Tectonic evolution of the San Juan Islands thrust system, Washington

Page created by Charlie Keller
 
CONTINUE READING
The Geological Society of America
                                                                        Field Guide 9
                                                                             2007

Tectonic evolution of the San Juan Islands thrust system, Washington

                                                           E.H. Brown
                                                           B.A. Housen
                                                          E.R. Schermer
                      Department of Geology, Western Washington University, Bellingham, Washington 98225, USA

                                                                        ABSTRACT

                             The mid-Cretaceous San Juan Islands–northwest Cascades thrust system is
                        made up of six or more nappes that are a few kilometers or less thick, up to one
                        hundred kilometers in breadth, and that were derived from previously accreted
                        Paleozoic and Mesozoic terranes. This field trip addresses many questions regard-
                        ing the tectonic evolution of this structural complex, including the homeland of the
                        terranes and the process of post-accretionary dispersal that brought them together,
                        how thrusting in the San Juan Islands might have been related to coeval orogenic
                        activity in the neighboring Coast Plutonic Complex, and the origin of blueschist
                        metamorphism in the thrust system relative to subduction and nappe emplacement.
                        The geology of this trip has many counterparts in other outboard regions of the
                        Cordillera, but some aspects of the tectonic processes, as we understand them to
                        date, seem to be unique.

                            Keywords: San Juan Islands, thrust faults, terranes, blueschist metamorphism, kine-
                        matic analysis, paleomagnetism.

INTRODUCTION                                                                       San Juan Islands–northwest Cascades thrust system are poorly
                                                                                   known and have been the focus of our recent work.
     Rocks and structures of the San Juan Islands of northwest                          Many aspects of the lithology, structure, and metamorphism
Washington record a long and complex history related to Cor-                       are similar to the Mesozoic evolution of other parts of the Cordil-
dilleran convergent margin tectonism. The area is underlain by                     lera; other aspects may be unique to the San Juan Islands. The east-
the San Juan Islands–northwest Cascades thrust system, made                        west transect across the San Juan Islands during this field trip will
up of nappes a few kilometers or less thick and up to 100 km in                    highlight the different terranes juxtaposed by the thrust system,
breadth (Figs. 1, 2), thrust onto the continental margin during                    and structures formed before, during and after high-pressure–
mid-Cretaceous time (e.g., Misch, 1966; Brown, 1987; Bran-                         low-temperature (HP-LT) metamorphism. The trip builds on ear-
don et al., 1988). The nappes have an oceanic history, indicat-                    lier work that identified the main terranes and structures in the
ing accretion to the edge of the North American continent, but                     San Juan thrust system (e.g., McClellan, 1927; Danner, 1966;
they also bear clear evidence of interaction with the continen-                    Vance, 1975; Whetten et al., 1978; Brandon et al., 1988). Our
tal margin long preceding their emplacement in Washington.                         recent results on structure, metamorphism, geochronology, and
Their mid-Cretaceous arrival in Washington as thrust sheets                        paleomagnetism will provide a forum for discussions that bear
was likely the consequence of some type of post-accretionary                       on the tectonic history and correlation with other Cordilleran
fragmentation and dispersal. The timing and mechanisms of the                      terranes. We will compare and contrast units from the external,
accretion, dispersal and final emplacement of terranes of the                      unmetamorphosed parts of the thrust system to the more internal
Brown, E.H., Housen, B.A., and Schermer, E.R., 2007, Tectonic evolution of the San Juan Islands thrust system, Washington, in Stelling, P., and Tucker, D.S., eds.,
Floods, Faults, and Fire: Geological Field Trips in Washington State and Southwest British Columbia: Geological Society of America Field Guide 9, p. 143–177,
doi: 10.1130/2007.fld009(08). For permission to copy, contact editing@geosociety.org. ©2007 The Geological Society of America. All rights reserved.

                                                                               143
144                                                                                                                 Brown et al.

                                                                                                                             Figure 1. Regional setting of the San Juan Islands—northwest Cas-
                                                                                                                             cades area in the northwest Cordillera. AX—Alexandria; BA—Baker
           CH                                                                                                                terrane; CC—Cache Creek terrane of Miller (1987); CH—Chugach
                AX
                                                                                                                             terrane; EK—Eastern Klamath terrane; FR—Franciscan complex;
                                                                                                                             GV—Gravina belt; GVS—Great Valley sequence; H—Huntington
56
                                                                                                                             terrane; IZ—Izee terrane; MT—Methow basin; QS—Quesnellia;
13                                                                                                                           SC–FR—Straight Creek–Fraser River fault; SF—Shoo Fly complex;
  5                                                                                                                          ST—Stikinia; WA—Wallowa terrane; WJ—Western Jurassic belt;
                   GV                        ST
                                                                                                                             WR—Wrangellia; WTrPz—Western Triassic and Paleozoic belt;
            AX           YT                                                                                                  YT—Yukon-Tanana terrane. Sources: Burchfiel et al. (1992a); Gehrels
                                                128
                                                                                                                             and Kapp (1998); Wheeler and McFeely (1991). B.C.—British
                                                 56
                 AK                                                                                                          Columbia; CA—California; cc—Cache Creek belt; Cz—Cenozoic
                B.C                                                                                                          rocks and surficial deposits; ID—Idaho; mc—McCloud belt of Miller
                    .
     WR                                                                                                                      (1987); OR—Oregon; NV—Nevada; Wash.—Washington.
                                                           CC
                                                               cc       QS
                                 COA

                                                                                                                             units that experienced subduction and HP-LT metamorphism. In
                                                                                                                             particular, we would like to consider how the geology of the area
                                  ST

                                                     ST
                                                      mc                                                                     relates to various hypotheses regarding the origin and paleogeog-
                                     PLU

                                                                                                                             raphy of the terranes, and the evolution of deformation before,
                                                     Ya

     130                                                                                                                     during, and after emplacement in their current location.
                                                       la
                                       TON

                                                          co

      50
                                                            m

                                                    MT
                                                               fa

                                                                           SC-FR fault
                                                                 ul
                                           IC

                                                                    t

                                                                                                                             TECTONIC SETTING
                                                C
                                                 O

                                WR
                                                    M

                                                      P
                                                          LE                              QS                                      The San Juan Islands–northwest Cascades thrust system lies
                                                               X                              mc
                                                                                                                             at the south end of the 1500 km long Coast Plutonic Complex,
                                                                                                                             a belt of continental arc plutons and metamorphic country rock
                                                                                                                        50
                                                                        MT                    B.C.                116        that formed from Late Jurassic to Early Cenozoic (Figs. 1, 2).
           Fig. 2                                                                         Q S Wash.                          Outboard of the Coast Plutonic Complex and intruded by it is
                                                                    CP                                                       the Insular superterrane composed of the co-joined Wrangellia
                                                                        C
                                                                                                                             and Alexander terranes. Inboard of the Coast Plutonic Complex
                                                                                                            ID               are rocks of the Early Cretaceous continental margin, including
                                                                                         Cz                                  the Methow stratigraphic sequence in Washington. Detritus, cur-
                                                                                                                             rent indicators and stratigraphy in the Methow sequence indicate
                                            Columbia                                                                         absence of an outboard sediment source until ca. 110 Ma (Ten-
                                                                                                             46              nyson and Cole, 1978; Haugerud et al., 2002), thus we view the
                                                Embayment                                            WA
                                Cz                                                                                           locale of the Washington Cascades and San Juan Islands as an
                                                                                          BA
                                                                                               cc
                                                 OR                                                  H
                                                                                                                             ocean basin until that time. Major orogenic activity characterizes
                                                                      IZ
                                                                                                                             the region from ca. 110–80 Ma, during which nappes of the San
                                 WJ                                            Blue Mtns.
     42                                                                                                                      Juan Islands–northwest Cascades thrust system were emplaced,
      125                  cc                                                                                                the Coast Plutonic Complex was intruded by voluminous arc
                                                    200 kilometers
                           z

                                                                                                                             plutons, and country rock of the complex was locally buried to
                            P
                         Tr
                        W

                   cc             Klamath                                                                                    depths of up to 35 km (in the “Cascade crystalline core”; Figs. 2
                          EK                                                                           42
                          mc
                                  Mountains
                                                                                                    116                      and 3) and was deformed by orogen-normal and orogen-parallel
            FR                    CA                                                                                         displacements. Overlapping the waning stages of this orogenic
                                                                        NV
                                                    No.                                                                      pulse was development of the Nanaimo stratigraphic sequence,
                                                    Sierra                                                                   bearing detritus from the San Juan Islands–northwest Cascades
                                  cc SF
                                                                                                                             thrust system as well as from the Coast Plutonic Complex, in
                          GVS
                                       mc                                                                                    an elongate basin extending north from the San Juan Islands. In
                                                                                                                             Eocene time the orogen was cut obliquely and displaced ~170 km
                                                                                                                             (estimates range from 90 to 190 km; e.g., Vance, 1985; Misch,
                                                                                                                             1977) by the N-S dextral, strike-slip Straight Creek–Fraser River
                                                                                                                             fault system. Restoration of the fault shows the San Juan Islands–
                                                                                                                             northwest Cascades thrust system to have lain along the southern
                                                                                                                             margin of Wrangellia and the Coast Plutonic Complex (Fig. 3)
123
                                                                          CPC
                                          Q
                                              B.C.                                VC                                           CH
                                              WA                                                                                                         HZ
               NA                                                                NORTHWEST
WR
                                                                                       YA                                                      T
                                                         BP
                            ES                                                                                                                                        121
               HS                TB                                                                                                                                      49
         A                                                CZ
                                   LM                                               NK
                                                                                   Mt Baker
     OC      CO                            EA

                                                                                                                                                        Ros
       GA                                                           CH      TS YA                                                         A'

                                                                                                                                                         s Lak
                              FC                                                                                                EA
                                                                                       NK
                                                                    EA

                                                                                                                                                          e fault
                    LS
                                                                                              CH
       SAN JUAN                                 LS HH                     CASCADES
       ISLANDS
                                                                           HH
                                                             EM
                                                                            D
                                                                  Me

                                                                                 DM
                                                                    lan

                                                                                   F
                                                                     ge B

                                                    Q                            EM
                                                               WM                                                                   CRYSTALLINE
                                                                          elts

       N                                                                                                                                           T
                     PUGET
                                                                                                                                                          88-96 Ma
                           SOUND                                        WM                                                          CORE                  plutons
                                                                                                                                                   48
       30 kilometers
                                                              T                                                                      CW
                                                                                                                     . fault
                                                                                              Straight Ck. - Fraser R

                                                                                                                        TG
                                                                                                                                                                    CN

                                                                                                                                                                    Windy
                                                                                                                               CN                                   Pass
                                                                                                                                                                    Thrust
                                                                                                                                                   MS
                                                                    T                                                                 ING

                                                                                                                                EA
   A
Figure 2 (on this and following page). San Juan Islands–northwest Cascades thrust system and surroundings. Based on compilation by Brown
and Dragovich (2003) and references therein. Abbreviations given in Table 1. (A) Map. B.C.—British Columbia; WA—Washington.
146                                                                 Brown et al.

A                                                                                                                                                                                                               A'
                                                                                                                                                          Mt Baker
                                     Lummi                                                           Twin Sisters                                         window
           Orcas Island                                                                                                                                                        Shuksan             Chilliwack
                                     Island                                                           Range                                         YA                          thrust             batholith
                      GA                                                                                       VC
    NA             OC       FC                                                                    YA
                                   FC                                                                     TS
                       CO               LM                   CN               EA                     CH                                                                                  EA                      SL
                                                       EA                                                  BP                                                                 CH
    HS           TB    ES    TB                                                                                                                           NK
                                   ES                  OC                       BP                        CH                                                                              BP
                                                                                 CH                                                                                                                       CC
                                                                                                          NK
    WRANGELLIA
                                               depositional or intrusive contact                                                                               10 km                            Straight
 B                                             fault contact                                                                                          no vertical exaggeration                 Creek fault

                                                   Figure 2 (continued). (B) Cross section.

in Late Cretaceous time. South of this orogenic complex is the                                                                                                                Q
                                                                                                                                                                                  UE
Columbia Embayment, an area covered primarily by Cenozoic                                                                                                                           SN
                                                                                         Mid-Late                                                                                        ELLI
                                                                                                                                                                                             A
volcanic rocks, thought to be underlain by primitive crust, and                          Cretaceous                                                                           MT
                                                                                                                                                                                           B.C.
                                                                                         Plutons
considered in some models to be a possible homeland for the                                                                                                                                WA
                                                                                                                                                                              Ro
thrust system nappes (e.g., Davis et al., 1978; Vance et al., 1980).                                                              Jur. -                                        s s
                                                                                                                                                                               HZ Lake
East and south of the Columbia Embayment are accreted terranes                                                                                                  SE                        Fa
                                                                                                                                               E. Cret.          SE                          ult
of the Blue Mountains, and Klamath Mountains respectively                                N
                                                                                                                                                                                                   Zo
                                                                                                                                                                                                     ne
(Fig. 1), the latter especially bearing similarities to units of the
                                                                                   W                      G                                       Plutons                      CW
San Juan Islands–northwest Cascades thrust system.                                  RA                        eo
                                                                                                                   rg                                                                                 Cascade
                                                                                       NG                               ia                                        HL
                                                                                          EL         N                       S
                                                                                                                                 tr                                                                   Crystalline
                                                                                             LI                                       ai             B.C.
STRUCTURAL STRATIGRAPHY                                                                        A    NA                                     t                                           ING            Core
                                                                                                                                                     WA           NK EA
                                                                                   PRC                                                                                                 EA          WPT
                                                                                                                    N
     The nappe pile of the San Juan Islands–northwest Cascades                                                                                            NWCS                             HB
                                                                                   PACIFIC                                                                NAPPES                          MN
thrust system (Fig. 2) is characterized by mid to late Paleozoic
                                                                                   OCEAN
terranes overlain by Mesozoic terranes. The structurally lowest

                                                                                                                                                                MEL
component of the nappe complex is the East Sound Group in the

                                                                                                                                                                   ANGBELTS
                                                                                         N
San Juan Islands and correlative Chilliwack Group in the Cas-                                             CZ                                                                               CZ

                                                                                                                                                                      E
cades. These are island arc derived sedimentary and volcanic rocks
of Devonian–Permian age (Danner, 1966; Vance, 1975; Misch,                                                                                                                            SC-FR fault
                                                                                                                                                                                      restored
1966; Tabor et al., 2003). Calc-alkaline Devonian plutonic rocks                                    100 KM
presumed to be related to this arc are the Turtleback and Yellow
Aster Complexes of the San Juan Islands and Cascades, respec-                  Figure 3. Regional geology shown with hypothetical restoration of the
tively (Mattinson, 1972; Whetten, et al., 1978; Brandon et al.,                Straight Creek–Fraser River fault. (SC-FR fault) based on ~170 km of
1988; Tabor et al., 2003). This assemblage is likely related to arc            displacement (e.g., Umhoefer and Schiarizza, 1996). Abbreviations:
                                                                               HB—Hicks Butte inlier, HL—Harrison Lake stratigraphic sequence,
rocks that extend from California to northern British Columbia                 MN—Manastash Ridge inlier, PRC—Pacific Rim Complex, SE—
and mark mid-late Paleozoic convergence along the continental                  Settler Schist. See Table 1 for other unit abbreviations.
margin (McCloud belt of Miller, 1987).
     Higher in the nappe pile, in both the San Juan Islands and
Cascades, is a disrupted section including Permian to Juras-                         The highest nappes in the San Juan Islands–northwest Cas-
sic ribbon chert, Permian HP-LT schist, ocean island basalt,                   cades thrust system are Late Jurassic rocks that include ophio-
Permian limestone bearing Tethyan fusulinids (exotic to North                  litic plutonic rocks, mid-oceanic-ridge basalt, ribbon chert, and
America), and other materials (Fig. 2, Table 1). In the San Juan               arc-derived mudstone-sandstone. Units of these upper nappes
Islands, units are Orcas Chert, Deadman Bay Volcanics, and Gar-                that we will examine include rocks in the Lopez fault zone, the
rison Schist (Brandon et al., 1988), observed on this field trip. In           Constitution Formation, Fidalgo Ophiolite and Easton Meta-
the Cascades, this zone is referred to as the Bell Pass Mélange                morphic Suite. These units are closely similar to terranes in the
and in addition to the above mentioned rock types includes the                 western Jurassic belt, Franciscan Complex and Coast Range
10 × 4 km Twin Sisters dunite slab (Tabor et al., 2003). Rocks                 Ophiolite of the Klamath Mountains and California Coast
and structures of this zone are similar to the “Cache Creek belt”              Range (e.g., Brown and Blake, 1987; Garver, 1988; Blake and
of Miller (1987) that extends sporadically from northern British               Engebretson, 1994; J.S. Miller et al., 2003).
Columbia to California and apparently represents accretionary                        The nappe geometry portrayed in Figure 2B and described
mélange of mainly oceanic rocks.                                               above interprets the Cascades and San Juan Islands nappe piles
TABLE 1. KEY TO UNITS
Thrust system units
  EASTON METAMORPHIC SUITE (EA)—Late Jurassic ocean floor and trench deposits, well-recrystallized Early Cretaceous blueschist.
  FIDALGO COMPLEX (FC)—Late Jurassic arc-related ophiolite, minimal fabric, incipient prehnite-pumpellyite metamorphism.
  CONSTITUTION FORMATION (CO)—Late Jurassic trench deposits, minimal fabric, incipient blueschist metamorphism.
  LUMMI FORMATION (LM)—Late Jurassic ocean floor and trench deposits, penetrative fabric, incipient blueschist metamorphism.
  LOPEZ STRUCTURAL COMPLEX (LS)—Jurassic to Early Cretaceous ocean floor and trench deposits, incipient blueschist metamorphism.
  TWIN SISTERS DUNITE (TS)—Mantle-derived ultramafic tectonite.
  TURTLEBACK COMPLEX (TB) and correlative YELLOW ASTER COMPLEX (YA)—early to middle Paleozoic gabbro/tonalite, and paragneiss in YA, minimal
     fabric, amphibolite, greenschist and prehnite-pumpellyite facies metamorphism.
  GARRISON SCHIST (GA) and correlative VEDDER COMPLEX (VC)—ocean floor deposits, Permian epidote-amphibolite and blueschist metamorphism.
  ORCAS CHERT including DEADMAN BAY VOLCANICS (OC) and correlative BELL PASS MELANGE (BP)—Triassic-Jurassic chert, lesser oceanic-island
     basalt in OC and BP; exotic blocks of Early Cretaceous sandstone-argillite, Twin Sisters Dunite, Yellow Aster Complex, and Vedder Complex in BP; Garrison
     Schist and limestone with Permian Tethyan fusulinids in OC.
  EAST SOUND GROUP (ES) and correlative CHILLIWACK GROUP including Cultus Formation (CH)—Silurian to Jurassic island arc, McCloud fauna, minimal
     fabric, incipient blueschist metamorphism.
  NOOKSACK FORMATION (NK)—Jurassic to Early Cretaceous island arc possibly formed contiguous with Wrangellia. Slaty fabric, incipient prehnite-
     pumpellyite metamorphism.
  INGALLS TECTONIC COMPLEX (ING)—Early to Late Jurassic ocean floor and forearc or backarc–related ophiolite, prehnite-pumpellyite metamorphism and
     thermal aureole. Occurs east of the Straight Creek–Fraser River fault, but is correlative with the higher nappes in the thrust system.

Mélange belts
 HELENA-HAYSTACK MELANGE (HH)—serpentinite matrix, blocks of graywacke, mudstone, chert, basalt-rhyolite and 150–170 Ma gabbro-tonalite.
 WESTERN MELANGE BELT (WM)—scaly argillite matrix, blocks are mostly Late Jurassic–earliest Cretaceous lithic sandstone/siltstone, some 150–160 Ma
    gabbro-tonalite blocks.
 EASTERN MELANGE BELT (EM)—mostly meta-chert and greenstone, Devonian-Jurassic fossils, 165–190 Ma tonalite-gabbro, Permian Tethyan fusulinids.

Footwall units to the San Juan Island thrust system
  HARO FORMATION and SPIEDEN GROUP (HS)—Triassic to Early Cretaceous arc-derived sedimentary rocks, zeolite facies metamorphism.
  WRANGELLIA (WR)—Paleozoic arc and Triassic ocean plateau complex, microcontinent, zeolite facies metamorphism.

Cascade crystalline core, part of the Coast Plutonic Complex
 TONGA FORMATION (TG)—Early Cretaceous trench deposits and arc volcaniclastic rock, greenschist and amphibolite facies.
 CHIWAUKUM SCHIST (CW)—Early Cretaceous accretionary complex, Barrovian amphibolite facies metamorphism.

Overlap units
 NANAIMO GP. (NA)—Late Cretaceous epicontinental marine sedimentary rock, zeolite facies.
 CHUCKANUT FORMATION and related units (CN)—Eocene fluviatile sedimentary rock, virtually unmetamorphosed.
148                                                            Brown et al.

to be approximately at the same level and laterally contiguous.        AGE OF THRUSTING
This is based in part on correlations of terranes between the two
regions (as shown in Fig. 2 and Table 1). The structural model              The age of assembly of the nappes is uncertain because
also assumes a simple in-sequence assembly of the nappe pile.          observed structures could potentially have formed during one
Because the stratigraphy is not exposed under the broad nappe of       of many tectonic events, including initial accretion going back
Easton Suite between the Cascades and San Juan Islands, out-of-        to the Paleozoic for the older terranes, post-accretionary ter-
sequence thrust models relating nappes in these two areas could be     rane translation of at least hundreds of kilometers, emplace-
viable. Cowan and Bruhn (1992) proposed that Cascades nappes           ment of nappes into the regional geologic setting of north-
lie at a higher structural level than those in the San Juan Islands.   west Washington, and deformation related to the Eocene and
McGroder (1991) favors a break in continuity of nappes in the          younger fold and thrust belt affecting the Nanaimo Group
hidden zone between the Cascades and San Juan Islands caused           and Chuckanut Formation (England and Calon, 1991). Cer-
by out-of-sequence thrusting and folding of the nappe pile.            tainly some metamorphic fabric and possibly some fault
     Peripheral to the San Juan Islands nappe pile along its           boundaries are inherited from events pre-dating assembly of
northwest flank are the arc-derived Late Triassic Haro Forma-          nappes in their present setting (Brown et al., 2005). However,
tion, the Late Jurassic–Early Cretaceous Spieden Group, and the        there is good evidence for major mid-Cretaceous assembly.
Late Cretaceous Nanaimo Group bearing detritus from the thrust         This deformation is referred here to as the thrusting event.
system. These units lack evidence of HP-LT metamorphism and            Nappes of the thrust system were emplaced and unroofed in
penetrative tectonite fabric, and thus are considered to be “exter-    the San Juan Islands vicinity by the time of deposition of the
nal” to the thrust system (Brandon et al., 1988). Owing to the dif-    Nanaimo Group (Vance, 1975); the oldest part of the Nanaimo
ferent tectonic and metamorphic histories, a fault is assumed to       known to bear detritus from the thrust system is ca. 85 Ma
separate the nappe pile from the external units. This fault, named     (latest Campanian-earliest Santonian; Brandon et al., 1988). A
the Haro fault, cannot be directly observed, but is inferred to dip    maximum age for thrusting in the San Juan Islands is given by
under the nappe pile based on regional dips and a gravity survey       fault juxtaposition of Late Aptian (112–115 Ma) fossiliferous
(Johnson et al., 1986; Palumbo and Brandon, 1990). The Haro            rock with 124 Ma HP-LT metamorphic rock on Lopez Island
fault may have been reactivated during south-vergent thrusting in      (one of our field trip stops). In the Cascades, a population of
the Cowichan fold and thrust belt (England and Calon, 1991).           detrital zircons in the Nooksack Formation (footwall to the
     The ultimate footwall to nappes of the San Juan Islands–          nappes) gives a maximum depositional age of 114 Ma, and a
northwest Cascades thrust system is problematic in the San Juan        large sandstone raft in the Bell Pass Mélange bears 119 Ma
Islands, but clearer in the Cascades. Based on arguments given         detrital zircons (Brown and Gehrels, 2007).
above that external units underlie the San Juan Island nappes and           More precise ages of thrusting are known for two localities:
observation that Wrangellia underlies Nanaimo Group units on           K-Ar whole rock ages of 87 and 93 ± 3 Ma were obtained for two
Vancouver Island, one could infer that Wrangellia is basement          mylonite samples from the west flank of the Twin Sisters Dunite
to the San Juan Island nappes (e.g., Cowan and Bruhn, 1992).           (Armstrong in Brown, 1987). Movement on the Windy Pass
In the Cascades, evidence indicates that nappes are thrust over        thrust is dated at ca. 94 Ma by relationships with U-Pb zircon-
the southern end of the Coast Plutonic Complex. In the central         dated plutons that predate, postdate and are involved in thrusting
Cascades, the Ingalls Complex, a component of the San Juan             (R.B. Miller et al., 2003). Thus, major displacement is broadly
Islands–northwest Cascades thrust system, is thrust over Chi-          bracketed between ca. 115 and 85 Ma based on youngest terranes
waukum Schist and Mount Stuart batholith along the Windy               involved and the age of rocks bearing detritus of the nappes, and
Pass Thrust (Figs. 2, 3; Miller, 1985). In the northwest Cascades,     a more limited time frame is suggested to be ca. 90–95 Ma from
the relatively undeformed Jurassic-Cretaceous Nooksack Group           dated rocks in two fault zones.
which underlies the nappe pile (e.g., Misch, 1966) appears to be a
southern extension of the Harrison Lake stratigraphic sequence in      METAMORPHISM
the southern British Columbia Coast Plutonic Complex (Fig. 3;
Monger and Journeay, 1994). Along its western flank, the Coast              Most units in the San Juan Islands–northwest Cascades
Plutonic Complex is intrusive into Wrangellia. Thus, one inter-        nappe pile show effects of Cretaceous HP-LT metamorphism.
pretation for the regional structure is that Wrangellia and the        The degree of recrystallization and metamorphic fabric devel-
Coast Plutonic Complex constituted a structural block in mid-          opment varies greatly, even within the same units. In the Cas-
Cretaceous time that served as footwall to the San Juan Islands–       cades, evidence of HP-LT metamorphism is found virtually
northwest Cascades thrust system in both the San Juan Islands          in all thrust system units of Jurassic or older age. The blue-
and Cascades (e.g., Brown, 1987; McGroder, 1991; Monger and            schist facies Easton Metamorphic Suite in the Cascades bears
Brown, 2008). Other interpretations place nappes of the San Juan       synkinematic metamorphic minerals dated at 120–130 Ma by
Islands–northwest Cascades thrust system within, and as part of,       K-Ar and Rb-Sr (Brown et al., 1982; Armstrong and Misch,
the country rock of the Coast Plutonic Complex (Monger and             1987). Rock units younger than 120 Ma (Nooksack Forma-
Journeay, 1994; Cowan and Brandon, 1994).                              tion and sandstone in the Bell Pass Mélange) lack definitive
Tectonic evolution of the San Juan Islands thrust system, Washington                                      149

evidence of high-pressure metamorphism. In the San Juan                  TECTONIC EVOLUTION
Islands, aragonite (Fig. 4) and lawsonite are widely devel-
oped in Jurassic and older rocks that are otherwise relatively                A number of features and arguments point to primary accre-
unaltered (Vance, 1968; Glassley et al., 1976). This incipient           tion and residence of terranes of the San Juan Islands–northwest
HP-LT metamorphism has been considered to be related to                  Cascades thrust system along the continental margin prior to
mid-Cretaceous thrusting (Brandon et al., 1988; Maekawa                  mid-Cretaceous assembly in the present nappe pile. As Brandon
and Brown, 1991) but so far the only isotopic ages available,            et al. (1988) note, the presence of detritus in sandstones from
Ar-Ar muscovite, indicate metamorphism at 124 Ma (Brown                  diverse sources, including metamorphic rock, chert, and silicic
et al., 2005) and ca. 137–154 Ma (Lamb, 2000), older than the            arc volcanic rock (e.g., Constitution Formation) suggests prox-
emplacement phase of thrusting.                                          imity to a “continent-like” landmass. They also note that else-
     The age of blueschist metamorphism relative to thrusting            where in the Cordillera correlatives of Paleozoic terranes of the
is critical to understanding the tectonics of the thrust system.         San Juan Islands–northwest Cascades thrust system (e.g., East
If aragonite was formed during thrusting, burial on the order            Sound Group) accreted long before the mid-Cretaceous. Addi-
of 20 km is required at the ~200 °C temperature estimated for            tional arguments and evidence are provided by the: (1) the Yellow
metamorphism (Brandon et al., 1988), indicating a great thick-           Aster Complex (Figs. 2 and 6; Table 1), a pre-Devonian terrane
ness of overlying nappes. An alternative concept that blueschist         with links to the continent indicated by beds of quartz arenite
metamorphism in the thrust system is inherited from an event             and a suite of detrital zircons that match those of the miogeo-
predating nappe emplacement may be possible for the older                cline (Brown and Gehrels, 2007); and (2) Permian blueschist
terranes. However, Schermer et al. (2007) showed that HP-LT              metamorphism in some units (Garrison Schist, Vedder Complex;
metamorphism lasted during several phases of brittle deforma-            Armstrong et al., 1983), indicating that these rocks were involved
tion that followed juxtaposition of the internal San Juan Island         in convergent margin tectonics long before thrusting in the San
nappes, including the late Aptian Richardson rocks. If all of            Juan Islands–northwest Cascades system.
the HP-LT metamorphism in the San Juan Islands is related to                  Although terranes of the thrust system are similar to
the same subduction zone, the time span of deformation and               other outboard units of the Cordillera, especially those in the
metamorphism in that subduction zone could be several tens               Klamath Mountains with which they have been correlated
of millions of years (at least from 124 Ma to some time after            (see below), some aspects of the thrust system are unique.
112 Ma, but likely beginning earlier). The subduction zone               The stacking sequence of the San Juan Islands–northwest
model requires emplacement in the San Juan Islands vicinity              Cascades thrust system is older on the bottom, younger on
after HP-LT conditions ended, and on structures that are not             top, approximately reversed from that generally understood
exposed in the internal nappe pile (Schermer et al., 2007). Fig-         for primary accretion, as in the Klamath Mountains where the
ure 5 summarizes various interpretations of the age of meta-             oldest rocks are on top (Irwin, 1981). The duration of assem-
morphism relative to deformation.                                        bly of the terranes is a few tens of millions of years at most,

                                                                                                                                 1.0 mm

                                 A                                                                         B
Figure 4. Aragonite in the San Juan Islands. (A) Coarse aragonite from marble in the Orcas Chert unit, McGraw-Kittinger quarry, Orcas Island
(Vance, 1977, p. 194). The sample shown is a single crystal exhibiting twin lamellae on a cleavage surface that extends across the entire speci-
men. (B) Aragonite veins crossing foliation in the Constitution Formation, South Beach, San Juan Island.
150                                                           Brown et al.

                                                SW directed
                                                thrusting                                     NW directed
                      Brown, 1987                                                             thrusting
                                                                                                          87-90 Ma
                    NW Cascades            HP-LT            120-130 Ma

                    San Juan Is.                                                        NW directed
                                                                                        thrusting
                     Maekawa &                                                                        HP-LT
                     Brown, 1991                                 penetrative cleavage

                                                                                  SW directed
                                                                                   thrusting      HP-LT
                     Cowan &
                     Brandon, 1994
                                                                                       local          penetrative
                                                                                    cataclasis        cleavage

                                                                      D1                         D2
                                                                    SW-NE                              NW
                                                                   contraction                         thrusting
                    Bergh 2002                                                                          NW-SE
                                                                                                        strike-slip
                                                                       penetrative cleavage
                                                                                                           HP-LT

                                                   penetrative
                     Brown et al.,                 cleavage                                   thrusting
                     2005
                                                                  HP-LT 124 Ma

                                                                    SW-NE contraction
                                                                    NW-SE extension         emplacement
                     Schermer                                                                 in SJI
                     et al, 2007
                                               penetrative
                                               cleavage                    veins & brittle
                                                                             faulting
                                                                                         HP-LT

                                                                               remagnetization
                     Burmester
                     et al. 2000        remagnetization in the eastern SJI sometime during K normal chron
                                                     rotation of SJI rocks after remagnetization

                                     140         130          120          110          100           90              80
                                                                      Ma
                   Figure 5. Interpreted sequence of deformational and metamorphic events in the San Juan Islands
                   (SJI) thrust system presented in different reports. Absolute time of events is for the most part only
                   loosely constrained in the reports referenced here. HP-LT—high-pressure–low-temperature.

much briefer than the ~300 m.y. period of accretion that built         all the Paleozoic rocks. We are not aware of anywhere else
the Klamath complex (Irwin, 1981). Cretaceous blueschist               along the Cordillera that Paleozoic rocks are affected by Cre-
metamorphism in the San Juan Islands–northwest Cascades                taceous blueschist metamorphism. Thus, the building process
thrust system affects not only Jurassic-Cretaceous Franciscan          of the San Juan Island nappe pile is different than that under-
type rocks as in the Klamath Mountains, but also apparently            stood for other parts of the Cordilleran margin.
Cretaceous Rocks
                                      Jurassic Rocks                                         30                        177 Ma

                                                                                                          fossil age
                                                                                                                              SPIEDEN GROUP
                                                                                             25
                                            155 Ma                                                                            Sentinal Island Fm.

                                                                                    Number
                            70                                                               20
                            60
                                                        EASTON SUITE

                  Number
                                                                                             15
                            50

                            40                                                               10

                            30                                                               5
                                                                                                                                224 Ma
                            20                                                               0
                                                                                              80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220 240 260 280 300
                            10                                238 Ma
                            0                                                                        119
                             80       120    160   200         240     280                                                      sandstone in
                                                                                             25
                                            148 Ma                                                                              BELL PASS
                            60                                                                                         165
                                                                                             20                                 MELANGE

                                                                                    Number
                            50                     FIDALGO COMPLEX
                   Number

                                                                                             15
                            40
                                                                                                             143
                            30                                                               10

                                                                                                                                    233
                            20                                                                5

                            10                                237Ma                           0
                                                                                               80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220 240 260 280 300
                            0
                             80       120    160        200    240     280                   3                                  ss in BPM
                            70                                                               1
                                            148 Ma
                            60                                                               200    600          1000 1400      1800 2200   2600

                            50                  LUMMI FORMATION
                   Number

                                                                                                         152 Ma
                            40                                                                        125
                                                                                             30
                            30                                                                                                   TONGA
                                                                                                                                FORMATION
                                                                                    Number

                            20
                                                                                             20
                            10

                            0
                             80       120    160   200         240     280                   10
                                            149 Ma

                            40                                                               0
                                                                                              80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220 240 260 280 300
                                                        CONSTITUTION
                   Number

                            30                           FORMATION
                                                                                             80               153 Ma
                                                                                             70
                            20
                                                                                             60                                 NOOKSACK
                                                                                                                                  GROUP
                                                                                    Number

                            10                                                               50

                                                                                             40
                            0
                             80       120    160               240                           30
                                                        200            280
                                                   Ma                                        20    114 Ma
                                                                                             10
                                                                                             0
                                                                                              80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220 240 260 280 300
                                     Early Paleozoic Rock                                                                Ma

                             25                               1825
                                                                             YELLOW ASTER
                                                                               COMPLEX
                             20

                             15
                   number

                                                                      2069 2321
                             10
                                                                                2528
                                                1404
                                 5                                                                             3316
                                      960

                                 0
                                 800        1200        1600     2000        2400        2800          3200
                                                                  Ma

Figure 6. Detrital zircon age distributions in terranes of the San Juan Islands–northwest Cascades thrust system (Spieden
Group from Housen and Fanning, unpublished; other units from Brown and Gehrels, 2007).
152                                                           Brown et al.

     Notwithstanding the important contributions of many previ-       Islands, respectively, that they interpreted to indicate northwest-
ous studies of the San Juan Islands–northwest Cascades thrust         directed thrusting. Brandon et al. (1993) disputed this conclu-
system, the homeland of the nappes and the tectonic process of        sion for the San Juan Islands, suggesting that lineations mapped
their transport and emplacement remain unresolved issues. Three       by Maekawa and Brown (1991) are the product of differential
published interpretations (Fig. 7) are:                               solution-mass-transfer, not thrusting. Cowan and Brandon (1994)
(1) An orogen-normal contractional model in which the nappes          described folds and Riedel shears in the Lopez and Rosario fault
     formed as continental borderland terranes that were caught       zones that they interpret to indicate southwest transport of the
     in a collision zone between the offshore Wrangellian micro-      nappes (orogen-normal). In the eastern San Juan Islands, Lamb
     continent and North America (Brandon and Cowan, 1985;            (2000) reported northeast vergent (orogen-normal) isoclinal folds
     Brandon et al., 1988; Rubin et al., 1990; McGroder, 1991;        dated by synkinematic mica at ca. 137–154 Ma (see above) in
     Burchfiel et al., 1992b; Cowan and Brandon, 1994; Monger         rocks inferred to be related to the Easton Suite. Bergh (2002)
     and Journeay, 1994).                                             observed folds, stretching lineations, and shear zones in the
(2) A transcurrent-transpressional model in which the nappe ter-      Lopez and Rosario fault zones supporting both orogen-normal
     ranes originally accreted or were deposited south (or north?)    and orogen-parallel displacement and conceived the two-stage
     along the margin from their present location and then moved      model described above and shown in Figures 5 and 7. Burmester
     coastwise, finally stacking up in a reentrant of the continen-   et al. (2000) found that many of the rocks in question have been
     tal margin formed by the south end of Wrangellia (Brown,         reoriented after acquiring their magnetization, which developed
     1987; Maekawa and Brown, 1991; Brown and Dragovich,              during or after the fabric was formed; therefore they suggested
     2003; Monger and Brown, 2008).                                   that the orientation of the fabrics cannot be used to determine
(3) A two-phase model in which terranes were first juxtaposed         direction of transport in the present frame of reference. Brown
     by orogen-normal thrusting along the continental margin          et al. (2005) determined that fabric in blueschist tectonite of the
     south of Wrangellia, and then underwent orogen-parallel          Lopez fault zone predates thrusting and they suggested that much
     thrusting and strike-slip faulting (Bergh, 2002).                of the kinematic analysis in the San Juan Islands has been carried
     Resolution of the emplacement history of the San Juan            out on similar pre-thrust fabric and therefore may not be use-
Islands–northwest Cascades thrust system is central to our            ful in understanding emplacement of the nappes. Gillaspy (2004)
understanding of mid-Cretaceous orogeny in the Pacific North-         and Schermer et al. (2007) found that faults and extension veins
west, including: the cause of crustal thickening and Barrovian        indicate a protracted period of orogen-normal shortening coupled
metamorphism in the crystalline core, the origin of the Nanaimo       with orogen-parallel extension during aragonite metamorphism
basin, and the configuration of terranes along the North American     that postdates thrusting, juxtaposition of the terranes, and pene-
margin in the Early Cretaceous. On a broader regional scale, the      trative fabric formation. The different interpretations are summa-
San Juan Islands–northwest Cascades thrust system is relevant         rized in Figure 5. To more effectively make use of these structural
to understanding evolution of the 1500-km-long Coast Plutonic         observations, the challenge for future workers is to understand
Complex which extends from northwest Washington to Alaska.            the age of outcrop-scale structures relative to the age of emplace-
Based on their interpretation as orogen-normal contractional          ment of the nappes.
features, thrusts of the San Juan Islands and northwest Cascades
have been correlated with thrusts in northern British Columbia        Regional Considerations
and Alaska and cited as evidence for a west-vergent thrust sys-
tem that extends virtually the entire length of the Coast Plutonic         Another strategy for establishing nappe displacements is
Complex and has accommodated many hundreds of kilometers              consideration of regional geology. Because units of the San
of mid-Cretaceous shortening between the Insular superterrane         Juan Islands–northwest Cascades thrust system bear evidence
and North America (Rubin et al., 1990).                               of residence along the continental margin prior to emplacement
                                                                      in the present day setting, direct accretion of these rocks from
Kinematics of Outcrop Scale Structures                                the west, the Pacific basin, seems improbable. Derivation of
                                                                      the nappes from the northeast is envisaged in the contractional
     One approach to understanding displacement of nappes in          model of Brandon and Cowan (1985) and McGroder (1991)
the San Juan Islands–northwest Cascades thrust system is kine-        which invokes a root zone for the nappes along the northeastern
matic analysis of outcrop scale structures. Such studies to date      edge of the Cascade core in the approximate area of the Ross
yield somewhat disparate results (Fig. 5). Brown (1987), working      Lake fault zone (Figs. 2 and 3). In this view, during Wrangellia
in the Cascades, reported a set of orogen-normal stretching linea-    collision the nappes were driven to the southwest, riding over
tions in the Easton Suite coeval with 120–130 Ma blueschist min-      the Cascade core and the northeastern flank of Wrangellia.
erals (see above). Younger orogen-parallel lineations were found      Regional geologic features cited as supportive of this model are:
in mylonite zones separating Cascades nappes (ca. 90 Ma, see          coeval crustal thickening in the Cascade core suggesting thrust
above). Smith (1988), and Maekawa and Brown (1991) mapped             loading, contractional structures in the Cascade core, and inter-
orogen-parallel stretching lineations in the Cascades and San Juan    pretation that the Nanaimo Group was deposited in a foreland
McGroder, 1991
                                 Late Jurassic
                                                                                     98 Ma
                                             ST                       WR     CPC
                                                                                                          MT    QS
                               WR                 CC                       SK
                                                                                    NWCS       CORE
                                                        QS                                     terranes

                                                                                     94 Ma                           A
                                                                                NWCS
                                      CH           MT
                                      NK                                                             MT
                                                                                          SK                   QS
                                CPC
                                           NWCS
                                           terranes

                             Brown, 1987                       90-95 Ma
                       Early Cretaceous                                              MT

                                                                          Plutons              CORE
                         WR       CPC QS                            WR
                                   NK

                                                                                    NWCS
                                                                                                               B
                                  ?
                         F

                             NWCS

                                                                F
                                                                                100 km

                                E. to mid-Cretaceous                       Late Cretaceous
                                           CPC               Bergh, 2002

                                     WR                                             CPC
                                                                                WR

                                                                      F
                                                                                                               C
                                                                       area of
                                                               EA      San Juan
                                                                                                EA
                                                                       Islands
                                 F
                                                            Lopez
                                                            fault                           Lopez
                                                            zone                    Rosario fault
                                                  Rosario                           fault   zone
                               100 km             fault                             zone
                                                  zone

Figure 7. Schematic drawings of three published models for tectonic evolution of the San Juan Islands–northwest Cascades thrust system
(NWCS). (A) Contractional model of McGroder (1991). Terranes of the thrust system were formed in a basin between Wrangellia and the con-
tinental margin. Convergence between these masses thrust the intervening terranes as nappes over the Cascade crystalline core (including the
Skagit migmatite complex) and onto the eastern edge of Wrangellia, achieving orogen-normal shortening of some 400-500 km. (B) Transcurrent
model of Brown (1987). Terranes of the San Juan Islands–northwest Cascades thrust system are interpreted to have accreted 100s of km south
of their present site and south of Wrangellia. Blueschist metamorphism and orogen-normal fabrics were recorded in the Easton Suite. Post-
accretionary displacement moved the terranes northward along the coast as a fore arc sliver, driven by dextral-oblique Farallon–North America
convergence, until they collided with a reentrant in the continental margin formed by the south end of Wrangellia. (C) Two-phase model of Bergh
(2002). Terranes of the San Juan Islands–northwest Cascades thrust system lay south of Wrangellia and developed orogen-normal contractional
structures during the D1 phase in response to high-angle Farallon–North America convergence. D2 structures include NW and SE coastwise
displacements as low-angle wedge extrusions caused by sinistral-oblique Farallon convergence. CPC— Coast Plutonic Complex; F—Farallon
plate. Other abbreviations as in Fig. 1 and Table 1.
154                                                              Brown et al.

basin caused by emplacement of San Juan Islands–northwest                 rocks had all been remagnetized during or after folding, and that
Cascades nappes. However, several aspects of regional geology             the predominantly normal polarity of the remagnetized directions
pose problems for this interpretation.                                    indicated to them that this remagnetization occurred during the
(1) The contractional model invokes transit of nappes of the              Cretaceous Long-Normal Chron (116–83.5 Ma). The remagne-
      San Juan Islands–northwest Cascades thrust system over              tized directions from the San Juan Islands are scattered, how-
      the Cascade crystalline core (Fig. 3) at precisely the time         ever, indicating that a significant amount of rotation and/or tilt
      of great magmatic arc activity in that region. No rocks             occurred after this remagnetization event.
      related to this arc activity are found in the San Juan Islands            Paleomagnetic studies of the unmetamorphosed “external”
      or Cascades, except where nappes lap onto the southern              units of the San Juan Islands have more promising results. The
      edge of the Cascade core in the vicinity of the Windy Pass          exception is the Haro Formation; Hults and Housen (2000) have
      thrust (Figs. 2 and 3).                                             found that these rocks were also remagnetized prior to folding,
(2) Nappes of the San Juan Islands–northwest Cascades thrust              despite their lack of any significant metamorphism.
      system carry metamorphic aragonite acquired prior to (as                  The rocks of the Spieden Group have complex magnetizations,
      well as after) thrusting. Aragonite has been shown experi-          with the majority of these clastic rocks having poorly resolved
      mentally to invert quickly to calcite outside its stability field   magnetizations. Dean (2002) found three magnetic components in
      at elevated temperature except under conditions of abnor-           most of the Late Jurassic Spieden Bluff Formation samples, which
      mally low T/P, less than 10 °C/km (Carlson and Rosenfeld,           yielded an inconclusive paleomagnetic fold test. The Early Cre-
      1981). Transit of the thrust system nappes over the active          taceous Sentinel Island Formation has a simpler, two-component
      arc would place them in a region of abnormally high T/P,            magnetization in some of the rocks. Dean (2002) found that the
      precluding preservation of aragonite.                               second-removed component from the Sentinel Island Forma-
(3) The elongate, orogen-parallel Nanaimo basin is flanked not            tion passes the inclination-only paleomagnetic fold test, with the
      by terranes of the San Juan Islands–northwest Cascades              best-clustered inclinations occurring at 100% untilting. The mean
      thrust system, but by plutonic rocks of the Coast Mountains.        inclination of 64°, α95 = 7.8°, suggests an Early Cretaceous paleo-
      Thrust system terranes occur south along strike from the            latitude of 46° N. Comparing this direction with that expected for
      Nanaimo (Figs. 2 and 3), and thus the basin is not likely a         the present-day location of Spieden Island calculated from a stable
      consequence of nappe loading.                                       North America reference pole (Housen et al., 2003), a latitudinal
      Many workers have envisaged a southerly origin of some              translation of 1500 ± 1000 km is estimated for these rocks.
or all of the terranes of the San Juan Islands–northwest Cas-                   The Nanaimo Group has been the subject of extensive paleo-
cades thrust system, in the Columbia embayment, Klamath                   magnetic study, primarily from outcrops in the Canadian Gulf
Mountains, or California Coast Range (e.g., Davis et al., 1978;           Islands (Ward et al., 1997; Enkin et al., 2001; Kim and Kodama,
Vance et al., 1980; Brown and Blake, 1987; Garver, 1988; Burch-           2004), with limited work from Orcas Island (Housen et al.,
fiel et al., 1992b). Davis et al. (1978) and Vance et al. (1980)          1998). All of these studies have found that most Nanaimo Group
proposed that the Mesozoic ophiolitic terranes of the San Juan            rocks have poorly defined magnetizations (~60% “failure rate”
Islands–northwest Cascades system formed in a “pull-apart gap”            reported for most sample collections). However, a significant
in southeastern Oregon and subsequently moved northward and               number of samples in all of these studies (a few 100 out of ~1000
were obducted onto the continent. Geologic features cited in sup-         samples collected) have well-defined magnetizations that pass a
port of the model are: (1) thrust emplacement of the Ingalls ophio-       reversals or fold test. Studies of inclination error, notably Kim
lite over the south edge of the Cascade core, (2) absence from            and Kodama (2004), suggest that inclination error in these sedi-
eastern Oregon and western Idaho of some continental margin               ments is moderate (8–10°), and that when corrected for the paleo-
terranes that are part of the Mesozoic assemblage to the north            magnetic inclinations in these rocks place the Nanaimo Basin at
and south along the Cordillera, and (3) Sr isotope ratios and seis-       a paleolatitude of 41° N during Campanian-Maastrichtian time.
mic velocities indicating primitive crust underlying the Columbia         Using a Late Cretaceous North American reference pole for
embayment. More recent geophysical evidence for a deep crustal            comparison, a translation of 1600 ± 900 km is indicated for these
rift in the Columbia embayment is a linear break in the gravity           rocks since ca. 75 Ma.
field running along the southern margin of the embayment (Riddi-                Related constraints on the Late Cretaceous paleogeography
hough et al., 1986).                                                      of the San Juan Islands also come from paleofaunal data from
                                                                          the Nanaimo Group rocks. Kodama and Ward (2001) argued
Paleomagnetic and Other Constraints of Paleogeography                     that the lack of rudistid bivalves in the otherwise well-preserved
                                                                          paleofauna of the Nanaimo Group can be used to constrain the
     Paleomagnetic studies of the rocks in the San Juan Islands           paleolatitude of these rocks. Rudistids are tropical to subtropi-
have had mixed success in constraining their tectonic history,            cal reef forming bivalves, and are common in a number of Late
with the main complication being an extensive remagnetization             Cretaceous marginal basin rocks from Baja California to Central
that has affected all of the “internal” units that have experienced       California. Using estimated locations of rudist-bearing basins,
high P-T metamorphism. Burmester et al. (2000) found that these           and the locations of anoxic black shales (Marca Shale) that mark
Tectonic evolution of the San Juan Islands thrust system, Washington                                  155

the presence of a cold-water upwelling zone along the ancient
California margin, Kodama and Ward (2001) suggested that the

                                                                                                                                  0
Nanaimo Group rocks were located at or north of the location

                                                                                                                                 14
of the Moreno Basin (central California, 42° N reconstructed
paleolatitude) at 75 Ma. Some additional support for this con-                   Ale utian -

                                                                                                                      KA
                                                                                                     D
                                                                                               W

                                                                                                                   AS
straint comes from the recognition of a marine reptile fauna from

                                                                                                       F
                                                                                                ra

                                                                                                                 AL
Nanaimo Group rocks on Vancouver Island, which share some

                                                                                                     ng
provinciality with the marine reptile fauna of the Moreno Forma-

                                                                                                      ell
tion from central California (Nicholls and Meckert, 2002).
     Another set of data, detrital zircon age distributions, has also
been used to test paleogeographic constraints on the location of
the Nanaimo Group rocks. Mahoney et al. (1999) used the pres-
ence of several Archean-aged zircons to indicate that the Nanaimo
Group rocks had been located no more than 500 km south of its                 P-MF
present-day location, during Late Cretaceous time. Using the same
set of data, Housen and Beck (1999) compared variations in the                   50 mm/yr
detrital zircon age distributions as a function of stratigraphic posi-
tion within the Nanaimo Group. They argued that variations in            Yakutat
Proterozoic-aged zircons support a source of detritial zircons from      terrane,
the Mazatzal and Yavapai orogens in southwest North America, and         transform
that northward migration of the Nanaimo Basin during its deposi-
tion was consistent with other paleomagnetic evidence, and plate         displacement                                                  60
                                                                                                                 North
motion estimates. The analyses of Kodama and Ward (2001), and

                                                                                             F-QCF
Kim and Kodama (2004) also supported the conclusion of Housen
                                                                                                                 America
and Beck (1999), that the Nanaimo Group reached the “moder-                                                      plate
ate” paleolatitude of ~43° N at 75 Ma, consistent with the so-called
“Baja-BC” (Baja–British Columbia) hypothesis.                                 Pacific
     Taken together, these paleogeographic data would be most                 plate
consistent with the “Klamath origin” models discussed above.
Complicating this correlation, however, are the proposed ties
between the San Juan Islands rocks and Wrangellian or North

                                                                                                                                       0
                                                                                                                                      12
Cascades basement, as abundant paleomagnetic data from strati-
fied rocks of Wrangellia/Insular affinity (Wynne et al., 1995,
Enkin et al., 2003), or barometrically corrected plutonic rocks
(Housen et al., 2003) both indicate more southerly paleolatitudes                                                     Casc
(36 N, and 3000 ± 700 km of translation) for these units during                300 KM
mid-Cretaceous time (93–88 Ma).
                                                                                                                      ade arc
                                                                                                              LRF
Modern Analogues?                                                                         Juan                                  CAN 50
                                                                                          de Fuca                               U.S .
                                                                                          plate                                    .
     Modern tectonic regimes along the western North American                                          8 mm/yr
margin (Fig. 8) that serve as possible analogues for emplacement
of the San Juan Islands–northwest Cascades thrust system via
coastwise movement are collision zones formed by northward
displacement of: (1) Siletzia against the south end of Wrangellia                                         Siletzia,
(e.g., Wells et al., 1998), and (2) the Yakutat terrane against the
                                                                                                          fore-arc displacement
southeast corner of Alaska in the Saint Elias orogen (Plafker et al.,
1994). Siletzia lies in the Cascade forearc, driven by a combina-        Figure 8. Modern-day analogues of orogen-parallel thrusting in the
tion of oblique plate convergence and Basin and Range extension          Pacific Northwest. F-QCF—Fairweather-Queen Charlotte fault,
(Wells et al., 1998). Seismic reflection allows identification of        DF—Denali fault, LRF—Leech River fault. References: Plafker et al.
                                                                         (1994), Wells et al. (1998); Bruhn et al. (2004).
Siletzian rocks under Wrangellia to depths of 15–20 km along
shallow to moderately north-dipping faults (Clowes et al., 1987).
Total northward displacement is not known, but Beck (1984)
suggested paleomagnetic discordance indicates as much as 300–
156                                                            Brown et al.

400 km. The current rate of arc-parallel transport is 6–8 mm/yr at      ever, caution must be exercised to avoid a nasty fall on the slick
the northern end of the terrane (Wells and Simpson, 2001).              seaweed-covered rocks that may be present. Please pay attention to
     The Yakutat terrane is moving north along the Fairweather–         the field trip guides as the departure time draws near, to ensure you
Queen Charlotte transform fault at 45–50 mm/yr relative to              are on the vessel, and the trip can run in a safe and timely fashion.
North America (Plafker et al., 1994; Bruhn et al., 2004). At the        After we have finished the Stuart Island stop, participants will re-
corner area in southern Alaska where plate interaction changes          embark for a ~45 min trip to Spieden Island.
from transform to convergent, the Yakutat terrane is colliding
with the continent (Fig. 8). A north-dipping Benioff zone and the       Stop 1-1. Fossil Cove, Stuart Island, Nanaimo Group
Wrangell magmatic arc in this region both testify to significant        (Fig. 10)
subduction of the Yakutat terrane (and probably other materials).
The convergent zone is marked by a thin-skinned accretionary                  The Nanaimo Group comprises a set of 11 formations, ranging
complex of Cretaceous and younger rocks displaced northward             from Turonian to Maastrichtian in age, composed of clastic marine
on gently to moderately dipping thrust faults (Bruhn et al., 2004).     and deltaic sedimentary deposits (Fig. 10). The ages of these rocks
Displacements are strongly partitioned between strike-slip faults       are constrained by biostratigraphy (e.g., Haggart, 1994), and mag-
and thrusts. Both analogues are characterized by low-dip thrusts        netostratigraphy (Enkin et al., 2001). These rocks were deposited
accommodating margin-parallel displacement indicating that              in a large marginal basin, extending ~175 km from its southern-
such structure, as possibly fits the San Juan Islands–northwest         most extent in the San Juan Islands to its northernmost extent on
Cascades thrust system, is not a tectonic anomaly.                      Vancouver Island. The Nanaimo Group contains several elements
                                                                        that are of tectonic interest. Structurally, the Nanaimo Group
FIELD TRIP GUIDE                                                        rocks (along with the Paleocene-Eocene Chuckanut Formation)
                                                                        are folded as part of the Cowichan fold and thrust belt (England
     The field trip guide begins at Friday Harbor, San Juan Island      and Calon, 1991; see also Mustoe et al., this volume, and Blake
(Fig. 9). Before departing, be certain that you have brought along      and Engebretson, this volume). One of the primary constraints on
warm clothes, raingear, and good field boots.                           the age of uplift and thrusting of the metamorphosed “interior”
     Please do not use rock hammers or collect specimens any-           domain of the San Juan Islands is the presence of metamorphosed
where on this trip unless specifically advised.                         sandstone clasts interpreted as being derived from the Constitution
                                                                        Formation that are found in conglomerates of the Extension Forma-
DAY 1                                                                   tion of the Nanaimo Group on Orcas and Stuart Islands (Brandon
                                                                        et al., 1988). On a larger scale, age distributions of detrital zircons
      Day 1 is spent primarily on the terranes “external” to the San    (Housen and Beck, 1999; Mahoney et al., 1999), paleomagnetism
Juan Islands thrust system. These units are the Haro Formation,         (Ward et al., 1997; Housen et al., 1998; Enkin et al., 2001; Kim and
Spieden Group, and Nanaimo Group. They broadly overlap in age           Kodama, 2004), and fossil assemblages (Kodama and Ward, 2001)
with rocks in the nappe pile but are distinguished by their absence     have been used to evaluate possible large-scale displacements of
of, or very low-grade (zeolite facies), metamorphism, and, in the       the Nanaimo Group rocks.
case of the Spieden and Nanaimo Groups, an absence of penetra-                On Stuart Island, the turbidites and sandstones of the Haslam
tive tectonite fabric. These units are important to understanding the   Formation, the conglomerates of the Extension Formation, and
younger portion of the tectonic history of the San Juan Islands.        the sandstones and siltstones of the Pender Formation can be
The field trip will begin with a drive from Friday Harbor across        found (Fig. 10). A stop at Fossil Cove, on the NW end of Stuart
San Juan Island to picturesque Roche Harbor, on the northern end        Island (a boat trip of ~45 minutes), allows for examination of the
of San Juan Island. We will depart from the boat ramp at Roche          bedding and sedimentary structures in these rocks, as well as the
Harbor, taking a chartered craft to Stuart and Spieden Islands.         many fossils (primarily Inoceramus). Time permitting, we may
We will be landing on public access beach areas, but please note        stop at a beach where the Extension Formation crops out, in order
that only the intertidal zone in these areas is considered to be pub-   to examine the conglomerate clasts of this interesting unit.
lic property, and that the uplands are privately owned. Access to
Spieden Island in particular is restricted by its owner.                Stop 1-2. North Shore Spieden Island, Spieden Group
                                                                        (Fig. 11)
Directions and Other Instructions
     Before departing on the Humpback Hauling vessel, be certain             Spieden Island is one of the largest (perhaps the largest) pri-
that you have brought warm clothes and your lunch. Even if the          vately owned island in the San Juan archipelago. It has a color-
weather appears to be sunny, raingear is recommended. A lifejacket      ful history, most notably as “Safari Island,” when in the 1970s
(provided on the vessel) is required at all times, and please do not    a group of investors purchased the island with the bright idea
forget yours on the beach. If you are prone to seasickness, please      of transforming it into a private exotic game hunting reserve.
take appropriate precautions. The vessel has a landing-craft type       The island was stocked with many species of exotic game ani-
ramp, so we will be able to disembark on relatively dry land. How-      mals (mostly Asian and African deer, goat, sheep, and antelope
Kn
                               75                                                                                                                                      ORCAS
  70
          Kn              Kn                                                                                                                                           ISLAND
          70          65            Kn
 1-1            Kn        55 84
                                              Kn
                     30
STUART
ISLAND
                                                                                                                                                                      Pe                            Pt
                                                    1-2
                                                              JKs                SPIEDEN
                                                                                  ISLAND
               ro fault
         Ha                                   Trh
                                         1-3                                               Or
                                                                                                ca
                                                                                                        s t                                                                                                      TrJo
                                                                                                            hrus
                                                                                                                 t
                                         Pt                           TrJo
                                                    Pt
                     TrJo

                                                                                                 Ro
                                                                                                           sa
                               JKc                                                                              rio
                                     TrJo
                                                                             Jc                                            th
                                                                                                                                ru
                                                                                                                                         st
                                                                                                                                                                                                            Jc
       SAN JUAN
       ISLAND                                                                                                  R
                                                                                                                oc
                                                                                                                     h
                                                                                                                         H arbor
                                                                                                                     e

                                                                                                                                   rd.

                                                                                    averton Val
                                                                                  Be           le   y rd
                                                                                                           .                                                                                               SHAW
                                                                                                                                                                    Friday
                                                                                                                                                                    Harbor                                 ISLAND
                                                                                                                                                       Argyle Ave

                                         PTrd
                                                                                        San Juan Valley rd.

                 Lime Kiln Point                         Pg                                 Jc
                                          1-4
                                                     W

                                                         es
                                                           tS
                                                             i de
                                                                                                                                                                                                      lt

                                                                    rd.               Bailer Hill rd.
                                                                                                                                                                                                  fau
                                                                                                                                   Cattle Point rd.

                                                                          TrJo
                                                                                                                                                                                               ay

 Kn = Nanaimo Group
                                                                                                                                                                                            kB

 JKs = Spieden Group
 JKl = Lopez Structural Complex
                                                                                                                                                                                           Buc

 Jc = Constitution Formation
 TrJo = Orcas Chert
 Trh = Haro Formation                                          N                                                                                      American
 PTrd = Deadman Bay Volcanics                                                                                                                         Camp                                                       JKl
                                                                                                                                                                           Pickett's Ln.

                                                                                                                                                                                                             Cattle
 Pg = Garrison Schist
                                                                                                                                                      2-1                                                    Point
  Pe = East Sound Group
                                                                          2.0 km                                                                                                                           2-2
  Pt = Turtleback Complex

Figure 9. Map of San Juan Island and vicinity. Solid circles locate field trip stops. Sources are Brandon et al. (1988) and
Burmester et al. (2000).
158                                                                           Brown et al.

                                               74
Turn
  50
     Point                     70

                                                                              65
                   Kne
                                     78                                                        50
  48                                                                               34
                          65
                                                                                                                        Kne                    85
                                                    Knh
   64
                                                                     62    Prevost 28
                     76
                                                          80
                                                                           Harbor                                                   Satellite
                                          83                                                                       Knh                                        48
    Fossil                     Kne                   83                                             76                        55    Island
             78                                                           72 72
    Cove                                                   50
                                                                                                              81
             63                                                                          58                                                              71
  Stop 1-1          Knp                                   65
                                                                                                                   83
                                                                                                         64
                      62                                                                                                      71
                                                                                                                                              56
                                                                     Knp                                                                                       Knh
A                                                                                  53     65                              70

         Nanaimo Group: 56                                                                                                                                                  70        54

         Knp: Pender Fm 75                                                                           55
                                                                                                                                         75

         Kne: Extension Fm                      61                                                            50         Reid                                               61
                                                                                                                                        Harb
         Knh: Haslam Fm                                                                                                                            or
                                                                 Knp                                               Knp
                                                                45                            Kne                                                                        Kne     63

                                                                             Stu                                                   50
                                                                                                                                               32
                                                                                        art
                                                                                               Isla                                                                                   N
                                                                                                         nd                                                                      14

                                                                                                                                                        22
                                                                                                         55
                                                                                                                    26
                                                                                                                                                                   scale 1 km
Figure 10 (on this and following page). Geology of Stuart Island, from
                                                                                                                                                   24
Mercier (1977). (A) Geologic map.
                                                                                                                                         22

species). Needless to say, the concept of hunting exotic game in                          trip back to the Roche Harbor boat ramp, where the seaborne por-
the midst of an ecological paradise did not work out; the island                          tion of this trip will end.
reverted to Spieden Island, and the descendants of the surviving                                After leaving the Roche Harbor boat ramp, we will drive to
creatures can be seen cavorting around the island today.                                  Davidson Head, parking on the shoulder of the road at the “neck”
     Geologically, Spieden Island, and nearby Sentinel Island, are                        of the head. We will then walk northwest along the beach, exam-
the only known occurrences of the late Jurassic–early Cretaceous                          ining the exposures of the Haro Formation in the intertidal zone.
Spieden Group. The Spieden Group is composed of two forma-                                Fans of fresh oysters will be certain to notice the abundant (likely
tions, the Oxfordian-Kimmeridgian Spieden Bluff Formation, and                            seeded) oysters present on the Haro Formation outcrops.
the uppermost Valanginian Sentinal Island Formation (Fig. 11).
The ages of these units are constrained by biostratigraphy                                Directions to Stop 1-3
(McClellan, 1927, Haggart, 2000), primarily via fossils of                                    From Roche Harbor waterfront, drive southwest on Reuben
Buchia. The rocks of both formations are clastic sediments, with                          Memorial Drive.
finer-grained turbidite deposits characterizing the Spieden Bluff                         0.2 mi    Go left on Roche Harbor Road.
Formation, and volcaniclastic-rich sandstone, mudstone, and con-                          0.9       Go left (NW) on Afterglow Drive.
glomerates characterizing the Sentinel Island Formation. The rocks                        1.8       Neck of Davidson Head; park on gravel shoulder on
also display some soft-sediment deformation features; some have a                                   right side of road.
very weak anastomosing scaly cleavage, and have been folded.
     Our field trip stop will be located on a wave-cut bench,                             Stop 1-3. Davidson Head, San Juan Island, Haro Formation
exposed at low tide, on the north shore of Spieden Island. Here
we will see outcrops of both formations, and localities that dis-                             The north shore of San Juan Island is home to one of the
play the locally abundant macrofossils. We will have ~30 min                              most geographically restricted units in the San Juan Islands—the
at this location; please follow the instructions of the trip leaders                      Late Triassic (Norian) Haro Formation. This unit crops out on
closely. After we re-embark, the vessel will take us on a ~40 min                         Davidson Head, and is a 700-m-thick mixed volcaniclastic unit.
You can also read