Market Perspectives Private Clients - Barclays Private Bank

Page created by Micheal Steele
 
CONTINUE READING
Market Perspectives Private Clients - Barclays Private Bank
Private
Clients   Market
          Perspectives
          August 2019
Market Perspectives Private Clients - Barclays Private Bank
Market Perspectives Private Clients - Barclays Private Bank
Foreword
Despite US equities hitting an all-time high in July, we will be keeping our end-
year forecast at 3000 for the S&P 500. While there may be an urge to reduce
risk after the strong performance by equities, accommodative central bank
policy looks set to support equity valuations for some time yet.

Indeed, risk assets typically             research shows that environmental,
outperform safer ones late in the         social and governance issues can
cycle. In the current late-cycle          add value to security selection and
environment, equities and emerging        improve portfolio performance.
markets debt look set to outperform.
That said, security selection and         The gold price has bounced
having active strategies will be key.     by close to 11% this year, as
                                          geopolitical tensions intensify and
Major central banks’ increasingly         rate-cut expectations grow. Rather
dovish tone has triggered record          than looking to make investment
flows into most parts of the bond         gains from holding gold, we believe
market, resulting in depressed rates      the yellow metal’s key attribute for
and spreads. As we head deeper            investors is as a diversification tool.
into the cycle, and with ever higher
levels of leverage, a diversified and    “Safe” assets and risk assets have
selective approach to bond investing      been positively correlated this year,
is key.                                   as good news is seen as bad by
                                          financial markets. Continuously
At a time when investors are keen         improving growth is set to return
to boost income, opportunities in         risk assets to the normal state of
emerging markets debt may offer           affairs, where good news is seen as
one possible solution. In doing so,       good, perhaps later this year.

                                          Jean-Damien Marie
                                          and Andre Portelli,
                                          Co-heads of Private Bank Investments

                                                                                    Market Perspectives August 2019 | 1
Market Perspectives Private Clients - Barclays Private Bank
Market Perspectives Private Clients - Barclays Private Bank
Contents
4      When good news is bad news
6      A closer look at late-cycle performance
7      Equities at a tipping point?
8      Time to be selective in fixed income
10     Selecting for alpha in emerging markets debt
12     Golden moment
14     Multi-asset portfolio allocation

Contributors
• Gerald Moser, Chief Market Strategist – gerald.moser@barclays.com
• Julien Lafargue, Head of Equity Strategy – julien.lafargue@barclays.com
• Damian Payiatakis, Head of Impact Investing – damian.payiatakis@barclays.com
• Michel Vernier, CFA, Head of Fixed Income Strategy – michel.vernier.barclays.com
• Henk Potts, Senior Investment Strategist – henk.potts@barclays.com

                                                                                     Market Perspectives August 2019 | 3
Market Perspectives Private Clients - Barclays Private Bank
Gerald Moser, Chief Market Strategist – gerald.moser@barclays.com

  When good news is bad news
  The “good news is bad” reaction of equities and bonds to macroeconomic
  data has been all too prevalent so far in 2019. So how soon will it be
  before risk assets revert to normal and react positively to good news?

   Liquidity and growth are two                                       As the economy starts to expand,                               In the first instance, positive growth is
   intertwined factors that are vital                                 central banks can slowly remove                                perceived positively by risk assets and
   to the outlook for the economy                                     liquidity with an eye to extending                             negatively by “safe” assets (see chart
   and prospects for financial assets.                                the economic cycle for as long as                              below). This is the common state of
                                                                      possible. At that stage, it is usually                         affairs. With strong growth, equities
 Traditionally, central banks ease                                    all about mitigating inflation risks                           react well while safe assets such as
 monetary conditions during a                                         and avoiding excesses building up                              government bonds, gold or the Swiss
 recession to provide more liquidity.                                 in the economy. That said, liquidity                           franc typically underperform. This
 This results in cheap credit and                                     may need to be increased at a later                            regime has prevailed for most of the
 easy access to financing for                                         stage of the economic cycle, as is the                         past couple of years.
 households and companies and in                                      case currently.
 turn helps the economy to recover.                                                                                                   However, since the start of the year,
                                                                       In a nutshell, liquidity is like a fuel                       “good news is bad news” has been in
                                                                       that can be adjusted to control the                            vogue. In this setup, risk assets and
                                                                       strength of the growth engine.                                 safe assets are positively correlated.
“Liquidity is like a fuel                                                                                                             Whenever economic data starts to
                                                                       When good news is bad                                          improve or surprise positively, not
 that can be adjusted to                                               In financial markets, the relationship                         only do safe assets underperform
 control the strength of                                               between growth, liquidity and assets                           but growth-sensitive assets, such as
 the growth engine.”                                                   is not constant. There are usually two                         equities, underperform as well (see
                                                                       different regimes: “good news is good                          chart on opposite page).
                                                                       news” and “good news is bad news”.

                             S&P 500 index gains usually associated with rising US bond yields
              3100                                                                                             200

              2900
                                                                                                               150

              2700

                                                                                                               100
              2500
                                                                                                                      Basis points
Index point

              2300                                                                                             50

              2100
                                                                                                               0

              1900
                                                                                                               -50
              1700                              S&P 500 (LHS)
                                                3-month change in 2-year US yields (RHS)
              1500                                                                                             -100
                     2014                2015             2016              2017           2018         2019

                                                                    Year

                     Source: Bloomberg
Market Perspectives Private Clients - Barclays Private Bank
A good news is bad news regime is                                   We need a continuous improvement
                         typically the situation that happens                                in growth data for risk assets to
                         when the growth environment is                                      switch back into the normal “good
                         weak and markets question the                                       news is good news” regime. This is
                         strength of the recovery. Market                                    unlikely in the next month or two but
                         participants would rather see more                                  could happen later in 2019.
                         liquidity injections to ensure growth
                         does not fall further rather than
                         wager on growth recovering by itself.
                                                                                           “We need a continuous
                         Reverting to normal
                         With central banks easing, or                                      improvement in growth
                         indicating that they will do so soon,                              data for risk assets to switch
                         the liquidity part of the equation                                 back into the normal ‘good
                         has been taken care of, at least for
                         the time being. But fixed income                                   news is good news’ regime.”
                         markets have priced in more easing
                         than is likely. This could weigh on
                         risk assets if only a small rebound in
                         growth is seen in the three months
                         to September, as we expect.

                                                S&P 500 reacts positively to negative economic news
                         14%                                                                                                        -35

                         12%
                                                                                                                                    -30
                         10%
S&P 500 year on year %

                          8%                                                                                                        -25

                          6%
                                                                                                                                    -20
                                                                                                                                          Index point

                          4%
                                                                                                                                    -15
                          2%
                                                                                                         worse economic surprise
                          0%                                                                                                        -10
                                                                                                         better economic surprise
                          -2%
                                                  S&P 500 (year on year)
                                                                                                                                    -5
                          -4%                     Citi global economic surprise index (RHS, inverted)

                          -6%                                                                                                       -0
                            Feb-2019            Mar-2019        Apr-2019          May-2019         Jun-2019       Jul-2019

                                                                           Date

                            Source: Bloomberg
                                                                                                                                                        Market Perspectives August 2019 | 5
Market Perspectives Private Clients - Barclays Private Bank
Gerald Moser, Chief Market Strategist – gerald.moser@barclays.com

  A closer look at late-cycle performance
  Risky assets tend to outperform safer ones in a late-cycle environment. As central banks
  ease monetary policy further deep into the cycle, will risky assets outperform this time?

 When we launched our investment                                                       their returns also supports them over                   asset class. Although the upside
 theme “investing in a late cycle” in                                                  government bonds or credit.                             to equity index levels may be more
 April, we briefly described the typical                                                                                                       muted than in past late-cycle
 performance of the main assets                                                        Investment grade is actually the least                  episodes, single-stock selections
 during a late-cycle phase. We now                                                     likely to deliver a positive return, while              and active strategies could provide
 take a closer look at the pattern of                                                  high yield’s past performance is also                   investors with double-digit returns.
 cross-asset performance seen during                                                   lacklustre towards the end of the
 that part of the cycle. We then relate                                                cycle. The median performance of                        With the dovish turn from the US
 those past results to our views in the                                                those two asset classes is negative                     Federal Reserve seen in recent
 context of a late cycle.                                                              using historical data. Within fixed                     months, our conviction towards
                                                                                       income, the clear outperformer is EM                    emerging markets assets remains
Don’t derisk too early                                                                 debt. Not only does it show historical                  relatively strong. This also extends
Performance data since the mid                                                         positive returns, but is almost as                      to the fixed income world. Similar to
1970s shows that risky assets tend                                                     likely to be positive as it is for equities             what has happened previously, we
to outperform safer assets in a                                                        or commodities.                                         believe that EM sovereign debt should
late-cycle environment (see chart).                                                                                                            fare better than DM sovereign bonds.
The median annual performance of                                                      This time is unlikely to be much                         While EM debt looked less attractive
emerging markets (EM) equities and                                                    different: focus on equities and                         when US yields were above 3.2%
commodities is particularly strong,                                                   EM debt                                                  last year, levels of around 2% make a
with developed market (DM) equities                                                   In the current cycle, we prefer equities                 compelling case for the asset class for
also performing well. In addition to                                                  over fixed income. As central banks                      investors looking for yields.
the strong performance of the above                                                   are pushing rates ever lower, we see
asset classes, the consistency of                                                     more relative opportunities in the                       The one area where it may be different
                                                                                                                                               this time around is for commodities.
                                                                                                                                               In a typical late-cycle environment,
                                     Risky assets more likely to deliver positive returns in a late cycle                                      it is the best performing asset as
                                                                                                                                               demand far outstrips supply. But with
                 90
                                                                                                                                               the surge in shale oil output seen this
                 80                                                                                                                            decade, US oil production has been
                                     probability of positive returns in late cycle
                 70                                                                                                                            through a rebirth which limits the
                 60                                                                                                                            potential for upside in energy prices.
Percentage (%)

                 50                                                                                                                            That said, gold is one commodity that
                 40                                                                                                                            could be considered for diversification
                 30
                                                                                                                                               reasons, especially with the cost of
                                                                                                                                               holding it being very low.
                 20
                 10
                  0
                           e

                                                s

                                                               d

                                                                          s

                                                                                       d

                                                                                                        s

                                                                                                                  s

                                                                                                                            es

                                                                                                                                          es
                                              ie

                                                                        er

                                                                                                     nd

                                                                                                                 tie
                        ad

                                                            el

                                                                                        e

                                                                                                                              ti

                                                                                                                                         iti
                                                                                     ht
                                           ur

                                                         yi

                                                                       nk

                                                                                                                 ui

                                                                                                                           ui
                      gr

                                                                                                 bo

                                                                                                                                        od
                                                                                   g
                                           s

                                                         h

                                                                                                             eq

                                                                                                                        eq
                                                                     Li

                                                                                ei
                                        ea
                     t

                                                        g

                                                                                                                                     m
                                                                                                 n
                  en

                                                                                w
                                                     hi

                                                                                             ig
                                      Tr

                                                                                                            EM

                                                                                                                       DM

                                                                                                                                    m
                 m

                                                                            de

                                                                                            re
                                                    US

                                                                                                                                   Co
                                     US
                st

                                                                                            ve
                                                                          tra
              ve

                                                                                        so
            in

                                                                        D

                                                                                      EM
                                                                      US
 US

       Source: Barclays, Refinitiv
Market Perspectives Private Clients - Barclays Private Bank
Julien Lafargue, Head of Equity Strategy – julien.lafargue@barclays.com

Equities at a tipping point?
Equity valuations appear expensive on several measures and suggest caution. However,
is reducing portfolio risk a good idea when central bank policy is so accommodative?

 With US equity markets reaching new                                                            In other words, we believe that              there is no doubt their effect is positive.
 all-time highs in July, many investors                                                         sentiment is more likely to shift            Indeed, should markets become
 consider the current backdrop to be                                                            back and forth between recession             volatile again, we would expect further
“toppy”. We share some of that feeling                                                          fears and goldilocks than it is to stay      intervention from central banks.
 and do not feel compelled to revisit                                                           perfectly still.
 our fair value estimate (S&P 500 index                                                                                                      Second, our cautiousness is echoed
 around 3000 at the end of 2019)                                                                 Be wary of reducing portfolio risk          by many investors who prefer to wait
 just yet. But we also caution against                                                           Our cautiousness on the outlook for         on the sidelines. This idling capital is
 the urge to take too many chips off                                                             equities suggests reducing risk ahead       earning next to zero and represents
 the table.                                                                                      of what looks like another – possibly       a significant drag on performance.
                                                                                                 significant (or more than 10%)              Should market sentiment deteriorate
Our cautiousness is a result of what                                                            – drawdown.                                  temporarily, long-term investors are
we would consider unreasonable                                                                                                               likely to “buy the dip”, supporting
expectations. Indeed, our assessment                                                            However, we see two main reasons             equity prices and preventing a
is that the market is discounting some                                                          why cutting risk aggressively may not        large pullback.
sort of perpetual “goldilocks” scenario                                                         be a good move. First, going against
whereby growth is neither too                                                                   central banks has been a losing              Our message remains unchanged:
good nor too bad and central banks                                                              strategy for years and this is unlikely to   stay invested but ensure portfolios
continue to provide ample liquidity.                                                            change. While the long lasting impact        are exposed to the appropriate level
Although this may happen (it’s                                                                  of quantitative easing and negative          of risk and look for idiosyncratic
arguably been the case for more than                                                            interest rates is questionable, from a       opportunities (rather than market
10 years now), the market’s perception                                                          short-term equity market perspective,        beta).
is likely to change.
                                                                                                                                             Looking ahead
                                                                                                                                             As we look towards the remainder of
                                                                                                                                             2019 and the beginning of 2020, we
                      S&P 500 returns growth driven by multiples gains in 2019                                                               continue to see a backdrop where
                                                                                                                                             both economic and earnings growth
                      25.0%
                                                                                                                                             should allow equities to gain ground.
                                                                                                                                             The main question revolves around
                      20.0%                                                         1.5%                                                     valuations. Multiples, in particular in
                                                                                                                                             the US, have expanded significantly in
Year-to-date change

                                                                                                                                             the last six months and it is difficult
                      15.0%
                                                                                                                                             to argue for further expansion (see
                                                                                                                                             chart). As such, returns are likely to be
                      10.0%                                                        19.5%                                                     more muted, at least at the index level.
                                                                                                      Change in 12 months
                                                                                                      forward earnings
                        5.0%
                                                                                                      Change in 12 months
                                                                                                      forward price-to-earnings ratio

                        0.0%
                                                                                S&P 500 index

                        Sources: DataStream, Barclays Private Bank. July 2019
                                                                                                                                               Market Perspectives August 2019 | 7
Michel Vernier, CFA, Head of Fixed Income Strategy – michel.vernier.barclays.com

Time to be selective in fixed income
As we head deeper into the cycle and with ever higher levels of leverage,
a diversified and selective approach to bond investing is key.

Central bank monetary policy has                             Only once inflation starts to retrace       induced distress include Argentina,
the power to move markets quickly                            from current low levels towards the         Brazil, Greece, US high yield energy, UK
and sharply. So it is little wonder                          Fed’s longer term inflation target of       retail or the Chinese property market.
that investors pay much attention                            2%, will rates trend higher. At least for
to central banks. That said, it is fixed                     now this seems unlikely.                    Default risk
income investors that are at the sharp                                                                   The impact of credit cycles on global
end, being directly affected by policy                       Buy-and-hold bond investors might           growth and capital markets has long
shifts for two reasons.                                      not only focus on central bank “bail        been debated by many; including the
                                                             outs”, yield and spread, but most           renowned economists Hyman Minsky,
First, rate policy, and bond purchasing                      importantly assess how likely they are      Barry Eichengreen or Irving Fisher.
programmes, directly impacts rate-                           to get their capital back along with
sensitive fixed income portfolios and                        any promised coupon payments.               Economic growth, default rates and
determines how much can be earned                                                                        the performance of fixed income
for any new bond investment.                                 Dangers of excessive debt                   assets are all interconnected. Rather
                                                             In a period of macroeconomic                than opening the debate over the
Second, rate policy indicates how                            consolidation, the most decisive factor     credit cycle, we focus on fixed
confident central banks are about                            is usually the level of leverage. Debt is   income investments.
the outlook for the domestic, and                            a supporting factor for the economy
global, economy. The less confident                          as it allocates surplus cash efficiently    Previous stressed periods have proved
policymakers are about the outlook,                          to where it is required to invest in        one point for successful buy-and-hold
the more willing they are to provide                         future growth. Excessive debt, on the       investors: being selective is the key
monetary support to the economy.                             other hand, can lead to inefficiencies      to success. As much as most of the
                                                             and distress in the economy.                distress examples mentioned above
Rush to bonds                                                                                            have led to spill-over effects and
Major central banks are taking a more                                                                    increased volatility in other markets,
dovish tone, with the Federal Reserve                                                                    they did not necessarily trigger a
(Fed) leading the way by cutting rates                      “In a period of macroeconomic                global wave of debt defaults. Even
in its July meeting by 25 bps and                                                                        the 2008 credit crisis did not result
halting its balance sheet reduction                          consolidation, the most                     in major defaults for holders of debt
in August.                                                   decisive factor is usually                  in non-financial investment grade
                                                             the level of leverage.”                     corporate companies.
The move was not as dovish as
markets had priced in, with chairman
Jerome Powell denying that this was
the start of an easing cycle and the                         Not all distress will eventually end up     “Previous stressed periods
front end of the curve selling off                           in a global credit crisis like in 2008.
as a result. The dovish stance and                           However, at a time of contracting            have proved one point for
monetary support from central banks                          growth, too much leverage can spill          successful buy-and-hold
has led to record flows into most                            over and have negative impacts across        investors: being selective
parts of the bond market.                                    sectors and regions. In recent years,
                                                             good examples of excessive debt-             is the key to success.”
According to rating agency Moody’s,         Spotting the investment opportunities   markets bonds historically performed
the default rate for Baa rates issuers      In coming editions of “Market           well in a late cycle, in sync with the
did not surpass 1.5%. during the credit     Perspectives” we will highlight where   commodity cycle and central bank
crisis. To put this into perspective, the   leverage has been built up and to       accommodation. But as always,
default rate of US high yield issuers       what extent it may be a concern for     diversification and selection is key in
stood at 2.9% in May.                       fixed income investors.                 all areas of the bond market.

Leverage on the rise                        Our key calls in the fixed income
Since the substantial contraction           market are longer term rated
seen in 2008, the level of financial        bonds and USD-denominated               “We believe
leverage globally has increased:            emerging markets bonds. While not
the rise of corporate leverage,             without risk, we believe that longer     that longer term BBB
developed and emerging market               term BBB bonds and US dollar-            bonds and US
government leverage, increase in loan       denominated emerging markets             dollar-denominated
market assets and flood of wealth           debt offer a good risk reward in the
management products seen in China           current environment.                     emerging markets
help to demonstrate the point.                                                       debt offer a good
                                            BBB long duration bonds offer            risk reward in the
At times of distress, not every market      significant higher spreads compared
segment should be considered as             to sovereigns. Meanwhile, spreads        current environment.”
excessive or problematic necessarily.       are comparably safer in times of
Bond investors should be conscious of       subdued economic growth compared
this and be selective with investments.     to speculative grade bonds. Emerging

                                                                                      Market Perspectives August 2019 | 9
Damian Payiatakis, Head of Impact Investing – damian.payiatakis@barclays.com

Selecting for alpha in emerging markets debt
Non-financial data can be vital to spotting yield opportunities in emerging
markets corporate debt and improving portfolio performance.

In this late-cycle environment, with                                                  Appreciating downside risks in EMD                                    Investors who use non-financial
investors struggling to generate                                                      Investors in all corporate bonds are                                  information, which is generally
income, as a house we believe that                                                    subject to asymmetrical risk – where                                  split into three categories of
emerging markets debt (EMD) can                                                       downside risks of distress or default                                 environmental, social and
offer attractive yield opportunities.                                                 tend to be larger than the upside                                     governance (ESG) information, can,
That said, selection is key.                                                          produced by returns on committed                                      as we previously explained, better
                                                                                      coupon payments.                                                      understand an organisation’s long-
Generating alpha through security                                                                                                                           term risk and return prospects.
selection can be challenging.                                                         Emerging markets have heightened
But in EMD, where higher levels of                                                    risks given the greater potential                                     Research supports positive impact of
information inefficiency exist more                                                   for political and economic volatility.                                using ESG data
than in many other asset classes,                                                     Flows of capital in and out of this                                   A growing body of academic and
it is tougher still. Investors who                                                    asset class are primarily driven by                                   industry evidence suggests that
incorporate non-financial data                                                        currency movements and often a                                        incorporating ESG considerations
into their decisions can gain an                                                      poor understanding of individual                                      into fixed income portfolios is likely
information advantage to identify                                                     market dynamics.                                                      to improve returns.
the best risk-reward opportunities
in the asset class.                                                                   We believe that effective selection of                                The Quantitative Research team in
                                                                                      EMD securities requires greater insight                               Barclays Investment Bank conducted
Below we outline why and                                                              into individual issuers. Financial data                               innovative research in October
how inclusion of non-financial                                                        from accounting statements provides                                   2016, and expanded it in October
information in the EMD investment                                                     a critical baseline of information. But a                             2018, that concluded accounting
process can improve performance                                                       more holistic, and informed, approach                                 for ESG characteristics can improve
for investors who make the effort.                                                    also includes non-financial information.                              bond performance. The team

                                   Portfolios of high-ESG issuers have outperformed low-ESG portfolios
                                               in the euro and US dollar IG markets (2009-18)

                   USD IG market                                                                                              Euro IG market

           MSCI                                                                                                       MSCI
                                                   43                                                                                                  51
high vs low ESG                                                                                            high vs low ESG

  Sustainalytics                                                                                             Sustainalytics
                                       27                                                                                                         43
high vs low ESG                                                                                            high vs low ESG

                   0             10             20             30             40              50                              0       10        20          30      40   50

                                    Average basis points per year                                                                       Average basis points per year

                   Source: Bloomberg Barclays Bond Indices, MSCI ESG Research, Sustainalytics, Barclays Research
found that investment grade bond                                                                data about governance arrangements,                                                         Acknowledging data challenges
portfolios constructed with an ESG                                                              such as board dynamics, director                                                            Transparency and non-financial
tilt, irrespective of data provider,                                                            effectiveness, or family commitment                                                         data remain more limited in
outperformed the market.                                                                        to the company.                                                                             emerging markets.

Other research1 supports the above                                                              Improving ESG data in                                                                       Specialist ESG data providers cover
findings – that ESG complements                                                                 emerging markets                                                                            a limited portion of the universe.
traditional factors in fixed income                                                             More recently, additional data about                                                        Private companies who dominate
well; and tilts can improve default                                                             social and environmental factors is                                                         much of the issuance do not have the
risk in portfolios.                                                                             helping to manage the associated                                                            same, or sometimes any, reporting
                                                                                                risks and disparities of operating                                                          requirements about their ESG activities.
Notably, most research has focused                                                              in emerging markets. Regulation                                                             Some investors engage directly with
on the relationship of ESG insight                                                              in emerging markets is often less                                                           companies to get this insight – and
and developed markets and                                                                       stringent and social needs are often                                                        encourage greater reporting.
investment grade issuers, where                                                                 higher. This makes controversial
more data is available. However,                                                                behaviour by debt issuers a greater                                                          But transparency is improving. An
it seems reasonable to infer a                                                                  risk, and therefore a likely impact for                                                      increasing number of companies
similar correlation between ESG in                                                              debt holders.                                                                                are self-reporting as they recognise
EMD investing.                                                                                                                                                                               the benefit to potential investors.
                                                                                                Although there are a range of ESG                                                            Since 2010, 15 key emerging market
Start with governance, extend to                                                                risks that could affect an issuer,                                                           countries or exchanges have set
social and environmental factors                                                                the materiality of these depends                                                             out regulations for stewardship
Using non-financial data when                                                                   upon the sector and the industry.                                                            and governance codes2. Having to
assessing fixed income is primarily                                                             Disclosure on ESG will help determine                                                        publish sustainability reports will
a tool to manage downside risks,                                                                the sustainability risks on the                                                              offer investors more insights into the
though innovative approaches are                                                                business model over the long term.                                                           company’s management of these non-
emerging for upside benefits too.                                                                                                                                                            financial practices.
                                                                                                For instance, in the mining sector
While governance has generally                                                                  social issues, such as health and                                                           Value of ESG in security selection
been the main focus, evaluation                                                                 safety practices, employee relations                                                        Given the nuances of investing in
of environmental and social risks                                                               and community engagement, can                                                               emerging markets, incorporating
is increasingly being used in credit                                                            materially affect creditworthiness.                                                         non-financial data into investment
analysis, given the new, valuable,                                                                                                                                                          decision-making can strengthen
insight these factors can provide.                                                              Recent disasters in the mining sector                                                       identification of future risks and
                                                                                                in Brazil also point to the importance                                                      opportunities that could affect an
In emerging markets, issuers                                                                    of environmental issues. For example,                                                       issuers ability to repay debt.
frequently are private companies                                                                the collapse of Vale’s Brumadinho
and have complex and opaque                                                                     dam in January resulted in at least                                                         This is especially critical when
ownership practices. Starting by                                                                60 fatalities, with more than 200                                                           investing late in the cycle. Significant
reviewing governance continues to                                                               people still missing. While only                                                            downturns in markets affect all assets,
be a wise practice to understand                                                                accounting for 2% of the company’s                                                          but generally disproportionately more
the motivations of the issuer. While                                                            output, Moody’s cut their rating to                                                         so for EMD and idiosyncratically
complex structures may appear                                                                   Ba1 (or “junk “rating) from Baa3,                                                           between EMD issuers. Investors
unclear, ultimately the aim is to                                                               and S&P Global Ratings and Fitch                                                            who can look beyond the index, and
confirm that the interests of the                                                               both cut Vale to BBB-, their lowest                                                         effectively select assets, stand to
issuer are aligned with long-term                                                               investment-grade rating. Investors                                                          generate attractive yield opportunities
debt holders. This can be achieved                                                              who missed this risk have been                                                              from this asset class.
with insight from non-financial                                                                 affected accordingly.

1
    From “Sustainable Investing and Bond Returns” in the Journal of Environmental Investing 2017
Fidelity White Paper, July 2018
2
    Corporate governance codes in EM – Brazil (2016), Egypt (2016), Malaysia (2014), Pakistan (2013), Poland (2016), Russia (2014), Taiwan (2010), Thailand (2012), The Philippines (2016), Turkey (2014), UAE (2011)

                                                                                                                                                                                               Market Perspectives August 2019 | 11
Henk Potts, Senior Investment Strategist – henk.potts@barclays.com

Golden moment
After the rally in the gold price this year in a flight to safe-haven assets, what role can the
yellow metal play in investors’ portfolios?

Falling global growth forecasts,                            Investors that are apprehensive about       Leading purchasers include Russia,
ongoing geopolitical tensions and                           the economic outlook primarily gain         Turkey and Kazakhstan. A range of
aggressive policy easing expectations                       exposure to gold through exchange           factors are proffered for the surge in
have investors queuing up to buy gold.                      traded funds (ETFs). Gold ETFs are a        purchases including “dedollarising
                                                            more efficient way to hold gold when        reserves”, reducing counterparty risk
Gold attractions                                            compared to buying bars and coins           and diversifying holdings.
Recent months have seen the rally in                        after the costs of buying, storing
the gold price extend. In May, we saw                       and insuring physical gold is taken
the biggest monthly increase since                          into account. Flows into gold ETFs
2016, pushing the price of gold up                          have climbed this year. According to        “Central bank purchases
to its highest level since April 2013.                      Bloomberg data, three million ounces
Currently trading around the $1400                          were added in the first half of this         [of gold] rose 74% in
an ounce level, gold is up close to                         year, with the total gold held by ETFs      2018 compared to 2017.”
11% year to date. However, this is still                    up 4.2%.
significantly below the $1920 all-time
high achieved in September 2011.                            Central bank gold purchases
                                                            Two decades ago, Gordon Brown,              Lacklustre jewellery demand
The radical pivot in US interest rate                       the then British Chancellor of the          Rising demand from investors has
expectations seen in recent months                          Exchequer, decided to sell just over        helped to overshadow the relatively
has also had a significant impact                           half of Britain’s gold reserves. The        lacklustre demand for gold used
on the price of gold. A lower policy                        controversial move was executed at          in jewellery. Global gold jewellery
path reduces the opportunity cost of                        an average price of $275 an ounce.          demand only rose 1% in the first
holding a zero interest bearing asset.                      It is estimated that the decision           quarter of 2019 on a year-on-
Lower interest rates can also weaken                        cost the taxpayer as much as £5bn,          year (y/y) basis. The slowdown in
the dollar, so reducing the costs for                       although it’s hard to quantify the          growth and rising trade tensions
non-dollar dominated buyers.                                exact loss/gain given we don’t know         held back Chinese buyers. Political
                                                            how the proceeds were invested.             and economic disruption in Europe
                                                                                                        and currency weakness in Turkey
                                                            While the Labour government were            and Iran also cut demand. On the
                                                            cautious about the precious metal’s         positive side, wedding purchases
“In May, we saw the biggest                                 long-term prospects, there are a            and lower prices boosted Indian
monthly increase since                                      wide range of governments that are          demand (+5% y/y) while the US
                                                            still willing to increase their holdings.   only registered minimal growth.
2016, pushing the price                                     World Gold Council figures show
of gold up to its highest                                   central bank purchases rose 74%
level since April 2013.”                                    in 2018 compared to 2017. Central
                                                            banks added 651 tonnes last year,
                                                            which was the most since 1971.
“Global gold jewellery                           Furthermore, demand from the                 Gold is also seen as a hedge against
                                                 dentistry industry, a traditional user       inflation. Data suggests gold hasn’t
 demand only rose 1% in                          of gold, has been in structural decline      done a great job as a store of value
 the first quarter of 2019 on                    over the past decade as the industry         over the past few years. However, over
 a year-on-year (y/y) basis.”                    adopts alternative materials including       longer periods of time, such as the
                                                 all ceramic crowns.                          past century, it has been a useful tool.

                                                 Supply on the up                             Most importantly for us, we think
Industrial needs                                 While jewellery and industrial demand        that gold should be used as a
Industrial demand is subsidiary to               growth has been limited, supply has          diversification tool, as demonstrated
the role of jewellery in determining             steadily been rising. Mine production        through our Discretionary Portfolio
the total demand for gold. With gold             rose to record level last year, driven by    Management asset allocation model.
being a very efficient conductor, not            new projects coming on line and state        For the majority of our clients, the
tarnishing and able to be melted down,           supported expansion. Rising recycling        allocation to gold should be in the low
it is valuable to the electronics industry.      has also boosted the supply of gold,         single-digit percentage range. Clients
                                                 particularly from the distressed             trust us to preserve and grow their
Gold is used in a range of devices               economies of Iran and Turkey.                wealth. Gold can be used to preserve
including smartphones, global                                                                 portfolios during turbulent times, but
positioning systems and televisions.             A diversification tool                       is unlikely to be the source of growth
While the quantities per device are              Investors are attracted to gold for a        over prolonged periods of time.
very small, the aggregated volume                multitude of different reasons. Rightly
used is still worth monitoring. The              or wrongly, gold is seen as a safe-
recent slowdown in hardware sales,               haven asset. There’s no fundamental
due to the slower replacement                    reason why this should be the case,          “For the majority of our clients,
cycle, has held back demand growth.              but if enough people believe it, it starts
                                                 to generate its own truth.                    the allocation to gold should
                                                                                               be in the low single-digit
                                                                                               percentage range.”

Jewellery accounts for almost half gold demand

                                         1%
                           2% 2%
                      6%

                                                    Jewellery
                                                    Other fabrication
 17%
                                                    Investment
                                                    Industrial fabrication
                                                    Official sector
                                                    Electronics
                                                    Other industrial & decorative
                                                    Medals & imitation coins
  9%
                                                    Dental
                                   45%

          3%

                           15%

  Source: Bloomberg

                                                                                               Market Perspectives August 2019 | 13
Gerald Moser, Chief Market Strategist – gerald.moser@barclays.com

Multi-asset portfolio allocation
Barclays Private Bank discusses asset allocation views within the context of a multi-asset
class portfolio. Our views elsewhere in the publication are absolute and within the context
of each asset class.

Cash and short duration bonds:                                lower inflation expectations and         maintain low conviction to the asset
neutral                                                       dovish monetary policies. Given          class as margin pressure typically
• Our preference for higher quality,                          this backdrop, we anticipate the         increases late in the economic cycle.
  liquid opportunities translates into                        asset class to predominantly be
  our positioning in short duration                           a diversifier rather than a major      • Following the recent rally in riskier
  bonds, which offer an attractive                            source of returns.                       assets, high yield bonds look
  risk-return trade-off in the context                                                                 expensive. Spreads are tight by
  of an inverted yield curve.                              • Although US dollar real rates             historical standards, which we do
                                                             remain at historical low levels, they     not view as attractive in the context
• Nonetheless, we maintain a neutral                         are still too attractive to ignore        of the credit and liquidity risk taken
  exposure to the asset class as real                        relative to the other developed           and the returns available from other
  interest rates remain negative in                          bond markets. UK and European             asset classes.
  most jurisdictions.                                        bond markets failed to synchronise
                                                             with US rates due to their own          Emerging markets bonds: neutral
Fixed Income: neutral                                        geopolitical challenges, and
We see moderate risk-return                                  depressed yields make it difficult      • The Fed’s dovish stance and
opportunities in fixed income given                          to find these markets attractive.         stronger local currencies should
the recent spread tightening and late                                                                  continue to provide some relief
cycle dynamics. Sovereign rates are                        Investment grade bonds: neutral             to the largely dollar-denominated
less attractive in the context of a low                                                                emerging markets (EM) debt.
yield environment and that we see the                      • A still benign macro outlook and
higher-quality segment of corporate                          easing interest rates should be         • Although choppy energy prices
credits as a better alternative, given                       broadly positive for investment           and unresolved trade disputes
their relative safety and better returns.                    grade bonds. Nevertheless, we             provide a headwind to emerging
                                                             remain neutral on the asset class         markets bonds, credit quality hasn’t
We remain cautious on the riskier                            amid mounting concerns over the           deteriorated and the economic
parts of corporate debt as they don’t                        rising pile of corporate debt.            momentum backdrop remains
entirely compensate investors for the                                                                  reasonably positive.
level of risk taken at a time when credit                  • Although spreads have tightened
events may be on the rise. Emerging                          significantly since the beginning       • Spreads have tightened since
markets bonds remain our favourite                           of this year, we believe investment       the beginning of the year as
bet to enhance returns at this stage in                      grade bonds will continue to earn         investor flows reverted back
the cycle due to their yield pick-up.                        some carry and thus outperform            into EM bonds amid improving
                                                             low yielding government bonds,            sentiment. However, spreads remain
Developed government bonds:                                  specifically in Europe.                   comparatively wide versus high
neutral                                                                                                yield bonds and offer a better risk-
                                                           High yield bonds: low conviction            return profile. We favour US dollar
• Developed government bonds                                                                           emerging markets hard-currency
  worldwide have been losing their                         • While default rates are at                bonds due to their relatively
  appeal as rates edged down amid                            historical low levels and corporate       attractive valuations.
  softening economic growth,                                 fundamentals remain robust, we
Equities: positive                         • We favour active management and           Commodities: neutral
Positioning in high-quality,                 selective stock picking of companies      • The sole exposure within
growth companies through active              with strong balance sheets,                 commodities continues to be our
management is our preference given           although we are agnostic on the             position in gold which we view as
our view that in late cycle, alpha           geographical allocation of our equity       complementary to the other risk
(actively selecting superior businesses)     positions. We focus on businesses           mitigating assets in the portfolio,
out-performs beta (passively following       with high cash returns on capital,          especially in light of the low interest
the market). Although we see more            with conservative capital structures        rate environment and global
compelling opportunities in developed        and ideally an ability to reinvest cash     trade fears.
market equities, the recent repricing        in future growth at equally high
in emerging markets equities resulting       rates of return. The US tends to offer    • We find little attraction in this asset
from trade tensions provides what            us more opportunities to invest in          class outside of precious metals
we believe is a short-to-medium term         these kind of businesses meaning            and find our risk budget better
entry point.                                 that North America remains the              deployed elsewhere.
                                             largest geographical weighting
However, not all emerging markets are        within the equity allocation.             Real estate: neutral
created equal, with Asia appearing to
provide stable (albeit lower) growth       Emerging markets equities: neutral          • Real estate should continue
than Latin America. That said, our view                                                  to provide mild diversification
on emerging markets may change in          • While markets have grown                    benefits. We anticipate loose
the longer run should emerging market        increasingly cautious following             monetary policies to favourably
equity appreciate excessively. It is for     heightened protectionism fears,             impact returns, although weaker
these reasons we have high conviction        emerging markets equities should            economic growth could prove to be
in developed market equities and             benefit from attractive valuations          a headwind.
remain neutral on emerging markets           and steady economic activity out
equities depending on the time horizon       of the region, which will continue        Alternative trading strategies:
and risk budgeting of the portfolio as       to underpin expansionary, albeit          low conviction
a whole.                                     softening, growth.
                                                                                       • We maintain a low conviction
Developed market equities:                 • We expect fiscal and monetary               in alternatives due to their high
high conviction                              easing in China to counteract               expense and a lack of investment
                                             a slowdown in the region and                opportunities in this space. The
• Earnings growth is still expansionary,     limit downside risk to earnings             limited use of leverage should
  albeit slowing, with growth forecast       expectations. Trade tensions still          further cap returns for the
  to be low-to-mid single digits over        pose a significant risk but will likely     asset class.
  the year. Healthy fundamentals             dissipate as economic pragmatism
  continue to underpin the investment        should eventually prevail.                • Nonetheless, sudden spikes
  case for this asset class, while                                                       in volatility, which are likely to
  valuations are not excessively           Other assets: neutral                         materialise more often in a late-
  stretched compared to history.           Alternative asset classes will continue       cycle environment, may lift the
                                           to provide diversification to our             asset class at least in the short term.
• Increasingly accommodative central       portfolio, but are not expected to
  banks and fairly constructive macro      be main drivers of returns. Gold is
  data from both sides of the Atlantic     set to benefit from its status as a
  should support recovery globally.        safe haven in the late cycle, while
  This backdrop should lift the asset      real estate and alternative trading
  class further, even though downside      strategies are underpinned by a weak
  risks from trade tensions remain in      investment case.
  the background.

                                                                                       Market Perspectives August 2019 | 15
Investments can fall as well as rise in value. Your capital or the income generated from your investment may be at risk.
This communication is for Barclays Private Bank customers only. This document has been issued by the Investments division at Barclays Private Banking and Overseas Services (“PBOS”)
division and is not a product of the Barclays Research department. Any views expressed may differ from those of Barclays Research. All opinions and estimates included in this document
constitute our judgment as of the date of the document and may be subject to change without notice. No representation is made as to the accuracy of the assumptions made within,
or completeness of, any modeling, scenario analysis or back-testing. Barclays is not responsible for information stated to be obtained or derived from third party sources or statistical
services, and we do not guarantee the information’s accuracy which may be incomplete or condensed.
This document has been prepared for information purposes only and does not constitute a prospectus, an offer, invitation or solicitation to buy or sell securities and is not intended to
provide the sole basis for any evaluation of the securities or any other instrument, which may be discussed in it. Any offer or entry into any transaction requires Barclays’ subsequent
formal agreement which will be subject to internal approvals and execution of binding transaction documents. Any past or simulated past performance including back-testing, modeling
or scenario analysis contained herein does not predict and is no indication as to future performance. The value of any investment may also fluctuate as a result of market changes.
Neither Barclays, its affiliates nor any of its directors, officers, employees, representatives or agents, accepts any liability whatsoever for any direct, indirect or consequential losses (in
contract, tort or otherwise) arising from the use of this communication or its contents or reliance on the information contained herein, except to the extent this would be prohibited by
law or regulation. This document and the information contained herein may only be distributed and published in jurisdictions in which such distribution and publication is permitted.
You may not distribute this document, in whole or part, without our prior, express written permission. Law or regulation in certain countries may restrict the manner of distribution of
this document and persons who come into possession of this document are required to inform themselves of and observe such restrictions.
The contents herein do not constitute investment, legal, tax, accounting or other advice. You should consider your own financial situation, objectives and needs, and conduct your own
independent investigation and assessment of the contents of this document, including obtaining investment, legal, tax, accounting and such other advice as you consider necessary
or appropriate, before making any investment or other decision... THIS COMMUNICATION IS PROVIDED FOR INFORMATION PURPOSES ONLY AND IT IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE. IT IS
INDICATIVE ONLY AND IS NOT BINDING.
Barclays offers private and overseas banking, credit and investment solutions to its clients through Barclays Bank PLC and its subsidiary companies. Barclays Bank PLC is authorised by
the Prudential Regulation Authority and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority and the Prudential Regulation Authority (Financial Services Register No.122702) and is a member
of the London Stock Exchange and NEX. Registered in England. Registered No. 1026167. Registered Office: 1 Churchill Place, London E14 5HP.
Barclays Bank Ireland PLC, trading as Barclays Private Bank, is regulated by the Central Bank of Ireland. Registered in Ireland. Registered Office: One Molesworth Street, Dublin 2, Ireland,
D02 RF29. Registered Number: 396330. VAT Number: IE4524196D. Calls are recorded in line with our legal and regulatory obligations, and for quality and monitoring purposes.
Barclays Bank PLC Monaco is licensed to operate its activities in Monaco and falls under the dual supervision of the Monegasque regulator ‘Commission de Contrôle des Activités
Financières’ (with regards to investment services) and the French regulator ‘Autorité de Contrôle Prudentiel et de Résolution’ (in respect of banking services). The registered office of
Barclays Bank PLC Monaco is located at 31 avenue de La Costa, MC98000 Monaco – Tel. +377 93 153535. Barclays Bank PLC Monaco is also registered with the Monaco Trade and
Industry Registry under No. 68 S 01191. VAT N° FR40 00002674 9.
Barclays Bank PLC Monaco is a branch of Barclays Bank PLC which is registered in England under No. 1026167, authorised by the Prudential Regulation Authority and regulated by the
Financial Conduct Authority and the Prudential Regulation Authority. The registered offices of Barclays Bank PLC are located at 1 Churchill Place, London E14 5HP.
Barclays Private Asset Management (Monaco) SAM – 31 Avenue de la Costa, B.P. 4 – MC 98001 Monaco Cedex is registered in Monaco. Tel. +377 93 10 51 51. S.S.E.E. N° 671C06692 –
R.C.I. N° 94 S 03039 – Registered VAT No° FR 00 00003617 7.
Barclays Bank (Suisse) SA is a Bank registered in Switzerland and regulated and supervised by FINMA. Registered No. CH-660.0.118.986-6. Registered Office: Chemin de Grange-Canal
18-20, P.O. Box 3941, 1211 Geneva 3, Switzerland. Registered branch: Beethovenstrasse 19, P.O. Box, 8027 Zurich. Registered VAT No. CHE-106.002.386. Barclays Bank (Suisse) SA is a
subsidiary of Barclays Bank PLC registered in England, authorised by the Prudential Regulation Authority and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority and the Prudential Regulation
Authority. It is registered under No. 1026167 and its registered office is 1 Churchill Place, London E14 5HP.
Barclays Bank PLC (DIFC Branch) (Registered No. 0060) is regulated by the Dubai Financial Services Authority. Barclays Bank PLC (DIFC Branch) may only undertake the financial services
activities that fall within the scope of its existing DFSA licence. Principal place of business: Private Bank, Dubai International Financial Centre, The Gate Village Building No. 10, Level
6, PO Box 506674, Dubai, UAE. This information has been distributed by Barclays Bank PLC (DIFC Branch). Certain products and services are only available to Professional Clients as
defined by the DFSA.
Asset classes, asset allocations, tactical asset allocation views, product classes and/or strategies may be available in other jurisdictions but may not be accessible to investors in India.
Barclays offers wealth and investment products and services to its clients through Barclays Bank PLC registered in England and operates in India through its subsidiaries, Barclays
Securities (India) Private Limited (BSIPL), Barclays Wealth Trustees (India) Private Limited (BWTIPL) and Barclays Investments & Loans (India) Private Limited (BILIPL). BSIPL is a
company incorporated under the Companies Act, 1956 having CIN U67120MH2006PTC161063. BSIPL is registered and regulated by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI)
as a Portfolio Manager INP000002585, Investment Adviser INA000000391, Research Analyst INH000001519, Broker : NSE Capital Market INB231292732, NSE Futures & Options
INF231292732, NSE Currency derivatives INE231450334, BSE Capital Market INB011292738, BSE Futures & Options INF011292738, Depository Participant with the National Securities
Depository Limited (NSDL) IN-DP-NSDL-299-2008. BSIPL is also registered as a Mutual Fund Advisor having AMFI ARN No. 53308. The registered office of BSIPL is at 208, Ceejay
House, Shivsagar Estate, Dr. A. Besant Road, Worli, Mumbai – 400 018, India. Telephone No: +91 22 67196363. Fax number: +91 22 67196399 Compliance Officer contact details: Name:
Mr. Anupam Mohaney, Contact number: +91 22 61754000, E-mail: bsiplcompliance@barcap.com Investor Grievance E-mail: BSIPL.concerns@barcap.com Website: www.barclays.in/
bsipl. BWTIPL is a company incorporated under the Companies Act, 1956 having CIN U93000MH2008PTC188438. BWTIPL is a licensed corporate agent having License No CA0078
under IRDAI for (i) HDFC Standard Life Insurance Company Limited and (ii) ICICI Lombard General Insurance Company Limited. The registered office of BWTIPL is at 208, Ceejay House,
Shivsagar Estate, Dr. A. Beasant Road, Worli, Mumbai – 400 018, India. Telephone No: +91 22 67196363. Fax number: +91 22 6719639. Email Address for corporate agency (insurance)
matters: xrawealthindiainsura@barclayscapital.com, Email Address for other matters: wealthindiatrust@barclaysasia.com, Grievance: BWTIPL.concerns@barclays.com, Website: www.
barclays.in/BWTIPL. Grievance Officer contact details: Name: Ms. Poonam Mirchandani, Contact number: +91 022 6719 6359. BILIPL is a company incorporated under the Companies
Act, 1913 having CIN U93090MH1937FTC291521. BILIPL is registered and regulated by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) as a Non Banking Finance Company (NBFC): Registration no.B-
13.02176. The registered office of BILIPL is at. Nirlon Knowledge Park, Level 10, Block B-6, Off Western Express Highway, Goregaon (East), Mumbai – 400063, India. Telephone No: +91 22
61754000. Fax number: +91 22 61754099. Grievance Redressal Officer contact details: Name: Mr. Ruzbeh Sutaria, Contact number: +91 22 61754244, Grievance E-mail: bililcompliance@
barclayscapital.com. Website: www.barclays.in/BILIL

privatebank.barclays.com

IBIM9298_PB_India
Go further,
Reach higher,
See beyond.

                Market Perspectives July 2019 | 19
You can also read