CLIENTS' EXPECTATIONS, BILLABLE HOURS AND SANITY - Ventura County Bar Association
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
A U G U S T – T W O T H O U S A N D T W E N T Y O N E
CLIENTS’ EXPECTATIONS,
BILLABLE HOURS AND
SANITY
by David Shaneyfelt
Page 12
MARC D. ANDERSON PRESIDENT'S MESSAGE 3
HAVE YOU HEARD? 5
SARA PETERS PUBLIC DEFENDER’S OFFICE PROVIDES MORE THAN CRIMINAL DEFENSE 10
CLASSIFIEDS 15
CREATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION
CONTINUING THE EXPANSION AND TRADITION
OF EXCELLENCE IN MEDIATION AND ARBITRATION
ESTABLISHED IN 1986 BY PAUL D. FRITZ ESQ. (1941-2011)
MEDIATION OF ALL CIVIL DISPUTES
• Business Litigation • Construction Defects • Serious Personal Injury
• Partnership Dissolution • Insurance Claims • Wrongful Death
• Probate • Professional & Medical Malpractice • Trade Secret Disputes
• Employment - Wrongful Termination • Real Estate Disputes • Health Care Issues
HIGHLY SKILLED AND EFFECTIVE MEDIATORS
Hon. David W. Long David M. Karen, Esq.
• Ventura County Superior Court, Retired • 35 Year Trial Attorney
• Appointed Judge of the Ventura County • Member, American Board of Trial
Municipal Court Advocates (ABOTA)
• Appointed and served for two years as • The Straus Institute for Dispute Resolution
Ventura County Superior/Municipal Pepperdine School of Law (2004)
Commissioner
• Chair of the VCBA-ADR Section
WE GET IT DONE
cdrmediation.com (805) 498-9494
JUDICATE WEST -- JOINING FORCES WITH CDR IN VENTURA COUNTY
David M. Karen, Esq.
DKaren@Judicatewest.com
OFFICES AVAILABLE (805) 498-1212
3155 Old Conejo Road, Thousand Oaks, CA
AUGUST 2021 • CITATIONS 3
PRESIDENT’S MESSAGE
by Marc D. Anderson
I hope you are all enjoying your summer. Scout on the other team say, “I could’ve
probably gotten the ball from him, but I
Bodie and I just returned from a week didn’t want him to fall and BREAK A HIP.”
at Boy Scout camp. This was our third
summer camp together. Our first two The Friendship Lodge has WiFi for the
camps were at Camp Chawanakee on adult leaders. The password is shared in
Shaver Lake outside of Fresno. This year we whispered conversations. We had been at
were at Camp Big Horn at Circle X Ranch camp two days when I asked someone for
near Lake Arrowhead. it. “Axl Rose dollar sign 25. Axl and Rose
are capitalized, I think, and there is a space
I love the simple routine of summer camp. between them and before the dollar sign,
The opening and closing campfire, morning I think.” I enter it - incorrect. I try ten
and evening flags, breakfast, lunch and more times - change the capitals, change At the closing campfire on Friday night
dinner together in the dining hall, merit the spaces. Incorrect every time. I give up, each troop puts on a short skit. We debated
badge classes during the day and free time too embarrassed to ask again. Later that for a bit on whether to do one of the
in the late afternoon. I walked a lot, read a night I’m back in the Friendship Lodge classics - invisible bench or gum balls - but
lot, napped a bit in the hammock, watched determined to get online. I spy a counselor, we decided to do our own skit that included
Bodie climb the rock wall and made new certainly a reliable source. “Axl Rose dollar the accordion and got the crowd involved.
friends. sign 25.” Hmm. “How is Axl spelled?” I The boys did a great job and the crowd
ask. “A-X-L-E.” I mention that I saw Guns- loved it. I’ve posted the YouTube link on the
The best part of camp for me was getting N-Roses in concert well before the staff Ventura County Bar Association Facebook
to see the boys and girls being kids after member was born and Axl Rose spells his page if you want to see it. https://www.
more than a year of pandemic restrictions: name A-X-L. He says “Axl Rose was in AC/ youtube.com/watch?v=jG3DH-HQNds.
singing goofy songs, doing the Polar Plunge DC, wasn’t he?” My gasp quiets the room.
at 5:30 a.m., riding the zip line, playing Driving home was bittersweet. We all
“No, Axl Rose was in Guns-N-Roses.” “Are
Uno by lantern just before lights out, and laughed as we relived the week’s highlights,
you sure?”
buying sodas, candy and ice cream from the but eventually the scouts in my car were
trading post. I especially enjoyed hearing I brought my accordion to camp. I played texting friends, watching videos or listening
the muffled conversations in the tents while the Scouts were at their merit badge to music on their headphones. I was left
just before the kids fell asleep. Everything classes and I had our campsite to myself. alone with my thoughts. I thought about
seemed almost back to normal at camp. I played at the empty amphitheater in how fast my kids are growing up and about
the evenings. Some of the Scouts walked how much I cherish these adventures we
At one of our troop bonding activities we through the amphitheater on the way to have together.
played another troop in soccer. It was hot their campsites and would stop and listen. Marc D. Anderson is
and we were playing in a dusty horse corral I played at the quad at night just before a lawyer with Hiepler
with a mostly deflated ball. I decided to play quiet time while the staff finished up at the & Hiepler, APC, in
for a bit. I got the ball, drove to the goal, office and Scouts and adult leaders walked Oxnard. He represents
and just missed outside. I didn’t score, but to and from the showers. I am an amateur plaintiffs in personal
I felt good that I could keep up with these accordionist, but it was fun to share music injury and wrongful
young boys and girls. Then I overheard a with the kids. death cases.
4 CITATIONS • AUGUST 2021
2021 VCBA
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
OFFICERS
President
Marc D. Anderson
President-Elect
Jacquelyn D. Ruffin
Secretary-Treasurer
Brian C. Israel
Past President
Kathryn E. Clunen
Executive Director
Sandra D. Rubio
Linda K. Ash Kata Kim
Rachel Coleman Louis H. Kreuzer
Margaret J. Coyle Monica O’Hearn
Vanessa M. Frank Guillermo“Bert” Partida
Carla L. Hartley Sara Peters
Joshua S. Hopstone Trevor M. Quirk
Brian C. Israel H. Frederick Seigenfeld
Damon L. Jenkins Kristine A. Tijam Team Dembowski
Stephanie A. Johnson Lauren R. Wood Ellyn Dembowski / Kellye Patterson
Top Producer 2007-2018
805.320.1206, 805.415.4419
CITATIONS EDITORIAL BOARD team@teamdembowski.com
DRE 01441424 / 01914558
Co-Managing Editor
© 2019 Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices California Properties is a member of the franchise system of BHH Affiliates LLC.
Cari Ann Potts
Co-Managing Editor
Wendy C. Lascher
Publisher
Mediation
Sandra D. Rubio
Creative
J.P. McWaters
Ted Andrews Sara Peters Where common sense
Alice Arnold Rabiah A. Rahman
Rachel Coleman Mari K. Rockenstein and the law intersect.
Karen B. Darnall Lauren E. Sims
Panda L. Kroll Kathleen J. Smith
Carol Mack Al Vargas
Michael McQueen Richard Walton Business / Contract Personal Injury
Employment Oil & Gas
CITATIONS is published monthly by the
Real Property Other
Ventura County Bar Association. The articles
in CITATIONS are the views of the authors,
and should not be construed as legal advice. Gisele Goetz, Esq., Mediator
Every situation is different. Consult a lawyer Hollister & Brace, a professional corporation
if you need legal advice.
Submit all advertising, Submit all editorial
Serving Ventura and Santa Barbara Counties
classified and calendar matters to:
Member: State Bar of California, VCBA, SBCBA
matters to:
VCBA CITATIONS
4475 Market St. 5425 Everglades St.
Suite B
Ventura, CA 93003
Ventura, CA 93003
t: 805.644-7188
(805) 963-6711
t: 805.650.7599 f: 805.644-7390
f: 805.650.8059 capotts@mwgjlaw.com
e: bar@vcba.org GMGoetz@hbsb.com
www.vcba.org
AUGUST 2021 • CITATIONS 5
HAVE YOU HEARD?
VENTURA NEW COURTHOUSE RULES Deborah Meyer-
SUPERIOR COURT Morris has earned
SELECTS NEW Fully vaccinated individuals are not a Masters Degree in
COMMISSIONER required to wear masks, but those who Educational Leadership
choose not to wear masks must self-attest and Administration
The judges of the that they comply with state and federal at Cal Poly San Luis
Ventura Superior Court vaccination requirements. Others must Obispo. Meyer-Morris
have announced the wear masks that cover nose and mouth is looking to start a new
selection of R. Paul Kawai as the court’s within all public areas of the courthouse VCBA Disabled Lawyers
newest commissioner. Mr. Kawai is an or courtrooms (but not in internal DA and & Legal Professionals Bar Association. If
accomplished trial attorney with over 19 PD offices.) Masks with valves, neck gators, you identify as a disabled lawyer or legal
years of experience. He will join the court bandanas and handkerchiefs not allowed. professional, and are interested please email
on August 3, 2021. Children under two years old and those her at dmeyermorris@kdeklaw.com.
with medical, mental health or disability
Kawai is currently a Senior Deputy Public Ian Elsenheimer is
conditions precluding masks are exempt joining Ferguson Case
Defender with the Ventura County Public from the order. In the jury assembly room Orr Paterson, LLP as an
Defender’s Office, where he represents and courtrooms people will be seated in associate. He will work
criminal defendants in all types of felony every other seat. with the firm’s land
matters. Prior to that, he was proprietor
use, transactional and
of his own law practice, the Kawai Law Other courthouse changes: VCSC no real estate departments.
Group, from 2010 to 2014, specializing in longer requires public check-in outside the After Aug. 9, you
criminal defense. Hall of Justice. Civil matters will continue can reach Ian at
to be heard on CourtCall only, unless (805) 659-6800, ielsenheimer@fcoplaw.com.
From 2007 to 2010, he served as an attorney otherwise ordered by the assigned judge.
with the Utah County Public Defender
Association, where he maintained a felony
caseload of approximately 200 cases per
year. Before that, he was a junior partner
with the law firm Esplin Weight from
2001 to 2006, litigating criminal defense,
criminal and civil appeals, domestic law
and tort matters.
Kawai served on the Governor’s Gang Jeff G. Coyner, Mike
Task Force in Salt Lake City, Utah, from M. Khalilpour and
2008 to 2011, which was charged with Matthew T. Bechtel
the development and implementation of Wendy Lascher flying with @Astro Katie, have been named
legislation and programs to reduce gang Daughter of CITATIONS editorial board partners at The
related activity, crime and violence. member Carol Mack. Green Law Group,
LLP. Coyner has
Kawai has been a Judge Advocate with represented businesses,
JHB Inns of Court resumes. Meetings
the U.S. Army Reserves since 2003. He government entities
will be the second Tuesday of October-
is currently Team Chief, responsible for and individuals in real estate disputes,
November 2021 and January-April,
supervising and training a team of 16 environmental matters, business and
2022 at Sterling Hills Country Club. To
army lawyers, providing legal assistance insurance litigation and mass tort actions.
renew or join, contact sandra@vcba.org,
to service members, and instructing Khalipour has represented and assisted
(805) 650-7599.
commanders, officers, and soldiers in numerous businesses with identifying and
Panda Kroll is Co- implementing strategies to manage risk,
areas of military law. He also served as
Chair of the national protect against exposure, ensure regulatory
Command Judge Advocate with the U.S.
Timeshare Litigation compliance, and protect company assets
Army in Afghanistan from 2006 to 2007
Group formed in and business litigation. Bechtel is a
and is a recipient of the Bronze Star. civil litigator with extensive experience
2021 by the American
Association for Justice. in ERISA (employee benefits) and general
Kawai is a graduate of Brigham Young
For more information, employment law. (805) 306-1100.
University and earned his law degree from
the J. Reuben Clark School of Law. contact Panda at
pkroll@pandakrollesq.com.
.
6 CITATIONS • AUGUST 2021
BAR LEADERSHIP
ADR SECTION
David Karen 498-1212
ANIMAL LAW
Emily Robinson 497-7474
ASIAN AMERICAN BAR ASSOCIATION
Jessica Wan 659-6800
BANKRUPTCY
Michael Sment 654-0311
BARRISTERS
Frederick Seigenfeld 254-2777
BENCH-BAR RELATIONS COMMITTEE
Hon. Matt Guasco 256-4972
BLACK LAWYERS ASSOCIATION
Damon Jenkins 644-7188
BUSINESS LITIGATION SECTION
Erik Feingold 644-7188
CITATIONS
Cari Potts 644-7188
Wendy Lascher 659-6800
CLIENT RELATIONS
Michael Christiano attorneymichaelchristiano@gmail.com
COURT TOUR PROGRAM
Thomas Hinkle 656-4223
CRIMINAL DEFENSE BAR ASSOCIATION
Doug Ridley 208-1866
DIVERSITY BAR ALLIANCE
Jill Friedman 644-7188
EAST COUNTY BAR
Doug Bordner 644-7188
EMPLOYMENT LAW
Rabiah A. Rahman 626-8337
FAMILY LAW BAR
Amy Van Sickle 642-7070
IMMIGRATION LAW
Vanessa Frank 641-9300
INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY
Peter Veregge & Rebecca Makitalo 496-1164
J.H.B. INN OF COURT
Panda Kroll 551-0773
JUDICIAL EVALUATION COMMITTEE
Linda Ash lindaash99@gmail.com
LAW LIBRARY COMMITTEE
Eileen Walker 444-6308
SOGI ALLIANCE
Mickye Coyle 662-1716
NATURAL RESOURCES SECTION
Kate Neiswender 649-5575
PROBATE & ESTATE PLANNING SECTION
Amber Rodriguez 643-4200
VCLA, INC.
Cesar A. Libanati support@vclegalaid.org
Managing Attorney
VC TRIAL LAWYERS ASSOCIATION
Richard Bredlau 650-3100
VC WOMEN LAWYERS
Rennee Dehesa 525-7104
VCBA STAFF 650-7599
Sandra Rubio - Executive Director
Nadia Avila - Associate Executive Director
Deborah Tovar - Member Relations Assistant
Brenda Bodie - CTP Coordinator
AUGUST 2021 • CITATIONS 7
P R O B A T E , T R U S T & D I V O R C E R E A LT O R
JOSE LUIZ MORALES
#1 IN VENTURA COUNTY*
Serving Ventura, Santa Barbara and Los Angeles Counties
RESULTS MATTER
The largest asset in your case deserves a proven expert
DAYS ON
MARKET 23 5 STAR
REVIEWS 100+ CASES
SERVED IN 100+
Market average: 70 days **Yelp, Zillow, Google & Facebook Market Average >5
805 387 9333
DRE #01891119 *Based on listings sold in 2017. ** Source VCCAR 2017
MORALES GROUP
REAL ESTATE ADVISORS
Welcome Susana Cruz!
Quirk Law Firm is pleased to announce Susana Cruz joined
the firm as an associate attorney.
Susana was born and raised in Santa Barbara. She is fluent
in Spanish. She has a 12 year old daughter who loves to
dance flamenco. She loves to hike, spend time with her
family and travel outside the U.S.A. She has experience in
worker’s compensation law, family law, criminal defense
and personal injury law.
Susana will focus on personal injury litigation.
877 S. Victoria Ave., Suite 111, Ventura, CA 93003 | 805-650-7778
8 CITATIONS • AUGUST 2021
AUGUST 2021 • CITATIONS 9
COVERAGE THAT PROMISES TO PROTECT.
BUILT WITH YOU IN MIND.
Becoming a member of Lawyers’ Mutual is more than choosing an insurance provider,
it’s joining a community of your peers and receiving our promise to protect you.
All of our innovative policies are designed in conjunction with underwriting, claims
and insurance experts who hold over 100 years of experience in the legal malpractice industry.
Member Benefits Continuing Legal Education Cyber Coverage
Unique programs, specialty rates, credit card payments, instant financing and exclusive
member benefits are all part of your Lawyers’ Mutual policy that has made us the premier
provider for the past 43 years.
Protect yourself. Protect your clients. Protect your future.
www.lawyersmutual.com
Our strength is your insurance
10 CITATIONS • AUGUST 2021
PUBLIC DEFENDER’S
OFFICE PROVIDES MORE
THAN CRIMINAL DEFENSE
by Sara Peters
We all know the Public Defender’s Office property theft offenses as misdemeanors. the court and represent them through that
provides legal representation for indigent (They could previously be charged as process, which could potentially involve a
persons charged with a crime. But did you felonies or misdemeanors.) Persons hearing.
know about the other services it provides? interested in applying to reclassify an
Ventura County’s new Public Defender, offense covered by Proposition 47 should Eliminating Criminal Administrative Fees
Claudia Bautista, explains that her office call the Public Defender’s Office at (805)
offers several services and resources aimed 662-6522 or (805) 654-2449 to speak to a Did you know that, until July 1, California
at alleviating the collateral consequences Prop 47 law clerk – before the deadline of counties and courts would charge fees for
of arrest, conviction and imprisonment. Nov. 4, 2022. things like being arrested and having a
It also provides legal representation for public defender represent you in court?
persons involuntarily committed to mental Proposition 64, which passed in 2016, And that’s just the beginning. According
institutions and those who seek to challenge reduced the punishment for many to the Debt Free Justice California flyer
mental health conservatorships. marijuana-related offenses. To apply for Bautista gave me, counties used to charge
the reclassification of a marijuana-related for seemingly everything: arrest; booking;
Alleviating Collateral Consequences offense from a felony to a misdemeanor, go citation/release on own recognizance;
to the Prop 64 Quick Link on the Public registration for court-appointed lawyer; cost
Expungements Defender’s website. of your court-appointed lawyer; probation
or parole supervision; pre-sentence/
Having a conviction on your record can Termination of Megan’s Law Registry investigation report; jurisdictional transfer;
make it extremely difficult, if not impossible, Requirement home detention; electronic monitoring;
to get a job. And the consequences of interstate compact supervision; payment/
unemployment affect more than just the Until this year, California was one of installment plan; work furlough program;
individual with the conviction. Poverty is only four states that required a lifetime of home detention program; voluntary work
a leading cause of recidivism. The Public registration on the Megan’s Law website release program; and electric monitoring
Defender’s Office can help someone get their for most sex offense convictions. As a instead of bail or jail.
criminal record expunged – which allows result, the online registry has become
them to truthfully state on job applications overcrowded with low-risk offenders, For the majority of people released from
that they haven’t been convicted (unless which detracts the public’s attention jail and prison – who are already at a
it’s a government job or one that requires from the high-risk offenders we should disadvantage when it comes to obtaining
a government-issued license). To get be aware of. Additionally, managing a housing and employment – being further
started, go to the Expungements section registry that’s overwhelmingly diluted with burdened by debt like this makes it nearly
of the Public Defender’s website, which low-risk offenders isn’t the best use of law impossible to get on their feet. What’s even
contains a link to an online form. Detailed enforcement resources. more unsettling are the implications of
information and answers to frequently this for Black Americans and other racial
asked questions about expungements can This January, Senate Bill 384 eliminated minorities.
also be found there. the one-size-fits-all lifetime registration
requirement and replaced it with a three- Thanks to Assembly Bill 1869, as of July 1,
Reclassifications tier system. Tier 1 requires ten years counties and courts are no longer allowed
of registration for those convicted of to charge or collect the above-mentioned
The Public Defender’s Office can file an misdemeanor or non-violent felony sex fees. But certain, other fees can still be
application for reclassification to have a offenses. Tier 2 requires twenty years charged and collected. Bautista encourages
felony conviction for certain non-violent of registration for the more serious and anyone with questions about fees to call the
offenses changed to a misdemeanor on violent sex offenses. Tier 3 requires lifetime Public Defender’s Office.
someone’s criminal record. A felony registration for repeat sex offenses and the
conviction carries more of a stigma than a most serious sex offenses. Opportunities to Work Off Fines for Persons
misdemeanor conviction – and is thus far without Housing
more likely to stand in the way of housing Beginning July 1, persons in Tiers 1 and
and employment. Another reason to apply 2 who have completed their ten or twenty If someone is without housing and unable
for reclassification is it’s easier to expunge a years of registration on the Megan’s Law to pay off fines assessed for infractions or
misdemeanor than a felony. website may file a petition to request certain misdemeanors that don’t carry
removal from the registry. For those mandatory jail sentences, they have the
When Proposition 47 passed in 2014, it who qualify based on income, the Public option of working off the fine by performing
recategorized most drug possession offenses Defender’s Office will file a petition with community service or participating in a
and low-value (not exceeding $950)AUGUST 2021 • CITATIONS 11
program like AA. To do this, they need Public Defender’s Office paralegals will referred to as an LPS conservatorship (from
to attend Homeless Court, which usually help connect anyone – not just clients – to the 1967 Lanterman-Petris-Short Act).
takes place during the last Friday of the the resources they need. Their paralegals This allows for involuntary mental health
month at a location that serves persons can be reached at (805) 654-2201. treatment and estate management. After a
experiencing homelessness. To apply for conservatorship petition is filed, a hearing
Homeless Court or get more information, Protecting the Mentally Ill—and Those is held. Conservatees can challenge the
call the Public Defender’s Office paralegals Accused of Having a Mental Illness conservatorship at or after the hearing with
at (805) 654-2201. the assistance of an attorney from the Public
Persons charged with crimes aren’t the only Defender’s Office. These conservatorships
Additional Opportunities for ones at risk of losing their freedom – so expire after one year and cannot be renewed
Veterans without Housing too are those accused of having a serious without another hearing. The Public
mental illness. When that happens, the Defender provides representation at those
Persons without housing who are also Public Defender is there to safeguard their as well.
veterans have the additional option of constitutional rights too.
attending Stand Down Court, which is part Help for Arrested Relative with Mental Illness
of a three-day event that generally occurs Challenging Forced Medication
once a year in July. At Stand Down Court for Involuntarily Committed When someone with a mental illness
fines and fees can be waived in exchange for is arrested, it’s unlikely they’ll get the
community service performed at the event. When a person’s mental health disorder medical treatment they need unless
Attorneys and law clerks from the Public causes them to be gravely disabled, or a someone informs the County Jail Medical
Defender’s Office can also help attendees danger to themself or others, they may Department (at (805) 654-3346) about the
obtain other resolutions, like case dismissal be placed in an evaluation and treatment mental illness and advocates on their behalf.
and expungement. The Stand Down event facility for up to 72 hours. During this 5150 The Public Defender’s website contains a
also offers medical screenings, dental care, hold (from section 5150 of the Welfare helpful flyer entitled “My Arrested Family
psychological counseling, VA benefits and a and Institutions Code), or any subsequent Member Has a Mental Illness What Do I
variety of other social services. hold, the patient cannot be forced to take Do?” It also recommends preparing a fax
antipsychotic medication unless a hearing to request that the person be screened for
Although this year’s Stand Down event was takes place where a judge finds that they placement in the mental health unit and
cancelled due to COVID 19, it’s possible lack the capacity to refuse treatment. At gives detailed instructions for doing so.
that a shortened version of the event, the hearing, the patient is represented by an The form is located in the Mental Health
featuring Stand Down Court, will happen attorney from the Public Defender’s Office. section of Public Defender’s website. (Look
later this summer or fall. for Mental Health on the pull-down menu
Challenging Involuntary Commitment under Services).
Alternative Sentences for Veterans Over 72 Hours
The Public Defender’s website contains
Veterans convicted of crimes they committed If, at the end of a three-day 5150 hold, the a lot of other useful information too. It’s
as a result of psychological injuries suffered patient is still gravely disabled, or a danger a great resource for their clients and the
in combat have the option of receiving to themself or others, they can be kept community in general. Learn more at
mental health treatment in lieu of serving for up to fourteen additional days for the vcpublicdefender.org.
a jail sentence. Veterans Court is the result purpose of receiving intensive treatment –
of a collaboration between the Department but only after a hearing. Bautista says the
of Veterans Affairs and Ventura County’s Public Defender’s Office has a dedicated
Superior Court, Public Defender, District attorney who represents patients in those Sara Peters practices
Attorney and Probation Department. The hearings, which take place in courtrooms family law and civil
Public Defender’s Office represents veterans located on the premises of Vista del Mar litigation in Ventura.
in this special court and connects them to and Hillmont Psychiatric. She has a background
services in the community. in employment law
Challenging Mental Health Conservatorships
and is a former special
Housing, Food & Other Community Resources education teacher.
Persons who are gravely disabled and
Bautista says anyone is welcome to contact unwilling or incapable of accepting She can be reached
her office to get help obtaining housing, treatment may be placed on a mental at (805) 200-7418 or
food, or other community resources. The health conservatorship – sometimes srp@peterslawgroup.com.12 CITATIONS • AUGUST 2021
CLIENTS’ EXPECTATIONS, BILLABLE HOURS, AND SANITY
by David Shaneyfelt
This article is excerpted from Shaneyfelt, “Confessions of a Catholic Litigator,” 17 U. St. Thomas L.J. 111, 127 (2020); some paragraphs and
footnotes have been rearranged, and subheadings added. For the extensive references supporting this article, please see p. 13
Greed or excellence?
Who bears responsibility for this structure
of sin? Everybody and nobody. Big budgets
may or may not be set by greed. Lawyers
may have a sincere desire to serve clients
excellently, and billing attorneys may or
may not bill high hours for the sake of
greed, envy or power. Associate attorneys,
for instance, have no choice; they are given
billable minimums, and they will be fired
if they fail to meet them. Partners may
fare no differently. If a client wants advice
about something first thing Monday, the
lawyer will work all weekend to provide
it. Everyone is responsible, and most are
Lawyers bill by the hour. The more hours development obligations, and non-billable
miserable. No Catholic litigator should
they bill, the more money they make. and internal administrative matters. And
want to be miserable. In theory, an all-
Lawyers also promise excellent services for we are not counting time for chit-chat and
consumed litigator might be able to
their clients, and excellent services typically coffee breaks. (A friend tells me he “double
practice the seven virtues – prudence,
require many billable hours. Clients who bills” during bathroom breaks, because he is
justice, temperance, courage, faith, hope,
want excellent services know this and more productive there). Billing eight hours
and charity – but those who do so are as
will pay those bills. When bills become a day will only be done with early arrival
rare as hen’s teeth.
predictable, law firms set budgets according and late departure times and supplemental
to the predictions. They expect attorneys to hours gained on Saturdays and Sundays. The prize is more pie
meet those budgets through billable hours
requirements. No life for the biller means trouble As a Scottish proverb goes, he who loves
the law will soon get his fill of it. This is
Budgets and billables High billable requirements mean one
especially true for young attorneys on the
inescapable consequence: no life for
track to partnership in big firms. A friend
Big budgets entail high billable requirements. the biller. When one has no life, one
of mine described the experience as trying
In 1958, the American Bar Association becomes prey to the usual consequences
hard to win a pie-eating contest where
recommended a 1,300 hour-a-year target for – depression, infidelity, divorce, substance
the prize for winning is more pie. This
attorneys. Today’s expectations exceed 2,000 abuse, health problems, early death,
aphorism is now making its way into the
in most large law firms. suicide. Bar associations and mental health
public domain.
professionals have devoted considerable
To put in perspective a 2,000 hour-a-year attention to the growing problem of A third alternative: live your life
target, consider that eight hours a day times lawyer mental health. Several state bars
five days a week times fifty weeks a year offer hotlines, public education and Not surprisingly, litigators tend to be of
will reach that target, and leave an attorney lawyer assistance programs; seven state bar two kinds: those who die at their desks and
with a two week vacation. Consider further, associations have added a mandatory mental those who decide to leave them. I plan not
that such a goal will be reached if one is health component to their continuing legal to be the former.
willing to forfeit all nine of the customary education requirements. A 2016 ABA
holidays (New Year’s Day, Martin Luther survey of 13,000 lawyers found that 21 David Shaneyfelt
King Day, President’s Day, Memorial Day, percent qualify as problem drinkers (a rate represents clients with
Fourth of July, Labor Day, Columbus Day, more than triple the rate for the general claims against insurers.
Thanksgiving and Christmas). Consider population, and nearly double the rate for He practices with The
further the day or two required to fulfill other highly educated professionals); 28 Alvarez Law Firm in
continuing legal education courses. percent struggle with depression; and 19 Camarillo.
Consider days for illness, birthday parties, percent have symptoms of anxiety. “[T]he
funerals and inescapable social obligations. likelihood of depression is 3.6 times higher
Consider time needed for firm meetings for lawyers than other employed people.”
and retreats, department meetings, clientAUGUST 2021 • CITATIONS 13
References
• 1958 requirements (Ronda Muir, • Mental health assistance (See Debra • Scottish proverb (Cordry, The
A Short History of the Billable Hour Cassens Weiss, State Bars Battle Lawyer Multicultural Dictionary of Proverbs: Over
and the Consequences of Its Tyranny, Depression; Legal Profession Ranks Fourth 20,000 Adages From More Than 120
LAW PEOPLE (June 18, 2007), http:// in Suicide Rate, ABA J. (Jan. 22, 2014, 11:45 Languages, Nationalities, and Ethnic Groups
w w w. l a w p e o p l e b l o g . c o m / 2 0 0 7 / 0 6 / AM), https://www.abajournal.com/news/ (No. 10429).)
articles/profitability/ashort-history-of-the- article/state_bars_battle_lawyer_depression_
billable-hour-and-the-consequences-of-its- legal_profession_ranks_fourth_in_suicid. • Aphorism (See Sara Randazzo, Being
tyranny.) [sic].) a Law Firm Partner Was Once a Job for
Life. That Culture Is All but Dead, WALL
• 2000 hour expectation (See Law Firm • ABA survey/likelihood of depression ST. J. (Aug. 11, 2019), https://www.wsj.
Hours—the Real Story, ABOVE THE (ABA, Profile of the Legal Profession com/articles/being-a-law-firm-partner-was-
LAW (July 24, 2012, 1:30 PM), https:// 59 (2019), https://www.americanbar.org/ once-a-job-for-life-that-culture -is-all-but-
abovethelaw.com/career-files/law-firm-hours- content/dam/aba/images/news/2019/08/ dead-1156536243.
the-real-story.) ProfileOfProfession-total-hi.pdf; see also
Debra Cassens Weiss, Perfectionism,
• Real impact of billable hours ((For a ‘Psychic Battering’ Among Reasons for
detailed analysis of real-life impact of billable Lawyer Depression, ABA J. (Feb. 18,
hours on lifestyle, see Yale L. Sch. Career 2009, 3:40 PM) https://www.abajournal.
Dev. Off., The Truth About the Billable com/news/ article/perfectionism_psychic_
Hour (July 2018), https://law.yale.edu/sites/ battering_among_reasons_for_lawyer_
default/files/area/department/cdo/document depression.)
/billable_hour.pdf.)14 CITATIONS • AUGUST 2021
Make an Informed
Client Referral
CARRINGTON LINDENAUER
Turn to the Lawyer
ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION PROFESSIONALS
Referral Service! Mr. Carrington and Ms. Lindenauer have
conducted over 4,000 mediations, 300
How often do you get a call from a arbitrations and have been discovery referees
prospective client with a legal need in multiple complex matters. Mr. Carrington
that falls outside your area of (ABOTA Member) has been a full-time
practice?
mediator since 1999 and Ms. Lindenauer has
▪ Our LRS is the only State Bar been mediating since 2011. Their professional
certified (certification #0059) association as of 2017 reflects their jointly held
and ABA approved Lawyer commitment to the values of tenacity, creativity,
Referral Service in our county; and the highest ethical standards applied to the
▪ LRS has been providing quality resolution of every dispute.
referrals as a public service since Serving Los Angeles, Orange, Ventura, Santa Barbara,
1978; San Luis Obispo, and Kern Counties
▪ LRS panel attorneys are required
* NOW: MEDIATIONS AND ARBITRATIONS
to meet specific experience
BY VIDEO CONFERENCING *
requirements as a prerequisite to
VIRTUAL PRIVATE CAUCUSES AND
joining the service;
COMPLETE CONFIDENTIALITY
▪ Every LRS attorney is required to
carry malpractice insurance; CARRINGTONLINDENAUER.COM
(805) 650‐7599 R.A. CARRINGTON
805-565-1487
VICTORIA LINDENAUER
805-730-1959
ratc@cox.net lindenauer_mediation@cox.net
Need to reach out to your colleagues and rely on their experiences?
Use the VCBA ListServes which are a Member Benefit!
The ListServe is intended to facilitate communication among its members by providing an opportunity to post a query on a
substantive or procedural issue. Once you send an email, every member on that specific list will receive the message. To
protect the ListServe participants from spam or other unwanted solicitation, you can only send messages using the email in
your VCBA Profile. Otherwise, it will automatically be rejected. Members are automatically added based off your Areas of
Practice and VCBA Sections you belong to. If you do not belong to that group email, the system will not allow you to use it.
vcba_administrative@intustalk.com vcba_epp@intustalk.com
vcba_adr@intustalk.com vcba_family@intustalk.com
vcba_appellate@intustalk.com vcba_federal@intustalk.com
vcba_bankruptcy@intustalk.com vcba_immigration@intustalk.com
vcba_business@intustalk.com vcba_insurance@intustalk.com
vcba_civil_lit@intustalk.com vcba_ip@intustalk.com
vcba_civil_rights@intustalk.com vcba_labor_employment@intustalk.com
vcba_construction@intustalk.com vcba_land_use@intustalk.com
vcba_consumer@intustalk.com vcba_malpractice@intustalk.com
vcba_corporate@intustalk.com vcba_municipal_governmental@intustalk.com
vcba_criminal@intustalk.com vcba_non-profit@intustalk.com
vcba_disability@intustalk.com vcba_real_estate@intustalk.com
vcba_education@intustalk.com vcba_taxation@intustalk.com
vcba_elder@intustalk.com vcba_torts@intustalk.com
vcba_environmental@intustalk.com vcba_workers_comp@intustalk.comAUGUST 2021 • CITATIONS 15
CLASSIFIEDS
TRANSACTIONAL ASSOCIATE - Busy PARALEGAL - Ferguson Case Orr
10-attorney law firm in Oxnard seeking a Paterson LLP seeks a full time, top notch LIFE CARE PLANNER
transactional associate with three plus years paralegal experienced in litigation. An ideal Injury & Disability Consultant
experience to join our team of professionals. candidate has at least five years of experience
Generous salary, including 401k, profit in litigation, including drafting discovery, TBI SCI BURNS
sharing and health insurance. Remote basic pleadings, electronic discovery
PTSD ORTHO CRPS
work is available. Please send inquiries and and case management. Our litigation
résumés to Cynthia at cponce@rstlegal.com. department covers many different areas of AMPUTATIONS
the law, including employment, real estate,
Karen Luckett
intellectual property, trusts and probate, OTR, CLCP, CCM, CDMS
Personal Injury | Work Comp | Med Mal
FAMILY LAW TRIAL ATTORNEY - personal injury and business disputes.
for hybrid remote/office. Zonder Family Please send your résumé with a cover injuryxpert@gmail.com
Law Group is a Westlake Village firm
looking for a seasoned family law trial
letter introducing yourself and describing
your experience to sbarron@fcoplaw.com.
805.570.0306
associate (seven-20 years of experience) Applicants without relevant experience will
with courtroom experience, oral advocacy not be considered.
abilities, influential and commanding
presence. Excellent pay and benefits. Great
opportunity for lawyers in a solo practice
who would like to merge their practice or
for a semi-retired solo. Send confidential
résumé to hello@zonderfamilylaw.com.CITATIONS PRSRT STD
US POSTAGE
Ventura County Bar Association
4475 Market Street, Suite B PAID
PERMIT NO. 507
Ventura, CA 93003 OXNARD, CA 93030
New RN Aubrey’s David pinning new
Graduation Party! Sergeant Kaylene!
1st Thanksgiving without Kaylene
Bed Head
Pie Time
This too shall pass: 2020 Dinner AKA Cranberry Queen Ariya!
We appreciate your criminal law referrals!
WWW.DavidLehrLaw.COM
805‐477‐0070You can also read
