Effective and integrated public transport

Page created by Lee Harrington
 
CONTINUE READING
Effective and integrated public transport
60
     CITY OF MELBOURNE - TRANSPORT STRATEGY - 2012

                                                     public transport
                                                     Effective and integrated
Effective and integrated public transport
61
     CITY OF MELBOURNE, TRANSPORT STRATEGY - 2012
Effective and integrated public transport
CITY OF MELBOURNE > TRANSPORT STRATEGY

                                                Effective and integrated
                                                public transport

                                                                                   Overview                               need to enable better east west
                                                Goal                                                                      travel through the sub-region.
                                                                                   Public transport includes rail,
                                                Public transport will be           tram, bus, taxi, car share and bike    Priorities
                                                the most attractive way            share and, for regional trips, air
                                                                                   travel – all cases of the use of a     Planning public transport for
                                                to travel around the               shared vehicle. Government plays       growth
                                                municipality and the               a major role through ownership,        Over the next 20 years the
                                                inner metropolitan                 operation, regulation and              municipality and the inner region
                                                                                   coordination of these services.        will see continued significant
                                                Melbourne region. An               State Government is largely            growth in population and
                                                integrated system of               responsible for running much of        employment. The main growth
                                                rail, tram, bus, taxi, car         the public transport system, but       sector will be knowledge/services.
                                                                                   local government, as the land use      Constraints on public transport
                                                and bike share will                regulator, and the manager of the      availability may significantly impede
                                                meet customer’s needs              pedestrian network, has a key role     labour productivity. Melbourne’s
                                                and be fully                       integrating the system with land       productivity growth has been
                                                                                   use and the walking component          falling in recent years, in part due
                                                coordinated with the               of each public transport trip.         to these constraints on its transport
                                                municipality’s                     The City of Melbourne has an           system. This sector thrives on the
                                                pedestrian network. It             additional role, as it is at the hub   agglomeration effects of high
                                                                                   of the public transport system.        densities enabled by very good
                                                will be possible to live           Melbourne’s public transport           transport connections. This growth
                                                and do business in                 network extends throughout             will need to be matched by a
                                                                                                                          significant expansion and upgrade
                                                inner Melbourne                    metropolitan Melbourne, with
                                                                                                                          of the public transport system.
                                                                                   varying degrees of service. Most
                                                without needing a car.             of the train stations and tram
                                                                                   stops are in the inner metropolitan
                                                                                                                          Public transport within the
                                                                                   region because much of the
                                                                                                                          central city
                                                                                   expansion beyond this region has       Metropolitan train and tram
                                                                                   been enabled and driven by car         networks have traditionally
CITY OF MELBOURNE - TRANSPORT STRATEGY - 2012

                                                                                   usage. The inner metropolitan          focussed on Swanston Street as
                                                                                   region also has the highest            the spine of the central city. This
                                                                                   densities of residents and jobs.       has reinforced both the public
                                                                                   The municipality of Melbourne          transport network itself and the
                                                                                   has the highest concentration          economic productivity of the
                                                                                   of public transport services.          city. As the city has expanded
                                                                                                                          projects like the City Loop and
                                                                                   Public transport in the inner
                                                                                                                          road-based tram improvements
                                                                                   metropolitan sub-region needs
                                                                                                                          have improved the ability of the
                                                                                   to provide for continuing high
                                                                                                                          network to deliver and disperse
                                                                                   employment and residential
                                                                                                                          larger numbers of people to their
                                                                                   growth, coordination with land
                                                                                                                          destinations in the Hoddle Grid.
                                                                                   use development, integration of
                                                                                   all the public transport modes as      Swanston Street plays a vital
                                                                                   one system, increased capacity,        role in the tram network,
                                                                                   reliability and accessibility, and     the bicycle network and for
                                                                                   establishing a complementary           pedestrians. Balancing these
                                                                                   role with private transport,           competing priorities has made
                                                                                   particularly in addressing the         the redevelopment of the street a
                                                                                                                          challenge. A significant opportunity

62
Effective and integrated public transport
Sunbury                                                                                 Sunbury

                                                                         Eltham                                                                                Eltham

  Caroline                                                                                Caroline
  Springs                                                                                 Springs

                                                                         Ringwood                                                                                Ringwood
                                                                                                       Sunshine

                                       St Kilda                                                                               St Kilda
                              Williamstown                                                                           Williamstown

                                                                                                                              Brighton
   Melbourne 2010
   Werribee
                                       Brighton                                             Werribee
   Public Transport Index
                                                                           Dandenong                                                                               Dandenong
            Excellent
     Very good (25 - 32 points)
             Very Good
               Good
         Above Average                            Mordialloc                                                                             Mordialloc
             Average
         Below Average                                                                                                                         Chelsea
                                                        Chelsea
               Poor
              Minimal
     Below minimum service
                                                                                            Melbourne 2030
                                                                                            Public Transport Index
      Average: 14.5                                                                           Average: 19.7                                  Frankston
                                                      Frankston

                                      Coburg
                                       Coburg                                                                                 Coburg

                 Essendon
                  Essendon                                                                             Essendon

                                                                           Heidelberg                                                                              Heidelberg

                                                                                                                                                                                   CITY OF MELBOURNE, TRANSPORT STRATEGY - 2012

                                                       Clifton
                                                        Clifton                                                                                Clifton
                                                        Hill
                                                          Hill                                                                                  Hill

Footscray
 Footscray                                                                               Footscray

                                                                           Camberwell
                                                                           Camberwell                                                                              Camberwell

                                                                Toorak
                                                               Toorak                                                                                 Toorak
                           Port                                                                               Port
                        Melbourne                                                                          Melbourne
     V

                                      St Kilda                                                                               St Kilda

                                                                              Caulfield
                                                                             Caulfield                                                                                   Caulfield

    Melbourne 2010                                                                          Melbourne 2030
    Public Transport Index                                                                  Public Transport Index
      Average: 14.5                                                                           Average: 19.7

Fig 6.0 Spatial Network Analysis for Multimodal Urban Transport Systems (SNAMUTS) 2010. Source: RMIT. Dr Jan Scheurer                                                              63
Effective and integrated public transport
CITY OF MELBOURNE > TRANSPORT STRATEGY > EFFECTIVE AND INTEGRATED PUBLIC TRANSPORT

                                                exists with the development of          suited to meet the demands of            and 36,000 people use the
                                                the Melbourne metro rail project        people travelling late at night.         Federation Square tram stop.
                                                to create better tram connections                                                In 12 years these numbers will
                                                and land use integration through        Integrating public transport             more than double, to 380,000.
                                                Southbank, to the west of the           modes as one system
                                                CBD and the north of the CBD .          Each of the public transport modes       Reliability
                                                                                        suits different types of trips. These    Overloaded trains, cancellations
                                                Coordinated development of              modes must be integrated into a          and maintenance difficulties are
                                                transport and land use                  seamless public transport system         reducing train service reliability.
                                                The development of urban                allowing users to mix and match          Melbourne’s large suburban rail
                                                transport and land use must             modes easily to suit their trip needs.   system is ill suited to providing
                                                be coordinated. Rail and tram           This has started, with Public            a high frequency, high capacity
                                                are space efficient and high            Transport Victoria and myki              service. The reliability of the tram
                                                capacity, making them ideal             providing customers with                 and bus services is undermined
                                                for the mobility needs of high          information for a single user            by delays caused by road traffic
                                                density mixed development land          perspective for trip planning and        congestion and insufficient
                                                uses. These modes are also at           payment, but we are only beginning       priority at intersections.
                                                their most efficient when their         to optimise the coordination of rail,    Users rate reliable departure and
                                                high infrastructure and running         tram and bus routes, the modal           arrival times as more important
                                                costs are spread across a large         interchanges and the incorporation       than journey time. As customers
                                                number of trips over the whole          of taxi, car share and bike share        come to rely more on public
                                                daily and weekly cycle.                 directly into one system, planned        transport its reliability becomes
                                                This relationship is evident in the     developed and coordinated                more critical. Improvements to
                                                region of the Melbourne’s network       across government departments,           reliability require improvements to
                                                extending out from the central          transport companies and                  infrastructure as well as operations.
                                                city along the inner south-eastern      agencies, and local government.
                                                corridor. This area has the highest     A ‘one system’ approach to               Accessibility
                                                density of stops, interchanges and      planning and governance.                 A world standard public transport
                                                service levels and is also the region                                            system in a dense, mixed-use city
                                                with metropolitan Melbourne’s           Making our public transport              provides users with good access
                                                highest effective jobs density.         system more effective                    to a wide range of destinations
CITY OF MELBOURNE - TRANSPORT STRATEGY - 2012

                                                The economy in this region is also                                               at most times of the day and
                                                                                        Capacity
                                                well serviced by high capacity                                                   week. The London Underground,
                                                                                        Public transport capacity today          Paris Metro and New York
                                                roads for driving, but driving is a
                                                                                        cannot comfortably meet demand.          Subway do this. These metro
                                                space hungry mode best suited
                                                                                        To meet the future demand from           style systems provide business
                                                to lower density urban areas.
                                                                                        projected growth, especially at          users, visitors and residents with
                                                As this region’s land use density
                                                                                        peak times, the capacity of the          a high degree of accessibility,
                                                increases, driving will become a
                                                                                        system will need expansion and           meeting most of their transport
                                                less effective mode. This trend is
                                                                                        significant upgrades, including           requirements and underpinning
                                                evident already in the municipality
                                                                                        metro style separated train lines,       the economy in those city centres.
                                                and particularly in the central city.
                                                                                        new rolling stock, tram and bus
                                                Twenty-four hour activity in the City                                            An assessment of the accessibility
                                                                                        priority, and new tram routes.
                                                of Melbourne requires reliable and                                               afforded by Melbourne’s combined
                                                                                        The walking component of public          rail, tram and bus network1 shows
                                                safe inter-peak transport options.
                                                                                        transport journeys also requires
                                                There is currently a clash between
                                                                                        more capacity. Many parts of
                                                the hours of operation of many                                                   1 Spatial Network Analysis for
                                                                                        the pedestrian network are now
                                                central city land uses (restaurants,                                             Multi Modal Urban Transport
                                                                                        at capacity during peak times.           Systems (SNAMUTS) 2010.
                                                bars and clubs) and the hours of
                                                                                        More than 153,000 people per             RMIT. Dr Jan Scheurer
                                                public transport operation. Taxis
                                                                                        day use Flinders Street Station
                                                and flexible bus transport are best
64
Effective and integrated public transport
that a large east-west corridor        into a system of separated metro      Walking in particular is a critical
through the inner Melbourne            style lines, reducing travel times    trip component of the public
region provides users with above       by 25 per cent, increasing service    transport system and its ability to
average accessibility. A world class   frequency to no less than every       service land uses effectively. The
system should provide them very        10 minutes, adding new rolling        locale of a station or stop must link
good to excellent accessibility.       stock, redeploying tram routes        with convenient, logical and safe
By expanding and upgrading             to provide a more even service        walking connections. The design
Melbourne’s public transport           spread across the central city, and   and management of the public
network over the next 20 years,        adding new services and links.        realm between stops and stations
the system would provide very                                                must be integrated with the design
                                       Building the complementary            of stops, stations and interchanges.
good to excellent accessibility
                                       relationship with private
over a much larger area. With this                                           Driving has been the dominant
                                       transport
degree of accessibility, users would                                         mode of metropolitan travel
be able to go anywhere, anytime        Disjointed strategic transport        for nearly 50 years, but it is not
using the public transport system      planning is the result of long        the universal solution it once
much as they would use their car.      institutionalised separation          appeared to be. In the more
                                       at all levels of governments          dense parts of the city, public
The scenario expansions
                                       between the planning and              transport and walking are the
and upgrades include a new
                                       provision for private transport       most effective combination, so
Footscray to Caulfield Metro line,
                                       and that for public transport.        driving needs to be designed to
reengineering the train network

                                                                                                                     CITY OF MELBOURNE, TRANSPORT STRATEGY - 2012

                                                                                                                     65
Effective and integrated public transport
CITY OF MELBOURNE > TRANSPORT STRATEGY > EFFECTIVE AND INTEGRATED PUBLIC TRANSPORT

                                                complement this combination              opportunities in the west (especially   transport in and out of the
                                                rather than compete with it.             in the services sector) and improve     city during these times.
                                                Cycling is an ideal mode for             its competitive advantage as            There is scope to extend tram
                                                extending the catchment of public        a freight and logistics hub.            services into the night on Fridays
                                                transport. High quality cycling          The 2008 East West Link Needs           and Saturdays. The City of
                                                networks linking stops and stations      Assessment (EWLNA) identified            Melbourne will work with others
                                                with residential and employment          that the lack of rail capacity          to explore the value of extending
                                                centres, are critical for enabling       through North Melbourne and             trams until 2am, and running
                                                cycling to complement the public         the City Loop constrains the            services on selected routes all
                                                transport system. Facilitating           ability to boost rail services to       night to provide a complementary
                                                the carriage of bicycles on some         and from the west. The Regional         service with NightRider buses.
                                                public transport vehicles may            Rail Link (RRL) and the proposed
                                                also be appropriate. Secure bike         Footscray to Caulfield Metro Rail        Contributing to emissions
                                                parking at suburban stations             link are designed to build a rail       reductions
                                                can facilitate a form of ‘park and       service to the west comparable          The public transport system will
                                                ride’ that is significantly more          with that serving the south east.       be a central component of a low
                                                space and cost efficient than            The City of Melbourne’s envisages       emissions future. High capacity
                                                ‘drive and ride’ car parking. This,      the urban renewal of Docklands,         public transport will enable
                                                together with improved bike              E-Gate, Arden Macaulay and              people to move throughout inner
                                                share mobility options in the            the land north of Dynon Road            Melbourne in an environmentally
                                                central city, can enable public          as an intensive employment and          efficient way. Sustainable
                                                transport users to integrate             residential corridor extending          transport behaviour will be further
                                                cycling easily into their journey.       out from the central city to the        enabled by fine grain public
                                                                                         Footscray Central Activities Area       transport modes throughout the
                                                Enabling east west travel                                                        municipality, such as tram and
                                                                                         and beyond. These land uses would
                                                Whilst the population of the             be serviced by the new rail services    bus systems, taxis, car and bike
                                                western half of the metropolitan         and by new and re-directed tram         share programs, which together
                                                region is growing rapidly, this is not   and bus services to the inner west.     will provide flexibility in mode
                                                being matched with strong jobs                                                   choice without the embedded
                                                growth. The high effective jobs          Public Transport and the                restrictions of vehicle ownership.
                                                density along the south eastern          24-hour city
CITY OF MELBOURNE - TRANSPORT STRATEGY - 2012

                                                                                                                                 Zero Net Emissions by 2020
                                                corridor between central Melbourne       The NightRider bus provides the         (Update 2008) sets a target for
                                                and Clayton is underpinned               best solution to late night public      reducing the carbon intensity of
                                                by a strong road and public              transport on Fridays and Saturdays.     the public transport system: a
                                                transport network. There is no                                                   20 per cent reduction by 2020.
                                                                                         Extending train operating hours
                                                comparable employment corridor
                                                                                         may not be ideally suited to            The most effective way to
                                                or underpinning transport network
                                                                                         the night time transport task.          achieve this in Melbourne will be
                                                west of the Maribyrnong River.
                                                                                         Trains have a significantly              to decarbonise the fuel supply,
                                                The western suburbs need better          higher operating cost than              through the introduction of low-
                                                transport connections with Central       buses. Additionally any overlap         carbon or clean source energy,
                                                Melbourne and the south eastern          between trains and NightRider           thereby reducing reliance on
                                                employment corridor, as well             will result in competition              emission-intensive sources.
                                                as with the Port of Melbourne.           between the two modes.                  Additionally, improvements to
                                                These connections would boost
                                                                                         Considerable improvements               the energy efficiency of the
                                                the west’s capacity to attract and
                                                                                         to NightRider have been                 public transport network, such as
                                                retain businesses and reduce social
                                                                                         made in recent years. This has          regenerative braking on trains, can
                                                disadvantage by providing better
                                                                                         contributed to high demand              also contribute to overall reductions
                                                access to the central city for work,
                                                                                         for services. Further improving         in greenhouse gas emissions.
                                                education and other purposes. They
                                                                                         service frequencies will increase
                                                would also open up new business

66
Effective and integrated public transport
67
     CITY OF MELBOURNE, TRANSPORT STRATEGY - 2012
Effective and integrated public transport
CITY OF MELBOURNE > TRANSPORT STRATEGY > EFFECTIVE AND INTEGRATED PUBLIC TRANSPORT

                                                 6 Train

                                                Goal                                Context                                cities across the world have (or
                                                                                                                           are installing) a metro rail system
                                                                                    An efficient and reliable train
                                                Train travel to and                 network is the central component
                                                                                                                           to meet the more intensive
                                                                                                                           passenger rail task. Unlike a
                                                within the City of                  of a well functioning public           suburban rail system, a metro
                                                Melbourne will be                   transport system. High capacity        (or rapid transit) rail system is
                                                                                    and fast train connections are vital   a network of dedicated lines
                                                convenient, reliable,               for enabling access to the central     segregated from each other and
                                                safe and efficient. Peak            city and the variety of facilities     other rail traffic and running back
                                                                                    and services hosted there.
                                                hour (peak direction)                                                      and forth along the one line.
                                                                                    The Melbourne train system carries     Passengers wanting to traverse
                                                train frequency will be             about 400,000 people each day          the network make interchanges
                                                increased by 50 per                 on a network of 830 km of track,       at hub stations where two or
                                                cent from 2011 service              using 180 six-carriage trains. There   more lines pass by each other.
                                                                                    is no other mode of transport with
                                                levels.                             the capacity and efficiency of
                                                                                                                           Melbourne needs a metro style
                                                                                                                           rail service that can run at higher
                                                                                    trains, capable of moving people       frequencies and speeds and
                                                                                    into and from the central city.        with greater reliability. Running
                                                                                    Improving train network                at frequencies of every five
                                                                                    efficiency and integration with        minutes means a timetable is
                                                                                    complementary modes of                 not required. The metro network
                                                                                    transport is essential if we are       can be complemented by a
                                                                                    to support sustainable growth          suburban rail service to the
                                                                                    in the number of residents and         outer metropolitan areas.
                                                                                    employment opportunities
                                                                                    in the City of Melbourne.              The costs of congestion on
                                                                                    Melbourne has a large suburban         trains
                                                                                    rail system. Suburban rail systems     Overcrowding on our train network
                                                                                    operate on main line tracks,           makes access to the City of
                                                                                    carrying a mix of other rail traffic   Melbourne difficult for some people
                                                                                    such as regional passenger             across the metropolitan area
CITY OF MELBOURNE - TRANSPORT STRATEGY - 2012

                                                                                    rail and freight services. This        and coming from some regional
                                                                                    means that the train traffic is        centres. It also affects inner city
                                                                                    more complex, headways are             residents who are unable to access
                                                                                    longer, average speeds slower          persistently overcrowded services.
                                                                                    and service frequencies lower.         This can be especially problematic
                                                                                    As the density of activity in          at peak times, when many people
                                                                                    Melbourne’s inner metropolitan         rely on the rail network to get to
                                                                                    region has grown over the last         work. Further overcrowding on our
                                                                                    20 to 30 years, our suburban           trains has the potential to suppress
                                                                                    system has become increasingly         jobs growth in inner Melbourne.
                                                                                    ill-suited to meet the rail service    It has been calculated that for
                                                                                    needs of these parts of the city.      every 10 per cent of overcrowding
                                                                                                                           on Melbourne’s trains, the city
                                                                                    Issues                                 misses out on creating between
                                                                                                                           1600 and 2600 jobs1. The peak
                                                                                    The suburban rail system is            rail capacity of Melbourne’s train
                                                                                    inadequate for inner Melbourne
                                                                                    The dense inner metropolitan           1 Currie, G, 2010 Understanding Urban
                                                                                    regions of most large advanced         Agglomeration Benefits in Mass Transit
                                                                                                                           Project Evaluation, Monash University
68
Effective and integrated public transport
Seymour

                                                                          Upfield
                                                               Craigieburn                                                                           South Morang            Hurstbridge
                                               Tullamarine

                                                                                                                                                                      Eltham
                 Sunbury
 Bendigo

              Melton
                                                                                                                Parkville                        Clifton Hill
 Ballarat
                                                                                                                                                                                     Doncaster

                                                                                   Flagstaff
                                                  Footscray        North
                                                               Melbourne                                         Melbourne
                                                                                                                 Central
                           Wyndham Vale
                                                  Newport                                                                                                                                                Lilydale
                                                                                                                              Parliament
 Geelong
                                                          Southern Cross
                           Laverton
                                                                                                                            Richmond           Burnley          Camberwell
                                          Williamstown

                                                                              Flinders St

                                                                                                                             South Yarra                                            Alamein              Belgrave
                                                                                                                                                          Caulfield

                                                                                                                                                                                               Glen Waverly

                                                                                                                                                                                              Rowville

                                                                                                                                           Sandringham

                                                                                                                                                                                                         Traralgon
Metropolitan train network 2030                                                                                                                      Baxter          Cranbourne East
                                                                                                                                                                                           Pakenham

Fig 6.1 Possible Train Network Concept 2030 showing new lines with less convergence

                                                                      Seymour

                                                                                                                                                     South Morang            Hurstbridge
                                                                                Upfield

                                                               Craigieburn
                                                                                                                                                                     Eltham
                Sunbury
Bendigo

           Baccus Marsh
                                                                                                                                                Clifton Hill
                                                                                                           Melbourne

Ballarat
                                                                                               Flagstaff

                                                                                                           Central

                                                                                                                                                                                                                     CITY OF MELBOURNE, TRANSPORT STRATEGY - 2012
                                                  Footscray       North
                                                              Melbourne

                                                 Newport                                                                                                                                                 Lilydale
Geelong                                                                                                                       Parliament
                                                         Southern Cross
            Werribbee      Laverton
                                                                                                                            Richmond           Burnley          Camberwell      Ringwood
                                          Williamstown

                                                                             Flinders St
                                                                                                                                                                                    Alamein              Belgrave
                                                                                                                             South Yarra
                                                                                                                                                           Caulfield
                                                                                                                                                                                               Glen Waverly

                                                                                                                                            Sandringham

                                                                                                                                                                                                         Traralgon
Metropolitan train network 2011                                                                                                                     Frankston        Cranbourne East
                                                                                                                                                                                           Pakenham

Fig 6.2 Train Network Configuration 2011 showing pressure on Flinders Street
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     69
CITY OF MELBOURNE > TRANSPORT STRATEGY > EFFECTIVE AND INTEGRATED PUBLIC TRANSPORT > TRAIN

                                                                                                                                               Royal Pde

                                                                                                                                                                     St
                                                                                                                                                                  Swanston
                                                                                                                                  Parkville
                                                                                                                                                                         Grattan
                                                                               Dynon R                                                                                                 St
                                                                                         d
                                                                                                                         Queensb
                                                                                                                                       erry St

                                                                                                                                                                                                                           Hoddle St
                                                                                                            Arden      Victoria
                                                                                                                                  St
                                                                               Footscr
                                                                                       ay Rd
                                                                                                                                                                                  CBD North
                                                                                                                                                              t
                                                                                                                                                           eS
                                                                                                                                                 rob
                                                                                                                                              LaT
                                                                                                                                                                             Sw
                                                                                                 INK

                                                                                                                                                                             ans
                                                                                                                                                                              ton

                                                                                                                                                           CBD                         CBD South
                                                                                               CITYL

                                                                                                                                                                                  St
                                                                                                                                          Kin
                                                                                                                                  Spe

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          St
                                                                                                                                              gS

                                                     Melbourne Metro project

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        Church
                                                                                                                                   nce

                                                                                                                                               t
                                                                                                                                       r St

                                                                                                                                                                                                              MCG
                                                           Roads

                                                           Freeway

                                                           Existing stations

                                                           Existing rail

                                                           Melbourne CBD

                                                           Parks                                                                                                         Domain                       Domai
                                                                                                                                                                                                           n Rd

                                                           Proposed underground rail

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        Toorak
                                                           Proposed underground station                                                                                                                                                              Rd
                                                                                                                                                                                                                    d
                                                                                                                                                                                               St K

                                                                                                                                                                                                                  Punt R

                                                           Portal
                                                                                                                                                                                                ilda
                                                                                                                                                                                                  Rd

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       Comm
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 ercial R
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          d
CITY OF MELBOURNE - TRANSPORT STRATEGY - 2012

                                                Fig 6.3 Melbourne Metro project proposed alignment Source: Department of Transport

                                                system is currently approximately                      ability of the public transport                                                      provide excellent accessibility
                                                40 per cent overloaded and this is                     system to function as an                                                             and high passenger capacity to
                                                projected to go as high as 44 per                      integrated multi modal system.                                                       serve what will be high intensity,
                                                cent by 2015, even with current                        Some precincts such as the train/                                                    mixed-use areas very similar to the
                                                planned improvements in place.                         tram interchange at Swanston                                                         current central city. The long-term
                                                Regional Rail Link is an important                     Street, at Flinders Street Station,                                                  planning for land use development
                                                project addressing train congestion                    or the Spring Street exits for                                                       and transport planning in these
                                                by constructing new tracks to                          Parliament Station, have not                                                         contexts must be coordinated.
                                                separate suburban trains from the                      been designed for current peak
                                                                                                                                                                                            Greenhouse emissions and
                                                west from regional trains servicing                    capacity and congestion will only
                                                                                                                                                                                            energy cost
                                                Geelong, Ballarat and Bendigo.                         increase as patronage grows.
                                                                                                                                                                                            Melbourne’s train network
                                                Poor customer pedestrian                               Urban renewal areas will require                                                     currently relies on electricity
                                                connections and interchanges                           new train services                                                                   generated by brown coal. This is
                                                Poor pedestrian connections                            Major urban renewal areas such as                                                    very greenhouse gas intensive.
                                                for customers around modal                             City North and Arden-Macaulay                                                        Fuel costs are expected to rise in
                                                interchanges is undermining the                        will require new rail services to
70
the future, including the cost of           Rowville are currently being
electricity to run the train network.       studied.                                 Green St                                                                                       St

                                                                                                          Street
                                                                                              reet                                                                              s
                                                                                                                                                                       ne
                                                                                                                                                                     ai
                                                                                                                                                                 H

Objectives and actions                  57. Priority Action: Work with the

                                                                                                                                                   M
                                                                                                       Fogarty

                                                                                                                                                    ac
                                                                                                                                                            au
                                            Department of Transport to

                                                                                                                                                                la
                                                                                                                                                                   y
                                                                                                                                                                     Ro
Re-engineer the suburban rail               achieve the conversion of the

                                                                                                                                                                             ad
                                                                                                             Arden St
                                                                                                            et        re
                                                                                    Area subj
system to provide a metro                   suburban rail network into a                      ect
                                                                                    Metro mas to Melbourne
                                            metro style system.                                terplannin
service                                                                                                   g

The suburban train system needs         Melbourne Metro
to be converted into a metro                                                                         Arden Station
                                        The State Government has
train service to cater for the                                                                                                   Queensb
                                        proposed that one of the next                                                                                           erry St
large number of users and to
                                        major improvements to the train

                                                                                                                        Street

                                                                                                                                         Terrace

                                                                                                                                                                           Street
serve the growth and intensity of

                                                                                                                                                       reet
                                        system is to be the Melbourne

                                                                                                                                                   Stawell St
development in inner Melbourne.

                                                                                                                      Laurens

                                                                                                                                                                  Dryburgh
                                                                                                                                 Munster
                                        Metro rail tunnel. This new service,
Creating a metro system could           planned to be operating by around
increase the capacity of the train      2020, was initially proposed                                                                   Victoria
                                                                                                                                                Street
network from approximately              by the East West Link Needs
135 trains in the morning peak          Assessment (the Eddington Report)                                                                  Miller Stre
                                                                                                                                                       et
hour to about 256 trains.               and is similar to the North-South
 đƫ Through-route trains – The          Underground Rail Line proposed
    most efficient way for trains to    in the City of Melbourne’s previous
    operate is to travel from one       transport strategy, Moving             Fig 6.4 Proposed Arden station location
    side of the metropolitan area to    People and Freight 2006-2020.
    the other, running through the                                             plans in close consultation with
                                        The project would provide a high
    central city. This means they                                              the community and the State
                                        capacity underground train running
    spend as little time as possible                                           Government to ensure that the local
                                        from Footscray, via new stations
    in the most congested part of                                              land use and transport planning is
                                        at Arden-Macaulay, Parkville, City
    the network which, in                                                      fully integrated with the planning
                                        North, City South and Domain
    Melbourne, is the City Loop.                                               for the proposed Melbourne Metro.
                                        to join the existing train network
 đƫ Separate lines – When lines are     near South Yarra station. The          The timeframes envisaged in the
    separated they can be               Melbourne Metro would add              City of Melbourne’s plans are                                                                             CITY OF MELBOURNE, TRANSPORT STRATEGY - 2012

    upgraded independently              24, nine-car trains per hour to        coordinated with State Goverment’s
    (including larger train sets and    Melbourne’s network and be able        project timelines. In November
    new signalling) and                 to carry 60,000 people per hour.       2011 the Victorian Government
    breakdowns are isolated to a                                               submitted a bid to Infrastructure
                                        The Melbourne Metro proposal
    single line. Washing and repair                                            Australia for $130 million for
                                        is a major city shaping project
    facilities are provided for each                                           pre-construction work on the
                                        comparable in scale and effect with
    line so trains do not travel on                                            project (nominally for 2012/13).
                                        the City Loop. Planning for the new
    the network to access               Melbourne Metro stations at Arden,     The Melbourne Metro proposal
    servicing. Trains can be run        Parkville, CBD North, CBD South        must provide for a very high
    simply and more frequently          and Domain has been incorporated       level of transport and land use
    because complex timetabling         into City of Melbourne’s new           integration. New development
    and track sharing is avoided.       Municipal Strategic Statement          located near stations or feeder
 đƫ New routes – As Melbourne           (MSS), the Arden-Macaulay              services to the Melbourne Metro
    grows, new train lines will be      Structure Plan 2012 and City North     (such as new tram or bus lines)
    needed. The first of these will      Structure Plan 2012. These are plans   should be strongly transit-oriented.
    be the Melbourne Metro Rail         for the local land use development,    The project should include a review
    Tunnel. Other potential future      transport and mobility in these        of existing transport systems to
    extensions to Melbourne             urban renewal areas. The City of       ensure they provide optimal service
    Airport, Doncaster and              Melbourne has developed these          to the growing city. In particular

                                                                                                                                                                                            71
CITY OF MELBOURNE > TRANSPORT STRATEGY > FLEXIBLE AND ADAPTABLE PRIVATE TRANSPORT > TRAIN

                                                                                                                                    W

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                Lyg
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     Car
                                                tram services should be re-routed                                               Morrah
                                                                                                                                                       Street
                                                                                                 ive

                                                from the overcrowded Swanston

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        Street
                                                                                               Dr

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     Bouverie
                                                                                            k

                                                Street corridor on to routes that
                                                                                             r
                                                                                          Pa

                                                will feed better transport service                                         Story St
                                                                                                                                   reet
                                                to the west of the central city.
                                                                                                                                                                         Royal Parade
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      Victoria
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               Street
                                                The project must integrate the
                                                new stations with the surrounding
                                                                                                 Roya Melb
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      eet

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 R us
                                                                                                                                ourne Ho
                                                urban fabric to enhance the                                                                                                                                                                                                              n S
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             tr

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     CB
                                                                                                                                                         spital
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  nkli

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     sell
                                                                                                                                                                                                            Melbourn                                                        Fra
                                                mobility, liveability and economic

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       DN
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        e Univers
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               ity

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          Str
                                                                                                                                           Parkville
                                                performance of the city. This                                                                        Station

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         ort

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             e et
                                                                                                             Fl
                                                                                                               em

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            hS
                                                would mean excellent pedestrian                                           in                                                                                          Grattan
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             Street
                                                                                                        et

                                                                                                                             g

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              tat
                                                                                                    re

                                                networks to ensure that the walking                                                     to
                                                                                                  St

                                                                                                                                           n

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 ion
                                                                                               yn

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      e   t
                                                                                                                                                R                                                                                                                                                                 tre
                                                                                           ck

                                                leg of public transport journeys is                                                                 oa                                                                                                                                                        e S
                                                                                          re

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          b
                                                                                         W

                                                                                                                                                         d                                                                                                                                            Tro
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 La

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              Sw
                                                                                                                                et

                                                prioritised, efficient and attractive.
                                                                                                                           re
                                                                                                                         St

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 a
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                ns t
                                                                                                                    d
                                                                                                              oo

                                                Construction of the Melbourne                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 et

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    on
                                                                                                          w

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          e
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      Str
                                                                                                        ck

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              le
                                                                                                       a

                                                                                                                                                                                        Pelham                                                                                                                                                       s da

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     Str
                                                                                                    Bl

                                                                                                                                                                      Eliz

                                                Metro would take several years                                                                                                                                                Street
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               Lon

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         eet
                                                                                                                                                                        abe

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             Street

                                                and have a significant impact                        C
                                                                                                                                                                             th

                                                                                                        ou
                                                                                                             rt
                                                                                                                                                                             St

                                                                                                               ne
                                                on city operation. Construction                                     y
                                                                                                                        St
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         Leicester

                                                                                                                           r   ee
                                                in the central city is complex                                                      t

                                                and affects many people and
                                                businesses. The City of Melbourne        Fig 6.5 Proposed Parkville station                                                                                                                                           Fig 6.6 Proposed CBD North station
                                                will need to work closely with the       location                                                                                                                                                                     location
                                                State Government to minimise
                                                negative impacts of construction.

                                                58. Priority Action: Work closely
                                                    with the Department of
                                                    Transport on the planning and
                                                    construction of the Melbourne
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          Dal

                                                    Metro project to ensure it
                                                    is well integrated with the                                                                                                              et
CITY OF MELBOURNE - TRANSPORT STRATEGY - 2012

                                                                                                                                                                                   e
                                                                                                                                                                               Str
                                                    existing city and its future                                                                             Bou
                                                                                                                                                                 rke
                                                    development and enhances
                                                                                                                                                Sw
                                                                                                                                                  ans

                                                    Melbourne’s transport
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            St
                                                                                                                                                       ton

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              Ki

                                                    network in addition to
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                ld
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    a
                                                                                                                                                         Str

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        Rd

                                                    actively supporting future rail
                                                                                                                                                            e et

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     Domain
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     Road
                                                    extensions to Doncaster.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        R us
                                                                                                                                                                      CB

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             sell
                                                                                                                                                                        DS

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    Do

                                                                                                                                                        et
                                                Improve customer pedestrian                                                                    Str
                                                                                                                                                   e
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               Str

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      m
                                                                                                                                                                          out

                                                                                                                            ins
                                                                                                                        Coll
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  e et

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       ai

                                                interchanges and connections
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         n
                                                                                                                                                                             hS

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              St

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               Bromby
                                                                                                              Eliz

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      Street
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    eet
                                                                                                                                                                               tat

                                                The design of the public realm
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                at

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              Str
                                                                                                                   a

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  io

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        rs
                                                                                                                 bet

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   de
                                                                                                                                                                                  ion

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     Street

                                                                                                                                                                                                                              Flin
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    n

                                                around existing and proposed
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          Street
                                                                                                                        h S

                                                stations needs to optimise
                                                                                                                            tre

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 Arnold

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        Adams
                                                                                                                               et

                                                                                                                                                                                                                               Federation Square
                                                pedestrian priority, safety,                                                                                                                                                                                                City of Port Phillip
                                                                                                                                                                               n
                                                                                                                                                                        atio
                                                                                                                                                                   t st
                                                                                                                                                                                                            St K

                                                amenity and convenience of                                                                        s     Str
                                                                                                                                                            ee
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                Toorak
                                                                                                                                          der
                                                                                                                                                                                                                 ilda

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        Road
                                                all rail customers as they move                                                 Flin
                                                                                                                                                                                                                      Rd

                                                between the station and their
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 St K

                                                final destination, or the next leg                                                                                                  SO
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      ilda

                                                                                                                                                                                        U
                                                                                                                                                                                            TH

                                                of their journey. This requires                                                                                                                  G
                                                                                                                                                                                                     AT
                                                                                                                                                                                                        E
                                                                                                                                                                                                            A
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          Rd

                                                                                                                                                                                                             V
                                                                                                                                                                                                                 EN

                                                specific improvements to facilitate                                                                                                                                    U
                                                                                                                                                SO

                                                                                                                                                                                                                          E
                                                                                                                                                   U

                                                convenient access for people with        Fig 6.7 Proposed CBD South station                                                                                                                                           Fig 6.8 Proposed Domain station
                                                                                         location                                                                                                                                                                     location
72
disabilities to existing and future    62. Action: Advocate for the
underground train stations. The            hours and days of operation of
Flinders Street precinct, and links        Flagstaff Station to be similar
to the Federation Square tram              to other City Loop stations.
stop and the Elizabeth Street
                                       Greenhouse emissions and
tram terminus require specific
                                       energy cost
short term improvements.
                                       There are opportunities to
59. Priority Action: Work with the     reduce the greenhouse intensity
    Department of Transport and        of the public transport network
    train operators to ensure that     through both the operation of
    areas around train stations        the network and the energy
    provide excellent pedestrian
                                       that is used to power it.
    access.
                                       63. Action: Advocate to improve
60. Priority Action: Work with
                                           the overall energy efficiency
    State Government to ensure
                                           of the train network and in
    the municipality’s urban
                                           particular increase the use of
    renewal areas (Southbank,
                                           low-carbon and clean-source
    Docklands, E-Gate, Arden-
                                           energy to power Melbourne’s
    Macaulay and City North) are
                                           train system.
    planned to prioritise direct,
    high quality, high capacity
    pedestrian links for 800m
    around new and existing
    stations.

Coordinate land use
intensification with existing and
new rail stations
The development of land around
new rail stations should be
planned to maximise the benefit                                               CITY OF MELBOURNE, TRANSPORT STRATEGY - 2012
of the accessibility provided by
the train network. Higher density,
mixed-use developments should
be located closest to stations.
Existing train stations, such as
Flagstaff and North Melbourne, will
play a more important role as urban
renewal of the inner north and west
of the central city continues. These
stations should be managed to
complement this increase in activity
and provide convenient access for
residents, commuters and visitors.

61. Priority Action: Work with
    the State Government to
    ensure that planning for new
    rail stations and precincts
    integrates land-use planning
    with the transport network.

                                                                             73
CITY OF MELBOURNE > TRANSPORT STRATEGY > EFFECTIVE AND INTEGRATED PUBLIC TRANSPORT

                                                 7 Tram

                                                Goal                                Context                                    traffic manoeuvres crossing the
                                                                                                                               rails, such as cars turning right.
                                                                                    Melbourne’s trams are an iconic
                                                Tram operations in the              part of the city’s street life.         đƫ Only limited priority at
                                                City of Melbourne will              They connect Melbourne’s inner             intersections with signals along
                                                                                    suburbs and shopping centres               tram routes – Trams receive
                                                be improved to offer a              and offer a fine grain of mobility          some level of priority at traffic
                                                more frequent and                   compared with the longer                   lights but this could be
                                                                                                                               significantly increased. On
                                                reliable service. Tram              distance task performed by the
                                                                                                                               average, Melbourne’s trams
                                                                                    heavy rail network. Melbourne’s
                                                stops will be better                trams have the potential to                spend 17 per cent of their
                                                integrated into the                 be one of the world’s leading              journey time waiting at traffic
                                                                                                                               signals. Analysis by Yarra
                                                public realm to improve             surface transport systems.
                                                                                                                               Trams shows that changing
                                                passenger access,                   Trams serve approximately                  signal operation to give trams
                                                                                    600,000 people every day in
                                                safety and amenity,                 Melbourne’s inner metropolitan
                                                                                                                               dynamic priority (signals
                                                                                                                               responding to arriving trams)
                                                with 90 per cent of                 areas, on a 247 km network that            on Swanston Street could
                                                stops upgraded to                   is worth between $10 billion and           result in delays being reduced
                                                                                    $15 billion. Trams can move more           by up to 33 per cent.
                                                ‘level access’ by 2016.             than 10,000 people per hour in
                                                                                    a single arterial traffic lane that     đƫ Tram stops are too frequent –
                                                                                    could otherwise move only 800              Melbourne’s tram stops are
                                                                                    cars. During peak hour on key              very closely spaced compared
                                                                                    routes into the city, trams already        with tram and light rail systems
                                                                                    move more people than motor                overseas. This provides
                                                                                    vehicles. For example, they move           excellent access to tram
                                                                                    56 per cent of the people travelling       services, however it can also
                                                                                    on Nicholson Street, Carlton,              mean frequent stopping, which
                                                                                    and 54 per cent of the people              increases travel time.
                                                                                    on Bridge Road, Richmond.               đƫ Tram stop design is inefficient
                                                                                    The tram network is one of                 for passenger boarding – Many
CITY OF MELBOURNE - TRANSPORT STRATEGY - 2012

                                                                                    Melbourne’s most important                 tram stop designs are
                                                                                    strategic assets. Trams provide high       inefficient. These include stops
                                                                                    quality, on-street public transport        yet to be converted to level
                                                                                    that does not require passengers           access and stops where
                                                                                    to travel underground to access it.        passengers have to wait for
                                                                                                                               vehicles to halt before they can
                                                                                    However Melbourne’s trams                  cross traffic lanes.
                                                                                    are amongst the slowest in
                                                                                    the world, running at around           Many tram routes in the city
                                                                                    16 kph throughout the system           have developed as corridors of
                                                                                    and 10 kph in the city.                mixed use and often high density
                                                                                                                           land uses. This integration of
                                                                                    The low average running                efficient transport and centres
                                                                                    speeds are caused by:                  of employment and housing is
                                                                                     đƫ Sharing tramways with general      beneficial for people living, working
                                                                                        road traffic – This means trams    and visiting these areas, as well
                                                                                        are being stalled in road          as for the macro-urban form of
                                                                                        congestion and stopped by          Melbourne. While this is common
                                                                                                                           in the inner city, many tram routes
                                                                                                                           in the middle and outer network
                                                                                                                           are underdeveloped and have
74
the potential to accommodate
significantly more residents,
jobs and other services.

Issues
Slow tram speeds
There are many factors that
impede and slow down trams,
together making Melbourne’s
trams the slowest in the world.
Delays caused by sharing tramways
with general road traffic result
in unpredictable delays and
even cancellations of services.
Consequently, the tram service
becomes less reliable in running to
timetable, which deters travellers
from using the service. It is also
extremely expensive to manage
a tram network that is heavily
impacted by traffic; if trams were         Fig 7.1 Level access tram stop in Swanston Street, Melbourne
not held up by traffic congestion,
the same level of service could
be achieved with approximately
100 fewer trams. (Melbourne has
486 trams, including 37 historic W
class vehicles). Many tram routes
in the city of Melbourne have been
separated from traffic, however
trams are often still held up by non-                                                                                       CITY OF MELBOURNE, TRANSPORT STRATEGY - 2012
compliant traffic and right turning
vehicles. These issues can be most
obvious on streets which provide
access to off street car parking.
Considering the critical role
that trams play in the transport
system, they are often afforded
little priority at traffic lights, which
can reduce the quality of the
service they provide. The City of
Melbourne has been working with
VicRoads and tram operators to
improve tram priority at signals
for many years, achieving some             Fig 7.2 Level access tram stop showing permeable access to footpath in StKilda
excellent results. However, more
can be done to reduce the time that
trams are held up at traffic lights.

                                                                                                                            75
CITY OF MELBOURNE > TRANSPORT STRATEGY > EFFECTIVE AND INTEGRATED PUBLIC TRANSPORT > TRAM

                                                Infrequent services
                                                Poor frequency of tram services
                                                can be a result of the problems
                                                which slow trams down. When
                                                services are significantly delayed,
                                                there is often a knock-on effect
                                                to other services using the same
                                                route or line, resulting in extended
                                                time gaps between services.                        2010 Tram Network
                                                                                                   Route Configuration
                                                Many tram routes are scheduled to               (Colours used for clarity only.)
                                                run at low frequency, due to a lack
                                                of rolling stock, lack of demand,
                                                or inability to accommodate
                                                more services on the existing
                                                infrastructure. Low frequencies are
                                                common in the inter-peak times.

                                                Stop and interchange design
                                                Tram stop designs need significant
                                                improvement to ease overcrowding
                                                and improve connections for
                                                walking. Level access stops have
                                                improved the safety and amenity
                                                of stops, as well as reducing
                                                loading times. In some cases
                                                they have calmed traffic in high
                                                pedestrian areas. However, some
                                                are now overcrowded and require
                                                staff to maintain passenger
                                                safety and efficient movement.
CITY OF MELBOURNE - TRANSPORT STRATEGY - 2012

                                                Extensive fencing is used to
                                                separate traffic (often 50 to 60
                                                kph zones) from pedestrian areas,
                                                which has led to an impermeable
                                                walking environment.
                                                Creating a more equitable,
                                                accessible transport system is a
                                                major driver for improving the
                                                design of tram stops. Meeting
                                                the requirements of the Disability                 2030 Tram Network
                                                Discrimination Act will ensure those               Route Configuration
                                                                                                (Colours used for clarity only.)
                                                with physical disabilities can access
                                                trams and it improves the ease and
                                                safety of access for all customers.
                                                Some of the most important tram         Fig 7.3 Tram congestion on Swanston        Fig 7.5 (Right)Tram routes moved to
                                                stops in the city are interchanges      Street                                     the west of the central city; additional
                                                between tram and train or               Fig 7.4 Trams to the west of the central   tracks at Victoria Parade, E-Gate and
                                                bus. For example, the Flinders          city and additional routes                 Haymarket. New tracks and routes on
                                                Street Station connection to the                                                   Dynon Rd, in Fishermans Bend, and
                                                                                                                                   along Grattan and Elgin Streets
76
Dynon Rd
                       Tram

                                                E-
                                                  Ga
                                                    te

                                           nd
                                n   s Be
                           erma
                       Fish

                                                         CITY OF MELBOURNE, TRANSPORT STRATEGY - 2012

Proposed Tram Network
     Existing routes
     Proposed route change
     New tracks required
     Urban renewal areas
                                                         77
CITY OF MELBOURNE > TRANSPORT STRATEGY > EFFECTIVE AND INTEGRATED PUBLIC TRANSPORT > TRAM

                                                Federation Square tram stop, and       many vehicles are too small: 147         streets (Flinders, Collins, Bourke, La
                                                the interchange between Southern       of the fleet’s 486 trams are Z            Trobe and buses on Lonsdale), at
                                                Cross Station and the tram network     class, which carry only 70 people,       streets such as King Street, would
                                                are extremely busy places in the       compared with the Bumblebee              significantly reduce tram delays.
                                                morning and evening peaks. Better      (C2 class), which carries 140            The Department of Transport
                                                tram stop design, and traffic          people. Recent increases in user         plans a test of ‘absolute priority’
                                                treatment, including lower speeds,     numbers has meant Melbourne’s            for tram routes 96 and 109, which
                                                can help create a more permeable       trams are becoming overcrowded           would reduce to zero the delays
                                                walking environment to ease            more often. Upgrading of the             trams experience at traffic signals.
                                                some of the current overcrowding,      fleet can address this issue and
                                                safety and amenity issues.             realise significant performance           66. Priority Action: Work with
                                                                                       and quality improvements.                    VicRoads to change traffic
                                                Network imbalances and gaps                                                         signalling to prioritise tram
                                                                                                                                    movements.
                                                The tram network in the city is        Objectives and Actions
                                                currently very dependent on the                                                 The road Network Operating Plan
                                                St Kilda Road-Swanston Street          Improving tram speeds                    (NOP) to be developed by the City
                                                corridor. The number of routes that    There are many infrastructure and        of Melbourne in cooperation with
                                                feed into this corridor means that     traffic management techniques            the Department of Transport and
                                                even a slight problem can have a       which can improve tram speeds            VicRoads will include the highest
                                                major impact on tram operations        across the network. Together,            level of priority for trams to ensure
                                                and people’s travel time. The          these initiatives can improve            fast running times, reduced tram
                                                emerging and future urban renewal      speeds from the current network          crowding, better reliability and
                                                areas will need to be serviced by      average of 16 kph, and central           a better customer experience.
                                                extensions to the tram network         city average of 10 kph.
                                                                                                                                67. Priority Action: Work with
                                                to deliver excellent accessibility.    On-road public transport needs               the Department of Transport
                                                                                       significantly greater priority over           and VicRoads to ensure that
                                                Greenhouse emissions and               general traffic in the allocation            the municipality’s Network
                                                energy cost                            of road space and time at traffic            Operating Plan provides a high
                                                Similarly to Melbourne’s train         signals. This can be achieved by             level of priority to trams.
                                                network, the tram system               better delineation between traffic
                                                currently relies on carbon                                                      Frequency boost
                                                                                       and tram lanes, and enforcement
CITY OF MELBOURNE - TRANSPORT STRATEGY - 2012

                                                intensive electricity. As the          of road rules that ensure trams          More frequent tram services will
                                                use and deployment of tram             and buses are not impeded.               deliver significant benefits for
                                                services increases, and in an                                                   access and mobility in the inner
                                                economic climate where fuel            64. Action: Work with Victoria           region. A frequency boost can
                                                costs are expected to rise, it             Police, VicRoads, the                be achieved by speeding up the
                                                will be increasingly important             Department of Transport and          network, minimising externalities
                                                                                           the Department of Justice to         which impede tram movements,
                                                to transition the tram fleet onto
                                                                                           improve traffic enforcement          and better design solutions for
                                                a sustainable power supply.                to reduce delays to trams and
                                                                                                                                busy tram stops and interchanges.
                                                                                           buses.
                                                Ageing tram fleet                                                                A 25 per cent increase in tram
                                                The age of Melbourne’s tram fleet       65. Priority Action: Work with the       frequencies will deliver substantial
                                                needs to be addressed. Many trams          Department of Transport to           network improvements, as
                                                will reach the end of their design         reduce tram and bus delays           detailed in the accessibility
                                                life during the next decade. The           by providing dedicated tram          analysis (Spatial Network Analysis
                                                                                           rights of way.                       of Multimodal Urban Transport
                                                lead-in time to buy new trams
                                                is three years, and the system         Giving greater traffic signal priority   Systems – SNAMUTS ) which
                                                requires a long term commitment        to trams across the network is a         underpins this strategy.
                                                to managing and expanding the          high priority for improving the
                                                capacity of the tram fleet. Trams are   level of service trams provide. In
                                                often overcrowded, partly because      the CBD, priority along east-west
78
CITY OF MELBOURNE, TRANSPORT STRATEGY - 2012

Fig 7.6
    xx.xFederation Square
         Caption yet to be Tram  Stop
                           inserted
                                        79
CITY OF MELBOURNE > TRANSPORT STRATEGY > EFFECTIVE AND INTEGRATED PUBLIC TRANSPORT > TRAM

                                                68. Priority Action: Work with         will be reduced in the city. There     that order. This is an opportunity
                                                    the Department of Transport,       is a requirement to balance the        to create a master plan for the
                                                    VicRoads and Yarra Trams to        needs of pedestrians, for example      streets on which these trams run, to
                                                    improve tram frequency and         their tolerance for long distances     ensure new transport infrastructure
                                                    average running speeds.            between stops, with the speed          is integrated with high quality
                                                                                       and operational needs of trams.        street design, pedestrian and
                                                Walkable stops and
                                                                                       New stops will be designed to          public transport priority, and
                                                interchanges
                                                                                       integrate much more easily into        new, more permeable stops.
                                                Constructing new level access
                                                                                       the surrounding footpath network
                                                stops for trams will be one of the                                            72. Priority Action: Work
                                                                                       and provide better access for              with the Department of
                                                most important parts of developing
                                                                                       cyclists. The City of Melbourne’s          Transport to master plan
                                                high mobility public transport
                                                                                       plans for Swanston Street, and             streets in preparation for the
                                                and pedestrian streets. These
                                                                                       the existing stop at Cleve Plaza           introduction of new low floor E
                                                should be constructed to provide
                                                                                       (Fitzroy Street, St Kilda) are             class trams.
                                                pedestrian priority access and high
                                                                                       examples of the new streetscape
                                                levels of pedestrian permeability.                                            Balance and optimise the
                                                                                       tram stop improvements we
                                                69. Priority Action: Work with         will see more of in the near           network
                                                    the Department of Transport,       future. This will mean greater         The City of Melbourne has
                                                    Yarra Trams and VicRoads           permeability for pedestrians,          identified opportunities to
                                                    to develop a four-year             reduced fencing, lower traffic         balance the tram network to ease
                                                    strategic plan to design and       speeds and better bicycle access.      over-burdened routes and also
                                                    construct level-access stops                                              assist poorly serviced areas. This
                                                    in the municipality as part        71. Priority Action: Work with the     strategy is closely aligned with
                                                    of a whole-of-streetscape              Department of Transport, Yarra
                                                    renewal. Include a review of                                              the urban renewal planned for
                                                                                           Trams and VicRoads to ensure
                                                    the function of existing level-                                           the municipality, and involves
                                                                                           the design of new level-access
                                                    access stops.                          tram stops that have excellent     improving tram services to the
                                                                                           pedestrian accessibility with      inner west of the central city.
                                                Providing access to trams and
                                                buses for people of all abilities is       the surrounding footpath
                                                                                           network.                           Trams to the west of the CBD
                                                important for access. By 2017, the
                                                Disability Discrimination Act (DDA)                                           There is an opportunity to redirect
                                                                                       New trams                              some of the trams currently using St
CITY OF MELBOURNE - TRANSPORT STRATEGY - 2012

                                                requires that 90 per cent of the
                                                public transport system (stops and     Melbourne needs a transparent,         Kilda Road to the west of the city.
                                                vehicles) must be DDA compliant.       ongoing asset management               This will help activate development
                                                Providing fully accessible stops       program of phasing out old             in the west of the CBD and reduce
                                                will contribute to a more equitable    trams, introducing new ones and        pressure on the Swanston Street-
                                                transport system, and also improve     expanding the tram fleet to cope        St Kilda Road spine. This would be
                                                the capacity and reliability of the    with strong patronage growth.          coordinated with the construction
                                                tram and bus networks by speeding      The arrival of 50 new E class          of a new tram interchange at
                                                up boarding and alighting.             trams in Melbourne between 2012        Domain as part of the Melbourne
                                                                                       and 2017 is welcome. Despite           Metro Domain station. The
                                                70. Action: Work with the              this, tram overcrowding will           Melbourne Metro will also service
                                                    Department of Transport, Yarra     worsen over that time due to           some of the current trips on
                                                    Trams and VicRoads on the          growth in passenger numbers.           the Swanston Street corridor.
                                                    construction of level access
                                                                                       As new trams are deployed on high      A north-south tram alignment
                                                    stops in the municipality
                                                    to meet comply with the            performing tram routes, the routes     running through the Haymarket
                                                    requirements of the Disability     should be upgraded to provide          roundabout will also improve
                                                    Discrimination Act.                the highest possible level of tram     tram accessibility to the west of
                                                                                       priority, high quality stops and       the central city. This will link the
                                                The high cost of new stops and the
                                                                                       route separation. New trams will       Royal Parade corridor with the
                                                need to reduce tram delays means
                                                                                       go on routes 96, 109, 19 and 112, in   Peel-William Street tram lines.
                                                that the overall number of stops
80
These options can be                      The City of Melbourne has been        Greenhouse emissions and
implemented in the short term,            working with the Department           energy cost
between 2011 and 2016.                    of Transport, the Department
                                          of Planning and Community             75. Action: Advocate to increase
Victoria Parade, E-Gate and               Development and adjacent                  the energy efficiency of
Haymarket                                                                           Melbourne’s tram system and
                                          municipalities to develop
                                                                                    the use of low-carbon and
The redevelopment of the E-Gate           tram routes 96 and 109 as                 clean-source energy.
site will require high quality public     examples of integrated transport
transport links into Docklands and        and land use planning.                Targets
the central city. A tram link via         Tram route 96 is already one
Footscray Road and pedestrian             of the most successful, and the       Increase tram running speeds
access to the North Melbourne             third most patronised, tram route     The City of Melbourne’s analysis
train station will provide this. Future   in Melbourne. However, current        of accessibility showed that
extension of this route beyond            running times between Spencer         increasing tram speeds by 25
E-Gate to the Dynon Road corridor         Street and East Brunswick are 40      per cent had a significant effect
will fit well with land use activity       per cent slower than in 1950 (28      on the accessibility provided by
linking central Melbourne with the        minutes today compared with           the public transport network.
Footscray precinct. A tram line           20 minutes in 1950). Route 96
will stimulate activity and deliver       trams spend 33 per cent of their      Increase service frequency
high quality access and mobility          journey time stationary. This is in   Progressively increase the service
for commercial and residential            addition to the 17 per cent of the    frequency across the network
developments along this route.            journey spent loading passengers.     to increase the accessibility
Other initiatives include connecting      This is a poor use of public          provided by the service. The
the two sections of tram track on         investment in the tram system.        City of Melbourne’s analysis of
Victoria Parade, between Swanston                                               accessibility showed that increasing
Street and Carlton Gardens, and           74. Priority Action: Work with
                                                                                service frequency was a key part
                                              Yarra Trams, The Department
linking the Errol Street service                                                of improving the overall public
                                              of Transport and VicRoads
with the Spencer Street corridor.             to implement the 96 and           transport accessibility. Frequencies
These initiatives can be                      109 route upgrade projects,       can be increased to a minimum of
implemented in the medium                     including ensuring that the       10 minutes in inter-peak times, by
term, between 2020 and 2030.                  network operating plan gives      implementing actions to improve        CITY OF MELBOURNE, TRANSPORT STRATEGY - 2012
                                              good signal priority through      running speed as well as adding
Fishermans Bend                               the city.                         more vehicles to the tram system.
Fishermans Bend is currently poorly
served by public transport. Any
future mixed use development of
this precinct must be accompanied
by high quality public transport
services. There are opportunities to
link Docklands and the 109 light rail
in Port Melbourne via the planned
Fishermans Bend development site.

73. Priority Action: Work with
    the Department of Transport
    and Yarra Trans and VicRoads
    to implement the long term
    reconfiguration and extension
    of the tram network proposed
    in this strategy.

                                          Fig 7.7 Collins Street, Melbourne                                               81
CITY OF MELBOURNE > TRANSPORT STRATEGY > EFFECTIVE AND INTEGRATED PUBLIC TRANSPORT

                                                 8 Bus

                                                Goal                                Context                                 strong patronage growth, and
                                                                                                                            provide an example of how buses
                                                                                    Melbourne’s bus network is
                                                Buses will develop as               experiencing similar growth to
                                                                                                                            can contribute to meeting the
                                                                                                                            mass transit task in Melbourne.
                                                an efficient and                    other public transport modes, and
                                                prioritised mode of                 this growth is forecast to continue.    Issues
                                                                                    In inner Melbourne buses are a
                                                public transport for                complementary component of              Reliability and travel times
                                                residents, workers and              the public transport network, in        Buses in the central city are often
                                                                                    many cases filling gaps in the train
                                                visitors to the city of             and tram networks and feeding
                                                                                                                            delayed or obstructed by general
                                                                                                                            traffic, both legally and illegally.
                                                Melbourne. Central city             or extending these rail routes.         Traffic using dedicated bus lanes,
                                                bus routes, such as                 Buses currently link the central        left turning vehicles which block
                                                Lonsdale and Queen                  city with the Doncaster area,           bus lanes, and general congestion,
                                                                                    Fishermans Bend, linking the            affect bus travel speeds, reliability
                                                streets will be                     Parkville precinct to North             and the frequency of services.
                                                improved for buses,                 Melbourne train station, and
                                                                                    offering late night transport           Poor scheduled frequency
                                                with travel times                   options, for example, NightRider.       The infrequency of some services
                                                reduced on these                    The use of NightRider buses has         is a major issue for Melbourne’s
                                                routes by 30 perƫcent.              been growing strongly. Patronage        bus network. Some routes
                                                                                    doubled to about 4,300 patrons          operate as little as once or twice
                                                                                    per weekend after 2008, when            per hour, and often do not offer
                                                                                    standard fares were applied.            late night or weekend service.
                                                                                    Buses are well suited to late           This is not a frequency level that
                                                                                    night operation. They are flexible       the City of Melbourne regards
                                                                                    (services can be quickly increased      as a minimum standard.
                                                                                    or rerouted to take account of
                                                                                    demand) run from ‘kerb-to-kerb’         Bus stop design
                                                                                    and can run on infrastructure           Many bus stops are too short to
                                                                                    that already operates 24 hours          cater for high-service bus routes
CITY OF MELBOURNE - TRANSPORT STRATEGY - 2012

                                                                                    a day (the road network).               and may need to be lengthened,
                                                                                    The City of Melbourne’s key CBD         requiring the removal of some
                                                                                    bus corridors are Lonsdale Street       on-street parking. Compared
                                                                                    (serving the Doncaster Area Rapid       to tram stops, bus stops often
                                                                                    Transit and other services) and         provide poor amenity.
                                                                                    Queen Street. In its busiest section,   Network imbalances and gaps
                                                                                    Lonsdale Street carries more than
                                                                                    1200 buses per weekday. Queen           In 2010 the Department of
                                                                                    Street carries nearly 750 buses.        Transport initiated a bus service
                                                                                    Bus lanes have been installed on        review for the Melbourne,
                                                                                    both sides of Lonsdale Street and       Port Phillip and Yarra areas.
                                                                                    on one side of Queen Street. These      This review contains many
                                                                                    projects were proposed in Moving        recommendations for improving
                                                                                    People and Freight 2006-2020.           bus services across the region.
                                                                                    The Doncaster Area Rapid Transit        Greenhouse emissions and
                                                                                    (DART) is a series of effective high    energy cost
                                                                                    capacity routes connecting the
                                                                                                                            The noise and air quality issues
                                                                                    central city to the Doncaster area.
                                                                                                                            associated with diesel fuelled
                                                                                    The routes continue to experience
                                                                                                                            buses are most prominent in
82
the central city. These vehicles
                                                                      144
can have a damaging impact
on inner urban amenity and the
environmental performance of

                                                                                                                 227
                                                                                                                       343
the public transport network as
a whole. Reliance on diesel also
exposes the bus industry to the
risks of future oil price fluctuations.

Objectives and actions                                                                                                                     855
                                                                                                              9
                                                                                                   256

Balance and optimise the
                                                                                                          1,25
                                                                                    160

                                                                                                                       269
network
Investment in the bus system can                                                            860                         256
                                                                                                     747

be a relatively cost effective way
of improving public transport
service provision. Enhancing                                                                113                 44
existing bus routes or adding new
routes to the network can also
                                                                                                         670

                                                                                                                                                               175
act as a precursor to future rail
and tram network extensions.
                                                                                                                             320

The initiatives proposed in the
Bus Service Review should
be implemented. Some of the
network changes and additional
bus network alterations are
shown in this strategy.
                                         Fig 8.1 Daily Bus volumes in the Central City, Source: Department of Transport
Buses in North Melbourne should
be diverted to better integrate
with activity in the Errol Street
precinct. Use of Queensberry                                                                                                                                            CITY OF MELBOURNE, TRANSPORT STRATEGY - 2012
Street for bus services should                                                               Australian bus patronage
respect the important role                                                                                      2001-2010
of the street for cycling.
The developing urban renewal                                          190%
                                                                                                                                                 SE QLD
area around Arden-Macaulay
                                                                      180%
will require excellent public
                                         Relative to 2001-02 levels

transport. The details of the                                         170%

transport network in this area will                                   160%

be developed in the future. The                                       150%
City of Melbourne supports a bus
                                                                      140%                                                                       Perth
link from Racecourse Road to
                                                                      130%                                                                       Melbourne
North Melbourne train station, to
serve the land use development                                        120%
                                                                                                                                                 Adelaide
in this area. This bus route may                                      110%                                                                                   Hobart
mature over time and eventually                                       100%
                                                                                                                                                 Sydney      Canberra

demand a tram service.
                                                                      90%
Buses in Fishermans Bend can
                                                                             2001    2002   2003         2004   2005    2006       2007   2008    2009         2010
be rationalised to benefit travel
times and untangle the central           Fig 8.2, Australian bus patronage 2001-2010, Source: Bus Association of Victoria
                                                                                                                                                                        83
CITY OF MELBOURNE > TRANSPORT STRATEGY > EFFECTIVE AND INTEGRATED PUBLIC TRANSPORT > BUS

                                                city components of these routes.      Increase running speed                 lengthened to allow buses to
                                                By terminating bus services at the    A bus system that is not impacted      move easily into and out of them.
                                                western end of the central city       by traffic congestion requires
                                                and integrating these with the                                               81. Action: Extend bus stops
                                                                                      dedicated bus lanes, traffic signal        where necessary by removing
                                                train, tram and other trunk bus       priority, safe and efficient stops         on-street parking or other
                                                routes, significant efficiencies can   and interchanges. The system               measures and improve bus
                                                be gained without any great loss      also needs to be managed in a              stop amenity.
                                                in convenience for passengers.        way that reduces the impact of
                                                There is scope to use the Lonsdale    general traffic on bus operations.     82. Priority Action: Work with the
                                                Street corridor for routes that                                                  Department of Transport to
                                                                                      For example, dedicated bus lanes
                                                                                                                                 improve the performance of
                                                enter the central city from the       require enforcement, and other             bus interchanges.
                                                south and north, such as routes       traffic impacts such as left turning
                                                216 and 220. This realignment         vehicles blocking bus lanes need       Meet late night travel demand
                                                will use the established Lonsdale     to be closely monitored and            with bus services
                                                Street bus lanes and stops.           avoided where possible. There is
                                                                                                                             Buses such as the NightRider
                                                                                      scope to incorporate automated
                                                76. Priority Action: Work with                                               service currently meet demand
                                                                                      enforcement techniques on key
                                                    the Department of Transport                                              for late night travel on Friday and
                                                                                      high mobility streets, to ensure
                                                    and the Bus Association                                                  Saturday evenings. Expanding
                                                    for the implementation            public transport priority is not
                                                                                                                             the times and days of NightRider
                                                    of the bus service review         impeded by illegal driver behaviour.
                                                                                                                             services, improving capacity,
                                                    recommendations.                                                         and adding new routes to the
                                                                                      79. Priority Action: Work with
                                                Bus operations in the central city        the Department of Transport,       network can help to improve public
                                                have been greatly improved by the         VicRoads and the Bus               transport accessibility when train
                                                introduction of bus lanes on key          Association to improve the         and tram services do not operate.
                                                routes, such as Lonsdale Street.          running speed of buses.
                                                Queen Street, which acts as the                                              83. Priority Action: Work with the
                                                                                      80. Priority Action: Work with the         Department of Transport and
                                                central city’s key north-south
                                                                                          Department of Transport and            Public Transport Victoria to
                                                route, requires similar priority.         VicRoads for separate bus              improve the NightRider bus
                                                77. Priority Action: Install north        rights-of-way.                         service including consideration
                                                    bound bus lanes on Queen                                                     of smaller more flexible buses.
CITY OF MELBOURNE - TRANSPORT STRATEGY - 2012

                                                    Street in the central city.
                                                                                      Better stops and interchanges          As the frequency of buses increases
                                                                                      There is a general need to improve     on key central city routes, the
                                                Increase service frequency            the legibility of bus stops across     impact of buses on the amenity of
                                                The City of Melbourne’s analysis      the network, including improved        the footpath will increase. Buses
                                                of the accessibility of the bus       design, signage and information.       run at a frequency of one per
                                                network found that increasing         The main bus interchange in the        minute on Lonsdale Street. Many
                                                bus speeds and service frequency      city is at Lonsdale Street, near       bus rapid transit systems around
                                                to a minimum of 10 minutes in         Spencer Street. This stop and          the world run buses in the centre
                                                inter-peak times significantly         link with Southern Cross Station       of the road in a similar way to how
                                                improved the service provided by      are important for the legibility       Melbourne’s trams operate. This
                                                the public transport network.         and convenience of the public          removes the buses from kerbside
                                                                                      transport network as a whole.          conflicts such as turning vehicles
                                                78. Priority Action: Work with        Pedestrians at this location, and      and reduces their impact on
                                                    the Department of Transport,      at other major bus stops, such as      footpath amenity. It also provides
                                                    VicRoads and the Bus              Lonsdale Street near Swanston          certainty to pedestrians about the
                                                    Association to improve bus        Street, require the highest possible
                                                    frequency.                                                               position of buses on the road.
                                                                                      pedestrian amenity and safety.
                                                                                      Many bus stops may need to be

                                                                                                                              Fig 8.3 Proposed bus network changes
84
You can also read