle command
                                                Fully interoperable with Joint systems
                                                  Mobile (strategic and tactical)
                                                    Fully integrated with maneuver
                                                      Lethal (through precision and volume)
                                                        Precise effects with area options
                                                          Reduced logistics
                                                           Ability to mass effects
                                                              24/7, all weather, all terrain

              To
               Toachieve
                  achieveDestructive,
                           Destructive,Suppressive
                                        Suppressiveand
                                                     andProtective
                                                         Protectiveeffects
                                                                    effectswhile
                                                                            whileminimizing
                                                                                 minimizing
 Create the          collateral damage and taking advantage of emerging  technology
                      collateral damage and taking advantage of emerging technology
  Thunder
                                                                                                    2
Must Deliver Precision Effects . . .

Capability
Capabilitytotorapidly
                rapidlyand
                        andaccurately
                             accuratelylocate
                                        locateand
                                               andattack
                                                   attacktargets
                                                          targets
with
withthe
      therequired
          requiredoperational
                     operationalresponsiveness
                                 responsivenessmatched
                                                 matchedtoto
desired  effects(lethal
desiredeffects    (lethaland
                         andnon-lethal)
                              non-lethal)and
                                          andthe
                                              thegreatest
                                                 greatest
efficiency.
efficiency.

                     Must
                     Musthave
                           havethese
                                 thesefor
                                       forPrecision
                                           PrecisionEffects:
                                                     Effects:
                ƒƒAccurate
                  Accuratetarget
                             targetlocation
                                    locationand
                                             andsize
                                                 size
                ƒƒAccurate
                  Accuratedelivery
                             deliverysystem
                                      systemlocation
                                              locationand
                                                       and
                  direction
                  direction
                ƒƒMeteorological
                  Meteorological
                ƒƒWeapon
                  Weaponand andammo
                                 ammoinfo
                                        info
                ƒƒAccurate
                  Accuratecomputational
                             computationalprocedures
                                             procedures

Create the
 Thunder
             . . . to be Relevant and Ready
                                                                    3
JFC Needs a Variety of Capabilities
                                                     Shaping Fires
    Can’t be totally         Destructive Fires at                 M270A1
     dependent on
    any one service           Extended Ranges
                                                                                      ATACMS
                  Fires to
                                                           Point & Area
                  Isolate
                                        HIMARS
  Capabilities that
  posture current                                    Guided Rocket
  force for future
                         Armed UAV
             Excalibur               Point & Area

                                120mm                             For
 Paladin                                    NLOS-C                 ForPrecision
                                                                       PrecisionEffects
                                                                                  Effectsneed:
                                                                                           need:
                                                             ƒƒAccurate
                                                                Accuratetarget
                                                                          targetlocation
                                                                                 locationandandsize
                                                                                                size
                                                             ƒƒAccurate  delivery  system
                                                                Accurate delivery system
                                                               location
                                                                locationand
                                                                         anddirection
                                                                              direction
                                                             ƒƒMeteorological
                                                                Meteorological
           F22                       NLOS-LS
                                                             ƒƒWeapon
                                                                Weaponandandammo
                                                                              ammoinfoinfo
                                                             ƒƒAccurate
                                                                Accuratecomputational
                                                                          computational
   Close Supporting Fires                       EFEC           procedures
                              PGMM                              procedures
                                                                                                   4
Missiles & Rockets
    RESPONSIVE LONG RANGE FIRES FOR THE JFC COMMANDER

  9 Organic fire support directly responsive to the JFC commander

                   9 Optimal platforms for engagement ~ 300km

                  9 All weather / all environments

                  9 Precise & smart munitions

                   9 ADA threat irrelevant
                        Highly effective in SEAD role
                        ATACMS – QRU: Command Posts
                      9 High volume continuous fires
                  9 Direct, digital linkage with sensors
                      9 Rapid fires against fleeting targets
                      9 Effectively engage nK arty system in 3-5 minute
                        window of vulnerability
9 Pilots not placed over targets … rockets and missiles are unmanned systems
9 Fires available to the joint force commander where and when they are needed
  Create the
   Thunder
                                                                            5
MLRS Rocket Transition
  Basic & Extended Range Rocket
                                                                                               Reduced
                                                                                     Point
                                                                                               Collateral
    Counterfire                                                                     Targets
                      SEAD                                                                      Damage

            Soft Targets                                                     Structures         One Round
                                                                                     Restrictive One Hit
                                                                                      Terrain One Kill
Guided MLRS Rocket                                                                                          Guided Unitary Rocket
                                               Guided Cargo Rocket
  • Increased Target Sets
  • Further Reduces Logistical Foot Per Target
  • Precision Engagements
                                                                                               • Maximum Range: 70-100 Km
  • Multi- Precision Engagements
                                                                                               • Minimum Range: 15 Km
  • Overcomes Large Total System Error
                                                                                               • Cylindrical Warhead Shape
  • Shoot-and-Scoot Type Targets
                                                                                               • Elliptical Warhead Shape

  350                                                                                                          Reduced
R                                                                                                              Collateral
  300                                                                                            Point
O                                      Extended Range                                           Targets         Damage
C 250
K 200                                                                                                   Moving
                                                                                                                  One Round
E 150                                                                                                   Targets Multi Hits
                              Basic M26                                                                           Multi Kills
T 100                                                             GMLRS IMU and               Structures
S                                                                   GPS Aided                           Restrictive
   50
                                                                                                         Terrain
    0
        5       10    15     20   25      30    35      40   45   50    55    60    65
                                                RANGE                                                                           6
What We’re Looking For
-- More Precision (Reduce CEP); Better Inertial Measuring Units / GPS
-- Predictable Effects and Controllable Effects
-- Scaleable Multiple Effects (Wrapped Penetrators)
-- Semi-autonomous / Autonomous Operations
-- Greater System Reliability
-- Increased Reach (Range)
-- Loiter Ability (Maneuverable)
-- Waypoint Flight
-- Automatic Target Recognition (Detect, Classify, Recognize, Identify)
-- In-Flight Communications (Update, Re-tasking, etc.)
-- Multiple Sensor Package (Uncooled IR, IR, Millimeter Wave, LADAR,
   TV, Semi-active Laser)
-- Greater Sensor Footprint
-- Reduced Size / Weight
-- Reduced Cost
-- Warheads with Controllable Separating Motors
                                                                          7
Excalibur Precision Bus
                           Unitary                                       Excalibur Family Variants
                              GPS Receiver
                    Inertial Measurement Unit – IMU
                                            Height of Burst, Point
 Canard Actuation Sys - CAS                 Detonating & Delay
                                            Sensors                Block I (Unitary):             Block II (Smart):
     Fuze Safe & Arm                                              Unitary (HE) warhead            Detect/acquire/engage
                                                                  Fin stabilized airframe         submunition capability
Unitary Penetrating                            GPS SAASM          Precision guidance
     Payload
                                             GPS Antennas
                                           System Battery
  Base Bleed                    Airframe
                                                                  Block III (Discriminating):     Future Blocks:
                                                                  Discriminating capability       Unlimited potential
                                                                   (e.g. Target Recognition)

                       Capabilities                                                     Future Potential
 • Precision bus capable of delivering a variety of                • Future potential is unlimited
     warheads
                                                                   • Serves as a bus to carry any payload that must
 •   Expands fire support capability to support                        be delivered at extended ranges with increased
     various missions                                                  precision
 •   Extended Range 35-40km                                        •   Future applications could include: home-on-jam,
 •   10m Circular Error Probable (CEP) at all ranges                   delivery of sensors, precision scatterable mines
 •   Decreased collateral damage                                   •   Other non-lethal applications
 •   Increased tactical efficiency

       Create the
        Thunder
                                                                                                                           8
Changing Role of the Cannon

    Current Force                                                           Future Force
          x                                                                  x
                                                                             UA

                  II                                                                II
                          Close Support: Attack of enemy troops,                   NLOS
                          weapons, or positions in close combat,
                          enabling maneuver forces as part of decisive
                          operations with the following categories of
                          fires:
                          • Destructive
                          • Suppressive
                          • Protective
         Close Support    • Special Purpose                              Close Support
   Shaping             Counterfire                               Shaping            Counterstrike

                                                          Tomorrow – NLOS-C emphasis on
Today - Direct Support cannons                            close support while other fires
must do it all – often resulting in                       assets (PAM, MRM, GMLRS & Joint
less responsive and effective fires                       fires) help with shaping and
                                                          counterstrike                             9
Modular Designs
Fires Battalion – Infantry BCT                                                                                    Fires Battalion – Heavy BCT
                                          II
                                                                                                                                                                     II
                                                          406
                                                                                                                                                                          457

                     I                    I                                      I
                    HHB   118                             184                   FSC   104                                           I                                I                I
                                                          (2X92)                                                                HHB         139                            222       FSC   97
                                                                                                                                                                           (2X111)
   Target
 Acquisition   18               MI   22
                                                                                                                   Target
                                                                                                                 Acquisition   30                 MI     22

                                                       Capability
                                                        Capabilityfor:
                                                                   for:
                                                       •Locating
                                                        •Locatingand
                                                                  andassessing
                                                                        assessingtargets
                                                                                     targetswith
                                                                                              withorganic
                                                                                                   organicTUAVs
                                                                                                            TUAVsandandradars
                                                                                                                        radars
                                                       •Providing  MET   for all BCT  indirect fire assets
                                                        •Providing MET for all BCT indirect fire assets
                                                       •Conducting
                                                        •Conductinginternal
                                                                      internalBCTBCTcounterfire
                                                                                      counterfireoperations
                                                                                                   operations
                                                       •Conducting
                                                        •Conductingsustainment
                                                                      sustainmentwith withorganic
                                                                                            organicassets
                                                                                                     assets
                                                       •Supporting
                                                        •Supportingairborne
                                                                     airborneand andair
                                                                                      airassault
                                                                                          assaultoperations
                                                                                                  operations(Infantry
                                                                                                              (Infantryonly)
                                                                                                                        only)
                                                       •Providing  platoon   fire units
                                                        •Providing platoon fire units

                                                                                      Fires Brigade
                                                                                                    X

                                                                Organic                                                             Assigned

                                                     II            II       I          I        I          I
                                                                   SPT    SIGNAL      TAB     HHB
                                               Rocket/Missile                                            ATK                                               IO
                                                                                                                                        Cannon
                                                                                                                                                          Enablers

                                                                                                                  Task Org based on: JSCP,TRO, Stationing and / or
                                                                                                                  Specific Operations

                                                   Capability
                                                     Capabilityfor:
                                                                for:
                                                   • •Providing
                                                       Providingclose
                                                                 closesupport
                                                                        supportand
                                                                                andprecision
                                                                                     precisionstrike
                                                                                                 strikefor
                                                                                                        forJFC,
                                                                                                            JFC,UEUEand
                                                                                                                      andbrigades
                                                                                                                          brigadeswith
                                                                                                                                   withcannons,
                                                                                                                                        cannons,
                                                      rockets,
                                                       rockets,missiles
                                                               missilesand
                                                                         andarmed
                                                                             armedUAVs
                                                                                     UAVswithout
                                                                                             withoutaugmentation
                                                                                                      augmentation
                                                   • •Employing
                                                       Employingcombinations
                                                                  combinationsofoforganic
                                                                                    organicandandassigned
                                                                                                   assignedenablers
                                                                                                              enablers
                                                   • •Conducting
                                                       Conducting sustainment and signal operationswith
                                                                  sustainment   and  signal  operations    withorganic
                                                                                                                 organicassets
                                                                                                                         assets
                                                   • •Locating
                                                       Locating and assessing targets with organic TUAVs andradars
                                                               and  assessing  targets  with  organic  TUAVs    and   radars
Create the
                                                   • •Providing
                                                       ProvidingMET
                                                                 METand
                                                                      andsurvey
                                                                           surveyfor
                                                                                   forall
                                                                                       allFires
                                                                                           FiresBDE
                                                                                                 BDEindirect
                                                                                                       indirectfire
                                                                                                                fireassets
                                                                                                                     assetsand
                                                                                                                            andradars
                                                                                                                                radars
 Thunder
                                                                                                                                                                                                10
NLOS-Cannon Caliber
              Decision

Create the
 Thunder                       11
                               11
Cannon Mission Module Priorities

 9 Range of at least 30KM for HE
 9 Accuracy must not exceed 0.55% of range at low angle, for
   ranges of 30 km or less (165m CEP)
 9 Rate of fire of at least 6 RPM
 9 Respond to a fire order in 30 seconds when moving
 9 Automatic loading (no personnel)
 9 Rearm the system in under 12 minutes
 9 On-board ammunition of at least 24 rounds
 9 Survivability through crew served weapon and active protection

 Create the
  Thunder
                                                                    12
Range vs Weight Savings

                                                                                    40 km
                                 36 km - M2005 VLAP***
                                                                                   Excalibur
                                                                                 M2005 VLAP***
                                         35 km
     32 km                              Excalibur                                    30 km      M2
                                                                             P                    000                31 km
  M2005 VLAP***                                                           RA                         ***
                                                                     49          28 km – M864                      M913 RAP
    Excalibur*                         26 km                       M5
                                M549 RAP M795 PIP**                                BBDPICM                        M2020 PFF***
        22 km                        23 km – M864                                22 km
                                       BBDPICM                             M795 HE, M825 SMK
M549 RAP M795 PIP**
                                         18 km                                   18 km                                 20 km
    17 km – M864
                                    M107HE, M483DP                          M107HE, M483DP                             M1 HE
       14 km                          M795, M825                               FASCAM
   M107HE, M483DP                       FASCAM
     M795, M825
      FASCAM

                                                                                                                                6 km

 155mm, 37 Caliber,               155mm, 38 Caliber,              155mm, 39 Caliber, Zone 5                 105mm – 62 Caliber
 Zone 3                           Zone 4                          FCS AoA Base Case                            1596 lb savings
   1949 lb savings                  1367 lb savings
BBDPICM: Base Bleed Dual Purpose Improved Conventional Munition
FASCAM: Field Artillery Scatterable Mine Field                                    * Excalibur range estimated
PIP: Product Improvement Program                                                  ** Technology base development
PFF: Pre-formed Fragment                                                          *** Foreign Tech Base / Not currently US certified
RAP: Rocket Assisted Projectile
VLAP: Velocity Enhanced Long Range Artillery Projectile                                                                                13
38 Caliber 155mm ECC Concept
SURVIVABILITY                                              LETHALITY
14.5mm 360o horizontal crew protection 306 lbs             155mm, 38 Caliber, Zone 4 cannon
  14.5mm top crew protection                                 6 rounds on board at ECC      723 lbs
30 mm frontal area crew protection                           18 rounds added for 24 rounds at FCC
  60o arc side crew protection                             CCSW (XM 307) - 300 of 300 rounds
HE/HEAT 360o protection (APS)                              Projectile Tracking System 231 lbs
  60o to 90o vertical dead space in coverage
7.62 Ball Protection for 15% Coverage of Mission
Module
                                                           OPERATIONAL MANEUVER
NBC filtration/sensing system                              Allocated C4ISR
  No NBC overpressure                                      4.8 hours from ECC to FCC
AP mine protection / No AT mine protection
No Smart top attack protection                             SUSTAINABILITY                  107 lbs
152 mm frag crew protection 360o for Crew                  Automated Rearm                Greater BII
No Aerial bomblet protection                               Ao baseline of 85%
                                                              (Requirement is 95%)
                                                           Water generation/purification/storage
MOBILITY                                                   100 km range / Fuel for 400 km at FCC
40 kph cross country sustained                             3 days rations/water added for FCC
70 kph hard-surface sustained                      Black Text = included at ECC
1m obstacle                                        Red Text = not included at ECC/FCC
1.5 m gap crossing                                 Blue Text = not included in ECC, added at FCC for the
                                                   capability
                                                   Hi-Lite = changes from 39 Caliber
  Create the                                                = weight savings investment
   Thunder
                                                                                                           14
Phase I - Precision
               Effects Study

Create the
 Thunder                           15
                                   15
Precision Fires Study
Purpose                                                                                         Fire Support
                                                                                               Sensor System
     9Evaluate current or near-term precision engagement capability                            FY05
     9Select those that will provide the best pay-off for improving the precision capability
     9Provide an improvement in engagement efficiency, meet rules of engagement (ROE) restrictions
     on effects, and provide potential logistical efficiency at a reasonable cost
     9Outline how the Army can expedite acquisition and fielding of these capabilities
                                                                                                   ACAAP
Methodology                                                                                        Ammo
     9 Identified capability gaps
     9 Working with industry and S&T communities developed proposals for a SAG decision
Evaluation
     9Effectiveness: Enhance accuracy, responsiveness & reduce collateral damage                        FY06
     9Cost: RDT& E, Integration (system and software), fielding to one BCT
     9Risk: Assessed by Technology Readiness Level - at least TRL 6
                                                                               Lightweight Counter
     9Schedule: Capability can be fielded to a BCT in 24-36 months                Mortar Radar

          Precision Effects                      Precision Guided Mortar Munition
          Mission Manager                                                                           FY06

                                FY06                                    FY07
    Create the
     Thunder
                                                                                                               16
Selecting the Best
                 Request for Proposals - 56
                GPS Time Fuze
                Advanced Cannon
                                                                                         Working Group - 24
                Artillery Ammunition Program
                Low Cost Course Correction (LCCC) Technology - 120mm Mortar   Accelerated Precision Guided Mortar Munition Fielding
                Approach for the 155mm M232 High Zone MACS                    Projectile Tracking System (PTS) for Paladin

                                                                                                                                                SAG - 5
                105mm Stryker Artillery Weapon System
                Projectile Tracking System for Paladin
                                                                              SMArt 155
                Optimized Control Kit for Missile Rounds                      GMLRS/BLU-108
                M898 SADARM Plus                                              Advanced Cannon Artillery Ammunition Program (ACA2P)
 Precision      An Improved Smart Submunition for M982 Excalibur (Smart)
                Improved Smart Submunition for the Guided MLRS                Viper Strike Precision Munition (UAV)
                                                                                                                                      • Accelerate Precision Guided
  Delivery                                                                    Precision Effects Mission Management Improvements
                                                                                                                                        Mortar Munition Fielding
                Precision Guided Mortar Munition 120mm XM395
                Course Correction Fuze
                                                                              Guided Unitary Rocket Accelerated Fielding
                SMArt 155
 Systems                                                                      Excalibur Upgrade for Paladin
                                                                                                                                      • Procure Advanced Cannon
                Course Corrected Fuze for Large Caliber Artillery
                Artillery Registration Shell Concept (ARSC)                   155mm BONUS Sensor Fuzed Munition System
    and         Precision Targeting Workstation
                155mm BONUS Sensor Fuzed Munition System
                                                                              Improved, Multi-Mode Unitary Warhead on ATACMS
                                                                                                                                        Artillery Ammunition Program
                                                                              M898 SADARM Plus & An Improved Smart Submunition for
 Munitions
                Non-Lethal Indirect Fire
                Course Corrector Fuze

                                                                                                                                      • Develop Precision Effects
                                                                              M982 Excalibur (Smart) (PLUS)
                Projectile Kinetic Energy Reduction System
                Viper Strike                                                  Precision Targeting Workstation
                BLU-108 Submunition Configured GMLRS
                Guided Projectiles
                                                                              M898 SADARM Plus & An Improved Smart Submunition for
                                                                              M982 Excalibur (Smart) (Excalibur)                        Mission Management for
                Rocket Assisted GPS Guided 155mm Projectile
                Modernized Copperhead
                Kinetic Energy Artillery
                                                                              Viper Strike Precision Munition (GMLRS)
                                                                              Improved Smart Submunition for the guided MLRS
                                                                                                                                        AFATDS
                GMLRS Unitary Cargo
                HIMARS C2
                                                                              SMArt 155 (GMLRS)
                Accelerated NLOS-LS
                Self-Propelled 120mm Mortar
                GMLRS Unitary
                ATACMS Unitary

 Mounted         Short Wave InfraRed (SWIR) Technology
                 EO/IR Sensors                                                 Fire Support Sensor System (FS3)                       • Additional Fire Support Sensor
  Optics         Proposal for CE #2
                 Tripod-Mounted Target Acquisition System
                                                                               Precision Tageting Acquisition Mobile (PTAM)
                                                                                                                                        Systems (FS3)

Dismounted
                 Dynamic Range Enhancement
                 Precision Targeting Acquisition Mobile (PTAM)                 TALON
   Optics
                 Common Remote Stabilized Sensor System
                 TALON

                 Shoulder Launched Unmanned Reconnaissance System (SLURS)

                                                                                                                                      • Accelerate Light Weight
                 Passive Hostile Artillery Locating HALO(+)

Counterfire
                 Lightweight Counter Mortar Radar                             Lightweight Counter Mortar Radar
                 Unmanned Air Vehicle
                 Weapon Locating Radar Enhanced Shelter
                                                                              Passive Hostile Artillery Locating (HALO+)
                                                                                                                                        Counter Mortar Radar
                 JLENS Spiral I
                 Q-36 Upgrade

Direction &
                 UWA DGPS Network
                 Position Location and Direction Determination

 Location        Joint Tactical Positioning System                            Joint Tactical Positioning System
                 Simplified Survey System

       CreateTeraScan
               the
   Met Thunder
           Profiler Block II                                                  TeraScan
                Ballistic Met Data via Guided Projectiles
                                                                                                                                                                       17
Analysis of Precision Fires Study

9 Phase I study recommendations to reduce target location error are
  critical enablers for precision effects and Joint capabilities
9 Combining greater precision through course correcting fuzes
  (CCF), combined with enhanced lethality of individual munitions
  provides a significant precision effects capability not present
  today
9 When employing 2-D CCF in conjunction with small target location
  errors, there is a significant reduction in the number of
  conventional rounds required to achieve desired effects and the
  corresponding logistics burden
9 CCF combined with ACAAP ammunition improves lethality and
  further reduces rounds required for desired target effects
Both
BothCCF
     CCFand
         andACAAP
            ACAAPammunition
                  ammunitionhave
                             haveaajump
                                    jumpstart
                                         startthrough
                                               throughother
                                                      other
                   ongoing
                    ongoingactions
                            actions
Create the
 Thunder
                                                                      18
CEP vs. AUPC (61K buy)
       $40000
                                                     Normalized to current           • 3 ea CCF options meet 30m
       $35000                 155 GPS Guided         Excalibur acquisition             accuracy
                                                    objective of 61,483 rds.         • AUPC for CCF options is one
       $30000                                                                          tenth that of new projectile
                                                                                       alternatives.
       $25000

       $20000
AUPC

                                               Note: Scale changes aboveNote:                       Notes
                                                                              Scale changes above the
                                                                         the break                    break
        $5000
                                                                                     • Cost includes round and fuze.
                                                                                       Propellant cost was not included
                        CCF                                                            because it is the same for all
       $4000                                                                           alternatives.
                       Guidance           CCF                                        • L/M 155 GPS Guided is new 155
                    Integrated Fuze                                                    round vice a fuze option.
       $3000                                                                         • Cost for PTS 1-D and 2-D options
                                   PTS 2-D
                                                                                       include $105.6M to field 12 Paladin
                                   Corrector
                                                    PTS 1-D
                                                                                       battalions with PTS.
                             CCF
                                                    Corrector
        $2000
                                                                Alternatives in red box do not meet
                                           I GPS Time
                                              Fuze                      30m CEP accuracy.
        $1000                           CCF                                                              M795 HE
                                                                                                        Base Case

           $0
                0       20         40          60        80       100          120    140       160      180        200

                                                                CEP (meters)                                                 19
Conclusions

9 Phase I recommendations are still valid. Some are already being
  worked in other venues such as Modularity. TRADOC Commander
  endorsement will help
9 Phase II recommendations offer significant capability enhancements.
  ACAAP ammunition was one of the Phase I recommendations
9 Development of GIF/CCF capability should be supported even if
  ACAAP ammunition is not procured. Significantly improves precision
  effects capability of current munitions stockpile
9 Both of the Phase II recommendations have ongoing efforts that we
  can leverage to accelerate fielding
9 All of the recommendations allow for spiral development

Create the
 Thunder
                                                                        20
Army’s Precision Fires
               Study

               Major General David P. Valcourt
                  Chief of the Field Artillery
Create the
             US ARMY FIELD ARTILLERY CENTER
 Thunder               FORT SILL, OK             21
BACK UP SLIDES

Create the
 Thunder
                              22
Priority 1 - Fire Support Sensor System

 Accelerate                                            “To optimize the stand off capabilities of fire
  Acceleratefielding
             fieldingofofFS3
                          FS3                          support, optical, lasing and thermal imagery devices
                                                       for the BFISTs and COLTs need improvement.”

                                                       “There is an immediate need in the field artillery
                                                       community for optic and designator systems that
                                                       are smaller and provide observation that exceeds
                                                       maneuver optical systems.”
                                                                               - 3ID OIF After Action Report

                                                         OEF           OIF      ONS       UR      TF Mod
                                                          X            X                   X          X

              EFFECTIVENESS                          COST                    RISK        SCHEDULE
                                              ~ $3M Non-recurring
 • > 2.5x day & night ID range of G/VLLD &
                                                    expense
 AN/TAS-4
                                              ~ $3M to field heavy
 • Meets all Heavy/Light Mounted
                                              brigade (7 systems)
 Requirement Key Performance Parameters                                      TRL 8          2QFY05
                                              ~ $1.7M to field light
 • Achieved 20m TLE at 10 Km during testing
                                              brigade (4 systems)
 • Common with maneuver targeting system
                                                Stryker brigades
 (LRAS3)
                                                currently funded
 Create the
  Thunder
                                                                                                               23
Priority 2 - Precision Guided Mortar
           Munition (PGMM)
Accelerate
 Acceleratedevelopment
              developmentandandLow
                                 Low           “Rules of engagement and clearance of fires in
                                               urban areas create unique challenges due to the use
Rate
 RateInitial
      InitialProduction
              Productionofofthe
                             the               of areas that they knew we would not strike with
PGMM
 PGMM(XM395
        (XM395projectile).
                 projectile).                  munitions based on our desire to not commit
                                               collateral damage (targets located in or beside
                                               schools, mosques, hospitals and housing.”
                                                                        - 3ID OIF After Action Report

                                                OEF         OIF        ONS        UR       TF Mod
                                                    X        X                                X

        EFFECTIVENESS                   COST                RISK               SCHEDULE
  Advantages
 • High angle trajectory enables
 employment in urban terrain.
 • Early Entry Scenario – Reduced
 indirect fire ammo consumption 56%   FY05 - $21M                            LRIP (100 rounds)
 (214 to 95 STONS)                                          TRL 5
                                      FY06 - $10M                                2QFY07
 • Accuracy (1m CEP) exceeds ROE
 restrictions
 Disadvantages
 • Requires laser designation
Create the
Thunder
                                                                                                        24
Priority 3 - Advanced Cannon Artillery
              Ammunition
                                                    “Simultaneous with advances in deep battle
 Field
  Fieldselected
         selectednon-developmental
                  non-developmental                 capabilities, there has been a decline in the
 conventional
  conventional105mm
                 105mmand
                        and155mm
                            155mm                   capabilities and demands for direct support/close
                                                    support fires. In addition to the efforts currently
 artillery
  artilleryammunition.
            ammunition.                             underway to improve cannon and rocket/missile
                                                    munitions, we need to provide precision munitions
                                                    for lighter systems.”

                                                            Letter from Cdr, 18th Abn Corps Artillery to CG,
                                                                                                   USAFAC

                                                     OEF          OIF        ONS        UR       TF Mod
                                                                                         X           X
       105mm HE PFF       155mm HE

        EFFECTIVENESS                       COST                 RISK                SCHEDULE
Improved effectiveness; 33% increase
in range for 155mm 39 caliber tube        Qualification ~
• > 50% reduction in minimum safe           $25.7M
distance reduces collateral damage      Procurement cost
and risk to friendly forces                                      TRL 8              2QFY06 (LRIP)
                                         same as current
• Eliminates UXO hazard                105mm and 155mm
• HE fill meets insensitive munition       munitions
requirements

Create the
 Thunder
                                                                                                               25
Priority 4 - Extended Range Lightweight
          Counter Mortar Radar
  Modify
    Modifyexisting
            existingLCMR
                      LCMRtotoincrease
                               increase
                                                        “The LCMR will clearly improve force protection,
                                                        complement the existing radars supporting OEF, and
  system
    systemacquisition
             acquisitionrange
                          rangefrom
                                from6km
                                      6km               provide an added capability to accurately locate
  toto10km
       10kmforfor120mm
                  120mmmortars
                          mortarswith
                                   with                 enemy forces.”
  better
    bettertarget
           targetlocation.
                   location.                                     - 82d Abn Div Operational Needs Statement

                                                         OEF        OIF       ONS        UR      TF Mod
                                                           X          X         X                   X

           EFFECTIVENESS                        COST                RISK              SCHEDULE

    •Fills Q-36 gap with 360 degree
    coverage
    • 50m CEP for 120mm mortars at 8.5        ~ $750K for
    km range                                  development
                                                                    TRL 7                3QFY06
       – Accurate enough for mortar and   ~ $2.4M to field one
       artillery engagement               brigade (4 systems)
    • Immune to small arms fire false
    alarms
  Create the
   Thunder
                                                                                                             26
Priority 5 - Precision Effects Mission
                Manager
Develop
 Developand andfield
                fieldAFATDS
                      AFATDS
                                                       “Rules of engagement and clearance of fires in
                                                       urban areas create unique challenges due to the use
enhancements
 enhancementsthat  thatprovide
                        providethe
                                the                    of areas that they knew we would not strike with
ability
 abilitytotomore
            moreeffectively
                  effectivelyemploy
                              employ                   munitions based on our desire to not commit
                                                       collateral damage (targets located in or beside
precision
 precisionmunitions.
             munitions.                                schools, mosques, hospitals and housing.”
                                                                               - 3ID OIF After Action Report

 Target Segmentation                                     OEF       OIF        ONS        UR       TF Mod
   (Sheafing) Tool
                                                                     X                    X

         EFFECTIVENESS                         COST                   RISK               SCHEDULE
 Allows accurate assessment and
 mitigation of collateral damage and
 fratricide                                  ~ $4.76M for
 • Allows optimization of precision         recommended             Low for
 munitions reduced delivery error           improvements         recommended                1QFY07
 • Architecture allows targeting and    Fields entire FA force   improvements
 engagement options to be distributed   (Active, NG, USMC)
 throughout the TOC

Create the
 Thunder
                                                                                                               27
Course Correcting Fuze (CCF)

Create the
 Thunder
                                       28
Course Correcting Fuze

9 What is CCF ? Fuze-sized module that is intended to replace
  a “NATO standard” fuze on existing stockpiled Army and
  Navy Ammunition.

9 What Does it Do ? Corrects the ballistic trajectory of the
  projectile, resulting in a small terminal miss distance.

9 What Difference Will It Make ?
  – Greatly reduce the number of rounds required to defeat a
    given enemy threat.
  – Applicable to existing cannon projectiles and mortar and
    systems.
  – Enhance “Maneuver Warfare” by reducing the time
    required to neutralize threats while minimizing logistic and
    re-supply burdens.

Create the
 Thunder
                                                                   29
How Does CCF Work?

                       GPS Satellites

                                                                                Guided Impact
                                                                                At Target
                                                                       Unguided Impact
                                                   • Predict Miss
                                                   • Deploy Controls
                                                   • Steer to Target
• Ballistic Solution       • DeSpin Nose
• Initialize Fuze          • Acquire GPS

                         CCF Fuze Replaces Other
                           NATO Standard Fuzes

                                                                                                30
Sense and Destroy Armor
                    (SADARM)

                        y A Smart Submunition For 155mm
                         Counter-Battery/Anti-Armor Missions
                        y Adaptable to Rockets & Missiles
                        y Top Attack, Robust Submunition
                        y Warhead Defeats Up to Top Armor of
                         MBT
                        y Limited quantity of M898 Projectiles
                         In the U.S. Army Inventory
                        y Production stopped 2001
                        y Contractor startup cost - $30M with
                         rounds delivered in 2-3 years

Create the
 Thunder
                                                                 31
SMArt 155

             • Developed by GIWS (Rheinmetall/Diehl JV)

             • 155mm Sensor Fuzed Munition (SFM) in production today for the German
             Army - 9000 Projectiles

             • Provides precision kill capability against enemy armor and artillery with
             demonstrated reliability and effectiveness

             • Demonstrated success against an array of countermeasures and various
             environmental conditions.

             • Demonstrated 90% reliability – Near zero dud rate in Lot Acceptance Test

Create the
 Thunder
                                                                                           32
155 BONUS

                  Carrier Shell
                                                      Acquisition Phase:
                                                      Currently in Production for Sweden and France
  Base           M864 (Ballistics)                    • Production Contract Awarded Fall 2000
  Bleed                                               • First Production Round Delivered Summer 2002
   Unit                                    Standard   • Series Qualification Ongoing during 2003
                                             Fuze
                                                      • Production Decision for Improved Sensor Fall 2003
                                                      • Series Delivery with Improved Sensors Fall 2004
                                     Expulsion
                                      Device
                                                                                   Canister, Pusher Plate
                    Two Cylinders
                                                                                     and Submunition
                   w/Two Warheads

Description:                                          Contractor Team:
  • 155mm Sensor Fuzed Anti-Armor Munition            • BONUS is a Joint Program of France and Sweden.
       • Dual Mode Seeker
       • wo Explosively Formed Penetrator Warheads    • BONUS is assembled in both Sweden and France.
  • Key Features                                      • BONUS will be licensed to an American Company
       • JBMOU Compliant
       • Fire and Forget Projectile
       • All Weather – All Climate System
       • Base Bleed for Extended Range
       • Winged Submunitions for Stability
       • First Pass Attack for Moving Targets
    Create the
     Thunder
                                                                                                            33
• Slides CG REMOVED

Create the
 Thunder
                        35
GMLRS Cargo Rocket
                                      ( Increment 2 )
                               Cargo Only Limited by Volume & Weight

                   DEPLOYABLE WINGS

Guidance Parameters Set
                                                Payload                     VOLUME:
During Pre-launch to
Accommodate Cargo Type                          Section                     8½ inch X 11½ inch Elliptical
                                                                            Cross section X 36 inch length
                                                                            Weighs 200-230 lbs max

                            Cargo Must Be Provided With Adapters for the
                                Standard Payload Dispensing System
System Key Performance Parameters ( Increment Two ):
 • Will Accept any CARGO That Meets Volume and Weight             Current Cargo Capability
 Constraints                                                           • Smart Surgical Strike Cargo
 • Variable (Up Loaded) Guidance Parameters will Accommodate              •BONUS (10 ea)
 Different Dispense                                                       •P3I Skeet (10 ea)
   Altitudes, Attitudes & Velocities                                      •SMart
 • Payload Dispense                                                       •BLU-108 (SFW) (2 ea) (8
   - Interfaces Will Include Mechanical Adapters and Software              Skeet)
       Requirements to Control Sequence                                • Smart Precision Strike Cargo
         - Timing of Dispense Operation                                   •Mini-Penetrator Rods
         - Information Exchange Between Warhead and Submunition             • (2 ea Large)
         - Power Inputs to CARGO Munitions                                  • (10 ea Small)
 • CARGO Provider will be Responsible for dispensing Adapters          • Non-Lethal
 and Software Adapters                                                    •Jammer/Sensor
   That Meet Interface Requirements                                       •Propaganda                    36
UNCLASSIFIED

                           GMLRS Cargo Rocket
                                                                                                          GPS / Inertially Guided to
 Trajectory Shaped to Engage                          Seeker Guides Warhead
                                                                                                           Estimated Target Area
      Dispersed Targets                                 to Target Position
                                                                                      Seeker Acquires
                               Submunitions Dispensed Directly
                                   Over Assigned Target
                                                                                        Target Array
       Targets Handed
     Off to Submunitions

                                                                                                                Warhead Self-
                                                                                                                 Destructs if
                                                                                                             Submunitions Have
                                                                                                             Not Been Dispensed

                                               Objective System Description:
• Single Shot, Multiple Kills 1                                                 • Can Carry Large Variety of Cargo Types1
• High component and subsystem                                                  • Services Targets with Large Target
  Commonality with MLRS Family of Weapons 1                                       Location Errors
• Built on Proven Technology 1                                                  • Large Search Area Capability
• End Game Trajectory Shaping for Optimum                                       • No Data Link Required (Updates Not
  Submunition Assignment 1 (Partial)                                              Necessary; but can be done) 1
• Stationary-To-Moving, Hard-to-Soft, All                                       • Maximized System Effectiveness
  Weather Target Engagement                                                       and Efficiency
   Create the                                    Note: 1 – Increment Two        • No New Training Required 1
    Thunder                                                                                                                       37
                                                                                                                                  37
Need for Sensor Fuzed Munitions

             •   Historical and recent analysis (Center for Army
                 Analysis DPICM Alternative Study, Jan 2001) has
                 consistently shown SFMs are an effective killer of
                 combat vehicles and artillery pieces

                  – SFMs contribute greatly in both Current and
                    Stryker scenarios

                  – SFMs significantly increase lethality and blue
                    artillery survivability

             •   SADARM ORD approved 1994 (invalid due to age)

             •   SADARM performance in OIF highlighted in 3rd ID
                 After Action Report (AAR)

Create the
 Thunder                                                              38
                                                                      38
JBMOU Sensor Fuzed Munition
            (SFM) Compliance Testing
           SMArt 155 – GIWS/ATK                SYSTEM
                                               SYSTEM CHARACTERISTICS:
                                                        CHARACTERISTICS:
                                               SMArt
                                               SMArt 155
                                                     155
                                               ¾
                                               ¾ Range
                                                  Range –– 2222 Km
                                                                 Km
                                               ¾
                                               ¾ Ballistic
                                                  Ballistic similarity
                                                            similarity with
                                                                       with M483
                                                                             M483 (DPICM)
                                                                                    (DPICM)
                                               ¾
                                               ¾ Sensor
                                                  Sensor Systems
                                                           Systems –– MMWMMW Active/Passive
                                                                                 Active/Passive and
                                                                                                and
                                                 IR
                                                  IR (DPICM)
                                                     (DPICM)
           Bonus – Bofors/UDLP                 ¾
                                               ¾ Submunition
                                                  Submunition Search
                                                                  Search area
                                                                           area –– 35,000
                                                                                   35,000 sq
                                                                                          sq MM
                                                 Bonus
                                                  Bonus
                                               ¾
                                               ¾ Range
                                                  Range –– 2727 Km
                                                                 Km (Base
                                                                      (Base Bleed)
                                                                              Bleed)
                                               ¾
                                               ¾ Ballistic
                                                  Ballistic similarity
                                                            similarity with
                                                                       with M864
                                                                             M864
                                               ¾
                                               ¾ Sensor
                                                  Sensor System
                                                           System –– Multi
                                                                        Multi band
                                                                              band Passive
                                                                                    Passive IR
                                                                                             IR
                                               ¾
                                               ¾ Submunition
                                                  Submunition Search
                                                                  Search area
                                                                           area –– 32,000
                                                                                   32,000 sq
                                                                                          sq MM

SYSTEM
SYSTEM DESCRIPTION:
       DESCRIPTION:
SMArt
SMArt 155
        155 and
            and Bonus
                 Bonus -- Autonomous
                           Autonomous fire
                                         fire and
                                              and forget
                                                    forget all
                                                           all weather
                                                               weather 155mm
                                                                       155mm projectile
                                                                               projectile containing
                                                                                          containing 22
top
top attack
    attack submunitions.
           submunitions. Submunitions
                            Submunitions areare ejected
                                                 ejected over
                                                           over armored
                                                                armored targets,
                                                                         targets, perform
                                                                                  perform aa
decreasing
decreasing spiral
             spiral scan,
                    scan, detect
                          detect the
                                 the target,
                                     target, initiate
                                              initiate warhead
                                                       warhead and
                                                                 and penetrate
                                                                     penetrate the
                                                                                the target.
                                                                                    target.
   Create the
    Thunder
                                                                                                          39
Phase II - Precision
               Effects Study

Create the
 Thunder                            40
                                    40
Phase II Guidance

9On 2 Feb 04, briefed CG, TRADOC on Phase I study results and
 USAFAC recommendations

9CG, TRADOC directed USAFAC to produce a matrix of all
 candidate munitions for providing “general purpose” precision
 capability

Create the
 Thunder
                                                                 41
Operational Insights -
        Precision Fires Study

Create the
 Thunder                         42
                                 42
Normalized

                                                                                                                                                        1.00

                                                                                            0
                                                                                                  0.20
                                                                                                          0.40
                                                                                                                   0.60
                                                                                                                                   0.80
                                                                                                                                                                                1.20
                                                                                                Base Case (1UE + 4 UAs)                                                                       1.40

 Thunder
Create the
                                                                                                BC without UE

                                                                                                                                          -16%
                                                                                                                                                               0%
                                                                                                BC without NLOS-M
                                                                                                                                                               0%
                                                                                                BC without NLOS-C
                                                                                                                                                               0%

                                                                                                BC without NLOS-LS

                                                                            Effectiveness
                                                                                                                                                               -1%

                                                                                                BC without Army Aviation
                                                                                                BC without Joint Air
                                                                                                                                                 -10%

                                                                                                Base Case (1UE + 4 UAs)
                                                                                                BC without UE
                                                                                                                 -50%

                                                                                                BC without NLOS-M
                                                                                                BC without NLOS-C
                                                                                                                                                                +4% +5%

               Army Aviation and Joint Air assets.
                                                                                                BC without NLOS-LS
                                                                                                                                                                                      +16%

                                                                            Total Weight

                                                                                                BC without Army Aviation
                                                                                                                                                                               +13%

                                                                                                BC without Joint Air
                                                                                                                                 -30%

                                                                                                Base Case (1UE + 4 UAs)
             • Force structure for the scenario is 4 UAs and 1 UEx.

                                                                                                BC without UE
                                                                                                                          -40%

                                                                                                BC without NLOS-M
                                                                                                                                                                          +13%

                                                                                                BC without NLOS-C
                                                                                                                                                                                       +20%

                                                                                                BC without NLOS-LS
                                                                            Total Cost

                                                                                                BC without Army Aviation
                                                                                                                                                                     +7% +9%
                                                                                                                                                                                                       of Indirect Fire Assets within the UA/UE

             • The Base Case consists of NLOS-M, NLOS-C, NLOS-LS, HIMARS,

                                                                                                BC without Joint Air
                                                                                                                                  -25%
                                                                                                                                                                                                     Comparative Effectiveness, Weight, and Cost

43
43
Insights from UA/UE Mix Analysis

  9 Units of Action are 16% less effective without the UEX assets
    and 10% less without Joint air assets
  9 With respect to NLOS-M, NLOS-C, NLOS-LS and Army
    Aviation, there is no loss in effectiveness with the removal
    of any one system; however, in all cases, an increase in
    weight of munitions fired and cost of the munitions becomes
    evident

Create the
 Thunder
                                                                    44
You can also read