Sample pages South Africa Power Report 2020/21 - www.africa-energy.com

 
CONTINUE READING
Sample pages South Africa Power Report 2020/21 - www.africa-energy.com
Sample pages
South Africa Power Report – 2020/21

www.africa-energy.com
Sample pages South Africa Power Report 2020/21 - www.africa-energy.com
About African Energy Reports

                                                                                    About African Energy Reports
                                                                                    South Africa Power Report 2020/21 is the
                                                                                    fourth in a series of easy to digest studies on key
                                                                                    energy industry segments presented by African
                                                                                    Energy’s consultancy group.

                                                                                    The reports are intended to provide executives,
    South Africa Power Report – 2020/21                                             financiers, investors, policy-makers and other
    Published April 2020                                                            stakeholders with a concise but authoritative
                                                                                    document that provides an overview of a

    Reports Editor
                                                                                    country’s politics and risk profile, and of the major
                                                                                    macroeconomic and business trends that impact
    David Slater
    david@africa-energy.com                                                         on projects. The reports provide data to illustrate,

    Contributors
                                                                                    and analysis to aid, understanding of critical
    Ajay Ubhi                                                                       questions for the energy industry.
    Daniel Westbury-Haines

    Live Data Editor
                                                                                    About African Energy
    Dan Marks                                                                       African    Energy        is   a   UK-based     market
    dan@africa-energy.com                                                           intelligence provider that has been helping
    Editorial Director                                                              businesses navigate the challenges of the African
    Jon Marks                                                                       continent’s complex industries for over two
    jon@africa-energy.com

    Sales and Service
                                                                                    decades.

                                                                                    Managed        and       owned    by      Cross-border
    Direct:+44 (0) 1424 721 667                                                     Information, African Energy has 16 full-time staff
    Fax: +44 (0) 1424 721 721
    Email: sales@africa-energy.com                                                  in the UK, and a network of correspondents and
                                                                                    associates active in over 40 African countries.

    www.africa-energy.com                                                           African Energy’s services include:

                                                                                    • Newsletter         –   A    respected    source   of
                                                                                    independent analysis since 1998, covering
                                                                                    emerging energy trends and the political and
                                                                                    governance issues that concern established
                                                                                    operators, new entrants and the finance sector.

                                                                                    • Live Data – Live-updated online data platform
                                                                                    featuring more than 6,500 power plants in Africa.
    2020 Cross-border Information. All rights reserved.
    Data and information published in African Energy is provided to Cross-          • Consultancy – Bespoke consultancy and
    border Information (CbI) by its staff and network of correspondents
    through extensive surveys of sources and published with the intention of        advisory services ranging from market entry
    being accurate. CbI cannot insure against or be held responsible for
    inaccuracies and assumes no liability for any loss whatsoever arising           studies for developers and financiers to large
    from use of such data.
    No portion of this publication may be photocopied, reproduced,
                                                                                    public sector-tendered monitoring and evaluation
    retransmitted, put into a computer system or otherwise redistributed
    without prior authorisation from Cross-border Information.
                                                                                    studies.
    Registered office: 4 Bank Buildings, Station Road,
    Hastings, East Sussex TN34 1NG, United Kingdom.                                 • Reports – Instant access to essential market
    Directors: JJ Marks, JM Ford, JD Hamilton, NJ Carn, E                           intelligence on Africa’s power, renewables, oil and
    Gillespie
                                                                                    gas sectors.

2                                                                              AFRICAN ENERGY • SOUTH AFRICA POWER REPORT • 2020/21
Sample pages South Africa Power Report 2020/21 - www.africa-energy.com
Contents

TABLE OF CONTENTS

1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY.......................................................................................13

COUNTRY SNAPSHOT ............................................................................................18

2. RISK MANAGEMENT REPORT...........................................................................19

3. POLITICAL OVERVIEW........................................................................................22
3.1 Structure of government ...............................................................................................................22
3.1.1 Political system............................................................................................................................22
3.1.2 Three tiers of government ...........................................................................................................22
3.1.3 Executive authority ......................................................................................................................23
3.1.4 Legislative authority.....................................................................................................................23
Box 1: Cyril Ramaphosa: a multi-faceted career ...............................................................................24
3.1.5 An independent judiciary under heavy stress .............................................................................25
3.2 Stability of political system ...........................................................................................................25
3.2.1 A social contract under pressure.................................................................................................26
3.2.2 Divisions within the African National Congress...........................................................................26
3.2.3 ‘State capture’ and other governance concerns.........................................................................27
3.3 The main political parties ..............................................................................................................27
3.3.1 Governing party: the African National Congress.........................................................................27
Box 2: Profiles of leading ANC actors ................................................................................................28
3.3.1.i Factional divisions .....................................................................................................................29
3.3.2 The official opposition party: Democratic Alliance ......................................................................29
Box 3: Profiles of leading Democratic Alliance figures......................................................................29
3.3.2.i Democratic Alliance splits: Good ..............................................................................................30
3.3.3 Radical opposition: Economic Freedom Fighters .......................................................................30
Box 4: Julius ‘Juju’ Malema and the EFF ...........................................................................................31
3.4 Elections ........................................................................................................................................31
3.4.1 Electoral system ..........................................................................................................................31
3.4.2 Most recent election....................................................................................................................31
3.4.3 Voter disenchantment..................................................................................................................33
3.4.4 Next elections..............................................................................................................................33
3.5 Corruption......................................................................................................................................33
3.5.1 Resistance to change..................................................................................................................34
3.5.2 Foreign courts and ‘state capture ...............................................................................................34
3.5.3 Transparency International rating ................................................................................................34
3.6 Security risk ...................................................................................................................................35

AFRICAN ENERGY • SOUTH AFRICA POWER REPORT • 2020/21                                                                                                   3
Sample pages South Africa Power Report 2020/21 - www.africa-energy.com
Contents

3.6.1 Personal security and criminality.................................................................................................35
3.6.2 Risks of political violence ............................................................................................................35
3.6.3 Risk of terrorism ..........................................................................................................................36
3.6.4 Risk of ethnic/tribal conflict.........................................................................................................36
3.7 Political economy and major policy initiatives.............................................................................36
3.7.1 Downgrades and gridlock in the political system........................................................................37
3.7.2 Economic policy ..........................................................................................................................38
3.7.3 National Development Plan 2013-30...........................................................................................38
3.7.4 Economic stimulus, recovery plans and social uplift ..................................................................39
3.8 Eskom and the ESI crisis ..............................................................................................................40
3.8.1 The politics of private energy investment....................................................................................41
Box 5: Minister of mineral resources and energy Gwede Mantashe ................................................42
Box 6: The 2019 Integrated Resource Plan........................................................................................43
3.8.2 Climate change............................................................................................................................43

4. MACROECONOMICS ..........................................................................................45
4.1 Overview ........................................................................................................................................45
4.1.1 Reform and missed targets .........................................................................................................46
4.1.2 A very difficult outlook .................................................................................................................47
4.2 Economic structure and stunted growth......................................................................................47
4.2.1 Trends/projections .......................................................................................................................47
4.1.2 Breakdown of economy by sector ..............................................................................................48
4.3 Inflation and the central bank .......................................................................................................48
4.4 Fiscal deficit and debt: rising fast under SOE burden.................................................................49
4.4.1 State-owned enterprises .............................................................................................................50
– Eskom................................................................................................................................................50
– South African Airways .......................................................................................................................50
– Denel..................................................................................................................................................50
4.4.2 The 2020 budget .........................................................................................................................51
4.4.3 Risk of debt distress....................................................................................................................51
– Debt-to-GDP......................................................................................................................................52
– Debt service-to-revenue ....................................................................................................................52
4.4.4 Major creditors and future borrowing ..........................................................................................52
4.4.5 Potential IMF deal........................................................................................................................53
4.5 Balance of payments.....................................................................................................................53
4.6 Foreign reserves and the rand ......................................................................................................53
4.7 Credit ratings .................................................................................................................................54

4                                                                       AFRICAN ENERGY • SOUTH AFRICA POWER REPORT • 2020/21
Sample pages South Africa Power Report 2020/21 - www.africa-energy.com
Contents

4.8 Key lending rates...........................................................................................................................55
4.9 WBG Ease of Doing Business.......................................................................................................55
4.10 Major recent developments ........................................................................................................56

MAP: SOUTH AFRICA’S ELECTRICITY INFRASTRUCTURE................................57

5. POWER SECTOR OVERVIEW .............................................................................60
5.1 Overview ........................................................................................................................................60
5.2 Market structure ............................................................................................................................60
5.2.1 Future developments...................................................................................................................61
5.3 Profiles of institutions....................................................................................................................61
5.3.1 Utilities.........................................................................................................................................61
– Eskom Holdings.................................................................................................................................61
5.3.2 Regulators ...................................................................................................................................62
– National Energy Regulator of South Africa ........................................................................................62
5.2.3 Ministries .....................................................................................................................................62
– Department of Mineral Resources and Energy..................................................................................62
– Department of Public Enterprises......................................................................................................62
– National Treasury ...............................................................................................................................62
– IPP Office...........................................................................................................................................63
5.4 Market operation ...........................................................................................................................63
5.5 Sector history ................................................................................................................................63
5.5.1 Ownership and organisation history............................................................................................63
5.5.2 Role of independent power producers........................................................................................66
5.6 Regional electricity trade ..............................................................................................................66
5.7 Financial challenges ......................................................................................................................67
5.8 Main consumers of electricity.......................................................................................................68

6. POWER SECTOR POLICY AND REGULATION..................................................69
6.1 Overview ........................................................................................................................................69
6.2 Major legislation ............................................................................................................................69
– National Energy Act, 2008 .................................................................................................................69
– National Energy Regulator Act, 2004 ................................................................................................70
– Electricity Regulation Act, 2006.........................................................................................................70
– Nuclear Energy Act, 1999 ..................................................................................................................70
– Grid Code ..........................................................................................................................................70
– National Environmental Management Act, 1998 ...............................................................................70
– Public Finance Management Act, 1999.............................................................................................70

AFRICAN ENERGY • SOUTH AFRICA POWER REPORT • 2020/21                                                                                                     5
Sample pages South Africa Power Report 2020/21 - www.africa-energy.com
Contents

– Draft Public Procurement Act, 2020 ..................................................................................................70
– Carbon Tax, 2019 ..............................................................................................................................70
– Independent Market Operator Bill, 2019 ...........................................................................................71
6.3 Sector plans and policies..............................................................................................................71
– White Paper on Energy Policy, 1998 .................................................................................................71
– Renewable Energy Policy White Paper, 2003....................................................................................71
– Integrated Energy Plan, 2016 ............................................................................................................71
– Integrated Resouce Plan, 2019 .........................................................................................................72
– Gas Utilisation Master Plan ...............................................................................................................74
– Eskom Transmission Plan, 2020-2029 ..............................................................................................74
– Roadmap for Eskom in a Reformed Electricity Supply Industry .......................................................74
Box 7: Key aspects of the Eskom Roadmap......................................................................................77
6.4 Legal requirements........................................................................................................................78
6.4.1 Generation ...................................................................................................................................78
6.4.2 Transmission................................................................................................................................79
6.4.3 Distribution ..................................................................................................................................79
6.4.5 Economic empowerment ............................................................................................................79
6.5 Procurement ..................................................................................................................................80
6.5.1 Competitive bidding ....................................................................................................................80
– Renewable Energy Independent Power Producer Procurement (REIPPP) programme ....................80
– Small Projects Independent Power Producer Procurement (SPIPPP) programme...........................82
– Coal Baseload IPP procurement programme....................................................................................82
– Battery energy storage systems ........................................................................................................83
– LNG-to-power IPP procurement programme....................................................................................83
– Risk Mitigation Power Purchase Programme ....................................................................................84
6.5.2 Municipality procurement ............................................................................................................85
6.6 Tariffs..............................................................................................................................................85
6.6.1 Regulatory clearing account........................................................................................................85
6.6.2 Wholesale ....................................................................................................................................86
6.6.3 Retail............................................................................................................................................86
6.6.4 Differences between Nersa and Eskom tariffs ............................................................................86
6.7 Currency risk..................................................................................................................................86
6.8 Major adverse incidents affecting IPPs........................................................................................86
– Eskom refusing to approve REIPPP projects ....................................................................................86
– Budget quote and transmission delays for REIPPPs ........................................................................87
– Sacking of Karén Breytenbach ..........................................................................................................87

6                                                                       AFRICAN ENERGY • SOUTH AFRICA POWER REPORT • 2020/21
Sample pages South Africa Power Report 2020/21 - www.africa-energy.com
Contents

6.9 Guarantees and mounting government liabilities ........................................................................88
Box 8: Eskom – a failing giant.............................................................................................................89

7. FROM THE NEWSLETTER ..................................................................................90

8. RESOURCE AVAILABILITY .................................................................................91
8.1 Overview ........................................................................................................................................91
8.2 Hydrocarbons market....................................................................................................................91
8.2.1 Overview......................................................................................................................................91
8.2.2 Key agencies ...............................................................................................................................91
– PetroSA..............................................................................................................................................91
– Petroleum Agency of South Africa ....................................................................................................91
– iGas....................................................................................................................................................92
– Transnet .............................................................................................................................................92
8.2.3 Legislation ...................................................................................................................................92
– The draft Upstream Petroleum Resources Development Bill ............................................................92
8.2.4 Licensing .....................................................................................................................................93
8.3 Coal ................................................................................................................................................93
8.4 Crude oil.........................................................................................................................................94
8.5 Natural gas.....................................................................................................................................94
8.6 Liquified natural gas ......................................................................................................................94
8.7 Geothermal ....................................................................................................................................95
8.8 Solar ...............................................................................................................................................95
8.9 Wind ...............................................................................................................................................95
8.10 Hydroelectricity ...........................................................................................................................96
8.11 Shale gas .....................................................................................................................................96
8.12 Regional gas ................................................................................................................................96
8.12.1 SADC master plan .....................................................................................................................97
8.12.2 Mozambique: from ‘modest producer’ to global player ............................................................97
– Export LNG projects ..........................................................................................................................97
– Potential pipeline projects .................................................................................................................98
8.12.3 Sasol’s Mozambique play and gas transition strategy ..............................................................98
8.12.4 Potentials for indigenous gas production coupled with LNG imports ......................................99
– Other sources of gas .......................................................................................................................100

MAP: SOUTH AFRICA’S OIL AND GAS INFRASTRUCTURE ..............................101

9. COMPETITIVE LANDSCAPE .............................................................................102
9.1 Overview ......................................................................................................................................102

AFRICAN ENERGY • SOUTH AFRICA POWER REPORT • 2020/21                                                                                                       7
Contents

9.2 Landmark power projects ...........................................................................................................102
– Largest power plant: Medupi Coal ..................................................................................................102
– Kusile Coal.......................................................................................................................................103
– Largest nuclear: Koeberg Nuclear ...................................................................................................103
– First IPP: Rand Central Electric Works Coal....................................................................................104
– Largest operating IPP: Avon Diesel .................................................................................................105
– First REIPPP: Kalkbuit Solar ............................................................................................................105
– Largest state-owned project: Kendal Coal ......................................................................................105
9.3 First renewable IPP procurement round: REIPPP round 1........................................................106
9.4 Under construction generation projects ....................................................................................106
– Aggeneys Solar PV ..........................................................................................................................106
– Bokamoso Solar PV.........................................................................................................................107
– Copperton Wind ..............................................................................................................................107
– Droogfontein Solar PV II ..................................................................................................................108
– Dyason’s Klip Solar PV I ..................................................................................................................108
– Dyason’s Klip Solar PV II .................................................................................................................108
– Garob Wind......................................................................................................................................109
– Greefspan Solar PV II ......................................................................................................................109
– Kangnas Wind .................................................................................................................................110
– Karusa Wind ....................................................................................................................................110
– Konkoonsies Solar PV II ..................................................................................................................111
– Ngodwana Mill Lignin Expansion ....................................................................................................111
– Nxuba Wind .....................................................................................................................................112
– Oyster Bay Wind..............................................................................................................................112
– Perdekraal East Wind ......................................................................................................................113
– Roggeveld Wind ..............................................................................................................................113
– Sirius Project One Solar PV .............................................................................................................114
– Soetwater Wind ...............................................................................................................................114
– Waterloo Solar PV............................................................................................................................115
9.5 Selected key developers.............................................................................................................115
– Actis.................................................................................................................................................115
– Biotherm Energy ..............................................................................................................................115
– Acwa Power.....................................................................................................................................115
– Juwi Renewable Energies................................................................................................................116
– Mulilo Renewable Energy ................................................................................................................116
– Sasol ................................................................................................................................................116

8                                                                       AFRICAN ENERGY • SOUTH AFRICA POWER REPORT • 2020/21
Contents

– SolarReserve South Africa...............................................................................................................116
9.6 Selected key financiers ...............................................................................................................116
– Absa Bank Ltd .................................................................................................................................116
– Nedbank and Nedbank New Energy Finance..................................................................................116
– Phakwe Group .................................................................................................................................116
– Old Mutual Investment Group South Africa Ltd ..............................................................................116

10. TRANSMISSION AND DISTRIBUTION ...........................................................117
10.1 Overview ....................................................................................................................................117
10.2 T&D losses .................................................................................................................................118
10.3 Critical issues facing the network.............................................................................................118
10.4 Sector reforms ...........................................................................................................................118
10.5 Planned grid improvements ......................................................................................................118
10.5.1 Strategic Grid Plan 2040 .........................................................................................................118
10.5.2 Transmission Development Plan (2020-2029) .........................................................................119
10.6 Regional trade ...........................................................................................................................120
10.6.1 Southern African Power Pool ..................................................................................................120
– Bilateral contracts............................................................................................................................121
– Competitive market .........................................................................................................................121
10.6.2 Existing interconnections ........................................................................................................123
10.6.3 Planned interconnections........................................................................................................123
– Botswana-South Africa (BoSa) ........................................................................................................123
– Mozambique-Zimbabwe–South Africa (MoZiSa).............................................................................123
10.7 Electricity imports/exports........................................................................................................124
10.7.1 Imports ....................................................................................................................................124
10.7.2 Exports ....................................................................................................................................124

11. OFF-GRID .........................................................................................................125
11.1 Overview ....................................................................................................................................125
11.2 Off-grid legislation and strategies ............................................................................................125
10.2.1 Integrated National Electrification Programme .......................................................................125
10.2.2 New Household Electrification Strategy..................................................................................126
11.3 Electrification and access rates................................................................................................126
– National............................................................................................................................................126
– Urban ...............................................................................................................................................126
– Rural ................................................................................................................................................126
11.4 Initiatives and programmes.......................................................................................................126
11.4.1 Off-grid Solar Home System Programme South Africa...........................................................126

AFRICAN ENERGY • SOUTH AFRICA POWER REPORT • 2020/21                                                                                                      9
Contents

11.5 Off-grid regulation .....................................................................................................................127
11.5.1 Electricity Regulation Act of 2006 ...........................................................................................127
11.5.2 Solar Home Systems...............................................................................................................127
11.6 Selected off-grid players...........................................................................................................127
11.6 Embedded generation...............................................................................................................128
11.6.1 Mines .......................................................................................................................................128

12. DEMAND AND SUPPLY OUTLOOK................................................................129
12.1 Overview ....................................................................................................................................129
12.2 Demand......................................................................................................................................130
12.2.1 Projections...............................................................................................................................130
12.2.2 Factors influencing growth ......................................................................................................130
12.3 Generation .................................................................................................................................130
12.3.1 Government projections ..........................................................................................................131
– Medium-term system adequacy (2019-2024) .................................................................................131
– Integrated Resource Plan 2019 (2019-2030)...................................................................................132
12.3.2 African Energy pipeline 2020-2024 .........................................................................................133
12.4 Demand and supply outlook, 2020-2030 .................................................................................134
12.5 The cost of cleaner coal............................................................................................................135

13. DATA TABLES...................................................................................................137
– Methodology....................................................................................................................................137
– Installed capacity, RE vs non-RE, 2010-2024 (MW & %) ................................................................137
– Installed capacity by fuel type, 2010-2024 (MW) ............................................................................138
– Installed capacity by fuel type, 2010-2024 (%) ...............................................................................138
– Installed capacity, liquid fuels breakdown, 2010-2024 (MW) ..........................................................139
– Installed capacity, liquid fuels breakdown, 2010-2024 (%) .............................................................139
– Installed capacity by technology type, 2010-2024 (MW) ................................................................140
– Installed capacity by technology type, 2010-2024 (%) ...................................................................141
– Installed capacity by ownership type, 2010-2024 (MW) .................................................................142
– Installed capacity by ownership type, 2010-2024 (%) ....................................................................142
– Installed capacity by provinces, 2010-2024 (MW)...........................................................................143
– Installed capacity by provinces, 2010-2024 (%) .............................................................................144
– Installed capacity by fuel, Eastern Cape, 2010-2024 (MW) ............................................................145
– Installed capacity by fuel, Free State, 2010-2024 (MW)..................................................................145
– Installed capacity by fuel, Gauteng, 2010-2024 (MW).....................................................................145
– Installed capacity by fuel, KwaZulu Natal, 2010-2024 (MW) ...........................................................145
– Installed capacity by fuel, Limpopo, 2010-2024 (MW) ....................................................................145

10                                                                    AFRICAN ENERGY • SOUTH AFRICA POWER REPORT • 2020/21
Contents

– Installed capacity by fuel, Mpumalanga, 2010-2024 (MW) .............................................................145
– Installed capacity by fuel, North West, 2010-2024 (MW) ................................................................145
– Installed capacity by fuel, Northern Cape, 2010-2024 (MW)...........................................................146
– Installed capacity by fuel, Western Cape, 2010-2024 (MW)............................................................146
Project listings ...................................................................................................................................147
– Operating .........................................................................................................................................147
– Under construction ..........................................................................................................................150
– In development ................................................................................................................................151

AFRICAN ENERGY • SOUTH AFRICA POWER REPORT • 2020/21                                                                                                 11
Section

1. Executive summary

In some contexts, the South African electricity supply industry (ESI) has been viewed as an attractive
destination for investment due to its stable government, economy and policy direction. This was
especially the case as the government rolled out its ground-breaking Renewable Energy Independent
Power Producer Procurement (REIPPP) programme in 2011.

However, for all South Africa’s strengths – which include a robust judiciary and banking sector – a
number of underlying tensions and challenges mean that long-term investments are far from being risk-
free. The South Africa Power Report 2020/21 outlines the market’s attractions and downsides for power
developers, financiers and other industry stakeholders.

A changing of the political guard
The South African political landscape appears, in many ways, a picture of stability. The ruling African
National Congress (ANC) has been victorious in every election of the post-apartheid era, which began
with the abolition of white rule in 1994. This masks a more unpredictable reality, however. While the
ANC won 57.7% of the popular vote in the 2019 election, it is torn by rampant factionalism. Meanwhile,
the recent rise of opposition parties – such as the Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF), led by political
firebrand Julius Malema, and the rebranded Democratic Alliance – points to a shifting political
landscape, providing plenty of political intrigue and fuelling crony relationships that have had a
significantly negative impact on business.

Within the ANC, battle lines have been drawn across ideological and pragmatic lines. Those loyal to
ex-president Jacob Zuma, who resigned in disgrace in 2018, rally around a cry for “radical economic
transformation”. New leader President Cyril Ramaphosa promises to deliver foreign investment, revive
the economy and restore the South African government’s domestic and international reputation by
rooting out corruption.

The impact and consequences of apartheid-era politics are deeply felt to this day, as high levels of
inequality and unemployment remain embedded in society. Broader anti-government frustrations have
brewed since the ANC to power in 1994, caused by sometimes alarmingly poor levels of governance,
widespread corruption and statist politics. While the legacy of apartheid looms over these issues, history
will likely judge that many of these abuses were eminently avoidable.

The jury is out on whether he will succeed, but Ramaphosa seems almost uniquely placed to begin
repairing the social contract. The president, a close ally of national icon Nelson Mandela, was the first
general secretary of the influential National Union of Mineworkers (NUM). Ramaphosa remade himself
as a leading entrepreneur – and has thus been promoted as a financially sensible and trustworthy
candidate, in stark contrast to Zuma – and enjoys broad support among the general populace.

Ramaphosa scored an approval rating of 62% in a February 2020 poll, which outstrips the approval of
the party he represents by around seven percentage points. However, balancing much-needed reform
with the support of key policy-makers is a political tightrope, and there is a palpable impatience resulting
from the government’s sluggishness in addressing key issues.

12                                                AFRICAN ENERGY • SOUTH AFRICA POWER REPORT • 2020/21
Executive summary
                                                                               Section

Tackling corruption and state capture
Since Ramaphosa assumed office, there have been some tangible improvements in pushing back the
frontiers of kleptocracy that were normalised under Zuma. Under the previous administration over
R500bn ($34bn) is alleged to have been stolen from state companies and government departments.
Milestones include the arrest in November 2019 of Zuma ally, former minister Bongani Bongo. Zuma
and his cronies have been put on trial in a system where the courts proved sufficiently robust to
withstand ‘state capture’ even if some judges and police bodies were caught (and literally bought) in
the Zuma web.

While this represents progress, critics argue that the pace of reform – reviving both the public’s and
international partners’ confidence in the South Africa state – has been far too slow. Zuma’s protracted
trial, a steady drip of revelations and crises in institutions crippled by poor governance, led by state
utility Eskom, mean the crisis of governance has not strayed far from the forefront of public
consciousness.

Overly cautious economic policies have proven too little, too late
The long-held hope of a post-apartheid transformation, which would blend social equity with economic
opportunity (and accelerated growth), has been undermined by a decade of disappointing growth. As
South Africa Power Report 2020/21 went to press, South Africa was alarmingly close to losing its last
remaining investment-grade credit rating (assigned by Moody’s Investors Service, which was widely
seen by markets as being too understanding towards the South African sovereign, unlike Standard &
Poor’s and other agencies).

Promises of reform by the incoming president have been welcomed by international investors but have
often seemed too sluggish or half-hearted in delivery to overcome the legacy issues that went
unchecked by previous administrations. South Africa remains confronted by unsustainably high
unemployment, a moribund economy (which in late 2019/early 2020 was reflected in successive
quarters of negative growth) and flailing state-owned enterprises (SOEs).

SOEs continue to siphon money from public coffers, rather than contributing positively to the national
economy. These shortfalls are exemplified by Eskom, which has become symbolic of national economic
malaise, as the state power utility struggles with over-employment, dependency on coal for power
generation and responsibility for the ever unpopular need for load-shedding. Prescriptions for reversing
Eskom’s decline go to the heart of many of country’s most pressing debates.

While South Africa has a vibrant financial services sector, and its market is sufficiently large and open
to attract entrepreneurs and innovators, opportunities for private investors may be constrained by the
continued dominance of the state and ‘statist’ perceptions; these perceptions continue to play a major
role in ANC, EFF and other policy prescriptions offered to a majority of voters who have hardly benefitted
from the fruits of a globalised, liberal economy. It could be argued these benefits would have been much
greater if South Africa had been truly liberalised and liberated. But that is a matter of great debate within
the ‘rainbow nation’, with consequences for those investing in the country potentially for decades to
come.

A power sector in crisis
The electricity supply industry’s struggles are well documented, and the government’s broken promise
to prevent load shedding has developed into a serious political and economic issue. The sector’s

AFRICAN ENERGY • SOUTH AFRICA POWER REPORT • 2020/21                                                      13
Executive summary

institutions have been seriously undermined, as highlighted by the resignation of Eskom chair Jabu
Mabuza in January 2020. Reliable power supply is critical to economic activity; its absence is particularly
ruinous to the mining sector, a key source of income and jobs. The problems are well-known and their
resolution is urgent, but such is the depth of South Africa’s crisis that deeply unpopular and value-
destructive load-shedding looks certain to be an unfortunate reality for the foreseeable future, as the
government itself admitted in early 2020.

Despite once being heralded as a world-leading model for state-led power management, years of
financial mismanagement have resulted in chronic failures of state utility Eskom, which now requires
significant structural reform. The government published the Roadmap for Eskom in a Reformed
Electricity Supply Industry in late-2019; this outlined plans to legally separate generation, transmission
and distribution (in structures reminiscent of the forward looking, but not properly implemented Energy
White Paper of 1998). Despite promising ‘bold actions’ to put Eskom on a track to financial sustainability,
many of the more difficult decisions were shirked on distribution, private participation and labour issues
in particular.

A decade of renewables, but coal remains the dominant fuel
Despite the power sector’s struggles in recent years, the Renewable Energy Independent Power
Producer Procurement (REIPPP) programme has had a profound impact on the energy mix and investor
landscape. Remarkably, between 2011 and end-2020, both renewable energy and IPP capacity as
percentages of the energy mix will have increased by more than threefold. The programme has been
implemented via four rounds of bidding, plus an additional concentrated solar power round. A fifth
REIPPP round is planned.

The on-grid energy mix remains dominated by coal, which accounts for 73% of total capacity and has
been prioritised in energy planning. Coal remains of real political significance as a source of employment
– suggesting that projects driven by ‘clean coal’ will remain an important element in the energy mix
despite efforts for South Africa to accelerate its carbon transition.

In 2019, following a highly protracted and politicised process, which exposed competing interests from
within the coal and nuclear lobby, a new Integrated Resource Plan (IRP) was published; this key
document for energy sector planning had not been updated since 2010. The latest version included
priority procurement of 2GW-3GW to help minimise load-shedding and expenditure on diesel, including
a substantially increased capacity for renewable energies but also, controversially, maintaining a
commitment to coal.

Bold reform plans face many challenges
However, the successful implementation of the new IRP is already being called into question. While
African Energy Live Data’s pipeline of in-development generation projects suggest that installed capacity
will reach the IRP’s medium-term target of 63,914MW in 2024, longer-term aspirations will hinge on the
ability to reform the debt-laden and loss-making Eskom. The ‘junking’ of South Africa’s credit rating is
expected to result in slower economic and electricity demand growth. The consequences may be a
reduction in Eskom’s ability to both cover its operating costs and to administer the necessary reforms
that will make the sector competitive; this is likely to make meeting the IRP’s long-term supply targets
more challenging. Beyond new capacity additions, improving availability levels at existing power plants
will be crucial in ending rolling blackouts. Even with lower demand growth, the current availability levels
of 60% will result in the supply deficit growing from -4.4% in 2019 to -6.3% in 2024.

14                                               AFRICAN ENERGY • SOUTH AFRICA POWER REPORT • 2020/21
You can also read