Tuamgraney, County Clare - A Community, Tourism and Cultural Development Study May 2018
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
Tuamgraney, County Clare A Community, Tourism and Cultural Development Study May 2018 Funded by
Produced by This feasibility Study was commissioned by Tuamgraney
Alan Hill Tourism Development Ltd Tourism Working Group and funded by Clare County
in association with Council. Its aim was to scope the potential of developing
Richard Rice (Healy Partners Architects) a sustainable tourism, community and cultural quarter
in the heart of the village to assist driving Rural
and
Development in the wider area. The core elements of this
Nevin Associates Ltd.
Study are the ancient St Cronan’s Church, Tuamgraney
Castle (c. 1600- built to protect this ecclesiastical legacy
Commissioned by which goes back over 1,000 years), and the nationally
Tuamgraney Tourism Working Group significant Tuamgraney Handball Club and Alleys.
Finally, these assets coexist with a Parish House, which
Designed by presented- within the overall campus. This intriguing
OpticNerve redevelopment scenario if fully realised will add genuine
value to both locals and visitors alike and position
Funded by Tuamgraney to be a key location in Fáilte Ireland’s new
destination brand- Ireland’s Hidden Heartlands.
Clare County Council
On average, once every generation communities in
Acknowledgements
rural Ireland are presented with an opportunity to
Tuamgraney Tourism Working Group would fundamentally change their development trajectory;
like to acknowledge the assistance of all The Tuamgraney community in East County Clare is now
those who inputted into this development of at this point. This Study has examined the options that
this study. In particular the group would like lie ahead to reinvigorate the local economy along with
to thank the elected members of the Killaloe its cultural, social and recreational life. It stands on the
shoulders of significant community achievements and a
Municipal District for their support and
recognisable momentum of late.
funding of this study:
Cllr Michael Begley, In order to properly investigate and communicate the
Cllr Pat Burke, interconnections between spaces and communities, this
Cllr Joe Cooney, Study adopts a spatial zonal approach, moving from an
Cllr Pat Hayes, inner Zone 1 (the tourism, community and cultural
Cllr Tony O’Brien, quarter), Zone 2 (the village) and flowing out to a
Zone 3 (East Clare). This spotlight is ever present
Cllr Alan O’Callaghan.
throughout the document. Tuamgraney, in addition,
cannot be removed from any debate about Holy Island
Further Information
or Lough Derg. All are inextricably linked by history,
tuamgraneytourism@gmail.com narrative and geography.
www.tuamgraney.ie
East Clare Memorial Park, Tuamgraney
1
Executive Summary
An essential building block of this Study has been the The scale of initial funding required for Phase 1 is
on-going conversation with the community through relatively modest (c. €300K); however, the returns are
the autumn of 2017 and spring of 2018. The constant significant in economic, infrastructural and societal
input of key partners like Clare Council and CLDC terms. Tuamgraney village has immediate challenging
/ LEADER has given the Study an authenticity along deficits to overcome, from accommodation to destination
with signposting immediate actions upon completion. recognition, but there are no obstacles that are beyond
The Study has identified that there is considerable their capacity to overcome through working together.
potential (and justification) to redevelop Zone 1 in an Tuamgraney, and in particular Zone 1, has the potential
incremental, imaginative three- Phase fashion as follows: to become a signature discovery point in the Ireland’s
Hidden Heartlands Brand to be developed.
Recommendation 1:
Conserve and enhance St. Cronan’s Church This change will only come about through greater
for the benefit of its congregation, local community participation in the process. The timeframe
community and visitors (Phase 1); needs to be viewed as being inter-generational. The
management challenge ahead is great, requiring new
Recommendation 2: ways of seeing, communicating and delivering the vision
Expand and enhance the Parish House as set out in this Study. The on-going practical support of
a community, cultural and visitor hub for key external partners will be critical to success.
Tuamgraney (Phase 1);
There is strong support evident for the built vision in
Phase 1. The visual enhancement will be significant, but
Recommendation 3: more importantly, it provides the community with new
Explore further the potential of
spaces to socialise, learn and entertain. The quality of life
the development of a National Handball
will be improved for many. Visitors likewise will benefit
Museum / Experience (Phase 2);
from an attractive, unique and authentic Irish rural
village close to the Shannon and with an important
Recommendation 4: (and entertaining) set of stories to tell and be told by
Explore the restoration of Tuamgraney gifted storytellers.
Castle to allow access for visitors
(Phase 3) This Study demonstrates a confidence that there is a
sustainable market for this integrated development
vision and that Tuamgraney has a key role to play in
the development of the new Ireland’s Hidden Heartlands
Brand.
2
Table of Contents
1 Introduction 3
1.1 Tuamgraney 4
1.2 Tuamgraney Tourism Working Group 4
1.3 Key Plans and Strategies 5
1.4 Terms of Reference 7
1.5 Defining the Study Zones 7
2 The Consultation Process and Key Findings 9
2.1 Introduction 10
2.2 Community Survey Feedback 10
2.3 Tuamgraney Community Mindmap 11
2.4 Key Findings 11
3 Key Recommendations and Core Strategic Partners 13
3.1 Zone 1 Recommendations 14
3.2 Zone 2 Recommendations 26
3.3 Zone 3 Recommendations 32
3.4 General Recommendations 33
3.5 Core Strategic Partners 34
4 Management, Operations & Finance 35
4.1 Governance 36
4.2 How Best to Manage Things Going Forward 37
4.3 Generating a Prudent Financial Model 38
4.4 Assumptions of the Financial Model 39
4.5 Revenue Forecasts 40
4.6 Conclusion 42
5 Conclusion 43
6 Appendices 47
6.1 Appendix A 48
6.2 Appendix B 49
6.3 Appendix C 49
6.4 Appendix D 50
6.5 Appendix E 51
6.6 Appendix F 52
1 Introduction
4
1.2
1.1 Tuamgraney Tourism
Tuamgraney Working Group
Tuamgraney is an award-winning village in East Clare Tuamgraney Tourism Working Group (TTWG) was
adjacent to the town of Scariff. It lies close to the shores established in late 2016 to examine the potential of
of Lough Derg with access to the lake via Reddan’s Quay and tourism and rural development in Tuamgraney.
and Scariff Harbour. The village is approximately 30 / The working group is made up of representatives of the
40 km from Limerick, Ennis, Shannon and Portumna. following:
It enjoys a strategic location on the main route around • Tuamgraney Development Association
Lough Derg with the core of the village marked by an • Bodyke / Tuamgraney Pastoral Council
attractive Memorial Park at the junction of the R352 • St Cronan’s Church Committee
(Ennis to Portumna road) and the R463 (Tuamgraney to • Tuamgraney Community Weekend Committee
Killaloe road). • Tuamgraney Handball Club
• Tourism Business Interests in Tuamgraney
The history of Tuamgraney dates from the 6th Century
when a Monastery flourished there – a sister foundation The group considers that strengthened tourism and
of Inis Cealtra (Holy Island) on Lough Derg. It is a cultural development in Tuamgraney has the potential
well-appointed village and a high performer in the Tidy to complement the flagship tourism proposals for Holy
Towns Competition- winning a bronze medal for the past Island / Inis Cealtra as outlined in the Inis Cealtra
6 years. It is also an overall winner of “Clare in Bloom” Sustainable Tourism & Visitor Management Plan. Clare
on several occasions, including 2017. Tuamgraney is County Council has funded this Study for Tuamgraney
a former overall winner in its population category in through support of the elected members in the Killaloe
the All Island Pride of Place awards. The community Municipal District.
has a strong record of accomplishment in community
development particularly through Tuamgraney
Development Association (TDA) founded in 1996 and
who initiated the formation of Tuamgraney Tourism
Working Group.
Tuamgraney and its immediate surroundings boasts a
range of activities; from equestrian, fishing, sightseeing,
golf, and offers high quality craft and artisan retailing
experiences. The village is the birthplace of world-
renowned author, Edna O’Brien, world champion
handball player, Pat Kirby, and well-known historian, the
late Dr. Edward MacLysaght.
East Clare Memorial Park, Tuamgraney
Reddan’s Quay, Tuamgraney
5
1.3
Key Plans and Strategies
1.3.1 1.3.2
Clare County Development Plan Lough Derg: Life at the Lake - A Roadmap
2017–2023 for Experience Development and
Scariff / Tuamgraney is identified in the Clare County Destination Marketing 2014–2017
Development Plan 2017–2023 as a Service Town for the This document was published in 2014 to guide those
East Clare area. Scariff / Tuamgraney had a population involved in Experience Development and Selling in the
in 2016 of 770. The Clare County Development Plan Lough Derg Area. The vision of the Study is to develop
2017–2023 identifies a focus on tourism for Tuamgraney. Lough Derg as a key destination for superb water based
activities combined with a range of very high quality
“Scarriff and Tuamgraney are recognised as one of the main walking, cycling, heritage, culture and food experiences
service centres in East Clare. The opportunity exists to allow that will entice domestic and international visitors to
these complementary settlements to expand to improve the stay longer.
range of services available to residents of both settlements
and to visitors to the area. This plan proposes that significant 1.3.3
service provision will continue to be directed towards the Lough Derg Heritage Audit 2011
more established town centre of Scarriff, while Tuamgraney An audit of the key heritage assets and themes associated
will be encouraged to complement this role with the provision with Lough Derg was undertaken in 2011. The purpose
of supporting services such as visitor accommodation, in of the audit was not only to determine the nature,
addition to building on its tourism potential arising from its characteristics and condition of the heritage assets
monastic heritage and attractive nature.” available, but also to understand how the heritage assets
could be utilised as visitor assets and built into the visitor
In recognition of the broader potential for tourism in experience. The Audit was commissioned by Clare, Galway
Tuamgraney, the Clare County Development Plan Zones and Tipperary County Councils. All the key heritage assets
a site for tourism development centred on St Cronan’s in Tuamgraney are referenced in the audit including St
10th Century Church and Tuamgraney Castle. It states the Cronan’s Church, Tuamgraney Castle and handball alleys.
following: “Tuamgraney’s location approximately mid-way
between the tourist centres of Mountshannon and Killaloe 1.3.4
provide it with the opportunity to harness its potential for Inis Cealtra Visitor Management and
Tourism development. The tourism potential of the village Sustainable Tourism Development Plan
rests in tapping into its unique heritage. The village is a This plan, published in July 2017, was commissioned by
former monastic settlement founded by St Cronan. The 10th Clare County Council with the remit to seek to ensure
century church that bears his name is the oldest church in the long-term conservation of this significant historical
continuous use in Ireland or Britain. The church has a strong and cultural site while expanding its attractiveness as a
association with Brian Boru and served as a heritage centre sustainable tourist destination for an increased number
from 1991 to 2014. In recognition of its potential to develop of visitors. The plan seeks to set this future vision
as a visitor attraction the site and adjacent lands are Zoned within a wider context and includes several references
for Tourism (TOU1)” to Tuamgraney given its historical links to Inis Cealtra
and the opportunity to orientate and direct visitors from
Tuamgraney to Inis Cealtra and vice versa.
6
1.3.5
Clare County Local Economic and
Community Plan (LECP) 2016–2021
The purpose of the plan is to promote economic
development and local and community development
in the functional area of Clare County Council. The
recognition in the plan of the potential for synergies
between community facilities and tourism is particularly
relevant to Tuamgraney.
Holy Island/Inis Cealtra
“Town and Village enhancement, including improved 1.3.8
maintenance, upgrading and renewal of community facilities Commission for Economic Development
and public spaces would not only provide quality of life of Rural Areas (CEDRA) Report
opportunities for residents but would also provide attractive This report was published in 2014 and
settings for visitors. Such enhancement would help those recommended a series of actions by government
towns and villages to achieve their potential to act as departments to support the long-term sustainable
catalysts for and / or partners in the regeneration of their development of rural Ireland. It also introduced the
more rural hinterland.” (Page 27) concept of Rural Economic Development Zones (REDZs).
Scariff & district was one of the REDZ identified in
1.3.6 County Clare. A concrete outcome is the significant
Clare Rural Development Strategy 2026 funding that has been provided for the marketing,
This is the first rural development strategy for County development and promotion of the Lough Derg Blueway
Clare and is very relevant to the broad aims of this which includes the Lough Derg Canoe Trail.
Study to drive rural development in Tuamgraney and
surrounding area. The strategy identifies Scariff / 1.3.9
Tuamgraney / Mountshannon as combined towns acting Blueways Ireland
as a hub for surrounding parishes. The Blueways are a network of multi-activity recreational
trails being developed by Waterways Ireland and its
1.3.7 partners. The new national product offering has a
LEADER Local Development Strategy (LDS) particular focus on the 180km of canoe trails with
This was developed by Clare Local Development currently 21 individual journeys. It represents a new
Company (CLDC) to achieve a number of objectives in thrust towards “slow tourism” attempting to be captured
the areas of: Enterprise Development and Tourism; Rural by Ireland’s Hidden Heartlands. For Tuamgraney
Towns, Community Facilities and Broadband; Hard-to- the overall tourism experience linking food, culture,
Reach Communities and Young People; Water Protection, heritage and activity is an attractive proposition and one
Biodiversity and Renewable Energy. Through an on-going the community is well positioned to capitalise upon.
conversation with CLDC it has been established that Continued engagement with Waterways Ireland will pay
there are considerable opportunities for support. handsome dividends into the future for Tuamgraney.
7
1.4 1.5
Terms of Reference Defining the Study Zones
Alan Hill Tourism Development Ltd and Associates were Three spatially distinct Zones were defined for the Study.
appointed by Tuamgraney Tourism Working Group to These zones are outlined and mapped on the next page.
carry out a feasibility Study, in consultation with key
stakeholders, for the sustainable development of tourism
in Tuamgraney. The Terms of Reference evolved as the
project proceeded and in light of findings. The objectives
of the Tuamgraney Community, Tourism and Cultural
Development Study were;
TOU1, Tourism Zoned Site, Tuamgraney
1: To provide proposals for the
a. St. Cronan’s Church
future sustainable management and b. Tuamgraney Castle
protection of the site TOU1 (see aerial c. Parish House
photograph) including how they inform d. Tuamgraney Handball Club
e. Additional Tourism Zoned Lands
visitor management;
2: To provide proposals on the
provision of community, cultural and
tourism development on site TOU1
e
and the village of Tuamgraney in order
to assist in driving rural development
in the wider East Clare area.
d
b
c
a
8 ZONE 1:
The land Zoned Tourism (TOU1) in
Parish
Tuamgraney, including St Cronan’s House &
Church & Graveyard, the Handball Gardens
Club & Alleys, Tuamgraney Castle, Tuamgraney
Castle
the Parish House and Garden
(front and back) and lands to the
Tuamgraney
rear of the Parish House. Handball
Club & Alleys
St. Cronan’s
Church, 964AD
Graveyard
Edna Reddan’s Quay
O’Brien Scariff
Plaque Dr. Tommy Daly
Plaque Lough
River Sha
Woollen Mill
and Shop Tuamgraney Lime Kiln
er
East Clare
East Clare
Riv
Equestrian
Centre Memorial
um
Park
hr
Handmade
oag
Chocolate
Cr
Factory
and Shop St. Joseph’s ZONE 1
RC Church ZONE 2:
Bodyke GAA Grounds 400m
Famine Memorial Park 540m Everything outside Zone 1
St. Coelan’s Well 1km and within the controlled
R352 speed limits of Tuamgraney
Bodyke 4km village.
Tulla 16km
Ennis 33km
Limerick 35km
ke GAA Grounds 400m
ne Memorial Park 540m
oelan’s Well 1km
2
yke 4km Tuamgraney
a 16km Community
is 33km Woodland
erick 35km Slieve Aughty
Whitegate
Crusheen Mountshannon R463
M18 Feakle
Scarriff g Killaloe 15km
h D er Limerick 45km
Barefield Loug
Tuamgraney
Tulla
Nenagh
ENNIS
Quin Kilkishen Killaloe ZONE 3:
Newmarket
Broadford
The broader East Clare area covers
on Fergus
roughly 640sq km, with the town of Ennis
Sixmilebridge O’Briensbridge M7
to the west, Limerick to the south, the
SHANNON Shannon Slieve Aughty Mountains to the north,
Bunratty
INTERNATIONAL Parteen and nearby Lough Derg, forming its
AIRPORT
tuary LIMERICK Eastern boundary of the outer Zone.
n o n Es
Sh a n N19 N18 CITY
M20
N242 The Consultation Process and Key Findings
10
Wilde Irish
Chocolates,
Tuamgraney
2.1 2.2
Introduction Community Survey Feedback
The role and importance of a thorough and continuous A key part of the consultation Phase of this Study was
consultation process- informing research and findings the feedback received through a Community Survey.
was not undervalued. It was appreciated by the It is clear from the analysis that there is a need for
community that future success would likely depend greater community participation in the delivery of
on foundations being laid and relationships built the development agenda going forward. As with the
(both internally and externally) in these early stages majority of similar communities it is the small number
rotating around a shared vision. A set of consultees of committed volunteers upon whose back the bulk of
(in discussions with TTWG) were identified across the the work rests. This status quo is no longer an option
public, private, community, agency and special interest for Tuamgraney. The Survey (10 questions) addressed
groups that needed to feed into the Study. In summary, the following: - issues facing the village, priority actions,
the consultation process involved one to one interviews, obstacles, creating a tourism economy, and village
telephone interviews, Zone 1 landowners interviews, enhancement.
Focus Group sessions with agency partners and with
relevant local organisations. There were formal Council
sessions with Elected Members and separately Council
Officers (x 4 sessions in total). Importantly there
Heritage in Tuamgraney
Are you aware of Tuamgraney’s rich ecclesiastical and
were well attended Public Sessions (X 2) in the Parish historical heritage?
House and the Secondary School. In total, an excess of
120 people participated in the consultation process; a
representative level of participation and feedback. In
81% Yes
order to secure a wider level of considered feedback from
the Tuamgraney community a Community Survey was
distributed and the results fed into the process.
4% No
15% Some Awareness
Could Tuamgraney’s existing heritage play a more
important part in the community, cultural, educational
and business life of the village?
70% Yes
4% No
26% Not Sure11
2.3
Tuamgraney Community 2.4
Mindmap Key Findings
The Tuamgraney Mindmap captured information that During such a Study, discoveries usually come from
was locally relevant to the village, i.e. Zone 2. The one of three sources- namely: what people, partners
exercise was a culmination of preliminary desktop and ‘friends’ of the project tell you during the talking
research and direct feedback and input that was received phase; what one’s own professional objectivity, informed
during an open public session. It is useful both in terms by experience, tells you; and finally what is revealed by
of baseline information for future monitoring and looking at best in class examples of similar ventures
evaluation of the village’s progress and development. It elsewhere. In table format on the following page are the
also captures a wide variety of local relevant information principal findings that have come out of the research and
that may help inform decisions and help information consultation phase that started at the end of September
retrieval for current and future project research. 2017 and finishing six months later. The commentary
piece (right column) is intended to place each in an
The list of consultees, results of the community survey unadorned strategic context.
and mindmap are included in appendix A.
Attractiveness of Tuamgraney 1 2 3 4 5
Within the village today, could you rate the attractiveness
of what is on offer to the visitor? (1 = Not Attractive to 5 = Highly Attractive)
Parking
Tourist Resources (information, signage, things to do)
Regular Events & Entertainment on Offer
Welcoming Environment (Friendly welcome)
Attractive Environment (clean, looking good, community pride)
Location / Ease of Access (to the village)
Commercial Outlets / Catering / Tourist Accommodation
Development Concerns 1 2 3 4 5
Please rate any possible concerns you may have about
tourism and heritage development in Tuamgraney? 1 = No Concern to 5 = Big Concern
Lack of Tourist Demand
Lack of Continued Support from External Public Partners
Inability of the Community to Agree on a Suitable Strategy
Negative Impact on the Community Fabric of the Village due to increased numbers
Negative Overall Environmental Impacts eg. cars, litter, noise
Expenditure on Tourism / Heritage not Necessary in the Current Climate
Ample supply of Similar Heritage Offerings in East Clare12
Ref Description Zone(s) Comments
Need for full alignment with emerging Lough Derg / Critical attention needs to be paid to the evolution
Holy Island propositions. of both these significant strategic projects. As much
1 3
as possible Tuamgraney needs to ‘drive’ rather than
be a ‘passenger’.
Need for enhanced cooperation and joint Isolationist thinking and parish rivalry will be to the
2 programming with Scariff and adjoining 3 detriment of the community. Partnership and joint
communities in East Clare. working are the language of today.
Tuamgraney possesses superior heritage Recognise the exceptional ‘assets’ at the
and recreational assets in a clean welcoming communities’ disposal. In themselves they will never
3 environment in a well located area destined for 2 3 create a tourism destination. Enhanced organisation
tourism growth over the coming decade. and added value will bring these ‘assets’ to a new
level.
Inadequate tourism related infrastructure, skills Without systematically addressing clear tourism
and experience e.g. accommodation & festivals / related deficits in the Tuamgraney economy little
4 2
events. substantial progress can be expected. Enhanced
commercialization is required.
Multiple owners of the primary heritage assets in All relevant parties / landowners in relation to the
the inner heritage cluster. inner Zone 1 need to buy-in to the redevelopment
project over its proposed development phases. It’s
5 1
important to remember any redevelopment is for
the benefit of the community and visitor alike. Dual
recognition is critical.
Respected artisan producers with a commitment These micro businesses will create employment,
to the development of the community however give the visitor a reason to stop, linger and spend
significantly more are required to create the money. More are required. These businesses need
6 2
necessary critical mass of micro businesses that to be suitably networked.
can form the foundation of a sustainable tourism
destination.
There exists capable development drivers, however Despite the fact that this is a community / voluntary
more participation will be required however more run enterprise it needs to aim to be managed to the
7 participation will be required from across the rest of 2 standards of the highest private sector business.
the community Commercial acumen and income generation has to
be ever-present in the way business is conducted.
Considerable practical support emerging from Recognise, acknowledge and continue to deliver
CLDC and Clare County Council. for those bodies / agencies that have supported
8 2 the community in the difficult early period. They
will likely see this as a long term relationship. Be
mindful to give them what they seek.
Potential mid-term partnership with Fáilte Ireland Through the ice-breaking of this Study continue to
as part of the emerging ‘Lakelands’ offering. develop the personal relationship with key officers
9 2 3 of Fáilte Ireland who have been tasked with creating
a new heritage tourism proposition around the
navigable waterways.
Key Tuamgraney ‘stories’ are St Cronan’s and Tourism is a fast changing sector of the Irish and
its relationships to Brian Boru & Holy Island and global economy. Technology, trends and fashion will
Visionary Edward MacLysaght so much more than influence what the visitor needs tomorrow however
10 1
just the founder of modern Irish genealogy. to hedge against these vagaries Tuamgraney
should focus on its core stories, told by excellent
storytellers in an authentic friendly atmosphere.13 3 Key Recommendations and Core Strategic Partners The apex of any Feasibility Study is a set of considered and integrated recommendations. These in turn have evolved from the findings which flowed from the extensive research and ‘listening’ phase of the project. The recommendations in this Study are presented for each of Zone 1, 2 and 3 and finally some general recommendations that are key to delivering over time on the overall vision of the Study.
St. Cronan’s doorway
14
3.1
Zone 1 Recommendations
3.1.1
Introduction
The assembly of St Cronan’s Church, Tuamgraney Castle, St Cronan’s 10th Century Church
the Handball Club and the adjacent Parish House on a St Cronan’s was built prior to 964AD and is the oldest
single site at one of the main entry points to Tuamgraney church in continuous use in Ireland. It is a rare surviving
presents a unique opportunity in which to develop a building in the country with a direct link to Brian Boru,
project that is inclusive of Heritage, Sports, Tourism who is recorded as having repaired the building, with
and Community uses. More broadly, the public realm visitors today still passing through the same 10th century
spaces can be developed in a manner that creates both doorway used by the High King of Ireland. This is the site
a strong sense of pride of place for the community and of the original monastery in Tuamgraney and was a sister
destination for the visitors. establishment of Holy Island. A round tower also existed
within the complex but no trace of it survives.
Zone 1 is located at the entrance to the village when
approached from Killaloe / Lough Derg. The proposed Tuamgraney Castle
site area along with a field to rear (west) is Zoned in the This 15th Century Tower House was built by the O’Grady
Clare County Development Plan 2017–2023 for Tourism clan to protect St Cronan’s Church in the same way as
use with the named objective in the Development Plan Tuamgraney’s round tower (long disappeared) provided
stating ‘make provision for amenity, leisure and tourism- protection in earlier centuries. It is a rare surviving
related developments to contribute to the tourism example of a tower house in a village setting in County
product, based on the network of loughs, harbours and Clare.
walkways in Scariff / Tuamgraney and the wider area’.
The site includes two protected structures (St Cronan’s Members of the O’Grady family almost invariably
Church &Tuamgraney Castle) which are separated by the provided the churchmen here from c. 1100 to 1600. The
Croaghrum River flowing through the site. O’Grady clan have very strong associations with Holy
Island and the ‘Church of the Wounded Men’ was their
The site location enjoys prominence to the public road mortuary chapel on the island.
which is the major tourism route for Lough Derg and
Holy Island into the future. The location is also at the
heart of Tuamgraney village being within metres of the
Memorial Park. The design intent behind the public
realm (Zone 1) could be taken forward to inform the
design style, and finishes for the public realm for the rest
of the village (Zone 2).Tuamgraney 60x30
Handball Alley 15
Tuamgraney Handball Club Parish House
The handball club is located immediately behind The existing Parish House is a single storey, modest
Tuamgraney Castle and consists of both a large format mid-20th Century dwelling which is currently used as the
(60 x 30) and normal format (40 x 20) handball Parish office and community meeting rooms. Set on its
courts, both enclosed. The club has a significant history, own grounds, it has a large garden area to the rear and
founded in 1911 and was the club of world handball a front garden which has the potential to engage more
champion Pat Kirby (1970). Kirby also collected four positively with the public roadway to the front.
successive All-Ireland senior softball singles titles (1974-
77) and six consecutive 40x20 medals (1975-80) before In conclusion, the buildings located on the site area
travelling to the USA where he dominated the USHA combine to present an opportunity to consider a
Masters series. He became the first Irish member of the development that engages in Heritage, Culture, Sports
prestigious USA Hall of Fame in 1986. When looking at and Community. While the presence of St Cronan’s
the history of Handball in Ireland, it intersects frequently Church and Tuamgraney Castle anchor the tourism and
with Tuamgraney. The handball club is vibrant and heritage element of the scheme, the development of the
well supported and includes among its club members Parish House allows the site area to host the necessary
Diarmaid Nash, one of the top players currently in the services and social events.
country including Irish Men’s Senior Doubles Champion
2018 and a World Men’s Doubles Winner (2015). It is recommended that Zone 1 develop to its full
potential over 3 clear phases.
Parish House with
Tuamgraney Castle
in background16
3.1.1.1 “Interpretation and information available on, and visitors
RECOMMENDATION 1 encouraged to visit, Tuamgraney—St Cronan’s church
Conserve and enhance St Cronan’s for the benefit at Tuamgraney to the south of Scarriff, was built before
of its congregation, local community and visitors 964AD, and is one of the oldest churches in use in Ireland,
(Phase 1) England, Scotland and Wales. A doorway in the church,
St Cronan’s Church is owned by the Church of Ireland, through which Brian Boru entered over 1,000 years ago, is
who are very proud of its unique history and are still intact.” (Page 131)
committed to its future. The church is open unattended
to visitors from April to September each year. Tuamgraney Development Association with the
assistance of funding from the Heritage Council installed
The building is a place of worship. There are no proposals visitor / interpretive signage in early 2018 to enhance
recommended for St Cronan’s that would compromise the visitor experience but it would benefit from further
this. The focus is on how the story of the building and discrete and sensitive interpretation. St Cronan’s Church
its history can be told in a sensitive manner. Indeed the has recently facilitated community events such as
stillness and quietness of the building, providing a place music and lectures. It is renowned for having excellent
for reflection for visitors, is viewed as an asset. acoustics. These initiatives are seen as an opportunity
to harness greater community and visitor usage all in a
The church and Tuamgraney have strong links with Holy manner that is respectful of its ecclesiastical importance.
Island / Inis Cealtra and this potential is well referenced
in the Clare County Council ‘Inis Cealtra Sustainable St Cronan’s is in good condition and there is no
Tourism Development Plan’ as documented below: substantial conservation or construction works to be
undertaken with the exception of re pointing of the west
“Given Tuamgraney’s strategic location on the main route gable. The building served a dual use as the East Clare
around Lough Derg and its riverside setting, there is an Heritage Centre from 1989 to 2014. Substantial repair
opportunity to stress the historical links between the two and conservation works were carried out by the East
ecclesiastical settlements as a way to orientate and direct Clare Heritage Group in the late 1980s / early 1990s
visitors to Inis Cealtra.” (Page 22) along with significant promotional work. Tuamgraney
continues to benefit from the legacy of this work.
“Focus on the development of Inis Cealtra will be developed
within the context of the other heritage attractions in
the northeast Clare area…extraordinary sites that should
serve as a natural adjunct and onward step from the
Mountshannon / Inis Cealtra destination, ideally via the
Pre-Romanesque Church at Tuamgraney”. (Page 73)Concert at St. Cronan’s Church
17
This Study recommends the following for St Cronan’s:
• Continue to open Church unattended from April to
September season and build on telling the story of
St Cronan’s over the last 1,000yrs aided by recent
signage funded by the Heritage Council;
• Continue to work seamlessly with the Church
authorities and congregation;
• Devise and install a high quality AV presentation
on the history of St Cronan’s Church / Monastery
at Tuamgraney and links with Brian Boru and Holy
Island;
• Upgrade appropriately the appearance of interior of
Church;
• Undertake necessary conservation works to west
gable (repointing with lime mortar);
• Develop a website / Facebook page for St Cronan’s
that is responsibly managed;
• Encourage wider use of St Cronan’s as a cultural
space that can be ‘packaged’ e.g. music, screenings,
talks and boutique conferences in keeping with the
character of the building;
• Offer St Cronan’s as a unique and historic marriage
venue;
• Develop a conservation management plan for St
Cronan’s including for the recording and storage of
the various stone fragments in the church.
• Reverse temporary alterations from the 1990s as the
building no longer functions as a heritage centre
Local actors
perform the role
of Brian Boru and
his brother Marcán,
at St. Cronan’s
10th Century Church18
3.1.1.2
RECOMMENDATION 2 This Study and the working group fully acknowledge
Expand and enhance the Parish House as that any decision on the future use of the building is
a community, cultural, and visitor hub for a matter for the community and the Pastoral Council.
Tuamgraney (Phase 1) The purpose of this Study is to create a vision for the
The Parish House is owned and managed by Bodyke / building as part of Zone 1, make recommendations on
Tuamgraney Parish and Pastoral Council. It currently its potential continued evolution as a space for locals
serves as a parish office on a part time basis in addition and visitors alike and advise on the feasibility of any
to being popular for community meetings and events. proposals.
The public consultation clearly showed that its evolution The benefit of the Parish House is that restrictions
into a community space in recent years is highly imposed by the various elements of confinement
valued by parishioners and there is a strong desire to (protected structures, existing activity, and available site
see it enhanced further for community and pastoral area) of the other three buildings are not encountered
use. Existing uses of the Parish House and potential with this building. There is more physical development
additional uses are contained in Appendix B. The research flexibility.
and consultation also noted similar initiatives / projects
that had been completed in Kilkishen and Flagmount The recommended development of this structure is to
in recent years and were planned or underway in accommodate all existing activity but also develop the
Ogonnelloe and Scariff and that need and capacity also location to accommodate a variety of uses allowing
existed in Tuamgraney. the building to evolve into an important hub for the
community / parish and visitors to the area.
There is also a recognition that a shared use with a visitor
focus would also be of wider benefit including helping The design approach to the Parish House therefore
sustain the house into the future. It would also help looks to retain all existing functions that the building
position Tuamgraney to benefit from sustainable tourism currently carries out and to develop the building with
development likely to emerge in the years ahead with the select refurbishment of the existing building and a single
strengthening of Holy Island as a destination and the storey extension to the rear. It is recommended that the
new Fáilte Ireland’s brand- Ireland’s Hidden Heartlands. existing building is modified to accommodate a café,
gift shop and toilets. The rear extension is intended to
accommodate multi-use areas which are flexible in their
format and capable of exhibition, community events,
co-working space, modest interpretation and functions.Blossom Harp Festival 2018, Tuamgraney
19
This Study recommends the following for the
Parish House;
• Bodyke / Tuamgraney Pastoral Council in
conjunction with wider parish and community
to expand the existing Parish House creating an
enhanced community, cultural and visitor space;
• Devise a structure for delivering the above vision
that ensures that the building remains in parish
In addition, the development of the rear garden into a ownership;
courtyard capable of assembly, play space, community • Examine potential for expanding the Parish House
events and markets should be considered. The location of to be of benefit to the entire East Clare cluster of
this courtyard can visually ‘surprise’, given its proximity parishes as a venue for meetings / talks as well as
to Tuamgraney Castle as well as future linkages to being a community / cultural centre for Bodyke /
adjoining tourism development in the future. Tuamgraney Parish.
• Using preliminary proposals in this plan, consult
The proposed public realm works (see image) are further on project through Community Planning
organised around the idea of unifying all the front garden Exercise being funded by CLDC / LEADER programme
areas into an open landscaped area. The route over to St (commenced April, 2018). In particular target
Cronan’s Church could be improved with the installation consultation at younger (u30) and older (over 60) age
of a foot bridge over the stream, aligning the route from groups to identify needs. Recognise the current multi-
the Castle to the Church. The landscape works could uses and reimagine new additional uses going forward;
include a sculpting of the landscape to allow ease of • If this vision is acceptable (and resources secured)
access to the stream terrace. The visual impact towards the extended Parish House should be used during
the public road would be strong and positive. day time by visitors and local alike. This attractive
space could offer: - coffee shop / cafe, learning Zone,
The opportunity of the project would also determine how local interpretation telling the Tuamgraney story,
traffic speed can be reduced to appropriate and safe levels tech hub, exhibitions, modest retailing (local crafts)
and present a project of scale to the passer by who is and events. In additional the existing parish office
encouraged to stop and explore not just the site area but would be refreshed, meeting facilities improved and
to continue to explore the other secrets of Tuamgraney. made more flexible, rest facilities expanded and the
In this respect the proposed public realm improvements outdoors Zone employed as an orientation space
for the area in front of Zone 1 extending up to the with capacity to host larger groups and events. The
Memorial Park are critical to the overall project. opening hours should aim to be 9am to 9pm.
• Devise key stories to be told in the building in spaces
that are shared with community uses. Commission
an interpretive framework. These include aspects of
history / heritage of Tuamgraney / East Clare e.g. literary
heritage, war of independence, famine history, industrial
heritage, biodiversity heritage, waterways heritage,
musical heritage. Further details in Appendix C.20
Architectural Approach
Artist’s
The architectural approach sees the development of
Impression
public space that achieves an ease of connection between
only
St Cronan’s Church, Tuamgraney Castle, The Handball
club and the Parish House.
6
The development of the Parish House
8
proposes the full retention of all 7
existing activities of this building and
the development of additional activities
9
such as Café (with frontage to both the
courtyard and the road), and multi-use
rooms which can be used for exhibition
and community uses. 4 5
The courtyard proposed to the rear of the
2
Parish House allows the holding of a variety
3
of events and a place of gathering.
The assembly of religious, historic, community
1
and sporting uses on the one location is truly
unique and offers a notable opportunity in the
development of a community and tourism hub
for Tuamgraney.
The proposed development of the public realm by way of
opening up the front gardens to the existing properties
will present a very positive aspect to those entering
Tuamgraney and achieves a sense of place and activity.
Artist’s Impression only
1 2 821
1 Walkway Bridge connecting 4 Exhibition space within castle 7 Existing Parish House: proposed
St. Cronan’s and the Castle Café/ Meetings/Shop & Toilets
5 Future rooftop viewing area
2 Enhanced riverside space created 8 Exhibition and multi-use space
6 Boundary wall removed to create
3 Timber screening to create more a new public realm 9 Courtyard multi-use space
natural backdrop for castle
Artist’s Impression only
8
6
7
9
3 5 4
Artist’s Impression only22
3.1.1.3
RECOMMENDATION 3 This Study has examined this concept further and
Explore further the potential of the development endorses it but on the basis that it should strive to be a
of a National Handball Museum / Experience national handball experience rather than just a handball
(Phase 2) museum. It should provide elements of history but also
The Lough Derg Heritage Audit (2011) recommended seek to give the visitor an experience of the game through
that without interfering with its playing function that exhibitions and / or trying the game.
the 60x30 handball alley in Tuamgraney could have a
dual function as a handball museum as well as providing Potential for GAA support for this should be explored as
demonstrations on how this traditional game is played. while handball features in the GAA museum in Dublin it
does not do so in a significant way nor is it in a handball
It suggested that the front wall of the 60x30 court could setting. A national handball experience does not exist
be used to project a short documentary about the history anywhere else in the country and therefore this could
of handball in Ireland. A documentary on handball and be a unique attraction particularly if coupled with the
its history featuring in part Tuamgraney has already other elements within Zone 1. Handball is the only
been produced and it may be possible to acquire and true international GAA sport with the World Handball
edit this at a relatively low cost. Projection and sound Championships rotating between Canada, America and
considerations would also be examined as part of any Ireland. The potential therefore exists also to bring this
interpretive framework. It is anticipated these could be international dimension to life.
provided without an excessive cost and a viewing gallery
already exists in the ball alley. The design intent and concept is to not interfere with the
function and vibrancy of the existing club but to explore
how to engage the visitor in a handball experience, to
allow observation and to, where appropriate, undertake
exhibition of the sport.23
Tuamgraney
60x30 Handball alley
It is acknowledged that as part of exploring this concept The Study recommends the following:
that potential operational issues would have to be • Subject to the agreement of the club explore in
examined. As the handball club itself is focused on more detail the potential for a National Handball
coaching and playing it is not anticipated nor expected Experience. This is not intended to interfere with
that it would be the main driver of such a project if it playing activities. GAA Handball Council to be
were to emerge but rather that it embrace and facilitate consulted and encouraged to participate.
the concept. • Over time, scope out with the Club the elements
of the current space to see what features could be
It is also recommended if Phases 2 and 3 proceed to refurbished or interpreted in imaginative ways to
address the visual impact of the existing 60x30 alley on add value to the experience. Ensuring there is an
the background view of Tuamgraney Castle. The erection ‘experiential’ aspect to a visit to the Club would be a
of a large timber screening is visualised in order to create distinct advantage for example seeing an exhibition
a more positive backdrop to the castle. This would also match, being taught to hit a handball, hearing and
present an opportunity for enhanced signage for the seeing the ‘legends’ that have commanded these
handball club. alleys down the years;
• Tastefully screen the facade of the 60x30 alley from
the roadside perspective to offer a better backdrop to
the Castle.
In summary, this project could be delivered at a relatively
modest cost and would appear to align with the
undiscovered points of interest that should be central to
the Ireland’s Hidden Heartlands Tourism brand.
Tuamgraney’s Pat Kirby,
1970 World Handball Champion24
3.1.1.4
RECOMMENDATION 4
Explore the restoration of Tuamgraney Castle to
allow access for visitors (Phase 3)
The castle tower is well constructed with some fine stone
details throughout. There is substantial repair required to
the tower to permit it be used for access and viewing. An
initial survey is proposed to review the condition of the
external façade from the perspective of soundness and
safety. The initial conservation works would look at repair
to the stairway to first floor level, repair to openings
generally and the conservation of the ground level vault
which has the potential to accommodate an element of
exhibition. A full bat survey and assessment would be
required prior to any works being carried out.
Tuamgraney Castle therefore while in need of notable
conservation and repair can be made capable of
incorporating an element of exhibition to the ground
floor vault. Initial ideas centre on the interpretation of
MacLysaght’s ‘Surnames of Ireland’. The longer-term
vision for the castle is its extensive repair with restoration
of stairs and providing access to upper levels including
roof level to achieve views over Tuamgraney and the East
Clare countryside including Lough Derg.
The Study recommends the following:
• In partnership with and subject to the agreement of
the landowner (MacLysaght family) examine how best
to a) make the building as safe as possible b) explore
opening the modest ground floor space possibly to
house a unique interactive presentation on clans,
genealogy and surnames of Ireland and c) technically
investigate opening up the upper floor of the Castle
with its commanding views over to Lough Derg.
• Seek funding for a conservation and repair Study
to determine scope of works necessary to allow the
building to be accessible.
• Investigate the hosting of an O’Grady clan rally
to raise the profile of the project and explore, for
example, the potential of crowd funding.
Tuamgraney Castle25
Killaloe
Approach Road,
Tuamgraney
3.1.1.5
RECOMMENDATION 5
Undertake public realm enhancement works
in front of Zone 1
The public realm generally refers to all areas between
buildings such as roads, footpaths and other spaces
that are in public ownership. The area in front of
Zone 1 extending up to the Memorial Park is an
important consideration for the successful development
of Zone 1 and the village generally. This area lies
within the Architectural Conservation Area (ACA) for 3.1.2
Tuamgraney and it is recommended that Clare County Conclusion
Council, subject to funding, advance an enhancement This study concludes there is significant potential in
scheme for this location having respect to the preliminary Zone 1 and the proposed phased approach is both
proposals in this study. In addition to helping highlight a sustainable and realistic. Zone 1 has the potential in
sense of arrival to Zone 1, any scheme should also aim to time to be a signature discovery point in the new
slow down traffic at this key location. Finally, the scheme Ireland’s Hidden Heartlands and given the advances
should ensure continuity of car parking for existing made with this study may be considered as a suitable
residential and community properties. pilot project for the rollout of this new brand.
3.1.1.6
RECOMMENDATION 6
Examine the potential of the
tourism Zoned lands to rear of site
Into the longer term examine the potential of opening
up some of the tourism Zoned privately owned land
to the rear of the Parish House to facilitate additional
parking and possibly creation of a sustainable community
enterprise. The Study recommends that this investigation
should be done in full consultation with the landowner.
Potential means of access,
subject to landowners agreement26
3.2
Zone 2 Recommendations
3.2.1
Tourism Infrastructure
1. Support the expansion of existing and the 2. Support the expansion of visitor accommodation
development of new craft and related enterprises in Tuamgraney
in Tuamgraney Even with its abundance of natural and heritage
It is the small micro businesses in the community assets there remains considerable work to be done
that will lead on bringing in visitors, increasing addressing the lack of basic tourism infrastructure
tourist expenditure in the community and generating especially accommodation. The exceptions to this
employment. Tuamgraney has a long tradition include the high quality Fáilte Ireland approved
of quality crafts with Wilde Irish Chocolates and Clareville House B&B in the village and the well-
McKernan’s Woollen Mills both in existence in the used self-catering accommodation in the East Clare
village over 20 years. Both have plans to grow their Golf Village in Bodyke. Tuamgraney and East Clare
offering to visitors and this should be supported has to increase dwell time by the visitor, as it will
by the various development agencies. Tuamgraney especially benefit from overnighting visitors. Planning
should position itself as a location for additional Permission exists for a new hotel and leisure centre
craft enterprises given its central location and the in Tuamgraney (Site Zoned Tourism TOU 2). The
potential for synergy with existing operators and construction of this hotel would be of enormous
emerging proposals in Zone 1. On-going work should benefit to tourism in East Clare and the proposals
include networking, cross selling, training and the for Zone 1 if implemented would help sustain such a
identification of gaps in the provision of commercial facility and vice versa.
services. It would be desirable to see the development
of a formal commercial network of operators and 3. Support the widening of the food offering
businesses in the village. Within the new Ireland’s in Tuamgraney
Hidden Heartlands, Tuamgraney has significant Nuala’s Bar and Restaurant is an award winning food
potential to be a key destination for artisan crafts. establishment in Tuamgraney serving both locals
and visitors. This Study endorses widening the food
offering in the locality with an emphasis on fresh
and local. The village would also benefit from the
presence of a coffee shop / cafe to serve both visitor
and local trade and the potential for this is included
in Zone 1.
Clareville House B&B, Tuamgraney1916 Centenary
Commemoration at 27
East Clare
Memorial Park’
3.2.2 3.2.3
Festivals & Events Recreation & Amenities
4. Build on success of existing festivals in Tuamgraney 7. Develop a walking and recreational plan
The Tuamgraney Community Weekend was There are a number of existing walks and amenities
established in 2012 and occurs each June Bank in the Tuamgraney / Scariff area e.g. Tuamgraney
Holiday Weekend. It is a family focused weekend Community Woodland, Scariff Riverside Park. There
and has potential to grow to attract more day visitors. would be a benefit to both communities coming
The Lough Derg 5k / 10k run is a welcome addition together to examine opportunities for expanding
to the calendar of events in recent years. There is a walks with the support of Clare Local Development
particular opportunity to build themes around the Company (CLDC) and Clare County Council.
strengths and identity of Tuamgraney including Improvements to these amenities are of benefit to
heritage, literary, genealogy, handball and its riverside the local community (health and wellness) and
location. The Blossom Harp Festival Weekend was visitors (things to do). These initiatives and others
established in 2016 and takes place on Palm Sunday outlined below will be essential to develop to ensure
Weekend each year. It is an enjoyable weekend of alignment with the new Ireland’s Hidden Heartlands
dance and music with harp, fiddle and set dancing tourism Brand.
workshops, a harp-makers exhibition and it attracts
participants from all over the Country. There is 8. Derive a greater benefit from Tuamgraney’s riverside
significant potential for this festival to grow and setting and the Lough Derg Blueway
develop. In addition to bringing this theme into festivals and
events there is potential to harness the benefits of the
5. Develop a calendar of events recently launched Lough Derg Blueway. In particular
A calendar of events for Tuamgraney and adjoining Waterways Ireland should be encouraged to install
communities will help with improving overall a slip way for small boats, SUP’s and canoes etc. at
inter-village coordination. The aim should be to Reddan’s Quay. The start-up of Derg Boat Trips from
sustainably grow the festival and events offering over Scariff Harbour in 2018 is a welcome development.
the coming ten years. As Tuamgraney is a well located Shannonside village,
it should benefit from the continued growth of
6. Support greater use of East Clare Equestrian Centre navigation on the Shannon. In summary, there has
as a multi-purpose event space. been a 10% per annum growth in cruise hire sector
The East Clare Equestrian Centre is a large indoor for the last 3 years (including 2017), while private
arena that also houses a well-attended car boot sale boating continues to increase with 8,500 boats now
each Sunday. The building has significant untapped on the system.
potential as an event space.28
Tuamgraney
Community
Woodland
3.2.4
Enhance the Built Environment
However, despite this impressive growth, boating 11. Enhance the use and appearance of
capacity is currently underutilised in both Scariff the East Clare Memorial Park
Harbour and Reddan’s Quay (35 boat capacity). The East Clare Memorial Park opened in 1952 is a
There is likely a perception abroad that there is garden of remembrance to the War of Independence.
little to do or see on land. This is best addressed by It is beautifully maintained by Tuamgraney
continued product / facilities enhancement coupled Development Association and is often commented
with heightened marketing and public relations. upon favourably by Tidy Town’s adjudicators. It
is recommended that it be further enhanced as a
9. Explore the potential of forest based ‘signature’ piece of open space with the support
outdoor adventure activities of Clare County Council given its historical
It is recommended to explore the significant potential significance and in particular, its central location in
of developing forest based outdoor adventure play Tuamgraney and on the Lough Derg driving route.
e.g. zip wire, adventure play zones and eco discovery There is potential in time to tell the story of the
park to add to the educational and outdoors appeal War of Independence in East Clare in the proposed
of the village to complement the heritage offering. enhanced Parish House in Zone 1 and thus create a
Not only could this open up new markets, but it link between the two locations.
could also help extend the tourist season. This should
be explored further with private or state owners 12. Eliminate derelict sites and property in the village
(Coillte). Tuamgraney is largely free of vacant and derelict sites
and properties but the exceptions- either side of the
10. Explore the provision of additional facilities “old hall” and Dun Carrig are taking seriously from
for families an otherwise attractive village. Clare County Council
A small amount of play equipment would be a is encouraged to work with these owners and the
welcome addition to the village. The Memorial local community to see these return to beneficial
Park should be explored as a suitable location for use. It is essential that these issues are addressed in
some suitable pieces of play equipment the design, the short term. They present an opportunity for infill
materials and scale would need to be carefully chosen development that will enhance the village.
and located to fit with the character of the park and
would require further consultation with all relevant
stakeholders. Consider also enhancing and expanding
on picnic areas for families and leisure cyclists.You can also read
