Investors Presentation - June 2020 - Conselleria d'Hisenda i ...

Page created by Franklin Stephens
 
CONTINUE READING
Investors Presentation - June 2020 - Conselleria d'Hisenda i ...
Investors Presentation
June 2020
                         1
Economic outlook
The Valencian Community

                                       Valencia    Spain
                                                                                 Principado
                                                                                 de Asturias

                                        23,255    505,990     Galicia                          Cantabria
 Surface (km2)
                                          4.6%     100%                                                   País Vasco

                                          5.03     47.35                                                       Navarra
 Population Jan ’20 (m)
                                         10.6%     100%
                                                                          Castilla y León      La Rioja
                                          111      1,202
 GDP 2018 (€ bn)
                                          9.2%     100%

                                        22,426    25,727                                                    Aragón
                                                                                                                         Cataluña
 GDP per capita 2018 (€)                                                              Madrid
                                         87.2%     100%
                                                            Extremadura

                                                                                   Castilla -
                                                                                  La Mancha                    Comunidad
  The Valencian Community was established in 1982                                                              Valenciana

  Located on the Eastern coast of Spain                              Andalucía
                                                                                                                            Baleares
                                                                                            Región
  Mid–sized region that constitutes                                                        de Murcia
  c. 5% of the national territory

  It incorporates the provinces of Valencia,
  Alicante and Castellon                                     Ceuta                                                     Canarias
                                                                            Melilla

Source: Instituto Nacional de Estadística (INE)                                                                                        3
The Valencian Community: Economic structure

         GROSS VALUE ADDED (2018)                              Valencia has an open, dynamic and diversified
                                                               economy.
          Construction
              7%
                                            Industry           Services weighed 72% of the regional GDP in 2018
                                              19%
                                                               – Tourism represents a high percentage of regional
                                                                 GDP (14,6%)
                                               Agriculture
                                                  2%           – The industrial sector represented 19% of the
                                                                 regional GDP in 2018.

                                                               – The industrial base includes automotive, food and
                                                                 beverages, chemical, building materials and textile
                                                                 companies
       Services                                                – The automotive industry represented 22% of
        72%
                                                                 regional exports ⇒ Ford’s plant is regarded as one
                                       *
                                                                 of the most efficient in Europe ( 2019).
                         EXPORTS
                                                               Highly-intensive in exports, compared to Spain.
                                   Valencia            Spain
                                                               – 27.5% of Valencia’s GDP (vs 23.7% in Spain)

                                                               – 10.74% of total exports in Spain. Along with
  Exports / Imports (%)
                                  109.35%          90.52%        Madrid is the third Community more exporter only
  March ’20 (last 12 months)
                                                                 below Catalonia and Andalusia.
  Exports (% of GDP)
                                    27.5%           23.7%      The Valencian Community holds a fundamental
  2018 (full year)
                                                               strategic position for commercial interconnections.

*Exports of goods                                                                                                 4
Source: INE and Secretaría de Estado de Comercio
The Valencian Community: Economic structure

A strong industry sector:
    The Valencian region is leader in Spain in the production of ceramic tiles. In 2018 represents for almost 94% of the
    country’s production, and 9% of total exports in the region.
    The region concentrates 62% of the footwear national production, 43% of footwear national exports and 9% of total
    exports in the region.
    Automotive industry production in the region represents in 2019, 15% of Spain’s total production, 15% of
    automotive national exports too, and 22% of total exports in the region. It represents 12.9% of regional GDP.
    Agrifood industry: It accounts in 2018 for almost 8% of the total national production ,13% of national agrifood
    exports and 20% of total exports in the region).
    Chemical industry. In 2018 represents 8% of the total output ,10% of national exports and 11% of regional GDP
    Highly competitive services:
    Valencia’s port is the leading commercial port on the West Mediterranean in terms of containerised cargo volumes
    9.6 million of foreign tourists visited the region in 2019 (+4% yoy).
  Services. Gross Value Added by activity. 2018                                                              €m                  % of Spain
  Trade and repair. Transportation, hotels and storage.                                                      24,653                9.5%
  Information and communications                                                                              2,021                5.0%
  Financial and insurance activities                                                                          3,613                8.2%
  Real estate activities                                                                                     12,684                10.1%
  Professional, scientific and technical activities                                                           7,083                7.3%
  Public Administration and defence. Compulsory S. Security. Education. Human
                                                                                                             17,217                8.8 %
  health and social work activities
  Artistic, recreation and entertainment services                                                             4,973                9,5%
  Total services                                                                                            72,244                 9.5%

Source: Conselleria de Economía Sostenible, Sectores Productivos, Comercio y Trabajo, INE and Secretaría de Estado de Comercio
                                                                                                                                              5
The Valencian Community

  Solid GDP growth rate

                                            GDP GROWTH (yoy, %)

  %
  8%

  6%
                     4.1%                                                                3.8%
              3.7%          3.6%                                                                       3.4%
   3.1%
  4%                                                                                            3.0%
                     4.1%                                                   2.2%                              2.4%
              3.5%                                                                       3.7%
   3.0%
  2%                        3.3%
                                   0.9%                                                         2.6% 2.9%
                                                    0.2%                                                    1.9%
  0%                                                       -0.8%                    1.4%
                                   0.6%                                -1.3%
                                                  -0.3%
 -2%                                                               -3.0%    -1.4%
                                          -3.8%            -1.7%
 -4%
                                                                   -4.0%
 -6%
                                          -5.8%
                                            Spain                     Valencia
 -8%
    2004      2005   2006   2007   2008   2009      2010   2011    2012    2013   2014   2015   2016   2017   2018

Source: INE                                                                                                          6
The Valencian Community: Weaknesses

    Key macro figures below than national average
        GDP per capita: 12.8 pp gap as of 2018 (Spain: 100 vs Valencia: 87.2).
    Imbalances in the current regional financing system…
        It has led to continuous deviations in the deficit target.
        Uncertainty about the final outcome of the reform of the regional financing model,
        after the committee of experts report. The central government has announced a draft for next
        November
    … which partly led Valencia to be the region with the highest relative regional
    indebtedness
        In 1Q20, debt to GDP represented 42.2% of Valencia’s GDP (vs 24.1% for the average of
        Spanish regions).
        Brexit: higher exposure to UK relative to other Spanish regions
        Political uncertainty in Spain
        Parliamentary fragmentation.
        Global economic shock.
        Uncertainty about the intensity and duration of COVID-19 outbreak. The Eur 1.4bn non-
        refundable fund from Central Government would soften the negative impact of COVID-19

Source: INE, Conselleria de Hacienda y Modelo Económico and BBVA Research                         7
The Valencian Community in figures: Unemployment

    Reduction and finally reversion of the gap between Spanish and Valencian
    unemployment rate
    From 1.9% (average 2012-2014) to 0.6% (average 2015-1Q2020).Current gap: -0.02%
                                                                                     UNEMPLOYMENT RATE (Quartely, %)
                                                              Average Gap 2012- 2014                                                                                                                     Average Gap 2015-1Q2020
  %                                                                              +1.9%                                                                                                                                           +0.6%

  30%                              28.73%
                                                                       28.04%
    26.83%

                                   26.94%                                                                  24.28%
  25%                                                                  25.93%
    24.19%                                                                                                                                     21.84%
                                                                                                           23.78%
                                                                                                                                                                                   19.77%
  20%                                                                                                                                          21.00%
                                                                                                                                                                                                                       17.13%
                                                                                                                                                                                   18.75%
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            14.70%
                                                                                                                                                                                                                       16.74%                                                                  14.41%
  15%

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      14.11%                                   14.39%
                                                                                                            Spain                                                         Valencia
  10%
        Mar-12
                 Jun-12
                          Sep-12
                                   Dec-12
                                            Mar-13
                                                     Jun-13
                                                              Sep-13
                                                                       Dec-13
                                                                                Mar-14
                                                                                         Jun-14
                                                                                                  Sep-14
                                                                                                           Dec-14
                                                                                                                    Mar-15
                                                                                                                             Jun-15
                                                                                                                                      Sep-15
                                                                                                                                               Dec-15
                                                                                                                                                        Mar-16
                                                                                                                                                                 Jun-16
                                                                                                                                                                          Sep-16
                                                                                                                                                                                   Dec-16
                                                                                                                                                                                            Mar-17
                                                                                                                                                                                                     Jun-17
                                                                                                                                                                                                              Sep-17
                                                                                                                                                                                                                       Dec-17
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                Mar-18
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         Jun-18
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  Sep-18
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           Dec-18
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    Mar-19
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             Jun-19
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      Sep-19
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               Dec-19
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        Mar-20
Source: INE                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      8
The Valencian Community in figures: Exports

     Exports have increased by 54% since 2011, significantly above data for the whole
     country

                                        EXPORTS OF GOODS (Index, 2011 = 100)

Source: Ministerio de Industria, Comercio y Turismo and Conselleria de Hacienda y Modelo Económico   9
The Valencian Community in figures: Tourism

    2019 set a historical record in No. of tourists, both in Spain and Valencia (83.7 m and
    9.6 m)
        Valencian Community is ranked in the top 5 destinations in Spain
          TOURISTS (Index , 2011 = 100)                     GUESTS IN HOTELS (Index, 2011 = 100)

 Index (2011 = 100)                                       Index (2011 = 100)
                                                    179
180                                           172         180
                                                                    Foreign guests in Spain
                                        167
                                                                    Foreign guests in Valencia
160                                                       160       Domestic guests in Spain
                                  145                               Domestic guests in Valencia
                                                149
140                                     146 147           140

                            123 134
                      117
120            112                                        120
                            121
                      116
   100 100
100        108                                            100
   100 102

  80              Spain            Valencia                80

Source: INE                                                                                        10
Fiscal targets and budget
Fiscal targets

     National and Regional deficit

                                                    BUDGET BALANCE (% of GDP)

  % of GDP

     2%

     0%

                                                                                                         -0.79%                          -0.20%*
                                                                                                                       -1.41%
    -2%                                                                                     -1.55%                              -1.91%
                                                                                                                                         -1.80%
                                                      -2.25%
                                                                   -2.66%       -2.66%                             -2.53%
                                                                                                     -2.98%                 -2.82%
    -4%
                                         -3.89%                                          -4.09%
                -4.70%
                             -4.99%                                         -5.13%
    -6%
                                                               -5.78%
                                                  -6.71%
                                      -7.02%
    -8%

   -10% -9.60%           -9.41%

                                                        Total Spain                         Valencia
   -12%
               2010         2011         2012         2013        2014         2015         2016         2017        2018   2019 (A) 2020 (T)

Total Spain Deficit excludes support to the financial sector .* Global target pending distribution between CCAA.                              12
Source: Ministerio de Hacienda
Budget outturn: Revenues

Revenues                                                                                                         Var. 2019/2018    Var. 2019/2012
                          2012       2013       2014      2015       2016       2017       2018       2019
(€ m)                                                                                                             €m        %       €m        %
Direct taxes                 3,917     2,949     2,956     3,069      3,496      4,394      4,499      4,557         58      1%       640     16%

Indirect taxes               6,329     5,131     5,504     5,610      6,160      6,625      6,938      6,897         -41    -1%       568      9%
Fees, sales & other
                               631       569       596      677         857        685        765      1,048        283     37%       417     66%
revenues
Current transfers             -487     1,869     1,201     1,106      1,262      1,210      1,159      1,355        196     17%      1,842   378%

Property incomes                 9          9        42          6          3          8          7          5        -2   -29%         -4   -44%

Current revenues           10,399    10.527     10,299 10,468        11,778     12,922     13,368     13,862        494      4%     3,463     33%
Disposal of real
                                 1          1        57          0          0          1          0          0        0    -100%        -1   -100%
investments
Capital transfers              204       248       139      103         235         88        101        277        176     15%        73     36%

Capital revenues              205        249       196      103        235         89        101        277         176    174%        72     35%
Non-financial
                           10,604    10,776     10,495 10,571        12,013     13,011     13,469     14,139        670      4%     3,535     33%
revenues

Source: Ministerio de Hacienda and Conselleria de Hacienda y Modelo Económico                                                                  13
Budget outturn: Expenditure

Expenditure                                                                                                Var. 2019/2018      Var. 2019/2012
                          2012       2013      2014      2015     2016          2017     2018     2019
(€ m)                                                                                                       €m        %         €m         %

Personnel expenses           4,647     4,750     4,900    5,222      5,342       5.438    5,795    6,190      395         7%     1,543      33%
Purchase goods &
                             4,523     3,207     3,897    4,024      3,463       3.457    3,636    3,663         27       1%      -860     -19%
services
Financial expenses             957     1,184     1,229      658       351          467      458      625      167     36%         -332     -35%

Current transfers            3,519     3,327     3,098    3,627      3,854       4.265    4,693    5,073      380         8%     1,554      44%

Current expenditure        13,646    12,468     13,124 13,531      13,010       13.627   14,582   15,551      969         7%    1,905      14%

Real investment                512       370       410      352       301          369      391      437         46   12%            -75   -15%

Capital transfers              870       822       830      431       269          418      397      498      101     25%         -372     -43%

Capital expenditure         1,382      1,192     1,240      783       570         787      788      935       147     19%        -447      -32%

Non financial
                           15,028    13,660     14,364 14,314      13,580       14.414   15,370   16,486    1,116         7%    1,458      10%
expenditure

Source: Ministerio de Hacienda and Conselleria de Hacienda y Modelo Económico                                                                  14
Budget result in 2019

    During 2019 current revenues have grown by 4%

       Boosted by the increase in Current Transfers 17% (€ 196 m).

       Fees, sales & other revenues increase by 19% (€ 143 m) (*).

       Direct tax increase by 1% (€ 58 m) and Indirect Taxes decrease 1% (€ 41) due to the change
       of VAT's settlement.

    Current expenditure has increased by 7%

       Current transfers increase by 8% (€ 380 m).
       Personnel expenses increase by 7% (€ 395 m).
       Financial expenses increases by 6% (€27) (*).
    The 2012 -2019 budget figures evolution shows
       Sustained improvement of the current balance over the period 2012 – 2018. From € -3,247
       million to € -1,214 million. But in 2019 it has worsened to € -1,689
    2019 ESA’s Deficit-to-GDP deficit 1.91% is very far from the target of 0.1%
       If around € 1.000 million underfunding in the regional financing system would have been
       corrected the ratio would have been reduced to 0.9% .

(*) Excluded one-off impact of € 140 m, compensated in both sides, revenues and expenditure.        15
Budget: Breakdown by type

                                                                     REVENUES

                   Capital          Property
                  transfers         incomes
                    2.0%              0.0%
  Current
  transfers
                                                     Direct taxes
  9.6%
                                                        32.2%
                                                                                                            Modifiable
                                                                                     Non                      Tax
                                                                                   Modifiable                60.0%
 Fees, sales &                                                                       Tax
 other revenues                                                                     40.0%
 7.4%

                                               Indirect taxes
                                                   48.8%

                                                                    EXPENDITURES
                                                                                          Capital
                  Real investment                                                       expenditure
       Capital          2.7%                                                               5.7%
      transfers
        3.0%                                         Personnel
                                                     expenses
                                                     37.5%

 Current
 transfers
 30.8%
                                                Purchase goods &
                                                services
                                                22.2%                                                   Current
     Financial expenses                                                                               expenditure
     3.8%                                                                                               94.3%

Source: Ministerio de Hacienda and Conselleria de Hacienda y Modelo Económico                                            16
Analysis of the region’s expenditures and revenues

    The Valencian Region public spending has been below the average Spanish regions…

                     Regional Public Expenditure. Average 2003-2019(€ per inhabitant )

                        Navarra                                                                                 4,601
                     País Vasco                                                                             4,291
                      Cantabria                                                                          4,032
                  Extremadura                                                                         3,797
                       La Rioja                                                                      3,746
                       Cataluña                                                                      3,695
                       Asturias                                                                     3,661
                        Aragón                                                                     3,574
                Castilla y León                                                                   3,493
                         Galicia                                                                  3,462
              Average Regions                                                                    3,381
            Castilla-La Mancha                                                                  3,353
                                                                                                            Gap 2003-2019
Avge. Regions Common Regime                                                                     3,318
                                                                                                             -€210(-6%)
                         Murcia                                                                3,228
                       Valencia                                                               3,171
                      Andalucía                                                              3,085
                       Baleares                                                              3,078
                         Madrid                                                             3,040
                       Canarias                                                             2,988
                                             0            1,000          2,000          3,000       4,000       5,000       6,000

  Source: FEDEA, ‘Las finanzas autonómicas en 2019 y entre 2003 y 2019, by Ángel de la Fuente .                                     17
  Conselleria de Hacienda y Modelo Económico.
Analysis of the region’s expenditures and revenues

    … and also in 2019

                                 Regional Public Expenditure. 2019(€ per inhabitant )

                        Navarra                                                                                      4,827
                     País Vasco                                                                                     4,711
                      Cantabria                                                                               4,134
                  Extremadura                                                                               3,977
                       La Rioja                                                                            3,899
                       Asturias                                                                           3,823
                        Aragón                                                                           3,771
                       Cataluña                                                                          3,762
                Castilla y León                                                                        3,630
                         Galicia                                                                      3,562
              Average Regions                                                                        3,483
Avge. Regions Common Regime                                                                         3,401
                                                                                                                  Gap 2019
                         Murcia                                                                     3,399        -€99 (-3%)
            Castilla-La Mancha                                                                      3,384
                       Valencia                                                                     3,384
                       Baleares                                                                    3,276
                         Madrid                                                                  3,151
                       Canarias                                                                 3,063
                      Andalucía                                                                 3,022
                                              0            1,000          2,000          3,000         4,000        5,000     6,000

Source: FEDEA, ‘Las finanzas autonómicas en 2019 y entre 2003 y 2019’, by Ángel de la Fuente.
 Conselleria de Hacienda y Modelo Económico                                                                                           18
Analysis of the region’s expenditures and revenues

   Valencian Region has been the worst financed during the period 2002-2017

Adjusted financing per-capita post equalization transfers. Average 2002- 2017(Spain = 100)

                                                                                                                               Gap 2002-2017
                                                                                                                                    7,5%

                                                                                                                                              19
 Source: FEDEA, La evolución de la financiación de las CCAA de régimen común 2002-2016’, and La liquidación del 2017 del Sistema de financiación de las
 CCAA de regimen común ; by Ángel de la Fuente
  Conselleria de Hacienda y Modelo Económico.
Analysis of the region’s expenditures and revenues

    … and it has been also the worst financed in 2017

             Adjusted financing per-capita post equalisation transfers. 2017(Spain = 100)

                                                                                                                             Gap 2017
                                                                                                                              7.8%

Source: FEDEA, ‘La liquidación del 2017 del Sistema de financiación de las CCAA de regimen común ’, by Ángel de la Fuente.              20
Institutional Framework
Institutional Framework

     Spain has been a Quasi-federal State since 1978

     The Spanish Government Administration has the following levels:
 1)Central Government
 2)17 autonomous communities
                                                                                 AUTONOMOUS COMMUNITIES
 3)50 provinces                                                                Public expenditure by areas (2018)
 4)and 8,000 plus municipalities

     The autonomous communities are mainly
     responsible for:
     Healthcare
     Education and Universities
     Environment
     Infrastructures
     Social Services
     Employment
     Economic Activities

     Public expenditure at the autonomous community level represents around 36% of total Spanish
     public expenditure

Source: Ministerio de Hacienda. Data of 2018 regarding to National Accounts.                                        22
Responsibilities of the European Regions

                           Spain           Germany     Austria   Belgium              Italy             France
                                                                           Ordinary           Special
                                                                            Status            Status

    Education                                                                                           (second.)
    Healthcare                                   (p)                (p)
    Transport

     Economy

      Justice

   Universities

       Police

 Infrastructures

   Environment

      Housing

  Local entities

      Culture

      Tourism

   Employment

 Social Services

Source: Conselleria de Hacienda y Modelo Económico                                                             23
Supervision Framework

A. Regional debt sustainability and management
  Debt is approved by the Valencian annual budget law
  Issuance of long term debt must be authorized by the central government’s Consejo de Ministros
  Stability and Budgetary General Law
  Autonomous Communities Financial Law (LOFCA):
  Debt burden can not exceed 25% of operative revenues ⇒ The rule does not apply until 2020.
  Funds must be spent on financing public works (real investments) ⇒ The rule does not apply until 2020.

B. Institutional support from the central administration

  1. Revenues
  Equalisation of the 75% regional taxes through the Guarantee of Basic Public Services Fund (GBPSF), according to
  adjusted population
  Revenues are less dependant from regional economic cycle
  The model penalises the tax rate reduction policies
  Global Sufficiency Fund (GSF) is an additional equalisation fund. Ensures that under the new financing frameworks
  no CC.AA.’s can receive less funds – status quo-; Competitivity Fund is used to reduce the deviation of financing per
  capita; Cooperation Fund for Autonomous Communities where the level of GDP per capita is lower than average

  2. Expenditure
  Increasing annual population is updated yearly for increasing the public resources
  Central Government guarantees a minimum level of provision of public services (healthcare, education and social
  services) by law (Art. 15 LOFCA)
  Central Government ensures that CC.AA.’s resources are enough for its responsibilities

                                                                                                                     24
Financing System for Spanish Regions

  Revenues

  Full responsibility (‘cupo’ system): Basque Country and Navarre

  The remaining Autonomous Communities have partial substantial responsibilities on revenues:
   – 50% Income Tax
   – 50% Value Added Tax (VAT)
   – 58% Special Taxes (alcohol, tobacco and gasoline)
   – 100% Electricity Taxes
   – 100% Inheritance Tax
   – 100% Stamp Duty
   – 100% Gambling Tax
   – Other Taxes and Duties

                                                                                                25
Financing System for Spanish Regions

   Regional
  resources                                        For each region                 Non-Socialised Funding

  Income tax        50%
                             25%
      VAT           50%
                                             Guarantee Fund for
                                            Fundamental Services                     Socialised Funding:
  State taxes       58%
                                             (education, health and
                                                social services)                    Divided amongst regions
   Electricity     100%      75%                                                   according to their adjusted
                                                        75% of                     population which takes into
    Property       100%                            regions’ revenues                account the dependency
  transfer tax                                             +                                 ratios.
                                                    State transfers
  Stamp duty
  Inheritance
      tax
                       Average contribution = 8%
                       of regional financing.
                                                                                                           Competitivity Fund
                                                                       Convergence Funds
 Central State                                                                                              Cooperation Fund
  Resources
                                                                       Sufficiency Funds

                        Current financing system should have been reviewed in 2014

Source: AFI and Ministerio de Hacienda                                                                                      26
National legal framework

  Spanish Constitution reform: New debt ceiling and stability budget principle law
  Approved by almost absolute majority of the Parliament, it sets both debt and deficit limits for all
  government levels, including regional and local
  Art. 135: ‘Financial burden payments are priority’ ⇒ Interest and public debt payments have
  priority over any other expenditure
  It came into force on 27th Sep 2011

  Spanish Law on Budgetary and Financial Sustainability of Public Administration
  It leaves no room for doubt: fiscal consolidation is a must
  Implements Article 135 of the Spanish Constitution

                                                  Key Points

   Structural Balance   0%. Exceptions must be approved by a majority in Parliament

                        60% of GDP or EU target: 44% for central government, 13% for regional government
   Public Debt
                        and 3% for local authorities

                        These limits will not come into force until 2020 (for all public administrations)
   Application
                        Until then, there will be a phase-in period

                        Medium term GDP growth reference rate
   Expenditure Rule
                        (according to EC methodology and published in an economic situation report)

   Budgets              Budgetary framework medium term (minimum 3 years)

                                                                                                            27
National legal framework

    Reforms are quite in line with other carried out by our European peers

    German legislation states that revenues and expenditure must be balanced, in principle, without
    recourse to credit, but this rule is applied differently to the Federal Government and the Landers

                                 Spanish constitution                              German constitution

 Central government       Max. structural deficit: 0.26% of GDP           Max. structural deficit: 0.35% of GDP

                                                                          Zero deficit
 Regional government      Max. structural deficit: 0.14% of GDP
                                                                          Debt can only be taken on for amortization

                          Natural disasters, recession or extraordinary   Natural disasters, recession or extraordinary
                          emergency situations beyond the State           emergency situations which considerably
 Exceptions to the        control                                         worsen the State’s financial situation
 limits
                          Exceptions must be approved by a majority in Requires a majority motion from the
                          Parliament                                   members of the Bundestag

                                                                          Law already in force for the central
                          Limits will not come into force until 2020      government (since 1st Jan 2016)
 Application
                          for all public administrations                  For Landers it will be applied from 1st Jan
                                                                          2020

                                                                          Potential access to aid for fiscal consolidation
 Special aid to regions
                                                                          for five regions in exchange of their
 with difficulties in     For the time being, no such aid is forecasted
                                                                          commitment to meeting certain targets
 fiscal consolidation
                                                                          during the transitional period

Source: BBVA Research                                                                                                   28
National legal framework

  Under the following framework, Central Government guarantees regional budgetary and
  debt discipline

                     Fiscal objectives established by Central Government
                     Regional Economic and Financial Plans (EFP) to be approved by
   Preventive        Central government
   Mechanisms
                     Budgetary and debt control
                     Non compliance risk warning: 1 month to adopt new measures

                     Automatic corrective measures
                     Authorization for all debt operations (long term only following EFP
    Corrective       approval)
   Mechanisms        Preliminary report from Ministry of Treasury for any subsidy or
                     agreements
                     Rebalancing Plans

                      Causes: No EFP submitted, not approved, no compliance EFP
                      Measures:
   Enforcement
    Measures          15 day adoption of a plan to cut expenditure
                      Possible exercise of regulatory authority on taxes granted by central
                      government

                                                                                              29
Financial Situation
Generalitat Valenciana: Ratings

    RATINGS

                                      Long Term                    Short Term

    Moody’s (Feb’20)              Ba1 (Stable outlook)                  NP

    S&P (May’20)                   BB (Stable outlook)                   B

    Fitch (Apr’20)                BBB- (Stable outlook)                 F3

    OTHER FEATURES

      Management through a special agency until August 2018⇒ Institut Valencià de Finances. After Decree
      119/2018, debt management falls under the “Conselleria de Hacienda y Modelo Económico” responsibility.

      Funding until 2011 was done in international capital markets ⇒ EMTN and ECP

      Since Dec’15 the EUR marketable debt instruments issued by regional and local governments located in the
      Euro area have been eligible for regular PSPP purchases (no primary purchases), as long as they meet
      the other conditions of eligibility, including a minimum rating

      Spanish regions enjoy the same regulatory treatment as sovereigns for banks and insurance
      companies:
      0% risk weighted and Level 1 LCR (0% haircut) for banks under Basel III and CRD IV
      0% capital charges for insurance companies under Solvency II
      Also eligible under Eurosystem haircut category II, similar to that supranational debt
.

                                                                                                           31
Generalitat Valenciana: Total Debt (ESA 2010)

                MAIN FIGURES (1Q20)                       BREAKDOWN BY TYPE

                                                              Bonds
 DEBT DISTRIBUTION                       €m             PPP
                                                               1%     Short Term loans
                                                        1%
                                                LT Loans                     2%
 General Administration               46,955   (Financial
                                                Entities)
 Other entities included in the                   12%
                                       1,203
 Public Administration Sector
                                                                        LT Loans (Central
 Total debt (1Q20)                    48,158                            Gvt' Mechanisms)
                                                                              84%

 Debt / GDP (1Q20)                    42.2%

Source: Banco de España                                                                  32
Funding Support Mechanisms from Central Government

 Regional Liquidity Fund (FLA)
 Since 2012, it has guaranteed financial aid until Autonomous Regions regain access to financial markets
 It has been replaced by the Fund for the Financing of Spanish Regions (FFSR)

 Fund for the Financing of Spanish Regions (FFSR)
 Created by RD 17/2014, it centralises all liquidity support from central government to regions
 Intention of central government to recentralise the funding of Spanish regions and increase the monitoring.
 There is no ‘temporary’ mention in the definition, reinforcing the idea of permanence
 4 different layouts:

                            Target: previous non-FLA regions and current FLA regions which fulfil the goals of
     FINANCIAL              budget stability, public debt and average payment period to suppliers
      FACILITY
                            Non ex-ante rebalancing plan is requested

     LIQUIDITY              Target: regions which do not meet the condition on average payment period to
       FUND                 suppliers

       SOCIAL               Optional format that allowed Spanish regions to refinance their pending debt with
        FUND                municipalities up to 31 December 2014

     SUPPLIER               Same purpose as the previous one
     PAYMENTS
                            Legally terminated from 1 January 2015
       FUND

                                                                                                                 33
Funding Support Mechanisms from Central Government

  Fund for the Financing of Spanish Regions (FFSR)
  The Financing Facility and the Liquidity Fund have similar funding goals
  Cash requirements due to:
        i)    Bonds maturities
        ii)   Long Term Loans maturities
              Funding needs derived from regional deficits
              The 2008/2009 financing System negative liquidation repayments
              Other financial operations approved by the central government
  Spanish regions are returning progressively to markets. CDGAE has authorized the return to the market of
 those regions that are under the Financial Facility Fund.

  Pros:
              Liquidity and funding support to regions during critical episodes
              Extremely low financing costs
              Reduction in the average payment time to suppliers

  Cons:
        i)    Loss of financial autonomy
        ii)   Loss of access to capital markets

Source: BBVA Research and Conselleria de Hacienda y Modelo Económico                                     34
Funding Support Mechanisms from Central Government

     Several mechanisms have been instrumented since 2012…

                                           FLA and Social Fund                                    Suppliers Payment Fund
                               Disbursed                Cost          Outstanding     Disbursed             Cost            Outstanding

           2012                   3,830               5.130%                  1,527     4,351        Euribor 3 m +525 pb       1,581

                                                                                         70          Euribor 3 m +395 pb        35
           2013                   3,119               3.820%                  1,170
                                                                                        931                3.34%               266

           2014                   6,057               2.097%                  3,786     2,221              3.34%               1,110

           2015                   8,760               0.834%                  5,475

           2016                   6,968               0.475%                  5,226

           2017                   5,409               0.840%                  5,409

           2018                   5,828               0.861%                  5,828

           2019                   6,783               0.511%                  6,783

           2020                   3,179               0.320%                  3,179

           Total                 49,933                                   38,383       7,573                                  2,992

  TOTAL OUTSTANDING                                                                                                41,375

     All mechanisms improved in 2015 their financial conditions to 0.834%

     Estimated 2020 FLA loan amount: € 8,441 m.
Data for cost stand for interest rate initial conditions. Data in € m and %                                                            35
Source: Conselleria de Hacienda y Modelo Económico, as of 31 May 2020
Funding Support Mechanisms from Central Government

    Significant cost savings thanks to the central government strong support

                                                     ESTIMATION OF SAVINGS

 €m                                   2014 (A) 2015 (A) 2016 (A) 2017 (A) 2018 (A) 2019 (A*) 2020 (B)

 Financial expenses                     1,229             658       351   467   458   485      485

 Savings related to
                                            -             571       878   762   771   744      744
 2014

(A) Actual / (B) Budget / (A*) Excluded one-off impact of € 140 m                                 36
Source: Conselleria de Hacienda y Modelo Económico
Debt Market Approach and Financing

                                   FUNDING STRATEGY (General Administration)

 €m                                                                                      2020                 2021                 2022

 Redemptions (Securities and Long term loans)                                          5,844.4              6,551.5               7,114.5

 Net Issuance Medium–Long term*                                                        2,407.8                 210.4                 91.2

 Gross Issuance Medium-Long Term                                                       8,252.2              6,761.9              7,205.7

*Net Issuance Medium-Long term, includes target deficit 0,2% GDP approved by the Central Government, deviation deficit 2019 and and the
2008-2009 regional financing system negative liquidation.                                                                                   37
Source: Conselleria de Hacienda y Modelo Económico, as of 31 December 2019
Debt Market Approach and Financing

     Improvement in current Debt Maturity profile thanks to the Central Government funding
     support

           GENERALITAT VALENCIANA DEBT: MATURITY PROFILE (General Administration)

  €m

 8,000
            7,229                7,115
 7,000                6,552                 6,631

 6,000
                                                       5,454

 5,000                                                            4,521

 4,000                                                                       3,468

 3,000                                                                               2,588

 2,000                                                                                       1,811
                                                                                                     1,084
 1,000
                                                                                                                    406
                                                                                                             98
       0
             2020      2021       2022       2023       2024       2025      2026    2027    2028    2029    2030   +2030

Source: Conselleria de Hacienda y Modelo Económico, as of 31 December 2019                                                  38
Debt Cost and Debt Average Life

     Reduction in Debt cost

                        GENERALITAT VALENCIANA: COST AND AVERAGE LIFE DEBT

  % / years

 6

                                                     5.12
 5                                                          4.58   4.70
                                             4.37                          4.45
                                    4.11             4.21                         4.21
       3.88               4.02                                     3.98
                3.87                                                                      3.91
 4
                                                            4.09
       3.65     3.73                                                                             3.75   3.76   3.62
 3                        3.30      3.22

 2                                           2.39

                                                                            0.80 0.96     0.96   0.92   0.88   0.80
 1

                                               Debt Cost (%)       Average life (years)
 0
       2007     2008      2009      2010     2011    2012   2013   2014    2015   2016    2017   2018   2019 1Q2020

Source: Conselleria de Hacienda y Modelo Económico                                                                    39
Secondary Market Spread

     Since 2012, secondary spreads of Valencian debt have decreased sharply

                             SECONDARY MARKET SPREAD ON SWAP (2001–2020)

*Data correspond to monthly averages.                                         40
Source: Bloomberg and Conselleria de Hacienda y Modelo Económico
Disclaimer

 This presentation has been prepared by Generalitat Valenciana

 This presentation does not constitute an offer or invitation by (or on behalf of) Generalitat Valenciana to subscribe or purchase any
 notes issued by Generalitat Valenciana

 This presentation is not intended to provide any valuation of the financial situation of Generalitat Valenciana nor any valuation of
 the notes issued by Generalitat Valenciana and not be considered as a recommendation to purchase notes made by Generalitat
 Valenciana. Each recipient of this presentation shall independently judge of the relevance of the information contained herein, shall
 make its own independent assessment and determine whether to participate in the transaction on researches and shall consult its
 own advisors as to legal, tax or other aspects, as it deems necessary

 This presentation should not be reproduced, distributed or transmitted to any other person nor published in whole or in part,
 including by e-mail, on the internet, intranet or otherwise

                                                                                                                                  41
You can also read