Mathematical model of the modified tissue deformation under stretching

Page created by Suzanne Benson
 
CONTINUE READING
E3S Web of Conferences 274, 11005 (2021)                                 https://doi.org/10.1051/e3sconf/202127411005
STCCE – 2021

      Mathematical model of the modified tissue
      deformation under stretching
      Rashit Kayumov1,2 [0000-0003-0711-9429], and Inzilija Mukhamedova1* [0000-0001-5869-6686]
      1Kazan State University of Architecture and Engineering, 420043, Zelenaya st. Kazan, Russia
      2Kazan National Research Technical University named after A.N. Tupolev, 420111, K. Marks st.,
      Kazan, Russia

                    Abstract. One of the effective methods for modifying natural and
                    synthetic materials is a use of the flocking process. To analyze a quality of
                    the modified fabrics, it is useful to have mathematical models describing a
                    stress-strain state of the fabrics when exposed to various loads. A method
                    has been developed for determining the stiffness characteristics of a
                    flocked fabric based on the results of testing samples cut at different angles
                    to the base at different tensile forces. This technique makes it possible to
                    analyze the effect of flocking on the mechanical characteristics of the
                    fabric. It was revealed that the theory of mixtures, when averaging the
                    properties of the fabrics and glue with respect to thickness, does not allow
                    determining the stiffness characteristics with acceptable accuracy. The
                    limits of applicability of the theory of mixtures were determined when
                    carrying out averaging of the mechanical characteristics with respect to the
                    area of the flocked fabrics.
                    Keywords: nonlinearly elastic model, flocked fabric, identification,
                    mechanical characteristics, methodology, numerical experiment.

      1 Introduction
      Giving the improved mechanical and technological properties to the materials is carried out
      by means of their mechanical, chemical, electromechanical and electrophysical
      modification. Currently, the textile industry is increasingly using the modification methods
      by processing fabrics with cold plasma [1, 2]. Plasma allows us to change properties of the
      surfaces of the materials in a wide range, improves the adhesive properties of the textile
      material, increases wear resistance while maintaining the previously obtained strength
      characteristics [3-6]. An increase in the fire resistance of linen fabrics produced by using
      the modification with the use of a plasma flow allows conducting a more efficient and more
      uniform solution absorption of the surface of textile materials [7].
          A sol-gel technology is widely used for innovative finishing of textile materials [8]. The
      main advantage of the sol-gel method over the others is that it allows us to control the
      structure of the resulting materials, a size of particles, a size and volume of pores, a surface
      area of films in order to obtain a material with the desired properties [9, 10]. In the modern
      context the researches are actively developing regarding improving the methods of

      *   Corresponding author: Muhamedova-inzilija@mail.ru

© The Authors, published by EDP Sciences. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons
Attribution License 4.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
E3S Web of Conferences 274, 11005 (2021)                            https://doi.org/10.1051/e3sconf/202127411005
STCCE – 2021

      modifying cellulose fibers to create a wide range of new materials with biocidal properties
      [11-13]. In the works [14-16] an antibacterial finish of textile materials was studied by
      copper nanoparticles.
          One of the effective methods for modifying natural and synthetic materials is a use of
      the flocking process [17]. With this technology, it is possible to obtain the required
      technological, operational properties of textile materials, as well as targeted improvement in
      the physicomechanical properties of fabricss [18-20]. A flocated surface, while frictioning,
      prevents mechanical damage, which is used in the manufacture of packaging and sealing
      elements, such as a window profile in cars.
          To analyze a quality of the modified fabrics, it is useful to have mathematical models
      describing a stress-strain state (SSS) of the fabrics when exposed to various loads. This is
      relevant due to the fact that such models will make it easier to solve the problem of
      optimizing a fabrics treatment technology.

      2 Materials and methods

      2.1 Nonlinearly elastic model of strain of the fabrics

      Let us introduce the efforts per unit length of the section of our sample. They are denoted
      through N11 , N 22 , N12 , (efforts along the basics, the weft and the shear force). The
      corresponding deformations are denoted through ε11 , ε 22 , γ 12 . Let us introduce the vectors
      {N}, { ε }:
                              {N} = {N11, N 22 , N12 }T {ε } = {ε11, ε 22 , γ 12 }T .
      The index «T» means a transposition operation.

                   P                                                                           P
             b

                                                  a

      Fig. 1. Strain of the tissue sample, chipped out at an angle to the base under an action of the force Р.
      For a nonlinear case in the axes of orthotropy, the elastic potential for the non-flocked
      fabrics is taken in the following form:
                                  2             4
                      W = D110ε11   / 2 + D112ε11  / 12 + D120ε11ε 22 +
                              2              4               2              6        (1)
                      + D220ε 22 / 2 + D222ε 22 / 12 + D330γ 12 / 2 + D334γ 12 / 30.

      Similarly, an elastic potential for the flocked fabrics is introduced. Let us distinguish the
      relations using the index «flock»:

                                                        2
E3S Web of Conferences 274, 11005 (2021)                                       https://doi.org/10.1051/e3sconf/202127411005
STCCE – 2021

                W flock = D110
                            flock 2          flock 4
                                 ε11 / 2 + D112                flock
                                                  ε11 / 12 + D120                flock 2
                                                                     ε11ε 22 + D220   ε 22 / 2 +
                    flock 4            flock 2           flock 6                                         (2)
                + D222   ε 22 / 12 + D330   γ 12 / 2 + D334   γ 12 / 30

     In the increments, a connection of the line forces through the increments of strains is
     written in the form:
                                   d {N } = [ D]d {ε } ,                        (3)

     where
                                 d 2W        d 2W         d 2W          d 2W
               =D11               = 2
                                       , D22  =  2
                                                    , D33 =   2
                                                                 , D12           .                       (4)
                                 d ε11       d ε 22       d γ 12       d ε11ε 22
     Then, according to (1), (3) the expressions for the stiffness characteristics of the non-
     flocked fabrics are obtained Dijfabr :
                          D11fabr =D110 + D112ε11  2
                                                      , D22fabr =              2
                                                                  D220 + D222ε 22
                         
                               fabr          fabr
                          D12
                         =          D=
                                     120 , D21        D12fabr
                           fabr                    4
                                                                                                         (5)
                              = D330 + D334γ 12
                           D33
                           fabr      fabr       fabr        fabr
                           D=
                              23    D=
                                     32       D=13        D=31    0
     The elastic law in the laboratory coordinate system x y , i.e. in the axes, being parallel to
     the edges of the test rectangular fabrics sample, shown in Fig. 1, takes the form:
                                                                          2
                                                                                                 
                                                                    Cos α      Sin 2α  − Sin 2α 
                                                                                                
          d {N } = [ D ]d {ε} ,   [ D ] = [T ] [ D] [T ]T , Т =  Sin 2α   Cos 2α    Sin 2α         (6)
                                                                     Sin 2α   − Sin 2α          
                                                                                        Cos 2α 
                                                                     2            2             
     For a numerical analysis of the strain process of the fabrics samples, the principle of
     Lagrange in the increments was used in the form:
                                    T             T
                                ∫ ∆N δε d Ω = ∫ ∆p δ u ,                         (7)
                                          Ω                 ω
     here Ω is an area occupied by a fabrics sample, ω is its boundary, ∆p is an increment of the
     vector of the line forces, applied at this boundary, δε, δu are variations of the vectors of
     strains and movements. For a discretisation of the area, the FEM (finite element method)
     was used with a six-nodal triangular element of the second order [21].
         For taking into account an inability of the fabrics to perceive the compressive load, the
     following approach was used. At each step of the load increment, the power field was
     analyzed Nij . If along the basics or the weft, the efforts N11 or N 22 took negative values,
     then at this step, according to the stiffness, D11 or D22 decreased by several orders of
     magnitude (in our case, 500 times). After that, a solution of the equation (7) was re-
     conducted, and the efforts were recalculated. This procedure was repeated until the field of
     strains and efforts became stabilized.

     2.2 Method of determining the mechanical characteristics
     Let it be considered known the test findings of the structures with measurement of external
     influences, and the parameters of the mathematical model of behavior of the material and
     structures are the desired. The parameters of the models will be chosen so that the results of
     the numerical calculation and test findings were close based on a minimality of the
     quadratic residuality between the calculated and experimental results [22-24]:

                                                                  3
E3S Web of Conferences 274, 11005 (2021)                                                         https://doi.org/10.1051/e3sconf/202127411005
STCCE – 2021

          =δ 2 (v1[( P)exp − ( P)* ]2 + m1 [∆a exp − ∆a* ]2 + k1[∆bexp − ∆b* ]2 )                                      α1 +

                (v2 [( P )exp − ( P )* ]2 + m2 [∆a exp − ∆a* ]2 + k2 [∆bexp − ∆b* ]2 )                       α2 +
                                                                                                                                (8)
                ............................................................................................. +
                + (vn [( P )exp − ( P )* ]2 + mn [∆a exp − ∆a* ]2 + kn [∆bexp − ∆b* ]2 )                          αn   .

      Here n is a number of the performed, ∆а* , ∆b* , ∆а exp , ∆bexp are calculated and experimental
      values of changes in the sides of the sample in the longitudinal and transverse directions,
      respectively (Fig. 1), α1,α 2 ,....α n are the angles between the base and the long side of the
      sample, v1,..., vn , m1,..mn , k1,...kn are the weight coefficients.

                                                    9
                                                    8
                                                    7
                                                    6
                                                    5
                                             P(H)

                                                    4
                                                    3
                                                    2
                                                    1
                                                    0
                                                        0       5          10         15         20         25             30
                                                                       elongation
                                                                          Удлинение (%)

                                                               grad(экспер)
                                                             0 град  (exp)                        grad
                                                                                              0 град   (mod)
                                                                                                     (модель)
                                                               grad  (exp)
                                                            30 град (экспер)                      grad(модель)
                                                                                              30 град   (mod)
                                                            45 grad  (exp)
                                                               град(экспер)                       grad (mod)
                                                                                              45 град(модель)
                                                               grad  (exp)
                                                            90 град(экспер)                       grad (mod)
                                                                                              90 град(модель)

      Fig. 2. Dependence of the average force at the end Р on the elongation of the experimental data and
      the theoretical curve according to the obtained stiffness characteristics of the polyester tissue,
      subjected to a cold plasma treatment during 180 sec.
      The stiffness characteristics D110 , D114 , D220 , D224 , D120 , D330 , D334 . are unknown. In this case,
      the following restriction must be fulfilled:
                                                    2
                                      D11 D22 − D12     >0                                         (9)
                                                          2
      The condition (9) will be satisfied if D110 D220 − D120 > 0 is accepted. To find the minimum
      δ 2 the standard gradient methods were used. The stiffness characteristics
       D110 , D112 , D220 , D222 , D120 , D330 , D334 were determined for the both flocked and original
      fabricss, based on the data analysis of the sample tests, cut out at the different angles
      (00 ,900 , 450 ,300 ) to the base under different stretching forces.
         In order to refine the techniques, the above approach was first tested on the following
      problem. A direct problem was solved with the given stiffness characteristics for the
      samples cut out at the different angles 00 ,900 , 450 . The results obtained were considered
      «experimental». Then a inverse problem was solved on the basis of the obtained
      «experiments», i.e. the stiffness characteristics of this mathematical model were

                                                                                4
E3S Web of Conferences 274, 11005 (2021)                                  https://doi.org/10.1051/e3sconf/202127411005
STCCE – 2021

     determined. The results showed the efficiency of the techniques and the developed
     program.

     2.3 Verification of the techniques by the example of determining the stiffness
     characteristics for the fabrics subjected to the treatment with a low-
     temperature plasma

     Further, the results of the experiments were analyzed, where the polyester fabrics, treated
     during 180 sec. with a cold plasma, was considered as an experimental sample. A loading
     diagram of the sample is shown on Fig.1. An identification of the unknown
     D220 , D222 , D120 , D330 , D334 was carried out according to the experimental data for the low-
     temperature plasma-modified fabrics samples, cut out at the angles to the base 00 , 900 , 450 .
     The sample, cut out at the angle 300 to the base, was considered a control one.
         As a result, the following stiffness characteristics were obtained for the polyester fabrics
     treated with a cold plasma:
                   D110 1.2,
                   =     =   D112 5900,
                                     =  D220 0.835, D222 = 1000,
                                                                                                    (10)
                        D120 = 0.178, D330 = 0.045, D334 = 2
     In (10), the stiffness coefficients have a number of dimensions [MPa* mm] .
         Next, the dependence P(∆a) was calculated for the angles 00 , 900 , 450 , as well as for
     the control sample with an angle of inclination to the base α = 300 . The results are shown in
     Fig. 2. It is seen that the results obtained are in good agreement with the experiment.

     2.4 Determination of the stiffness characteristics for the original fabrics,
     fabrics with glue and flocked fabrics from the results of the stretching
     experiments
     This section presents the results of processing the experimental data for the original fabrics,
     fabrics with an adhesive layer and flocked fabrics in order to determine the stiffness
     characteristics of the fabrics, glue and flocked layer. The stiffness characteristics Dij for the
     fabrics were also taken in the form (5). For performing numerical calculations, the
     experiments were used carried out for the samples which were cut out at the angles
      00 , 900 , 450 ,300 . In contrast to the previous case, these experiments do not know the values
      ∆b - changes in the transverse dimensions of the sample. However, in this case, it is
     possible to determine 4 functions Dij , but already based on the test results of 4 samples cut
     out at the different angles to the base α .
         After processing the experiments for the original fabrics, the following stiffness
     characteristics were obtained (fabrics thickness was 0.15 mm, a number of dimensions Dijk
     - [MPa* mm] ):
           ( D110 ) fabr = 8, ( D112 ) fabr = 43000, ( D220 ) fabr = 3.5,( D222 ) fabr = 3500,
                                                                                                    (11)
           ( D120 ) fabr = 0.97, ( D330 ) fabr = 0.17, ( D334 ) fabr = 195.
        For the tissie with glue, the following results were obtained (the thickness of the raw
     glue was 0.2 mm):

                                                             5
E3S Web of Conferences 274, 11005 (2021)                                   https://doi.org/10.1051/e3sconf/202127411005
STCCE – 2021

                       ( D110 ) fabr + qlue = 21, ( D112 ) fabr + qlue = 49000,
                        ( D220 ) fabr + qlue = 5.049, ( D222 ) fabr + qlue = 4000,
                                                                                                     (12)
                       ( D120 ) fabr + qlue = 0.97, ( D330 ) fabr + qlue = 0.26,
                        ( D334 ) fabr + qlue = 235.
      For the flocked fabrics it was found (the thickness of the flocked fabrics was 0.65 mm):
                            ( D110 ) flock = 26, ( D112 ) flock = 55500,
                            ( D220 ) flock = 6, ( D222 ) flock = 4100,
                                                                                                     (13)
                            ( D222 ) flock = 4100, ( D120 ) flock = 0.97,
                             ( D330 ) flock = 0.27, ( D334 ) flock = 235.5.
      It was found that the experimental results and the curves, obtained according to the
      developed model, are in good agreement with each other. The residuals have the values
      about 10 %.

      2.5 Possibility of applying the theory of mixtures when making calculation of
      a flocked fabrics for stretching

      This section presents the results of a study of two approaches to solving the problem of
      stretching fabrics samples. In the first one, the theory of mixtures is used, and in the second
      one, a pattern configuration of the flocked part of the fabrics is taken into account. In this
      case, a hypothetical flocked fabrics was considered, in which the stiffness of the flocked
      part could be higher than that of the real one. This excess was determined by the coefficient
       R = D flock / D0flock , where the components of the matrix D0flock were determined by the
      relations (13).
          The dependences of the force P were determined, which is required for elongation of
      the sample by 20 %, on the fraction of the area of the flocked part of the fabrics at the
      different R, obtained with an accurate account of the pattern configuration of the flocked
      part, and also obtained according to the theory of mixtures. In the latter case, it was
      assumed that:
                            Dijs = Dijfabr (1 − А flock ) + Dijflock A flock ,        (14)
      where А flock is a specific area of the flocked part.
          An analysis of the numerical experiments shows that, in our case, the formula of
      mixtures for the practical calculations can be applied with an error of about 5%, if the
      stiffnesses of the flocked part differ from the stiffness of the fabrics by no more than an
      order of magnitude.

      2.6 Dependence of the stiffness characteristics of flocked fabrics on the
      thickness of the raw glue
      Further, a possibility of using the theory of mixtures for averaging the stiffness
      characteristics with respect to thickness was studied. According to this theory, the
      components of the stiffness matrix of the glued fabrics can be represented as:
                                    D fabr=
                                          + qlue
                                                 Dijfabr + Dijqlue .                                 (15)
                                      ij

      The adhesive coating was assumed to be isotropic:

                                                             6
E3S Web of Conferences 274, 11005 (2021)                                                       https://doi.org/10.1051/e3sconf/202127411005
STCCE – 2021

                                               qlue    qlue    qlue    qlue
                                              D11   = D22   , D12   = D21   ,
                                              qlue
                                             D11   = Eqlue h qlue / (1 − ν qlue
                                                                           2
                                                                                ),                                                  (16)
                                               qlue             qlue
                                              D12     = ν qlue D11       .

     For the fabrics, the relations (4) were used.
         As shown by processing of the experimental data in determining the stiffness of a
     fabrics composite material by averaging the stiffness of the fabrics and glue with respect to
     thickness, the theory of mixtures (15) does not allow determining the parameters D qlue
     with an acceptable accuracy from the discrepancy between the experimental and numerical
     results.
         Therefore, to calculate stiffnesses of the flocked fabrics, depending on a thickness of the
     glue, it is necessary to take some other approaches. The simplest is a method of expanding
     these ratios in a series in terms of the degrees of a thickness of the raw glue h qlue .
     Since in the above experiments the stiffness characteristics were obtained only for two
     cases (for the initial fabrics and for the fabrics in which a thickness of the raw glue h qlue is
     0.2 mm), it is possible to use a polynomial of only the 1st order.
         Then the stiffness characteristics for the flocked fabrics can be represented as:
                                                                         h qlue                               h qlue
                     h qlue                       2     0.2 − h                                 2     h
            D11 (h            , ε11 ) =(8 + 43000ε11 )⋅                           + (26 + 55500ε11 )⋅                   ,
                                                                      0.2                                     0.2
                                                                               qlue                            qlue
                       qlue                                        0.2 − h h                                 hh
            D22 (h h                                  2
                              , ε 22 ) = (3.5 + 3500ε 22 )⋅                                          2
                                                                                        + (6 + 4100ε 22 )⋅        ,
                                                                       0.2                                    0.2
                                                                                                                                    (17)
                                                                               h qlue                                  h qlue
                     h qlue                               4     0.2 − h                                   4     h
            D33 (h            , γ 12 ) =   (0.17 + 194.5γ 12 )⋅                          + (0.27 + 235.5γ 12 )⋅                 ,
                                                                         0.2                                           0.2
                                                          qlue                  qlue
                       qlue                   0.2 − h h                      hh
            D12 (h h          ) = 0.978 ⋅                        + 0.978 ⋅        ,
                                                  0.2                         0.2
     where h qlue is a thickness of the raw glue.

     4 Discussions
     The developed techniques for determining the stiffness characteristics of the flocked
     fabrics, based on the results of testing the samples, cut off at the different angles
      00 ,900 ,300 , 450 to the base under different stretching forces, made it possible to analyze the
     effect of flocking on its mechanical characteristics. It was revealed that the theory of
     mixtures, when averaging the properties of the fabrics and glue with respect to thickness,
     does not allow determining the stiffness characteristics with acceptable accuracy. The limits
     of applicability of the theory of mixtures were determined when carrying out averaging of
     the mechanical characteristics with respect to the area of the flocked fabrics.

     Acknowledgements
     The work was performed within the framework of the Russian Foundation for Basic Research (project
     No. 19-08-00349) and the Russian Science Foundation (project No. 19-19-00059).

                                                                              7
E3S Web of Conferences 274, 11005 (2021)                     https://doi.org/10.1051/e3sconf/202127411005
STCCE – 2021

      References
      1. V. V. Khammatova, Influence of the multipacting plasma on the structure and physical
         and mechanical properties of textile fibers, Chemical fibers, 4, 47-49 (2005)
      2. M. N. Serazutdinov, R. A. Kayumov, Calculation of the strain properties of textile
         materials, News of universities. Technology of Textile industry, 5, 34-38 (2006)
      3. I. Sh. Abdullin, V. V. Khammatova, Influence of low-temperature plasma flow on the
         properties of textile materials (Publish. house of Kazan University, Kazan, 2003)
      4. R. A. Kayumov, I. Sh. Abdullin, M. N. Serazutdinov, V. V. Khammatova, I. Z.
          Mukhamedova, E. V. Kumpan, A. M. Shakirova, Physically nonlinear model of the
          fabrics materials processed in a high-frequency plasma flow, Bulletin of Kazan
          Technological University, 6, 42-53 (2010)
      5. I. Sh. Abdullin, V. V. Khammatova, E. V. Kumpan, Experimental studies of the
          influence of the multipacting plasma on the adhesive properties of composite materials,
          Applied Physics, 6, 92-94 (2005)
      6. M. F. Shaekhov, V. I. Khristolyubova, A. A. Rushintsev, V. E. Gorelysheva, Study of
          the characteristics of the high-frequency discharge flow of low pressure in
          technological processes of the diffusion formation of coatings on the products of
          complex configuration, Bulletin of the Technological University, 19(13), 98-100 (2016)
      7. I. Besshaposhnikova, S. E. Artemenko, L. G. Panova, T. V. Kulikova, O. A. Grishina,
          V. A. Steinle, M. V. Zagoruiko, Fire retardant modification of synthetic materials
          under the influence of laser radiation, Chemical fibers, 1, 48-51 (2008)
      8. W. N. W Ismail. Sol-gel technology for innovative fabric finishing – A Review, J Sol-
          Gel Sci. Technol, 78, 698-707 (2016)
      9. J. Foksowicz-Flaczyk, J. Walentowska, M.Przybylak, H. Maciejewski. Multifunctional
          durable properties of textile materials modified by biocidal agents in the sol-gel
          process, Surf. Coat. Technol, 304, 160-166 (2016) DOI:10.1016/j.surfcoat.2016.06.062
      10. X. Guo, Q. Zhang, X. Ding, Q. Shen, C. Wu, L. Zhang, H.Yang. Synthesis and
          application of several sol-gel-derived materials via sol-gel process combining with
          other technologies: a review, Sol-Gel Sci. Technol, 79, 328-358 (2016) DOI:
          10.1007/s10971-015-3935-6
      11. M. Grace, N. Chand, S. Kumar Bajpai. Copper Alginate-Cotton Cellulose (CACC)
          Fibers with Excellent Antibacterial Properties, Journal of Engineered Fibers and
          Fabrics, 4, 24-35 (2009) DOI: 10.1177/155892500900400303
      12. H. E. Emam, A. P. Manian, B. Siroka, H. Duelli, P. Merschak, B. Redl, Th. Bechtold.
          Copper (I) oxide surface modified cellulose fibers—Synthesis, characterization and
          antimicrobial properties, Surface & Coatings Technology, 254, 344-351 (2014) DOI:
          10.1016/j.surfcoat.2014.06.036
      13. A. Burkitbay, B.R. Taussarova. A.Z. Kutzhanova, S.M. Rakhimovu. Development of a
          Polymeric Composition for Antimicrobial Finish of Cotton Fabrics, Fibers & Textiles in
          Eastern Europe, 2(104), 96-101 (2014)
      14. B. R. Tausarova, S. M. Rakhimova. Cellulosic materials with antibacterial properties
          modified with copper nanoparticles, Chemistry of plant raw materials, 1, 163-169
          (2018)
      15. A. G. Hassabo, М. Е. Kl-Naggar, A. L. Mohamed, A. Ali, A.A. Hebeish Development
          of multifunctional modified cotton fabric with tricomponent-nanoparticlcs of silver,
          copper and zincoxide, Carbohydrate Polymers, 210, 144-156 (2019)
      16. Q. Xu, X. Ke, N. Ge, L. Shcn, Y. Zhang, F. Fu, X. Liu. Preparation of Copper
          Nanoparticles Coated Cotton Fabrics with Durable Antibacterial Properties, Fibers and
          Polymers, 19, 1004-1013 (2018) DOI: 10.1007/s12221-018-8067-5

                                                  8
E3S Web of Conferences 274, 11005 (2021)                    https://doi.org/10.1051/e3sconf/202127411005
STCCE – 2021

     17. V.A. Semenov. Theory and practice of electroflocking (Publishing house of VZPI,
        Moscow, 1992)
     18. L. V. Lobova, N. E. Bershev, I. A. Khromeeva. Superinsulating flocked material,
        Technical textiles, 2, 33-35 (2001)
     19. O. M. Ivanov, E. N. Bershev. Determination of the limiting characteristics of the
        flocking process, Electronic processing of materials, 4, 34-37 (1988)
     20. E. H. Bershev, O. M. Ivanov, I.O. Red'kin. Comparison of the efficiency of flock
         application on textile material during electroflocking by various methods, News of
         universities. Ser. Technology of Textile industry, 4, 35-38 (1987)
     21. I. F. Obraztsov, L. M. Saveliev, Kh.S. Khazanov. Finite Element Method in Problems
         of Aircraft Structural Mechanics (Higher school, Moscow, 1985)
     22. R. A. Kayumov, R. O. Nezhdanov, B.F. Tazyukov. Determination of the characteristics
         of fibrous composite materials by identification methods (Publishing house of KSU,
         Kazan, 2005)
     23. V. G. Nizameev, F. F. Basharov. The method of optimization of design parameters of
         truss plates for profiled flooring, Science prospects 7(106), 81-87 (2018)
     24. V. G. Nizameev, F. F. Basharov. The study of the bearing capacity of profiled flooring
         with the truss system, Science and business development ways 6(84), 76-81 (2018)

                                                  9
You can also read