T south african The source of quality content, news and insights - SA Jewish Report
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
t
south african n Volume 23 – Number 15 n 3 May 2019 n 28 Nisan 5779
T h e sour c e of qual i t y co n tent, n ews an d insights
www.sajr.co.za
Art Deco 19th century Royal Worcester hand painted
diamond ring moon vases decorated with irises
SOLD R9,000 SOLD R12,000
Art, antiques, objets d’art , furniture,
and jewellery
Art & antiques auction on 11 May 2019 9:30am Josef Lorenzl,
cold painted bronze and
View upcoming auction highlights at www.rkauctioneers.co.za ivory figurine on agate base
011 789 7422 • 083 675 8468 • 12 Allan Road, Bordeaux, Johannesburg SOLD R8,500
t
south african n Volume 23 – Number 15 n 3 May 2019 n 28 Nisan 5779
T h e sour c e of qual i t y co n tent, n ews an d insights
www.sajr.co.za
South African in shul during San Diego shul shooting
TALI FEINBERG constant threat of rockets there. now,” he says. “South Africa is living in the area expressed their says, referring to the actions
A
“This is a quiet town, and the usually 20 years behind the United shock at the shooting. “I heard the of the current United States
ubrey Meyerowitz, shul is in a quiet lane. There was States, but in security at shuls and news when I got home from shul, administration. “It is a passive or
originally from no security because no one ever public places, South Africa is 20 and was simply flabbergasted,” even active consent to allow them
Johannesburg, was in the expected this to happen here,” years ahead.” says Howard Schachat, originally to behave in a way they would
Chabad shul of Poway, California, says Meyerowitz, who had even He says the America of today from Cape Town. “I’ve been to never have before.
on Saturday when he heard shots seen children playing in the is a different place to what it that shul, and sang in the choir “Ten years ago, I would never
ring out. “It was the first aliyah of reception area of the shul just was when he arrived 23 years for a Barmitzvah there. It’s a have expected something like
the Torah, and I heard three shots. before the shooting. ago, and this kind of terrorism is lovely community. I was in tears this to happen in San Diego, but
I dropped to the floor now, with neo-Nazis saying
under the seats, and stayed ‘Jews will not replace us’
there.
“The whole thing took ‘In the face of darkness, spread light’ in Charlottesville, it’s a
different paradigm, and
only about 30 seconds to a Jews will always be the
minute but I counted about scapegoat.”
15 shots fired. I heard Daniel Weiss, also
women screaming and men originally from Cape Town,
shouting.” attends the shul, and his
He says there were about children go to Hebrew
70 or 80 people in shul school there.
– way more than were in It is a ten minute drive
the Pittsburgh shul when from where he lives, “and
Photo: Ilan Ossendryver
a shooting claimed eleven this definitely hit too close
lives six months earlier. to home”, he says. “It’s a
But, in this instance, huge shock, but in a way
more deaths were it could also be expected,
prevented because the especially in the US. Until
shooter’s gun jammed, and the laws change, it has just
he was confronted by a become too easy to get a
shul member who had been gun,” Weiss says.
in the military. “As soon He attended a vigil
as the shooting stopped, on the night after the
I ran out of an emergency shooting, along with
exit, so I never saw the hundreds of other people.
carnage,” says Meyerowitz. “The eight-year-old girl
But he knew the woman who was injured in the
who was killed in the attack was there. It wasn’t
attack, Lori Gilbert-Kaye. only a Jewish event, but a
“She was a wonderful, San Diego event, with an
charitable person, and her Praying for solidarity and unity at amazing blend of people,
family was at shul every the mayor and a senator.”
Chabad House in Johannesburg on
Shabbos.” The rabbi of He says the turnout
the congregation, Yisroel Tuesday night, following attacks on demonstrated that people
Goldstein, lost two fingers the Chabad of Poway shul were deeply affected by the
in the attack, but managed shooting way beyond the
to keep calm, and even Jewish community.
finish his sermon before Claire Ellman, originally
being taken to hospital. An from Johannesburg, has
Israeli man, Almog Peretz, and his “The attitude has been ‘no becoming an everyday occurrence. watching the rabbi speak after the known Rabbi Goldstein for 30
eight-year-old niece, Noya Dahan, one will worry us, we don’t have It is something he never could shooting.” years while working on Jewish
were also injured. They had moved a fight with anyone, and we’re have imagined when he made San “It’s almost like a lid of education projects. More recently,
to San Diego from Sderot (on a welcoming community’. But Diego his home. permission has been opened she interacted with him through
the Gaza border) to escape the obviously that will have to change Other South African expats for white supremacists,” he
Continued on page 5>>
IF YOU DON’T VOTE YOU CAN’T KVETCH
This year’s Great Debates saw leaders from several political parties discuss issues
pertinent to the community.
Now’s your chance to cast your vote and make your voice heard. #MakeUsCount
2 SA JEWISH REPORT si
n Br
i e f • • Wo
rld 3 – 10 May 2019
ew N
Third record year for
ew
N
its suburbs. The CDC pinned the Terrorism Bureau on Thursday,
rld
Appliance Repairs on Site
si
r i e f • • Wo
nB
resurgence on the unvaccinated, four days after a terror attack
Canadian anti-Semitism
r i e f • • Wo r l
, and those who brought back at eight churches and hotels in
a shers Anti-Semitic incidents in Canada rose to a measles from other countries. three cities in Sri Lanka that
in B
ishw toves
ws
record high for the third consecutive year, Prominent rabbis in New York killed at least 359 people and
dN
D , S
Ne
, s
e
w
s n e
si
ge Machi
according to an annual audit by B’nai Brith have called on their followers to injured hundreds. It called on
d
orl nB
••W rief
id g
Canada released on Monday. vaccinate their children. Israelis already in Sri Lanka to leave
Fr shin The audit showed 2 041 anti-Semitic as soon as possible, and for those planning
a s & more
W ble Dryer French philosopher afraid
incidents recorded last year in Canada – trips to cancel or delay those plans.
16.5% more than the 1 752 incidents in
Tum Call Jason 2017. to appear in public Buenos Aires honours
082 401 8239 / 076 210 6532 “This represents the third straight record- Alain Finkielkraut, a Jewish philosopher
breaking year for anti-Semitism in Canada, and one of France’s foremost thinkers, Olympic swimmer
FREE QUOTATIONS reflecting a ‘new normal’ regarding the said far-left protests against him meant he Argentinean Olympic swimmer Damian
landscape of anti-Semitism here,” said Ran could no longer show his face on the street. Blaum, who started his career at a Jewish
Ukashi, the director of B’nai Brith Canada’s Finkielkraut made the remark in sports club in Buenos Aires, was honoured
League for Human Rights. response to recent protests against him at by the Buenos Aires City Parliament as
Eighty percent of the incidents came the Sciences Po university in Paris, where an “outstanding sports personality” in
from online platforms such as Facebook, he spoke at a symposium on Europe’s recognition of his career.
Instagram, and YouTube. future. The Jewish athlete in February 2018 set
The demonstrators wrote, “We cannot a new record for swimming from Uruguay
US measles outbreak accept Finkielkraut’s ‘modern Europe’
and his islamophobic, racist, sexist and
to Argentina, crossing the Rio de la Plata
river in 9 hours, 6 minutes, a distance of
tops 700 homophobic rhetoric.” Commenting on about 26 miles (41.8km).
The measles outbreak in the United States, the protesters, Finkielkraut said, “You are
• All briefs supplied by JTA
especially prevalent among haredi orthodox the fascists. You are the 1930s. You are the
Jews, has topped 700 cases – the most in anti-Semites.”
one year since the Center
Shabbat times this week
for Disease Control (CDC)
declared the disease
Israel issues Sri Lanka Starts Ends
eliminated in the US in travel warning 17:19
17:46
18:08
18:38
Johannesburg
Cape Town
2000. Israel recently issued a travel warning of a
17:02 17:52 Durban
The record outbreak of “high and concrete (terror) threat” in Sri
17:22 18:12 Bloemfontein
704 cases reported last Lanka.
week by the CDC includes The warning was issued by the Israel
17:17 18:09 Port Elizabeth
400 cases in New York and National Security Council’s Counter- 17:09 18:01 East London
Torah Thought
Moral is normal
I
f anyone was bent on convincing us that Man-made laws are forever being Ultimately, morality
Torah was old-fashioned, this would be a amended to suit changing times and cannot be decided
good Parsha to prove it. Leviticus, Chapter circumstances. When a new super-highway by referendum. We
18, contains the Bible’s Immorality Act. Our is built, traffic officials may decide that it is desperately need
moral code, the forbidden relationships, who safe to raise the speed limit. Should there a higher authority Rabbi Yossy
Goldman
may marry whom and who may not – all be a fuel shortage, these same officials may to guide us in the Sydenham Shul
come from this week’s reading. decide to lower the speed limit in order to often confusing
We read this same chapter every year conserve the energy supply. dilemmas of life. In Egypt and Canaan, lots
on Yom Kippur afternoon. And every year But G-d’s laws are constant, consistent of degenerate behaviour was acceptable,
in every shul around the world someone and eternal. Divine legislation governs even popular. In this week’s Torah reading,
asks the very same question. “Why on moral issues. Values, ethics, right and G-d tells His people that He expects us to
Yom Kippur, Rabbi? Was there no other wrong, these are eternal, never-changing march to a different beat. We are called
section of the Torah to choose besides the issues. Humankind has been confronting upon to be a holy nation, distinctively
one about illicit sex? Is this an appropriate these problems since time immemorial. different in this, the most challenging test
choice to read in shul on the holiest day of From cavemen to Attila the Hun to nuclear of our morality. It doesn’t matter what is
the year?” superpowers, the essential issues really legal or trendy in Egypt, Canaan, America,
Fair question. So the Rabbis explain have not changed very much. Questions or Scandinavia. We have our own moral
that this is, in fact, the ultimate test of our of moral principle, good and evil, have guide, our own book of books which
holiness. The most challenging arena of been there from the very beginning. These requires no editing or revised editions for
VEHICLES WANTED
human conduct, the one that really tests questions are timeless. the new age.
the mettle of our morality, is not how we So we read that adultery was forbidden When the Torah teaches us to be holy
behave in synagogue but how we behave in Moses’ day, and it still is in ours. So is and distinctive, it is reminding us to be
in our bedrooms. To conduct ourselves incest. But it wouldn’t shock me at all if normal, not average. Average can be rather
appropriately in public is far easier than to the same forces motivating for new sexual mediocre. Just be normal, and retain your
be morally consistent in our intimate lives. freedoms soon began campaigning for Jewish uniqueness. It may not be easy. It
Old-fashioned? You bet. In a world of incestuous relationships to become legal. may not always be politically correct either.
ever-changing, relative morality where Shocking? Why? If it’s all about consenting You probably will not win any popularity
absolutely anything and everything goes, adults, why deny siblings? Given the contests. But you will be faithful to the
the Torah does, indeed, seem rather slippery slope of our moral mountains, eternal truths of life. And in the long run,
antiquated. nothing is unthinkable any more. you will be right. And happy.
Editor Peta Krost Maunder – editor@sajewishreport.co.za • Sub-editor Julie Leibowitz
Journalists: Nicola Miltz • Tali Feinberg • Jordan Moshe
T h e so u r c e o f q u a lit y c o n t e n t , n e w s a n d in sig h t s
Editorial co-ordinator Martine Bass – editorial@sajewishreport.co.za
Any make, any model, any condition Proofreader Kim Hatchuel – kim@a-proofed.co.za • CEO Dani Kedar – ceo@sajewishreport.co.za • Advertising Britt Landsman: 082 292 9520
– britt@sajewishreport.co.za • Design and layout Bryan Maron/Design Bandits – bryan@designbandits.co.za
Accident damaged vehicles and non-runners also wanted Subscriptions Avusa Publishing (Pty) Ltd. Tel: 0860 525 200 • Board of Directors Howard Sackstein (Chairperson), Herby Rosenberg, Dina Diamond, Herschel Jawitz,
Shaun Matisonn, Benjy Porter. Advertisements and editorial copy do not neccessarily reflect the views of the editor, staff and board of directors. Tel: 011 430 1980.
% Arnold AUTO
Orkin 082 823 7826
AFRICA
The SA Jewish Report subscribes to the Code of Ethics and Conduct for South African Print and Online Media that prescribes news that is truthful, accurate,
fair and balanced. If we don’t live up to the Code, within 20 days of the date of publication of the material, please contact the Public Advocate at 011 484 3612,
fax: 011 484 3619. You can also contact our Case Officer on khanyim@ombudsman.org.za or lodge a complaint on their website: www.presscouncil.org.za
3 – 10 May 2019 SA JEWISH REPORT 3
Hearing from the parties prior to elections
The SA Jewish Report attempted to interview all the leaders of the main parties running for election. In this edition, we secured interviews with the African Christian Democratic
Party (page 11), African National Congress (on this page), Congress of the People (page 10), Economic Freedom Fighters (page 9), Freedom Front Plus (page 10), Inkatha Freedom
Party (page 4), and United Democratic Movement (page 10). Leaders of the Democratic Alliance, and the Capitalist Party of South Africa were interviewed in previous editions.
Embassy downgrade not yet considered by cabinet, says Ramaphosa
TALI FEINBERG of the past decade, we stand ready to seize slumped more in the past 12 years than any weight to enterprise and supplier development.
P
these opportunities. For this, we need policy other nation that is not at war, but the president “Understanding that small businesses struggle
resident Cyril Ramaphosa revealed in a certainty and consistency, clean and effective insists we have begun to turn things around. to access markets, we are setting aside more
pre-election interview with the SA Jewish government, and a vibrant and innovative “We achieved a five-year high in foreign direct government-procurement opportunities for
Report that the decision to downgrade business community. Most importantly, we need investment in the past year, reaching R70.7 SMMEs [small and medium-sized enterprises].
South Africa’s embassy in Tel Aviv had “not been young, skilled South Africans who are motivated billion in 2018, up from R26.8 billion in 2017. We are encouraged by efforts from the private
considered yet by cabinet”. to make a difference. Through commissions of inquiry into state sector to do more to source goods and services
“Once the cabinet has fully engaged and “Young people need to see an economy capture, SARS [the South African Revenue from small and emerging businesses.
come out with a view on this matter, it will that has doubled in size since the advent of Service], and the Public Investment Corporation, Since taking office, the president has spoken
be communicated to the public. In other democracy, that has created an extra seven we are uncovering details of the wrongdoing many times about his vision for South Africa,
words, we remain seized with the modalities million jobs since 1994, and they need to ask of the past few years, and taking measures to but what is he doing to ensure that this is carried
of downgrading the South African embassy in themselves what they can do to make our address them. out – with or without him? “It is essential
Israel, and this matter has not been finalised,” economy grow even faster and create even more “We have made changes at the NPA, at SARS, that we build strong institutions that uphold
he said. jobs. in the police service, and in state security. We our constitution, promote the rule of law, and
This is direct contradiction to recent “It is for this reason that we are focusing effort are strengthening those institutions responsible advance the interests of South Africans,” he
comments by the Minister of International and resources on improving access to quality for investigating and prosecuting corruption. said. “Just as these institutions need to be free
Relations and Cooperation, Lindiwe Sisulu, from undue influence by any individual or
who said that the downgrade had already group, they should not be reliant on any
President Cyril Ramaphosa
begun. one individual. That is why I have spent
“South Africa is playing a constructive role much of the past year working to rebuild
in the Middle East,” the president continued, public institutions and mend relations
“and we use every opportunity that avails between government, business, labour,
itself to engage with all states in this region, and communities.”
including the Palestinians and Israelis. We Asked how he will keep extremists like
continue to host high-level talks and receive the EFF [Economic Freedom Fighters] at
numerous delegations from Israel and bay, the president responded, “South Africa
Palestine. We hope to intensify this in the is a strong and robust democracy. Without
future.” a popular mandate, no organisation
Asked if he still welcomed foreign direct – extremist or not – will be able to
investment by Israel, the president said, exercise influence over the policies and
“South Africa welcomes investment in our programmes of the state.”
economy from any investor that respects our In December 2018, the ANC
laws and supports the development of our parliamentary caucus signed a co-operation
economy.” agreement with Hamas. The SA Jewish
Turning to his own government ahead of Report asked the president how the ANC
next week’s elections, he assured the Jewish could align itself with such an organisation.
community that he continued to root out Ramaphosa responded that the agreement
corruption. “Those who have been accused was still being considered by the ANC as
of corrupt practices must be held to account education – from early childhood to university We are rebuilding state institutions, and have it had not been seen by all its structures. “I am
in terms of the law, without fear, favour, or – and why we have prioritised getting youth put capable boards in place to drive turnaround certain that it does not call for all the things you
prejudice. That is why we are establishing an into employment. Therein lies the future of the strategies at state-owned enterprises. Through mention, because this would be against our own
investigating directorate in the NPA [National country.” these and other efforts, we are working to constitution and beliefs as a nation.”
Prosecuting Authority] and have established a Regarding our massive crime problem, rebuild confidence among investors, business Asked what he could say to our community
special SIU [Special Investigation Unit] tribunal Ramaphosa said, “Building an inclusive economy people, and the South African public.” to convince it not to abandon South Africa,
to fast track the recovery of funds lost to the and dramatically reducing unemployment are The president said one of the greatest he responded, “We are not in denial about
state from corruption. essential to our efforts to overcome crime. As impediments to the growth of small business the huge challenges we still face, nor about
“I have no doubt that the law-enforcement we undertake this work, we are also improving was the continued dominance in some markets the severe impact that state capture and
agencies will act against those implicated in policing by, among other things, moving of established players. “Through interventions corruption has had on our economy, public
criminal activity, but must do so through due resources to station level, where the fight against like the new Competition Amendment Act, we institutions, and general levels of trust within
legal process. If we want to build strong, durable crime is most effective. aim to tackle monopolistic and anti-competitive society.
institutions, we must guard against arbitrary He said the police service was building practices, and create space for new entrants into But, “We have the opportunity to turn this
actions by those in power,” he said. better relations with communities, and “we are the economy. around. We have shown in the short space of
As described in this issue of the SA Jewish strengthening our capacity to tackle gangsterism “We are significantly expanding support a year that – as government, business, labour,
Report (see page 8), many young people are and organised crime. We have taken steps over for small businesses through our business- and other social partners – we are determined
considering leaving South Africa. Discussing why the past year to clean up the police service and incubation programme, opening up incubators to make a clear break with corruption,
they should stay, the president said, “Despite other law enforcement agencies so that they in townships and rural areas, where there is patronage, policy incoherence, and economic
its challenges, despite its history, South Africa are focused on the task of promoting safety and a great demand for assistance. Through the mismanagement. We are not merely saying
has abundant opportunities. Now, as we make security.” revisions we made to the BEE [black economic we are on a path of renewal. Our actions
a firm break with the difficulties and mistakes South Africa’s economic performance has empowerment] codes, we have given additional prove it.”
INVEST IN PROPERTY IN ISRAEL
FROM R5 MILLION REAL
Contact Herschel Jawitz in strict confidence
082 571 1829 | herschel@jawitz.co.za LIFE Real Estate.
NEW RELEASE | ON SHOW THIS SUNDAY NEW RELEASE | ON SHOW THIS SUNDAY NEW RELEASE | ON SHOW THIS SUNDAY ON SHOW THIS SUNDAY
LINKSFIELD | R1.390 MILLION GLENHAZEL / SUNNINGDALE | R 2.799 MILLION GLENHAZEL | R 1.999 MILLION WAVERLEY | R 5.2 MILLION
306 Linksfield Place. A light feel imbues this sunny, 123m2 11 Dale Road. A well-loved, north facing, 4 bedroomed family 91 Swemmer Road. This north facing, 6 bedroomed Versatile, family residence with so much to offer. Three
apartment. Views on all sides, overlooking the lights of home. 3 spacious, interleading reception rooms which lead comfortable family home will offer space and security for a receptions, eat-in kitchen, guest cloak, huge downstairs
Linksfield by night, and the trees of sports fields, by day. out onto a covered, entertainers patio. Fitted study. A child large or growing family. Inviting open plan reception areas suite of rooms, 3 additional ensuite bedrooms upstairs. 3
2 double bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, MES. Super enclosed friendly garden with glorious pool. Huge eat in kitchen, lead out to patio and pool area in secure child friendly garden. garages, staff accommodation & a pool. A home worthy of
balcony. Excellent security. Beautiful large grounds. 2 x Staff accommodation, double lock up garage and carport. A well fitted kitchen with a seperate Pesach kitchenette. Staff your attention. Directions: East along Bruce, right into Knox.
Directions: from Northfield Ave into Leigh or Swemmer into accommodation. Directions: From Northfield Avenue into
secure parkings. Pool in complex. Follow boards on Club
Street, to Linksfield Place. Opposite KD School. Dale Road. Leigh into Rosemary Road.
2 2 Web Ref: RL50921 4 2 Web Ref: RL50907 Web Ref: RL50242 4 4 Web Ref: RL11839
6 2
Ingrid Hoaten 082 490 6246 Joel 082 926 0287 | Laureen 083 789 0229 Joel 082 926 0287 | Laureen 083 789 0229 Chrissie Hammer 082 568 0440 | 011 880 3550
4 SA JEWISH REPORT 3 – 10 May 2019
Poway shooting exposes the fractured state of communal discourse
influences drove him to murder and Jewish hatred, except to go to the
terror. thesaurus? They’re a “scourge”, a
OPINION What we don’t hesitate to do in “disease”, a “poison”, a “pathology”.
the absence of hard information: But that formula has changed, like
Photo: David McNew/Getty Images
draw our own conclusions; lay blame; just about everything else, certainly
Andrew Silow-
Carroll – JTA wedge the shooter’s scant bio into in the past three years, and perhaps
H
the political frameworks that we’ve over a decade and more.
ere’s what we know about already erected. Jews can no longer agree on how
the shooter who took the The “react” story has long been to regard anti-Semitism. The left
life of a worshipper at a San a staple of ethnic journalism. After focuses on a far right energised by
Diego area Chabad and wounded a big global or national event, the rise of nationalist populism and
three others: he was a white, 19-year- you round up the reactions of, in politicians whose own nativist views
old college student who grew up in our case, Jewish organisations. sound awfully familiar to historians
an Orthodox Presbyterian church, Rarely are these condemnations or of hate. The right sees anti-Israelism
and he may or may not have tried celebrations surprising or even very as the “new anti-Semitism”, and People embrace
to set fire to a nearby mosque last interesting. Sympathy at natural regards as the biggest threat those outside the
month, perhaps inspired by the calamities, outrage at man-made whose support for the Palestinians Congregation
terrorist attacks at two mosques in ones, thumbs up or thumbs down quickly devolves into classic anti- Chabad
synagogue in
Christchurch, New Zealand. when the story is political, depending Jewish “tropes”. Centrists are
Poway, California
What we didn’t know: why he on your ideology. criticised for trying to straddle the
targeted a synagogue; why he wanted As to anti-Semitism reactions, line because failing to take sides
Jews to die; what combination how many ways can an organisation means they are weak on [insert your The dynamic was on display in of political commentary and into Der
of personal madness and outside express its dismay at acts of anti- enemy here]. the hours after the shooting at the Sturmer territory.
Poway Chabad. The Anti-Defamation Unlike Bend the Arc, however, the
Buthelezi proud to tell truth about Israel
TALI FEINBERG mediator for peace.”
League (ADL), long the community’s
compass on anti-anti-Semitism,
avoided the blame game.
Friends of the Wiesenthal Center
statement did not point fingers at
the American president or mention
He has visited Israel a number of times and formed close “It’s heartbreaking to see yet the actual Nazis who marched at
“The reason the Jewish community should vote for the bonds with its leaders, from Shimon Peres to Ariel Sharon another tragedy on Shabbat, on Charlottesville or ran as Republicans
Inkatha Freedom Party (IFP) is the same reason any South to Benjamin Netanyahu. “So, when people denigrate me the last day of Passover, exactly in last year’s midterms. Instead it
African should vote for the IFP: we are trustworthy. We for supporting Israel, I pity their ignorance. As far as my six months after the shooting condemned college students and
have a proven track record of leadership integrity and politics is concerned, I have always supported a two-state at the Tree of Life synagogue in professors who support the boycott
clean governance. There is nothing our country needs solution. I made this clear again in September 2015 when Pittsburgh,” which claimed 11 lives, of Israel, and leftist political leaders
more,” says Prince Mangosuthu Buthelezi, speaking to the I visited Israel at the kind invitation of the South African the ADL wrote on Saturday. like the British Labour Party’s
SA Jewish Report ahead of the national elections. Friends of Israel, together with several senior political But the ADL also didn’t look to Jeremy Corbyn and Republican Ilhan
“This is the most contested election South Africa has leaders,” he says. include the Poway shooting into Omar, “who have been accused of
faced. There are 48 options “It is counter-productive some sort of grab bag of anti-Jewish promoting anti-Semitism and of
on the ballot paper. But only for South Africa to escalate threats on the left and the right, trying to create a wedge between
one option is right for South tensions by taking sides. which has become the safe way to their countries and the State of
Africa. The IFP understands Having experienced our own talk about anti-Semitism. Instead it Israel”. It also singled out the United
that our nation’s future is history, we must surely be compared the shooting only to the Nations for its “baffling” anti-Israel
indivisible. There will be no champions of dialogue and recent attacks carried out by white, resolutions.
justice for one community negotiation. We should be male lone wolves – Christchurch, There was still another approach,
while another still suffers. We encouraging both sides to Pittsburgh – and to the far-right hate which was to find the commonalities
either swim together, or sink continue in dialogue so that a fest at Charlottesville. among the various brands of
together,” he says. two-state solution can become Others saw in Poway a reflection contemporary anti-Semitism.
As he pointed out at a reality. of their worst fears and bêtes noires. “The anti-Semitic intersection of
the Jewish community’s “We saw here in our own For a left-wing group like Bend the white nationalism, anti-Zionism,
celebration of his 90th country that intractable Arc: Jewish Action, the blame lay and Islamic Jew-hatred is to render
birthday last year, he has a problems could not be resolved squarely on the White House and its the Jews isolated and powerless,”
long history with Jews in with violence and armed current occupant. tweeted Einat Wilf, who served in
South Africa. When he was conflict.” “Although it may be hard to the Israeli Knesset as a member
a student at the University Buthelezi says he is proud to accept, the fact that we witnessed of the Labor and Independence
of Fort Hare, he became a Prince tell the truth about Israel and yet another act of white nationalist parties. “Each feeds off the others
member of the National Union Mangosuthu Buthelezi his friendship with the Jewish violence is sadly not ‘hard to believe’, as evidence that Jews have no
of South African Students. community. “Israel is the only as President Trump said in response allies, and therefore could be
“A number of our leaders were Jewish. As I became more country in the Middle East that allows freedom of religion, to the shooting,” Bend the Arc said. bullied, maligned, injured, and
and more involved in the liberation struggle, I met and freedom of expression, press freedom, and gender equality. “Not when the President and his killed, with no consequences.”
befriended many more Jewish leaders who were working Rather than cutting ties, South Africa needs to engage allies have helped mainstream white Unsurprisingly, this common
toward the same goals of political franchise, equality, and with Israel, he says. “The best way to learn is to engage. nationalism in American politics.” cause approach is rarely the way
social justice in South Africa. When we engage, meaningful change becomes possible. Compare that to the Friends of Twitter, where the left-right
“I was impressed by their sense of patriotism and The biggest test of true leadership is being able to do or of the Simon Wiesenthal Center divide is often on full display.
responsibility. The cause of justice and freedom was so say a difficult thing, as long as it is the right thing to do or for Holocaust Studies, a Canadian Either modern anti-Semitism
naturally their own cause, even when this was not their say. To be out of step with a battalion is the greatest test of affiliate of the Los Angeles-based is Trump’s fault, or the Boycott
fight. Duty, faith, and the knowledge of truth led them to leadership.” Simon Wiesenthal Center. Israel movement is the greatest
make it their fight.” Even in the midst of social crises, he believes education The Friends group was fast out danger facing the Jews. That
His Jewish compatriots included Helen Suzman and her must continue. “Education must be prioritised. No matter of the gate with a statement saying New York Times cartoon was the
husband, Dr Mosie Suzman, “who opened the doors of what the political circumstances, whether we are fighting that, “anti-Semitism and hate at result of vicious anti-Zionism
their home to us when we were in Johannesburg during for freedom, or fighting for a democracy that overcomes large continues to increase year to gone mainstream or part of the
those [apartheid] days. So did Clive and Irene Menell.” He inequality, education remains at the heart of our fight. year as nationalist white supremacist coarsening of the public discourse
was also close to Professor Phillip Tobias. “Let us teach our children the truth. Let us speak to groups expand globally”, but led by the “alt-right”.
“Arnold Zulman and his beautiful wife, Rosemary, have the next generation. Let us equip them to look beyond expanded the camera view to include For many there appears to be
nurtured our friendship for the past 50 years of my life. hashtags and populist slogans, beyond propaganda, “extreme leftists [who] unfairly and a fear that if the focus turns to
We went to shul with them, and attended their children’s and reductionist arguments. Let us give them a solid hypocritically defame Israel and one side of the political spectrum,
Barmitzvahs. Mr Zulman sometimes received calls from foundation by teaching them what has come before. radical Islamists [who] push an anti- we’ll go soft on the anti-Semitism
anonymous white voices in the dead of the night saying, And then, let us support them as they begin to build the Zionist agenda”. coming from the other side.
‘We know that you have Buthelezi in your home.’ He was future,” he says. It also included in its statement The historian Deborah Lipstadt
unfazed by this kind of intimidation. Buthelezi will be stepping down as party leader after the a condemnation of what normally notes this politicisation of anti-
“The simple fact is that most of the white South Africans elections. “I will continue as president of the IFP until our would have been the most anti-Semitism in her new book,
who were at the forefront of our liberation struggle were national elective conference, where a new leadership will outrageous anti-Semitic act of 28 Antisemitism: Here and Now.
Jewish. All the white South Africans who were arrested be elected. Our structures have unanimously nominated April 2019: a cartoon that appeared “Don’t see anti-Semitism
with Nelson Mandela were Jews,” he says. “Maybe the Secretary General Mayor Velenkosini Hlabisa to stand for in the New York Times international only on the other side of the
fact that the Jewish people have endured persecution for election. I myself will not stand.” edition depicting Israeli Prime political transom from which
centuries made them the kind of compassionate people Buthelezi is grieving the loss of his beloved wife, Minister Benjamin Netanyahu as you are located,” she warned in
that most of them are.” Princess Irene, who passed away in March after a long a guide dog (a guide dachshund, an interview with the Jewish
Buthelezi says he disagrees with the decision taken by illness. After the elections, he intends to spend time with actually), leading a blind Trump. The Telegraphic Agency. “If you’re only
the African National Congress to downgrade South Africa’s his grandchildren and stay involved in serving the country dog’s collar has a Star of David, and seeing it on the opposite side of the
Embassy in Israel. “It is short-sighted and regressive. in one way or another. “I have done this for more than 60 Trump is wearing a black yarmulke, transom, you’re instrumentalising
Moreover, it stands in opposition to our country’s role as a years. It is part of who I am.” pushing the cartoon out of the realm this for political purposes.”
3 – 10 May 2019 SA JEWISH REPORT 5
EFF turns Easter message
into anti-Israel diatribe
JORDAN MOSHE and his Jewish roots just like they
B
try to separate Jewish roots from
lending a religious message Israel.”
with a political one, the Also expressing outrage is the
Economic Freedom Fighters African Christian Democratic
(EFF) recently suggested that Jesus Party (ACDP) leader, Reverend
was a Palestinian. Wishing South Kenneth Meshoe, who said that
Africans well over Easter, the party there was absolutely no place for
descended into political criticism of such use of religious figures in the
Israel and blatant anti-Semitism. wilful distortion of history. In a
Wishing the public a “happy and responding statement, he said, “The
revolutionary Easter weekend” is ACDP condemns the unacceptable
how the message issued on 18 April habit of the EFF of releasing
by EFF spokesperson Mbuyiseni statements during Easter and
Quinton Ndlozi began. The party Passover alleging that Jesus Christ
then went on to caution people to was a Palestinian.
travel safely and drink responsibly. “I appeal to […] the leadership of
Mentioning the last supper, the EFF to respect our faith, and
the statement reminded readers stop spreading lies about Jesus
to be mindful of the needy, and Christ. All honest South Africans
to “prioritise the poor and less and people around the world know
privileged as the best embodiment that Jesus was born in Bethlehem
of Christ today”.
Immediately thereafter, the
of Judea, not Palestine. When Jesus
was born, the word Palestine was
South African in shul during San Diego shul shooting
religious message turned political. not even coined. The EFF’s political >>Continued from page 1
Reminding readers that Palestine is goal of trying to undermine the the Friendship Circle programme she runs out of his structured, facilitated groups to learn how hate breeds
“the birth and death place of Jesus state of Israel is rejected with the shul. She also knew Gilbert-Kaye – “she worked on many hate and love and understanding breeds love.”
Christ”, the EFF urged solidarity contempt it deserves.” tzedakah projects including the Friendship Circle”. Cheryl Horn, originally from Cape Town, says she knew
with the people of modern-day The South African Jewish Board Ellman said when she first heard of the shooting, she Rabbi Goldstein, and was horrified and shocked. “Today
Palestine, whom it said, “represent of Deputies (SAJBD) said that was shocked. “We had been at another shul for Shabbat and yesterday there were police cars outside our shul, and
the suffering, permanently Ndlozi’s invocation of the viciously morning, last day Pesach and when I dropped off the kids at
crucified, disfigured, and humiliated anti-Semitic “Christ-killer” Yizkor with our kids and four Hebrew day school this morning,
naked body of Christ hanging on imagery to defame the Jewish grandkids. We left near the end, there were cop cars there too.”
the summit for all shame”. state was deplorable, if predictable. and a police car pulled up at the Daniela Peiser Levi, who lived
This state of affairs is attributed According to Associate Director very secure entrance to our shul in Cape Town for a number
to Israel, described as being David Saks, this slander against and asked the guard to step up to of years, knew Gilbert-Kaye
guilty of “racial discrimination, the Jewish people is historically the van. We thought it was a bit through friends and her
colonisation and apartheid”. The one of the most pernicious, strange, but didn’t think much husband had gone to the Chabad
EFF asked the public not only inciting anti-Jewish bigotry and of it until we got home and a shul several times.
to pray for the oppressed, but frequently even acts of murderous friend called to tell me what had She says people “are on one
“participate in the international violence against Jewish happened. I learnt that Lori had hand feeling scared, like me. On
isolation of the apartheid state communities everywhere. been murdered only later that the other hand, it does unite
of Israel until they recognise “Likening the alleged crimes afternoon.” the community, and there is
Palestinian rights to equality and by Israel today with what Jews She says she never imagined a beauty in how everyone is
return of their land”. were supposedly guilty of twenty this could happen there, “but Rabbi Yisroel coming together to remember
The party’s appropriation of centuries ago has the obviously we are South Africans and are in Goldstein and Lori and those that were injured
a religious figure for political intended effect of portraying Jews Israel a lot, and we see the rise of Lori Gilbert-Kaye and to stand strong against hate.
ends and its suggestion that as being cruel and evil by nature,” anti-Semitism all over the world “We will continue to go to shul
Jesus was a Palestinian has been he says. “Whereas all mainstream and the dysfunctional individuals as always, but there is definitely
widely condemned. According to Christian movements have now who have access to guns in this a heightened sense of security
Benji Shulman, the director of distanced themselves from such country. Every week, it’s another at the shuls, the schools, and
public policy at the South African venomous ideologies, the EFF shooting. We had one of our community events. A friend of
Zionist Federation (SAZF), this appears to be quite comfortable to mosques burnt just last week by ours is organising the logistics of
appropriation is something the EFF fall back on the crudest medieval- an unknown arsonist. There’s a combination of hate and the funeral, which is expected to have a large turnout.”
does frequently, even in the face of era rhetoric and imagery in order violence being accepted values, having access to guns, Her first reaction when she heard of the shooting was
obvious historical truths. to demonise not only Israel but the and the now more open acceptance of being anti-Jew and fear, “as it hit really close to home. Poway is within the
“Jesus was a Jew from Judea,” Jewish people as a whole. anti-Muslim.” San Diego Jewish community, and we are all connected. It
says Shulman. “Unfortunately, a “The SAJBD rejects it with the To the South African Jewish community, she says, could have been any one of us. It just takes one person to
statement like this smacks of classic contempt it deserves, and all “Never be complacent! Keep your eyes open. Continue create a horror. My reaction was to let those I love know
Christian anti-Semitism, because decent-minded South Africans will with the great work of your CSO [Community Security how much they meant to me, and to give my kids extra
they are trying to separate Jesus surely do likewise.” Organisation]. Kids need to meet with other faiths in hugs and kisses. I want to keep them safe.”
SUNFOIL
KLEINE COOKING OIL
3499
DRAKEN
RED GRAPE JUICE
4299 750ml
NEGW
FR
AR
SU EE ! BISHUL
YISROEL
2L
Yummy!!
63 99
TONI
CAPE POINT
GLASS TONIC
WATER. ASSTD FLAV Macon Roll SHREDDED TUNA
SILVER STREAM
MUSHROOMS
19
IN BRINE PCS & STEMS
99 with fried egg
1.5L
each
Offers valid till 8 May or while stocks last
1399 170g
each 1199 250g
1 Long Avenue, Glenhazel 011 440 9517 | info@kosherworld.co.za | www.kosherworld.co.za Actual offers may differ from visuals shown.
We reserve the right to limit quantities.
Hours: Mon-Thurs 7am-10pm | Fri: 7am-4pm Sat:1/2 Hour After Shabbos -10pm | Sun: 8am - 10pm While stocks last. E&OE
6 SA JEWISH REPORT 3 – 10 May 2019
Jewish Report Are Israel’s missing in action coming home?
south african
O
The source of quality content, news and insights
n 18 October 2011, after 1 941 days in Hamas
Use your vote wisely, but VOTE captivity, missing Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit
was returned to Israel. The moment the first DATELINE:
T
pictures of Shalit – whom Hamas had refused even Red
his coming Wednesday is election day, and the run up to this momentous Cross access – crackled onto a big television monitor, a
MIDDLE EAST
day is confusing and frustrating for many of us. Just who do we vote for, silence descended upon the waiting crowd.
and what impact will our vote have on our future in South Africa? I was one of dozens of journalists in a press tent in Paula Slier
I certainly don’t have all the answers, nor am I about to tell you which way to Tel Nof Air Force Base. Tears glistened in even the most But here’s the problem. Moscow needs the help – or at
vote. I don’t believe in that kind of journalism, and I do believe this is a hugely hardened reporters’ eyes. least consent – of Damascus to find Israeli MIAs and the
personal decision. I was reminded of Shalit’s homecoming this week Syrian army, which is formally at war with Israel, cannot
Despite this, I have had debates and discussion with friends. These focused on as Israeli officials released two Syrian prisoners as a publicly admit it is involved in such operations. Hence,
two things: whether voting for small parties is worthwhile, and whether it is wise “goodwill gesture” after an Israeli soldier was returned to it vehemently denied it aided in the search and recovery
to vote for the man and not the party. As heated as these discussions became, I Israel at the beginning of last month. operation for Baumel’s remains.
still don’t have the answers. American-born Zachary Baumel went missing in 1982. Israeli officials, too, have said that there was no
So, as the newspaper for the South African Jewish community, we did the A tank commander, he was believed to be killed in the prisoner exchange with Syria over the return of his
only thing we could to help: we asked the parties the questions you would want Battle of Sultan Yacoub during the first week of the First body. But the release of two prisoners held in Israeli
answered. That way, we hoped, you will have a few arrows in your decision-making Lebanon War in June 1982. jails – whether viewed as a goodwill gesture or not –
quiver. For 37 years, his exact fate and that of two other was approved by the Israeli attorney general without
When trying to contact the leaders of the parties, the Democratic Alliance was soldiers missing from the same battle, Yehuda Katz government consent, and signed off by President Reuven
the first to respond. Its leader, Mmusi Maimane, was eager to meet us and he and Zvi Feldman, has been unknown. Largely believed Rivlin. The prisoners have since been sent to Syria.
did so before Pesach, which is why we ran the interview with him in our Pesach to have been killed, there was also speculation that However, Russian officials have made comments
edition. We also had a very easy time getting hold of the African Christian they’d been held by Palestinian organisations in Syria. contrary to those by both the Israelis and Syrians.
Democratic Party leader, our old friend Reverend Kenneth Meshoe, who is always Although the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) had considered Putin confirmed that, “Russian Army soldiers found
kind and available to us. He is a real announcing their deaths, in the end it never did. the body [of Baumel] in co-ordination with the Syrian
friend to our community and Israel. In Army intelligence suggests the unit belonging to the military” and his special envoy to Syria, Alexander
parliament, he is ever ready to take on our three was ambushed by Syrian forces while advancing Lavrentiev, stressed that the operation went ahead only
fight, and that of the Jewish state. to capture positions in eastern Lebanon ahead of an because it was deemed to be in Damascus’s interests.
Another old friend of the community, anticipated ceasefire. Twenty one soldiers were killed “This action was not unilateral,” Lavrentiev said. “Israel
Prince Mangosuthu Buthelezi, was also and more than 30 injured. A few tanks and prisoners made a decision… to release some of the Syrian citizens
keen to respond to our questions. He, too, (including the bodies of fallen soldiers) were taken to who are in Israeli jails. This was an act of interest for the
has strong bonds – that go way back – with Syria. Afterwards the tanks were displayed in Damascus Syrian side. We will not do anything that is contrary to
us. I do hope these last after he retires and one was even sent to Moscow and shown there years Syria’s interests, but only things that serve them.”
following the elections. later. It was eventually handed over to Israel. At a ceremony held in Moscow, the Russian defence
We contacted the presidency to request There are currently four other IDF soldiers who are ministry presented Israel with Baumel’s jumpsuit and
an interview with Cyril Ramaphosa, and missing-in-action (MIA) in addition to two others, both military boots in an Israeli-flag-covered coffin. His
he agreed to respond to our questions. confirmed killed in Gaza in 2014, but whose bodies have remains were found in the territory of the Yarmouk
We also approached Economic Freedom not yet been returned to Israel. refugee camp near Damascus, and were identified at the
Fighters (EFF) leader Julius Malema, For Jerusalem, the importance of bringing home Institute of Forensic Medicine at Abu Kabir and by the
Congress of the People leader Mosiuoa Lekota, and General Bantu Holomisa of MIAs is part of the fabric of a society where every family IDF’s chief rabbi.
the United Democratic Movement (UDM). We even spoke to the Freedom Front sends its sons and daughters to fight. When those Netanyahu told Putin, “Two years ago I asked you to
Plus. soldiers go missing, the trauma is a national one. The help us find the bodies of missing Israeli soldiers, and
Our intrepid team was hard at work, not taking “no” for an answer. return of Baumel after nearly
It was the responses we got that were eye opening, especially from the EFF. four decades, like the return of
The EFF, first and foremost, insists that it is happy to be supported by anyone, Shalit, was a reminder of how
as long as they don’t support Israel. It goes on to intimate that Israelis are “against deeply ingrained this value is.
humanity”. The party claims that Israel is killing children and babies, and forcing However, Baumel’s father,
Palestinians into the mountains without food or water. (See page 9.) Yonah, who passed away ten
These lies floored me, but more than that, it astonishes me that someone years ago, and his mother,
in a position of power in a political party can espouse these and other horrific Miriam, who is in her eighties,
allegations as truth. repeatedly accused the IDF
EFF elections spokesperson Veronica Mente went on to say that we needed to of not doing enough to
be open to paying better salaries… Clearly, we have the money! You know, all Jews retrieve their son. They always
are supposedly rich just like Shakespeare’s Shylock! remained convinced he was
Somebody in our community needs to take this up and ensure that those in alive.
the EFF – who don’t have to like us or the Jewish state – know the facts about the When the Syrian war
Middle East. It’s simply unacceptable that the party can spew this hate, based on broke out in March 2011, the
pure misinformation. This is exacerbated in the statement the party put out as an chaos that ensued created an
Easter greeting. (See page 5.) expectation in Jerusalem that
However, even General Bantu Holomisa, the leader of the UDM, has an there could be opportunities
exaggerated view of Israel’s might. (See page 10.) for Israeli MIAs in Syria to be
I can’t say I’m surprised that people have warped views about the Israeli- found. After Russia entered the
Palestinian situation. I, too, read all the ugly anti-Israel opinion pieces and fake war in September 2015, that
news out there, both in the mainstream and on social media. expectation grew. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu welcoming Israel Defense Forces soldier
However, I believe it is incumbent on political leaders to do their own research Moscow is in a unique Gilad Shalit at Tel Nof after his release from Hamas captivity
and find out the facts before they spew hate speech to those who would do them position. It maintains good relations with Jerusalem and you responded in the affirmative. I want to thank you,
no harm. Damascus while controlling the skies of Syria. my friend, for what you have done.”
Even the perceptions about the South African Jewish community and Jews in Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has taken The irony is that the USSR, which existed when
general make for concerning reading in our articles on political parties. special care to cultivate ties with Russian President Baumel was killed and captured, condemned the
The potential danger of these skewed views of Jews and Israel is so clearly Vladimir Putin. He has met him 16 times, and is one of activities of Israel at the time. Today it’s a somewhat
evident in the second attack by a gunman on a shul in the United States. This the most frequent heads of state to travel to Moscow. different Russia operating in Syria that helped to retrieve
time, almost six months to the day after the Pittsburgh attack, a 19-year-old Two years ago, he requested help in searching for Israeli his body.
opened fire in Chabad of Poway in San Diego. Senseless hate and divisiveness does MIAs. But Moscow has many interests – often conflicting –
not benefit anyone, neither does the verbal spread of hatred. Russians are particularly sensitive to this. Every to balance. First and foremost, it is focused on stabilising
Our hearts go out to all those affected by this killing. I ask and pray that we use year, thousands of Russian volunteers search for the regime of Syrian President Bashar Al-Assad and
this as a lesson to bring people together, and not push people apart. Words hurt! Soviet soldiers who fell during World War II defending co-operates with Iran and Hezbollah. At the same time,
Hatred kills! Enough! their homeland from the Nazis. Russians are also Putin has said on various occasions that the security of
More than anything, I ask that we all go into our polling booths with our grateful for the honour Yad Vashem, Israel’s Holocaust Israel is one of his main priorities in the Middle East,
consciences and – having read what the parties have to say – we vote. Remembrance Centre, pays to Soviet soldiers killed by and that Israel’s right to protect its national security is
No matter how confusing and frustrating the elections may seem, not voting the Nazis. There are plans underway to open a memorial unquestionable.
is far worse. As the South African Jewish Board of Deputies is saying in its in Jerusalem for the defenders of Leningrad during Just how this will work out regarding the recovery of
campaign, you can complain only if you have voted. World War II, which Putin plans to attend. more Israeli MIAs remains to be seen. There are rumours
Use that vote, it is all you have in trying to improve this country for yourselves In September last year, the Russian defence ministry that the body of legendary Israeli spy Eli Cohen has been
and all who live in it. confirmed that Russian forces in Syria were involved in a found in Syria, but these have been denied by Moscow
special search operation for Israeli MIAs in the country. and Jerusalem. Nonetheless, a senior Israeli diplomatic
Shabbat Shalom! It said Russian soldiers had come under fire from Islamic official says Moscow is continuing to search for the
Peta Krost Maunder State militants while searching an area with co-ordinates remains of the other two IDF soldiers who went missing
Editor provided by Israel. Although one Russian officer was in the same battle as Baumel. Israelis will continue to
wounded, the operation continued. hope and pray.
3 – 10 May 2019 SA JEWISH REPORT 7
A step too far, and a paper-thin apology
B
y now, you have most likely read if the so-called Jewish symbols of the Star about Jews leading a lame, blinded America. INNER VOICE
about the cartoon that the New York of David and the yarmulke were removed is Whereas he is fully entitled to choose to see
Times published last week. It depicted an interesting question. Then, it might have it this way, I believe he is mistaken, as most Howard Feldman
a Dachshund with the face of Israeli Prime relied on the defence that it was a comment readers will fail to make the distinction. As
Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, wearing a on Israel and not on Jews. Unfortunately, the was the case in Germany with the depiction as a journalist for some years, the one thing he
blue dog’s collar and a dangling Star of David clumsiness of the caricature left it very little of Churchill being led. knew for certain was that a newspaper would
necklace – in case one was not clear as to wiggle room, and it had little option but to In the course of my public activity and as a not respond well by being lambasted and
the religious nature of the animal. The dog’s admit defeat. commentator on these types of issues, I am accused of anti-Semitism. He urged readers
leash, also an Israeli blue, was held by a rather In essence, the publication went a step too often concerned by our reaction. These events to engage (in this case) with the New York
rotund Donald Trump, who wore sunglasses far. Especially since on the same day that it validate our fear and anxiety in the sense that Times, but not spew hatred and accusation.
for the visually impaired, and seemed to decided to acknowledge that the cartoon was they “prove” what we have been saying all Correspondence in that vein would just
have had a yarmulke placed on his head. The anti-Semitic, a 19-year-old walked into a shul along. So, in the case of the New York Times, entrench negative or anti-Semitic feelings. And
Jewish dog was clearly leading the “Judised” outside San Diego with the express intention which has been accused of being no friend to whereas I am not certain that I am comfortable
president. of killing as many Jews as possible. Its timing Jews or Israel, the publication of the cartoon with victim blaming, the adult part of my brain
The work was hardly original. A similar couldn’t have been worse. is vindication and proof of what we have does hear what he is saying.
cartoon appeared in Germany in the 1920s. Worth interrogating is the reaction to been feeling all along. It’s confirmation bias What is clear is that anti-Semitism has
Only then it was Winston Churchill being led this. Whereas almost everyone condemned in that no matter how many other “balanced” become mainstream. The lines are vague, and
by a haredi looking Jew. it, there were a few I came across who failed articles might have been published, this one we can expect to see more of it as the limits
It took two days for the New York Times to be offended by it. One Jewish social- corroborates our thesis. are tested. The “artist” at the New York Times
to acknowledge that the publication was in media user (who often expresses disdain This is not to suggest that this cartoon was produced a piece that fell on the wrong side
poor judgement, and that it contained anti- for Trump and Netanyahu) saw it more as not racist, and it is not to suggest that the of acceptability. For now. And so, the paper
Semitic tropes. It took another day for it to a comment about the personalities and the New York Times doesn’t engage in anti-Israel apologised. This time.
apologise. Whether it would have done so characters being depicted than as a metaphor rhetoric on an ongoing basis, but we do need It all reminds me of American Supreme
to temper our response. Court Justice Potter Stewart, who when asked
New York Times – ‘cesspool of hostility’ In conversation on this issue with David
Harris of the Clarion Project (an organisation
to define the threshold test for obscenity,
simply responded that although it was not
RON KAMPEAS – JTA mostly hid from their readers the Holocaust of that monitors global terror), he expressed that easy to do, “I know it when I see it.”
the Jewish people has today made its pages a
T
he Israeli ambassador to the United States safe space for those who hate the Jewish state.
has linked the New York Times to the “Jew- Through biased coverage, slanderous columns,
hatred of growing parts of the intellectual and anti-Semitic cartoons, its editors shamefully
class”. choose week after week to cast the Jewish state
Ron Dermer was speaking on Monday in as a force for evil.”
the US Capitol at the annual Holocaust Days of
Remembrance organised by the US Holocaust
Over the weekend, the Times apologised
for including in its international print edition a
Marketing/Brand Manager
Memorial Museum. cartoon depicting Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin
It was an unusually political attack on a PhoNetanyahu as a guide dog wearing a Star of The IUA/UCF are looking for a dynamic and experienced
day and at an event organised by an to: David collar and leading a yarmulke-clad
marketing / brand manager to join their new team.
Ale
institution that generally focuses President Donald Trump.
xW
on the historical meaning of the The cartoon led to intense
This is a full day position based in Johannesburg.
ong
Holocaust. criticism of the newspaper,
/G
etty Images
Dermer listed recent lethal including by some of its op-
attacks against Jews, including ed page columnists who are Requirements:
Saturday’s deadly shooting at consistently pro-Israel. Among • A degree in Marketing/PR or similar field
the Chabad of Poway, a suburb Israeli ambassador them is Bret Stephens, who wrote a • Minimum 5 years’ marketing and communication experience
designbandits.co.za/300419
of San Diego. Ron Dermer column about the cartoon excoriating • Good understanding of the Jewish community
He attributed the California his newspaper for “an astonishing act • Campaign/event management
attack, which killed one congregant and of ignorance of anti-Semitism”, coming • Digital media and marketing
injured three, and the October massacre at a from a news outlet “that is otherwise hyper- • Experience in working with a CRM platform (Salesforce)
Pittsburgh synagogue that killed 11 worshippers, alert to nearly every conceivable expression
to white supremacists. But Dermer added that “we of prejudice, from mansplaining to racial
have also seen anti-Semitism increasingly poison microaggressions to transphobia”. Stephens said Short-listed candidates will be contacted for an interview.
minds in the political classes of what once proudly the paper should apologise to Netanyahu. Please send CVs to iuaucf@beyachad.co.za
called itself the West”. However, Stephens, a former editor in chief
Describing what he termed “the Jew-hatred of of the Jerusalem Post, added, “I have now been
growing parts of the intellectual class”, Dermer with the Times for two years and I’m certain that
referred to anti-Semitism plaguing Britain’s Labour the charge that the institution is in any way anti-
Party and rising anti-Israel activity on campuses. Semitic is a calumny.”
“We have also seen one of the world’s most Dermer in his Holocaust remembrance speech
prestigious newspapers become a cesspool of also alluded to a recent controversy surrounding
hostility towards Israel that goes well beyond freshman Democrat, Representative Ilhan Omar,
any legitimate criticism of a fellow, imperfect who has been accused of invoking anti-Semitic
democracy,” Dermer said. slanders in some of her statements critical of
“The same New York Times that a century ago Israel. She has apologised for some, but not all.
If you
If you
areare
interested
interested
in obtaining
in obtaining
an EU
an passport,
EU passport,
If you
If you
areare
of Lithuanian
of Lithuanian
descent,
descent,
If you
If you
have
have
anyany
questions
questions
related
related
to Lithuanian
to Lithuanian
laws
laws
on citizenship,
on citizenship,
A unique
A unique
opportunity
opportunity
is coming
is coming
youryour
way!way!
Top expert
Top expert
in thisinfield,
this field,
Lithuanian
Lithuanian
lawyer
lawyer
Nida Nida
Degutiene,
Degutiene,
GM ofGMNext
of Next
StepsSteps
consultancy
consultancy
company,
company,
a jointa Israeli-Lithuanian
joint Israeli-Lithuanian
venture,
venture,
with with
exceptional
exceptional
experience
experience
in representing
in representing
the South
the South
African
African
JewishJewish
LitvakLitvak
community
community
for more
for more
than 10
than
years,
10 years,
will bewill
visiting
be visiting
Johannesburg.
Johannesburg.
On MayOn 13-14
May 13-14
Nida Nida
will bewill
ready
be ready
and eager
and eager
to assess
to assess
your eligibility
your eligibility
to apply
to apply
for EUforpassports
EU passports
according
according
to all to
requirements
all requirements
set out
setby
outtheby the
legislation,
legislation,
to explain
to explain
the process
the process
of applying
of applying
for citizenship
for citizenship
reinstatement,
reinstatement,
to provide
to provide
information
information
aboutabout
the documents
the documentsstored
stored
in Lithuanian
in Lithuanian
Nida Degutiene is a top
Nida Degutiene is aexpert
top expert
in thein the
State State
archives
archives
that might
that might
be relevant
be relevant
for your
for citizenship
your citizenship
restoration,
restoration,
and to and
answer
to answer
any other
any other
question
question
you might
you might
have.have.
field of
field
citizenship
of citizenship
reinstatement.
reinstatement.
Having
Having
Call our
Callrepresentative
our representative
of Nextof Next Ericka
StepsSteps Ericka
on 078
on886
0781800
886 1800
or send
or send
an email to ericka@nandos.com
an email to ericka@nandos.com
to book
to book
your private
your private
free-of-charge
free-of-charge lived in
lived
Israel
in Israel
for 5 for
years
5 years
and frequently
and frequently
consultation.
consultation.
Meetings
Meetings
will take
will place
take place
at TATA
at TATA
House,
House,
First Floor,
First Floor,
39 Ferguson
39 Ferguson
Rd, Illovo,
Rd, Illovo,
JHB. JHB.
visiting
visiting
SouthSouth
AfricaAfrica
for 10for
years,
10 years,
Nida Nida
has has
SinceSince
its inception,
its inception,
Next Next
StepsSteps
has become
has become
a leading
a leading
provider
provider
of citizenship
of citizenship
reinstatement
reinstatement
services
services
with 100%
with 100%
success
success
rate for
rateclients
for clients
in in acquired
acquired
the highest
the highest
level of
level
credibility
of credibility
SouthSouth
Africa,Africa,
Australia,
Australia,
Israel,Israel,
UK, Canada,
UK, Canada,
America
America
and others.
and others. among
among
the Jewish
the Jewish
community.
community.
Besides
Besides
an MA
andegree
MA degree
in law,inNida
law, Nida
holdsholds
a Global
a Global
MBA MBA
from from
IDC Herzliya
IDC Herzliya
in Israel.
in Israel.
Nida Nida
is is
passionate
passionate
aboutabout
JewishJewish
traditions,
traditions,
histo-histo-
ry andrycuisine,
and cuisine,
she isshe
theisworld-renowned
the world-renowned
author
author
of theofbook: A Taste
the book: A Taste
of Israel
of Israel
. .
You can also read
