DIGITAL STORM - CYBERSECURITY BUSH FLYING WITH MAF NEW SPACE - HOW TEMPEST IS SETTING THE PACE - December 2022

Page created by Cody Garner
 
CONTINUE READING
DIGITAL STORM - CYBERSECURITY BUSH FLYING WITH MAF NEW SPACE - HOW TEMPEST IS SETTING THE PACE - December 2022
DECEMBER 2022
AEROSPACE

                                                                  CYBERSECURITY
                                                                  BUSH FLYING WITH MAF
                                                                  NEW SPACE

                             www.aerosociety.com
December 2022
Volume 49 Number 12

                                                   DIGITAL STORM
                                                   HOW TEMPEST IS SETTING THE PACE
                                                       FOR MILITARY AEROSPACE
Royal Aeronautical Society
DIGITAL STORM - CYBERSECURITY BUSH FLYING WITH MAF NEW SPACE - HOW TEMPEST IS SETTING THE PACE - December 2022
ARCHIVE & INSIGHT BLOG

          Download the New AEROSPACE APP

                  Available for your phone and tablet
       Prepare for an awesome launch! AEROSPACE is now available as an app!
       AEROSPACE has continued to grow in stature and influence as the informative and expert source of
       aviation, aerospace and space news, opinion and analysis. Revitalised from a design refresh, the clearer
       sharper magazine now presents key stories in a crisp stylish setting now seamlessly integrated into a
       convenient app.
       Notifications when a new issue is available
            Download and browse past issues from the previous two years
            Download issues to read offline
            Search function
            Includes the twice weekly AEROSPACE Insight blog
            Available on Android and Apple devices.
       Search AEROSPACE on Google Play or iTunes, Download the app and log in using your aerosociety.com
       member portal username and password.
            The AEROSPACE App is the one-stop destination to the latest news in the fast-moving
               world of aerospace from The Royal Aeronautical Society. Download a copy now!

               publications@aerosociety.com           +44 (0)20 7670 4300                  @aerosociety

AEROSPACE APP advert 7_2021 280x210.indd 1                                                                  22/07/2021 15:29
DIGITAL STORM - CYBERSECURITY BUSH FLYING WITH MAF NEW SPACE - HOW TEMPEST IS SETTING THE PACE - December 2022
Volume 49 Number 12
December 2022

   EDITORIAL                                                                                                                     Contents
   Gambling the future                                                                                                           Regulars
   As this is being written, the last-ever Boeing 747 is making its final journey out                                            4 Radome                                   12 Transmission
   of Boeing’s giant factory, closing a chapter in aviation history that saw the iconic                                          The latest aviation and                    Your letters, emails, tweets
                                                                                                                                 aeronautical intelligence,                 and other social media
   ‘jumbo jet’ bring air travel to the masses and shrink the world. In company legend,                                           analysis and comment.                      feedback.
   Boeing ‘bet the farm’ on the 747, gambling that even if the US Air Force was
   not interested in it as a transport aircraft it might interest airlines with its ability to                                   11 Pushing the Envelope                    58 The Last Word
                                                                                                                                 Rob Coppinger asks if water                This month, Keith Hayward
   transport hundreds of passengers over long distances.                                                                                                                    discusses ICAO and its role
                                                                                                                                 injected powerplants are
        That gamble paid off. Yet today, some analysts are worried that Boeing has                                               about to make a resurgence                 on the international and
   become increasingly risk-averse when it comes to future product strategy –                                                    in a bid to reduce emissions.              political stage.
   especially when it comes to a clean-sheet new airliner – something the airframer
   has been mulling for years now. During a recent investors call, CEO David                                                     Features
   Calhoun stressed that any new aircraft is now a decade or more off. His logic,                                                14 Wind of Change                          30 Approaching the SMS
   which is difficult to refute, is that pressing environmental demands mean that any                                            In October, the RAeS hosted                Mandate
                                                                                                                                 senior members of the Team                 Safety Management System
   new airliner will have to offer double-digit fuel burn efficiency in order to win a                                           Tempest consortium and                     implementation is changing.
   place in tomorrow’s market. Still scarred by the 737 MAX crisis, Boeing’s launch                                              MoD officials for an exclusive             David Learmount reports
   decision is made more complex by the bewildering number of unconventional                                                     roundtable update on the FCAS              from Wing Engineering’s SMS
                                                                                                                                 programme.                                 seminar and workshop.
   configurations, competing propulsion and fuel solutions that may be available

                                                                                                                                                                                                              ESA
                                                                                                                                                                  MAF
   in the 2040s, many of which also require extremely close integration with the
   airframe. Long gone is the ‘easy’ upgrade path of fitting an airliner with engines
   of gradually increasing bypass ratios.
        However, while Boeing is pondering the options, its arch rival in Toulouse is
   set to make hay in the narrowbody sector and accelerate even further ahead in
   the next decade, with some predicting that the Airbus/Boeing market share may                                                 Of Flight and Faith
                                                                                                                                                          20                Launching into a New
                                                                                                                                                                                                       34
   end up 70/30 – a potentially irreversible decline. Moreover, if there is a decade-                                            Now in its 75th year of                    Era of Space
                                                                                                                                 operations, Mission Aviation               The 2022 RAeS President’s
   long drought in developing a clean-sheet airliner – who will design it? A skills gap                                          Fellowship has begun flying in             Conference was titled New
   may turn into a skills chasm.                                                                                                 Guinean skies. Robin Evans                 Space and looked at how the
        Getting this wrong, of course, could spell disaster, but if the alternative is a                                         reports on MAF’s bush flyers.              sector can adapt and grow.
   slow decline and fading glory, will Boeing roll the dice one last time?

                                                                                                                                                                                                              Iranian State TV
                                                                                                                                                                  Embraer

   Tim Robinson FRAeS, Editor-in-Chief
   tim.robinson@aerosociety.com @RAeSTimR
     Correspondence on all aerospace matters is welcome at: publications@aerosociety.com

Editor-in-Chief                                 Editorial Office                           2022 AEROSPACE subscription
                                                                                                                                                           24                                         38
Tim Robinson FRAeS                              Royal Aeronautical Society                 rates: Non-members, £195              Net Zero by 2050?                          Cyber Rattling
+44 (0)20 7670 4353                             No.4 Hamilton Place                        To place your order, contact:         The 2022 Global Aviation                   Is increasing digitisation
tim.robinson@aerosociety.com                    London W1J 7BQ, UK                         Wayne J Davis                         Summit brought together                    of aviation opening up a
                                                +44 (0)20 7670 4300                        +44 (0)20 7670 4354                   senior figures from across                 pathway to cyber risk?
Deputy Editor
                                                publications@aerosociety.com
Stephen Bridgewater                                                                        aerosubs@aerosociety.com              the industry to address                    Dave Sloggett asks if cyber
                                                www.aerosociety.com                                                                                                         threats to aviation are real or
+44 (0)20 7670 4351                                                                        Any member not requiring a print      climate change and
stephen.bridgewater@aerosociety.com             AEROSPACE is published by the Royal        version of this magazine should       biodiversity.                              imagined.
                                                Aeronautical Society (RAeS).               contact: membership@aerosociety.com
Production Manager
Wayne J Davis FRAeS
+44 (0)20 7670 4354
                                                Chief Executive
                                                David Edwards FRAeS
                                                                                           USA: Periodical postage paid at
                                                                                           Champlain New York and additional
                                                                                                                                 Afterburner
wayne.davis@aerosociety.com                     Advertising                                offices.                              42 Message from our President
                                                +44 (0)20 7670 4346                        Postmaster: Send address changes
Publications Executive
                                                partners@aerosociety.com                                                         43 Message from our CEO
Chris Male FRAeS                                                                           to IMS of New York, PO Box 1518,
+44 (0)20 7670 4352                             Unless specifically attributed, no
                                                                                           Champlain NY 12919-1518, USA.         44 Book Reviews
chris.male@aerosociety.com                      material in AEROSPACE shall be taken       ISSN 2052-451X                        47 Additions to the National Aerospace Library
Production Executive                            to represent the opinion of the RAeS.
                                                Reproduction of material used in this
                                                                                                                                 48 RAeS Diary
Annabel Hallam
+44 (0)20 7670 4361                             publication is not permitted without the                                         49 RAeS Branches Conference
annabel.hallam@aerosociety.com                  written consent of the Editor-in-Chief.
                                                Printed by Buxton Press Limited,
                                                                                                                                 50 Isle of Wight Branch STEM activities
Book Review Editor
Tony Pilmer                                     Palace Road, Buxton, Derbyshire                                                  51 RAeS 2022 Governance Review
book.reviews@aerosociety.com                    SK17 6AE, UK
                                                                                                                                 52 New Member Spotlight
                                                Distributed by Mail International.
                                                                                                                                 54 Elections
Cover: Tempest FCAS and its digital twin. (Leonardo)                                                                             55 Obituary – David Eveleigh Gibbings
                   Additional content is available to view online at: aerosociety.com/aerospaceinsight
                                                                                                                                                Read AEROSPACE and the Insight blog on your
                       Including: The importance of early reporting – EgyptAir Flight MS804, Electrify your commute,
                        Approaching the SMS mandate, Inclusive skies, Exclusive Team Tempest Roundtable highlights
                                                                                                                                                smartphone or tablet with the AEROSPACE app
                       podcast, Morson Projects welcomes first Leonardo trainees, Swift progress, Airship resurgence.              APP         Available from Apple App Store and Google Play.

        @aerosociety           i    Find us on LinkedIn         f     Find us on Facebook            www.aerosociety.com                                                                DECEMBER 2022                            13
DIGITAL STORM - CYBERSECURITY BUSH FLYING WITH MAF NEW SPACE - HOW TEMPEST IS SETTING THE PACE - December 2022
Blueprint
                     INTELLIGENCE / ANALYSIS / COMMENT

                     Advanced sustainment
                     Sustainment and life cycle costs would
                     be addressed through affordable
                     remanufacturing and lowered acquisition
                     costs.

                                                               Sensor fusion
                                                               The Modernized Apache would include
                                                               the latest sensors, combining these
                                                               with sensor fusion and pilot cognitive
                                                               and workload assistance.

                      DEFENCE

                      Future Apache breaks cover
                     At the US Army’s AUSA conference in October, Boeing Defense unveiled its concept for an evolved
                     AH-64 attack helicopter – the ‘Modernized Apache’ – to enable it to remain lethal into the 2060s in the
                     future Multi-Domain Operations battlespace. The Modernized Apache would build on the latest
                     AH-64Ev6 and include drivetrain upgrades, modular open systems, advanced sensors and mission
    Boeing Defense

                     systems, and long-range precision munitions and directed-energy weapons. Its stub wing weapon
                     mounts would increase from four to six pylons.

4                    AEROSPACE
DIGITAL STORM - CYBERSECURITY BUSH FLYING WITH MAF NEW SPACE - HOW TEMPEST IS SETTING THE PACE - December 2022
Mission system                                                        Drivetrain upgrades
A modular mission system will allow the                               The Improved Turbine Engine and
operators to ‘plug & play’ new sensors,                               upgraded drivetrain would increase
payloads and capabilities without                                     the Apache’s power, range, efficiency
extensive and costly integration.                                     and speed. The new GE901 engine
                                                                      will also power the US Army’s Future
                                                                      Attack Reconnaissance Aircraft (FARA)
                                                                      rotorcraft.

                                                                        Extra firepower
                                                                        Stub wing pylons would be increased
                                                                        from four to six, allowing the
                                                                        Apache to bring additional weapons
                                                                        and combat persistence to the
                                                                        battlespace.

                       Laser weapons
                       New weapons options for the Modernized
                       Apache would include longer-range precision
                       munitions, ‘air launched effects’, including
                       small drones and directed energy weapons.

                                                                                                     DECEMBER 2022   5
DIGITAL STORM - CYBERSECURITY BUSH FLYING WITH MAF NEW SPACE - HOW TEMPEST IS SETTING THE PACE - December 2022
Radome
    SPACEFLIGHT                                                                                               AEROSPACE

    Artemis 1 finally                                                                                         No clean-sheet aircraft

                                                                                                       NASA
    lifts off                                                                                                 until 2035, says Boeing
    On 16 November, NASA launched its uncrewed                                                                At an investors’ day call in   aircraft saying: “If it doesn’t
    Artemis 1 mission to the Moon from Launch                                                                 early November, Boeing         have a sustainability
    Complex 39B, Cape Canaveral, Florida. This was                                                            CEO David Calhoun              wrapper all around it, if it
    the third attempt to launch the SLS rocket and its                                                        poured cold water on           can’t meet the emissions
    Orion capsule on a translunar flight. A previous                                                          the long-mooted idea           tests, if it can’t deliver
    launch was scrubbed due to a hydrogen leak                                                                to launch a new clean-         significant performance
    while, earlier in November, the rocket stack on the                                                       sheet airliner in the          advantages, then there
    pad was buffeted by the high winds of Hurricane                                                           near future, saying that       won’t be an airplane.”
    Nicole, after a previous storm led NASA to delay                                                          it would now be 2035           However, he promised that
    the October launch and roll it back to the VAB                                                            at the earliest. Calhoun       the company would “pull a
    (Vehicle Assembly Building). The Orion module                                                             stressed that there needed     rabbit out of the hat” and
    and its attached European-built service module                                                            to be a 20%+ efficiency        introduce a new aircraft
    will now conduct a 25-day mission around the                                                              breakthrough to justify the    in the middle of the next
    Moon and back to splashdown on 11 December.                                                               launch of a clean-sheet        decade.

    UKRAINE CONFLICT
      DEFENCE                                                            DEFENCE

      Keep the air war pressure                                          Over 25% of Russian Ka-52 fleet
      on, warns RUSI                                                     destroyed
      A report on the air war          up stocks of missiles to          According to an intelligence

                                                                                                                                                                        Russian MoD
      in Ukraine from the UK           counter aircraft, cruise          update from the UK MoD,
      defence think tank, Royal        missiles and loitering            Russia is now confirmed to
      United Services Institute        munitions. This means             have lost over 25% of its Ka-52
      (RUSI) has warned that,          that there is an urgent           attack helicopter fleet in the war
      despite recent Russian           need for the West to              in Ukraine. There are now 23
      reverses, Ukraine will           deliver new Western-built         visually verified losses of Ka-52
      still need support from          SAM systems and missile           helicopters, or over a quarter
      the West. In particular,         ammunition, self-powered          of the 90-strong fleet, under
      the report highlighted           artillery systems (SPAAGs)        growing evidence that Moscow
      that Ukraine’s extensive         and, ideally, fighter aircraft,   has pushed its helicopter crews
      usage of Russian-made            to maintain the battlefield       into action to halt the Ukrainian
      SAM systems are burning          momentum on the ground.           counter-offensive.

    NEWS IN BRIEF
                                      test tools to eliminate            latest attempt to snag a             engineers, just in the US.     Aviation Administration
    The UK government                 persistent contrails. The          reusable first stage of its          The study highlights a         of China (CAAC).
    has launched a new                airline says the research          Electron rocket in mid-air           retention problem in the       Certification of the
    campaign to increase the          and findings will be shared        using a helicopter on 4              advanced aerial mobility       E195-E2 is expected to
    attractiveness of aviation        with the public.                   November failed after                sector, double that of the     follow shortly.
    careers. ‘Generation                                                 a telemetry problem.                 legacy aerospace and
    Aviation’ will aim to raise the   Northrop Grumman                   However, the launch did              defence industry which, it     Eviation has agreed a
    profile of aviation careers,      will roll out the first            put the MATS satellite               says, is due to ostracism.     deal to provide 25 Alice
    signpost opportunities to         B-21 Raider from                   for the Swedish National             It calls on organisations      electric aircraft to German
    rejoin, promote the sector,       Air Force Plant 41 in              Space Agency into orbit.             to “implement a culture        start-up airline Evia Aero.
    as well as use data and           Palmdale, California on                                                 of diversity, inclusion, and   The airline has yet to
    research to boost future          2 December. Currently,             According to a study by              equity.”                       begin flights and plans to
    resilience.                       six B-21s are in various           the Vertical Flight Society                                         use the nine-passenger
                                      stages of construction.            and hydrogen lobbying                Embraer has announced          Alice in a travel network,
    Delta Air Lines has                                                  group HySky Society,                 its E190-E2 airliner           spanning Germany,
    announced it is partnering        New Zealand/US launch              the emerging eVTOL                   has been awarded type          Austria, Belgium, Denmark
    with MIT to study and             provider Rocket Lab’s              sector will need 10,000              certification by the Civil     and the Netherlands.

6   AEROSPACE
DIGITAL STORM - CYBERSECURITY BUSH FLYING WITH MAF NEW SPACE - HOW TEMPEST IS SETTING THE PACE - December 2022
AIR TRANSPORT                                                                                          SPACEFLIGHT

                           A330 heads for Prime time Latest Chinese space
                                                                                                       station module blasts off

                                                                                              Airbus
                                                                                                       On 31 October, a Long       forward docking port to a
                                                                                                       March 5B launcher           side port on 3 November
                                                                                                       carrying the newest         to create a T-shaped
                                                                                                       module for the Chinese      structure. The addition
                                                                                                       Space Station lifted off    of the Mengtian module
                                                                                                       from Wenchang Launch        allows the station’s
                                                                                                       Complex in China. The       occupants to be doubled
                                                                                                       rocket was carrying the     to six astronauts from the
                                                                                                       23t Mengtian (‘Dreaming     current three on board.
                                                                                                       of the Heavens’)            With its completion, China
The aerial logistics arm of global e-commerce giant Amazon, Amazon Air, has signed a firm              Laboratory Module for the   now plans to keep it
agreement to lease 10 Airbus A330-300P2F converted freighters to bolster its cargo fleet.              Tiangong space station.     permanently occupied.
The cargo aircraft, which will enter service from 2023 and are being converted by EFW, will            The new science lab was     (See By The Numbers,
be operated by Hawaiian Airlines.                                                                      moved from the original     p 10).

GENERAL AVIATION                                                 AEROSPACE

Six dead after B-17 and                                        Stratolaunch conducts hypersonic
P-63 mid-air collision                                         vehicle captive carry test flight
All six people on board         the bomber’s tail while

                                                                                                                                                               Stratolaunch
an historic B-17G and           turning into the display
P-63 Kingcobra were             circuit. The pilot of the
killed on 12 November,          P-63 and the five people
when the aircraft collided      aboard the B-17 ‘Texas
in mid-air at an air show       Raiders’ were killed
in Dallas, Texas. The           instantly when the two
two warbirds, operated          aircraft disintegrated. No
by the Commemorative            one on the ground was
Air Force had been              injured with the wreckage       The giant six-engine, twin-fuselage Stratolaunch ‘Roc’ carrier aircraft has carried out
taking part in the Wings        landing within the airport      the first captive carry flight of the Talon-A uncrewed hypersonic test vehicle. The flight
over Dallas air show at         boundaries. The NTSB            took place from Mojave Air and Space Port, California on 28 October, with the test flight
Dallas Executive Airport        is now investigating the        lasting five hours. Stratolaunch, originally designed to launch rockets horizontally, has
when the P-63 took off          accident.                       now been repurposed into a high-speed test launch mothership.

                                of its Starlink internet                                               on 28 October. The          Volvo Group with a 50%
The first Boeing E-7            service, offering high-         Bombardier has signed                  drone, developed by         SAF blend powering its
Wedgetail for the Royal         speed, low-latency in-flight    a multiyear deal with                  Sichuan Tengden Science     ATR 72s.
Air Force has had its           internet for airliners and      aviation services company,             and Technology, has a
MESA radar installed.           bizjets from between            Signature Aviation for                 wingspan of 20m and a       On 15 November, two
The Northrop Grumman            $12,500 to $25,000              the purchase of enough                 maximum payload of 1.4t.    people were killed in Poland
Multi-role Electronically       per month. Installation         sustainable aviation fuel                                          when missiles, believed
Scanned Array (MESA)            will require customers to       (SAF) to cover all of its              Sweden’s Braathens          to be Ukrainian SAMs
which provides 360°             pay a one-time hardware         flight operations. The fuel            Regional Airlines has       launched to intercept
coverage with a giant           cost of $150,000 for the        will be used for production            claimed to be the world’s   Russian cruise missiles,
‘surfboard’ style antenna       necessary equipment             testing and certification              first airline to operate    landed in the village of
was fitted to the E-7           but, once complete,             flights, relocation flights,           regular services with the   Przewodów, near the
fuselage at STS Aviation,       Starlink promises an            customer demo flights and              maximum permissable         border with Ukraine. The
in Birmingham.                  aerial internet experience      after-service check flights.           blend of SAF. It will       same day had seen Russia
                                capable of video calls,                                                operate a twice-weekly      blitz Ukraine with around
SpaceX has launched             VPNs, streaming and even        China has flown a new                  Gothenburg-Lyon             100 missiles, a larger attack
the aeronautical version        gaming.                         four-engine cargo UAV                  corporate route for the     than on 10 October.

                                                                                                                                              DECEMBER 2022                   7
DIGITAL STORM - CYBERSECURITY BUSH FLYING WITH MAF NEW SPACE - HOW TEMPEST IS SETTING THE PACE - December 2022
Radome
    GENERAL AVIATION                                                                                                 AIR TRANSPORT

    Archer unveils Midnight eVTOL                                                                                    Precision Air crash into
                                                                                                                     Lake Victoria kills 19

                                                                                                   Archer Aviation
                                                                                                                     On 6 November, an ATR            were rescued by emergency
                                                                                                                     42-500 regional turboprop        services and local fishermen.
                                                                                                                     operated by Tanzanian airline,   The flight, PW 494, was on a
                                                                                                                     Precision Air crashed into       scheduled service from Dar
                                                                                                                     Lake Victoria, with the loss     es Salaam to Bukoba Airport
                                                                                                                     of 19 lives, including the two   on the shores of Lake Victoria
                                                                                                                     pilots. Twenty-four people       when the crash happened
                                                                                                                     out of the 43 on board           at around 0853 local time,
                                                                                                                     survived the incident, which     with bad weather reported at
    On 16 November, US urban air mobility developer Archer Aviation revealed its production                          saw the aircraft ending up       the time. Tanzania has now
    Midnight eVTOL. Midnight will carry four passengers and one pilot, and will have a range                         partly submerged in the lake     launched a full investigation
    of 60 miles with a crusing speed of 150mph. Charging turnaround time is aimed to be                              and appearing mostly intact      into the accident, with the
    10 minutes. The company has already won commitments from United Airlines which, in                               on social media photos.          aircraft’s ‘black box’ already
    August placed a $10m deposit towards the first 100 examples.                                                     The surviving passengers         recovered.

    DEFENCE                                                           AEROSPACE

    Chinese pilot recruitment                                         GKN claims hydrogen milestone
    probe spreads

                                                                                                                                                                                   GKN Aerospace
    Following reports that around   repercussions. One ex-
    30 former RAF pilots had        USMC Harrier pilot has
    been lured to work in China,    already been arrested in
    the governments of France,      Australia. The row blew up
    Australia and Canada have       after the UK MoD issued a
    also begun investigating        rare warning to pilots thinking
    whether Western ex-military     of selling their services
    pilots are helping to train     to China. However, a test
    Chinese pilots. The nations     pilot school in South Africa
    have warned their former        claimed that the UK MoD           GKN has annouced it has completed a major milestone in demonstrating the safe
    employees that helping the      had been fully aware of its       handling of an end-to-end liquid hydrogen aircraft fuel system. The ground-based
    Chinese military gain the       training links to China which     demonstrator, under the Innovate UK-funded Safe Flight project, was based around
    upper hand over Western         did not include the transfer of   the use of a hydrogen-powered search and rescue UAV to increase its endurance and
    allies could likely lead to     classified information.           used a proton exchange membrane (PEM) fuel cell stack to verify the fuel system.

    NEWS IN BRIEF
                                    announced at NBAA-                Jeppesen’s services                                                             the UK’s New Medium
    An uncrewed Northrop            BACE 2022 in Orlando              were impacted after a                          At the Zhuhai Air Show           Helicopter requirement
    Grumman Cygnus                  in October. The aircraft          reported ransomware                            in China, COMAC                  to replace the RAF
    cargo ship made it to           is now expected to be             cyberattack on the                             announced 300 new                Puma and three other
    the International Space         certified in the second half      company. The company                           orders from seven                helicopter types in UK
    Station (ISS) on 10             of 2024 with the delay            said it was experiencing                       Chinese lessors for its          service. The bidders are
    November after one of           attributed to availability of     technical difficulties                         C919 narrowbody airliner         Airbus (H175M), Boeing,
    its two main solar panels       the GE Aviation Catalyst          with some products                             – as well as 30 for the          Leonardo (AW149), and
    failed to deploy in orbit. It   turboprop engine. The             and services, as well                          ARJ21. The latest deal           Lockheed Martin (S-70M).
    was grappled by the ISS         850-1,600shp Catalyst             as the processing and                          for the C919 now brings
    Canadarm2 and safely            is the first clean-sheet          distribution of NOTAMs.                        the total orders to 1,115.       NASA has revealed the first
    berthed.                        business turboprop                However, the Boeing                            The first C919 is set to         crewed flight of Boeing’s
                                    engine design in 50 years         subsidiary stressed that                       be delivered to launch           CST-100 Starliner spacecraft
    Type certification of           and also the first to use         there was “no reason to                        customer China Eastern           has now slipped to April
    the Beechcraft Denali           3D-printed components.            believe that this incident                     this month.                      2023 from a previous launch
    turboprop single has been                                         poses a threat to aircraft                                                      date of February. Starliner,
    delayed by a year, parent       Flight planning software          or flight safety.” (See                        Four bidders have now            which was originally
    company Textron Aviation        and digital map provider,         ‘Cyber rattling’ p 38).                        been downselected for            supposed to fly in 2017, will

8   AEROSPACE
DIGITAL STORM - CYBERSECURITY BUSH FLYING WITH MAF NEW SPACE - HOW TEMPEST IS SETTING THE PACE - December 2022
SPACEFLIGHT                                                     AEROSPACE

                                                                                                          ATR celebrates

                                                                                                                                                                          ATR
Spaceport Cornwall
awarded lift-off licence                                                                              double certification
On the eve of the very          paperwork. The launch
first satellite launch from     will use Virgin Orbit’s
British soil, the UK CAA        modified Boeing 747
has awarded Spaceport           launch aircraft ‘Cosmic
Cornwall the first ever UK      Girl’ which will drop the
spaceport licence, opening      LauncherOne rocket over
the door for Virgin Orbit’s     the North Atlantic. The nine
‘Start Me Up’ mission           CubeSats for this mission       Turboprop manufacturer ATR has revealed that its ATR 42-600 regional airliner has finally
from Newquay airport later      include the DSTL/NRO            been certificated by the Civil Aviation Administration of China (CAAC). The airframer also
this month. The mission         Prometheus-2 satellite,         announced an order for three ATR 42-600s from an undisclosed Chinese customer.
was originallly scheduled       in-orbit manufacturing          Meanwhile, ATR also received EASA type certificates for its ATR 72 and 42 regional aircraft
to launch in November,          demonstrator SpaceForge,        outfitted with P&WC’s PW127XT-M turboprop engine. Purpose-built for the ATR, the
but had been reportedly         and the first satellite from    engine is expected to provide 40% extended time on wing, 20% lower maintenance costs
delayed by regulatory           Oman.                           and a 3% improvement in fuel efficiency over previous-generation engines.

DEFENCE                                                                                               AIR TRANSPORT

                                                                                               USAF
                                                                                                      IAG firms up A320neo
                                                                                                      and 737 MAX orders
                                                                                                      The shareholders of Aer            haul aircraft Airbus products.
                                                                                                      Lingus, British Airways, Iberia    However, the same day
                                                                                                      and Vueling parent group, IAG      also saw approval from the
                                                                                                      have approved a firm order         shareholders for a firm order
AFSOC tests roll-off missile carrier                                                                  to acquire 50 Boeing 737
                                                                                                      MAX airliners, with options
                                                                                                                                         for an additional 37 A320neo
                                                                                                                                         airliners, adding to a previous
USAF Special Operations (AFSOC) has conducted the first live-fire test of ramp-                       for another 100. Deliveries        order for 22 A320neo family
launched cruise missiles from a cargo aircraft in the European theatre in November.                   will take place from 2023 and      narrowbodies announced
The Rapid Dragon demo, over the Norwegian Sea, saw an MC-130J drop a pallet of                        2027, with the order divided       earlier this year, bringing the
unspecified weapons out of its rear cargo bay, which then fired their motors. A previous              between 25 737-8-200s and          total to 59 single-aisle aircraft.
test in 2020 saw long-range JASSM missiles used to destroy a mock target in the Gulf                  27 737-10s. The order marks        The agreement also includes
of Mexico. The Rapid Dragon palletised munition concept is designed to allow medium                   a shift in the IAG member          options for a further 50.
or large cargo aircraft to be quickly turned into bombers armed with precision stand-off              airlines’ narrowbody fleet, with   Deliveries of the A320neos
weapons.                                                                                              all its current short/medium-      will begin in 2025.

now not enter operational                                       To be delivered between
service until 2024 at the       Universal Hydrogen              2024 and 2027, this will               ON THE MOVE
earliest, according to NASA’s   plans to fly a modified De      grow the 737 MAX fleet
latest flight schedule.         Havilland Dash 8-300            from 94 to 146.                                                          recently stepped down as
                                with a hydrogen-fuel-                                                  Katherine Bennett                 CEO of Etihad Airways.
The UK CAA has issued           cell-based powertrain           Textron Aviation Defense               FRAeS, CEO of High
a consultation to simplify      by the end of the year. A       delivered the 1,000th                  Value Manufacturing               Terry Holloway FRAeS
gaining and maintaining         1-megawatt powertrain           Beechcraft T-6C Texan II               (HVM) Catapult has                received a Master Air
a GA private pilot licence      will be fitted in one engine    aircraft on 12 October. The            been awarded 2022’s               Pilot Certificate from the
in an overhaul of the PPL.      nacelle, with the aircraft to   landmark 1,000th airframe              Woman of Excellence by            Honourable Company of
The proposal includes           be test flown out of Moses      was handed over to the                 the International Aviation        Air Pilots at the annual
creating a single set of        Lake, Washington.               Colombian Air Force, which             Women’s Association               Trophies & Awards
licences for aircraft and                                       now has a fleet of five T-6C           (IAWA).                           Banquet on 27 October.
helicopters, as well as         Alaska Airlines has made        Texan IIs based in Palanquero.                                           Other winners included
a sub-ICAO licence for          the biggest order in its 90-    The latest customer for                Tony Douglas is to be             round-the-world flyers
flying in UK airspace only.     year history by exercising      the T-6C is Tunisia which              appointed CEO of new              Travis Ludlow and
The consulation ends on         options to acquire 52           received its first aircraft on 6       Saudi start-up airline RIA,       brother and sister Mack
16 December.                    Boeing 737 MAX airliners.       November.                              set to launch in 2024. He         and Zara Rutherford.

                                                                                                                                                      DECEMBER 2022             9
DIGITAL STORM - CYBERSECURITY BUSH FLYING WITH MAF NEW SPACE - HOW TEMPEST IS SETTING THE PACE - December 2022
By the Numbers
     Understanding the world of Aerospace through data

     China’s Tiangong space station

                             China’s Tiangong space station

                                                                                                                                    Graphic News
                                       China has successfully completed construction of its space
                                          station. Tiangong (Palace in the Sky) will link up with
                                          Beijing’s planned Xuntian space telescope and host
                                          experiments in orbit, around 400km above the Earth
                                            RUSSIA              APR 2021: TIANHE
                                                                (Harmony of the
                                               Beijing          Heavens) launched.
                                         CHINA                  Core module consists
                                        Wenchang                of 50 cubic metre-
                                        Launch site             living quarters,
                                                                service section – with
                               INDIA

                                                                communications,
                                                      Hainan    avionics, fuel, air and
                                                                water – and docking hub
                                                                     JUN 2022: Third crew launched
                              JUL 2022: WENTIAN                      to Tiangong aboard Shenzhou 14
                              (Quest for the Heavens)                spacecraft
                              launched. Crew oversees
                              installation                                                      Service section

                              OCT 2022: MENGTIAN (Dreaming
                              of Heavens). Third laboratory module
                              completes space station
                                                                                                  Solar panels

                                 Propulsion
                                 module                                              WENTIAN
                                                                                     Laboratory module

                                 SHENZHOU
                                 (Divine Vessel)
                                 Carries three astronauts
                                       LAUNCHER:
                                       Long March 5B
                                       rocket. Height: 56.9m,
                                       payload: 6.0 tonnes

                                       2023: XUNTIAN SPACE
                                       TELESCOPE (Space
                                       Sentinel) due to launch.
                                       Will orbit with Tiangong
                                       and dock for refuelling
                                       and maintenance.
                                       Will conduct research into
                                       formation of universe
                                       and dark matter
     Sources: AFP, South China Morning Post, NASA, Space.com        Picture: China National Space Administration   © GRAPHIC NEWS

10   AEROSPACE
Pushing the Envelope
Exploring advances on the leading edge of aerospace
                                                                                                                      Robert Coppinger

Water injection returns
W
                       ater injection into jet engines is       German Aerospace Center laboratory tests
                       not a new idea; it was used by       have been conducted for this new water injection
                       the Boeing 707 and early 747         technology with a goal of achieving a technology
                       models for thrust augmentation.      readiness level (TRL) of three by the end of 2022.
                       Since then manufacturers have        A TRL of three refers to an experimental proof of
favoured ever more efficient turbines instead but           concept.
now the pressures of climate change are changing                MTU Aero Engines’ advanced programmes
the business equation and water injection studies are       director, Dr Martin Stadlbauer explains that the WET
under way once again.                                       concept places a vaporiser into the exhaust gas
     The term ‘water’ injection is really a misnomer        to cool the gas down before it is cooled again in a
as it is steam that is being fed into the engine. The       condensing unit, liquifying the steam into water. When
steam can be introduced at an early stage, after            needed, that liquid water is fed into a vaporiser which
the low-pressure fan or it can be injected into the         uses excess turbine heat to turn it into overheated
combustion chamber. Its use can reduce nitrogen             steam that is injected into the combustion chamber.
oxide (NOx), a significant global warming contributor,
and fuel burn which reduces all the environmental           Water tank
impacts of aviation.
                                                            Stadlbauer expects an aircraft on a long flight to
Low hanging fruit                                           have a tank of water on board, in addition to the
                                                            steam collected by the vaporiser. He said that, while
Dr Uyioghosa Igie is a senior lecturer in gas turbine       the aircraft might need the tank for certain phases
engineering and operations at Cranfield University.         of flight, it will only be for a very limited timeframe
He views water injection as a ‘low hanging fruit’ for       with the majority of the flight served by water from
further improvements in jet engine performance.             the exhaust. Stadlbauer added that a water injection
Focusing on existing engine improvements may                geared turbofan will have a different nacelle shape.
seem redundant considering the expectations                      According to Stadlbauer, preliminary testing
of hybrid electric and hydrogen fuelled aircraft,           shows that water injection is feasible and Igie agrees.
but water injection will not end with fossil-based          His own work in his Cranfield laboratory has found
kerosene and can also be used for these future              clear unambiguous benefits.
propulsion systems.                                              The MTU work is aiming for an Airbus A320
     It can provide benefits to the SAF consuming           thrust class for its WET geared turbofan, which would
engines that will be employed for hybrid propulsion         be a very high bypass ratio engine with a smaller
and water injection into a hydrogen fuelled gas             engine core. The bypass ratio is the difference
turbine tackles a problem that they share with today’s      between the air volume going through the engine
engines, namely that of NOx production.                     core and that going around the engine accelerated by
     Starting this year, MTU Aero Engines is the            the engine’s fan at the front. Fuel burn improvements
                                                                                                                      WHEN NEEDED,
project co-ordinator for a three-year steam injection       are achieved by increasing the ratio and the engine
study called Sustainable Water-Injecting Turbofan           would use kerosene or SAF.                                THAT LIQUID
Comprising Hybrid-Electrics (SWITCH). It is being                The use of water aids the smaller engine core as     WATER IS FED
funded by the EU Clean Aviation Joint Undertaking,          the liquid creates a denser fluid passing through the     INTO A VAPORISER
which is spending €700 million on 20 engine                 engine. While water is incompressible, gas and air are    WHICH USES
projects.                                                   both compressible, and the presence of the water,         EXCESS TURBINE
     MTU’s water enhanced turbine (WET) concept is          therefore, allows the use of a smaller compressor.        HEAT TO TURN IT
a geared turbofan. SWITCH and WET aim to reduce                  MTU plans to have a ground demonstrator of its
carbon dioxide and NOx emissions, as well as the            WET concept engine ready by 2029. Water injection
                                                                                                                      INTO OVERHEATED
formation of contrails. The latter form when hot humid      was being used in Pratt & Whitney JT3C-6 engines          STEAM THAT IS
air from a jet exhaust, which also contains engine          on Boeing 707s in 1959 and come the end of this           INJECTED INTO
soot, mixes with the high-altitude air that has a low       decade, 70 years later, what was old could be new         THE COMBUSTION
vapour pressure and temperature.                            again.                                                    CHAMBER

                                                                                                                             DECEMBER 2022   11
Transmission
     LETTERS AND ONLINE                                             @aerosociety   in Find us on LinkedIn f               Find us on Facebook      www.aerosociety.com

                                                                                                                        in
                                                                                                                                                         Brandon Cheung: It was an
      Waterbird tops list of 2022 Heritage Awards                                                                                                        absolute blast speaking to
                                                                                                                                                         all the different companies

                                                                                                    Mark Wright/AHUK
                                                                                                                                                         today! Looking forward to
                                                                                                                                                         more events like this to
                                                                                                                                                         come. Thank you very much
                                                                                                                                                         for hosting this.

                                                                                                                                                         Peter Round (RAeS
                                                                                                                        RAeS Project Altitude            President): So good to
                                                                                                                                                         see so many young people
                                                                                                                                                         interested in all aspects of
                                                                                                                                                         aerospace.

      The Lakes Flying Company (LFC) has
      won Aviation Heritage UK’s Robert
      Pleming Memorial Award for 2022 for
      its recreation and successful flying of
      Waterbird, an exact replica of the first
      seaplane to fly with a stepped float.
           The award was set up in memory of its
      late Chairman, and was created specifically
                                                       Waterbird, the original of which was built
                                                       for Edward Wakefield by Avro, and flown
                                                       from Windermere in 1911. No construction
                                                       drawings survive for Waterbird, so the replica
                                                       – including its gamechanging stepped float
                                                       which reduced water drag during take-off
                                                       and has been used on all subsequent water-
                                                       borne aircraft – had to be built using only a
                                                                                                                       Nicholas Davis AMRAeS
                                                                                                                       Today we are at WMG
                                                                                                                       Academy in Coventry for
                                                                                                                       their annual Project Altitude
                                                                                                                                                           f
      to recognise innovation in the preservation,     few period photographs as a guide.                              event supported by Boeing,         Electric GPU
      conservation and restoration of aviation              The project, which has involved building                   Skyrora and Airbus.
      heritage, in the spirit of the outstanding       the replica using period materials, such

                                                                                                                                                                                        S Bridgewater/RAeS
      work which Dr Pleming led in returning Avro      as bamboo and a modern engine as the
                                                                                                                       Rebecca Archer
      Vulcan XH558 to the sky.                         only significant departure from the original,
           The group won this year’s award for         has taken 11 years to reach fruition with                       Brilliant end to mark
      the construction and flying of its replica of    waterborne flights in the summer of 2022.                       #teweek22, thanks RAeS
                                                                                                                       for supporting both Solihull
                                                                                                                       and Coventry WMG                  Rob Evans [Responding to:

     From the RAeS photo archives                                                                                      Academy Trusts making it
                                                                                                                       another memorable year for
                                                                                                                                                         BAE Systems demonstrates
                                                                                                                                                         electric GPU]: Probably
                                                                                                                       our students!                     not suitable to be used in
                                                                                                   RAeS/NAL

                                                                                                                                                         remote locations during a
                                                                                                                       Careers in Aerospace              time of conflict?
                                                                                                                                                         A nice looking demo toy
                                                                                                                       Responding to: ‘Today we          but like anything battery-
                                                                                                                       are hosting our annual            powered they come from
                                                                                                                       Careers in Aerospace &            a dirty background of
                                                                                                                       Aviation LIVE recruitment         mining. Processing the raw
                                                                                                                       fair at the RAeS’.                materials for batteries is
                                                                                                                                                         toxic to the environment
                                                                                                                       Colin Joy: Amazing                and they get transported
                                                                                                                       experience and insightful.        thousands of miles by
                                                                                                                       Thank you everyone who            diesel powered ships. They
                                                                                                                       worked hard for this event.       still need a power source to
                                                                                                                       Moreover, I would like to         charge them and when they
                                                                                                                       thank all the companies who       pack up altogether I can't
      His Majesty’s Airship No1 leaving its floating   Hermione because the naval contingent at
      shed at the Cavendish Dock, Barrow-in-           Barrow was attached to HMS Hermione, a                          came together and made            imagine they are easy to
      Furness. It was designed and built by Vickers    cruiser moored locally, preparing to act as                     this event a huge success.        recycle either.
      Sons and Maxim as an aerial scout airship        its tender.                                                     Special thanks, of course, to
      for the Royal Navy. It was the first British           When it was moved from its shed to                        the RAeS.                         Jasper Vd Heijden: It’s a
      rigid airship to be built and was constructed    conduct full trials on 24 September 1911,                                                         nice idea but the operating
      in a direct attempt to compete with the          it was broken in two by strong winds before                     Eslam Eldoky: What a day!         cost doesn’t include
      German airship programme. Often referred         it could attempt its first flight. Although it
                                                                                                                       Had such amazing talks            maintenance and initial
      to as Mayfly, a nickname given to it by the      never flew, its brief career provided valuable
      lower deck (ie the ship's non-commissioned       training and experimental data for British                      with different companies.         purchase. It seems way too
      crew), in public records it is designated HMA    airship crews and designers.                                    Really enjoyed that Cranfield     good to be true.
                                                                                                                       University talk though.

12   AEROSPACE
Andre Tempest: I'm sure          Escorts for Rivet Joints          The importance of early reporting – EgyptAir MS804
it's great on a nice clean
                                                                                                                                                               @SafetyAero

                                                                                                                                    Anna Zvereva/WikiCommons
concrete airfield. What          @GuardedDone
about front-line usage?                                                                                                                                        On the ICAO AIG Experts
                                 [Replying to 'Typhoons to
                                                                                                                                                               group we concluded 50%
                                 escort RAF Rivet Joints
                                                                                                                                                               of Annex 13 investigation
Zane Adams: Military             after Flanker 'accidently'
                                                                                                                                                               final reports are not
equipment goes from being        fires missile'] Scramble
                                                                                                                                                               published. ICAO has no
able to run on anything from     to fit AN/ALE-55 towed
                                                                                                                                                               authority to enforce the
                                 decoys?
firewood to grain alcohol to                                                                                                                                   SARPs. In 2018 the
requiring high-tech sensitive                                                                                                                                  BEA requested CASIA
electronic batteries and                                                                                                                                       to publish the report,
                                 @dissident_the Some
charging systems.                                                                                                                                              the presumption being
                                 very dangerous games
                                                                   The investigation into the loss of an EgyptAir Airbus                                       they'll challenge the
                                 being played by Russian
                                                                   A320 (similar to this) in 2016 has not been published.                                      findings in the report's
Richard Mallory-Allnutt:         forces here. But they have
                                                                                                                                                               comments. Additionally,
I suspect that many of the       had their TV, leaders and
                                                                  @steve_757 [Replying to          @GuardedDon A very                                          if a state does not open
naysayers are fixated on         politicians telling them that
                                                                  'The importance of early         worthwhile reminder of                                      an investigation, there's a
the environmental aspects,       they're on a 'war footing'
                                                                  reporting[1]] Knowing            certain nations’ deficient                                  limited provision in ICAO
                                 for several years now.
rather than the potentially                                       what happened means              performance.                                                Annex 13 for State of
huge operational benefits                                         we can amend any                 MH370 loss: Most recent                                     Registration or Design/
which such a device could                                         recommendations.                 update from Malaysia’s                                      Manufacture to open an
                                 @RAphotoVK RC-135                                                 (now disbanded) Safety                                      investigation.
provide. Hook this up to a
                                 "accidentally" mistook                                            Investigation Team –                                        Unfortunately, there's no
small wind turbine or solar                                                                                                                                    provision to compel a state
                                 Black Sea for North Sea?                                          31/7/17.
array, and you could easily                                       @SafetyAero The                                                                              to provide a final report,
                                                                                                   Metrojet KGL9268 loss:
charge it anywhere on Earth                                       Egyptian authorities             Most recent update from                                     SARPs or otherwise.
without the need for finding                                      have employed a dodge            Egypt’s AAID team –
                                 @dahedd_gs Romania,              which the French BEA
 fuel. Also, with no moving                                                                        15/11/15.
                                 Hungary & Turkey [are] all       have called their bluff on.
 parts, I suspect that this
                                 NATO allies; [it's] perfectly    Egypt has no difference                                                                      @SafetyAero There is
 unit’s mean time before         fine to be there.                filed with ICAO; they can        @Straker_64 There's no                                      nothing to prevent an ICAO
 failure and maintenance                                          independently issue an           report, ipso facto, there are                               Annex 13 investigation in
 requirements are infinitely                                      Annex 13 report without          no conclusions or safety                                    conjunction with a parallel
 superior to a conventional      @RAphotoVK If you look           state intervention.                                                                          criminal investigation. The
                                                                                                   recommendations. Until an
 unit too, meaning that you      at the flights I don't see                                        Annex 13 compliant report                                   investigations are mutually
 would likely need fewer of      ANY Romania, Hungary or                                           is issued it's all guess work.                              exclusive. Withholding the
 them. These units will also     Turkey around the tracks.        @cauchiphilippe Who              For a fire to cause a loss                                  publication of the report
 run silently too, reducing      Imagine what an outcry           has something to hide?           of control in flight with a                                 fuels speculation.
 noise levels and making it      there would have been if         Airbus or the Egyptian           probability of 10-7of the                                   The BEA letter to the
                                 Russian ships and aircraft       government?                      flight control system failing,                              Egyptian authorities
 easier to communicate. The
                                 were around UK ADIZ on                                            something is up.                                            emphasised this.
 list of positives could go      a daily basis!
  on. But if you want to sell
  people on these things, it’s
  important to emphasise the
                                  Top award for alta team                                          President at ASPA Dinner
  operational benefits.                                                                                                                                                                 Tim Robinson/RAeS

                                 The RAeS is pleased to          with additional support from
                                 announce that alta[2], an       Boeing UK, GKN, Collins
                                 industry-wide mentoring         Aerospace and Raytheon.
                                 scheme recognised for                "Since its launch in 2019,
                                 empowering women in             alta has seen continuous and
                                 aviation, has won the           positive growth and to be
                                 2022 Economic and               recognised in this way by the
                                 Social Research Council         ESRC is a true testament to
                                 Outstanding Business and        the hard work from the alta
                                 Enterprise Impact Award.        steering group and the team,"
 'Urning' a crust                     This very prestigious      said RAeS Education, Skills
                                 prize acknowledges the          & Diversity Manager Nicholas      RAeS President Peter                                        the Air Staff ACM Sir Mike
@Chris_Co1e [Replying            collaboration between the       Davis. "We hope to continue       Round (left) attended the                                   Wigston (right) presented a
to 'Business helps               Royal Aeronautical Society,     building the platform so that     annual Air & Space Power                                    special ASPA award to AVM
mourners scatter ashes by        the University of the West      many more women in the            Association dinner in                                       Paul Godfrey, who became
drone']. Well we all have to     of England, Airbus, the RAF     industry can feel empowered       London on 10 November.                                      the first commander of UK
'urn' a crust I suppose!         and Little Blue Private Jets,   in their careers.”                During the event, Chief of                                  Space Command in 2021.

  1. https://www.aerosociety.com/news/the-importance-of-early-reporting-egyptair-flight-ms804/
  2. https://www.aerosociety.com/get-involved/alta-mentoring/

                                                                                                                                                                          DECEMBER 2022                     13
DEFENCE
                       Tempest update

                   Wind of change
BAE Systems

                   In October, the RAeS hosted senior members of the Team Tempest consortium
                   and MoD officials for an exclusive roundtable update on the FCAS programme.
                   STEPHEN BRIDGEWATER reports.

                   F
                                our years on from the reveal of the            ‘What’ and ‘why’?
                                UK Tempest (or more correctly Future
                                Combat Air System or FCAS) fighter             Air Cdre Jonny Moreton, FCAS Portfolio Director,
                                programme at the 2018 Farnborough              explained the operational requirements for this future
                                Airshow, the project is now accelerating in    fighter ‘system’, saying “the end state here is one of
                   its concept and assessment (C&A) phase.                     an agile, adaptable, combat air system that can meet
                        With billions set to be invested in this highly        a threat that is moving at a pace that our current
                   advanced fighter project, Tempest will not only             combat air systems cannot cope with.”
                   provide the RAF with a highly capable next-                     With FCAS, the MoD and RAF have worked
                   generation combat air capability, it is also projected to   hand in glove with industry partners from the outset.
                   support thousands of British jobs and a PwC report          Air Cdre Moreton emphasised that by working with
                   assesses it could make a £26.2bn contribution to the        industry, the MoD was ensuring that it was “building
                   UK economy by 2050[1].                                      something with a philosophy that means it needs to
                        In late October, key partner members convened          be adaptable from day one.”
                   at No.4 Hamilton Place for an RAeS-hosted                       He went on: “With that in mind, we don’t talk
                   roundtable discussion. Themed ‘The role of                  about FOC [full operational capability]. No such thing
                   Tempest in delivering the next generation of the            exists anymore. We talk about in service dates and
                   UK’s Sovereign Combat Air Sector’, the afternoon            an IOC [initial operating capability] – but from then
                   was chaired by AEROSPACE Editor-in-Chief, Tim               on, we talk about an upgrade path that just continues
                   Robinson and saw senior members of the MoD and              to meet the pace with the threat.”
                   the RAF engage in candid and frank discussion with              One of the biggest questions surrounding
                   industry and supply chain representatives.                  the Tempest project since it was announced was
                        UK MoD’s Director of Future Combat Air, Richard        whether the ‘core platform’ will be crewed, uncrewed
                   Berthon began by bringing the room up to date               or optionally crewed? “As it stands, we currently plan
                   with progress towards the goal of a 2035 entry              to have a pilot in the cockpit in 2035,” revealed Air
                   into service date. “We went through an approval             Cdre Moreton. “However, by 2050 that person might
                   to launch the concept and assessment phase and              not be there as technology, specifically autonomy
                   we’re broadly halfway through that at this point,”          and artificial intelligence, might have advanced.
                   he explained. “This is looking at system concepts           We, therefore, need to have a programme that’s
                                                                                                                                        Opposite page:
                   and defining what are our future threats and future         adaptable enough to allow us to do that. We don’t        The high-level roundtable
                   opportunities, enabling us to work out what we want         just focus on 2035, because that’s just the start of     discussion took place at
                   to do and who we want as our international partners.”       the journey.”                                            RAeS HQ.

              14   AEROSPACE
The ‘how’, not just the ‘what’
Meanwhile, as one of the core Team Tempest
partners, Herman Claesen, BAE Systems, FCAS
Managing Director provided additional information
on recent progress: “Despite the Covid interruption
we have continued to ramp things up in the UK and
there are now more than 2,000 people working on
FCAS, something that’s growing on a weekly basis.
Around 70% of those jobs are also outside London
and the south-east of the UK, which helps with the
government’s ‘levelling up’ agenda.”
     “This programme is not just about delivering
a product that the RAF needs in response to the
operational requirements of the future,” he continued.
“The ‘how’ is equally important as the ‘what’. The
UK is extremely well-placed with the technical
knowledge and experience it has, along with the
support from government. We are on track to be
potentially one of the only nations – together with our
international partners – to achieve the goal of a next-
generation fighter by 2035. We are starting to see
evidence with the way we are de-risking technology
and building a low-observable supersonic technology
demonstrator. That is already demonstrating tangibly
how we are taking years out of the programme in
terms of timescale and costs.”
     “If you compare the computing power available in
the 1980s and 90s with our approach to digital data
today it is a huge leap,” Claesen explained. “We’ve
focused on model-based systems engineering
(MBSE) using open architectures, creating digital
twins, and using virtual environments to literally ‘left
shift’ the technology risk from where it typically is
at the back end of the life cycle to the front end of
the life cycle. In effect, we are ‘virtually’ starting the
flight tests in the first half of the first quarter of the
programme instead of the end.” In fact, BAE Systems
has already ‘flown’ the technology demonstrator for
hundreds of hours in what he referred to as a ‘high
fidelity virtual environment.’
     Rob Edmunds, Head of Transformation at partner
company Leonardo UK agreed: “The pace has been
unlike any other programme that has gone before,”
he declared. “From a sensor point of view we’ve gone
from real ‘blue sky thinking’ to simulations, worked
out which other directions to explore, progressed the
technology readiness level and now we’re looking
at the support capabilities and where we might take
things in the future.”
     Berthon emphasised that this swift pace is
fundamental to the project. “When it comes to
performance, time and cost we are prioritising
pace because of its direct impact on cost,” he told
the room. “We’re also prioritising pace because
it gives us the chance to get the capabilities and
services the RAF needs and then rapidly upgrade
and incrementally deliver them. The pace of the
                                                             Stephen Bridgewater/RAeS

programme is, therefore, what defines affordability
and allows us to get out into the market.”

                                                                                        DECEMBER 2022   15
DEFENCE
         Tempest update

     International collaboration                                  Meanwhile, the fast-moving geopolitical
                                                             environment and UK economic and political
     Meanwhile, since its launch in 2018, the project has    uncertainty have also presented a challenging
     attracted significant international interest – with     backdrop for this long-term aerospace project.
     partnerships and collaboration announced with Italy,    However, Berthon stressed that FCAS has high-level
     Sweden and, most recently, Japan.                       buy-in.
          “Work on selecting international partners is            “There is a recognition that FCAS is so important
     ongoing,” confirmed Berthon during the roundtable,      to our sovereignty, our military capability, our
     “but I think we are on the cusp and we are planning     international influence and the UK’s prosperity. These
     to make key decisions by the end of this year.”         are challenging economic times and inflationary
          However, thought must be given to the point in     pressures are very real, but we’ve got a robust
     the programme at which partners join. “The concept      programme and we’ve got a proposal with international
     and assessment phase will take us to 2025 after         partners that attracts very significant investment.”
     which we’ll move into the product development                Add in the long-term export potential of the
     and manufacturing phase” noted Claesen. ““There         Tempest and the benefits to the UK economy really
     are genuine practical considerations of bringing        ramp up. “It’s also about the role of industries,” added
     in additional partners during the ongoing concept       Caroline Donaghy, Director of Defence at ADS. “There
     and assessment phase as this would increase the         is a whole supply chain network keen to get involved.
     complexity of aligning requirements and we’re very      So, ultimately, this must succeed and must move at
     focused on maintaining the current momentum             pace.”
     on the programme. From a strategy perspective                Meanwhile, with the war in Ukraine highlighting the
     however, we do remain open to other partners joining    need for ‘control of the air,’ Berthon also emphasised
     the programme downstream.”                              to the delegates that the world finds itself in “an
          However, it is important not to forget that this   environment which is incredibly challenging. Future
     is far from a one-horse race and there is significant   economic stability is going to depend on national
     competition in the international fighter marketplace.   security and the role of the UK and NATO is going to         The latest renders of the
     The Franco-German FCAS/SCAF project and                 be ever more important.”                                     Tempest core airframe,
     the US’ Next Generation Air Dominance (NGAD)                 From an operational point of view, Air Cdre Moreton     revealed at Farnborough
     programme are also in development. Mark Miller,         urged the room not to “fall into the trap of thinking what   Airshow earlier this year
     Director of UK Defence at GKN warned: “It’s a very      is happening in Ukraine today is what the future looks       show an altered outer
                                                                                                                          mould line. Team Tempest
     competitive market and there’s not enough space for     like. We have all learned some interesting lessons from      insiders stress that this
     three next-generation fighter programmes. There just    the conflict but with FCAS we’re looking at threats          shape may not in fact be
     isn’t.”                                                 beyond the 15-20 year period.”                               the final configuration.

16   AEROSPACE
Sustainability                                           have made their career choice. We, therefore, need
                                                                                        to start approaching these youngsters while they
                               As well as future enemies, FCAS will also have           are still at school and there is a huge marketing
                               to meet the sustainability challenge, said Rolls-        effort required across the sector to engage with the
                               Royce’s Sustainability Executive, Andrew Eady.           students and their support networks, teachers, and
THIS IS A                      “We’re looking at enabling supply chains around          parents.”
                               green hydrogen fuels and the future role that                 Aileen Randhawa, HR Director at MBDA,
ONCE-IN-A-
                               synthetic fuels can play in the FCAS programme. If       affirmed that it is not just marketing that is needed.
GENERATION                     you have access to water, and you can suck carbon        “I’d describe it more as an education effort,” she told
OPPORTUNITY                    out of the air and use Fischer–Tropsch to create         the room. “If you think about teacher training and
TO CHANGE                      a synthetic hydrocarbon that really starts to move       the level of industry awareness that exists within
                               the conversation away from sustainability just being     primary and secondary schools, as well as higher
THE WAY WE                     decarbonisation into something that improves your        education facilities, it is quite limited. So industry
THINK ABOUT                    energy resilience and introduces fuel sovereignty.       can actually play a really important part in providing
COMBAT                         A lot of the supply chains for these areas are just      placements to expose those various young people
AIR FROM A                     emerging and are predominantly focused around            to the reality of an engineering career.”
                               the north-east of Britain.”                                   Randhawa emphasised that recruitment is
BUSINESS POINT                      “Our vision is that from 2035 we will be in a       about having role models. “If, as a school child, I can
OF VIEW, AN                    position where we’ll be using significant levels of      see a role model that I can identify with, I will then
ENGINEERING                    sustainable fuels,” agreed Air Cdre Moreton.             aspire to be like them. We also must ask ourselves
                                    On supply chain problems, Douglas Barrie,           what skills we are looking for, because FCAS is
POINT OF VIEW
                               Senior Fellow at the International Institute for         supposed to be transformative. Are those roles
AND FROM AN                    Strategic Studies, raised the thorny matter of supply    STEM related and, even if they are, how do we
OPERATIONAL                    chain sensitivities, asking how far down the chain       convince people to join the defence world rather
POINT OF VIEW                  manufacturers need to validate components. Barrie        than other sectors?”
                               suggested that “whereas second, third and fourth
                               tier suppliers previously needed to be validated, this   Recruiting the future
                               is now likely to change to fifth, sixth and seventh
                               tiers.”                                                  “The fact that we are employing from different
                                    Team Tempest is now working with a supply           socio-economic backgrounds and regional areas
                               chain of around 600 UK companies which, in part,         helps,” admitted Claesen, “but we’re looking at
                               reduces the risks associated with the material           opening regional offices and, perhaps, even regional
                               sourcing and physical delivery problems from             engineering hubs to get access to the people we
                               overseas suppliers.                                      need. Over the course of the project’s life cycle we
                                                                                        will need different types of employees. Now we need
                               Generation Tempest                                       systems engineers and architects that can think at
                 BAE Systems

                                                                                        the macro level and create solutions. Fast forward
                               Meanwhile, there is evidence that this once-in-          a couple of years and we will need the people to
                               a-generation project is inspiring a new cadre of         execute the plan, write the code, programme the
                               apprentices and graduates to join ‘Generation            robotics and the ‘cobotics’ and do all the testing, etc.
                               Tempest’ – substantially shifting the demographics       So, whereas people have traditionally worked for
                               towards a younger workforce.                             us for life we perhaps need to get used to people
                                    So far, more than 1,000 apprentices have been       cycling through the business for three years and then
                               recruited by the Tempest partner companies since         moving onto another career.”
                               the programme started and the BAE Systems                     He also emphasised that FCAS is already
                               graduates and apprenticeship programmes have             actively engaged with close to 100 SMEs,
                               been oversubscribed every single year. “We’ve seen       including “companies that we’ve never worked with
                               our FCAS workforce getting younger,” explained           before in the gaming and motoring industries.”
                               Claesen, “with 40% being under 40 and 20% being               Rolls-Royce Systems Designer James
                               under 30.”                                               Davies was probably the youngest person at the
                                    Nevertheless, Air Cdre David Tait, Defence          roundtable and a member of the Tempest Early
                               Suppliers Forum Lead for People and Skills, MoD,         Careers Network (TECN). He pointed out that
                               observed that aerospace and defence still struggles      many of the roles needed to design, build, operate
                               to recruit the best talent. “I think we need to take a   and maintain Tempest might not even be known
                               longer-term approach to the way we do workforce          yet, such is the pace at which the technology
                               planning,” he surmised. “The City targets students       and ideas are advancing. However, he admitted
                               in their first year at university, talks to them and     that awareness is still a challenge. “We’ve taken
                               coaches them and gets them on internships within         stands to events and find that it’s really about
                               the financial industry. The STEM sector normally         communicating with an audience that doesn’t know
                               waits until year three, by which time the students       that the opportunities to work in the sector exist.”

                                                                                                                               DECEMBER 2022       17
You can also read