The impacts of climate change on food security and health in Southern Africa

Page created by Mathew Powers
 
CONTINUE READING
The impacts of climate change on food security
and health in Southern Africa

H L Wlokas
Energy Research Centre, University of Cape Town, and the Free University, Berlin

Abstract                                                 privilege to prevent rain, cold or droughts from dis-
Climate change will have a great impact on               turbing their daily life.
Southern Africa according to the IPCC. Two closely            The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate
related topics, food security and health will be         Change (IPCC) called Africa ‘one of the most vul-
affected by the changes in many ways. Difficulties in    nerable continents to climate variability and change
transporting food through carbon regulations in air-     because of multiple stresses and low adaptive
freight, changing conditions for growing food crops      capacity’ (IPCC WGII 2007: 10). Similarly, Peter
and negative impacts on fishery might occur and          Lukey, Chief Director of the South African
will very possible lead to an increase in malnutrition   Department of Environmental Affairs and Tourism
in the region. Changes of the climate will also have     (DEAT), states that ‘Africa has become the worst-off
an effect on the way illnesses are transmitted and       victim of worldwide climate change’ (Engineering
cause a number of extreme weather events which           News Online 2008). Africa seems to be in such a
can have an extremely damaging consequence on            poor position because the majority of the popula-
human living. Two main efforts are being work on         tion on the continent are dependent on the weath-
in terms of dealing with these concerns. At the inter-   er for activities such as agriculture or fishing. The
national, regional and national levels, adaptation       degree of dependence is too great for the available
and mitigation action is being planned and imple-        capacity to deal with consequences of changing cli-
mented. Activities at each level are discussed and I     mate, thus causing the IPCC and the DEAT Director
argue this in this paper that currently the most effi-   to be alarmed.
cient way of dealing with the existing and future             With a change in the climate, agricultural pro-
burdens of climate change impacts are activities at a    duction, prices and infrastructure will change, limit-
national level, and enhanced effort has to be made       ing the amount and quality of food produced.
to improve regional and international collaboration      Again linked to the situation around nutrition in a
in addressing these issues.                              family, a country or the world is the state of health.
                                                         With inappropriate or too little food health condi-
Keywords: climate change, food security, health,         tions of people are getting worse. Supplementary
Southern Africa                                          climate changes like increasing temperature, floods
                                                         or droughts are threatening human physical and
                                                         psychological circumstances. And the link is also the
                                                         other way around: ‘Poor people are likely to have
                                                         less access to healthy, nutritious food, which results
1. Introduction                                          in a poor health status and lower labour productiv-
Human beings are dependent on the environment            ity. These two factors then contribute to perpetuat-
they live in. Even though it seems that humans in        ing the vicious cycle of poverty and malnutrition’
this century, all over the world, are more connected     (FAO 2005).
to technology than to the natural environments that           The two approaches currently adopted by the
surround them, this picture fails when it comes to       international community to deal with issues around
climate change. Through discussion around climate        the impacts of climate change are adaptation and
change and its impacts, the quality of life of poor      mitigation strategies. How adapting to changing sit-
people is increasingly taken into consideration.         uations or mitigating greenhouse gas emissions, or
Poor people have always been very dependent on           even a combination of both strategies, at national,
weather and environmental conditions; only the           regional and an international level may be relevant
wealthy minority of the world population has the         to food security and human health, which will be

12                                        Journal of Energy in Southern Africa • Vol 19 No 4 • November 2008
shown in this paper.                                     Zimbabwe, Mozambique, Lesotho, Swaziland and
    I argue that currently the most efficient ways of    South Africa.
dealing with existing and future burdens of climate
change impacts are activities at the national level,     3. Impact of climate change on food
and that enhanced effort has to be made to               security and health in Southern Africa
improve regional and international collaboration in      Two of the most important issues impacted on by
addressing these issues.                                 climate change described above in Southern Africa
    I provide a general introduction to climate          are food security and human health. Both have a
change impacts on Sub-Saharan Africa, followed           direct and essential impact on human existence.
by a discussion around the consequences of these         Food security concerns the available amount of
changes on food security and health in Southern          food for a certain purpose. This could be to feed a
Africa. Adaptation and mitigation, the two current       family or an individual, or to feed a nation, or even
strategies adopted to deal with the present and          the amount of food needed to feed the whole world
future situation, are introduced in section four.        population. Additional to the simple quantity of
Following the idea that these strategies are possible    required food, food security also includes concerns
to develop and implement at various levels; nation-      issues like the transport of food to people and stor-
al, regional and international actions are examined.     age issues. The quality of food is emphasized in the
Currently, implemented projects and policies are         term food safety (anonymous interview with partic-
considered in order to clarify how relevant action       ipant of World Economic Forum in Cape Town on
on which level can ease the burden of the impacts        SABC 2, 5. June 2008, 2pm). The divide between
of climate change on food security and health in         food security and safety is not going to be followed
Southern Africa.                                         throughout this paper, but is mentioned for reasons
                                                         of completion.
2. Climate change in Southern Africa                          The United Nations Organization for Food and
The IPCC report from 2007 defines Africa as ‘one         Agriculture (FAO) define the four most crucial fac-
of the most vulnerable continents to climate vari-       tors for a household’s food security as: ‘food avail-
ability and change because of multiple stresses and      ability, access to food, stability of supply and acces-
low adaptive capacity’ (IPCC WGII 2007: 10).             sibility, and the degree to which food is nutritious
Water and water related issues are expected to be        and safe and can therefore be utilized’ (FAO
the most challenging threats to the continent. Water     2005:1). Food availability is expected to be heavily
stress is going to influence between 75 and 250 mil-     impacted as climate change may transform ‘the
lion people’s lives by 2020 and change the condi-        area suitable for agriculture, the length of growing
tions for agricultural production drastically. In com-   seasons and yield potential’ (IPCC WGII 2007:10).
bination with increasing temperatures ‘the area suit-    The access to food and stability of supply are close-
able for agriculture, the length of growing seasons      ly linked to the conditions of the infrastructure. This
and yield potential, particularly along the margins      includes roads, railways, cargo transfer and the pos-
of semi-arid and arid areas, are expected to             sibility to transport food over long distances by
decrease’ (IPCC WGII 2007: 10). Unsure rainfall          plane. Roads and railways might suffer under
and longer dry periods are going to put extra stress     increasing weather stress and air transport might be
on farming production. Coastal areas are in danger       regulated due to greenhouse gas reduction affords.
from floods and sea-level rise by 2080, and chang-            The safety of food comes back to the quality of
ing conditions in the ocean are going to impact on       the available food. IPCC expects ‘agricultural pro-
fisheries and the people close to the sea (IPCC          duction, including access to food, in many African
WGII 2007: 10). ‘Exposure to climatic hazards and        countries and regions … to be severely compro-
vulnerability to climate change varies enormously        mised by climate variability and change’ (IPCC
between regions and sectors in Africa’ (Downing et       WGII 2007: 10). The FOA sees the 1.1 billion
al 1997: 21).                                            hectares of land which is already only arable under
    South Africa, for instance, is going to become       heavy endeavours expanded by 50-90 million
generally drier and warmer through climate change.       hectares as the result of climate change (FAO
Significant impacts are expected in ‘some sectors,       2005:2). The production of ‘yields from rain-fed
particularly agriculture, water resources, biodiversi-   agriculture could be reduced by up to 50% by
ty and human health’ and ‘these potential impacts        2020’ (IPCC WGII 2007:10) and it’s a consequence
will undoubtedly have detrimental effects on South       spreading hunger very quickly. Main sources of
Africa’s priority issues (i.e. poverty alleviation,      nutrition for people in Africa like beans, wheat,
employment, housing, access to and provision of          potatoes and rice are in danger of being difficult to
services, food security, potable water, HIV/AIDS,        produce in future.
etc.)’ (Lim 2004: 6).                                         Another important factor is rivers and coastal
    This paper focuses on the Southern African           zones. It is still uncertain if increasing temperature
region as a whole, including Namibia, Botswana,          will increase or hinder fish production, but clearly it

Journal of Energy in Southern Africa • Vol 19 No 4 • November 2008                                           13
will change something (IPCC 2001: 10). Many                 (Patz et al 2005:311), there is no strong discourse
countries in Africa are food-insecure and a large           obvious in the literature at the moment. The same
portion of the population rely on subsistence farm-         applies to HIV and AIDS. The effect of climate
ing where ‘farmers both consume their product and           change on this virus is little studied and assump-
sell it in local markets’ (Brown & Funk 2008: 580).         tions are very vague. Brown and Funk (2008: 581)
As a result ‘large-scale hunger can ensue, even             see the virus to be likely to ‘become more severe
when there is sufficient food in the market that has        and widespread with warming temperatures’, but
been imported from elsewhere’ as these farmers              there is also no evidence in the literature about this
cannot earn enough from their own crop sales to             matter.
buy the imported food (Brown & Funk 2008: 580).                 A positive influence is generally understandable
Current protests about the increasing food prices all       in very cold regions, where the number of people
over the world give an idea what this could mean            who die through cold waves might become less.
for people and political stability of the effected          Alternately, in warm regions like Africa even more
countries. Brown and Funk (2008:581) see by now             people will die due to heat stress (McMichael et al.
‘up to half of all malnutrition … driven by non-food        2006: 863). All in all, these kinds of big scale events
factors’. Taking all the influencing factors of food        are going to have a growing power over people’s
security into consideration the question which has          lives, particularly over people who live in areas very
to be asked and answered is: ‘Where is the food,            vulnerable to climate change such as coastal zones,
how is it grown and how traded?’ (anonymous                 places where storms are to be expected and regions
interview with participant of World Economic                at risk of droughts or floods. ‘Over 96% of disaster-
Forum in Cape Town on SABC 2, 5. June 2008,                 related deaths in recent years have taken place in
2pm). Possible approaches to answer these ques-             developing countries’ (African Development Bank
tions and act appropriately are discussed in the next       et al. 2003:X). Further health concerns exist due to
sections.                                                   spread of disease as the result of migration caused
    ‘The relative importance of climate change for          by climate change impacts (McMichael et al. 2006:
food security differs between regions’ (Gregory et          860-62, Patz et al. 2005: 311-15, IPCC WGII 2007:
al. 2005: 2139). This is also the case for the impacts      9-13).
of climate change on human health. An almost con-               In conclusion it can be said that the link between
tinent-wide problem is going be the impact of food          climate and health is most noticeable in cases where
insecurity on the health of people. Malnutrition is         extreme weather events like heat waves, floods,
likely to increase (IPCC WGII 2007:10, Brown &              storms, fires, or infectious diseases are the crucial
Funk, 2008: 580). According to the World Health             factor. ‘Other important climatic risks to health,
Organization, the estimated global number of peo-           from changes in regional food yields, disruption of
ple who are currently undernourished is 800 mil-            fisheries, loss of livelihoods, and population dis-
lion, with close to half of these living in Africa’ (Patz   placement (because of sea-level rise, water short-
et al. 2005:311). Authors like McMichael estimate           ages, etc) are less easy to study than these factors
the increase of underfed people by 5-10%                    and their causal processes and effects are less easi-
(McMichael et al. 2006: 863).                               ly quantified’ (McMichael et al. 2006: 860).
    Another threat is the possible increase of vector-          Food security and Health are closely related
bone diseases in some areas. In regions like the east       issues, as food for instance, has a direct impact on
African highlands ‘the potential incidence, seasonal        human health and the physical conditions of
transmission, and geographic range of various vec-          humans has a strong influence on their ability to
tor-borne diseases’ are expected to rise (McMichael         work and earn money. Figure 1 shows the main
et al. 2006: 862). These diseases include Malaria,          pathways by which climate change affects the
Dengue fever, Yellow fever, various types of viral          health of human beings, including the conse-
Encephalitis, Schistosomiasis, Leishmaniasis, Lyme          quences of food scarcity. The left side of the dia-
disease, and Onchocerciasis. Even though the IPCC           gram demonstrates the concept of climate change
report speaks about uncertainty in terms of the ‘the        and the middle section shows the main changes in
decrease or increase of the range and transmission          the environment as the result of climate change.
potential of malaria in Africa’ (IPCC WGII 2007:9),         The right side points out the effects on health, most
McMichael et al. (2006: 865) reviewed a number of           of which are negative, but some have also positive
studies ‘that have modelled seasonal changes in             consequences. Two types of interventions are men-
transmission [and] researchers estimate a substan-          tioned in the diagram. One is mitigation, which
tial extension - such as a 16-28% increase in per-          tackles climate change at the stage where it is
son-months of exposure to malaria in Africa by              caused and so works at the root of the problem.
2100’. However, ‘due to varying quality of long-            The second type is adaptation, which starts at a
term disease data across sites in Africa, and in part       much later point and deals with the symptoms of
due to the difficulty in adequately controlling for         the previous emitted amounts of greenhouse gases
demographic and biological (drug resistance) data’          (which might not have been able to prevent through

14                                          Journal of Energy in Southern Africa • Vol 19 No 4 • November 2008
Figure 1: Schematic summary of the main pathways by which climate change
                                     affects population health
                                Source: McMichael et al. (2006: 860)

mitigation or have been there before the interven-        land degradation (erosion, desertification), biodi-
tion started). Other areas of focus adopted by the        versity loss, natural resource management, health
international community to try to ease the burden         (HIV/AIDS, malaria etc), migration, rural liveli-
of the impacts of climate change are technology           hoods, poverty alleviation and coastal zone man-
transfer and research (IPCC WGII 2007:20). Ideally        agement. This paper takes a closer look at food
these are combined with adaptation and mitigation         security and health and discusses the possible adap-
action. To differentiate between these strategies is in   tation and mitigation strategies that can be adopt-
some cases neither possible nor necessary. Most of        ed.
the adaptation and mitigation programmes that are             Many definitions for adaptation and mitigation
going to be discussed contain elements of technol-        are available in the literature. The most common
ogy transfer and research. How adaptation and mit-        and probably deeply discussed one is the definition
igation are applied and to what extent they are rel-      used in the IPCC report which says that adaptation
evant for food security and health are examined in        refers to changes in ‘processes, practices, or struc-
the following section.                                    tures to moderate or offset potential damages or to
                                                          take advantage of opportunities associated with
4. Adaptation and mitigation action to                    changes in climate’ (IPCC WGII 2001:1). It involves
ease burdens                                              actions to reduce the vulnerability of regions and
The current and future impacts climate change has         communities to climate change (IPCC WGII
and will have on Southern Africa are creating a           2001:1). Adaptation can be spontaneous or
great need for people to change behaviour to be           planned action done by governments or civil socie-
able to survive in the new conditions. Areas where        ty, but ‘institutional and economic parameters
so-called adaptation is appropriate are, for exam-        determine the vulnerability and adaptive capacity
ple, disaster management (floods, droughts, storms        of societies’ (Hug et al. 2003:17).
etc), food security, water resource management,               In the international climate change negotiations

Journal of Energy in Southern Africa • Vol 19 No 4 • November 2008                                          15
decisions were made which were ‘initiated to devel-        change mitigation’ (Nganga 2006:7) are the most
op the adaptive capacity of poor people and the            effective approaches. The United Nations
poorer countries (…) to cope with the impacts of cli-      Framework Convention on Climate Change creates
mate change’ (Hug et al. 2003: 18). The required           the basis for future work and in the following -
capacity includes financial, human and knowledge           national, regional and international programmes
resources. Research about how to adapt to what,            will be stressed.
when and where has only started recently and there
are still very few people working in the field.            4.1 National strategies
Financial support is supposed to come from the so-         At a national level, adaptation could take place at
called developed countries. ‘As adaptation activities      different levels in society: national, sub-national (for
can be capital-intensive and the benefits highly           instance, provincial), and local, depending on
localized and immediate, the real challenge will be        country’s situation and sub-national circumstances
the development of secure, adequate and pre-               (Niang_Diop & Bosch: 186). To start with the low-
dictable funding to meet priorities, as well as equi-      est level where adaptation can happen, every indi-
table frameworks to access this funding’ (Winkler          vidual is adapting to changes in the environment.
2004:362).                                                 This action might happen unconsciously, but it is
    For instance, the cost of adaptation to expected       from an evolutionary science perspective as part of
sea-level rise in low-lying coastal areas with large       life on earth. Individual adaptation has limitations
populations is estimated to be at least 5-10% of           however, once financial or energy resources sources
GDP (IPCC WGII 2007:10). Considering these                 are emptied. The next step is then to look at com-
numbers, it becomes clear that the costs cannot be         munities at a whole. Possible actions addressing
carried by national budgets alone. Adaptation is not       food stress could be a change in used crop, invest-
an issue which can be dealt with in isolation.             ment in new irrigation systems, better soil conser-
Strategies like the Millennium Development Goals           vation and livestock management. Safe water
and the Poverty Reduction Strategy Papers have to          drinking technologies and new water use strategies
be able to be combined with adaptation action to           could have a positive impact on the health of the
get the greatest benefits and not hinder the success       community (Sharma 2002). It is also possible that
of other efforts (Hug et al. 2003:18). The IPCC            whole communities move away from areas with
supports this idea strongly with the advice to             high risk of extreme weather events.
‘include (…) adaptation measures in land-use plan-             As the biggest potential for fast and flexible
ning and infrastructure design and include (…)             adaptation is currently seen in community struc-
measures to reduce vulnerability in existing disaster      tures, the South African climate change NGO
risk reduction strategies’ (IPCC WGII 2007:20).            SouthSouthNorth (SSN) developed the SSN
Generally the adaptive capacity in Africa is low due       Adaptation project Protocol for Community Based
to low GDP per capita, widespread poverty,                 Adaptation (SSNAPP). ‘This tool is designed to
inequitable land distribution, and low education           assist project developers to identify, select, design,
levels (African Development Bank et al. 2003:3). In        fund raise, implement and monitor and evaluate
addition, climate change impacts in Africa affect          community based adaptation to climate change
many people. With a high number of people                  interventions in response to local climate change
depending on rain-fed agriculture and over 25% of          impacts in developing countries where all levels of
the population living in coastal areas, adaptation is      stakeholders are engaged at each step in the
necessary and might depend to a large extent ‘on           process’ (SouthSouthNorth a:2).
the degree of civil order, political openness, and             However, strategies and policies are usually the
sound economic management’ (African Develop-               responsibility of governments at a national level,
ment Bank et al. 2003:3).                                  while measures can be taken at a more local level
    It is obvious that strategies like mitigation are an   (individuals, enterprises, households, communities,
international task. Carbon emission regulations            etc.) (Niang-Diop & Bosch: 186). Large scale strate-
have to be thought through on a global level, miti-        gies and policies have to be made by governments,
gation action does not have a significant local effect     due to reasons of financial capacity, human
on food security. It might improve air-quality local-      resources and authority in the implementation. The
ly, but as long as in other places in the world peo-       international community agreed on procedures
ple keep or even increase emissions into the atmos-        which are supposed to help the countries with
phere, a positive impact on global warming will not        adaptation. Firstly, there is the National
be possible. It should also be noted that ‘even the        Communication (NC). All countries which ratified
most stringent mitigation efforts cannot avoid fur-        the Kyoto Protocol are committed to communicate
ther impacts of climate change in the next few             to the Conference of the Parties (Article 12, para-
decades, which makes adaptation essential’ (IPCC           graph 5 and Article 4.3). Countries have the chance
WGII 2007:20). A combination of both strategies or         to apply for financial support at the United Nations
‘adaptation options that also address climate              and will also get some advice on how to write the

16                                         Journal of Energy in Southern Africa • Vol 19 No 4 • November 2008
NC. In most of the cases the government depart-                  about the issues.
ment which deals with environmental issues is               •    Special focus is given to the most vulnera-
responsible for the report. Ideally, a country defines           ble regions and populations within each
an agency that is then in charge to research the                 country.
present and future impacts of climate change on the         •    All relevant institutions within the govern-
country and defines special concerns in terms of                 ment as well as civil society need to be
vulnerability, adaptation and mitigation. Next to                made aware of the problem and their
money, technical support can be asked for from the               respective roles in dealing with it.
United Nations Environmental Programme (UNEP),              •    The focus is on building long-term national
United Nations Development Programme (UNDP),                     adaptive capacity.
UNFCCC and also from ministries, universities,              •    Adaptation to climate change is effectively
non-governmental organizations (NGOs) and pub-                   mainstreamed into national and sectoral
lic and private firms (Mwakasonda 2008).                         development.
    The UNDP unit is responsible for the NC´s                    (Hug et al. 2003: 36).
developed an Adaptation Policy Framework (APF).
This APF includes a User´s Guidebook and techni-              It can be said that until present the most effective
cal papers. The main incentive of creating an APF        adaptation activities are done by individuals and
was ‘to assist and provide guidance to developing        communities even though their work is mostly
countries in identifying, prioritizing, and shaping      undocumented and not recognised as work under
potential adaptation options into a coherent strate-     the term adaptation. National programmes are
gy that is consistent with their sustainable develop-    starting slowly and, as shown by the South African
ment and other national priorities’ (UNDP& GEF           example, still have a long way to go to make a real
2003:iv).                                                difference. In South Africa, only a few projects have
    The National Communications harbour the              been implemented so far, and this was the first of
greatest potential for Non-Annex-I states to get         the sub-Saharan countries to submit the NC.
international attention, funding, and capacity build-         As none of the countries in Southern Africa are
ing programmes running in their countries. An            Annex-I states, mitigation action in terms of fulfilling
example of adaptation action of this kind is the         emission targets do not have to be taken into con-
research project developed by the Medical Research       sideration. South Africa is once again in the unique
Council and the University of Kwa-Zulu-Natal. The        position in Southern Africa of facing emission tar-
study looks at ‘the link between climate variables       gets in the next 10-15 years. The National Climate
and the distribution of malaria and schistosomiasis’     Change Response Strategy talks about ‘the mining
(Lim 2004:13). In South Africa research into agri-       and energy sectors … [as] particularly vulnerable to
culture and climate change has also been initiated       climate change mitigation measures’ (RSA 2004:5).
at the Universities of Stellenbosch, Kwa-Zulu-Natal      However, through the Clean Development Mechan-
and Pretoria, the South African Weather Service          ism (CDM), carbon reduction activities are made
and other Institutions. In 2004 two adaptation proj-     possible for Non-Annex-I countries (Kyoto, Article
ects addressing farming concerns, the CLOUD proj-        12). Emissions reduced in the developing country
ect in Limpopo and awareness workshops for the           can be sold through international carbon trade cer-
Department of Agriculture, were implemented (Lim         tificates to developed countries and help these
2004:12).                                                countries to reach their targets. Even though CDM
    In the paper ‘Poverty and Climate Change’, in        projects are contributing in a positive way to global
which a large number of international organizations      mitigation affords, they are not reducing the global
were involved in writing it, advice is given to devel-   emissions and can only be as good as the emission
oping countries which are willing to work on their       targets of the Annex-I states (Michaelowa et al.
national adaptation performance (African Develop-        2004, Ellis et al. 2004).
ment Bank et al. 2003). Firstly, it is advised that           The link between mitigation and food security at
work on the National Adaptation Programme of             a national level is based solely on the contribution
Action, which is similar to the APF process, is          of greenhouse gas emissions to global climate
strengthened. In doing this countries should further     change. The impacts of emissions on health are dif-
ensure that:                                             ferent, however, as indoor and outdoor air pollution
                                                         are major contributors to respiratory health diseases
   •    They involve the relevant stakeholders from      and local reductions of emission can have a big
        the most vulnerable sectors of the economy       impact on the health conditions of people (WHO
        and regions of the country.                      2005). A South African example is the Kuyasa CDM
   •    They also need to ensure that high-level         project. In this project, solar-water-heaters, ceilings
        policy makers are aware of the importance        and fluorescent bulbs are installed in houses in the
        of the issue.                                    low-income settlement of Kuyasa in Khayelitsha.
   •    The general public is made more aware            Through the installations, the project hopes to

Journal of Energy in Southern Africa • Vol 19 No 4 • November 2008                                             17
cause a change in behaviour and initiate a switch          Countries Fund (LDCF) and the Special Climate
over from polluting cooking methods like paraffin          Change Fund (SCCF) are both designed to support
or wood to electricity (Tyler 2007). This would be         concrete adaptation projects in developing coun-
expected to have a positive effect on the respirato-       tries (GEF website 11 June 2008). Some examples
ry health of the dwellers and according to the theo-       of endeavours around food security are the rather
ry of suppressed demand also reduce greenhouse             non-concrete research project like the ‘Climate
gas emissions. Adaptation and mitigation are thus          Change Adaptation and Mitigation and Food
combined in this CDM project.                              Security Concerns’, but there are also projects on
                                                           the ground like the ‘Reversing Land Degradation in
 4.2 Regional strategies                                   Zhomba through Integrated Catchment Manage-
National borders usually define areas where differ-        ment Programme’ in Zimbabwe.
ent thinking, planning and activities take place,              Another United Nations organization which is
‘however adaptation strategies, policies and meas-         working on adaptation issues is the Food and
ures must also be considered at the sub-regional           Agriculture Organization (FAO). They have devel-
and regional levels (e.g. when they are related to         oped, among other things, the Global Agro-
shared resources, as is the case with international        Ecological Zones methodology, which ‘can provide
rivers)’ (Niang-Diop & Bosch: 185). This leads the         a detailed understanding of the sensitivity of agri-
Southern African Development Community (SADC)              cultural crops and regional land-use systems to cli-
to get together and identify areas of priority for         mate change’ (unknown author 2002:10). Analyses
environmental policies. ‘These priority areas target       with this methodology have shown that ‘on aver-
environmental and developmental concerns in the            age, industrialized countries stand to make substan-
region which require immediate attention and call          tial gains in production potential, while developing
for both national and collective regional action’          countries are expected to lose’ (FAO 2005).
(Lim 2004:13). In reaction to these findings the               The FAO will also further monitor the relation-
SADC Food, Agriculture and Natural Resources,              ship between climate change and food security and
SADC Protocol on Shared Watercourse Systems                can be counted as one of the big international play-
and the SADC Forest Protocol have been devel-              ers in this field. There are many more international
oped. In addition to these actions within the SADC         organizations working in the field of adaptation in
community, the New Economic Plan for African               Southern Africa, the World Bank, International
Development (NEPAD) and the Millennium Dev-                Development Research Centre, the Institute for
elopment Goals are mentioned as frameworks for             Sustainable Development and Oxfam being but a
regional collaboration (Lim 2004:13).                      few. Oxfam, for instance, recently developed an
     Border crossing issues like food security and         Adaptation Financing Index, which ‘gives an indi-
health are probably most effectively addressed at          cation of what fairness in adaptation requires’. The
this scale. Improved cross-border transport systems,       USA, EU and Japan are identified as the three main
such as roads and railways, might enhance collabo-         entities responsible for climate change and they
ration in tackling issues such as supply and accessi-      should, according to the Index, be contributing
bility of food (IPCC WGII 2001: 10). SADC or               40%, 30% and 10% to the adaptation costs (Oxfam
NEPAD may also strengthen their position in inter-         2007).
national negotiations about agricultural subsidies if          Oxfam also gives some recommendations on
the countries collaborate and speak with one voice.        how to divide adaptation work at the different
In the African context, there is little discussion about   scales. For the international sphere the requests are
mitigation activities except for CDM projects.             to ‘contribute(…) to the international learning net-
     Regional actions are similar to national ones in      works on adaptation’ (Oxfam 2007) and to improve
that they are still in early stages. Even though the       regional collaboration in shielding cross border
potential to work together on adaptation strategies,       ecosystems and monitoring and forecasting of cli-
and at a later stage also on mitigation strategies, is     mate change (Oxfam 2007). Similarly, crucial is the
high due to similar social-economic backgrounds            role of the international players in areas like sys-
and geographically related burdens, only assump-           tematic observation, technology transfer and capac-
tions can be made about the impact collective              ity building. As ‘the inadequacy of systematic obser-
actions will have once actually implemented.               vations network which is necessary for climate char-
                                                           acterization’ is seen as one of the main barriers ‘to
 4.3 International strategies                              effective vulnerability and adaptation assessment in
At the international scale, the Global Environmental       Africa’ (Nganga 2006:12), this is an area where
Facility (GEF) is unquestionably the main player in        international cooperation can be pivotal. The two
the climate change adaptation scene. Aside from            other barriers Prof. Nganga identifies in his presen-
running surveys, assessments and initial pilot proj-       tation for the UNFCCC are ‘inadequate technolog-
ects, this monetary organization from the United           ical capacity to implement adaptation projects’ and
Nations, manages two funds. The Least Developed            technical capacity. Once again these issues are seen

18                                         Journal of Energy in Southern Africa • Vol 19 No 4 • November 2008
as challenges for action at the international level.      through basic measures like producing a National
The ‘Poverty and Climate Change’ paper delivers a         Communication.
list of recommendations for further steps towards             It would be great if institutions and government
collaboration in adaptation on the international          departments placed more effort into adaptation
level (African Development Bank et al. 2003). In          strategy research. With this work it would be possi-
addition to the issues mentioned earlier are an           ble to compare and define good practice examples
improvement of the international negotiating              on the national level, which in turn might help inter-
capacity amongst the developing countries and             national players to place better focussed incentives
measures to ‘become more effective at sharing the         to improve food security and human health in a
results of their work on adaptation amongst them-         changing climate.
selves’ (Hug et al 2003: 37).
     Apparently the adaptation work at the interna-
tional level is comprehensive and definitely
required. Pilot-projects showing what adaptation          Bibliography
could look like, and policy advice may help gov-          African Development Bank, Asian Development Bank,
ernments to make decisions. However, since devel-             Department for International Development, United
oping countries are still struggling to include climate       Kingdom, Directorate-General for Development,
change concerns into their policies and legislation,          European Commission, Federal Ministry for Econ-
                                                              omic Cooperation and Development, Germany,
more effort has to be put into raising the respon-
                                                              Ministry of Foreign Affairs – Development Coopera-
siveness of governments and other people in power.
                                                              tion, The Netherlands, Organization for Economic
     Mitigation action essentially happens at the             Cooperation and Development United Nations Dev-
international level. The national states are negotiat-        elopment Programme, United Nations Environment
ing and deciding how the international climate                Programme, The World Bank: Poverty and Climate
regime should work. For now, there is no specific             Change. Reducing the Vulnerability of the Poor
relation between global greenhouse gases reduction            through Adaptation. 2003.
efforts and food security or health other than the        Anonymous interview with participant of World
general link between emissions and climate change.           Economic Forum in Cape Town on SABC2, 5. June
Local impacts of mitigation on health have been              2008, 2pm.
covered in earlier sections already.                      Brown, M. & Funk, C.: Food Security under Climate
     It is obvious that there is a lot happening at the      Change. Science 319, February 2008, 580-581.
international level, and to cover all the activities is   Catford, J.: Food security, climate change and heath pro-
too large a task for this paper. International activity      motion: opening up the streams not just helping out
means international attention and that brings fund-          down stream. Health Promotion International,
ing and projects with it, a crucial factor for further       23:105-108, 2008.
work on every level.                                      Cooper, P., Dimes J., Rao, K., Shapiro B., Shiferaw B.,
                                                             Twomlow, S.: Coping better with current climatic vari-
5. Conclusion                                                ability in the rain-fed farming systems of sub-Saharan
Food security and health are two crucial issues of           Africa: An essential first step in adapting to future cli-
climate change not specific to, but particularly dra-        mate change? Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environ-
matic for Southern Africa. The present state of              ment 126 (2008) 24–35.
health and nutrition is already a cause for major         Downing, T., Ringius, L., Hulme, M., Waughray, D.:
concern and this will not improve if adaptation and         Adapting to Climate Change in Africa. Mitigation and
mitigation activities are not taken seriously. Action       Adaptation Strategies for Global Change 2, 19-44,
                                                            1997.
needs to be taken to improve the situation people in
these countries are living in currently, and to pre-      GEF: Climate Change Adaptation. The Climate Change
vent conditions from becoming even worse in the             Funds: Linking Adaptation to Development.
                                                            www.gefweb.org.interior.aspx?id=264, online on 11
coming years.
                                                            June 2008.
    I argue in this paper that currently the most effi-
cient way of dealing with the existing and future         Gregory, P., Ingram, J., Brklacich, M.: Climate change
                                                             and food security. Philosophical Transactions of the
burdens of climate change impacts are activities at
                                                             Royal Society B (2005) 360, 2139–2148.
national level, and enhanced effort has to be made
to improve regional and international collaboration       Ellis, J., Corfee-Morlot, J., Winkler, H.: Taking Stock of
                                                               Progress under the Clean Development Mechanism
in addressing these issues. International and region-
                                                               (CDM). Prepared for OECD and IEA, 2004.
al cooperation has started and in some cases
already delivering good results, but national gov-        Engineering News Online: Africa is the worst victim of cli-
                                                             mate change. www.saeon.ac.za/eNewsletter/Online/
ernments still carry heavy responsibilities that they
                                                             2008/february/africa-is-the-worst-victim-of-climate-
are not properly prepared for. Financial, human              change/> on 05.06.2008.
and knowledge resources are lacking, to the point
                                                          FAO: 31st Session of the Committee on World Food
that some countries are not even able to participate

Journal of Energy in Southern Africa • Vol 19 No 4 • November 2008                                                  19
Security. Special Event on Impact of Climate Change,      Options, Spring 2002, 11.
     Pests and Diseases on Food Security and Poverty        Winkler, H.: Climate Change and developing countries.
     Reduction. Background Document. 23-26 May 2005.           South African Journal of Science 101, July/August
Hug, S., Rahman, A., Konate, M., Sokona, Y., Reid, H.:         2005.
   Mainstreaming Adaptation to Climate Change in            WHO (World Health Organization): Indoor air pollution
   Least Developed Countries (LDCS), 2003.                    and                                         health.
IPCC 2001: Climate Change 2001. Impacts, adaptation           www.who.int/mediacentre/factssheets/fs292/en/index.
   and vulnerability. Chapters 10, 11, 17 and 18.             html, online on the 11 June 2008, published 2005.
   Contribution of Working Group II to the 3rd
                                                            Received 18 August 2008; revised 17 November 2008
   Assessment Report of the IPCC. 2001.
IPCC WGII 2007: Working Group II Contribution to the
   Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change Fourth
   Assessment Report Climate Change 2007: Climate
   Change Impacts, Adaptation and Vulnerability.
   Summary for Policymakers.
Kyoto Protocol: United Nations Framework Convention
   on Climate Change. Kyoto Protocol to the United
   Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change.
   UNFCCC Secretariat, 2007.
Lim, S.: Needs Assessment Report – State of Climate
   Change Adaptation in South Africa Policy Drivers,
   Research and Projects. Prepared for SouthSouth-
   North, 2004.
McMichael, A., Woodruff, R., Hales, S.: Climate change
  and human health: present and future risks. Lancet
  2006; 367: 859–69.
Michaelowa, A. 2006;, Jahn, M., Raubenheimer, S,
   Liptow, H.: HWWA Discussion Paper. Measuring the
   Potential of Unilateral CDM- A Pilot Study. HWWA
   Discussion Paper 263, 2004.
Mwakasonda, S.: Lecture. University of Cape Town, MEC
  5090Z, May 2008.
Nganga, J.: Climate Change impacts, vulnerability and
   adaptation assessment in East Africa. Presentation at
   UNFCCC African regional Workshop on adaptation,
   Accra, Ghana, 21-23 September 2006.
Niang-Diop, I. & Bosch, H.: Technical Paper 8.
   Formulating an Adaptation Strategy.
Oxfam: Adapting to climate change. What´s needed in
   poor countries, and who should pay. Oxfam Briefing
   Paper. May 2007.
Patz, J., Campbell-Lendrum, C., Holloway, T., Foley, J.:
    Impact of regional climate change on human health.
    Nature 438, November 2005.
Scharma, R.: Impacts and Adaptation on Climate
   Change. Presentation at the AIACC Workshop in
   Nairobi, 11-15 February 2002.
SouthSouthNorth a: Designing Adaptation Projects.
Tyler, E.: Accessing Carbon Finance for Sustainable
    Energy Interventions in Low-income Housing across
    South Africa. A Concept Funding Proposal to the
    National Housing Finance Cooperation. Prepared for
    SouthSouthNorth, May 2007.
RSA (Republic of South Africa): A National Climate
   Change Response Strategy for South Africa. 2004.
UNDP & GEF (United Nations Development Programme
  & Global Environmental Facility): The Adaptation
  Policy Framework. User´s Guidebook for the
  Adaptation Policy Framework. Final Draft. 2003.
Unknown author: Food Security and Climate Change.

20                                          Journal of Energy in Southern Africa • Vol 19 No 4 • November 2008
You can also read