INS DER - Has SA scuppered WA's defence sector? - INDIGENOUS ART BUNNINGS' NEXT BATTLE LUNCH WITH DALE ALCOCK - The West Australian

Page created by George Caldwell
 
CONTINUE READING
INS DER - Has SA scuppered WA's defence sector? - INDIGENOUS ART BUNNINGS' NEXT BATTLE LUNCH WITH DALE ALCOCK - The West Australian
WESTBUSINESS

  I N S
  WA’S BUSINESS MAGAZINE
                                       D E R       August 2016

                           Has SA scuppered WA’s
                              defence sector?

INDIGENOUS ART • BUNNINGS’ NEXT BATTLE • LUNCH WITH DALE ALCOCK
INS DER - Has SA scuppered WA's defence sector? - INDIGENOUS ART BUNNINGS' NEXT BATTLE LUNCH WITH DALE ALCOCK - The West Australian
INFINITI CENTRE PERTH 9 FROBISHER STREET, OSBORNE PARK, PERTH

                              Q50
    DRIVEN BY
A SENSATION, IN A
NEW DESTINATION
    We are proud to announce the opening of INFINITI Centre Perth,
 the first INFINITI Dealership in Western Australia. Come and experience
  technologies that take driver confidence to the next level, and styling
               that stands out even when you’re standing still.
                            www.infiniti.com.au

       EXPERIENCE THE RANGE AT INFINITI CENTRE PERTH. NOW OPEN.

 Q30                                                                   Q60
INS DER - Has SA scuppered WA's defence sector? - INDIGENOUS ART BUNNINGS' NEXT BATTLE LUNCH WITH DALE ALCOCK - The West Australian
Q50 model shown

QX70   QX80
INS DER - Has SA scuppered WA's defence sector? - INDIGENOUS ART BUNNINGS' NEXT BATTLE LUNCH WITH DALE ALCOCK - The West Australian
BORN ON THE TR AC K .
             BUILT F O R TH E RO A D.

The all-new Audi R8. 2016 World Performance Car.
Join the league of performance.
To experience the power of progress, book a priority test drive today
at Audi Centre Perth.
337 Harborne Street, Osborne Park | Tel. 9231 5888 | audicentreperth.com.au   AudiR8.com.au
INS DER - Has SA scuppered WA's defence sector? - INDIGENOUS ART BUNNINGS' NEXT BATTLE LUNCH WITH DALE ALCOCK - The West Australian
WESTBUSINESS
                                                                                                                                            WELCOME
I N S                              D E R                                                                                                    From the editor
Ancient and modern worlds collide                                                                                                           A bigger share of defence industry work is
There is more to Aboriginal art than dot paintings. Stephen                                                                                 one of the State’s best chances of picking
Bevis reports on the indigenous art taking the investment                                                                                   up the slack created by the downturn in
world by storm. P8-10                                                                                                                       the mining industry. But South Australia
                                                                                                                                            continues to win the bulk of manufacturing
Mad about Minjee                                                                                                                            work in this field. WestBusiness Insider
Smart, focused and with a natural Aussie charm, Perth golfing                                                                               considers the high-stakes battle between
prodigy Minjee Lee is a marketer’s dream. So why hasn’t she got                                                                             the two States for tens of billions of dollars
an Australian sponsor? Bridget Lacy reports. P12-14                                                                                         worth of contracts.
                                                                                                                                               In this edition, we also look at the
                                                                   P12-14
War games                                                                                                                                   contemporary and traditional Aboriginal art
Western Australia and South Australia are battling it out for                                                                               that is wowing the world and how a change
defence industry contracts. Peter Williams reports. P17-20                                                                                  to the business model of indigenous art
                                                                                                                                            centres, and to export laws, could help
Building a hardware empire                                                                                                                  reinvigorate the sector. Perth golfing
Homegrown Bunnings is to spread to Britain and Ireland in one                                                                                         prodigy and Olympian Minjee Lee
of the boldest moves in corporate history. Kim Macdonald                                                                                                also comes under the spotlight
reports. P22-25                                                                                                                                         and we assess how homegrown
                                                                                                                                                         Bunnings is likely to fare when it
PLUS                                                                                                                                                     rolls out the red hammer in
Motoring: Kim Ledger tests drives the BMW M2. P29                                                                                                        Britain and Ireland. Kim Ledger
                                                                                                                                                           test drives a luxury BMW and
Wine: Tony Grist, of Albion Capital Partners, opens his cellar.                                                                                             incoming Dockers president
P29                                                                                                                                                          Dale Alcock explains how he
Lunch: With the next Dockers president Dale Alcock. P30                                                                                                       starts the week as Dale and
                                                                                                                                                              ends it as gramps.
Cover: Premier Colin Barnett faces his SA counterpart across a
                                                                   P8-10                                        P29
game of Battleships. Digitally altered by John Henderson                                                                                                     Kim
 EDITORIAL Kim Macdonald Editor, WESTBUSINESS INSIDER magazine. 08 9482 3104 kim.macdonald@wanews.com.au                                                     Macdonald
 ADVERTISING Elizabeth Poustie 9482 3254 elizabeth.poustie@wanews.com.au. DESIGN John Henderson john.henderson@wanews.com.au

         Western Australia's best display home
                    VIEW SEACREST HOMES AWARD WINNING QUALIT Y, ON DISPL AY                                                                   WINNER
                                                                                                                               MBA WA 2016 OVERALL BEST DISPLAY HOME
                                                                                                                                              WINNER
                                                                                                                               HIA PERTH & WA DISPLAY HOME OF THE YEAR
                                                                                                                                              WINNER
                                                                                                                                 HIA WA 2015 KITCHEN OF THE YEAR
                                                                                                                                              WINNER
                                                                                                                                2016 HIA WA BATHROOM OF THE YEAR
                                                                                                                                              FINALIST
                                                                                                                               HIA AUSTRALIA DISPLAY HOME OF THE YEAR
                                                                                                                                              FINALIST
                                                                                                                               HIA AUSTR ALIA KITCHEN OF THE YEAR

                                                                                                                                      MIRAGE
                                                                                                                                THE

                                                                                                                                      2 MASSON MEWS, MOSMAN PARK

                                                                                                                                                             Builders Reg. No. 8869

                                                                                                                               seacresthomes.com.au
         Distinctive. Individual. World-class. The Mirage by Seacrest Homes is open by appointment - phone : Mary Musuruca : 0411 733 047
                                                                                                     email : pmusuruca@seacresthomes.com.au
        Seacrest Homes are custom design and construction specialists for residential projects upwards of $1m
INS DER - Has SA scuppered WA's defence sector? - INDIGENOUS ART BUNNINGS' NEXT BATTLE LUNCH WITH DALE ALCOCK - The West Australian
I   N   S    G   H   T

The art of                                A day in my working life
GOOD CHOCOLATE                            TERRY AGNEW, CHIEF EXECUTIVE OF RAC

T
       o make good chocolate
        you need two things.
        One is to source good
        quality cacao beans from a
single origin, and the other is to
take enough time during the
production process to develop the
optimal flavour of the beans.
   About 95 per cent of the world’s
chocolate comes from bulk cacao
beans and has a fairly generic taste.
But beans derived from a single
origin, when processed for as long as
24 hours, have rich and naturally
occurring flavours, which range from
citrus to rum and raisin.
   Most people are not surprised to
hear that the wide variety of wine is
due partly to the 500 flavinoid
components in grapes. But most people
don’t know that chocolate varieties can
be even more diverse because cacao
beans have 1500 different naturally
occurring flavours.
   You don’t even have to add anything
to single-origin beans to get these
flavours, and they require much less
sugar than the bulk variety that is
commonly found at supermarkets.
   There are only a handful of            Undercover boss: Terry Agnew in the field with patrol officer April Hames. Picture: Bill Hatto

                                          T
chocolate makers in Australia who
produce this way, and about 200                    here is no such thing as a           When I go out to our call centre         to talk to politicians. In the lead-up
worldwide.                                         typical day in my job, but        in Joondalup, I talk with our call          to elections you will hear us
   Ruth Myburgh, co-founder Gabriel                there are some regular            centre staff and occasionally listen        talking a lot about congestion.
Chocolate, Yallingup and Perth                     things that I do in my role       in to calls to help me stay in touch          An independent national

G
                                          as chief executive of RAC.                 with that important part of our             organisation called Infrastructure
         ood quality beans, with a           About six to eight times a year, I      business.                                   Australia predicts that if nothing
         decent amount of cacao butter,   go out with an RAC patrol van to              On one of these visits, one of the       changes, WA will have the four
         is key.                          give me a firsthand experience of          new call centre operators asked my          most congested roads in Australia
            Cacao butter is the most      the service. One problem with              name and what I did at the                  by 2031, and that seven of the top
expensive part of chocolate, so it is     executive roles is that they can           organisation. Her boss had a bit of         10 on the list will be in this State.
sometimes separated from the bean         sometimes be isolating and you             a chuckle about that.                         WA gets only one-third of the
and sold off separately.                  can lose touch with how things                RAC is unique in that it is a            fuel excise returned to its
   In lower-grade chocolate the butter    work at the front line.                    not-for-profit organisation that            transport infrastructure system,
is often replaced with cheap                 Going on patrol allows me to stay       also owns several profit-making             which is less than the 40¢ the other
alternatives like palm oil and other      in touch with how the system               businesses, ranging from                    States get in return. Both amounts
things that don’t belong in chocolate.    works from the patrol officers’            insurance, motoring and travel              are too low.
Some chocolatiers overcompensate          perspective, particularly in regards       through to a group of retirement              Internally, I meet with key
with cacao powder to make up for the      to safety and member service.              villages called St Ives.                    executives and senior leaders each
absence of cacao butter, but the             It also means I get to chat with           To fund the education campaigns          month to discuss, assess and drive
quality is never the same.                members about how long they’ve             and the advocacy work that we do,           the improvement to our culture,
   I used to be a chef, so I make         been with RAC and their                    we need to make profits in our              brand, membership and safety.
chocolate the way I cook, which means     experience with us, which helps            businesses, which means I have to           Our goal is to become West
I make sure the flavours                  me better understand the                   wear many hats. There is no risk of         Australians’ most valued
complement each other when                organisation from their                    ever getting bored in this job.             organisation by 2020.
I am mixing chocolate with                perspective.                                  One of our education programs              About once a month I like to
other ingredients.                           When I go on patrol, I take off         is to take 8000 schoolchildren              clear my schedule and have a
   Today I’m adding                       my tie and put on a high-vis vest,         through a re-enactment of a car             thinking day. It doesn’t always
Westwinds Gin to                          for safety reasons, over my usual          accident which we stage at Arena            happen, but I think it’s very
Caribbean chocolate,                      work clobber. The patrol officers          stadium each year. The idea is to           important to have the time to think
which is very gentle and                  usually tell the members that I’m          get them to think about the                 creatively about the bigger picture.
has a slight floral flavour               just a new guy from the office who         consequences of car accidents. It             Sometimes I sit in a coffee shop
that won’t overpower the                  is “learning the ropes”.                   has a big impact on the viewers.            or sometimes it’s on my balcony at
gin.                                         I think that relaxes people and            The advocacy work requires               home. A change in environment
   Sue Lewis, Sue Lewis                   encourages them to talk more               going up the hill to Parliament             helps me see things that I may
Chocolatier, Perth                        freely about RAC.                          House in Perth or over to Canberra          otherwise miss at my desk.
6                SEPTEMBER 2016
INS DER - Has SA scuppered WA's defence sector? - INDIGENOUS ART BUNNINGS' NEXT BATTLE LUNCH WITH DALE ALCOCK - The West Australian
CO
                                       “…a thrilling spectacle jam-packed with                                                                RP
                                                                                                                                                 OR PER
                                  white-knuckle acrobatic moments.” - LOS ANGELES TIMES                                                            AT FEC
                                                                                                                                                     EE T
                                                                                                                                                       NT FO
                                                                                                                                                         ERT R
                                                                                                                                                            AIN
                                                                                                                                                                MEN
                                                                                                                                                                    T

                                                            WRITTEN AND DIRECTED BY DAVID SHINER

      OPENS 13 APRIL 2017 UNDER THE BIG TOP, BELMONT RACECOURSE
                                  Cirque du Soleil and Kooza are trademarks owned by Cirque du Soleil and used under license.

 Step inside the intimate
 setting of the VIP Rouge Suite
 under the Big Top, one hour
 before the show and during
 intermission, with delectable
 wines and hors-d’oeuvres,
 take home souvenirs, and
 the best seats in the house.
 Perfect for groups or just
 a romantic night out.

                                               OFFICIAL SPONSOR            MEDIA PARTNERS            VENUE PARTNER
cirquedusoleil.com/kooza                                                                                                   VIP Event Bookings call: 1800 036 685
INS DER - Has SA scuppered WA's defence sector? - INDIGENOUS ART BUNNINGS' NEXT BATTLE LUNCH WITH DALE ALCOCK - The West Australian
I   N   D     G   E   N   O   U    S   A   R   T

              After a GFC-driven downturn, the world is rediscovering traditional and contemporary
              Aboriginal art. But export laws and art centres need attention, writes Stephen Bevis

F                                                           Ancient
        or Daniel Walbidi, the art centre at the
        Kimberley coastal settlement of Bidyadanga, a
        two-hour drive south of Broome, is more than
        a place where people can paint.
  “It is is a learning place where you also learn about

                                                            culture
the culture and the history,” Walbidi says. “It is a
store house for the artists, a safe place to be and it
brings in money for the community.”
  One of Australia’s finest contemporary artists,
Walbidi was the scrawny 16-year-old Yulparija kid
who sparked an art movement in 1999 when he

                                                            back in
walked into Broome’s Short Street Gallery and asked
owner Emily Rohr for painting supplies.
  His actions inspired his Yulparija elders in their
70s and 80s to start painting the stories of their
ancestral desert lands they had left more than 40
years prior.
  Sadly, many of those artists, acclaimed stars such

                                                            vogue
as Alma Webou, Weaver Jack and Jan Djan Billycan,
have since died after a dazzling burst of creativity
that mixed colourful desert iconography with bright
saltwater hues.
  “I was fearing for these days,” Walbidi says. “It
began with me and it will end with me. Many of the
artists have passed on, which is quite sad.”
  Now 33, Walbidi has exhibited around the world
and won major awards, including the Telstra
National Aboriginal and Torres Strait Art Award for         Kimberley, Top End and into southern urban areas in
painting in 2014.                                           the 1980s and 1990s, cutting through as an
  In May, Walbidi’s large 2013 canvas Kirriwirri set a      international force with shows at the Venice Biennale
new auction record for the artist when it went under        by Rover Thomas, Trevor Nickolls, Emily Kame
the hammer for $79,300, more than doubling the              Kngwarreye, Judy Watson and Yvonne Koolmatrie.
reserve price at Deutscher and Hackett in Melbourne.          Now, art museums in Europe and the US are
  Overall, the prices at the mixed-vendor auction           dedicated to showing Aboriginal art, which poet Les
suggest an upturn in the Aboriginal art market after        Murray described as “Australia’s equivalent of jazz”
years in the doldrums, with Deutscher and Hackett           and art historian Wally Caruana called the only
head of Aboriginal art, Crispin Gutteridge, declaring       internationally significant art movement to emerge
the auction the best of its kind since the highs of         from Australia.
2008.                                                         In Paris, the gigantic scales of Warmun artist Lena
  “It is good for my reputation,” says Walbidi, who         Nyadbi’s ancestral Kimberley barramundi adorn the
also can expect a 5 per cent resale royalty under a         roof of the Musee de Quai Branly for indigenous art.
copyright scheme introduced in 2010. “More than a           At Holland’s Aboriginal Art Museum in Utrecht,
year ago, the art market wasn’t really good and it          diverse currents of influences and styles of
affected artists and galleries. Hopefully it will recover   expression flow through the graphic drawings of
to its full glory.”                                         Vernon Ah Kee, the prints of Michael Nelson
  Yet there is a long way to go, particularly for           Jagamarra and the hyperactive patterns of street
remote art centres where thousands of artists have          artist Reko Rennie.
been supplying an over-saturated market for some              Derby painter Loongkoonan, who must be
years.                                                      Australia’s oldest working artist at 105, only took up
  The Aboriginal art market, said to be worth $400          the brushes in her mid-90s. The complex, jewel-like
million a year at its height in 2007, collapsed under       paintings of her traditional Nyikina bush tucker
the perfect storm of the global financial crisis, the       stories have won glowing reviews, art prizes and
high Australian dollar, the artist resale royalty           high-level international exposure, with works
scheme and tighter rules for collecting art through         showing this year at the Adelaide Biennial and on
personal superannuation funds.                              tour in the US.
  Countering that, to some extent, were tax changes           At the other end of the spectrum to Loongkoonan
last year allowing small businesses to claim an             stands Christian Thompson, just the second
immediate $20,000 write-off for plant and equipment,        Aboriginal to study at Oxford University, whose
including art to hang in the office.                        video, photography and performance art ranges
  Drawing on 40,000 years as the world’s oldest             across pop culture, identity politics, fashion and his
artistic tradition, the dynamic Aboriginal                  indigenous heritage.
contemporary art movement began in 1971 when                  A major exhibition of Aboriginal abstract
senior men of Papunya in the Northern Territory             paintings, No Boundaries, on loan from Miami Beach
were encouraged by schoolteacher Geoffrey Bardon            collectors Dennis and Debra Scholl, is touring seven
to paint traditional stories with acrylics on boards        American art museums over two years.
and canvases for the first time.                              Among the artists included are the late Kimberley
  The movement flowered across the desert,                  Gija artists Paddy Bedford and Janangoo Butcher

8                 SEPTEMBER 2016
INS DER - Has SA scuppered WA's defence sector? - INDIGENOUS ART BUNNINGS' NEXT BATTLE LUNCH WITH DALE ALCOCK - The West Australian
Cherel and Pintupi artist Warlimpirringa                        “They are our stories, no one else’s stories, so the
Tjapaltjarri, the brightest star of the acclaimed            people who tell them are the people they belong to as
Papunya Tula Artists.                                        the torch-bearers,” Walbidi says.
   Tjapaltjarri, about 58 and based in Kiwirrkurra in           For many remote communities, the art centre is the
WA’s Gibson Desert, held a sold-out show last year at        only source of earnings so the GFC and the
New York’s Salon 94 gallery which attracted prices of        regulatory changes had a vicious effect on many of
up to $90,000 a pop and enthusiastic coverage in the         them, says 40-year industry veteran and Japingka
New York Times, Wall Street Journal and New                  Gallery director Ian Plunkett.
Yorker.                                                         “The GFC brought some rationality to the market
   Dennis Scholl says he and his wife collected              but it had some dire consequences,” Plunkett says.
cutting-edge American art for 40 years before shifting          “Over 50 per cent of galleries and art dealers went
their focus to certain Aboriginal artists who were at        out of business,” he says. “That made it a
the vanguard of global contemporary art.                     concentrated market and the good operators survived
   “They are simply some of the finest abstract              that.
painters this planet has ever seen,” he says.                   “It forced people to look at the quality and the
   At the Harvard Art Museum, visitors are swooning          sources and to try to bring some confidence back into
over an even more significant exhibition in one of           the market by creating art that is easy to identify by
America’s most prestigious galleries.                        source and produced ethically.”
   Curated by Stephen Gilchrist, a Yamatji man from             One upside was that the collapse of the market,
WA, Everywhen features the eloquent, abstract                along with more stringent codes of conduct, flushed
paintings of Rover Thomas, Emily Kame                        out the worst of the carpet-baggers who were
Kngwarreye, Doreen Reid Nakamarra and Tommy                  exploiting artists and ripping off buyers with works
Watson, alongside multi-media works by Vernon Ah             of suspect provenance.
Kee and Christian Thompson.                                     “People are more educated and asking the right
   Gilchrist, on a six-month secondment to Harvard           questions, usually, and not just buying something
from the University of Sydney, says an exhibition of         because it is a bargain or appears to be,” Plunkett
such scope has not been seen in the US for more than         says. “I wouldn’t want to have a painting on the wall
25 years.                                                    if I knew the artist had been ripped off and burnt. It
   “It has been energising to see how people                 would be ruined for me.”
encounter Aboriginal art for the very first time and            In many ways, art expert Tim Klingender created
see how they react to it and read it and connect to it,”     the international market for Aboriginal art in 1996
Gilchrist says. “I wanted to present people with what        when he led a Sotheby’s strategy to show works in
I think is the great sophistication, beauty and politics     New York and London before their auction in
of this art form.”                                           Australia.
   “The whole show has raised the temperature or                Last year, Klingender organised Sotheby’s first
contributed to an uplift in visibility of Aboriginal         stand-alone auction of Aboriginal art in London,
culture. For me, Aboriginal art always has been hot.         where the bidding from collectors around the world
It is not a trend. It has been going on for 40,000 years.”   drove some pieces to world-record prices.
   Gilchrist, who trained at the University of WA and           “Indigenous Australian art isn’t everybody’s cup of
the Art Gallery of WA, said more pathways needed to          tea but there are enough people spread around the
be opened for Aboriginal people to control the destiny       world who love to collect it,” Klingender says.
of a movement which had been determined largely by              “It truly is the one area of art in this country that
outsiders.
   “In some ways the Aboriginal market became a                                                     CONTINUES PAGE 10
victim of its own success,” he says. “The market
became over-saturated and it is really important to
open up other markets.
   “The art centres need more assistance because
they are such important community hubs,
particularly in WA when the WA Government wants
to shut down some remote communities. These are
important sites of cultural practice and transmission
of knowledge and some economic security as well.”
   In comments echoed by Walbidi, Gilchrist says for
too long the intermediaries and stewards of the
inter-cultural exchange in Aboriginal art have been
white dealers, managers, curators, academics and
writers. More pathways to education and training
need to be opened.
   Walbidi has been developing his skills as a curator
and gallery conservator through Desert River Sea, a
partnership between several Kimberley art centres
and the Art Gallery of WA, sponsored by Rio Tinto.
   Wesfarmers Arts and the National Gallery of
Australia have been partners since 2009 in an
indigenous arts leadership scheme to redress the
imbalance by training the next generation of
administrators and curators.

Main image: Christian Thompson, Scorch the Earth
2013,from his Pagan Sun series of photographs,
C-type print. Turner Galleries
INS DER - Has SA scuppered WA's defence sector? - INDIGENOUS ART BUNNINGS' NEXT BATTLE LUNCH WITH DALE ALCOCK - The West Australian
FROM PAGE 9                                                                                                                   representing almost 4000 artists, produced less than
                                                                                                                              20 per cent of the sector’s sales, raising concerns
has a global following.” Most of the 75 works came                                                                            about their viability.
from the 1000-strong collection of Dutch billionaire                                                                            The most common split of sales through art
Thomas Vroom and could only be sold because they                                                                              centres is 60 per cent to the artist and 40 per cent to
had left Australia in the early 1990s before the advent                                                                       run the art centre.
of laws governing the export of cultural materials.                                                                             More art centres want to diversify from
  Klingender is consigning works for another                                                                                  “bread-and-butter” paintings into value-added
Sotheby’s auction in London this month but has been                                                                           products such as fashion, soft furnishings and design
waiting for many months for export permits for 16                                                                             objects for the commercial market, according to the
artworks, ranging from Kimberley and Arnhem Land                                                                              peak body for more than 25 art centres around WA.
bark paintings to large desert acrylic canvases.                                                                                WA Aboriginal Art Centre Hub co-ordinator
  “I don’t know if I will be able to get many of them                                                                         Christine Scoggin says trade fairs such as Revealed in
in time for the sale,” he says.                                                                                               Perth, the Darwin Art Fair and Desert Mob in Alice
  Klingender says the market is being stymied by the                                                                          Springs are important outlets but many centres are
moveable cultural heritage laws under which                                                                                   hamstrung by vast distances, inadequate facilities
indigenous artworks over $10,000 and older than 20                                                                            and high staff turnover.
years must be cleared by an expert panel before they                                                                            Too many centres relied on a single staff member,
can be sold overseas.                                                                                                         often a young university-educated woman from the
  Non-indigenous Australian artworks, by                                                                                      city who might burn out after three or four years.
comparison, must be worth more than $250,000 and                                                                                “Most art centres operate on the smell of an oily
be more than 30 years old before they require such                                                                            rag,” Scoggin says. “It is such an expensive State to
clearance.                                                                                                                    operate in.
  “I have been trying to nurture and build that                                                                                 “They need investment in human capacity, in
market over decades but that is what still holds it           Daniel Walbidi, painting category winner of 2014 Telstra        trained Aboriginal staff and not have a model with a
back,” Klingender says.                                       National Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Art Award.       salary for one person expected to do everything. Most
  “It pretty much makes the market unworkable.”                                                                               art centres we work with are in that situation.
  Both sides of politics support proposed                     and agencies reveals that many still are battling for             “In no other industry would we expect one person
amendments to more efficiently distinguish between            survival after losing money over the decade to 2013.            to be the business manager, finance manager, HR
artworks intended for the fine art market and other             The Art Economies Value Chain research, led by                manager, the arts marketing expert and the person
culturally significant objects.                               Curtin University analyst Tim Acker, points to signs            wrapping up artworks for freight, filling online
  But changes went on hold because of the Federal             of uneven recovery and diminished losses over the               orders and keeping the website up to date.
election and are unlikely to roll out until later next        past two years.                                                   “Sometimes things need to be valued outside
year.                                                           Art centres received $160.3 million in Federal                Australia for Australians to sit up and go, ‘Hey, this is
  A survey of 200 remote art centres, art businesses          funding over the decade but half of them,                       really great what we have’.”

                                                                                                                                      Tighter SMSF
                                                                                                                                      rules for your
                                                                                                                                      art collection
                                                                                                                                      Art collections, Aboriginal or otherwise, must now
                                                                                                                                      meet stricter rules which govern self-managed super
                                                                                                                                      funds.
                                                                                                                                         Since July 1, SMSF investments in artwork, jewellery,
                                                                                                                                      antiques, vintage cars, rare coins, boats, wine and any
                                                                                                                                      other collectables considered personal-use assets must
                                                                                                                                      be for genuine retirement purposes and not provide
                                                                                                                                      any present-day benefit.
                                                                                                                                         The rules have applied since July 1, 2011 for any
                                                                                                                                      assets purchased after that date, although possessions
                                                                                                                                      held before this time were previously in a five-year
                                                                                                                                      grace period.
                                                                                                                                         If you haven’t cashed in your art assets, you need to
                                                                                                                                      ensure you comply with the Australian Tax Office rules.
                                                                                                                                      This means you can’t lease the item to a related party,
                                                                                                                                      items can’t be stored or displayed in a private
                                                                                                                                      residence of a related party, decisions about storage
                                                                                                                                      must be documented and the written record kept, and
                                                                                                                                      finally, the items must be insured in the fund’s name
                                                                                                                                      within seven days of acquisition.
                                                                                                                                         If the item is transferred to a related party, a
                                                                                                                                      qualified independent valuation is required and the sale
                                                                                                                                      price must reflect its true commercial value.
                                                                                                                                         A “related party” includes members of the SMSF,
                                                                                                                                      relatives of the members and any business
Personal-use assets must be for genuine retirement purposes and not provide any present-day benefit. Picture: R. Leopoldina Torres    associates/entities under the member’s control.
ANNUAL                                          The Hon John Howard OM AC

LEADERSHIP
                                                Former Prime Minister

SUMMIT 2016
                                                Annabel Crabb
                                                Writer and Broadcaster

Join 13 internationally and nationally
recognised leaders for one amazing day of
leadership insights and inspiration in Perth.

WEDNESDAY 19 OCTOBER
HYATT REGENCY PERTH
                                                Sam Walsh AO FAIM

           BOOK NOW
                                                Former Chief Executive
                                                Rio Tinto

           Book at aimwa.com
           or call +61 8 9383 8000

Proudly supported by

                                                John Eales AM
                                                Former Australian Rugby
                                                Captain & Player
A   U   S   T   R   A   L    A   N   S   P   O   R   T

Australian business has been slow to get on board
with Perth golfing prodigy Minjee Lee, who is feted by
brands across the globe. Bridget Lacy reports on
the challenge of getting an Australian sponsor.

In the
line of
flight
W
            hen coach Ritchie Smith first came across
            Perth schoolgirl Minjee Lee on the golf
            course eight years ago, he not only saw a
            potential golf champion — he saw the
potential for off-course stardom too.
  She was only 12 years of age back then, but her
natural charm, resilience and steadfast focus were
already abundantly evident.
  Though he wouldn't use the words, he saw the
beginnings of Brand Minjee.
  “She’s a good looking girl and she’s very
personable,” Smith says. “I have always seen her as
having opportunities corporately as well.”
  Lee was identified as a future talent and added to
the senior State squad as a development player before
she hit her teens.
  Pretty soon she was leaving girls far older than her
in the shade and breaking Golf WA records that are
unlikely to be repeated any time soon.
  Lee rapidly rose to prominence, becoming the
world No.1 amateur and then announcing her
graduation to professional ranks in September 2014
with a playful video featuring Fremantle champion
Matthew Pavlich at her home club Royal Fremantle.         Minjee Lee in
  Talent management company IMG quickly signed            action during round
her to their staple of golf stars, which includes Jason   2 of the 2014 World
Dufner, Ernie Els, Henrik Stenson, Charl Schwartzel       Ladies
and women’s world No.1 Lydia Ko.                          Championship in
  Since joining the world’s elite women’s tour, the       Haikou, China.
LPGA, Lee has lived up to the hype, winning twice         Picture: Getty
already and climbing inside the top 15 in the world       Images. Opposite,
rankings.                                                 at Crown Perth for
  “Minjee, her talent level speaks for itself,” a         a golf dinner in
spokesman from IMG explains.                              2013. Picture: John
  “She was the No.1 world amateur. The talent level       Koh
was clearly there and we were also pretty impressed           “There has been a move away from sponsoring            came from Australia... but she is also quite popular in
by her maturity in conversations that we had with her       individuals. It’s far more competitive because           Korea and internationally.
and her family.                                             sponsors are demanding standards.”                         “Week-to-week we start to see a little bit more.
  “We saw Minjee as the total package. She has got a          Lee’s 2016 goals are around pushing into the             “She’s learning a little bit what it’s like — her
great personality about her. She has got a fun little       world’s top 10 and performing well at the majors.        weekly routine on the golf side — there has been
Australian charm to her.                                      But with golf’s return to the Olympics for the first   more on the media side that she has become
  “She has lived up to all those expectations here in       time in more than 100 years, Rio de Janeiro could be     accustomed to.
her second year on Tour. She has done nothing but           a game-changer for her.                                    “If you were to look at her from the week she
exceed expectations since turning pro.”                       Lee won a place as the top-ranked Australian           turned pro at Evian (championship) in 2014 to where
  Lee learnt all about expectation at this year’s           woman (world No.17) and has spoken                       she is now, I think she feels much more comfortable.
Women’s Australian Open in Adelaide in February.            enthusiastically about the chance to experience the      She is much further on than what she was then.
  As Australia’s No.1 player, Lee was carrying the          Olympics, describing it as “special”.                      “It was certainly something we spoke about.”
hopes of a nation on her shoulders and had the                “Obviously a major is huge, but everyone is going        For a world-class champion, Lee’s team has
commitments to go with it.                                  to remember you if you win an Olympic medal,” Lee        remained remarkably small.
  She faced the press in the lead up to the tournament      has said.                                                  James says the only thing that has changed since
and zipped from television interview to television            The Olympics is a flash point, because the general     she was 13, is having a professional caddie on board.
interview as organisers fielded numerous media              public who have little interest in golf will jump on       Caddy Jeremy Young has been on the bag since her
requests for her time.                                      board when an Australian medal is on the line.           breakthrough win at Kingsmill Championship in
  But arguably her biggest moment came in the                 Hirons says the market will change hugely on the       Virginia in May last year.
Pro-Am before the tournament when she was teamed            back of the Games, when companies will be keen to          “I hope that doesn’t change,” James says. “I can’t
with representatives from Qantas. It is understood          piggyback on the glory of Australia’s best               see it changing in the near future.”
there was a hope she could make the partnership             performers.                                                Smith, though based in Perth, is still her coach. He
more permanent if she could impress on the day.               “I really think that will be important for her         speaks with Lee over the phone for much of the year
  But an Australian sponsor has remained elusive for        career,” Smith, who will join her at the Games, says.    and travels to work with her about every six weeks.
Lee. But those around her believe she is closing in.        “She’s really keen to do well so hopefully she does.”      “It’s (her team) exactly the same as it’s always
  She has a lucrative contract with Korean finance            “There’s 60 players playing in the Olympics,” an       been,” Smith says.
giant Hana Bank, with Srixon her equipment partner,         IMG representative says.                                   “It’s unusual for the LPGA possibly, but not the
Descente for apparel and shoe brand Ecco.                     “The reality is that the top 20 are probably             PGA Tour. The top three players in the world have
  Golf Australia also continues to provide significant      the ones with the best chance to medal. A                   their original coaches with them and original
financial aid to one of their most exciting exports.        good result can do wonders for any of the                    crew.
  GA high performance director Brad James said              players in the field.”                                          “On the LPGA a lot of them are prone to peer
homegrown backing was important.                              Lee’s parents are Korean, but she and                       pressure. Some of them change it up and they
  “We would love an iconic Australian brand on her,”        her younger brother Min Woo were born                        often fail because of it.”
he said. “She wants that, it’s something that she           and raised in WA. Min Woo, 18, says his                         As for physio and massage, Lee organises
desperately wants. I think she’s extremely                  sister is proud to represent Australia.                      herself.
marketable.                                                   “She was born and bred here so she                                  “We’ve educated Minjee to such a level
  “She’s not only a top-20 player, Australia’s No.1         always been in the Australian                                         that she knows what to work on and
player in the world, she has a fantastic smile and she      tradition and she has a lot of pride,”                                 when, pretty much,” Smith says. “She
wants to be part of culture of Australian golf going        he says.                                                               will be more educated than anyone that
forward. That’s something that I think is really                                                                                    has gone out there before.
attractive for companies.”
  IMG say they are working hard to secure “blue
                                                            ‘There are many great                                                      “There are masseuses and trainers on
                                                                                                                                     tour, so she can go and get loosened up
chip” Australian support.
  Smith says a multinational Australian company
                                                            athletes out there now                                                  in the right areas.
                                                                                                                                       Lee’s mother Clara travels with her.
would get on board if they were smart.
  But Sport Business Partners managing director
                                                            and they are all                                                        They have recently rented a property in
                                                                                                                                    Dallas as their US base after living out of
Martin Hirons warned it would not come easy.
  Hirons says Lee’s performances on the course,
                                                            competing for the same                                                 hotel rooms for the first 18 months.
                                                                                                                                     Min Woo and Minjee’s dad Soo Nam still
particularly at the majors, are the key, but she would
need to do plenty of work off it too, such as developing
                                                            dollar. It’s become                                                  live at the family’s Winthrop home, where
                                                                                                                                 she spends an extended time at Christmas.
her social media presence.                                  increasingly difficult.                                                 But for much of the year, the men and
  Twitter is her favourite platform, but she has only                                                                             women of the family don’t see one another.
6300 followers and has put out only about 200 tweets,       Martin Hirons                                                            “We talk often, just send messages back
which is a low count for a professional sportsperson.                                                                             and forth,” Min Woo says. “It’s hard at
  “I’d say she’s outside the top 10 Australian female         Lee’s career earnings are already                                    times — we can’t see each other as much
athletes in terms of marketability, but she’s on a          approaching $US2 million. But her                                      as a normal family. We do Facetime and
trajectory,” he said. “She is still only 20 years of age.   biggest bang for buck is likely to be                                   messaging.”
  “The challenge for Minjee will be keeping on top of       off the course, where she is currently                                     Min Woo says his sister has always
all her commitments with sponsors, media, social            believed to be netting close to $A1                                      been independent and the family knew
media. Tournament organisers and sponsors will              million annually.                                                        very early on she was going to be a
want more time the more success she has.                      To that end, she has had to work                                   superstar.
  “We’re in a huge transition period with female            hard on her Achilles’ heel — her media                              He said if you drew a line charting his and
sport. The new AFL women’s league is going to take a        profile.                                                          his sister’s lives, his would be squiggly and
chunk out of the market. Golf’s reach is not at the           Lee has clearly been uncomfortable in                           hers would be dead straight.
same level as some of the other sports yet.                 interviews since she burst on to the scene                          “She was always focused,” he says. “She
  “I’m sure it’s disappointing (not to have an              at a young age, but the team around her                           was always on task. She’s pretty level headed,
Australian sponsor) but it’s just the reality of the        insist she has vastly improved.                                  she just plays her own game. She has never
competing interests and the dynamics around sport             “Typically on the LPGA Tour we have                            been cocky or anything like that.
and increasingly, women’s sport.                            anywhere between 15-20 clients who are in                         “She was always at the top of the leaderboard
  “There are many great athletes out there now and          the field,” the IMG spokesman says.                            where ever she played. We always knew she had
they are all competing for the same dollar. It’s become       “Minjee gets a lot of media requests — it’s
increasingly difficult.                                     ramped up. Most of the requests last year                                                        CONTINUES PAGE 14
Pictured here in 2011, Lee made a name for
                                                                                                                                       herself before graduating from Methodist
                                                                                                                                                Ladies College. Picture: Ian Munro
FROM PAGE 13

the potential to win tournaments and go as far as she
is doing right now.”
   Min Woo, who wants to follow in his sister’s
footsteps and one day join the PGA Tour, says fame
has not altered his sibling.
   She has remained steadfast in the face of Min
Woo’s regular requests for her to buy him a car with
her growing winnings.
   He says it’s “pretty cool” to see his sister mobbed
by fans at the end of a round, and that the attention
has never fazed her. She embraces the support with
the same level-headedness she shows in her
competitions.
   “She’s the same old Minjee, she hasn’t changed,”
Min Woo says.
   “She likes reading. I think she spends a lot of time
with her friends on Tour. It’s mostly golf, but I think
she hangs out with her friends normally.                    girls talk about Minjee,” he says. Smith says what          of the more marketed players on Tour already. I
   “Sometimes it gets on my nerves that I’m always          sets Lee apart is her ability to get over                   couldn’t tell you how far she’ll go.”
called Minjee’s brother. But at the same time I             disappointments quickly.                                      But IMG aren’t trying to hide their excitement.
wouldn’t be here without her.                                 He says her outstanding proprioceptive sense and            “I’ve been nothing but impressed with Minjee,” the
   “It’s actually pretty cool to have a sister doing what   her work ethic were what made her a prodigy, rather         spokesman says. “A lot of rookies come on tour and
she’s doing.                                                than any innate ability in the sport.                       are wide-eyed and are playing with people they’ve
   “She has a lot of fans out there. It was cool to see       “The gift is the ability to play, the talent is knowing   grown up idolising. Minjee has taken it in her stride.
them in Adelaide.”                                          how to use it,” Smith says.                                   “This year she is much more comfortable than she
   Legendary veteran Karrie Webb, 41, has been one            “Minjee is always good for a laugh. She is able to        was last year. There’s not an entourage.
of the great Australian sporting success stories as a       take the mickey out of herself.”                              “Her mum is with her every week, she’s quite
seven-time major winner and hall of famer. But                Smith is bullish about how much better Lee can get        self-sufficient.
James says the next crop of golfers are already listing     in a golfing sense, but he is unsure how much her             “Honestly it comes down to if she continues to go
Lee and rising Victorian Su Oh as their idols.              profile can grow.                                           on the same trajectory. The sky is the limit for Minjee
   “Karrie has had a phenomenal career but now the            “It’s pretty big already,” Smith says. “She’d be one      and she knows that as well.”

                                                                                          Make your next
                                                                                           conference an
                                                                                       underwater experience
                                                                                      AQWA boasts Perth’s most outstanding function venue with
                                                                                      spectacular views of the Indian Ocean and Hillarys Boat Harbour.
                                                                                      Surround your guests with tropical fish and colourful corals for a
                                                                                      truly memorable event where you won’t even need to get wet!

                     91 Southside Drive, Hillarys 6025 | www. aqwa.com.au/functions | functions@aqwa.com.au | 9203 6622
G r e at      bu i l d e r s    f o l l ow            t h e      pl a n .

At   Va l e n t o ,    w e   f o l l ow            yo u r       d r e a m s .

       A   lu x u ry    bu i l d e r     l i k e    n o      o t h e r

           V A L E N T O . C O M . A U     o r     6 3 8 0   3 0 50
Doric awarded contract to manage delivery of
$345.2m HMAS Stirling Redevelopment
Leading Western Australian                design, procurement, construction,                    of quality developments for the
construction company Doric Group has      commissioning and handover of the                     Government.”
been awarded the contract to manage       project.
the delivery of the $345.2 million                                                              Over the past five years, Doric has
redevelopment of the HMAS Stirling        Design activities are expected to be                  successfully delivered a number of
naval base on Garden Island.              completed by mid-2017 followed by                     major State Government projects,
                                          Construction, with the works expected                 including the Acacia Prison expansion
The project will see a major upgrade      to be complete by January 2020.                       ($90 million), Busselton Health Campus
and refurbishment of key infrastructure   The project is expected to see a                      ($90 million) and The Quarter, Karratha
and facilities, with a broad range of     peak workforce of approximately 300                   ($60m).
works to buildings, roads, maritime       people, and to deliver sub-contracting
structures, mechanical systems,           opportunities for local businesses.                   Doric was also the reserve respondent
electrical services, communications                                                             for the WA Government’s $428 million
systems, water and sewerage               Doric Chief Executive Officer Vince                   New Museum Project and is currently
infrastructure and the base entrance.     Mulholland said the company was                       delivering Yagan Square.
                                          delighted to have been awarded such a
The base, also known as Fleet Base        significant contract.                                 Mr Mulholland said Doric had a strong
West, is the Royal Australian Navy’s                                                            project pipeline in place, but would
largest naval establishment nationwide    “HMAS Stirling is a key government                    continue to seek opportunities across
and provides operational and logistical   facility, and one that plays a crucial role           the building and construction sector.
support to the RAN’s surface fleet,       both at a State and national level,” said
submarines and aircraft stationed in      Mr Mulholland.                                        “Our State is undergoing a real
WA.                                       “We are very happy to have been                       transformation in both our
                                          entrusted with the responsibility of                  metropolitan and regional areas, and
As Managing Contractor, Doric             delivering this project, which will                   we are excited about playing a part in
will be responsible for the detailed      further add to our growing roster                     that.”

                                                                                                                                  doricgroup.com.au
                                          Level 1, 420 Hay Street Subiaco WA 6008 t +61 (8) 9388 2655 f +61 (8) 9388 1484 e doric@doricgroup.com.au
N   T   E   R   S   T   A   T   E

         STATES AT WAR
Battle for defence dollars rages across the Nullarbor, Peter Williams writes
W
        hen Linda Reynolds went on local radio last                                                         offshore patrol vessels (OPVs) priced at about $500
        year to talk up WA’s capabilities for defence
        shipbuilding, the Liberal senator was taken
                                                        “South Australia’s whole message                    million. Direct jobs would peak at 6000 in a decade.
                                                                                                              WA would build 10 OPVs worth about $2.5 billion
aback by the response.
  “We had talkback callers saying I was basically on
                                                        and their whole attitude is one of                  and up to 21 Pacific patrol boats contracted to
                                                                                                            Henderson-based shipbuilder Austal for more than
drugs to think that we could even build ships here
in WA,” she says. The former Army Reserve
                                                             strident begging bowl politics.                $500 million. The WA build equates to about 9 per
                                                                                                            cent of the program.
brigadier realised there was a lot of work to be               WA Senator Linda Reynolds                      It is argued WA will make tens of billions of dollars
done.                                                                                                       more over decades on vessel maintenance. But for
  The Federal Government was headed                                                                         those wondering why South Australia came out on
towards massive spending decisions about                        So when the Turnbull Government in          top of the construction program, a cursory glance at
naval shipbuilding. If West Australians were                  April determined the locations of an          Defence SA’s website provides some clues.
ignorant about their defence industry, how could              unprecedented $89 billion splurge on new        Chaired by former military chief Angus Houston,
decision makers in Canberra be convinced                        naval vessels, Liberals were pleased to see the SA Government body’s advisory board includes
the State was an alternative to South                                WA named alongside South               the Premier, Defence Industry Minister, retired Royal
Australia?                                                            Australia as the two hubs of defence Australian Navy brass and senior corporate types.
  “Having seen what we’re capable of                                   shipbuilding.                        Chief executive Andy Keough was the RAN
doing and what we’re in fact doing, it                                    But not all hubs are created      submarine fleet commander and a senior executive at
infuriated me no end just listening to                                  equal.                              Government-owned shipbuilder ASC.
the whining — pretty much —of the                                         The plan would see South            “Defence South Australia is a smoothly oiled
South Australians about how they                                        Australia host the builds of 12     machine,” Australian Strategic Policy Institute
deserved all of this because their                                       submarines worth about $50
economy was stuffed,” Senator                                            billion, nine future frigates
Reynolds says.                                                           valued at $35 billion and two                                             CONTINUES PAGE 18

                                                                                                                                   SEPTEMBER 2016                17
FROM PAGE 17                                           companies that have been knocking on ministers’
                                                       doors in WA over the years and if it didn’t have
                                                                                                                  ‘This has been a deliberate strategy
defence and strategy program director Andrew
Davies says. “They’ve been very effective lobbyists.”
                                                       anything to do with mining, people weren’t
                                                       interested, ” he said. “It’s only very recently when
                                                                                                                  to capitalise on the home-porting
  WA Labor defence industry spokesman Paul
Papalia says: “They’ve got extraordinary firepower
                                                       that’s all gone south that they’ve all of a sudden got
                                                       interested in defence.”
                                                                                                                  of naval vessels at HMAS Stirling.’
advocating for South Australian industry, looking for     WA Premier Colin Barnett countered by calling Mr        WA Commerce Minister Michael Mischin
opportunities in Canberra, often frequently in         Weatherill “a bit of a dill”. Hundreds of vessels had
Canberra conveying the argument to Federal             been built in this State, Mr Barnett protested.              Mr Mischin says the Barnett Government has had
politicians.”                                             Critics say it’s no surprise WA missed out.             a continuous focus on the defence industry as a key
  And on top of that is State industry group the          “What WA got compared to what we could have             industry sector, and has strongly promoted the
Defence Teaming Centre with 230 corporate              potentially had is the scraps around the kitchen           Australian Marine Complex at Henderson, south of
members, including seven of Australia’s eight prime table,” Australian Manufacturing Workers’ Union               Perth.
shipbuilders. South Australia’s taxpayers also chip in State secretary Steve McCartney says. “This State            “The State has positioned itself as a hub for naval
— $2.3 million to DTC over five years in the latest    government should have done a lot more over here to        maintenance,” Mr Mischin says. “This has been a
Budget. DTC acting chief executive Kerryn Smith        fight for it.”                                             deliberate strategy to capitalise on the home-porting
says there has been a dedicated defence strategy in       Senator Reynolds believes the State has been given      of naval vessels at (Garden Island’s) HMAS Stirling.”
SA since 2000.                                         a fair go. “Twelve months ago, we weren’t even on the        “In 2013-14 alone, defence contracts managed at the
  WA on the other hand went into battle with no        radar,” she says. “There is billions worth of contracts    AMC totalled an estimated $624 million, creating up
dedicated defence agency or minister (the industry     now to be let.                                             to 3000 jobs,” Mr Mischin says. Financial support was
comes under the commerce portfolio), while Senator        “It makes sense to have the large combatant vessels     being provided to 16 small and medium-size
Reynolds co-founded the WA Defence Industry            because they’ve got the facilities in South Australia,     businesses to upgrade their skills and capabilities.
Council at the end of last year. Run out of the        and they do have the workforce there now to do               On top of the respective lobbying efforts, it is well
Chamber of Commerce and Industry WA with State         those,” she says. “I’m not an apologist for South          documented that the political dice were loaded in
government assistance, it has senior industry figures Australia. But I think in the national interest it is the   SA’s favour. With car manufacturers shutting down
involved but not much funding.                         right decision to have two national shipbuilding           their operations, a looming slump in defence
  While Defence SA spent $1.2 million on promotion hubs.”                                                         shipbuilding spelled trouble for Federal Liberal-held
and events alone in 2014-15, WA Commerce                  Commerce Minister Michael Mischin says the WA           seats, among them that of Cabinet heavyweight
Department figures showed just over $50,000 was        Government is “very pleased” with the hub status.          Christopher Pyne.
spent last year promoting the industry. Two full-time “This decision is testament to the significant private        “The politics of the shipyards in South Australia
equivalent staff are devoted to defence matters.       and public sector investments in naval shipbuilding,       and the so-called valley of death has got in the way of
  SA Premier Jay Weatherill stuck the boot in last     repair and maintenance, upgrade and through-life           rational decision-making,” Dr Davies says.
year. “I know for a fact that there have been          sustainment capability at Henderson.”                        Senator Reynolds says: “Their whole message and

    THE AUSTRALIA MANUFACTURING WORKERS’ UNION

         AMWU IS THE                                                  AMWU SHIPBUILDING WORKERS HAVE BEEN CAMPAIGNING TO MAKE SURE THAT
                                                                      OUR NEXT GENERATION OF OFFSHORE PATROL VESSELS ARE BUILT IN AUSTRALIA.

        SHIPBUILDERS’                                                                                                                       THIS MEANS JOB SECURITY

           UNION.                                                         WE HAVE SECURED                                                   FOR A GENERATION OF
                                                                                                                                            WORKERS AND OUR FAMILIES
                                                                                                                                            FOR YEARS TO COME.

                                                                      A COMMITMENT FROM THE                                                 We’re proud to be a strong
                                                                                                                                            and smart Union that gets
                                                                                                                                            things done, and stands up

                                                                      GOVERNMENT TO BUILD 10                                                IRUZRUNLQJSHRSOHb
                                                                                                                                            But we’re only as strong as
                                                                                                                                            our members, and there’s

                                                                             OFFSHORE PATROL                                                more work to be done.
                                                                                                                                            When we stand together we

                                                                              VESSELS IN WA.
                                                                                                                                            have protection, we have a
               AFTER YEARS OF                                                                                                               voice, and we win. Do you
                                                                                                                                            want to be one of us?
         CAMPAIGNING AGAINST THE
           LIBERAL GOVERNMENT’S
         ATTACKS ON SHIPBUILDING
          JOBS, AND FIGHTING FOR
            A CONTINUOUS LOCAL
          BUILD, WA SHIPBUILDING                                                                         Join our fight today
                                                                                                          Head to: www.amwu.org.au/join
             WORKERS HAVE WON.
                                                                                                                                   Authorised by Paul Bastian, AMWU National Secretary.
SA Premier Jay Weatherill and WA Premier Colin Barnett listen to then prime minister Tony Abbott at a COAG meeting last year. Picture: AAP AAPIMAGE

their whole attitude is one of strident begging bowl           “The same Government in Canberra made a                     interstate, while the rest is the sustainment and
politics.”                                                   decision to base half the navy in Perth and to gift           maintenance spread over many decades.
  SA Defence Industry Minister Martin                        Western Australia twice the amount of the money                    Mr Mischin believes the marginal seats were not a
Hamilton-Smith points out that WA has enjoyed vast           that will be spent on building submarines and                 factor, instead pointing to the presence of
benefits from the resources industries. “We didn’t           warships in the way of sustainment.                           government-owned submarine and shipbuilder ASC
have a mining, oil and gas boom in South Australia,”           “I know which side of the deal I’d rather be on.”           in Adelaide and a common user facility.
he says. “One thing that can help to balance the               Senator Reynolds agrees that the build accounts for              “The location for naval shipbuilding by the
books is the way Government chooses to spend its             only about 30 to 40 per cent of spending. That                Commonwealth                             is based more on shipbuilding, repair
                                                                                                                           ........................................................................................................................................
capital.                                                     includes fabrication which can be performed                   CONTINUED P20
FROM PAGE 19

and maintenance capability,” he says.
   Dr Davies argue there’s also a strong financial
incentive for the Federal Government to give the
work to its own shipyard, considering there are
proposals to privatise ASC.
   Now the big decisions have been made, Mr Pyne as
the newly appointed Defence Industry Minister has
been keen to appear inclusive, making his first trip
under the portfolio to Henderson at the Austal
shipyard. He said WA would be the national centre
for building “non-combatant” ships.
   The industry in SA has also been extending the
olive branch. “The program will take little heed of
State borders,” Ms Smith says. “It’s not about
growing South Australia’s piece of the pie, it’s more
about growing the pie. We genuinely believe not any
one State could undertake this work.”
   But Mr Papalia has doubts that the OPV program
will even get to WA. The Federal Government wants          The most recent government contract for WA’s Austal shipyards, tipped as a favourite to win defence contracts, were new
it to begin in SA to provide work before the frigate       customs vessels delivered earlier this year. Picture: Mogens Johansen
program’s targeted start in 2020.
   “Do you really think anyone will believe the South      he would not trust the ASC to build a canoe. He lost
Australians will just roll over and relinquish             the portfolio a month later.
something that they’re already doing in South                 “Those programs encountered some difficulty
Australia?” he says. “I’m just very sceptical that will    because of the stop-start nature of our shipbuilding
even happen.”                                              industry,” Mr Hamilton-Smith says. “The continuous
   Mr Hamilton-Smith says the handover is a matter         build program that we’re now going to get I think will
for the Federal Government, but may depend on the          deliver one of the most efficient and effective
start time of the frigate build. “Our understanding is     shipyards in the world.”
that they’ve committed to build OPVs in South                 Dr Davies say ASC is in better shape these days, but
Australia until the frigate work kicks in,” he says.       adds that there remain questions about its ability to
   Dr Davies says start-up costs would be doubled          manage a defence program of this magnitude.
because of the move. “There’s absolutely no way if            In Henderson, Australian Securities
you were doing rational workforce planning that            Exchange-listed Austal has built patrol boats for both
you’d do it that way.”                                     the navy and the Australian Border Force since the
   So how do the rival hubs stack up? Dr Davies’           late 1990s, and this year delivered two high-speed
assessment is clear cut: “You’ve got a thriving            support vessels for the navy of Middle East nation
commercially viable engineering and shipbuilding           Oman. In Alabama, it has been building more than 20
sector over in WA, and you’ve got one in South             LCS and troop carriers for the US Navy worth more
Australia that relies on government contracts.             than $US5 billion.
                                                              Austal has expressed interest not only in setting up
‘You can change that. There’s a                            in SA to meet project requirements but in acquiring
                                                           all or part of the ASC if it is put up for sale.
lot of opportunity for WA to                                  Dr Davies says Austal’s main WA competitor for
                                                           the OPVs could be British company BAE Systems,
                                                                                                                         Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull tours Austal at Henderson,
                                                                                                                         with Austal chiefDavid Singleton. Picture: Danella Bevis
muscle up.’                                                which is upgrading the RAN’s Anzac frigates in
                                                           Henderson.                                                    biennial Indian Ocean defence expo. “What we
WA Labor defence industry spokesman Paul Papalia              The other main WA contender for defence projects           should be doing now is ramping up an aggressive
                                                           is Civmec, a heavy engineering firm new to                    campaign to target this whole suggestion that it’s all
  “The contrast is pretty stark.”                          shipbuilding which pitched itself as a submarine              bedded down and South Australia has got the lion’s
  Mr Hamilton-Smith says WA’s industry is vibrant          builder. Civmec this year acquired the Newcastle              share,” Mr Papalia says. “You can change that.
but focused on smaller vessels like catamarans and         facilities of shipbuilder Forgacs.                            There’s a lot of opportunity for WA to muscle up.”
pleasure craft. “Only South Australia has actually            The rival facilities are Adelaide’s Techport and             A common complaint among the companies
built a submarine. Only South Australia has built          Henderson’s AMC. The SA Government has budgeted               wanting to be involved is a lack of coordination
and launched an air warfare destroyer.”                    $6 million over three years to bring defence                  between government departments. In a recent
  While Austal has built patrol vessels in Henderson,      companies to SA and is spending $1 million to expand          example, it took four months for the Government to
he says the littoral combat ships it makes in Alabama      Techport.                                                     make a decision about assisting a commercial project
for the US Navy are a different proposition to                While saying SA was more proactive and                     involving Civmec and vessel builder Evolution
submarines and frigates. “That’s not in Perth, it’s in     supportive than WA, one corporate visitor reported            Commercial. The request was declined.
the US and it’s a completely different business.”          that waterfront space was limited at Techport and               “A number of them will talk about projects they
  No one disputes that Adelaide is long established in     deemed the AMC a superior proposition.                        would have liked to have done but it was just
naval shipbuilding. ASC built the Collins Class               So what is WA going to do to bring in the potential        impossible in terms of the time frames to get State
submarines and is approaching the conclusion of the        billions of dollars in work and accompanying jobs?            Government departments to make decisions,”
$9 billion build of three air warfare destroyer vessels.      Mr Mischin says his department has been working            Senator Reynolds says. “I’d like to see a one-stop shop
  The AWD program suffered a $1.2 billion budget           with the key decision makers of the naval programs.           for these industries.”
blowout, blamed on an unwieldy project alliance            Without giving figures, the Minister says the State is          She also wants to see the WA Government provide
between ASC, the Department of Defence and                 planning to increase resources for the defence                sovereign guarantee bonding for projects.
Raytheon implementing a design by Spanish                  industry within the Department of Commerce. “WA                 Mr McCartney demands a bipartisan approach:
shipbuilder Navantia.                                      is not looking to replicate the South Australian model        “This shouldn’t be about which colour flag they’ve
  Former defence minister David Johnston, a WA             of a dedicated agency or minister.”                           got whether it’s blue or red, this is about winning
senator at the time, infamously claimed in 2014 that          Labor has a policy of doing both, and introducing a        work for Western Australia.”

20                 SEPTEMBER 2016
You can also read