SHAPING YOUR CAREER QUEST - BY30% - American Association for Clinical ...

Page created by Christina Newton
 
CONTINUE READING
SHAPING YOUR CAREER QUEST - BY30% - American Association for Clinical ...
January/February 2020
                                                      DOUBLED
                                                       D-DIMER
                                                     THRESHOLD
                                                       LOWERS
                                                      NEED FOR
                                                      IMAGING

                                                     30%
                                                          BY
                                    Clinical
                                 Laboratory
                                      News
                                                        PAGE 6

     An AACC Publication   | Volume 46, Number 1

SHAPING                                              The Rise of
                                                   Metagenomics
YOUR
CAREER                                               CAR-T Cell

QUEST                                                  Therapy:
                                                        The Lab
                                                     Connection
SHAPING YOUR CAREER QUEST - BY30% - American Association for Clinical ...
ANALYZER WELLNESS FROM THE INSIDE OUT

  BeyondCare     SM

  Quality Monitor
  for Hematology

ONLY FROM SYSMEX:     From this point on, you run QC—Sysmex will do the rest. BeyondCare Quality Monitor
                      for Hematology (BCQMh) is a groundbreaking quality management program that
THE COMPLETE          monitors the health and accuracy of your analyzers. Providing continuous calibration
FITNESS TRACKER FOR   verification, standardized troubleshooting guidance, and compliance-ready reports,
ANALYZER HEALTH       BCQMh alleviates QC busy-work allowing more meaningful use of your staff’s expertise.
                      Predictive algorithms detect and correct analyzer performance issues sooner than today’s
                      standard quality control practices and can even dispatch a service engineer before an issue
                      becomes a failure. As the leader in hematology, you trust Sysmex with the health of your
                      patients. Now, trust us to manage the health of your analyzers.

                      ASK YOUR SYSMEX REPRESENTATIVE HOW BCQMh WILL
                      FOREVER TRANSFORM LABORATORY QUALITY MANAGEMENT
www.sysmex.com/BCQM   FOR THE BETTER.
                                                                                            © 2020 Sysmex America Inc.
SHAPING YOUR CAREER QUEST - BY30% - American Association for Clinical ...
JA NU A RY/ FE BR U A RY 2020   CONTENTS                            1

                                                              www.aacc.org

                            EDITORIAL STAFF
                            Managing Editor Bill Malone                                   8 Metagenomic Next-generation Sequencing
                            Senior Editor Genna Rollins                                       Modern Tool for Diagnosing Infectious Diseases
                            Senior Manager, Communications and PR
                            Christine DeLong
                            BUSINESS STAFF                                               14 No Wrong Turns
                            Business Communications Specialist                                How Clinical Laboratory Scientists Shape Careers to Match Their Passions
                            Ana Zelada

                            Board of Editors
                            Chair
                                                                                         20 CAR-T Cell Therapy From a Clinical Laboratory Perspective
                            Danyel Tacker, PhD, DABCC, FAACC                                  Careful Monitoring Before and After Infusion Is Critical to
                              West Virginia University, Morgantown, W.Va.                     Successful Treatment
                            Members
                            Dustin Bunch, PhD, DABCC
                              Nationwide Children’s Hospital, Columbus, Ohio

                                                                                         8
                            Sara Love, PhD, DABCC
                              Hennepin Healthcare, Minneapolis, Mn.
                            Mark Marzinke, PhD, DABCC, FAACC
                              Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine,
                              Baltimore, Md.
                            Alison Woodworth, PhD, DABCC, FAACC
                              University of Kentucky Healthcare, Lexington, Ky.
                            Melanie L. Yarbrough, PhD, DABCC, DABMM
                              Washington University School of Medicine,
                              St. Louis, Mo.

                            AACC Officers
                            President Carmen L. Wiley, PhD, DABCC, FAACC
                            President-Elect David G. Grenache, PhD, DABCC,
                            MT(ASCP), FAACC
                            Treasurer Steven Kazmierczak, PhD, DABCC,
                            FAACC

                                                                                                                                                             30
                            Secretary Anthony A. Killeen, MD, BCh, PhD,
                            DABCC, FAACC
                            Past President Dennis J. Dietzen, PhD, DABCC,
                            FAACC

                            Advertising Sales
                            The Townsend Group
                            2025 M Street, NW, Suite 800, Washington, DC 20036

                                                                                                                                                              20
                            www.townsend-group.com
                            Phone: +1 202.367.1259
                            Kevin McDonnell, National Sales Manager
                            Email: kmcdonnell@townsend-group.com

                            Subscriptions
                            AACC
                            900 Seventh St., NW, Suite 400
                            Washington, DC 20001
                            Phone: +1 202.857.0717 or +1 800.892.1400
                            Email: custserv@aacc.org

                            Editorial Correspondence
                            Bill Malone, Managing Editor
                            Phone: +1 202.835.8756 or +1 800.892.1400
                            Email: bmalone@aacc.org
                            Clinical Laboratory News (ISSN 0161-9640) is published
                            monthly (10 times per year—Jan/Feb., March, April,

                                                                                         14
                            May, June, July/August, Sept., Oct., Nov., and Dec.) by
                            the American Association for Clinical Chemistry. 900
                            Seventh St., NW, Suite 400, Washington, DC 20001.
                            Phone: +1 202.835.8756 or +1 800.892.1400 Fax:
                            +1 202.877.5093. Contents copyright © 2020 by the
                            American Association for Clinical Chemistry, Inc., except
                            as noted. Printing in the U.S.A. POSTMASTER: Send
                            address changes to AACC, 900 Seventh St. NW, Suite
                            400, Washington, DC 20001.

                            Design and Production Management                                  Departments                                            Hereditary thrombophilia
                                                                                          2   Federal Insider
                                                                                                                                                     testing is generally
                                                                                          4   Bench Matters
                                                                                                                                                     reserved for children
                                                                                          6   The Sample
                                                                                         26   Special Section:
                                                                                                                                                     with unprovoked
                                                                                              Lab Stewardship Focus
                                                                                                                                                     thrombotic episodes
Cover: LaylaBird / iStock

                                                                                         30   Regulatory Roundup                                     and a family history of
                                                             The full text of Clinical   32   Industry Playbook                                      thrombosis. It is usually
                                                             Laboratory News can
                                                             be found on EBSCO’s         36   Ask the Expert                                         not recommended if
                                  @ CLN_AACC
                                                               CINAHL Complete
                                                              database and is also
                                                           searchable via the EBSCO
                                                                                                                                                     a thrombotic episode
                                                              Discovery Service™
                                                                                                                                                     is provoked by strong
                                                                                                                                                     risk factors.
                                                                                                                                                     p36
SHAPING YOUR CAREER QUEST - BY30% - American Association for Clinical ...
2                  J A NU A RY /F E B R U A RY 2020

                            Hospitals Challenge Price Transparency Rule
                            Hospital groups took legal action to oppose a new rule from the Centers for Medicare
                            and Medicaid Services (CMS) that greatly expands price information available to
Federal Insider             consumers for everything from laboratory tests to surgeries. Notably, the rule requires
                            that hospitals not only publish online their standard charges for all services but also
                            all payer-specific negotiated rates for their services, which the American Hospital
                            Association (AHA) said will confuse patients.
                               “Today’s rule mandating the public disclosure of privately negotiated rates between
                            commercial health insurance companies and hospitals is a setback in efforts to provide
                            patients with the most relevant information they need to make informed decisions
                            about their care,” AHA and several other hospital groups wrote in a joint statement.
                            The legal challenge from AHA and hospitals argues that the rule exceeds the adminis-
                            tration’s authority.
                               According to CMS administrator Seema Verma, however, the rule will increase com-
                            petition and reduce healthcare costs for consumers. “Under the status quo, healthcare
                            prices are about as clear as mud to patients,” she said. “Today’s rules usher in a new era
                              that upends the status quo to empower patients and put them first.”
                                    The final rule will require hospitals to make prices public in two ways beginning
                                   in 2021. Hospitals will have to make public all charges—including payer-specific
                                     negotiated charges—via a comprehensive machine-readable file that includes
                                       billing codes. This will allow anyone with the proper software to easily analyze
                                       and publish data for use by consumers.
                                           In addition, hospitals will have to display online so-called shoppable services
                                       in a consumer-friendly manner, including payer-specific negotiated charges, the
                                       amount the hospital is willing to accept in cash from a patient, and the mini-
                                      mum and maximum negotiated charges for 300 common shoppable services.
                                    Shoppable services are those that the consumer could schedule in advance, such
                                   as laboratory testing or a bundle of services like cesarean delivery.
                                   The rule also gives CMS enforcement tools including monitoring, auditing, cor-
                             rective action plans, and the ability to impose civil monetary penalties of $300 per day.
          ■                                           this proposal, if adopted, would further   previously been tested with this method,
          AACC CALLS FOR IMPROVED                     limit the ability of patients to obtain    which would limit somatic cancer
          COVERAGE OF CERTAIN CANCER                  appropriate, evidence-based assessment     testing. “While repeat testing of genes
          TESTS                                       of their hereditary risk for breast or     for hereditary risk of cancer should not

          A       ACC is calling on the Centers for
                  Medicare and Medicaid Services
          (CMS) to make significant changes to
                                                      ovarian cancer,” the association said.
                                                          In addition AACC is concerned with
                                                      the agency’s decision to consider breast
                                                                                                 be covered, NGS testing to assemble
                                                                                                 a somatic profile of a patient’s cancer
                                                                                                 is appropriate and should be covered,”
          its proposed national coverage determi-     and ovarian cancers together as if they    AACC wrote. “Determining the molecu-
          nation for next-generation sequencing       were synonymous. AACC commented            lar profile of an advanced cancer can
          (NGS) for Medicare beneficiaries with       that “many clinical trials assess only     specifically dictate treatment and several
          advanced cancer. The CMS proposal           one cancer type without the other. It is   FDA-approved treatments necessitate
          would limit Medicare payment for            important to note that although breast     biomarker measurement.”
          breast and ovarian cancer tests to those    and ovarian cancer have similarities           Finally, AACC recommended that
                                                                                                                                               ryasick / E+ / Getty Images

          cleared by the Food and Drug                with respect to gene mutations and         CMS focus on the clinical indications
          Administration (FDA).                       hereditary risk, there are important       with sufficient evidence based on pub-
              In a comment letter to CMS, AACC        differences in how the two cancers orig-   lished practice guidelines rather than
          noted that currently FDA has not            inate and develop within individuals.”     a specific laboratory technology. CMS
          cleared nor approved any NGS tests              The association also took issue with   should use existing guidelines to establish
          for hereditary risk assessment of either    the CMS decision in the proposal not       the coverage policy for cancer type,
          condition. “We are also concerned that      to cover NGS testing if a patient has      genetic alteration, and treatment option.
SHAPING YOUR CAREER QUEST - BY30% - American Association for Clinical ...
AMP UP THE SIGNAL.
 DIAL DOWN THE NOISE.

Surmodics™ IVD Provides the Gold Standard in Immunoassay Components and Service
For 40 years, Surmodics™ has provided leading in vitro diagnostic companies critical components for
developing sensitive, reproducible immunoassays. Whether you are developing an ELISA/EIA,
point-of-care device, western blot or microarray, Surmodics products provide the gold standard for
increased sensitivity, stability and accuracy. Our high performance, ready to use formulations ensure
quality and a quicker path to commercialization.
Our goal is your goal: ensuring accurate and reliable results every time, for every patient.

             ELISA Stabilizers,                   ELISA Substrates                ELISA Stop Solutions   DIARECT™ Antigens   Microarray Slides/
            Diluents & Blockers                                                   & Support Reagents        & Antibodies         Surfaces

Your partner in quality
ISO 13485:2016 & ISO 9001:2015 CERTIFIED

For more information or samples, contact orders@surmodics.com.
952-500-7200 | www.surmodics.com/ivd
© 2019 Surmodics, Inc. All rights reserved. SRDX-IVD-241 A
SURMODICS and the SURMODICS logo are trademarks of Surmodics, Inc. and/or its affiliates.
DIARECT is a trademark of DIARECT AG.
SHAPING YOUR CAREER QUEST - BY30% - American Association for Clinical ...
4                 J A NU A RY /F E B R U A RY 2020

                              How to Keep Multisite Multi-
                              Analyzer Validations on Track
Bench                        I   n multisite healthcare organizations, a patient might
                                 present for testing at different laboratory sites during
                                                                                                considerations for assay mapping
                                                                                                include testing volume and required
Matters                       a single healthcare episode or between healthcare visits,
                              healthcare providers might practice at multiple locations, and
                                                                                                turnaround time for the test,
                                                                                                specimen stability, and potential for
                              individual laboratory sites might require operational backup.     sample and reagent carryover.
                              For each of these scenarios, laboratory results are expected to
                              be sufficiently comparable to ensure optimal care. Multi-         THE TEAM
                              analyzer, multisite validation to ensure comparable patient       Our core validation team members
                              results is not only a good laboratory practice, but also a        included staff who perform the stud-
                              regulatory requirement.                                           ies, and those who manage the data,
                                  Thorough planning, well-documented validation protocols,      review, and approve results. We gained
                              a multidisciplinary team effort, and detailed communications      from the knowledge and experience
                              to all stakeholders will keep a complex multisite multi-          of some team members who work at
                              analyzer validation on track. Here, we describe the approach      a single site and others who perform
                              we took in planning the validation of three automated             duties at several sites, such as clinical
                              platforms across five Ontario sites at LifeLabs, the largest      biochemists and IT specialists. The
                              community laboratory in Canada. Our validation at two large       complexity of implementing many
                              central sites each with 15,000 to 20,000 daily test volume        analyzers at multiple sites also requires
                              and three regional sites each with 1,000 to 6,000 daily test      significant involvement from other
                              volume included 23 analyzers covering 45 assays from a            teams, like facilities, procurement,
                              single chemistry platform, and 28 analyzers covering 27 assays    automation specialists, and vendors.
                              across two immunoassay platforms. We also validated two           We found it particularly helpful to
                              automation lines at two central laboratories.                     designate a project manager who had
          Danijela                                                                              insights into the operations at all loca-
          Konforte, PhD,      THE PROTOCOL                                                      tions and who knew our validation
          FCACB               A documented validation protocol outlines the planned             and implementation requirements.
                              validation studies, and we advise having a single validation      This individual planned the project
                              protocol for each platform that is to be validated. The
                              protocol should be comprehensive and specific, including
                              detailed step-by-step procedures for each study.
                              This eliminates variability in how the studies are
                              performed and allows for adequate comparisons
                              across the sites. The protocol should include
                              defined acceptance criteria for each study,
                              as decided by the lab director. We also
          Kika Veljkovic,     recommend that each protocol be
          PhD, FCACB          discussed and formally approved by

                                                                                                                                            MR.Cole_Photographer / Moment / Getty Images
                              internal stakeholders at each site, since
                              large scope validation studies come with
                              a significant resource commitment and
                              substantial cost. In our experience it
                              also helps to share validation protocols
                              with vendors to make them aware if the
                              validation acceptance criteria are different
                              from vendor-stated ones and to ensure
                              easier, faster troubleshooting.
                                  As part of our validation protocol, we
                              also decided which assays to validate at which
                              sites and on which analyzers—this is sometimes
                              referred to as “assay mapping.” Some important
SHAPING YOUR CAREER QUEST - BY30% - American Association for Clinical ...
JA NU A RY/ FE BR U A RY 2020                                                                 5

                                                                                                                                      Paul Bradbury / Caiaimage / Getty Images
timelines, ensured team communica-           sample volumes for the number of            multiple sites are involved. In addi-
tions and the pace of validation and, in     analyzers to be validated and studies to    tion to daily or weekly touch-point
a way, kept the whole team accountable       be completed. Sample concentrations         meetings, we used validation progress
throughout the validation.                   should cover the analytical measure-        spreadsheets to show visually where
    Using a staggered validation             ment range. Aliquots might need to          sites were in process, assigning colors
approach, in which one site performs         be prepared, stored, and transported        to validation steps—for example, study
valid ation prior to another site, reduces   between sites while preserving sample       in progress (yellow); study completed
the number of staff required for valida-     stability. Since there could be several     (green); follow-up needed (red); etc. In
tion at any one time and puts less stress    dozen assays and several analyzers vali-    addition, we sent automatic emails to
on laboratory operations overall. This       dated simultaneously, we recommend          inform all team members each time a
strategy also enabled us to promptly         using inventory spreadsheets to log         validation stage changed. This enabled
discover and mitigate issues before          available samples and concentrations        prompt engagement of the accountable
we moved on to validations at other          for each assay.                             team members at each validation stage.
sites. To ensure the entire project has          Data management can be a big                These activities, although requir-
adequate resources, we suggest identify-     validation bottleneck. In multi-analyzer    ing considerable time and effort, allow
ing key operators for each platform          validations, there could be thousands       for a well-coordinated and successful
and group of analyzers. The in-depth         of data points from a single validation     multisite multi-analyzer validation. This
training they receive from vendors can       study, so labs should plan to automate      enables adequate assessment of test
be leveraged for internal training of the    data management as much as possible.        result comparability, ensuring standard-
remaining operators at all sites.            For example, data can be exported from      ized, high-quality patient care across all
                                             analyzers into validation spreadsheets in   sites of the organization.
VALIDATION SAMPLES AND DATA                  .csv files. We also recommend that labs
MANAGEMENT                                   take advantage of statistical software      Danijela Konforte, PhD, FCACB, and
We advise labs to start collecting valida-   packages like Excel with Analyse-it, EP     Kika Veljkovic, PhD, FCACB, are
tion samples early—including patient         Evaluator, and R.                           clinical biochemists at LifeLabs Medical
samples, proficiency testing materials,                                                  Laboratory Services in Toronto,
reference materials, and spiking materi-     COMMUNICATION                               Ontario, Canada.
als—that will be needed based on each        Communication matters with any              +EMAIL: Danijela.Konforte@lifelabs.com;
validation protocol. Plan sufficient         validation, but even more so when           Kika.Veljkovic@lifelabs.com
SHAPING YOUR CAREER QUEST - BY30% - American Association for Clinical ...
S
     6                   J A NU A RY /F E B R U A RY 2020

                                   Raising D-dimer Threshold Cuts Need for Chest Imaging
                                   by 30% in Suspected Pulmonary Embolism
                                   Raising the D-dimer threshold for patients with low or moderate clinical
                                   pretest probabilities of pulmonary embolism (PE) effectively rules out PE
                                   and reduces the need for chest imaging by one-third (N Engl J Med 2019;
                                   381:2125–34).
The Sample                            The primary goal of diagnostic testing for suspected PE is to determine
                                   which patients should be treated with anticoagulants and which should not,
                                   according to investigators in the Pulmonary Embolism Graduated D-Dimer
                                   study. Current practices generally rule out PE in patients with low clinical
                                   pretest probabilities when they have D-dimer results
SHAPING YOUR CAREER QUEST - BY30% - American Association for Clinical ...
JA NU A RY/ FE BR U A RY 2020                 7

■                                          system, which is based on Cerner’s          95. When at
SEPSIS DIGITAL ALERT SYSTEM                St. John Sepsis Algorithm. Initially        least three of the criteria were met,
IMPROVES 3 KEY OUTCOMES                    this integrated part of Imperial’s          an alert would fire.

I  mplementation of a digital sepsis
   alert system in a multisite U.K.
hospital network was associated with
                                           electronic health record (EHR) ran in
                                           silent mode, during which alerts were
                                           not visible to clinical staff, then was
                                                                                          Similarly the system would fire
                                                                                       an alert for suspicion of severe
                                                                                       sepsis when two or more of these
improved outcomes—including low-           switched to live mode. The implemen-        criteria were met along with at
ered odds of 30-day mortality across all   tation started in inpatient units, before   least one criteria indicative of organ
patients (0.76 odds ratio)—and shorter     spreading to emergency departments,         dysfunction, including: serum creati-
hospital length of stay and more timely    hematology units, and finally all other     nine increase over baseline ≥0.5 mg/
start of antibiotics for patients who      inpatient units.                            dL (72 hr lookback); total bilirubin
alerted in emergency departments               Coupled with the alert system,          ≥2.0 mg/dL or 2.0
tively) (J Am Med Inform Assoc 2019;       multidisciplinary care pathway that         mmol/L (12 hr lookback); and sys-
doi:10.1093/jamia/ocz186).                 would launch when a clinician con-          tolic blood pressure
SHAPING YOUR CAREER QUEST - BY30% - American Association for Clinical ...
Victor Habbick Visions / Science Photo Library / Getty Images

                                                                         8
                                                                         J A NU A RY /F E B R U A RY 2020

                                                                META G
JA NU A RY/ FE BR U A RY 2020                       9

                                                                 W
                                                                                 hen culture, serology,
                                                                                 and polymerase chain
                                                                                 reaction (PCR) can’t
                                                                                 identify the cause of a
                                                                patient’s infection, inappropriate
                                                                therapy, excess healthcare costs, or
                                                                even the individual’s death all are
                                                                possibilities. In contrast to these
                                                                tests that generally look for one
                                                                pathogen at a time, metagenomic
                                                                next-generation sequencing
                                                                (mNGS) analyzes a broad spectrum
                                                                of microorganisms at once, poten-
                                                                tially providing quicker diagnoses
                                                                and avoiding untoward outcomes.
                                                                    A clinical mNGS test is expen-
                                                                sive—sometimes more than $2,000.
                                                                But it might be worthwhile when
                                                                routine tests don’t provide infor-
                                                                mation, for immunocompromised
                                                                patients infected with pathogens that
                                                                do not affect healthy people, or for

A GENOMIC
                                                                patients who can’t tolerate invasive
                                                                diagnostic procedures, said clinical
                                                                laboratorians who use the test.
                                                                    “It’s exciting to think about how
                                                                mNGS can help us improve care.
                                                                There’s a lot of promise in these
                                                                methods,” said David Peaper, MD,
                                                                PhD, an assistant professor of labora-
                                                                tory medicine at Yale University and
                                                                director of clinical microbiology at
                                                                Yale New Haven Hospital in New
                                                                Haven, Connecticut. However, these
                                                                tests are limited by risk of con-
                                                                tamination, designs geared to specific
                                                                types of pathogens, bioinformatics
                                                                challenges, and databank deficiencies,
                                                                said Peaper and others.

                                                                Diverse Pathogen Detectors
                                                                Clinical mNGS typically involves
                                                                extracting cell-free (cf) DNA,
                                                                cfRNA, or both from a body fluid,
                                                                amplifying the nucleic acids via PCR,
                                                                generating libraries, and shotgun
                                                                sequencing nucleic acids at a very
                                                                high depth. Genomic laboratories
                                                                use software to analyze the millions
                                                                of reads generated in each sample

  NEXT-GENERATION SEQUENCING
                                                                and identify those that align to
                                                                nucleotide sequences of pathogens
                                                                in various databases, such as the
                                                                National Center for Biotechnology
                                                                Information (NCBI) GenBank.
                                                                    A $2,200 University of California,

  Modern Tool for Diagnosing Infectious Diseases                San Francisco (UCSF) test analyzes
                                                                both DNA and RNA to diagnose
                                                                causes of meningitis and encephali-
                                                                tis from bacteria, viruses, fungi, and
  BY DEBORAH LEVENSON                                           parasites found in cerebrospinal fluid.
10              J A NU A RY /F E B R U A RY 2020

     UCSF software analyzes reads, iden-      published data on the first 100 tests     scientific officer at BioID Genomics,
     tifies those that align to pathogens     used at a children’s hospital showed      a biotechnology company that spe-
     in GenBank, and issues a qualitative     that sensitivity and specificity of the   cializes in sequencing and software
     report noting the pathogens present      test for a clinically relevant infec-     solutions to identify and character-
     in the sample, along with interpretive   tion were 92% and 64%, respec-            ize microbes.
     clinical notes. A sequencing board,      tively (Open Forum Infect Dis
     modeled on a tumor board, discusses      2019;6:pii:ofz327).                       Challenges Ahead
     results in real time with treating          Published evidence is emerging         mNGS involves many challenges,
     physicians and may make recom-           on using the Karius test for diagnos-     according to recent reviews of
     mendations about additional testing.     ing endocarditis, including a case        the technology (Clin Infect Dis
     Turnaround time from shipping            in which the test helped identify         2018;66:778–88; Nat Rev Genet
     samples to delivery of a qualitative     a Coxiella burnetii infection (Open       2019;20:341–55). These include
     report is generally within a week,       Forum Infect Dis 2019;6:ofz242).          sample contamination with nucleic
     said Charles Chiu, MD, PhD, a key        The company’s website lists several       acid during collections and from
     developer of the UCSF test and a         unpublished abstracts it says support     sequencing reagents, and design of
     professor of laboratory medicine and     use of the test in diagnostic and man-    tests for particular pathogens. For
     director of the clinical microbiology    agement algorithms.                       example, a test must process RNA
     laboratory at UCSF.                         Karius is planning to use the          to detect RNA viruses. So mNGS
         The test performs well in head-      test to discern sepsis causes, often      pneumonia assays that do not test for
     to-head comparisons with routine         missed by culture. A paper describ-       RNA might miss respiratory syncytial
     clinical testing and can make diagno-    ing validation of the test for this       virus, an RNA virus that commonly
     ses usual microbiology tests cannot,     purpose compared Karius test results      causes pneumonia, Chiu said.
     according to recent research (NEJM       to standard of care on 350 patients           Meanwhile, tests do not detect
     2019;380:2327–40). Among 204             with suspected sepsis. The Karius         all pathogens equally. For example,
     pediatric and adult patients in eight    test identified responsible pathogens     mycobacteria might be more dif-
     hospitals, the UCSF test detected        at a rate about three times higher        ficult to detect because lysing them
     58 infections in 57 of the patients.     than blood culture, and 28% higher        for nucleic acid release requires
     Hospitals’ routine tests missed 13       than all microbiology testing com-        more significant cell wall disrup-
     or 22% of these infections. Among        bined. Results from Karius agreed         tion. Also, a negative result might
     seven of those 13 diagnoses made         with blood culture 93.7% of the time      only reflect high leukocyte count
     solely by mNGS, results guided tar-      (Nat Microbiol 2019;4:663–74).            of a sample (corresponding to high
     geted treatment with clinical effect.       The UCSF and Karius tests may          human DNA and/or RNA host
         Redwood City, California-based       be the most prominent in the mNGS         background) or low sequencing
     Karius matches sequences from            space, but they aren’t the only ones.     depth of a specimen, rather than the
     cfDNA in blood plasma to a curated       San Francisco-based IDbyDNA, in           absence of a pathogen.
     company database of 21,000 refer-        partnership with ARUP Laboratories,           Databases also may contain
     ence microbe genomes and delivers        offers a $500 test of DNA and RNA         mislabeled information and include
     reports that show species occurring      detecting 200 pathogens in samples        pathogen strains that do not infect
     in greater than expected concentra-      from respiratory disease patients.        humans. Other challenges include
     tion. Turnaround is fast—typically       The company delivers results within       differentiating colonization from
     about 48 hours from blood draw,          29 hours after receiving samples.         infection, lack of method standard-
     including shipping. A team of on-call    Robert Schlaberg, MD, PhD, MPH,           ization, bioinformatic data storage,
     infectious diseases specialists review   IDbyDNA’s chief medical officer           and patient privacy.
     results with clinicians, particularly    and co-founder, attributed the quick
     for challenging cases, said Timothy      turnaround to data analysis via the       mNGS in Practice
     A. Blauwkamp, PhD, Karius’s co-          company’s Exemplify platform,             Alexander McAdam, MD, PhD,
     founder and chief scientific officer.    which it markets to other labs.           director of the infectious diseases
         The $2,000 Karius test helps            Tests from Scottsdale, Arizona-        diagnostic laboratory at Boston
     diagnose acute infections in immu-       based Fry Laboratories use blood          Children’s Hospital (BCH) and an
     nocompromised patients, invasive         and sequence a region of the 16S or       associate professor of pathology at
     fungal infections, and cardiovascular-   18S rRNA gene found in bacteria,          Harvard Medical School, said that
     related infections, according to the     archaea, fungi, protozoa, amoeba,         it’s difficult to fit mNGS into cur-
     company. A recent study showed           and algae. Tests, which do not use        rent microbiology testing paradigms
     that the test identified responsible     shotgun sequencing, cost $1,495           built on tests costing less than $100.
     pathogens in 86% of 15 children          and generally take a week with            However, his lab has integrated
     with pneumonia and resulted in           shipping, said Jeremy Ellis, PhD, Fry     mNGS into its normal battery of
     changes in antibiotics for almost        Laboratories’ chief scientific officer.   tests. McAdam regularly sends
     half of them. Meanwhile, stan-           Fry Laboratories compares findings        mNGS tests to Karius and UCSF,
     dard methods diagnosed only 46%          to “a curated NCBI ‘nt’ and ‘16s’         but only after preliminary negative
     of the children (Diagn Microbiol         database” about these organisms,          results on routine tests and approval
     Infect Dis 2019;94:188–91). Other        added Ellis, who also serves as chief     from a BCH laboratory director.
JA NU A RY/ FE BR U A RY 2020   11

                                                                “People are showing what’s
                                                                possible with mNGS. We still
                                                                have to fit it into existing
                                                                systems in a way that’s realistic
                                                                about resources available and
                                                                the value provided.”
                                                                – ALEX GRENINGER, MD, PHD
Victor Habbick Visions / Science Photo Library / Getty Images
12            J A NU A RY /F E B R U A RY 2020

“It’s exciting to think about how mNGS                                                                      The BCH lab works with ordering
                                                                                                            clinicians to ensure they understand
                                                                                                            the tests’ utility and the workflow
                                                                                                                                                     and deep-seated liver abscesses that
                                                                                                                                                     can’t be biopsied, and suspected
                                                                                                                                                     endocarditis when valve replace-
    can help us improve care. There’s a                                                                     involved.
                                                                                                                At Yale, Peaper occasionally uses
                                                                                                                                                     ment is not an option. Before
                                                                                                                                                     ordering, Peaper and clinicians

       lot of promise in these methods.”                                                                    mNGS tests for scenarios including
                                                                                                            diagnostic conundrums, critically ill
                                                                                                            immunosuppressed patients with
                                                                                                                                                     discuss how positive, inconclusive,
                                                                                                                                                     and negative results would affect
                                                                                                                                                     care. More data from select patient
                                                                     – DAVID PEAPER, MD, PHD                tissue-based infections, brain lesions   populations would make decisions
                                                                                                                                                     easier, he added.
                                                                                                                                                         Sometimes results show zero
                                                                                                                                                     or few reads of the true culprit,
                                                                                                                                                     so diagnosis requires another
                                                                                                                                                     method. Peaper recalled recent
                                                                                                                                                     encephalitis cases detected by
                                                                                                                                                     antibody, not the UCSF test. Chiu
                                                                                                                                                     recollected seeing too few reads of
                                                                                                                                                     Mycobacterium tuberculosis to call a
                                                                                                                                                     test positive for it. A different test
                                                                                                                                                     confirmed M. tuberculosis.
                                                                                                                                                         Current mNGS tests can iden-
                                                                                                                                                     tify diagnostic gaps in hospital lab
                                                                                                                                                     testing and remind physicians about
                                                                                                                                                     the breadth of organisms covered
                                                                                                                                                     in differential diagnoses, said Alex
                                                                                                                                                     Greninger, MD, PhD. The sensitiv-
                                                                                                                                                     ity of mNGS is much less affected
                                                                                                                                                     by antibiotics than that of culture,
                                                                                                                                                     added Greninger, who participated in
                                                                                                                                                     early development of the UCSF test
                                                                                                                                                     and is now developing an mNGS test
                                                                                                                                                     at University of Washington, where
                                                                                                                                                     he is an assistant professor of labora-
                                                                                                                                                     tory medicine and associate director
                                                                                                                                                     of virology.
                                                                                                                                                         Greninger pointed out that no
                                                                                                                                                     mNGS tests have been cleared by
                                                                                                                                                     the Food and Drug Administration
                                                                                                                                                     (FDA). Draft FDA guidance issued
                                                                                                                                                     in 2016 gives labs developing tests an
                                                                                                                                                     idea of “what validation should look
                                                                                                                                                     like for a test that’s very different
                                                                                                                                                     from traditional tests,” he added.
                                                                                                                                                         Noting that now-commonplace
                                                                                                                                                     PCR was new and labor-intensive in
Victor Habbick Visions / Science Photo Library / Getty Images

                                                                                                                                                     the 1980s, Greninger envisions a day
                                                                                                                                                     when mNGS could become a usual
                                                                                                                                                     test. “People are showing what’s pos-
                                                                                                                                                     sible with mNGS,” he said. “We still
                                                                                                                                                     have to fit it into existing systems in
                                                                                                                                                     a way that’s realistic about resources
                                                                                                                                                     available and the value provided.”

                                                                                                                                                     Dr. Chiu has a patent on algorithms
                                                                                                                                                     used in automated software developed
                                                                                                                                                     by UCSF to analyze and interpret
                                                                                                                                                     metagenomic sequencing data.

                                                                                                                                                     Deborah Levenson is a freelance writer
                                                                                                                                                     in College Park, Maryland.
                                                                                                                                                     +EMAIL: dlwrites@verizon.net
Developing an Innovative
New Assay?

Let’s Talk About Innovative QC Material.
Aalto Scientific has been providing our customers with solutions for Quality Control Materials
for more than 40 years; bringing novel assays to market faster, with fewer regulatory hurdles.

 Custom OEM/Private Label Solutions for:

      • Calibration Verification & Linearity                                 • Filling, Lyophilization & Packaging

      • Controls & Calibrators                                               • Antigen Purification

      • Proficiency Material                                                 • Contract Manufacturing

                                                 Visit us in booth Z3 A49 at the
                                           Medlab Middle East 2020 exhibition in Dubai
                               aaltoscientific.com | aaltosales@aaltoscientific.com | 1.800.748.6674
TURNS
                                   WRONG
J A NU A RY /F E B R U A RY 2020

                   NO                How Clinical Laboratory Scientists Shape Careers to Match Their Passions
14
JA NU A RY/ FE BR U A RY 2020   15

                                                         LaylaBird / iStock

BY KIMBERLY SCOTT
16               J A NU A RY /F E B R U A RY 2020

      W
                     ith the job outlook for    For 14 years she worked for United          auto-verification. This ultimately led
                     clinical laboratory        Hospital in St. Paul, first as a general-   her off the bench where she crafted
                     scientists (CLS)           ist on the evening shift, then as chem-     rules for auto-verification.
                     expected to grow much      istry lead on the day shift. In 2016           “I like that my job changes every
     faster than for other professions, the     she took a job as chemistry technical       day,” she explained. “I like the fast
     career possibilities for people just       specialist at Children’s Minnesota. In      pace, and I like the challenges I
     entering the field appear limitless.       her current position, Bartos performs       face. Analyzers are going down,
     From working at the bench to               competency assessments (including           the phone is ringing, there’s always
     focusing on research to performing         proficiency testing review for the          something going on. I also enjoy
     data analysis, CLS professionals have      College of American Pathologists) and       interacting with healthcare provid-
     a wide range of potential career           ensures that the chemistry laboratory       ers and collaborating. This allows me
     paths from which to choose.                meets all federal and state regulations.    to use my critical thinking skills and
         According to the Bureau of Labor           “What I like best about my job is       to play detective. It’s what makes
     Statistics, the job market for clinical    that I do a lot of troubleshooting and      this job so exciting.”
     laboratory technologists and techni-       problem-solving,” said Bartos, who             Rockefeller advises new CLS
     cians is expected to grow by 11%           recently completed her MBA with a           professionals to volunteer when
     between 2018 and 2028, compared            concentration in business analytics.        growth opportunities are offered
     to 5% for the average growth rate for      “I like using data to drive informed        within a laboratory to gain exposure
     all occupations. This growth is being      decisions, and I’m very interested in
     driven, in part, by an increase in the     quality control.”
     aging population and an increase in            Bartos advises junior CLS to
     the number of laboratory tests being       be open to new experiences and
     ordered by clinical providers.             to get involved with professional
         CLS staff members, also known          organizations. Conferences are a
     as medical technologists, earn a           great way to stay current, as are
     bachelor of science degree and then        certificate programs such as those
     typically complete a 1-year training       offered through AACC, she added.
     internship program before sitting          For example, Bartos is certified as a
     for a comprehensive written exam.          specialist in chemistry and also holds
     Once certified, CLS professionals can      a graduate certificate from University
     pursue a variety of career trajectories.   of Minnesota in performance
     But where they launch their careers        improvement.
     is often not where they land. Below
     we highlight the stories of several        Facing Everyday Challenges
     CLS professionals who have found           Amy Rockefeller, MLS(ASCP),
     career success, all anchored in their      switched her major from account-
     passion for science and patient care       ing to microbiology at the begin-
     and in an insatiable curiosity that        ning of her college career and never
     keeps them on creative journeys.           looked back. She received a bach-
                                                elor’s degree in microbiology with
     The Joy of Problem-solving                 a CLS option from California State
     Erin Bartos, MT(ASCP)SC, a chem-           University, Chico, and performed a
     istry technical specialist at Children’s   1-year internship at University of
     Minnesota in St. Paul, knew from an        California, Irvine.
     early age that she wanted to work             Rockefeller’s first job was with
     in healthcare. As a child she was          Sharp Healthcare System in San
     diagnosed with aplastic anemia and         Diego, where she worked as a gen-
     received a bone marrow transplant          eralist for 6 years. Eventually, she
     at the University of Minnesota. “I         moved to University of California,
     became fascinated with what hap-           San Diego, where she started as a
     pened to my blood after it was taken,”     senior specialist and was promoted
     she explained.                             to supervisor and then to clinical lab
         After high school, Bartos was          manager.
     offered a scholarship to Mount Mercy          As a generalist, Rockefeller
     College in Cedar Rapids, Iowa, and         was exposed to various specialties,
     decided immediately to pursue              including hematology, coagulation,
     medical technology. After completing       chemistry, and urinalysis. Working
     her internship at St. Luke’s Hospital      on the bench allowed her to be a
     in Cedar Rapids, Bartos worked at          key operator on different analyz-
     Trident Hospital in Charleston and         ers and to work on middleware
     eventually moved back to Minnesota.        information technology projects for
JA NU A RY/ FE BR U A RY 2020                                                                                         17

                                                                                     – JEFFREY YOUNG, MLS(ASCP)CM
                                                                                                                    which meant that I traveled continuously.”
                                                                                                                    different clinical systems. I had a large territory,
                                                                                                                    “I became a subject matter expert on five or six
to different specialties. She also rec-   From CLS to Application                                                                                                          labs with validation studies. I would
ommends taking advantage of online        Specialist                                                                                                                       make sure they understood how to
resources, such as online communi-        When his plans to attend medical                                                                                                 use the analyzers and the software. I
ties like AACC Artery (artery.aacc.       school changed after getting his micro-                                                                                          became a subject matter expert on
org) and continuing education, as         biology degree from the University of                                                                                            five or six different clinical systems.
well as networking through atten-         Idaho, Jeffrey Young, MLS(ASCP)CM,                                                                                               I had a large territory, which meant
dance at conferences.                     decided to pursue a career in clini-                                                                                             that I traveled continuously.”
   “There really are a lot of differ-     cal laboratory science at Idaho State                                                                                                When his family grew and he
ent paths you can take,” she said.        University. The CLS program with a                                                                                               needed a position that required less
“You can stay on the bench, you           90-day clinical rotation allowed him to                                                                                          travel, Young took a job as a develop-
can go into administration. If you        graduate with a CLS degree at about                                                                                              ment technologist for Providence
stay on the bench, there are many         15 months. Young worked as a bench                                                                                               Health in Portland, Oregon. The role
different departments you can work        technologist for a short period before                                                                                           was similar to the one he performed
in depending on the size of your          taking a position as a field application                                                                                         for Beckman Coulter, but from the
healthcare system. You can get into       specialist for Beckman Coulter.                                                                                                  perspective of the customer, not the
biotech. There are many options. If           “It was kind of a hybrid role, part                                                                                          vendor.
you have a CLS license, you won’t         technical support and part customer                                                                                                  “I perform validation studies,
have a problem finding a job.”            service,” he explained. “I would help                                                                                            I write procedures, I help set up

                                                                                                                                                                                                                     LaylaBird / iStock
18                         J A NU A RY /F E B R U A RY 2020

instrument interfaces and verify that                                              mentors, she decided to continue
the vendor’s equipment is communi-                                                 pursuing laboratory medicine. It
cating with our laboratory informa-                                                took Ayala-Lopez 7 years to gradu-
tion system,” he explained.                                                        ate from the program at University
   While he is in a somewhat uncon-                                                of Nevada, Las Vegas, because she
ventional role for a CLS professional,                                             was working full-time and going to
Young noted that there are many dif-         Clinical Laboratory                   school part-time. After graduating,
ferent career pathways for laboratory        Scientist Career                      she got a job at St. Rose Dominican
scientists, and that there are a lot                                               Hospital in Las Vegas, where she
of options outside of the traditional        Resources                             was a generalist, rotating throughout
                                             AACC’s clinical laboratory                                                        Erin Bartos
bench tech to lead tech to supervi-                                                the lab.
sor/manager career pathway.                  scientists (CLS) community                Ultimately, Ayala-Lopez decided
   “It’s a stable career choice and has      offers scientific, career, and        to pursue research and moved to
been dependable through times of             networking opportunities              the University of Washington so
economic turmoil,” he said. Like the         for all members who work in           that she could get academic medi-
others interviewed for this article,         laboratory management and             cal laboratory experience. Following
Young advised that all CLS profes-           operations. For career advice         that, she attended Michigan State
sionals get involved with professional       videos, mentoring, certification      University, where she earned her
organizations early in their career.         resources, and more, visit the        graduate degree in pharmacology
“Go to conferences, network, and             AACC CLS community online,            and toxicology.
participate,” he said.                       www.aacc.org/community/                   “My research was on how adipose
                                             clinical-laboratory-scientists-       tissue affects blood vessels,” she        Amy Rockefeller
Broadening Horizons                          community                             explained. “I graduated in 2016 and
After taking part in an allied health                                              did a research post-doc fellowship
services camp while in high school,                                                at Yale University, where I was in
Pamela Banning, MLS(ASCP)CM,              she advances promotion of vocabu-        lab medicine studying leukemia. My
PMP(PMI), knew she wanted to              lary terminology, provides technical     plan was to do a clinical chemistry
study science in college. She obtained    support in database management           fellowship after my research fellow-
her bachelor’s degree in biology at       for various clients, and represents      ship, and that’s what I am doing now
Boise State University in Idaho and       3M HIS clients with standards            at Vanderbilt. I’m four months into
then completed a 1-year medi-             development organizations, such          a two-year fellowship to prepare fel-
cal technology program. Banning’s         as Regenstrief Institute’s Logical       lows to be lab directors.”
internship was at St. Alphonsus           Observation Identifier Names and             “I love being a CLS. Being a CLS       Jeffrey Young
Regional Medical Center in Boise.         Codes (LOINC) Committee.                 requires that you have analytic skills,
   Banning’s first job was at Holy            “It’s like the ultimate puzzle for   that you can interpret data and
Rosary Hospital in Ontario, Oregon.       me because I didn’t build any of the     trends, that you can communicate
After marrying a Marine, she moved        information systems, but we apply        those, both written and orally,” she
around often, but always found there      LOINC for the assays and SNOMED          said. “As a CLS, you must be able
was a need for CLS professionals. “I      CT for the non-numerical values to       to adjust to new procedures since
never had a problem finding work,”        all of them,” she explained. “All my     science is always changing. There is a
she said. “I worked at a doctor’s         earlier jobs prepared me for this. I     lot of room for growth, especially in
lab, a trauma center, different sized     use my medical terminology every         molecular and informatics.”
hospitals. I had about eight differ-      day. It would be so much harder to           Ayala-Lopez recommends that
ent positions over 16 years, but that     do this job without medical technol-     CLS students find mentors in their
really helped me be a generalist. I got   ogy certification.”                      programs who can guide them along         Pamela Banning
to do blood banking, microbiology,            Banning advises new CLS profes-      their career paths. She also suggests
lots of different things.”                sionals to broaden their horizons,       reaching out to people on LinkedIn
   By the late 1980s, as labora-          keep up with technology changes,         or through professional organizations
tory information systems first came       and be involved online. “Seek            to find out more about jobs they find
into play, Banning found that she         out opportunities to be in cross-        interesting. “Just ask them if they
enjoyed working with information          department teams, to see how other       would be willing to talk to you for
technology. She was hired by ARUP         departments work,” she said. “Learn      20 minutes. I’ve never had anybody
Laboratories to convert microbiology      to see things from a different point     turn me away,” she said. “There are so
department workcards to computer-         of view.”                                many options for a CLS professional.
based templates. Eventually, she                                                   You can work in a government lab,
migrated to the IT department doing       From Bench to Research                   forensics, public health. Find what          Nadia
database administration.                  Nadia Ayala-Lopez, PhD,                  interests you and then pursue it!”         Ayala-Lopez
   After 7 years at ARUP, Banning         MLS(ASCP), initially saw a clini-
joined 3M Health Information              cal laboratory science degree as a       Kimberly Scott is a freelance writer
Systems (HIS) almost 19 years ago as      stepping-stone to medical school,        who lives in Lewes, Delaware.
a healthcare data analyst. In this job,   but after discussions with several       +EMAIL: kmscott2@verizon.net
New FDA Regulations, Hospital Glucose Meters
FDA Product Code PZI, 2019:
Blood Glucose Meter for Near-Patient Testing 

FDA Product Code NBW, 2019:
Blood Glucose Test System, Over the Counter. These device types are not
intended for use in healthcare or assisted-use settings such as hospitals,
physician offices, or long-term care facilities because they have not been
evaluated for use in these professional healthcare settings.

Use of a meter cleared by the FDA as Product Code NBW is
considered “OFF-LABEL” when used anywhere in a hospital. 
Is your hospital glucose meter cleared as FDA Product Code PZI
for hospital use or NBW cleared and off label for hospital use?

                                        GLUCOSE

                              Cleared as FDA Product Classification PZI.                                               novabiomedical.com
                              Intended for use in near-patient testing.

 U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Product Classification PZI. https://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/cdrh/cfdocs/cfpcd/classification.cfm?id=680
 U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Product Classification NBW. https://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/cdrh/cfdocs/cfpcd/classification.cfm?id=633
 U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Self-monitoring blood glucose test systems for over-the-counter use. Guidance for industry and Food and Drug Administration staff.
  Silver Spring, MD: 2018. https://www.fda.gov/media/87720/download
 Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Reissuance of S&C 15-11. https://www.cms.gov/Medicare/Provider-Enrollment-and-Certification/SurveyCertificationGenInfo/
  Downloads/Survey-and-Cert-Letter-15-11.PDF
Steve Gschmeissner / Science Source

                                      20
                                      J A NU A RY /F E B R U A RY 2020
JA NU A RY/ FE BR U A RY 2020   21

                 BY SUZANNE THIBODEAUX, MD, PHD

CAR-T
Cell Therapy
From a Clinical Laboratory Perspective
22                  J A NU A RY /F E B R U A RY 2020

Careful monitoring before and after infusion is critical
to successful treatment

             C
                           areful monitoring of       for manufacturing, either in-house
                           patients throughout the    where the cells were collected and the
                           duration of chimeric       patient will be infused, or at an exter-
                           antigen receptor           nal central manufacturing facility, the
           (CAR)-T cell therapy, including their      typical model for most sites (8).
           laboratory profiles, helps guide and           Many important considerations
           refine clinical management—from            for product preparation and trans-
           preparing and considering potential        port center on the safety of both
           candidates to monitoring the long-term     patient and product. Labs must use
           recovery of those who receive this         special handling for any product that
           powerful new therapy. Two CAR-T cell       requires cryopreservation before the
           products, tisagenlecleucel and axicabta-   product gets packaged and shipped.
           gene ciloleucel, have been approved by     This includes performing cell counts
           the Food and Drug Administration           on a hematology analyzer, character-
           (FDA) and are quickly becoming             izing the cellular composition by flow
           mainstays in hematologic and oncologic     cytometry, adding cryoprotectant and
           treatment strategies (See page 24). This   proper labeling, and checking both
           minireview considers CAR-T cell            patient and product identification
           therapy from the perspective of clinical   multiple times (8).
           laboratories, with the goal of empower-        During manufacturing, which can
           ing clinical laboratorians with informa-   take 2 weeks, patients need clinical
           tion so that patients receive optimal      monitoring to ensure that they remain
           care regardless of clinical setting.       stable until the CAR-T cells can be
                                                      infused. The manufacturing process
           The Role of Laboratories Before            is typically monitored by release
           CAR-T Cell Infusion                        testing, which helps ensure product
           Collecting source material is criti-       safety, purity, and potency. Laboratory
           cal to the CAR-T cell manufactur-          assessment typically includes product
           ing process. Since CAR-T cells are         composition by flow cytometric char-
           autologous, i.e. the donor is also the     acterization of CAR-T cells; product
           recipient, patients must be evaluated      sterility by microbial culture and
           carefully before they become can-          testing for endotoxin and mycoplasma
           didates for CAR-T cell therapy and         contamination; and functional assays
           cellular collection by apheresis. In the   to assess in vitro cytotoxic function
           case of tisagenlecleucel, patients must    and activation (9).
           stop certain treatments, including             Once manufacturing is complete
           allogeneic therapies and immunosup-        and testing has confirmed that the
           pressants, for up to 12 weeks before       product can be released for use, the
           apheresis collection. Monitoring           product is then frozen, shipped back
           hematologic parameters or immuno-          to the infusion site, and stored in a
           suppressant levels in the blood may        cellular therapy laboratory until the
           be necessary to ensure patients are        patient is ready for product infusion.          Detecting CAR-T cells themselves
           adequately prepared leading up to                                                      is not as straightforward. CAR-T cells
           cellular collection and continued dur-     After CAR-T Cell Infusion                   can exhibit atypical morphologic fea-
           ing treatment to adjust their therapy      After a patient has been infused with       tures, and methods to detect the CAR
           as needed to maintain their health         CAR-T cell product, the T cells ideally     protein itself are not commercially
           status (7).                                recognize their target antigen, activate,   available. In addition, the potential
                                                                                                                                            Steve Gschmeissner / Science Source

               Although most cellular collec-         and begin to proliferate and exert anti-    customization of CAR proteins pro-
           tions are successful, certain laboratory   tumor effects. Response to therapy can      hibits at this time development of any
           parameters are crucial to determine        be monitored by detecting malignant         single assay to detect CAR-T cells (2).
           whether a patient can proceed with         cells. The clinical lab examines periph-        Patients can exhibit expected and
           collection. There must be enough           eral blood or other potentially affected    unexpected effects from CAR-T cell
           T cells in the peripheral blood to be      tissues by standard means such as           therapy infusion. A well-characterized
           collected, as measured by absolute         examining peripheral blood smears for       and potentially serious adverse effect
           lymphocyte count and/or peripheral         morphology and/or using flow cytom-         is cytokine release syndrome (CRS).
           blood CD3 counts. After collection,        etry to detect malignant cells by protein   Characterized by high fever, organ dys-
           cells must be prepared and transported     expression (7).                             function, hypotension, and increasing
JA NU A RY/ FE BR U A RY 2020                     23

                                                                                     encephalopathy, agitation, delirium,
                                                                                     and seizures (10). Laboratory evalu-
                                                                                     ations currently do not aid in charac-
                                                                                     terizing neurotoxicity. The ASTCT
                                                                                     encouraged continued exploration of
                                                                                     potentially useful laboratory charac-
                                                                                     terization of patients who demonstrate
                                                                                     clinical signs and symptoms of adverse
                                                                                     events from CAR-T cell therapy (10).
                                                                                     Additional laboratory characterization
                                                                                     of patients who experience adverse
                                                                                     effects from CAR-T cells could help
                                                                                     inform the larger community about
                                                                                     laboratory testing that has diagnostic,
                                                                                     therapeutic, or prognostic potential for
                                                                                     CRS and neurotoxicity.
                                                                                         Notably, CAR-T cells can effec-
                                                                                     tively eliminate normal cells if they
                                                                                     express the target antigen; this phe-
                                                                                     nomenon is known as on-target/off-
                                                                                     tumor toxicity. In the context of the
                                                                                     FDA-approved therapies that target
                                                                                     CD19, B cell aplasia is an anticipated
                                                                                     effect, since normal B cells also express
                                                                                     CD19 and are therefore subject to
                                                                                     elimination by anti-CD19 CAR-T
                                                                                     cells. This requires monitoring patients
                                                                                     who receive CAR-T cells directed
                                                                                     against CD19 to assess whether they
                                                                                     develop B cell aplasia, mainly by
                                                                                     measuring serum gammaglobulins
                                                                                     (7). Hypoglobulinemia can be man-
                                                                                     aged clinically with immunoglobulin
                                                                                     replacement therapy.

                                                                                     ALTHOUGH MOST CELLULAR COLLECTIONS ARE
                                                                                     SUCCESSFUL, CERTAIN LABORATORY PARAM-
                                                                                     ETERS ARE CRUCIAL TO DETERMINE WHETHER
                                                                                     A PATIENT CAN PROCEED WITH COLLECTION.

oxygen requirements, CRS ranges           quantitation, are not widely available,        Clinical laboratorians should be
from mild to life-threatening and is      which translates into a long turnaround    aware of the potential laboratory
attributed to extremely high levels of    time since they must be sent out.          abnormalities that accompany treat-
cytokines, specifically interleukin 6     The nonspecific nature of other lab        ment with CAR-T cells. For example,
(IL-6) (10, 11).                          parameters that might be altered during    patients might experience cytopenias
    The American Society for              the course of CRS—such as ferritin         in the period following infusion. In
Transplantation and Cellular Therapy      and C-reactive protein—as well as the      this instance, they might resemble a
(ASTCT) recently published guidelines     potential lag time between symptoms        patient who has undergone a hema-
for defining and grading CRS. While       and altered lab values, support treat-     topoietic progenitor cell transplant,
certain aspects of CRS are almost         ing patients empirically based off their   although they received entirely differ-
certainly determined by laboratory        clinical presentation.                     ent cells. Prolonged B cell aplasia and
values, such as transaminitis and other       Neurotoxicity, also called immune      hypogammaglobulinemia associated
signs of organ dysfunction, laboratory    effector cell-associated neurotoxicity     with CAR-T cells directed to CD19
parameters are not included as factors    syndrome, is another adverse effect of     could predispose them to develop
to determine the presence or severity     CAR-T cell infusion and can present        infections. These patients might then
of CRS. Some tests, such as serum IL-6    with neurological symptoms such as         be similar to other patients who are
24                           J A NU A RY /F E B R U A RY 2020

How CAR-T Cell Therapy Works
Chimeric antigen receptor (CAR)-T cells are            The two Food and Drug Administration                Notably, while CAR-T cell products
autologous T cells that undergo genetic            (FDA)-approved CAR-T cell products in clinical      have shown very promising results, they
modification to express a receptor that            use—tisagenlecleucel (Kymriah) and axicabta-        have only gained approval for certain
contains four basic components: 1)                 gene ciloleucel (Yescarta)—both contain scfvs       hematologic malignancies and have
extracellular single chain variable fragment       directed against CD19, a cell surface protein       less-than-100% response rates. In addi-
(scvf) specific to a target antigen, 2) a          expressed on many B cell malignancies. The          tion, efforts to use CAR-T cells in solid
transmembrane region, 3) intracellular T           CAR constructs for the two commercial               malignancies have not yet proven success-
cell receptor (CD3 zeta chain), and 4) T cell      products differ mainly in the intracellular         ful. So while at this point CAR-T cell
co-receptor domain. The T cell receptor            costimulatory component that renders the            therapy has not yet been proven to be a
and co-receptor activates the T cell to            cytotoxic T cell function: CD28 in axicabta-        magic bullet, it does have the high
exert its cytotoxic T cell functions upon the      gene ciloleucel and CD137/4-1bb in tisagen-         potential to become a mainstay in
target cell (1).                                   lecleucel. They also differ in the vector used to   oncologic therapy.
    These CAR-T cell components are                deliver the genetic material into T lympho-             Most clinical and laboratory character-
customizable. For example, different scvfs         cytes: Tisagenlecleucel is manufactured using       ization in patients has taken place in the
can be used to recognize different targets,        a lentiviral vector, and axicabtagene ciloleucel    context of the two FDA-approved CAR-T
or different T cell coregulatory molecules         uses a gammaretroviral vector (2).                  cell products, and some laboratory profile
can be added. CAR-T cells, via the scvf,               It is interesting to speculate that these       components in patients are specific to the
recognize surface targets that are reproduc-       noted differences between the commercial            particular CAR T cell therapy. For instance,
ibly expressed on malignant cells and not          products might be due to the almost                 B cell aplasia is an expected side effect of
expressed on tissues that are known to             simultaneous and parallel progression of each       CAR-T cells directed against CD19, since
cause irreparable damage to nonmalignant           through the FDA approval process. As data           normal B cells also express CD19 and are
tissues that cannot be readily managed             accrue over time, the different profiles of the     therefore eliminated in the same manner as
clinically.                                        two CAR-T cell products might become                the malignant cells expressing CD19.
    CAR-T cells are manufactured from              clearer. Tisagenlecleucel and axicabtagene          However, this side effect would not be
peripheral blood T cells. After collection of      ciloleucel have shown impressive results            expected in a patient who received CAR-T
starting material by apheresis, the cells are      treating malignancies that, up until this point,    cells directed against a different target
transported to a processing facility where a       have had extremely poor prognoses (3).              antigen not expressed on B cells.
vector, typically retroviral in nature, contain-   Treatment with axicabtagene ciloleucel                  Familiarity with the different types of
ing the genetic material for the CAR is            demonstrated a 58% complete response rate           CAR-T cell products currently in clinical use
introduced into the T cells. The T cells are       after 2 years in patients with relapsed             as well as those in clinical development will
then cultured and stimulated to proliferate.       refractory diffuse large B cell lymphoma (3, 4).    be useful for anticipating potential
Once the desired number of cells for               Treatment with tisagenlecleucel yielded an          scenarios that might arise during evalua-
infusion has been obtained, the cells are          overall survival rate of 73% at 1 year (4). Both    tion of these patients. Laboratory involve-
transported back to the site of infusion. The      products received FDA approval for large B          ment is essential throughout the process of
patient then receives the cells, and is            cell lymphomas; tisagenlecleucel also has           CAR-T cell treatment so that care can be
monitored for response in both acute and           approval for relapsed and refractory B acute        delivered in a timely manner that optimizes
chronic settings (2).                              lymphoblastic leukemia (5, 6).                      patient outcomes.
You can also read