2020 Cocoa No-Deforestation & Agroforestry Action Plan Progress Report

Page created by Eric Reyes
 
CONTINUE READING
2020 Cocoa No-Deforestation & Agroforestry Action Plan Progress Report
Cocoa No-Deforestation &
 Agroforestry Action Plan
     Progress Report

     2020
2020 Cocoa No-Deforestation & Agroforestry Action Plan Progress Report
Content

Foreword3
Ou r C ommit ment                                                                       4
Ou r Approach                                                                           5
No -Deforestat ion & Ag roforest r y Ac t ion Pla n – Prog ress 2 02 0                  6
  Ke y Per for ma nc e I nd ic ators                                                    7
  O u r ach ie vement s                                                                11
  St at u s of No -Defore st at ion & Ag rofore st r y Ac t ion Pla n p er or ig i n   15

Insig ht: C ol lec t ive Ac t ion t hroug h t he L a ndsc ape Approach                 18
T he C ocoa & Forest Init iat ive – Prog ress 2 02 0                                   19
Key cha l lenges a nd way for wa rd                                                    21
A n nex : T he C ocoa & Forest Init iat ive – Deta i ls                                25
   P rog re s s Tr ac k i ng Table – Gha na                                            26
   P rog re s s Tr ac k i ng Table – C ote d ’ Ivoi re                                 29

                                      L I N D T & S P RÜ N G L I
                             MAÎTRE CHOCOLATIER SUISSE DEPUIS 1845
2020 Cocoa No-Deforestation & Agroforestry Action Plan Progress Report
3
                                                               N O - D E F O R E S TAT I O N A N D AG R O F O R E S T RY AC T I O N P L A N
                                                                                      PROGR E S S R EPORT 2 02 0

                                                                                   Foreword
Increased production of cocoa, especially in West Africa,      source any cocoa from protected areas and to avoid con-                        achieved progress in scaling activities and increasing our
has so far unfortunately gone hand in hand with the loss       version of valuable forest land for cocoa production in our                    efforts towards collective action. This included capacity
of tropical forests. Deforestation causes biodiversity loss,   supply chain. Our ▶ No-Deforestation & Agroforestry Ac-                        building for field staff and farmers, the distribution of
fosters climate change, and affects cocoa farmers’ liveli-     tion Plan, launched in 2019, covers all of our cocoa origins.                  shade trees and promotion of agroforestry, and joining proj-
hoods. Tropical forests have inherent value, and they also        The long-term nature of our engagement with cocoa                           ects with a Landscape Approach to address deforestation.
provide critical ecosystem services for neighbouring ag-       farmers – specifically those in the Lindt & Sprüngli Farm-                         This report shares our progress towards reaching our
ricultural production. Biodiverse forests absorb carbon        ing Program – provides the basis for tackling deforesta-                       ambition of a deforestation-free cocoa supply chain by
dioxide, help to stabilize the climate, and regulate the       tion in our cocoa supply chain. During the first year of                       2025 (which means for us covered by a fully implemented
water cycle by contributing to local rainfall. They also       implementation of the Action Plan, we developed proce-                         No-Deforestation & Agroforestry Action Plan), and high-
protect farmers against floods, drought, and soil erosion,     dures, piloted and launched new activities, deepened our                       lights our achievements, challenges, and key learnings to
among countless other benefits. Yet, forests continue to       understanding, and learned how to best approach each                           guide our journey in the coming years.
be lost and degraded at alarming rates.                        activity. Details can be found in the ▶ No-Deforestation &
    To contribute to ending deforestation and forest deg-      Agroforestry Progress Report 2019. 2020 marked the sec-
radation, Lindt & Sprüngli has comitted to ensure to not       ond year of implementation. Building on a solid basis, we
2020 Cocoa No-Deforestation & Agroforestry Action Plan Progress Report
4
                                                                               N O - D E F O R E S TAT I O N A N D AG R O F O R E S T RY AC T I O N P L A N
                                                                                                      PROGR E S S R EPORT 2 02 0

                                                                                   Our Commitment
Lindt & Sprüngli implements its commitment to source
all its cocoa from areas free from deforestation by 2025
(= covered by a fully implemented No-Deforestation &
Agroforestry Action Plan) 1 through our No-Deforestation
& Agroforestry Action Plan and in collaboration with our
supply chain partners. The Action Plan outlines four
primary objectives:

               No cocoa sourcing from
               protected areas as per
               local laws

               No expansion of land for cocoa cultiva-
               tion into areas defined by the High
               Carbon Stock Approach or equivalent

               Agroforestry systems for
               cocoa production

               Supporting (community) forest
               protection and restoration

1
     ur goal to source all cocoa free of deforestation means by 2025 we will fully implement the multiple measures defined in the Action Plan to prevent deforestation and promote agroforestry. Already since 2019, farmers in our
    O
    supply chain are no longer allowed to clear forest. One of the first measures implemented as part of the Action Plan was, based on farm mapping and overlaying of these maps with protected areas, to immediately stop sourcing
    from protected areas as per local laws and to introduce new processes to control and prevent Program farmers are involved in clearing land in protected land or HCV/HCS areas. The Action Plan is a long-term process to work
    towards our commitment. As we assume responsibility of our supply chain and work with traceability and segregation (not based on the Mass-Balance approach), the implementation of a sustainability program is a pre-­requisite
    for compliance with the Action Plan. We are currently working on achieving our target of 100% sustainably source cocoa by 2025. Along with the increase of sustainably sourced cocoa, the Action Plan will be implemented
    stepwise in all supply chains. The implementation of these processes in the cocoa bean supply chain is reviewed annually as part of the Earthworm Foundation's external assessment of the Farming Program.

                                                                                                      L I N D T & S P RÜ N G L I
                                                                                             MAÎTRE CHOCOLATIER SUISSE DEPUIS 1845
2020 Cocoa No-Deforestation & Agroforestry Action Plan Progress Report
5
                                                              N O - D E F O R E S TAT I O N A N D AG R O F O R E S T RY AC T I O N P L A N
                                                                                     PROGR E S S R EPORT 2 02 0

                                                                         Our Approach
We operationalize our commitment through the ▶ No-
Deforestation & Agroforestry Action Plan for cocoa.                                                                                          The ▶ World Cocoa Foundation (WCF); ▶ IDH, the Sus-
Separate action plans are in place for each of our cocoa                                                                                     tainable Trade Initiative; and the governments of Côte
origins, adapting the global Action Plan to the local                                                                                        d’Ivoire and Ghana drive the Cocoa & Forests Initia-
context.                                                         The Cocoa & Forests Initiative (CFI): Collective                            tive. The Prince of Wales launched the Initiative in
    For cocoa beans, country-specific action plans are in-       Action to End Cocoa-Related Deforestation                                   March 2017 and reviewed implementation progress in
corporated into our sustainability program for cocoa             The governments of Côte d’Ivoire and Ghana and 35                           November 2018.
beans, the ▶ Lindt & Sprüngli Farming Program. This Pro-         leading cocoa and chocolate companies, representing                             Deforestation of tropical rainforests is a major issue
gram is implemented together with our suppliers and              85% of global cocoa usage, have joined together in the                      in Côte d’Ivoire and Ghana, which together produce
other partners. To ensure efficient integration, the Action      ▶ Cocoa & Forests Initiative to end deforestation and                       nearly two-thirds of the world’s supply of cocoa, the
Plan elements are structured along the four pillars of the       restore forest areas. Their combined actions play a cru-                    main ingredient in chocolate. ▶ Côte d'Ivoire and
Lindt & Sprüngli Farming Program: Traceability & Farmer          cial role in sequestering carbon stocks in West African                     ▶ Ghana respectively lost 25% and 8% of their humid
Organization, Training and Knowledge Transfer, Farmer            forests and addressing climate change, in line with the                     primary forest between 2002 – 2019, with a significant
Investments & Community Development and finally, Ver-            Paris Climate Agreement. The Cocoa & Forests Initia-                        portion of deforestation attributable to cocoa farming
ification & Continuous Progress.                                 tive delivers on Sustainable Development Goal 13 (Cli-                      expansion.
    Cocoa-driven deforestation is of particular relevance        mate Action) and 15 (Life on Land).                                             Cocoa provides crucial employment and income to
in West Africa, where most cocoa is grown. Working to-              The Cocoa & Forests Initiative is a public private                       smallholders in West Africa. An accelerated transition
wards no-deforestation and agroforestry therefore re-            partnership based on frameworks for action (▶ Côte                          to sustainable livelihoods is essential for ensuring their
quires commitments from all actors with influence on the         d’Ivoire and ▶ Ghana) and action plans for the private                      long-term economic security. Thanks to public and
forest landscapes. Implementing effective measures – such        sector (▶ Côte d’Ivoire and ▶ Ghana) and public sector                      private sector actions, notably through the Cocoa &
as formalized forest management plans and improved               (▶ Côte d’Ivoire and ▶ Ghana) that spell out commit-                        Forests Initiative, this transition is under way, with
governance for forest protection – is a shared responsibil-      ments to:                                                                   recent reports (from ▶ Global Forest Watch and the
ity and requires coordinated and collaborative efforts of        — protect and restore forests,                                              ▶ United Nations) showing that the rate of primary for-
governments, companies, and civil society organizations.         — promote sustainable cocoa production and                                  est loss was halved in both Côte d’Ivoire and Ghana
In 2017, Lindt & Sprüngli became signatory of the Cocoa             farmers’ livelihoods,                                                    from 2018 to 2019.
& Forest Initiative (CFI), a regional public-private part-       — engage communities and boost social inclusion.
nership. Our cocoa beans and cocoa butter sourced
through a sustainability program from Ghana and Côte
d’Ivoire are covered by our commitment to the Cocoa &
Forests Initiative (CFI). Based on the CFI framework, we
have committed to multi-year CFI targets (see annex with
our targets on page 25) and annual action plans, which
are integrated into our sustainability programs for cocoa
beans and butter in both countries.                                                  L I N D T & S P RÜ N G L I
                                                                            MAÎTRE CHOCOLATIER SUISSE DEPUIS 1845
2020 Cocoa No-Deforestation & Agroforestry Action Plan Progress Report
6
                    N O - D E F O R E S TAT I O N A N D AG R O F O R E S T RY AC T I O N P L A N
                                           PROGR E S S R EPORT 2 02 0

        No-Deforestation & Agroforestry
         Action Plan – Progress 2020
 Despite the challenges associated with the global Covid-19 pandemic causing a
     variety of restrictions affecting work with farmers in the field, we made
 considerable progress together with our suppliers and partners. Good progress
  was made in terms of scaling activities, establishing management processes,
and strengthening key intervention areas in accordance with the results from our
   internal progress analysis and external verification. We further engaged in
      increasing collaborative action to scale our efforts beyond farm-level.
2020 Cocoa No-Deforestation & Agroforestry Action Plan Progress Report
7
                                                                                    N O - D E F O R E S TAT I O N A N D AG R O F O R E S T RY AC T I O N P L A N
                                                                                                           PROGR E S S R EPORT 2 02 0

                                                                                                Key Performance Indicators
The indicators below track key progress towards the goals                                                                                                          We are proud that after 12 years of groundwork, we suc-
of our No-Deforestation & Agroforestry commitment.                                                                                                                 cessfully achieved our cocoa bean commitment in 2020:
                                                                                                                                                                   100% of the cocoa beans we source come from a fully
                                                                                                                                                                   traceable and externally verified supply chain. The Farm-
 No-Deforestation & Agroforestry Action Plan Indicators                                                                                                            ing Program is implemented in all five of our cocoa bean
 Scope: all cocoa (beans, butter, powder, finished chocolate). ICCO conversion rates used.
                                                                                                                                                                   origins, typically with multiple suppliers per country.
Indicator                                                                                              2019               2020              Goal 2025              Further, we increased the percentage of segregated and
% of cocoa (in volume) sourced from farmers covered by a                                               56%                63%               100%                   verified cocoa butter from 27% in 2019 to 33% in 2020,
“No-Deforestation & Agroforestry Action Plan” 2
                                                                                                                                                                   and continued to improve and expand our sustainable
% of cocoa (in volume) sourced from farms proven not to be                                             47%                60%               100%
located in protected areas as per local laws 3
                                                                                                                                                                   cocoa butter programs. These improvements resulted in
% of cocoa (in volume) sourced from farmers covered by a fully                                         0%                 0%                100%
                                                                                                                                                                   63% 4 of our cocoa products (beans, butter, powder and
implemented “No-Deforestation & Agroforestry Action Plan”                                                                                                          finished chocolate) being sourced through sustainability
# of shade trees distributed through sustainable cocoa sourcing Programs                               484,332            876,036           Farmers have avg.      programs and covered by a No-Deforestation & Agrofor-
                                                                                                                                            25 shade trees per     estry Action Plan. The volume of cocoa sourced from
# since start of Programs                                                                              1,387,067          2,263,103         hectare on farms
                                                                                                                                                                   farms proven not be located in protected areas as per local
                                                                                                                                                                   laws is slightly lower at 60%, because some farms in the
                                                                                                                                                                   most important supply chain in Ghana still need to be
                                                                                                                                                                   mapped and undergo legality checks, while in Ecuador
                                                                                                                                                                   some farms will only be counted once they are more close-
                                                                                                                                                                   ly monitored and supported (see details page 8).
                                                                                                                                                                      The implementation of the Action Plan is a long-term
                                                                                                                                                                   process, we do not yet have any cocoa volumes covered by
                                                                                                                                                                   a fully implemented Action Plan to report. However, a
                                                                                                                                                                   considerable effort was made to increase the scale and
                                                                                                                                                                   speed of shade tree distribution. 876,036 shade trees were
                                                                                                                                                                   distributed in 2020, which represents an 80% increase
                                                                                                                                                                   compared to 2019.

                                                                                                                                                                   2
                                                                                                                                                                        overed by a No-Deforestation Action Plans means that a supply chain
                                                                                                                                                                       C
                                                                                                                                                                       is either covered by our own action plan, by CFI or both.
                                                                                                                                                                   3
                                                                                                                                                                        lease note that this indicator does not mean that the rest of the cocoa
                                                                                                                                                                       P
                                                                                                                                                                       comes from protected areas. Our cocoa supply chain is not yet fully
                                                                                                                                                                       traceable, and GPS mapping of farmers is still ongoing.
                                                                                                                                                                   4
                                                                                                                                                                       using the ICCO conversion factors

                                                                                                           L I N D T & S P RÜ N G L I
                                                                                                  MAÎTRE CHOCOLATIER SUISSE DEPUIS 1845
2020 Cocoa No-Deforestation & Agroforestry Action Plan Progress Report
8
                                                                                   N O - D E F O R E S TAT I O N A N D AG R O F O R E S T RY AC T I O N P L A N
                                                                                                          PROGR E S S R EPORT 2 02 0

    Indicators from Lindt & Sprüngli Farming Program Theory of Change
    Scope: 100% of our cocoa bean sourcing supply chain (=from the Lindt & Sprüngli Farming Program).
    Total number of farmers in Program was 79,979 in cocoa season 2019/20.

Indicator                                                                                               2019             2020              Goal 2025
# of farmers proven not to be located in protected areas as per local laws 5                            58,124 (74%)     75,625 (95%)      100%

# of farmers with minimum 25 permanent shade trees per hectare                                          10,584 (13%)     10,870 (13%)      100%

# of farmers with minimum 5 permanent shade tree species per hectare                                    41,711 (52%)     41,952 (52%)      100%

Average number of permanent shade trees per hectare                                                     13               15                25

Average number of shade tree species per hectare                                                        4                4                 5

We have made considerable progress in the Farming Pro-
gram supply chains regarding our commitment to not
source from any farmers located in protected areas. GPS
mapping (points or polygons) and legality checks of the
last 5% of farmers are ongoing. Part of those are some
farmers in Ecuador, who are located in protected areas.
The concerned areas are not National Parks or Reserves
but do include High Conservation Value (HCV) areas, for
example around important watersheds where agricultural
production is permitted by the government. The con-
cerned Farming Program farmers hold government per-
mits to operate in these areas, which was reviewed as part
of the legality check. We are currently implementing
additional support and provide guidance for the farmers
in these areas to make sure their farming practices are in
line with conservation principles. They will only be count-
ed as fully compliant once they are completely covered by
additional support and monitoring.

5
     lease note that this indicator does not mean that the rest of the farmers
    P
    are located in protected forests as per local laws. GPS mapping of farms
    did not yet cover 100% of farmers in the Program at the end of season
    2019/20.

                                                                                                           L I N D T & S P RÜ N G L I
                                                                                                  MAÎTRE CHOCOLATIER SUISSE DEPUIS 1845
2020 Cocoa No-Deforestation & Agroforestry Action Plan Progress Report
9
N O - D E F O R E S TAT I O N A N D AG R O F O R E S T RY AC T I O N P L A N
                       PROGR E S S R EPORT 2 02 0

                                                                               The Farming Program indicators also show our progress
                                                                               regarding the promotion of agroforestry systems. Com-
                                                                               pared to season 2018/19, a considerable increase in shade
                                                                               trees and shade tree species on farms has been registered.
                                                                               However, our data analysis and reliability checks revealed
                                                                               that this data may not be fully reliable. Data collection in
                                                                               field is challenging, and sample and measurement meth-
                                                                               odologies differ across origins. Because the internal mon-
                                                                               itoring and data collection process was already finished
                                                                               by the time of reporting, re-collection and on-site verifi-
                                                                               cation of data was not possible. As an immediate action,
                                                                               we will develop additional guidance on data collection
                                                                               and aggregation of agroforestry indicators for the field
                                                                               staff and engage our suppliers to streamline the data col-
                                                                               lection, analysis and reporting process for the next season.
                                                                                   In parallel, we are actively supporting technical solu-
                                                                               tions to measure this kind of data (see page 21). We are
                                                                               collaborating with the ▶ Swiss Federal Institute of Tech-
                                                                               nology (ETH) to develop methods to remotely measure
                                                                               shade levels and reliably monitor our progress and con-
                                                                               tribution to agroforestry. Upon completion of this project,
                                                                               we hope to be able to measure and report on the indicator
                                                                               # of farmers with minimum 30% shade cover on cocoa
                                                                               farms. Read more about this project in the respective
                                                                               ▶ Project Fact Sheet.

                       L I N D T & S P RÜ N G L I
              MAÎTRE CHOCOLATIER SUISSE DEPUIS 1845
2020 Cocoa No-Deforestation & Agroforestry Action Plan Progress Report
10
                                                        N O - D E F O R E S TAT I O N A N D AG R O F O R E S T RY AC T I O N P L A N
                                                                               PROGR E S S R EPORT 2 02 0

                                          Achievements within the Farming Program (cocoa beans) since 2008
                                                          (Indicators by end of September 2020 – end of 2019/20 cocoa season)

             100%
             of sourced cocoa beans are
                                                      443
                                                      field staff financed by the
                                                                                                                5     origins
                                                                                                                 of cocoa
                                                                                                                                                                          79,979
                                                                                                                                                                          farmers participating in the
             traceable and externally                 Farming Program support                                    beans covered                                            Farming Program across
             verified in 2020                         and advise the farmers                                                                                              all countries of origin

Higher productivity                                                                              Diversified long-term incomes and increased
on farms                                                                                         resilience of farming households
                                                       158
                                                       cocoa farming model farms
                                                                                                 10,961
                                                                                                 farmers with additional income-
                                                       5,990,841                                 generating activities since start
                                                       cocoa seedlings distributed               of the Program
                                                       since start of the Program
                                                                                                                                       3,014
                                                       (with 325,095 cocoa seedlings
                                                       distributed in 2019/20 cocoa
                                                                                                 21,883                                community members partici-
                                                                                                 farmers trained in additional         pating in a total of 137 Village
                                                       season)                                   income-generating activities          Savings and Loan Associations
                                                                                                 since start of the Program            (VSLAs) or equivalent

Conservation of biodiversity and natural ecosystems
                                                                          1,940,122
                                                                          shade tree seedlings distributed
67,462                                                                    since start of the Program
farmers with all farms                                                    (666,048 distributed in 2019/20
GPS located                                                               cocoa season)
                                                                                                                41,952
                                                                                                                (52%) farmers with at least
                                                                          4                                     5 permanent shade tree
                                                                          shade tree species per                species per hectare
                                                                          hectare on average
                                                                                                                10,870
                                                                          15                                    (14%) farmers with at least
                                                                          permanent shade trees                 25 permanent shade trees
                                                                          per hectare on average                per hectare

                                                                               L I N D T & S P RÜ N G L I
                                                                      MAÎTRE CHOCOLATIER SUISSE DEPUIS 1845
11
                                                                 N O - D E F O R E S TAT I O N A N D AG R O F O R E S T RY AC T I O N P L A N
                                                                                        PROGR E S S R EPORT 2 02 0

                                                                                      Our achievements
Based on the solid groundwork laid in the first year of
implementation, 2020 marked our second year of imple-
mentation of the Action Plan. For our cocoa bean supply
chains, implementation was done by 443 field staff
financed by the Lindt & Sprüngli Farming Program in the
countries of origin. The field staff is responsible for im-
plementing the guidelines of the No-Deforestation &
Agroforestry Action Plan into practice. Our local imple-
mentation partners were sensitized to the concepts and
topics of the action plan (such as agroforestry), and ac-
companied by select specialist organizations, including
the ▶ Earthworm Foundation, ▶ ECOTOP or ▶ ICRAF to
develop their knowledge and capacity to implement the
Action Plan. For years, Lindt & Sprüngli has built part-
nerships with several organizations, including ▶ NCRC,
▶ Helvetas or ▶ WCF, to create synergies and connect the
Program in different origins to other relevant local sus-
tainability initiatives.

Traceability and farm mapping
Through implementation of the Lindt & Sprüngli Farm-             to ensure that we are not sourcing cocoa from forests or
ing Program over the years, suppliers have built robust          protected areas. Today, 95% of our Farming Program
traceability systems for our sustainable cocoa to ensure         farmers across all five cocoa bean origins have GPS plot-
it is clearly marked and traceable back to farmers. Trace-       ted or mapped the boundaries (“polygon”) of all their
ability systems are now fully in place and all of the Action     farms. In the CFI countries, mapping has been finalized
Plan requirements are integrated into Farming Program            for 80% of farmers in Ghana and 76% in Côte d’Ivoire,
activities, processes, and monitoring and verification           where we have a sustainable cocoa butter program.
systems.
     Aside from implementing robust traceability systems
that allow us to accurately identify the exact origin of our
cocoa beans, we implemented processes and procedures
to onboard new and monitor existing farmers. This in-
cludes GPS mapping the farms in our supply chain. Hav-
ing full visibility of where farmers are located is a key step

                                                                                        L I N D T & S P RÜ N G L I
                                                                               MAÎTRE CHOCOLATIER SUISSE DEPUIS 1845
Training and knowledge transfer
                                                                                                                             An important pillar of our No-Deforestation & Agrofor-
                                                                                                                             estry Action Plan is training & knowledge transfer. Our
                                                                                                                             Farming Program curriculum includes good agricultural,
                                                                                                                             social, environmental practices, and it is adapted and im-
                                                                                                                             proved on a continuous basis. As the Farming Program
                                                                                                                             has been running for several years in many origins and
                                                                                                                             is well-established, new training methodologies and top-
                                                                                                                             ics are being included. Environmental training modules
                                                                                                                             are becoming more important as trainings on No-Defor-
                                                                                                                             estation and conservation principles in agriculture are
                                                                                                                             being rolled out. As a first step, the capacity building
                                                                                                                             of the field staff is provided to ensure the team has the
                                                                                                                             knowledge to train the farmers. The knowledge transfer
                                                                                                                             on HCV/HCS training is done by our partner Earthworm
                                                                                                                             Foundation. The concepts behind the Action Plan are
                                                                                                                             transferred into practical guidelines for farmers, for
                                                                                                                             example guidelines on farm extension or the protection
                                                                                                                             of riparian areas and water bodies. Agroforestry trainings
Identification and protection of valuable forest patches      In Madagascar, an in-depth landscape assessment is per-        (see below) have been introduced for a small group of
in cocoa producing areas                                      formed to identify priority zones for conservation and         farmers and should be scaled to all the farmers in the
In 2020, we continued our collaboration with the ▶ Earth-     carbon stock (HCV and HCS), ecological restoration, and        coming years. This will deliver environmental value in
worm Foundation to better understand and protect valu-        diversified cocoa production. The results will be integrated   addition to benefits to farmers and the community in
able forest patches close to the farms in our supply chain.   into a landscape management plan which will be devel-          terms of diversifying incomes and improving food secu-
To this end, we piloted an integrated High Carbon Stock       oped and managed by a local governance body in the             rity. In the CFI origins, trainings on Climate Smart Cocoa
(HCS) / High Carbon Value (HCV) assessment within the         frame of a multi-stakeholder landscape project.                (CSC), in which farmers learn about the effects of climate
supply chain in the Enchi district of Ghana last year. The       Conducting HCV/HCS assessments is a resource-in-            change on their cocoa production and how to mitigate
▶ High Carbon Stock Approach (HCSA) is a methodology          tense exercise due to the wide dispersion of farms across      these negative effects, was scaled to a major group of farm-
that distinguishes forest areas for protection (together      different regions in each origin. Therefore, we are inno-      ers, and will be provided to all the farmers in our sustain-
with HCV) from degraded lands with low carbon and             vating with the Earthworm Foundation to identify and           ability programs in the next two years.
biodiversity values. Our work in Enchi continued with a       manage conservation areas at the farm level. The meth-             Along with the curricula, training methods are in-
study on potential incentive mechanisms to protect valu-      odology of “Holistic Farm Plans” will be developed and         creasingly shifting from general group trainings to more
able, unprotected rural forests through engagement with       piloted in our two supply chains in Ecuador with the aim       tailored capacity-building workshops based on farmer
farmers and communities. Once available, the results will     to support farmers by co-creating a vision for the devel-      segmentation. Further, in many supply chains, trainings
provide insights to the discussion around potential en-       opment of the entire farm in accordance with conserva-         are complemented with coaching visits and the provision
gagement and incentive schemes for forest conservation        tion principles through participatory engagement with          of farm development plans tailored to the needs of the
at farm and community level.                                  the farmers and their families. The pilot will specifically    farmers. The more personalized support to farmers helps
                                                              engage farmers close to protected areas.                       keep them motivated to participate in the Program.
                                                                                  L I N D T & S P RÜ N G L I
                                                                         MAÎTRE CHOCOLATIER SUISSE DEPUIS 1845
13
                                                                 N O - D E F O R E S TAT I O N A N D AG R O F O R E S T RY AC T I O N P L A N
                                                                                        PROGR E S S R EPORT 2 02 0

Distribution of multi-purpose shade trees                        By combining the agroforestry-related support with train-
and promotion of agroforestry                                    ings on holistic farm management and climate-smart
Promoting agroforestry systems continues to be a prior-          agriculture, we look to support our farmer base by creat-
ity for Lindt & Sprüngli. In season 2019/20, shade tree          ing greater economic resilience.
distribution was scaled up in all our origin countries. We
distributed 876,036 shade trees (of which 809,964 in CFI         Investments in productivity, additional income
origins), now totaling 2,263,103 multi-purpose shade trees       opportunities and access to financial products
distributed since our efforts started. Shade trees were          Complementary to farmer trainings and the promotion
planted on farms as well as in riparian buffer zones, where      of agroforestry systems, we continued to make invest-
necessary.                                                       ments to increase productivity and support farmers in the
    We further worked on monitoring and gaining a better         creation of additional income generating activities and
understanding of the challenges and critical success factors     access to financial products. In many origins, income di-
of implementation, for example, regarding the survival rates     versification workshops and financial literacy trainings
of shade trees in the field. To this end, we started several     are currently being scaled up.
projects with specialized organizations to assess our current        In Madagascar, after an analysis of the most suitable
efforts, identify gaps and build the local staff’s capacity to   supply chains for farm and income diversification, we will
support farmers to establish and optimize agroforestry.          launch trainings on ginger, vanilla, small livestock and
    In Ecuador we engaged ▶ ECOTOP, an organization              honey production in season 2020/21. As a complementa-
specialized in dynamic agroforestry methods, to support          ry measure, we accelerated the establishment of new Vil-
the implementation partners by helping them to design            lage Saving and Loan Associations (VSLA) groups to
and establish dynamic agroforestry demonstration plots.          support communities. In the Dominican Republic, we
These are tailored to the local conditions in Ecuador and        facilitated access to a savings cooperative. In Papua New
for different types of farms. In dynamic agroforestry, the       Guinea, farmers were supported to open bank accounts.
farm functions as a system so that external inputs become        In Ghana, 50 new VSLAs were set up in Farming Program
redundant. During season 2019/20, the first five plots were      communities within the season, bringing the total to 137
established, properly managed and maintained through-            functioning VSLAs with 3,014 members. The Farming
out the year with remote support from ECOTOP. The plots          Program in Ghana further provided training on addi-
have raised the interest of farmers, as the first food crops     tional income opportunities to 19,543 farmers (30%). As
were harvested. The work has shown that farmers must             a result, 10,755 of the farmers were able to generate ad-
be accompanied very closely during the starting phase,           ditional non-cocoa income. Furthermore, we defined
which is highly resource intense. Additionally, farmers          eligibility criteria for a new revolving fund designed to
are interested in what crops fit into the agroforestry mod-      support farmers’ adoption of alternative income-gener-
el and can also be sold on the local market. The aspect of       ating activities. Twenty eligible farmers are so far regis-
marketing the multiple crops produced on dynamic agro-           tered to benefit from the revolving fund once it launches
forestry farms needs further attention in the near future.       in the 2020/21 season.
    In Ghana and the Dominican Republic, we have part-
nered with research institutions to evaluate our current
actions and define how our approach could be strengthened.
                                                                                        L I N D T & S P RÜ N G L I
                                                                               MAÎTRE CHOCOLATIER SUISSE DEPUIS 1845
14
                                                             N O - D E F O R E S TAT I O N A N D AG R O F O R E S T RY AC T I O N P L A N
                                                                                    PROGR E S S R EPORT 2 02 0

                                                             sources from, are now linked to landscape initiatives. In                      competing interests in this multifunctional landscape. In
                                                             the Kakum and the Juabeso / Bia West landscapes, two                           the first months of the project, the landscape assessment
                                                             key sourcing regions in which protected areas are sur-                         started to identify High Carbon Stock (HCS) and High
                                                             rounded by cocoa farmers, we have partnered with the                           Conservation Value (HCV) areas: the priority risk zones
                                                             ▶ Nature Conservation Research Centre (NCRC), a local                          for deforestation. Further, a stakeholder analysis and first
                                                             organization specialized in community-based conserva-                          multi-stakeholder meetings were performed to build up
                                                             tion (see ▶ Project Factsheet Kakum Sustainable Cocoa                          a locally rooted governance system.
                                                             Landscape) and support two projects. Both projects will
                                                             build on existing community-based resource-manage-                             Active participation in sector initiatives
                                                             ment structures to build a functioning, well-integrated                        As part of the activities to implement our Action Plan, we
                                                             local governance system for landscape planning and pres-                       are signatories of the ▶ Cocoa and Forest Initiative (CFI).
                                                             ervation. To this end, we collaborate with our farmers                         Through this partnership, we engage with other key play-
                                                             and suppliers, as well as other companies, farming com-                        ers in the cocoa and chocolate industry, as well as the
                                                             munities and local authorities. To better assess the impact                    governments of Ghana and Côte d’Ivoire, to stop co-
                                                             of such collective action for conservation, we participate                     coa-related deforestation. Specific CFI indicators are in
                                                             in testing a monitoring & evaluation approach to measure                       the annex of this report (see page 26) and cover the Farm-
                                                             progress at the landscape level (see ▶ Project Factsheet).                     ing Program and our sustainability programs for cocoa
                                                             Its development is co-funded by the ▶ Lindt Cocoa Foun-                        butter in Ghana and Côte d’Ivoire. Further, we continued
                                                             dation. Additionally, the two landscape projects will pi-                      our active participation in the Biodiversity & Ecosystems
                                                             lot ▶ Landscale, a sustainability standard for landscapes.                     working group of the ▶ Swiss Platform for Sustainable
                                                             The ▶ Asunafo-Asutifi Landscape programme, our third                           Cocoa. This working group promotes information ex-
Engagement in collection action at landscape level           engagement at the landscape level in Ghana, was recent-                        change and learning between all members and takes a
As announced in the previous progress report, we iden-       ly initiated by the World Cocoa Foundation (WCF) in                            leading role in defining the biodiversity targets, which
tified landscape initiatives relevant to our supply chains   partnership with ▶ Proforest and several CFI member                            will be a crucial element of this multi-stakeholder initia-
to work towards climate-resilient and deforestation-free     companies.                                                                     tive in the future.
landscapes in partnership with other actors. We made             In Madagascar, we launched a multi-stakeholder land-
good progress regarding our engagement in supporting         scape project (▶ Project Factsheet) in collaboration with
landscape-level efforts and are currently engaged in four    ▶ Helvetas Swiss Intercooperation (Helvetas), the ▶ Swiss
initiatives, three in Ghana and one in Madagascar. All       State Secretariat for Economic Affairs (SECO), ▶ Earth-
long-term engagements just started and considerable ef-      worm Foundation, the ▶ University of Berne and other
forts will be needed to successfully implement them.         private sector partners. The collaborative efforts target
    In Ghana, our sustainable cocoa comes from four out      the cocoa-producing region of the Sambirano valley and
of six Hotspot Intervention Areas (HIA). HIAs are pri-       aim for sustainably managed landscapes to contribute to
ority cocoa production regions in proximity to important     resilient livelihoods for the local population, and for defor-
forest reserves and national parks. The areas were defined   estation-free cocoa production. The project, coordinated
by the government as priority areas for coordinated sus-     by Helvetas, supports the development and implementation
tainability efforts. Three of the four HIAs our company      of an adequate planning instrument that considers the

                                                                                    L I N D T & S P RÜ N G L I
                                                                           MAÎTRE CHOCOLATIER SUISSE DEPUIS 1845
15
                                                             N O - D E F O R E S TAT I O N A N D AG R O F O R E S T RY AC T I O N P L A N
                                                                                    PROGR E S S R EPORT 2 02 0

                                            Status of No-Deforestation & Agroforestry Action Plan per origin

                                                                                                                                                                                                               New Guinea
                                                                                                                                                                                                  Madagascar

                                                                                                                                                                                                                            Dominican
                                                                                                                                                                                                                            Republic
                                                                                                                                                                                        Ecuador
                                                                                                                                                                                Ghana

                                                                                                                                                                                                               Papua
The activities of our Action Plan are structured along       Activity                              Description
the four pillars of the Lindt & Sprüngli Farming Program.    GPS Farm Mapping                      Cocoa plots of all farmers are GPS mapped (polygon or point; in buffer
The details in the individual origin action plans and de-                                          zones and close to protected forests always polygon).

fined priority activities vary due to different local cir-   Check legality of farm locations      Farm points/maps are compared with official protected forest maps,
                                                                                                   and legality of farm location with regards to protected forests checked.
cumstances. The tables below summarize progress on
                                                             Follow-up actions of farm mapping     a) Farmers already in the Program:
the implementation of activities within each of the five     and legality check                    In case legality check reveals issues, they are reported and solved,
Lindt & Sprüngli Farming Program cocoa bean origins.                                               together with the respective local authorities/institutions and farmers.

                                                                                                   b) Farmers newly joining the Program:
1. Traceability and Farmer Organization                                                            In case legality check reveals issues, farmers are not allowed to join the
Ensure no cocoa sourcing from protected areas,                                                     Program, and reported to the respective local authorities/institutions.

and no expansion of cocoa cultivation into forests           Notification when extending farms     All farmers are informed that they have to notify field staff when they
                                                                                                   extend their farms (either extension of existing farm or establishing new
                                                                                                   farm), so that farm mapping followed by legality and HCS/HCV area
                                                                                                   check can be made, and if necessary, farm expansion into forests can
                                                                                                   be avoided. If internal monitoring or external verification reveals that
                                                                                                   farmers still expanded into HCS/HCV, or if expansion into HCS/HCV is
                                                                                                   made without notifying field staff, they are excluded from the Program.
             fully implemented                               New farmers joining Program           Farmers that join the Program and passed the legality check, but farm
                                                                                                   on land that was deforested until 4 years before joining the Program,
             partially implemented                                                                 are prioritized for agroforestry systems.

             not yet implemented                             Traceability up to Lindt & Sprüngli   Every cocoa bean delivery is traceable up to Lindt & Sprüngli. We
                                                                                                   receive traceability certificates, indicating locations and farmers behind
                                                                                                   deliveries. At all levels, cocoa is clearly marked and kept segregated.
             improvement

                                                                                     L I N D T & S P RÜ N G L I
                                                                            MAÎTRE CHOCOLATIER SUISSE DEPUIS 1845
16
                                                           N O - D E F O R E S TAT I O N A N D AG R O F O R E S T RY AC T I O N P L A N
                                                                                  PROGR E S S R EPORT 2 02 0

                                                                                                                                                                                                             New Guinea
                                                                                                                                                                                                Madagascar

                                                                                                                                                                                                                          Dominican
                                                                                                                                                                                                                          Republic
                                                                                                                                                                                      Ecuador
                                                                                                                                                                              Ghana

                                                                                                                                                                                                             Papua
2. Training and Knowledge Transfer                         Activity                              Description
Ensure field staff and farmers are capable of implement-   Training of field staff               All field staff is trained on the content and implications of
ing our No-Deforestation & Agroforestry commitment                                               this Action Plan.

                                                           Farmer trainings                      All farmers are sensitized and trained on:
                                                                                                 – This Action Plan (content and implications), including the
                                                                                                    importance of a mid- and long-term view for their farm prosperity
                                                                                                 – Good Agricultural Practices (GAP), with focus on higher yield
                                                                                                    per hectare
                                                                                                 – Good Environmental Practices (GEP), with focus on organic
                                                                                                    farming methods, biodiversity, forest protection
                                                                                                 – Sustainable intensification, integrated farm management and
                                                                                                    farm diversification
                                                                                                 – Agroforestry systems, shade management and climate smart cocoa
                                                                                                 – Farm renovation and rehabilitation

                                                                                                                                                                                                             New Guinea
                                                                                                                                                                                                Madagascar

                                                                                                                                                                                                                          Dominican
                                                                                                                                                                                                                          Republic
                                                                                                                                                                                      Ecuador
                                                                                                                                                                              Ghana

                                                                                                                                                                                                             Papua
3. Farmer Investments and Community Development            Activity                              Description
Increase farmer income, reduce pressure on forests,        Premiums and productivity             Farmers receive a premium per delivered metric ton of cocoa beans,
establish agroforestry systems, protect and restore                                              whenever possible in the form of inputs, tools or services for cocoa
                                                                                                 productivity improvement. Further, they are tought on, and receive
forests                                                                                          support for producing their own organic inputs. We will also look at if,
                                                                                                 and how we could include Payment for Ecosystem Services (PES) as
                                                                                                 part of the premium scheme.

                                                           Cocoa seedlings                       Farmers have access to improved cocoa seedlings, and receive support
                                                                                                 in establishing nurseries. Before handing out cocoa seedlings, field staff
                                                                                                 verifies that they are planted where no deforestation is caused.

                                                           Shade trees                           Farmers have access to permanent shade trees to establish agroforestry
                                                                                                 systems, potentially also through establishing nurseries. We will work
                                                                                                 on defining shade trees that have additional benefits (e.g. for soil,
                                                                                                 additional income, biodiversity), are locally accepted, and native.

                                                           Additional income opportunities       Farmers receive training and support for their additional income
                                                                                                 generating activities. Attention is paid to avoid additional income
                                                                                                 generating activities that could cause further deforestation.
             fully implemented
                                                           (Community) partnerships for forest   We will initiate or participate in projects whereby communities and/or
             partially implemented                         protection and restoration            individual farmers located close to protected and other HCS/HCV
                                                                                                 areas are supported in protecting and (where necessary) managing
             not yet implemented                                                                 these areas. Further, we will support reforestation efforts in line with
                                                                                                 land use planning and landscape approaches to foster resilient and
                                                                                                 thriving landscapes.
             improvement
                                                                                     L I N D T & S P RÜ N G L I
                                                                            MAÎTRE CHOCOLATIER SUISSE DEPUIS 1845
17
                                                     N O - D E F O R E S TAT I O N A N D AG R O F O R E S T RY AC T I O N P L A N
                                                                            PROGR E S S R EPORT 2 02 0

                                                                                                                                                                                                   New Guinea
                                                                                                                                                                                      Madagascar

                                                                                                                                                                                                                Dominican
                                                                                                                                                                                                                Republic
                                                                                                                                                                            Ecuador
                                                                                                                                                                    Ghana

                                                                                                                                                                                                   Papua
4. Verification and Continuous Progress              Activity                             Description
Make sure we deliver on our commitment, activities   Internal Performance Monitoring      As part of the on-farm internal performance monitoring visits, covering
can continuously be improved, and ultimately show                                         all farmers in the Program, the implementation of this Action Plan (and
                                                                                          specifically the adoption of farmers) is monitored on a yearly basis.
the intended results
                                                     External Assessments                 The Earthworm Foundation is assessing the Program in all origins on
                                                                                          a yearly basis, including implementation of ths Action Plan, and gives
            fully implemented                                                             recommendations for improvement.

                                                     Satellite Monitoring                 We piloted Starling in Ghana, and are currently evaluating how we can
            partially implemented                                                         use satellite monitoring to monitor our no-deforestation commitment
                                                                                          going forward, ideally with a collaborative approach.
            not yet implemented
            improvement

                                                                             L I N D T & S P RÜ N G L I
                                                                    MAÎTRE CHOCOLATIER SUISSE DEPUIS 1845
18
                                                             N O - D E F O R E S TAT I O N A N D AG R O F O R E S T RY AC T I O N P L A N
                                                                                    PROGR E S S R EPORT 2 02 0

                                         Insight: Collective Action through
                                              the Landscape Approach
Context                                                      The Landscape Approach                                                         Relevance for Lindt & Sprüngli
Deforestation and the resulting implications for carbon      The Landscape Approach implies a collaboration of mul-                         Initiatives at a landscape level will be important to achieve
emissions and biodiversity loss are among the most sig-      tiple stakeholders in a landscape across different econom-                     the objectives of our ▶ No-Deforestation & Agroforestry
nificant sustainability challenges. The last decades of      ic sectors to reconcile competing social, economic and                         Action Plan. Participating in programs at a landscape
sustainable sourcing efforts addressing environmental        environmental objectives. A landscape is understood by                         level in different locations permits us to coordinate and
and social conditions at farm-level has proven that these    visible features of an area of land, its landforms, and how                    align our Farming Program activities with the vision,
issues reach far beyond the boundaries of individual         they integrate with natural or man-made features. It in-                       norms and values of the local communities, governments
farms. Often, they are systemic in nature and closely con-   cludes elements of geophysically defined landforms such                        and other private sector actors. By ensuring all stakehold-
nected to rural communities and other actors in a cocoa      as mountains, hills, water bodies; living elements of land                     ers work towards the same goal, we achieve bigger impact.
landscape. To achieve significant impact over time, issues   cover including indigenous vegetation; human elements                          While the Landscape Approach is no silver bullet, it is a
cannot be solved by one single company supporting a          including different forms of land use, buildings, and                          good way of collaborating and working on issues that
limited number of farmers linked to its supply chain. In-    structures; and transitory elements such as lighting and                       exceed the ability of individual actors to respond at scale.
stead, impactful change requires scale, collaborative ac-    weather conditions. Combining both their physical ori-                         This engagement is complementary to our Farming Pro-
tion and coordinated efforts with all the stakeholders in    gins and the cultural overlay of human presence, often                         gram, allowing us to engage beyond our own supply chain
a specific landscape. This includes collaboration with       created over millennia, landscapes reflect a living syn-                       (see page 14). With our engagement at landscape level, we
non-cocoa supply chain players present in the same geo-      thesis of people and place, that is vital to local and na-                     aim to create value and help to shape the history of con-
graphical area, whose operations equally impact the local    tional identities.                                                             servation in cocoa landscapes by developing the first suc-
ecosystem connected to the cocoa industry.                       A key component of the Landscape Approach is inte-                         cessful Landscape Approach use cases.
                                                             grated landscape management, which builds on locally
                                                             embedded governance structures that facilitate commu-
                                                             nity-based resource management for forest conservation.
                                                             Local governance linked to coordinated action at a land-
                                                             scape or regional level enables more effective protection
                                                             and restoration of forests. In the cocoa sector, this ap-
                                                             proach will be essential to curbing forest loss and achiev-
                                                             ing sustainability at scale and over time.

                                                                                    L I N D T & S P RÜ N G L I
                                                                           MAÎTRE CHOCOLATIER SUISSE DEPUIS 1845
19
                                                               N O - D E F O R E S TAT I O N A N D AG R O F O R E S T RY AC T I O N P L A N
                                                                                      PROGR E S S R EPORT 2 02 0

                                               The Cocoa & Forest Initiative –
                                                      Progress 2020
Key performance indicators
As part of our commitment to the Cocoa & Forests Initia-
tive, we started integrating the activities outlined in our
▶ No-Deforestation & Agroforestry Action Plan into our
▶ Lindt & Sprüngli Farming Program for cocoa beans, as
well as our segregated cocoa butter sustainability pro-
grams in Ghana and Côte d’Ivoire. In 2020, our focus was
mainly to scale up activities across all supply chains in
which we work based on long-term partnerships with
suppliers and partners. We are on track to meet the targets
which were set for 2025. We increased the share of cocoa
butter coming from such Programs, adapted our long-
term agreements with suppliers according to CFI targets
and also made achievements in areas where no specific
targets were set.

                                                               Indicator                                                                                           2020
                                                               # of farmers in the direct supply chain (=participating in Lindt & Sprüngli Farming Program         75,630
                                                               and sustainable butter program)

                                                               # and % of farms mapped in direct supply chain                                                      60,480 (80%)

Ghana                                                          # of plots mapped in the direct supply chain                                                        103,817

We source sustainable cocoa beans and butter from Ghana.       # of farmers trained in Climate Smart Cocoa (CSC) best practices in season 2019/20                  29,512

All activities are implemented by our supply chain partners,   # farmers informed, trained, and/or consulted on forest policy/law enforcement,                     27,234
                                                               forest protection, and restoration in 2019/20
while we have our dedicated supply chains on the ground.
By the end of season 2019/20, a total of 75,630 farmers were   # of multi-purpose trees (i.e. permanent shade trees) distributed for on-farm planting in 2019/20   661,780

participating in our sustainability programs and were cov-     # of farmers trained in Good Agricultural Practices in 2019/20                                      58,629

ered by our efforts under CFI.                                 # of individuals participating in additional Income Generating Activities (IGA’s)                   11,130

                                                               # of members of Village Saving and Loan Associations (VSLAs) in the current year                    3,928

                                                               # of Village Saving and Loan Associations (VSLAs) active in the current year                        168

                                                                                       L I N D T & S P RÜ N G L I
                                                                              MAÎTRE CHOCOLATIER SUISSE DEPUIS 1845
20
                                                              N O - D E F O R E S TAT I O N A N D AG R O F O R E S T RY AC T I O N P L A N
                                                                                     PROGR E S S R EPORT 2 02 0

                                                              Indicator                                                                                             2020
                                                              # of farmers in the direct supply chain (=participating in Lindt & Sprüngli Farming Program           17,233
                                                              and sustainable butter program)

                                                              # and % of farms mapped in direct supply chain                                                        13,172 (76%)
Cote d’Ivoire                                                 # of plots mapped in direct supply chain                                                              14,624
We source sustainable cocoa butter from Cote d’Ivoire.        # of farmers trained in Climate Smart Cocoa (CSC) best practices in 2019/20                           9,711
All program activities are managed and implemented by         # individuals receiving Payment for Ecosystem Services (PES) in 2019/20                               644
our supply chain partners. Due to the complex nature of
                                                              # of multi-purpose trees (e.g. permanent shade trees) distributed for on-farm planting in 2019/20     148,184
cocoa butter production, not all the supply chains are ful-
                                                              # of farmers trained in Good Agricultural Practices in 2019/20                                        13,667
ly dedicated to Lindt & Sprüngli but shared with other
                                                              # of individuals in the current reporting year enrolled in a formal financial products and services   1,870
companies. By the end of season 2019/20, a total of 17,233
                                                              # of members of Village Saving and Loan Associations (VSLAs) in the current year                      55
farmers were participating in our sustainability programs
                                                              # of Village Saving and Loan Associations (VSLAs) in the current year                                 2
and were covered by our efforts under CFI.

                                                                                      L I N D T & S P RÜ N G L I
                                                                             MAÎTRE CHOCOLATIER SUISSE DEPUIS 1845
21
                                                             N O - D E F O R E S TAT I O N A N D AG R O F O R E S T RY AC T I O N P L A N
                                                                                    PROGR E S S R EPORT 2 02 0

                                            Key challenges and way forward
We have identified overarching challenges for the imple-
mentation of our No-Deforestation & Agroforestry Action         Research project to develop methods for remotely                            Objectives
Plan through engagement with suppliers and partners,            estimating shade tree cover & carbon stocks                                 To meet each of these challenges, in this project we will:
including our external assessor, the Earthworm Founda-                                                                                      1. D
                                                                                                                                                evelop methods to rapidly assess shade-tree
tion. Work is still ongoing to address the complex issues       Background                                                                     cover and carbon stocks in existing cocoa farms,
identified in our previous progress report.                     Agroforestry – the deliberate inclusion of shade trees                         across large scales, and repeatedly over time;
                                                                in cropping systems – can increase the sustainability                       2. D evelop an easy-to-use, cost-effective tool
Data collection and monitoring                                  of cocoa production by supporting high levels of bio-                           to measure changes in shade-tree cover in
Internal monitoring is a key instrument of the continuous       diversity, buffering cocoa from climate changes, miti-                          cocoa farms, and to monitor progress towards
learning process that we promote in our programs. With-         gating future climate change through carbon seques-                             implementing agroforestry commitments;
in the Lindt & Sprüngli Farming Program, 100% of farm-          tration, and encouraging agricultural intensification                       3. Develop spatially-explicit recommendations
ers must be internally monitored on an annual basis to          without deforestation. Because of these advantages, and                        for optimal levels of shade-tree cover accounting
track the implementation progress of our Program. Some          in response to supply-chain and reputational risks,                            for locally-varying growing conditions across
of our KPIs, especially the No-Deforestation & Agrofor-         chocolate producing companies are increasingly engag-                          Ghana and the Côte d’Ivoire; and
estry KPIs, require a more sophisticated, time–intense          ing in efforts to implement cocoa agroforestry in major                     4. D etermine the carbon-sequestration potential
data collection process (e. g. counting of shade trees per      producing countries. However, this effort is currently                          of cocoa agroforestry.
hectare). To increase data accuracy and go beyond simply        hampered by limited information on current levels of
surveying farmers, suppliers have started work with ad-         shade-tree cover and carbon stocks in individual farms                      Outcomes
ditional data collection based on small samples to verify       and across entire regions; and the lack of an efficient,                    The project outcomes are expected to be a prototype of
KPIs. Through data analysis and collaboration with our          cost-effective tool to monitor progress on their agro-                      a digital tool that will allow remote monitoring of
suppliers we have found some data inconsistencies across        forestry initiatives and commitments. Moreover, im-                         shade-tree cover and carbon stocks in cocoa farms over
years and origins. This could be related to unclear guid-       plementing agroforests in a way that does not compro-                       time as well as recommendation for optimal shade-tree
ance and definition of KPIs or limited data reliability of      mise production requires recommendations for optimal                        cover and estimates of the carbon sequestration poten-
data from internal monitoring surveys. As no technical,         levels of shade-tree cover across large geographic re-                      tial of Ghanaian cocoa farms. These outcomes will be
automated solutions to measure outcomes are available,          gions while accounting for locally variable growing                         useful for monitoring and evaluation of industry-led
we will increase our efforts to provide better guidance on      conditions. Using available methods, developing such                        agroforestry initiatives and will allow planning of sci-
KPIs and data collection methodologies.                         recommendations is currently not possible.                                  entifically informed implementation of agroforests
                                                                                                                                            with targeted distribution of shade trees and predic-
                                                                                                                                            tions of carbon-sequestration from on-farm tree plant-
                                                                                                                                            ing across Ghana. The first results are expected in 2022.

                                                                                                                                            More information, see ▶ Project Factsheet

                                                                                    L I N D T & S P RÜ N G L I
                                                                           MAÎTRE CHOCOLATIER SUISSE DEPUIS 1845
22
                                                               N O - D E F O R E S TAT I O N A N D AG R O F O R E S T RY AC T I O N P L A N
                                                                                      PROGR E S S R EPORT 2 02 0

Identification and protection of HCV and HCS areas             Former Program farmers located in protected areas
Many of the activities in our Action Plan require visibil-     As part of our commitment, we have performed legality
ity of HCV and HCS areas. These are forests and areas          checks of farms and identified 3,536 farmers who are op-
which may not be legally protected, yet are ecologically       erating illegally in protected areas. All these farmers have
important and which we are committed to protecting.            already been part of the Lindt & Sprüngli Farming Pro-
However, conducting such assessments is highly resource        gram before the CFI implementation. We already ceased
intense. Once the results are available, it is yet another     cocoa sourcing from these identified farmers in the
challenge to find practical solutions to designing and         2018/19 cocoa season. However, the concerned farmers
funding relevant incentive mechanisms for farmers and          are still in the Program for continuous monitoring and
communities which will lead to their active participation      ensuring that they do not expand their lands any further.
in protecting forest areas and restoring important habi-       Meanwhile, we are waiting for official guidance on what
tats. Therefore, we believe it makes sense to integrate such   needs to be done with these farmers, and how we can
assessments into collective initiatives by industry and        support potential transitions, and/or updated forest
other stakeholders. Efforts should define locally adapted      boundary maps, which might show different legal status
and embedded strategies to support and incentivize local       of the concerned farms. Farms and farmers found in pro-
actors to engage in forest conservation, beyond individ-       tected areas will be shared with the government based on
ual farmers in a company’s supply chain. In parallel, prac-    CFI guidelines, once social safeguards are functional.
tical tools to apply the HCV and HCS concept on a mi-          Once policies and procedures are clear, we will engage
cro-level should be developed. As described on page 12,        with local authorities, our suppliers, and farmers to find
we are currently running a pilot in Ecuador to test such       solutions regarding their future presence and cocoa pro-
a methodology.                                                 duction activities in these areas.

                                                                                      L I N D T & S P RÜ N G L I
                                                                             MAÎTRE CHOCOLATIER SUISSE DEPUIS 1845
23
                                                              N O - D E F O R E S TAT I O N A N D AG R O F O R E S T RY AC T I O N P L A N
                                                                                     PROGR E S S R EPORT 2 02 0

                                                                                                                                             Scaling agroforestry efforts
                                                                                                                                             Promoting the transition towards agroforestry systems in
                                                                                                                                             cocoa production is one of our main commitments and
                                                                                                                                             continues to be a priority in the coming years. After scal-
                                                                                                                                             ing shade tree distribution and gaining a better insight
                                                                                                                                             on the challenges and critical success factors of imple-
                                                                                                                                             mentation, we have established collaborations with expert
                                                                                                                                             organizations to support our partners and make sure the
                                                                                                                                             field staff has the capacity to train farmers in agrofores­t ry.
                                                                                                                                             However, there are other key issues to support a more
                                                                                                                                             radical transformation of agroforestry systems, for exam-
                                                                                                                                             ple creating market access and linkages, securing land
                                                                                                                                             tenure, or making agroforestry attractive for farmers
                                                                                                                                             through Payments for Ecosystem Servicces (PES). While
                                                                                                                                             the creation of new markets for agroforestry products
                                                                                                                                             requires closer collaboration and coordination of distrib-
Satellite monitoring & deforestation risk assessments         in the Cocoa & Forests Initiative. To help realize effective                   uted trees at the landscape level, the possibility of land
Various real-time satellite monitoring technologies to        landscape partnerships, and contribute to deforestation                        tenure and tree registration also influences the attractive-
monitor risk of forest encroachment associated with sup-      monitoring, the World Cocoa Foundation (WCF) and                               ness of planting and maintaining trees on cocoa farms.
ply chains have been developed in recent years. Satellite     Climate Focus in partnership with the World Resources                          To date, unfortunately, no affordable and scalable model
monitoring and deforestation risk assessments are cur-        Institute (WRI) are further working with companies to                          for providing farmers with land titles or services to reg-
rently performed by our suppliers. For satellite monitor-     develop a comprehensive dataset of cocoa plot locations                        ister trees exists. In Ghana, we have run a pilot for a ser-
ing to be impactful, we believe that technology is just the   in the direct supply chain and an aligned method for as-                       vice delivery model for land document with a service
starting point. Once tools allow for real-time detection of   sessing deforestation risk. An aggregate view of cocoa plot                    provider. To enable farmers to receive their land title,
forest disturbances, alerts must be verified in the field.    locations across West Africa will provide a basis for iden-                    Lindt & Sprüngli has pre-financed the service, while farm-
This data will permit answering key questions on legality,    tifying opportunities for pre-competitive collaboration.                       ers were asked to claim their land paper and pay for the
drivers of deforestation and potential solutions to address   Paired with the outputs of the risk assessment, collabo-                       service only once the documentation is available. Of the
the challenges. To move towards action, common defini-        ration can proceed in the areas that matter most for ad-                       89 farmers who participated in the project, only 52%
tions, monitoring methodologies and tools will hopeful-       dressing deforestation. The risk assessment will be made                       claimed their land title and paid for the service. The proj-
ly enable a collective effort by industry and governments     available as a freely accessible public good through WRI’s                     ect has demonstrated that the costs for receiving land
to create joint monitoring and remediation mechanisms         Global Forest Watch platforms to help drive aligned de-                        documentation is too high and we are currently evaluat-
on the ground. This is a pre-condition to drive action,       forestation risk management across the cocoa sector for                        ing options to reduce the costs, either by adopting a dif-
especially in regions where non-cocoa related sectors,        impact at scale.                                                               ferent pricing model or seeking co-funding from other
such as mining, have become important drivers for de-             Complementary to our participation in these joint ef-                      actors in the sector. Finally, payment for ecosystem ser-
forestation.                                                  forts, we engage in landscape programs which aim to build                      vices seems an attractive concept to support farmers for
    Lindt & Sprüngli supports current efforts by the gov-     local governance structures that could potentially facili-                     maintaining their trees on farms. However, financing of
ernments of Ghana and Côte d’Ivoire to develop national       tate the implementation of mitigation measures in the                          such schemes (if not connected to carbon credits) is still
satellite monitoring platforms through our membership         long-term.                                                                     an issue and requires new schemes with multiple actors
                                                                                     L I N D T & S P RÜ N G L I
                                                                                                                                             contributing financially.
                                                                            MAÎTRE CHOCOLATIER SUISSE DEPUIS 1845
You can also read