Home, flammable home - AUSTRALIA - Bushfire and Natural Hazards

Page created by Carl Griffin
 
CONTINUE READING
Home, flammable home - AUSTRALIA - Bushfire and Natural Hazards
ISSUE THREE 2019

                 AUSTRALIA
      Conflicting cues in emergency warnings
    Fire Australia 2019 exceeds expectations
                Strength in shared resources

   Home,
flammable
   home
 Demonstration burn shows
value of home fire sprinklers
Home, flammable home - AUSTRALIA - Bushfire and Natural Hazards
When I programme an
F220 Network late on a Friday,
I still get the next day off.
                                                                                                          A Pertronic F220 network is
                                                                                                          programmable from a single point using
                                                                                                            Ethernet-connected Pertronic FireUtils®.
                                                                                                                   Pertronic FireUtils® is a free software
                                                                                                                   app that makes it quick and easy to
                                                                                                                    programme any F220 fire system.
                                                                                                                    Typically a 34-panel network
                                                                                                                   configuration upload takes less than
                                                                                                                   one minute.
                                                                                                                           FireUtils® runs on Windows 7, 8
                                                                                                                                and 10 and is free to
                                                                                                                                      authorised fire industry
                                                                                                                                        professionals.

                                                                                                            Programming an F220 network is quick and
                                                                                                            easy with Ethernet-connected Pertronic
                                                                                                            FireUtils®

                                                                                                            The F220 is independently tested and certified
                                                                                                            to AS 7240.2, AS 7240.4, and AS 4428.3

Contact Pertronic for more information
PERTRONIC INDUSTRIES PTY LTD

Brisbane                     Sydney                       Melbourne                    Adelaide                    Perth

                                                                                                                                               F220
3/43-49 Sandgate Road        19/287 Victoria Road         B2/2a Westall Road           65 Manton Street            3/71 Beringarra Avenue
Albion QLD 4010              Rydalmere NSW 2116           Springvale VIC 3171          Hindmarsh SA 5007           Malaga WA 6090
Phone 07 3255 2222           Phone 02 9638 7655           Phone 03 9562 7577           Phone 08 8340 9533          Phone 08 6555 3008
sales.qld@pertronic.com.au   sales.nsw@pertronic.com.au   sales.vic@pertronic.com.au   sales.sa@pertronic.com.au   sales.wa@pertronic.com.au

www.pertronic.com.au                                                                                                                           FIRE ALARM SYSTEM
Home, flammable home - AUSTRALIA - Bushfire and Natural Hazards
ISSUE THREE 2019
                                                                                                                                                                                             CONTENT


    THE PROGRESS
    JOURNEY                                                                                                                                                        AUSTRALIA
                               One of our driving motivations at AFAC is to
      STUART                   support the development and capability of
      ELLIS AM
                                                                                                                                                                IN THIS ISSUE
                                                                                                                                         12
                               our member agencies to ensure the safety
      Chief Executive Officer, of communities across Australia and
      AFAC                     New Zealand.                                                                                                                      12 H ome, flammable home
                                  Twice a year, the AFAC National                                                                                                15 US lessons for home fire sprinkler
                               Council – comprising the chiefs of fire,                                                                                              adoption
                               emergency services and land management
                                                                                                                                                                 16 Impacts of conflicting cues in
                               organisations from across Australia and
                                                                                                                                                                     emergency warnings
                               New Zealand – meet to discuss the
                               strategic direction and priorities of the                                                                                         19 New SA routine service registration
                               sector. In April, the National Council                                                                                                confirms FPA Australia proposal
                               convened in Canberra to endorse new                                                                                               20 Strong growth for Fire Australia 2019
                               and revised AFAC Doctrine, in response
    to changes across the sector. It will ensure our agencies uphold                                                                                             24 Partnerships build capacity in the
    good practice and remain agile when presented with the                                                                                                           Pacific
    challenges that come with our often unpredictable and complex                                                                                                28 Divulging data – how numbers and
    work environment.                                                                                                                                                figures are helping South Australia
        These developments are, of course, made possible by the
                                                                                                                                                                 30 Professionalising fire safety
    input and experience of our member agencies that contribute
    to the collective knowledge of the fire and emergency services                                                                                                   engineering: the Education Report
    sector through AFAC’s collaboration framework, our network of                                                                                                32 Sharing the load

                                                                                                                                     28
    35 specialised groups and networks from across Australia and                                                                                                 36 Thinking about the future at AFAC19
    New Zealand, guided by AFAC’s five Strategic Directions.
        Our commitment to creating more diverse and inclusive                                                                                                    38 A time to remember and reflect
    workplaces has continued, with the Male Champions of Change                                                                                                  40 Coexisting with combustion: the future
    Fire and Emergency Group marking two years since its inception                                                                                                   of bushfire management
    and having completed a range of projects. Read more about its

                                                                                                                                     32
                                                                                                                                                                 42 The particles making building cladding
    ongoing journey toward achieving gender balance within fire and
    emergency services on page 10.
                                                                                                                                                                     fire-safe
        We are proud to be taking steps forward in improving the safety                                                                                         REGULAR FEATURES
    of Australian homes with the launch of the Home Fire Sprinkler
                                                                                                                                                                  4       News
    Coalition (HFSC) this year, a joint initiative between AFAC and
    FPA Australia. Residential sprinklers can be the difference                                                                                                  44      	AFAC Q&A
    between a small amount of damage and a disaster in your home,                                                                                                46       Blast from the past
    as shown by the demonstration burn at the HFSC launch in
                                                                                                                                                                 48       Standards Australia update
    Sydney, covered on page 12.
        Resource sharing between agencies continues to be a                                                                                                      49       Calendar of events
    focus for AFAC and was the central theme of our 2019 Motorola                                                                                                50       Movers and shakers
    Knowledge Event Series, covered on page 10. We also take the
                                                                                                                 OUR COVER
    opportunity to look back at the latest fire season with AFAC’s
    National Resource Sharing Centre, as seen on page 32.
                                                                                                                 Flames and smoke engulf a room with no sprinklers and shatter its sliding door during a
        I hope you enjoy this edition of Fire Australia.
                                                                                                                 demonstration burn to launch the Home Fire Sprinkler Coalition.
                                                                                                                                                                         PHOTO: TOM BICKNELL, FPA AUSTRALIA

                                                                                                                 ABOUT FIRE AUSTRALIA
    ADVERTISING LISTING
                                                                                                                 Fire Australia is a joint publication of Fire Protection Association Australia, AFAC and the Bushfire and Natural
     2    PERTRONIC                                        23    CONTROL PANELS AUSTRALIA                        Hazards CRC. We aim to bring the latest news, developments and technical information to the fire protection
                                                                                                                 industry, emergency services and natural hazards research organisations. Fire Australia is produced quarterly
     5    JOHNSON CONTROLS                                 26    BOSS FIRE
                                                                                                                 and distributed throughout Australia and New Zealand. Editorial submissions are welcome and can be sent
     7    SECURITON                                        39    PROVIDERS OF CHOICE                             to: tom.bicknell@fpaa.com.au. For more details on submitting a contribution, please contact the editors.
     9    SECURITON                                        51    ALAN WILSON INSURANCE BROKERS
                                                                                                                 JOINT EDITORS                                                       Fire Australia magazine is
    11    FIRESENSE                                        52    VIKING                                                                                                              printed by a printer with
                                                                                                                                                                                     ISO14001 Environmental
    15    ARCHER TESTING
                                                                                                                 Tom Bicknell  (FPA Australia)                                       Management System
    19    BLUE MOUNTAINS ECONOMIC                                                                                TEL +61 3 8892 3118 tom.bicknell@fpaa.com.au                        Accreditation using
          ENTERPRISE                                                                                             Nathan Maddock  (Bushfire and Natural Hazards CRC)                  vegetable-based inks onto
                                                                                                                 TEL +61 3 9412 9600 nathan.maddock@bnhcrc.com.au                    FSC -certified paper.
    To advertise in Fire Australia, contact: Tom Bicknell,                                                       Leone Knight  (AFAC)                                                ISSN 1032-6529 (Print)
    FPA Australia, PO Box 1049, Box Hill VIC 3128, Australia 1300 731 922 tom.bicknell@fpaa.com.au               TEL +61 3 9418 5241 leone.knight@aidr.org.au                        ISSN 2200-9221 (Online)

    DISCLAIMER  The views expressed in this publication are not necessarily those of FPA Australia, AFAC or the Bushfire and Natural Hazards CRC. Articles and advertisements are published in good faith but Fire
    Australia magazine and its agents do not warrant the accuracy or currency of any information or data contained herein. Fire Australia magazine and its agents do not accept any responsibility or liability whatsoever
    with regard to the material in this publication.  It is not possible for FPA Australia to ensure that advertisements published in this magazine comply in all respects with the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 and
    the provisions which apply to advertising. Responsibility lies with the person, company or agency submitting the advertisement for publication.  Material in Fire Australia magazine is subject to copyright. This
    publication may not be reproduced in printed or electronic form without permission. Contact 1300 731 922.

                                                                                                                                                           ISSUE THREE 2019    FIRE
                                                                                                                                                                       2019 FIRE AUSTRALIA                                           3
Home, flammable home - AUSTRALIA - Bushfire and Natural Hazards
NEWS ISSUE THREE 2019
    
                                                                                                                                              and capability is required for electricity

        A POWERFUL CASE
                                                                                                                                              networks to continue to deliver quality
                                                                                                                                              services in the future for the community.

        FOR FUTURE RESEARCH
                                                                                                                                              With our climate and demographics
                                                                                                                                              changing, new vulnerabilities and risks
                                                                                                                                              are emerging. Australia’s networks
                                                                                                                                              need to respond to these significant
                                                                                                                                              challenges. These priorities will help
                                                                                                                                              them.”
                                                                                                                                                  Four high-level priorities for research
                                                                                                                                              related to natural hazard resilience for
                                                                                                                                              electricity networks were identified:
                                                                                                                                              ◆◆understanding the fundamental
                                                                                                                                                 vulnerabilities of Australia’s
                                                                                                                                                 electricity networks and strategies
                                                                                                                                                 to minimise the risks posed by those
                                                                                                                                                 vulnerabilities
                                                                                                                                              ◆◆new approaches to stakeholder
                                                                                                                                                 engagement to support better
                                                                                                                                                 planning and implementation of
                                                                                                                                                 resilient networks and distributed
                                                                                                                                                 generation capability

                                                                                                                 PHOTO: SOUTH AUSTRALIA SES
                                                                                                                                              ◆◆new concepts in operation and
                                                                                                                                                 regulation of electricity networks
                                                                                                                                                 (including frameworks)
                                                                                                                                              ◆◆harnessing current and new data to
                                                                                                                                                 enhance forecasting and modelling of
                                                                                                                                                 electricity networks to better manage

                          E
                                                                                                                                                 the risk and impacts associated with
        Emergency                  lectricity networks have            Australia. The statement forms                                            natural hazards.
        services                   considered their future research    part of a broader national research                                        These research priorities represent
        dealing with a             needs and have identified the       agenda in natural hazards emergency                                    the consensus view of industry experts
        fallen tree and   following as their highest priorities:       management that was developed by the                                   and are based on extensive consultation
        powerline.
                          ◆◆risk and vulnerability                     CRC in 2017.                                                           and discussion. By synthesising this
                          ◆◆stakeholder engagement                         By identifying the research priorities                             information, the research makes it
                          ◆◆regulation                                 for Australian electricity networks, the                               easier for researchers, policymakers
                          ◆◆capturing data for better forecasting     statement poses questions to guide a                                   and practitioners at all levels to plan
                             and modelling.                            national research agenda and prioritises                               and prioritise their work, thus enabling a
                              Australian electricity networks          knowledge gaps to be filled, explained                                 nationally coordinated research capacity
                          – a statement on national research           Dr Richard Thornton, CEO of the                                        to address the major issues of our
                          priorities for natural hazards emergency     Bushfire and Natural Hazards CRC.                                      day, and supporting the uptake of that
                          management and resilience was                    “Our electricity networks are                                      research into practice.
                          released on 16 May by the Bushfire           undergoing transformation, and
                          and Natural Hazards CRC, S&C Electric        the research priorities represent a                                    The National Research Priorities are available
                          Company and Energy Networks                  consensus view on what new knowledge                                   at: bnhcrc.com.au/nationalpriorities.

                                                        of women in the fire protection sector.
                                                            Attendees heard from Elissa Fazio,
        WOMEN IN                                        a fire engineer with News Corp and
                                                                                                                                                                                               PHOTO: TOM BICKNELL, FPA AUSTRALIA

        FIRE SPARKS                                     Board Director of FPA Australia; Amanda
                                                        Leck of AFAC; and Lorraine Carli of US
        CONVERSATION                                    organisation the National Fire Protection

        F
                                                        Association (NFPA). The session drew
                PA Australia held its first ‘Women      on their experience in improving gender
                in Fire’ session at the recent          diversity in the fire and emergency
                Fire Australia Conference and           services, engineering and in the US fire
        Tradeshow 2019 in May, drawing more             protection sector.
        than 50 professionals to hear from                  “We have a group of young female          need to change the public image of fire                                   The Women in
        key figures in the industry and discuss         fire engineers at NFPA, and they go out       protection to make it a visible career                                    Fire session at
        strategies to attract more women to             into the community and talk to young          path for young women.                                                     Fire Australia
        fire protection.                                girls about getting into fire engineering,”       “I think we need to start really early
                                                                                                                                                                                2019 drew on
                                                                                                                                                                                the experience
            The session had one of the largest          Ms Carli said. “These women took this         with that message [that women can do                                      of other
        attendances of the conference,                  upon themselves and said, ‘we can do          this job],” she said. “Unless children are                                industries.
        reflecting a broad interest within the          this for our community’.”                     exposed to that opportunity, they won’t
        industry to address the low percentage              In Australia, Ms Fazio identified a       go down that pathway.”

4           FIRE AUSTRALIA    ISSUE THREE 2019
Home, flammable home - AUSTRALIA - Bushfire and Natural Hazards
It’s amazing what can happen when your
                             team isn’t satisfied with “good enough”.

T: 1300 725 688 (toll free) E: FSP.InsideSales.ANZ@jci.com
Home, flammable home - AUSTRALIA - Bushfire and Natural Hazards
NEWS ISSUE THREE 2019
    

        HEALTHY AGEING AND RETIREMENT
        FOR FIRST RESPONDERS

        A
                 FAC hosted the ‘Healthy             National Engagement Manager for
                 Ageing, Healthy Retirement’         Police and Emergency Services,
                 masterclass in April, in            presented findings from a national

                                                                                                                                                                       PHOTO: ZOE KENYON, AFAC
        recognition of the continued need to         survey of the mental health of 21,000
        address the mental health and wellbeing      emergency services personnel. The
        issues faced by fire and emergency           study was conducted with support from
        services personnel across Australasia.       the Bushfire and Natural Hazards CRC.
           The masterclass, sponsored by                 Rich Adams from Team Rubicon
        Stewart and Heaton Clothing Company,         Australia spoke about the key values
        aimed to raise awareness of the issues       of purpose, community and identity for         by showing how good health is aligned                  AFAC’s event
        around transitions into retirement. It       military veterans and first responders.        with a good work ethic.                                focused on
        provided insights into good practice         Mr Adams presented on the resources                Representatives of South Australia                 mental health
        from across the fire and emergency           available for veterans after service,          Metropolitan Fire Service, Ambulance
                                                                                                                                                           and wellbeing
                                                                                                                                                           issues facing
        services sector to demonstrate the           including recognising the impacts of           Victoria and Police Association of                     Australia’s
        impact of retirement on the mental           retirement on veterans’ sense of identity.     Victoria also shared their insights on                 fire and
        health and wellbeing of personnel.               Andrew McGarity, Manager, Industry         mental health and a healthy transition                 emergency
           A diverse range of presenters             Management Health and Safety at Fire           into retirement at the masterclass.                    services
        and discussion topics painted a              and Rescue NSW, also presented at the              The partnership between AFAC and                   personnel.
        comprehensive picture of the current         event. Mr McGarity spoke about how             Stewart and Heaton highlights the work
        research and initiatives to assist with      inspiration was drawn from the National        of agencies at the forefront of practice in
        healthy ageing and retirement for first      Rugby League (NRL) to develop the              the mental health and wellbeing space.
        responders.                                  Career Transition Booklet, which               The event took place in Melbourne
           James Maskey, Beyond Blue’s               supports current and former firefighters       on 17 April.

                                                                                                     PHOTO: AMY MULDER, BUSHFIRE AND NATURAL HAZARDS CRC

        Fire Safety Assessment                       after an order has been published in

        accreditation opens for                      the NSW Government Gazette, which is
                                                     expected in January 2020.
        applications                                     Following this, relevant fire protection

        A
                                                     work in the state will be required to be
                  pplications for the new Fire       undertaken by a CFSP accredited by
                  Safety Assessment (FSA) class      FPAS or other future approved schemes.
                  of accreditation under the Fire        The FSA class of accreditation will
        Protection Accreditation Scheme (FPAS)       ultimately be available across multiple           Dr Blythe McLennan presenting at the workforce
        opened in early April.                       jurisdictions, however the initial launch         and volunteerism 2030 RAF.
            The launch of the new class of
        accreditation is the start of a yearlong
                                                     will be focused on NSW.
                                                         The launch of the class and its
                                                                                                       Forums firing with
        process to assess and recognise the          recognition by the NSW Government is              utilisation focus

                                                                                                       T
        competence of fire safety practitioners      a major step forward in fire protection
        in two key areas of work.                    for the state, and a validation of the                    he Bushfire and Natural Hazards CRC’s
            The FSA class of accreditation           effort the industry has voluntarily                       new-look Research Advisory Forums
        certifies individuals who assess             invested in raising competency and                        (RAFs) have provided an effective
        the performance capability of fire           standards.                                        platform to discuss the utilisation of CRC research
        safety measures to inform annual or              “In recent years thousands of                 and projects.
        supplementary fire safety statements.        individuals in the fire protection                    Since the CRC began in 2013, the format of
            This class of accreditation has been     industry have voluntarily gained FPAS             the forums has evolved many times to reflect
        designed to address the requirements         accreditation and related training,               the current needs of the research. The latest
        for certain fire protection work in NSW to   and the launch of the new Fire Safety             change allows a greater focus on the utilisation
        be carried out by a ‘competent fire safety   Assessment class is another major                 of research according to themes, rather than the
        practitioner’ (CFSP) under the state’s       step in that path of industry self-               previous focus on individual projects.
        2017 fire safety reforms.                    improvement,” FPA Australia CEO Scott                 The first of the new RAFs was held in conjunction
            As per the NSW Government’s              Williams said.                                    with the Northern Australia Fire Managers Forum
        approval of the FSA and Fire Systems             “The recognition of the FSA and               and also looked at that particular region of Australia.
        Design (FSD) classes of accreditation        FSD classes of accreditation is a                 The second RAF focused on bushfire mitigation as
        in February, individuals holding FSA         strong endorsement from the NSW                   a workshop and formed part of the 6th International
        accreditation will be recognised as          Government that the industry is on the            Fire Behaviour and Fuels Conference. RAFs
        CFSPs under the 2017 reforms.                right track in holding ourselves to a high        have also been held in Melbourne on the theme
            That recognition will be formalised      standard, in order to deliver the best fire       workforce and volunteerism, and in Canberra on the
        by the NSW Government after a phase-         protection services to the community              theme economics, policy and planning.
        in period of approximately 12 months,        that we can.”

6          FIRE AUSTRALIA    ISSUE THREE 2019
Home, flammable home - AUSTRALIA - Bushfire and Natural Hazards
ISSUE THREE 2019                 NEWS


                                                                                                                               PHOTO: QUEENSLAND FIRE AND EMERGENCY SERVICES
                                                                                     The International Association of
                                                                                 Wildland Fire (IAWF) conference
    GLOBAL FIRE                                                                  highlighted the interconnected
    FOCUS ON                                                                     nature of the global fire community,
                                                                                 simultaneously taking place in three
    DIVERSITY,                                                                   locations: Sydney, Australia; Marseille,
    CULTURAL                                                                     France; and Albuquerque, United
                                                                                 States. The Sydney conference saw
    BURNING AND                                                                  337 delegates attend – not only from all
    COMMUNITIES                                                                  Australian states and territories, but also
                                                                                 delegates from 12 other countries.
                                                                                                                                                              The collection features best practice guidance for warnings and

    T
                                                                                     The conference wrapped up with two
             he latest research and                                              successful field trips – one focusing on                                     public information during an emergency.
             lessons learned about                                               the investigation of unseasonable fires,
             bushfire behaviour and fuels                                        coordinated by the New South Wales                                               Warnings Collection
    management were shared at the                                                Rural Fire Service, and the other explored
                                                                                                                                                                  launched online

                                                                                                                                                                   A
    6th International Fire Behaviour and                                         iconic Blue Mountains fire management
    Fuels Conference, which was held                                             sites with the Office of Environment and                                                    collection of resources covering the
    from 29 April to 3 May. The focus was                                        Heritage New South Wales.                                                                   theme of ‘warnings’ has been made
    centred on people, with sessions                                                 The Bushfire and Natural Hazards                                                        available online. The Warnings Collection
    dedicated to Indigenous fire                                                 CRC was a lead partner with the IAWF                                             is available on the Knowledge Hub, an online
    management, community recovery,                                              in all three conferences, with the New                                           initiative that supports education and learning
    shared responsibility, women’s careers                                       South Wales Rural Fire Service and                                               developed by the Australian Institute for Disaster
    in fire and the new National Fire                                            the Bureau of Meteorology as major                                               Resilience (AIDR).
    Danger Ratings System research.                                              supporters in Sydney.                                                                The collection recognises the life-saving value
                                                                                                                                                                  of public information and warnings during an
               Michelle                                                                                                                                           emergency. The resources available support learning
        McKemey from                                                                                                                                              and best-practice guidelines, which are informed
       the University of
                                                                                                                                                                  by research featured in the Australian Journal of
      New England and
      Lesley Patterson,                                                                                                                                           Emergency Management and the Bushfire and
     Banbai Aboriginal                                                                                                                                            Natural Hazards CRC.
     Elder and Ranger,                                                                                                                                                The collection includes a four-part video series
      presenting at the                                                                                                                                           presented by Associate Professor Amisha Mehta and
                           PHOTO: AMY MULDER, BUSHFIRE AND NATURAL HAZARDS CRC

      6th International                                                                                                                                           Associate Professor Brooke Fisher Liu, who explore
    Fire Behaviour and                                                                                                                                            the key concepts and strategies to provide effective
     Fuels Conference,
               Sydney.                                                                                                                                            risk and warning information.
                                                                                                                                                                      There is also exclusive footage from the AFAC18
                                                                                                                                                                  conference powered by INTERSCHUTZ in Perth,
                                                                                                                                                                  which showcases a panel session about how to
                                                                                                                                                                  improve the dissemination of public information
                                                                                                                                                                  and warnings.

                                                                                                                                                                  The Warnings Collection is available on the AIDR Knowledge
                                                                                                                                                                  Hub. Visit bit.ly/2HyJt3g.

                                                                                                   How does Jack
                                                                                                   protect a small premise
                                                                                                   against fire?
Home, flammable home - AUSTRALIA - Bushfire and Natural Hazards
NEWS ISSUE THREE 2019
    
                                                                                                                                      Children as agents

                                                                      PHOTO: DAVID BRUCE, BUSHFIRE AND NATURAL HAZARDS CRC
                                                                                                                                      of change in disaster                              STRATEGY
                                                                                                                                      preparedness                                       RELEASE FOR

                                                                                                                                      I
                                                                                                                                          nvesting in children’s education on            AFAC

                                                                                                                                                                                         T
                                                                                                                                          bushfire behaviour enables them
                                                                                                                                          to participate in bushfire planning,                    he AFAC Strategy 2019–2023
                                                                                                                                      development and implementation and                          has been released and lays
                                                                                                                                      brings progress to their communities –                      the foundations for AFAC’s
                                                                                                                                      that’s the belief of Bushfire and Natural          vision, values, purpose and approach
                                                                                                                                      Hazards CRC researcher Dr Briony                   in delivering strategic support to its
        The Northern Australia Fire Managers Forum brought together                                                                   Towers. Dr Towers, from RMIT University,           members into the future.
        leaders to discuss emergency management within the region.                                                                    recently featured on the Emerging                      The AFAC Strategy covers
                                                                                                                                      Minds podcast, in the episode Disaster             future service delivery; significant
        Northern fire issues                                                                                                          preparedness: myths and programs                   organisational relationships,
        aired at forum                                                                                                                that hold promise, which forms part                partners and key stakeholders;

        A
                                                                                                                                      of the Community Trauma Toolkit. In                AFAC’s international connections;
                    wet and muggy Darwin was the location for                                                                         the podcast, Dr Towers explains that               and the advancement of the
                    the 2019 Northern Australia Fire Managers                                                                         children who have been involved in the             sector’s capability.
                    (NAFM) Forum, which brought together fire                                                                         development of their family’s bushfire                 The document summarises the
        managers from across the north of Australia to discuss                                                                        plans have a sophisticated understanding           role of AFAC within the emergency
        topics of interest to the tropical savannas. The forum                                                                        of bushfire risk. However, being involved in       management sector. It also outlines
        was held on 3 April 2019, with a field trip the following                                                                     developing the plans is just a starting point.     AFAC’s commitment to support
        day where the participants visited the Tiwi Islands to view                                                                        “Uncovering misconceptions and                the development of more resilient
        Indigenous-based plantation forestry operations.                                                                              investing in children’s education on               communities across Australia and
             The Executive Director of Bushfires NT, Collene                                                                          bushfire behaviour enables them to                 New Zealand through assisting the
        Bremner, opened the forum with comments on the                                                                                genuinely participate in bushfire plan             membership network.
        challenges of fire management across the north of                                                                             development and implementation and                     It provides an insight into the
        Australia, drawing on specific issues in the Northern                                                                         become agents of change for their                  work of AFAC and how this will
        Territory.                                                                                                                    communities,” Dr Towers said.                      support member agencies into the
             Other talks focused on the main highlights, activities                                                                                                                      future. Importantly, it communicates
        and weather impacts of the last fire season and how                                                                           Listen to the podcast at www.emergingminds.        AFAC’s role in building the
        these would affect the season. Despite good rainfall                                                                          com.au or on podcast platforms.                    collective knowledge and capability
        during the forum, the wet season, as a whole, across                                                                          PHOTO: AFAC/BUSHFIRE AND NATURAL HAZARDS CRC       of the sector by collaborating
        the Northern Territory and Western Australia received                                                                                                                            across jurisdictions to discover
        below average rainfall. Queensland, in contrast, was                                                                                                                             opportunities, solve problems and
        still feeling the effects of a severe drought and several                                                                                                                        promote a community-centred
        major fires that were quickly followed by two cyclones                                                                                                                           approach.
        and extensive flooding.
             The NAFM Forum 2019 attracted 46 participants                                                                                                                               The AFAC Strategy 2019–2023 is available
                                                                                                                                      Dr Briony Towers presenting her work on child-
        and was hosted by Bushfires NT, with the support of the                                                                       centred disaster risk reduction at the AFAC18      online. Visit bit.ly/30FmLhs.
        Bushfire and Natural Hazards CRC.                                                                                             conference in Perth last year.

                                                                                                                                      T
                                                                                                                                               he future of Queensland’s               a sound plan for the betterment of the
        CRC supports Queensland’s future                                                                                                       emergency services has now
                                                                                                                                               been set out in a strategic plan,
                                                                                                                                                                                       public, explained the CRC’s Partnership
                                                                                                                                                                                       Development Director Sarah Mizzi.
        The Bushfire and Natural Hazards CRC                                                                                          with research and insight from the                   “It is a strategy to ensure the agency
        has aided Queensland’s future emergency                                                                                       Bushfire and Natural Hazards CRC.                is well positioned and well prepared for
        management systems.                                                                                                               Queensland Fire and Emergency                the future, to better meet unforeseen
                                                                                                                                      Services (QFES) engaged the CRC                  challenges and supporting ways to work
                                                                                                                                      to assist with the agency’s strategic            better with communities,” Mizzi said.
                                                                                                                                      planning into the next decade as part of             By partnering with the CRC,
                                                                                                                                      its new Strategy 2030.                           QFES was able to develop a better
                                                                                                                                          The CRC coordinated workshops,               understanding of how it can work with
                                                                                      PHOTO: QUEENSLAND FIRE AND EMERGENCY SERVICES

                                                                                                                                      conducted additional research studies            the community, rather than for the
                                                                                                                                      and used focus groups to contribute to           community, during times of need.
                                                                                                                                      the final report.                                    Through the strategy development
                                                                                                                                          Strategy 2030 aims to position QFES          process, QFES has also benefited
                                                                                                                                      as an innovative and trusted leader in           from the CRC’s expertise, gained
                                                                                                                                      community safety, making it adaptable            through its ongoing research
                                                                                                                                      to the changing needs and expectations           across a number of programs
                                                                                                                                      of the community.                                including emergency management
                                                                                                                                          The CRC is well positioned to provide        capability, incident management,
                                                                                                                                      support to QFES in this process and              volunteering, emergency warnings
                                                                                                                                      in ensuring that the organisation has            and communications.

8           FIRE AUSTRALIA    ISSUE THREE 2019
Home, flammable home - AUSTRALIA - Bushfire and Natural Hazards
ISSUE THREE 2019                  NEWS
  

      ROBOTICS EDUCATION MEETS
      EMERGENCY RESPONSE

      I
         nnovative ideas for building resilience   the future’ – such as such as virtual reality,
         and partnering agencies with schools      robotics and 3D printing – and respond to
         was at the forefront at the Disaster      real-world scenarios and problems.
      Resilient Australia–New Zealand School           The Bot Rescue program challenges

                                                                                                    PHOTO: ALANA BEITZ, AFAC
      Education Network (DRANZSEN) Forum           students to design a robot to assist in an
      in Victoria.                                 emergency scenario through collecting
          The first DRANZSEN event for 2019        data, clearing debris or retrieval and
      captured a diverse range of child-           delivery. Students also create a 3D
      centred approaches to learning about         disaster scene for the robot to navigate.
      natural hazards, harmful impacts and         This practical activity is part of a unit of
      opportunities to reduce risk and build       learning with a focus on natural hazards,                          how fire and emergency service agencies        Julie Fagan
      community resilience, including hands-       exploring local risk, harmful impacts on                           can partner with Victorian Tech Schools        from Geelong
      on robotics design.                          communities and current technologies                               to engage with students and explore            Tech School
          Geelong Tech School Director             used by response agencies.                                         technological solutions to real-world
                                                                                                                                                                     presents the
                                                                                                                                                                     Bot Rescue
      Leanne Collins presented with STEM               Ms Fagan said the Bot Rescue                                   problems while facilitating a conversation     program.
      facilitator Julie Fagan, who showcased       program was popular with students                                  about disaster response and resilience.
      their Bot Rescue program, developed          because it appealed to existing curiosity                          The DRANZSEN event roadshow informs
      in partnership with Victoria State           about emergencies and disasters.                                   the National DRANZSEN Forum taking
      Emergency Service.                           The program also explores emerging                                 place in Melbourne on 30 August 2019.
          In 2016, the Victorian Government        technologies that are shifting the                                 DRANZSEN Forums are free events
      allocated $128 million to establish ten      way emergency agencies respond to                                  offered through the Australian Institute for
      Tech Schools across the state. Tech          scenarios, allowing young minds to                                 Disaster Resilience.
      Schools partner with state, private and      consider challenges and opportunities
      independent schools to offer educational     in the industry for themselves.                                    For more information on DRANZSEN, visit:
      programs that incorporate the ‘tools of          Importantly, the program demonstrates                          bit.ly/2JzB55C.

Early warning and highest sensitivity in small areas.
SecuriRAS ASD 531 aspirating smoke detector:
ü Perfect for electric cabinets, IT racks, portable switchrooms,
  ventilation ducts, car parks and roof spaces
ü Fast and easy 3 step commissioning
ü Selectable Class A, B or C sensitivity, 75 m pipe length, IP 54 enclosure
ü A simple affordable and reliable ASD solution

Authorised Business Partner:

Securiton AG, Alarm and Security Systems
www.securiton.com, info@securiton.com
A company of the Swiss Securitas Group
Home, flammable home - AUSTRALIA - Bushfire and Natural Hazards
NEWS ISSUE THREE 2019
     

         RESOURCE SHARING EXPERTISE
         AROUND AUSTRALASIA                                                                                                                                                                    City of
                                                                                                                                                                                               Webster Fire

         C
                                                                                                                                                                                               Chief and
                   onfronted with longer                            in Houston, Texas presented on the                                                                                         Emergency
                   operational seasons and the                      operational lessons and challenges                                                                                         Manager

                                                                                                                          PHOTO: ZOE KENYON, AFAC
                   complexities of climate change,                  from multi-hazard events, including                                                                                        Patrick Shipp
         fire and emergency services are                            the national-level space target hazard,                                                                                    and AFAC
                                                                                                                                                                                               National
         experiencing growing pressure on their                     Hurricane Harvey, wildfires and human-
                                                                                                                                                                                               Resource
         existing resources, requiring an increase                  made disasters.                                                                                                            Sharing
         in response capability and cross-border                        He was accompanied by NSW Rural                                                                                        Centre
         deployments.                                               Fire Service Assistant Commissioner                                                                                        Manager
             To confront these challenges, AFAC                     Steve Yorke, who provided an Australian                                    Attendees gained valuable insights              Luke Purcell
         and Motorola teamed up to deliver the                      perspective on resourcing. As Director,                                about the importance of effective                   answer
         2019 Knowledge Event Series on the                         Operational and Mitigation Services                                    coordination and communication with
                                                                                                                                                                                               audience
                                                                                                                                                                                               questions
         topic ‘sharing resources in response to                    at NSW RFS, Assistant Commissioner                                     different agencies during operational               at the
         multi-hazard events: perspectives from                     Yorke has been active in many major                                    periods. The event took place in every              Melbourne
         Texas, USA’.                                               fire incidents and has been deployed to                                Australian state and territory and in               Motorola
             Fire Chief and Emergency Manager                       Canada and Tasmania through the AFAC                                   Wellington, New Zealand between                     Knowledge
         Patrick Shipp from the City of Webster                     National Resource Sharing Centre.                                      27 May and 12 June.                                 Event.

                                                                                                                                                    Two years of change
         BURNING                                                                                                                                    in the sector
         POTENTIAL AT
                                                                                                                                                    T
                                                                                                                                                             he Male Champions of Change Fire and
                                                                                                                                                             Emergency Group marked two years since
         PRESCRIBED FIRE                                                                                                                                     the group’s establishment when they met
         FORUMS                                                                                                                                     on 30 April in Canberra.
                                                                                                                                                        Founder of the Male Champions of Change

         T
                                                                                                                                                    and former Australian Sex Discrimination
                  wo prescribed burning forums                                                                                                      Commissioner Elizabeth Broderick AO shared
                  recently addressed the current                                                                                                    lessons arising from her experience with
                                                       PHOTO: DEB SPARKES

                  and future issues of the practice.                                                                                                the strategy. Ms Broderick spoke about how
             The North Australia Savanna Fire                                                                                                       listening and learning can build a gender diverse
         Forum allowed practitioners and locals                                                                                                     organisation, and about the need to address both
         in the Northern Territory to address                                                                                                       the covert and overt unconscious discrimination
         emerging technologies and issues in                        Attendees discuss prescribed burning practice at                                that can exist in a workplace.
         delivering savanna burning carbon                          the Institute of Foresters of Australia Subtropical                                 Ms Broderick concluded by stating that a
         abatement programs.                                        Forum.                                                                          focus on gender equality is not a “battle of the
             Carbon abatement programs allow                        overcome them. Eighty people attended                                           sexes”. Based on her experiences, Ms Broderick
         land management organisations to sell                      the forum, from land management                                                 said everyone benefits from a clear focus on
         carbon credit units to the government                      agencies, state and private forestry                                            gender equality and the overall capability of an
         through the Emissions Reduction Fund,                      organisations, fire services and research                                       organisation lifts in response to the change.
         or to businesses who are seeking to                        institutions.                                                                       AFAC CEO Stuart Ellis thanked all organisations
         offset their greenhouse gas emissions.                        The participating groups agreed that                                         and leaders involved in the strategy for the progress
         By increasing the extent of prescribed                     the increase in cultural burning is an                                          made over the past two years. He reminded the
         burning undertaken, the savanna                            emerging opportunity that can provide                                           ‘Champions’ that the strategy demands a personal
         burning projects abate approximately                       multiple benefits for prescribed burning.                                       and organisational commitment from members,
         1.2 million tonnes of CO2e each year,                      The groups also recognised that an                                              and about the importance of consistency between
         which represents ten percent of all                        increased community understanding                                               words and actions.
         carbon credit units produced across all                    and involvement in prescribed burning                                               The Male Champions of Change strategy is
         methods.                                                   would help to address some of the                                               about male leaders advocating for, and acting
             The second forum was the Institute                     outstanding challenges and assist with                                          to advance, gender equality. The initiative
         of Foresters of Australia Subtropical                      ecological and risk reduction outcomes.                                         is convened by the Victorian Human Rights
         Forum, which took place in Lismore. The                       The Centre of Excellence for                                                 and Equal Opportunity Commissioner Kristen
         event focused on prescribed burning for                    Prescribed Burning is an initiative of                                          Hilton, alongside a group made up of men and
         multiple outcomes in north-east NSW                        the Australian Institute for Disaster                                           women who are leaders from across the fire
         and south-east Queensland.                                 Resilience, and communicates the                                                and emergency services sector, including AFAC
             Participants workshopped the                           guiding frameworks and principles                                               members. These Champions work together to
         changes they have witnessed in bushfire                    regarding prescribed burning.                                                   advance gender equality and support an increase
         management and the challenges they                                                                                                         in the representation of women in leadership
         face in addressing these changes, and                      For more information, please visit:                                             positions across the sector.
         they brainstormed innovative ideas to                      bit.ly/2J1sQya.

10          FIRE AUSTRALIA    ISSUE THREE 2019
By the Fire Industry,
For the Fire Industry
You asked, we delivered.
With over 30 years’ fire industry experience, FireSense has a range of TPS & Fire Rated cables to
cater specifically to the fire industry.

We designed our cables with you, the fire contractor in mind.

          Smallest Diameter on the market

          Easiest to strip

          Always in stock

          Delivered direct to site

          Independently Certified

         Approved to relevant Australian Standards

 FireSense TPS & Fire Rated Cables are the benchmark
 in the fire industry, with a larger range than ever before.

          Visit our website, or call your local branch for further information.

                                                                                                                                      firesense.com.au

sales@firesense.com.au               salesvic@firesense.com.au                salesqld@firesense.com.au
02 8850 2888                        03 9646 4557                            07 3890 8842

FireSense is a specialist supplier of electronic fire systems and fire rated cabling products to installers and wholesalers.

With an extensive range of products covering electronic fire detection systems, building evacuation systems,
high sensitivity aspirated smoke detection systems, fire alarm control cabling and fire rated power and control cables,
FireSense is the right partner for your next major project.

FireSense’s head office and warehousing is located in North West Sydney and has regional sales offices and warehousing in Melbourne and Brisbane.
DEMO BURN REPORT

     A FRNSW
     firefighter
     extinguishes
     the blaze that
     took hold of the
     room without a
     sprinkler at the
     demonstration
     burn.

     PHOTOS: FPA AUSTRALIA

     HOME, FLAMMABLE HOME
                                                 J
     Identical rooms, identical furniture and           ust four minutes and 30 seconds        facility in Londonderry to highlight the
     an identical spark: two demonstration              after a small fire was lit in a        life-saving value of residential sprinklers.
     burns to launch the Home Fire Sprinkler            purpose-built reproduction of an       The event preceded changes to the
                                                 average apartment lounge room, the            National Construction Code (NCC) 2019
     Coalition have shown the life-saving        inside of the structure reached a deadly      introduced on 1 May, requiring all newly
     value of installing automatic sprinkler     1,245 degrees Celsius.                        constructed shared accommodation
     systems in modern Australian homes.             Next door, an identical lounge room       buildings under 25 metres and over
                                                 replica reached just 90 degrees – the         three storeys to have sprinklers installed,
                                                 temperature and flames dulled by a            going beyond previous requirements for
     BY   ALANA BEITZ                            single residential sprinkler installed into   sprinklers only in residential buildings
                                                 the structure’s roof.                         above 25 metres.
     AFAC
                                                     The demonstration burns took place            To ensure the public and industry
                                                 on 29 April at Fire and Rescue NSW’s          stakeholders are aware of the new
                                                 (FRNSW) fire research and testing             NCC 2019 regulations and the safety

12          FIRE AUSTRALIA    ISSUE THREE 2019
DEMO BURN REPORT

value of residential sprinklers, the           took 29 minutes.                                   winter as the temperature drops. The
Home Fire Sprinkler Coalition – a                  Many synthetic items of furniture and          demonstration burn replicated what
partnership between AFAC and FPA               other belongings also create a deadly              could occur if a spark from a heating
Australia – has been established to            smoke as they burn. The same research              device or fireplace escaped and
provide independent, non-commercial            found that home fire sprinklers provide            caught hold.
information about sprinklers.                  dual protection to residents during a                  Each room was 3.6 m by 6 m in
                                               house fire by suppressing the spread               size, common dimensions for a room
Synthetics spark concern                       of flames and acting as a physical                 in a modern apartment. Maintaining
The new NCC 2019 regulations respond           barrier for smoke movement within the              consistency between the two rooms
to the risks of modern Australian homes,       space. This creates a safer operating              is key to the integrity of a side-by-side
namely the increase in synthetic materials     environment for firefighters when                  demonstration burn and the focus of
used to build and furnish them. Fuelled by     they arrive on the scene of a sprinkler-           the FRNSW Fire Investigation and
these materials, residential fires can reach   controlled fire.                                   Research Unit.
deadly flashover (the complete ignition of                                                            “We replicate everything, so one
combustible materials in a compartment         Hitting close to home                              room is an exact clone of the other,
due to radiant heat) in as little as three     The demonstration burns were                       from the paint and the hangings on the
minutes.                                       specifically designed to reflect the               walls down to the carpet on the ground,”
    Speaking to the media at the               typical living conditions of everyday              FRNSW Fire Research Team Leader
demonstration burn, FRNSW                      Australians. In each test structure, a             Morgan Cook explained.
Commissioner and AFAC President Paul           small fan heater sat beside a couch                    Common house items were used
Baxter conveyed the deadly potential of        with a blanket draped over it – a                  in each room, including two couches,
modern furnishings.                            familiar scene in many homes during                a coffee table, a lamp, a bookcase,
    “Most people don’t realise when they
settle in to watch Netflix at night, they
                                                        Room temperature readings (by height intervals)
are sitting on basically a drum of petrol      Temperature °C
– that is what all of our furniture is made    1400                                                                1245.1
out of these days.”
                                               1200
    Research conducted by FRNSW,
                                               1000
AFAC, FPA Australia and CSIRO
following the coronial inquest into a           800

tragic 2012 Bankstown apartment fire           600
confirmed the increased fire risk of           400
modern Australian homes.                                            90.4
                                                200
    The investigation found that a fire in
a modern home can spread in less than             0
                                                                             2:00                           4:30                    6:30
five minutes, a fatal reduction in the time                                              Time (mins)
residents can escape compared to older                   180cm Non-sprinklered           120cm Non-sprinklered       60cm Non-sprinklered
homes built between 1950–70, which                       180cm Sprinklered          120cm Sprinklered     60cm Sprinklered

                                                                                                                                                The room
                                                                                                                                                with no
                                                                                                                                                sprinkler and
                                                                                                                                                its synthetic,
                                                                                                                                                flammable
                                                                                                                                                contents were
                                                                                                                                                completely
                                                                                                                                                destroyed
                                                                                                                                                during the
                                                                                                                                                demonstration
                                                                                                                                                burn.

                                                                                                                 ISSUE THREE 2019    FIRE AUSTRALIA              13
DEMO BURN REPORT

     The residential
          sprinklers
          contained
        the blaze to
      just one area
        of the room
          during the
     demonstration
               burn.

                       curtains, cushions, a rug and a child’s       maximum of 90.4 degrees. At the time of               “That provides the critical time for
                       play tent.                                    the sprinkler activation, the temperature         the occupants of the building to be able
                          “It’s really important that these burns    of the room at mid-level (120 cm) had             to escape.”
                       are identically laid out and accurately       only reached 33.4 degrees, and the                    FRNSW’s Morgan Cook said the
                       recorded, both for the credibility of our     ground level (60 cm) temperature was              launch of the Home Fire Sprinkler
                       research and to show how much impact          just 20.3 degrees.                                Coalition was a success and generated
                       a sprinkler will have during a home fire,”        After firefighters extinguished both          an important discussion about home
                       Mr Cook said.                                 fires, the difference between the two             fire safety and building regulations.
                          Conditions outside the rooms               rooms was clear. The room without a                   “The visual impact of a demonstration
                       were closely supervised, and the wind         sprinkler had reached flashover point             burn is a really powerful tool in changing
                       direction and speed, air temperature,         at about 2 minutes and 30 seconds,                public understanding of home fires.
                       humidity and pressure were measured           engulfing every item in the room and                  “It’s really simple when you see both
                       to monitor their impact on the burns.         leaving nothing to be salvaged.                   of the rooms after the fires have been
                          Inside, three temperature readings             Comparatively, the room with a                extinguished – without a sprinkler a
                       took place in each room every two             sprinkler contained the blaze to just             room is completely destroyed in no time
                       seconds for the duration of the               one side of one couch, damaging some              at all. Seeing that really pushes people
                       burns – one at average head height            of the items in the room but leaving the          to act,” Mr Cook said.
                       (180 centimetres), one at sitting height      majority untouched by flames.
                       (120 cm) and one at floor level (60 cm).          “In almost all circumstances, the             More information about automatic residential
                                                                     fire will be limited to sometimes just            sprinklers, including regulation changes in
                       A tale of two burns                           the object of origin, but most likely the         the NCC 2019, is available on the Home Fire
                       Two minutes after each spark was lit,         room of origin,” Commissioner Baxter              Sprinkler Coalition website:
                       the temperature in both rooms hit             explained at the demonstration burn.              www.homefiresprinklers.org.au.
                       90 degrees, activating the sprinkler
                       in one room.
                           While the temperatures dropped in
                       the room equipped with a sprinkler, the
                       heat in the room without one continued
                       to climb, jumping from 90 degrees to
                       314.1 degrees in just 15 seconds. Another
                       15 seconds later, the temperature more
                       than doubled, reaching 752.3 degrees.
                           The temperature continued to rise,
                       reaching a maximum of 1,245 degrees
                       and collapsing the roof and shattering
                       the glass sliding doors before firefighters
                       intervened. In these conditions, a person
                       would not survive.
                           In comparison, the temperature in         FRNSW Commissioner and AFAC President Paul Baxter addresses the media
                                                                     at the Home Fire Sprinkler Coalition launch.
                       the room with a sprinkler reached a

14        FIRE AUSTRALIA    ISSUE THREE 2019
RESIDENTIAL SPRINKLERS

US LESSONS FOR HOME FIRE
SPRINKLER ADOPTION
BY   TOM BICKNELL                                 “We know the solution exists in home                               and two-family homes, no reduction in
                                              fire sprinklers,” she stated. “More than                               building has been seen, and installation
FPA Australia

I
                                              90 percent of the time, home fires can                                 costs have averaged only US$1.35 per
    n the US, 80 percent of fire-related      be controlled by only one sprinkler head.”                             sprinklered square foot.
    deaths occur at home, from an                 In the US experience, consumers                                        Efforts to increase home sprinkler
    annual average of 368,000 home            have been on board. In surveys of                                      adoption in the US have also run
fires. That number was a driving factor       homeowners, the US HFSC found that                                     into resistance from a residential
behind the establishment of the US            74 percent would be more likely to                                     construction industry unfamiliar with
Home Fire Sprinkler Coalition in 1996,        buy a home with fire sprinklers, and                                   sprinklers, and a sprinkler industry
formed to educate the public about the        70 percent said a sprinklered house                                    unfamiliar with residential construction.
life-saving value of fire sprinklers in the   had more value.                                                            But despite the challenges, work to
home.                                             Some of the key hurdles to                                         increase home fire sprinkler adoption
    Australia’s own recently established      overcome, however, are in perceptions                                  in the US and in Australia will continue,
                                                                                                                                                                 US consumers
Home Fire Sprinkler Coalition (HFSC) is       that sprinklers cost too much and will                                 spurred on by another number shared         are on board
modelled after the US organisation, and       stall construction, said Ms Carli. But the                             by Ms Carli with conference attendees:      with home
the local industry heard some of the key      data doesn’t support this concern; in                                  “The risk of dying in a home fire           sprinklers,
lessons learned by the US HFSC in its         US jurisdictions that have introduced                                  decreases by 85 percent if sprinklers are   according to
23 years of operation at the recent Fire      requirements for sprinklers in new one                                 present.”                                   Lorraine Carli.
Australia Conference and Tradeshow
2019 in Melbourne.                                                                         PHOTO: TOM BICKNELL, FPA AUSTRALIA
    Lorraine Carli, President of the US
HFSC and Vice President of Outreach
and Advocacy at the National Fire
                                              “We know the solution
Protection Association, spoke about the        exists in home fire
US experience with home fire sprinklers.
    “We know that 80 percent of fire           sprinklers. More than
deaths happen in the home, so if we’re
going to solve the problem we have to
                                               90 percent of the time,
go to the home,” she said.                     home fires can be
    The speed of fire spread in homes
has dramatically increased in the last         controlled by only one
half century due to the ubiquity of
synthetic materials in furnishings, she
                                               sprinkler head.”
explained, as well as the trend towards                                – Lorraine Carli
open-plan living spaces that allow faster
fire propagation.
PROTECTIVE ACTION

     IMPACTS OF
     CONFLICTING CUES IN
     EMERGENCY
     WARNINGS

     New research confirms a long-held suspicion that emergency
     warnings do not always have precedence when other
     sources conflict with official advice.

               BY DR PAULA DOOTSON,                      action. Environmental cues such as the       Processing model and the Protective
               ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR                       weather outside, information offered by      Action Decision model.
               DOMINIQUE GREER,                          the media or the actions peers are taking        The Risk Information Seeking and
               SOPHIE A. MILLER AND                      all influence people’s decisions and can     Processing model proposes seven
               PROFESSOR VIVIENNE                        inhibit taking timely protective action.     factors that influence the extent to
               TIPPETT                                        When cues from different information    which people seek out information and
                                                         sources are in conflict, such as when        the time they spend analysing it. These
               Queensland University of Technology and
                                                         a flood evacuation warning has been          include:
               Bushfire and Natural Hazards CRC
                                                         issued but the weather conditions in the     ◆◆individual characteristics

               A
                                                         immediate area appear sunny and fine,        ◆◆perceived hazard characteristics (i.e.
                         ustralia’s emergency services   it can cause uncertainty about the right        risk perceptions)
                         agencies face immense           action to take.                              ◆◆affective response to the risk
                         challenges when responding           Our team, through the Bushfire and      ◆◆social pressures to possess relevant
               to natural hazards. Evacuating people     Natural Hazards CRC project ‘Effective          information
               in affected regions requires time,        risk and warning communication during        ◆◆information sufficiency
               influence, coordination and expertise.    natural hazards’, found that conflicting     ◆◆one’s personal capacity to learn
                   Triggering large-scale public         cues do exist across multiple hazard types   ◆◆beliefs about the usefulness of
               evacuations in time-critical situations   and can affect information processing of        information in various channels.
               of flood or bushfire is problematic, as   risk perceptions, and therefore prevent          The Risk Information Seeking and
               there is always some uncertainty about    appropriate protective action.               Processing model is built on the idea
               whether, or how, a natural hazard will                                                 that just because information is available
               occur. Compounding this problem is the    Undertaking the research                     does not mean people will do anything
               fact that emergency services are not      This research draws on two models to         to respond to it.
               the only source of information that the   explain the effect of conflicting clues:         The Protective Action Decision
               public uses when considering taking       the Risk Information Seeking and             model suggests that an individual’s

16     FIRE AUSTRALIA ISSUE THREE 2019
PROTECTIVE ACTION

                                                Research has shown that environmental cues,
                                                                                                   perceptions, and therefore prevent
                                                  such as the weather outside, influence how
                                                      individuals react to warning messages.       appropriate protective action. The
                                                                                                   significant results were evenly spread
                                                                                                   across hazards, suggesting the problem
                                                                                                   is not unique to one hazard.

                                                                                                   Findings
                                                                                                   CONSISTENT CUES
                                                                                                   Consistent cues refers to when the
                                                                                                   instruction in the emergency warning
                                                                                                   was consistent with the environmental
                                                                                                   cue and social cues of media, a warning
                                                                                                   from an unofficial organisation, and
                                                                                                   peer behaviour. When presented with
                                                                                                   consistent cues, participants were more
                                                                                                   likely to intend to evacuate; perceive
                                                                                                   risk about the event; share information
                                                                                                   with friends, family and peers; find
                                                                                                   emergency warnings to be effective;
                                                                                                   comprehend the information; and have a
                                                                                                   higher current information level.
                                                                                                   Behavioural intentions to evacuate:
                                                                                                   participants were more likely to intend to
                                                                                                   evacuate under the ‘bushfire, evacuate
                                                                                                   now’, condition when the emergency
                                                                                                   warning was consistent with a social cue
                                                                                                   from the media.
                                                                                                   Risk perceptions about the
                                                                                                   flood/bushfire: perceived hazard
                                                                                                   characteristics were higher for
                                                                                                   participants when they received
                                                                                                   consistent instructions from emergency
                                                                                                   warnings, environmental cues and social
                                                                                                   cues of media and unofficial warning
                                                                                                   organisations across bushfire and flood,
                                                                                                   and across both escalations of warnings.
                                                                                                   Sharing information with friends,
                                                                                                   family and peers: information sharing
                                                                                                   was more likely for participants who
                                                                                      PHOTO: CFA   received consistent environmental and
                                                                                                   media cues across ‘flood, prepare to
decision to engage in a protective             environmental cue – e.g. a gif (an image            evacuate’ and ‘bushfire, evacuate now’
action is informed by how they process         file that supports both animated and                warnings.
socio-environmental cues alongside             static images) of a sunny day, bushfire or          Perceived effectiveness: perceived
official communications. Environmental         flood – or one of three social cues – e.g.          effectiveness has to do with how
cues include smells and sights, while          a media article suggesting evacuating               attention-grabbing, powerfully
social cues incorporate the behaviour          or staying, an organisation releasing               informative, meaningful and convincing
of others. This can produce modelling          an unofficial warning suggesting                    the emergency warning was, and
behaviours, media coverage as a form           evacuating or staying, or observed                  whether it was worth remembering.
of authority to effect behaviours, and         behaviour of neighbours evacuating or               Participants perceived emergency
information from unofficial sources as         staying. Taking protective action in the            warnings to be more effective when
another behavioural influence.                 event of bushfire or flood can mean any             social cues from the media and unofficial
    Previous research indicates that           number of things, including preparing               warning organisations were consistent
many situational and personal factors          property and family for evacuation,                 with emergency warnings or ‘evacuate
will affect an individual’s behaviour in       calling for emergency assistance or                 now’ messages across flood and
an emergency, such as age, gender,             telling friends or family about the event.          bushfire.
language, country of birth and past            The survey also collected information               Perceived comprehension: perceived
experience with hazards.                       on participants’ age, gender, language,             comprehension has to do with how easy
    Our team surveyed 2,649 adults             country of birth and past experience                it was for participants to understand
across all Australian states and territories   with hazards to ascertain whether                   the message and comprehend the
about bushfires and floods. The                these impacted the likelihood of taking             information in the message. Perceived
respondents were randomly assigned             protective action.                                  comprehension was higher for
to one of 32 experimental conditions               Our research has confirmed                      participants who received a ‘bushfire,
that presented them with an emergency          emergency services agencies’                        evacuate now’ warning that was
warning (‘prepare to evacuate’                 suspicions that conflicting cues can                consistent with the social cue of an
or ‘evacuate now’) and either an               affect information processing of risk               unofficial warning organisation.

                                                                                                              ISSUE THREE 2019 FIRE AUSTRALIA            17
PROTECTIVE ACTION

                                                                                                                            WORD FROM THE
                                                                                                                            EMERGENCY SERVICES

                                                                                                                            To have empirical evidence of how
                                                                                                                            conflicting cues can impact what the
                                                                                                                            community thinks and how they act
                                                                                                                            is important for us because it helps
                                                                                                                            emergency services agencies tailor
                                                                                                                            the information and warnings it delivers
                                                                                                                            to the community during emergency
                                                                                                                            events. These findings, combined with
                                                                                                                            the next stage of the research project,
                                                                                                                            will help us develop ways to address
                                                                                                                            ambiguity caused by conflicting cues
                                                                                                                            to encourage the community to take
                                                                                                                            protective action. Specifically, we will
                                                                                                                            use these findings and future work
                                                                                                                            to inform how we can tailor warnings
                                                                                                                            and the key messages delivered by
                                                                                                                            operational personnel to acknowledge
                                                                                                                            the lack of environmental and visual
                                                                                                                            cues of the immediate threat.”
                                                                                                                            – Hayley Gillespie,
                                                                                                                              Executive Manager Media at Queensland
                                                                                                                              Fire and Emergency Services
                                                                                              PHOTO: SOUTH AUSTRALIAN SES

           This is the   Current information level: current              participants were more likely to seek              evacuating. Seemingly, the social cue
      first research     information level refers to the                 out additional information, while their            was enough confirmation so they did
              to offer   participants’ perceived knowledge of a          information processing and self-efficacy           not need to read more of the warning or
            empirical    hazard. Participants perceived they had         were affected.                                     seek further confirmation. Conversely,
         evidence of
          the impact     a higher current information level when         Seek out further information:                      heuristic information processing was
      of conflicting     they received a ‘flood, evacuate now’           information-seeking refers to the                  found to be higher for participants who
     cues and how        emergency warning consistent with a             participants’ likelihood of searching              received a ‘flood, prepare to evacuate’
     they influence      social cue from an unofficial warning           for information about a hazard in order            emergency warning that was in conflict
               public    organisation.                                   to understand it better, as opposed to             with the social cue of an unofficial
        behaviour in                                                     tuning out when the topic of the hazard            warning organisation.
            Australia.
                         CONFLICTING CUES                                comes up. Participants were more likely            Ability to follow the instruction:
                         Conflicting cues refers to when the             to seek information when a ‘bushfire,              self-efficacy has to do with a person’s
                         instruction in the warning message              prepare to evacuate’ emergency                     perceived ability to complete a task or
                         conflicted with the environmental               warning conflicted with the social cue             engage in a specific action. Participants
                         and social cues, unofficial warning             of an unofficial warning organisation.             perceived their self-efficacy to be
                         organisations and peer behaviour.               While seeking out additional information           higher when the emergency warning
                         When faced with conflicting cues,               is sometimes encouraged and thus                   was consistent with the social cue of
                                                                         could be considered a protective                   peers performing evacuation actions
     Note: This stimulus has been changed and stylised                   action, it can result in milling behaviour         in the bushfire context. Interestingly,
     graphics used for the purpose of this article.                      – a communicative process whereby                  participants perceived their self-efficacy
                                                                         individuals come together in an attempt            to be higher when the ‘bushfire,
                                                                         to define the situation, confirm the threat        evacuate now’ emergency warning
                                                                         or risk, and propose and adopt new                 conflicted with the media social cue.
                                                                         behaviours (known as protective actions).
                                                                         Getting stuck in the milling process for           What next?
                                                                         extended periods of time can potentially           Our team is planning to develop
     Conflicting cue instructions for a flood warning (presented after   place individuals in danger.                       and test intervention to mitigate the
     the emergency warning message): You look outside the window         Process the information: heuristic                 negative effects of conflicting cues to
     and see it is a sunny day.
                                                                         information processing happens when                improve protective action. Among other
                                                                         individuals skim through information, do           things, the intervention could include
                                                                         not spend much time thinking about the             an acknowledgment of the potential
                                                                         information, or believe they have been             existence of conflicting cues in official
                                                                         presented with far more information                emergency warnings. It could also require
                                                                         than they personally need about a topic.           emergency warnings to better convey a
                                                                         Heuristic information processing was               sense of urgency. The outcomes of our
     Consistent cue instructions for a flood warning (presented after    higher for participants who received a             research have the potential to optimise
     the emergency warning message): You look outside the window         ‘flood, evacuate now’ warning that was             emergency warnings and encourage
     and see it is raining.                                              consistent with the social cue of peers            community compliance.

18        FIRE AUSTRALIA ISSUE THREE 2019
You can also read