THE GREAT BRITISH TAKE-OFF - LIGHTNING II HEADS FOR FARNBOROUGH DÉBUT - UK'S NEW CIVIL AEROSPACE R&D - Royal Aeronautical Society

Page created by Seth Yang
 
CONTINUE READING
THE GREAT BRITISH TAKE-OFF - LIGHTNING II HEADS FOR FARNBOROUGH DÉBUT - UK'S NEW CIVIL AEROSPACE R&D - Royal Aeronautical Society
THE GREAT
                      BRITISH
                      TAKE-OFF
                      LIGHTNING II HEADS
www.aerosociety.com
                      FOR FARNBOROUGH
                      DÉBUT

                            July 2014

                            UK’S NEW CIVIL
                            AEROSPACE R&D
                            WILD ABOUT THE
                            CAT
                            NASA’S PATH TO
                            MARS
THE GREAT BRITISH TAKE-OFF - LIGHTNING II HEADS FOR FARNBOROUGH DÉBUT - UK'S NEW CIVIL AEROSPACE R&D - Royal Aeronautical Society
His Royal Highness The
Prince of Wales is presented
with his Honorary Fellowship
certificate in 1978 by the
then-President Prof Lew
Crabtree. RAeS (NAL).

HRH The Prince of Wales accepts invitation
to become Honorary President in 2016
The Royal Aeronautical Society is delighted to announce that His         The Chief Executive of the Royal Aeronautical Society, Simon
Royal Highness The Prince of Wales has accepted the Society’s        Luxmoore said: “We are honoured that The Prince of Wales has
invitation to act as its Honorary President for 2016, the 150th      graciously accepted our invitation to become our Honorary
anniversary year of the establishment of the Society.                President during our 150th anniversary year. 2016 will be an
     His Royal Highness’s Presidency will continue the Royal         occasion to celebrate innovation, not only through past
Family’s long association with the Royal Aeronautical Society. Her   achievements but, more importantly, through looking to the future.
Majesty The Queen became the Society’s Patron in 1952,               As such, we very much intend to support His Royal Highness’
succeeding her father, King George VI, in this role. Both Their      continuing commitment to encouraging youth opportunity. The
Royal Highnesses The Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh, and The       support of our Honorary President in this important area will inspire
Prince of Wales are Honorary Fellows, the Society’s highest and      the next generation towards even greater innovations in science,
most prestigious award. The Duke of Edinburgh was Honorary           engineering and technology in general, and to aerospace and
President during 1966, the Society’s centenary year.                 aviation in particular.”
THE GREAT BRITISH TAKE-OFF - LIGHTNING II HEADS FOR FARNBOROUGH DÉBUT - UK'S NEW CIVIL AEROSPACE R&D - Royal Aeronautical Society
BAE Systems
Volume 41 Number 7

                                                                                                                                NASA
July 2014
                                                                                                Carrier countdown                                                                         NASA’s path to Mars
                                                                                                A look at the behind-                                                                     Dr Ellen Stofan, Chief
                                                                                                the-scenes work                                                                           Scientist of the US space
                                                                                         14     integrating the F-35B
                                                                                                with the UK’s new                                                   34                    agency, explains the
                                                                                                                                                                                          Red Planet exploration
                                                                                                aircraft carriers.                                                                        roadmap.

Contents
Correspondence on all aerospace matters is welcome at: The Editor, AEROSPACE, No.4 Hamilton Place, London W1J 7BQ, UK                       publications@aerosociety.com

                           Comment                                                                                                     Regulars
                                                                                                                                       4 Radome
                                                                                                                                       The latest aviation and                          12 Transmission
                                                                                                                                       aeronautical intelligence,                       Your letters, emails, tweets
                                                                                                                                       analysis and comment.                            and feedback.

  Gulf bellwether
                                                                                                                                       10 Antenna                                       58 The Last Word
                                                                                                                                       Howard Wheeldon looks                            Keith Hayward on
                                                                                                                                       at how Italy is securing its                     the importance of the
                                                                                                                                       defence aerospace industrial                     Farnborough Air Show to the
                                                                                                                                       base with a F-35 final                           UK aerospace industry.
                                                                                                                                       assembly plant.

                                                                                                                                       Features
  This month the global aerospace industry will descend on Farnborough. This
  year the UK is riding high — with fresh R&D impetus on the agenda, the F-35
  making its first overseas visit and the Airbus A350 making its Farnborough                                                           16 Plane speaking —

                                                                                                                                                                                                                              Airbus Group
  début. However, for the A350, the recent decision by Emirates to cancel 70                                                           Paul Everitt, ADS
                                                                                                                                       On the record with the CEO
  widebody orders might be seen in some quarters as a worrying development                                                             of the UK’s aerospace,
  for the civil aerospace market — and not just in Toulouse. Though Airbus                                                             defence and security industry
  is confident that there will be no financial impact from these long-term                                                             body.                                            28

                                                                                                                                                                       GKN
  production orders, any hint of Gulf carriers hitting capacity constraints,
                                                                                                                                                                                        Technology horizons
  or revising growth estimates downwards, after driving so much of the                                                                                                                  Airbus Group’s Chief
  commercial aeropace industy in the past 20 years, will be a concern in Seattle                                                                                                        Technology Officer, Dr Jean
  as well. However, it is worth remembering that only in November, Emirates                                                                                                             Botti, on turning science
                                                                                                                                                                                        fiction into science fact.
  confirmed its commitment to the A380, by placing an order for 50 at the
  Dubai Air Show. A case of simply re-adjusting fleet planning? That said, the                                                     20

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                Raytheon
  regular drumbeat of orders from the Gulf mega-carriers has perhaps led to
  the entire aerospace community taking their relentless expansion for granted.                                                        Preparing for tomorrow
  It may not be an aircraft order bubble but an airliner cancellation from global                                                      The UK’s Aerospace
  carrier Emirates, the bellwether and poster-child for air traffic growth may                                                         Technology Institute reseach
                                                                                                                                       into future technology.
  raise alarm bells — especially if other Gulf carriers decide to follow suit.
                                                                                                                                                                       AgustaWestland    32
  Tim Robinson
                                                                                                                                                                                        More bangs for your buck
                                                                                                                                                                                        Raytheon’s Paveway IV
         tim.robinson@aerosociety.com                                                                                                                                                   weapon is set to gain extra
                                                                                                                                                                                        capabilities.

                                                                                                                                                                                        36 Working together
                                                                                                                                       24                                               Report on 2014 RAeS
                                                                                                                                                                                        Education and Skills seminar.
NEWS IN BRIEF
  Editor-in-Chief
  Tim Robinson
                                              AEROSPACE is published by the Royal
                                              Aeronautical Society (RAeS).
                                                                                          AEROSPACE subscription rates:
                                                                                          Non-members, £150
                                                                                                                                       Wild about the cat
                                                                                                                                       The AW159 Wildcat                                40 Farnborough is coming
  +44 (0)20 7670 4353                                                                                                                                                                   What to look out for at this
                                              Chief Executive                             Please send your order to:                   helicopter enters UK miltary
  tim.robinson@aerosociety.com                Simon C Luxmoore                            Dovetail Services Ltd, 800 Guillat                                                            year’s air show.
                                                                                                                                       service.
  Deputy Editor                               Advertising                                 Avenue, Kent Science Park,

                                                                                                                                   41 Afterburner
  Bill Read                                   Emma Bossom                                 Sittingbourne, Kent ME9 8GU, UK.
  +44 (0)20 7670 4351                         +44 (0)20 7670 4342                         +44 (0)1795 592939
  bill.read@aerosociety.com                   emma.bossom@aerosociety.com                 +44 (0)844 856 0650 (fax)
  Publications Manager                                                                    ras@servicehelpline.co.uk
                                              Unless specifically attributed, no
  Chris Male                                  material in AEROSPACE shall be taken        Any member not requiring a print
  +44 (0)20 7670 4352                         to represent the opinion of the RAeS.       version of this magazine, please             42 Message from our President
  chris.male@aerosociety.com                                                              contact: membership@aerosociety.com
                                              Reproduction of material used in this                                                    43 Message from our Chief Executive
  Production Editor                           publication is not permitted without the    USA: Periodical postage paid at
  Wayne J Davis                               written consent of the Editor-in-Chief.     Champlain New York and additional            44 Book Reviews
  +44 (0)20 7670 4354                                                                     offices.

                                                                                                                                                                                           Online
  wayne.davis@aerosociety.com                 Printed by Buxton Press Limited,                                                         47 Library Additions
                                              Palace Road, Buxton, Derbyshire             Postmaster: Send address changes
  Editorial Assistant                         SK17 6AE, UK                                to IMS of New York, PO Box 1518,             48 Sir Henry Royce lecture
  Alfonso Serrano Alcala                                                                  Champlain NY 12919-1518, USA.
                                                                                                                                       50 3D printing
  Book Review Editor                                                                                                                                                                    Additional features and content
                                              Distributed by Royal Mail                                                                51 ILA 2014
  Brian Riddle                                                                            ISSN 2052-451X                                                                                are available to view online on
  Editorial Office                                                                                                                     52 Diary                                          www.media.aerosociety.com/
  Royal Aeronautical Society                                                                                                                                                                   aerospace-insight
  No.4 Hamilton Place                                                                                                                  53 RAeS Council                                  Including: The Airbus A300, Heathrow vs
  London W1J 7BQ, UK                                                                                                                   54 Corporate Partners                            Gatwick, Video of RAeS lecture by Dr Ellen
  +44 (0)20 7670 4300                         Front cover: The F-35 JSF will be making its first international public                                                                   Stofan, NASA Chief Scientist on Pathways
  publications@aerosociety.com                appearances this month at RIAT and the Farnborough Air Show.                             55 Obituaries                                        to Mars, CV-22 Osprey in the UK,
  www.aerosociety.com                         Lockheed Martin
                                                                                                                                       56 RAeS Elections                                          European MALE plan.

     @aerosociety             i   Find us on LinkedIn        f   Find us on Facebook            www.aerosociety.com                                                                                             JULY 2014                    13
THE GREAT BRITISH TAKE-OFF - LIGHTNING II HEADS FOR FARNBOROUGH DÉBUT - UK'S NEW CIVIL AEROSPACE R&D - Royal Aeronautical Society
Radome
    INTELLIGENCE / ANALYSIS / COMMENT

                                  Drag reduction
                                  The ovoid fuselage reduces the 'wetted area'
                                  per passenger by 4-14% compared to com-
                                  parable widebodies such as the Boeing 777,
                                  Ilyushin Il-96 and Airbus A340-300.

      Range
      The Frigate Ecojet is
      optimised for shorter routes
      than traditional widebody
      aircraft. Against single-aisle
      aircraft on flights of 1,500km
      the company estimates it is
      15-25% more fuel efficient
      than an A320.

                                                                                     Belly cargo
                                                                                     The Frigate Ecojet's two
    NEWS IN BRIEF                                                                    lower freight compartments
                                                                                     can accommodate up to 20
                                                                                     LD-3 containers or cargo on
    ?????? ???? ???? ??? ???                                                         95 ×125 pallets.
     Cross-section
    ????? ????? ??????

    ?????? ???? ???? ??? ???
    ????? ????? ??????

    ?????? ???? ???? ??? ???
    ????? ????? ??????

    ?????? ???? ???? ??? ???
    ????? ????? ??????
                                                                    Frigate Ecojet

    ?????? ???? ???? ??? ???
    ????? ?????

4   AEROSPACE / JULY 2014
THE GREAT BRITISH TAKE-OFF - LIGHTNING II HEADS FOR FARNBOROUGH DÉBUT - UK'S NEW CIVIL AEROSPACE R&D - Royal Aeronautical Society
Cabin
                               The triple-aisle cabin could
                               seat 280-350 passengers in
                               a three-cabin layout or 400
                               in a single-class economy
                               configuration. Seats would                                       Specifications
                               be a minimum of 20in wide                                        Range                   3,500km
                               and have a pitch of 32in.                                        Cruising speed          442kt
                                                                                                Passengers              280-400
                                                                                                Runway length           2,400m
                                                                                                MTOW                    123,000kg

                                                Engines
                                                The Frigate Ecojet                               Lower landing
                                                project team is
                                                considering various
                                                                                                 weight
                                                                                                 With its shorter, compact
                                                engines, including PD-                           configuration, the 300-passenger
                                                18R and PS-90A20 or the                          Ecojet has the lowest maximum
                                                latest Rolls-Royce and                           take-off weight of any passenger
                                                Pratt & Whitney engines.                         aircraft with a similar capacity.
                                                                                                 This translates, says the company,
                                                                                                 into 44%-56% lower airport
                                                                                                 landing fees.

W

    AIR TRANSPORT

    Eco-efficient oval
    From Russia's Rosaviaconsortium is this ultra-widebody airliner concept optimised for medium-haul flights — the
    Frigate Ecojet. It uses a horizontally ovoid fuselage section to reduce the wetted area per passenger, allowing
    up to 11 abreast in economy seating — giving a maximum capacity of 352 seats. Calculations by Russia's Central
                                                                                                                                         Frigate Ecojet

    Aerohydrodynamics Institute (TsAGI) has confirmed the project's eco-efficient credentials — estimating that the
    Ecojet's integrated efficiency is 35% higher compared to modern airliners. Rosaviaconsortium estimates a market
    for about 600 Ecojets between 2020-2030.

       @aerosociety   i   Find us on LinkedIn   f   Find us on Facebook   www.aerosociety.com                                JULY 2014                    5
THE GREAT BRITISH TAKE-OFF - LIGHTNING II HEADS FOR FARNBOROUGH DÉBUT - UK'S NEW CIVIL AEROSPACE R&D - Royal Aeronautical Society
Radome
     Insurgents strike                                                       AEROSPACE
     airports in Pakistan
     and Iraq                                                                                  Solar Impulse 2 maiden flight
     An attack by Islamic militants on Karachi
     Airport, Pakistan, left 39 dead, including
     the ten insurgents involved. The raid on 9
     June, saw the airport closed as guerillas
     attacked the VIP and cargo terminal and a
     widebody hangar. The airport reopened
     after an overnight battle.
     Meanwhile, in Iraq, an uprising of the
     Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS)
     insurgent group saw the militants take
     control of Mosul's civil airport and
     a military airbase with US-supplied                                           The Solar Impulse 2 solar-powered aircraft made its first flight from Payerne in
                                                                 Solar Impulse

     equipment and helicopters, reportedly                                         Switzerland on 2 June. A larger version of the earlier Solar Impulse 1, the new 72m
     including Black Hawks and Bell 407s.                                          wingspan aircraft is to attempt to fly around the world without fuel in 2015.

    AIR TRANSPORT                                                                                               SPACEFLIGHT
          Emirates axes A350 order, as Airbus NASA set for ‘flying
                   begins early long flight tests saucer' test
                                  Dubai-based carrier                            shares fell almost 4% while    In July NASA is to                   robotic Mars missions,
                                  Emirates Airline has                           Rolls-Royce shares fell by     test its new                               the LDSD test over
                                  cancelled an order for 70                      2%. As AEROSPACE goes          Low-Density                                   the Pacific Ocean
                                  Airbus A350s following a                       to press, Airbus has begun     Supersonic                                      will simulate the
                                  fleet requirement review.                      early long flights (ELF)       Decelerator                                      entry, descent
                                  Airbus has said that                           with the cabin-equipped        (LDSD)                                           and landing
                                  this cancellation will                         MSN2 A350 prototype,           at the US                                       speeds that a
                                  not adversely affect the                       with Airbus workers as         Navy's range in                               spacecraft would
                                  A350 programme, as                             passengers. MSN5, the          Hawaii. Designed                           be exposed to when
                                                                                                                                              NASA

                                  the deliveries were not                        second cabin-equipped          to evaluate technologies             flying through the Martian
                                  scheduled to start until the                   A350 XWB is set to fly         which could be used for              atmosphere. (See NASA's
                                  end of the decade. Airbus                      imminently.                    landing future human and             path to Mars, p 34).

    NEWS IN BRIEF
                                                                                 will enable the FAA air                                             ATR72-600 turboprop was
    Investigators are looking     49 people onboard                              traffic control centre at      Russian Helicopters                  allowed to fly 13 times in
    into two 'unprecedented'      a Ukrainian AF Il-76                           Albuquerque to ensure that     has confirmed that it                scheduled service with a
    airspace incidents over       transport were killed when                     there is safe airspace for     has abandoned plans                  damaged tail.
    Austria in early June where   it was shot down on 14                         suborbital space flights to    to jointly develop a new
    13 aircraft temporarily       June by pro-Russian rebels                     be operated from Virgin        2·5t rotorcraft with                 Airbus Defence and Space
    disappeared from ATC          using MANPADS near                             Galactic’s base in New         AgustaWestland. However,             has revealed an upgraded
    radar screens in a            Luhansk, Ukraine.                              Mexico.                        the two companies will               variant of its A330 MRTT
    ‘blackout’.                                                                                                 continue to co-operate               — the Enhanced. This
                                  Virgin Galactic has                            A Gulfstream IV business       to produce the AW139                 aligns the MRTT with the
    Turkish Airlines has          announced an agreement                         jet crashed in Hanscom         helicopter for the Russian           latest civil A330 and also
    converted 15 options for      with the US Federal                            Field, Massachusetts, on       market.                              includes avionics, mission
    Boeing 737 MAX 8s into        Aviation Administration                        31 May, killing all seven                                           systems and IFF upgrades.
    firm orders, adding to a      (FAA) which will allow the                     people onboard. The            The Australian Transport
    previous firm order for 40    space tourist company                          aircraft caught fire during    Safety Bureau (ATSB) is              A partnership to combine
    of the type and ten of the    to operate through US                          take-off, going off the end    investigating an incident            space activities has
    larger 737 MAX 9 aircraft.    airspace. The agreement                        of the runway.                 in which a Virgin Australia          been agreed by UK, US,

6   AEROSPACE / JULY 2014
THE GREAT BRITISH TAKE-OFF - LIGHTNING II HEADS FOR FARNBOROUGH DÉBUT - UK'S NEW CIVIL AEROSPACE R&D - Royal Aeronautical Society
AIR TRANSPORT                                                                  DEFENCE
IATA profit warning for                                                             Sukhoi T-50 suffers engine fire
airlines
The International Air               December. Total revenues
Transport Association               would reach $746bn in
(IATA) has warned that              2014, the body said. With
profits for the global airline      average net margins of
industry in 2014 may be             2·4% that equates to just
adversely affected by poor          $5·42 per passenger. As
economic growth in China.           well as slower growth in
IATA predicts that airlines         China, IATA also pointed
may make $18bn of                   to taxes, fuel prices,
profits this year, down from        regulation, infrastructure
a previously predicted              constraints and ATM
                                                                          Sukhoi

$18·7bn earlier in March            inefficiencies eating into
and $19·7bn estimated in            airline profits.
                                                                                                                           The fifth Sukhoi T-50 fighter prototype suffered damage
GENERAL AVIATION                                                                                                           on 10 June at the Zhukovsky test centre outside Moscow,
                                                                                                                           when a fire above the right inlet broke out on landing. The
                                                                                                                           pilot was not injured and Sukhoi says the ‘incident will not
                                           Aerion revamps SSBJ                                                             affect the timing’ of the T-50 test programme.

                                               with larger trijet                                                          AEROSPACE
                                                                                                                           MH370 hunt setback
                                                                                                                           Australian authorities co-      discounted as the final
                                                                                                                           ordinating the international    resting place of MH370’.
                                                                                                                           underwater search for           Reports from the US Navy
                                                                                                                           the missing Malaysian           say that the acoustic ‘pings’
                                                                                                                           777 MH370 have said             detected in April, may have
                                                                                                                           that despite scouring over      been from the searching
Aerion has revamped its supersonic business jet (SSBJ) design — now with a larger                                          850km2 of the Indian            ships themselves or other
cabin and extended range. The AS2 SSBJ features three engines versus two on the                                            Ocean floor in the vicinity     man-made sources. The
previous design. Aerion anticipates that the AS2 will still be certified in 2021 with                                      of pings thought to be          search will continue over
first flight expected in late 2018 or early 2019, followed by a 24-month certification                                     from the aircraft’s beacon,     a larger 60,000km2 arc in
                                                                                                                  Aerion

                                                                                                                           the ‘area can now be            the Indian Ocean.

Australia and Canada. The           Wichita, Kansas, factory.                                                              crashed at the Moron            Technology (ALHAT) test
UK will join the agreement,         The nine-passenger bizjet                      Bombardier has delivered                Air Base, near Seville,         involved descending an
which has been previously           features a Garmin G3000                        the first of 90 enhanced                on 9 June. The cause            unmanned Morpheus
signed by the other three           flight deck and is set to                      CRJ900 regional jets to                 of the accident is under        lander from 800ft using
nations. The agreement              receive FAA certification                      American Airlines. The                  investigation, but the          on the ALHAT systems for
lays the groundwork for             later this year.                               original orders for the                 aircraft crashed into the       guidance.
an international version                                                           aircraft, which will operate            ground less than a mile
of the US Joint Space               The US FAA has cleared                         under the American Eagle                from the runway threshold.      Swiss manufacturer Pilatus
Operations Center                   the Boeing 787 for                             brand, was first announced                                              began taking orders for its
(JSpOC), which acts as a            extended ETOPS flights                         in December 2013 and                    NASA has conducted a            new PC-24 utility/business
central clearinghouse for           over water for 330                             included an additional 40               key technology test at the      jet at the Geneva EBACE
the military’s tracking of          minutes, or five and a half                    options.                                Kennedy Space Center            show in May. The rollout
space-based objects.                hours. This expands on                                                                 in preparation to land an       of the first of three PC-24
                                    the previous ETOPS limit                       Spanish Air Force pilot                 unmanned spacecraft on a        prototypes is scheduled for
Cessna has rolled out the           for the 787 and opens up                       Captain Fernando Llusa                  rugged planetary surface in     1 August, with the maiden
first production example            the longest trans-Pacific                      Carrascosa of Ala 11 was                the dark. The Autonomous        flight to follow in early
of its Citation CJ3+ at its         routes.                                        killed when his Eurofighter             Landing Hazard Avoidance        2015.

     @aerosociety     i   Find us on LinkedIn   f   Find us on Facebook                www.aerosociety.com                                                                    JULY 2014    7
THE GREAT BRITISH TAKE-OFF - LIGHTNING II HEADS FOR FARNBOROUGH DÉBUT - UK'S NEW CIVIL AEROSPACE R&D - Royal Aeronautical Society
Radome
                           AIR TRANSPORT                                                   DEFENCE
                           Arke 787 arrives in
                           style
                           The first Boeing 787               Force Demo Team.
                           for Dutch charter                       Arke has three
                           carrier Arke                              787-8s on
                           got a VIP                                   order, which
    RNLAF F-16 Demo Team

                           welcome                                     will be used
                           when it was                                 on services

                                                                                                                                                                                                 Brazilian Air Force
                           escorted                                    between
                           by F-16s                                   Amsterdam
                           of the Royal                             and the
                           Netherlands Air                      Caribbean.

                           AEROSPACE                                                                                                  World Cup defenders
                                                                                                                                      Brazil’s military have      stadiums will suspend
                                                                CSeries uncontained                                                   been deployed as part       landings at nearby
                                                                      engine failure                                                  of the security measures
                                                                                                                                      surrounding the month-
                                                                                                                                                                  airports while matches
                                                                                                                                                                  are underway. The effort
                                                                                                                                      long FIFA World Cup         involves 12,600 personnel
                                                                                                                                      tournament. A restricted    from the Brazilian Air Force
                                                                                                                                      zone above football         and 77 aircraft.

                                                                                                                                      GENERAL AVIATION
                                                                                                                                      UK CAA relaxes fixed-
                                                                                                                                      wing microlight rules
                                                                                                                         Bombardier

                                                                                                                                      On 28 May, the UK           the aircraft no longer
                                                                                                                                      CAA announced the           need a Permit to Fly
                                                                                                                                                                  to operate in the UK.
                                                                                                                                      de-regulation of all
                                                                                                                                                                  The move, undertaken
                           Bombardier temporarily suspended flight tests on its CSeries regional jet following an                     single-seat fixed-wing
                                                                                                                                                                  after consultation with
                           ‘uncontained’ low pressure turbine engine failure on 29 May. The incident occurred during                  microlights.                stakeholders, expands the
                           a ground maintenance test of flight test aircraft FTV-1 at Mirabel, Quebec, and involved a                 This means, for             previous SSDR category
                           Pratt & Whitney PW1500G engine. The company has since resumed engine ground tests.                         airworthiness purposes,     from 2007.

                           NEWS IN BRIEF
                                                          transfer to T2 over the next     Soyuz rocket to the                        Alenia Aermacchi have       aircraft will be delivered
                           Rolls-Royce has run            few months.                      International Space Station                announced a joint           between 2017 and 2019.
                           the first Trent 1000-                                           (ISS). The three-man crew                  proposal to develop a
                           TEN engine which will          On 23 May, an RAF                consisted of Germany’s                     next generation (medium     A USAF Global Hawk has
                           eventually be used to          RC-135W Rivet Joint              Alexander Gerst, Russia’s                  altitude long endurance)    flown in UK airspace for
                           power future models of         made its first training          Max Surayev and NASA’s                     MALE UAV. The companies     the first time. The UAV,
                           the Boeing 787. The new        flight in UK airspace from       Reid Wiseman.                              say, if approved by         operating at 50,000ft in
                           78,000lb thrust engine is      RAF Waddington since                                                        European governments,       controlled airspace, was
                           scheduled for certification    delivery last November. The      Gulfstream has introduced                  such a jet-powered MALE     taking part in a NATO
                           at the end of 2015.            RC-135W has now been             the 7,500nm range                          design could be ready by    evaluation called Unified
                                                          cleared to an ‘initial release   G650ER which the US                        2020.                       Vision 2014.
                           The new £2·5bn Terminal        to service’, according to        manufacturer claims
                           2 at Heathrow Airport          the MoD.                         makes it the world’s                       Air New Zealand has         United Launch Alliance
                           was opened on 4 June                                            longest-range business jet.                ordered ten Airbus          (ULA) launched the
                           to passengers using 34         On 28 May a multinational                                                   A320neos, one A320          USAF's sixth Block IIF
                           United Airlines' flights.      crew launched from               Airbus Defence and                         and three A321s in a deal   GPS satellite atop a Delta
                           A further 25 airlines will     Kazakhstan aboard a              Space, Dassault and                        worth up to $1·5bn. The     IV rocket on 16 May.

8                          AEROSPACE / JULY 2014
THE GREAT BRITISH TAKE-OFF - LIGHTNING II HEADS FOR FARNBOROUGH DÉBUT - UK'S NEW CIVIL AEROSPACE R&D - Royal Aeronautical Society
GENERAL AVIATION                                                           SPACEFLIGHT
                                           550mph jet powered
                                                      flying car
Greg Brown

                                 Two US inventors, Greg           GF7 would use a 3,500lb
                                 Brown and Dave Fawcett           Williams FJ44-4 turbofan
                                 have unveiled a concept          to power this ‘flying car’,
                                 for a four-seat jet-powered      with electric propulsion
                                 roadable aircraft, capable       on the ground. The team
                                 of taking off and achieving      are aiming for a flying
                                                                                                   SpaceX

                                 speeds of 550mph. The            prototype in four years.

                                  Rolls-Royce opens new                                                     SpaceX reveals Dragon V2
                                  facility                                                                  Commercial space              ISS in low Earth orbit. The   landing-legs and retro-
                                  Rolls-Royce has opened a new £100m                                        company SpaceX has            Dragon V2 is also reusable    rockets to enable it to land
                                  advanced fan/turbine disc production                                      revealed the manned           and is equipped with          vertically after re-entry.
                                                                                                            version of its cargo-
                                  facility, in Washington, UK. Once
                                  operational, it will produce some 2,500
                                                                                                            carrying Dragon capsule,
                                                                                                            which will be able to carry
                                                                                                                                          DEFENCE
                                  discs per year.                                                           seven astronauts to the
                                                                                                                                          Swiss vote no to Gripen
                                 AIR TRANSPORT                                                                                            The people of Switzerland     to the proposals. The public
                                                                                                                                          have voted to abandon a       vote could also threaten
                                 INFOGRAPHIC: Local heroes: the                                                                           proposed purchase of 22       other proposed measures,

                                 value of regional UK airports                                                                            Saab Gripens to replace
                                                                                                                                          the Swiss Air Force’s
                                                                                                                                                                        including a pact between
                                                                                                                                                                        Saab and Pilatus to offer
                                                                                                                                          remaining Northrop F-5        the PC-21 turboprop as
                                                                                                                                          fighters.                     a possible solution for
                                                                                                                                               Held on 18 May, 52%      Sweden's future pilot
                                                                                                                                          of respondents voted ‘no’     training requirements.

                                                                                                                                           ON THE                       Correction
                                                                                                                                           MOVE                         In last month’s
                                                                                                                                          ATR has appointed             AEROSPACE in the
                                                                                                                                          Patrick de Castelbajac as     article on Eurofighter
                                                                                                                                          its new CEO.                  upgrades ‘In the
                                                                                                                                                                        Typhoon’s path’ the
                                                                                                                                          Paul Watts is the new         phrase ‘leading-edge
                                                                                                                                          GM of Bell Helicopter’s       route extensions’ was
                                                                                                                                          Lafayette, LA assembly        used. It should, of
                                                                                                                                          plant.                        course, be ‘leading-
                                                                                                                                                                        edge root extensions’.
 Airport Operators Association

                                                                                                                                          Bristow Group                 We apologise for any
                                                                                                                                          announced that John           confusion caused.
                                                                                                                                          Briscoe has been

                                                                                                                                                                               ✎
                                                                                                                                          appointed to the position
                                                                                                                                          of Senior Vice President
                                                                                                                                          and Chief Financial
                                                                                                                                          Officer.

                                    @aerosociety    i   Find us on LinkedIn   f   Find us on Facebook           www.aerosociety.com                                                       JULY 2014    9
THE GREAT BRITISH TAKE-OFF - LIGHTNING II HEADS FOR FARNBOROUGH DÉBUT - UK'S NEW CIVIL AEROSPACE R&D - Royal Aeronautical Society
antenna:                                                              Global Outlook and
                                                                           Analysis with
                                                                           HOWARD WHEELDON

                             The Italian Job

                              J
 THE ITALIANS                          ust as British, French, Spanish and German      terms of further potential defence cuts could well
 ARE TO BE                             governments have all been forced to             mean that retention of sovereign capability and skills
 COMMENDED                             take a long hard look at what they spend        will continue to play a large part in dictating future
                                       on defence, so too has the new Italian          policy toward defence equipment procurement.
 FOR THE MANNER                        government been questioning future defence      While critics would regard this as playing ‘politics’,
 IN WHICH                              capability needs with renewed vigour. In        as opposed to creating well thought out defence
 THEY HAVE                   March, weeks after taking office, newly appointed         ‘strategy’ I suggest, despite the rhetoric and ambition
 AGAIN PLACED                Italian Prime Minister Matteo Renzi suggested             to the contrary, that in a fractious and delicate
                             that the defence budget would be cut by €3·7bn            parliamentary system such as the one that Italy has,
 MAINTENANCE                 in 2015/16 and that a White Paper overseen by             when pressured Prime Minister Renzi will likely tread
 AND                         a group of experts managed by the Italian Ministry        a far more cautious path on defence cuts than the
 SUSTAINMENT                 of Defence would be published before the end of           one currently being targeted.
                             the year. The White Paper would apparently run in
 OF SOVEREIGN                parallel with a separate defence commission review
                                                                                             Notwithstanding the importance of Italy within
                                                                                       NATO, it is also right to point out that, after several
 MANUFACTURING               that is looking at future procurement.                    rounds of past defence cuts, Italy retains, when
 CAPABILITY OVER                  That Parliament, as opposed to the Supreme           compared to fellow Northern European NATO
 AND ABOVE THE               Defense Council, is now required to provide the           members, a high level of air power capability. The
                             primary decision and influence, marks a huge              Italian Air Force (Aeronautica Militare) fast combat
 CHEAPER RISK                change in attitude and approach to Italian defence        jet inventory had, not so long ago, been as high as
 AVERSE OPTION               procurement. It is one that is known to be opposed        253 aircraft. However, at the time of writing, the
 OF BUYING                   by Italy’s President, Giorgio Napolitano, but probably    current fast jet inventory is believed to comprise 16
 COMPLETED                   unlikely to be reversed. Desperate to cut public          AV-8Bs, 55 still active Tornado aircraft in both IDS
                             spending, Prime Minister Renzi has suggested that a       and IT-ECR form (another 44 aircraft are held as
 AIRCRAFT OFF-               further €3bn of defence cuts could emerge over the        retired or stored), 52 AMX ground-attack aircraft plus
 THE-SHELF                   next three years, these being facilitated by closure      a still expanding fleet of 71 Eurofighters. When the
                             of almost 400 military barracks plus additional cuts      remaining Eurofighters on order have been delivered
                             to planned numbers of F-35 Joint Strike Fighters.         the total will amount to 96 aircraft.
                             In the case of the latter, these had already been               Although intended numbers of F-35s could
                             slashed from an original intention to acquire 131         still be cut, the Italian Government continues to
                             aircraft down to 90. As if to back the intention to       have a stated intention to acquire 90 aircraft from
                             further cut F-35 procurement, on 19 March the             Lockheed Martin. These are currently specified as
                             Italian Parliament signed off a report that called for    being 60 ‘A’s and 30 ‘B’ STOVL variants. Clearly, given
                             significant cuts to the F-35 programme.                   the age of some legacy aircraft, modernisation of
                                  Italy had already been going through a process       the fast jet fleet is essential but, like other nations,
                             of previously agreed defence cuts that would see          including France, faced with the similar affordability
                             current numbers of military personnel reduced by          utility issues, the Italian Government remains under
                             20% by 2022. The White Paper, when it emerges,            considerable pressure from the ECB to balance its
                             is, however, more likely to highlight the need to         books and to start reducing debt.
                             speed up the process of scrapping legacy capability.            Even so, having worked hard to support its
                             Aware of the need to modernise, I take the view that,     NATO allies over the past 20 years and proven the
                             despite pressure to recommend further programme           potency and efficiency of its air power capability, I
                             cuts, it will likely focus on important elements of       suggest that, given the proximity of Italy to some of
                             future defence strategy and capability requirement.       the more troubled regions of the world, it may be
                             If correct, this would suggest that what eventually       worth reminding that Italians have a tendency to
                             emerges as a result of the White Paper may not be         be far more sensitive to the needs of maintaining
                             quite as bad as it appears on the surface.                strong defence than some of Europe’s other NATO
                                  It is also worth remembering that Italy has a        members. Indeed, just as we are seeing defence
                             very different attitude and approach to its defence       chiefs in France placing their heads over the parapet
                             industrial base than countries such as Britain. To that   objecting to further defence cuts and complaining
                             end and despite being strongly supportive of EU           that those already authorised have gone too far, I
                             membership, Italy places national interest, sovereignty   doubt that Italian service chiefs will take another
                             and skills retention as a high priority. Translated in    proposed round of defence cuts on the chin.

10   AEROSPACE / JULY 2014
Lockheed Martin's
                                                                                                                                                     F-35 Fort Worth
                                                                                                                                                     facility. Italy has
                                                                                                                                                     built its own
                                                                                                                                                     assembly line at
                                                                                                                                                     Cameri.
Lockheed Martin

                       The issue of maintaining sovereignty, jobs and                    in the maintenance and sustainment of sovereign
                  skills is also likely to play a role here. Just as Italian             manufacturing capability over and above the cheaper
                  industry continues to build Eurofighter aircraft, so too               risk-averse option of buying completed aircraft off
                  has the nation decided to build in-country all the F-35                the shelf. What is equally impressive is that, given
                  aircraft that it orders for the Aeronautica Militare. The              the requirement for common standards of design
                  superb built-for-purpose Alenia Aermacchi facility at                  and build, meaning that the Italian method of wing
                  Cameri will also build the 37 F-35s that have been                     production and final aircraft assembly is not at
                  ordered by the Royal Netherlands Air Force.                            variance with that of US production standards, it
                       Retention and, more importantly, sustainment                      appears that, from an efficiency and productivity
                  of sovereign manufacturing capability, is hugely                       point, the Cameri facility has already more than
                  important to Italy. While Britain, a Tier One partner in               achieved its objectives.
                  the F-35 programme producing approximately 15%                              With capacity to produce approximately 71 wing-
                  of the aircraft, along with Australia, Norway, Denmark                 sets per annum, the current plan is for production of
                  and Turkey will take all the F-35s they acquire directly               65 wing-sets a year in a programme that expects to
                  from LM in Fort Worth, the Italians have chosen to                     deliver a total of 835 wing sets in the years ahead.
                  continue the long tradition of manufacturing or, in the                In terms of aircraft assembly, the initial plan is to
                  case of the F-35, assembling most of what it requires                  produce eight F-35s per year by 2018, increasing to
                  in terms of defence capability at home. Italy has                      two aircraft per month thereafter.
                  secured considerable additional work on the F-35                            During my visit I was able to see the first four
                  programme and is a second source supplier of F-35                      Italian-assembled aircraft at various stages of
                  wing-sets for LM.                                                      production. The first, AL-001, was due to be powered
                       Having recently visited the Cameri production                     up in June with a first flight anticipated in May/June
                  facility which is already well engaged in construction                 2015. Aircraft AL-002 and AL-003 were also in the
                  work on the complex F-35 wing-sets that are                            preliminary stage of construction.
                  then exported to the US, the engineering prowess                            The Cameri facility is a reminder that Europe
                  and programme expertise developed was very                             has not lost the art of investing in military aircraft
                  impressive. Starting from a green-field site in 2011,                  manufacturing. But, in the great scheme of things,
                  the now complete complex contains no fewer than                        unless Europe decides to be bold and to look at
                  22 different buildings that have been designed for                     investing in a new manned aircraft programme and
                  a variety of purposes, including wing manufacture,                     gets its act better together on UAVs, we will continue
                  aircraft assembly, final finishing and acceptance                      to be beholden to the US. It is our choice to make
                  testing. The hope is that, eventually, the plant will be               but, once made, there can, in the highly sophisticated
                  the centre of excellence for all European F-35 MRO                     world of military aircraft technology, be no turning
                  and future upgrade work.                                               back.
                       With 6,000 Italian jobs reliant on the F-35, of                        Italy’s plan for F-35 production may appear to be
                  which Cameri will eventually be responsible for                        a brave decision and one that others would consider
                  around 1,500 both in wing manufacturing and full                       to be full of potential risk but it is to be commended
                  aircraft assembly, the success of Cameri is hugely                     for the bold statement it sends. While the plan has
                  important. The decision to invest in a full ‘Final                     great merit, in my view, achieving the wider long-term
                                                                                                                                                                            Lockheed Martin

                  Assembly and Check Out’ (FACO) facility was not                        vision to be Europe’s F-35 MRO centre of excellence
                  taken lightly and there remains a high degree of                       on the Cameri site will, at a time when Italy is striving
                  potential risk. The Italians are to be commended                       to cut expenditure on defence, require a degree of
                  for the manner in which they have again placed                         stability to emerge first.

                      @aerosociety   i   Find us on LinkedIn   f   Find us on Facebook         www.aerosociety.com                                              JULY 2014               11
Transmission
     LETTERS AND ONLINE

                                                                                                          Eurofighter
                                                                                                                        resources in place for the      community and individuals
                                                                                                                        future — just like any other    already knew, she did
                                                                                                                        business.                       give glimpses of direction
                                                                                                                                                        and food for thought (and
                                                                                                                        Kim Verbraeken All              answered a heck of a lot of
                                                                                                                        this does is take the           questions). It does seem
                                                                                                                        focus away from a global        there is some momentum
                                                                                                                        problem. Pilot shortage         toward Moon followed by
                                                                                                                        combined with high cost         Mars missions. There is no
                                                                                                                        of training not only is a UK    doubt that, on the face of it,
                                                                                                                        issue, the entire world is      the UK could cautiously get
                                                                                                                        facing the same problem.        involved, especially as we’ve
                                                                                                                        These problems should be        the talent. We just need to
                                                                                                                        tackled on a global scale,      have strings attached to the
                                                                                                                        and industry plus govern-       substantial financial backing.
                                                                                                                        ments need to take action.      Following the RAeS
                                                                                                                        An isolated BALPA pro-          presentation, she gave
                                                                                                                        posal focused on the UK         another talk at London
                                                                                                                        situation only will agravate    University. She is a great
                                                                                                                        the situation!                  ambassador for NASA
                                                                                                                                                        and for the sciences and
                                                                                                                                                        struck many chords for
                                                                                                                                                        me (astronomy, aero/

                                                                                                                                 i
                                                                                                                                                        space, planetary physics,
                                                                                                                                                        geophysics). I think, if we
     Air-to-air refuelling from a Tornado to a Typhoon.                                                                                                 see much more of her in the
                                                                                                                                                        future, it would be a delight
                                                                                                                                                        and I’m very pleased to have
     Typhoon tankage                     cheaper version. With the        bonds or by the money the                                                     spoken to her.
     I have known since the              consequence of yet another       pilots make for them over
     first flight of its precursor/      debacle, different only in       time. It’s not the taxpayers’                                                 Michael T Systems
     quasi-prototype EFA 30              magnitude from the farce         problem, it’s a problem the                                                   Engineer [On Hybrid Air
     years ago that the Typhoon          of the catapult/no-catapult/     industry brought upon itself                                                  Vehicles Airlander airship(2)]
                                                                                                                        Geoffrey W Chartered            I’m fascinated by these
     would need more tankage.            catapult decade-hence-           by creating a market where                    Senior Aircraft Structural
     Every small warplane, from          maybe aircraftless carriers.     people have to self fund.                                                     aircraft but doesn’t the world
                                                                                                                        Design and Development          have a shortage of helium?
     the Spitfire and before,            Power in international affairs   It’s Catch 22. No sponsor-                    Engineering Professional
     has. It would have been             necessitates military muscle.    ship so people self fund,                                                     Or is it OK to use hydrogen
                                                                                                                        [On RAeS lecture from Dr        now?
     far more economical, in             Scrimping on defence             people self funding so no                     Ellen Stofan, Chief Scientist
     performance degradation             incurs waste that renders        need to provide sponsor-                      of NASA(1)]
     as well as money, to design         our pretensions ridiculous,      ship                                          NASA can only achieve this
     this in, when it would have         that destroys the important                                                    aim if the US government
     been virtually free! A thicker      influence that Britain could     Tim Lee-Foster No. All                        and people are behind it like
     wing would have increased           exert.                           that will do is cement                        the days of Apollo but I do
     the internal volume and,                                             this ridiculous tax into                      not think there is enough
     because deeper, still have              Noel Falconer FRAeS          place. We should be                           support in the US, a joint
     weighed less; while a little                                         campaigning to get rid                        venture like the ISS would
     more sweepback held                                                  of it entirely. But it’s not                  be the best way forward,
     down the sonic drag. As did                                          going to happen until                         possibly with China involved

                                                  f
     MoD, the RAF and BAE.                                                the shortage really starts                    instead of Russia, However,
     The catch was that the                                               to bite — and right now                       this would be dependent on      @lawlorpd [on Emirates
     saving was long-term and                                             it isn’t. There is still no                   US politics so is unlikely.     A350 cancellation] as-
     the expenditure immediate,                                           shortage of newly qualified                                                   tonishing — Farnborough
     inside the event horizon of                                          pilots looking for that first                 Dee A Aircraft technician       and some better news
     politicians concerned to                                             job — the problem lies                        at American Airlines            can’t come quick enough
     buy the coming election                                              with getting them some                        Dr Ellen’s talk was very        for the Airbus press office.
     and, at best, the next. They                                         experience.                                   enjoyable and well
     pressured — is blackmailed          Derek Pake [On corporate                                                       presented, considering she
     too strong a word? — the            partner briefing about man-                                                    was originally supposed         @McBaine146 vote of
                                                                          Llyr Jones No.
     defence community, with             aging the future pilot short-                                                  to have shared the stage        no confidence in #Airbus
                                                                          Commercial airlines need
     threats to vital projects and       age] Here’s a better idea,                                                     with a colleague and had        and the A350? Not that
                                                                          pilots, and these airlines
     implicitly to the existence         have the airlines pay for                                                      to conduct it alone. While      Boeing and the 787 is
                                                                          should invest to make sure
     of individual Services,             the training and recoup it                                                     most of the content was         much better.
                                                                          they have the necessary
     to accept the close-in-             back through sliding scale                                                     what we as an aerospace
                                                                          suitably qualified,

12   AEROSPACE / JULY 2014
.                                                                                                                    @Josephaviation [on
                                                                                                                                                         new Aeroscopia Museum]
@AlexdEsterre [On                                                                                                                                        Yes, one very impressive
RAeS Bristol Branch                                                                                                                                      new Airbus museum.
lecture on electric flight] A
thoroughly enjoyable event
this evening, feel privileged
to be around some of                                                                                                                                     @DanVanderberg HSA
Britain’s most intelligent                                                                                                                               did a fine job on the wing
minds. #Aviation                                                                                                                                         and kept British know how
                                                                                                                                                         on A300 after Govt pulled
                                                                                                                                                         out. Undaunted (relieved?)
@PeterFarrowAST [On                                                                                                                                      Airbus kept going.
managing the pilot short-
age] big question here,
do we ‘manage’ it or take                                                                                                                                @jvrermondon Hope you
action to negate it?                                                                                                                                     have enjoyed Aeroscopia
                                                                                                                                                         and we’ll get back once it
                                                                                                                                                         is full and ready for its first
                                        A Concorde and prototype A300 in the new Aeroscopia Museum at Blagnac.                                           visitors ;)
@pilotjobsuk Pilot
Shortage? Tell that to
the hundreds of currently
unemployed pilots.                  @flyinggibbon [On                      @PhilipDjaferis [On fire               @PaulMarks12 The                      @Baz577 Why has
                                    the Embraer KC-390]                    destroying an Il-96 on the             reluctant German team                 Captain Eric Brown never
                                    Interesting, how does the              ground in Moscow] The                  he seconded to grab                   been awarded a knight-
                                    turbofans’ reverse thrust              fire apparently started in             the Nazi planes was                   hood??? Oh yes, he’s not
@Getintoflying [On the
                                    compare to the range of                the cockpit. It was parked             interesting too, and his              a 20-something sports
new UK CAA GA draft
                                    say a C-27 to stop once                there for months and was               US ops ...                            ‘celebrity’ ...
regulations] What does
                                    down?                                  up for sale but who wants
the @AeroSociety make
                                                                           an Il-96?
of the @UK_CAA draft
GA policy? Our thoughts
here: getintoflying.co.uk/                                                                                                                              @EdwardHawkins
                                    @Rob_Coppinger [On                     @crichardson123 [On                   @GlosAirport here he is
features/                                                                                                                                               Truly impressive when we
                                    aircargo drones decades                Eric ‘Winkle’ Brown BBC               opening @JetAgeMuseum                  think of today’s talk about
                                    away]. We hear this at                 TV documentary] what an               a few weeks ago. Amazing               the ‘speed of change’,
                                    Aerosociety event but an               amazing pilot and amazing             man. pic.twitter.com/
@AGM100UTC [On                                                                                                                                          ‘transformational change’,
                                    EU Commission study                    man — a truly national                qdZx4MNOu8
MH370 mystery disap-                                                                                                                                    etc.
                                    has identified tech map,               jewel!
pearance] This whole
                                    follow-on concepts study
event is alarming ... sh.
                                    possible.
                                                                           Lt Cdr Eric Brown piloting modified de Havilland Mosquito FBVI, LR359, which made the first twin-
                                                                           engined carrier-borne landing on to HMS Indefatigable on 25 March 1944.

                                                                                                                                                                                             RAeS NAL
@durtgeek [On a short-             @jonititan Personal deliv-
age of maintainance                ery drones are technically
technicians] If there was          feasible but the barriers
more of a push towards             are regulation and liability.
focusing on maintenance
instead of pilot careers for
youth all the time.

                                    @PauloNurra [On PAK-
                                    FA fire accident] It could
                                    be for sure an expensive..
@AngusBatey [On news                trade off between repair or
from RAeS RPAS confer-              new built.
ence] ‘UK govt opposes
                                                                           1. http://aerosociety.com/News/Insight-Blog/2257/VIDEO-Dr-Ellen-Stofan-NASA-Chief-Scientist-on-the-path-to-Mars
EASA plans for single                                                      2. http://aerosociety.com/News/Insight-Blog/2081/Airships-a-new-dawn
UAS regulation regardless
of size’ says to industry: “if     @martinmcnamara
you think we’re wrong, tell
us.” #RPASToday
                                   Oops ... ah well, most
                                   prototypes have one glitch
                                   or another...
                                                                                                 Online
                                                                                                 Additional features and content are available to view
                                                                                                 online at http://media.aerosociety.com/aerospace-insight

     @aerosociety     i   linkedin.com/raes
                          Find us on LinkedIn   f   facebook.com/raes
                                                    Find us on Facebook.       www.aerosociety.com
                                                                               www.aerosociety.com                                                                            JULY 2014            13
DEFENCE
                       Queen Elizabeth carriers

                   Carrier Countdown
                   This month on 4 July the first of the UK's new Queen Elizabeth-class (QEC)
                   carriers is set to be launched by Her Majesty the Queen — an important
                   milestone in restoring Britain's naval air power. TIM ROBINSON talks to
                   some of the engineers responsible for putting the 'air' in aircraft carrier.

                   THERE IS
                   A UNIQUE                                    he thing to bear in mind with the

                                             “T
                                                                                                        the transitions between aircraft variants” notes
                   CAPABILITY                                  QEC,” says David Atkinson, F-35          Atkinson.
                   HERE IN THE UK                              Integration Lead, BAE Systems, “is
                                                               the sheer scale of the flight deck.
                   AT BAE                                      It is just huge — three times bigger
                                                                                                        Leveraging simulation
                   SYSTEMS AT                 than the Invincible-class deck.” Atkinson is part         Integration of the F-35 with the QEC, in particular,
                   WARTON, WHICH              of the industry team that is working on this giant        has harnessed the growing power of simulation and
                   IS TO SIMULATE             flagship project. This BAE team, distinct from the        synthetic modelling to de-risk the process. Inside a
                                              company’s prime role in the Aircraft Carrier Alliance     F-35 motion simulator at BAE Warton's facility, test
                   OPERATION                  (ACA), is the interface between the aircraft (F-35)       pilots can assess the aircraft in the landing pattern,
                   OF THE F-35                and naval teams working on this project — to              develop CONOPS (CONcepts of OPerationS)
                   WITH OUR, OR               ensure that the UK's new stealth fighter and its          and take-off and land on a ‘virtual’ HMS Queen
                                              new carriers mesh as smoothly as possible. The            Elizabeth. The simulation is not bound to the F-35B
                   ANYBODY ELSE’S,            team, reporting up to the F-35 Joint Programme            and QEC either — it can also emulate F-35C and
                   AIRCRAFT                   Office via Lockheed Martin, is the first ‘port of call’   CVN characteristics. Additionally, to enhance realism
                   CARRIER                    for ACA and the MoD for questions about F-35              and develop procedures for take-off and recovery,
                                              integration. Says Atkinson: “Our role is to help the      other multiple ‘virtual’ F-35s can be inserted into
                   David Atkinson             MoD and ACA ensure the F-35B is integrated as             the simulations — to allow the pilot to assess how a
                   F-35 Integration Lead      efficiently and effectively as possible with the QE       formation of aircraft would recover to the ship. Says
                   BAE Systems                Class aircraft carrier.” This has involved extensive      Atkinson: “There is a unique capability here in the
                                              engineering, simulation and modelling — going             UK at BAE Systems at Warton, which is to simulate
                                              back a number of years.                                   operation of the F-35 with our, or anybody else’s,
                                                  However, as defence observers will know,              aircraft carrier who provides their model to us.” He
                                              the CVF future carrier project hasn't always been         observes: “It is the result of many years of [flight
                                              smooth sailing. The UK Government's switch from           simulation] experience in the facilties at Warton
                                              STOVL F-35B to CV (cats and traps) variant and            which has resulted in the leading edge that we have
                                              back again in 2012, not only looked like dithering        and can bring to bear on these two hugely important
                                              and cost valuable resources, but also set project         programmes.”
BAE Systems

                                              engineers racing to make up lost time. “That                  Though the F-35B’s advanced fly-by-wire flight
                                              interruption has had an effect on the programme,          control system has taken much of the hard work
                                              however our simulator models have helped to ease          out of vertical landings — the simulation has already

              14   AEROSPACE / JULY 2014
The F-35 motion simulator
                                                                  at BAE Warton has been
                                                                  crucial in developing QEC
                                                                  CONOPS.

                                                                      aircraft has all three (including the nose) wheels in
                                                                      contact right up until the point where the aircraft
                                                                      leaves the deck — giving positive nosewheel              QE- CLASS
proved its worth in helping test the Shipborne                        authority throughout. Additionally, the F-35Bs smart
Rolling Vertical Landing (SRVL) manoeuvre, which is
a UK-specific landing technique that allows higher
‘bring-back’ (several thousand pounds additional
                                                                      flight control system ‘knows’ when it is going up a
                                                                      ramp and will pre-position the control surfaces and
                                                                      effectors to launch at the optimum angle to avoid
                                                                                                                               28
                                                                                                                               MILLION
weight) of weapons and fuel — especially in hot                       pitch-up or down.
climates. SRVL sees the pilot land in hover mode
                                                                                                                               HOURS SPENT
but with forward speed — enabling the wings to                        Thermal challenges                                       DEVELOPMENT
generate useful lift. Unlike a traditional carrier                                                                             & DESIGN
approach at 130kts, where the pilot is prepared                       However, the biggest engineering challenge in
to ram the throttle open in case of a 'bolter' — the                  F-35 integration, says Atkinson, is the aero-thermal
SRVL ends with the aircraft automatically moving
the propulsion system to idle and the pilot applies
                                                                      environment surrounding the hot-exhaust gas of
                                                                      the F-35B and its 40,000lb thrust F135 engine.
                                                                                                                               250,000
the brakes. Input from test pilots in the simulator                   This challenge is not novel to the F-35 but has been     LITRES OF
has also added SRVL-specific symbology — a                            known about since the 1960s and the Hawker               PAINT USED
ship-referenced velocity vector to the pilots HMDS                    Siddeley P.1154, when it was realised that any
(Helmet Mounted Display System), to better judge                      supersonic P.1127/Harrier follow-on would need
the approach path using this recovery technique.                      extra effort to tackle this problem. Indeed, a scale
                                                                      F-35 hot-gas test rig has been used at Warton for
                                                                                                                               250,000
                                                                      some years to explore the aircraft's external thermal    KM OF
Lights, camera, action
                                                                      environment.                                             ELECTRICAL
Indeed the SRVL concept has also made another                             For the QE-class this has been dealt with in the
change in the F-35/QE integration — that of a                         development of a thermal metal spray to protect          CABLE
new stabilised lighting system or ‘Bedford Array'.                    the flight deck against high-exhaust temperatures.
Independent of the two glide path indicators (for                     This says Atkinson, was a unique challenge — while
both helicopters and fixed-wing aircraft) in the                      thermal metal spray existed, for use on an aircraft
port catwalk, this proprietary system, developed by                   carrier it had to combine heat-resistant properties
QinetiQ and manufactured by AGI Ltd uses LED                          with those needed by a flight deck — for example
lights in the deck tramlines to provide a gyro-                       the friction characteristics needed to grip aircraft
stabilised glidepath alignment cue and a forward                      tyres in wet conditions. Thermal proofing measures
and aft limit line to F-35B pilots carrying out SRVL                  such as higher temperature resistant paints and
approaches. The ‘Bedford Array’ approach lighting                     shields also extends to the catwalk and liferafts.
was trialed with QinetiQ's VAAC Harrier testbed in                    Says Atkinson: “The historic STOVL knowledge and
2008. Indeed, work on the QEC visual landing aids                     experience that was developed throughout the 60s
goes back even further, to the very start of the CVF                  to 80s has allowed UK understanding of ground
programme and these aids have been progressively                      erosion and hot gas to be brought to bear on this
developed using the Warton flight simulator.                          aircraft's ship interface.”
     The lighting on the QEC is innovative in other
ways. Giant TV-style ‘departure boards' on the side                   Conclusion
of the islands allow information (and even video) to
be viewed by flight deck personnel or aircrew sitting                 After the launch, the next milestone will see HMS
in readiness. It can also, if needed, project white                   Queen Elizabeth head for sea trials in 2016. This
light, acting as floodlights for maintenance or other                 will most likely see the first aircraft landings on
operations at night.                                                  the carrier, albeit with helicopters to support this
                                                                      activity. First rotary-wing ship operating limit tests
Not your father's ski-jump                                            are planned for 2017. First of class fixed-wing deck
                                                                      trials with F-35Bs from the US are planned to begin
The QE-class's ski-jump, too, has been carefully                      by the end of 2018 and to be completed in 2019,
designed and engineered from the beginning —                          leading to an Initial Operating Capability in 2020.
drawing on BAE's Harrier heritage. Says Atkinson:                          Thus, in 2020, the UK will possess a state-of-
“We had to go back into the archives and talk                         the-art warship and valuable floating piece of real
to people who had actually been involved with                         estate — able to embark up to 36 stealth F-35s
                                                                                                                                                   Aircraft Carrier Alliance

trials with the Sea Harrier and Harrier to make                       and/or helicopters (including Chinooks) to project
sure we understood the history of ski-jump ramp                       power, presence or offer assistance anywhere in the
development. The aircraft carrier ski-jump is a UK                    world. This potent carrier strike force represents a
innovation and something the UK is very proud                         massive jump in capability over the Invincible/Harrier
of”. The QEC's ski-jump is longer (200ft) than the                    era — and perhaps, in one way, sees the UK's CVA-
Invincible-class (150ft) and designed so that the                     01/P.1154 ambitions of the 1960s come full circle.

   @aerosociety   i   Find us on LinkedIn   f   Find us on Facebook      www.aerosociety.com                                           JULY 2014                  15
PLANE SPEAKING
                         Paul Everitt

                                                                     Plane Speaking with:
                                                       Paul Everitt      On the eve on this year’s Farnborough
                                                                         Air Show, we catch up with PAUL EVERITT,
                                                                         CEO, ADS Group, to ask him about the current
ADS Group

                                                                         status of the UK aerospace and defence
                                                                         industry, the concerns of his members and
                                                                         the possible implications of Scottish
                                                                         independence to UK plc.

                                               A
                                                             EROSPACE: How would you sum                  incredibly important development. The commitment
                                                             up the state of the UK aerospace             of industry and government to a £2bn forward
                                                             industry today?                              programme of R&D investment is very substantial,
                                                                                                          particularly since it takes us not just to the next
                                                                                                          election, but the election after that. So we go
                                                                                                          through both this Parliament and the life of the next
                                               PE: It’s a really positive and optimistic time. There is   Parliament. That really gives us a sense that this is
                                               a lot of genuine excitement across industry. I guess       a long-term arrangement. The role of the ATI is one
                                               that the background context to that is a range of          of developing strategy and co-ordinating resources.
                                               things. You’ve got exciting products, some of which        We know what we are trying to do in terms of where
                                               we will see at Farnborough and others that are or          the UK’s key strengths lie and the challenges of
                                               are about to come onto the marketplace. We’ve also         the customer requirements from airlines. Therefore,
                                               got growth in the civil market, which is continuing        what we need to do is to deliver products that will
                                               and looks very firm. We are seeing that increasing in      satisfy that customer demand. The ATI’s role is
                                               terms of deliveries, alongside the strong orderbook.       to bring these things together in a coherent and
                                               I think the other one, at least from a UK perspective,     co-ordinated way. In the past we tried to invest in
                                               is linked to the broader context of industrial             everything and eke out as broad a coverage as
                                               strategies. The Government gets the importance             possible from the limited resources available. Now,
                                               of industrial strategy. It is absolutely committed to      ATI is going to focus the investment that delivers
                                               a genuine partnership with industry, providing the         the best return for the UK as a whole. That is a very
                                               support, certainty and continuity that gives us the        significant and important development.
                                               confidence to invest.
                                                                                                          Q: What is currently the biggest concern to your
                                               Q: How significant is the launch of the                    aerospace and defence members?
                    The UK’s space sector      Aerospace Technology Institute (ATI)? (see
                    is becoming increasingly
                    important.
                                               page 20-23). Can a new ‘virtual’ R&D centre                PE: The biggest concerns across civil aerospace,
                                               really replace the RAE Farnborough of old?                 are challenges in the marketplace. We have
                                                                                                          customers that are very keen to buy more products
                                               PE: It’s a different world, I don’t think we are trying    (which is really good) but the economics of their
                                               to recreate things. The ATI needs to be seen in the        businesses mean that to buy more products
                                               context of all the work by the Aerospace Growth            they need a more competitive offering. That has
                                               Partnership (AGP) and again the link back from             ramifications from the very top of the supply chain
                                               that into the broader commitment to industrial             all the way down through it. The combination of
                                               strategies. There is no doubt that the ATI is an           increasing demand as well as the competitive
             SSTL

            16      AEROSPACE / JULY 2014
“Airbus is clearly an
absolutely crucial part
of the UK industry”

                                                                                                                                                  Airbus
pricing pressures, are challenging for individual                       the excitement, but also career opportunities. This
businesses. The growth in demand is certainly                           is to ensure that we win our fair share, if not more
challenging in terms of finding and identifying a                       than our fair share of the people that are available.
pipeline of appropriately qualified and skilled people.                 Hopefully this will also inspire more people to take
For some businesses, particularly those that are                        the right kind of courses and get the right type of
smaller scale and further down the supply chain,                        qualifications, so we increase that pipeline of talent.
ensuring they can finance the opportunities that
are available to them is high on their priority list. On                Q: There seems to be a tremendous amount of
the defence side, there are clearly concerns about                      activity in STEM outreach – but the industry still
the overall level of available spend. The obvious                       seems to be struggling to attract talent. What
route when the domestic customer constrains                             are we doing wrong?
expenditure, is to look to export markets. We are in a
set of circumstances where all of the major markets                     PE: This holds true for an awful lot of organisations,
are suffering similar levels of constraint, therefore,                  not just aerospace, but also across both
export markets are increasingly competitive. We’re                      manufacturing and engineering. We’ve got lots
all pitching in, and fighting for, business in a limited                of activity, all of it generally very good and well
number of areas, which has its own challenges.                          meaning but it is fragmented. It can mean we
Within the UK and with our own domestic customer,                       confuse as many as we inform. It’s a really tough
we are going through a significant change in reform                     job to try and tell people that somebody else
of defence acquisition. This includes the changes                       knows better. It would be nice if we could get a
outlined in the Defence Reform Act, devolved                            bit more coherence. From an ADS point of view
responsibilities to frontline commands, and as we                       this is typified around the work we do on Futures
come to the end of this Parliament, what the future                     Day. We collaborate and work with a range of key          IF WE MAKE IT
strategy is going to be and how that is going to be                     partners and stakeholders to maximise the value of
                                                                                                                                  MORE COMPLEX
played out through the next SDSR.                                       the opportunity that Futures Day offers. As far as
                                                                        we can, we are adding value to the activity rather        TO OPERATE
Q: On skills — has the UK got enough                                    than seeing it as something that is competing             WITHIN THE
engineers and scientists to meet its needs                              with what other people are trying to do. For us, the      LARGER UK
for the aerospace and defence industry going                            themes at the show are AGP and DGP (Defence
forward?                                                                Growth Partnership). We’ve got some really good
                                                                                                                                  FOOTPRINT,
                                                                        examples of a successful piece of activity around         THEN THAT ISN’T
PE: I guess all the evidence suggests ‘not yet’. If you                 the MSc Bursary scheme. We want to use the                GOING TO BE
look at the work that has been done by a variety                        show to demonstrate what the AGP has been able            POSITIVE FOR US
of different organisations, including many learned                      to help create, in getting young people who have
bodies, and work from Government, they all indicate                     qualified, or passed their exams by the time of the       AS AN INDUSTRY.
that, across all manufacturing and engineering                          show, as well as the next 200 who will be starting        WE ARE
sectors, that we are not generating enough people                       in September. There’s a real challenge out there but      CONCERNED
with the right skills and qualifications. So that is                    there are some good things that are happening. Our
                                                                                                                                  ABOUT THE
a challenge for us all. If we look at Farnborough,                      aim is to get people to focus on perhaps a more
the work we are doing around Futures Day is very                        ‘limited’ range of activities and draw people into        IMPLICATIONS
much focused on engaging people at an early point                       the successful activities that are being undertaken.      OF SCOTTISH
about what the sector can offer, both in terms of                       Hopefully, we create a bigger impact through them.        INDEPENDENCE

     @aerosociety   i   Find us on LinkedIn   f   Find us on Facebook      www.aerosociety.com                                             JULY 2014       17
You can also read