Issue 10 The Urban Wildlife Edition September - October 2018 - The Endangered ...

Page created by Barry Thomas
 
CONTINUE READING
Issue 10 The Urban Wildlife Edition September - October 2018 - The Endangered ...
Issue 10
                                                              The Urban Wildlife Edition
                                                              September - October 2018

Conservation Matters - Issue 10: The Urban Wildlife Edition                            1
Issue 10 The Urban Wildlife Edition September - October 2018 - The Endangered ...
A WORD FROM THE CEO                                               2         Showcasing our supporters: Annual support from Assore
                                                                            Limited                                               35

NOTICEBOARD
                                                                            Meet the pack                                        35
•    Events                                                       3
                                                                            •     Emily Taylor
                                                                            •     Boaz Tsebe
FEATURES                                                                    •     Shumani Makwarela
•    The birds of Delta Park – observing changes over more
     than 40 years                                                4         Ways to give: Every swipe counts!                    37
•    Creating owl-friendly children                               7
                                                                  8                                                              38
•    Wildlife-friendly gardening – a return to nature                       Pups’ place
Showcasing our supporters: Celebrating an anniversary with                  e-SHOP                                               39
Signature Lux by Onomo                                            11
                                                                            In closing: Mwitu’s missive                          41
•    There’s a bat in my kitchen, what should I do?               11
•    Green spaces                                                 15
•    Shark mystery: Where have South Africa’s Great Whites
     gone?                                                        17
•    Win! Wildlife on your doorstep photography and
     drawing competition                                          20

Ways to give: A will to preserve our true wilderness areas        21

TAILS FROM THE FIELD
•    Farm planning: on the path to sustainable land
     management                                                   22
•    Making the most of a tough situation                         23
•    Wildlife and Energy training project spreads wings to
     Lesotho                                                      24
•    Opening the door to a world of knowledge                     24
•    Oil and gas development and its implication on Grey
     Crowned Cranes and wetlands                                  26

Showcasing our supporters: Q20 supports carnivore
conservation                                                      27

Green heroes
•    Giving hope to wildlife                                      28

Ways to give: Donating is now as easy as snapping your
fingers… or your phone!                                           29

Walking the talk
•    Greening an urban environment                                29

Science snippets
•    Big data for biodiversity                                    30
•    A safe haven for Wild Dogs near Kruger National Park         30

Showcasing our supporters: Leasing this property will lead to
R10,000 for the EWT                                               31

Wildlife fact file                                                31
•          Giant Bullfrog
•          Barn Owl
•          African Grass Owl
•          Spotted Eagle Owl
•          Large-spotted Genet
•          Brown House Snake/Common House Snake

                                    Physical Address: Building K2, Ardeer Road, Pinelands Office Park,
           Modderfontein 1609, Gauteng, South Africa, Postal Address: Private Bag X 11, Modderfontein 1645, Gauteng, South Africa
                                          Tel: +27 (0) 11 372 3600 Fax: +27 (0) 11 608 4682 NPO

1                                             Conservation Matters - Issue 10: The Urban Wildlife Edition
Issue 10 The Urban Wildlife Edition September - October 2018 - The Endangered ...
Among the many issues and perspectives that serve to fragment the               THIS is what the Constitution of South Africa, in Section 24 actually
conservation sector, rather than unite it, perhaps the greatest is the          says:
concept of ‘Sustainable Use,’ and where one positions yourself or your          Section 24 - Everyone has the right –
organisation along this rather long and winding spectrum. From the                    a) To an environment that is not harmful to their health or well-
one extreme, which says that humans cannot use any element of our                     being; and
natural world for their benefit at all, to the other end, which claims                b) To have the environment protected, for the benefit of
that full exploitation of nature and all its components is a human right              present and future generations, through reasonable legislative
no matter the form this use may take, or its impacts on nature going                  and other measures that –
forward.                                                                              i.   prevent pollution and ecological degradation;
                                                                                      ii. promote conservation; and
Thankfully, most conservation organisations in South Africa sit                       iii. secure ecologically sustainable development and use of
somewhere far from the edges of these extreme views, and this helps                   natural resources while promoting justifiable economic and social
to maintain a balance on most platforms. The EWT firmly believes in                   development.
the use of nature to the benefit of ALL species, humans included, so
essentially we stand FOR the concept of Sustainable Use. The trouble

is not with the principle, but rather, in our view, how it is being adapted     What’s so fantastic about this Constitution of ours is that it not only
to suit the needs of a small but increasingly influential pool of ‘special      affords humans the right to a clean and healthy environment, but that
interest’ groups that stand to benefit from use that is sustainable only        this applies to future generations: those not even born yet! This right,
insofar as it can be sustained, and not for the persistence of a healthy        it states, will be realised through conservation (first and foremost) and
environment for all other creatures.                                            then the “ecologically sustainable development and use of natural
                                                                                resources”. It is quite clear that the application of sustainability (or
In 1992, the World Bank stated that their interpretation of the term            persistence if you will) is in relation to the environment and not its
Sustainable Development was “… development that lasts”. With no                 use. Simply put, the environment must be sustainable, not just our
reference to the environment being the entity that should in fact last,         use thereof.
which is more to the heart of what the Rio Convention (at which the
term gained global traction) undoubtedly meant. Ironically, nearly              Therefore, seeing as the Endangered Wildlife Trust so firmly believes
30 years later, we see some sectors of society interpreting the term            in the power of this true environmental right and the ability of our
Sustainable Use in much the same way. And you argue with them at                natural resources to sustainably and equitably transform and uplift
your peril, for the very first thing they like to quote is the South African    human lives, we are driving a process to re-examine the narrative
Constitution which allegedly enshrines the right of all people to use           around sustainable use (as it is currently being interpreted). A better
natural resources in any way that they like. The trouble is, it doesn’t.        interpretation of the Constitutional Right, we would argue, would be
                                                                                to truncate section 24(b)iii to be simply SUSTAINABLE CONSERVATION

                                                 Conservation Matters - Issue 10: The Urban Wildlife Edition                                            2
Issue 10 The Urban Wildlife Edition September - October 2018 - The Endangered ...
in which “ecologically sustainable” is positioned appropriately                Sustainable Conservation exists when the conservation of biodiversity,
alongside environmental use.                                                   with all its various wildlife components existing naturally in a
                                                                               functioning ecosystem, becomes the driving factor. Ecological
In short, the EWT:                                                             sustainability requires functioning systems and balance and we hold
     1. Holds that sustainable use as is sometimes applied in South            that this underpins the environmental right in our Constitution.
           Africa is currently NOT in line with the spirit or even the
           language, of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa;      To achieve Sustainable Conservation, various forms of both
     2. Has become increasingly concerned with the narrow and                  consumptive and non-consumptive use can and should be employed
           misguided approach to sustainable use currently being taken         as a means of sustaining the system, and ensuring equitable benefit
           in some quarters, leading to industry-scale abuses based            sharing for those who contribute to, are impacted on, or who co-exist
           on the use of a single entity with no value to the broader          as part of these systems. The use of nature in a balanced, holistic and
           ecological or social systems; and instead                           equitable manner is indeed the way in which humans realise their
     3. Supports and promotes sustainable conservation as follows:             environmental right. This would be to the benefit of the “everyone”
                                                                               to which our Constitution refers, including those generations not yet
Sustainable Conservation embodies the true spirit of the environmental         born. Above all, the conservation of our natural world remains central
rights of all people in South Africa – ensuring that the point of departure    to any use thereof, for without these systems, there is no future.
in any decision, policy or system is that the environment (as a complete
and holistic system) is protected for the benefit of present and future        Yolan Friedmann
generations.                                                                   EWT CEO
                                                                               YolanF@ewt.org.za

                                                            1 October:
                                                           World Habitat                                        13 October:
                                                                Day                                            Migratory Bird
                                                                                                                    Day

                        21 November:
                       World Fisheries                                                    4 October:
                             Day                                                         World Animal
                                                                                              Day

          EWT Events
         24 October: Country Club Johannesburg Talk – Book launch: The Game ranger, the knife, the lion
         and the sheep – David Bristow, in conversation with Dr Harriet Davies-Mostert. For more information,
         contact RebeccaM@ewt.org.za
         12 – 16 November: Raptor Research Foundation 2018 Annual Conference, Skukuza, Kruger National
         Park. For more information, contact AndreB@ewt.org.za

3                                               Conservation Matters - Issue 10: The Urban Wildlife Edition
Issue 10 The Urban Wildlife Edition September - October 2018 - The Endangered ...
walk around the sanctuary, and also where I gave my first public bird
                                                                            talk to WBC members. It is no exaggeration to say that “I cut my birding
                                                                            teeth” in the park.

                                                                            On 10 December, 1981, Cynthia and I moved in to the flat in the Delta
                                                                            Environmental Centre, and Delta Park became my “garden”, birding
                                                                            patch and study area. I can still remember looking out the window
                                                                            on that first day in our new home and seeing a male Eurasian Golden
Geoff Lockwood, Resident Manager of the Delta Environmental                 Oriole moving through the trees around the main sanctuary dam.
Centre                                                                      The 37 years since then have brought a succession of amazing bird
geofrey@iafrica.com                                                         sightings, and have allowed me to document the changes in the local
                                                                            urban bird population – initially through submissions to the first
My first memory of what is now Delta Park dates back to 1964, when          Southern African Bird Atlas Project (SABAP 1) and, currently, to SABAP
I was attacked and repeatedly stung by a colony of paper wasps that         2. Since January 2002, 234 species have been recorded in Delta Park,
I had disturbed whilst clambering over a dry-stone walled kraal on          with a further 29 species having been recorded historically, but not
the property. I was back a few times during the early 1970s, dodging        again since the start of the intensive survey in 2002.
security to bird in what was then being developed as the Florence
Bloom Bird Sanctuary, and then later when I joined the monthly              Being based in the park has also allowed me to undertake a long-
outings of the Witwatersrand Bird Club (WBC) held on the third              term study of aspects of the biology, diet, breeding, longevity and
Saturday afternoon each month. It was here that I guided my first bird      post-fledging dispersal of the family of Spotted Eagle Owls that have
                                                                            nested in the park for over 40 years. Initially they nested in the bird
                                                                            sanctuary, using a succession of old Hamerkop nests, but a run of bad
                                                                            luck involving hailstorms and collapsing nests meant that they only
                                                                            fledged a total of three chicks in five years. After building a nest box
                                                                            for them on the back of the tower of the Centre in 1986, their breeding
                                                                            success improved dramatically and they have reared an average of just
                                                                            under three chicks per year since then. Unfortunately we have seen
                                                                                                               a radical increase in the numbers
                                                                                                               of Pied Crows in Gauteng in recent
                                                                                                               years, with counts of over 40 birds
                                                                                                               in Delta Park in recently. The crows
                                                                                                               have been relentless, harassing the
                                                                                                               owls at every turn, and in 2017,
                                                                                                               the pair failed to breed for the first
                                                                                                               time. A similar story is unfolding this
                                                                                                               season. The owls were copulating
                                                                                                               and visiting the box each evening
                                                                                                               a week ago and egg-laying seemed
                                                                                                               imminent but the crows have driven
                                                                                                               the adults off again.

                                                                                                                It is not just the owls that are being
                                                                                                                impacted by the increase in the
                                                                                                                crow population. They regularly
                                                                                                                also harass all the raptors species
                                                                                                                as well as Egyptian Geese and
                                                                                                                even dogs in the park. They are
                                                                                                                particularly effective and efficient
                                                                                                                nest predators and, if their numbers
                                                                                                                continue to increase, could have a
                                                                                                                significant negative impact on the
                                                                                                                breeding success of many of our
                                                                                                                urban species. For this reason I
                                                                                                                would appreciate any information
                                                                                                                regarding the Pied Crow population
                                                                            in the greater Johannesburg area – behaviour, numbers, population
                                                                            trends, diet, interactions with other bird species etc. so that we can try
                                                                            and determine what is driving this increase, and what the impacts on
                                                                            other species are likely to be. Once we fully understand the nature and
                                                                            causes of the problem, it may be possible to manage it.

                                                                            Part of my bird ‘work’ in Delta Park has involved the ringing of over
                                                                            3,000 birds of over 50 species. In most cases, I hear nothing further
                                                                            after I release the bird, but there have been exceptions. Over the years,
                                                                            I have recovered rings from nine of the Southern Masked Weavers that
                                                                            I had ringed in the park from Spotted Eagle Owl pellets – along with
                                                                            the ring of yet another weaver, and also of a Cape White-eye (both
                                                                            ringed by another ringer about 4 kms from the park). Another of ‘my’
                                                                            ringed weavers was killed by a cat in Vanderbijlpark – 90 kms from
                                                                            Delta Park. My most amazing ringing experience however has been

                                             Conservation Matters - Issue 10: The Urban Wildlife Edition                                             4
Issue 10 The Urban Wildlife Edition September - October 2018 - The Endangered ...
my relationship with “red over metal”. On 25 May 2000, a female Cape
                                   Robin Chat found her way into the Centre building and, before releasing
                                   her, I fitted a numbered metal SAFRING ring. Twenty-one days later she
                                   was back in the building – and I decided to add a red plastic ring above
                                   the metal one so that I could identify her at a distance and keep track
                                   of how long she stayed around. I wasn’t expecting anything, but 18
                                   years and nearly two months later she is still around the Centre! After
                                   hundreds of re-sightings, and after re-trapping her four times over the
                                   years, I now start most mornings trying to check if she is still around. I
                                   get anxious if I don’t see her for a few days…and then she is back again
                                   and I can relax. She is already more than 18 months older than the
                                   previous longevity record-holder and pushes that record still further
                                   with every sighting! We have come a long way together!

                                   Throughout my involvement with the park, there have been changes
                                   in its birdlife. Some species have disappeared, whilst others have
                                   appeared, established themselves, and are now common. There has
                                   also been a regular stream of vagrants and new species continue pop
                                   up regularly, the most recent being a Grey-headed Bush Shrike feeding
                                   around the entrance to the Centre on 7 July 2018.

                                   During the late 1970s, towards the end of a protracted drought,
                                   White-backed Mousebirds were regular in the park and surrounding
                                   suburbs. The drought broke – and my last record of this typically arid
                                   western species in the area was in 1981. Now only Speckled and Red-
                                   faced Mousebirds occur.

                                   In other cases where we have lost a species, a closely-related species
                                   seems to have supplanted the original one – raising questions as to
                                   what had changed environmentally so as to favour the colonising
                                   species. Perhaps the best example of this has been the demise of Cape
                                   Weavers in Delta Park – and the rise of Thick-billed Weavers over the
                                   same period. Between 2002 and 2007, Cape Weavers were breeding
                                   residents in the park, with an initial population of around 25 birds but
                                   in 2006, the population began to contract, and my last record of this
                                   species in the park was in September 2009. By contrast, Thick-billed
                                   Weavers were recorded only as sporadic visitors between 2002 and
                                   2007 but their numbers have since steadily increased to the point
                                   where over 60 now breed in the park and we regularly see flocks of
                                   several hundred birds flying in to feed during winter.

                                   Another dramatic area of change has been in the raptors that I have
                                   recorded in Delta Park – with a total of 28 species recorded to date.
                                   More and more species seem to be drawn to our ‘urban forest’ and
                                   at least some of these are establishing resident populations. During
                                   my tenure, Black, Ovambo and Little Sparrowhawks have become
                                   regular, with the latter two species having bred successfully on several
                                   occasions. Long-crested Eagles have become fairly regular visitors –
                                   as have European Honey Buzzards, and I’ve even had Bat Hawk and
                                   African Goshawk hunting over the park. At the same time, we seem
                                   to be losing, or have lost, our Yellow-billed Kites and Lanner Falcons.
                                   Lanners were fairly common during the late 1970s and early 1980s
                                   have all but disappeared, while Peregrine Falcons now seem to be
                                   replacing them.

                                   If you bird in and around Delta Park, please join the Delta Park Bird
                                   Challenge on the Birdlasser App and log your sightings so that we can
                                   continue to monitor these changes.

                                   Geoff Lockwood is the resident manager of the Delta Environmental
                                   Centre; a keen birder, atlasser and photographer, as well as a tour
                                   leader for Victor Emanuel Nature Tours based in Austin, Texas. He has
                                   lived in Delta Park for nearly 37 years, and has enjoyed monitoring the
                                   changing birdlife in the park over the past 40 years.

5   Conservation Matters - Issue 10: The Urban Wildlife Edition
Issue 10 The Urban Wildlife Edition September - October 2018 - The Endangered ...
Sentinels
                    the

        cranes of south africa
Photogra phs by D a n i el D o l pi re • Text by D av i d Al l an

In 2013, photographer Daniel Dolpire set off on a passion-driven odyssey that
would consume the next five years of his life. The Sentinels: Cranes of South
Africa is the culmination of that epic journey.
It is little wonder that cranes so captivated Daniel. They are some of the most
stately and spectacular of all birds and their joyous and acrobatic dancing is
simply breathtaking.
The Sentinels is a photographic festival celebrating the beauty and uniqueness
of these remarkable birds. Daniel travelled through the heart of South Africa’s               AVAILABLE FROM 1 OCTOBER
‘crane country’, meticulously documenting these birds in their natural habitat.
                                                                                         168 pages • more than 180 photographs
Sharing with us timeless images of cranes at rest and in action as they go
about their daily routines, he draws us deep into the private lives of these
flagship species, even revealing intimate details of their nesting activities.
With text by ornithologist David Allan, The Sentinels provides an unmatched
window into the allure and wonder of South Africa’s cranes and the enchanting
places they call home.

PRE-ORDER SPECIAL R695 (excl. delivery) at www.hphpublishing.co.za/pages/daniel-dolpires-sentinels

                                           Conservation Matters - Issue 10: The Urban Wildlife Edition                           6
Issue 10 The Urban Wildlife Edition September - October 2018 - The Endangered ...
Creating owl-friendly children                                              to accept the presence of owls in townships. Owls offer a long-term,
                                                                            sustainable solution to high rodent numbers through biological control,
                                                                            and could eliminate the need to use poison. Owlproject.org focuses on
Delina Chipape, Project Coordinator, Ecosolutions                           a strong conservation and education component when dealing with
delina@ecosolutions.co.za                                                   local communities.

Gauteng is the business hub of South Africa and subsequently has            The owl release programme is an Owlproject.org initiative, aimed
one of the highest human populations in the country, resulting in the       at creating owl-friendly children within owl-friendly environments.
establishment of large townships throughout the province. About 15          Through this programme, young owls that end up in captivity for
years ago, a trend was observed in the townships such as Alexandra,         various reasons are integrated back into the wild. The programme
Sebokeng and Katlehong, where there were drastic increases in rodent        has proven to be an excellent awareness raising initiative, and has
numbers in and around the townships. The high rodent populations            helped to nurture a real appreciation for owls within these township
caused concerned residents to turn to poison, unfortunately doing           areas. Most children living in townships have little or no interaction
more harm than good. The Department of Health was called to                 with wildlife, and by acting as a surrogate parent to a young owl, they
intervene after two children died in Sebokeng after ingesting rat           are often left with a resounding appreciation for owls. The owls we
poison. This is a very common occurrence in South Africa, with over         receive have been handed over by various institutions such as the
100 children dying from ingesting rat poison every year, and a child        SPCA, Johannesburg Wildlife Vet and concerned citizens, after being
admitted to hospital on an almost daily basis.                              removed from buildings in townships and suburbs at the request of
                                                                            residents, or after being orphaned or injured.
The high rodent numbers in townships draw rodent-feeding predators
such as owls. Owls are prevalent in mythologies around the world,           The owl release programme is aimed at returning owlets to the
including South Africa, and due to deep-seated cultural beliefs,            townships they came from. The owls that are released each get ringed
their appearance often results in increased human-wildlife conflict.        with a SAFring, which serves as a method to identify the owl and
Owlproject.org addresses the mythological fears that people in              access additional information about the individual through the SAFring
townships have about owls.                                                  database, run by the Animal Demography Unit (ADU) at the University
                                                                            of Cape Town.
Addressing these mythological fears and educating residents on the
ecological importance of owls is the first step in getting communities

7                                            Conservation Matters - Issue 10: The Urban Wildlife Edition
Issue 10 The Urban Wildlife Edition September - October 2018 - The Endangered ...
Through the Township Owl Project, Owlproject.org organises the
annual Alex Owl Day in Alexandra Township, during which children are          Wildlife-friendly gardening – a
                                                                              return to nature
engaged in various environmentally themed activities. The winning
school walks away with prize money that is to be used to start or grow
environmental clubs at their schools. In 2017, the children had great fun
painting wooden owl cut-outs provided to them. Some of the children
proudly displayed their art pieces at numerous events such as the             Emily Taylor, Coordinator, EWT Urban Conservation Programme
BirdLife South Africa Bird Fair at the Walter Sisulu National Botanical       EmilyT@ewt.org.za
Gardens, and the Knysna Timber Festival. In 2017, Owlproject.org was
nominated for a Special Achievement Award from the Owl Hall of                “Gardening becomes so much simpler, so much more enjoyable, when
Fame at the International Owl Centre in Houston, Minnesota.                   you work with nature, rather than against it. A haven for wildlife can
                                                                              still be a beautiful garden and we hope you will be able to see the
                                                                              proof of this at Brenthurst and join us in this great adventure.” – Strilli
                                                                              Oppenheimer, Brenthurst Gardens, Johannesburg

                                                                              Living in an environmentally friendly way and practising Ecological
                                                                              Landscaping, primarily through the use of indigenous plants, will
                                                                              entice all sorts of wildlife to your garden and provide a functional
                                                                              ecosystem that will contribute to the ecology of the broader area
                                                                              in which you live. A string of such properties can go a long way to
                                                                              reducing the effects of habitat fragmentation on wildlife, by creating
                                                                              pathways made up of green stepping stones between green areas in
                                                                              the city. These pathways greatly benefit genetic and species richness
                                                                              in all areas of the city through connecting populations and reducing
                                                                              pressure on isolated sites.

                                                                              Basic principles of Ecological Landscaping
                                                                              •     Maintain natural landscapes as far as possible
                                                                              •     This includes soil, rocks, indigenous vegetation and structural
                                                                                    aspects such as water courses and topography.
                                                                              •     Integrate designs into the existing landscape
                                                                              •     Work with what you have to ensure ecological integrity of the
                                                                                    property
                                                                              •     Retain natural vegetation buffers around water features
                                                                              •     This will help prevent the spread of alien/invasive species by
Owlproject.org is also currently leading an Owl Naming Programme.
Traditionally each owl species in South Africa has common names in            •     restricting their access to water
Afrikaans or English, but this project aims to officially include names       •     Remove alien invasive plant species wherever possible
in all nine indigenous South African languages in media and reference         •     Select new plant species carefully (see section on selecting plants
materials. The project will be undertaken nationally and will involve               below)
numerous secondary schools. Each school will provide suggested
names based on appearance, biology and behaviour of the owl                   •     Approach pest management holistically to avoid unnecessary use
species. Once the proposed names are obtained, Owlproject.org will                  of pesticides
collaborate with WITS University Department of Linguistics to make            •     Use organic mulches and fertilisers
sure the names are grammatically and linguistically correct before            •     Plant at different heights
finalising and publishing them. The goal of this project is to include
the new names for the owl species in the next Roberts Bird Book. The
languages that will be covered are Sepedi, Southern Sotho, Tswana,            Why plant indigenous?
Ndebele, Zulu, Xhosa, Tsonga and Swati.                                       Indigenous animals are far more likely to inhabit a property if the
                                                                              property contains indigenous plants that can provide these animals
                                                                              with the best resources. Indigenous gardening may not create the
                                                                              archetypal western idea of a beautiful garden but it brings with it a
                                                                              wilder, more alive and vibrant environment that can ultimately sustain
                                                                              itself. Remember, however, that it will require a substantial amount of
                                                                              work, and time, to get an already transformed area of land to a point
                                                                              where it becomes a self-sustaining, functional ecosystem.

                                                                              The basics
                                                                              While planting indigenous is preferable to planting exotic, it is still
                                                                              important to select plants from your specific region, as they have
                                                                              adapted to the area’s specific rainfall patterns and weather conditions.
                                                                              Also ensure that the plant is suitable for the amount of sun it will be
                                                                              exposed to.

                                                                              Selecting plants
                                                                              Some species, be it herbs, vegetables, trees, shrubs or grasses,
                                                                              grow more successfully when planted next to certain other species.
                                                                              This is known as companion planting. There are, however, plant
                                                                              combinations that have a detrimental effect on each other, or out

                                               Conservation Matters - Issue 10: The Urban Wildlife Edition                                              8
Issue 10 The Urban Wildlife Edition September - October 2018 - The Endangered ...
animals often drown in even small bodies of water if the sides are
                                                                             steep or slippery and they cannot get out.

                                                                             Cover
                                                                             Garden wildlife also needs sufficient cover from the elements, as
                                                                             well as from each other (and domestic creatures such as dogs, cats,
                                                                             and children). Adding items such as rocks can help create shelter for
                                                                             small species. It is advisable also not to be too tidy and to let your
                                                                             grass grow a little bit, particularly around the edges of beds and water
                                                                             features – this will provide a perfect habitat for smaller organisms.
                                                                             When landscaping does not allow for natural nesting opportunities,
                                                                             it may be useful to install some artificial structures such as bird or bat
                                                                             boxes, yet there are no guarantees that these will be utilised by desired
                                                                             species. Any artificial houses must be accessible and ensure minimal
                                                                             disturbance by children and predators (including domestic animals).

                                                                             Space
                                                                             Different wildlife species require different sizes and types of habitat.
                                                                             Use of space in Ecological Landscaping is very important to ensure
                                                                             that animals have a variety of options, including space that is relatively
                                                                             undisturbed by human activity.

                                                                             Some other ideas
                                                                             •   Give your dog or cat a bell to reduce the threat they pose to
                                                                                 indigenous wildlife
                                                                             •      Erect barriers around young plants and remove them once the
                                                                                    plants have become more established and are more resilient to
                                                                                    disturbance by children, animals and wildlife
                                                                             •      Make certain areas more inviting for children and pets so that
                                                                                    they don’t disturb wildlife habitats

                                                                             Being water wise
                                                                             Following the basic principles of Ecological Landscaping will
                                                                             automatically assist you in saving water but there are many other
                                                                             things you can do to decrease your water usage, which will in turn
                                                                             contribute to maintaining our country’s natural water balance. The
                                                                             first step in living a water-wise lifestyle in your house and garden is
                                                                             to conserve municipal water by using it sparingly – not leaving taps to
                                                                             run and fixing any leaks in taps or pipes. But there are multiple other
                                                                             simple ways in which you can contribute further:

                                                                             •      Reuse grey water from sinks and bathtubs to water non-food
                                                                                    plants
                                                                             •      Harvest free rainwater in rain tanks (such as JoJo Tanks)
compete each other for resources. So, if you are not companion               •      Remove declared alien invader plants
planting, you should at least consider designing your garden so that         •      Select appropriate grass types
plants near each other are non-competing.
                                                                             •      Zone your garden into different hydro zones and group plants
                                                                                    according to their water usage requirements
Attracting wildlife to your garden                                           •      Use compost, manure and water retentive polymers
As with humans, plants and animals have a hierarchy of needs, and at
the base of this hierarchy are food, water, cover and space.                 •      Mulch, mulch, mulch! This allows the water to slowly percolate
                                                                                    into the soil and not evaporate too quickly
Food                                                                         •      Irrigate efficiently by applying the right amount of water at
To cater to as wide a variety of species as possible, you will want to              the right time. Watering during the hottest time of the day is
diversify the types of food items available in your garden. To cover                extremely wasteful because the moisture evaporates almost
all your bases you should ensure that there is green vegetation, fruit,             immediately and very little water actually reaching the plant roots
seeds, insects, nuts and nectar rich flowers. This will attract many         •      Use innovative watering techniques such as drip irrigation, soaker
species of birds and bats, small mammals, insects, reptiles and                     hoses, installed timers or cut-off valves
amphibians (provided they can get into the property), and other
necessary micro-organisms. It is also helpful to ensure that food items
                                                                             Rand Water has wonderful tips on how to save water on their website
are available at different and appropriate heights – particularly if
                                                                             – www.randwater.co.za
you are hoping to attract a certain species. You may want to use bird
feeders in winter periods when food availability is low.
                                                                                 You can support the critical work of the EWT’s Urban
Water
                                                                                 Conservation Programme, which strives to connect people with
Having a permanent source of clean water in your garden will make
                                                                                 nature, by visiting www.givengain/c/endangered/ and using the
it irresistible to wildlife, provided it is safe from predators and
                                                                                 reference “urban” in the message box.
undisturbed. It is also advisable that water sources are designed
in such a way that animals can get in and out of the water easily, as

9                                             Conservation Matters - Issue 10: The Urban Wildlife Edition
Located in greater Kruger, Limpopo, South Africa
+27 (0) 11 817 5560 • reservations@karongweportfolio.com
                               www.karongweportfolio.com

                          Conservation Matters - Issue 10: The Urban Wildlife Edition   10
Showcasing our supporters                                                     There’s a bat in my kitchen,
Celebrating an anniversary with
                                                                              what should I do?
Signature Lux by Onomo                                                        Emily Taylor, Coordinator, EWT Urban Conservation Programme
                                                                              EmilyT@ewt.org.za
They say time flies when you are having fun. It feels like just yesterday
                                                                              A recent study of the distribution of urban wildlife in the City of
that the EWT entered into a cause-related marketing relationship with
                                                                              Johannesburg produced findings that indicate that wildlife sightings are
the then Signature Lux Hotel, championed and facilitated by three
                                                                              reported most in areas not far from green spaces (parks, waterways,
Richland directors – Johan Franck, Paul Kelley and Paul Hailwood.
                                                                              nature reserves etc.), but also in areas dominated by certain
                                                                              land-cover classes. Over 25% of sightings were recorded in urban
According to Johan, there is a seamless relationship between tourism
                                                                              residential areas with dense trees and bush, and these areas were
and conservation as globalisation is continuously breaking boundaries
                                                                              also where the most species diversity was recorded. These results
as people travel the world for either business or leisure. It was,
                                                                              mimicked many from around the world that say that these suburban
therefore, a no-brainer for these philanthropists to connect the dots
                                                                              areas provide the richest variety of habitat, food and shelter, and
and come up with a cause-related marketing concept where R5 per
                                                                              are therefore attractive to many animal and plant species. Many of
booking is donated to the work of the EWT to support its work against
                                                                              these animals have become so common, having adapted to survive
extinction
                                                                              by raiding our rubbish bins or nesting in our roofs, that many people
                                                                              consider them to be pests.
A year later, over R300,000 has been raised through this initiative.
Signature Lux Hotel was recently acquired by Onomo Hotel group,
                                                                              Adapting to living in close proximity to humans has also reduced
slightly changing the name to Signature Lux Hotel by Onomo and
                                                                              many species’ fear and so these animals frequently come into conflict
according to Hannes Pienaar, General Manager, and Anne Alp,
                                                                              with residents, particularly when they become accustomed to being
Financial Manager “there is no need to change the winning formula”
                                                                              fed, either intentionally or unintentionally, such as is the case with
as the Onomo brand shares the same passion for conservation, and
                                                                              the baboons in Cape Town. There are, however, indigenous species
this relationship is growing from strength to strength.
                                                                              that have a bad reputation but that aren’t nearly as destructive or
                                                                              undesirable as is conceived. Bats and birds are just some of the animals
The affordable guest experience, contemporary comfort and the art
                                                                              that are frequently encountered in and around homes.
of African living with tech-savvy service aimed at the global-minded
business travellers, unique personalised freedom and hassle-free
flexibility that is synonymous with millennials and business travellers       Bats
alike is what makes this hotel a unique option. And what is equally
unique is that by booking into this hotel, you automatically become           Why should we conserve bats?
a philanthropist and a champion for conservation, as part of your             One insectivorous bat can consume 50–70% of its body weight in insects
booking fee is donated to the EWT.                                            in one night. This aids extensively in the prevention of the spread of
                                                                              diseases and controls the number of bothersome mosquitoes. Fruit
As we move into the second year, the EWT thanks the three Richland            eating bats pollinate many of the indigenous plants on which we rely
directors for conceptualising this productive relationship and Onomo          for food, drink and beautiful flowers.
Group for sharing this vision.
Find out more at http://signatureluxhotels.com/                               Concerns related to the presence of bats
                                                                              A common misconception is that bats breed profusely due to the large
                                                                              number of individuals that congregate in roosts. The truth is that bats
                                                                              have very low reproductive rates, usually only producing one pup after
                                                                              a gestation period of between two and six months, depending on the
                                                                              species. For their size, they are the slowest reproducing mammals in
                                                                              the world. Due to this low reproductive rate, population viability is
                                                                              gravely affected by high mortality rates when bats are placed under
                                                                              threat, such as they are in many urban areas. Due to large-scale
                                                                              habitat loss, bats have had to adapt to living in urban areas, and
                                                                              have become an essential part of our ecosystem, but they also fall
                                                                              victim, often unintentionally, to many human activities in urban areas.
                                                                              Some of the greatest dangers bats face are as a result of ignorance,
                                                                              superstition, indirect poisoning and roost disturbance or destruction
                                                                              during development.

                                                                              Myths – fact or fiction?
                                                                              •      Bats are rats with wings.

                                                                                     Fiction: Bats are not related to rodents but are classified in a
                                                                                     group of their own called Chiroptera, more closely related to
                                                                                     primates than rodents.
                                                                              •      Bats suck human blood.

                                                                                     Fiction: There are only three species of bats that consume blood
                                                                                     and these occur only in South America. The tiny amount of blood
                                                                                     consumed is usually lapped up from an open wound of an animal
                                                                                     and not sucked as is often thought.

11                                             Conservation Matters - Issue 10: The Urban Wildlife Edition
•    Bats are physical manifestations of human souls not
     yet at peace.

     Fiction: This belief is a result of bats occupying caves,
     which were often resting places for the dead.

•    Consuming bat eyeballs will allow you to see in the
     dark.

     Fiction: Bats cannot see in the dark, they use
     echolocation to find their way around.

•    Bats breed profusely.

     Fiction: Bats have slow reproductive rates.

•    Bats get tangled or nest in your hair.

     Fiction

•    Bats are aggressive and will attack.

     Fiction

There are, however, some valid concerns people have
around bats inhabiting their homes. These include:

•    Noise disturbance
•    Droppings in and around the house
•    Odour
•    Damage to crops                                                      Wherever your adventure
•
•
     Dirt associated with bats
                                                                          takes you, Trappers is the
                                                                          place to go for all your outdoor
     Carry mites, fleas etc.
•    Present a health risk (e.g. Rabies)
    o    Like any other mammal, bats can carry rabies                     equipment & apparel needs.
         but the percentage of those infected is no more
         significant than for any other indigenous species.

Threats to bats in urban areas
Just as bats have the potential to cause problems for us in
our homes, our activities can also have detrimental effects
on bat populations:

•    Domestic pets
•    Poisoning
•    Drowning
•    Sticky fly-traps
•    Electrocution
•    Habitat modification and other disturbances

What to do?
The first thing to consider is whether the root of your
problem is definitely bats. Mice and rats have similar
droppings and are far more likely to be the culprits of
destructive behaviour. If it is the thought of bats roosting
in your house that is the problem, there are a number of
effective mitigation techniques that take your safety, and
that of the bats, into account:’

•    Assess habitat: Is there a particular plant that is                    Stores country wide
     attracting the bats? Certain tree species, for
     example, attract fruit bats – the culprits of urine                          trappers.co.za              /TrappersOutdoor
     spraying when returning to their roosts. Consider
                                                                            Images are for illustrative purposes only.

                                                Conservation Matters - Issue 10: The Urban Wildlife Edition                      12
removing or relocating such plants, as even ridding your property        Birds
     of the bats will not solve the problem if another colony simply
     moves in to utilise the plant.
                                                                              Why should we conserve birds?
                                                                              As with bats, birds play vital roles in the maintenance of a healthy
•    Physical exclusion
                                                                              natural system through pollination of flowers, seed dispersal,
     o   This can be done by attaching one-way tubes at all entry             as a source of food and pest control, but to name a few of the
         points to the roost so that the bats can come out but cannot         ecological services they provide. Having an owl in your area can
         re-enter.                                                            significantly reduce rodent populations more efficiently and with no
                                                                              negative effects on the environment or the health of people and other
     o   Never evict bats during the winter while they are hibernating        animals. Birds are also an important part of many cultural and religious
         because they are too weak to search for a new roost and              traditions and are appreciated for their aesthetics and song all over
         will die. It is also problematic to evict adult bats between         the world.
         September and January, as this is when the babies are being
         nursed and, if trapped inside without adults, will die and           Concerns related to the presence of birds
         create an odour problem.                                             Generally, we like birds in our gardens, provided they are attractive
                                                                              and sing sweetly. There are others, however, that we are not so fond
     o   The best time to evict bats and implement exclusion methods          of. Hadedas, for example, are incredibly loud, cause a mess with their
         in South Africa is between February and May after babies             large droppings, and are not very pretty. The same goes for crows, Grey
         have been nursed.                                                    Go-away Birds and other such unfortunate species. Birds of prey, like
     o   Cover all possible entry points with bird netting / wire or fill     owls, are also not a favourite of many. In many African cultures, owls
         them in                                                              are considered to be a bad omen, or an evil spirit, and in others they
                                                                              are caught and killed as ingredients in traditional medicine and ritual,
•    Deterrents                                                               while some people fear that large birds of prey present a danger to
     o   Audible deterrents – Ultrasonic devices that emit high               their pets, small livestock, and even children. Some common concerns
         frequency sounds that confuse the bats; predator calls. In           people have include:
         general, these devices have not proven very effective                •         Noise
                                                                              •          Droppings
     o   Chemical deterrents – Gels, sprays or powders that
         discourage bats from occupying the area                              •          Odour
                                                                              •          Damage to property and equipment
•    Alternative roosts – bat boxes
                                                                              •          Nuisance
•    Sealing the structure while providing an alternate roost (a bat          •          Dirty
     box) is the most effective long-term solution.
                                                                              •          Carry mites, fleas etc.
                                                                              •          Birds present a health risk
When selecting and implementing control measures, bear the
following in mind:                                                            Threats to birds in urban areas
     All chemical usage on bats is illegal (bats are protected by             As with bats and other indigenous wildlife that has adapted to sharing
     provincial legislation).                                                 our space, birds are vulnerable to injury as a result of our activities,
                                                                              such as through:
     Chemicals that kill bats are also hazardous to humans and pets.          •         Domestic pets
     Poisoning or removal of a colony can be a fruitless exercise             •          Poisoning
     because the roost is then made available for other bat colonies          •          Collisions with power lines
     to move in.                                                              •          Collisions with vehicles
     Some pest control services will offer to catch and release bats          •          Habitat modification and other disturbances
     far away, but bats have been proven to return from up to 600             •          Electrocution
     kilometres away and so they may very well come back.                     •          Killed in traps and shot

                                                                              What to do?
                                                                              To prevent annoyance or damage to property as a result of the
                                                                              presence of certain, less desirable, bird species, there are a number of
                                                                              control methods that can be implemented that do not pose a threat to
                                                                              the lives of the birds, or any other organisms. These include:
                                                                              •     Exclusion
                                                                                   o     Use of bird netting to prevent access and roosting
                                                                                   o     Anti-roosting wire system / chicken mesh / spikes
                                                                                   o     Electric wires

                                                                              •     Deterrents
                                                                                   o     Visual deterrents e.g. scarecrow methods
                                                                                   o     Chemical and gel repellents
                                                                                   o     Audio deterrents - ultrasonic devices; distress calls; predator
                                                                                         calls

                                                                              •     Trapping and releasing elsewhere

                                                                              •     Alternative roosts – owl boxes / nest boxes

13                                             Conservation Matters - Issue 10: The Urban Wildlife Edition
DRINK BEER FOR A GOOD CAUSE
       ZE TOPS AT SPAR BIERFEST NOW MAKES GIVING BACK (WHILE HAVING A GOOD
                          TIME!) AS EASY AS EIN, ZWEI, DREI!

    Now you have ze awesome hopportunity to give back to your favourite charity by “buying”
                  a Standard Bier Hall ticket to ze Saturday lunchtime events.
      Standard Bier hall Tickets cost only R175 each und 100% of ze net proceeds from each
               ticket sold by you will be donated to your charity or chosen cause.

                                        HERE’S HOW IT WORKS:

           STEP                                     STEP                                         STEP
             1                                        2                                            3

     Select your Bierfest                      Select                                     Click on “Donate now!
         2018 event                   ‘Endangered Wildlife Trust’

           STEP                                     STEP                                         STEP
            4                                        5                                            6

Visit the secure donation page       Get in touch with Bierfest at                 Drink beer for a good cause!
   and make your donation             michele@bierfest.co.za to
                                          claim your tickets

                                             SABierfest      SABierfest

                                           WWW.BIERFEST.CO.ZA

                            Conservation Matters - Issue 10: The Urban Wildlife Edition                           14
Green spaces                                                                    bird sanctuary boasts up to 250 bird species. With no entrance fee
                                                                                attached to visiting the park, it is worthwhile to visit just to take a walk
                                                                                with your dog or have a picnic with the family.
Zethu Sibiya, Environmental
Education & Urban Conservation Project Officer, EWT Urban                       Also situated at the Delta Park is the Delta Environmental Centre.
Conservation Programme                                                          School and community groups make use of the centre, where hand-on
ZethuS@ewt.org.za                                                               activities take place both indoors and outdoors. Schools visiting the
                                                                                centre may explore different environmental topics such as biodiversity,
A green space is an outdoor, vegetated area that sustains communities           water and waste management. For a small entrance fee, both adults
of living organisms and fulfils ecological functions. In truth, the services    and learners can have access to the educational displays at the Gold
provided by green spaces in our urban areas are far too complex for us          Fields Discovery Centre. The Delta Environmental Centre includes a
to fully comprehend. Often referred to as ‘green lungs’, these vegetated        recycling centre/depot which was built in order to minimize the waste
areas filter carbon dioxide in the air and release oxygen so that we            which is dumped and buried at landfills.
may breathe. This is but one service they provide that keep humans
alive, one amongst countless others. We cannot endure without them.             Useful Information
Perhaps the psychological wellbeing that they allegedly bring us is our         Location: 77 Craighall Rd, Victory Park, Randburg, 2195
sub conscious’ way of reminding us of this fact.                                GPS Coordinates: S 26.1235; E 28.0084
                                                                                Classification: Open Park Land
Johannesburg contains an impressive 2,343 parks, and this number                Established: 1930’s
does not include private open spaces or the some ten million street side        Size: 104 ha
trees in the city. Combine all of this with smaller residential gardens,        Opening hours: 06:00 – 18:00 (Monday to Sunday)
and it is easy to understand why the city is known as the largest urban         Park Entrance fee: Free
forest in the world. If one follows the logic of the study mentioned, it’s      Delta Environmental Centre Fee: R62.00 per learner for 3 hour
not surprising either that Africa.com rates Johannesburg as the fourth          programme
most liveable city in Africa.                                                   R37.00 per learner for 1½ hour programme
                                                                                Activities: Walking trail, birding, and weekly parkrun, small concerts
                                                                                Facilities: Toilets, braai facilities, picnic area, play area for children,
Delta Park                                                                      scout training grounds.
                                                                                Special Features: Florence Boom Bird Sanctuary, Recycling Depot and
Delta Park is one of Gauteng’s oldest parks, situated in northern
                                                                                Delta Education Centre
Johannesburg. The park includes the Florence Bloom Bird Sanctuary,
                                                                                Species of interest: Striped Mice, Slender Mongoose and Large
which is considered the oldest bird sanctuary in the city. The 7.5 ha
                                                                                Spotted Genet can be found foraging around the park. You may find a

15                                               Conservation Matters - Issue 10: The Urban Wildlife Edition
rare occurrence of reptiles such as Rinkhals and Marsh Terrapins.
Delta Environmental Centre Email Address: delta@deltaenviro.org.za

Beaulieu bird sanctuary
Beaulieu Bird Sanctuary is situated within a gated community in
Kyalami. There are three bird hides in the sanctuary, which all provide
a unique viewing experience of the different bird species. There are
also walkways that allow visitors the opportunity to get a closer view
of their favourite bird species.

Useful Information
Location: Witpoort (Beaulieu), Midrand, 1684
GPS Coordinates: S 25.9804; E 28.0697
Classification: Bird sanctuary
Size: 16 ha
Opening hours:        Daylight
Park Entrance fee: Free
Activities: Birding
Facilities: Bird Hide
Special Features: Walkways for unique birding experience
Species of interest: African Reed Warbler, African Wattled Lapwing,
Blacksmith Lapwing, Black-crowned Night Heron, Black-headed Heron,
Malachite Kingfisher and African Fish Eagle.
Website: http://www.jhbcityparks.com
Telephone number: 011 712 6600

James and Ethel Gray Park
James and Ethel Gray Park in Birdhaven, Johannesburg is 36 hectares
in size. The Sandspruit River flows through the park, attracting a
multitude of bird species and residents alike. The park was originally a
bird sanctuary and was named after the former Johannesburg mayor,
James Gray, and his wife, but is now hugely popular with picnickers,
runners and walkers, particularly those with dogs. On a weekend
evening local residents and their socialised dogs come out in scores to
enjoy the well cared-for, beautiful and safe park. The park is now fully
fenced and contains new ablution facilities, a play area for kids, safe        Useful Information
parking and a lovely landscape with views of the famous Johannesburg           Location: Houghton Drive, Houghton
skyline.                                                                       GPS Coordinates: S 26.173289, E 28.052085
Useful Information                                                             Classification: Municipal Nature Reserve
Location: Atholl Oaklands Road                                                 Established: 1936
GPS Coordinates: S 26.139431, E 28.062826                                      Size: 16 ha
Classification: Open Park Land                                                 Opening hours: 06:00 – 18:00 (Monday to Sunday)
Established: 1946                                                              Park Entrance fee: Free
Size: 36 ha                                                                    Activities: Walking trails, birding, dog walking, educational walks, art
Opening hours: 06:00 – 18:00 (Monday to Sunday)                                exhibitions, photography
Park Entrance fee: Free                                                        Facilities: Toilets, parking, play area for children, benches.
Activities: Walking trails, birding, Acrobranch, dog walking, playing          Special Features: Indigenous vegetation and koppies, views of the city,
Facilities: Toilets, parking, play area for children, open field for games,    animal statues by James Delaney.
benches.                                                                       Species of interest: Pristine indigenous vegetation, particularly Rock
Special Features: Views of the city                                            Elder (Afrocanthium mundianum), Velvet Rock Elder (Afrocanthium
Species of interest: Over 100 bird species have been recorded in the           gilfillanii) and the large Yellowwoods (Podocarpus latifolius).
park.                                                                          Follow Friends of The Wilds on Facebook to keep up to date with
                                                                               events.
The Wilds
The Wilds is a 16 hectare Municipal Nature Reserve nestled in the              For more information on these and other green spaces in Johannesburg,
koppies behind Houghton in Johannesburg. The Wilds is made up of               please contact Johannesburg City Parks and Zoo (JCPZ):
indigenous vegetation, koppies, waterfalls, and rambling walkways.             Website: www.jhbcityparks.com
Once considered a haven for criminals, the park was for a long time            Telephone number: +27 11 888 4831
avoided by residents and became overgrown and desolate. In recent              Johannesburg City Parks Email address:
years, the community has partnered with Joburg City Parks and Zoo              joburgconnect@joburg.org.za
to reclaim and revive the park. One resident, James Delaney, was the
pioneer for this revival and enticed others to start using it through art.
James created 67 beautiful owl statues and installed them throughout
the park, drawing more and more people to come and view the
exhibits. He has since installed many more statues of bushbabies, a
kudu, a pangolin, ostriches and monkeys. The park is now extremely
popular with Joburgers streaming through to take part in walks,
picnics, rock climbing, fun days, or just enjoy the exquisite and tranquil
landscape of the park.

                                                Conservation Matters - Issue 10: The Urban Wildlife Edition                                           16
this poorly regulated fishery and has granted licenses to politically
 This article first appeared in Yale Environment 360                          connected boat owners, whose catch is often sold to Australia, where
 https://e360.yale.edu/features/shark-mystery-where-have-south-               it winds up in fish ’n chips.
 africas-great-whites-gone
                                                                              Since 2013, about three to six demersal longliners — fishing boats that
                                                                              set lines with up to 2,000 baited hooks on or near the sea floor — have
Shark mystery: Where have                                                     been working hundreds of miles of the southern coast of South Africa.
                                                                              Fallows says these boats have intensified their efforts in recent years

South Africa’s Great Whites
                                                                              and have driven stocks of smaller shark species to collapse, which may
                                                                              have led to starvation of juvenile Great Whites and driven other Great
                                                                              Whites elsewhere. The fishery may also be illegally hooking and killing

gone?                                                                         young Great Whites and protected hammerhead sharks, he believes.
                                                                              While noting the decline in False Bay and other areas, some South
                                                                              African scientists say they still have not determined the cause. Other
Adam Welz                                                                     possibilities, these scientists say, are that pods of Killer Whales —
adamwelz@gmail.com                                                            which feed on Great White Sharks — are more active in the area,
                                                                              driving the Great Whites elsewhere. Changing ocean conditions, some
The world’s most famous sharks are the Great Whites off Cape Town,            experts say, could also be forcing Great White Sharks to search for new
featured in the popular “Air Jaws” series. But now these sharks have          hunting grounds.
mostly gone missing, and some experts blame a fishery for depleting
the smaller sharks that the Great Whites feed on.                             “There could be some shift in the environment happening,” says
                                                                              Meaghen McCord, founding director of the South African Shark
It’s a shimmering early morning in False Bay, a shallow, 18-mile-wide         Conservancy. “We’re just not sure, and with us being on the cusp of
basin on the southwest corner of South Africa. A small boat with a            possible large climate-related shifts, few scientists are prepared to say
dozen tourists sways rhythmically in the swell just downwind of Seal          anything conclusive just yet.”
Island, a strip of rock that barely clears the water and is covered
with thousands of breeding Cape fur seals and tens of thousands of            Marine biologist Sara Andreotti, a postdoctoral researcher at
seabirds. The animals’ waste saturates the breeze with sharp-smelling         Stellenbosch University, led a study that estimated the total South
ammonia, and a light veil of winter air pollution hangs over the city of      African population of Great Whites at only between 353 and 522
Cape Town, which lies just to the north.                                      individuals in 2011 – making them far more scarce than the country’s

Suddenly and almost silently, a gusher of white water explodes from
the sea 100 yards from the boat. The tourists glimpse a muddled flash
of fins and a massive tail whipping around inside the crown of flying
foam. The seething water flattens, and seconds later the gasping snout
of a wounded seal breaks the surface. The unmistakable dorsal fin of
a large Great White Shark comes up straight and steady behind it, and
the seal is taken down in the giant fish’s jaws.

Since 1996, Chris Fallows has made a good living taking thousands of
tourists and dozens of film crews into False Bay to witness extraordinary
sights like this, either from the deck of his boat or from an underwater
cage held alongside. Great Shite sharks congregate around Seal Island
in the southern winter to feed on newly weaned Cape Fur Seals, which
take their first, naive swims at this time of year. The White Sharks here
are noted for their breach kills; starting at depth, they swim rapidly
upward and hit shallow-swimming seals from below. The sharks’
momentum carries them in the air, which makes for the spectacular
images in the Air Jaws series of documentary films — largely hosted
by Fallows — that have had billions of views on the Discovery Channel
since 2001.

“The flying sharks of False Bay are now the most famous sharks in the
world,” he says.

It’s become increasingly rare, though, to witness these remarkable
kills, particularly in the last two years. For more than two decades,
Fallows has been keeping records of kills and attempted kills by sharks
seen from his boat in False Bay. These sightings have dropped from a
peak average of more than 11 events per trip in 2004 to around 0.3
events per trip in 2017 and this year. Other shark tourism operators
and scientists have noted a similar change in the world’s best-known
shark hunting ground and for at least a hundred miles to the east. The
question now is, what has happened to the sharks?

Fallows and his colleagues in South Africa’s shark tourism business
think they have the answer. The culprit, they believe, is a long-line
fishery that has been targeting smaller species of sharks, including
Soupfin and Smooth-hound sharks, which are a favoured prey species
of Great Whites. The South African government has encouraged

17                                             Conservation Matters - Issue 10: The Urban Wildlife Edition
well-known rhinos. She cautions that pointing to Orcas and undefined          55). Shark populations usually recover from decline far more slowly
environmental changes can move the focus from overfishing by                  than most bony fishes, over decades rather than years. Given this,
“shifting the blame onto something we don’t have control upon.”               and the pivotal ecological role sharks play as top predators, Chivell
Andreotti says that fishermen are “targeting Great White food left,           believes the government needs to put an immediate moratorium on
right, and centre.” She’s concerned that observations by shark tourism        shark demersal longlining, “because in a year’s time it might be too
operators – who spend more time on the water than most scientists             late.” South Africa’s fisheries are largely regulated by the Department
– indicate a sharp population decline since her study was completed,          of Agriculture, Forestry, and Fisheries (DAFF), which gathers data on
but says no peer-reviewed data is yet available to confirm such a drop.       fish catches and populations and grants fishing rights to individuals
 “I’m angry and desperate,” says Wilfred Chivell, who owns a large            and companies that conform to certain requirements, such as owning
cage-diving ecotourism company in the epicentre of shark-watching,            appropriate boats or belonging to race groups that were disadvantaged
Gansbaai (“Goose Bay”, in Afrikaans), about 30 miles east of False Bay.       under the apartheid regime. DAFF scientists analyze data to make
He says that sightings of White WSharks have declined sharply in his          catch size recommendations for different species, but DAFF managers
area, too, and that local fishermen complain to him that demersal             (many of whom are not scientists) ultimately determine fishing
longliners have wiped out the Bronze Whaler Sharks they used to               permit conditions and grant fishing rights based on a number of
catch by handline from small boats offshore. Chivell says he has had          considerations, many of which are political.
to pay the locals not to catch the remaining Bronze Whalers close to
shore so he can have something to show his clients when Great Whites          In 2014, the government launched Operation Phakisa, a drive to “grow
are absent.                                                                   the ocean economy” and help reduce the country’s shockingly high
                                                                              unemployment rate by creating a million new jobs. Employees at
 In 1991, South Africa became the first country to grant legal protection     environmental non-profits say that DAFF management is now under
to Great White Sharks, and since then shark viewing and cage diving           immense pressure to be seen creating jobs. The South African fishing
have become a major tourist industry along its southern coast,                industry has been beset by allegations of high-level corruption for
hosting more than 80,000 visitors a year and helping to contribute            years; many of the biggest players in scandals linked to the current
tens of millions of dollars to the economy. Many shark conservation           ruling party have roots in fishing.
organisations are active here, sharks are often portrayed positively in
the local media, and many visitors doubtless leave with the impression        A 2014 government-commissioned investigation into fishing permit
that South Africa is serious about shark conservation.                        irregularities found that at least three participants in the demersal
                                                                              shark longline fishery had obtained rights without having the required
Most sharks are vulnerable to overfishing because they have few               shark-fishing boats. Imraan “Imie” Patel — head of Letap Fishing CC
young, mature slowly, and live a long time (Soupfin Sharks can live to        — somehow got a shark permit with a squid-fishing boat. Another
                                                                              influential player in the sector, Sharmilla van Heerden of Fisherman
                                                                              Fresh, has multiple boats and touts her relationships with DAFF
                                                                              officials.

                                                                              Fallows and Chivell do not have conclusive evidence that Soupfin and
                                                                              Smooth-hound shark populations have collapsed or that demersal
                                                                              longliners are to blame, because they have not been given access to
                                                                              DAFF’s catch data and DAFF scientists have yet to complete current
                                                                              stock assessments for these species. But they say that DAFF’s data
                                                                              must show that stocks of these sharks are in trouble; a presentation
                                                                              about fishing rights given by DAFF officials to coastal communities in
                                                                              June includes a graph showing Smooth-hound and Soupfin sharks as
                                                                              “under heavy fishing pressure” and Soupfin sharks as “depleted.” DAFF
                                                                              did not respond to requests for comment for this article or provide
                                                                              Yale Environment 360 with recent data on shark catches.

                                                                              A research programme led by shark researcher Matt Dicken has tagged
                                                                              674 Smooth-hound Sharks in the port of Coega, about 500 miles east
                                                                              of False Bay. Dicken says that of the nine tags reported outside the
                                                                              port, seven were from sharks caught by demersal shark longliners.
                                                                              Unpublished data from an acoustic tagging program that tracks fish
                                                                              along the South African coast suggests high mortality rates among
                                                                              young Hammerhead and Bronze Whaler sharks.

                                                                              Chris Fallows has documented dramatic drops in young Hammerhead
                                                                              Sharks in a nursery site on the south coast. Although Hammerheads are
                                                                              strictly protected, he says it’s likely they’re being caught by demersal
                                                                              longliners, which are active in the area.

                                                                              WWF-South Africa also has raised red flags about shark fishing via its
                                                                              South African Sustainable Seafood Initiative (SASSI), which scientifically
                                                                              assesses available data and ranks species as green (well-managed),
                                                                              orange (consume with caution) and red (do not buy) to encourage
                                                                              consumers to buy fish from well-managed stocks. In 2015, SASSI
                                                                              ranked Soupfin and Common Smooth-hound sharks as red species
                                                                              owing to a lack of data about stocks and indications that they may be
                                                                              overfished.

                                                                              “We operate according to the precautionary principle,” says Pavitray
                                                                              Pillay, manager of SASSI. “We need evidence that the stock is healthy,”

                                               Conservation Matters - Issue 10: The Urban Wildlife Edition                                             18
You can also read