UNDOCUMENTED MIGRANTS AND THE EUROPE 2020 STRATEGY: MAKING SOCIAL INCLUSION A REALITY FOR ALL MIGRANTS IN EUROPE - PICUM POSITION PAPER
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
PICUM POSITION PAPER UNDOCUMENTED MIGRANTS AND THE EUROPE 2020 STRATEGY: MAKING SOCIAL INCLUSION A REALITY FOR ALL MIGRANTS IN EUROPE NOVEMBER 2015
PICUM POSITION PAPER
The Platform for International Cooperation on Undocumented Migrants (PICUM) was founded in 2001 as
an initiative of grassroots organisations. Now representing a network of more than 140 organisations and
100 individual advocates working with undocumented migrants in 33 countries, primarily in Europe as well
as in other world regions, PICUM has built a comprehensive evidence base regarding the gap between
international human rights law and the policies and practices existing at national level. With over ten years
of evidence, experience and expertise on undocumented migrants, PICUM promotes recognition of their
fundamental rights, providing an essential link between local realities and the debates at policy level.
Based on the realities faced by undocumented migrants and migrant workers in precarious situations - those
with short term residence permits in insecure employment situations - this position paper aims at informing the
debates on poverty and social inclusion, education and on labour migration. This paper develops links with the
three social targets of the Europe 2020 Strategy – poverty, employment, and education - offering insight to
how the targets could positively impact undocumented migrants and how the inclusion of this group could help
achieve the objectives of the Strategy.
Report produced by Kadri Soova and Michele LeVoy (PICUM)
Sincere thanks to Maëlle Lena and all the PICUM members that have contributed to this report.
November 2015
This publication was made possible with kind support from:
This report has received financial support from the European Union Programme for
Employment and Social Solidarity “EaSI” (2014-2020). For further information please
consult: http://ec.europa.eu/social/easi
Supported by a grant from the Foundation Open Society Institute in
cooperation with the Open Society Initiative for Europe of the Open
Society Foundations
Cover photo: Undocumented Lives (www.undocumentedlives.com) by Katja Tähjä and Kaisa Viitanen, 2013
PICUM
Platform for International Cooperation on Undocumented Migrants
Rue du Congres / Congresstraat 37-41, post box 5
1000 Brussels
Belgium
Tel: +32/2/210 17 80
Fax: +32/2/210 17 89
info@picum.org
www.picum.org
Design: www.beelzepub.comUNDOCUMENTED MIGRANTS AND THE EUROPE 2020 STRATEGY
TABLE OF CONTENTS
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY.........................................................................................................................................................................................................2
EUROPE 2020 STRATEGY: A BRIEF OVERVIEW ....................................................................................................................... 3
1. EMPLOYMENT............................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 4
1.1 References to migrants in the employment target ........................................................................................... 4
1.2 Labour market demand in low wage sectors and EU policy responses........................ 4
1.3 More regular channels for labour migration..................................................................................................................6
1.4 Recommendations.................................................................................................................................................................................................. 7
2. POVERTY.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................9
2.1 References to migrants in the poverty target.............................................................................................................9
2.2 Irregular migrants and poverty...........................................................................................................................................................9
2.3 Access to homeless services............................................................................................................................................................ 10
2.4 Child poverty.................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 11
2.5 Access to health services.......................................................................................................................................................................... 11
2.6 Recommendations................................................................................................................................................................................................13
3. EDUCATION...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................14
3.1 References to migrants in the education target .................................................................................................14
3.2 Access to education and training for undocumented children and youth................14
3.3 Recommendations ............................................................................................................................................................................................. 15
1PICUM POSITION PAPER
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The five headline targets of the Europe2020 Strategy in the fields of employment, reduction of poverty,
education, climate and energy and research and development were set to reach the overall objective of Europe
2020, launched in 2010 as the European Union’s strategy for smart, sustainable and inclusive growth. These
include concerted efforts to empower and activate disadvantaged groups across EU member states and find
sustainable solutions for the future of the EU labour markets. However, implementation of a comprehensive
approach that would promote economic growth that contributes to social justice, decent work, combating
poverty, investing in an inclusive and universal education system and to the transition from informal to formal
economy in labour market sectors vulnerable to exploitation, has fallen behind.
This position paper develops links with the three social targets of the Europe 2020 Strategy – poverty,
employment, and education - offering insight to how the targets could positively impact undocumented migrants1
and how the inclusion of this group could help achieve the objectives of the Strategy. Based on the realities
faced by both undocumented migrants as well as migrant workers in precarious situations (those with short
term residence permits in insecure employment situations) this position paper aims at informing the debates on
poverty and social inclusion, education and on labour migration.
The inclusion of migrants irrespective of their migration status in the broader implementation of the Europe
2020 Strategy is crucial as migrants face an increased and disproportionate risk of poverty and social exclusion,
human rights violations and discrimination. Due to the multiple failings of labour migration systems in Europe,
migrant workers in low wage sectors face great difficulties in maintaining their regular migration status. Low-wage
migrant workers often fluctuate between regular and irregular status, making a social strategy solely based on
residence status counterproductive. While many undocumented migrants in Europe, including undocumented
children and youth, are able to at one point regularize their status, the restrictions they may have faced in
accessing education and health care services not only result in an abuse of their human right to education and
health, but also result in wasted potential and can have harmful long term health impacts.
The inequality faced by Europe’s workers has resulted in increased labour segmentation, low wages and
normalization of exploitative working conditions.
The growth of ‘in work poverty’ may increase hostility towards undocumented workers, often viewed as
unwelcome competition for scarce jobs, and blamed with lowering wages and safety standards. This paper
particularly focuses on specific issues concerning the unrecognised labour market needs in low wage
employment sectors and the precarious situation facing migrant workers in the informal sector. The paper
explores how the creation of more adequate labour migration channels could positively impact economic
recovery and improvement of working conditions.
The paper also addresses undocumented children and It is in the mutual benefit of
poverty; access to homeless services and health care for
undocumented migrants; as well as the reasons for early
European society as a whole to
school leaving among undocumented children and youth. It ensure fair and inclusive working
aims to contribute to the understanding that it is in the mutual conditions, quality services,
benefit of European society as a whole to ensure fair and protection and justice, and
inclusive working conditions, quality services, protection and
justice, and secure and regular residence statuses for migrant
secure and regular residence
workers. statuses for migrant workers.
By providing a set of concrete policy recommendations for EU institutions on ways to include undocumented
migrants in the social inclusion, employment and education policies, this paper hopes to contribute to a better
understanding of the relevant role of the Europe 2020 Strategy and the EU.
1 Undocumented migrants are third country nationals who are currently living/working in the EU without valid residence
permission.
2UNDOCUMENTED MIGRANTS AND THE EUROPE 2020 STRATEGY
EUROPE 2020 STRATEGY:
A BRIEF OVERVIEW
These targets include The Europe 2020 initiative2 was launched in 2010 as the European
Union’s strategy for smart, sustainable and inclusive growth, representing
concerted efforts to
a commitment from the EU institutions and member states to steer the EU
empower and activate collectively towards a more equal and sustainable future both in terms
disadvantaged groups of economic and human progress. Five headline targets in the fields of
across EU member states employment, reduction of poverty, education, climate and energy and
research and development were set to reach the overall objective. These
and find sustainable
targets include concerted efforts to empower and activate disadvantaged
solutions for the future of groups across EU member states and find sustainable solutions for the
the EU labour markets. future of the EU labour markets.
The employment target aims to have 75% of 20 to 64 year old men and women employed by 2020. This includes
the setting up of a “forward-looking and comprehensive labour migration policy responsible for the needs of
labour markets” and “better integration of migrants in the workforce”.
The poverty target sets out to reduce poverty by lifting at least 20 million people out of the risk of poverty
and social exclusion by 2020. “Provision of innovative education and employment opportunities for deprived
communities and the development of a new agenda for migrants’ integration to enable them to take full
advantage of their potential” are some of the suggested ways on how to achieve this.
The education targets aim to reduce early school-leaving rates below 10% and have at least 40% of 30-34 year-
olds completing third level education.
Although civil society has welcomed the Europe 2020 Strategy and in particular the focus on addressing poverty
and social exclusion, main concerns lie in the strong emphasis on economic growth and austerity policies that
overshadow progress on the social targets. 3
The Strategy reached its half way mark in 2015 and PICUM will explore how it has set out to include the migrant
population and what has the EU has delivered so far in terms of progress in the three social targets relating to
employment, poverty and education.
2 Commission Communication Europe 2020: A strategy for smart, sustainable and inclusive growth, COM(2010) 2020 final.
http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=COM:2010:2020:FIN:EN:PDF
3 See for example: EAPN, Briefing Note on the EU2020 Strategy, 2011. http://www.eapn.eu/images/stories/docs/EAPN-
position-papers-and-reports/2011-briefing-note-europe-2020-en-final.pdf.
3PICUM POSITION PAPER
1. EMPLOYMENT
1.1 References to migrants in the employment target
Launched in 2010, the European Commission’s Flagship Initiative “An Agenda for new skills and jobs”4, which
aims to support the objectives of the Europe 2020 employment target, made a promising start in guiding the
EU policy agenda on labour migration, a policy area governed by both DG Home Affairs and Migration and DG
Employment and Social Affairs. It suggests that “the potential of third-country migrant inflows is not fully utilised
and insufficiently targeted to meet labour market needs, despite the substantial contribution of migrants to
employment and growth” and furthermore that “a mapping of the skills profile of third-country nationals already
living in the EU, would be instrumental in determining how the expanding legal framework of EU and national
admission schemes for migrant workers could help mitigate skills shortages”.5
Despite the promising analysis of this Flagship Initiative, the promotion of a comprehensive labour migration
policy for third country migrant workers is a complex and difficult task on the EU level. One of the areas in
which the EU has had difficulty in legislating has precisely been the admission of third country nationals for the
purposes of paid employment and independent economic activity.6
1.2 Labour market demand in low wage sectors and EU policy
responses
According to the OECD7, the working age population in Europe will According to the OECD,
shrink by 50 million by 2060. Even with the success of any planned
the working age population
activation policies, it will not be enough to mitigate this prognosis
without labour migration policy reform. However, current statistics in Europe will shrink by 50
show that the labour markets of EU member states are increasingly million by 2060. It will not
restrictive to third country migrant workers: the total number of first be enough to mitigate this
time residence permits for all remunerated activity reasons (not
prognosis without labour
differentiating for the type of employment, skill level or sector) in the
EU28 went down from 786,892 in 2008 to 535,478 in 2013.8 migration policy reform.
4 Commission Communication An Agenda for new skills and jobs:A European contribution towards full employment COM
(2010) 682 final. http://eur-lex.europa.eu/resource.html?uri=cellar:776df18f-542f-48b8-9627-88aac6d3ede0.0003.03/
DOC_1&format=PDF
5 Commission Communication An Agenda for new skills and jobs: A European contribution towards full employment, op.
cit., p.2 and p.12.
6 A. Triandafyllidou, S. Marchetti, Europe 2020: Addressing Low Skill Labour Migration at times of Fragile Recovery, RSCAS
Policy Paper 2014/05, p.1. http://cadmus.eui.eu/bitstream/handle/1814/31222/RSCAS_PP_2014_05.pdf?sequence=1.
7 B. Westmore, International migration: the relationship with economic and policy factors in the home and destination
country. OECD Economics Department Working Papers no. 1140, page 5. http://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/economics/
international - migration -the - relationship -with - economic-and - polic y-fac tors-in -the - home -and - destination -
country_5jz123h8nd7l-en;jsessionid=ddskmnbgsfht.x-oecd-live-03.
8 Eurostat, First permits by reason, length of validity and citizenship, December 2014. http://appsso.eurostat.ec.europa.eu/
nui/show.do?dataset=migr_resfirst&lang=en.
4UNDOCUMENTED MIGRANTS AND THE EUROPE 2020 STRATEGY
The EU’s labour migration policies, with the exception of the recently adopted directive regulating seasonal
work, have thus far mainly focused on highly skilled workers, leaving very few regular employment opportunities
for low-wage workers from outside the EU. At the same time, particular sectors of the economy in the EU rely on
the presence of a migrant workforce that works undeclared in the informal economy due to limitations on work
and residence permit opportunities which force these migrants to work in precarious conditions with an irregular
status due to lack of alternatives.9
The presence of migrant workers demonstrates that labour market
National and EU migration
demand exists in low wage occupations most notably in the restaurant,
policies continue to hospitality, agriculture, construction, retail, and domestic work sectors.
offer few possibilities for Nonetheless, national and EU migration policies continue to offer
migrant workers from third few possibilities for migrant workers from third countries to receive
work and residence permits to work regularly in these low wage
countries to receive work
sectors. Due to widespread unofficial work arrangements, undeclared
and residence permits to activity and informal recruitment channels in these sectors, very little
work regularly in low wage comprehensive cross-country data is available about sectorial labour
sectors. shortages or labour market outcomes for different migrant profiles10,
as these workers are often not recognised, registered or counted in
national statistics.11
Circular migration – the temporary and often repetitive movement of a migrant worker between the country of
origin and destination for the purpose of employment- has been promoted by the European Commission in the
Global Approach to Migration12 as the preferred policy choice for managing labour mobility and many member
states utilize some form of temporary or circular migration schemes.13 However, trade unions and researchers
caution against the overemphasis on circular and temporary migration schemes as “many jobs filled by temporary
migrant workers, including at middle- and lower-skilled levels, are actually ‘permanent’ jobs, given the structural
nature of such labour market shortages14”. Disregarding the permanent nature of these jobs could eventually
lead into more irregularity and undeclared work.15 Researchers also suggest that in the long-term it would be
more beneficial to admit workers based on general skills rather than specific sectorial profiles to facilitate labour
market matching and increase transparency.16
9 B.Anderson, Migration, immigration controls and the fashioning of precarious workers in Work, Employment and Society,
Volume 24, Number 2, June 2010, p.306
10 G. Lemaître, Migration in Europe: An overview of results from the 2008 immigration module with implications for
labour migration in Matching Economic Migration with Labour Market Needs, OECD/European Union, 2014, p.351.
http://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/social-issues-migration-health/matching-economic-migration-with-labour-market-
needs_9789264216501-en
11 International Labour Organisation, The informal economy and decent work: a policy resource guide, supporting transitions
to formality, International Labour Office, Employment Policy Department – Geneva, 2013, p. 2. http://www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/
groups/public/---ed_emp/---emp_policy/documents/publication/wcms_212689.pdf
12 Commission Communication The Global Approach to Migration and Mobility COM(2011) 743 final. 2011. http://eur-lex.
europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELEX:52011DC0743&from=EN
13 European Migration Network, Temporary and Circular Migration: empirical evidence, current policy practice and future
options in EU Member States, 2011. http://ec.europa.eu/dgs/home-affairs/what-we-do/networks/european_migration_
network/reports/docs/emn-studies/circular-migration/0a_emn_synthesis_report_temporary__circular_migration_
final_sept_2011_en.pdf
14 R. Cholewinski, Labour migration, temporariness and rights in Rethinking the Attractiveness of EU Labour Immigration
Policies, in Ed. S. Carrera et al., Rethinking the Attractiveness of EU Labour Immigration Policies, CEPS, 2014, p.23.
http://www.ceps.eu/system/files/RETHINKING%20LABOUR%20IMMIGRATION%20POLICIES_withcover.pdf
15 S.Olney and R. Cholewinski, Migrant Workrs and the Right to Non-Discrimination and Equality in Ed. C. Costello, M.
Freedland. Migrants at Work: Immigration and Vulnerability in Labour Law, 2014, Oxford University Press, p.277
16 M.Kahanec, Labour market needs and migration policy options: towards more dynamic labour markets, in, in Ed. S.
Carrera et al, CEPS, 2014 op. cit., p.52.
5PICUM POSITION PAPER
1.3 More regular channels for labour migration
The creation of more regular channels for low wage migrant workers is potentially
Workers are
hindered by the lack of political will on member state level to propose legislation
pushed into that could be perceived as “bringing more migration” and in particular more low-
the informal wage migrant workers.17 Policy-makers tend to respond to negative public opinion
economy and about migrants by closing most regular channels for admitting low-skilled migrants
for economic purposes, aiming to meet the demand by admission through other
into an irregular
channels or by tacit approval of high levels of irregular employment.18 This inactivity
situation when a results in lost tax revenue and more irregular migration, as these workers are
structural labour pushed into the informal economy and into an irregular situation when a structural
demand is not met labour demand is not met through official labour migration channels. This situation
in turn creates a vast decent work deficit with high levels of labour exploitation, work
through official
place accidents19 and general worsening of working conditions.20 Undocumented
labour migration migrant workers are particularly vulnerable to unsafe working conditions and face
channels. many barriers across Europe to access compensation for work place accidents.21
There is a clear and significant role for an There is a clear and significant role for an
adequate labour migration policy in better adequate labour migration policy in better
supporting the EU 2020 goal of growth
and competitiveness and in reducing and
supporting the EU 2020 goal of growth and
preventing undeclared work and irregular competitiveness and in reducing and preventing
migration. undeclared work and irregular migration.
As a first step, researchers highlight the need to acknowledge that there is a structural demand for migrant
labour force in certain occupations that is related to factors such as the long-term demographic processes (the
ageing of European societies), the configuration of nuclear families without extended support networks to cover
needs for care of children or elderly/disabled people, as well as the participation of women in paid work outside
the home – all irreversible phenomena that persist even in periods of acute economic downturn.22
The UN Special Rapporteur on the Human Rights of Migrants has appealed to EU governments to recognise
their real labour needs, particularly in the low-wage and medium-wage sectors, and has asked the EU to help
those states combine facilitated regular migration for such sectors.23 The next step is to find ways to end the
political impasse surrounding any new initiatives around the creation of more regular channels for labour
migration, particularly for low-wage employment. There is also a need for further consolidation, streamlining, and
transparency of standards and rights of the current EU labour migration policy, a framework currently characterised
by fragmentation, legal uncertainty, discrimination and competing multi-layered migratory statuses.24
17 R. Cholewinski, Study on obstacles to effective access of irregular migrants to minimum social rights, Council of Europe,
2005, p.18. http://mighealth.net/eu/images/e/ec/Chol.pdf
18 Ed. A. Platonova, G.Urso, Labour Shortages and Migration Policy, International Organisation for Migration, 2012, p.23.
http://labourmigration.eu/research/report/22-Labour%20Shortages.
19 See Platform for International Cooperation on Undocumented Migrants, Position paper on the European Commission
Communication on an EU Strategic Framework on Health and Safety at Work 2014-2020. http://picum.org/picum.org/
uploads/publication/PICUM%20Position%20paper_EU%20Framework%20on%20OSH%202014_2020_November%20
2014.pdf
20 International Labour Conference, 104th Session, 2015, Proposed Recommendation Concerning the Transition from the
Informal to the Formal Economy, ILC.104/V/1, p. 21 http://www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/groups/public/---ed_norm/---relconf/
documents/meetingdocument/wcms_302539.pdf
21 EU Fundamental Rights Agency, Fundamental rights of migrants in an irregular situation. A comparative report,2011, p.48.
http://fra.europa.eu/sites/default/files/fra_uploads/1827-FRA_2011_Migrants_in_an_irregular_situation_EN.pdf
22 A. Triandafyllidou, S. Marchetti, op. cit., p.6.
23 F. Crépeau, End of Mission Statement Migrants and the Mediterranean: UN rights expert on human rights of migrants follow
up visit to Brussels for further development of his study on EU border management, Banking on mobility to regain control of
EU borders, February 2015. http://www.ohchr.org/EN/NewsEvents/Pages/DisplayNews.aspx?NewsID=15544&LangID=E
24 S. Carrera, E.Guild, K.Eisele, The Next Generation of EU Labour Immigration Policy: Conclusions and Recommendations in
Ed. S. Carrera et al., Rethinking the Attractiveness of EU Labour Immigration Policies, CEPS, 2014, p.128. http://www.ceps.
eu/system/files/RETHINKING%20LABOUR%20IMMIGRATION%20POLICIES_withcover.pdf
6UNDOCUMENTED MIGRANTS AND THE EUROPE 2020 STRATEGY
Evidence demonstrates When analysing and designing policy choices, it is important to take into
account, however, the undocumented migrant workers forming part of
that regularisations help
the European labour force25 and consider measures such as ongoing
to re-regulate the labour regularisations linked to employment and social security contributions26
market, enforce labour to promote the transfer of such workers into the formal economy. Evidence
rights and have a positive demonstrates that regularisations help to re-regulate the labour market,
enforce labour rights and have a positive impact overall.27
impact overall.
1.4 Recommendations
Legislation:
>> Establish a better regulated EU labour market by creating more entry and stay opportunities for third country
migrant workers across skill levels and labour sectors through the reintroduction of a framework directive on
admission and stay of third country migrant workers, and/or through additional sectorial directives similar to the
“Seasonal Workers” and “Blue Card” Directives.
Policy:
>> Improve labour conditions in low wage sectors to address undeclared work and exploitation by developing
policies to reinforce the implementation of internationally recognised labour rights for all workers,
irrespective of status.
>> Remove barriers preventing undocumented workers from reporting exploitation and abuse by supporting
member states in setting up of a “firewall” - a clear separation in law and practice between the powers and remit
of labour and social inspectors and migration law enforcement authorities. Requirements for labour inspectors
to report undocumented migrants to immigration authorities should be eliminated and sharing of personal
information for immigration enforcement purposes should be prohibited.
>> Allow for transition to permanent migration in circular and temporary migration schemes as labour shortages
in these sectors is not temporary and could lead into more irregularity and undeclared work.
>> Reduce undeclared work and irregular migration by strengthening the residence status of third country migrant
workers by uncoupling residence and work permits so that loss of employment would not automatically lead
to loss of residence status.
>> In labour market assessment and projections, take account of the undocumented workers who are already
part of the labour force and promote ongoing regularisations based on employment and social security
contributions.
>> Enhance coordination between DG HOME (Home Affairs and Migration), DG EMPL(Employment, Social
Affairs, Skills and Labour Mobility), social partners and civil society organisations working with migrant
workers concerning labour shortages, enforcement of labour rights and labour migration policy through
regular consultations.
25 According to the findings from the Clandestino project in 2008, it is estimated that there are between 1.6 and 3.8 million
undocumented migrants in the European Union, a large majority of whom work to survive as they have no recourse to
public allowances.. See: A. Triandafyllidou, CLANDESTINO Project Final Report, November 2009, p.11. http://clandestino.
eliamep.gr/wp-content/uploads/2010/03/clandestino-final-report_-november-2009.pdf
26 The Portuguese model is an example. See J. Peixoto and C. Sabino, Portugal: Immigration, the labour market and policy
in Portugal: trends and prospects, IDEA working Papers, N°6, April 2009, p.44. http://www.idea6fp.uw.edu.pl/pliki/WP6_
Portugal.pdf
27 Regularisations in the European Union (REGINE), Study on Practices in the Area of Regularisation of Illegally Staying
Third-Country Nationals in the Member States of the EU, Final Report,2009, p. 47. http://research.icmpd.org/fileadmin/
Research-Website/Project_material/REGINE/Regine_report_january_2009_en.pdf
7PICUM POSITION PAPER Data: >> Improve data collection on the migrant workforce and actual and projected labour market needs in low wage sectors through better disaggregated and comprehensive statistics at Eurostat and national level that would inform the need for residence and work permits in those sectors. >> Improve EU-wide collection of disaggregated data on work place accidents of migrant workers and promote access to labour accident compensation for all workers irrespective of immigration status. >> Enforce monitoring of the implementation of labour rights protection of undocumented workers in the EU Employers’ Sanctions Directive by collecting cross-country data on the amounts of unpaid wages received by workers and sanctions received by employers. Funding: >> Create direct funding opportunities for civil society organisations, trade unions providing first-line assistance to undocumented workers with labour rights complaints in addition to channelling allocated structural funding for this purpose. 8
UNDOCUMENTED MIGRANTS AND THE EUROPE 2020 STRATEGY
2. POVERTY
2.1 References to migrants in the poverty target
The poverty target sets out to reduce poverty by lifting at least 20 million people out of the risk of poverty and
social exclusion by 2020. It includes the “provision of innovative education and employment opportunities for
deprived communities” and “development of a new agenda for migrants’ integration to enable them to take full
advantage of their potential” as one of the suggested ways of how to achieve the target.
Similarly to the employment target, the poverty target indicators do not differentiate or offer specific attention
to the poverty gap between the general population and foreign born populations, who are most in and at risk
of poverty. According to Inequality Watch, the poverty rate in 2010 of the population of 18+ years and more was
26.9% for immigrants born outside of the EU, 15.9% for immigrants born within the EU and 14.8% for Europeans
living in their country of origin.28
Furthermore, data from Eurostat proves that the immigrant population The immigrant population
is highly vulnerable to downturns in the economy. In the peak years
of the EU economic recess, between 2009 and 2011, the group of
is highly vulnerable to
third country nationals at risk of poverty increased from 31% to 35%, downturns in the economy.
compared to the total population, which increased from 15% to 16%.29
It must also be noted that this data refers only to regular migrants, as no comparative Eurostat data is available
concerning rate of poverty of the irregular migrant population due to the economic recession. Nonetheless,
available research does demonstrate the link between economic downturn and irregularity, as employers are
less likely to keep formal work relationships, potentially causing loss of residence status as result. 30 Further
research from Spain concludes that undocumented migrants have been particularly affected by the crisis
through the increasingly hostile policies towards migrants, which restrict their access to basic services and
employment. 31
2.2 Irregular migrants and poverty
To prevent irregular migration, many EU member states have resorted to limiting the main elements of social
inclusion, namely health, shelter, education and a fair income, for its most vulnerable group of migrants, which
effectively pushes them into poverty. The legislative and practical barriers facing undocumented migrants in
accessing these rights have the clear intent of driving them into a situation of destitution so intolerable, that it
should compel their departure from Europe and deter other migrants from coming. 32
28 Inequality Watch, Poverty in Europe: the Current Situation, http://www.inequalitywatch.eu/spip.php?article99&lang=en.
29 Eurostat October, 2014 http://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/help/new-eurostat-website
30 A.Kraler, M.Rogoz, Irregular migration in the European Union since the turn of the millennium –development, economic
background and discussion, Database on Irregular Migration, Working paper 11/2011, p.13. http://irregular-migration.net/
31 C. Manzanedo, R. Gonzales Fabre, Impacto de la crisis económica sobre los inmigrantes irregulares en España, 2009,
Pueblos Unidos, p.5. http://pueblosunidos.org/wp-content/uploads/2009ImpactoCrisisEmigrantesEspaña.pdf
32 See Dutch example in R. Cholewinski, op. cit, Council of Europe, 2005, p.22.
9PICUM POSITION PAPER
Not only are these policies grossly ineffective in their aim to curb irregular Restricting access to
migration, but restricting access to minimum social rights can increase
minimum social rights
the marginalisation and stigmatisation of migrants in the eyes of the
general population, with a potential to increase racism in the society.33 can increase the
Restricting access to social services for undocumented migrants can in marginalisation and
turn undermine policy objectives in the areas of social cohesion, labour stigmatisation of migrants
market, public health, and education strategies, and risk downgrading
in the eyes of the
Europe’s labour conditions. Furthermore, such restrictive policies also
disproportionately impact upon individuals in an irregular migration general population, with
situation with vulnerabilities due to age, gender and serious medical a potential to increase
conditions, including women, children and those with urgent health needs. racism.
2.3 Access to homeless services
The European Commission has made some advances in addressing the specific disadvantages faced by migrant
populations, and undocumented migrants in particular, in some of the analytical and policy tools of the Social
Investment Package. 34
The Staff Working Document Confronting Homelessness in the European Union35 confirms that “the rising pro-
portion of migrants, especially those who are undocumented, among the homeless is alarming” and suggests
that “guaranteeing basic rights and improving access to work and basic services can prevent homelessness
among undocumented migrants.” The document also states that “while some form of basic service access is
usually available to homeless people in Member States, it is not always guaranteed, and this is especially true
for undocumented migrants.”
Making EU funds available Recognition of the existence and realities of homeless undocumented
migrants and of the financial and legislative barriers faced by service
for the development of providers when finding solutions for this group, is an important
homeless services for advance, but much remains to be done to create durable solutions
undocumented migrants on in practice. Decriminalisation of shelter provision to undocumented
the local level are examples migrants under the EU Facilitation Directive, which would enable
migrants to access shelter without fear of being reported and service
of vital impending policy providers to provide services without fear of repercussions36 and
advances. making EU funds available for the development of homeless services
for undocumented migrants on the local level are examples of vital
impending policy advances. 37
33 R. Cholewinski, op. cit, Council of Europe, 2005, p.18.
34 European Commission, Social investment: Commission urges Member States to focus on growth and social cohesion,
http://ec.europa.eu/social/main.jsp?langId=en&catId=1044&newsId=1807&furtherNews=yes.
35 European Commission, Commission Staff Working Document, Confronting Homelessness in the European Union, 2013.
http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/ALL/?uri=CELEX:52013SC0042.
36 EU Fundamental Rights Agency, Criminalisation of migrants in an irregular situation and of persons engaging with them,
2014, p.16 http://fra.europa.eu/sites/default/files/fra-2014-criminalisation-of-migrants-0_en_0.pdf
37 Platform for International Cooperation on Undocumented Migrants, Housing and Homelessness of Undocumented
Migrants in Europe: Developing Strategies and Good Practices to Ensure Access to Housing and Shelter, 2014, pp. 22-
23. http://picum.org/picum.org/uploads/publication/Annual%20Conference%202013%20%20report%20HOUSING_EN_
FINAL.pdf
10UNDOCUMENTED MIGRANTS AND THE EUROPE 2020 STRATEGY
2.4 Child poverty
The European Commission has also published specific Due to their lack of migration
recommendations on child poverty38 as part of the Social
status, undocumented children
Investment Package. This is a welcome step, recognizing children
as individual rights holders and the need to prioritise integrated are confronted with numerous
social investment in children, particularly in times of crisis. Due barriers to accessing rights and
to their lack of migration status, undocumented children are basic services and thus face an
confronted with numerous barriers to accessing rights and basic
increased risk of child poverty.
services and thus face an increased risk of child poverty.
With access to quality services as one of the central pillars of the recommendation, member states are urged
to ensure health care services are adapted to ensure undocumented children can enjoy their right to health.
The recommendation specifically calls to “Improve the responsiveness of health systems to address the needs
of disadvantaged children — Ensure that all children can make full use of their universal right to health care…
Devote special attention to [inter alia] undocumented or non-registered children”.
Poverty and social exclusion The specific mention of health care services is an essential
advancement, however undocumented children’s access to
during childhood can have other crucial services such as education and other measures
serious short and long-term countering social exclusion should also form part of the EU
consequences, including Social Investment priorities. Poverty and social exclusion
reducing the social and economic during childhood can have serious short and long-term
consequences39, including reducing the social and economic
contributions young people make contributions young people make to their societies in the
to their societies in the future. future.
It is crucial to recognize that these arguments apply equally to all children, regardless of their or their parents’
migration status. While there is no clear data demonstrating that irregular migration is reduced by limiting
the human rights of undocumented children and denying access to essential services, an increasing body
of research is demonstrating the great individual harm and exacerbation of social inequalities that restrictive
migration policies have on the detriment of individuals, families and communities alike.40
2.5 Access to health services
Access to health care services is limited for undocumented migrants in many EU countries.41 Nearly all European
Union member states restrict access to health care services to different degrees for undocumented migrants
through regulations on migration and health at national level. Such policies are detrimental to individual,
community and public health, the functioning of public health care systems and social cohesion, and contrary to
medical ethics and legal human rights obligations.42
38 European Commission, Commission Recommendation of 20/02/2013, Investing in Children: Breaking the Cycle of
Disadvantage, 2013. http://ec.europa.eu/justice/fundamental-rights/files/c_2013_778_en.pdf.
39 P. Hoelscher, (2004), A thematic study using transnational comparisons to analyse and identify what combination of
policy responses are most successful in preventing and reducing high levels of child poverty, European Commission,
2004, p.37. http://ec.europa.eu/employment_social/social_inclusion/docs/child_poverty_study_en.pdf
40 R. Sabates-Wheeler, The Impact of Irregular Status on Human Development Outcomes for Migrants, Human Development
Research Paper 2009/26, 2009 http://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/19209/1/MPRA_paper_19209.pdf and S. Carrera,
M.Merlino, Undocumented Immigrants and Rights in the EU. Addressing the Gap between Social Science research and
Policy-making in the Stockholm Programme?, CEPS, 2009, p. 33. http://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/5087071.pdf
41 European Union Fundamental Rights Agency. Migrants in an irregular situation: access to healthcare in 10 European
Union Member States, 2011. http://fra.europa.eu/sites/default/files/fra_uploads/1771-FRA-2011-fundamental-rights-for-
irregular-migrants-healthcare_EN.pdf
42 Platform for International Cooperation on Undocumented Migrants, Access to Health care for Undocumented Migrants
in Europe: The Key Role of Local and Regional Authorities, 2014, p.20. http://picum.org/picum.org/uploads/publication/
PolicyBrief_Local%20and%20Regional%20Authorities_AccessHealthCare_UndocumentedMigrants_Oct.2014.pdf
11PICUM POSITION PAPER
While some member states have shown progress in recent years – including Sweden43, which broadened its
entitlements for undocumented migrants in legislation in 2013, or Italy, which now allows undocumented children
accompanied by their parents or other caregivers to access health care services through the national health
insurance system44 - others have restricted existing entitlements as a result of austerity measures (e.g. Spain45).
The costs of excluding The costs of excluding undocumented migrants from health
care services greatly surpass those of including them, since
undocumented migrants from their health condition will usually worsen, thus leading to
health care services greatly increased expenses to the state as emergency care is generally
surpass those of including them, more expensive than preventative care46. Exclusion of certain
since their health condition will groups of persons from health care creates potential wider
risks to community health and forces medical professionals to
usually worsen, thus leading take on unnecessary administrative burdens and to jeopardise
to increased expenses to the their medical ethics by having to refuse patients on grounds
state as emergency care is of residence status. Lack of entitlements on national level
generally more expensive than also puts enormous stress on local and regional governments
and civil society organisations that struggle to provide this
preventative care. essential service to all persons on the basis of medical needs.
Although the organisation and delivery of health services is in national level competence, according to the
Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, impacts on health must be considered and addressed in the
development and implementation of all relevant EU policies47. Inclusive and efficient health care provision for
undocumented migrants in all EU member states across the European Union is necessary to achieve public
health objectives, and can be better achieved through cooperation at European level. The European Commission
has to a limited extent recognised the increasing need to address undocumented migrants in its work on health
inequalities and universal access to health services through its Communication on Solidarity in Health: Reducing
Health Inequalities48 and the ensuing European Parliament Resolution on Reducing Health Inequalities in the EU,
which includes a call for ensuring access to health services for undocumented migrants.49
43 Red Cross Sweden, New law gives undocumented migrants the right to health care, 2013. http://www.redcross.se/
PageFiles/6433/webinfo%20sjukv%C3%A5rdslag%20engelska.pdf.
44 Platform for International Cooperation on Undocumented Migrants, op.cit. 2014, p.13.
45 Since 1 September 2013, a Royal Decree has limited adult undocumented migrants’ access to health care to emergency
and maternity health care only. Royal Decree Act 16/2012 (introducing Art 3ter.al.4 of Law 16/2003), http://www.boe.es/
diario_boe/txt.php?id=BOE-A-2012-5403.
46 Schäfer W et al., QUALICOPC, a multi-country study evaluating quality, costs and equity in primary care. BMC Family
Practice 2011;12:115. http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2296/12/115.
47 “A high level of human health protection shall be ensured in the definition and implementation of all Union policies and
activities” (Article 168).
48 European Commission Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council, the European
Economic and Social committee and the Committee of the Regions, Solidarity in Health: Reducing Health Inequalities in
the EU, 2009. http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?qid=1396946539740&uri=CELEX:52009DC0567.
49 European Parliament, Resolution of 8 March 2011 on reducing health inequalities in the EU, 2010/2089(INI), para 5.
http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=OJ:C:2012:199E:0025:0036:EN:PDF
12UNDOCUMENTED MIGRANTS AND THE EUROPE 2020 STRATEGY
2.6 Recommendations
Legislation:
>> Address the legislative, financial and administrative barriers faced by undocumented migrants and
organisations assisting them within the context of the Europe 2020 poverty target - in particular the lack
of access to the homeless and health care services - and promote social investments in these areas that
include all migrants irrespective of their residence status.
>> Revise the Facilitation Directive to decriminalise social assistance to undocumented migrants by explicitly
excluding provision of social and humanitarian services such as health care and homeless shelters from its
scope. Renting accommodation to undocumented migrants in an irregular situation should not be considered
facilitation of stay.
Policy:
>> Ensure undocumented migrants are addressed in the work of DG SANCO (Health and Food Safety) and DG
EMPL and systematically assess and explicitly address the impacts of policies across relevant sectors on
undocumented migrants.
>> Implement the Commission Recommendation Solidarity in Health: Reducing Health Inequalities and the
European Parliament Resolution on Reducing Health Inequalities in the EU, which includes a call for ensuring
access to health services for undocumented migrants.
>> Support member states in setting up a “firewall” - a clear separation in law and practice between the powers
and remit of health professionals, health administration, social service providers, local authorities and
migration law enforcement authorities. Requirements for public officials to report undocumented migrants to
immigration authorities should be eliminated and sharing of personal information for immigration enforcement
purposes should be prohibited. Detection practices should not be carried out in or near health care services.
>> Integrate the specific concerns of migrants, particularly undocumented migrants, in all EU instruments and
initiatives designed to improve progress on the Europe 2020 Strategy, including:
>> the implementation of the EU Social Investment Package
>> the Scoreboard for Social and Employment indicators
>> Country Specific Recommendations.
>> Enhance coordination between DG HOME, DG EMPL, DG SANCO, health and education professionals and
civil society organisations working with undocumented migrants through regular consultations.
Data:
>> Develop a system to collect comparable and anonymised data on irregular migration flows in the EU and the
impact of all public policies – migration control mechanisms, regularisation programmes, etc. - on the living
conditions of undocumented migrants and their access to basic services on a regular basis. Data disaggregated
by age, sex, country of origin, education, occupation, skill level and other relevant information such as
residence status, issuance of entry, exit and work permits, and changes in nationality should be collected and
disseminated. States should ensure the inclusion of households affected by migration in local statistical and
data systems, as well as in nationally-representative living standards, expenditure, and labor force surveys.
Member states should ensure that such data collection is not used for immigration control purposes.
Funding:
>> Invest in the research and provision of innovative and inclusive services that would respond to the urgent
need for durable solutions for the growing numbers of undocumented migrants among the EU’s homeless
population.
>> Channel relevant EU funding, unrestricted to regular residence status holders, to local level, where services
are delivered.
13PICUM POSITION PAPER
3. EDUCATION
3.1 References to migrants in the education target
The education target is mainly focused on reducing early-school leaving, which remains a significant problem
for the immigrant population. According to Eurostat data, foreign born children are most affected by early school
leaving in the EU. Although showing a positive general declining trend in recent years, in 2013, 11.1% native-born
children left education or training early compared to 22.7% of foreign-born children.50
Undocumented children in particular are vulnerable to early school leaving, due for example, to the lack of
further educational and work opportunities because of their migration status, financial restrictions for continuing
higher education, termination of their studies due to an order to leave the country, as well as fear of being
apprehended in school.51
3.2 Access to education and training for undocumented children and
youth
In addition to early-school leaving, restrictions in accessing and completing education and training and other
barriers such as detection practices that are linked to educational facilities52 prevent undocumented children
and youth from enjoying their right to education and development.
The right to education is enshrined in a number of international and European human rights instruments and the
right to free compulsory education is applicable to all children, regardless of immigration status.53 All EU member
states have laws on education that require children to attend schooling for at least eight years. In most countries,
this is understood to implicitly include undocumented children. While this means that participation in compulsory
education is often possible for undocumented children, the fact that the legislation is unclear commonly results
in administrative barriers, limitations in taking official examinations and receiving certification, and exclusion from
non-compulsory education.54
Restricted access to education during childhood will significantly impact children’s full enjoyment of childhood,
cognitive and social development, and future economic prospects. Such restrictions both violate children’s
rights and severely curtail the opportunities and benefits of migration for adolescents and youth, as well as for
the communities and societies they live in, as many undocumented children do obtain a residence status55 and
eventually become part of the EU work force.56
50 Eurostat, Early leavers from education and training by sex and country of birth, January 2015. http://appsso.eurostat.
ec.europa.eu/nui/show.do?dataset=edat_lfse_02&lang=en.
51 Special Rapporteur on the Human Rights of Migrants François Crépeau, PICUM, National University of Lanús,
Human Rights of Undocumented Adolescents and Youth, in partnership with OHCHR and UNICEF, July 2013, p. 34.
ht tp: // w w w.globalmigrationgroup.org /sites/default / f iles/uploads/gmg -topic s/mig - data / Human - Right s- of-
Undocumented-Adolescents-Youth.pdf.
52 This includes arrests at and near or on way to school on grounds of the residence status of children or their parents and
mandatory passing of residence information from school administration to migration authorities.
53 EU Fundamental Rights Agency, op.cit., A comparative report, 2011, p.85.
54 Platform for International Cooperation on Undocumented Migrants, Protecting undocumented children: Promising policies
and practices from governments, 2015, p. 4, forthcoming.
55 The Regularisations in the European Union (REGINE) study demonstrates that children have been a preferential group in
the regularisation programmes and mechanisms across Europe, op.cit.,,2009, p. 51.
56 Special Rapporteur on the Human Rights of Migrants François Crépeau, PICUM, National University of Lanús, op. cit., p. 16.
14UNDOCUMENTED MIGRANTS AND THE EUROPE 2020 STRATEGY
Schools should represent Schools should represent safe environments, where school
administrations do not report undocumented children to the
safe environments, where immigration authorities and children and parents are not arrested
school administrations do by immigration authorities within the vicinity of schools or on their
not report undocumented way to school.
children to the immigration Some countries have put in place measures to allow for families
authorities and children and to request deportation proceedings to be postponed if children
parents are not arrested by are attending school, so as not to interrupt their education. Where
children are at threat of deportation, there are examples from around
immigration authorities within
the world of school communities and civil society mobilising to
the vicinity of schools or on support fellow students and their families, and prevent deportation,
their way to school. or campaigning for re-entry if deported.57
3.3 Recommendations
Legislation:
>> Address the legislative, financial and administrative barriers faced by undocumented children within the
Europe 2020 education target - in particular the lack of access to the same statutory education as national
children - and promote social investments in the area of education that include all children and youth
irrespective of their or their parents’ residence status.
>> If an undocumented child is facing a deportation order, Peer learning- more towards EU promote measures
that delay deportation until children have completed the school year and any pending examinations, with
possibilities for further delay for children to finish their compulsory education or regularisation based on the
acquirement of education, depending on individual circumstances and the best interests of the child.
Policy:
>> Support member states in setting up of a “firewall” - a clear separation in law and practice between the powers
of school administration, social service providers, local authorities and migration law enforcement authorities.
Requirements for school administration to report undocumented migrants to immigration authorities should
be eliminated. Sharing of information about the migration status of students and their families for immigration
enforcement purposes should be prohibited. Detection practices should not be carried out within the vicinity
of schools or students’ way to school.
>> Enhance coordination between DG EAC (Education, Culture, Youth and Citizenship), DG HOME, DG EMPL,
DG SANCO, health and education professionals and civil society organisations working with undocumented
children through regular consultations.
>> Ensure that undocumented children are included systematically in the work of DG EAC and the peer-to-peer
mechanisms for good practice exchange among member states coordinated by DG EAC.
Data:
>> Improve research and develop system to collect comparable and anonymised data disaggregated by
variables such as age, sex, country of origin, education, occupation, skill level and other relevant information
such as residence status, issuance of entry, exit and work permits, and changes in nationality and the
developmental impact of early-school leaving among undocumented children and on regularisations of
undocumented children across the EU. Member states should ensure that such data collection is not used for
immigration control purposes
57 Special Rapporteur on the Human Rights of Migrants François Crépeau, PICUM, National University of Lanús, op. cit., p. 31.
15You can also read
