Facing Eviction Part II - Mass Legal Services

Page created by Jimmie Hines
 
CONTINUE READING
Facing Eviction Part II - Mass Legal Services
Tenants’ Rights in Massachusetts During COVID
            MCLE Basic Benefits Training Series
                      April 14, 2021

     Facing Eviction Part II

                  Pattie Whiting
             Harvard Legal Aid Bureau

                    Hed Ehrlich
    Justice Center of Southeast Massachusetts

            Key Takeaways
• How eviction cases are being heard in the
  Housing Court during COVID
• The two ways an eviction case can be
  resolved
• How to identify where a tenant is in the
  eviction process
• How you can help a tenant facing eviction

                                                       2
Facing Eviction Part II - Mass Legal Services
How Housing Court
       Is Operating During COVID
• Most housing courts are now open but access
  to the courthouse is still limited.
• Most court events are still happening
  remotely rather than in person.
  www.mass.gov/info-details/remotevirtual-
  court-services
  www.mass.gov/orgs/housing-court
                                                              3

     Housing Court During COVID
 Zoom is being used for remote court events
 • Video is the default, but litigants can call in by phone
   if they don’t have access to the internet.
 • If tenants don’t have internet access or can’t figure
   out Zoom, some courts have rooms set up in the
   clerk’s office for litigants to use for Zoom hearings.
 • If a tenant has disability or technology challenges,
   you can request an in person hearing. Contact the
   clerk’s office.

                                                              4
Virtual Clerk’s Counter
When to use the Virtual Clerk’s Office:
  Ask questions about case status
  Request copies of documents not available through
     masscourts.org
  Discuss/address scheduling issues
  Discuss the need for an interpreter or a reasonable
     accommodation
 Different divisions may be doing things differently, so
 contact the Clerk’s office with questions
 https://www.mass.gov/info-details/remotevirtual-court-
 services

   Virtual Housing Specialist Counter

 Using Zoom, you can speak to a Housing
  Specialist as if you were at the courthouse
 When to use the Virtual Housing Specialists
  Counter:
   To discuss cases appropriate for a
    Temporary Restraining Order
   To discuss any special concerns
    in advance of a scheduled mediation session
Virtual Court Service Center
 Available statewide via phone at
  (646) 828-7666 and Zoom. Meeting ID
  1615261140
 When to use the Virtual Court Service Center:
     Refer tenants who need assistance filling out
      Answer and Discovery, CDC Declaration,
      motions, and other important forms
 Court Zoom Stations available in Brockton,
  Chelsea, Springfield, and Worcester

        Attorney General Zoom Spaces
Attorney General’s Office has set up public computer
stations at the following places:
    Brockton: The Family Center at Community Connections,
     1367 Main Street, Brockton; contact (508) 857-0272
    Lawrence: Center de Apoyo Familiar, 375 Common
     Street, Suite 204, Lawrence; contact (978) 332-7108
    Lynn: Lynn YMCA – 20 Neptune Blvd, Lynn; contact (781)
     581-3105
    Everett: Eliot Family Resource Center (Everett) – 548
     Broadway, Everett; contact (781) 581-4750
Hot Spot Information
List and map of outdoor hotspots at libraries:
https://libraries.state.ma.us/wifi

List of hotspots offered through MassTech program:
https://broadband.masstech.org/wifi

Map of Xfinity hotspots: https://www.xfinity.com/learn/internet-
service/wifi

Map of Spectrum hotspots: https://www.spectrum.com/internet/wifi-
access-points?opredirect=wifi-hotspots?opredirect=wifi-access-
points?opredirect=wifi-hotspots&opredirect=wifi-hotspots

             Virtual Lawyer for the Day
• Many of the Housing Courts have a Virtual Lawyer for
  the Day program where unrepresented tenants can
  get information, advice, and limited assistance.
• You should strongly recommend to your clients that
  they ask to speak to someone from the Lawyer for the
  Day program as soon as they get on to a virtual court
  event.
• To find out whether Lawyer for the Day is available in
  your court, call your local legal services office or
  contact the court.
Court Resources
    Tenancy Preservation Program
• The Tenancy Preservation Program (TPP) is a homelessness
  prevention program based in the Housing Court.
• TPP works with tenants facing eviction as a result of behavior
  related to a disability.
• TPP works with tenants to set up services to address the
  underlying causes for the eviction.
• TPP may be available to assist “upstream” before a court
  complaint is filed.
• Let your client know of TPP availability at all Housing Courts,
  and encourage your clients to reach out to them.
                                                                    11

                   First Tier Event
• During COVID, the first court event after a
  landlord files an eviction case is called a First
  Tier event.
• The First Tier event is typically scheduled with
  a housing specialist and intended as a check in
  with the parties and as an opportunity to
  mediate an agreement to resolve the case.

                                                                    12
First Tier Event
• The Landlord and/or the mediator may pressure the
  tenant to sign either a temporary agreement (ex. to
  pay rent while the case is pending) or an agreement
  resolving the whole eviction case.
• Some cases cannot/should not settle at the time of the
  First Tier event (because Discovery is not compete,
  because landlord insists on possession and tenant
  cannot yet commit to move, and other reasons)
• It is okay not to settle at the first court event!!

                                                        13

 First Tier Event in Nonpayment Cases
• If a case is brought for nonpayment of rent and the
  tenant has a pending application for rental assistance
  (RAFT, ERAP or other program), the case should be
  continued for another First Tier Event to allow the
  application to be processed.
• If the landlord does not agree to continue, the tenant
  may need to file a motion to continue.

                                                        14
What happens after the
             First Tier Event?
• If the case is not continued for another First Tier
  event or settled, the case will be scheduled for a
  Second Tier event with a judge.
• The Second Tier event could be scheduled as soon as
  two weeks after the First Tier event.
• If the tenant has not filed an Answer with a jury
  demand, the Second Tier event will likely be the trial.

                                                        15

       Resolving an Eviction Case
   • Eviction cases can be resolved in two ways:
     either by an agreement between the parties
     or by the judge after a trial.

   • More than 90% of eviction cases are
     resolved by an agreement reached between
     the parties.

                                                        16
Agreements
• The agreement is usually an Agreement for Judgment (AFJ),
  where judgment for “possession” and any rent owed enters
  for the landlord.
• A “judgment for possession” means that the landlord won
  the right to the apartment. Often, however, the AFJ will
  allow a tenant to stay in their home if they comply with
  certain terms (usually involving payments and/or behavior).
• A tenant should not agree to terms that she will not be able
  to follow. The consequences for violating an AFJ is almost
  always immediate eviction.
• Agreements cannot be changed unless both sides agree, so
  don’t agree to something thinking you can ask for a change
  to the terms later.
                                                                17

       Mediation or Negotiation
    • Most summary process cases are resolved by an
      agreement between the parties rather than going
      to trial.
    • Parties at Housing Court are invited to mediate
      using a Housing Specialist, or they may negotiate
      directly with the opposing party in an effort to
      reach a settlement.

                                                                18
Mediation or Negotiation (continued)
  • Mediation is an opportunity to problem-solve about
    the case and craft a compromise between the parties.
  • While agreements arising from mediation or
    negotiation can be good for the tenant, sometimes
    unrepresented tenants are taken advantage of since
    most landlords have experienced attorneys
    representing them.
  • Advocates have to be vigilant to make sure that
    tenants are not being pressured into settling their
    case or agreeing to bad settlements or terms that
    they cannot comply with.

                                                               19

            Tips for Agreements
• Make sure that everything that’s important is in the
  agreement (for example, that certain repairs are getting
  done, or that the tenant is given an extension on when the
  monthly rent is due). Make sure the tenant gets something
  out of the agreement too!
• Ask to talk to the Lawyer for the Day for assistance
  negotiating an agreement or to review the terms of the
  agreement before the tenant signs it, if one is available.
• Above all: do NOT sign anything that is unrealistic for the
  tenant to fulfill. If they cannot comply with the agreement,
  the landlord can come back to court and ask that they be
  allowed to move the tenant out.

                                                               20
Advocacy Tips:
    Booklet 10 Negotiating a Settlement

• Use Worksheet: What Terms Do I Want
  See Booklet 10, Legal Tactics page 585.
• Organize the tenant’s goals and demands as well as
  their vulnerabilities.
• Read about negotiation strategies and get answers to
  common questions.
• Review alternative forms of settlement or resolution
  to the case besides an Agreement For Judgment
  (stipulations v. judgments).

                                                            21

         After an Agreement:
       Motion to Issue Execution
   • If the eviction case was settled by an Agreement for
     Judgment and the landlord claims that the tenant
     did not comply with the terms, the landlord can file
     a Motion to Issue Execution, which asks the court to
     give the landlord permission to move the tenant out
     of their home.

   • If the motion is based on nonpayment of rent, the
     tenant should ask for a stay under the CDC
     moratorium (through June 30th) or if they have a
     pending application for rental assistance.

                                                            22
Execution
                                                See Legal Tactics
                                                Form 21
                                                page 671

                                                              23

      Motion to Issue Execution
• The main issue the court will consider in deciding the
  motion is whether the tenant complied with the
  agreement (“whether there was a substantial breach of
  a material term of the agreement”).
• Other issues like conditions of disrepair are usually not
  considered by the judge, even if the tenant did not pay
  rent because of problems in their home.
• A tenant should NEVER withhold rent if they’ve signed
  a court agreement that requires them to pay rent.

                                                              24
Motion to Issue Execution (cont.)
• If the court allows the landlord’s motion to issue execution,
  it issues the next day and the landlord may take the
  execution to a constable to serve a notice that if they do
  not vacate the premises, the tenant and all property will be
  removed on a specific date and time which is at least 48
  hours after the notice is served (“a 48 hour notice”).
• A tenant that has signed an agreement and then violates it
  can be moved out very quickly. That is why it is very
  important to make sure that the tenant can comply with
  the terms of the agreement before they sign.

                                                                  25

          Summary Process Trial
     • If the parties can’t reach an agreement
       resolving the case, it will go before a judge
       for a trial.
     • Most tenants go to trial without a lawyer.
     • Tenants don’t need to use special legal
       language, they just have to make sure the
       judge understands the issues, facts and
       arguments that are important to the
       tenant’s case.

                                                                  26
Summary Process Trial (cont.)
• Landlord goes first and presents her evidence (for
  example: witness testimony, documents, photos, notices,
  etc.).
    Tenant has a chance to cross-examine witnesses and
     object to evidence.
• Then tenant gets to present her case and evidence
  (including testimony, documents, photos etc.).
    Landlord has a chance to cross-examine witnesses
     and object to evidence.

                                                                        27

               Tips for Virtual Trials
• If the tenant wants to offer documents or photos into
  evidence, they must have them scanned and be able to
  send it electronically to the court and the landlord so
  everyone can see it during the hearing. If a tenant doesn’t
  know how to do this, have them contact the court ASAP
  for assistance.

• If the tenant or the landlord is going to use documents or
  exhibits during trial, ensure that the tenant and any of
  her witnesses have a way to view those documents in real
  time.
   • If the tenant or their witness is on the phone, they will not be
     able to see the documents.
What Happens After the Trial
• The court will mail the decision to the parties.
   – Tenant may win “possession” i.e. the right to the apartment
     and/or damages or may need to make a payment in order to
     keep possession
   – Landlord might win possession and/or money damages
     against the tenant
• The parties have 10 days from the date of the court’s
  decision to appeal. (Tenant can also seek stay of
  execution in appropriate cases.)
• If the landlord wins at trial, she may be entitled to a
  judgment for possession of the apartment and/or a
  judgment for unpaid rent.

                                                                   29

What Happens After the Trial (cont.)
• If the landlord wins at trial and the tenant doesn’t
  appeal within 10 days, they can get the execution, which
  is then given to a sheriff or constable.

• The constable then serves a 48 Hour Notice on the
  tenant notifying her that if she does not move out of the
  unit, he will levy on the execution – which means he will
  move the tenant and her property out of the apartment.
• The 48 Hour Notice must state the date and time the
  tenant will be moved out and must be served at least 48
  hours notice prior.

                                                                   30
48 Hour Notice to Vacate

                                                               31

           What to Do If A Client
           Receives a 48 hour notice
• Seek a “Stay” or Temporary Restraining Order (TRO) Against
  Use of Execution: If the tenant has been served with the 48
  hour notice and is not ready or able to move, he may go the
  court to ask for more time in his home.
   – If the motion is based upon nonpayment of rent, the
     tenant should seek a stay under the CDC moratorium (if
     still in effect) and/or ch. 257 if they have a pending
     application for rental assistance.

• Get Default Removed or Ask for New Hearing: If the tenant
  was defaulted in court, or if they missed a hearing on a
  motion to issue execution (lack of notice, illness, etc.), the
  tenant should file papers to get the default removed or to ask
  for another hearing.
                                                               32
Temporary Restraining Order
            Form 15
• Write a complaint explaining what is going on and
  what the tenant wants the court to do about it.
• Bring all proof.
• Ask for an Affidavit of Indigency to have fees waived.
• Hearing will be right away or soon after case is filed
  (client may need to serve the landlord).
• Tell the judge what is happening and what the tenant
  wants the court to do.
• Listen carefully to the court’s decision and get a copy
  of her written order granting or denying the request
  for relief.
                                                               33

        Levy on the Execution
• If the tenant does not ask for a TRO/stay or the judge
  denies their request, the levy will go forward.
• Advise tenants to get their important belongings together
  and bring them with them (clothes, birth certificate and
  other important papers, medicines, etc.).
• MA storage law – property must be stored in a licensed and
  bonded warehouse; can be sold after 6 months.
• A few Massachusetts communities (including Cambridge,
  Somerville, Malden, and Framingham) have local eviction
  moratoria currently in place which prohibit landlords from
  levying on an execution in certain types of cases.

                                                               34
Practice Tips for Helping Tenants Facing Eviction
The most important thing to do when attempting to assist a client facing eviction is to
properly assess where she is in the process. Here are some helpful questions to ask to
quickly figure out what stage the case is at:

1.    Can you read me the notice you have received?
      •    Might be an Notice to Quit, Summons, Court Date Notice, Judgment, or 48 hr.
           notice—advice and options are different depending on the notice.

2.    Have you ever been to court before?
      • If yes there could be an underlying agreement in the case and you want to ask
         about that.
      • Check MassCourts.org to look up the case.

3.    Does the notice say that the Sheriff will be coming to your house to move you out?
      •   Consider filing a TRO, trying to negotiate with the landlord, or preparing for levy
          by applying to shelter.

                                                                                                35

     Ways to Help Tenants Facing Eviction
• Get them connected to legal services/CELHP/Lawyer for the
  Day
• Provide assistance applying for rental assistance (if needed)
• Help them file an Answer, Discovery and Jury demand (using
  MADE or forms on masslegalhelp.org)
• Help them access Zoom to enable them to fully participate in
  court events
• Connect them with the Tenancy Preservation Project, a
  community group or other organization that can provide
  additional services and support

                                                                                                36
Ways to Help Tenants Facing Eviction
• Scan documents needed for a motion hearing or trial and
  help the tenant send them to the court:
   – Notices to the landlord about conditions (including emails and texts)
   – Rent receipts
   – Photographs of poor housing condition
   – Inspection reports verifying poor housing conditions
• Help them prepare for the hearing
   – Create a list of things to say to the judge
   – A list of questions to ask the landlord

                                                                             37
You can also read