IN THEIR OWN WRITE Diplomatic Couriers: "Eyes On" Sensitive Cargo for 100 Years - FAMILY LIAISON AT 40 - American Foreign ...

Page created by Roberta Carlson
 
CONTINUE READING
IN THEIR OWN WRITE Diplomatic Couriers: "Eyes On" Sensitive Cargo for 100 Years - FAMILY LIAISON AT 40 - American Foreign ...
P U B L I S H E D BY T H E A M E R I CA N F O R E I G N S E R V I C E A S S O C I AT I O N   N OV E M B E R 2 0 1 8

 Diplomatic Couriers: “Eyes On”
  Sensitive Cargo for 100 Years

                          IN THEIR OWN WRITE

                           FAMILY LIAISON AT 40
IN THEIR OWN WRITE Diplomatic Couriers: "Eyes On" Sensitive Cargo for 100 Years - FAMILY LIAISON AT 40 - American Foreign ...
IN THEIR OWN WRITE Diplomatic Couriers: "Eyes On" Sensitive Cargo for 100 Years - FAMILY LIAISON AT 40 - American Foreign ...
IN THEIR OWN WRITE Diplomatic Couriers: "Eyes On" Sensitive Cargo for 100 Years - FAMILY LIAISON AT 40 - American Foreign ...
IN THEIR OWN WRITE Diplomatic Couriers: "Eyes On" Sensitive Cargo for 100 Years - FAMILY LIAISON AT 40 - American Foreign ...
FOREIGN
                                  SERVICE                                                       November 2018 Volume 95, No. 9

                        Cover Story:
            Diplomatic Courier Service Centennial
                                                                                                     Focus on
                      22                                                31                        Foreign Service
             None Swifter                               From Pouches to Cargo:                       Authors
             Than These                                   Diplomatic Couriers
       A veteran courier salutes the                            Today
     Diplomatic Courier Service’s first                    The couriers’ mission has not
                                                                                                               34
        100 years and a career that                      changed, but their scope of work
                                                                                                In Their Own Write
        offers both satisfaction and                     and responsibility have expanded   We are pleased to present this year’s
         the opportunity to serve.                                dramatically.             collection of books by Foreign Service
           By James B. Angell                                     By Vince Crawley               members and their families.

                                                                                                               53
                                                                                                Of Related Interest
                                                                                              Here are recent books of interest
                      27                                                                      to the foreign affairs community
           U.S. Diplomatic                                                                   that were not written by members
              Couriers:                                                                            of the Foreign Service.
             A Historic
              Timeline                                                                                         59
                                                                                                 Coming into
                                                                                             Their Own ‘Write’—
                                                                                             A Look Back at an FS
                                                                                            Women’s Writers’ Group

                                              Feature

                                                64
                   The Family Liaison Office—
             Making a World of Difference for 40 Years
                 Each generation has redefined and built on the work of                      During the 1960s FS women writers
               earlier colleagues, sharing a commitment to safeguard and                    from the Greatest Generation banded
                improve the well-being of our Foreign Service community.                       together to polish their craft and
                                                                                                   get their work published.
                                    B y M e t t e O. B e e c r o f t
                                                                                              B y Fr a n c e s c a H u e m e r K e l l y

THE FOREIGN SERVICE JOURNAL | NOVEMBER 2018                                                                                                5
IN THEIR OWN WRITE Diplomatic Couriers: "Eyes On" Sensitive Cargo for 100 Years - FAMILY LIAISON AT 40 - American Foreign ...
FOREIGN
                                              SERVICE

         Perspectives                                          85
                                                          Reflections                         Departments
                   7                                  An Unexpected Find
         President’s Views                             in Deir al-Qamar                       10     Letters
       Telling Our Story to the                         By Daniel Morris
           American People                                                                    13     Talking Points
       By Barbara Stephenson                                   86
                                                          Local Lens
                   9                                  Bukhara, Uzbekistan
        Letter from the Editor                       By Melinda McIntyre                      Marketplace
    Tales from the Foreign Service
         By Shawn Dorman                                                                      80     Classifieds

                                                                                              82     Real Estate
                  19
         Speaking Out                                                                         84     Index to Advertisers
  Radically Simple Ideas for a
Better State: Foreign Service 2.0
           By JC Windham

    AFSA NEWS                          THE OFFICIAL RECORD OF THE AMERICAN FOREIGN SERVICE ASSOCIATION

                                                                    72 16,914!
                                                                    73 Retiree VP Voice—No Soup for You!
                                                                    73	Last Chance to Update Your Information for the
                                                                         2019 Retiree Directory
                                                                    74 Stick with AFSA in Retirement
                                                                    74 AFSA Welcomes Consular Fellows
                                                                    74 AFSA Receives “Clean” 2017 Audit
                                                                    75 AFSA on the Hill—The Race to the Midterms
                                                                    75 FSJ Editor Gives Lecture on Diplomacy

                                                   74               76 AFSA Honors Amb. Tom Shannon
                                                                    76 AFSA Welcomes New Governing Board Member
                                                                    76 AFSA Governing Board Meeting, September 12
                                                                    77 AFSA’s Outreach Goes from Coast to Coast
    70 Foreign Service Night at Nationals Park                      78	Notes From Labor Management—
    71 State VP Voice—Foreign Service Family Ties                        Performance Management: A How-To Guide

    72	FCS VP Voice—Working in Concert with State                  79 AFSA Welcomes Incoming USAID Officers
        to Advance Economic Security                                79 AFSA Welcomes New Team Members

On the Cover—The Diplomatic Courier Service then and now. Photo: U.S. Department of State/Diplomatic Security Service.

6                                                                                               NOVEMBER 2018 | THE FOREIGN SERVICE JOURNAL
IN THEIR OWN WRITE Diplomatic Couriers: "Eyes On" Sensitive Cargo for 100 Years - FAMILY LIAISON AT 40 - American Foreign ...
PRESIDENT’S VIEWS

Telling Our Story to the American People
BY BA R BA R A ST E P H E N S O N

I
   recently spent two weeks on the road,          companies competitive, to keep them              give us a shot at delivering some real
   explaining to fellow Americans what            viable and visible in overseas markets,          wins for the American people—and a
   we in the Foreign Service do and why it        also materially contributes to America’s         shot at proving your worth in a high-
   matters to them. As AFSA president, I          soft power, to our standing in the world         stakes, highly competitive promotion
have been determined to increase aware-           and to America’s global leadership.              process.
ness of and appreciation for the vital                In every talk, I remind fellow Ameri-            Additional overseas positions, espe-
work of the U.S. Foreign Service. We have         cans that, if they are concerned that            cially for economic officers, would help
made real progress on this front, with            America’s global leadership is being             address serious commercial competition
your help. I hope each of you will join us        challenged as China gains commercial,            in the short term while also, over the
in the effort.                                    economic and political ground (and Con-          longer term, developing the leadership
    In every talk, I explain how the              gress, which has held a dozen hearings           bench the American Foreign Service will
Foreign Service works to keep threats at          on this topic, certainly is), they should        need over the coming decades.
bay so our fellow Americans are safe at           not overlook one key, cost-effective,                How can you help? First, tell your
home, and I give examples that illustrate         “shovel-ready” component of the solu-            stories. Sincere thanks to each and every
the many ways we help level the playing           tion set: the U.S. Foreign Service. We’re        one of you who contributed to the “Eco-
field for American businesses. That not           eager to get back on the field and cover         nomic Diplomacy Works” collection for
only helps keep our country prosperous,           all the bases.                                   the upcoming January-February double
it also reminds host nations, through the             I remind audiences that China’s              edition of The Foreign Service Journal.
positive example American businesses              spending on diplomacy has increased by               These rich stories will reach members
so often provide, what they love about            40 percent over the past five years while        of Congress (who all receive the FSJ) and
America—our cutting-edge innovation               America’s spending on core diplomatic            the American public (through AFSA’s
and design, our transparent and account-          capability has fallen by a third. I let          outreach), as well as serving as an inspi-
able business processes, our fair hiring          them know that, while I am grateful to           ration to fellow members of the Foreign
and promotion practices, our unparal-             Congress for recognizing that America’s          Service who see how you made economic
leled excellence at managing complex              global leadership could not afford the           diplomacy work at your post and try it at
projects and solving complex problems.            deep cuts proposed to the international          theirs.
    I make clear that our economic and            affairs budget, we could really use some             Active-duty members who host
commercial diplomacy is about more                additional funding to rebuild America’s          members of Congress have an enviable
than successful transactions that keep            core diplomatic capability so that our           opportunity to highlight the excellent
us prosperous—as important as that is             country can compete effectively in the           work being done at their post, so I urge
                         (please see FCS          current environment.                             all of you hosting a CODEL to plan ahead
                         VP Dan Crocker’s             One hundred million dollars would go         and polish your story. Effective story-
                         excellent column         a long way: it would cover the overseas          telling takes time and effort, but it’s a skill
                         on commercial            support costs for shifting 300 mid-level         worth mastering. And, if you are retired,
                         diplomacy in             FSO positions from Washington to                 please join the Speakers Bureau and take
                         AFSA News). The          embassies and consulates overseas,               advantage of the rich library of material
                         work we do to            where the Foreign Service works its real         AFSA is developing on what the Foreign
                         keep American            magic for the American people. It would          Service does and why it matters. n

                          Ambassador Barbara Stephenson is the president of the American Foreign Service Association.

THE FOREIGN SERVICE JOURNAL | NOVEMBER 2018                                                                                                     7
IN THEIR OWN WRITE Diplomatic Couriers: "Eyes On" Sensitive Cargo for 100 Years - FAMILY LIAISON AT 40 - American Foreign ...
FOREIGN

                                                              CONTACTS
             SERVICE

                                                                                          www.afsa.org
Editor in Chief, Director of Publications
Shawn Dorman: dorman@afsa.org
Managing Editor
Susan Brady Maitra: maitra@afsa.org
Associate Editor
Donna Gorman: gorman@afsa.org                                  AFSA Headquarters:                               ADVOCACY
Publications Coordinator                                         (202) 338-4045; Fax (202) 338-6820             Director of Advocacy
Dmitry Filipoff: filipoff@afsa.org                             State Department AFSA Office:                       Kim Greenplate: greenplate@afsa.org
                                                                 (202) 647-8160; Fax (202) 647-0265             Legislative Fellow
Advertising Manager
                                                               USAID AFSA Office:                                  Drew Donaher: donaher@afsa.org
Allan Saunders: ads@afsa.org
                                                                 (202) 712-1941; Fax (202) 216-3710
Art Director                                                   FCS AFSA Office:                                 BUSINESS DEPARTMENT
Caryn Suko Smith                                                 (202) 482-9088; Fax (202) 482-9087             Director of Finance and Facilities
                                                                                                                   Femi Oshobukola: oshobukola@afsa.org
Editorial Board                                                GOVERNING BOARD                                  Controller
Alexis Ludwig, Chair                                           President                                           Kalpna Srimal: srimal@afsa.org
James “Jim” Bever                                               Hon. Barbara Stephenson:                        Controller, Accounts Payable and
Fred Boll
                                                                stephenson@afsa.org                                Administration
Angela Bond
                                                               Secretary                                           Cory Nishi: cnishi@afsa.org
M. Allyn Brooks-LaSure
Karen Brown Cleveland                                           Hon. Tom Boyatt: tdboyatt@gmail.com             Administrative Assistant and Office Manager
Shawn Kobb                                                     Treasurer                                           Ana Lopez: lopez@afsa.org
Harry Kopp                                                      Hon. Earl Anthony “Tony” Wayne:                 Scholarships and Events Coordinator
John G. Rendeiro Jr.                                              WayneEA@gmail.com                                Theo Horn: horn@afsa.org
Priyadarshi “Pri” Sen                                          State Vice President
Dinah Zeltser-Winant                                            Ken Kero-Mentz: keromentzka@state.gov           COMMUNICATIONS AND MEMBERSHIP
                                                               USAID Vice President                             Director of Communications and Membership
                                                                Jeff Levine: jlevine@usaid.gov                     Ásgeir Sigfússon: sigfusson@afsa.org
THE MAGAZINE FOR FOREIGN AFFAIRS
                                                               FCS Vice President                               Communications and Marketing Manager
PROFESSIONALS
The Foreign Service Journal (ISSN 0146-3543),                   Daniel Crocker: Daniel.Crocker@trade.gov           Allan Saunders: saunders@afsa.org
2101 E Street NW, Washington, D.C. 20037-2990 is               FAS Vice President                               Manager, Retiree Outreach and Engagement
published monthly, with combined January-February               Kimberly Svec Sawatzki: kim.sawatzki@usda.gov      Christine Miele: miele@afsa.org
and July-August issues, by the American Foreign Service
                                                               Retiree Vice President                           Online Communications Manager
Association (AFSA), a private, nonprofit organization.
Material appearing herein represents the opinions of the        John K. Naland: nalandfamily@yahoo.com             Jeff Lau: lau@afsa.org
writers and does not necessarily represent the views of        State Representatives                            Member Accounts Specialist
the Journal, the Editorial Board or AFSA. Writer queries        Karen Brown Cleveland
and submissions are invited, preferably by email. The
                                                                                                                   Ashley Dunn: dunn@afsa.org
Journal is not responsible for unsolicited manuscripts,         Don Jacobson                                    Awards Coordinator
photos or illustrations. Advertising inquiries are invited.     Deborah Mennuti                                    Perri Green: green@afsa.org
All advertising is subject to the publisher’s approval.         Roy Perrin                                      Retirement Benefits Counselor
AFSA reserves the right to reject advertising that is not
                                                                Lilly Wahl-Tuco                                    Dolores Brown: brown@afsa.org
in keeping with its standards and objectives. The appear-
ance of advertisements herein does not imply endorse-          USAID Representative
ment of goods or services offered. Opinions expressed in        William C. Hansen                               LABOR MANAGEMENT
advertisements are the views of the advertisers and do         FCS Alternate Representative
not necessarily represent AFSA views or policy. Journal
                                                                                                                General Counsel
subscription: AFSA member–$20, included in annual               Lola Gulomova                                     Sharon Papp: PappS@state.gov
dues; student–$30; institution–$40; others–$50; Single         FAS Alternate Representative                     Deputy General Counsel
issue–$4.50. For foreign surface mail, add $18 per year;        Thom Wright                                       Raeka Safai: SafaiR@state.gov
foreign airmail, $36 per year. Periodical postage paid
                                                               BBG Representative                               Senior Staff Attorneys
at Washington, D.C., and at additional mailing offices.
Indexed by the Public Affairs Information Services (PAIS).       Steve Herman                                     Zlatana Badrich: BadrichZ@state.gov
                                                               APHIS Representative                               Neera Parikh: ParikhNA@state.gov
Email: journal@afsa.org                                         Jeffery Austin                                  Labor Management Counselor
Phone: (202) 338-4045                                          Retiree Representatives                            Colleen Fallon-Lenaghan:
Fax: (202) 338-8244                                             Hon. Alphonse ‘Al’ La Porta                       FallonLenaghanC@state.gov
Web: www.afsa.org/fsj                                           Philip A. Shull                                 Senior Labor Management Advisor
© American Foreign Service Association, 2018                                                                      James Yorke: YorkeJ@state.gov
                                                               STAFF                                            Labor Management Coordinator
PRINTED IN THE U.S.A.
                                                               Chief Operating Officer                            Patrick Bradley: BradleyPG@state.gov
Postmaster: Send address changes to                               Russ Capps: capps@afsa.org                    Grievance Counselors
AFSA, Attn: Address Change                                     Chief of Strategic Initiatives                     Ayumi Hasegawa: HasegawaA@state.gov
2101 E Street NW                                                  Linnea Gavrilis: gavrilis@afsa.org
Washington DC 20037-2990                                                                                          Heather Townsend: TownsendHA@state.gov
                                                               Executive Assistant to the President             Labor Management Advisor
                                                                  Jennie Orloff: orloff@afsa.org                  Michael R. Wallace: WallaceMR2@state.gov
                                                               Office Coordinator                               Law Clerk
                                                                  Therese Thomas: therese@afsa.org                Benjamin Phillips: PhillipsBE@state.gov
                                                               Staff Assistant
                                                                  Allysa Reimer: reimer@afsa.org                PROFESSIONAL POLICY ISSUES
                                                                                                                Director of Professional Policy Issues
                                                                                                                   Julie Nutter: nutter@afsa.org

8                                                                                                                    NOVEMBER 2018 | THE FOREIGN SERVICE JOURNAL
IN THEIR OWN WRITE Diplomatic Couriers: "Eyes On" Sensitive Cargo for 100 Years - FAMILY LIAISON AT 40 - American Foreign ...
LETTER FROM THE EDITOR

Tales from the Foreign Service
B Y S H AW N D O R M A N

O
           ne of our favorite tasks each          Today.” Special thanks to the Diplomatic      We hope this month’s celebration of FS
           year is to bring together and          Security Public Affairs team for the amaz-    writing will inspire you to consider how
           highlight as many new books            ing photos. If you are in Washington this     you might want to share your stories and
           by Foreign Service authors             month, please visit the courier centen-       perspective.
as we can, showcasing the writing and             nial exhibit in the U.S. Diplomacy Center         The FSJ is always seeking submissions
storytelling talents of the U.S. diplo-           pavilion.                                     on topics of interest or concern to mem-
matic community through “In Their                     In this month’s feature, best friend of   bers of the FS community. We are also
Own Write.” Along with that, we feature           the Foreign Service family Mette Beecroft     seeking authors for our upcoming focus
books that we think would be “of related          shares the inside story of the creation of    topics, listed here. Figure on at least 8 to
interest” to the Foreign Service reading          the Family Liaison Office 40 years ago and    12 weeks from submission to publication,
community.                                        its unique role helping FS families ever      so please keep that in mind when submit-
    This year’s collection features four          since.                                        ting for focus topics.
dozen books by FS authors. The range of               And in President’s Views, Ambassador          We want your transformational Speak-
topics is wide. A few standouts include           Barbara Stephenson offers her take on         ing Out submissions (1,500-1,800 words),
a memoir by Grace Kennan Warnecke,                the importance of “Telling Our Story to       opinion pieces that offer a critique and,
daughter of George Kennan (Daughter               the American People,” encouraging all         ideally, suggestions for a better way
of the Cold War) and a biography of               of us to help the American public better      forward. Or share a feature article (1,800-
Llewellyn Thompson (The Kremlinologist)           understand and appreciate what the            2,000 words) or a Reflection (700-1,200
by his two daughters Jenny and Sherry             Foreign Service does and why it matters.      words). Every article is better with photos
Thompson. In Cold Waters, Raymond                                                               (and we welcome your favorite recent
Malley takes us to the Arctic and Antarc-                                                       photo as a submission to Local Lens).
tica. And in a treat for the senses, Tania          2019 FSJ Focus Topics                       We also seek submissions for occasional
Teschke brings us The Bordeaux Kitchen,                                                         features: FS Know How, FS Heritage and
filled with gorgeous photos taken by the            January-February:                           Family Member Matters.
author in France.                                       Economic Diplomacy Works                    Articles go to the FSJ Editorial Board
    In “Coming into Their Own Write,”               March: Health and Wellness                  for final consideration. For information
frequent contributor Francesca Kelly                    in the Foreign Service                  on how to submit and details about
introduces us to a writer’s group from the          April: NATO at 70                           each type of submission, please visit
1960s that inspired women of the FS com-            May: The FS Career: What’s New              www.afsa.org/fsj-author-guidelines.
munity to write and publish their stories.          June: Migration                             Send all submissions to journal@afsa.org.
    Through this month’s cover story, we            July-August: Managing Competition               And we want to know what you think
are proud to highlight the centennial of                from China                              about what you read in the Journal, so
the Diplomatic Courier Service. Veteran             September: Preventive Diplomacy             please send comments over to us as
                      courier James Angell          October: In Their Own Write                 letters to the editor (up to 500 words).
                      brings the history to         November: 30th Anniversary,                 This year we added “Letters-Plus,” a
                      life in “None Swifter             Fall of the Berlin Wall                 space for extended responses (up to
                      Than These,” followed         December: AFSA Awards                       900 words) to important issues raised in
                      by Vince Crawley’s                + A Look at the New/Old Russia          Journal articles that warrant a continuing
                      “Diplomatic Couriers                                                      conversation.
                                                                                                    Thank you for reading, and for writing.
                      Shawn Dorman is the editor of The Foreign Service Journal.                We look forward to hearing from you. n

THE FOREIGN SERVICE JOURNAL | NOVEMBER 2018                                                                                               9
IN THEIR OWN WRITE Diplomatic Couriers: "Eyes On" Sensitive Cargo for 100 Years - FAMILY LIAISON AT 40 - American Foreign ...
LETTERS

Everyday Strategy                               petence in strategic planning. I have         expanded in the management and lead-
    Matt Boland’s article in the September      witnessed firsthand the costs                 ership courses offered at FSI. I hope we
FSJ, “You Have a Strategy: Now What?”           this failure has wrought on the                         can also focus on that sweet
is great. I am a strong proponent of the        institution, especially in the                              spot in strategic plan-
daily practice of strategic planning.           past 17 years since 9/11, as                                ning between long-term
In Lomé, I organize the agenda of our           we’ve served—in Washington                                 objectives and short-term
country team meetings by integrated             and overseas—alongside                                    realizable goals that can be
country strategy (ICS) goals; every week        agencies who have made                                    measured, acknowledged
we go through each of the four goals, and       this investment.                                         and built on by every team
members share what their sections did              Count on me to do                                    member.
that week to advance our objectives.            what I can to help                                        Stephanie Syptak
    I find that this generates very fruitful    advance this initiative.                                  Deputy Chief of Mission
talk “across the table” among country              Henry Wooster                                         U.S. Embassy Singapore
team members, who are prompted to                  Deputy Chief of Mission
think in new ways about the issues and             U.S. Embassy Paris                         Helpful and Timely
how different sections can make a contri-                                                        Thank you for drawing my atten-
bution to each goal. We’ve come up with         Worth Reading                                 tion to this helpful and timely report
some unique and innovative collabora-           and Teaching                                  on strategic planning. I have shared
tions through that process, and we have             “You Have a Strategy” in the Septem-      this with the Bureau of East Asian and
a country team that works exceptionally         ber issue is worth reading and teaching.      Pacific Affairs leadership, here in D.C.
well and has high morale as a result.           After four years as chief of mission, I       and in the field, and encouraged close
    I tell all the officers that I want them    strongly believe that a strategy-driven       consideration of the important recom-
to be able to explain to their mothers          approach—with a common strategy               mendations.
what we do here and why it’s important.         built and understood by all—is vital to          W. Patrick Murphy
That explanation begins with a thorough         success.                                         FSO, Deputy Assistant Secretary for
understanding and a clear explanation               After three tours on the National                   East Asian and Pacific Affairs
of our strategic goals. I mention our           Security Council staff, I’m convinced            Washington, D.C.
strategic goals in every town hall or large     that adopting this approach would
meeting with the staff, and emphasize           make State a stronger interagency             A Zero-Sum Game?
that every single employee in the mission       player. I sent the article to Marc Ostfield      Much if not most of the obstacle to
plays a role in achieving those objec-          at FSI suggesting they teach it there.        progress in reforming the State Depart-
tives. I tell the Locally Employed staff that       Greg Schulte                              ment to reflect the world in which it
they are key messengers (“my ambas-                 Ambassador, retired                       operates is summed up in the article
sadors”) on whom I depend to explain                U.S. Mission to the United Nations,       ”The Demise of MED’s Child and Family
the embassy’s objectives to their families,                Vienna                             Program” in the September FSJ.
friends and neighbors.                                                                           Everything that happens seems to be
    Dave Gilmour                                Don’t Forget                                  viewed as a zero-sum game. If you get
    Ambassador                                  the Sweet Spot                                something, I must give something up;
    U.S. Embassy Lomé                              My warmest congratulations to the          and that must diminish my importance
                                                FSJ for the excellent article on strategic    within the department.
Tradecraft                                      planning in your September edition.              It was that way before my retirement
    Matt Boland’s article is a valuable         These recommendations draw from a             in 2005, and it looks like nothing has
contribution to diplomatic tradecraft. I        wealth of experience and represent con-       changed in the ensuing years.
am disheartened that the State Depart-          crete methods for improving this effort          Harry Chamberlain
ment has never made a commitment                across the department.                           FSS, retired
to require that officers develop com-              It would be great to see this article         Spring Hill, Florida

10                                                                                                NOVEMBER 2018 | THE FOREIGN SERVICE JOURNAL
Saying No to Diversity                           Jay Porter, a European affairs desk
         A trio of articles in the September      officer, equates diversity with superior
     Foreign Service Journal typifies the         results: an embassy team containing a
     diversity mania sweeping the Foreign         diplomat who shares the ethnicity of the
     Service: “Who Is the Future of the           host country better understands that
     Foreign Service?” by Barbara Bodine,         host country.
     “A Foreign Service for America” by               Now, were that true, the department
     Representative Joaquin Castro                would promote better understanding
     (D-Texas) and “Diversity: Not Just a         by sending our Muslim diplomats to
     Cause for the Underrepresented”              Arab countries. It would be Catholics,
     by Jay Porter.                               say, to Ireland, Italy or Poland. Atheists
         Each largely ignores diversity’s         and democratic socialists? Off you go
     elephant-in-the-room question, the           to Cuba, China, Venezuela and, when it
     double-edged sword: What exactly does        opens, North Korea.
     diversity bring to the table in terms of         And although it’s not clear whether
     achieving optimal foreign policy formu-      the writer extends his judgments on
     lation and execution?                        ethnicity to include race, might not
         Although making token mention            African American and Asian American
     of patriotism, intelligence, knowl-          diplomats best serve in Africa and Asia?
     edge and character (let’s call them the          Heavens! What diversity here?
     “Foreign Service essentials”), Ambas-        Rather, it’s the double-edged sword:
     sador Bodine’s article really focuses on     diversity obtained by dividing Foreign
     the need to recruit “the right people,”      Service personnel into ethnic and racial
     those who are the colors of the rain-        groups, stereotyping and assigning
     bow, LGBTQ and, if I read correctly,         them accordingly.
     women—at least half.                             Recruiting on the basis of diversity
         Might, then, the Foreign Service admit   necessarily comes at the expense of the
     the less qualified by applying the “right    “Foreign Service essentials.” How can it
     people” criterion, while rejecting the       be otherwise when, for example, diver-
     most qualified if they are not, say, the     sity recruitment’s modus operandi—
     color of the day? Or, once the Foreign       based as it is on race, ethnicity, gender
     Service has enough LGBTQ officers,           and sexual preferences—excludes broad
     would it reject the next gay applicant       groups of applicants (half the males,
     though he or she has the diplomatic          possibly) from fair competition?
     qualities of a Talleyrand or Metternich?         Frankly, those who are patriotic,
         In effect, failure to maintain the       intelligent, knowledgeable and charac-
     “essentials” turns full-throttle diversity   ter-filled don’t give a damn what people
     recruiting into a double-edged sword.        look like; nor are they likely to recruit or
         Here’s another double-edger: Only        advance anyone on that basis. Rather,
     by diversifying the Foreign Service, Rep.    they hold the “essentials” close and are
     Castro writes, can we gather minorities’     the best champions and practitioners of
     support behind American diplomacy            both effective diplomacy and successful
     and global leadership. In other words,       diversity. n
     the congressman and his adherents                Richard W. Hoover
     want a Foreign Service that (as the old          FSO, retired
     saw goes) looks like them.                       Front Royal, Virginia

12                                                     NOVEMBER 2018 | THE FOREIGN SERVICE JOURNAL
TALKING POINTS

                                                                                             order to confer deriva-      white, non-Hispanic males. Not a single
                                                                                             tive diplomatic status to    African-American female has been nomi-
                                                                                             their spouses.               nated for an ambassadorship.
                                                                                                 A third official said        Foreign Policy echoed Zeya’s argu-
                                                                                             that if the marriage         ment on Sept. 17, writing that nearly a
                                                                                             requirement couldn’t         dozen current and former State Depart-
                                                                                             be met, the depart-          ment officials told FP that “Trump’s
                                                                                             ment would “work with        failure to address the problem would
                                                                                             individuals on a case-       likely exacerbate recruitment challenges
                             United States Denies                          by-case basis to help them try to legally      at Foggy Bottom and could undercut U.S.
                             Visas to Same-Sex                             adjust their status to remain in the United    foreign-policy priorities abroad.” Accord-
                             Partners of Foreign                           States after the deadline.”                    ing to FP, of the 52 political appointees
                             Diplomats                                         The New York Times reported on Oct.        Trump has nominated, 48 are white,

                             O     n Oct. 1, the Trump administra-
                                   tion announced that it would begin
                             denying visas to the unmarried, same-sex
                                                                           2 that former U.S. Ambassador to the
                                                                           United Nations Samantha Power called
                                                                           the new policy “needlessly cruel and
                                                                                                                          while 38 are men.
                                                                                                                              On Sept. 28, State Department official
                                                                                                                          Kiron Skinner responded. Skinner, who
                             partners of foreign diplomats and other       bigoted” in a tweet.                           became the department’s director of
                             employees of the United Nations. The                                                         policy planning in September, told the
                             same-sex partners of these diplomats          Diversity in Diplomacy?                        Washington Examiner that while “most
                             have until the end of the year to either
                             marry or leave the country.
                                The decision was made despite the
                                                                           O      n Sept. 17, Politico published an
                                                                                  article by former Foreign Service
                                                                           Officer Uzra Zeya lamenting the decline
                                                                                                                          institutions” in the United States aren’t
                                                                                                                          adequately diverse, “given some of the
                                                                                                                          trends in the U.S. against diversity—espe-
                             fact that many of these diplomats hail        in diversity since the start of the current    cially racial diversity—the State Depart-
                             from countries that do not recognize          administration. Wrote Zeya: “Our prog-         ment is doing much better.”
                             same-sex marriage and would face pros-        ress on diversity was far from adequate,           Skinner, who is African-American, told
                             ecution in their home countries if they       but for most of my career, across both         the Examiner that diversity is a priority for
                             were to marry in the United States.           Democratic and Republican administra-          Secretary Mike Pompeo, saying: “I think
                                The decision was widely covered by         tions, I could say with confidence that        me joining the State Department is one
                             the U.S. press, including The Washington      my government was striving to build a          example of it—in a leadership role, on the
                             Post, Politico, NPR, Time, CNN, Fox News,     diplomatic corps that looked more like         seventh floor, near Mahogany Row, run-
                             USA Today and other major outlets.            America as a whole. …That is, until the        ning the historic think tank shop for the
                                In a teleconference conducted “on          Trump administration.”                         State Department.”
                             background,” an unidentified senior               Zeya notes that in the first five months       Ambassador (ret.) Linda Thomas-
                             administration official said that the         of the current administration, the State       Greenfield, who up until her retirement
                             new policy, which they called “forward-       Department’s three most senior African-        in 2017 was the most senior African-
                             leaning,” will affect approximately 105       American officials “were removed or            American woman at the State Depart-
                             families currently in the United States.      resigned abruptly from their positions,”       ment, disagrees. “Diversity is not a
ISTOCKPHOTO.COM/WALDEMARUS

                                Another official on the call said that     along with the top-ranking Latino officer,     priority for this administration. It’s not
                             the policy change is merely intended to       all of whom were replaced by whites.           on their agenda,” she told Foreign Policy.
                             “mirror what U.S. policy is now,” refer-      She used public data from AFSA to point        “We can’t have a Foreign Service in which
                             ring to the fact that as of Sept. 30, 2018,   out that 64 percent of President Trump’s       the world sees and thinks our entire lead-
                             U.S. diplomats must be legally married in     ambassadorial nominees have been               ership is white and male.”

                             THE FOREIGN SERVICE JOURNAL | NOVEMBER 2018                                                                                            13
Cars are parked outside of the
                                                                                                                                           Saudi consulate in Istanbul on
                                                                                                                                           Oct. 13 as the waiting continued
                                                                                                                                           after the disappearance of
                                                                                                                                           prominent Saudi journalist
                                                                                                                                           Jamal Khashoggi (inset).
ARIF HUDAVERDI YAMAN/ANADOLU AGENCY/GETTY IMAGES

                                                                                                                                              BY ALFAGIH AT ARABIC WIKIPEDIA
                                               Saudi Journalist                              ability Act to punish any Saudi citizens      ‘Thank you very much. We’ll buy it from
                                               Disappears in Istanbul                        or political leaders found to have been       China.’ That doesn’t help us—not when it

                                        T            he disappearance and possible mur-
                                                     der of Saudi journalist and dissident
                                               Jamal Khashoggi, a Washington Post
                                                                                             involved in the alleged murder of Mr.
                                                                                             Khashoggi.
                                                                                                 A bipartisan group of senators asked
                                                                                                                                           comes to jobs and not when it comes to
                                                                                                                                           our companies losing out on that work.”
                                                                                                                                               Mr. Khashoggi’s disappearance also
                                               columnist, is bringing renewed attention      President Trump on Oct. 10 to trigger         raises questions about just how tough
                                               to U.S.-Saudi relations.                      the act, which would give the president       the administration is willing to be on
                                                   Mr. Khashoggi, a legal U.S. resident,     120 days to decide whether to impose          Saudi Arabia, a close ally. The president’s
                                               went to the Saudi consulate in Istanbul       sanctions on any specific individuals         first overseas trip was to the Kingdom
                                               on Oct. 2 to obtain paperwork he needed       involved with the journalist’s disappear-     and Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin
                                               for his upcoming nuptials to a Turk-          ance.                                         Salman is known to be close to the presi-
                                               ish citizen, Hatice Cengiz. But he never          However, in her Oct. 11 press briefing,   dent’s son-in-law Jared Kushner.
                                               came out.                                     State Department Spokesperson Heather             The incident has also shined a light
                                                   The Washington Post reported on Oct.      Nauert pushed back, saying: “I under-         on the fact that the United States still
                                               11 that the Turks claim to have audio         stand that Congress may be interested in      does not have ambassadors in place in
                                               recordings of Khashoggi being interro-        that, in a Global Magnitsky investigation,    either Saudi Arabia or Turkey. An Oct.
                                               gated, tortured and murdered inside the       but we don’t know the facts of this case      10 press briefing grew contentious when
                                               consulate while his fiancée waited for        just yet. So I think they’re getting ahead    State Department Deputy Spokesperson
                                               him outside.                                  of themselves at this point.”                 Robert Palladino was asked by a reporter
                                                   Turkey agreed on Oct. 11 to a request         The Magnitsky Act allows for targeted     to name the ambassadors to Turkey and
                                               by Saudi Arabia to form a joint com-          sanctions against specific individu-          Saudi Arabia.
                                               mittee to probe what happened to              als, rather than countrywide sanctions,           Foreign Policy quoted the evasive
                                               Khashoggi. It is unclear whether the          such as halting arms sales, which the         answers given by Palladino, who seemed
                                               United States will join that committee.       president has said he would not con-          unwilling to admit that not only do we
                                                   In an Oct. 11 op-ed in The Washington     sider. The Washington Post on Oct. 11         not have ambassadors in either of these
                                               Post, Senator Ben Cardin (D-Md.) called       quoted Trump as saying: “If we don’t sell     two important countries, but no names
                                               on the United States to use the Global        it to them, they’ll say, ‘Well, thank you     have even been put forward for confir-
                                               Magnitsky Human Rights and Account-           very much. We’ll buy it from Russia.’ Or      mation.

                                               14                                                                                                                              NOVEMBER 2018 | THE FOREIGN SERVICE JOURNAL
Nikki Haley Resigns

O     n Oct. 9 U.S. Ambassador to
      the United Nations Nikki Haley
announced her resignation, saying that
she would leave her post at the end of
the year. The announcement has led to
considerable speculation.
    Sources close to Amb. Haley said there
was nothing suspicious about the timing,
insisting Haley merely wanted to make
the announcement before the midterms
to give the president ample time to
choose her successor before year’s end.
                                                   DEPARTMENT OF STATE

    CNN commentators suggested three
other reasons Haley might have decided
to resign. In an Oct. 9 column, the news
outlet suggested she was upset at being                                  USUN Ambassador Nikki Haley, National Security Advisor John Bolton and Secretary
“edged out” by John Bolton and Secretary                                 of State Mike Pompeo at a press conference on the margins of the 73rd Session of the
                                                                         United Nations General Assembly in New York on Sept. 24.
of State Mike Pompeo. Or, they said, not-
ing she is more than $1 million in debt,
she might simply need to make some                                       considering a run for the presidency in       Oct. 8—the day before Haley submitted
money in the private sector.                                             2020 or 2024 and wanted to leave while        her resignation—a federal government
    Finally, CNN brought up the most                                     still relatively unscathed.                   watchdog, Citizens for Responsibility and
talked-about reason: Haley might be                                          Another possible reason is that on        Ethics in Washington, asked the State
                                                                                                                       Department to investigate whether the
                                                                                                                       U.N. ambassador broke any regulations
    For someone who cares about institutions and                                  Heard on the Hill                    by accepting multiple flights on private
    building institutions that will last, it’s heartening                                                              jets belonging to three South Carolina
    to me that someone from within is coming in this                                                                   executives. Haley was also reprimanded
    position. I’m sure cheering you on today.”                                                                         by the Office of Special Counsel in Sep-
                       —Chairman Bob Corker (R-Tenn.),                                                                 tember 2017 for using her official Twitter
       Senate Foreign Relations Committee, Nomination                                                                  account to advocate for a political candi-
       Hearing for David Hale for appointment as Under                                                                 date in direct violation of the Hatch Act.
            Secretary of State for Political Affairs, Aug. 16.                                                             And then there was “Curtaingate,”
                                                                                                                       launched by the Sept. 13 New York Times
     It is equally important that we adequately fund the                                                               article calling out the $52,701 the State
                                                                                                              JOSH

    State Department, USAID and others so that our                                                                     Department spent to equip her New York
    diplomats and our foreign assistance advisors can provide a better, more durable                                   residence with customized mechanized
    alternative to quick Chinese inducements. Only such a multi-faceted approach                                       curtains (initially ordered during the
    will truly help us meet the growing challenge that China poses. Understanding and                                  Obama administration).
    then solving these challenges are upfront investments that will pay unmeasurable                                       Otherwise, however, her tenure as U.N.
    dividends in the end.                                                                                              ambassador has been relatively blemish-
                         —Ranking Member Ed Markey (D-Mass.), Senate Foreign Relations                                 free and her favorability ratings are much
                        Committee Subcommittee on East Asia and the Pacific, in a hearing,                             higher than those of the president. An
              “The China Challenge, Part 2: Security and Military Developments,” on Sept. 5.                           April 2018 Quinnipiac University poll
                                                                                                                       showed 63 percent of American voters

THE FOREIGN SERVICE JOURNAL | NOVEMBER 2018                                                                                                                     15
approved of her job performance, while           Diplomat Killed
                                           75 percent of Republicans viewed her             in Madagascar
                                           performance favorably. The same poll
                                           showed the president’s own approval
                                           rating at just 39 percent.
                                                                                           I   n a press statement released on Sept. 24,
                                                                                               the State Department confirmed that a
                                                                                            U.S. Foreign Service officer was found
SITE OF THE MONTH: RADIO.GARDEN                The race to replace Haley has only           dead in his residence in Antananarivo
                                           begun. Dina Powell, an early frontrun-           on Sept. 21. Multiple news outlets, includ-

 L    isteners can tune into thousands
      of radio stations across the world
 using a free radio service called
                                           ner who was formerly a Trump official
                                           and now works at Goldman Sachs in
                                           New York City, took herself out of the
                                                                                            ing Reuters, Time, CNN and ABC, reported
                                                                                            on the death.
                                                                                                According to the Daily Beast and others,
 Radio Garden. Using an interactive        running without explanation. President           a suspect was apprehended while trying to
 3D globe, listeners can hover over        Trump told reporters that there are five         scale the perimeter fence outside the resi-
 icons that tune into radio stations,      names on his short list to replace Haley,        dence. The suspect is currently in custody.
 whether Hitradio Dragon in the Czech      but he declined on Oct. 11 to name any               As we go to press, the name of the victim
 Republic, Radio Xamsadine in Sen-         of those people other than Powell.               has been officially released: Kevin Webb.
 egal or Mandalika FM Radio Lombok
 in Indonesia.
     According to one of the founders      Contemporary Quote
 of the project, Jonathan Puckey, “The
                                                    Dissent, and the energetic debate that underlies it, is an essential
 main idea is to help radio makers and              component of our duty. It is as important a part of our duty as discipline
 listeners connect with distant cul-       and obedience. Dissent, as understood and practiced in the Foreign Service,
 tures and reconnect with people from      is not just about personal integrity. It is also about professional integrity,
 home and thousands of miles away.”        and the integrity of our policymaking process.
     In Radio Garden’s History section
                                           When we took our oath, we swore to uphold and defend our Constitution.
 listeners can tune into clips through-    We committed ourselves to the values, rights and institutions that define
 out radio history. Listeners can hear     our democracy, and to respect the will of our sovereign: the American people.
 Radio Moscow announce history as          We cannot meet this commitment if we are unable to speak our mind.
 Valentina Tereshkova becomes the
                                           We must be able to provide our elected leaders our best understanding and
 first woman to visit space in 1963. Or    assessment of a situation, and we must be clear about the consequences of
 listeners can hear a 1942 broadcast       decisions and actions. Sometimes those consequences are moral and ethical;
 from Warsaw where German propa-           sometimes they are practical; sometimes they are strategic; and sometimes
 ganda disseminates news of wartime        they combine all three.
 victory—and a jamming station joins
                                           Dissent, no matter how purposeful, has a bitter aftertaste. By its nature it
 in on the same frequency to counter       reflects a failure to affect a change in thought, decision or action. Within
 those claims and provide a different      the world of foreign policy and diplomacy, we must become comfortable
 perspective.                              with the understanding that we will not always prevail.
     The Jingles section helps listeners
                                           But we must also understand that the institutions we are a part of, and the
 identify various stations and learn       great Republic that we represent, have remarkable characteristics of intro-
 types of radio programming.               spection, reflection and rectification. In this sense, dissent, as we understand
     Radio Garden was launched in          and practice it, is not a single event that passes without effect. Instead, it is part
 2016 using public funds from the          of a larger conversation that we have with ourselves. It is designed to give
 Netherlands Institute of Sound            us pause, to think anew, and to have a touchpoint to return to when
 and Vision. It was developed by the       we have recognized that we have made a mistake.
 Amsterdam-based Studio Moniker,                                      —Former Under Secretary of State for Political Affairs Tom Shannon,
 and is now run by Studio Puckey.               speaking at the Oct. 10 AFSA award ceremony on accepting the Christian A. Herter Award
                                                                                               for constructive dissent by a senior officer.

16                                                                                                 NOVEMBER 2018 | THE FOREIGN SERVICE JOURNAL
50 Years Ago

    My Day with JFK

   I   have scanned in vain a
       few thousand pages of
    intimate memoirs of the
                                                                  Secretary [of State
                                                                 George] Ball, arriving
                                                                 perhaps five minutes
    life and work in the White                                   before the appointed
    House under John F.                                         hour of 12:30 to
    Kennedy for any mention                                     deliver the requested
    of my day. The most memorable               oral briefing. We stood outside the
    experience of my career to date was         president’s office in a nervously
    apparently just another workday in          bustling corridor until Atomic Energy
    the lives of Sorensen, Schlesinger, et      Commission Chairman [Glenn T.]
    al. I refer to the visit to Washington      Seaborg, General Maxwell Taylor, Mr.
    of the then Austrian Federal Chan-          Bundy and one or two others whom I
    cellor, Dr. Alfons Gorbach, in May          could not identify emerged. At about
    1962.                                       12:35 we were ushered into the oval
        The planning and preparations           office, which was so familiar from
    for the visit, of course, began several     countless photographs.
    months before. During the final few             The president came from behind
    weeks I was engaged, as Austrian            his desk, shook hands and invited
    desk officer, almost full time in the       us to sit on the two couches which
    drafting and clearing of briefing           extended from either arm of his
    papers, advising the Office of Proto-       rocking chair, flanking the fireplace.
    col and the White House social staff        Mr. Ball and Mr. Tyler took seats on
    on preparation of the guest list for        the president’s left, and I sat alone
    the president’s luncheon, selection         on his right. The president braced
    of gifts to give the Chancellor, etc.       his feet on the end of the coffee
        A representative of McGeorge            table between the couches in order
    Bundy’s White House staff stopped           to propel his rocker while he spoke.
    at my office every few days to pick         This put his feet almost in my direct
    up copies of all available papers.          line of sight, and I found myself star-
    As a conscientious bureaucrat, I            ing at them.
    pointed out that in many cases these            I had read that the president was
    documents were only uncleared               not known as a fashion leader, but I
    drafts which did not yet have the           was still surprised to see faded blue
    concurrence of my departmental              nylon socks with numerous pillings,
    colleagues or superiors, but this did       which are the customary drawback
    not in the least deter him. He said he      of such hose. This touch of mundane
    wanted to have the original thinking        reality brought home to me that this
    of the desk officer, as well as the final   was just another routine day for the
    distillation of the entire bureaucracy.     president.
        When the day finally came, Acting           —Jack Sulser, from his article by
    Assistant Secretary Tyler and I rode        the same title in the November 1968
    over to the White House with Acting         edition of the FSJ.

THE FOREIGN SERVICE JOURNAL | NOVEMBER 2018                                               17
USAID Tests
     Cash Transfers
     A     recent experiment conducted by
           USAID made the news on Sept.
     14 when The Atlantic published a story
     about the “A/B Test” in Rwanda to deter-
     mine which would be a more effective
     way to disperse aid and prevent malnu-
     trition: a “holistic” intervention involving
     education, donations and sanitation, or
     a simple cash transfer to each concerned
     household.
         In the $140 billion foreign aid sec-
     tor, the authors wrote, “donors rarely
     measure the effectiveness of individual
     programs, let alone weigh one interven-
     tion against another.” The authors lauded
     USAID’s willingness to look hard at its
     own effectiveness with traditional pro-
     grams as “unusual, and quite brave.”
         USAID released the results publicly
     in September. They showed that “neither
     the holistic intervention nor the smaller
     cash transfers moved the needle much
     on nutrition.”
         However, large cash transfers of
     approximately $530 per household made
     a significant difference, as those families
     were able to save 60 percent more while
     at the same time purchasing healthier,
     more varied foods for their families.
     Children in those households were taller
     and weighed more than children in other
     households.
         The results of the experiment show
     that cash transfers should be considered
     by donors when applicable, the authors
     argue. They also remind us of the need
     to consider the needs and desires of the
     recipients themselves when designing
     effective aid programs. n

         This edition of Talking Points was com-
     piled by Donna Gorman, Dmitry Filipoff
     and Shawn Dorman.

18        NOVEMBER 2018 | THE FOREIGN SERVICE JOURNAL
SPEAKING OUT

Radically Simple Ideas for a Better State:
Foreign Service 2.0
BY JC WINDHAM

O
             ur jobs are complex; the           We need to revamp both our hiring process
             environment we work in is
             constantly changing, both at
                                                and our current personnel system to better
             home and abroad. We struggle       execute today’s and tomorrow’s mission sets.
to learn languages, new cultures and
jobs; build relationships; effect positive
change; and then do it all again after a           But the result will be worth it, and the     skill sets and experience levels for each
couple of years.                                future Foreign Service will be better for it.   specialty.
    Unfortunately, the bureaucracy that                                                             c) Individuals with more experience
supports that Foreign Service has become        Generalists Need to Go:                         and relevant skill sets can be hired at
equally complex, for both good and bad,         Cones Become Specialties                        higher grades, based on the cost of labor.
potentially hampering the Department               The idea of a “jack-of-all-trades,               d) The number of new hires can equal
of State’s ability to effectively accomplish    master of none” or an individual being          the number of positions.
our mission and affecting morale.               “a mile wide and an inch deep” is simply            e) Tenure requirements can be
    In the following I propose several          not effective in today’s world. Businesses      removed and replaced with a standard
changes to our bureaucracy that I con-          and government agencies have been               three-year probationary period.
sider radical because they are substantial      shifting to specialization for decades,             f) The consular tour requirement can
deviations from our current processes           while our generalists are still expected        be eliminated for non-consular special-
but are also simple. To be clear, “simple”      to perform duties outside their field to        ties.
does not necessarily mean easy: if our          prove their initial worth (e.g., consular           g) The foreign language requirement
leadership chooses to implement the             tours).                                         can be removed for tenure and probation.
ideas below, it will require substantial           We need to revamp both our hir-                  h) A standardized orientation for all
work and, potentially, even legislative         ing process and our current personnel           Foreign Service officers can be followed
action.                                         system to better execute today’s and            by specialty-specific tradecraft training.
                                                tomorrow’s mission sets. First, exist-
              JC Windham is a financial         ing generalists should be converted to          Forget the Foreign
              management officer, currently     specialists, and their respective cones to      Service Exam
              serving in Washington, D.C.       specialties.                                        With the conversion of generalist
              His previous assignments were        This conversion would have the fol-          fields to specialists, the Bureau of Human
              to Khartoum and Asuncion. As      lowing benefits:                                Resources can develop and tailor specific
an FS family member before that, he served         a) Accurate data on the actual cost of       hiring practices that will attract the most
in Brazzaville. Prior to joining the Foreign    conducting diplomacy, “doing busi-              talented, experienced and diverse indi-
Service, he worked as a civilian financial      ness” and generating congressionally            viduals to excel in each specialty (similar
manager with the Department of the Navy         mandated reports can be derived from            to the way specialists are hired now).
in the Washington, D.C., area for nine years.   overtime compensation.                          Further, each specialty can adjust the
He lives with his wife and two four-legged         b) Hiring practices and processes            hiring grade (salary) based on the market
children in Arlington, Virginia.                can be tailored to necessary and specific       rate and cost of labor.

THE FOREIGN SERVICE JOURNAL | NOVEMBER 2018                                                                                             19
The deputy chief of mission should also be                                                      some embassies would fall under, but
the chief operating officer of the embassy.                                                     would not require the closure of any over-
                                                                                                seas facilities.

                                                                                                Home or Abroad?
Welcome, Consular                                ture of the employee’s accomplishments             Move as many regional bureau Civil
Adjudicators                                     than the current practice of providing         Service positions as appropriate overseas
   Create a new consular adjudicator/            bullet points to a reviewer with whom the      to centralized regional support hubs
interviewer specialty to enable removal of       employee may only rarely interact.             to better provide real-time support to
the consular tour requirement for officers                                                      embassy operations. This may be Nairobi
and to improve consular services, perfor-        A Better MED                                   for AF, for example, or Bangkok for EAP.
mance and consistency. These positions               It has become increasingly difficult to    These positions could be staffed at five-
would have five-year assignments and             hire competent medical professionals into      year intervals, similar to how other agen-
would alternate between overseas and             the Foreign Service because of the differ-     cies announce and advertise for overseas
domestic to support domestic consular            ence between private-sector compensa-          positions (e.g., the Drug Enforcement
operations.                                      tion and what the department offers.           Administration).
   The assignments for these positions           Other government agencies, such as the             A good litmus test for whether a posi-
would be based on foreign language skills.       Veterans Administration, have overcome         tion should be offshored would be to
For example, someone with Spanish-lan-           this by developing specialized pay scales      evaluate how much required HST/D.C.
guage fluency might serve in Mexico City,        specific to the respective profession/posi-    interaction that position involves by
then back in the United States, and then         tion.                                          comparison with the provision of services
in Bogotá to maximize the department’s               The Bureau of Medical Services and         directly to posts; if the scale tips more
investment in foreign language education         department management should develop           to the latter, then the position should go
and also the individual officer’s skill set in   a separate pay scale for regional medical      overseas. This would also free up head-
language nuances and local cultures.             officer, regional medical officer/psychia-     quarters space to allow for consolidation
                                                 trist and other MED professions to better      of some offices back into Main State and
What Do You Really                               recruit and retain talented practitioners in   reduce our Washington, D.C., footprint.
Think Of Me?                                     those fields.
    Modify the annual Employee Evalua-                                                          No More Bait and Switch
tion Report in two ways:                         One World                                          An assignment to an overseas mis-
    First, add three boxes that each man-           The State geographic bureaus should         sion should be a contract between the
ager checks:                                     be aligned with the Department of              employee and the department, yet the
    a. Ready to Promote                          Defense’s Regional Combatant Com-              State Department retains unilateral
    b. Ready to Promote with Conditions          mands to better coordinate support and         authority to reduce the compensation
(spelled out in Manager Statement)               missions.                                      accorded to that employee.
    c. Not Ready to Promote                         This would split the Bureau of Western          The Hardship Allowance, Cost of Liv-
    Second, in place of a rater and reviewer     Hemisphere Affairs into South Ameri-           ing Adjustment, Danger Pay Allowance
statement, have a rater/manager state-           can Affairs and North American Affairs         and number of R&Rs should be locked
ment, a peer statement and an employee           (which would also oversee domestic             in as a floor based on the panel date
statement. The selection of the peer/            operations), transfer most of North Africa     of the employee. These benefits can
employee should be unique per year and           into the Bureau of African Affairs and         increase during the officer’s tour, but
per tour; in other words, the officer has to     combine parts of the bureaus of Near           they should not be reduced below the
use a different peer and different employee      Eastern Affairs and South and Central          amount at the time of paneling.
for each EER.                                    Asian Affairs to form a new Bureau of Asia         This will create more financial stability
    While not a full 360-degree evaluation,      Pacific Affairs.                               for the officer, as well as stability for per-
this system captures a more accurate pic-           This would change which bureaus             sonnel budgeting.

20                                                                                                   NOVEMBER 2018 | THE FOREIGN SERVICE JOURNAL
Keep Us Safe
    Diplomatic Security should have two
different law enforcement professions—
DS investigation agents, who would be
domestically based and follow a career
progression similar to other domestic
federal law enforcement agencies; and
DS Foreign Service agents, who would
spend the majority of their careers over-
seas.
    This would allow both sets of agents to
develop specialized skills specific to their
respective career fields.

The World Isn’t Flat,
But We Should Be
    The deputy chief of mission should
also be the chief operating officer of the
embassy.
    Having an additional layer of bureau-
cracy between the DCM and the current
management sections leads to a constant
game of “telephone,” where information
is selectively filtered both up and down
the chain of command. In most instances,
this is a severe detriment to embassy
operations and the morale of the largest
section in the embassy.
    The management officer cone/spe-
cialty should be eliminated, with the
management sections reporting directly
to the DCM. Current management
officers can be offered early retirement
buyouts or select a specialty and transfer
based on availability.

Tomorrow
    None of the above changes are easy,
and many will rail against them as at best
naïve or, at worst, malicious. My intent
is to generate conversations and effect
changes with these ideas that will both
make our organization more effective
and improve the lives of Foreign Service
officers tomorrow and in the future. n

THE FOREIGN SERVICE JOURNAL | NOVEMBER 2018    21
COVER STORY             DIPLOMATIC COURIER SERVICE CENTENNIAL

          None Swifter
          Than These

                                                                      U.S. DEPARTMENT OF STATE/DIPLOMATIC SECURITY SERVICE
Couriers with U.S. ships in Danzig, March 31, 1919.

22                                                               NOVEMBER 2018 | THE FOREIGN SERVICE JOURNAL
T
                         his year marks the centennial of the U.S.    The first diplomatic couriers, informally known as the “Silver
                         Diplomatic Courier Service. Established   Greyhounds” (named after King Charles II’s messengers), set
                         in Paris at the end of World War I to     up shop at 4 Place de la Concorde on Dec. 2, 1918. Their motto,
                         ensure the inviolability of classified    “None Swifter Than These,” was taken from Herodotus’ descrip-
                         communication between U.S. diplo-         tion of the Persian couriers of 440 B.C. and remains the Diplo-
                         matic missions across Europe, the Dip-    matic Courier Service’s motto today. Following World War II the
                         lomatic Courier Service has grown from    Diplomatic Courier Service became part of the State Depart-
                         15 military personnel in a single city to ment’s Division of Communication (Information Management),
                         approximately 100 civilian profession-    and in 1985 it was folded into the Bureau of Diplomatic Security
als serving in 11 divisions and hubs across the globe: Frankfurt,  pursuant to recommendations the Inman Commission made to
Dakar, Abidjan, Pretoria, Nairobi, Manama, Bangkok, Seoul, São     consolidate the department’s security efforts.
Paulo, Miami and Washington, D.C. These dynamic individuals           Constant travel is inherently dangerous, and the six diplo-
are entrusted with the secure delivery of classified material to   matic couriers who perished in the line of duty during the past
more than 270 U.S. missions worldwide.                             century have all died in plane crashes: Seth J. Foti in 2000 in
    Yet even as the Diplomatic Courier Service approaches a full   Bahrain; Joseph P. Capozzi in 1963 in Cameroon; Willard M.
century of dramatic history, and is at work all around the world,  Fisher in 1953 in Tanzania; Richard T. Dunning in 1951 in Libe-
the vast majority of State Department                                                      ria; Homer C. White in 1945 on a flight
personnel (let alone the American               A veteran courier salutes the that departed from Liberia and never
people) do not know it exists.
                                                Diplomatic Courier Service’s reached its destination in Ghana; and
                                                                                           James N. Wright in 1943 in Portugal.
                                               first 100 years and a career
The Silver Greyhounds
    Major Amos J. Peaslee (who later          that offers both satisfaction                      A Perilous Profession
served as U.S. ambassador to Australia)       and the opportunity to serve.                          Others were more fortunate. For
conceived the idea of a trans-Atlantic                                                           instance, Henry E. Coleman survived
courier service during World War I to                      BY JAMES B. ANGELL                    with his diplomatic pouch after a Ger-
improve delivery of mail and official                                                            man U-boat torpedoed the British liner
messages to American troops fighting in France. General John J.        Western Prince on Dec. 14, 1940, in the mid-Atlantic. And on
Pershing signed off on the initiative in March 1918, and a group       April 20, 1968, Thomas Taylor was one of only six survivors
of seven Army officers led by Peaslee quickly cut delivery times       aboard a South African Air 707 that crashed in mountainous ter-
between Washington and Paris from five weeks to less than              rain outside Windhoek, Namibia. Miraculously, his diplomatic
two. The improvement was so dramatic that after the armistice,         pouch remained intact after the crash.
the American Commission to Negotiate Peace asked Peaslee to               More recently, on May 25, 2008, Andy Perez was on a Kalitta
report to Paris and set up a courier service to help U.S. diplo-       Air plane that crashed at the end of a runway on takeoff from
matic missions across Europe support Herbert Hoover’s Ameri-           Brussels with 4,000 kilograms of regional classified material
can Relief Administration.                                             bound for Manama on board. He assisted the crew and secured
                                                                       his classified pouches until cleared reinforcements arrived from
James B. Angell joined the Department of State in 1993 and was         Embassy Brussels and Consulate General Frankfurt to set up a
promoted into the Senior Foreign Service in 2011. He has been          command post for the huge salvage operation. In recognition
posted twice in Washington, D.C., most recently as the director of the of his bravery and dedication to duty, Perez received the State
Diplomatic Courier Service, and is currently director of the Frank-    Department’s Heroism Award.
furt Regional Diplomatic Courier Division. Before joining the State       Despite its small size, the Diplomatic Courier Service has a
Department, Mr. Angell was an archaeologist and interpretive ranger    global reach. Last year, it securely transported 103,167 pouches
for the U.S. National Park Service.                                    weighing 5,548,257 pounds, via 3,309 separate diplomatic cou-

THE FOREIGN SERVICE JOURNAL | NOVEMBER 2018                                                                                         23
You can also read