NO SAFE HAVEN The Press Under Fire THE NEW RULES OF ENGAGEMENT - WINNERS OF THE OVERSEAS PRESS CLUB AWARDS

Page created by Herbert Zimmerman
 
CONTINUE READING
NO SAFE HAVEN The Press Under Fire THE NEW RULES OF ENGAGEMENT - WINNERS OF THE OVERSEAS PRESS CLUB AWARDS
DATELINE
                            WINNERS OF THE OVERSEAS PRESS CLUB AWARDS

     NO
     SAFE
     HAVEN
     The Press
     Under Fire
     THE NEW RULES
     OF ENGAGEMENT
      2015 ANNUAL EDITION

r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 1                                               4/17/15 5:05 PM
NO SAFE HAVEN The Press Under Fire THE NEW RULES OF ENGAGEMENT - WINNERS OF THE OVERSEAS PRESS CLUB AWARDS
Lenovo is a proud sponsor
                            of the Overseas Press Club.
                            Congratulations to all of
                            tonight’s winners.

        2

r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 2                                 4/17/15 5:05 PM
NO SAFE HAVEN The Press Under Fire THE NEW RULES OF ENGAGEMENT - WINNERS OF THE OVERSEAS PRESS CLUB AWARDS
PRESIDENT’S LETTER
                            MARCUS MABRY

                            I COULD NOT BE MORE PROUD OF THE                             There have always been dictators and
                            Dateline you are holding in your hands. The              despots, corrupt governments and criminal
                            OPC’s annual gala is always the work of a cast of        syndicates, determined to kill journalists. But
                            thousands. Dozens anyway. From our 79 judges             the assassinations of Jim Foley and Steven
                            to our 441 entries, considered with great delib-         Sotloff were made even more gruesome because
                            eration by people who have a lot of other work to        of their manner and the distribution of videos
                            do, to Bill Holstein and his dinner committee that       on social media. And the journalists of Charlie
                            round up the support needed to make this night           Hebdo were killed in their offices.
                            happen, to Paul Moakley and Alexis Gelber, who               I could not be prouder of the role of the
                            edited this beautiful and deeply alarming maga-          OPC has taken in meeting these challenges. The
                            zine, and Victor Williams who designed it.               OPC was founded by staff reporters at global
                                I could not be more proud to be president of         news behemoths. But increasingly foreign cov-
                            the OPC. This is a time of enormous tumult in            erage is brought to us by freelancers working
                            our industry and in our profession. For decades,         several “strings,” or on contract for mainly one
                            technology and economics have led to a shrink-           news organization.
                            ing of traditional journalism, even as they have             Since I became president of the OPC last
                            provided new independent platforms for free-             summer, we became one of the leading organi-
                            lance and citizen journalists.                           zations crafting the first ever industry standards
                                Those threats, as well as the Obama admin-           for freelancer safety in conflict zones. As I said
                            istration’s zeal for pursuing journalists and their      when we signed the protocols in February, this
                            sources, have been with us for a while. (We              is not enough—it is only the first step in play-
                            were grateful that the administration dropped            ing our part to equip, inform, and convene news
                            the case against NewYork Times reporter James            organizations and foreign correspondents, what-
                            Risen, though also originally brought it.) But           ever their employment status, in the global jour-
                            2014 and early 2015 saw one the highest death            nalism environment of today.
                            tolls for journalists in an entirely different, if not       But this is just one area where the OPC has
                            entirely new threat, an existential one: journal-        found renewed enthusiasm for our mission of
                            ists targeted for assassination for doing our job.       making foreign correspondence and foreign
                                                                                     correspondents as strong as they can be.
                                                                                     From new lower rates for students, to month-
                                                                                     ly meetups, to a soon to be re-launched web-
                                                                                     site and expanded Global Parachute reporting
                                                                                     resource—the OPC is more dedicated than ever
                                                                                     to enshrining, promulgating, and celebrating the
                                                                                     very best international coverage.

                                                                                     MABRY IS PRESIDENT OF THE OVERSEAS
                                                                                     PRESS CLUB OF AMERICA AND EDITOR AT
                                                                                     LARGE AT THE NEW YORK TIMES.

                                                                                                                                     3

r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 3                                                                                                          4/17/15 5:05 PM
NO SAFE HAVEN The Press Under Fire THE NEW RULES OF ENGAGEMENT - WINNERS OF THE OVERSEAS PRESS CLUB AWARDS
CONTENTS

                  A MOST VIOLENT YEAR 8                             THE CORNELIUS RYAN AWARD 37                                            OPPOSITE >
                      By Douglas Jehl                                                                                             Sub-Saharan African
                                                                 THE MADELINE DANE ROSS AWARD 37                                   migrants on a fence
                   THE IMAGE WARS 18                                                                                        between Morocco and the
                                                                      THE DAVID A ANDELMAN AND                              Spanish enclave of Melilla.
                      By Fred Ritchin
                                                                        PAMELA TITLE AWARD 46                              For more than seven hours,
             DIGITAL SECURITY CHECKLIST 20                                                                                   migrants sat atop the 20-
                     By Robert Guerra                            THE JOE AND LAURIE DINE AWARD 46                           foot fence dividing Europe
                                                                    THE WHITMAN BASSO AWARD 46                                  from Africa, refusing to
                   WEIGHING THE RISKS 22                                                                                      come down. Buffeted by
                      By Kathy Gannon                          THE ROBERT SPIERS BENJAMIN AWARD 46                               winds whipping along
                                                                                                                                   the cliffs of Africa’s
                       BATTLE SCARS 28                         BEST MULTIMEDIA NEW PRESENTATION 47                           Mediterranean coast, the
                      By Sebastian Junger                                                                                     men nursed their bloody
                                                                   BEST INVESTIGATIVE REPORTING 47                         feet and pleaded in broken
                     A VICIOUS CYCLE 54
                                                                             BEST COMMENTARY 47                              French for the Red Cross.
                 Infographic by Heather Jones                                                                                               April 3, 2014.
            THE OPC ANNUAL AWARDS FOR 2014:                                   ALSO IN THIS ISSUE:
                                                                             PRESIDENT’S LETTER 3                                   PHOTOGRAPH BY
                      ROBERT FRIEDMAN                                          By Marcus Mabry                                     SANTI PALACIOS—
                    2014 AWARDS CHAIR 31                                                                                          ASSOCIATED PRESS
                                                                            DAVID ROHDE
                 THE HAL BOYLE AWARD 32                              PRESIDENT’S AWARD WINNER 7
              THE BOB CONSIDINE AWARD 32                       WHERE OPC MEMBERS ARE WELCOME 51                                       ON THE COVER:
                                                                                                                          Yazidi refugees in Northern
         THE ROBERT CAPA AWARD 32 AND 34-35                                                                                Iraq stranded in the Sinjar
                                                                                                                          Mountains wait for a rescue
                THE OLIVIER REBBOT AWARD                                                                                      helicopter, Aug. 12, 2014.
                       33 AND 38-39
         THE JOHN FABER AWARD 33 AND 40-41                                                                                       While on a helicopter
                                                                                DATELINE 2015:                                  delivering aid to Yazidi
             FEATURE PHOTOGRAPHY AWARD                                                                                          civilians, photographer
                                                                                  PAUL MOAKLEY                              Moises Saman survived a
                      33 AND 48-49                                                   EDITOR                                crash in Northern Iraq that
             THE LOWELL THOMAS AWARD 33                                           ALEXIS GELBER                            killed the pilot and injured
                                                                                                                                several passengers on
              THE DAVID KAPLAN AWARD 36                                              EDITOR                                  board, including another
                                                                               VICTOR WILLIAMS                                    photographer, Adam
            THE EDWARD R MURROW AWARD 36                                                                                      Ferguson, and The New
                                                                               DESIGN DIRECTOR                               York Times’ Paris bureau
             THE ED CUNNINGHAM AWARD 36
                                                                               NANCY NOVICK                                     chief Alissa J. Rubin. “If
                THE THOMAS NAST AWARD                                                                                       we had been another 50
                                                                             ASSISTANT DESIGNER                             meters higher we’d all be
                      36 AND 43-44                                            AND PRODUCTION                                 dead,” Ferguson told the
              THE MORTON FRANK AWARD 37                                                                                                           Times.
                                                                             PATRICIA KRANZ
                                                                        OPC EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR                                        PHOTOGRAPH BY
             THE MALCOLM FORBES AWARD 37                                                                                  MOISES SAMAN—MAGNUM

        OVERSEAS PRESS CLUB OF AMERICA BOARD OF GOVERNORS 2014 – 2015

        PRESIDENT               ACTIVE BOARD             PETER S. GOODMAN          ROBERT                ASSOCIATE                PAST PRESIDENTS
        MARCUS MABRY            MEMBERS                  Editor-in-Chief           NICKELSBERG           BOARD MEMBERS            EX-OFFICIO
        Editor at Large         JACQUELINE               International             Freelance             BRIAN I. BYRD            MICHAEL S. SERRILL
        The New York Times      ALBERT-SIMON             Business Times            Photojournalist       Program Officer          DAVID A. ANDELMAN
        FIRST VICE              U.S. Bureau Chief        CHARLES GRAEBER                                 NYS Health
                                Politique                                          LARA SETRAKIAN        Foundation               JOHN CORPORON
        PRESIDENT                                        Freelance Journalist
        CALVIN SIMS             Internationale           and Author                Co-Founder & CEO                               ALLAN DODDS
                                                                                                         BILL COLLINS
        President and CEO                                                          News Deeply                                    FRANK
                                                                                                         Director, Public &
        International House     RUKMINI                  AZMAT KHAN                                      Business Affairs         ALEXIS GELBER
                                CALLIMACHI               Investigative Reporter    MARTIN SMITH          Ford Motor Company
        SECOND VICE                                                                                                               WILLIAM J.
                                Foreign                  BuzzFeed News             President
        PRESIDENT                                                                                        EMMA DALY                HOLSTEIN
                                Correspondent                                      Rain Media
        ABIGAIL PESTA                                                                                    Communications
                                The New York Times       DAN KLAIDMAN                                                             MARSHALL LOEB
        Freelance Journalist                                                                             Director
                                                         Deputy Editor             LIAM STACK                                     LARRY MARTZ
        THIRD VICE                                                                                       Human Rights Watch
                                JANE CIABATTARI          Yahoo News                Breaking News
        PRESIDENT                                                                                                                 ROY ROWAN
                                Columnist                                          Reporter              DANIEL SIEBERG
        PANCHO                  BBC.com                                            The New York Times    Global Head of           LEONARD SAFFIR
        BERNASCONI                                       EVELYN LEOPOLD
                                                         Independent                                     Media Outreach           LARRY SMITH
        Vice President/News                                                                              Google
        Getty Images            CHRIS DICKEY             Journalist                SEYMOUR TOPPING                                RICHARD B. STOLLEY
                                Foreign Editor           United Nations            Emeritus Professor    ABI WRIGHT
        TREASURER               The Daily Beast, Paris                             of International      Director
        TIM FERGUSON                                                               Journalism                                     Overseas Press Club
                                                         PAUL MOAKLEY                                    Alfred I. DuPont
        Editor                                                                     Columbia University                            of America 40 West
                                                         Deputy Director                                 Columbia University
        Forbes Asia                                                                                                               45th Street—New
                                                         Photography and                                 Awards                   York, NY 10036
        SECRETARY                                        Visual Enterprise         CHARLES WALLACE                                212 626-9220 www.
        DEIDRE DEPKE                                     TIME Magazine             Freelance Writer                               opcofamerica.org
        Journalist and Author                                                                                                     @opcofamerica

        4

r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 4                                                                                                                            4/17/15 5:05 PM
NO SAFE HAVEN The Press Under Fire THE NEW RULES OF ENGAGEMENT - WINNERS OF THE OVERSEAS PRESS CLUB AWARDS
      5

r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 5       4/17/15 5:05 PM
NO SAFE HAVEN The Press Under Fire THE NEW RULES OF ENGAGEMENT - WINNERS OF THE OVERSEAS PRESS CLUB AWARDS
PepsiCo is a proud sponsor of the
                                76th Annual OPC Awards Dinner
                        As a company that does business in more than 200 countries
                            and territories, PepsiCo thanks the Overseas Press Club
                            of America and its members for everything they to do to
                                            bring attention to serious issues.

                                                                www.pepsico.com
                                                              www.twitter.com/pepsico

                                                                                                                                                             TOMAS MUNITA —THE NEW YORK TIMES

                                    © 2015 PepsiCo, Inc. All Rights Reserved. This Ad contains valuable trademarks owned and used by
                                       PepsiCo, Inc. and its subsidiaries and affiliates to distinguish products of outstanding quality.

r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 6                                                                                                                  4/17/15 5:05 PM
NO SAFE HAVEN The Press Under Fire THE NEW RULES OF ENGAGEMENT - WINNERS OF THE OVERSEAS PRESS CLUB AWARDS
PRESIDENT’S AWARD WINNER 2014
                                        DAVID ROHDE

                                                                                                                 David Rohde
                                                                                                                 reporting
                                                                                                                 from
                                                                                                                 Kandahar,
                                                                                                                 Afghanistan
                                                                                                                 2008.

                                        SCOTT KRAFT, THE DEPUTY EDITOR                not just journalism. They were a service to
                                        of the Los Angeles Times, told Robert         history, to humanity, and to memory.
                                        Friedman, the head judge of the OPC               And they were just the beginning of
                                        awards, “It is an honor to serve.”            what would be a celebrated career that
                                            In addition to No Safe Haven, that        would take him from Afghanistan to the
                                        could be the theme of this year’s OPC gala:   courts of New York’s outer boroughs. While
                                        An Honor to Serve.                            on book leave from The New York Times,
                                            The award winners—in their diversi-       Rohde and two colleagues were held cap-
                                        ty tonight, from The New York Times to        tive in Pakistan by the Taliban for sev-
                                        Medium, and in the diversity of the topics,   en months in 2008 and 2009 before he
                                        from Central African Republic to Doha—        escaped.
                                        all pay a tribute to journalism in the ser-       So it should come as no surprise that
                                        vice of something larger than headlines       David was a leader—some might even say
                                        and glory.                                    the leader—in shaping the set of guide-
                                            Tonight’s recipient of The President’s    lines and protocols that more than 60 news
                                        Award is in keeping with that theme: An       organizations and journalism groups have
                                        Honor to Serve. His life has been spent in    signed on to. Others were crucial to get-
                                        service to others.                            ting the effort off the ground and still oth-
                                            I have known David Rohde for nearly       ers in efforts to take it from a list of goals
                                        half my life, meeting him in Zagreb during    to industry doctrine. But David drove the
                                        the Bosnian war. As a freelancer on con-      process that got us to where we are today,
                                        tract for The Christian Science Monitor,      and he continues to be a linchpin in where
     TOMAS MUNITA —THE NEW YORK TIMES

                                        he brought back the first seemingly incon-    we go next.
                                        trovertible evidence that there had been a        And that’s not even his day job. As an
                                        massacre in Srebrenica. Those stories were    investigative reporter for Reuters, and a for-
                                                                                      mer columnist, David continues to do the
                                                                                      exclusive truth telling, and serving human-
                                                                                      ity, that have been his stock in trade.
                                                                                          I can’t wait to see what he does in the
                                                                                      second half of his career.—MARCUS MABRY

                                                                                      FOR THE NEW GLOBAL SAFETY PRINCIPLES
                                                                                      AND PRACTICES VISIT: HTTP://BIT.LY/1B58HCC

                                                                                                                                         7

r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 7                                                                                                              4/17/15 5:05 PM
NO SAFE HAVEN The Press Under Fire THE NEW RULES OF ENGAGEMENT - WINNERS OF THE OVERSEAS PRESS CLUB AWARDS
A MOST VIO L

r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 8   4/17/15 5:05 PM
NO SAFE HAVEN The Press Under Fire THE NEW RULES OF ENGAGEMENT - WINNERS OF THE OVERSEAS PRESS CLUB AWARDS
O LENT YEAR                      IN 2014 THE WORLD
                             SEEMED TO IGNITE. AND
                                JOURNALISTS WERE
                               OFTEN THE TARGETS.
                                 BY DOUGLAS JEHL

                                            BULENT KILIC
                                         AFP/Getty Images
                                      An Islamic State militant
                                        just after an air strike
                                            on Tilsehir hill near
                                            the Turkish border
                                         at Yumurtalik village,
                                            Sanliurfa province,
                                         Turkey. Oct. 23, 2014.

 r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 9                                     4/17/15 5:05 PM
NO SAFE HAVEN A MOST VIOLENT YEAR

        MOST OF US WHO HAVE                           Post’s Tehran correspondent, had been         horribly cursed.
                                                      detained by the Iranian authorities. In           In many ways, 2014 was a year in
        SPENT OUR CAREERS                             December, a satellite-phone delivered         which the world seemed to ignite. All at
        AROUND FOREIGN NEWS                           word that photographer Michel du Cille        once, it sometimes seemed, came war
        HAVE FOUND WAYS TO                            had fallen unconscious on an arduous          in Ukraine and Gaza, renewed chaos in
        COPE WITH THE DANGERS                         hike in a remote location while covering      Afghanistan, the march of Islamic State
                                                      Ebola in Liberia.                             extremists in Iraq, Syria and beyond,
        OF COVERING CONFLICTS.                           Michel, a three-time Pulitzer Prize        and the awful toll of instability and
           It will be fine, we tell ourselves. No     winner, died before reaching a hospital.      disease in West Africa. Not counting
        one really wants to target a journalist.      Jason, as of this writing, remained in Ira-   du Cille, more than 60 journalists were
           But all that can be punctured with the     nian custody after eight months without       killed in the line of duty, including four
        ring of a telephone. Your correspondent       access to a lawyer and without any pub-       from the Associated Press.
        has been detained, we hear. Your pho-         lic indication of the charges against him.         Perhaps most indelibly, the dead
        tographer has collapsed. Your reporter        Another reporter, Austin Tice, a freelanc-    included American freelance journal-
        is missing.                                   er whose work appeared in The Post            ists James Foley and Steven Sotloff,
           In the deadly year that was 2014,          and McClatchy Newspapers, remains             beheaded so brutally by their extremist
        we at The Washington Post were                unaccounted for after being abducted          captors in Syria in videotaped produc-
        among the news organizations that             in Syria in August 2012. The blow to their    tions broadcast on social media.
        received those kinds of calls. In July, via   families has been unfathomable.                     Of course, journalists have never
        a scratchy mobile phone connection,              Other journalists and other news           been immune from risk—even though
        came news that Jason Rezaian, The             organizations have been even more             those of us who have worked as for-

        10

r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 10                                                                                                                4/17/15 5:05 PM
MICHEL DU CILLE
                                                                                                                      The Washington Post
                         MOISES SAMAN                                                                                   Eva Togbah waits in a
                                                                                                                       van to enter a Doctors
                         Magnum for TIME                                                                             Without Borders clinic in
                         After surviving a
                                                                                                                    Monrovia, Liberia. Tobgah,
                         helicopter crash,
                                                                                                                       sick and bleeding from
                         Yazidi refugees, along
                                                                                                                      the mouth, came to the
                         with Kurdish and
                                                                                                                      clinic with four relatives
                         Iraqi Army personnel,
                                                                                                                              on Sept. 23, 2014.
                         board a rescue
                         helicopter transporting
                         them from the crash
                         site back to Kurdish-
                         controlled Dohuk
                         Province. Sinjar
                         Mountains, Iraq,
                         Aug. 12, 2014.

                                                   eign correspondents sometimes hoped              with its detention of Rezaian and doz-
                                                   that a press card or a windshield plac-          ens of Iranian journalists, do not appear
                                                   ard proclaiming “media’’ might spare             to have been swayed by the concern
                                                   us from a missile strike or from captors         about possible blowback.
                                                   wielding AK-47s.                                     As The Post’s foreign editor, I see
                                                     But there was a time, not so long ago,         my job as helping readers make sense
                                                   when it did seem possible to believe             of what is most consequential around
                                                   that the essential role that news orga-          the world. The size of our foreign staff
                                                   nizations played as a messenger might            (which now numbers 20 correspon-
                                                   afford at least some protection; even            dents in 15 bureaus) attests to our
                                                   the bad guys need us, we would tell              commitment to up-close, first-hand
                                                   ourselves.                                       coverage. But the places where the
                                                     It is now undeniable that this old cal-        most consequential events were unfold-
                                                   culus does not always apply. Extremist           ing—Syria, Ukraine, Iraq, Gaza—have also
                                                   groups such as Islamic State clearly see         become the most dangerous.
                                                   public-relations benefit, not cost, in killing      No journalist ever wants to limit cov-
                                                   journalists, not just in Syria but else-         erage of a major story. But in practice,
                                                   where, as in this year’s attack on the           the threats facing journalists in parts of
                                                   offices of Charlie Hebdo in Paris. Among         Iraq and Syria controlled by the Islamic
                                                   governments, Egypt, with its conviction          State mean that a historic narrative
                                                   of three Al Jazeera reporters, and Iran,         there is unfolding without witnesses. At

                                                                                                                                            11

r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 11                                                                                                                 4/17/15 5:06 PM
SERGEY
          PONOMAREV
          The New
          York Times
          Palestinians mourn
          members of the Nigim
          family who were
          killed in an Israeli
          airstrike in Jabaliya,
          Gaza. Aug. 4, 2014.

r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 12         4/17/15 5:06 PM
r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 13   4/17/15 5:06 PM
Bloomberg is proud to support the

                                                              Overseas Press Club

                                                                                                                    M
                                                                                                                    K
                                                                                                                    b
                                                                                                                    t
                                                                                                                    a
                                                                                                                    u
                                                                                                                    a
                                                                                                                    l
                                                                                                                    p
                                                                                                                    F
©2015 Bloomberg L.P. All rights reserved. S577905973 0

                                                                 14

                                                         r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 14               4/17/15 5:06 PM
NO SAFE HAVEN A MOST VIOLENT YEAR

        JEROME SESSINI
        Magnum
        Kiev, Ukraine: a
        bloody stretcher in
        the aftermath of
        a protest between
        unidentified snipers
        and protesters that
        left more than 70
        people dead.
        Feb. 20, 2014.

                               the same time, Iran’s cruel and uncon-        by David Rohde of Reuters, who spent
                               scionable detention of Rezaian has            so many months held captive by the
                               prevented The Post from covering that         Taliban in Pakistan, has devoted par-
                               country at a pivotal time in its history.     ticular attention to drawing up proposed
                                  As Jason’s boss, I have worked             guidelines to ensure that freelance jour-
                               closely with his family and with other        nalists are better trained and equipped
                               senior leaders at The Post, including         before they venture into conflict zones.
                               Frederick J. Ryan Jr., the publisher, to         We at The Post take seriously our
                               explore every possible channel in seek-       responsibilities to all of those who work
                               ing Jason’s release. The Post has also        for us, and we’re working to sharpen
                               supported similar efforts led by the fam-     our own practices for correspondents,
                               ily of Austin Tice.                           freelancers, and also for the local re-
                                  While The Post’s ethical guidelines        porters, translators, drivers and others
                               prohibit its journalists from engaging in     on whom we often depend.
                               political activities, our executive editor,      There are lessons to be drawn from
                               Martin Baron, advised the newsroom            the toll of the past year—about training,
                               in February that it would be entirely         planning, even cybersecurity. The world
                               appropriate to advocate for journalistic      doesn’t show any sign of getting safer,
                               freedom and for the freedom of our            and being clear-eyed about weighing
                               colleague. A number of Post employees         the risks is the best way to make sure
                               have now joined in signing a petition on      that we can keep telling these stories.
                               Change.org calling for Jason’s release.
                                  A valuable initiative led, among oth-      JEHL IS FOREIGN EDITOR OF THE
                               ers, by press freedom organizations and       WASHINGTON POST.

                                                                                                                  15

r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 15                                                                                        4/17/15 5:06 PM
JOHN MOORE
           Getty Images
           Omu Fahnbulleh
           stands over her
           husband Ibrahim
           after he fell in
           an Ebola holding
           center in Monrovia,
           Liberia, leaving
           him unconscious.
           He died the same
           day. August 15, 2014.
           CITATION WINNER
           FOR ROBERT CAPA
           AWARD

r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 16         4/17/15 5:06 PM
r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 17   4/17/15 5:06 PM
NO SAFE HAVEN ESSAY

       THE
       IMAGE
       WARS
        BY FRED RITCHIN

        THE RECENT MURDERS BY                        aggravates the initial horror to the point    for ISIS. But looking at a video of the
                                                     where there seems to be no escape.            last seconds of life of those killed can
        ISIS OF FOREIGN JOURNAL-                         But there are crucial differences. In     also be seen as an act of empathy with
        ISTS AND AID WORKERS                         that kind of digitally enabled bullying,      them, as well as with their families and
        SPARKED ENORMOUS OUT-                        not only are the attackers at fault, but      friends, sharing some of their grief and
        RAGE AND CONDEMNATION.                       so are the others in the community who        their revulsion. Just because murder-
                                                     view and pass along the video with an         ers want people to look at these videos
        But what seemed to have provoked             expectation of voyeuristic enjoyment.         does not mean that one should not, or
        much of the fury were the videos of the      But in the case of the videos produced        should, comply—one can view them in
        beheadings that were produced and            by ISIS, viewers are not complicit in the     many ways that deny their intended
        distributed by the murderers themselves.     murders and no social bond is being           messages. As we have learned from
           Committing horrific acts and then         broken or frayed by watching them             literary theory, the reader or viewer, not
        broadcasting them is an attempt to           (looking at something is not endorsing        only the author, determines meaning.
        humiliate the victims and, by extension,     it). In fact, carefully watching the videos       One way of interpreting these videos
        to mock those in their home countries        may well be a way to understanding            (and there are others that were made
        whose values they represent. No one          the mindset of the murderers and the          for regional viewing that are just as hor-
        else, ISIS seems to say, can report upon,    threats that they pose. It can also lead      rific, showing massacres and behead-
        interpret, or judge their organization’s     to a political will to punish the perpetra-   ings of local people) is that ISIS forced
        actions, other than themselves.              tors.                                         their captives into what were essentially
           In some ways these videos resemble            There is more to consider, however,       snuff films, presenting them as individu-
        what has been called “happy slap-            as became clear in the debate on social       als but denying any sense of agency on
        ping” among adolescents—someone              media and elsewhere about whether             their part or any sense of redemption in
        is beaten up, or sexually attacked, and      to post these videos online. One had to       the killing. It is not, as in the Bible, Abra-
        the video of the event that is circulated    take into account the horrific character      ham being told by God to spare Isaac,
        afterwards becomes a re-victimization        of the videos, their invasion of privacy,     but a man, his face concealed, who is
        that can, at times, lead to the suicide of   as well as a desire not to make the           announcing that members of his group
        the victim. Social media, or what might      individuals’ deaths a spectacle, poten-       can kill with impunity any others unlike
        in this case be called anti-social media,    tially providing a public relations coup      themselves. There are no scruples, no

        18

r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 18                                                                                                                   4/17/15 5:06 PM
A still from a video posted online shows American journalist James Foley shortly before he was executed.

        room for discussion, and no other pos-          instead to focus on civilian casualties        stepped in with its own macabre form
        sible ending—due process is not part of         on each side. In Syria a military police       of cinema verité, and by doing so has
        their vocabulary.                               photographer, code-named Caesar,               managed to temporarily dominate the
           The executions are also an assertion         had to smuggle out tens of thousands           image war.
        of a media monopoly—not only are the            of photographs of prisoners whom                 What is the best antidote to the im-
        ISIS video creators the central protago-        he asserted had been tortured and              age wars assaulting us? Certainly we
        nists in this image war, but as produc-         executed in secret by the Assad regime.        have to try to seek a more rational
        ers and directors they also control the         The impact of previous imagery on              explanation of why such images are
        exclusive rights to its representation.         world opinion—such as the famous               being made. In the case of ISIS, are the
        Unlike the attacks of September 11,             1972 photograph of a young girl being          people making these images powerful,
        when the production and distribution of         napalmed in Vietnam, or the one of the         or desperate? Are we being asked to
        the imagery was left to others, ISIS does       summary execution of a captive on a            watch holy war, or pornography? And
        not allow individual interpretations by         Saigon street in 1968—continues to play        by looking at this excruciating imagery,
        outsiders. After September 11, photo-           a cautionary role.                             are we being complicit or are we do-
        graphs by amateurs and professionals               In the case of ISIS, which is not inter-    ing our duty as citizens in a globalized
        alike were used as part of a process            ested in working within international          world?
        of grieving and remembering, because            norms, an image war of concealment               This act of resistance may be carried
        many of those depicting the suffering           makes little sense. The creation of hor-       out in solidarity with those who have
        did so out of empathy, unlike those who         rors for public consumption is both an         been so awfully victimized. One can
        aim to humiliate and re-victimize.              explicit rejection of such conventions         recite their names.
           Contemporary image wars usually              as well an appeal to nihilistic youth who        May their memory endure.
        have tried to conceal activities that may       are being encouraged to join, sanc-
        not jibe with international humanitar-          tioning their own rage and frustration.
                                                                                                       RITCHIN IS DEAN OF THE SCHOOL
        ian laws, rather than flaunt those that         In their version of the image war, the         AT THE INTERNATIONAL CENTER
        can be perceived as war crimes. During          shooter in the video game actually gets        OF PHOTOGRAPHY. HIS LAST
        the conflict in Gaza neither Hamas nor          to kill the target, as brutally as possible;   BOOK IS BENDING THE FRAME:
        Israel wanted the media to accompany            the man with the knife gets to mock            PHOTOJOURNALISM, DOCUMENTARY,
        their combatants, for example, but              the world’s greatest military. ISIS has        AND THE CITIZEN (APERTURE 2013).

                                                                                                                                            19

r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 19                                                                                                                 4/17/15 5:06 PM
NO SAFE HAVEN TECHNOLOGY

      DIGITAL                                                                                                     addresses cyber security as part of its
                                                                                                                  Journalism Security Guide.

      SECURITY
                                                                                                                      Reporters Without Borders also has
                                                                                                                  published an Online Survival Kit, available in
                                                                                                                  five languages.
                                                                                                                      Digital First Aid Kit is a guide published by
                                                                                                                  a dozen media-related NGOs, including Free
                                                                                                                  Press Unlimited, Freedom House, Global Voices,

      CHECKLIST
                                                                                                                  and Internews.

                                                                                                                  SURVEILLANCE SELF-DEFENSE PROVIDES
                                                                                                                  A PRACTICAL FIVE-POINT GUIDE TO
                                                                                                                  PROTECTING YOURSELF AND YOUR
                                                                                                                  INFORMATION:
                                                                                                                  1. Develop a data retention and destruction
        ROBERT GUERRA                                                                                             policy: You should not destroy evidence, but
                                                                                                                  you can maintain a retention policy in which
                                                                                                                  you routinely purge your files. Make sure the
                                                             computer, including at least one in addition         policy is written and followed by everyone.
        INVESTIGATIVE REPORTERS                              to the default administrator account. Making         2. Basics of data protection: Require logins
        FACE A TWO-FOLD                                      sure the second account has no administrative        for accounts and screensavers. Make your
        CHALLENGE: surveillance                              privileges, then use that login for your daily       passwords strong. Make sure you trust your
        software has become mind-                            work. If malware tries to install automatically,     systems administrator.
                                                             the computer will alert you with a message           3. Proper use of passwords: Don’t use
        bogglingly sophisticated;                            requiring the administrator password.                the same password for multiple accounts.
        and funding is pouring in for                                                                             And change the passwords regularly. Can’t
        development of new technologies.                     MALWARE                                              remember a lengthy password? Consider
        These new products are                               Beware of suspicious attachments, keep               an encrypted password manager such as
        purchased on the gray market                         your programs updated, and install a good            1Password or Keypass.
                                                             antivirus program or malware scanner such            4. Data encryption: Governments can get
        by governments that spy on their                     as Detekt.                                           around password-protected data. But well-
        public—and their press.                              If possible, avoid opening attachments on            encrypted data is more difficult.
                                                             your computer. Instead use online editors            5. Protection from malware: Avoid opening
        Robert Guerra, a Canadian based digital              such as Google Docs to view and edit                 attachments and PDF documents on your
        security expert, warns that most reporters           documents.                                           computer.
        aren’t even taking the most basic precautions.       Watch for emails from groups or people
            “If you become known for investigative           you might know, but which seem slightly              Eva Galperin of the EFF provides this tip sheet
        reporting, people can use digital tools to come      off—small grammar changes or odd                     for Best Practices. Key points:
        after you and your data,” says Guerra, who           punctuation.                                         1. Skype isn’t as secure as you might think.
        for more than a decade has trained NGO               Outdated computers without the latest                Instead you should use a more secure, peer-
        staffers and journalists to securely manage          security patches will put you on greater risk.       to-peer service such as Talky.io or meet.jit.si.
        relationships and data online. “Start with the                                                            2. SMS messaging is not secure and not
        principles. Know the risks”.                         WHEN SOMETHING GOES WRONG                            encrypted. If you have a smart phone, use
        Guerra suggests starting here:                       Make noise if your computer starts acting            a secure chat tool such as Redphone, Signal,
                                                             wacky. Reach out to one of the nonprofit             Threema or Silent Circle
        EMAIL                                                groups dedicated to detecting and tracking           3. Instant message with Pidgin or Adium
        At home, use “https” so that your web                attacks and training users:                          (Mac OSX)
        browsing traffic is encrypted. If you don’t, it’s    The Committee to Protect Journalists, based
        as if you were in a busy public place having         in New York, advocates on behalf of reporters        Steve Doig, a professor at Arizona
        a conversation with a confidential source,           around the world and fields requests for             State University, provides these tips in his
        Guerra explains, “but you’re both screaming.”        assistance.                                          presentation Spycraft: Keeping Your Sources
        Install the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF)’s   Reporters Without Borders, based in Paris,           Private (Powerpoint):
        HTTPS Everywhere extension in your browser           does similar advocacy as CPJ.                        1. Search the web with IXQuick, which
        so that your connection defaults to a secure         The Electronic Frontier Foundation, based in         doesn’t save your IP address or search terms.
        connection “https” where possible.                   San Francisco, advocates for digital rights.         2. Disguise your caller ID with SpoofCard.
            Don’t assume your employer is                    The Citizen Lab at the University of Toronto         This works for international calls as well.
        protecting your account. Ask your                    researches Internet security and human rights.       3. Buy no-contract cell phones with cash.
        technology desk about what precautions it                                                                 4. Encrypt communications:
        takes, and consider getting a personal account       TUTORIALS AND TIPSHEETS                                  Pretty Good Privacy is strong and
        from Google, Yahoo or RiseUp over which you          There’s no shortage of guides to digital security.       an industry standard.
        have control.                                        Many are overly complex and not terribly                 Spam Mimic encrypts messages in
            Passwords and the Two-Factor Login               useful for working journalists. But there’s help         spam-like email
            It is recommended that you activate an           out there, and it’s worth designating someone            Clean out deleted files for good using
        additional layer of protection—the two-factor        on your team, in your newsroom, or at your               Webroot Window Washer
        login present in many online services today.         nonprofit to take the lead in ensuring that your         When obtaining leaked documents from
        When you activate the two-factor login, you          work is protected.                                       a government source, beware of invisible
        will need to enter your password and a unique        Some resources:                                          watermarks.
        authentication code that can be generated via            Security in a Box offers a series of video            The London-based Centre for Investigative
        a mobile app or sent via text message.               tutorials on simple ways to maintain a low           Journalism has an 80-page handbook,
            Login Settings                                   online profile. Available in many languages.         Information Security for Journalists, full of the
            Establish multiple user accounts on your             The Committee to Protect Journalists             latest tips and techniques.

        20

r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 20                                                                                                                                     4/17/15 5:06 PM
Congratulations to all
                              the winners of the
                              2014 OPC Awards

                                                      21

r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 21                            4/17/15 5:06 PM
NO SAFE HAVEN PORTFOLIO

      WEIGHING
      THE RISKS
        BY KATHY GANNON

                                                                                                                  LEFT:
                                                                                                      Gannon (center
                                                                                                              left) and
                                                                                                    Niedringhaus with
                                                                                                        Afghan police
                                                                                                     recruits in Kabul,
                                                                                                        Afghanistan in
                                                                                                        October 2012.

                                                                                                                  RIGHT:
                                                                                                            An Afghan
                                                                                                      woman waits in
                                                                                                     a changing room
                                                                                                      to try out a new
                                                                                                       burqa, in Kabul,
                                                                                                           April 11, 2013.

        IN DECEMBER LAST YEAR                           Doing up the zipper on my coat wasn’t a            do I ensure that the shooting doesn’t define
        I RETURNED TO PAKISTAN.                         near to impossible chore. I wore shoes with        me, that one horrific incident doesn’t over-
                                                        laces. I didn’t wake every morning giving          shadow a career that has brought me such
        It was just for two weeks, but                  myself a pep talk or a berating—depending          joy and pride?
        it had the effect of helping me                 on the day—about coping with the pain and              People often ask whether the shooting
        reconnect with the person I had                 the value of putting a positive spin on the        has changed me. The honest answer is that I
        been before the April 4, 2014                   progress I had made.                               am really not sure, having focused so much
        shooting in eastern Afghanistan,                   So much, it seemed, had changed.                of my energy on healing physically. I do
        when a crazed gunman stole                         I have been humbled by the outpour-             know that I am as impatient as I ever was. I
        from me one of my dearest                       ing of kind words, and the talk of courage         am still stubborn and opinionated.
                                                        and bravery. Still, most of the time I have felt       I also feel incredibly lucky that I always
        friends, the award-winning                      neither brave nor courageous. Instead my           loved my life. I was doing what I wanted
        photojournalist Anja Niedringhaus,              time seems to be preoccupied with keeping          to do, living in a region that offered glar-
        and changed my life.                            fear at bay, not thinking about the next sur-      ing examples of the very best and very worst
           The last time I had been in Pakistan         gery, nor dwelling on questions for which I        of us. When the gunman stopped firing that
        was in early March 2014—almost a month          have no answers: What will the future hold?        horrible day last April and I looked down to
        before the shooting. I had originally gone      What will I be able to do? Will I be able to       see all the blood and my near-severed hand, I
        to Afghanistan to fill in on the AP desk and    type with both hands? How do I massage             was sure I was dying. The recurring thought
        then to cover the presidential election. Then   the physical and emotional scars so that I         as I prepared myself for death was that I had
        I was strong. I could type with both hands.     am not forever a walking wounded? How              had an amazing life. I had no regrets.

        PHOTOGRAPHS BY ANJA NIEDRINGHAUS—ASSOCIATED PRESS

r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 22                                                                                                                          4/17/15 5:06 PM
I looked to my left at Anja, not sure        zone? No matter how much you seek to mit-       ty of getting out, leaving behind the safety
        whether she was alive or dead, taking com-       igate the risk—and we all do—risk remains.      of an office, to tell the story, was unshake-
        fort in having her by my side.                       For me the answer is in the hearts of       able. It was never about her. It was always
            Since I survived—thanks in no small          those journalists who have paid the price       about those whose stories she wanted to tell
        part to the emergency surgery performed by       either with their lives or their once healthy   through her pictures.
        an Afghan surgeon at the struggling Khost        bodies.                                             She was smart in how she approached a
        Hospital—I have taken a closer look at many          I think of Anja, my friend who died at      story. She understood the risks, always had
        things that I previously gave only a passing     my side. Her pictures captured the souls of     a back-up plan, was never foolhardy or cava-
        thought to, including our profession.            the people, and the many conflicts she cov-     lier about the dangers involved. But she also
            Dozens of journalists have been killed       ered laid bare those souls. The misery of       never ran away from the risks to leave the
        in the last year. The world has lost videog-     war brings out the worst and best of people     story untold.
        raphers, photographers and writers, all of       and everything in between, and Anja cap-            Anja represents all of us who do this
        whom believed in the value of telling the sto-   tured it all. She made us see. We didn’t see    job. None of us wants to die or be hurt, but
        ry. Others have suffered horrific life-chang-    only tanks and mortars. In her images we        neither do we want to be held hostage to
        ing injuries in pursuit of the story.            saw people, their pain, strength, courage and   fear nor debilitated by the question: “What
            More than ever before we struggle with       even their hope in what often seemed to the     might happen?”
        the question of what constitutes acceptable      outsider a hopeless situation.                      What we want is just to tell the story.
        risk. No story is worth dying over, but are          Anja and I would often talk about why       GANNON IS THE ASSOCIATED PRESS
        there stories that are worth the calculated      we did this job. Her belief in the rightness    REGIONAL CORRESPONDENT FOR
        risks we take whenever we go into a conflict     of what she did and the absolute necessi-       AFGHANISTAN AND PAKISTAN.

                                                                                                                                                  23

r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 23                                                                                                                        4/17/15 5:06 PM
A Libyan rebel prays next to his gun
        on the frontlines outside the city of
        Ajdabiya, south of Benghazi, eastern
                                                   An Afghan Army soldier adjusts
        Libya, March 21, 2011.
                                                 his helmet at a training facility on
                                                the outskirts of Kabul, May 8, 2013.

        24

r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 24                                                      4/17/15 5:06 PM
NO SAFE HAVEN PORTFOLIO

                                          Injured U.S.Marine Cpl. Burness
                                             Britt reacts after being lifted
                                              onto a medevac helicopter
                                        from the U.S. Army’s Task Force
                                        Lift “Dust Off,” Charlie Company
                                                   1-214 Aviation Regiment,
                                          Helmand Province of southern
                                                 Afghanistan, June 4, 2011.

                                   ANJA NIEDRINGHAUS (1965-2014) WAS
                                  A GERMAN PHOTOJOURNALIST WHO
                                 WORKED FOR THE ASSOCIATED PRESS.
                                    SHE WAS THE ONLY WOMAN ON A
                                 TEAM OF 11 AP PHOTOGRAPHERS THAT
                                   WON THE 2005 PULITZER PRIZE FOR
                                  BREAKING NEWS PHOTOGRAPHY FOR
                                        COVERAGE OF THE IRAQ WAR.

                                                                       25

r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 25                                             4/17/15 5:06 PM
An Afghan
           National Police
           officer mans a
           checkpoint on
           the outskirts of
           Maidan Shahr,
           Wardak province,
           Afghanistan. May
           15, 2013.

r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 26    4/17/15 5:06 PM
r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 27   4/17/15 5:06 PM
NO SAFE HAVEN SEBASTIAN JUNGER

      BATTLE
      SCARS
        BY SEBASTIAN JUNGER

                                                                                                        I wasn’t going to be engaging with it
                                                                                                        myself—I thought I could take that affec-
                                                                                                        tion and take my energy and my time
                                                                                                        and continue to be involved by starting
                                                                                                        an organization that might help the jour-
                                                                                                        nalists who are still working out there.
                                                                                                           Tim died from a wound that was not
                                                                                                        necessarily mortal. He bled out. He died
                                                                                                        of loss of blood. He died in the back of a
                                                                                                        pickup truck racing to a Misrata hospital.
                                                                                                        He died minutes from help. And there
                                                                                                        were journalists around him and other
                                                                                                        rebel fighters, who conceivably might
                                                                                                        have been able to help him and slow
                                                                                                        down his blood loss. But none of them
        I REMEMBER WHEN I WAS                           to Libya together on assignment in 2011.
                                                                                                        were medically trained. None of them
        YOUNGER THINKING, IF I WAS                      And right after we were at the Oscars
                                                                                                        knew what to do.
                                                        for Restrepo, just about at the last minute,
        COVERING A WAR AND I                            for personal reasons I couldn’t go. Tim
                                                                                                           Just a quick lesson in this. If you’ve
        WASN’T IN A SITUATION WHERE                                                                     got nothing else, you just put your knee
                                                        went on his own. And he was killed in
                                                                                                        into the person’s wound and bear down
        PEOPLE WERE SHOOTING                            the city of Misrata. I got the phone call
                                                                                                        as hard as you can. Even that kind of
        IN MY DIRECTION, I WASN’T                       in New York, and within about an hour
                                                                                                        pressure into a wound can collapse the
        REALLY COVERING THE WAR.                        of the shock of that terrible phone call, I
                                                                                                        artery and slow down blood loss. So I’ve
                                                        realized that I was never going to cover
                                                                                                        started an organization called Reporters
        A totally silly way to think. What              war again.
                                                                                                        Instructed in Saving Colleagues, RISC.
        you’re really doing is answering a                 Not so much that I was worried per-
                                                                                                           Its mission is to provide free combat
        personal need for excitement—and not            sonally for myself. But I suddenly under-
                                                                                                        training and combat medicine: frontline
        necessarily a pure quest for information.       stood the effect on other people. I was
                                                                                                        medicine for experienced freelancers
            But we’re human. That’s going to            married at the time. My wife, Daniela,
                                                                                                        who cover wars. We unfortunately
        happen. It’s an important thing to be           loved Tim. I was watching the effect on
                                                                                                        don’t have enough funding to train
        aware of. I’ve been very lucky as a             her, and on Tim’s girlfriend. And in the
                                                                                                        people who are not reporters yet. We
        journalist, in the stories that I’ve covered,   coming days, I would see the effect on
                                                                                                        focus on freelancers, because they are
        and in people’s responses to my work.           his family and friends. I realized that it’s
                                                                                                        the majority of people in war zones.
        I’ve also been very lucky, two or three         absolutely possible to gamble with your
                                                                                                           Their casualty rate has doubled in
        times that I can think of, that I didn’t get    own life. There are very good reasons
                                                                                                                                                      CHRISTOPHER ANDERSON—MAGNUM PHOTOS

                                                                                                        the past ten years. They are often very
        killed or really badly hurt. It’s interest-     to do it. What’s ethically way more com-
                                                                                                        broke, and they can’t afford to invest in
        ing, though. Looking back, what I find          plicated is gambling with other people’s
                                                                                                        their own training. So we pay for four
        is that the situations that really disturb      happiness. Ultimately that’s what you’re
                                                                                                        days of lodging for them, a four-day
        you psychologically aren’t when there’s         doing when you go to a war zone.
                                                                                                        intensive medical training course, and a
        danger to yourself. It’s the pain of others.       I think there’s a point in your life
                                                                                                        combat medical kit, for 72 freelancers a
        Damage to other people. It’s incredibly         where you do have to put the concerns
                                                                                                        year. We exist completely from dona-
        traumatizing.                                   of others before your own concerns
                                                                                                        tions and people’s generosity.
            The event in my life as a journalist        or ambitions. I don’t think 20 or 30—or
                                                                                                           We’re going into our fourth year.
        that fundamentally changed the stories          maybe even 40—is that point. Nearing
                                                                                                        We’re very, very proud of RISC. If you
        that I would cover was the death of my          50 it certainly is. At least it was for me.
                                                                                                        have any interest at all in it, please look
        good friend, the British photojournalist        So I stopped war reporting completely.
                                                                                                        us up online—RISCTraining.org.
        Tim Hetherington.                               Incredibly, I have never had even a
            Tim and I were in Afghanistan together      passing regret about that decision.             JUNGER IS AN AWARD-WINNING
        in a small American outpost called Re-             But I’m incredibly proud of the people       JOURNALIST, FILMMAKER AND AUTHOR.
        strepo. We made a film together called          who are still doing it. It’s a very necessary   THIS PIECE WAS EXCERPTED FROM A
        Restrepo. We were friends, brothers,            job. What I wanted to do with my love           SPEECH AT THE 2015 OPC FOUNDATION
        colleagues—we were supposed to go               of journalism and foreign reporting—since       SCHOLARSHIP LUNCHEON.

        28

r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 28                                                                                                                     4/17/15 5:06 PM
Congratulations
                                                      to this year’s award winners!

                                                                                    for Media
CHRISTOPHER ANDERSON—MAGNUM PHOTOS

                                                                        www.google.com/mediatools

                                                             Connecting the media with Google's tools.

                                     r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 29                                          4/17/15 5:06 PM
S:7”

                             CONGRATULATIONS
                             TO THE WINNERS.
                             TONIGHT YOU
                             ARE THE HEADLINE.

                                                                                                                                                                                                         S:10.25”
                                                                                                                                                                                                                    T:11.25”
                             Citi would like to congratulate the winners of the
                             76th Annual Overseas Press Club Awards. Their efforts
                             in keeping to the highest standards of journalism not only
                             promote professional integrity, they promote progress.

                             © 2015 Citibank, N.A. Citi and Citi with Arc Design are registered service marks of Citigroup Inc. The World’s Citi is a service mark of Citigroup Inc.

        30

r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 30                                                                                                                                                             4/17/15 5:06 PM
A young Palestinian girl, injured when a UN school for refugees was hit by an Israeli tank shell, lies in the emergency room of Kamal Adwan
                                Hospital in Beit Lahia. July 24, 2014. OLIVER WEIKEN European Press Agency CITATION WINNER FOR JOHN FABER AWARD
                      B:11.75”
S:10.25”
           T:11.25”

                                                                      ANNUAL AWARDS 2014
                                                                          ROBERT FRIEDMAN, AWARDS COMITTEE CHAIR

                                            EACH YEAR, DOZENS OF JOURNALISTS                       America looked at the exploitation of foreign
                                            volunteer their time to sift through hundreds          workers employed on U.S. military bases in
                                            of entries for 22 Overseas Press Club awards.          Afghanistan. And Jason Motlagh in the Virginia
                                            It’s a lot of work, for which they get neither         Quarterly Review painstakingly reconstructed
                                            pay nor much recognition. The judges—there             what happened during and after the collapse
                                            were 79 this year—include editors, foreign             of a factory in Bangladesh in 2013, where
                                            correspondents and journalism professors. As           more than 1,100 garment workers perished.
                                            Scott Kraft, deputy editor of the Los Angeles              Three media organizations captured two
                                            Times, a former bureau chief in Nairobi,               top prizes each this year: The New York Times
                                            Johannesburg and Paris and head judge for              for coverage of Ebola and the cover-up by
                                            the Hal Boyle Award this year, put it: “It’s such      the U.S. military of the contamination of its own
                                            a rewarding experience for me—it’s an honor            soldiers by chemical munitions; the Los Angeles
                                            to serve.”                                             Times for reporting on the Ukraine conflict and
                                                 It’s also rewarding for the winners. They         the wave of migrants from Central America;
                                            deserve all the recognition they get for putting       and Al Jazeeera America for reports on U.S.
                                            their lives on the line to bring us their accounts     military workers and the war in Gaza. One
                                            of wars, epidemics and disasters. This year’s          photographer, Marcus Bleasdale, won one
                                            winners took us to the front lines of the fight        award and one citation for his visceral images
                                            against Ebola in West Africa; to eastern               from the Central African Republic, where a
                                            Ukraine whose fields were littered with the            violent conflict has been raging for years as the
                                            debris of a passenger jet shot down over this          world’s attention was focused elsewhere. His
                                            disputed territory; and to Mexico’s border             work, and that of all the winning journalists and
                                            with the U.S., where an army of children were          photographers this year, is testament to why
                                            seeking refuge from poverty and violence at            we do what we do–those of us who witness
                                            home. One theme that caught the attention of           and those of us who benefit from their courage
                                            judges this year: the horrendous conditions            and skill. It is indeed an honor to honor them.
                                            in which humans toil. HBO set its sights on the
                                            plight of migrant workers building stadiums            FRIEDMAN IS EDITOR-AT-LARGE,
                                            for the 2022 World Cup in Qatar. Al Jazeera            BLOOMBERG NEWS

                                                                                                                                                                         31

r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 31                                                                                                                                           4/17/15 5:06 PM
ANNUAL AWARD WINNERS 2014

        THE HAL BOYLE AWARD                                                   THE BOB CONSIDINE AWARD
        Best newspaper, news service or                                       Best newspaper, news service or online
        online reporting from abroad                                          interpretation of international affairs

                             The New York Times                                                         Los Angeles Times
                             EBOLA FROM THE FRONT LINE                                                  UKRAINE: A NATION TORN APART
                                                                                                        The Los Angeles Times coverage of the
                             When the world’s attention focused on                                      Ukrainian conflict stood out from the
                             the devastating spread of Ebola in West                                    rest for its guts, credibility, originality,
                             Africa, reporters for The New York Times                                   depth and sophistication of interpre-
                             delivered, day after day, foreign corre-                                   tation, and its engaging writing style
                             spondence at its best. In a series of power-                               that made every story a gripping and
                             ful stories, Times correspondents captured                                 compelling read. The intimacy of de-
                             the crisis in all its dimensions – writing                                 tail – the shattered glass of the airport
                             lyrically about the human drama and de-                                    terminal, the magic helmet, the bullet
                             livering smartly analytical pieces about the                               hole described to the second decimal
                             global effort to stop the disease’s spread                                 point, the minibus from hell – combined
        ADAM NOSSITER        and where that effort went wrong. They           SERGEI LOIKO              with sophisticated analysis of how the
          @AdamNossiter      also dug beneath the surface of the un-                                    economic effects disrupted everyone’s
                             folding disaster with stories that showed a                                daily lives. The reporters’ bravery took
                             deep understanding of the continent, writ-                                 us to places we hadn’t seen before.   
                             ing sensitively about the toll the disease
                             was taking on African cultural traditions
                             such as hand-holding in church and kiss-
                                                                                                        SPONSORS: WILLIAM J. HOLSTEIN
                                                                                                        AND RITA SEVELL
                             ing friends and relatives. In the tradition of                             Judges: Amanda Bennett,
                             Hal Boyle, for whom this award is named,                                   freelance; Melissa Pozsgay,
                             Times reporters never shied away from                                      Bloomberg News; Carol Rosenberg,
                             the front lines despite the risk. In one                                   Miami Herald; June Thomas, Slate
                             memorable piece, the Times wrote about
                             the death of a star basketball player in Li-
                                                                                                        CITATION:
                             beria and several generations of a house-
                                                                                                        ANTHONY FAIOLA, GREG MILLER,
                             hold destroyed. In another, a 4-year-old
                                                                                                        KEVIN SULLIVAN AND SOUAD
        NORI ONISHI          orphaned by Ebola roams a clinic looking         CAROL WILLIAMS            MEKHENNET
          @Onishinyt         for someone to take her home, another              @cjwilliamslat          The Washington Post
                             soul adrift.
                                                                                                        FOREIGN FIGHTERS
                             SPONSOR: NORMAN PEARLSTINE
                             IN MEMORY OF JERRY FLINT                         THE ROBERT CAPA GOLD MEDAL AWARD
                             Judges: Scott Kraft, The Los Angeles             Best published photographic reporting from abroad
                             Times; Barry Bearak, formerly of The             requiring exceptional courage and enterprise
                             New York Times; Scott MacLeod,
                             American University of Cairo;                                         MARCUS BLEASDALE
                             Elizabeth Mehren, Boston University                                      @marcusbleasdale
                                                                                                   Instagram: marcusbleasdale
                             JUDGE BEARAK RECUSED HIMSELF
                             FROM FINAL AWARD SELECTION
                                                                                                   Human Rights Watch,
                                                                                                   Foreign Policy and National
                                                                                                   Geographic Magazine
                             CITATION:                                                                 CENTRAL AFRICAN
        HELENE COOPER        (Judge Kraft recused himself
          @helenecooper                                                                                REPUBLIC INFERNO
                             from final citation selection)
                                                                                                       Marcus Bleasdale viscerally captured
                             RICHARD MAROSI                                                            the brutal violence in the Central African
                             AND DON BARTLETTI                                                         Republic at a time when the world’s at-
                             Los Angeles Times                                                         tention was focused on ISIS, Ukraine and
                             PRODUCT OF MEXICO                                                         other crises. His menacing, unnerving im-
                                                                              ages of chaos had a profound impact on the judges. The images
                                                                              place the viewer in the moment in a way that demands and holds
                                                                              attention.

                                                                              SPONSOR: TIME MAGAZINE

                                                                              CITATION:
        SHERI FINK                                                            (Judge Pancho Bernasconi of Getty Images
          @sherifink                                                          recused himself from final citation selection.)
                                                                              JOHN MOORE @jbmoore6400
        AND THE NEW
        YORK TIMES STAFF                                                      Getty Images THE EBOLA CRISIS IN MONROVIA, LIBERIA

        32

r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 32                                                                                                                        4/17/15 5:06 PM
THE OLIVIER REBBOT AWARD                                      FEATURE PHOTOGRAPHY AWARD
        Best photographic reporting from abroad                       Best feature photography published in any
        in magazines or books                                         medium on an international theme

                             JEROME SESSINI                                                  RODRIGO ABD
                               @itsnotme3                                                      @rodrigoAbd
                             Magnum Photos,                                                  Associated Press
                             TIME and De Standaard                                           PERU’S ILLEGAL GOLD MINING
                             CRIME WITHOUT PUNISHMENT                                        Rodrigo Abd shines a light on an under-
                             Jerome Sessini’s photographs                                    reported subject, the threat looming for
                             of the wreckage of a Malay-                                     20,000 wildcat gold miners in Peru. His
                             sia Airlines jet shot down over                                 photographs are intimate and straight-
                             eastern Ukraine last year cap-                                  forward, documenting the subject with-
                             tured imagery that is profoundly                                out stylistic trickery, enhancing their
                             elegiac. There is a quiet strength                              journalistic value.
                             that propels the narrative and
                             shows the horrors in a manner
                             that doesn’t make the viewer
                             turn away from what is a difficult
                                                                      SPONSOR: CYMA RUBIN, BUSINESS OF ENTERTAINMENT
                                                                      JUDGES FOR ALL FOUR PHOTOGRAPHY AWARDS:
                             scene to process.                        Pancho Bernasconi, Getty Images; Jim Collins, NBC News; Lucy
                                                                      Gilmour, The Wall Street Journal, Ed Kashi, photographer;
                                                                      Robert Nickelsberg, photographer; Alan Taylor, Atlantic.com
        THE JOHN FABER AWARD
        Best photographic reporting from abroad
        in newspapers or news services
                                                                      THE LOWELL THOMAS AWARD
                             BULENT KILIC                             Best radio or audio news or
                               @kilicbil                              interpretation of international affairs
                             Agence France Presse
                             EUROMAIDAN REVOLUTION                                           PRI’s The World
                             IN KIEV                                                         REPERCUSSIONS OF THE ARAB SPRING
                             Bulent Kilic brings viewers right into                          In a series of stories for PRI, Marine Olivesi
                             Ukraine’s revolution, capturing the                             describes the ordinary people whose
                             chaos of the moment. His work is                                lives have been torn apart by extremism
                             inspired visual reporting under dif-                            around the Middle East, from a young Lib-
                             ficult conditions. Each image can                               yan freedom fighter desperately search-
                             stand alone, and together they                                  ing for a brother who has joined jihadis in
                             form a strong narrative.                                        Syria to the fellow who regrets bring-
                                                                                             ing Chechen fighters into Syria. Olivesi
                                                                                             is a brave, enterprising, creative young
        CITATION:                                                                            reporter who took on an extremely ambi-
        OLIVER WEIKEN                                                 MARINE OLIVESI         tious assignment that goes way beyond
        European Pressphoto Agency                                     @marineolives         the headlines to examine the origins and
        2014 WAR BETWEEN ISRAEL AND HAMAS                                                    outcomes of extremism.

                                                                                             SPONSOR: FELICE LEVIN
                                                                                             Judges: Dorinda Elliott, freelance;
                                                                                             Rick Hornik, SUNY Stony Brook; Sarah
                                                                                             Lubman, Brunswick Group; Alberto
                                                                                             Riva, International Business Times

                                                                                             CITATION:
                                                                                             EMILY HARRIS,
                                                                                             AHMED ABU HAMDA
                                                                                             AND ABU BAKR BASHIR
                                                                                             NPR
                                                                      AARON                  WAR IN GAZA
                                                                      SCHACHTER
                                                                        @worldaaron

                                                                                                                                        33

r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 33                                                                                                             4/17/15 5:06 PM
THE
          ROBERT
          CAPA GOLD
          MEDAL
          AWARD
          WINNER
          MARCUS
          BLEASDALE
          Human Rights
          Watch,
          Foreign Policy
          and National
          Geographic
          Magazine
          CENTRAL AFRICAN
          REPUBLIC INFERNO

          Marcus Bleasdale
          viscerally captured
          the brutal violence
          in the Central
          African Republic at
          a time when the
          world’s attention
          was focused on ISIS,
          Ukraine and other
          crises. His menacing,
          unnerving images
          of chaos had a
          profound impact
          on the judges. The
          images place
          the viewer in the
          moment in a way
          that demands and
          holds attention.

                                  In the Central African Republic, a Christian lies dead
                                  seconds after being shot by Rwandan soldiers. He
                                  had killed a Muslim civilian in revenge for the killing
                                  of his cousin minutes earlier, and was dragging the
                                  body to the fire when peacekeepers shot him. An
                                  example of the hatred boiling over in Bangui, capital
                                  of the CAR. Feb. 9, 2014.

        34

r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 34                                                                  4/17/15 5:06 PM
    35

r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 35       4/17/15 5:06 PM
ANNUAL AWARD WINNERS 2014

        THE DAVID KAPLAN AWARD                                                 THE ED CUNNINGHAM AWARD
        Best TV or video spot news reporting from abroad                       Best magazine reporting in print or
                                                                               online on an international story
                                                                                                      Medium/Matter
                                                                                                      WHOEVER SAVES A LIFE
                                                                                                      In the best tradition of wartime story-
                                                                                                      telling, Aikins’s vivid characters offer
                                                                                                      a truly fresh window into the Syrian
                                                                                                      conflict. The wisecracking, passionate
                                                                                                      young men, a volunteer rescue team in
                                                                                                      Aleppo, remain with us long after read-
                                                                                                      ing. In an inspirational and even funny
                                                                                                      story, Aikins captures the friends’ long-
                                                                                                      ings and doubts with astute empathy.
                                                                                                      Despite intense risks to himself, Aikins
        NICK SCHIFRIN              PHILIP MARAVILLA BEN MULKEY                                        keeps himself out of his understated
            @nickschifrin,           @phil_maravilla
                                                                               MATTHIEU AIKINS        prose, which is enriched by the quiet
        Instagram: nickschifrin;                                                 @mattaikins          photographs of  Tomada. A reminder
        Al Jazeera America CONFLICT IN GAZA                                                           that the essence of war lies in these
                                                                                                      intimate moments, far from the halls of
        The reporting of Nick Shifrin and his crew from Gaza for Al Jazeera
                                                                                                      diplomatic power.
        America distinguished itself in a field crowded with excellence.
        It offered a seamless shifting of perspective from both sides of the                          SPONSOR: FORD MOTOR COMPANY
        border; empathy shown by reports from, in some cases, the living                              Judges: Vivienne Walt, Time; Clay
        rooms of the ordinary people caught in the crossfire; and brevity                             Chandler, freelance; James Graff,
        and wit in writing.                                                                           The Wall Street Journal; Scott
        SPONSOR: BEN AND KAREN SHERWOOD                                                               Johnson, freelance
        Judges: Bob Ivry, Bloomberg News; Alison Fitzgerald, Center
        for Public Integrity; Dean Starkman, Los Angeles Times; Jenny                                 CITATION:
        Strasburg, The Wall Street Journal                                                            PATRICK RADDEN KEEFE
                                                                                                      The New Yorker
                                                                               SEBASTIANO             THE HUNT FOR EL CHAPO
        CITATION: HOLLY WILLIAMS, AGNES REAU, ERIN LYALL,
        JUSTINE REDMAN, ABDI CADANI AND ANDY STEVENSON                         TOMADA
        The CBS Evening News with Scott Pelley HOLY WAR                          @sebastianoTP

        THE EDWARD R. MURROW AWARD
        Best TV or video interpretation or documentary on
        international affairs                                                  THE THOMAS NAST AWARD
                                                                               Best cartoons on international affairs
                              POV, PBS and American
                              Documentary Inc.
                          BIG MEN
                                                                                                      SIGNE WILKINSON
                                                                                                        @signewilk
                          A surprising story that takes the viewer to an                              Philadelphia Daily News
                          unexpected place and introduces uncon-                                      Wilkinson wades into the big story and
                          ventional characters. ``Big Men’’ unpacks a                                 emerges with fresh ideas, delivering an
                          single oil deal, in the Republic of Ghana, and                              alternative take on events explored by
                          examines it, Rashomon-like, from the points                                 others. Her original treatment provokes
                          of view of oilmen, venture capitalists, mili-                               thinking on many of the most important
                          tants, human-rights activists, politicians and                              issues of the day. The missile targeting
                          citizens of other countries who have endured                                terrorists also targets people living near
        RACHEL            the same plight. It reveals a farrago of politics,                          them; the search for the wreckage of
        BOYNTON           corruption and greed that attends the com-                                  Malaysia Airlines flight 370 is made even
          @bigmenthemovie mercialization of natural resources in devel-
                                                                                                      more difficult by an ocean full of floating
                          oping nations. Deeply reported and compel-                                  junk. Signe is often irreverent – and funny.
                          lingly told, this is investigative journalism of
                          the highest order.
                                                                                                      Judges: Robert Sullivan, freelance;
                                   SPONSOR: CBS                                                       Allen Alter, CBS; Peter Goodman,
                                   Judges: Bobby Ghosh, Quartz; Jaime                                 International Business Times; Marcy
                                   FlorCruz, former CNN; Micah Garen,                                 McGinnis, Al Jazeera America; Victor
                                   freelance; Belinda Luscombe, Time                                  Navasky, Columbia Journalism School

                                   CITATION:
                                   MARCELA GAVIRIA
                                   @marcellular
        SIMON KILMURRY             PBS Frontline and ProPublica
             @skilmurry            FIRESTONE AND THE WARLORD

        36

r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 36                                                                                                                   4/17/15 5:06 PM
THE MORTON FRANK AWARD                                                      THE CORNELIUS RYAN AWARD
        Best magazine international business news                                   Best non-fiction book on international affairs
        reporting in print or online
                               Bloomberg Businessweek                                                        EVAN OSNOS
                                  THE HEDGE FUND AND THE DESPOT                                                 @eosnos
                                                                                                             Farrar, Straus & Giroux
                                  Six years after Robert Mugabe brutalized the
                                                                                                            AGE OF AMBITION: CHASING
                                  opposition to win re-election in 2008 as pres-
                                                                                                            FORTUNE, TRUTH AND FAITH IN
                                  ident of Zimbabwe, Bloomberg reporters
                                                                                                            THE NEW CHINA
                                  Cam Simpson and Jesse Westbrook set out
                                  to trace a $100 million cash infusion originat-                            A powerful look into the soul of China
                                  ing from a U.S. hedge fund that helped prop                               as its 1.3 billion inhabitants clamor for
                                  up his dictatorial, financially hard-pressed                              economic and spiritual success after
                                  regime at a crucial moment. In this well-                                 decades of deprivation. The book is
                                  written, diligently researched page-turner,                               distinguished by Osnos’s ability to pen-
                                  Simpson and Westbrook raised the veil on a                                etrate Chinese society at all levels and
                                  series of financial transactions involving the                            tell revealing stories about the country’s
        CAM SIMPSON               Wall Street hedge fund, bankers and mining        breakneck transformation. The writing is elegant, and the first-
           @CamSimpsonNews        companies headquartered in London, shell          hand reporting breaks new ground in explaining the trajectory
                                  companies and a rich platinum mining claim        of today’s China.
                                  in Zimbabwe controlled by the government.
                                                                                    SPONSOR: FRIENDS OF RICHARD THRELKELD
                                  Their account shows how global investments        Judges: Dan Hertzberg, former Bloomberg; John Bussey,
                                  can end up in treacherous hands with ter-         The Wall Street Journal; Joyce Barnathan, International Center
                                  rible unintended consequences. Much of the        for Journalists; Neil Hickey, Columbia Journalism Review
                                  reporting was done from afar after Simpson
                                  went to Zimbabwe with a valid visa, only to
                                  have government officials there threaten his      CITATION:
                                  arrest and force him to flee.                     JACK FAIRWEATHER
                                                                                    Basic Books
                                  SPONSOR: MARC LEMCKE                              THE GOOD WAR: WHY WE COULDN’T WIN
                                  Judges: Allan Dodds Frank, freelance; Walt        THE WAR OR THE PEACE IN AFGHANISTAN
                                  Bogdanich, The New York Times; Richard
                                  Greenberg, NBC; Consuelo Mack, Consuela
                                  Mack Wealth Track
        JESSE                                                                       THE MADELINE DANE ROSS AWARD
        WESTBROOK                 CITATION:                                         Best international reporting in the print medium or online
                                  WILLIAM LANGEWIESCHE                              showing a concern for the human condition
                                  Vanity Fair THE CHAOS COMPANY
                                                                                                             The Virginia Quarterly Review
                                                                                                             THE GHOSTS OF RANA PLAZA
        THE MALCOLM FORBES AWARD                                                                             The Madeline Dane Ross Award goes to
        Best international business news reporting in                                                        the best international reporting in the print
        newspapers, news services or online                                                                  medium showing a concern for the human
                                                                                                             condition. That requirement is impossible to
                                  STEPHEN GREY                                                               quantify – it must be felt. Of the nearly 40
                                  AND REUTERS TEAM                                                           submissions to this category, “The Ghosts
                                     @stephengrey                                                            of Rana Plaza” evoked the deepest of feel-
                                  Reuters                                                                    ings, of sympathy for and outrage over
                                  COMRADE CAPITALISM                                                         the horrendous death of 1,100 workers in
                                  This series of nine stories showed how                                     Dhaka as a result of a factory collapse on
                                  President Vladimir Putin and his billionaire                               April 24, 2013. The piece renders in heart-
                                  friends control the Russian economy and           JASON MOTLAGH            breaking detail the humanity of the victims
                                  siphon off billions of dollars for them-            @jasonmotlagh          and their would-be rescuers, linking them
                                  selves. Reuters was the first news orga-                                   to all of us through the clothing that Bangla-
                                  nization to document how contracts and                                     desh produces in vast quantities for the rest
                                  money moved through offshore tax ha-                                       of the world. Our cheap jeans come at the
                                  vens because it was able to obtain access                                  cost of their lives. The story was painstak-
        to confidential bank and travel databases. The corruption extended                                   ingly reported by Jason Motlagh, movingly
        even to the supply of a Russian rocket to the U.S. space program.                                    photographed by Motlagh and Atish Saha
                                                                                                             and superbly edited and presented by the
        SPONSOR: FORBES MAGAZINE                                                                             Virginia Quarterly Review.
        Judges: William J. Holstein, business journalist/author; Pete
        Engardio,The Boston Consulting Group; Jo Ling Kent, Fox News;
                                                                                                             SPONSOR: LINDA FASULO
                                                                                                             Judges: Howard Chua-Eoan, Bloomberg
        Azmat Khan, Buzzfeed; Leah Nathans Spiro, Riverside Creative
                                                                                                             Businessweek; Jeff Chu, Fast Company;
        Management
                                                                                                             Dorothy Parvaz, Al Jazeera

        CITATION: JO BECKER, STEVEN LEE MYERS                                                                 CITATION: JOSHUA HERSH
                                                                                    ATISH SAHA                The Virginia Quarterly Review,
        AND JIM YARDLEY                                                                @sahaAtish
        The New York Times                                                                                    THE LESSONS OF ATMEH
        PUTIN’S WAY
                                                                                                                                                        37

r2_150185opc_CS5.5.indd 37                                                                                                                            4/17/15 5:07 PM
You can also read