COST RECOVERY IMPLEMENTATION STATEMENT - PERSONAL PROPERTY SECURITIES REGISTER - the PPSR

Page created by Kyle Nguyen
 
CONTINUE READING
COST RECOVERY IMPLEMENTATION STATEMENT - PERSONAL PROPERTY SECURITIES REGISTER - the PPSR
COST RECOVERY
         IMPLEMENTATION STATEMENT
           PERSONAL PROPERTY SECURITIES REGISTER
                                        Effective 1 July 2018

           Cost recovery involves government entities charging individuals or non-
           government organisations some or all of the efficient costs of a regulatory
           activity. This may include goods, services or regulation, or a combination of
           them. The Australian Government Charging Framework1, which
           incorporates the Cost Recovery Guidelines, sets out the framework under
           which government entities design, implement and review regulatory
           charging activities.

1
 The Australian Government Charging Framework and the CRGs are available on the Department of Finance
website (www.finance.gov.au).
PPSR COST RECOVERY IMPLEMENTATION STATEMENT - AFSA

CONTENTS
CONTENTS.......................................................................................................................... 2
INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................................. 3
   PURPOSE OF THE CRIS ....................................................................................................... 3
   DESCRIPTION OF THE REGULATORY CHARGING ACTIVITY.......................................................... 3
POLICY AND STATUTORY AUTHORITY TO COST RECOVER .......................................... 5
   GOVERNMENT POLICY APPROVAL TO COST RECOVER THE REGULATORY ACTIVITY ....................... 5
   STATUTORY AUTHORITY TO CHARGE ...................................................................................... 5
COST RECOVERY MODEL ................................................................................................. 6
   OUTPUTS AND BUSINESS PROCESSES OF THE REGULATORY CHARGING ACTIVITY ........................ 6
   COSTS OF THE ACTIVITY ....................................................................................................... 6
VOLUME FORECASTS ........................................................................................................ 7
FINANCIAL RESERVES ....................................................................................................... 8
STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT ....................................................................................... 10
FINANCIAL ESTIMATES .................................................................................................... 10
FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE............................................................................................. 11
NON-FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE .................................................................................... 11
RISK ASSESSMENT .......................................................................................................... 12
KEY FORWARD DATES AND EVENTS ............................................................................. 13
CRIS APPROVAL AND CHANGE REGISTER .................................................................... 14
ANNEX A: PROPOSED ACTIVITIES AND SCHEDULED CHARGES ................................. 15
ANNEX B: LEGISLATIVE AUTHORITY TO CHARGE ......................................................... 17
ANNEX C: VOLUMES RELATING TO EACH CHARGE ...................................................... 18
ANNEX D: ACTUAL VS FORECAST VOLUMES VARIANCE FOR PAST YEARS............... 19

5/4/2018                                                      www.afsa.gov.au                                                  Page 2 of 19
PPSR COST RECOVERY IMPLEMENTATION STATEMENT - AFSA

INTRODUCTION
PURPOSE OF THE CRIS
This Cost Recovery Implementation Statement (CRIS) provides stakeholders with information on how
the Australian Financial Security Authority (AFSA) implements cost recovery for the Personal Property
Securities Register (PPSR). The document seeks to demonstrate the link between the price charged
for a PPSR service and cost of the effort to deliver the activity.

This CRIS also reports financial and non-financial performance information for the PPSR and contains
financial forecasts for 2018-19 and three forward years. AFSA will maintain the CRIS until the activity
or cost recovery for the activity has been discontinued.

DESCRIPTION OF THE REGULATORY CHARGING ACTIVITY
Background

AFSA’s policy outcome on behalf of the Australian Government is to:

            Maintain confidence in Australia’s personal insolvency and personal
            property securities systems through delivering fair, efficient and
            effective trustee and registry services, and risk-based regulation.

This policy outcome is delivered through two separate programs:

    1. Personal Insolvency and Trustee Services; and
    2. Operation of a National Register of Security Interests in Personal Property.

The funding of these two programs is managed separately and this is reflected in a separate CRIS
for the activities of each program. This CRIS focuses only on the PPSR activities. PPSR activities are
100% cost recovered, with the revenue retained by AFSA. AFSA does not receive appropriation
funding for the PPSR.

Under the Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (PPS Act), the PPS Registrar is responsible for the
operation of the PPSR. AFSA has operational responsibility for administration of the PPSR. AFSA’s
Chief Operating Officer holds the position of PPS Registrar. The Attorney-General’s Department has
responsibility for the Personal Properties Securities (‘PPS’) policy and legislation.

The PPSR is a national online register that offers important consumer protection. Consumers and
businesses can check whether any valuable goods are free from existing financed debt and safe
from possible repossession, before they purchase.

Businesses that sell on retention of title or consignment, or hire or lease out goods for more than
two years, can register to protect their security interest in case a customer becomes insolvent.
Businesses can also use their assets as collateral to raise finance.

The PPSR covers goods and assets that are not land, buildings or fixtures, such as motor vehicles,
boats, crops, livestock and other items.

5/4/2018                                 www.afsa.gov.au                              Page 3 of 19
PPSR COST RECOVERY IMPLEMENTATION STATEMENT - AFSA

Key Activity Groups

Operation of the PPSR can be categorised into two key activity groups:

    1. Registrations - security interests over personal property (not land, buildings or fixtures) can be
       registered, amended and discharged on the PPSR; and
    2. Searches - clients can search the PPSR to ascertain if a security interest is held relating to a
       specific person or item of personal property.

These two activity groups are derived from AFSA’s responsibility for administration of the PPS Act,
as it relates to the register, and the provision and maintenance of the necessary systems and
processes that allow users to access the Register in order to:

          register financing statements (the term for data which is to be registered)
          amend existing financing statements
          discharge financing statements
          search the register
          obtain a copy of the full search results.

AFSA makes the online environment available 24/7. It also develops and maintains the processes
required to ensure high quality data on the PPSR.

Stakeholders

Based on historical data, PPSR stakeholders fall into the following categories:

Fee-paying stakeholders (end users):

Registrations
    Secured parties (creditor, lender, supplier or lessor) lodging security interests over personal
       property.

Searches
    Parties interested in the security position of personal property.

Non-fee paying stakeholders

Debtors and Grantors
    Parties who must pay or perform the primary obligation(s) owed to the creditor or party
       making the relevant advances/loans.
    Other parties who have interests in secured assets being used as collateral.

Charging Context

Charging for PPSR activities is in accordance with the Australian Government Charging Framework
(‘the Charging Framework’). The Charging Framework encompasses the Australian Government
Cost Recovery Guidelines which together help to deliver the following:

          Promote equity, whereby the recipients who create the need for a government activity, rather
           than the general public, bear its costs:

5/4/2018                                     www.afsa.gov.au                             Page 4 of 19
PPSR COST RECOVERY IMPLEMENTATION STATEMENT - AFSA

          Influence demand for government activities;
          Improve the efficiency, productivity and responsiveness of government activities and
           accountability for those activities; and
          Increase cost consciousness for all stakeholders by raising awareness of how much a
           government activity costs.

Proposed Changes to Fees and Charges

A schedule of proposed charges effective 1 July 2018 is attached as Annex A.

Changes to fees and charges have broadly resulted from the following:

          Increased search and registration volumes reducing the per unit cost;
          Decreased costs including delayed replacement of the PPSR system; and
          Cessation of funding recovery for enhancements due to retained balance of this reserve.

The delay in the replacement of the PPSR system itself resulted from the Digital Transformation
Agency reforms, specifically relating to ICT projects over $10 million dollars and the associated
risk. These reforms prompted an independent review of the system which concluded that the existing
system was capable of being significantly enhanced. Improving useability and implementing
legislative reform in relation to the PPSR could be undertaken via incremental system enhancement,
thereby enabling AFSA to manage and mitigate overall implementation risk more effectively.

POLICY AND STATUTORY AUTHORITY TO COST RECOVER
GOVERNMENT POLICY APPROVAL TO COST RECOVER THE
REGULATORY ACTIVITY
The Australian Government’s policy since the establishment of the PPSR, announced in the 2007-08
Budget, is for its operation to be fully cost recovered. The proposed charges to be introduced effective
from 1 July 2018 will ensure that the full cost base of the PPSR is recovered.

STATUTORY AUTHORITY TO CHARGE
The statutory authority for AFSA’s fees is provided under Section 190 of the PPS Act which provides
that the Minister (the Attorney-General), may by legislative instrument, determine fees for registration
and search services. Details of the current fees will be set out in the Personal Property Securities
(Fees) Determination 2018 (when approved) and made available at www.comlaw.gov.au .

The specific legislative provisions for each of AFSA’s proposed charges are detailed in Annex B.

The PPSR fees are not subject to Goods and Services Tax (GST) under A New Tax System (Goods
and Services Tax) Act 1999 and A New Tax System (Goods and Services Tax) Amendment
Regulations 2013 (No.2).

5/4/2018                                   www.afsa.gov.au                           Page 5 of 19
PPSR COST RECOVERY IMPLEMENTATION STATEMENT - AFSA

COST RECOVERY MODEL
OUTPUTS AND BUSINESS PROCESSES OF THE REGULATORY
CHARGING ACTIVITY
As described in the section ‘Key Activity Groups’ of this CRIS, the ultimate objective of the PPSR is
to facilitate the registration of security interests and the ability to search the PPSR to ascertain if a
security interest is held relating to a specific person or item of personal property.

AFSA’s involvement at the transaction-level in the vast majority of the actual registrations and
searches is by providing automated internet-based processes. AFSA’s efforts (and costs) are
focused toward operating, maintaining, and enhancing the PPSR infrastructure and functionality.

COSTS OF THE ACTIVITY
Overview of Costs

The proposed charges reflect the cost of effort to deliver PPSR services. AFSA utilises an Activity-
Based Costing (ABC) model for calculating the costs of the processes required to deliver the activities
provided. The ABC model is built utilising a work effort survey for each activity, ensuring that
resources dedicated to maintaining service level standards are appropriately captured against
relevant charges.

AFSA costs are assigned to each activity either as a direct or indirect cost as described in the following
sections. A summary of assigned costs is noted below.

 Cost Type   Category           %     Description

             ICT               41     Depreciation and amortisation of the PPSR software and infrastructure,
                                      infrastructure operating costs, service providers and other ICT personnel
                                      directly attributable to the PPSR.

 Direct      Corporate          0     N/A

             Business          18     Contact Centre support staff and other PPSR-related business areas.

             ICT               10     Expenses relating to support of corporate IT systems.

 Indirect    Corporate         31     Corporate costs including management, finance, legal, communications,
                                      property and human resources.

             Business           0     N/A

             TOTAL             100

Direct Costs

Direct costs are assigned where they can be directly traced to an activity. By analysing each team’s
structure and processes, costs such as direct employee expenses and direct supplier costs were
identified and attributed to the relevant activity.

A detailed analysis of ICT costs was undertaken which identified direct costs associated with each

5/4/2018                                    www.afsa.gov.au                                   Page 6 of 19
PPSR COST RECOVERY IMPLEMENTATION STATEMENT - AFSA

activity. These include the operational costs of supporting applications, dedicated servers and ICT
infrastructure dedicated specifically to operating the PPSR. Costs were allocated by identifying
storage capacity, length of processes and activity volumes.

Indirect Costs

Indirect costs represent all costs that cannot be directly attributed to a specific process. These costs
are typically corporate functions, infrastructure operational costs and management responsibilities
related to PPSR activities.

Indirect costs have been allocated into a number of cost pools, based on either staff, capacity or
volume-driven cost drivers. The choice between using staff, capacity or volume based drivers has
been determined with reference to the functions of the cost pools.

Examples of the PPSR-related cost pools which are treated as indirect costs are:

          PPSR Statistics & Corporate Reporting
          PPSR Information Management
          PPSR Communications
          PPSR Media
          PPSR Corporate Publications
          PPSR Web Content.

Corporate costs allocated on a FTE basis include property and certain human resources activities. A
calculation is made of the proportion of workforce effort dedicated to each of AFSA’s major business
processes. The full costs of these particular teams will be apportioned to both insolvency and PPSR
activities within AFSA. Other corporate costs such as finance and ICT are allocated using a
combination of FTE, capacity and volumes where applicable. An example of finance costs that are
volume driven in the allocation of costs to business processes are Treasury. ICT costs identified as
volume driven include items such as Servers and Data Storage.

Relationship between Depreciation and Capital Expenditure

Depreciation of AFSA’s fixed assets, and amortisation of AFSA’s intangible assets, are subsets of
both the direct and indirect costs above.

The proposed charges presented in this CRIS are costed to cover all of AFSA’s operating costs,
including depreciation and amortisation of assets. Depreciation and amortisation are used as a proxy
for the likely capital expenditure required for the replacement of assets in future.

VOLUME FORECASTS
Charges for each PPSR activity are derived by applying forecast volumes against the respective
costs. The proposed fees utilise 2018-19 forecast volumes.

Past trends have been overlaid against expected economic conditions over the foreseeable future to
arrive at the quoted volume forecasts contained within this CRIS document. Details of forecast
volumes are outlined in Annex C.

5/4/2018                                  www.afsa.gov.au                            Page 7 of 19
PPSR COST RECOVERY IMPLEMENTATION STATEMENT - AFSA

Material changes in volumes will be addressed through a new CRIS. All activity movements will be
assessed annually for impacts on costings to ensure compliance with the charging framework i.e. that
charges reflect the efficient cost of service.

The demand for AFSA’s activities, and therefore AFSA’s revenue stream, is sensitive to market
fluctuations. The operating costs of the PPSR are predominantly fixed costs. The scenario of variable
revenue and fixed costs increases the risk of AFSA either over-recovering or under-recovering
revenue to match the PPSR operating costs. AFSA continuously monitors PPSR revenue to ensure
charging is appropriate.

Volumetric Past Performance

Annex D provides a historical view of the volumetric performance against each category in order to
highlight the areas that have contributed to the over recovery to date. As outlined earlier within this
same document PPSR is a relatively new system having been introduced in 2012 and as such the
level of data that was available in its infancy to accurately project activity into the out years was very
limited. Price adjustments and volumetric updates have been progressively made since 2012 (via
new CRIS documents) as trends emerge.

Historical and Proposed Charges

AFSA publishes all relevant charges, along with current and previous CRISs on the ‘cost recovery’
page on its website at the following address:

http://www.ppsr.gov.au/AbouttheRegister/AboutFees/Pages/CostRecoveryImpactStatement.aspx

FINANCIAL RESERVES
The total funds held by AFSA comprise of the Capital Investment Reserve (CIR) and the Cost
Recovery Operating Reserve (CROR).

Capital Investment Reserve

Since commencement of the PPSR, AFSA has recovered funds for enhancement and replacement
of PPSR assets. These funds are set aside in the CIR. The historical accumulated balance of the
CIR is detailed in Table 1.

Table 1

                                        2013-14          2014-15           2015-16         2016-2017
                                          ’000             ’000              ’000             ’000

 Opening Capital Investment
                                        $6,653            $7,800           $15,398          $25,193
 Reserve
 Depreciation Contribution              $12,664          $13,891           $13,446          $10,112

 Investment expenditure                -$11,517           -$6,294          -$3,651           -$3,805
 Closing Capital Investment
                                        $7,800           $15,398           $25,193          $31,501
 Reserve

5/4/2018                                   www.afsa.gov.au                             Page 8 of 19
PPSR COST RECOVERY IMPLEMENTATION STATEMENT - AFSA

The forward projections for the CIR are detailed in Table 2.

Table 2

                                             2017-18              2018-19     2019-20    2020-21        2021-22
                                               ’000                 ’000        ’000       ’000           ’000
 Opening Capital Investment                  $31,501              $30,301     $29,817     $27,065       $19,313
 Reserve
 Depreciation Contribution                    $3,000               $5,378      $5,378     $5,378            $5,378

 Investment Expenditure                      -$4,200              -$5,862      -$8,130   -$13,130       -$16,170

 Closing Capital Investment                  $30,301              $29,817     $27,065     $19,313           $8,521
 Reserve

The major expenditure from CIR over the forward years will be the enhancement of the PPSR and
associated infrastructure. The options for replacement are under review and outcomes will determine
the capital requirements in later years. If AFSA is holding excess funds, strategies will be considered
to realign CIR balances.

Cost Recovery Operating Reserve

AFSA proposes to utilise a CROR to manage the under/ over recovery of fees. The CROR balance
would be maintained at no more than ten percent of annual program expenditure.

AFSA will transfer any accumulated reserve surplus funds to government as part of the management
strategy for CROR. This strategy has been developed as:

     1. It would be impracticable to return surplus funds to past customers for two main reasons:
            a) it would require tracing actual customers through third party service providers; and
            b) the administrative effort involved would be significant and likely result in small returns
                to past customers;
     2. An insufficient nexus exists between past end users of the register and future end users to
        enable returning the funds through reduced future fees; and
     3. AFSA is also unable to retain these funds under the government funding framework.

Table 3 outlines the forward projections of the balance of the Cost Recovery Operating Reserve.

Table 3

 Cost Recovery Operating                    2017-18            2018-19       2019-20     2020-21        2021-22
 Reserve                                      ’000               ’000          ’000        ’000           ’000

 Opening Reserve                            $40,870            $12,081       $4,082      $4,082             $4,082

 Operating Results                          $6,594               $0            $0          $0                $0
 Transfer to Government*                   -$35,383            -$7,999         $0          $0                $0
 Closing Reserve                            $12,081             $4,082       $4,082      $4,082             $4,082
*Refer to page 9 detailing management of ‘Cost Recovery Operating Reserve’

5/4/2018                                             www.afsa.gov.au                         Page 9 of 19
PPSR COST RECOVERY IMPLEMENTATION STATEMENT - AFSA

Total Financial Reserve Funds

Table 4 provides a summary of total funds held by AFSA relating to CIR and CROR.

Table 4

 Combined Reserves                        2017-18           2018-19            2019-20          2020-21            2021-22
                                            ’000              ’000               ’000             ’000               ’000
                                          $30,301           $29,817            $27,065           $19,313           $8,521
 Capital Investment Reserve
 Cost Recovery Operating                  $12,081            $4,082            $4,082              $4,082          $4,082
 Reserve
                                          $42,382           $33,899            $31,147           $23,395           $12,603
 Balance

STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT
Stakeholder Consultation

This version of the CRIS has been prepared for stakeholder consultation. Feedback from
stakeholders will be incorporated in the final version of the CRIS and will be summarised in this
section.

FINANCIAL ESTIMATES
Projections

Table 5 outlines the financial results, which AFSA is currently expecting to achieve against the PPSR
program. Forward projections cover the period for which published Portfolio Budget Statements are
available.

Table 5

 Expenses and                 2017-18             2018-19             2019-20              2020-21             2021-22
 Revenues                    (Budget)               ‘000                ‘000                 ‘000                ‘000
                                ‘000
 Operating                    $38,424             $35,168              $35,168             $35,168             $35,168
 Expenses[1] = X
 Depreciation                  $3,000              $5,378              $5,378               $5,378              $5,378
 Expense
 Total Expenses =             $41,424             $40,546              $40,546             $40,546             $40,546
 X
 Revenue = Y                  $48,018             $40,546              $40,546             $40,546             $40,546

 Operating                     $6,594                $0                   $0                  $0                  $0
 Results
 (Balance[1] = Y –
 X)
Materiality defined by AASB1031 and PGPA (Financial Reporting) Rule 2015, AASB 108 Accounting Policies, Changes in Accounting
Estimates and Errors and AASB 101 Presentation of Financial Statements as defined by AASB108.

5/4/2018                                          www.afsa.gov.au                                     Page 10 of 19
PPSR COST RECOVERY IMPLEMENTATION STATEMENT - AFSA

FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE
Historical Performance

Table 6 outlines the historical financial performance of the PPSR program.

Table 6

                                                  2013-14                 2014-15                   2015-16                2016-2017
                                                    ‘000                    ‘000                      ‘000                    ‘000
                                                  $31,905                 $36,029                   $37,135                  $37,556
 Operating Expenses*
                                                  $10,965                  $8,018                      $0                        $0
 Repayment to Government*^
                                                  $42,870                 $44,047                   $37,135                  $37,556
 Total Expenses = X
                                                  $49,742                 $51,789                   $46,423                  $48,721
 Revenue = Y
                                                   $6,872                  $7,742                   $9,288                   $11,165
 Balance = Y – X

 Opening Cost Recovery                            $11,223                 $18,096                   $25,838                  $32,126
 Operating Reserve
                                                   $6,872                  $7,742                   $6,288                    $8,744
 Transfer in/ (Out)+
 Closing Cost Recovery                            $18,096                 $25,838                   $32,126                  $40,870
 Operating Reserve
* Excludes recoveries for enhancements of PPSR and associated expenditure – refer to CIR table. ^ Repayment to Government represents funding to
establish PPSR. + AFSA returned $3.0m to government in 2015-16 and $2.43m in 2016-17 due to efficiency arrangements

The Cost Recovery Operating Reserve has accumulated funds over the years due to various reasons.
Several factors are outlined on page 5 ‘Proposed Changes to Fees”. Other factors include delays to
update fees due to anticipated changes arising from the statutory review of the PPS Act. The review
is yet to be finalised with an exact date unknown at this stage. The strategy to manage Cost Recovery
Operating Reserve is outlined on page 9.

NON-FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE
Estimates of activity for future years are shown at Annex C. Annex D shows the alignment/difference
of actual activity with estimates. Variations of actual activity from estimates will also be the basis of
the review of cost attribution and prices annually.

The table below describes the goals and performance measures for the activity covered in this CRIS.
At the end of the financial year, the results against each performance measure will be published.
These performance measures are reflected in AFSA’s corporate plan 2017-18 with a focus on aligning
AFSA’s operations to best achieve AFSA’s targets as outlined within the Attorney-General’s Portfolio
Budget Statements.

5/4/2018                                                  www.afsa.gov.au                                           Page 11 of 19
PPSR COST RECOVERY IMPLEMENTATION STATEMENT - AFSA

Key Performance Indicators

 Our Goals       Performance Measures

                 Stakeholder feedback demonstrates outcomes achieved have assisted in creating an
                 environment that minimises harm caused by significant non-compliance with the law or a
                 failure by the regulated community to adhere to an expected standard of behaviour.
 Foster          95% of referrers notified of assessment decision within 15 working days of receipt of
 Confidence      allegation and all relevant information.

                 More than 90% of investigations completed within 12 months of acceptance for investigation.
                 Proportion of online registry services availability is greater than or equal to 99%.

 Deliver Value   Positive financial result for personal property securities program.

 Effective
                 Improved customer satisfaction.
 Services

 Quality
                 Improved customer satisfaction.
 Information

RISK ASSESSMENT
Risks

This section provides analysis of the risks relevant to AFSA’s cost recovery on the PPSR, in terms of
materiality, complexity and sensitivity.

Materiality

AFSA is funded so that cost recovered revenue covers all of its operating expenses. AFSA manages
its expenses for the PPSR from revenue raised as it does not receive appropriations from Government
for this activity. This scenario makes it crucial for AFSA to reliably forecast its expected volumes and
revenue. Significant time and effort is undertaken to ensure the volumetric forecasts are accurate
and reliable to ensure AFSA’s cost structures remain largely aligned to any revenue fluctuations.

AFSA may over or under recover revenue due to inaccurate costs and/or volumes. AFSA continually
monitors its revenue in comparison to its operating costs on a program basis. Material variances are
monitored and managed in accordance with the Commonwealth Charging Framework and may result
in the development of a new CRIS.

Complexity

PPSR fees and services by their nature are simple, as the product which one obtains for a given fee
is clearly defined.

While the output of the PPSR as a system is clearly defined, and while AFSA operates under a policy
of the Register being readily available, the Register does possess the inherent complexities
associated with maintaining a system so that it is continually operational (i.e. 24/7). System outages

5/4/2018                                     www.afsa.gov.au                             Page 12 of 19
PPSR COST RECOVERY IMPLEMENTATION STATEMENT - AFSA

and planned maintenance can compromise AFSA’s service delivery of the PPSR. From a policy
perspective however, the PPS Act (s147) affords some flexibility, allowing the Registrar to not operate
the PPSR when it is not practical to do so. This power is generally only exercised marginally, and
when possible, it is exercised at times which have minimal impact on end users. For example, the
PPSR is scheduled to be maintained between 9pm and midnight every Wednesday, Canberra time.
AFSA endeavors to provide ample communications to stakeholders before any scheduled
maintenance which makes the PPSR unavailable to users.

AFSA does not expect these inherent complexities to substantially impact the revenue derived by the
PPSR.

Sensitivity

Historically, revenue derived from PPSR fees has been above forecasts each year of operation,
noting that the system only commenced in 2012. PPSR revenue could be adversely affected by a
downturn in areas of the market where goods are frequently purchased through secured financing
arrangements. AFSA continually monitors its revenue in comparison to its operating costs.

AFSA seeks to ensure forecasted volumes are as robust as possible, understanding the inherent
limitations that exist with all forecasting work. The CROR will assist to manage fluctuations in volumes
and their impacts on revenue until AFSA can implement updated charges.

KEY FORWARD DATES AND EVENTS
The following key dates are guides to expected activity within the PPSR program:

April 2018:  Public consultation to be confirmed.
May 2018:      Accountable Authority certification and Ministerial approval of the CRIS.
June 2018:     Publication of the final version of the CRIS.
July 2018:     Implementation of revised fees.
October 2018: Update of key performance indicators, financial forecasts and results.
October 2019: Review and update key performance indicators, financial forecasts and results.
November 2019: Update volume forecasts
October 2020: Review and update key performance indicators, financial forecasts and results.
November 2020: Update volume forecasts

5/4/2018                                  www.afsa.gov.au                           Page 13 of 19
PPSR COST RECOVERY IMPLEMENTATION STATEMENT - AFSA

CRIS APPROVAL AND CHANGE REGISTER
  Date of CRIS change   CRIS change                 Approver      Basis for change

                                                    Title of      Updated schedule of
  XX/02/2018            Certification of the CRIS   accountable   charges
                                                    authority
                                                    Title of      Updated schedule of
  XX/02/2018            Agreement to the CRIS       responsible   charges
                                                    minister

5/4/2018                               www.afsa.gov.au                      Page 14 of 19
PPSR COST RECOVERY IMPLEMENTATION STATEMENT - AFSA

ANNEX A: PROPOSED ACTIVITIES AND SCHEDULED CHARGES

 REF. NO.   ACTIVITY GROUPS                                                    Online                Online              Contact Centre             2018-19                    2019-20                    2020-21                2021-22

            Register or amend a Financing Statement and related          Previous Charge             Charge                  Charge                 Revenue                 Revenue                   Revenue                    Revenue
    1       charges                                                      $ (GST Exclusive)      $ (GST Exclusive)       $ (GST Exclusive)              $                       $                         $                          $

            Register a Financing Statement where the duration is 7
   1.01     years or less                                                  $             6.80   $               6.00    $                   -   $       12,652,992     $          12,652,992      $          12,652,992      $       12,652,992

            Register a Financing Statement where the duration is
   1.02     more than 7 years but less than or equal to 25 years           $            34.00   $              25.00    $                   -   $        2,347,200     $           2,347,200      $           2,347,200      $         2,347,200

   1.03     Register a Financing Statement for a not stated end time       $        119.00      $             115.00    $                   -   $        6,105,810     $           6,105,810      $           6,105,810      $         6,105,810

            TOTAL REGISTRATIONS                                                                                                                 $       21,106,002     $          21,106,002      $          21,106,002      $       21,106,002

            Register or amend a Financing Statement and related
    2       charges

            Amend a Financing Statement where the duration is 7
            years or less (e.g. extension of end date, addition of a
   2.01     grantor)                                                       $             6.80   $               6.00    $                   -   $        1,012,380     $           1,012,380      $           1,012,380      $        1,012,380

            Amend Financing Statement where the duration is more
            than 7 years but less than or equal to 25 years (e.g.
   2.02     extension of end date, addition of a grantor)                  $            34.00   $              25.00    $                   -   $             73,725   $                 73,725   $                 73,725   $             73,725

            Amend a Financing Statement for a not stated end time
   2.03     (e.g. additional grantor)                                      $        119.00      $             115.00    $                   -   $             86,135   $                 86,135   $                 86,135   $             86,135

            Amend registration (end time to an earlier time, or remove
   2.04     grantor where multiple grantors exist)                         $                -   $                   -   $                   -   $                 -     $                     -   $                      -   $                 -

            TOTAL AMENDMENTS                                                                                                                    $        1,172,240         $       1,172,240          $       1,172,240      $       1,172,240

5/04/2018                                                                        www.afsa.gov.au                                                              Page 15 of 19
PPSR COST RECOVERY IMPLEMENTATION STATEMENT - AFSA

 REF. NO.                         ACTIVITY GROUPS                                        Online                        Online                  Contact Centre                     2018-19                2019-20                2020-21                  2021-22

                                                                                    Previous Charge                           Charge                     Charge                        Revenue                Revenue                 Revenue                   Revenue
    3         Discharge Financing Statement                                        $ (GST Exclusive)                $ (GST Exclusive)          $ (GST Exclusive)                             $                      $                       $                         $

   3.01       Discharge Financing Statement                                       $                   -      $                         -   $                        -     $                  -       $                  -   $                -       $                    -

              TOTAL DISCHARGES                                                                                                                                            $                 -        $                  -   $                -       $                    -

    4         Searches (note 1)

   4.01       Search - via all available avenues                                  $               3.40      $                   2.00       $                7.00           $          18,268,248     $      18,268,248      $       18,268,248       $       18,268,248

              TOTAL SEARCHES                                                                                                                                               $          18,268,248     $      18,268,248      $       18,268,248       $       18,268,248

    5         Other

              Develop a special purpose report for Account Holders ($
   5.01       per hour)                                                           $                   -         $                      -   $             300.00               $                  -   $                  -   $                -           $                -

   5.02       Maintenance of Registrations (note 2)                               $               4.00          $                4.00      $                    -             $                  -   $                  -   $                -           $                -

              TOTAL OTHER                                                                                                                                                     $                  -   $                  -   $                -           $                -

              TOTAL PPSR                                                                                                                                                       $      40,546,490     $     40,546,490           $   40,546,490           $   40,546,490

   Note 1. Search fee allows drill down on each returned registration and includes search certificate. A search may be re-accessed following the provision of the initial search results.

   Note 2. Revenue has been estimated at nil on the basis that an unpaid maintenance fee is not enforceable as debt owed to the Commonwealth (refer to section 2.1 of this CRIS).

   Note 3. The above fees are not subject to GST.

22/2/2018                                                                                                           www.afsa.gov.au                                                                                                  Page 16 of 19
PPSR COST RECOVERY IMPLEMENTATION STATEMENT - AFSA

ANNEX B: LEGISLATIVE AUTHORITY TO CHARGE
 REF. NO.                                                              ACTIVITY GROUPS                                                          AUTHORITY TO RECOVER

      1     Register or amend a Financing Statement and related charges

    1.01    Register a Financing Statement where the duration is 7 years or less                                                                PPS Act s150, s190

    1.02    Register a Financing Statement where the duration is more than 7 years but less than or equal to 25 years                           PPS Act s150, s190

    1.03    Register a Financing Statement for a not stated end time                                                                            PPS Act s150, s190

      2     Register or amend a Financing Statement and related charges

    2.01    Amend a Financing Statement where the duration is 7 years or less (e.g. extension of end date, addition of a grantor)               PPS Act s150, s190

    2.02    Amend Financing Statement where the duration is more than 7 years but less than or equal to 25 years (e.g. extension of end date,   PPS Act s150, s190
            addition of a grantor)

    2.03    Amend a Financing Statement for a not stated end time (e.g. additional grantor)                                                     PPS Act s150, s190

    2.04    Amend registration (end time to an earlier time, or remove grantor where multiple grantors exist)                                   PPS Act s150, s190

      3     Discharge Financing Statement

    3.01    Discharge Financing Statement                                                                                                       PPS Act s150, s190

      4     Searches

    4.01    Search - via all available avenues                                                                                                  PPS Act s170, s190

      5     Other

    5.01    Develop a special purpose report for Account Holders ($ per hour)                                                                   PPS Act s176, s190

    5.02    Maintenance of Registrations (note 2)                                                                                               PPS Act s168, s190

5/04/2018                                                                       www.afsa.gov.au                                                               Page 17 of 19
PPSR COST RECOVERY IMPLEMENTATION STATEMENT - AFSA

ANNEX C: VOLUMES RELATING TO EACH CHARGE
 REF.                                            ACTIVITY GROUPS                                              2018-19      2019-20      2020-21         2021-22
 NO.

    1    Register or amend a Financing Statement and related charges                                          Volumes      Volumes      Volumes         Volumes

  1.01   Register a Financing Statement where the duration is 7 years or less                                2,108,832    2,108,832    2,108,832       2,108,832

  1.02   Register a Financing Statement where the duration is more than 7 years but less than or equal to     93,888       93,888       93,888          93,888
         25 years

  1.03   Register a Financing Statement for a not stated end time                                             53,094       53,094       53,094          53,094

         TOTAL REGISTRATIONS                                                                                 2,255,813    2,255,813    2,255,813       2,255,813

    2    Register or amend a Financing Statement and related charges

  2.01   Amend a Financing Statement where the duration is 7 years or less (e.g. extension of end date,       168,730      168,730      168,730         168,730
         addition of a grantor)

  2.02   Amend Financing Statement where the duration is more than 7 years but less than or equal to 25        2,949        2,949        2,949           2,949
         years (e.g. extension of end date, addition of a grantor)

  2.03   Amend a Financing Statement for a not stated end time (e.g. additional grantor)                        749          749          749             749

  2.04   Amend registration (end time to an earlier time, or remove grantor where multiple grantors exist)    38,545       38,545       38,545          38,545

         TOTAL AMENDMENTS                                                                                     210,973      210,973      210,973         210,973

    3    Discharge Financing Statement

  3.01   Discharge Financing Statement                                                                       1,538,121    1,538,121    1,538,121       1,538,121

         TOTAL DISCHARGES                                                                                    1,538,121    1,538,121    1,538,121       1,538,121

    4    Searches

  4.01   Search - via all available avenues                                                                  9,134,124    9,134,124    9,134,124       9,134,124

         TOTAL SEARCHES                                                                                      9,134,124    9,134,124    9,134,124       9,134,124

    5    Other

  5.01   Develop a special purpose report for Account Holders ($ per hour)                                       -            -            -               -

  5.02   Maintenance of Registrations (note 2)                                                                   -            -            -               -

         TOTAL OTHER                                                                                             -            -            -               -

         TOTAL PPSR                                                                                          13,139,031   13,139,031   13,139,031      13,139,031

5/04/2018                                                                         www.afsa.gov.au                                                   Page 18 of 19
PPSR COST RECOVERY IMPLEMENTATION STATEMENT - AFSA

ANNEX D: ACTUAL VS FORECAST VOLUMES VARIANCE FOR PAST YEARS
                                                                                                       2013-14     2013-14     2013-14    2014-15     2014-15      2014-15     2015-16     2015-16     2015-16     2016-17     2016-17     2016-17
                                                                                               Year
                                                                                                       Actuals     Forecast    Variance   Actuals     Forecast     Variance    Actuals     Forecast    Variance    Actuals     Forecast    Variance
 Ref.No    Activity *

    1.01   Register a Financing Statement where the duration is 7 years or less                        2,087,317   1,879,010    208,307   1,912,262   1,935,381      -23,119   2,037,034   1,750,000    287,034    1,987,776   1,750,000    237,776
    1.02   Register a Financing Statement where the duration is > 7 years but < or = to 25 years        136,704      84,524      52,180     72,930      87,060       -14,130     73,928      70,000        3,928     88,498      70,000      18,498
    1.03   Register a Financing Statement for a not stated end time                                     249,439      47,770     201,669     58,574      40,555       18,019      48,253      55,000       -6,747     50,046      55,000       -4,954
           Total                                                                                       2,473,460   2,011,304    462,156   2,043,766   2,062,996      -19,230   2,159,215   1,875,000    284,215    2,126,320   1,875,000    251,320

 Old 2.1   Attach a document to a Financing Statement                                                    10,617      14,079      -3,462       7,725     14,502        -6,777          0      10,000      -10,000          0      10,000      -10,000
           Total                                                                                         10,617      14,079      -3,462       7,725     14,502        -6,777          0      10,000      -10,000          0      10,000      -10,000

    2.01   Amend a Financing Statement where the duration is 7 years or less                             84,668      44,349      40,319    123,767      45,679       78,088     105,581      40,000      65,581     159,044      40,000     119,044
    2.02   Amend Financing Statement where the duration is > 7 years but < or = to 25 years                2,228       6,898     -4,670       2,301       7,105       -4,804       2,782     18,000      -15,218       2,780     18,000      -15,220
    2.03   Amend a Financing Statement for a not stated end time                                            766        1,971     -1,205       1,338       2,030        -692         532        4,000      -3,468        706        4,000      -3,294
    2.04   Minor amendment to Financing Statement or a change of free text description of collateral     30,282      19,710      10,572     19,673      20,302         -629      32,856      40,000       -7,144     29,179      40,000      -10,821
           Total                                                                                        117,944      72,928      45,016    147,079      75,116       71,963     141,751     102,000      39,751     191,709     102,000      89,709

    4.01   Search of the register by grantor                                                           2,891,625   2,102,268    789,357   3,304,646   2,165,336    1,139,310   3,534,618   3,000,000    534,618    3,856,380   3,000,000    856,380
    4.02   Search of the register by serial number                                                     3,894,992   3,974,047    -79,055   4,140,593   4,093,269      47,324    4,612,289   3,800,000    812,289    4,624,007   3,800,000    824,007
    4.03   Search of the register by registration number                                                227,948     356,046    -128,098    132,855     366,727      -233,872    127,695     125,000        2,695    129,401     125,000        4,401
    4.04   Undertake an ordinal search of the register                                                       83         865        -782         56         891         -835          50          73          -23         60          73          -13
           Total                                                                                       7,014,648   6,433,226    581,422   7,578,150   6,626,223     951,927    8,274,652   6,925,073   1,349,579   8,609,848   6,925,073   1,684,775

 Old 7.1   Reissue search certificate                                                                       504         225        279         928         232          696         839          90         749         276          90         186
 Old 7.2   Issue a copy of a verification statement                                                        2,000          0       2,000       2,085          0         2,085       1,082       2,500      -1,418       1,325       2,500      -1,175
           Total                                                                                           2,504        225       2,279       3,013        232         2,781       1,921       2,590       -669        1,601       2,590       -989
* Excludes non-fee and non-revenue generating activity

5/04/2018                                                                            www.afsa.gov.au                                                              Page 19 of 19
You can also read