Effect of an Aspartame-Ethanol Mixture on Daphnia magna Cardiac Activity

Page created by Arnold Cross
 
CONTINUE READING
Page 1 of 9
                                               Impulse: The Premier Journal for Undergraduate Publications in the Neurosciences
                                                                                                                          2009

Effect of an Aspartame-Ethanol Mixture on Daphnia magna
Cardiac Activity
Stephanie Schleidt1, Danielle Indelicato2, Ashley Feigenbutz1, Cierra Lewis1, and Rebecca
Kohn2
1
Neuroscience Department, Ursinus College, Collegeville, Pennsylvania, 19426, 2Biology Department, Ursinus
College, Collegeville, PA, 19426

Aspartame in conjunction with alcohol has been shown to increase the blood alcohol level in
humans faster than alcohol and sucrose (Wu et al., 2006). To determine the potential effects of
various mixtures of ethanol and aspartame on the nervous system, the heart rate of Daphnia
magna (D.magna, water flea) was measured in deionized water (control), ethanol, aspartame,
and five different mixtures of ethanol and aspartame. The heart rate was chosen as a
representative measure since it is controlled by the nervous system and the heart rate of D.
magna can easily be measured. The results were statistically evaluated by student’s t-test. A
significant increase in heart rate was observed for all mixed assays compared to both control and
ethanol, but not to aspartame. The data suggests that the aspartame and alcohol mixture have a
greater effect on D. magna heart rate than water or ethanol, but not aspartame alone. We propose
that alcohol in combination with aspartame has potentially detrimental consequences for the
nervous system.

Keywords: Daphnia magna; nervous system; aspartame; alcohol; metabolism; neuropathology;
blood alcohol level

Introduction
        Stimulants and depressants, specifically              been shown to cause neurological and
aspartame and alcohol, have been the focal point              behavioral symptoms in certain individuals
in many scientific studies both in conjunction                ranging from headaches and mood alterations to
with each other and as separate entities. The                 dizziness and insomnia (Bradsiock et al., 1986).
combination of aspartame and alcohol has                      These symptoms are thought to result from the
resulted in a marked increase in blood alcohol                role each component of aspartame plays once
levels when compared to alcohol and sugar (Wu                 entering the body (Butchko et al., 2002).
et al., 2006). Anecdotal reports suggest that                          Fifty percent of aspartame is comprised
alcohol and aspartame, a component of diet                    of phenylalanine, which is either converted in
sodas, are popular, particularly among women,                 the liver to tyrosine (a non-essential amino acid)
to minimize the caloric intake of mixed                       or remains unchanged. In order for either
alcoholic beverages (Henkel, 1999).                           tyrosine or phenylalanine to cross the blood
                                                              brain barrier (BBB), binding to a large neutral
Aspartame                                                     amino acid transporter (NAAT) must occur
         Aspartame, an artificial sweetener, was              (Humphries et al, 2008). Since NAAT is the
approved by the U.S. Food and Drug                            only way in which phenylalanine, tyrosine, and
Administration in 1981 and has been used as a                 other amino acids can cross the BBB, a great
tabletop sweetener and in beverages, breakfast                deal of competition exists for the limited binding
cereals, desserts, and chewing gum since then                 sites (Humphries et al., 2008).          Increased
(Henkel, 1999). Aspartame consumption has                     aspartame intake increases the number of NAAT
Page 2 of 9
                                               Impulse: The Premier Journal for Undergraduate Publications in the Neurosciences
                                                                                                                          2009

sites occupied by phenylalanine, therefore                    known as acidosis (Humphries et al., 2008).
inhibiting the transportation of other essential              Methanol poisoning has been shown to result in
neutral amino acids into the brain. (Yokogoshi et             dizziness, headaches, and behavioral alterations,
al., 1984; Coulombe and Sharma, 1986). The                    which are all effects that have been reported
increase of phenylalanine in the brain has been               from aspartame consumption (Thomas, 2005).
seen to cause a phenylketonuria effect, which is                       Several studies have shown the
a hereditary disorder characterized by the                    detrimental effects of aspartame metabolites on
accumulation of phenylalanine (Mehl-Madrona,                  the nervous system. One specific study on the
2005).     This results in a decrease in the                  acetylcholinesterase of the frontal cortex of
dopamine and serotonin production and since                   suckling rats concluded that the increased
serotonin plays a critical role in behavior,                  concentration of metabolites in the bloodstream
control of sleep, appetite, and neuroendocrine                resulted in seizures, memory loss, headaches,
function, a decrease in serotonin levels will have            and cholinergic defects (Simintzi et al., 2007).
effects on these behaviors (Humphries et al.,                 This led researchers to conclude that high
2008).                                                        dosages (toxic levels) of aspartame are
         Aspartic acid, also known as aspartate,              detrimental to the nervous systems of the rats,
is an excitatory neurotransmitter in the central              even though the consumption of normal levels of
nervous system (CNS) and comprises 40% of                     aspartame showed little effect on their frontal
aspartame. Aspartic acid increases depolariza-                cortex. Interestingly, aspartame itself had little
tion at the postsynaptic membrane.              The           effect, but the metabolites were responsible for
increased       depolarization      can      induce           the decreased enzymatic activity (Simintzi et al.,
neuroendocrine disturbances and the rapid firing              2007). Not only has aspartame been shown to
of neurons ultimately results in the failure of               have an effect on enzyme activity, but it has
enzymes to function optimally (Humphries et al.,              been suggested to disrupt the metabolism of
2008). Unlike other amino acids in the brain,                 amino acids, protein structure, neuronal function,
aspartic acid is not one of the essential amino               and catecholamine concentrations in the brain
acids. As a result of the excitatory effects of               (Humphries et al., 2008).
aspartic acid, the concentration in the brain must
be controlled to prevent excess stimulation of                Alcohol
the nerve cells (Magnuson, 2007).                                      Heavy alcohol consumption has been
         Methanol,      constituting     10%      of          shown to cause depressive episodes, severe
aspartame, is poisonous at temperatures above                 anxiety, insomnia, temporary cognitive defects,
86°F and therefore becomes toxic once                         and peripheral neuropathy (Schuckit, 2009).
aspartame is ingested.        Methanol is found               Once alcohol is consumed, about 98% enters the
naturally in fruits and vegetables, but in that case          bloodstream through the walls of the small
it is bound to pectin. When it is bound to pectin,            intestine (Schuckit, 2009).
the body is unable to break down the molecule                          Alcohol, regardless of the dose,
and therefore the methanol is never released into             enhances the activity in the inhibitory γ-
the bloodstream (Thomas, 2005). In aspartame,                 aminobutyric acid (GABA) systems throughout
methanol is not bound to pectin and is therefore              the brain (Schuckit, 2009).        GABA is an
considered to be in its “free” form. In this case,            inhibitory neurotransmitter that binds to specific
the methanol is released to a greater degree and              transmembrane receptors in the plasma
at an increased rate (Magnuson, 2007). The                    membrane of the pre-synaptic and post-synaptic
methanol present from the breakdown of                        neurons. Upon binding, ion channels open
aspartame is converted in the liver to                        resulting in the influx of chloride ions or the
formaldehyde, which is a known neurotoxin and                 efflux of potassium ions. When alcohol is
carcinogen      (Humphries      et    al.,   2008).           introduced into the system, the inhibitory action
Formaldehyde is further broken down into                      of GABA is augmented. Since GABA is not
formic acid, which accumulates in the brain,                  present in one specific location in the brain, but
kidneys, spinal fluid, and other organs and can               rather in several locations, the presence of
lead to excess acid in body fluids, which is                  alcohol inhibits several activities in the brain
Page 3 of 9
                                              Impulse: The Premier Journal for Undergraduate Publications in the Neurosciences
                                                                                                                         2009

resulting in behavioral changes including muscle             2006). Participants in a study who consumed
relaxation and somnolence (Schuckit, 2009).                  “diet-alcoholic” drinks containing aspartame
         Alcohol consumption also stimulates the             were found to have higher blood-alcohol levels
neurons of the serotonergic system, which is                 when compared to those consuming alcoholic
located in the raphe nucleus at the base of the              drinks containing sucrose (Wu et al, 2006). In
brain (Schuckit, 2009). This area influences                 addition, alcohol, like aspartame, has been found
brain functions that are related to attention,               to affect heart rate. Alcohol has a depressive
emotions, and motivation (Lovinger, 1991).                   effect on the nervous system by first depressing
Studies have shown that individuals who                      the highest cerebral centers of the brain
consume large amounts of alcohol have                        (prefrontal cortex) then the motor and sensory
differences in brain serotonin levels in                     centers, the cerebellum, spinal cord and finally
comparison to non-alcoholics (Lovinger, 1991).               the medulla (Karpas, 1916). The medulla is
Lovinger (1991) also showed that both short and              responsible for controlling breathing, heart rate
long term exposure of alcohol has an effect on               and other basic involuntary functions in the body.
the serotonin receptors that convert the signal              By depressing this part of the brain, alcohol can
produced by serotonin into functional changes in             also reduce heart rate.
the signal-receiving cell.Even a single exposure                      Since the heart rate is modulated by
to alcohol has an effect on the synaptic functions           different parts of the brain, the heart rate can be
of serotonin. Upon alcohol ingestion, levels of              used in order to determine the effect of
serotonin metabolites in the urine and blood                 aspartame and alcohol, both combined and as
increase, indicating an increase in serotonin                separate entities, on the nervous system
release from the nervous system. This has been               (Guyenet, 1990).
suggested to be a result of enhanced signal                           The small fresh water crustacean, D.
transmission at serotonergic synapses (Lovinger,             magna, was used in this experiment because of
1991). Research investigating the effects of                 their transparent carapace, which allows for
ethanol on the nervous system has shown that                 increased visibility of the internal organs and
alcohol has the ability to disrupt an active                 makes monitoring the heart rate of the individual
fragment of the activity-dependent neuro-                    easier (Environmental Inquiry, 2006). It was
protective protein (ADNP) called NAPVSIPQ                    hypothesized that treatment with aspartame (a
(NAP) (Chen and Charness, 2008). NAP is an                   stimulant) alone would increase the heart rate
octapeptide that is necessary in signaling Fyn               while treatment with alcohol (a depressant)
Kinase (a member of the Scr Family Kinase),                  would depress the heart rate. Since alcohol and
resulting in normal axonal outgrowth in cerebral             aspartame have opposite effects on the nervous
granule cells, found in the brain (Chen and                  system, it was thought that the combination
Charness, 2008). NAP has been shown to protect               would result in a heart rate comparable to the
the nervous system against a wide variety of                 base heart rate of D. magna. D. magna were
insults, including alcohol exposure. Therefore,              treated with alcohol and aspartame alone and in
disrupting the activity of NAP and the presence              different combinations to determine the effect on
of excess ethanol due to social drinking in                  the nervous system.
humans have resulted in neuronal migratory                   Materials and Methods
malfunctions,      improper       axonal-dendritic
connections, as well as apoptosis of glial and               Daphnia magna
neuronal progenitor cells (Chen and Charness,                        All D. magna used in this experiment
2008).                                                       were purchased through Ward’s Natural
                                                             Science© and housed in containers containing
Alcohol and Aspartame                                        spring water.       D. magna utilized were of
        In recent years, “sugar-free” alcoholic              different sizes and states of maturity.
beverages have become more popular, but
consuming alcoholic beverages that contain                   Ethanol Solutions
aspartame in place of sucrose may result in a                        Preliminary tests showed that a 2.0%
greater degree of adverse effects (Wu et al,                 alcohol stock solution, manufactured by Ward’s
Page 4 of 9
                                              Impulse: The Premier Journal for Undergraduate Publications in the Neurosciences
                                                                                                                         2009

Natural Science© (Rochester, New York), was                  twenty D. magna were used in the mixed assays.
fatal for D. magna, but 0.2% elicited a decrease             For Assay # 1 n=21, for Assay # 2 n=21, for
in heart rate without fatalities. Four successive            Assay # 3 n=22, for Assay 4# n=29, and for
ethanol dilutions in deionized water were then               Assay # 5 n=27.
prepared: 34.32 mM (0.2%), 17.16 mM (0.1%),
8.58 mM (0.05%), and 4.29 mM (0.025%). The                   Table 1. Mixed assay concentrations for ethanol and
amount of alcohol ingested could not be                      aspartame in 50 µL.
determined since the alcohol level in the fleas
could not be measured. Forty D. magna were                   Assay #         Ethanol (mM)            Aspartame (mM)
used in the ethanol assays, n=10 for each                       1                30.89                     1.0
concentration.                                                  2                24.02                     3.0
                                                                3                17.16                     5.0
Aspartame Solutions                                             4                10.30                     7.0
         Equal® was used as the source of                       5                3.43                      9.0
aspartame. Three solutions with the following
concentrations; 10.0 mM, 1.0 mM, and 0.1 mM                  Heart Rate Acquisition
in deionized water were prepared. It has been                         Each D. magna was chosen randomly
discussed that, in humans, aspartame only has                and removed from a jar of fresh water with a
negative effects at levels much higher that the              plastic pipette and transferred individually onto
recommended 40 – 50 mg/kg body weight/ day                   a concave microscope slide.          Any water
(Magnuson, 2007). Thus, a high concentration of              remaining on the slide was entirely absorbed
aspartame was chosen for the initial assay. The              with a paper towel. Then D. magna were
solubility of aspartame is about 30 g/L at room              submerged in 50.0 µL of one of the following:
temperature. Considering a molecular weight of               deionized water for the base heart rate, alcohol
294.31 g/mole for aspartame, a starting solution             solutions, aspartame solutions, or mixed assays.
of 10.0 mM was close to the maximum                          Subsequently, D. magna were allowed to
concentration at room temperature. It is difficult           acclimatize to the environment for two minutes,
to judge how much of the compound was                        and then the heart rate was counted for one
ingested by D. magna, but based on an estimated              minute. Heart rate was recorded with the use of
average body weight of 30.0 mg, the organisms                a hand held, manual counter. A different D.
were exposed to 49.05 g/kg body weight (10.0                 magna was used for each assay.
mM), 4.905 g/kg body weight (1.0 nM), and                             The base heart rate was acquired by
0.49 g/kg body weight (0.1 mM). Thirty D.                    transferring each D. magna into deionized water,
magna were used in the ethanol assays, n=10 for              allowing it to acclimatize for two minutes, and
each concentration.                                          recording heart rates for one minute. Statistical
                                                             analysis was performed similarly in the other
                                                             parts of the experiment. Fifty D. magna were
                                                             used for the base heart rate assay.
Mixed Assays
        Five mixed assays were made from                     Statistical Analysis
initial concentrations of 34.32 mM (0.2%)                             The average heart rate and standard
ethanol and 10.0 mM aspartame. The                           error of the mean (SEM) were calculated for
concentration of ethanol in each successive                  each concentration of each part of the
mixture decreased while the aspartame                        experiment (ethanol, aspartame, and mixed
concentration increased (Table 1). This type of              assays). Statistical significance at α = 0.05 and
varying solution was chosen to parallel alcoholic            α = 0.01 was evaluated using the student’s t-test.
drinks with diet soda, since the proportion of
                                                             All calculations were performed on the
alcohol in those drinks varies inversely with the
                                                             statistical software SPSS.
amount of aspartame.         Similarly, in this
experiment the volume of liquid the organism
was exposed to was limited. One-hundred and
Page 5 of 9
                                                       Impulse: The Premier Journal for Undergraduate Publications in the Neurosciences
                                                                                                                                  2009

Results                                                               heart rates with increasing concentrations,
                                                                      compared to base rate (Fig. 2). When compared
Base Heart Rate                                                       to the base rate the highest increase in heart rate
        To compare the effects of aspartame and                       was observed at a concentration of 10.0 mM
alcohol on the cardiac activity of D. magna, a                        with a heart rate of 243 +/- 9 bpm (t (30.6) =
base heart rate (BR) of 204 +/- 7 beats per                           -4.09, p < .01, n=10) (Fig. 2).
minute (bpm) was established (n=50).
                                                                      Heart Rate in Mixed Assay
Heart Rate in Ethanol
        In order to evaluate changes in D.
magna heart rate in ethanol the fleas were
exposed to increasing ethanol concentrations
(4.29, 8.58, 17.16, and 34.32 mM). The alcohol
showed an overall depressive trend on heart rate.
However, only ethanol concentrations 17.16 and
34.32 mM showed a significant decrease with

                                                                         Figure 2. D. magna heart rate change in aspartame. D.
                                                                         magna heart rate was significantly increased from base
                                                                         rate in 10.0 mM aspartame but not in any of the two
                                                                         lower concentrations. Thus, in subsequent testing 10.0
                                                                         mM of aspartame concentration was used. Bars represent
                                                                         SEM; n = 10 for 10.0 mM and 0.1 mM; n = 11 for
                                                                         concentration 1.0 mM; * = p < .01

  Figure 1. Daphnia magna heart rate change in
                                                                               To evaluate possible influences of
  ethanol. Heart rate in increasing ethanol concentrations            ethanol in combination with aspartame on heart
  was compared to base rate. Generally, a depressant                  rate, a series of mixed assays were administered
  trend was seen, but only concentrations 17.16 and 34.43             (Table 1). The base solutions for the mixed
  mM decreased heart rate significantly. 34.32 mM was                 assays were 34.32 mM ethanol and 10.0 mM
  used for subsequent testing. Error is SEM, n = 10 for               aspartame, which were chosen because each
  each concentration, n = 50 for BR; * = p < .01.                     caused the greatest depression or stimulation of
                                                                      heart rate respectively.
total heart rates of 180 +/- 4 bpm (t (54.7) = 3.24,                           Both ethanol and aspartame were
p < .01, n = 10) and 133 +/- 8 bpm (t (23.32) =                       observed to be different from base rate, as
6.95, p < .01, n = 10) respectively (Fig. 1). For                     mentioned before. When compared to base rate,
further investigation, an ethanol concentration of                    Assays # 1 through # 5 also showed significant
34.32 mM was utilized to capitalize on the most                       differences with Assay #1 at 250 +/- 3 bpm (t
pronounced       depressive     effect   of     this                  (66.12) = -6.26, p < .01, n = 21), Assay # 2 at
concentration.                                                        248 +/- 4 bpm (t (68.82) = -5.50, p < .01, n = 21),
                                                                      Assay # 3 at 233 +/- 4 bpm (t (69.97) = -3.63, p
Heart Rate in Aspartame                                               < .01, n = 22), Assay # 4 at 231 +/- 3 bpm (t
        To assess changes of heart rate in                            (63.68) = -3.67, p < .01, n = 29), and Assay # 5
aspartame three different concentrations of                           at 234 +/- 5 bpm (t (74.98) = -3.63, p < .01, n =
aspartame were examined (10.0 mM, 1.0 mM,                             27) (Fig. 3, significance denoted by *).
                                                                               Increases in heart rate were found for all
and 0.1 mM). When D. magna was submerged                              combination assays, when compared to heart
in aspartame, the fleas tended to exhibit higher                      rate in ethanol alone (Assay # 1 with t ( 29) =
Page 6 of 9
                                                Impulse: The Premier Journal for Undergraduate Publications in the Neurosciences
                                                                                                                           2009

16.38, p < .01; # 2 with t (29) = 13.68, p < .01;              potentially be eliminated with further testing.
Assay # 3 with t ( 30) = 11.93, p < .01; Assay #               The results obtained could be due to a novel
4 with t (37) = 15.07, p < .01, and Assay # 5                  metabolic pathway involved in the combined
with t (35) = 10.838, p < .01) (Fig. 3, depicted               processing of ethanol and aspartame or due to
by o).                                                         the aspartame pathway that could partially
          When comparing each assay with its                   override the depressive effect of alcohol.
successive assay (Assay # 1 with # 2, Assay # 2                         The nervous system activity of D.
with # 3, Assay # 3 with # 4, and Assay # 4 with               magna, gauged by cardiac output, was greatly
# 5), only Assay # 3 was observed to be                        affected by the introduction of a stimulant, a
significantly different from its preceding Assay               depressant, and a combination of both. D.
# 2 (t ( 41) = 2.39, p < .05) (Fig. 3, denoted by +).          magna, has become an established model
Heart rate in aspartame was not different from                 organism because they are easily cultured and
any of Assays # 1-5 (Fig. 3).                                  have short reproductive cycles. While the main
                                                               areas of focus on D. magna as a model organism
                                                               lie in ecology and evolution, it has been shown
Discussion                                                     that the crustacean exhibits about a 55% genetic
                                                               homology with humans, suggesting it to be
        In the first experiments conducted                     eligible as a model for some for human
(ethanol assay), a decrease in heart rate was                  processes (Gilbert, 2007).
observed with increasing ethanol concentrations                         The experiments conducted were to
demonstrating that ethanol has a depressive                    understand the side effects and the mechanisms
effect on heart rate. Heart rate was considered                that underlie the process of how stimulants and
representative of the actions on the nervous                   depressants affect nervous system activity.
system for the purpose of this experiment                      Previous research on stimulants has found that
because the heart rate is regulated by the                     they increase CNS or sympathetic nervous
nervous system in D. Magna, and therefore                      system activity with a spectrum of effects such
changes in heart rate were used to assess                      as cardiovascular stimulation and increased
changes in nervous system activity (Guyenet,                   energy levels (Rothman and Baumann, 2003). In
1990).                                                         the presence of stimulants, synaptic levels of
        The second part of the experiment, in                  monoamine neurotransmitters are elevated in
which D. magna were introduced to various                      neurons, specifically dopamine, serotonin, and
concentrations of aspartame, resulted in an                    norepinepherin (Sofuoglu and Sewell, 2008).
increase in heart rate as the concentration of                 Neurotransmitter concentrations increase as a
aspartame solutions increased, confirming the                  result of blocking transporter–mediated reuptake
stimulant effect of aspartame.                                 inhibitors from the synapse (Rothman and
        In the final part of the experiment,                   Baumann, 2003). Excess levels of serotonin
mixed assays of aspartame and ethanol were                     have been associated with cardiac and
used to determine the combined effects of a                    pulmonary disease, and stimulants such as
stimulant and a depressant. The results of the                 amphetamine analogs act as substrates for the
mixed assay (Fig. 3) showed a marked increase                  serotonin transporters, which release serotonin
of D. magna heart rate with even a minimal                     from platelets, in turn elevating plasma blood
addition of aspartame to ethanol (Assay # 1).                  levels of the neurotransmitter (Zolkowska et al.,
These findings suggest that the ingestion of                   2006). Plasma serotonin stimulates mitogenic
aspartame has a greater impact on heart rate than              activity from cardiovascular cells (Zolkowska et
alcohol. There was no systematic difference                    al., 2006).
among Assays #1 – 5 or when comparing the                               Depressants also affect CNS activity
assays with aspartame alone. This may indicate                 through different mechanisms. Ethanol, a
that any amount of aspartame in combination                    depressant, enhances GABAergic synaptic
with alcohol has a significant influence on D.                 inhibition by means of allosteric potentiation of
magna metabolism and heart rate. The                           postsynaptic GABA receptors (Ariwodola and
difference between Assays # 2 and # 3 could                    Weiner, 2004). This mechanism plays a vital
Page 7 of 9
                                              Impulse: The Premier Journal for Undergraduate Publications in the Neurosciences
                                                                                                                         2009

role in the effects of ethanol, most notably on              provides a basis for understanding the possible
cognition. GABA receptors are responsible for                side effects of excessive consumption of
mediating fast synaptic inhibition. Hippocampal              aspartame in conjunction with alcohol. Human
GABA activity is potentiated by ethanol when                 studies have shown that aspartame can cause
there is a blockade of GABA B receptors                      migraines, seizures, depression and anxiety
(Ariwodola and Weiner, 2004). Ethanol was                    (Bradsiock et al., 1986). Alcohol has been linked
also found to increase GABAergic transmission                to depression, anxiety and cognitive deficits
into the ventral-tegmental area dopaminergic                 (Schuckit, 2009). Thus temporary or long-term
neurons, in which GABA inhibitory post                       nervous system alterations by alcohol and
synaptic currents are enhanced (Theile et al.,               aspartame may cause serious health risks that
2008). The increase of overall GABA in the                   have not yet been identified but could become
CNS produces a decrease in cardiovascular                    manifest with increasing consumption of
activity (Segura and Haywood, 1991).                         aspartame in the future.
         Considering the large increase in D.
magna heart rate in all five mixed assays, further
investigation appears to be warranted aimed at               Acknowledgements
identifying similar effects in larger organisms
like mice, and eventually in humans.                         We thank Ursinus College for funding our
Examination of larger animals would allow                    research.
controlling the amount of ingested alcohol and
aspartame. Memory or behavior tasks could then
be used to evaluate other effects of the mixture
on nervous system functions. Furthermore,
                                                             Corresponding Author
neurotransmitter levels in the brain of these
                                                             Cierra Jené Lewis
animals could be measured. The results could
                                                             Ursinus College
shed light on the pathways involved in the
                                                                     rkohn@ursinus.edu
metabolism of alcohol in conjunction with
                                                                     601 E Main Street
aspartame. We also suggest investigating the
                                                                     Collegeville, PA 19426
effect of aspartame doses that come closer to the
maximum recommended amount of 40 – 50
mg/kg body weight/day.
         Further research on the effects of                  References
aspartame and alcohol, similar to our experiment,
should be particularly directed towards                      Bradstock MK, Serdula MK, Marks JS, Barnard
individuals who consume beverages containing                        RJ, Crane NT (1986) Evaluation of
aspartame and/ or alcohol. In one survey, two                       reactions of food additives: the
out of every five students were found to binge                      aspartame experience. Am J Clin Nutr
drink (Wechsler et al., 1998) and research                          43:464-9.
studies surveying the dietary habits of female               Burkhart CG (2009) ‘Lone’ atrial fibrillation
college students (43%), found that artificial                       precipitated by monosodium glutamate
sweeteners (specifically aspartame) were                            and aspartame. Toledo.Int J Cardiol in
frequently used to reduce weight gain in                               press,
combination with other dietary methods                                 doi:10.1016/j.ijcard.2009.01.028
(Malinauskas et al., 2006). Since both aspartame             Butchko HH, Stargel WW, Comer CP, Mayhew
and alcohol are consumed on college campuses,                       DA, Benninger C, Blackburn GL, de
the target population for future research could                     Sonneville LM, Geha RS, Hertelendy Z,
encompass college students and long-term or                         Koestner A, Leon AS, Liepa GU,
short-term     effects    of   alcohol/aspartame                    McMartin KE, Mendenhall CL, Munro
consumption on the nervous system                                   IC, Novotny EJ, Renwick AG,
         Though our research was not conducted                      Schiffman SS, Schomer DL, Shaywitz
on humans, D. magna nervous system research                         BA, Spiers PA, Tephly TR, Thomas JA,
Page 8 of 9
                                              Impulse: The Premier Journal for Undergraduate Publications in the Neurosciences
                                                                                                                         2009

        Trefz FK (2002) Aspartame: Review of                 Karpas MJ (1916) Alcohol and the nervous
        Saftey. Regul Toxicol Pharm 1:1-93                           system: Part 1. Am J Nurs, 16(5): 408-
Center for Disease Control (1984) Evaluation of                      410.
        Consumer Complaints Related to                       Lovern S, Strickland R, Klaper R (2007)
        Aspartame Use. MMWR, 33, 605-7.                              Behavioral and physiological changes in
        Retrieved        March       3,      2009.                   Daphnia magna when exposed to
        http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mm                           nanoparticle    suspensions      (titanium
        wrhtml/00000426.htm                                          dioxide, nano-C60, and C60HxC70Hx).
Chen S, Charness ME (2008) Ethanol inhibits                          Environ Sci Technol .June 15; 41(12):
        neuronal differentiation by disrupting                       4465–70.
        activity –dependent neuroprotective                  Lovinger DM (1997) Role of Serotonin in
        protein signaling. PNAS, 105, 19962-7.                       Alcohol’s Effects on the Brain. Alcohol
Coulombe        RA,     Sharma       RP     (1986)                   Health Res W 21(2):114-20.
        Neurobiochemical alterations induced                 Magnuson B A, Burdock GA, Doull J, Kroes
        by the artificial sweetener aspartame                        RM, Marsh GM, Pariza MW, Spencer
        (NutraSweet). Toxicol Appl Pharm 83                          PS, Waddell WJ, Walker R, Williams
        (1): 79-85.                                                  GM (2007) Aspartame: A Safety
Environmental Inquiry (2006) Bioassays Using                         Evaluation Based on Current Use Levels,
        Daphnia: Why Daphnia? Cornell                                Regulations, and Toxicological and
        University and Penn State University.                        Epidemiological Studies. Crit Rev
        Retrieved February 6, 2009 from                              Toxicol 37:629-727.
        http://ei.cornell.edu/toxicology/bioassay            Malinauskas BM, Raedeke TD, Aeby VG, Smith
        s/daphnia/                                                   JL, Dallas MB (2006) Dieting
Gilbert D (2007) Daphnia Genome Annotation                           practices ,weight perceptions, and body
        & Analysis Notes. wFleabase.org, July.                       composition: a comparison of normal
        Retrieved on April 30, 2009 from                             weight , overweight, and obese college
        http://wfleabase.org/docs/.                                  females. Nutr J 5:1-8.
Guyenet P (1990) Role of the Ventral Medulla                 Rothman RB, Baumann M (2003) Monoamine
        Oblongata in Blood Pressure Regulation.                      transporters and psychostimulant drugs.
        In A. D. Loewy, & K. M. l Spyer,                             Eur J Pharm 479:23-40.
        Central Regulation of Autonomic                      Schuckit MA (2009) Alcohol-use disorders.
        Functions (pp. 145-150).                                     Lancelot 373: 492-501.
Henkel J (1999) Sugar substitutes: Americans                 Simintzi I, Schulpis K, Angelogianni P (2007)
        opt for sweetness and lite. FDA                              The     effect    of    aspartame        on
        Consumer Magazine, November –                                acetylcholinesterase      activity       in
        December. Retrieved on April 29, 2009                        hippocampal homogenates of suckling
        from                                                         rats. Pharmacol Res 56(2):155-9.
        http://www.fda.gov/fdac/features/1999/6              Sofuoglu M, Sewell, R.A (2009) Norepinephrine
        99_sugar.html.                                               and Stimulant Addiction. Addict Biol.
Hubert HB, Feinleib M, McNamara PM,                                  14(2):119-29.
        Castelli WP (1983) Obesity as an                     Theile JW, Morikawa H, Gonzales RA,
        independent        risk     factor     for                   Morrisett RA (2008) Ethanol Enhances
        cardiovascular disease: 26- year follow-                     GABAergic        Transmission         Onto
        up of participants in the Framingham                         Dopamine Neurons in the Ventral
        Heart Study. Circulation 968-77.                             Tegmental Area of the Rat. Alcohol Clin
Humphries P, Pretorius E, Naude H (2008)                             Exp Res 32: 1040-8.
        Direct and indirect cellular effects of              Thomas P (2005) Aspartame’s toxic content.
        aspartame on the brain. Eur J Clin Nutr                      The Ecologist. 35-46.
        62: 451-62.                                          Thomasson HR, Edenberg HJ, Crabb DW, Mai
                                                                     XL, Jerome RE, Li TK, Wang SP, Lin
                                                                     YT, Lu RB, Yin SJ (1991) Alcohol and
Page 9 of 9
                                         Impulse: The Premier Journal for Undergraduate Publications in the Neurosciences
                                                                                                                    2009

       aldehyde dehydrogenase genotypes and             Wu KL, Chaikomin MD, Doran S, Jones KL,
       alcoholism in Chinese men. Am J Hum                    Horowitz M, Rayner CK (2006)
       Genet 48: 677-81.                                      Artificially Sweetened Versus Regular
Wechsler H, Dowdall G, Maenner G, Gledhill-                   Mixers Increase Gastric Emptying and
       Hoyt J, Lee H (1998) Changes in Binge                  Alcohol Absorption. Am J Med, 119:
       drinking and related problems among                    802-4.
       American College students between                Yokogoshi H, Roberts SH, Caballero B,
       1993 and 1997. Results of the Harvard                  Wurtman RJ (1984) Effects of
       School of Public Health College                        aspartame and glucose administration on
       Alcohol Study. J Am Coll Health                        brain and plasma levels of large neutral
       47:57-68.                                              amino acids and brain 50hydroxyindoles.
                                                              Am J Clin Nutr 40:1-7.
You can also read